Military Review

ERA military technopolis: why does the Defense Ministry need its own Skolkovo

73

Federal State Autonomous Institution "Military Innovative Technopolis" ERA ". Source: dfnc.ru


Trendy technoparks


The idea of ​​building innovative townships uniting specialized universities, research institutes and high-tech companies under one roof came to Russia from the United States. The ancestor of technoparks was Stanford University, where after the war a territorial cluster was formed in which students studied, researched, and then worked in the branches of leading American companies. Later all история evolved into Silicon Valley, and every self-respecting country wanted to synthesize something similar on its territory.

By the way, in our country, since Soviet times, analogs of technoparks, which were called Academic Towns, have been functioning quite successfully. The most famous of them, of course, is the Novosibirsk Academgorodok of the Siberian Branch of the Russian Academy of Sciences. Nearby is the no less famous science town of Koltsov, where the world-famous State Research Center VB "Vector", the alma mater of the second Russian anticoid vaccine, operates. It is possible to relate differently to the fact that a center with deadly pathogens was located near the city of Novosibirsk with a population of one million, but Vector turned out to be a very effective institution in the end. In Soviet times, it was engaged in defense issues, and now it is the leading research institute of Rospotrebnadzor, successfully solving issues of protecting the population from a wide range of pathogens.


All conditions for comfortable scientific activity have been created in the technopolis. The main thing is that it is effective. Source: arispro.ru

Skolkovo can be called a real anti-example of the effectiveness of innovative technology parks. When the Russian analogue of the California Silicon Valley was discovered in 2010, the question arose: why? What is the purpose of creating an expensive scientific center if there is Novosibirsk, Tomsk, Krasnoyarsk and many other academic towns? The whole Moscow region is replete with scientific centers - Pushchino, Zelenograd, Dubna, Chernogolovka ...

Why not invest "Skolkovo" billions in the further development of these institutions?

Most of the Russian Academgorodoks are known all over the world and have very strong ties with foreign institutions and investors. Obviously, the initiators of the Skolkovo project need an exclusively image project that has little to do with technological breakthroughs. Or the founding fathers were driven by completely different motives, unknown to a wide circle.

And in 2018, a beautiful and high-tech technopolis "ERA" (Elite of the Russian Army) appears in the Russian army. The relevance of creation, according to the Ministry of Defense, is due to the need to reduce the time from the creation of innovative scientific projects to their implementation in the form of weapons, military and special equipment. A detailed analysis of the activities of the technopolis, which is more like a sanatorium on the Black Sea coast, makes one think about the correctness of the chosen goals.

Science and technology games


To begin with, the scientific leaders of the military technopark have identified sixteen (!) Priority development areas for it at once. Here are robotics, artificial intelligence, biotechnology, nanomaterials, and even development weapons on new physical principles. In addition to this, there is the Lomonosov design center and the Kulibin mini-factory. That is, the developers propose to resolve issues of strategic importance, to carry out full-fledged R&D in sixteen key areas in a relatively small coastal area. Here, even geographically, there is little space for solving such large-scale tasks. But that's not all. Part of the technopark is occupied by congress and exhibition areas, as well as scientific and educational clusters for working with gifted children.


On February 23, a night drone show was organized in the technopark. Source: era-tehnopolis.ru

Quite expectedly, there could be no talk of any kind of science in the ERA technopark from the very beginning - the conditions were simply not created for this. Therefore, for the formation of a scientific school in the resort of Anapa, more than 270 organizations and enterprises engaged in scientific and technical work of a defense profile were involved. You don't have to go far for examples. Military Medical Academy. CM. Kirov, one of the most authoritative scientific centers in Russia, has been working with the ERA technopolis for more than two years. In particular, they develop cell technologies, tissue engineering and carry out molecular genetic research.

The prevention of sudden cardiac death among military personnel is highlighted as a separate area. Two divisions of the technopolis are working on this problem at once - the laboratory for monitoring the vital functions of the body of military personnel and the prevention of pathological conditions and the laboratory for molecular genetic research. The directions, of course, are very relevant and promising for the Russian army. But why transfer such complex projects from St. Petersburg to Anapa?

