200 years since the Battle of Borodino

32
200 years since the Battle of BorodinoRussia 7 September marks the 200 anniversary of the battle of Borodino. AT stories The country is one of the most important battles, both because of its importance during the Patriotic War 1812, and the role of the memory of this battle in the formation of the national consciousness of the people.

Most of the ceremonial events dedicated to the battle, including the reconstruction of the battle on the Borodino field near Moscow, were held on September 2. But exactly 200 years from the day Russian and French troops stood on this field to death against each other, it is still being celebrated today. Although here, as in many other moments surrounding the history of the battle, there are differences. In 1812 Russia lived in the old style, according to which the battle took place on August 26. The French on the same day were 7 September. At the same time, the federal law “On the days of military glory and memorable dates of Russia” points to September 8 during the battle. The reason for the discrepancy is that when preparing the law in 1995. the date was calculated based on the fact that the discrepancy between the old and the new style was 13 days. However, this is true for the beginning of the 20th century, and in 1812g. the difference between the two styles was only 12 days.

Public Council for the Promotion of the State Commission on Preparations for the Celebration of the 200 Anniversary of the Victory of Russia in the Patriotic War 1812. previously proposed to make the necessary clarifications in federal law. At the same time, the traditional reconstruction of the Battle of Borodino, which takes place annually and to which the main celebratory events were timed this time, is usually held on the first weekend of September.

There is another controversial point in the history of Borodin - the question of winners. In a report to Emperor Alexander I, the commander of the Russian army, Mikhail Kutuzov, reported on his victory. However, on the tomb of Napoleon Borodino is listed among the greatest triumphs of the French commander. Usually, in such disputes, they recall the saying of the French emperor that the French showed themselves worthy of victory, and the Russians deserved the right to be invincible. True, Napoleon himself did not use this “formulation” in his memoirs — one of his generals, Jean-Jacques Germain Pele, leads it. Supporters of the "French" victory indicate that the troops of M. Kutuzov left the main fortifications on the Borodino field and surrendered Moscow, their opponents - that the army was nevertheless saved. But the fact that it was the main, most difficult and fierce battle of the 1812 war, no one doubts.

In history it often happens that the importance of an event is realized much later than how it happened, or the interpretation of its meaning changes to the opposite. With the battle of Borodino and World War 1812g. this did not happen. Already in 1814g. The date of the final expulsion of Napoleon's troops from Russia - December 25 - becomes one of the main holidays of the empire. In 1814, to the return of Russian troops from Paris, in Moscow and St. Petersburg were built Triumphal arches, in 1834g. The Alexander Column was built in St. Petersburg, and in 1837, during the celebration of Borodin's 25 anniversary, a decision was made to build the Cathedral of Christ the Savior.

Emperor Nicholas I gave a new shine to the celebration of victory. He paid special attention to the Borodino field. In 1839 a monument to Russian soldiers was erected here and a museum was founded. At the same time, the first "reconstruction" of the battle took place, during which 120 thousand soldiers of the regular army were involved.

However, with the greatest scope, the victory was celebrated in 1912, which was the centenary of the battle. Celebrations then held 25-29 August (old style), that is, in the days of the Battle of Borodino and the previous battles. A special touch was the presence at the celebrations of war veterans 1812. In total, the 25 empire turned out to be such people between the ages of 108 and 122 years, including the participant of the Borodino battle, Pavel Tolstoguzov, who was 112 years old. But only five veterans were able to arrive in Moscow. The famous panorama of the Battle of Borodino was created for the 100 anniversary.

The memory of Borodino manifested itself not only in museums and monuments. Already for younger contemporaries, the name of a village near Moscow turned into a symbol. For Mikhail Lermontov, the symbol of this feat in the era of “heroes of our time”, for Alexander Pushkin in the poem “The Borodino Anniversary” - a symbol of the power of Russia, able to withstand the military power of all Europe, for Leo Tolstoy - a symbol of the national spirit.

After the October Revolution, for a while, assessments of the 1812 war. changed - in the historical works devoted to her, the shortcomings of tsarism and the "anti-people" nature of the conflict were emphasized. The peasants, according to this interpretation, defended their homes from marauders, and not the Fatherland, and the reasons for the war were the contradictions of the leading bourgeois powers (Russia was not among them and as a result played a secondary role in the history of the Napoleonic wars) . At the beginning of the 30's the museum was plundered, the symbols of the Russian statehood were torn down, the temple of the Smolensk Icon of the Mother of God, erected in memory of the fallen, became a workshop.

