Military Review

Putin: on the "red line" and three calls for the West

153

Source: kremlin.ru


Agenda


The message of the President of the Russian Federation to the Federal Assembly is, as they say, a classic of the genre. They know about him, they are preparing for him, the authors even happened to get into the press room with a broadcast. But no instant calls to action and decisions are expected from him. After all, the theses in the message, although important, are, as you know, strategic, but still - recommendatory.

However, not this time - the president's address to the deputies and senators came at a very alarming moment for the country, when the conflict in Donbass at any moment could turn into a full-scale war with all the ensuing consequences. The head of state, perhaps, even had to promptly change the prepared text, strengthening the accents, according to the situation.

Traditionally, the message can be divided into two parts: domestic and foreign. And the second component, judging by the agenda, should be a priority. But it is not so. Historical experience shows that Russia fell into protracted crises precisely because of internal discord and social disorder. But external factors, on the contrary, collected and strengthened the country. Therefore, the situation inside the country is just as important.

In the first place, of course, is the topic of coronavirus. In his message, Vladimir Putin thanked the Russians, doctors and scientists for the fight against the Covid-19 pandemic. On the one hand, the numbers are quite serious: 4,7 million people in the country fell ill, over 100 thousand people died. But, on the other hand, an effective vaccine against coronavirus has been developed, vaccination is difficult, but gaining momentum.

Over the past year, the state has set social accents in such a way that the threat of mass unemployment has remained largely on paper, but in words, that is, it has not turned into a large-scale problem. And most importantly, we managed to preserve a single economic space: the regions did not close on the principle of “at least survive on our own”.

The second aspect is, in fact, the internal political one. Social irritation in society is gradually but growing. The government continues to tighten the "screws", to take punitive measures, but the effectiveness of the state mechanism itself does not increase. Beacon institutions such as the police and the courts do not inherently change. It is very difficult to achieve a quick response to violations already 100 kilometers from Moscow.

Therefore, such a factor as Navalny (the head of an organization included in the register of foreign agents) must be taken seriously. Although this is a "sent Cossack", and his supporters are few. But, if irritation in society grows, then this vector can quickly increase at the expense of the dissatisfied. It is no coincidence that the state has clearly marked a red line for this Vladimir "inmate" - all structures that support his movement can turn into extremist, that is, undermine national security. And the conversation with the extremists in the country will be short.

But, again, only punitive measures cannot be dispensed with. It is no coincidence that Putin voiced a whole package of social measures in his message. Among them are support for families with children, and an increase in the number of budget places in universities for young people, etc. The measures, in principle, are not bad, but this is nothing more than a soft correction, rather than a fundamental change in the social trend. A lot of problems have accumulated in this area, and “gifts” alone are indispensable.

For external partners


But the foreign policy part of the President's message is completely different. Extremely specific and even harsh. Apparently, throwing, retreating and avoiding blows are over. Vladimir Putin's address to the Federal Assembly was the finale of a great job of drawing "red lines" on the ground.

The recent transfer of several armies and formations to the south and west of the country and the conduct of eloquent exercises demanded a resume. And it is like this - we will not give offense to Donbass, but don’t think about Crimea in general. If you are rude and incite "tobacco", then no one will seem a little. The northern Black Sea region may become a closed zone, and the project of "independent Ukraine" will end.

But it's not just Ukraine. The West in Eastern Europe is playing a great strategic game. The attempted coup d'etat in Belarus says a lot - the task of pushing Russia to the edge of the "heartland" has not been removed from the agenda. Vladimir Putin called the actions of American agents to eliminate Lukashenko unprecedented.

And the point is not that "dad" is irreplaceable at this stage. And the fact that the United States, as noted by expert Rostislav Ishchenko, is walking on a very dangerous brink of being drawn into a large-scale conflict by a nuclear power, which is Russia.

The President of the Russian Federation once again recalled that the country has a large military and nuclear potential:

“Russia is updating military equipment in the army, including nuclear weapon... "Avangard", "Peresvet" are already in service, soon the troops will enter the "Sarmat", re-equip (the army) with missiles "Dagger", "Caliber" and "Zircon". Work continues on "Petrel" and "Poseidon".

And finally, the final emphasis in Vladimir Putin's address:

"The organizers of any provocations against Russia will regret it as they have not regretted anything for a long time."

The statement is harsh, but it’s just not about war, but about peace. In other words, let the “external partners” stop at the peaceful stage, you don’t have to go beyond these “red markers”, and everyone will be fine.

But many still ask the question - why did Russia mark its "red lines" so late? Indeed, since the end of the 80s of the last century, the USSR (and then the Russian Federation) only gave up its positions. First, the Warsaw Pact bloc disappeared. The Western partners stated that they would not involve the countries that were part of this bloc into their orbit.

But wherever there - pretty soon the Czech Republic, Hungary, Poland and other "fragments" of the Internal Affairs Directorate were drawn into NATO. Then there were speeches that the former republics of the USSR would not be touched. But here, too, the realities turned out to be different - the Baltic countries were turned into an eastern outpost of NATO, and now they are approaching Ukraine at full speed. And only when NATO, figuratively speaking, were on the way to Rostov-on-Don, Russia had to rigidly place "landmarks".

Third "call"


There are many reasons for this, but economic ones are in the foreground. Since the beginning of the 90s of the last century, the Russian Federation has decided to build a fundamentally different economic model, in contrast to the USSR, which aspired to autarky. That is, to develop all possible industries to the maximum and to depend on external partners to a minimum.

Of course, the new autarchy did not work out. The Soviet Union was dependent on other countries for many aspects, especially when it began exporting hydrocarbons to the West. The Russian Federation has simplified the model, ruthlessly discarding many industries and plunging domestic production into the crisis, and, consequently, its own population.

A radical liberalization of the country's financial market has taken place - investments flowed to us, mainly of a speculative nature. A reverse trend also emerged - oligarchic groups, having earned capital in the "super-efficient" sectors of the economy, mainly raw materials, were actively withdrawing money abroad. The desire to please the West, to enter into close contact with it, was transformed into endless concessions, but only from our side.

The first "call" that we never became friends sounded in 2008 - in South Ossetia. The second was in Ukraine, in 2014, when Crimea went home. The introduction of economic sanctions for the "annexation" of the peninsula has sobered the political elite of Russia in many ways. It became clear that the collective West is stubbornly pursuing a strategy, if not elimination, then the maximum suppression of the "threat" from the east. National interests of the Russian Federation, as a nuclear power, as it turned out, no one was going to take into account.

Thank God, since 2014, our country has begun to rapidly move away from external food dependence. The implementation of the import substitution program began in the industrial sector. But, according to Doctor of Economics Valentin Katasonov, many reforms in the country turned out to be half-hearted, and some, in general, remained on paper.

The saddest thing is that the financial policy of the state has not changed. The principle of currency liberalization remained prevailing. Attempts to expand the cash flows leaving the country have been made more than once, but the main vector has not changed.

Already in March of this year, Vladimir Putin held a meeting on investment in the domestic economy. Then it was announced that the authorities would strongly encourage those who would invest in the country. But, in addition to incentives, it is reasonable to introduce at least some kind of restriction on the cross-border movement of capital in the current situation. But not a word was said about this.

If we talk about the President's message to the Federal Assembly, then, according to Valentin Katasonov, it is not balanced. A number of harsh foreign policy statements were made, but they were in no way backed up by domestic economic theses. Expert conclusion:

"So far, no major changes in the trajectory of economic development of the Russian Federation are foreseen."

In other words, the army and navy are, of course, reliable allies of Russia, but without a serious transformation of the country's economic model, they may find themselves without a reliable rear. A significant part of the political elite continues to follow the old rails, still hoping that it will be possible to make friends with the West. Largely because of this, the "red lines" were marked so late.
Author:
153 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. nnm
    nnm April 29 2021 10: 08
    +42
    I apologize, but after a couple of first paragraphs I did not read further, because I realized that I had listened / read exactly the same thing for many years in a row ...
    1. Civil
      Civil April 29 2021 11: 56
      +4
      What country is such a message, they looked right in the mirror.
      1. nnm
        nnm April 29 2021 12: 22
        +5
        Well, it depends on what you understand when speaking of the "country" - the people, or the system of state power.
        1. Civil
          Civil April 29 2021 14: 31
          +2
          Quote: nnm
          Well, it depends on what you understand when speaking of the "country" - the people, or the system of state power.

