Retired Indian general: the S-400 air defense system will help us identify the weaknesses of the Chinese J-20 fighter, Washington has no reason to interfere with us

33

The Indian media publishes materials in which it talks about the plans of the country's military command to deploy S-400 anti-aircraft missile systems. It was noted that the first deliveries are expected at the beginning of the next (2022) year, and India will immediately place the Russian-made air defense system in the border area with China.

The Indian press expresses confidence that the Indian military command is taking such a step in order to "check the stealth parameters of the Chinese J-20 stealth fighters." Several dozen of these 5th generation fighters are already in service with the PLA Air Force. Earlier, one or two (according to various sources) J-20s were transferred by the Chinese to the Khotan airfield, from where the flight time to the Indian border is only a few minutes.



This happened against the background of the aggravation of the situation in the disputed region of Ladakh - where the servicemen of the two nuclear powers came together in a "stick and stone" battle. Some time later, after reaching an agreement, the Chinese side withdrew its J-20 fighters from the aforementioned airfield.

India believes that the Chinese Air Force can repeat such a transfer at any time. And the location of the 5th generation fighters 250-300 km from the Indian borders in New Delhi is seen as an "outright threat." It is for this purpose that it is planned to deploy the Russian-made S-400 Triumph air defense system in the northeast, near the border with the PRC. Also, as noted by Indian journalists, this can become a kind of "probing the ground" for the reaction of the United States. The Indian authorities have repeatedly tried to obtain guarantees from the Americans that the CAATSA sanctions package will not be applied in the event of S-400 deliveries from Russia. The United States avoids a direct answer to the sanctions, noting that "it will be possible to talk about this if India will deploy the S-400 on its territory." At the same time, in India itself, a fair question is asked:

The United States imposed sanctions against Turkey for the purchase of the S-400. Ankara was told that Russian-made anti-aircraft systems "do not fit into NATO's air defense system." Let's say they really don't fit. But how can the same thesis be promoted in relation to India? We are not part of NATO. We are also opposed to China, just like the United States itself.

A retired Indian general, speaking to local journalists, expresses his point of view:

The S-400 will help us identify the weaknesses of the Chinese fifth-generation J-20 fighters. Washington has no reason to interfere with this. He's not on the Chinese side ...
33 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. +6
    5 August 2021 14: 19
    The United States imposed sanctions against Turkey for the purchase of the S-400 ...

    It is very interesting to know what China thinks about the supply of S-400s to India ...
    1. +2
      5 August 2021 14: 25
      Quote: Doccor18
      It is very interesting to know what China thinks about the supply of S-400s to India ...

      Are you curious to know why China is preparing 110 silos for missiles against (???):
      1. +1
        5 August 2021 14: 28
        Quote: ROSS 42
        Are you curious to know why China is preparing 110 silos for missiles against (???):

        Where is the connection?
        1. +3
          5 August 2021 14: 32
          Quote: Doccor18
          Where is the connection?

          Connection with what? What is the Chinese business to whom Russia is supplying air defense systems that have no restrictions on either supply or relation to offensive weapons?
          We do not climb into the Chinese garden and they should not be "very much" interested in what is growing in our beds.
          1. +3
            5 August 2021 15: 34
            Quote: ROSS 42
            Connection with what?

            Communication of the Indian S-400 and the new positioning area of ​​the silos of the ICBM of the PRC ..?

            Quote: ROSS 42
            What is the Chinese business to whom Russia supplies air defense systems ...

            Oh yes, what is their business ... But it does not really fit in with those trills from our various media about the great "Russian-Chinese friendship" ...

            Quote: ROSS 42
            ... no relationship to offensive weapons?

            But the problem for the Chinese Air Force in the disputed area will create a real one, so now this will always have to be taken into account in any planning.

            Quote: ROSS 42
            We do not climb into the Chinese garden

            It's true. True, India is "over the fence" from the "Chinese garden" ...

            Yes, it is clear that this contract will not change the balance of power, but it's still interesting, and even at the moment when there is extremely strong pressure on China from the Democrats ... the British squadron, sanctions ...
            1. +4
              5 August 2021 15: 44
              Quote: Doccor18
              It's true. True, India is "over the fence" from the "Chinese garden" ...

