Military Review

Several countries disappointed by Iran's decision to "not pay compensation" in the case of the downed Ukrainian Boeing

61

Among the passengers of flight PS752 of Ukraine International Airlines, which took off from Tehran airport on January 8 last year and suffered a plane crash, there were representatives of different states. Several countries, whose citizens were on the plane and died, are disappointed with Iran's decision "not to pay compensation" in the case of the Ukrainian Boeing shot down by its military.


According to the agency TASS, a joint statement was made in which Ukraine, Great Britain, Sweden and Canada expressed their position.

We remind the Islamic Republic of Iran that, in accordance with international law, it is obliged to pay reparations in full to a group of countries

- said in a statement.

If Tehran continues to persist, these four states will begin to demand that the Islamic Republic be held accountable at the international level, turning to the appropriate legal structures.

Shortly before this, Tehran’s representatives refused to participate in negotiations on compensation payments, which were scheduled for November 22.

Among the countries demanding compensation from Iran is Ukraine, whose military has already shot down foreign civilian planes in 2001 and 2014. In the latter case, Kiev refuses to admit its crime and tries to blame Russia for it.

It should be added that the above countries (Ukraine, Canada, Britain and Sweden) themselves rejected compensation of 900 thousand dollars for each victim. This size, offered by Tehran, did not suit the plaintiffs. At the same time, it was Ukraine that expressed and continues to express the greatest claims on the amount of compensation.
Photos used:
https://www.facebook.com/flyuia.ua/
61 comment
Ad

Subscribe to our Telegram channel, regularly additional information about the special operation in Ukraine, a large amount of information, videos, something that does not fall on the site: https://t.me/topwar_official

Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. Andrei Nikolaevich
    Andrei Nikolaevich 25 November 2021 09: 52
    +15
    Well, anything can happen. Ukrainians, piled up a bunch of planes and nothing .. Somehow they live and do not worry.
    1. KCA
      KCA 25 November 2021 10: 05
      +18
      Ukraine paid compensation for the downed TU-154 to Israeli citizens, no Russian citizens
      1. bukhach
        bukhach 25 November 2021 10: 08
        +13
        Well, you are like a little one, then the Jews, and then the goyim, you need to understand!
        1. KCA
          KCA 25 November 2021 10: 23
          +3
          So all the Jews were there, children were taken from Novosibirsk to Israel
          1. Kayala
            Kayala 25 November 2021 10: 42
            +1
            Of course, try not to pay Israel, they will leave you without the last pants! And Russia, Russia can not be paid, she is kind, forgives everyone everything.
            1. Alex777
              Alex777 25 November 2021 10: 49
              0
              You are too gullible. Kuchma did not admit his guilt, but he paid everyone.
              1. Kayala
                Kayala 25 November 2021 10: 54
                +1
                Maybe so, I really don't know the details. But even if so, then, as you yourself indicated, the skakuas paid 200 thousand dollars each, and from Iran, even 900 thousand is not enough for them.

                That's really the truth:
                Ho-hol will remain ho-crap
                You want to let him go to Europe
                Where to act with the mind
                ............. well, then you yourself know!
                1. Alex777
                  Alex777 25 November 2021 10: 55
                  +1
                  Quote: Kayala
                  The Skakuas paid 200 thousand dollars each, and from Iran they paid less than 900 thousand each.

                  Exactly.
                  Of course, the grief of the relatives of the victims cannot be measured with money, but the difference in numbers does not seem justified. hi
                  1. Edvid
                    Edvid 25 November 2021 11: 30
                    -12
                    I remember that for a relative who died on a downed passenger Boeing by the Iranian air defense, an American bought three hundred million dollars from Iran !! ...
                    1. Alex777
                      Alex777 25 November 2021 11: 35
                      +3
                      I remember that for a relative who died on a downed passenger Boeing by the Iranian air defense, an American bought three hundred million dollars from Iran !! ..

                      What are you talking about! fellow
                      The United States shot down an Iranian Airbus A3B1988-300 on July 2, 203.
                      In February 1996, an amicable agreement was signed between the United States and Iran, after which the case was dismissed in court. Under the terms of the agreement, the United States was to pay compensation in the amount of $ 131,8 million (including $ 61,8 million to the heirs of 248 dead, at the rate of $ 300 for each able-bodied victim and 000 for each dependent), and Iran waived further claims against USA in connection with this disaster.
                      Regretting the loss of life and calling the incident a terrible human tragedy, the US government nevertheless did not formally plead guilty and did not apologize for the incident.

