Military Review

"Knock down NATO's breath": Russian political scientist proposed to conduct a series of nuclear tests

264
"Knock down NATO's breath": Russian political scientist proposed to conduct a series of nuclear tests

Political scientist Dmitry Yevstafiev, a professor at the Higher School of Economics, suggested “to knock down NATO's breath” by temporarily withdrawing from the Nuclear Test Ban Treaty and carrying out a series of nuclear explosions. He stated this in the "Sunday Evening" program on Channel One.


Commenting on the statement by NATO Secretary General Jens Stoltenberg on NATO's position on the Nord Stream 2 gas pipeline, Evstafyev said that the North Atlantic Alliance has ceased to be a military-political bloc, being transformed into a geopolitical system that aims to redistribute the world in the interests of the United States.

According to the professor, NATO has become a US instrument for solving geopolitical tasks, and in modern conditions Washington is ready to use this force to seize the resources of other countries. It is not excluded that in the near future the US will use NATO to resolve the issue with Russia by force.

The West does not have the resources and time for a medium-term and long-term policy towards Russia. (...) They are boiling, and morally they mature to the point that the only way to solve problems with respect to Russia is this or that option of forceful resolution

- said the professor.

Since the United States does not accept methods of persuasion other than forceful methods in order to "cool the hotheads in the West," Yevstafiev suggests "to slow down their pace, to bring down their breath." To do this, Russia needs to temporarily withdraw from the Nuclear Test Ban Treaty and conduct a series of nuclear explosions, combining them with any major NATO exercises.

In this situation (...) we must temporarily withdraw from the Nuclear Test Ban Treaty and carry out a series of 20-25 demonstration nuclear explosions, and combine them with any major NATO exercises. We have fewer and fewer other options to cool hotheads in the West.

- he added.
264 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. Mark kalendarov
    Mark kalendarov 27 March 2021 10: 44
    +26
    The direction is correct. This world only respects strength.
    1. Insurgent
      Insurgent 27 March 2021 10: 50
      +33
      Since the United States does not accept methods of persuasion other than forceful methods in order to "cool the hotheads in the West," Yevstafiev suggests "to slow down their pace, to bring down their breath." To do this, Russia needs to temporarily withdraw from the Nuclear Test Ban Treaty and conduct a series of nuclear explosions, combining them with any major NATO exercises.

      Explosions, for explosions? Just to show that Russia can spit on the agreement, to revive its opponents?

      what what what ... In my opinion, if you really "bang", then such actions should also carry some scientific and applied value, in order to improve nuclear weapons.

      What has always been the practice of holding such events ...
      1. Flooding
        Flooding 27 March 2021 11: 04
        +12
        Quote: Insurgent
        Explosions, for explosions? Just to show that Russia can spit on the agreement, to revive its opponents?

        you can fantasize how the United States will react
        for example, a series of atomic explosions
        too weak
        and rushed ...

        Professors from the Higher School of Economics have been delighted on TV in recent years
        1. Starover_Z
          Starover_Z 27 March 2021 11: 21
          +1
          Quote: Flood
          Professors from the Higher School of Economics have been delighted on TV in recent years

          "Professor" - 3 classes of education! Just a provocateur!
          Do not frighten the "partners" by conducting nuclear explosions prohibited by treaties, but pushing the world towards the abyss is easy!
          1. letinant
            letinant 27 March 2021 11: 43
            +22
            Quote: Starover_Z
            Quote: Flood
            Professors from the Higher School of Economics have been delighted on TV in recent years

            "Professor" - 3 classes of education! Just a provocateur!
            Do not frighten the "partners" by conducting nuclear explosions prohibited by treaties, but pushing the world towards the abyss is easy!