          And what do aliens work in the system of state power? One is an organic part of the other.
          1. nnm
            nnm April 29 2021 15: 31
            +10
            Your statement would be true if:
            1. A significant number of citizens would not be passive
            2. If the executive authorities were elected
            3. If the persons elected to these bodies carried out election programs
            Then yes, one could say - that one is part of the other.
            And so, to put it simply, the majority are indifferent to the elections, because in fact they are not important, because we elect only deputies, and they have no responsibility for promising one thing and doing another. Therefore, where are "we" and where are "they" ....- "your opinion is very important to us! Stay on the line until the next electoral cycle."
            1. Krasnoyarsk
              Krasnoyarsk April 29 2021 20: 33
              +9
              Quote: nnm
              2. If the executive authorities were elected

              Election of the executive branch is a two-edged regiment.
              In elections, any, usually talkers win, those who know how to speak long and beautifully "without a piece of paper." And often they are not ready for real professional work. There are, of course, exceptions, but very rarely. In addition, it is very difficult to remove an elected one from his post, even in spite of obvious failures in work.
              1. Herman 4223
                Herman 4223 April 30 2021 07: 04
                +5
                And it's also corruption. A pre-election campaign requires a lot of money, which no one will give just like that.
            2. Revival
              Revival April 29 2021 23: 56
              0
              "1. A substantial number of citizens would not be passive."

              Further, you can not argue, to each his own, we get and rejoice ...
            3. Simple
              Simple April 30 2021 11: 17
              +2
              Quote: nnm
              if:
              1. A significant number of citizens would not be passive
              2. If the executive authorities were elected
              3. If the persons elected to these bodies carried out election programs


              Your definitions can be applied to both the United States and the FGR, but in contrast to Russia, the well-being of the people (on average in a hospital), you must agree, is a little different.

              Maybe the problem of "ineffectiveness of power" is on a different plane?
          2. AUL
            AUL April 29 2021 16: 22
            +3
            Largely because of this, the "red lines" were marked so late.
            And they were marked? It was only promised that they will... Well, yes, you can promise a lot ...
            1. Fan-fan
              Fan-fan April 29 2021 16: 48
              0
              So I have not heard anything specific about the "red lines". Blah - blah - blah and that's it.
    2. aslanismaili611
      aslanismaili611 April 30 2021 01: 35
      -3
      Quote: nnm
      I apologize, but after a couple of first paragraphs I did not read further, because I realized that I had listened / read exactly the same thing for many years in a row ...

      And after the headlines, I went straight to the comments. Here then, I think, there is no reason to distort everything, we are not politicians. The most interesting thing will be said here.
    3. iouris
      iouris April 30 2021 12: 09
      -1
      Red line and three green bells.
  2. Dmitry V.
    Dmitry V. April 29 2021 10: 18
    +32
    Outright nonsense!
    Directly waiting for the message of the nights did not sleep.
    Better tell me why everything has risen in price? Why does the "Kremlin prisoner" not credit himself with the rise in food and fuel prices?
    May God rest his political career!
    1. New Year day
      New Year day April 29 2021 10: 45
      +17
      Quote: Dmitry Vladimirovich
      Why does the "Kremlin prisoner" not credit himself with the rise in food and fuel prices?

      Therefore, to give money is He, and to raise prices is They
    2. Volder
      Volder April 29 2021 13: 13
      .
      Quote: Dmitry Vladimirovich
      Better tell me why everything has risen in price? Why does the "Kremlin prisoner" not credit himself with the rise in food and fuel prices?
      Prices rose in the 1990s as well, and the population was then poorer. Stability was only in the USSR. Do you want the return of socialism and a planned economy? And by the way, there is inflation in many countries, even in Europe. This is a side effect of the market economy. Or do you want to see a government regulated market? Then it will no longer be a market.
      1. Esoteric
        Esoteric April 29 2021 13: 40
        +16
        All his life he was an anti-communist. But now I want the return of socialism. Where I know that I will not be thrown out on the street to die, where there is a lot of work, for every taste.
        1. Fan-fan
          Fan-fan April 29 2021 16: 54
          +7
          I confirm that in the days of the USSR, after graduating from the university, I decided to find a job myself - I just walked down the street and entered every institution and workers were needed everywhere, they did not say anywhere that there were no vacancies.
        2. Esoteric
          Esoteric April 29 2021 22: 41
          +4
          It's right. Required everywhere. Just work, here's a deal for you, earn. Health has deteriorated - a vacation and a sanatorium, at ridiculous prices, or completely free. Ill - so you will be taken to any clinic, the operation is free. There is an example with a friend. He developed bone sarcoma, he lived in a village. I’m not lying. By helicopter to the regional center, and then to the Institute of Radiology, or whatever it is, to Moscow. Saved. Naturally, he did not serve in the army, here I think there should be no questions why.
          Yes, there were excesses. There is nothing to say here. Why was it impossible for a person honestly working to buy (build) a house for himself in a village? It is not right. Again, his own small business, like a bakery, a handicraft workshop, a hairdresser, and so on, was impossible. This is also wrong.
          In general, some kind of confusion in my answer to you. I don’t think that in the leading countries of the West (of course I mean Europe, especially Scandinavia, and in the same England, medicine is free) capitalism. There is a hybrid, and it is not clear what to call it.
          Well, now we have classical feudalism. Health to you, this is the most important thing!
        3. Revival
          Revival April 30 2021 00: 00
          +3
          By the way, the constitutional court allowed the debtor to be evicted from the only home.
          Progress...
      2. Ross xnumx
        Ross xnumx April 29 2021 13: 44
        +11
        Quote: Volder
        And by the way, there is inflation in many countries, even in Europe. This is a side effect of the market economy.

        Are you sure it's collateral? In my opinion, it is in the market economy that this principle of eternal inflation is laid, which is formed only due to the difference in the volumes of produced and consumed. It is the market economy that is based on “giving in growth”. And they give air. It was the absence of gold content that turned world currencies into "paper wrappers", conventionally called money.
        Quote: Volder
        Or do you want to see a government regulated market? Then it will no longer be a market.

        Do you want the development of the Russian economy to be finally "legalized" by annual budget messages? It is impossible to solve a mathematical problem where quantities undergo a change in the process of solving. This is exactly what is happening now, and the state is simply obliged to keep such values ​​as energy prices, taxes on profits and others, on which the final price of a product (product) depends, constant in order to have a tangible real result. Bank speculation, set free to float and standing out as government institutions (Sberbank, VTB and other crap), is the main source of inflation. I'm not even talking about the so-called additional capitalization.
        The situation is even worse when the national currency is a derivative of someone's “designated” reserve currency.
      3. Dmitry V.
        Dmitry V. April 29 2021 14: 29
        +9
        Quote: Volder
        Or do you want to see a government regulated market? Then it will no longer be a market.

        I want the state to live within its means and not pulling out of us and the economy by the constant depreciation of the ruble and inflation of 16-18% of additional income in the form of printed paper.


        Too often, the "Kremlin prisoner" and the company began to resort to the depreciation of the ruble, as the simplest tool for extracting rent from the population!
    3. Revival
      Revival April 29 2021 23: 57
      +1
      What a long sentence ...
  3. Lannan Shi
    Lannan Shi April 29 2021 10: 19
    +23
    Beacon institutions such as the police and the courts are essentially unchanged. It is very difficult to achieve a quick response to violations already 100 kilometers from Moscow.

    Unlimited optimism. I live much closer than 100 km from Moscow. To Red Square, 55 km, if in a straight line. The very border of the Lobnensky and Dmitrovsky districts. To achieve the reaction of our beloved police, even to outright crime .... This is not the easiest thing. Personally, I, the border of this quickest reaction, would have drawn through the list of contacts from the phones of the chiefs of police stations, internal affairs departments, and other courts and prosecutors there. yes
    1. Intruder
      Intruder April 29 2021 10: 42
      +1
      I live much closer than 100 km from Moscow. To Red Square, 55 km, if in a straight line. The very border of the Lobnensky and Dmitrovsky districts
      I envy you, you live close to Krasnaya, I have a dipped beam, to go for mushrooms and berries - 120 km, when I was still living in Siberia, and even now to "run" to the lakes to another state, almost - 300 km, one way! wink
    2. Ingvar 72
      Ingvar 72 April 29 2021 10: 46
      +6
      Quote: Lannan Shi
      Unlimited optimism.

