Military Review

The Paris court overturned the decision to collect $ 1,3 billion from the Russian Federation in favor of Ukraine

68

The Paris Court of Appeal, like the Ministry of Justice of the Russian Federation, considers that the arbitration in the case of the claim of "Oschadbank" of Ukraine does not have the necessary jurisdiction. Therefore, the Paris court overturned the decision to collect $ 1,3 billion from Russia in favor of Ukraine.


This was reported by the press service of the Ministry of Justice of the Russian Federation.

What kind of lawsuit are we talking about?

In 2018, the arbitration tribunal decided to satisfy the claim filed in 2015 by the Ukrainian "Oschadbank" against Russia to pay him compensation for the transfer of his property in Crimea to Russian ownership after the reunification of the peninsula with the Russian Federation. The plaintiff estimated its losses at $ 1,3 billion.

Oschadbank's claims were based on the Russian-Ukrainian Agreement on the Encouragement and Mutual Protection of Investments. But Russia, which filed an appeal, managed to prove that this case does not fall within the scope of this document. After all, the Crimean branches of "Oschadbank" were created back in the Soviet period, and they were opened by the Savings Bank of the USSR. And Russia is the legal successor of the USSR. Thus, in accordance with international law, this case does not fall under the jurisdiction of the arbitral tribunal, and the earlier decision should be canceled.

It is important that the Paris Court of Appeal has created a precedent that will be taken into account when considering other cases related to the "Crimean inheritance".
68 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. svp67
    svp67 31 March 2021 13: 18
    +27
    The Paris court overturned the decision to collect $ 1,3 billion from Russia in favor of Ukraine.
    The Paris Court of Appeal has created a precedent that will be taken into account when considering other cases related to the "Crimean inheritance".
    Oh, and sho tse bulo? And what about the retinue of Ukraine?
    1. Overlock
      Overlock 31 March 2021 13: 22
      +17
      Quote: svp67
      And what about the retinue of Ukraine?

      Law is law!
      1. svp67
        svp67 31 March 2021 13: 25
        +25
        Quote: Overlock
        Law is law!

        I beg you, the Western justice has proved more than once in resolving controversial issues in relation to Russia that "the law, that the tongue, where it turned, then it happened ..." One "debt" of Gazprom's three billion to Naftogaz is worth something.
        What's happening now?
        1. Overlock
          Overlock 31 March 2021 13: 27
          +17
          Quote: svp67
          Western justice has already proved more than once in resolving controversial issues in relation to Russia that "the law, something that pivot, where it turned, then it happened ..

          Did they disobey in Paris? For whom or for what? This is the decision that refutes you.
          1. svp67
            svp67 31 March 2021 13: 31
            +3
            Quote: Overlock
            It is this decision that refutes in

            But no ... Any exception, only confirms the rule. Until that moment, they had made a decision to recover 1,3 billion, as I understand there also dripped interest.
            No, there is clearly some progress in the world. Maybe that's how they decided to appease us and get our vaccines, otherwise in France with CoVidl a quiet horror has been going on ...
            Well, as at least some version
            1. 1976AG
              1976AG 31 March 2021 13: 39
              +4
              Quote: svp67
              Quote: Overlock
              It is this decision that refutes in

              But no ... Any exception, only confirms the rule. Until that moment, they had made a decision to recover 1,3 billion, as I understand there also dripped interest.
              No, there is clearly some progress in the world. Maybe that's how they decided to appease us and get our vaccines, otherwise in France with CoVidl a quiet horror has been going on ...
              Well, as at least some version

              And we refused to supply them with the vaccine? On the contrary, we do not refuse anyone, so what is the point of appeasing us?
              1. svp67
                svp67 31 March 2021 13: 41
                +2
                Quote: 1976AG
                On the contrary, we do not refuse anyone, so what is the point of appeasing us?