However, when in the war years the struggle against the invasion of the “two-tongues” again became topical, the previous assessments of the 1812 events returned. Perhaps for the fallen at the Borodino field in 1812g. the best sign of memory was the fierce resistance that the soldiers of the Red Army put to the fascist troops in the battles of Borodino in October 1941. In December of the same year, the museum reopened, albeit in evacuation in Almaty. The Museum-Reserve on the Borodino field reopened to the 150 anniversary of the battle - in 1961, while the temple was restored.
Our news channels

Subscribe and stay up to date with the latest news and the most important events of the day.

32 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. +1
    7 September 2012 08: 27
    Plus article - definitely. There is respect for the feat of the Russian Soldier, there is a brief excursion into History, and there are critical assessments of events.
    Eternal glory and memory, who laid down their heads in that battle, upholding the independence and power of Russia!
    1. +2
      7 September 2012 09: 16
      It is good that remembering such dates raises the spirit and patriotism. But we must also remember other victories so that our children are proud and grow up on the exploits of fathers and grandfathers.
      good
    2. +6
      7 September 2012 09: 59
      Quote: esaul
      There is respect for the feat of the Russian Soldier


      And I have respect for the feat of the Russian General who fought and died together with their soldiers
      A.A. was killed Clouds, injured Vorontsov, K. Mecklenburg, Bagration shell-shocked Neverovsky
      1. Gavrilon
        0
        7 September 2012 12: 49
        The article is a huge plus !!! The education of today's youth, especially boys, should be based on examples of the greatest heroism of their people !!! And I dare gentlemen to notice that now very often certain people (even dumbly call them that) try to rewrite history, showing what barbarians the Russians were, and these holidays, dates, and just the very attitude to native history will very well affect the education of future generations.
    3. 0
      7 September 2012 13: 47
      Glory to our soldiers!
      1. 0
        7 September 2012 16: 34
        I congratulate you! Drink for our intolerant ancestors who offended the French at 100, otherwise I’ve been blindfolded for a month now drinks
  2. Svistoplyaskov
    +3
    7 September 2012 08: 28

    In the country since ancient times
    The number of illustrious husbands;
    The people are powerful, strong
    Yes serves the whole universe
    An example of true glory! ..
    May ancient morals be preserved -
    May Russian blood not cool down -
    Love for the Fatherland! (A. Pisarev)
    1. +2
      7 September 2012 08: 38
      Svistoplyaskov,

      Greetings, Michael! Frame - CLASS! The war of 1812 and the events preceding and following it are my old "historical love".
      1. Svistoplyaskov
        +3
        7 September 2012 09: 05
        Hello Valery, I also like "the time of the Napoleonic wars", apparently thanks to Russian literature, which gave that time a certain aura of nobility and gallant heroism!
        1. +4
          7 September 2012 10: 15
          Quote: Whistling
          Hello Valery, I also like "the time of the Napoleonic wars", apparently thanks to Russian literature, which gave that time a certain aura of nobility and gallant heroism!


          Well, nobility and gallantry were present indisputably. including the French.

          Here is one small episode.

          The granddaughter of Suvorov left Moscow.
          Stumbled upon a detour of the French dragoons.
          She introduced herself ....
          Having learned that the French were the granddaughter of the great Suvorov ... they saluted right away and accompanied her for a long time in order to save her from possible troubles.
          1. +4
            7 September 2012 11: 04
            Quote: volkan
            Well, nobility and gallantry were present indisputably. including the French.


            Another episode

            Davout caused particular dislike in Russia for his behavior during the French stay in Moscow: he arranged for himself a bedroom and an office in the altar of the Chudov Monastery
            by the way, each officer had his own horse; all were dressed in church robes, a sure proof of the robbery of Orthodox churches; and Colonel Dulfus had a lot of booty, consisting mainly of expensive church items.
            1. +3
              7 September 2012 12: 07
              Vadivak

              I agree ... this also happened.

              Therefore, I say that there was respect and nobility, but of course there was bestiality.