      This is not optimism, but calming the patient, and instead of treatment.
    3. 210ox
      210ox April 29 2021 10: 50
      +16
      Example-Krasnodar Territory. 10-12 people die every day from covid, with 100-103 sick. It is extremely difficult to get an appointment with a specialist (especially in a children's referral). There is practically no record, only through the regional Ministry of Health on the hotline. About legal filing and courts. The topic of corruption in the province is a separate song, even a hymn to the invincible hydra. And about-why so late marked the "red lines"? It's not too late. Remember Putin's Munich speech. It's just that the elections are on the way and the United Russia must be supported loudly. And in the Donbas, they will continue to shoot and kill people. Here's what you need to know about these lines. This is not for an external enemy - he knows his own strengths and capabilities, but for an internal audience. Alas, not Stalin at the head of the country.
      1. 210ox
        210ox April 29 2021 11: 22
        +1
        Hey, mincers are sad! Does it really hurt your eyes?
        1. Overlock
          Overlock April 29 2021 11: 53
          +1
          Quote: 210ox
          What, really pierces the eyes?

          There is nothing to say to them, so they are minus natihari! This is the job - they have nothing to brag about
      2. mikh-korsakov
        mikh-korsakov April 29 2021 12: 04
        +12
        The article is complete nonsense! In every thesis it is a lie. I am quoting the author of "The USSR, which strove for autarchy." It's like autarchy from Cuba to Vietnam. In the late 80s, they gave me an EC1840 for production needs, so there is a Hungarian processor and Bulgarian floppy disks. The fact that this legacy was ineptly profiled is another.
        1. Fan-fan
          Fan-fan April 29 2021 17: 04
          -1
          And when I was young, I worked on the EC1840K, but you are wrong, our processor is there - K1810VM86, by the way, almost a complete analogue of Intel's processor.
      3. Nastia makarova
        Nastia makarova April 29 2021 12: 21
        +1
        in Sochi, silence on covid, apparently completely won))))
        1. 210ox
          210ox April 29 2021 12: 26
          +4
          Yeah. In terms of morbidity, it is the second after Krasnodar. Twenty to thirty people every day. It's official. I just follow the statistics, we ourselves live in another settlement of the Kuban.
          1. Nastia makarova
            Nastia makarova April 30 2021 15: 04
            +2
            All of us except the infectious diseases hospital were again transferred to a normal state, which means there are no covid ones
        2. ximkim
          ximkim April 29 2021 18: 07
          +1
          Apparently, there are no conditions for the virus, therefore there is silence)))
      4. dauria
        dauria April 29 2021 14: 57
        0
        10-12 people die every day from covid, with 100-103 sick.


        Confused nothing? Above is only the death rate from plague in medieval Europe. 30% died there. You have 10% of the flu. recourse
        Even without treatment, it is not more than 1%. Or are they shooting sick people in Krasnodar?
        1. 210ox
          210ox April 29 2021 15: 19
          +2
          Not confused. Look at the data in the media. "Yuga.ru" 80 deaths per week. This offhand opened the first site that came across.
        2. Antonio_Mariarti
          Antonio_Mariarti April 29 2021 15: 30
          +1
          Quote: dauria
          ЕС1840

          In the Russian Federation, excess mortality is 350k. This sounds more like the truth.
    4. Esoteric
      Esoteric April 29 2021 14: 05
      0
      Dear Lynnan! I don’t know, but I haven’t had acute respiratory infections, flu, or other infectious ailments since 2000. I made it my rule to have a bottle of beer every day, no more, but normal, not powder.
      And seriously, I don't get sick at all, I have never had a temperature during this time.
      Probably they will recognize me as an alcoholic lol
  4. Doccor18
    Doccor18 April 29 2021 10: 19
    +19
    And the second component, judging by the agenda, should be a priority.

    Well this is not new. 30 years ago ...
    Over the past year, the state has set social accents in such a way that the threat of mass unemployment has remained largely on paper, but in words, that is, it has not turned into a large-scale problem.

    Agitprom in action.
    1. Intruder
      Intruder April 29 2021 10: 44
      +2
      Agitprom in action.
      only weak and somehow not very confident and firm in these very words and promises, but before actions, well, almost like on gloomy trampolines - until the moon, which year ... wink
      1. Doccor18
        Doccor18 April 29 2021 10: 50
        +4
        Quote: Intruder
        only weak ..

        And there was no other.
        Agitation and propaganda are also art.
  5. Vladimir_2U
    Vladimir_2U April 29 2021 10: 23
    +3
    As Parshev wrote - "Having said A, you will have to speak the rest of the letters of the alphabet, and quickly!"
  6. rocket757
    rocket757 April 29 2021 10: 26
    +3
    Putin: on the "red line" and three calls for the West
    ... As always, there are many words, we will look at the deeds.
    1. paul3390
      paul3390 April 29 2021 10: 34
      +24
      Really, over 20 years of empty promises and totally verbiage have not seen enough? what
      1. rocket757
        rocket757 April 29 2021 10: 54
        -4
        What do you want to suggest so that we don't have to "look"?
        By the way, here, there, in many places, MUCH, DIFFERENT was offered, and what has been done over the years?
        PS I, from this power, do not expect anything new, good, but since there is nothing else NOW, I will just look ...
        PP S is not 20 years old, but 30! Or "saints 90", is it something else?
        1. Reptiloid
          Reptiloid April 29 2021 11: 34
          0
          Good afternoon, Victor! hi
          Quote: rocket757
          ...... I, from this power, do not expect anything new, good, but there is nothing else NOW, ........ PP S is not 20 years old, but 30! Or "saints 90", is it something else?

          What does the West want from the Russian Federation all these 30 years?
          To leave the place where the American "interferes" (from Syria, Nagorno-Karabakh ... give up Crimea, give up the Kuriles, give up Donbass, give up Kaliningrad, generally break up into 40-60 small states where it will be easy to dictate the wishes of the United States.
          And after these 30 years, only now, they were called an unfriendly country. After all the sanctions, setups, military actions, mayapov near our borders ----- "The Russian Federation is ready for dialogue." In my opinion, it is clear that they do not need this dialogue at all
          1. Overlock
            Overlock April 29 2021 11: 54
            -1
            Quote: Reptiloid
            What does the West want from the Russian Federation all these 30 years?

            exactly 30? In the 90s, who fed the country? - The damned West with its products.
          2. rocket757
            rocket757 April 29 2021 12: 01
            +4
            Dmitry, good afternoon soldier
            With the west, foreign countries, for the most part, everything is clear, but the most important things for US, affairs, events take place in our country, inside.
            How are we doing, here, they will go, also on ... there, they will be broadcast and influence.
            Those. we need strength and order within the country !!! Then we will be able to afford to look at the overseas ... from above, from our high, strong tower, t.s.
            1. Ross xnumx
              Ross xnumx April 29 2021 13: 59
              +11
              Quote: rocket757
              From the west, foreign lands, for the most part everything is clear, but, the most important for us, things, events take place in our country, inside.

              Should be happening. SHOULD! It is within the country that independent heavy engineering should develop, which will make it possible to send all these Western sanctions and restrictions “to nowhere”.
              In Russia, this is what happens:
              “Someone” Doesn't Leave Power
              And now that year
              Sends empty promises.
              1. rocket757
                rocket757 April 29 2021 14: 14
                +5
                That's right, MUST do not mean they will happen.
                That's why I write, I focus on this ... Schaub was not distracted, helluva lot. For us, the main thing is here in our country.
            2. ball
              ball April 29 2021 16: 16
              +6
              If there is political will, it is possible to get rid of corruption in a month, to raise the economy in a year, at the most.
              That is my opinion.
              1. rocket757
                rocket757 April 29 2021 17: 30
                +2
                Do you want like under Stalin or L Kuan Yew ??? It will not work otherwise, especially with such a system that rules us.
                It's not even a fantasy, it's ......
                1. Kamarada
                  Kamarada 1 May 2021 14: 54
                  +1
                  And if, as under Stalin, you do not act (God forbid that I be mistaken), then Russia will die out. It's just a matter of time.
                  1. rocket757
                    rocket757 1 May 2021 15: 18
                    0
                    Repetition as then, just like that, you can't ...
                    It can be tough, even necessary, but very stubborn, skillful people can do this, and they certainly should not depend on the current ruling class!
              2. Kamarada
                Kamarada 1 May 2021 14: 51
                0
                From corruption for a year. And the economy over a five-year period. But another person is needed. This one and the company can't. This is already clear to everyone and it is sad.
                1. rocket757
                  rocket757 1 May 2021 15: 19
                  0
                  These I can’t, WILL NOT! They are henchmen of the ruling class ... and who are the ruling ones ???
          3. Fan-fan
            Fan-fan April 29 2021 17: 11
            -1

            What does the West want from the Russian Federation all these 30 years?

