Project 23900 UDC "Priboy": a waste of money or a highly efficient warship?
Universal amphibious ships (UDC) as part of the naval fleet (Navy) Russia is currently absent. Everyone remembers the epic with the acquisition of four French Mistral-class UDCs, which ended with the sale of ships intended for the Russian Navy to Egypt and the return of funds by France for their purchase. Even then, a lot of criticism sounded to the address of the Mistral-class UDC, ranging from the alleged design flaws and ending with the lack of goals and objectives for ships of this class. After the aggravation of relations with Western countries and the termination of the contract for the Mistrals, Russia had to solve the issue of creating the UDC on its own.
French UDC of the Mistral type. Photo wikipedia.org
Currently, two Project 23900 Priboi universal amphibious assault ships (UDC) are being built for the Russian Navy. And again, as in the case of the Mistrals, the opinion is often expressed that these ships are absolutely useless for the Russian Navy.
Consider, is this really so? What tasks can the UDC of Project 23900 "Priboy" solve as part of the Russian Navy?
Anti-submarine defense (PLO)
Enemy submarines are one of the most significant threats to the Russian Navy. A particular threat is the possibility that enemy multipurpose nuclear submarines (PLA) can "sit on the tail" of Russian strategic missile submarine cruisers (SSBNs) when they leave their home bases, and then simultaneously destroy them as part of the enemy's application sudden disarming strike.
On the problems of Russian anti-submarine defense in general, and anti-submarine aviation in particular, it was repeatedly said on the pages of the Military Review. The UDC of project 23900 under construction is capable of carrying, according to various sources, about 16-20 helicopters. When solving the problems of PLO, UDC of project 23900 "Priboy", equipped with an air group consisting only of Ka-27M anti-submarine helicopters (or those that will replace them), is able to significantly enhance the anti-submarine capabilities of the Russian Navy, ensuring the safe deployment of SSBNs.
Helicopter Ka-27M of the Black Sea Fleet naval aviation. Photo function.mil.ru
The development of a modern anti-submarine helicopter and its large-scale production are one of the main priorities of the Russian Navy.
In addition to anti-submarine helicopters UDC project 23900 "Priboy" instead of landing ships can be carried in the dock chamber unmanned boats (BEC) и autonomous unmanned underwater vehicles (AUV), also optimized for anti-submarine missions.
Thus, in solving PLO problems, the UDC of project 23900 "Priboy" will not yield, and in some ways even surpass the "classic" aircraft carriers. Of course, this will only be so if the UDC is equipped with modern and effective anti-submarine helicopters, BEC and AUV.
Previously, the advantage of Nimitz-class aircraft carriers was the ability to carry carrier-based PLO aircraft, but now such aircraft are not in service with the US naval forces. Perhaps China will be the first to build carrier-based PLO aircraft in the new millennium. In any case, for the deployment of SSBNs, coastal-based ASW aircraft are quite enough. But PLO helicopters do not have a long flight range, so a floating airfield will be very useful for them.
Air defense (AA)
The most important task of an aircraft carrier is to provide air defense for an aircraft carrier / ship strike group (AUG / KUG). The best way to solve this problem can be aircraft carriers equipped with catapults capable of providing takeoff of airborne early warning aircraft (AWACS). In turn, carrier-based fighters should ensure the defeat of attacking aircraft and anti-ship missiles (ASM) of the enemy.
Of course, the capabilities of the UDC in this regard are much more modest, but, nevertheless, this type of ships is also capable of significantly strengthening the air defense of the KUG.
First of all, we are talking about AWACS helicopters - they are quite effectively used by those countries that cannot afford AWACS deck aircraft. For example, on the newest British aircraft carriers of the Queen Elizabeth type, it is the AWACS helicopters that are deployed - the absence of catapults prevents AWACS aircraft from being deployed, despite the aircraft carrier's impressive displacement of about 76 tons.