What is the purpose of turning yesterday's students into researchers, who have entered the scientific companies of the “Elite of the Russian Army” through a competition?

Any sane researcher will confirm that modern research requires serious equipment and a lot of time, otherwise everything will turn into profanity. And in the technopark, servicemen have to contribute in just a year to the study of sudden cardiac death and other fundamental problems of military medicine.

Recall that a future doctor is taught at a medical university for at least six years. At the same time, no one deprived recruits in the military innovation city of combat, physical and fire training. Who in 12 months will leave the gates of the technopark - an accomplished scientist or defender of the Motherland? It seems that neither one nor the other. By the way, the recruits of scientific companies in the ERA technopolis are for some reason called operators.

Forge of scientists for the army


Scientific curators of the technopolis in Anapa are already reporting on the first successes of the operators and their leaders. By mid-2020, 12 patents for inventions, 29 certificates of registration of programs and databases were received, 42 rationalization proposals were submitted and 153 publications were published. This data should be treated with caution.

Everyone can see what importance is attached to the technopolis not only by the high command of the Ministry of Defense, but also by the top officials of the state. Hence such an intense activity. If the Moscow State Technical University was involved in joint projects. N.E. Bauman, Air Force Academy named after N.E. Zhukovsky, the Military Academy of the MTO them. General of the Army A.V. Khruleva, Concern "Constellation" and many other organizations, we should expect a cumulative "flurry" of scientific "discoveries".


Development of marine technologies of defense significance. Perhaps the only direction that can justify the creation of a technopolis in Anapa. Source: era-tehnopolis.ru

A short excursion into a wide range of scientific research of the military technopolis.

Together with the MTO Academy, the development of renewable energy sources for border outposts, technologies for the use of liquefied natural gas, as well as the expansion of the use of environmentally friendly fuel in the army is underway. In particular, within the framework of the direction "Liquefied natural gas technologies", operators of scientific companies have developed a model of a fuel tank for gas storage with regulation by a sealed membrane. To manage these projects, scientists from St. Petersburg regularly visited their wards in Anapa.

According to the Ministry of Defense, the average score of recruits-operators of scientific companies is growing every year and last year was 4,71. The selection is carried out among several dozen leading universities in the country. And the competition for the place is more than 28 people. The high efficiency of the technopark's work in attracting young people to elite military service is also declared. About 20% of graduates (or demobilized) decided to "devote their lives to the Armed Forces in the simplest of science as officers", and another 60% became "employees of research institutes and the defense industry organization."


Scientific mouth operators. Source: mil.ru

At one of the international conferences last year, the employees of the Military Innovative Technopolis ERA summed up in the article:

"In a short time, the ERA has turned from an idea into a serious scientific, educational and industrial complex that allows one to study objects of various complexity, from microcircuits to spacecraft."

Neither add nor subtract.

An ERA full of questions


The creation of a broad-profile research center on the Black Sea coast raises several very serious questions at once.

Why weren't the funds allocated for the “Elite of the Russian Army” initially distributed between specialized defense universities and departments? In these research (without quotes) organizations, scientific schools have been created for decades, if not centuries.

Why would the professors drive along the St. Petersburg - Anapa route just to supervise the work of the research operators who are demobilized in a few months? Definitely, the Military Medical Academy has enough of its students, given the competition for admission. And in other military universities, there are no problems with future scientists either. And even if there is a shortage of motivated officers-researchers, then it is definitely not worth solving this problem with the ERA quasi-scientific technopolis.

Why are these games in science, which are more suitable for schoolchildren and the Ministry of Education, but not the Ministry of Defense? How will an operator be able to create, for example, a spacecraft within a year of service? No, of course, it can, if you provide an assembly diagram, the necessary components and an intelligent scientific advisor. But then what is the value of this operator and the scientific and technological innovation that everyone is talking about? And, finally, what will happen to the scientific work in the technopolis, if suddenly all third-party assistants are engaged in their main work and will not be scattered on joint projects with the ERA technopolis?