            And don't we want the same from them? Don't we want the United States or England to disintegrate?
            We want. This is mutual, so you shouldn't take offense at them for it.
            Although our history is full of moments when the United States helped us free of charge, for example, the famine in the Volga region (when 5 million of our citizens died) or the collapse of the USSR, when they sent us food for nothing.
            1. Reptiloid
              Reptiloid April 30 2021 08: 14
              +1
              .... And do we not want too ...... the collapse of the United States or England. .....
              eeeee her her, my friend! 5 hi Do not mix meanings, do not substitute concepts wink winked If you or I, or comrades in VO, want the disintegration of the United States, then this is not the policy of our state. For our state, the United States has been partners for 30 years. Remember the rhetoric and all the actions of the United States? That with Obama, that with Trump, that with the can, ----- "two big differences"
              At the same time, there is a writing and media part of the population who drowns for staff members and who are "ashamed that I am Russian." .... and in the states like this.
        2. Volder
          Volder April 29 2021 13: 26
          +1
          Quote: rocket757
          PP S is not 20 years old, but 30! Or "saints 90", is it something else?
          The liberal 90s are different. You need to understand! :)
          1. rocket757
            rocket757 April 29 2021 13: 35
            +1
            There is only to и after ...
            Now we live after and it's time to accept it as a fact ... and then various options for actions, intentions, plans. Someone is good at what, who understands how it all.
      2. Intruder
        Intruder April 29 2021 13: 41
        +2
        20 years of empty promises and totally verbiage have not seen enough?
        Apparently not, if people "hawala" gloomy ideas for over 20 years and rejoices in all this ... yes !
        1. rocket757
          rocket757 April 29 2021 14: 21
          +1
          And what is it \ that people saw such that would distract from listening to sweet fairy tales and empty promises ??? The same fairy tales, or even legends of deep antiquity ... maybe beautiful, pleasant, but WHERE IS WHERE ???
          There is no one to be distracted by and stop chewing on the old gum.
          Those at the top, around them, the elite and the "advanced intelligentsia" are busy with their own, more interesting, important affairs and for the rest of the people they are ... very on top.
          We have no new Bolsheviks who went differently, their own way!
          1. Intruder
            Intruder April 29 2021 14: 45
            0
            We have no new Bolsheviks who went differently, their own way!
            And it will not be, how do you imagine something like that in the modern world - the Internet, globalization and international contacts for everyone !? Those times have already passed and remained in the history of the last century, now are other times and, most importantly, several generations of other people have been born to their parents ... A real revolutionary does not chew matzo and burrito in bistros and cafes and does not go to rallies with an empty plastic cup and with a smartphone in their hands, hated and beautiful from manicure! He is from a different class and with his own vision, goals and objectives, as well as the means that justify the sacrifices made, for the sake of the Great Idea !!!
            1. rocket757
              rocket757 April 29 2021 15: 19
              +1
              Quote: Intruder
              And it will not be, as you imagine in the modern world

              Not everyone can even imagine it, not what to CREATE!
              A special talent is needed ... precisely because conditions have changed, people have picked up a lot of different things, although in the depths, in the fundamentals, many remain the same as our ancestors were.
              In general, everything is hidden in the fog and you have to ... have to, in short.
            2. Reptiloid
              Reptiloid April 30 2021 09: 26
              +1
              ........ a real revolutionary doesn't eat in bistros and cafes. .....
              hi I do not agree with you, remember the beginning of the 20th century.
    2. mikh-korsakov
      mikh-korsakov April 29 2021 12: 16
      +17
      I think. that Putin's position about the red lines is an empty cheek. Why? And for one simple reason that he refused to mark these red lines. Very comfortable position. Let's say they disconnected us from Swift. People get telefaxes from the depths of the closets. But enterprises from this incur real losses, and a decline in living standards sets in. And what about Putin? Putin makes a sarcastic face and says that the red line has not yet been reached, but you (the enemies) are already close. In general, the situation is known in the analysis, it can be interpreted as an asymptotic approximation to the red line. However, I would not denounce Putin. Putin is the chick of Sobchakov's nest. And oranges do not grow from aspen. But this theater has been too long.
      1. rocket757
        rocket757 April 29 2021 12: 28
        0
        Quote: mikh-korsakov
        Putin's position on red lines is an empty cheek

        He is a politician, to expect something concrete from such, like, he gave his word - hold it !!! not worth it.
        They are all like that ... it's not even complacency, it's just a statement of fact.
        Something else and how it will be ... we'll see, because we don't want / can't create anything else, but nothing will happen, nothing will change ... the rich will get richer, and the people ??? the people will continue to bite.
        1. Fan-fan
          Fan-fan April 29 2021 17: 23
          0
          the people will continue to plunge.
          They don't even want to go to the bay, but happily throw their caps up. My bro, for example, was delighted to raise the retirement age for us, although the former cop himself calmly retired when he was still very young.
          1. rocket757
            rocket757 April 29 2021 17: 34
            +2
            There is social discontent and a noisy minority happily throw themselves in caps.
            There are many, many indifferent, this is the saddest thing ...
            The main thing is that the light at the end of the tunnel is not visible and Danko, leading, the illuminating path is not visible !!!
            There are enough Susanins and Sharons, this is a fact.
        2. Reptiloid
          Reptiloid April 30 2021 09: 19
          +1
          Quote: rocket757
          ...... He is a politician, to expect something specific from such, like, he gave his word - hold on! They're all like that ... it's not even complacency, it's just a statement of fact.
          Something else and how it will be ... we will see, because we do not want / cannot create anything else, but nothing will happen by itself, ........

          hi good day, Victor! I have always thought that politicians are not saying what they really are, but what is in the context at the moment. You cannot expect sincerity from them. Are image-makers and political scientists, and advisers, and secretaries really needed for a politician to speak sincerely? lol To hide reality, in my opinion ...
          1. rocket757
            rocket757 April 30 2021 09: 40
            +1
            Hi Dmitry soldier
            What can be said if a politician does not know how to keep his nose downwind, if his assistants and advisers do not sense what requests / wishes are in society, this is ... a team of losers !!!
            That's all.
            What kind of team we have, at the top, we must decide for ourselves.
            1. Reptiloid
              Reptiloid April 30 2021 09: 51
              +1
              ...... what ..... team .....
              in my opinion, Victor, we have a team located in recourse some half asleep, whatever to say request otherwise ..
              1. rocket757
                rocket757 April 30 2021 10: 02
                +1
                We love to laugh at the expense of the "brake Balts", but when you look at the top of us, no matter how funny, it becomes.
                1. Reptiloid
                  Reptiloid April 30 2021 10: 58
                  +1
                  Victor! There --- they were late, here --- they did not calculate, in another place ---- they did not think ...
                  Either these are brakes, over which, or laugh, or be horrified, or worse, ----
                  ..... stupidity or betrayal ...

                  How many similar things have happened in 30 years. After all, they scolded the USSR, and now the republics are retreating into the zone of influence of other countries ...
                  Quote: rocket757
                  We love to laugh at the expense of the "brake Balts", but when you look at the top of us, no matter how funny, it becomes.

                  It's a shame for the state ...
                  Before the evening hi
                  1. rocket757
                    rocket757 April 30 2021 11: 10
                    +1
                    It's a shame for the state, that's true.
                    Happily. soldier
      2. Overlock
        Overlock April 29 2021 13: 31
        +5
        Quote: mikh-korsakov
        I think. that Putin's position about the red lines is an empty cheek.

