Military Review

"They write about the Second Front, but not a word about the Battle of Stalingrad": Putin spoke about history textbooks

101

President Putin touched upon the issue of teaching stories in schools and universities. According to the head of state, it is necessary to educate young people on heroic examples not only of the past, but also of the present. This is the basis of patriotic education.


Vladimir Putin noted that sometimes, "when you read history textbooks, you are simply amazed."

According to the president, "they often write such things that the question arises of who and how missed it as a teaching material."

Head of State:

They write about everything: they write about the Second Front, but not a word about the Battle of Stalingrad.

The President suggested that “take a closer look at what is written in Russian textbooks”. Additional funds will be allocated to update textbooks and tutorials.

Vladimir Putin noted that education and science are the most important components at all times. The development of the country is impossible without this.

In his message to the Federal Assembly, the President touched upon the development of nuclear, hydrogen and storage energy, and also added words about the need for environmental monitoring.

The level of greenhouse gas emissions should be less than in the EU, subject to the development of industrial potential.

Putin:

The work of all government bodies and the scientific community should be aimed at improving the quality of life of our people.


The President pointed out that it is necessary to develop the economy of the so-called closed cycle - using waste again.
Photos used:
Russian President's website
101 comment
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. apro
    apro April 21 2021 12: 52
    +21
    They write about everything: they write about the Second Front, but not a word about the Battle of Stalingrad.

    Himself beaten. Or is the Ministry of Education not subordinate to him? The tricks of the State Department?
    1. Thrifty
      Thrifty April 21 2021 12: 59
      +2
      apro-obey can be nominally, listen, but not hear, and then imitate vigorous activity! The main thing is to be able to splurge! Many have learned this well from him, especially the tame governors!
      1. apro
        apro April 21 2021 13: 01
        -2
        Quote: Thrifty
        The main thing is to be able to splurge!

        It is clear that there are many smart and cunning. Someone should at least define the general line. And control what they do not cross. Or it is the concern of some other president.
        1. Thrifty
          Thrifty April 21 2021 13: 13
          +3
          apro-but, free noodles during this time of his "speech from the throne" so much was hung on the ears!
          1. Sling cutter
            Sling cutter April 21 2021 13: 35
            -4
            Quote: Thrifty
            -but, free noodles during this time of his "throne speech" so much was hung on the ears!

            And I liked everything, from the suits from the bryony to the gold collar on the currency, there is no need to talk about the watch, these are city budgets.
        2. Civil
          Civil April 21 2021 13: 17
          -10%
          The propaganda is to blame, and what does the President have to do with it. The state media are to blame for having wiped out the Victory.
          1. Sling cutter
            Sling cutter April 21 2021 13: 48
            -13%
            Quote: Civil
            The propaganda is to blame, and what does the President have to do with it. The state media are to blame for having wiped out the Victory.

            Everything is clear, you have to go to the military registration and enlistment office to take a queue, you have to repeat it.
      2. Artyom Karagodin
        Artyom Karagodin April 21 2021 17: 10
        +2
        I agree. Our power is very heterogeneous. Not all VO readers will agree with this, but there are patriots there, and quite a few. However, there are enough traitors, and they are VERY influential since the 90s, when they were the overwhelming majority. And now these rely on the support of our oligarchs, most of whom do not hide their attitude to the country on which they profited. It is only in the comments that it is easy to expose them, and it is much more difficult to remove them from power. Even Stalin could not clean up everyone, as evidenced by the rapid departure of the party elite from the ideals of communism after his death.
        1. yang174
          yang174 April 21 2021 19: 35
          +2
          Artem, the biggest problem is that 95% do not want to do anything, if they see that someone is doing crap, then they are silent. So keep quiet and get the result you deserve. I work as a builder. I try to do it efficiently, and I look after others. if you do, if you don’t hand over the work, you won’t get money, but most of them sit on salaries and don’t care the frost, but they are all smart, with education. here the general construction engineer did not accept the job because the screed on the street (footing with a mortar mixture) was not primed for laying paving tiles on !!! mortar ... on the street ... nafig engineer ... physics 6kl ... who, except for spilling the base on the street with water, even primed there? and told her, who are you here? and we live
          1. Artyom Karagodin
            Artyom Karagodin April 22 2021 09: 06
            +1
            Yes, this happens quite often. But with regard to the percentage of "do not care" and "business executives" (and they still exist) - everywhere in different ways. Much depends on who specifically manages the district, region, city, village. He can keep the "trouser pullers" in good shape, or he can lead them.