Time, as you know, will put everything in its place. Russia already has a sad experience of reflection on Rusnano and Skolkovo. I would really not like the history of the technopolis of the Ministry of Defense to be added to this.
Author:
73 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. Bykov.
    Bykov. 31 March 2021 15: 03
    .
    Do not spoil the porridge with butter. The more technoparks the better.
    1. lucul
      lucul 31 March 2021 15: 22
      .
      Do not spoil the porridge with butter. The more technoparks the better.

      If on the mind - then who can argue?
      But these policies, the enemies will be the first to fall apart from the inside.
      1. Prisoner
        Prisoner 31 March 2021 16: 54
        +3
        what Even so, huh? We will stand like this, poke around in our noses, and will they ruin? Wait!
        1. lucul
          lucul 31 March 2021 17: 11
          -6
          Even so, huh? We will stand like this, poke around in our noses, and will they ruin? Wait!

          Well, the USSR was falling apart like that, and with tacit approval.
          1. Monster_Fat
            Monster_Fat 31 March 2021 17: 27
            +15
            This is such a veiled sinecourt, a springboard for children into a well-fed, well-to-do life at the state (taxpayers') expense.
            PS: in Soviet times, everything was developed not at resorts, but at institutes, and design bureaus closer to the production base, where it is convenient to carry out experimental design work and debug technologies, etc.
      2. Nazar
        Nazar 31 March 2021 17: 46
        +3
        lucul - "according to the mind" - how is it? The author does not understand the most important thing - this town is a "filter", .. well, or a "personnel department" - it is clear that serious developments requiring many years of work will be done not in this town, but to filter out capable guys. to verify their suitability for scientific work in practice, it is this town that should. And the fact that the professors were shaken a little - they were forced to go and work with the guys, so this is also correct, again, they do not go to Magadan.
        The author himself wrote: "About 20% of graduates (or demobilized) decided to" devote their lives to the Armed Forces in the simplest of science as officers ", and another 60% became" employees of research institutes and the defense industry organization. " What questions "why" can there be after that? 80% of the result is at the exit from this town (!!!), but at least one, even the most sophisticated university in the country can fall by the fact that 80% of its graduates work in their specialty - eh?
        1. nickname7
          nickname7 April 3 2021 13: 44
          +1
          but filter out capable guys. check their suitability

          filtering can be elementary with the help of exams
          1. Nazar
            Nazar April 4 2021 14: 02
            0
            nick7 - The exam is, of course, a filter, but kind of one-time. one-time, and here for a whole year and in a year it is quite possible to understand what these guys are capable of, and during this time they themselves will decide what they want to do next.
    2. yehat2
      yehat2 April 1 2021 13: 56
      +3
      only it does not look like a technopark, but like a sinecure-sanatorium for thieves' sons and "necessary people".
      1. Hagen
        Hagen April 1 2021 15: 58
        +1
        Quote: yehat2
        only it does not look like a technopark, but like a sinecure-sanatorium for thieves' sons and "necessary people".

        Thugs don't go to the army. They are on hold. Here, just a filter for those who do not have the means to excuse themselves. And then, come to school and ask, do many graduates want to become, for example, microbiologists? I think only a few ... And then they called me up, put me practically at the school desk, depending on my abilities. The man started to work, got into, got interested, after being discharged to the reserve, he decided to continue working in the industry that might not have been interesting in childhood. Already good. Yes, here's another, regarding the author of the article. Aspirants for the title of "military journalist" would find it useful to know that demobilization is the process of transferring the armed forces and economy of a state from martial law to a peaceful one. Dismissal from the army in peacetime on the grounds available in the article (after the expiration of the military service by conscription or the term of the contract) is called retirement.
        1. yehat2
          yehat2 April 1 2021 16: 16
          +5
          Quote: Hagen
          Thugs don't go to the army. They are on hold.

          for a fast-paced career, seniority is needed.
          living for a couple of years on the seashore in a sanatorium and getting a seniority is great.
          I lived and studied in the campus and have an excellent idea of ​​which external conditions help and which hinder my work.
          this center is not for work.
          1. Hagen
            Hagen April 1 2021 16: 21
            0
            Quote: yehat2
            for a fast-paced career, seniority is needed.