        For some reason I agree with you hi
  7. Stalnov I.P.
    Stalnov I.P. April 29 2021 10: 32
    +15
    A message at the level of a collective farm meeting in the USSR, and not the most advanced one.
    1. Doccor18
      Doccor18 April 29 2021 10: 54
      +9
      Don't be bad about collective farms.
      At a collective farm meeting, there were cases when the chairman, along with the accountant, was dismissed from office by voting of the collective, and spontaneously, unexpectedly ... that the recent leadership was upset to tears.
      This is unthinkable now.
  8. parusnik
    parusnik April 29 2021 10: 32
    +6
    [B]
    "The organizers of any provocations against Russia will regret it as they have not regretted anything for a long time." [
    /b ]..... They will go to hell, and we will go to heaven, respectively. And we have heard this. And speaking of the message, the Assembly, I remember the immortal "Oh, I sent, so I sent!" (... from the cartoon Last year's snow was falling).
    1. Reptiloid
      Reptiloid April 29 2021 11: 47
      +3
      hi hello, Alexey! It was like this
      ..... we will go to heaven, and they will just die .......

      It can be understood that we are talking about sacrifice. It is not clear in the name of what the people are ...
      I remembered completely different words
      ... boldly we will go into battle for the Power of the Soviets,
      and as one we will die fighting for this ...
  9. paul3390
    paul3390 April 29 2021 10: 34
    +15
    "And you friends, if you don’t sit down, you’re not good for musicians." The system must be changed, and as quickly as possible, and not paint the facade of Putin's oligarchy! Moreover, as life has shown, they are not even able to paint the facade ...
    1. Semyonich from the Urals
      Semyonich from the Urals April 29 2021 11: 33
      .
      You would be more careful to click on the keys with a rake ..
      And then, as if under an article about extremism, do not fly into
      1. paul3390
        paul3390 April 29 2021 18: 13
        -1
        And I have nothing to be afraid of, unlike you - I am not ashamed of my opinion and will confirm it anywhere. Look - he decided to scare me with organs .. Nothing - the old Bolsheviks spent half their lives in prisons and exile, which means that I will not be ashamed to suffer for the truth. And your advice - roll it up and shove it where your type of thoughts are generated.
        1. Semyonich from the Urals
          Semyonich from the Urals April 29 2021 19: 04
          -1
          I don’t scare you at all ..
          I agree with you myself .. but now the times are mean, you can fly where you don't expect ..
          1. paul3390
            paul3390 April 29 2021 21: 12
            +1
            I am, you see, a communist. My convictions do not allow me to show off ...
  10. YasenPen
    YasenPen April 29 2021 10: 40
    +12
    In his message, Putin voiced a whole package of social measures ...

    After all, the theses in the message, although important, are, as you know, ... recommendatory in nature.

    Blah blah blah...
  11. Basarev
    Basarev April 29 2021 10: 40
    +12
    And this is definitely not a recording? It's the same every year.
  12. Stirbjorn
    Stirbjorn April 29 2021 10: 41
    +1
    Why is the photo old, and not from the Message ?!
    1. Ingvar 72
      Ingvar 72 April 29 2021 10: 49
      +3
      So the message is globally nothing new. All the same songs, but with different music. request
    2. nnm
      nnm April 29 2021 10: 51
      +2
      Is there a difference?)))
  13. New Year day
    New Year day April 29 2021 10: 44
    0
    A significant part of the political elite continues to ride on the old rails,

    And it will go on. This elite determines the vector of movement of the country. It is difficult to imagine that having money and immovable property there, families living there, they will deprive themselves of such opportunities. And we have no other elite
  14. eleronn
    eleronn April 29 2021 10: 45
    +17
    Personally, I am fed up with his messages! I would like to hear a report on the work done following the results of the previous "messages" from the people.
    1. NDR-791
      NDR-791 April 29 2021 11: 06
      +7
      Quote: eleronn
      I would like to hear a report on the work done following the results of the previous "messages" from the people.

      We can only hear this ...
    2. ABC-schütze
      ABC-schütze April 29 2021 11: 45
      .
      In general, what "people" are you broadcasting about? .. If about the people of Russia, from the author of regular (and very topical ...) messages to the Federal Assembly, it is he who elects the head of state. So far, I can say one thing ... The discussed article, which is much more meaningful, so far not very numerous "comments" to it. I am not at all sorry for their authors, in this case. So far, literally everything is in the nature of "general watering" and emotional "snorting". No more ... And the general answer is this. Russia does not set a goal to live off the "printing press". And it means that he will live and plan budget expenditures, according to the money earned, and not the "wishlist" of the dissatisfied public. Moreover, under any Russian government (from "red" to "white"). And under the anti-Russian government, that is, the one about which foreign doctors of Russian "fighters against corruption" dream languidly, the Russian people, in general, will not get a fig. Akromya "free recommendations", the Russian state from its own economy "to remove away", and "to sell and reduce everything." An example of the former united Ukraine is a blessing in front of the nose ... But, as the message obviously implies, there will be no anti-Russian power in Russia. It's a shame, right? ..
      1. Overlock
        Overlock April 29 2021 11: 56
        +8
        Quote: ABC-schütze
        But, as it obviously follows from the message, there will be no anti-Russian government in Russia.

        I do not understand! Is the current government anti-Russian?
        1. ABC-schütze
          ABC-schütze April 29 2021 12: 10
          .
          Your "misunderstanding" is your problem, not the Russian authorities. And not mine ...
          1. Overlock
            Overlock April 29 2021 12: 24
            +8
            Quote: ABC-schütze
            Your "misunderstanding" is your problem, not the Russian authorities.

            You have something with logic and spelling
            Quote: ABC-schütze
            But as it obviously follows from the message, there will be no anti-Russian government in Russia

            Decipher your deep thought
            1. ABC-schütze
              ABC-schütze April 29 2021 12: 39
              .
              Counteroffer. And more logical, by the way. Decipher your "deep misunderstanding" ...
              1. Overlock
                Overlock April 29 2021 12: 44
                +3
                Quote: ABC-schütze
                Decipher your "deep misunderstanding" ...

                What to decipher what is written clearer than clear?
                1. ABC-schütze
                  ABC-schütze April 29 2021 12: 51
                  -6
                  And what exactly did you, in the context of your own "misunderstanding" of the simple text, write? .. Moreover, the other authors of the comments, whose logic, I think, is all right, do not demonstrate any "misunderstanding" about what I have written. And they only express obvious dissatisfaction ...
                  1. Overlock
                    Overlock April 29 2021 13: 02
                    +3
                    Quote: ABC-schütze
                    And what exactly did you, in the context of your own "misunderstanding" of the simple text, write? .. Moreover, the other authors of the comments, whose logic, I think, is all right, do not demonstrate any "misunderstanding" about what I have written. And they only express obvious dissatisfaction ...

                    drove by.
      2. Fan-fan
        Fan-fan April 29 2021 17: 36
        -2
        Quote: ABC-schütze
        An example of the former united Ukraine, good in front of the nose

        And can you put North Korea and Venezuela as an example? Why not be compared with the best, for example, European countries - Finland, Sweden, Switzerland, etc.? Why are you being compared to the most retarded?
        1. ABC-schütze
          ABC-schütze April 30 2021 15: 05
          0
          Maybe I'll put it. After all, they do not allow themselves to be ruined by the street congregations. And under external pressure (absolutely not legal ...) they do not bend. By the way ... Lover of "blissful" examples. From what - such an overturning of Switzerland and Sweden, in the context of "examples" for Russia, did you seize on? ILLEGAL overthrow of the LEGAL power by the crowd, has not been observed today. In contrast to the former united Ukraine, for example, in the context of possible Russian "democratic-reformist" perspectives from all sorts of programless mediocrity - clown-patients Charité, I referred. It is quite logical and appropriate. This is the first ... Now, the second ... I am somehow far from convinced that if such a "democratic reform" (coup d'etat with the overthrow of power) happened today in Switzerland or Sweden, they would not have followed the path of the former united Ukraine. And they would not have collapsed quickly and with a bang. It seems to me that, say, the same People's Party would hardly tolerate the forceful usurpation of power by all sorts of "green" or "cosmopolitans." As well as vice versa ... Yes, and in the same Sweden, for such a plot, home-grown boys, such as "breakviks" would be found enough. After all, they very calmly banged Palma. So, I strongly recommend choosing examples of "democratic reform" from real life, from those that are more relevant and closer to the topic, and not those that are "pleasing to the eye" ... For this, everyone, acre of noteworthy "fighters against corruption" - Charité patients, with the Proletarian holiday. And, I believe, the Victory Day parade will be no less meaningful and clear than the Message of the Supreme Commander. It will be fun to read the comments of the "critics" ...
  15. unaha
    unaha April 29 2021 10: 48
    +11
    "It is no coincidence that the state clearly marked a red line for this Vladimir" inmate "- all structures supporting his movement can turn into extremist, that is, undermining national security" - judging by these words, anti-corruption investigations, freedom of expression are very much "undermining national security" opinions, independent (from the state) journalism and fair elections.
    1. New Year day
      New Year day April 29 2021 11: 13
      +9
      Quote: unaha
      anti-corruption investigations very much "undermine national security"