              Once again, the idea confirms that war largely depends on the personal qualities of specific people in specific situations.
              1. wax
                0
                10 September 2012 00: 47
                And here is the story with the nobility and filth of the same Frenchman at different stages of the 12 year war. And this man is Napoleon himself. Upon entering Smolensk, he visited the Holy Assumption Cathedral (which, incidentally, the Poles desecrated 200 years before) and ordered his own not to touch anything there, and even put up security. When retreating from Moscow, he ordered to blow up the Moscow Kremlin.
            2. Perseus
              +1
              7 September 2012 17: 31
              Without this, it does not happen, this is still a war and not an excursion. This war is not in vain called the "last war of gentlemen", because there were neither tortured prisoners by thousands, nor plundered and destroyed cities with the slaughtered local population, the French, by the way, for robbery and violence against the locals were punished in the flesh to death, followed this personally Napoleon. Although it rather depends not on the time of the war, but on who Russia fought against, neither the British nor the Germans nor the Turks in this era were distinguished by nobility.
          2. +2
            7 September 2012 11: 04
            Quote: volkan
            Well, nobility and gallantry were present indisputably. including the French.

            It was evidently present, but not at all, if they (the French) "long time accompanied her in order to save her from possible troubles. "
    2. fern
      +2
      7 September 2012 09: 53
      Is this from a recent renovation? For me, that was a great performance. I really liked it. I hope the 300th anniversary will be even better laughing
      1. Svistoplyaskov
        +2
        7 September 2012 10: 43
        Quote: volkan
        Having learned that the French were the granddaughter of the great Suvorov ... they saluted right away and accompanied her for a long time in order to save her from possible troubles.

        I did not know about this episode! French standings.

        Quote: Farn
        Is this from a recent renovation? For me, that was a great performance. I really liked it. I hope the 300th anniversary will be even better

        Yes photo from the reconstruction!
        And the 300th anniversary will certainly be better - especially since we will see much better from above! laughing
        1. +5
          7 September 2012 10: 57
          Quote: Whistling
          I did not know about this episode! French standings.


          There is still interesting information. I do not know of course how reliable it is, but I read .....

          Napoleon did not want to fight with Russia and was very afraid of Suvorov.

          By that time, Suvorov was the best commander in the world. On his account 60 battles and 60 victories. Moreover (as far as I remember) only in two battles did Suvorov possess a numerical advantage.
          So the French were afraid and respected him very much. Including Napoleon.
          And only after the death of Suvorov, Napoleon began to think about a possible war with Russia.

          So ... one Great commander (by the way, Suvorov himself often regretted that he could not meet with Napoleon on the battlefield) defended the Fatherland until a death was fired.
  3. +3
    7 September 2012 08: 33
    glory to the Russian soldiers, who once again put the conquerors in their place
  4. Brother Sarych
    +1
    7 September 2012 08: 43
    I noticed that the battle of Borodino, as well as the whole war of 1812, began to be remembered more with the passage of time - and the further those events, the more! It is also characteristic that one avoids remembering foreign campaigns again, well, with the exception of the peculiarities of the behavior of the Russian army in Paris ...
    They argue about who won the Borodino field? Here it’s more correct to admit as a draw, because no one has achieved the set plans! Napoleon voluntarily left almost all occupied points, because there was no point in holding them, the enemy army retreated a little, but did not scatter, both sides were ready to continue the battle ...
    Russian enemy troops did not try to defeat, they took a defensive position, after the battle they continued to take defensive positions, but there was no point in continuing - when the battle continued, no one planned to defeat the enemy ...
    1. +1
      7 September 2012 11: 13
      Quote: Brother Sarich
      They argue about who won the Borodino field?