            And an analogy is also appropriate here: a certain substance tends to float upward, and if, for example, on the surface of a pond there are many water lilies, but among them ... something floats, then, as a rule, no one looks at the water lilies. So it is here. The niggas salaries are always striking. Therefore, it seems that there are significantly more of them than there really are.

            I don’t know how where, but in our Stavropol Territory, even with a subsidized budget, the roads over the past 10 years have become such that we have already forgotten what it is like to drive on the highway no faster than 40 km / h. Indeed, it became cool. And they are constantly maintained in good condition. But in settlements - very differently. MinVody, despite the fact that it is not the poorest city, is a quiet horror in terms of roads. And our Zelenokumsk (a former village, 35 thousand population) is a completely different matter, even the residents themselves note. Asphalt is not everywhere, but where it has appeared in recent years, it is of excellent quality. Because the mayor was a do-it-yourselfer. But he was not from EdR, so over time he was competently wiped out from power. Now we cannot say that everything began to fall apart, just the pace of work has become completely different:

            - Stepan! The guest carriage broke.
            “I see, master.” The axis flew. And the needles must be changed.
            - How much will you do?
            - I'll do it in a day.
            - And for two?
            - Well ... For ... We’ll do it in two.
            - And in five days?
            “Well, if you try, you can do it in five.”
            - And for ten?
            - Well, master, you are setting goals! For ten days one can not cope, then an assistant is needed - homo sapiens!
            - Take assistants, but not earlier!
        2. Andrei Nikolaevich
          Andrei Nikolaevich April 22 2021 09: 40
          0
          Artyom, even Menshikov was a steal and a sneaky guy. But nevertheless "nestling of Petrov's nest" ".
        3. Vladimir Mashkov
          Vladimir Mashkov April 23 2021 17: 46
          +1
          Quote: Artyom Karagodin
          It is only in the comments that it is easy to expose them, and it is much more difficult to remove them from power. Even Stalin and he could not clean everyone,

          I agree with you. And I am amazed and laugh at the frenzy with which the VO Achtivists attack Putin! Of course, this is not from a great mind, although they seem to themselves and to each other very smart. But you can't see everything "from the couch" ... lol

          After all from great ideas declared by Putin to their implementation in life is often a long and long way and the same large number of performers, many of whom are either lazy, stupid or obvious sabotage NOT do what is supposed to be done, and some deliberately slow down the matter! The eternal Russian problem ...

          Here is what is too mild with pests and careless - bad!
      3. yang174
        yang174 April 21 2021 19: 27
        +1
        well, there is the same .. just a stupid person, not an illegal spy with an analytical mindset ... there is still no way to compare
    2. halpat
      halpat April 21 2021 13: 02
      +24
      It is high time to sweep away the crowd of textbook authors, of whom literally hundreds have spawned (according to history) during the time of Borka the drunkard.
      Half of these "scholarly affiliates" are noteworthy Russophobes, and there are also latent Bandera supporters. And already 90 percent absolutely definitely received, at one time, grants and grants from various "humanitarian" Western structures. It is difficult to blame many of them for this because they had absolutely nothing to eat then. Hunger is not an aunt, you can't sing like that.
      But you need to take a closer look at them, at least.
      1. NIKN
        NIKN April 21 2021 13: 14
        0
        Quote: Halpat
        Hunger is not an aunt, you can't sing like that.
        But you need to take a closer look at them, at least.