            Then there is no logic in your words, if you do not frighten them with trials, then how will this event push the world towards the abyss? They just laugh and that's it, but if they get scared then yes, but then Evstafiev is right, it will make them think. The world was safer when nuclear weapons were tested and that was when the rules were followed. And all these contracts are for a diversion. Example: The ABM Treaty, all the time it was in force, the Americans were developing, went to the final tests and withdrew from the treaty, presented with a fact. Therefore, I believe that all these agreements are slowing us down!
            1. sniperino
              sniperino 27 March 2021 12: 06
              +3
              Quote: letinant
              The world was safer when nuclear weapons were tested and that was when the rules were followed.
              Hopefully, we have the latest nuclear weapon development in store, awaiting testing to be carried out immediately after the first appropriate test by the Americans. Let them see that the answer will not be long in coming.
              1. Alex777
                Alex777 27 March 2021 12: 19
                0
                Americans have long been looking for a reason to abandon the ban on nuclear tests, and the HSE professor is playing into their hands, hiding behind a patriotic agenda. negative
                We do not need nuclear tests under any pretext. We have almost renewed the nuclear triad.
                And the States are just beginning to do this. hi
                1. sniperino
                  sniperino 27 March 2021 12: 49
                  +4
                  Quote: Alex777
                  We do not need nuclear tests under any pretext
                  Do you think that they can conduct tests, and in response we should only express concern and warn about inadmissibility? So they do not understand nifiga in Russian, but they are used to lying in English so that they might think we are bluffing. Testing for testing, i.e. to convey to partners the idea in a visual-figurative form, quite accessible even to preschoolers from 4 years old.
                  1. hydrox
                    hydrox 27 March 2021 18: 17
                    +2
                    These are just the tests needed for old YaBG, in order to check their compliance with the SanPins - it is not worse to finish off than to interrupt. yes
                    1. sniperino
                      sniperino 27 March 2021 20: 24
                      +1
                      Quote: hydrox
                      tests are needed for old nuclear weapons
                      Or so. I'm talking about the same thing: to test what is more needed, and not necessarily nuclear, but so that the signal clearly passes through the first signal system, and not in words. In words, let their experts "guess" and the press rattles that it was the answer of the Russians.
                      1. hydrox
                        hydrox 28 March 2021 05: 13
                        +5
                        Exactly!
                        Our enemies need to be shaken so that they feel in their gut the very fact that we have something to experience, and seismicity, in turn, will show that the subject is in a good vigorous state, which the minke whales cannot say about their YaBGs, which do not have the ability to reload the heads as fresh plutonium, and due to the loss of technology.
                        And at the same time, our sworn friends should KNOW that we can carry out tests not only on New Earth, but also in Massachusetts or Quebec, and we have plenty of stuff to pack new YaBG and we can easily do it, unlike the British liars. and beggars with regard to minke plutonium.
                      2. Vladimir Mashkov
                        Vladimir Mashkov 28 March 2021 12: 14
                        +2
                        Yevstafiev's dream is beautiful, of course, but rather belated and hardly achievable for a number of reasons.

                        First. Very it is difficult, almost impossible to convince to be adequate to the impudent inadequacy of the United States, firmly convinced that he has every right to be them and that it is necessary to act exactly the way he acts.

                        The second... Politics of the current Leader of Russia in geopolitics very cautious and he prefers to "play black" (number two), and usually decides to take decisive offensive actions only with minimal risk and full confidence in success. There are almost no chances to agree with Yevstafiev's proposal.

                        The third... The current situation in geopolitics is such that the United States, with the coming to power of Biden-Democrats, sharply inflamed tensions in the world and, trying to save its diminishing influence in Europe due to SP-2, "Sputnik V", is ready to unleash a "hot war" against Russia, followed by a powerful leap in Russophobia, the instrument of which will be Ukraine and the Armed Forces of Ukraine. and volunteers-Russophobes around the world.

                        Here you need to think not how to scare the United States and the West, but how to answer with dignity in the coming battle.
                      3. napalm
                        napalm 28 March 2021 13: 38
                        +2
                        Evstafiev's dream is beautiful, of course, but it is pretty late and hardly realizable for a number of reasons. Very sound reasoning. Let whoever put you a minus refute all three points.
                      4. Vladimir Mashkov
                        Vladimir Mashkov 28 March 2021 14: 29
                        +1
                        Quote: napalm
                        Evstafiev's dream is beautiful, of course, but it is pretty late and hardly realizable for a number of reasons. Very sound reasoning. Let whoever put you a minus refute all three points.