            Enrolled in the university for the military department, they will also be awarded a lieutenant ... for a month and a half of nothing laughing
        2. aglet
          aglet April 2 2021 11: 12
          +1
          "And then, come to school and ask, do many graduates want to become, for example, microbiologists?"
          the stump is clear. but as he was drafted into the army, he immediately wanted to become a microbiologist, he couldn't eat. everything is easier than running at ranges with machine guns, and not in the Komi, or in Siberia. anapa is anapa. one word-kids resort
          1. Hagen
            Hagen April 2 2021 16: 59
            -1
            Quote: aglet
            everything is easier than running on ranges with machine guns, and not in the Komi,

            There are more benefits from some in warm Anapa than from a dozen with machine guns in Komi.
            1. aglet
              aglet April 3 2021 10: 01
              +2
              "Some people are more useful in warm Anapa than a dozen with machine guns in Komi."
              Well, what use can they be? what can be done in six months? to glue the layout of the satellite out of cardboard? or to compile a Linux program with some proud name? but as for others, I agree, I myself served in Novorossiysk, however, more at polygons
        3. nickname7
          nickname7 April 3 2021 13: 47
          -1
          ask, do many graduates want to become, for example, microbiologists? I think units

          high salaries are needed and the people will reach out, and they will train specialists, and they will go abroad.
      2. Rubi0
        Rubi0 April 2 2021 22: 35
        +1
        So many people complain that the children of the right people study at Stanford on the California coast, well, they did it on the Black Sea coast and it's still bad. And besides, if this young people have something in their worldview that it is possible to live and study under palm trees not only in California, but also in their homeland in Gelendzhik, then this is also a good result, especially since these are future armies
        1. aglet
          aglet April 3 2021 10: 03
          +1
          "especially since these are future armies"
          God forbid such a future. especially in the army
    3. nickname7
      nickname7 April 3 2021 13: 42
      +2
      Do not spoil porridge with butter

      this is not porridge with butter this is the fifth wheel in the cart
  2. rocket757
    rocket757 31 March 2021 15: 05
    +14
    ERA military technopolis: why does the Defense Ministry need its own Skolkovo
    It is possible that the forelock of red devils and other Pokemon nearby, even the spirit, WAS NOT !!!
    1. Alien From
      Alien From 31 March 2021 15: 10
      +9
      These are the golden words!
      1. Ross xnumx
        Ross xnumx 31 March 2021 15: 29
        +9
        ERA military technopolis: why does the Defense Ministry need its own Skolkovo

        I remember how military factories issued civilian developments to the country. I remember how the military representatives checked the quality and then turned a blind eye to the "marriage".
        I don't know why Moscow Region needs its own Skolkovo - I'm afraid to guess, especially in memory of the minister's carpentry workshop, but here's a funny video:
        1. Alien From
          Alien From 31 March 2021 15: 31
          +3
          I don't like this man, but sometimes in his humor there are very strongly veiled hints of the real state of affairs ...
          1. Ross xnumx
            Ross xnumx 31 March 2021 15: 34
            +2
            Quote: Alien From
            I do not like this person

            I don't like men at all ... Will is an interesting character and his sarcasm and causticity are no worse than Maxim Galkin's veiled criticism of state policy.
          2. Hagen
            Hagen April 1 2021 16: 17
            0
            Quote: Alien From
            heavily veiled hints of the real state of affairs ...

            This man ran out of technologies on a tablet and a flash drive, apparently, he did not hear about Rosatom, Rostec and others, although he uses their achievements in full growth. And he escaped from "science" himself, and now he encourages others to move something .... Saddled a wave of verbiage and earns on loafers with calloused lips.
        2. Doccor18
          Doccor18 31 March 2021 16: 04
          +9
          Looked, laughed ...

          Recently, on a nearby branch, some commentators have been diligently arguing that there is no money to build the Fleet. But for these "technopolises" in the resort areas - there is money ... Just imagine how many yards this "high" idea cost ..?
          1. boni592807
            boni592807 April 1 2021 21: 37
            -4
            Doccor18 (Alexander), yesterday, 16:04, - ".. Looked, laughed .. Just imagine how many yards this" high "idea cost ..? ..."