        Yes, but free cheese in a mousetrap is usually only for the second mouse ... "We have something with a mousetrap, there is a support of democratic values ​​that does not work for it, since the time when Gorbachev said that now we have democracy and glasnost, and what kind of publicity ... but at least it’s all paid for.
      2. Bad_gr
        Bad_gr April 21 2021 13: 51
        +8
        Quote: Halpat
        Half of these "scholarly affiliates" are noteworthy Russophobes,

        Our children of many government officials are now studying in prestigious foreign educational institutions. The time will come - they will return from there and, thanks to the money and connections of their parents, will receive jobs in government structures. With love for Russia grafted in England, America and hedgehogs with them. And at the moment, I do not see an end to this mockery of the country.
        Maybe someone sees the end of the bacchanalia of managers and Russophobes in the country, share your visions.
        1. seacap
          seacap April 21 2021 14: 11
          +8
          They have already received it, all this time they have been actively and diligently creating a hereditary estate society, and in one country, more precisely in one territory, they have not considered this country and people for a long time, but only as a means, living according to different laws and with different privileges and responsibilities, for the nobility and for the slaves.
        2. Konstantin Gogolev
          Konstantin Gogolev April 21 2021 14: 13
          +2
          Moreover, they go there already "prepared by the example of their parents" (the attitude has developed) - they already understand that working in leadership positions, they can not receive a salary - these are trifles in comparison with real income. Problems with the law can be solved, etc.
        3. halpat
          halpat April 21 2021 15: 03
          -2
          [quote = Bad_gr] [quote = khalpat] ... share your visions. [/ quote]
          Well, I'm not a Mechnikov fitter smile who had visions from the fountain.

          Let the children of officials finish their studies :) Not everyone will learn to be Russophobes and will come to Russia as sent Cossacks.
          There are positive examples of this :)

          “Consent is a product with complete non-resistance of the parties. The answer is the equivalent of a thought. "
          installer Mechnikov, 12 chairs, I. Ilf / E. Petrov smile
        4. yang174
          yang174 April 21 2021 19: 36
          0
          9g and wall. Available wrote?
      3. Looking for
        Looking for April 21 2021 16: 53
        -5
        but why go far. On this resource, all over the praise of Western technology and Western tactics and strategy. Such an impression. that the site is not Russian, but some kind of European. And the local authors hammer the head of the people with some kind of ratsars. armor. swords .. revolvers. any rubbish, but not in any way native Russian military history and technology.
    3. Svarog
      Svarog April 21 2021 13: 18
      +7
      Quote: apro
      They write about everything: they write about the Second Front, but not a word about the Battle of Stalingrad.

      Himself beaten. Or is the Ministry of Education not subordinate to him? The tricks of the State Department?

      I have the same banal question .. is it not destiny to disperse the ministers? It seems that he was collected from the Internet the claims of the people ... and he fulfills them ..
      1. Yves762
        Yves762 April 21 2021 13: 40
        0
        Quote: Svarog
        I have the same banal question .. is it not destiny to disperse the ministers?

        How is Comrade. Stalin asked (they say that): ".... And how many divisions does he have?" -, not in particulars, but in general principle (essence) it is the same. fellow
        Quote: Svarog
        It seems that they have collected people's claims from the Internet ... and he is working them out ..
        -
        Why not.?. request
        Especially in view of the above ...
    4. Piramidon
      Piramidon April 21 2021 13: 40
      -7
      Quote: apro
      Himself beaten. Or is the Ministry of Education not subordinate to him? The tricks of the State Department?

      Do you think that the president should personally read all the textbooks?
      1. apro
        apro April 21 2021 13: 42
        0
        Quote: Piramidon
        Do you think that the president should personally read all the textbooks?

        He must identify educational priorities and make them clear to follow.
        1. Egoza
          Egoza April 21 2021 14: 34
          +6
          Quote: apro
          He must identify educational priorities and make them clear to follow.