                        You have been here for a long time and, for sure, you know that there are many not only adequate opponents, but also enemies of normal people. And Russian, and from near and far abroad. They minus silently. Some reasonable people are simply persecuted, fiercely minus in violation of the Rules. And accomplices - plus for obvious nonsense, which is also a violation of the Rules. The regulation could clarify the introduction of the indicator of who votes and how: it would be immediately visible xy from xy. But - for some reason - they do not enter ...
                    2. your1970
                      your1970 28 March 2021 15: 48
                      -1
                      the volume of oil supplies to the United States in 2020 increased 14 (!!!!!) times ...
                    3. sniperino
                      sniperino 29 March 2021 12: 23
                      +1
                      Quote: Vladimir Mashkov
                      Here you need to think not how to scare the United States and the West, but how to adequately respond in the upcoming battle.
                      Think you are not thinking about a decent answer? Good or bad, it's not for me to judge. I believe that this is not a reason to withdraw from psychological warfare. Moreover, we have one important advantage in the information war: they have to lie and dodge, and we only need to show where they do it. But no one canceled the emotional impact of the picture of a probable answer: it is better to see once, as they say. We ourselves need this, so that our people see not only their threats, but also that there is an answer to them, and feel confident enough in conditions when an army of bots is spreading negativity: from despondency, distrust of the authorities to panic.
                    4. The comment was deleted.
                    5. Vladimir Mashkov
                      Vladimir Mashkov 29 March 2021 13: 18
                      +1
                      Quote: sniperino
                      Think you are not thinking about a decent answer?

                      Totally agree with you! And - I'm sure - all the options have long been thought out, preparations have been made. The main thing is not to miss the beginning. I hope they won't.
                    6. sniperino
                      sniperino 29 March 2021 15: 42
                      +1
                      Quote: Vladimir Mashkov
                      The main thing is not to miss the beginning.
                      It is a fact. This is the only way to minimize losses. That is why I recall here the Caucasus-2020 exercises as an example of combining the education and training of drugs with a moral and psychological impact on a potential partner and his fans.
                2. sniperino
                  sniperino 29 March 2021 13: 48
                  +1
                  Quote: Vladimir Mashkov
                  The policy of the current Leader of Russia in geopolitics is very careful and he prefers to "play black" (number two), and decisive offensive actions, as a rule, goes only with minimal risk and full confidence in success.
                  All that can be added to this is that he cares about our army. All together it looks like a desire to gain time to minimize damage to one's country and build up power for a worthy response to the enemy. In order not to succeed like Povetkin and White.
          2. Alex777
            Alex777 28 March 2021 00: 32
            +7
            Do you think that they can conduct tests, and in response we should only express our concern and warn about inadmissibility?

            I clearly wrote that I believe: we do not need trials.
            We don't need trials in the States.
            Carrying them out while the States observes the moratorium is a completely unnecessary provocation.
            When the United States demonstrates its true face to the whole world, then there will be a different conversation.
            In the meantime, suggestions like:
            Since the United States does not accept methods of persuasion other than forceful methods in order to "cool the hotheads in the West," Yevstafiev suggests "to slow down their pace, to bring down their breath." For this Russia needs to temporarily withdraw from the Nuclear Test Ban Treaty and conduct a series of nuclear explosionsby combining them with any major NATO exercises.

            are a provocation in the interests of those circles in the United States who want to lift the moratorium.
            1. sniperino
              sniperino 28 March 2021 03: 01
              +2
              Quote: Alex777
              Carrying them out while the States observes the moratorium is a completely unnecessary provocation.
              I write the same thing, but in other words, if you read a little more carefully:
              Quote: sniperino
              and we answer
              What are you arguing with?
              1. Alex777
                Alex777 28 March 2021 11: 32
                +2
                First of all, I don’t argue.
                Secondly, what are you talking about our answer to? request
                States do not test.
                Russia does not conduct tests.
                Let everything remain so.
                And the professor suggested that Russia start unilaterally conducting nuclear tests.
                On this I disagree with him. hi
              2. sniperino
                sniperino 28 March 2021 11: 42
                +3
                Quote: Alex777
                the professor suggested starting nuclear tests. On this I disagree with him.
                And I disagree, that's why I'm writing about an alternative to the professor's provocative proposal. hi
      2. Tusv
        Tusv 27 March 2021 13: 30
        -1
        And what do you have against the HSE? Is this a paradigm? My oldest son finished it. And they taught, besides Python, sheer Americophobia, and I sent him there to learn twice. Is it a fact. Reinforced concrete
        1. Flooding
          Flooding 28 March 2021 15: 32
          0
          Quote: Tusv
          And what do you have against the HSE? Is this a paradigm? My oldest son finished it. And they taught, besides Python, sheer Americophobia, and I sent him there to learn twice. Is it a fact. Reinforced concrete

