Military Review

"There is no Afghan army anymore, but it was in the middle of the list in terms of its power": experts criticized the GFP rating of the world's armies

38

A version of the ranking of the armies of the countries of the world is being discussed on the network. It was presented some time ago by specialists of the analytical center GFP (Global Firepower). The authors of the study say that they studied the power and combat effectiveness of the armies of the world according to fifty different criteria. At the same time, armies of 2021 states of the world entered the global ranking by mid-140.


The top three in the rating looked like this: the US Army, the Russian Armed Forces, and the People's Liberation Army of China. The coefficient of the American army in the rating is 0,0718 (ideally 0). Russia has 0,0791.

It is noteworthy that, as Western analysts write, the research then clearly did not take into account the trends associated, among other things, with the state of affairs in Afghanistan. It is likely that in this case, it would come to revise the items "Military planning" and "Conducting special operations", which are also studied when compiling the rating. Obvious problems arose with the planning of the operation to withdraw US troops from Afghan territory. At the same time, the American army had to practically surrender all its positions to the militants. At the same time, the militants received huge reserves of American weapons.

In the five strongest armies in the world, the armies of India and Japan were named. At the same time, the Japanese army, according to the compilers of the rating, is more powerful than, for example, the armies of France and Great Britain, which have a nuclear arsenal. This fact is criticized by experts from the International Institute for Security Analysis, who believe that the real power of the Japanese self-defense forces is clearly exaggerated.

The Turkish army was put on the 11th line, believing that the Brazilian army is two positions higher in terms of its power.

The Iranian army is considered by the compilers of the rating list to be more powerful than the German army. And the most powerful army from the countries of the post-Soviet space (not counting Russia) is considered by the authors of the rating to be the Ukrainian armed forces. They were placed in the middle of the third decade - between the armies of Vietnam and Thailand. The army of the Republic of Belarus is considered worthy of only the 50th place - at the level of the armies of Chile and Uzbekistan. The Azerbaijani troops were "assigned" the number of points, which puts them only on the 63rd position.



Following them is the Syrian army, which literally daily participates in hostilities with the use of various weapons.

Particular attention is drawn to the Afghan army, which was placed in 75th place. This is taking into account the fact that the Afghan army as such does not actually exist at the moment after its total defeat by the militants of the Taliban terrorist group (banned in the Russian Federation).

Experts note that if the power of the Afghan army really corresponded to the indicated place, then most of the soldiers and officers today would continue to fight in their positions and would not surrender the city as if it were a “game on paper”:

This analysis once again proves its complete inconsistency. There is no longer any Afghan army. But she was put in the middle of the ranking of the armies of the world. Then questions about other positions - how much they correspond to objective reality.
Photos used:
Twitter / Ministry of Defense of Afghanistan, Ministry of Defense of Azerbaijan
38 comments
Ad

Subscribe to our Telegram channel, regularly additional information about the special operation in Ukraine, a large amount of information, videos, something that does not fall on the site: https://t.me/topwar_official

Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. alex neym_2
    alex neym_2 2 September 2021 13: 35
    +13
    "Reckoning" and "being" - in my opinion, these are two different things, which Afghan showed: no matter how much money you give, no weapons without a fighting spirit, no army can withstand an ideologically grounded enemy. And the experts draw their conclusions sitting on the couch and for a long, long time "think" what to come up with for the sake of money giving ...
    1. Finches
      Finches 2 September 2021 13: 53
      +10
      It's better to be than to seem ... And all these ratings are complete bullshit, in fact!
      1. Trapp1st
        Trapp1st 2 September 2021 14: 31
        +1
        And all these ratings are complete bullshit, in fact!
        Naturally bullshit, everyone knows whose army is the strongest in Europe))
    2. gohomeyanki
      gohomeyanki 2 September 2021 15: 37
      0
      The spirit is there, the possession of weapons is also there.
      But the desire to fight for the occupation government is not very good. But by the way, they have it mutually. Ghani jumped into the helicopter or whatever he had there, loaded his belongings, and flew away before his patron.
  2. Cron
    Cron 2 September 2021 13: 35
    +2
    "There is no Ukrainian army anymore, but it was one of the strongest in Europe": experts criticized the words of Poroshenko and Zelensky
    1. mvg
      mvg 2 September 2021 15: 07
      -13
      she was one of the strongest in Europe

      Ukraine has "tested" all its troops in Donbass .. has 1000+ tanks, while the modernization is higher than the T-72B3. There is a PMC with good training .. What kind of aviation remained. Who has that much in Europe? Poland, Germany?
      It's too early to write off 404. She's been written off for 20 years, but she lives.
      1. Cron
        Cron 2 September 2021 15: 54
        +6
        Quote: mvg
        Ukraine has "tested" all its troops in Donbass .. has 1000+ tanks, while the modernization is higher than the T-72B3. There is a PMC with good training .. What kind of aviation remained. Who has that much in Europe? Poland, Germany?