          So he designated! At the anniversary parade of Victory, he did not exhibit any portraits of Comrade. I.V. Stalin, nor Marshal Zhukov, nor other marshals of VICTORY! He was perfectly understood. So now let the beloved make claims on the textbooks
      2. seacap
        seacap April 21 2021 14: 19
        +1
        Actually, for this there should be the Academy of Sciences of the Russian Federation, as it was a little earlier in the Council of Deputies, which they hated, "which produced only galoshes and balalaikas," there is also the Ministry of Education and Science, by the way, the Ministry of Health. And what confused you so much, he is not the only one in charge of the country? This is a rhetorical question, no answer is required.
      3. Roman070280
        Roman070280 April 21 2021 14: 19
        -5
        Do you think that the president should personally read all the textbooks?

        Well, from somewhere he suddenly found out, "what they write about, but not a word about what" ..))
        1. Piramidon
          Piramidon April 21 2021 14: 35
          0
          Quote: Roman070280
          Well, from somewhere he suddenly found out, "what they write about, but not a word about what" ..))

          "Well-wishers" whispered))).
          1. Roman070280
            Roman070280 April 21 2021 14: 37
            -7
            "Well-wishers"


            Once in quotes, it means they lied to him ..
            In fact, everything is fine ..))
        2. Egoza
          Egoza April 21 2021 14: 35
          +2
          Quote: Roman070280

          Well, from somewhere he suddenly found out, "what they write about, but not a word about what" ..))

          So I read, maybe I was looking for what they write about his reign in history books. Or is it not time yet?
          1. Roman070280
            Roman070280 April 21 2021 14: 38
            -5
            So I read, maybe I was looking for what they write about his reign in history books. Or is it not time yet?


            I was looking for myself in the section about the Second Front ..))
      4. for
        for April 21 2021 16: 11
        0
        Quote: Piramidon
        Do you think that the president should personally read all the textbooks?

        Vladimir Putin noted that sometimes, "when you read history textbooks, you are simply amazed."
      5. RUSS
        RUSS April 21 2021 21: 21
        +2
        Quote: Piramidon
        Do you think that the president should personally read all the textbooks?

        The issue of history textbooks has been procrastinating for 10 years, there were instructions from the president, but things are still there.
    5. credo
      credo April 21 2021 14: 08
      +9
      Quote: apro
      According to the president, "they often write such things that the question arises of who and how missed it as a teaching material."

      So here we are, Vladimir Vladimirovich, very, very much like to know "... who missed it and how as a teaching material.", Given that all textbooks are coordinated with the Ministry of Education.
    6. tihonmarine
      tihonmarine April 21 2021 14: 16
      +3
      Quote: apro
      Himself beaten. Or is the Ministry of Education not subordinate to him? The tricks of the State Department?
      Isak Frumin, a member of the HSE Academic Council, who was the World Bank's representative in Russia, wrote manuals for secondary schools, which are still used by children. We can say that it was then that a certain factory for the production of meanings began to form, which included Skolkovo and Sberbank. There is already an updated foresight project of education - 2035, its author is the globalist foresight "Imyarek" - the main "overseer" for digitization.
      And these comrades are teaching the children about life.
    7. zloybond
      zloybond April 21 2021 19: 43
      +2
      The education minister teaches children to love America and not know or respect their history.
    8. iouris
      iouris April 21 2021 20: 48
      0
      Not carved, but sculpted!
  2. Avior
    Avior April 21 2021 12: 55
    +5
    ... they write about the Second Front, but not a word about the Battle of Stalingrad.

    And what is this tutorial?
    1. Ross xnumx
      Ross xnumx April 21 2021 13: 41
      +5
      "They write about the Second Front, but not a word about the Battle of Stalingrad": Putin spoke about history textbooks

      It was not necessary to edit the constitution, but to recall the one that was in the USSR, which made it possible to achieve victory in the war, and in science, and in the economy ... Maybe I would have remembered not about galoshes and the EBN house, but about the Pavlov House "...
  3. Thrifty
    Thrifty April 21 2021 12: 56
    +1
    He himself promised to hold a referendum on renaming the city back to Stalingrad, and that's it, forgot about his promise?
    1. apro
      apro April 21 2021 12: 59
      +3
      Quote: Thrifty
      and that's it, forgot about your promise?