          specifically, against pro-Westerners who teach in this institution and are regularly invited to television.
          others are simply not shown.
          maybe they are
      3. keeper03
        keeper03 27 March 2021 14: 30
        +3
        HSE works for the FSA, it is high time to close this bardel! No. belay soldier
      4. bk0010
        bk0010 27 March 2021 19: 37
        +1
        Quote: Alex777
        Americans have long been looking for an excuse to abandon the ban on nuclear tests
        What for? The matmodel was worked out back in the mid-80s, and therefore abandoned testing. Calculating is now easier and cheaper than measuring.
        1. Alex777
          Alex777 28 March 2021 00: 26
          +2
          The matmodel was worked out back in the mid-80s, and therefore abandoned testing.

          That is why I wrote that we do not need trials.
          Why the States are looking for a reason to abandon the moratorium is not a question for me. hi
          1. Pandiurin
            Pandiurin 28 March 2021 23: 28
            +1
            Quote: Alex777
            The matmodel was worked out back in the mid-80s, and therefore abandoned testing.

            That is why I wrote that we do not need trials.
            Why the States are looking for a reason to abandon the moratorium is not a question for me. hi


            Matmodels never fully correspond to a real object.
            If the design, some operating principles change, other materials are used, then it is advisable to check the material model in practice, as well as the product itself.

            The Americans most likely have a strong interest in withdrawing from the treaty and conducting a series of tests. Because they are developing new nuclear weapons of low yield and adjustable detonation power.

            Most likely, the United States will conduct such tests, and let them be the first to violate the treaty.

            We just need to prepare in advance and think carefully about what we will experience.
            All the same, it carries costs and pollution of the territory, even if it is underground tests.
            That would not conduct tests for the sake of tests. Surely we also have something to confirm and check and improve.
            1. Alex777
              Alex777 29 March 2021 14: 17
              0
              Totally agree! drinks
    2. ccsr
      ccsr 27 March 2021 18: 18
      +3
      Quote: sniperino
      Hope we have the latest nuclear weapon development in store waiting to be tested,

      In fact, we also have old nuclear weapons in excellent performance, so it makes no sense to bother checking them with the help of detonation - the professor is apparently far from military science. But constantly launching rockets to check the accuracy of the flight and disengaging warheads in the form of mock-ups must be done constantly, because this is our most important argument. Now three boats have surfaced from under the ice, and, unfortunately, none have launched, and this is bad. Therefore, it is necessary to include the launch of a strategic missile in the program of any exercise of the Northern Fleet - in this way we will shoot old ones and force the West to change diapers more often.
      1. sniperino
        sniperino 27 March 2021 21: 18
        -1
        Quote: ccsr
        make the West change diapers more often.
        I am against "more often", but not a pacifist. If, with the help of open sources and Patrushev, we link some of our tests, exercises, etc., forcing them to change diapers, in time to their noticeable military activity (for example, immediately after their nuclear weapons tests), then they themselves will create a semantic the construct "the answer of the Russians". So that no one would have any doubts that Russia has an answer. Otherwise, the words of politicians and diplomats do not reach everyone. If one simply demonstrates frequently, then there will be not a "response", but a "Russian threat". There is a difference.
        1. hydrox
          hydrox 28 March 2021 05: 24
          0
          That is, do you agree with the provision that a real nuclear threat should take place?
          Then I will agree with you that helplessly knocking a shoe on the podium of the Security Council to make the laughing stock of the whole world is a stupid and unworthy occupation of our country.
          1. sniperino
            sniperino 28 March 2021 10: 08
            0
            Quote: hydrox
            there must be a real nuclear threat
            "Nuclear" is secondary here. Bacteriological, chemical ... no difference: a military threat. The reality of the threat is assessed by the General Staff, Security Service of the Russian Federation; a specific response to a specific threat may be a state secret, this is not discussed. I would replace the word "real" with "open". For example, we entered the Black Sea and received an unexpected response “Kavkaz-2020”.
            Quote: hydrox
            to knock a shoe on the podium of the Security Council to the laughing stock of the whole world
            If Lavrov, in response to Powell's shock with the test tube, offered to put it on the table in front of him and banged, at the same time, a shoe on the table, demonstrating what he was going to do with it so that everyone could be convinced of Powell's deceit and fake test tube, it would probably be adequate and memorable ANSWER and would laugh at the fake itself and Powell's reaction to Lavrov's proposal.
      2. Pandiurin
        Pandiurin 28 March 2021 23: 33
        0
        Quote: ccsr
        Quote: sniperino
        Hope we have the latest nuclear weapon development in store waiting to be tested,