Helicopter AWACS Merlin HM2 Crowsnest. Photo en.wikipedia.org
The Russian Navy also has an AWACS helicopter - Ka-31. This model is already somewhat outdated, although it can be used, but still, the Russian Navy needs a new AWACS helicopter equipped with a modern radar station (radar) with an active phased antenna array (AFAR). Such a machine will be useful not only for the Navy, but also for providing air defense (air defense) of ground targets. When repelling massive attacks of low-flying air attack weapons (EAS), the possibility of increasing their detection range and the possibility of over-the-horizon destruction of missiles using target designation from AWACS helicopters will be extremely useful given the chronic shortage of AWACS aircraft of the A-50M type or promising A-100.
The development of a modern AWACS helicopter should become one of the most important priorities for both the Russian Navy and the Russian Air Defense Forces.
An AWACS helicopter can not only warn of the approach of enemy low-altitude air defense systems, but also carry out over-the-horizon guidance of anti-aircraft guided missiles (SAMs) with an active radar guidance head (ARL GOS) or an infrared homing head (IR GOS), such as those used in anti-aircraft - missile systems (SAM) "Polyment / Redut", which are equipped with modern Russian warships (or "land" S-350 "Vityaz"). Without an airplane / helicopter AWACS, the detection range of low-flying EHV will always be limited by the radio horizon. The presence of 4-6 AWACS helicopters on board the UDC will ensure their round-the-clock watch in the air during a threatened period.
Article The interaction of ground-based air defense missile systems and airplanes the risks of "friendly fire" were indicated - the defeat of air defense aviation by air defense missile systems due to the presence of many rapidly moving air targets and the operation of electronic warfare equipment. AWACS helicopters in such a situation will have a certain advantage - they can occupy a strictly defined echelon in the air, which will be excluded from the shelling sector of shipborne air defense systems.
The capabilities of the UDC air defense are not limited to the use of AWACS helicopters. In general, a helicopter is a rather difficult air target for the enemy. Air battles between planes and helicopters did not happen very often - most helicopters were not at all adapted for air combat. However, when they happened, the planes did not always come out victorious. There is no doubt about the destruction of an Iranian F-24 fighter jet by an Iraqi Mi-4 combat helicopter. There is also unconfirmed information about the destruction of the American F-24 fighter by the Syrian Mi-14 combat helicopter - and this is no longer a joke.
Nevertheless, helicopters of the past were poorly adapted for air battles, but now the situation is changing.
The newest Russian combat helicopter Ka-52M carries the Rezets radar with an active phased antenna array, including 640 transmit and receive modules (PPM), capable of detecting air targets at a distance of up to 50 kilometers. Previously, Ka-52 helicopters were tested with short-range air-to-air missiles. There are no technical obstacles to equipping the Ka-52M with both RVV-MD (short-range) missiles with an infrared homing head (IR seeker) and RVV-SD (medium-range) missiles with ARL seeker. In this case, target designation of the RVV-SD outside the range of the "Rezets" radar can be issued by AWACS helicopters. Similar solutions can be implemented on the Ka-52K naval combat helicopter.
The prototype of the Ka-52 combat helicopter with the R-73 short-range air-to-air missile. Photo wikipedia.org
Potentially, the Ka-52M / Ka-52K are capable of carrying 4 RVV-SD, or up to 8 RVV-MD, or 2 RVV-SD and 4 RVV-MD (in the worst case, 2 RVV-SD and 2 RVV-MD). Air-to-air missiles based on portable anti-aircraft missiles (MANPADS) or promising small-sized air-to-air missiles developed on the basis of missiles, a Ka-52 helicopter can take even more - about 16 missiles per combat vehicle (or even more ).
Thus, in the variant of manning an air group for solving air defense tasks, the UDC of project 23900 "Priboy" can carry 4-6 AWACS helicopters and 12-14 Ka-52K combat helicopters, capable of collectively lifting about 50-200 air-to-air missiles into the air of various types.