      Do you remember a lot of his promises and I do not remember.
      1. Thrifty
        Thrifty April 21 2021 13: 08
        0
        apro, it's time to stop making new promises, and rigidly demand the fulfillment of old ones! There is just a breakthrough of fairy tales, and with the execution as in a cemetery, there is complete silence. ..
        1. WHAT IS
          WHAT IS April 21 2021 13: 13
          +4
          I agree, it is necessary to demand fulfillment, but there were a lot of these promises, with implementation not very ...
        2. apro
          apro April 21 2021 13: 17
          0
          Quote: Thrifty
          it's time to stop making new promises

          And with what to go for a new term ??? when you give promises to the electorate, etuzazim appear.
          Quote: Thrifty
          and hard to demand the fulfillment of old ones!

          And who to ask? with yourself? so many objective reasons ... non-fulfillment.
      2. Yves762
        Yves762 April 21 2021 13: 43
        +1
        Quote: apro
        Do you remember a lot of his promises?

        Aha.!.
        Do not raise the retirement age while he is president! wassat
      3. Ross xnumx
        Ross xnumx April 21 2021 13: 44
        0
        Quote: apro
        Do you remember a lot of his promises and I do not remember.

        And then the uncle told everything:
        https://proza.ru/2019/01/03/1530
  4. 12.7
    12.7 April 21 2021 13: 00
    +7
    Why can't we just fire from top to bottom, everyone who is responsible for this, starting with the minister? The option is even simpler - just reprimand the minister and set a deadline
    1. Thrifty
      Thrifty April 21 2021 13: 05
      0
      12.7-they know how much to put in their pocket, how much to give "up", and the new ones will suddenly change the rules for dividing the pie. ..
      1. novel66
        novel66 April 21 2021 13: 17
        +8
        as one plumber used to say
    2. novel66
      novel66 April 21 2021 13: 09
      +5
      even better - to announce a term to the minister
      1. Thrifty
        Thrifty April 21 2021 13: 12
        +1
        Roman 66 - they are there indefinitely, the main thing is to be able to lick in time, and to substitute a neighbor for distribution. ..
        1. novel66
          novel66 April 21 2021 13: 14
          +2
          it infuriates ... complete impunity
          1. Uncle lee
            Uncle lee April 21 2021 13: 44
            +1
            Quote: novel xnumx
            . complete impunity

            Roma, but as a new term: Entrepreneur-creator!
            1. novel66
              novel66 April 21 2021 14: 08
              +1
              already funny ... another option is a spreader
        2. Thrifty
          Thrifty April 21 2021 13: 18
          +2
          See how his fans rushed en masse to minus quietly! The site has already smelled of gray. ..
    3. Incvizitor
      Incvizitor April 21 2021 13: 33
      +1
      Because nepotism, if no one covers it, they will be fired if it is hidden from above, they are not touched.
    4. 72jora72
      72jora72 April 21 2021 13: 34
      +3
      The option is even simpler -
      Fire yourself ...
      1. Uncle lee
        Uncle lee April 21 2021 13: 46
        +3
        Quote: 72jora72
        yourself ...

        Will not work ! It is zeroed out! And it means pure like a tear of a baby!
        It is the predecessor's fault!
  5. marchcat
    marchcat April 21 2021 13: 01
    +1
    I suddenly remembered about training, although they have been talking about quality for more than a dozen years. Not too late ???
    1. frruc
      frruc April 21 2021 13: 22
      +1
      Yes, everyone speaks and speaks. Tongues grind - do not roll bags.
    2. Antidote
      Antidote April 21 2021 14: 11
      +1
      Elections are on the nose, you need to throw a bone and cheer up.
    3. Sergey Aleksandrovich
      Sergey Aleksandrovich April 21 2021 15: 14
      +2
      Previously, at least sometimes they remembered the weight of the school bag, completely forgot about the problem. We switched to backpacks, but the weight only increased. Soon exoskeletons will be relevant, they will not be lifted at all.
  6. rocket757
    rocket757 April 21 2021 13: 02
    +11
    "They write about the Second Front, but not a word about the Battle of Stalingrad": Putin spoke about history textbooks
    So it is ... so much has to be corrected, explained to your wards, the mind is incomprehensible! I just want to take a textbook and delete from it outright nonsense, lies! And then we wonder where the koliizurengoya come from !!!
    1. poquello
      poquello April 21 2021 13: 13
      +6
      Quote: rocket757
      "They write about the Second Front, but not a word about the Battle of Stalingrad": Putin spoke about history textbooks
      So it is ... so much has to be corrected, explained to your wards, the mind is incomprehensible! I just want to take a textbook and delete from it outright nonsense, lies! And then we wonder where the koliizurengoya come from !!!