            Thank you, how I returned to the end of the 80s lol .
            There the "fighters" against militarism collected and burned children's toys, pistols, tanks and firecrackers. Peace to the world, to the war! wassat True, then everything was flooded with shtatovskie for decades. bully
            Further, the military-industrial complex and KOSMOS with the SA and the Navy called "idle things and places for burning" yards of owls rubles. The military-industrial complex and KOSMOS began to transfer to de-militarization rails. They released the latest technology, the United States did not even have a project yet, they hung up noodles about "SOI", and began to produce pots and pans with frying pans fool
            States from the shock "self-destructive" reforms of the USSR at first were stunned, and then began to buy development and developers at the root for a penny. Those who were not bought, many who did not leave, who stumbled, who slipped. The country was building a "light" capitalist ... was it before them ...

            And the current technopolises of the RF Ministry of Defense, the opportunity to grow, educate (do not lose - draining to the USA or ...)and get ... reality.
            Not tracks sown according to aggressive trends .. wassat .
            Catching up with partners is a bit cognitive, but at the expense of scientific and technological revolution to "cut" (overtake at the upcoming turn of history), there is hope ... wink
            Russia, as usual, has 2 options in the future recourse :
            1- worst,
            2- miraclebut, as usual, man-made by Russia itself.
            Where, let's go ??? hi
      2. knn54
        knn54 31 March 2021 15: 58
        +10
        The KEY word is Anapa.
    2. 210ox
      210ox 31 March 2021 17: 56
      +6
      I can only justify this by the selection of promising personnel for further work. Nothing else. I visit Anapa, Vityazevo, I pass this territory. Everything is really compact there. What serious laboratories to place there is really incomprehensible. Unless to invent models on computers.
  3. Dmt
    Dmt 31 March 2021 15: 30
    +5
    I must note that from the outside, this very ERA looks like a good boarding house, of which there are many on Pionersky Prospect of the resort city. And it looks, as they say, "for all the money" - one of (and perhaps the most) attractive that is there.
    1. 210ox
      210ox 31 March 2021 17: 58
      +2
      So this is the boarding house. It was created on the basis of an abandoned and purchased by the Ministry of Defense of the sanatorium.
      1. Dmt
        Dmt April 1 2021 08: 37
        +2
        "Hellas" used to stand there
  4. Alexander Kopychev
    Alexander Kopychev 31 March 2021 15: 37
    +4
    With all the negative expressed in the article, one positive impression is that recruits with Brains will not lose these Brains. And the best thing we would like to believe in is to actively develop them.
  5. URAL72
    URAL72 31 March 2021 15: 40
    +2
    As I understand it, these technopolises are not for scientific work, but for training personnel for existing research institutes and design bureaus. It's not bad too. And then from the Polytech to managers - that's not the point.
    1. Aviator_
      Aviator_ 31 March 2021 19: 03
      +3
      As I understand it, these technopolises are not for scientific work, but for training personnel for existing research institutes and design bureaus.
      The leading universities of the country - MIPT, MEPhI, Voenmekh, Baumanka - coped with this quite successfully - but what the article is about is cutting money.
      1. t-12
        t-12 31 March 2021 21: 19
        +2
        what the article is about is cutting money
        What the article is about is a picture for TV. For the audience to enjoy the power of science and technology.
        And if you do everything seriously, then science should be in Each universities and research institutes, and technology - at Each factory. And not in the only exemplary "technopolis".
  6. Victor Tsenin
    Victor Tsenin 31 March 2021 16: 00
    +4
    > Not, of course, can, if you provide an assembly diagram, the necessary components and an intelligent supervisor. But then what is the value of this operator and the scientific and technological innovation that everyone is talking about?

    But in the process, the operator will gain invaluable experience, technical knowledge, and may want to continue intellectual work for the good of the country in the Era. Isn't this already an important value?
    1. Aviator_
      Aviator_ 31 March 2021 19: 05
      +8
      But in the process, the operator will gain invaluable experience, technical knowledge, and may want to continue intellectual work for the good of the country in the Era. Isn't this already an important value?