                Well, here's how to say ... After the statements of their President that Russia is waging a "war of vaccines", it may be worth it.
                1. 1976AG
                  1976AG 31 March 2021 13: 45
                  +2
                  It would be worth doing a lot, but our leadership is very patient
                  1. Nyrobsky
                    Nyrobsky 31 March 2021 18: 32
                    +5
                    Quote: 1976AG
                    It would be worth doing a lot, yes, our leadership is very patient

                    Along the way, now is the time to roll out a counterclaim to Ukraine through the same court, and demand compensation for 25 years of using our property in the form of the aforementioned asset winked
                    After all, the Crimean branches of "Oschadbank" were created back in the Soviet period, and they were opened by the Savings Bank of the USSR. And Russia is the legal successor of the USSR.
                    1. Shurik70
                      Shurik70 31 March 2021 21: 07
                      0
                      For the first time, or what?
                      The dill did not work for the first time, they will file a second claim (appeal against the court decision)
                      And so on to infinity.
                      1. Alex Justice
                        Alex Justice April 1 2021 18: 14
                        0
                        The loser pays the costs. They are unlikely to want gossip.
                    2. Bow
                      Bow April 1 2021 01: 05
                      -1
                      And what other property that belonged to the USSR does Ukraine use? The ground, for example.

                      There are just some tricks with jurisdiction, and not the recognition of our right to our inheritance, squeezed out by the independents.
                      1. Vladimir Mashkov
                        Vladimir Mashkov April 1 2021 12: 02
                        -1
                        Correct and necessary decision of the Parisian court! smile
            2. TerraSandera
              TerraSandera April 1 2021 06: 45
              0
              And the fact that they are given vaccines, take them, but they still don’t take them. And then they gave a "bribe"?)
        2. Pete mitchell
          Pete mitchell 31 March 2021 14: 04
          +11
          Quote: svp67
          Western justice has more than once, in resolving controversial issues with respect to Russia, proved that "the law, something that pivot, where it turned, then it happened ... What is happening now?"

          Hopefully it's green whistle - Europe is tired of the pressure of staff members and the interests of the 404 country do not interest anyone at all
        3. Captain Pushkin
          Captain Pushkin 31 March 2021 14: 27
          +6
          Quote: svp67
          What's happening now?

          They have a shortage of covid-19 vaccines. They are afraid to make them angry once again, otherwise we will send them on an erotic journey with the vaccine (they consider us the same scoundrels as they themselves).
      2. URAL72
        URAL72 31 March 2021 13: 28
        +15
        Well, since the law works, then it's time for the successor of the USSR to file a lawsuit against Ukraine, and at the same time the Tribalts for the theft of USSR property. Or let them transfer what remains to the ownership of the Russian Federation - ports, for example, pipelines, power plants, railways, etc. All the remaining Georgia will sharply become our friends.
        1. XXXIII
          XXXIII 31 March 2021 14: 46
          +3
          Quote: URAL72
          Well, since the law works, then it's time for the successor of the USSR to file a lawsuit against Ukraine, and at the same time the Tribalts for the theft of USSR property. Or let them transfer what remains to the ownership of the Russian Federation - ports, for example, pipelines, power plants, railways, etc. All the remaining Georgia will sharply become our friends.

          This should have been done for a long time, but apparently there is a policy that is not visible to society. They do not speak about it aloud, but only use it as a mouthpiece when it is necessary to make noise in the heads of the people of the country. hi
      3. Insurgent
        Insurgent 31 March 2021 13: 29
        +9
        Quote: Overlock
        Law is law!


        Come on ... When necessary, the "Western democracies" turn a blind eye to the illegal, criminal actions of the Outskirts.
        For example ? And for example, the use of the Armed Forces for a punitive operation in Donbass. Silence yes yes yes

        Where is the Law,"the rule of law" ? Is he there, the "law"?
    2. Free wind
      Free wind 31 March 2021 13: 24
      -13%
      Dear Ukrainian, how will it be in Russian? I'm not in the subject.
      1. svp67
        svp67 31 March 2021 13: 26
        +2
        Quote: Free Wind
        I'm not in the subject.