      You have forgotten the words of Yarovaya - "if you fight corruption, then Russia will fall apart"
      1. ABC-schütze
        ABC-schütze April 29 2021 12: 17
        .
        And you are an inattentive reader. Because Russia will really fall apart if the sponsors of the Russian "fighters against corruption" are "state departments", foreign grandmothers who carry (on the sly, I emphasize ...) parcels to them, to foreign patients and other "independent" from the Russian state .. So, here Yarovaya is 100% right. Although I personally did not hear her words ...
        1. 2 Level Advisor
          2 Level Advisor April 29 2021 12: 53
          +4
          And you try not to exaggerate in your own way, as you like, but to listen literally - what they said, without your own ideas about corruption "from the State Department" nothing was said ...
          1. ABC-schütze
            ABC-schütze April 29 2021 13: 15
            .
            Duc, not only Yarovaya is talking about "Russian corruption". The State Department mentioned by me, as one can assume, has become something like more than she is "chronically preoccupied. They cannot even eat ... At one time, a certain" Kerry ", already with a" whole portfolio ", came to this subject. , without my "ideas" does not work ...
        2. New Year day
          New Year day April 29 2021 14: 24
          +1
          Quote: ABC-schütze
          if the sponsors of the Russian "fighters against corruption" are "state departments", zabugorn

          So there is no prophet in your homeland? laughing
          Quote: ABC-schütze
          Although I personally did not hear her words ...

          It can be fixed
          1. ABC-schütze
            ABC-schütze April 30 2021 14: 32
            0
            1. In any case, among the authors of the comments to the article about the Message, they are not exactly visible. And I do not pretend to this status ... 2. Well, if those who so indistinctly comment on the Message (including, alas, you ...) gathered to "correct", then I do not observe any particular difference from Yarovaya ...
    2. ABC-schütze
      ABC-schütze April 29 2021 11: 26
      .
      Judging by your comment, the mentioned "structures supporting his movement", that is, the State Department, grandmother Kantslerin, secretly (and secretly from the German taxpayer ...) carrying parcels to "patient Charite", as well as the NATO laboratory of the Bundeswehr, which gives him medical "diagnoses", that is, the most, "fighters against Russian corruption", as well as "journalists independent of the state" (from which state they are "independent" ...), and, of course, the most objective "guarantors" of some "fair" elections in Russia ... By the way ... Why do you neglect the epithet "legitimate" elections? .. And resort to populist and emotional lyrics, using the epithet "honest"? introduction of amendments to the Constitution of Russia initiated by him? ..
      1. Overlock
        Overlock April 29 2021 11: 58
        +7
        Quote: ABC-schütze
        Judging by your comment, the aforementioned "structures supporting his movement", that is, the State Department, grandmother Kantslerin, secretly (and secretly from the German taxpayer ...) carrying parcels to "patient Charite", as well as the NATO laboratory of the Bundeswehr, giving him medical "diagnoses"

        What a fiery speech!
        Then EP-
        Quote: ABC-schütze
        and there is i.e. most, "fighters against Russian corruption", as well as "journalists independent of the state" (from which state they are "independent" ...), and, of course, the most objective "guarantors" of some "fair" elections in Russia

        After all, it was the United Russia that became known to the country Navalny. United Russia pulled him into the political world request
        1. ABC-schütze
          ABC-schütze April 29 2021 12: 23
          .
          Well, if so, then she gave him a kick in the ass. So everything is normal here. It is not clear only why you call the running of the clown character without a political program through the streets and his antics in front of youngsters "the political world" ... In Russia, it seems, it is not the States. And politics is not identified with a clown booth ...
          1. Overlock
            Overlock April 29 2021 12: 28
            +8
            Quote: ABC-schütze
            Well, if so, then she also gave him a kick in the ass. So everything is normal here.

            Seriously?
            Quote: ABC-schütze
            It is not clear only why you call the running of the clown character without a political program through the streets and his antics in front of youngsters "the political world" ...

            I'm telling you that you have a problem with the logic!
            But it turns out that you don't even know how to read
            Quote: Overlock
            Navalny became known to the United Russia country. United Russia pulled it out в political world
            1. ABC-schütze
              ABC-schütze April 29 2021 12: 36
              .
              Well, if you identify the "character WITHOUT a political program" mentioned by me with the "political" world, from which they gave him a kick .. Then with "logic, you are all right. I am happy for you ...
              1. Overlock
                Overlock April 29 2021 12: 49
                +5
                Quote: ABC-schütze
                Well, if you identify the "character WITHOUT a political program" I mentioned with the "political" world, from which he was kicked ..

                You don't know Russian! What does the preposition mean "in" In russian language?
                We open the explanatory dictionary:
                The preposition "in" is used
                ... to denote phenomena, objects that are an area, inwards which action is directed .... "
                therefore
                Quote: ABC-schütze
                "character WITHOUT a political program" equates with the "political" world

                You identify.
                1. ABC-schütze
                  ABC-schütze April 29 2021 13: 06
                  -7
                  I authorize you to be my proofreader for style, spelling and punctuation. Moreover, I have only a solid "threefold" "in Russian", and you already have a "whole explanatory dictionary" always open. But ... Where did you see the preposition "B" in my quotation? .. By the way, for an educational program ... The preposition "in" in Russian is quite freely used not only to designate the area in which the action is directed. But also to designate the area in which SOMETHING IS HAPPENING AND WITHOUT AN ACTIVITY DIRECTED into it ...
                  1. Overlock
                    Overlock April 29 2021 13: 14
                    +4
                    Quote: ABC-schütze
                    I authorize you to be my proofreader for style, spelling and punctuation.

                    Not worthy of such an honor
                    Quote: ABC-schütze
                    Moreover, "in Russian" I have only a solid "three"

                    In fact of the matter.
                    Quote: Overlock
                    United Russia pulled it out в political world


                    Quote: ABC-schütze
                    WITHOUT a political program "with a" political "world identify