      Or maybe it's better for this "operator" to first get a basic technical education at a university? What has been announced is the "Young Technicians" circle in the resort area.
      1. Victor Tsenin
        Victor Tsenin 31 March 2021 19: 15
        0
        Maybe so, or maybe the operator has already received it at the university / technical school. It doesn't look like a circle, with such leaders and such infusions.
        1. Aviator_
          Aviator_ 31 March 2021 19: 29
          +1
          If the "operator" is already educated, then during the Soviet era he was called up to the Armed Forces and offered to go to the military office (numbered research institute). And it was justified. Here it is Skolkovo with Rusnano in one bottle and in another department.
          1. Victor Tsenin
            Victor Tsenin 31 March 2021 19: 34
            0
            It was during the times of the mighty USSR, I understand. But in these realities, with all the introductory Era, it is rather a plus, i.e. if it helps to keep the patriotic guys for the good of the country, it will pay off.
            1. Aviator_
              Aviator_ 31 March 2021 19: 40
              +2
              if it helps to detain patriotic guys for the good of the country

              It won't help. We need very specific actions to educate young people, and here is profanation.
              1. Victor Tsenin
                Victor Tsenin 31 March 2021 19: 54
                -1
                Young people study according to profiles, yes / no? The era provides appropriate conditions for young techies, yes / no? Era is a pleasant place to fulfill the potential of young people, yes / no? I do not argue with you, do not misunderstand, but in my opinion, I do not see anything bad in the Era (well, except for corruption during construction / operation))
                1. Aviator_
                  Aviator_ 31 March 2021 19: 58
                  +2
                  Young people study 5-6 years old at a university, not in the ERA. Young people will have the potential for realization only after graduation, are they going to study in the ERE for 5 years? Now, even with unfinished bachelors, it is not clear what to do, but they studied for 4 years. This is a typical sawmill by the sea.
                  1. Victor Tsenin
                    Victor Tsenin 31 March 2021 20: 01
                    -1
                    I know where and how many young people study. According to Ere, do you think it is completely useless, even for interested parties?
                    1. t-12
                      t-12 31 March 2021 21: 21
                      +2
                      Interested what is?
                      1. Victor Tsenin
                        Victor Tsenin 31 March 2021 21: 25
                        -1
                        Of course, those interested in the topic of the issue under discussion.
                    2. Aviator_
                      Aviator_ 31 March 2021 21: 34
                      +1
                      Yes, I think its benefits are equal to those of Skolkovo and Rusnano. Only the Ministry of Defense did not have their analogues, now it does.
      2. DED_peer_DED
        DED_peer_DED April 1 2021 22: 33
        +2
        Quote: Aviator_
        this is a circle of "Young Technicians" in a resort area.

        42 rationalization proposals were submitted

        Yeah...
        Yoshkin cat ... that's a creative impulse!
        I’m wondering what can be rationalized by an "operator-rationalizer" being separated from the operation of the object of rationalization?
        A mop in your ultra-modern barracks, or a spoon in the dining room?
  7. Modya
    Modya 31 March 2021 16: 42
    +5
    The trouble is that “the state has money to provide all large families with housing” - it’s dumb! Raise pensions to an acceptable level - "so inflation will jump!" But to have such a toy in each department, which costs several billions annually - “this is a matter! It's investment, innovation! "
  8. Maks1995
    Maks1995 31 March 2021 17: 15
    +3
    So: Zelenograd - Yeltsin Skolkovo - in flight.

    Skolkovo ... in flight, famous for Rybka, and her pimp, deputy director of Skolkovo ...
    Even in "Made by Us" they couldn't really explain what awesome they are doing there ...

    Ros nano - in flight, famous for Red, profaned purchases of foreign firms and killers of iPhones for a billion ...

    It's time for Era. What will she be famous for ...
    1. DED_peer_DED
      DED_peer_DED April 1 2021 22: 37
      +2
      Quote: Max1995
      It's time for Era. What will she be famous for ...