The advantage of combat helicopters, especially those placed on the UDC deck in advance, is their ability to take off as quickly as possible, quickly engaging in battle and avoiding the destruction of anti-ship missiles on the UDC deck.
The combination of AWACS helicopters, combat helicopters with air-to-air missiles and shipborne air defense systems, capable of receiving target designation from AWACS helicopters, will significantly increase the protection of shipborne strike groups from enemy air forces.
In the dock chamber, BECs can be placed, capable of carrying electronic warfare equipment, false targets and reconnaissance equipment, which additionally increase the capabilities of the KUG to repel an air raid.
Anti-ship capabilities
The capabilities of the Project 23900 Priboy UDC to combat enemy surface ships will be determined by the composition of its air group. And here the Russian Navy has a serious advantage. The fact is that the Ka-52K Katran combat helicopters presumably should be able to use the Kh-35 subsonic low-flying anti-ship cruise missiles with a firing range of up to 300 kilometers - a more modern analogue of the American Harpoon anti-ship missiles, as well as the Kh-31 anti-ship missiles with a flight speed of more than three strides and a flight range of about 100 kilometers.
From top to bottom - Ka-52K Katran carrier-based combat helicopter, Kh-35 and Kh-31 anti-ship missiles. Photo wikipedia.org
Thus, in the variant of manning with an air group for solving anti-ship tasks, the UDC of project 23900 "Priboy" can carry 4-6 AWACS helicopters and 12-14 Ka-52K combat helicopters, capable of collectively lifting 24-28 anti-ship missiles of various types into the air.
The interaction of AWACS helicopters capable of detecting enemy surface ships at a considerable distance, as well as combat helicopters capable of launching anti-ship missiles "from a jump", will make it possible to deliver sudden and rather intense anti-ship missile attacks against the enemy's KUG that does not have air support.
You can pay attention to the fact that the composition of the air group in the anti-ship version is the same as in the version of manning the air group for solving air defense missions - only the composition of the weapons will differ, that is, this type of UDC air group will be quite universal.
Do not forget about the possibility of using anti-tank weapons from combat helicopters, for example, the Hermes-A guided weapon system, with a firing range of about 15-20 kilometers - such ammunition can be effective against small ships and auxiliary ships of the enemy that do not have strong air defense ...
In the anti-ship version of the Project 23900 Priboy UDC, instead of air-cushion landing ships, they can carry BECs and AUVs, optimized for anti-ship missions, including reconnaissance, jamming, deploying sea mines and striking anti-ship missiles.
Projection of force
Let's make a small digression. One of the most important tasks of the fleet is expeditionary operations - what to do, in the real world it is not ideals that rule, but economic interests. Even the Soviet Union, despite its communist ideology, actively promoted its economic interests abroad.
Now we are capitalists - everyone wants to live well, and preferably even better. The trade balance of our country is such that a huge amount of household goods, attractive to ordinary citizens, is supplied from abroad. And those made in Russia often consist of foreign components. This situation will not change soon. Foreign goods are purchased for freely convertible currency, and this currency must be taken somewhere.
We have products that are interesting to many foreign countries - these are weapon, resources, food, nuclear power plants, and much more, and our own production of high-tech products with high added value is gradually developing.
The problem is that the free market exists only in the minds of especially "stubborn" liberals. In reality, the leading economies of the planet are mercilessly fighting for sales markets, sparing neither enemies nor allies (suffice it to recall the French, whom the United States put in a "well-known position" first with the Mistrals intended for Russia, and now with nuclear submarines, intended for Australia).
In other words, you will have to gnaw the place in the sun with your teeth - to displace unwanted regimes in third world countries, to support “ours”, to “push” allies a little and to “hint” to opponents. Considering that ninety percent of the world's trade is carried out through shipping, approximately 70 percent of the world's population lives within 100 kilometers of the seas and oceans, and most of the marine activities, such as merchant shipping, fishing and offshore oil and gas production , are carried out within a two-hundred-mile zone from the sea coast - the fleet must play one of the most important roles in solving these problems.