              For example, China, which was carrying a forest to its country, is not at all worried about the fires in Yakutia. Why should we be concerned about the mutual hostility of our neighbors, whose population is dozens of times larger than the Russian one?
              1. +3
                5 August 2021 16: 10
                Quote: ROSS 42
                ... who was carrying a forest to his country, is not at all disturbed by the fires in Yakutia. Why should we

                And again, excuse me, I don't see the connection.
                1. The forest is on fire in Russia. The most that China can do is offer its assistance in extinguishing, as Russia offered this assistance to Turkey ...
                2. Russia itself sells timber to China, and with pleasure, but this in no way affects the economy of India.

                Quote: ROSS 42
                Why should we be worried about the mutual hostility of our neighbors, whose population is dozens of times larger than the Russian?

                1. If (God forbid) your two neighbors begin to feel a strong non-pollution towards each other, then sooner or later this problem will affect you too ...
                2. It is especially problematic when these neighbors have a serious weight category.

                At this point, Russia has become a Great Peacemaker, and this would have brought us a tremendous political effect, even if it didn’t work out, but at the same time, it wouldn’t immediately bring money. The problem is that China has almost stopped buying Russian weapons, and India is too fickle ...
                1. 0
                  5 August 2021 16: 12
                  Quote: Doccor18
                  And again, excuse me, I don't see the connection.


                  laughing
      2. 0
        5 August 2021 15: 43
        Quote: ROSS 42
        ... Are you curious to know why China is preparing 110 silos for missiles against (???):

        For example, I'm interested to know why you only highlighted Russia on the map, but forgot about India and the United States? Maybe you know more than anyone else in the world about the launching shafts of the PRC, but here you are only showing ignorance? soldier
    2. +1
      5 August 2021 14: 27
      Do the ACTING generals agree with his opinion?
      1. +3
        5 August 2021 14: 38
        The retiree compares favorably with those in action, he can afford to speak ...
        Active - follow orders ...
    3. +4
      5 August 2021 14: 55
      Quote: Doccor18
      It is very interesting to know what China thinks about the supply of S-400s to India ...

      What do you think? Something seems to me that they are not very happy ...
      The Indian press expresses confidence that the Indian military command is taking such a step in order to "check the stealth parameters of the Chinese J-20 stealth fighters."
      A couple of dozen J-20s are certainly a threat, but a big threat comes from hundreds of J-16s.

      1. +3
        5 August 2021 15: 38
        Quote: svp67
        Something seems to me that they are not very happy ...

        This is to put it mildly ...

        In fact, the geopolitical adversary is significantly strengthened by the air defense system.
    4. +1
      5 August 2021 15: 39
      Quote: Doccor18
      It is very interesting to know what they think in China about the supply of S-400s to India ...

      And it is also interesting to know how such an independent country as India is afraid to anger the United States for buying Russian weapons and for some such personal belongings the United States is holding India? recourse
      1. +1
        5 August 2021 17: 11
        Quote: credo
        and for some such personal belongings the United States is holding India?

        Sanction dollar ..
    5. +1
      7 August 2021 21: 23
      Quote: Doccor18
      1. If (God forbid) two of your neighbors start
      feel a strong non-pollution to each other, then
      sooner or later this problem will affect you too ...
      2. It is especially problematic when these neighbors
      have a serious weight category.

      explain the thought)))
      there was already a military conflict between China and India, and how is it touched us?
      well, except for the purchase of weapons from us.
      1. 0
        8 August 2021 08: 05
        I was referring to a serious conflict between the two countries, and not a "cane battle" of dozens of people.
        Quote: Gunter
        There was already a military conflict between China and India, and how did this affect us?

        And it was more than once ... and every time the USSR failed to stand aside, condemning the actions of Beijing (against the background of a cooling of relations with China).
        And which side will Russia choose today if it suddenly gets too hot?
        1. +1
          8 August 2021 21: 36
          Quote: Doccor18
          And which side will Russia choose today if it suddenly gets too hot?

          and what for, let me ask, should we choose which side in someone else's conflict?
          We will, as Sean Connery said, wait until the corpse of the enemy floats by.
          and China, in my opinion, is not our friend at best, unlike distant India.
          1. 0
            8 August 2021 22: 00
            Quote: Gunter
            and what for, let me ask, should we choose which side in someone else's conflict?