                      When do you think Iran shot down an American Boeing?
                      1. Edvid
                        Edvid 26 November 2021 02: 04
                        0
                        An error occured with the theme, sorry:
                        https://healtheconomics.ru/news/item/amerikanka-otsudila-u-philip-morris-300-mln-dollarov
                      2. Alex777
                        Alex777 26 November 2021 12: 01
                        0
                        An error occured with the theme

                        It happens. wink
                    2. Avior
                      Avior 25 November 2021 13: 03
                      0
                      an American woman bought three hundred million dollars from Iran !! ...

                      on the contrary, Iran with Americans
                    3. Lionnvrsk
                      Lionnvrsk 25 November 2021 13: 48
                      0
                      Quote: Edvid
                      I remember that for a relative who died on a downed passenger Boeing by the Iranian air defense, an American bought three hundred million dollars from Iran !! ...

                      belay Are you by any chance not from Ukraine? repeat Mriyas are some incredible!
          2. SKVichyakow
            SKVichyakow 25 November 2021 11: 11
            -3
            Quote: KCA
            So all the Jews were there, children were taken from Novosibirsk to Israel

            it turns out our Jews are not considered them, and do not belong to the Jews.
            1. Alex777
              Alex777 25 November 2021 12: 00
              -1
              You are too gullible. Kuchma did not admit his guilt, but he paid everyone.
      2. Alex777
        Alex777 25 November 2021 10: 42
        +10
        Quote: KCA
        Ukraine paid compensation for the downed TU-154 to the citizens of Israel, but not to the citizens of Russia.

        In 2003, Ukraine signed intergovernmental agreements with Russia and Israel on compensation to the relatives of those killed in the plane crash without a legal admission of guilt. In accordance with these agreements, Ukraine paid $ 200 for each victim - $ 7,8 million to Russia and $ 7,5 million to Israel.

        Mislead the public.
      3. kig
        kig 25 November 2021 11: 40
        +2
        Quote: KCA
        Russian citizens do not


        Lenta.ru Dec 15, 2004: The Ukrainian Foreign Ministry transferred $ 7 to Russia to pay compensation to the relatives of the Russian passengers who died on the Tu-809 airliner shot down by the Ukrainian military over the Black Sea in October 660, RIA Novosti reports.
      4. Lionnvrsk
        Lionnvrsk 25 November 2021 13: 52
        +2
        Quote: KCA
        Ukraine paid compensation for the downed TU-154 to Israeli citizens, no Russian citizens

        Why did you come up with such crap? Had a dream or really want to kick into a puddle?
        In 2003, Ukraine signed intergovernmental agreements with Russia and Israel on compensation to the relatives of those killed in the plane crash without a legal admission of guilt. In accordance with these agreements, Ukraine paid $ 200 for each person killed - $ 7,8 million to Russia and $ 7,5 million to Israel.
    2. Civil
      Civil 25 November 2021 10: 17
      -8
      They say this is a muddy story ... not everything in it is unambiguous. They write everything on these filthy Internet. Here is the Persian.
      1. Alex777
        Alex777 25 November 2021 10: 51
        +4
        The Sumerians paid 200 thousand for each who died due to their fault,
        and Iran is told that 900 thousand are not enough. The Persians have not yet understood them.
      2. Kronos
        Kronos 25 November 2021 11: 50
        0
        Nothing muddy. Iran almost immediately acknowledged the shootdown.
        1. Civil
          Civil 25 November 2021 12: 11
          -6
          Quote: Kronos
          Nothing muddy. Iran almost immediately acknowledged the shootdown.

          Judging by the reaction and cons, something is not so clear.
  2. napalm
    napalm 25 November 2021 09: 56
    -1
    I wonder how much they would be happy with.
  3. svp67
    svp67 25 November 2021 09: 58
    +2
    Several countries disappointed by Iran's decision not to pay compensation for the downed Ukrainian Boeing
    The title of the article does not correspond to its content ... So far, that Iran has refused to negotiate compensation for the relatives of the victims of this tragedy, there is no talk of compensation for the plane in the article.
  4. Nafanya from the sofa
    Nafanya from the sofa 25 November 2021 10: 00
    +7
    The Superior Court of Ontario, Canada ruled that Iran deliberately shot down a Ukrainian UIA Boeing 737 aircraft in January 2020.