      )))))))))))))) I have a small guy when he reads them - he just breaks the pattern, and when to answer them, the dilemma - in truth or according to the textbook
      1. rocket757
        rocket757 April 21 2021 14: 00
        +2
        It's easier with us ... we talked with the teacher, went to the panorama of the Battle of Stalingrad and there are no more questions ... especially since the textbooks of the "harmony" program were almost everywhere scrapped! Here are the next ones, we'll see ...
        1. poquello
          poquello April 21 2021 18: 58
          -1
          Quote: rocket757
          talked with the teacher, went to the panorama of the Battle of Stalingrad

          so it is about Stalingrad, but about the Battle of the Ice? When some "historians" try to pass him off as a battle with three hundred vrazhin))))))))))))))))))), naive Teutonic ninja gathered to take the city by this number. And according to the "respected in the textbook" Kurbsky, who betrayed Ivan the Terrible and led the Polish troops against Russia?
          1. rocket757
            rocket757 April 21 2021 19: 44
            +1
            Show children the film "Alexander Nevsky", there are enough good Soviet films on the history of our Motherland .... add what was not shown.
            1. poquello
              poquello April 21 2021 19: 56
              +1
              Quote: rocket757
              Show children the film "Alexander Nevsky"

              Are you a supporter of the Medinsky method? The film is good, but with historical blunders, but since it is good, can it be passed off as a real story? No, thanks, I naturally used it as the basis of those events, but as an argument it is not suitable.
              1. rocket757
                rocket757 April 21 2021 20: 10
                +1
                There is visual material, interesting for children, without serious mistakes, why not use it?
                I am not preparing future historians, but future defenders of the fatherland. The film gives the right direction of thought, and you can correct, correct mistakes along the way.
                In the Museum of the Battle of Stalingrad there is a technique that could not take part in that battle in any way, and so what? Children are interested and this is the main thing, after all, it was not alien ships that were put there, the technique of a later period is simple ...
    2. Reptiloid
      Reptiloid April 21 2021 13: 46
      +2
      Victor, you are aware of all this "education". What about the GULAG and millions of innocent people? Is it true that this is in the textbooks?
      1. rocket757
        rocket757 April 21 2021 14: 03
        +2
        Quote: Reptiloid
        What about the GULAG and millions of innocent people? Is it true that this is in the textbooks?

        Continuous nonsense !!! But I emphasize again, we have the "Harmony" program, and it was as if the enemies wrote it! We are one of the last to study this program! she was scrapped almost everywhere.
        Next year there will be something different. Boom to see.
        1. Reptiloid
          Reptiloid April 21 2021 14: 11
          +1
          read your other comment about the trip good + + + + + +
          1. rocket757
            rocket757 April 21 2021 14: 42
            +1
            And how else can you explain it differently, show it.
            Everything is close by, and Mother Motherland is visible from everywhere in good weather.
            1. Reptiloid
              Reptiloid April 21 2021 15: 23
              +2
              Quote: rocket757
              And how else can you explain it differently, show it.
              Everything is close by, and Mother Motherland is visible from everywhere in good weather.