            If only because you can't sit on the sidelines. Why? China, and especially India, is full of our weapons systems, for which ammunition, repairs, and possibly the purchase of an additional batch are needed. So who are we going to sell to? India? Then goodbye to "partnership" relations and unanimity of opinions in the UN. China? Then goodbye contracts from India. Both? To be honest, this is very hard to believe. In this regard, we are unlikely to outplay the striped ones. Only they could masterfully sell weapons on both sides of the front ...
            Quote: Gunter
            China, in my opinion, is not our friend at best, unlike distant India.

            There is something to seriously think about ...
  2. +5
    5 August 2021 14: 21
    The S-400 is just a link in the layered air defense system. It is impossible to consider it as a panacea for everything and everyone, even with Indian brains, BUT you need to have such complexes. You just need to continue to be friends with Russia, and not look for friends among those who once gladly shot Hindus from cannons. Let it be GB, but the United States did not come from the moon. Now they are blowing one tune.
  3. 0
    5 August 2021 14: 21
    I don't think the mountains are the best place to use the S-400 ... what
  4. +2
    5 August 2021 14: 22
    These ridiculous gypsies ... in general, the United States is always only on its side and will merge the Indians as soon as it becomes profitable.
    1. +3
      5 August 2021 14: 35
      Quote: Marachuh
      Funny these gypsies

      billion 300 million gypsies of two hundred nationalities
      it's good to be a purebred Aryan without an admixture of gypsy
    2. 0
      5 August 2021 15: 12
      Retired Indian General:

  5. +3
    5 August 2021 14: 35
    Washington has no reason to interfere with this. He's not on the Chinese side ...

    The Indian general has some strange notion about the reasonableness of Washington's actions. The US has a reason to sell its air defense systems to India and thus show the whole world how they are countering the "Chinese threat".

    A bit off-top, but to the topic:
    why of all the irons, especially the Indian spill, shout that the Su-57 is NOT the fifth generation because of its fourth generation engines? The J-20 also flies on engines of an even more "old" type and nothing, for an Indian general it is still a five.
  6. 0
    5 August 2021 14: 57
    Quote: ROSS 42
    Are you curious to know why China is preparing 110 silos for missiles against (???):
    So this is against Mongolia.
    1. KCA
      0
      5 August 2021 15: 27
      Maybe I don't remember how many centuries China was under the rule of the Mongols, 5, like
  7. 0
    5 August 2021 14: 58
    "...The S-400 will help us identify the weaknesses of the Chinese fifth-generation J-20 fighters. Washington has no reason to interfere with this. He's not on the Chinese side........ "
    ======
    Oh, and they are funny, these Indians! Are they really that stupid and do not understand that this is "just business"? Or maybe too "sly .. (Sorry!) .. booty"? Interesting: WHOM are they once again trying to "dissolve" and "calm down"? Are they not themselves? request what
  8. +1
    5 August 2021 15: 49
    I give a standing ovation. General is cunning laughing
    That's how you let him down, well done! Not a general, but a true diplomat !!! hi
  9. +5
    5 August 2021 16: 27
    The S-400 will help us identify the weaknesses of the Chinese fifth-generation J-20 fighters. Washington has no reason to interfere with this. He's not on the Chinese side ...


    They will still interfere ...
  10. +1
    5 August 2021 21: 29
    Even without looking at the 400D map of the Himalayas, my personal opinion is that this is not the best location for the C XNUMX. PLA Air Force pilots can safely pass through the gorges to the launch point across mainland India. India has something to drive the PRC planes above Everest. Maybe all this is boiling around Ladakh, is this the key point of the Himalayan air defense?
  11. 0
    5 August 2021 21: 39
    If finances allow, why not give it a try.
  12. -1
    7 August 2021 00: 04
    Retired generals and politicians in any country are objective)))