        And thank God ... So this is not about your interest
        1. Free wind
          Free wind 31 March 2021 13: 30
          -13%
          That is, people like me, poor and narrow-minded. Are you super-super-advanced?
          1. Insurgent
            Insurgent 31 March 2021 13: 34
            +10
            Quote: Free Wind
            That is, people like me, poor and narrow-minded. Are you super-super-advanced?

            Bad mood ? Do you need to bite into the edge with someone?
          2. svp67
            svp67 31 March 2021 13: 36
            +3
            Quote: Free Wind
            That is, people like me, poor and narrow-minded.

            Sorry, but this is your speculation ...
      2. Bow
        Bow April 1 2021 01: 11
        +1
        Quote: Free Wind
        and in Russian how will it be?

        In Russian it will be correct "in Russian"
    3. Alien From
      Alien From 31 March 2021 13: 24
      +3
      They threw us, they threw us - bandits because (C)
      1. svp67
        svp67 31 March 2021 13: 37
        +2
        Quote: Alien From
        They threw us, they threw us - bandits because th

        Worse, "evil"
    4. Invoce
      Invoce 31 March 2021 13: 25
      +3
      This is "ZRADA" for horses! Again, you need to figure out who, or rather why, to file a claim with the European Court of Justice against Russia.
      What will they come up with now? It is possible for the use of the Black Sea, dug by the great Ukrainians, without payment. Or for Russia's refusal to recognize itself as a party to the conflict in Donbass request
    5. xorek
      xorek 31 March 2021 13: 27
      -5
      Quote: svp67
      Oh, and sho tse bulo? And what about the retinue of Ukraine?

      And that's what they feed on ... I think there are hundreds more lawsuits, it's in their blood.
      Russia is of course a generous soul, but it hates impudent people! angry
    6. mojohed2012
      mojohed2012 31 March 2021 13: 32
      -1
      So yak zhe them zrozumiti? Stink from one side for Ukraine, and from the other - to seize Russia. Have the French ceased to bend to the will of the United States?
      But what about NATO? But what about European solidarity? But what about Euro-Atlantic unity?
    7. Free wind
      Free wind 31 March 2021 13: 41
      -7
      Just write in Russian, I don’t understand what you wrote.
      1. svp67
        svp67 31 March 2021 13: 46
        +3
        Quote: Free Wind
        Just write in Russian, I don’t understand what you wrote.

        Please.
        Oh, and sho tse bulo? And what about the retinue of Ukraine?
        And what was that? But what about the whole world with Ukraine?
        1. Insurgent
          Insurgent 31 March 2021 14: 01
          +6
          Quote: Free Wind
          Just write in Russian, I don’t understand what you wrote.

          Quote: svp67
          Please.


          Cool yes lol

          I, 1 + 000 times, wrote short expressions in movi and on deliberately distorted "surzhike", and no one ever made a claim - "I do not understand" laughing ...
          1. Paranoid50
            Paranoid50 31 March 2021 14: 39
            +6
            Quote: Insurgent
            and on a deliberately distorted "surzhik"

            A distorted surzhik ... So it won't take long to cause the devil - some kind of horror ... am wassat hi
            1. svp67
              svp67 31 March 2021 14: 57
              +4
              Quote: Paranoid50
              Distorted surzhik ... T

              Forgive me, but how can you distort what is already distortion?
              1. Insurgent
                Insurgent April 1 2021 09: 25
                +3
                Quote: svp67
                Forgive me, but how can you distort what is already distortion?

                Nevertheless, somehow I try to distort the distorted, in order to further point out the inferiority of the Zadensky-Selyukovsky "surzhik", which even (!!!) differs from the analogous somewhere in the South-East like a toad from a viper ...

                By the way, are you chuli "canadian version" movi?

                Try to listen yes (there is no talk of trying to reproduce at all wassat ).
          2. Piramidon
            Piramidon 31 March 2021 15: 16
            +3
            Quote: Insurgent
            and no one ever made a claim

            This Alexander - often acts as a troll here. Bored comrade, so I found myself some entertainment.
    8. RealPilot
      RealPilot 31 March 2021 14: 34
      +3
      Perfect solution!
      And even amazing by modern standards.