              And I have these sculptures on my desk. Height --- about 20cm. Metal. Even in the USSR, my grandmother received a gift at the factory. That's what.
              1. rocket757
                rocket757 April 21 2021 15: 45
                +1
                Our military plant made receivers in the pedestal of such a figure ... however, there was such a distribution list for consumer goods.
                1. Reptiloid
                  Reptiloid April 21 2021 15: 57
                  +1
                  I just have separate shapes. I would also like other copies of Soviet monuments ... except for the bust of V.I.
  7. Machete
    Machete April 21 2021 13: 08
    +1
    Commander-in-chief, he announced - take control.
  8. nnm
    nnm April 21 2021 13: 22
    +5
    He himself has been raising the question of a single history textbook for many years. But the question is not what to write it, but what will be written in it. I have a friend, a young man from United Russia, and he calmly tells how they are sent to write negative comments, for example, under posts about Stalin. Recently they rushed to "fight" with some Samara or Saratov deputy who mentioned Stalin in a positive way.
    So how do we get this textbook with such a policy?
    And when to teach history, if the teaching hours on it are cut to a minimum. Even in universities, almost two or three centuries of our history are taught in one lecture. And even worse at school.
    So having a single textbook won't change anything.
    1. BMP-2
      BMP-2 April 21 2021 13: 45
      +2
      So it seems like there is already a normal history textbook: Spitsyn E. Yu. A complete course on Russian history for teachers, professors and students. Book 1-4. Published back in 2015. What other textbook is needed?
      1. nnm
        nnm April 21 2021 14: 34
        +4
        As much as I personally disagree with what is written in it, but this work is extremely subjective. Well, with all my support for the ideas outlined in this work, there can be no terms in the textbook containing emotional value judgments such as "liberal tusovka" (section 3 of the topic 1990, volume 4), there should be no references, moreover, referring them to historiography on statements participants, or statements of all parties should be provided, there should not be emotional vernaculars such as "The KGB was finally finished off", etc. (the same volume, topic).
        Again, I more than agree with the main line of work, but .... THE TEXTBOOK must be impartial !!! In no case should children drive their own line based on personal preferences into their heads. Our country has a huge number of historical positive phenomena, and they should precisely LEAD the student to the necessary conclusions, and not drive them into his head with every sentence. The younger generation must learn to think, and not repeat what others have said, it must reflect, not copy, it must realize that our history is complex, that there were both black and white stripes, must be able to accept them, be responsible for their decisions, and not be nodding dummies.
        1. BMP-2
          BMP-2 April 21 2021 15: 16
          +3
          At the expense of excessive emotionality and a free style of presentation - yes, it is lame. It could have been corrected ...
          1. nnm
            nnm April 21 2021 15: 19
            +3
            Sure. An excellent choice as a base. I only skimmed the sections after your words. I just think that due to the one-sided attention on the part of the author, some negative moments in history could have escaped his gaze, which can and even should be talked about. And this is already more difficult to fix than to simply eliminate emotionality.
            But yes, at first, superficial glance, the work you indicated can become an excellent basis.
  9. Basarev
    Basarev April 21 2021 13: 34
    +2
    He still did not cope with the previous covenant about history, but has already started talking about a new one. I remember that he promised a single textbook, the most impartial ... But then shamefully merged.
  10. Hagen
    Hagen April 21 2021 13: 46
    +1
    They write about everything: they write about the Second Front, but not a word about the Battle of Stalingrad.

    Really noticed ?! Maybe someday he will finally notice the editorial policy on TV, at least on state channels? And at the same time, will they begin to set up the policy of financing film projects? Still, it is necessary to develop a state-forming and unifying ideology.
  11. Revival
    Revival April 21 2021 13: 53
    +5
    "They write about the Second Front, but not a word about the Battle of Stalingrad."

    Moreover, the mausoleum is enclosed with cardboard, uh-huh ...

