Military Review

Are they starting to leave? To the resignation of Alexei Kudrin

72
Are they starting to leave? To the resignation of Alexei Kudrin



Didn't sit well


Aleksey Kudrin, chairman of the country's main control office, the Accounts Chamber, chose not to wait for a signal from the president and left on his own. As he states, in business, for the implementation of projects that can bring real benefits. As you can see, with the benefit in the joint venture of the Russian Federation it somehow became not very good.

The ex-Minister of Finance and even the Deputy Prime Minister, who was in charge of the entire economy and finance, were redirected to state control, that is, to the Accounts Chamber, after a long pause. In advisers, assistants or whatever. Years before, the RF SP had managed to leave the Federal Assembly and become directly subordinate to the head of state, and many were surprised by the appointment of the liberal Kudrin there.

But not us, because we knew quite well what undeniable authority Alexei Leonidovich enjoyed at the very top. Moreover, he never hid his by no means indisputable economic views, and was rightfully considered almost the ideological leader of the liberal government party.

However, already then someone thought that in the new post, which, by the way, went to Kudrin, we repeat, not immediately, but with a pause, he can “reforge”. As an example of a reforged, they cited Sergei Kiriyenko, who ruled Rosatom, and he still remains in the locomotives of the economy, and even Anatoly Chubais, although he had already begun shamelessly cutting Rosnano.

However, Kiriyenko, unlike Kudrin, never had particularly liberal views, and he was almost framed for default, but the leader of our painfully liberal economic bloc of the government does not need examples. From the word "completely" - Kudrin himself is an example to whom you want in terms of perseverance and perseverance, reaching stubbornness.

One opposition to the Tax Code - many years ago and already forgotten, which was worth it, not to mention the combination with the Russian external debt. There, in the first roles, there was actually Kudrin's forerunner in the Ministry of Finance - Mikhail Kasyanov, who, it would seem, wrote off everything at once.

Auditors, hey!


In fact, Kasyanov, together with his Western colleagues, thoroughly cleaned out the Russian treasury. No, there was no direct theft there, but the conditions for early debt cancellation in reality were those that usually occur during delinquency, restructuring or prolongation. But this is not about that, it's about the Accounts Chamber and its outgoing chairman.


Needless to say, under Kudrin, there was not a single serious check with concrete results in the RF SP. For billions or at least hundreds of millions of money returned to the treasury. Kudrin's team somehow managed to stay away from the showdown with the same "Rosnano", and the senators took it upon themselves.

Long before Kudrin, even under Sergei Stepashin as chairman of the main control body of the country, the Accounts Chamber more than once or twice swung at the sacred - at the Central Bank and how its bins were replenished and spent. However, the "taboo" from above was imposed firmly and forever.

Now the auditors of the Accounts Chamber have frankly dismissed the Bank of Russia as an inaccessible object, as well as many other structures. Although for Kudrin, neither the leadership of the Central Bank of the Russian Federation, nor the heads of state corporations seem to be at all sacred cows. But why, then, the assessments of the effectiveness of the disposal of the country's reserve funds, carried out during the leadership of Alexei Leonidovich, can only be called pathetic.

It was about the same with the costly and essentially failed projects for the reconstruction of the BAM and the Trans-Siberian Railway under the wing of Russian Railways, and with the activities of state corporations. The current joint venture of the Russian Federation did not succeed with conclusions on the belated, but no less terrible defeat of the civil aviation industry, which is now painfully and so far unsuccessfully trying to revive.

Not so bad


In the work of the Accounts Chamber in recent years, there has been another oddity - they almost regularly criticize what should have been welcomed. At least for reasons of saving public funds. Instead of discussing the still unconvincing pension reform, the head of the RF SP for some reason disputed the need for reorganization, and in fact, the quiet liquidation of development institutions, like the same Rosnano and Skolkovo.

When it was proposed to use funds from the National Security Fund to fight the pandemic, for some reason the Accounts Chamber reminded that this was hardly possible under the law. Fortunately, it turned out to be possible, and how. It is the same, however, now, when they are trying to steal from Russia, or rather, they have already stolen, the lion's share of the reserves, that it is not worth putting money in a money-box, from where they just don't say.