                    Learn Russian, young man. I don't detain you anymore
                    1. ABC-schütze
                      ABC-schütze April 29 2021 13: 24
                      -6
                      I see ... Then counter advice. Learn Russian, dear proofreader. For according to the dictionary, to which you yourself refer, the SAME term pulled out by you, cannot in any way mean an action directed "INSIDE". And used in the preposition "B". For, in Russian, "pulling out" is possible ONLY FROM somewhere ... From home, from hut, from school. Let's say, where did they pull you from? ..
                    2. ABC-schütze
                      ABC-schütze April 29 2021 13: 29
                      -5
                      Being a humane person and taking into account the "peculiarities" of your "logic", I explain In Russian, it would be much more reasonable for you to write the EP "Dragged" him into the political world "... And not" Dragged him out "into this one. You pick up without my prompting ...
      2. unaha
        unaha April 29 2021 13: 03
        +6
        "Why do you neglect the epithet" legitimate "elections?" - because they, like many things in the country now, are completely legal, but they are completely unfair and are not even close to being honest. Those. as a conditional example, let us take the right to express an opinion - the constitution, for example, guarantees such a right, and the by-law stipulates that such expression is possible on any day, except from Monday to Sunday, and is approved by those against whom it is directed. Legal? Yes. Fair and feasible? not.
        So with the elections - can an opposition candidate (really oppositional, not "type") be nominated? Can. And the fact that only these candidates for some reason cannot pass the "municipal filter" or suddenly criminal proceedings are initiated, well, that's how it turned out, right? But everything is legal, isn't it?
        1. ABC-schütze
          ABC-schütze April 29 2021 14: 11
          -7
          The epithets "honest" and "fair" are lyrics for a communal kitchen or tram. And for the elections of state, regional or municipal authorities, in a state governed by the rule of law, there is only ONE ONE criterion. Are they LEGAL or not. And in the Russian Constitution (adopted, by the way, at the PUBLIC REFERENDUM ...) IT IS NOT ANYWHERE SAID that, for example, the "right" to meetings for the purpose of the "expression of opinion" mentioned by you is "free". I will give an example, and unlike you, it is not at all "conditional". Article 31 of the current Russian Constitution states: "Citizens of the Russian Federation have the right to assemble peacefully, without weapons, to hold meetings, rallies and demonstrations, processions and pickets." Where is the term "free" here? .. It is NOT in the Constitution. This is written HONESTLY. AND VISIBLY CLEAR AND UNIFORMALLY. This means that ANY assemblies to which citizens have a constitutional right must be organized and held in the manner determined by laws or by-laws adopted in accordance with a legal procedure, by the legal authority. And I remind you that the Constitution was adopted by the PEOPLE of Russia in a referendum. But whether someone "likes" this order or not, that's another matter. Do not like it, change the power at LEGAL ELECTIONS. But, BY THE LAW, again, and not according to concepts like "honest" - "dishonest" ...
      3. unaha
        unaha April 29 2021 13: 15
        +3
        "as well as" independent from the state journalists "(from which state they are" independent "- mainly from the one in which they reveal the problems. If you are not ready to accept alternative views, then you become like which the scandal with Sanders does not count as it was exposed by "Russian hackers".
        1. ABC-schütze
          ABC-schütze April 29 2021 13: 34
          -6
          Well, yes ... I understand your answer. Then I believe that in the Third Reich there would have been quite enough "independent" journalists ready, say, to "reveal the problems" of the USSR ...
          1. unaha
            unaha April 29 2021 14: 09
            +4
            And then! And as for Khan Batu ... With such "arguments", there is no point in continuing the discussion.
            1. ABC-schütze
              ABC-schütze April 29 2021 14: 28
              -5
              Continue it or not, it's up to you. I asked you a question about your "explanation" and did not receive a clear answer. For this, I remain a supporter of the following Leninist thesis: "You cannot live in society and be free from society." ... Man is a biosocial being, and without society he will not be able to live, develop and take shape as a person. "The state is the highest form of social organization, and the aforementioned" journalists "are just" people. "And, therefore, to be" independent " from the state in which they live and are engaged in "journalism", in principle, they cannot. No matter how they would like it. And no matter how they treat this state ... And, therefore, all the talk about some kind of "independent" from the state journalism is empty demagoguery. They may or may not support the policy of the authorities, but this has nothing to do with the notorious "independence" from the state. And if their position in relation to the policy of the state coincides with the position of its opponents (all the more external ...) and publicly approved from the outside, ANY state has all the legal rights (even the OBLIGATION ...) to keep their PUBLIC activities under special control ... And this is by no means "invented" by the "Russian authorities" ...
  16. The comment was deleted.
  17. Dynamic systems
    Dynamic systems April 29 2021 11: 15
    +8
    With affection he looked at the sleepy "servants of the people" laughing There was no snoring ...
    Duty applause "cheered up the spirit" of those "thinking about Russia" ... wassat crying
    And the expression "cheered up" resembled a phrase from the movie "VIY":
    "Panochka is dead! fellow "
    "Has already died wassat "... crying
  18. Virus-free crown
    Virus-free crown April 29 2021 11: 29
    +8
    Expert opinion:

    "So far, no major changes in the trajectory of economic development of the Russian Federation are foreseen."

    crying

    In the meantime, it is not foreseen - then all that negative that is now will grow at an alarming pace, starting with social tension ...
  19. Esoteric
    Esoteric April 29 2021 11: 38
    +12
    Don't give a damn about Navalny. Recent news. The Constitutional Court allowed the only housing to be sold for debts. Getting ready for the millions of homeless people on the streets?
    1. Woodman
      Woodman April 29 2021 12: 08
      -5
      Quote: Ezoterik
      sell the only housing for debts. Preparing for the millions of homeless people on the streets

      You would at least have taken an interest in the topic you have just written about ... And then you would have grieved for the future homeless people ...
      1. Freeman
        Freeman April 29 2021 13: 12
        +4
        Quote: Lesovik
        Quote: Ezoterik
        sell the only housing for debts. Preparing for the millions of homeless people on the streets

        You would at least have taken an interest in the topic you have just written about ... And then you would have grieved for the future homeless people ...


        The thing is that in Russia, there is still "the law that the tongue".
        And "real law enforcement practice" so perverts its "spirit", relying on the "letter", that it is simply "astonishing". request

        "Wangui" that basically it will be applied not against "bankrupt" owners of "elite real estate" who declared it "the only housing" - but against debtors of "microfinance organizations". IMHO
        1. Woodman
          Woodman April 29 2021 13: 23
          -6
          Quote: Freeman
          but against the debtors of "microfinance organizations". IMHO

          Even in this case, there are clear norms of living space, which should not be deprived of debtors. And those who have contacted microfinance are unlikely to have extra square meters that can be used to pay off debts.
          Although, in my opinion, all this microfinance needs to be closed. Now such organizations can be successfully replaced with credit cards of any banks. At least their appetites are not so monstrous. And people do not associate with microfinance from a great mind.
          P.S. When trying to post a comment, the following message appeared: The message contains text that is not valid for publication.
          I still didn't understand why ...
          1. Freeman
            Freeman April 29 2021 13: 53
            +1
            Lesovik Today, 13:23
            Even in this case, there are clear norms of living space, which should not be deprived of debtors. And those who have contacted microfinance are unlikely to have extra square meters that can be used to pay off debts.


            It is not the quantity of "square meters" that matters, but their price.
            Even a "murdered Khrushcheb" in the center of a city with a population of 100 will be more expensive than a "barrack" on its outskirts or in the "neighborhood".

      2. Esoteric
        Esoteric April 29 2021 13: 30
        +5
        Yes, I read it. It seems to be all according to the mind. A person owes over a lot of money, but instead of repaying the debt, he buys a house for himself, the price of which is much higher than the amount of the debt, and declares this house to be the only one. Here I agree, this gentleman had to repay the debt, the funds were available. Didn't give it away, but bought real estate to get away from paying off the debt? Take it, no questions asked. This is essentially a scam.
        But the trouble is that this practice will be applied to people living in "huts" who can barely survive and cannot repay their debt. Don't take it? Different situations happen, from elementary wages were delayed and there was nothing to eat, until I fell ill, and there was no money to buy medicine, the alternative was in a coffin.
        The owners of the mansions will keep everything, and the owners of the "huts" will go to the homeless.
        1. Woodman
          Woodman April 29 2021 14: 47
          -2
          Quote: Ezoterik
          Didn't give it away, but bought real estate to get away from paying off the debt? Take it, no questions asked. This is essentially a scam.

          So, because of this, the law was adopted.
          Quote: Ezoterik
          But the trouble is that this practice will be applied to people living in "huts" who can barely survive,