    So take a closer look at ........
  12. Petrik66
    Petrik66 April 21 2021 14: 05
    +2
    Again, not in business ....... already tired. Landing where?
  13. seacap
    seacap April 21 2021 14: 06
    +4
    Less than 30 years later, they finally realized that even if he read the rest of the textbooks, he would get a stroke in general. About these Sorsk textbooks, approved and implemented by the Higher School of Economics, our (no, of course) reformers (destroyers) all the time from every "iron" teachers of the old formation and parents, until they were fired and their mouths poked, shouted.
  14. Mavrikiy
    Mavrikiy April 21 2021 14: 10
    +4
    Head of State:
    They write about everything: they write about the Second Front, but not a word about the Battle of Stalingrad.
    The President suggested more attentively “see what they write in Russian textbooks. " To update tutorials and tutorials additional funds will be allocated.
    Madhouse. Who will look, who wrote the textbooks, will he edit them? VSA and company. Once the money was cut for writing, now they will rearrange the commas, but leave the meaning. angry
    1. To deprive the writers of filthy textbooks of the right to participate in the writing of textbooks in the future.
    2. We have Spitsin and Starikov, they don't have many stars on their epaulettes, but there is oil in their heads. They will fix all the textbooks for a little money. Svanidze can't trust it!
  15. Roman070280
    Roman070280 April 21 2021 14: 17
    -6
    "They write about the Second Front, but not a word about the Battle of Stalingrad": Putin spoke about history textbooks


    "They write about the Stalinist repressions, but not a word about the executions and planting of plunderers of socialist property"
    Putin spoke about history textbooks
  16. Evil 55
    Evil 55 April 21 2021 14: 24
    +2
    "Servant of the people" does not know what the relevant ministries are doing? I DO NOT BELIEVE,,,
  17. Hort
    Hort April 21 2021 14: 48
    0
    Yeah, they write about Stalingrad and Kursk, but three lines about Rzhev, nothing at all about Voronezh
    1. Sergey Aleksandrovich
      Sergey Aleksandrovich April 21 2021 19: 10
      +1
      And what is wrong with Voronezh?
      1. Hort
        Hort April 22 2021 11: 24
        0
        The Voronezh operation is poorly covered, although the intensity of the battles there was no worse than the Stalingrad
  18. PavelM
    PavelM April 21 2021 16: 06
    +4
    Quote: Piramidon
    Do you think that the president should personally read all the textbooks?

    Bad Stalin read, and why can't a good Putin?
    1. Alf
      Alf April 21 2021 18: 48
      0
      Quote: PavelM
      Quote: Piramidon
      Do you think that the president should personally read all the textbooks?

      Bad Stalin read, and why can't a good Putin?

      Once upon a time, for the power is concerned about where to draw a red line, so that the "partners" do not offend.
  19. PavelM
    PavelM April 21 2021 16: 17
    0
    Quote: nnm
    .... THE TEXTBOOK must be impartial !!!

    This is mistake. The textbook should educate the Citizen and the Patriot. All interpretations must meet the State interests, correspond to the slogan - "think about your Motherland first, and then about yourself." Otherwise, not even Hitler, but sleepy Biden will ruin us one by one.
    1. Alf
      Alf April 21 2021 18: 50
      +3
      Quote: PavelM
      All interpretations must meet the State interests,

      And what are the state interests of Russia now?
      Quote: PavelM
      correspond to the slogan - "first think about the Motherland, and then about yourself."

      And for this there must be an Ideology in the state. And now it is officially not in Russia.
    2. poquello
      poquello April 21 2021 20: 26
      0
      Quote: PavelM
      This is mistake. The textbook should educate the Citizen and the Patriot

      just "sleepy Biden" will analyze this "patriot's textbook" and cut the fish like a cook, and plant seeds of doubt about the veracity of this textbook, as has already happened with very sad consequences
  20. Reserve buildbat
    Reserve buildbat April 22 2021 11: 33
    0
    What news ... In Soros's anti-Russian textbooks, they glorify the "allies" who were attached to victory, who mainly helped the Germans, and are silent about the real war ...
    Moreover, it turns out that the education system for children with Down syndrome introduced in Russian schools does not allow the graduation of literate and intelligent people, like the accursed Soviet, the best in the world, education system ... And who would have thought ...
  21. LTMax
    LTMax April 22 2021 11: 34
    0
    Head of State:

    They write about everything: they write about the Second Front, but not a word about the Battle of Stalingrad.


    I alone think that this speech should end something like this:

    "Mr. Kramtsov, don't you think that you do not quite match your position?"

    ?????