But not from the Central Bank, not from the Ministry of Finance, not from the Accounts Chamber. Here is such a liberal consensus. The deficit budget, which could now even run into a surplus, since import spending has fallen sharply, is simply taken for granted in the Accounts Chamber.

Considering it seems that their job is to check how the funds were used and not how they were planned. But the practice of preventing the inefficient use of these funds in the Accounts Chamber was started under Sergei Stepashin, but already under Tatyana Golikova, it was safely brought to naught.


Who's next?


Should we now be afraid of a wave of resignations following Kudrin? We doubt that it is removed for anything specific. Kudrin is too careful, and most likely, he really leaves on his own. Although today the auditors really have something to aim at. However, the fuse, as practice convinces, is not the same now.

And is it even worth fearing the departure of someone from those who are close to or even at the same time with the former minister, former deputy prime minister and, for sure, the former head of the control department, Alexei Kudrin. The liberal bloc of the executive branch, and not only the executive branch, has long been in need of a fair purge.

And it just looks like the cleansing of the rows will be very difficult. Yes, the notorious office plankton that has settled in the economic departments and is ready to replace the current aging liberals is really saturated with the ideas of the liberal economic school. All of them, who are now in the region of 30-50, were taught that way.

But it, liberal economics, is by no means completely vicious in its essence, and its pioneer, the British Lord Keynes, did not at all deny the need for state regulation of the economy. Moreover, under certain conditions, and they are now, extremely tough. Keynes even talked about the extent of the state's presence in the economy.

By the way, this is what supporters of economic freedom so often complain about, both inside Russia and abroad. But we will not now make predictions about the leaders of our beloved ministries and departments. Everything will happen exactly as it takes time. There can be no doubt about this.
Author:
Photos used:
equipnet.ru, medvejiyugol.ru
72 comments
Ad

Subscribe to our Telegram channel, regularly additional information about the special operation in Ukraine, a large amount of information, videos, something that does not fall on the site: https://t.me/topwar_official

Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. Aerodrome
    Aerodrome 30 November 2022 14: 55
    +39
    and the President, there is absolutely nothing to do with it ...
    1. The comment was deleted.
    2. AdAstra
      AdAstra 30 November 2022 15: 01
      +15
      "Rafik is not the culprit" © lol "" "
      1. marchcat
        marchcat 30 November 2022 15: 59
        +4
        in the joint venture of the Russian Federation there was not a single serious check with concrete results at all
        An invaluable benefit, probably, brings the joint venture, for ??????
    3. Doccor18
      Doccor18 30 November 2022 22: 41
      +4
      Quote: Aerodrome
      and the President, there is absolutely nothing to do with it ...

      And this is the main point!
    4. Master 2030
      Master 2030 3 December 2022 08: 00
      +2
      Tsar-good boyars-bad. Just remember about Charles in England, Louis 16th and Kolyamba No. 2.
  2. Vladimir Vladimirovich Vorontsov
    Vladimir Vladimirovich Vorontsov 30 November 2022 14: 56
    +3
    Alexei Kudrin, Chairman of the country's main control office - Accounts Chamber, chose not to wait for a go-ahead from the president and left himself

    ***
    - Miscalculated or miscalculated? ...
    ***
    1. Aerodrome
      Aerodrome 30 November 2022 15: 57
      +12
      Kudrin, already "left", what has changed? planted? -No, did they start a "case"? - no ... he returned and let's again "benefit the country" ... Putin doesn’t know that ...
      1. dorz
        dorz 30 November 2022 19: 38
        +14
        Quote: Aerodrome
        Kudrin, already "left", what has changed? planted? -No, did they start a "case"? - no ... he returned and let's again "benefit the country" ... Putin doesn’t know that ...

        The same deck of "boyars" is shuffled. Nothing will change, Ksenia is back.
        1. Nyrobsky
          Nyrobsky 30 November 2022 22: 43
          +14
          Quote: dorz
          Quote: Aerodrome
          Kudrin, already "left", what has changed? planted? -No, did they start a "case"? - no ... he returned and let's again "benefit the country" ... Putin doesn’t know that ...

          The same deck of "boyars" is shuffled. Nothing will change, Ksenia is back.