      What about the rest of the infrastructure of the former Ukrainian SSR? If there is a continuation of the Russian Spring, then the rest can be interpreted according to the same principle.

      But then there is another "guaido" who fled, for example, to New York. Will be called a government in exile ...
      And he will demand on behalf of the entire ukrostate through foreign (international language does not dare to name) money of $ 100 billion for the loss of state assets ... As Hodor was awarded 50 for Yukos, this swindler.

      And then the courts say: the USSR was building, and Russia is the successor! And rightly so.
    9. Fitter65
      Fitter65 31 March 2021 16: 22
      +2
      Quote: svp67
      Oh, and sho tse bulo? And what about the retinue of Ukraine?

      Well, you see, several hedgehogs died, they had to apply to the Stockholm arbitration court, that would have sued Ukraine everything, according to the law ...
    10. knn54
      knn54 31 March 2021 17: 42
      +3
      This is Zrada.
      1. svp67
        svp67 31 March 2021 17: 44
        0
        Quote: knn54
        this is Zrada.

        Yes, you sho ... belay
    11. Mwg
      Mwg April 1 2021 03: 43
      +1
      Tse zrada pislya peremogi!
      1. svp67
        svp67 April 1 2021 06: 20
        +1
        Quote: MVG
        Tse zrada pislya peremogi!

        Yeah, left alone
        Quote: MVG
        after
  2. Overlock
    Overlock 31 March 2021 13: 23
    +21
    Trifle (1.3 billion) nationwide, but still in the treasury. Pleasantly
    1. TerraSandera
      TerraSandera April 1 2021 06: 54
      0
      In the sense of the treasury? Whose? They will not be taken from the treasury, that's all. No extra +. Arbitration costs only. Well, in case of loss, there would be a minus.
  3. Ru_Na
    Ru_Na 31 March 2021 13: 23
    +3
    Oh, that's bad luck, the overcoming has turned into zrada again, there will be no free money!
  4. The comment was deleted.
  5. GRIGORIY76
    GRIGORIY76 31 March 2021 13: 31
    +4
    How so? After all, everyone knows that the courts in Europe always act against our country ..
    Wow..
  6. Crimean partisan 1974
    Crimean partisan 1974 31 March 2021 13: 33
    0
    zrada splendid ... another hole in the budget of the junta was organized ... so that the can can help nat ... and then they will completely stop fighting the war with the east wind
    1. svp67
      svp67 31 March 2021 13: 38
      +1
      Quote: Crimean partisan 1974
      sultry ... another hole in the budget of the junta has been organized ...

      So, as I understand it, they have already managed to write out bonuses for themselves, and not only get and spend, but now, what? To return?
      1. Crimean partisan 1974
        Crimean partisan 1974 31 March 2021 13: 44
        0
        and now what? To return?
        ..... yes, they will write off on the bike, and that's all ... business is ... Timokha's kiryushka with a nourishing person, this will turn a mosquito on the nose, it will not undermine
        1. Free wind
          Free wind 31 March 2021 14: 59
          -3
          Can you speak Russian? Kiryushka, timokhoshka, stnyushka, budlnvtstvo, I think you are sitting in some sort of shed. These words. what does it mean? Please speak Russian. Well, if you know how, of course.
          1. svp67
            svp67 31 March 2021 16: 33
            +2
            Quote: Free Wind
            Kiryushka, timokhoshka, stnyushka, budlnvtstvo,

            And why do you lisp and skip the vowels? Are you sick?
            1. Crimean partisan 1974
              Crimean partisan 1974 31 March 2021 17: 25
              -1
              And why do you lisp and skip the vowels? Are you sick?

              probably some kind of acquired trauma that does not allow us to appreciate the humor ... he would have talked with puberts, then he would have generally with a deaf zihav
              1. svp67
                svp67 31 March 2021 17: 42
                +1
                Quote: Crimean partisan 1974
                then I would generally do it with a blunt zihav