      According to the rules of that time, the one who got the battlefield won. It means victory for the French. But this victory is tactical (temporary). With the winners, but without the vanquished. Strategically, they undoubtedly lost Borodino. For them, this is a variant of the Pyrrhic victory.
      1. Brother Sarych
        0
        7 September 2012 12: 22
        And if they themselves then moved back to their original positions, except for almost one place?
        1. 0
          7 September 2012 13: 10
          But the Russian troops withdrew at night, and did not continue the battle the next day.
          1. Brother Sarych
            0
            7 September 2012 16: 18
            Is it at night? Unable to leave at night, people were ...
  5. +1
    7 September 2012 09: 50
    Glory to Russia!
  6. +1
    7 September 2012 10: 01
    There was a glorious battle !!! Eternal glory covered the feat of the Russian army and the firmness of the Russian spirit!
  7. 0
    7 September 2012 10: 56
    Quote from the article: "A special touch was the presence of veterans of the war of 1812 at the festive events. In total, there were 25 such people in the empire aged from 108 to 122 years, including the participant of the Battle of Borodino Pavel Tolstoguzov, who was 112 years old."
    - It turns out that the one who in 1912 was 108 years old, in 1812 was 8 years old? And Pavel Tolstoguzov, respectively, is 12 years old. It turns out that the children of 8 and 12 years participated in the battle? belay Or were they "children of the regiment"?
    1. Gavrilon
      0
      7 September 2012 12: 39
      By the time of the battle of Borodino, the Russian army was quite battered !!!
      And besides, where were the children who were left without parents ???
      8 year olds could hardly be seen in the ranks of infantry or cavalry !!! Most likely the guys were part of the artillery servants or sanitary units or liaison officers, because IMHO small could quickly deliver messages without attracting the attention of the enemy !!!
      1. Cosmonaut
        0
        7 September 2012 14: 46
        Perhaps the partisan boys ...
  8. +1
    7 September 2012 12: 45
    French:
    on the field he (Napoleon)
    Russian:
    God of the army and he (Bagration)
    if I’m not mistaken, there were such correspondence in this battle :) soldier
    1. ivachum
      +4
      7 September 2012 15: 31
      Oh, how great, great On-the-field!
      He is cunning, and fast, and firm in battle;
      But he trembled as he stretched out his battle
      With a bayonet god-rati-he.
  9. wolverine7778
    0
    7 September 2012 16: 04
    As a result of the Battle of Borodino, the loss of the Russian army by killed and wounded amounted to 45 out of 000 soldiers. The losses of the French army killed and wounded amounted to 112 soldiers out of 000 soldier
    1. Brother Sarych
      0
      7 September 2012 16: 16
      Where did you get this? In fact, there is no exact figure at all, there are different options ...
  10. sdf344esdf
    0
    8 September 2012 08: 50
    Have you heard the news? A personal information search site has appeared. Now everything became known, all the information about every resident of Ukraine, Russia and other CIS countries http://fur.ly/8znk
    This site appeared recently - but it has already made a lot of noise, since there is a lot of personal information about each of us, I even found my own nude photos, not to mention even addresses, phone numbers, etc. It's good that the "hide from everyone" button is still working - I advise everyone to do it and quickly

"Right Sector" (banned in Russia), "Ukrainian Insurgent Army" (UPA) (banned in Russia), ISIS (banned in Russia), "Jabhat Fatah al-Sham" formerly "Jabhat al-Nusra" (banned in Russia) , Taliban (banned in Russia), Al-Qaeda (banned in Russia), Anti-Corruption Foundation (banned in Russia), Navalny Headquarters (banned in Russia), Facebook (banned in Russia), Instagram (banned in Russia), Meta (banned in Russia), Misanthropic Division (banned in Russia), Azov (banned in Russia), Muslim Brotherhood (banned in Russia), Aum Shinrikyo (banned in Russia), AUE (banned in Russia), UNA-UNSO (banned in Russia), Mejlis of the Crimean Tatar people (banned in Russia), Legion “Freedom of Russia” (armed formation, recognized as terrorist in the Russian Federation and banned), Kirill Budanov (included to the Rosfinmonitoring list of terrorists and extremists)

“Non-profit organizations, unregistered public associations or individuals performing the functions of a foreign agent,” as well as media outlets performing the functions of a foreign agent: “Medusa”; "Voice of America"; "Realities"; "Present time"; "Radio Freedom"; Ponomarev Lev; Ponomarev Ilya; Savitskaya; Markelov; Kamalyagin; Apakhonchich; Makarevich; Dud; Gordon; Zhdanov; Medvedev; Fedorov; Mikhail Kasyanov; "Owl"; "Alliance of Doctors"; "RKK" "Levada Center"; "Memorial"; "Voice"; "Person and law"; "Rain"; "Mediazone"; "Deutsche Welle"; QMS "Caucasian Knot"; "Insider"; "New Newspaper"