Most of the expeditionary wars in our time are waged by special operations forces (MTR), private military companies (PMCs), the supply of weapons and military advisers to "friendly" regimes.
Periodically, situations arise and will continue to arise when their own may need emergency air support - striking the enemy, delivering ammunition, and evacuating.
In such situations, UDC can prove to be an invaluable resource. In the expeditionary version of the Project 23900 Priboy UDC, 2-3 AWACS helicopters and 8-12 Ka-52K combat helicopters and 6-7 Ka-29 transport and combat helicopters (or transport and combat helicopters that will replace them) can be carried.
The combination of Ka-52K combat helicopters and Ka-29 transport and combat helicopters can be extremely effective for solving expeditionary missions. Photo wikipedia.org
The maximum range of the Ka-52K combat helicopters is about 500 kilometers, the Ka-29 transport and combat helicopters - about 350 kilometers. The use of outboard fuel tanks (PTB) will increase this range by about 20%. And this is not the limit.
Equipping combat and transport-combat helicopters, as well as PLO and AWACS helicopters with air refueling systems, should become another top priority for the Russian armed forces.
In this case, a part of the air group can act as fuel tankers, providing a significant increase in the range of combat and transport-combat helicopters, as well as the patrol time of PLO and AWACS helicopters.
Thus, the UDC of project 23900 Priboy can potentially provide a solution to the tasks of air support, supply and / or evacuation of MTR fighters, PMC specialists, military advisers, as well as other persons, within an approximately 500-kilometer zone from the coastline.
And of course, Project 23900 Priboy UDCs can not only provide air support, but also land about 1000 marines and 75 units of military and automotive equipment of various types. A decrease in the number of combat helicopters, and an increase in the number of transport-combat helicopters as part of the UDC air group, will make it possible to promptly supply the landing force and evacuate the wounded, while maintaining the possibility of air support (for example, the composition of the air group may be as follows: 2 AWACS helicopters and 4-6 Ka combat helicopters -52K and 10-12 Ka-29 transport and combat helicopters).
Someone will say that the expeditionary capabilities of the Project 23900 Priboy UDC will be limited to actions against third world countries. But we are not talking about actions against a stronger, or even equal enemy - no one is going to throw UDC against Japan or Turkey, and in general, expeditionary actions are just being carried out in third world countries. In addition, the reality is that without an extraordinary strain of forces and means, as well as huge losses, not a single country in the world, including the United States, will currently be able to conduct expeditionary operations or carry out a large-scale amphibious landing from the sea against states possessing any modern and a motivated military.
Conclusions
The UDC is only a means for deploying its air wing, landing force and its delivery vehicles. The effectiveness of the UDC itself depends on their composition and effectiveness.
Many of the complexes listed in the article are not yet available in the Russian armed forces - there is no modern AWACS helicopter, the PLO helicopters and the Ka-29 transport and landing helicopters are outdated, the Ka-52K Katran combat helicopters have not yet received all the capabilities described in this article: no BEC and AUV, capable of performing anti-submarine and anti-ship missions, to solve air defense missions. At the same time, two UDCs of project 23900 "Priboy" have already been laid and are under construction.
On the other hand - "there would be bones, but the meat will grow." The progressive development of promising weapon systems will make it possible to gradually build up the capabilities of the Project 23900 Priboy UDC and expand their functionality.
If the UDC project 23900 "Priboy" is fully equipped with the combat units described in this article, then the Russian Navy will receive an extremely flexible tool capable of solving strategic nuclear deterrence tasks (safe deployment of SSBNs), act in the interests of general-purpose forces (increasing the effectiveness of air defense KUG and strikes against anti-ship missiles), to defend the economic and political interests of the Russian Federation in the framework of expeditionary operations.
The potential of the Project 23900 Priboy UDC will be fully revealed when various options for air groups and amphibious forces are formed for them, both relatively universal and optimized for performing highly specialized tasks.
Information