        In fact, we also have old nuclear weapons in excellent performance, so it makes no sense to bother checking them with the help of detonation - the professor is apparently far from military science. But constantly launching rockets to check the accuracy of the flight and disengaging warheads in the form of mock-ups must be done constantly, because this is our most important argument. Now three boats have surfaced from under the ice, and, unfortunately, none have launched, and this is bad. Therefore, it is necessary to include the launch of a strategic missile in the program of any exercise of the Northern Fleet - in this way we will shoot old ones and force the West to change diapers more often.


        It is customary to warn about ICBM launches.
        Imagine three submarines float up and without warning figurate ICBMs, suddenly someone somewhere, while diapers will change which thread the button will press.
        1. ccsr
          ccsr 29 March 2021 11: 06
          0
          Quote: Pandiurin
          It is customary to warn about ICBM launches.

          Naturally, such a launch would have been warned in advance.
          Quote: Pandiurin
          Imagine three submarines float up and without warning they figure ICBMs,

          I said that one ascent and one precise launch along the polygon is enough - it is necessary to show that it is technically possible.
          Quote: Pandiurin
          while the diapers will change which thread the button will press.

          You yourself know that this could not be, since we warn you in advance. Yes, it would not be a massive take-off - there, too, are not fools tracking the situation.
    3. Narak-zempo
      Narak-zempo 28 March 2021 13: 23
      0
      Quote: sniperino
      Hope we have the latest nuclear weapon development in store

      There is, and not one, do not worry.
  2. Flooding
    Flooding 27 March 2021 15: 20
    +2
    Quote: letinant
    They just laugh and that's it, but if they get scared then yes, but then Evstafiev is right, it will make them think.

    fear is a natural feeling inherent in most people with a healthy psyche
    but at the same time, frightened people react very differently
    think our grandfathers were not afraid to go to the bayonet
    fear in itself is not as important as the act that followed that fear
    but here options are possible
    up to very undesirable

    and in light of this, the role of a blackmailer proposed by this expert is not only very unsightly, but can also lead to the opposite effect of the expected
  • ultra
    ultra 27 March 2021 13: 59
    +6
    Quote: Starover_Z
    Carrying out nuclear explosions prohibited by treaties

    There are no agreements on underground tests, there is a moratorium on such tests, it is voluntarily taken by Russia.
  • vlad.baryatinsky
    vlad.baryatinsky 27 March 2021 15: 43
    -1
    Quote: Starover_Z
    "Professor" - 3 classes of education! Just a provocateur!

    You have. put it mildly.
    For example, during the Second Karabakh turmoil, this sower of "brilliant ideas" proposed, in company with Kurginyan and Bagdosarov, to inflict a Nuclear Strike on Baku.
    And all this rushed from the Federal Channel to the approving grunting of such "figures" as the deputy of the State Duma of the Russian Federation Zatulin (!)
    A person convicted of the trust of voters.
  • bk0010
    bk0010 27 March 2021 19: 34
    +3
    Quote: Starover_Z
    Do not frighten "partners" by carrying out nuclear explosions prohibited by treaties
    The task is not to frighten, the task is to clearly show that the concept "they will not dare", which is circulating in the highest military-political circles of NATO with regard to our retaliatory or retaliatory-on-counter strike, does not correspond to reality.
  • Vladimir_2U
    Vladimir_2U 27 March 2021 14: 47
    0
    Quote: Flood
    Professors from the Higher School of Economics have been delighted on TV in recent years