          Is it somehow included in the government of the state? The mouse, of course, is still the same, but it was not allowed to manage the boyar class.
          As for the appointment of Kudrin, the author somehow missed the fact that at one time there was a conflict between Medvedev and Kudrin, during which DAM unambiguously told Kudrin that, they say, whoever does not support his plans and ideas can blame all four sides, after which, in fact, Kudrin left the post of head of the Ministry of Finance and for a couple of three years did not shine in the political field from the word at all. GDP, in principle, competently peddled the topic of the conflict and put Kudrin in the post of head of the joint venture, as a result of which he got the opportunity to get even for his "offense" and gained the authority to spoil the atmosphere of the cloudless existence of DAM and his liberal party with Dvorkovich and Co. Now Dvorkovich and Chubais are being extinguished abroad, DAM is sitting out a pension period in the Security Council and periodically, with its cries and threats, it introduces Russians into bewilderment, and Kudrin is leaving for a position not related to state administration.
          Here now, as it were, Siluanov, Gref and Golikova with Nabiullina should also be pushed into specialists in monitoring mosquito populations in permafrost conditions against the backdrop of increased interest in the Northern Sea Route, excommunicating them from the possibility of influencing state interests. But apparently, such things are not done with kondachka and the tentacles of "influence from the outside" are cut off gradually. The conflict between DAM and Kudrin is here -
          https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vyY7VgvNuPs
          1. Aviator_
            Aviator_ 1 December 2022 08: 02
            -1
            as a result, he got the opportunity to get even for his "offense" and gained the authority to spoil the atmosphere
            Yeah, the only thing that liberals do professionally is spoil the air.
          2. TerraSandera
            TerraSandera 3 December 2022 08: 02
            -1
            Hehe, you are fantastic. Nabis was recently reset to zero, and the president was in favor with both hands. You can’t talk like that about Grefs and other Silyanovs and remove them, remove them to other positions late, but “Own” ones. And they know a lot of their own and follow "The livestock of the coma" They won't, but they will take advantage of the Chubais case, leave for indulgence, hand it over with giblets. And the system will become even less stable, as others will be shaken, which is what the West needs. Therefore, either in prison, in watered prisoners, or continue to steal, saw, create sabotage, in general, do their usual business or do nothing.
            Any of these options is very beneficial to the West, absolutely any.
      2. Doccor18
        Doccor18 30 November 2022 22: 43
        +8
        Quote: Aerodrome
        Kudrin, already "left", what has changed?

        Blessed is he who believes that the course of the capitalist economy depends on a particular person, blessed and unhappy ...
  3. Lech from Android.
    Lech from Android. 30 November 2022 15: 01
    +12
    Quote: Vladimir Vladimirovich Vorontsov
    Missed or miscalculated? ...

    More likely to have washed off in time.
    1. man
      man 30 November 2022 15: 59
      +6
      More likely to have washed off in time.
      I'm sure he signed up to volunteer!
    2. Irokez
      Irokez 1 December 2022 10: 08
      +2
      Quote: Lech from Android.
      More likely to have washed off in time.

      Here, in a strange way, the dates coincided with the entry into force on December 1 of the law on foreign agents.
      Everything is sad for them:
      "On November 30, the Federation Council approved a law on amendments to relevant laws, which provides that foreign agents will not be able to enter the civil service, be organizers of public events, members of election commissions with the right to vote, and also engage in enlightenment and education of minors. After the entry into force of the law employees of the internal affairs bodies, as well as customs authorities, in the event of acquiring the status of a foreign agent, will not be able to continue their service."
      Source: https://rusvesna.su/news/1669843982
      So the SVO is going on not only in Ukraine, but also in the Russian state as a whole.
  4. Vladimir80
    Vladimir80 30 November 2022 15: 06
    -1
    Rodents scatter from a sinking ship?
    1. tihonmarine
      tihonmarine 30 November 2022 15: 17
      +8
      Quote: Vladimir80
      Rodents scatter from a sinking ship?

      Rodents scatter when they are poisoned with chlorophos.
  5. g_ae
    g_ae 30 November 2022 15: 09
    +28
    Yes, they will find him a warm place, why worry. The Russian government does not abandon its own. If the quartermaster from the Moscow Region, after the embarrassment of the start of mobilization, was appointed by the Inspector General, then there will be no problems at all. A friend of Chubais to the same. Well, a companion at least.
    1. Gvardeetz77
      Gvardeetz77 30 November 2022 19: 27
      +4
      Quote: g_ae
      Yes, they will find him a warm place, why worry. The Russian government does not abandon its own. If the quartermaster from the Moscow Region, after the embarrassment of the start of mobilization, was appointed by the Inspector General, then there will be no problems at all. A friend of Chubais to the same. Well, a companion at least.