        Do you laugh when you write all this, or do you seriously?
        Yes, everyone saw how they rolled all their troops in cauldrons. Two capitulations in the form of Minsk, after two boilers.
        Tanks says modernized. What's the point if their aviation crumbles to dust? The only thing I want to wish them is such geniuses as you are in the leadership.

        It's too early to write off 404. She's been written off for 20 years, but she lives.

        And who writes them off? Grief experts? The powerful of this world, on the contrary, are trying to blind this misunderstanding with everyone so that it does not fall apart. Why shouldn't she live? Do you see some kind of miracle in this or what?
        1. dauria
          dauria 2 September 2021 16: 17
          0
          Yes, everyone saw how they rolled all their troops in cauldrons.


          Well, "for one beaten two unbeaten give" - ​​Russian wisdom. Do not forget. Another thing is that for it government this the army will not fight. At the same time, one can recall the mighty army of the USSR. What's the point?
          These ratings do not include the main thing - the people, their attitude to a particular war. Otherwise, an incident may turn out - the coolest army will spit, scratch its turnips and go home.
        2. The comment was deleted.
          1. The comment was deleted.
        3. The comment was deleted.
      2. Zoomlion
        Zoomlion 2 September 2021 19: 15
        +1
        By all indicators, Belarus is alone, on its own, Ukraine is being rolled into asphalt
      3. paul3390
        paul3390 2 September 2021 19: 16
        0
        Ukraine "tested" all its troops in Donbass .. has 1000+ tanks, while the modernization is higher than the T-72B3.

        Well - if you call a massive drape run-in .. what Then Aloizievich robust Wehrmacht upgraded at Stalingrad! laughing

        And - how much did they modernize there? Five pieces? Ten? In addition, the thesis is rather dubious about the above, given the real capabilities of the current Tsegabonia and the quality of the source material in the form of the T-64.
      4. abrakadabre
        abrakadabre 3 September 2021 08: 25
        +3
        has 1000+ tanks, while the upgrade is higher than the T-72B3.
        You mean those that are already overgrown with trees?

        Or about such an upgrade:
      5. VORON538
        VORON538 6 September 2021 15: 04
        -1
        Your "poles" will not help you, as always. However, you can go straight from your battle couch straight into battle, as you wanted :))) A Ukrainian who does not live in a war would go to his censor to his colleagues in misfortune :))) There you have such a legion of warriors :)))
  3. rocket757
    rocket757 2 September 2021 13: 36
    +2
    "There is no Afghan army anymore, but it was in the middle of the list in terms of its power": experts criticized the GFP rating of the world's armies
    All the ratings there are very "cool" .... it's better not to remember about truthfulness, or rather about the inflatedness of their criteria for choosing and assigning the most, most.
    1. lucul
      lucul 2 September 2021 14: 16
      -1
      All the ratings there are very "cool" .... it's better not to remember about truthfulness, or rather about the inflatedness of their criteria for choosing and assigning the most, most.

      Just one of the elements of large-scale Western propaganda.
      1. rocket757
        rocket757 2 September 2021 14: 39
        +1
        Yes, PR, advertising, propaganda, if not ALL of them, then certainly a lot.
  4. Uncle lee
    Uncle lee 2 September 2021 13: 37
    +1
    This analysis once again proves its complete inconsistency.
    All these calculations are paper casuistry, nothing more! feel
  5. Speedy
    Speedy 2 September 2021 13: 52
    +10
    It is taught that the Taliban (banned on the territory of the Russian Federation) have the strongest army in the world after the type of defeat of the United States))
    1. VORON538
      VORON538 2 September 2021 14: 54
      -1
      Did the United States win in Afghanistan? Judging by what is happening there, the Americans just fled in time. hi
      1. Speedy
        Speedy 2 September 2021 15: 06
        0
        Well, I wrote "like")). The students think they have won.
  6. APASUS
    APASUS 2 September 2021 14: 07
    +3
    This is taking into account the fact that the Afghan army as such does not actually exist at the moment after its total defeat by the militants of the Taliban terrorist group (banned in the Russian Federation).