      Young lads for spa ladies. "Eratically", though :)
  9. parusnik
    parusnik 31 March 2021 17: 17
    +3
    Each ministry, Skolkovo and ERA ... so we will break through smile
  10. what's up
    what's up 31 March 2021 17: 26
    0
    If in your mind - an idea for the future, well, very good! Cool science city - the ultimate dream! But in our reality, God forbid, another cut ...
  11. Virus-free crown
    Virus-free crown 31 March 2021 17: 53
    +5
    ERA ... Shmera ...
    You don't have to go far - Zelenograd, Pushchino, Dubna ... Inject some money there for the Army - and they will do everything ... soooooo personnel now "... they are eating up without salt" ... But no ... we need (we ?!) another "Skolkovo" to do, where state money disappears like in a black hole ... Again someone wants to warm their hands ... recourse

    Yes, even for a third of the money that was irretrievably lost in Skolkovo, but investing it in Zelenograd ... we would have our microelectronics equipment no worse than world samples !!! am
    1. DED_peer_DED
      DED_peer_DED April 1 2021 22: 42
      +1
      Quote: Corona without virus
      But no ... we need (we ?!) to make another Skolkovo, where state money disappears like in a black hole ... Again, someone wants to warm their hands ...

      "You are forever responsible for everyone you have tamed" (c)

      Understand-a-aye ... (c)
  12. tralflot1832
    tralflot1832 31 March 2021 18: 01
    0
    I have such a suspicion that the Era technopolis was created for the export of young, beautiful, unmarried Anapchan women from the northern coast of the Black Sea! lol
    1. Nastia makarova
      Nastia makarova April 1 2021 11: 53
      0
      and why take them out of there?
  13. 123456789
    123456789 31 March 2021 21: 58
    0
    Feast in Time of Plague soldier
  14. Tavrik
    Tavrik 31 March 2021 21: 58
    +4
    Military Medical Academy. CM. Kirov, one of the most reputable scientific centers in Russia, has been working with the ERA technopolis for more than two years.

    Where will they go? They were given a task - they fulfill it.
    But why transfer such complex projects from St. Petersburg to Anapa?

    The climate is better there.
    and another 60% became "employees of research institutes and defense industry organizations"