      Already as of "yesterday" they found, he will head the Russian segment of the entire Yandex and he is also "gifted" 5% of the shares of this company
      1. g_ae
        g_ae 30 November 2022 21: 42
        +10
        Well, that's all right. For feeding. As at one time cities were given food, so now corporations. Look like "Rosnano" Tolyan was given to feed. And no money, no result, no Tolyan.
      2. Damir Shamaev
        Damir Shamaev 1 December 2022 12: 03
        0
        He will now develop, Khan is shorter than Yandex
  6. tihonmarine
    tihonmarine 30 November 2022 15: 10
    +6
    and even Anatoly Chubais, although he had already begun the shameless cutting of Rosnano.

    The Americans quickly reforged this little boy to their side, he always remains faithful to them like a dog.
  7. FoBoss_VM
    FoBoss_VM 30 November 2022 15: 12
    +14
    They should be planted, not left. Nabiulina, Siluanov, Manturov and Shoigu get ready
    1. The comment was deleted.
  8. Maks1995
    Maks1995 30 November 2022 15: 17
    +9
    So many times in the media it was that the SP checked someone and found .... found the wrong billions, but ....
    they are all someone's ... Chubais, Rogozin, Yakunin, the Central Bank, (i.e. Duma, Edra and VV Putin), etc.

    BUT! They are all untouchable. Putin himself, as the media proudly wrote, does not surrender HIS OWN ..
    So, blaming the Kremlin structure for not sinking the Kremlin projects... is strange.
    She doesn't decide.
    Most likely, it simply informs - how much someone "optimized". And then they say from above - transfer the neighbor to the chair, remove it from the eyes or ... raise it ....
  9. 2 Level Advisor
    2 Level Advisor 30 November 2022 15: 17
    +9
    he seems to be moving into the leadership of the non-poor Yandex (semi-officially - under state control), so it’s definitely not a direct exile, he won’t lose money ...
    "Yandex" is a transnational company in the information technology industry, whose parent legal entity is registered in the Netherlands, which owns the Internet search engine of the same name, an Internet portal and web services in several countries. It occupies the most prominent position in the markets of Russia, Belarus and Kazakhstan. In November 2022, The Bell published information according to which the Chairman of the Accounts Chamber, Alexei Kudrin, discussed the reorganization of Yandex with Russian President Vladimir Putin. As a result, the co-founder of the company, Arkady Volozh, will develop foreign business, and Alexei Kudrin will receive 5% of the company, take a place in management and will develop the Russian division. According to Forbes, in February 2022, Yandex ranked 1st in the ranking of the 30 most expensive companies on Runet. The company's value was estimated at $ 17,397 billion. "
    1. Wildcat
      Wildcat 1 December 2022 22: 16
      +6
      hi
      Hats off, your comment is one sensible comment out of 58!
      57 people will definitely not be able to understand "how much 5% of $17,397 billion will be."
      1. 2 Level Advisor
        2 Level Advisor 1 December 2022 22: 26
        +2
        thank you hi I thought, and so it is clear that this is, to put it mildly, not a downgrade, but it seems not to everyone ...
      2. Klaus8691
        Klaus8691 2 December 2022 06: 04
        +1
        So that's a good deal! Like a candle factory...
        1. Wildcat
          Wildcat 2 December 2022 06: 15
          +4
          good
          Alleluia!
          If you write how much "unfortunate Kudrin" will receive "cashed" in foreign currency and rubles (approximately, of course) - I'll give you a plus!
          Only, mind you, without abbreviations - the number of even zeros in these numbers is very important!
          1. Klaus8691
            Klaus8691 2 December 2022 07: 08
            +1
            869850000 ... It seems something like this) There should be enough for bread.
            1. Wildcat
              Wildcat 2 December 2022 07: 14
              +3
              I myself don’t really understand such figures ... I believe you on your word! good
              And how will "poor Kudrin" get this amount from an ATM, for a long time? And how it will carry home, it's hard, probably .... wassat

              There should be enough for bread.