                Angry you ...
    2. Flooding
      Flooding 31 March 2021 14: 14
      +2
      Quote: Crimean partisan 1974
      zrada splendid ... another hole in the budget of the junta was organized ... so that the can can help nat ... and then they will completely stop fighting the war with the east wind

      this is not the end of the story
      the Ukrainian side is going to appeal this decision to another instance
      1. Crimean partisan 1974
        Crimean partisan 1974 31 March 2021 14: 34
        -1
        the Ukrainian side is going to appeal this decision to another instance
        .... yes, it doesn't matter .... everything goes to the point that many European institutions in the Russian Federation do not bully act .... the doors are slamming one after the other
  7. rocket757
    rocket757 31 March 2021 13: 52
    +2
    It is important that the Paris Court of Appeal has created a precedent that will be taken into account when considering other cases related to the "Crimean inheritance".
    Precedent, precedent, how much in this word ... for lawyers! Okay, let's see what and who will be able to squeeze out of this situation?
  8. From Tomsk
    From Tomsk 31 March 2021 14: 02
    +4
    From the 8th grade Ukrainian textbook of geography, it became known that the ancient Ukrainians cared about the future, so as not to leave their offspring without a piece of bacon: they founded strawberry fields in Finland, toilets in Poland and the Leningradskoe highway in Moscow.
  9. APASUS
    APASUS 31 March 2021 14: 08
    0
    Therefore, the Paris court overturned the decision to collect $ 1,3 billion from Russia in favor of Ukraine.

    Ukraine received these funds? If received, then at least a hundred Paris courts will rule in favor of Russia.
    1. suhorukofal
      suhorukofal April 1 2021 05: 29
      0
      If they started transferring money, they would not have filed an appeal. So you can sue for a very long time, file an appeal until the decision comes into force. True, for Ukraine this is not a hindrance, there is even a court decision, but they may not execute it. Everything to friends, to enemies - the law. A precedent, of course, has been created, but I do not share the general optimism, we must look at how the situation will develop further, so we play with the enemy, according to the rules that he comes up with himself.
  10. yehat2
    yehat2 31 March 2021 14: 29
    +2
    the flow of such decisions makes it quite clear to Ukraine that Europe considers the secession of Crimea to be legitimate. In addition, it is worth constantly reminding that at that moment 7 regions of Ukraine were seriously thinking about leaving the country, not 1 Crimea, and this process was 99 percent created by Ukraine itself, preventing a number of territories from separating only with the help of violence. Many of them fled not to the Russian Federation, but simply farther from Kiev. This is also worth remembering when Ukraine blames the incident on the Russian Federation.
  11. Evil 55
    Evil 55 31 March 2021 14: 55
    0
    Strange and incomprehensible ... why this is suddenly made a fair decision in the light of the pan-European trend of public mockery of Russia ..
  12. Chersky
    Chersky 31 March 2021 15: 43
    0
    I think that distant claps are heard ... And these are neighbors' farts torn)))
  13. Glory to Berkut
    Glory to Berkut 31 March 2021 15: 53
    +3
    After all, the Crimean branches of Oschadbank were created back in the Soviet period, and they were opened by the Savings Bank of the USSR

    Is it possible to announce the entire list of our legacy temporarily occupied by Ukraine? repeat
  14. NF68
    NF68 31 March 2021 16: 09
    0
    This is all the machinations of Putin's agents!
  15. orionvitt
    orionvitt 31 March 2021 16: 51
    +1
    It is important that the Paris Court of Appeal has created a precedent that will be taken into account when considering other cases.
    But this is the case. As they say, a trifle, but nice. It turns out that all the "proud and independent" have is what the Russians have left them. Since the non-landowners have abandoned the legacy of the USSR, carried out decommunization, then let them not blather. good
  16. ZAV69
    ZAV69 31 March 2021 22: 21
    0
    In Europe, something died.
  17. sgr291158
    sgr291158 April 1 2021 04: 16
    0
    What a sour people, just to snatch for free.