          That's when this practice will be applied in the way you are talking about - then it is worth talking about it. In the meantime, the law is being adopted to curb fraud. Essentially a good purpose. And you are already turning it inside out.
  20. Yaroslavl
    Yaroslavl April 29 2021 11: 48
    +11
    saber rattling will no longer cause a rise in national pride ... everyone understands it, except for the grandfather .... we need an increase in the welfare of citizens ... this is what we should not only mention in vain, but start doing it for a long time
  21. ABC-schütze
    ABC-schütze April 29 2021 12: 03
    .
    In short, the best example for the critics of the author of the message to the Federal Assembly, presumably, would be the "100-day" speech of the pensioner Biden. That would be "and we have this" in Russia? .. Really guys ... Milestone "won". Nayi. "rallied" ... the States "returned to the world." And, again, "moved forward" ...
    1. Fan-fan
      Fan-fan April 29 2021 17: 52
      -1
      It would be enchanting if Biden could be led to us, and Putin to them? Who do you think would have the best circus?
  22. Mikhail3
    Mikhail3 April 29 2021 12: 22
    +12
    The main problem is in the structure of the state, in the underlying foundation. In the framework, so to speak, the ideology, according to which the state is filled with people who revive this framework. What kind of people does our state apparatus consist of? What kind of people did you decide to recruit there? Well, it's not a secret to anyone.
    Our state, wholly and completely, consists of thieves. As before, the Russian Empire built its framework from the aristocracy. How did the USSR build two organizational structures in parallel - the economy of their workers, and the control, party economy, of careerists (which ultimately destroyed it). But today's Russia is ruled by thieves. At all levels. A substantial part of these thieves were owned by organized crime groups, being their actual owners. Then the organized crime groups became out of fashion, as bureaucratic thieves built chains that allowed them to grab from the budget as much as they wanted, and deal with opponents with the hands of security officials. Usually no blood. Progress!
    It is ridiculous to turn away from reality, but this is exactly what the authorities are doing now. It is amusing to observe the attempts of the Law to "put things in order". The mass of the people was captured and condemned! Really! So what? Among thieves, you can only behave like a thief, otherwise they will devour you. Arrest at least every day, the people who have come to the place of thieves will be exactly the same, and they will steal in the same way. The "vertical of power" does not allow other people into itself, It simply cannot, it is so created. The order is already in place. Thieves' order. Just a couple of little problems ...
    First of all, thieves are not able to build, create. This is absolutely unrealistic, impossible, "whatever the scientists of the Chui Valley invented, and still came out anasha." And secondly, thieves organically, at the deepest level, cannot stand workers, specialists, creators. Thieves hate such people and are afraid of them. Such is the grief.
    Our country in its current state is, in principle, incapable of development. There is no one to develop it. There are no ways by which the creators could get to any processes of creation, improvement. We will not stand the pressure. We will not survive the crisis. Hard times at the thieves' hut, this is "you die today, and I will die tomorrow." I personally don't see any hope ...
    1. Kronos
      Kronos April 29 2021 17: 31
      0
      Aristocrats in the Russian Empire finally became parasites in the bulk by the beginning of the 19th century.
      1. Mikhail3
        Mikhail3 April 30 2021 12: 34
        0
        This nonsense has surprisingly deep roots in Soviet consciousness. This is completely wrong) You see, there are basic principles by which real people direct the upbringing of their offspring. The aristocracy in Russia was strange, that's true. For example, the English aristocracy brought up and educates in their descendants the strength and developed ability to betray in time. Betrayal is a high art and the meaning of life of the Anglo-Saxons.
        And the Russian aristocracy brought up various nonsense in their offspring - honor, loyalty, courage, dignity, and other non-modern nonsense. To our great regret, in the Russian aristocratic environment, the direction of Knowledge was not formed, that is, no critical importance was attached to education and the ability to think. This is one of the main reasons why RI lost and died.
        And the Russian government in a certain sense abandoned the aristocracy. When they needed the qualities necessary at the time of the industrial-scientific revolution, they did not demand them from the aristocracy, but began to simply look for other, ready-made people. Among common people, merchants, etc. Not receiving instructions from the authorities, the aristocracy was simply confused. And the authorities themselves were not clearly aware of the changes. The response was purely situational, without understanding the current processes.
        Well, this is how our imperious thieves are now trying to plug holes, not realizing their current position. They can figure it out, but they really don't want to. It is better for the country to perish and the people to be annihilated than they achieve the realization of who they are and where they are going ...
        1. Kronos
          Kronos April 30 2021 14: 02
          0
          What nonsense? As soon as the edict was issued stating that military service was mandatory in the 19th century, the aristocracy lost its last duties.
          1. Mikhail3
            Mikhail3 4 May 2021 09: 36
            0
            Well, such) The aristocracy continued to bear the state on itself. Serve in the state apparatus in the most responsible positions. Determine politics and, in many respects, the economy. Do you think your responsibilities are something like compulsory sweeping of the yard)? Yes, kings shouldn't have done that. But that is another story.
  23. iouris
    iouris April 29 2021 12: 32
    -1
    1) Will the enemy be defeated?
    2) Will the victory be ours?
    3) Is Siberia ours?
    ... Lebedev really wanted to be called Baron of Moscow (he comes from the First See). But in London they thought it was too bold, and made it ... Siberian. ... Now the full name of the Russian in translation sounds like this - "Baron Lebedev from Hampton in London's Rind-on-Thames and Siberia in the Russian Federation."
  24. nikvic46
    nikvic46 April 29 2021 12: 36
    +3
    All the same, criticism sounds due to the fact that the majority of the country does not participate in the affairs of the state. The state lives by itself, people are on the sidelines. Even under capitalism, if an ordinary person can participate in the financial affairs of the country, everything looks different. about socialism. There a person buying any purchase knows that his money will go to the state's piggy bank, and not to some uncle. But that's not all, the main thing is that there is no formalism. This generates large and small injustices. And what could be worse for a person?
  25. Roman070280
    Roman070280 April 29 2021 12: 56
    +8
    all structures that support his movement can turn into extremist, that is, they undermine national security.


    Anyone who doesn't like Putin is an extremist ...
    It would be even easier ..))
    1. evgen1221
      evgen1221 April 29 2021 16: 20
      +3
      When will the tsaki be forced to put on and do it twice in front of the beloved authorities?
  26. evgen1221
    evgen1221 April 29 2021 16: 19
    +3
    The next thing, guys, we have driven the country once again, but believe us, you will disappear without us, and be sure to vote for the appointed receivers, they are very good, you see how the number of millionaires has grown dramatically, and you see how we tighten the nuts until the threads are broken, and you say we manage ineffectively, we conduct our business extremely efficiently, but they do not concern you, because this is a private business. Thank you for your attention, tomorrow prices will rise and the weather will be great.
  27. Tank jacket
    Tank jacket 1 May 2021 08: 46
    -1
    Cheating # 1
    "Of course, the new autarchy did not work. The Soviet Union depended on other countries in many respects, especially when it began exporting hydrocarbons to the West. The Russian Federation simplified the model, ruthlessly discarding many industries and plunging domestic production into a crisis, and therefore its own population."
    Cheating # 2

    "A radical liberalization of the country's financial market has taken place - investments have flowed to us, mainly of a speculative nature."
    negative
  28. Tank jacket
    Tank jacket 1 May 2021 08: 57
    0
    And again a lie ...
    "The second aspect is actually internal political. Social irritation in society is gradually, but growing. The government continues to tighten the" screws ", take punitive measures, but the effectiveness of the state mechanism itself does not increase. Such" beacon "institutions such as the police and courts, in essence do not change. Already 100 kilometers from Moscow, it is very difficult to achieve a quick response to offenses. "
  29. TatarinSSSR
    TatarinSSSR 1 May 2021 11: 07
    0
    The Russian people are now in limbo. On the one hand, he sees that the United States and the West are actively putting pressure on the country economically, politically and militarily. Provocations, internal ferment of pro-Western liberals and agents, false accusations, sanctions, military maneuvers, diplomatic war, etc., are all visible and understandable. But another thing is not clear - prices in shops, gas stations and resorts are growing by leaps and bounds, while there are no problems with food, fuel and hotels in the country. The endless corruption and impunity of employees of all ranks in the Ministry of Internal Affairs, Justice, city administrations and so on are also incomprehensible. About the traffic police separately generally keep quiet - there, starting with the driving exams, everything is already through the tax, otherwise you will not pass. And at the same time, salaries in many industries are not raised by a ruble. And the interest on bank loans for the population is simply horse-drawn. How does it compare with the confrontation with the United States?
  30. Trotil42
    Trotil42 4 May 2021 08: 54
    0
    Quote: Volder
    Quote: Dmitry Vladimirovich
    Better tell me why everything has risen in price? Why does the "Kremlin prisoner" not credit himself with the rise in food and fuel prices?
    Prices rose in the 1990s as well, and the population was then poorer. Stability was only in the USSR. Do you want the return of socialism and a planned economy? And by the way, there is inflation in many countries, even in Europe. This is a side effect of the market economy. Or do you want to see a government regulated market? Then it will no longer be a market.

    30 years have passed since then ... Germany after the war in 30 years has become the third economy of the world ... it was dismembered and bombed ... the factories were taken out by reproduction. What Putin calls stabilization ... is the degradation of the Soviet legacy ... Corruption blooms in such a magnificent color ... Why does he not take credit for this?