              Again, I'm not sure, but in the "bread" part, we should expect a joint project of the "Forbes rich list" and "Guinness records" in the nomination "the largest black caviar sandwich, which is larger than the country of Liechtenstein"! laughing
              1. Klaus8691
                Klaus8691 2 December 2022 07: 18
                +1
                Well, 300 pieces will be withdrawn every day, and there the interest on the deposit will drip. So he is unlikely to have to face "there is no money, but you hold on" ...
  10. Vadim Topal Pasha
    Vadim Topal Pasha 30 November 2022 15: 18
    +1
    Maybe the author still has a mistake in the title? Not "they" but "them"?
    1. dauria
      dauria 1 December 2022 05: 36
      +5
      Maybe the author still has a mistake in the title? Not "they" but "them"?

      There is no error. They leave themselves, not "they leave". They get into the boats, and an orchestra with a conductor remains on board the sinking Titanic. Yes, the captain, on whom nothing depends, and who has nowhere to go. .
  11. Vadim Topal Pasha
    Vadim Topal Pasha 30 November 2022 15: 18
    +2
    Quote: Vladimir Vladimirovich Vorontsov
    Alexei Kudrin, Chairman of the country's main control office - Accounts Chamber, chose not to wait for a go-ahead from the president and left himself

    ***
    - Miscalculated or miscalculated? ...
    ***

    I miscalculated! :)
  12. Virus-free crown
    Virus-free crown 30 November 2022 15: 28
    +8
    The authors are completely unaware of the news))
    Kudrin has not gone anywhere. It's just that Yandex was divided into 2 parts - Russian and foreign, in exchange for the right to do anything abroad, Volozh gave the Russian part under state control, and Kudrin was appointed "looking after Yandex" by the state bully
  13. Old Horseradish
    Old Horseradish 30 November 2022 15: 41
    +12
    You should not wishful thinking. They didn't go anywhere, they just got richer. And stop raving about all sorts of "cunning plans."
  14. Zadok
    Zadok 30 November 2022 15: 42
    +1
    cutting Yandex began. Volozh at least managed to dump

    Sorry, I'm not smart enough to write a normal comment and, according to the site administration, does not carry useful information.
  15. guest
    guest 30 November 2022 15: 54
    -5
    One representative of the fifth column in power has become less and this is good news.
  16. dandy
    dandy 30 November 2022 16: 51
    +10
    They're starting to leave, you say? They must first sit down on the track for a certain number of years. But who will put them down? They are monuments to the “saints of the nineties,” where they all came from, monuments to that comprador policy, the consequences of which are still being reaped. And for sure, each of that cohort has something against each other, for sure. Mutual responsibility is, apparently, an indispensable thing in those circles. And here, at least don’t grit your teeth, nothing will happen. Such people do not sit down. I recall the book squads ,, White Arrow ,, and the series ,, Sword ,, ...
    1. Garik Gorkin
      Garik Gorkin 1 December 2022 01: 12
      +4
      You are right, there is a wonderful film White Arrow 2007.
      https://ru.wikipedia.org/wiki/Белая_стрела_(фильм)
      White arrow. Retribution 2015
      https://www.kino-teatr.ru/kino/movie/ros/111000/annot/
      These films are about how corrupt judges tried to cover up the biggest criminals, and then several honest employees of the Ministry of Internal Affairs and special forces began to shoot these criminals themselves.
      The authorities are afraid of these films, so they are rarely shown.
      The following article describes failed attempts to implement this idea in Russia:
      https://ru.wikipedia.org/wiki/Белая_стрела
    2. Klaus8691
      Klaus8691 2 December 2022 06: 06
      +2
      "Bound by one chain. Bound by one goal..."
  17. Postcode
    Postcode 30 November 2022 16: 57
    +7
    During the period of Kudrin's work, there were quite high-profile cases based on the results of the work of the joint venture, the same Chubais, nothing more than the joint venture gave the first analysis of the activities of its structure. And how many high-profile cases, dismissals at the level of heads of regions, including the work of the regional departments of the joint venture. Kudrin's appointment, at one time, was based on his principles and decency. Being of liberal views, you can be a completely honest person, and vice versa, how many kissing desks the ticket of the pro-government party were then sent to the stage ...
    1. Ivan staryi
      Ivan staryi 1 December 2022 05: 46
      0
      The joint venture does not have regional offices. There are control and accounting bodies of the constituent entities of the Russian Federation.
      1. Postcode
        Postcode 1 December 2022 08: 32
        +1
        Does this fundamentally change the essence of the matter?
        1. Ivan staryi
          Ivan staryi 1 December 2022 19: 23
          0
          No, in principle, I couldn’t resist!)) Most likely, all the same, it has an indirect relation to the affairs at the level of the management of the subjects of the joint venture.
  18. Mishka78
    Mishka78 30 November 2022 17: 51
    +11
    I'll give an unpopular opinion, but still.
    Kudrin is a mighty block in Russian politics and the vertical of power.
    One of the persons close to the emperor worked both as a minister and the first deputy chairman of the government and, importantly, in the Leningrad mayor's office in a certain period.
    So, for me, he was one of the best auditors in the Accounts Chamber, because. his political weight, authority and free personal access to one person outweighed many. As a result, his audit was really feared. The same Roskosmos, Rosnanu, the Ministry of Defense, he checked and wool without much fear.
    Every year, his department revealed violations worth 800-1000 billion.
    https://www.rbc.ru/rbcfreenews/5e1d22309a7947140df3ce3e?from=article_body
    He could quite openly express his opinion, without touching the boss, of course.
    https://www.rbc.ru/politics/30/08/2018/5b8748c49a7947bc3450e8aa