    For example, I considered HSE to be a hotbed of liberals, for example, but here people are just happy! Western citizens and politicians should be reminded directly that Russia has nuclear weapons and what it is!
    1. bk0010
      bk0010 27 March 2021 19: 39
      0
      Quote: Vladimir_2U
      For example, I considered HSE to be a hotbed of liberals, for example, but here people are just happy!
      Other universities that had buildings in the center of Moscow were driven into the HSE, they were then evicted to the outskirts, and in the center now the original HSE faculties are located.
  • yuratanja1950
    yuratanja1950 28 March 2021 11: 26
    -1
    Quote: Flood
    Professors from the Higher School of Economics have been delighted on TV in recent years


    Hmm ... And such professors teach in higher educational institutions ... "Doctor of Political Science" ...
    And where will we spend a series of "bachs", at his dacha?
  • Nikon OConor
    Nikon OConor 27 March 2021 11: 06
    -1
    I also think that tests are needed during NATO exercises, but it is necessary to bang so that not "in the dust", but with tactical ammunition. Strategic ones are not so scary: there are many issues that will fly in, they will not get there, to decide - not to decide on it. But tactical ones are not so harmful for the environment, and they will make it clear to especially frostbitten warriors that they will not hit cities with peaceful people, but precisely their dear ones.
    1. Insurgent
      Insurgent 27 March 2021 11: 13
      +2
      Quote: Nikon OConor
      I also think that tests are needed during NATO exercises, but it is necessary to bang so that not "in the dust", but with tactical ammunition. Strategic ones are not so scary: there are many issues that will fly in, they will not get there, to decide - not to decide on it. But tactical ones are not so harmful for the environment, and they will make it clear to especially frostbitten warriors that they will not hit cities with peaceful people, but precisely their dear ones.

      I can correct you.
      It was not about ground testing certain systems of nuclear deterrence, and about underground tests of conditionally - "nuclear explosive devices".

      The ban on testing nuclear weapons in all spheres (except for underground ones) is marginal and unshakable and cannot be revised.
      And Moscow, Beijing and Washington are well aware of this ...
      1. Nikon OConor
        Nikon OConor 27 March 2021 11: 15
        +3
        I also relied on this thesis. As far as I know (I can be wrong of course) underground is not prohibited. Therefore, it is not necessary to withdraw from the agreement. That is why I thought - since "temporarily go out", then we are talking about ground ...
        1. Insurgent
          Insurgent 27 March 2021 11: 22
          +1
          Quote: Nikon OConor
          I thought - since "temporarily go out", then we are talking about ground ...

          It's about "temporary moratorium"(constantly renewed), and voluntary , almost a "gentlemen's agreement", to test
  • Paragraph Epitafievich Y.
    Paragraph Epitafievich Y. 27 March 2021 11: 33
    -1
    Quote: Insurgent
    Explosions, for explosions? Just to show that Russia can spit on the agreement, to revive its opponents?

    Exactly. Frostbite of the ears is intended to annoy the grandmother. But the fact that the proposal to 'give a damn' and 'show' comes from a representative of a neoliberal office should make the overly expressive 'spoilers' think.
  • Terenin
    Terenin 27 March 2021 14: 17
    +3
    These "analysts", with the HSE, will recommend right now. Then you will not rake
  • Thunderbolt
    Thunderbolt 27 March 2021 20: 32
    +1
    Quote: Insurgent
    ... In my opinion, if you really "bang", then such actions should also carry some scientific and applied value, in order to improve nuclear weapons.

    Your view is wrong, and the message of a political scientist, there is a purely populist move from the category of "how many missiles we have, if they climb, we'll hit America !!!" The political scientist "forgot" or not at all aware of all the agreements between the Pentagon and the Strategic Missile Forces. What blood was given to the existing strategic parity. This is a whole epic, how much the Russian military-strategic bloc made powerful efforts to preserve, attention, PARITY in the strategic nuclear forces.
  • Alanart
    Alanart 28 March 2021 19: 32
    0
    Well, find a butt - no problem. Surely, there are new designs, and check the reliability of the old ones, the filling has already been changed and more than once, well, like where they messed up.
    But it's not worth it;)
  • paul3390
    paul3390 27 March 2021 11: 08
    -15%
    It's not about the explosions. And in the iron confidence of opponents that if something happens, they will shy away at them without hesitation. That's how it was under the USSR. And now - why our leadership will throw a vigorous loaf? For their families in the West? Yachts, mansions, villas? By your Western accounts? Everything that has been acquired in 30 years of backbreaking labor to plunder the country? Yah?