    So it was the Taliban who took the place of the Afghan army and that's it, just fix it
    1. aybolyt678
      aybolyt678 2 September 2021 14: 23
      +4
      Quote: APASUS
      So it was the Taliban who took the place of the Afghan army and that's it, just fix it

      do not tell me, now the coefficient of the USA needs to be removed and the Taliban add points for the technique smile
      1. APASUS
        APASUS 2 September 2021 14: 28
        +2
        Quote: aybolyt678
        e tell me, now the coefficient of the USA needs to be removed and the Taliban add points for the technique

        After escaping from Afghanistan, the United States can safely bet on China.
        1. aybolyt678
          aybolyt678 2 September 2021 21: 09
          +1
          Quote: APASUS
          After escaping from Afghanistan, the United States can safely bet on China.

          And if the escape is just a military operation with a certain information cover? after all, do not forget that the United States has a doctrine: organized chaos and the theory of the core (buying key figures), while everything is in accordance request
          1. APASUS
            APASUS 3 September 2021 08: 55
            0
            Quote: aybolyt678
            And if the escape is just a military operation with a certain information cover?

            The operation has just been performed with an ax. I understand that the noise raised at the Kabul airport is a cover. The Americans do not want to be asked questions about the transfer of weapons to terrorists
            1. aybolyt678
              aybolyt678 3 September 2021 14: 22
              0
              Quote: APASUS
              I understand that the noise raised at the Kabul airport is a cover

              still unloading dead US Marines, Biden watch .....
  7. Stepan S
    Stepan S 2 September 2021 14: 55
    +1
    The objective reality of the specialists of the analytical center GFP (Global Firepower) turned out to be purely subjective.
    It is convenient to sit in the office to arrange the coefficients in the boxes and draw conclusions based on "alternative mathematics" belay
  8. sen
    sen 2 September 2021 15: 07
    +1
    The Taliban began selling American-made military equipment to Iran.
    Iran International reports.
    Photos with American military equipment are circulating on social networks, including tanks and Hummers being transported towards Tehran.
    https://mignews.com/news/technology/taliby-nachali-peredachu-amerikanskoj-tehniki-iranu.html
    1. alch3mist
      alch3mist 2 September 2021 18: 21
      0
      The Taliban began selling American-made military equipment to Iran.

      Even if it's just trolling, it's still good. Neither the exceptional, nor the chosen of God clearly did not count on this.
  9. Denis812
    Denis812 2 September 2021 16: 31
    +5
    Some kind of stupidity.
    The rating is intended for comparison with other armies of the world, and not for predicting "what will happen if the higher ranks who are supposed to control the army are overthrown."
    That way we can say that the USSR had an army in last place in the world.
    Well, what - the USSR collapsed. With all its millions of soldiers and a bunch of missiles and tanks.
  10. iouris
    iouris 2 September 2021 17: 35
    0
    But the Afghan Taliban (banned in the Russian Federation) became No. 14 in terms of military power, and maybe No. 6. Wait and see.
    1. abrakadabre
      abrakadabre 3 September 2021 08: 32
      0
      But the Afghan Taliban (banned in the Russian Federation) became No. 14 in terms of military power, and maybe No. 6. Wait and see.
      It is also interesting where the Saudis and the Houthis are in this rating.
  11. Going
    Going 2 September 2021 18: 01
    0
    This analysis once again proves its complete inconsistency. There is no longer any Afghan army. But she was put in the middle of the ranking of the armies of the world.


    They flattered the United States, all these ratings are far from the truth.
  12. Arian
    Arian 2 September 2021 18: 39
    0
    Do not forget, on whose money all sorts of supposedly "independent" agencies, expert groups, etc. are fed and supported. Here is the full embodiment of the phrase: who pays and calls the tune. The French army in 1940 was also considered the strongest in Europe.
  13. alch3mist
    alch3mist 3 September 2021 00: 56
    0
    It was presented some time ago by specialists of the analytical center GFP (Global Firepower).

    And they do not hesitate: Hitler's GFP was called the Secret Field Police (GeheimFeldsPolitsai), the sister of the Gestapo.
  14. Tuzik
    Tuzik 3 September 2021 10: 15
    0
    bullshit these are all ratings, and financial is the same
  15. KONSTANTIN LUGANSKY
    KONSTANTIN LUGANSKY 3 September 2021 20: 28
    0
    Let's be frank, there is no stronger Russian army today
  16. Ismail Mowsumow
    Ismail Mowsumow 4 September 2021 07: 47
    0
    And who knows the realties of another military rating, an analogue of this global fireover? Throw off if not difficult