    Well, what conclusions were drawn from his checks - this is no longer up to him. This is for those who make decisions based on the results of the audit.
    Violations were revealed for a trillion, 5 billion returned to the treasury, 17 criminal cases were opened, of which 5 went to court, of which 4 were acquitted due to covering losses.
    1. Ivan staryi
      Ivan staryi 1 December 2022 06: 57
      +1
      You're right. Specialists of the Joint Venture are not employees of the Cheka in leather jackets and with revolvers, and in their reports the information is usually interesting! What is called "smart enough".
  19. Zaurbek
    Zaurbek 30 November 2022 19: 40
    +3
    Question to the studio, what kind of private business can Kudrin help? Whether large or small?
  20. Blue fox
    Blue fox 30 November 2022 20: 45
    +1
    Oceania is rapidly moving towards Land Decree 2.0. The only question is who will be the author. Yes, and Ostasia has not yet been defeated.
    1. Turtle
      Turtle 1 December 2022 21: 48
      0
      God bless Eurasia! We have room 101
  21. bandabas
    bandabas 30 November 2022 21: 05
    +5
    Another liberalist has gone into free swimming. And the Guarantor on the drum. A raven does not peck out a crow's eyes.
  22. Romanovski
    Romanovski 30 November 2022 21: 59
    0
    ""... Are they starting to leave? To the resignation of Alexei Kudrin ... ""
    ---------
    Good riddance ... Let them go to "develop" the economy of the USA, Europe and Israel .... Russia is fed up with liberal pseudo-economy, which is designed to pump capital, brains (!) And raw materials from Russia to the West, and in Russia itself - to slow down science-intensive and other productions with stupid tax policy and idiotic laws ... We will learn an effective economy, IDEOLOGY and new people's communism from China ... And also learn from the successful economic experience of India, Vietnam, Iran, the United Arab Emirates, Singapore ...
  23. Yellow bubble
    Yellow bubble 1 December 2022 07: 45
    +2
    Leaves because there is nothing more to consider, Chubais left, Kudrin left who is next? Who is next? Russia is sleeping, Russians don't care about sleeping pills on TV. There is no war, everything is fine, almost all of Ukraine is free, Does Putin know this?
    1. Turtle
      Turtle 1 December 2022 21: 46
      +1
      Quote: Yellow bubble
      Who's next?