    And what - does anyone really believe that Putin will press the button ?? Yes, schaz! That is why mattress makers become impudent - they know that capital is always dearer to the bourgeois than the Motherland. And this capital is with them .. So ..
    1. Nikon OConor
      Nikon OConor 27 March 2021 11: 24
      +5
      Believe me, if we really get so bad that it really is ... Nobody will wait for orders from the Kremlin, every officer on duty in the regiment's command post has the opportunity to bang. Imagine the number 1 crew sitting at the checkpoint and watching and listening to our cities burning, their families have already been burned down, and they will be waiting for an order that may never be?
      1. paul3390
        paul3390 27 March 2021 11: 35
        -12%
        Do you seriously think that everyone sitting at the button has the opportunity to just take and bang ??? belay
        1. Nikon OConor
          Nikon OConor 27 March 2021 12: 00
          +24
          Excuse me where you served? I am in the Rocket Regiment, and I do not count, but I know it. And I also know that 95% of the shift supervisors, seeing that the cities are burning in atomic fire, will ask for the command command of the division, if there is no answer - "the key to start", and if the general's answer is "no," they will be sent to hell. The commanders of the regiments and their deputies have no villas in Europe, but there is a Motherland and it is in the nearest city, which will soon burn down or has already burned down. Moreover, if cities burn, the hospitals know for sure that they will not be sorry.
          1. Nikon OConor
            Nikon OConor 27 March 2021 12: 00
            +5
            you can minus ... strategists))
          2. Maximilian37
            Maximilian37 27 March 2021 13: 07
            +1
            Your cons is twisted by VO, so that you would tell more secrets. Don't fall for provocations ...
            1. Nikon OConor
              Nikon OConor 27 March 2021 13: 13
              +5
              Yes, these are not secrets at all .... I remember a film of the mid-80s made in the USA, when a warhead was stolen from our Kartala missile division and sold to the broads. Of course he laughed (I saw this film for the first time after the service). When he quit: he was warned / asked not to disclose it for 5 years ..., "Voevoda" was removed a long time ago, only the satellites were left to start up. So secrets 0 are "open-ended" secrets.
              1. Maximilian37
                Maximilian37 27 March 2021 13: 53
                +3
                You are not the only commentator on VO with admission, but what if someone will let it slip! The site is, as I understood it, in the hands of our "sworn friends".
                1. Nikon OConor
                  Nikon OConor 27 March 2021 14: 42
                  +2
                  Well, I've been here for half a year, probably officially, and for 3 years, I have never read the secret ... Looks like we are conscious))
          3. Terenin
            Terenin 27 March 2021 14: 22
            +3
            Quote: Nikon OConor
            And I also know that 95% of the shift supervisors, seeing that the cities are burning in atomic fire, will ask for the command command of the division, if there is no answer - "the key to start", and if the general's answer is "no," they will be sent to hell. The commanders of the regiments and their deputies have no villas in Europe, but there is a Motherland and it is in the nearest city, which will soon burn down or has already burned down. Moreover, if cities are on fire, the hospitals know for sure that they will not be sorry.

            Why wait for our cities to burn?
            Before the nix, you need to navigate where it is ... Dima Peskov. If in England, then the key to the start ... am
            1. Nikon OConor
              Nikon OConor 27 March 2021 15: 52
              +2
              During my service, the doctrine was different, only a response and only when in cities. Something like this.
          4. JonnyT
            JonnyT 27 March 2021 15: 20
            +6
            In in. I recall a case in the 90s when, at the behest of the Supreme Commander-in-Chief, Bori came to disarm the Teik missile division, but the brigade commander took and brought all the poplars into the fields and did not let them be cut.
            Then Chubais and his bandits wanted to destroy the substation, but on the same evening the substation was taken under the control of the military, and the Chubaikov lackeys were told that if they tried to get into a secure facility, their black jeeps would turn into a sieve.
            And if now criminal and treacherous orders come from the top, then no one will carry them out, except for the same traitors to corruption
            1. Nikon OConor
              Nikon OConor 27 March 2021 16: 00
              +4
              I support it, this was not only in the 90s, but also in the early 2000s. A not entirely correct example: the Kazakhstan-Russia border, partisans (who illegally crossed the border) broke through with a large consignment of drugs. The border guards asked for help from their own - they dumped a bolt of 32 (I don't know why, probably someone had a share), the border guards asked for help from the Strategic Missile Forces, our division blew up the calculations of the reinforcement of 6 regiments, combed all the steppes and groves, found everyone .. there was about 50 kg of grass ...
          5. ccsr
            ccsr 27 March 2021 18: 28
            -1
            Quote: Nikon OConor
            And I also know that 95% of shift supervisors, seeing that cities are burning in atomic fire,