    The practice of courts to make decisions that extend beyond their jurisdiction will sooner or later lead to a complete halt of all international treaties and / or obligations. This will not lead to anything good. Humanity is strenuously "digging a hole" for itself.
    1. paul3390
      paul3390 25 November 2021 10: 33
      0
      Well, we also have the famous Basmanny Court .. So we need to be guided exclusively by the verdicts of the Basmachi in all international affairs !! In the image and likeness, so to speak ..
      1. vl903
        vl903 25 November 2021 12: 05
        0
        Quote: paul3390
        Well, we also have the famous Basmanny Court .. So we need to be guided exclusively by the verdicts of the Basmachi in all international affairs !! In the image and likeness, so to speak ..

        do not agree. High Syzran District Court should deal with international affairs in our country!
    2. abrakadabre
      abrakadabre 25 November 2021 10: 52
      +5
      The practice of courts to make decisions that extend beyond their jurisdiction will sooner or later lead to a complete halt of all international treaties and / or obligations.
      Iran needs to play this game about the supranational jurisdiction of the courts. Namely: in case of appeal to some kind of foreign court, to start office work on the fact of a criminal offense: interference in the internal affairs of the country and an attempt on the foundations of the constitutional order. In short, in this vein.
      Moreover, refer to the consideration in court of some of the most provincial regions - bakhsha. And then any district courts in New York can hear cases of this level, while others cannot. It is essential to conduct business precisely in the wilderness, in some southeastern Baluchistan, but to widely cover it at the highest national and international level. Record keeping on recognition of the composition of the court as an anti-government terrorist and criminal group. With corresponding sentences and appeals to Interpol for search, arrest and extradition.
      It is also feigned "from the master's shoulder" then to replace possible death sentences for 10-20 years or life imprisonment.
      The stump is clear that it will be a comedy. Nobody will turn anyone over to Iran. But why not troll the West? Referring to their numerous precedents. And then the Exceptional do this all the time.
      1. igor67
        igor67 25 November 2021 11: 14
        0
        Quote: abrakadabre
        The practice of courts to make decisions that extend beyond their jurisdiction will sooner or later lead to a complete halt of all international treaties and / or obligations.
        Iran needs to play this game about the supranational jurisdiction of the courts. Namely: in case of appeal to some kind of foreign court, to start office work on the fact of a criminal offense: interference in the internal affairs of the country and an attempt on the foundations of the constitutional order. In short, in this vein.
        Moreover, refer to the consideration in court of some of the most provincial regions - bakhsha. And then any district courts in New York can hear cases of this level, while others cannot. It is essential to conduct business precisely in the wilderness, in some southeastern Baluchistan, but to widely cover it at the highest national and international level. Record keeping on recognition of the composition of the court as an anti-government terrorist and criminal group. With corresponding sentences and appeals to Interpol for search, arrest and extradition.
        It is also feigned "from the master's shoulder" then to replace possible death sentences for 10-20 years or life imprisonment.
        The stump is clear that it will be a comedy. Nobody will turn anyone over to Iran. But why not troll the West? Referring to their numerous precedents. And then the Exceptional do this all the time.

        Iranians opened a criminal case over the shooting down of the plane and attracted qisuda 10 military personnel
      2. Avior
        Avior 25 November 2021 11: 36
        -4
        Iran needs to play this game about the supranational jurisdiction of the courts.

        that is exactly what Iran did in its time - sued the United States for the Iranian airliner shot down in 1988 by the Americans by mistake in the International Court of Justice.
        The Americans paid compensation without waiting for a court decision.
        1. abrakadabre
          abrakadabre 25 November 2021 12: 05
          +2
          that is exactly what Iran did in its time - sued the United States for the Iranian airliner shot down in 1988 by the Americans by mistake in the International Court of Justice.
          The Americans paid compensation without waiting for a court decision.
          You do deliberately confusing warm with soft. Namely:
          Iran in this particular case agreed to issue compensation - 900 thousand despicable US dollars for the deceased. They all refused and now they are extorting more. Exactly they extort. To which Iran sent everyone on an erotic journey on foot. Now they are threatening the court. It was about this that I suggested that the Iranians should undertake a little oncoming movements. For there is nothing.
          And there is no need to shame me with victims here. Iran was not the first to raise the turbid wave. The grief of relatives and the fair payment of compensation for the victims, the Western countries, which drive this wave, are of the last interest. Therefore, the counter movement of Iran should be similar.
          1. Avior
            Avior 25 November 2021 13: 08
            +1
            You are deliberately confusing warm with soft. Namely:
            Iran in this particular case agreed to issue compensation - 900 thousand despicable US dollars for the deceased. They all refused and now they are extorting more. Exactly they extort.