      antoshka siluanov is the chief expert on financial terrorism. I remembered Borka Yeltsin: "There will be no default!" Itching to wonder how such a character would be executed by the Chinese comrades?
  24. Dedok
    Dedok 1 December 2022 08: 10
    +1
    I'm wondering what kind of "share" Kudrin will get in Yandex?!
    can you buy it with the sovereign's salary (or is it still "given")?
    I hesitate..
  25. Aleprok
    Aleprok 1 December 2022 08: 14
    +2
    the main red-haired thief fled, so Kudrin is no longer needed
  26. Metallurg_2
    Metallurg_2 1 December 2022 08: 29
    +4
    The liberal party in power needs mass executions.
  27. bija089
    bija089 1 December 2022 09: 08
    +1
    Friends will be saved, the rest will be put under the knife
  28. NightmareIvanych
    NightmareIvanych 1 December 2022 09: 23
    +6
    You yourself know who the most important liberal is ... Moreover, he publicly admitted this .. So they don’t go anywhere, leave your wet fantasies ...
  29. Glory1974
    Glory1974 1 December 2022 10: 42
    +3
    According to rumors, Kudrin is being prepared for the presidency.
  30. DmSol
    DmSol 1 December 2022 11: 05
    +1
    The question is not who is leaving. The question is who will come.
  31. Armen Sologyan
    Armen Sologyan 1 December 2022 12: 08
    +2
    I just can’t understand some Russian citizens on their passports why they don’t like independent Russia with their own sovereignty so much, but worship the Western idols of the dollar and the euro. Why only bad things are taken from the West. For example, in the USA, each of its citizens hangs out the US flag and does everything for their country, and some of ours are shaking in front of the dollar and the euro ???
  32. for
    for 1 December 2022 12: 12
    +1
    Alexei Kudrin, chairman of the main control office of the country - the Accounts Chamber, chose not to wait handouts from the president and left on his own. As he states, in business, for the implementation of projects that can bring real benefits. As you can see, with the benefit in the joint venture of the Russian Federation it somehow became not very good.


    And the authors are sure that it was not? Something quickly and efficiently, and even with his recommendation, accepted his resignation.
  33. Vadim Topal Pasha
    Vadim Topal Pasha 1 December 2022 15: 31
    +1
    Quote: dauria
    Maybe the author still has a mistake in the title? Not "they" but "them"?

    There is no error. They leave themselves, not "they leave". They get into the boats, and an orchestra with a conductor remains on board the sinking Titanic. Yes, the captain, on whom nothing depends, and who has nowhere to go. .

    Maybe you can write an article on this topic? And then send me a link? I'd love to know the details...
  34. Fangaro
    Fangaro 1 December 2022 21: 40
    +1
    Where are modern weapons? Where is the cosmodrome on the far frontier? Where is the Russian gold reserves? Where is GLONASS in every car? Where is the production of FPGAs, Elbrusov?
    Does the joint venture consider it at will, or does it check as directed?
    Maybe, yes, I am sure that the former head of the joint venture, Kudrin, is a liberal in politics and economics. But I don’t believe that he would “freeze his ears to spite his grandmother” - I don’t believe it.
  35. Turtle
    Turtle 1 December 2022 21: 41
    +1
    Sounds "Road" group Leningrad.
  36. anclevalico
    anclevalico 2 December 2022 07: 25
    +2
    Human naivete. Once you get there, no one goes anywhere. They just move from one warm place to another. This is Putin's command vertical. Do what you want and come what may.
  37. Vincent price
    Vincent price 3 December 2022 02: 06
    +3
    Do not give out what you want but what is real. This system will not change itself
  38. Patriot228
    Patriot228 4 December 2022 13: 55
    -1
    Yes, for the mere fact that Kudrin did not allow Roskosmos to be plundered during the reign of Rogozin the trampoline, a monument should be erected to him.
    Kudrin told Putin about violations in Roskosmos worth ₽30 billion
    Read more at RBC:
    https://www.rbc.ru/society/23/03/2021/6059d2fa9a7947d9e3530c59

    It’s good that at least our “supreme” removed Trampoline Sr. in time, otherwise the karachun would have come to the industry.
  39. vvn_vl
    vvn_vl 5 December 2022 12: 00
    +2
    and if you delve into the civil aircraft industry, then so much will come out ... pogosyans, manturovs, all kinds of chess players, husbands of ministers-accountants ... shake up contracts with Bombardier and others ... or maybe organize sharashkas for such people? you look, and the planes will appear
  40. Dmitry Karabanov
    Dmitry Karabanov 7 December 2022 11: 27
    +1
    Kudrin has absolutely nothing to fear. The worst thing is that he will go along the route of Chubais. Because Putin does not abandon his friends!