    Perhaps this is the benefit of the ERA. A sort of recruiting center for defense enterprises. You can look after your future employees. NN in uniform.
    In general, the ERA benefits everyone:
    - the faculty received the legal opportunity to ride south at public expense;
    - smart university graduates got the opportunity to spend a relaxed year in the army and, possibly, look out for a future place of work;
    - enterprises got the opportunity to take a closer look at future employees;
    - the officers received a certain number of thieves' posts on the seashore;
    - the senior management received one more place in the south, which can be regularly checked, monitored and "provide methodological assistance";
    - Well, the minister got his own court Skolkovo.
  15. Peaceful SEO
    Peaceful SEO 31 March 2021 23: 48
    -2
    It's simple. Personnel with good potential are selected there. And cadres, as you know, decide everything.
  16. RMT
    RMT April 1 2021 09: 51
    +2
    It is good to serve in Anapa.
  17. Mikhail3
    Mikhail3 April 1 2021 10: 13
    0
    God! Our country is simply an inexhaustible deposit of reasons for bitter laughter!
    The situation is as follows. Under socialism, scientists lived well, but without much chic. Our country was one family working towards a common goal. And the scientists did their duty very seriously! The USSR had a huge number of scientific and technical achievements, which it actively used. However, we "no longer need either socialism or the USSR." We have chosen the capitalist path of development!
    And how are scientific and technical achievements achieved under capitalism? Everything is simple here - a person who makes a discovery or comes up with a useful technical solution becomes very, very rich. The only thing that pushes people on the path of science under capitalism is greed. It's too hard a lot to be a scientist or an engineer of the highest qualification. But...
    Our elite are not capitalists. In capitalism, they ALSO do not understand nicher, because of what kind of people they are, how their personality is arranged. Therefore, they will never, never. under no circumstances will they agree that scientists and engineers should be paid, and even a lot. And these our geniuses came up with a wonderful solution - since the damned slaves do not want to burn their brains in super-efforts for free, but let's make them ... pubs ... military! That is, slaves under oath! Awesome ...
    Now scientists and engineers will walk between the barracks and production buildings in formation. With a song. Minting step. The sergeants will restore order among them. And discoveries with inventions will be made by order of Mr. Major! Then it will be handed over to Mr. Major, for subsequent implementation ...
    There are no words. There are no words)))
  18. yehat2
    yehat2 April 1 2021 13: 55
    +1
    I do not understand.
    what is bad about the fact that they decided to do the development not in the taiga, but in a more pleasant climate.
    Only I did not understand why on the seashore - it seems to me that such a center should be on the outskirts at least a couple of kilometers from the coast. And it turns out naturally a sanatorium and no developments.
    There is absolutely no territory for experimental tests and laboratories.
  19. rica1952
    rica1952 April 2 2021 11: 49
    +1
    Let's start with the fact that the specific scientific research institutes of the Ministry of Defense have been destroyed; military academies have been thrown out of Moscow; well, we shouldn't even talk about the Russian Academy of Sciences, a complete degrading vinaigrette. The question is why this was done. The answer is a simple clan-oligarchic system of power and a liberal-monetary model of the economy. Our liberal economic bloc will not allow this to happen with our science, our developed industry. Skolkovo, and similar laundering offices please. And the result is obvious the leading countries are already leaving the 6th technological order, we are marking time in the 4th.
    1. Mikhail3
      Mikhail3 April 2 2021 12: 43
      0
      It is "this" that has been done because science has absolutely, completely, completely nothing to do in the capital. This is confirmed by the entire history of all states) All the "scientists" to whom the capital is given do not want to engage in science, but to steal and intrigue, so that against the background of science, they want to fix their affairs. Nasty little business ...
  20. SiberianGun
    SiberianGun April 2 2021 22: 47
    0
    In Russia, this is already a proven technology for cutting the budget. Following the example of Skolkovo. It is called an "effective manager". That is, this is a group of people who may not be specialists at all in the technological field, but who are professional managers in jackets. State managers. At Skolkovo, such effective managers received a lot of money for megaprojects.
    This ERA shnyaga is made using the same technology. The main thing here is to come up with the necessary organization and squeeze out the dough. Well this is Russia!
  21. Andrey Krasnopoyas
    Andrey Krasnopoyas April 3 2021 23: 18
    +1
    Instruct to create anti-torpedo protection for our Navy)))
  22. Basarev
    Basarev April 5 2021 11: 02
    0
    The answer is simple: no one thought about science. The era from the very beginning was a PR and a drink. And the rest is propaganda for the narrow-minded. And our other technopolises are similar. The main thing is missing: economic and political freedom. In the United States, the state invests in Silicon Valley - but does not have the right to demand anything.
  23. Maks1995
    Maks1995 April 6 2021 22: 18
    -1
    By the way, there is news today - the Skolkovo answer to Mask is closed.
    CosmoCourse ...
    7 years and no visible results ...
  24. Nikolay Senkin
    Nikolay Senkin April 7 2021 12: 12
    0
    The author of the article is worried for a reason. He apparently feels that the presence of the Era Technopark on the “golden sands” is not yet a guarantee of success. Here a reservation is appropriate. If the army sees itself as self-sufficient, then it is doomed. And if the army does not separate itself from the light, then the reflection should also be deeper, more complete, and not because the light wants so, but because relying on the corresponding secular processes is a guarantee of its vitality.

    It should be. Ahead of all, it is necessary to develop not the technological component of the economy, which is what modern technoparks are doing, but the innovative one. Their difference is that innovative technologies always implement subject-object (and therefore digitalized) relations. While market innovations implement more complex subject-subject relationships, relationships when the consumer's response is much less predictable. Actually, this is what makes the army and the institution of innovative entrepreneurs (marketers) related.

    Thus, an army ahead of its time must:

    a) to support the creation and promote the development of the institution of market, and not only technological, entrepreneurs (since the state is not concerned with this, and does not know how);
    b) establish the necessary infrastructure to facilitate the prompt and mutually beneficial exchange of relevant standards;
    c) generalize and use the experience of operating technoparks.

    And in their current form, military technopolises are a systemic error that entails ineffective spending of funds, since not a single bird, not a single plane will take off on one wing.
  25. Vladimir Vlasov
    Vladimir Vlasov April 9 2021 19: 04
    0
    Living on the seashore is the dream of many smart ass.
  26. Vladimir Vlasov
    Vladimir Vlasov 1 June 2021 14: 02
    0
    It's just that very cunning officials have arranged for themselves an almost free "place of residence" on the shores of the warm resort sea. There are no other reasons in the technopolis.