            I don’t want to use words like “primitive lies”, so I’ll write softly - you don’t need to blindly believe what you have written, the article is misleading, Iran did not offer such amounts of compensation.
  5. Troll
    Troll 25 November 2021 10: 04
    +6
    As such, the international law referred to by these few countries does not exist. There are direct agreements between countries. And if, according to any treaty between Iran and England on an accidentally shot down plane, the country must pay a penalty, then yes, Iran is violating this treaty. But the problem is that such a contract does not exist and only private insurance companies bear losses in the form of insurance payments.
  6. rotmistr60
    rotmistr60 25 November 2021 10: 21
    -2
    Ukraine, UK, Sweden and Canada
    Maybe Ukraine was first told about international law (the downed Tu-154, and sooner or later the Malaysian Boeing will emerge)?
  7. askort154
    askort154 25 November 2021 10: 33
    -1
    (Ukraine, Canada, Britain and Sweden) have themselves rejected compensation of $ 900 for each victim.

    Even for the Canadian-British-Swedes, the amount is not small.
    And for Ukraine it is fabulous. And she sobbed, cursed, but - signed a refusal.
  8. Bradley
    Bradley 25 November 2021 10: 34
    -5
    Is 900 thousand dollars a lot? They could have brought it to at least 1 million.
    1. Avior
      Avior 25 November 2021 11: 02
      -2
      You can compose a million. Iran did not offer such compensation.
  9. Avior
    Avior 25 November 2021 11: 01
    -4
    It should be added that the above countries (Ukraine, Canada, Britain and Sweden) themselves rejected compensation of 900 thousand dollars for each victim.

    The author is a notable storyteller. Iran did not offer such amounts of compensation.
    1. The leader of the Redskins
      The leader of the Redskins 25 November 2021 11: 29
      +2
      Not only a storyteller, but also a supreme judge. Not a single investigation into the plane downed in 2014 has ended. The Dutch court has not yet passed a verdict, and the author has already hanged this case on Ukraine.
      1. Roman_vh
        Roman_vh 25 November 2021 17: 26
        0
        Who do you want to hang on?
        Or has it all been hanged?
        1. The leader of the Redskins
          The leader of the Redskins 25 November 2021 17: 33
          +2
          If I had authority, evidence and facts, I would have made a statement long ago and laid out all of the above. But surrounded by all that array of information and fakes, I can only declare like one of the greats:
          "All I know is that I know nothing."
          Therefore, I am in no hurry to hang labels on anyone.
          1. Roman_vh
            Roman_vh 25 November 2021 17: 35
            0
            And why so, the "partners" over there are not afraid of labels, which means that we are not forbidden.
      2. Astronomy
        Astronomy 25 November 2021 23: 45
        +1
        Quote: Leader of the Redskins
        The Dutch court has not yet passed a verdict, and the author has already hanged this case on Ukraine.

        Court in Amsterdam - in the court complex "Schiphol".
        these are 4 suspects. (3 citizens of Russia and 1 of Ukraine)
        He cannot blame the country.
        But the Grand Chamber of the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) will hold hearings on the admissibility of the case "Ukraine and the Netherlands v. Russia", which unites three large cases (nos. 8019/16, 43800/14 and 28525/20). Postponed until January 26 2022 year. There is MH17 and war and so on. Even the removal of children ..
        There is a lot in common between them. The materials of the district court will participate in the ECHR.
        And there is a lot of evidence. But the trial is underway. The defense always has the opportunity to challenge.
  10. iouris
    iouris 25 November 2021 11: 23
    -2
    During a shootout with the United States and Iran, civilian planes must hide. The FAC is guilty, who made a "responsible decision". Himself or was it demanded of him?
  11. Santa Fe
    Santa Fe 25 November 2021 11: 32
    -5
    Iran is inadequate, but very useful in the fight against Israel. Therefore, in this situation, we should support all decisions of Tehran.

    And in general, from the perspective of the Iranians, why pay compensation right away if there is no need for it?
    1. Roman_vh
      Roman_vh 25 November 2021 17: 28
      0
      And what, and we have someone fighting with Israel?
      I didn’t know.
      1. Santa Fe
        Santa Fe 26 November 2021 11: 21
        0
        The Soviet and Russian leadership has always supported and armed those who directly stated that this state should not exist
        1. Roman_vh
          Roman_vh 27 November 2021 00: 19
          0
          Jews armed and are arming Georgians and Ukrainians, let alone Europeans and Americans. And sho? Are they fighting with Russia?
  12. vl903
    vl903 25 November 2021 12: 02
    +1
    here is a pure setup from the Americans. let them pay.
  13. prior
    prior 25 November 2021 12: 10
    0
    They whipped up military hysteria around Iran - they got a shot down Ukrainian plane.
    Now they are whipping up military hysteria around Russia ...
    Even wondering who will fall under the hot hand and what will be left of him ?!
  14. Lukash
    Lukash 25 November 2021 12: 38
    -4
    Why point out in the article that in 2014 Russia allegedly shot down a Boeing and "Kiev refuses to admit its crime and is trying to blame Russia for it"? The court in the Netherlands has already admitted the guilt of Ukraine in this episode, Russia was able to prove its complete innocence. Operate with facts, not speculation.
    1. Avior
      Avior 25 November 2021 13: 14
      -3
      The court in the Netherlands has already admitted the guilt of Ukraine in this episode, Russia was able to prove its complete innocence.

      Primitive lies - what else is there to add?
      1. Korax71
        Korax71 25 November 2021 15: 13
        -4
        15 shirts for a comment do not just fall, so you have to compose wassat
        1. Roman_vh
          Roman_vh 25 November 2021 17: 29
          -2
          Are they paying you such pennies? And what, you are not sorry for the manicure?
      2. Roman_vh
        Roman_vh 25 November 2021 17: 30
        -3
        The prosecutor will add.
  15. Looking for
    Looking for 25 November 2021 17: 41
    -1
    Quote: Alex777
    You are too gullible. Kuchma did not admit his guilt, but he paid everyone.

    and you can find out the basis for such a statement?
    1. Avior
      Avior 25 November 2021 18: 55
      -1
      In accordance with the Claims Settlement Agreement signed by Russia and Ukraine on December 26, 2003, the Ukrainian government transferred $ 7 to pay relatives of the deceased Russian passengers. Compensation was paid ex gratia, that is, without recognition of legal liability [809]. Relatives of Israeli passengers were paid $ 660 million [52].

      https://ru.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Катастрофа_Ту-154_над_Чёрным_морем
  16. zloybond
    zloybond 25 November 2021 18: 23
    0
    It is more interesting about Mmoldavia - they will demand a debt, turn off the gas or so we will play with a wide soul))) ???
  17. Astronomy
    Astronomy 25 November 2021 23: 57
    +1
    It should be added that the above countries (Ukraine, Canada, Britain and Sweden) themselves rejected compensation of 900 thousand dollars for each victim. This size, offered by Tehran, did not suit the plaintiffs. At the same time, it was Ukraine that expressed and continues to express the greatest claims on the amount of compensation.

    I was looking for where the author got the amount - except for a link to Topvar, I could not find it.
    Iran offered 80 thousand to Ukraine. Ukraine rejected it.
    In December 2020, the Iranian authorities agreed to pay the family of each victim of what happened to the Ukrainian plane for $ 150 thousand in compensation.
    This is less than the United States, Ukraine paid 20 years ago even to the same Iranians.
    Ukraine demands because this is its plane. Her crew. It is in demand from others, since it is a Ukrainian state-owned airline.
    Actually, for an example, I found this:
    At the end of 2015, the Ingosstrakh company paid the relatives of the victims of the plane crash about 700 thousand rubles per person who died. They received another 1 million rubles each from the state and 150 thousand each from the airline. The lawyer Anatoly Kucherena then called the insurance payments scanty.
    In early 2016, a group of 30 relatives filed claims in Egyptian courts against Kogalymavia and Ingosstrakh for moral damages in the amount of $ 3 million for each victim.
  18. Ilgizl
    Ilgizl 26 November 2021 10: 58
    0
    Iran, our strategic partner, can be on the case to express concern and support.