            I wonder how they will see this, sitting in the "glass" where the rocket is located?
            I myself sat underground on duty at one time in another system, and if something happened, then the first thing to do was to shut down the metal doors using an electric drive - even if it was an element of the teachings. In addition, the seismic sensors were located around the perimeter, so that we did not know anything yet, having received a signal from them, we automatically battened down one single entrance.
            So there is no need to tell about the shift supervisors - they don’t know what’s going on outside, and will only execute the command, and if the representative of the 12th department gets his team, and not what they suddenly want. At least that was the case in the Soviet Army, and I don't think that anything has changed now.
            1. Nikon OConor
              Nikon OConor 27 March 2021 18: 56
              +2
              In addition, the seismic sensors were located around the perimeter, so we did not know anything yet, having received a signal from them, we automatically battened down one single entrance.

              Did you serve at the communications center? So we had better systems, with wire communication hundreds of kilometers underground. We tried to catch the wire diggers, but we caught it and then restored it ...
              The operational situation at the checkpoint has always been, and if it is not there - "the key to the start"
            2. Nikon OConor
              Nikon OConor 27 March 2021 19: 04
              +2
              You involved do not know the response system? Regiment + regiment + all regiments - then division headquarters, then army headquarters ... if not, then launches
            3. Nikon OConor
              Nikon OConor 27 March 2021 19: 16
              +1
              I myself sat underground on duty at one time in another system, and if something happened, then the first thing to do was to shut down the metal doors using an electric drive - even if it was an element of the teachings. In addition, the seismic sensors were located around the perimeter, so that we did not know anything yet, having received a signal from them, we automatically battened down one single entrance.

              It was you who battened down and waited ... and I personally was in the RAP during the exercises (calculation of the autonomous launch).
              In the absence of a signal from the command post of the division headquarters or the command post of the regiment, we climbed out of the bunkers, (with tools and in the OZK) got into the transport and went to the launcher (1 sergeant, 1-2 soldiers and a junior officer). The officer would open the required hatch and use the tools to launch, and we guarded the approaches in the directions. It is clear that during a combat launch, both the officer in the mine and the soldiers on the outskirts were burned alive ...
              1. ccsr
                ccsr 27 March 2021 22: 27
                -2
                Quote: Nikon OConor
                It was you who battened down and waited ... and I personally was in the RAP during the exercises (calculation of the autonomous launch).

                So we had to determine whether to give you a command to start or not by a number of signs - so you were only performers, and we worked at a slightly different level.
                Quote: Nikon OConor
                It is clear that during a combat launch, both the officer in the mine and the soldiers on the outskirts were burned alive ...

                This is something new - did you accidentally come up with it? Or have you already had such cases?
                1. Nikon OConor
                  Nikon OConor 28 March 2021 19: 58
                  +1
                  See for yourself: when the "Voevoda" is launched, all living things within a radius of 150-200 meters burn out. The RAP is located 25-40 meters from the launcher in 4 (or especially dangerous) directions. An officer in the mine manually launches. Who will remain alive? Probably those who "had to determine whether to give you a start command or not by a number of signs." It is strange that with such tolerances you do not know about the RAP. Although everyone has their own nuances - "every soldier should know YOUR maneuver" Something like this ...
                  1. ccsr
                    ccsr 28 March 2021 20: 44
                    -1
                    Quote: Nikon OConor
                    See for yourself: when the "Voevoda" is launched, all living things within a radius of 150-200 meters burn out. The RAP is located 25-40 meters from the launcher in 4 (or especially dangerous) directions.

                    I do not know who you have and what was planning, but as far as I understand, you want to prove that you were all insane there, since you did not foresee the consequences of the launch.
                    Quote: Nikon OConor
                    An officer in the mine manually launches. Who will remain alive?

                    He is not alone there, so I do not believe that the safety of the personnel was not taken care of.
                    Quote: Nikon OConor
                    It is strange that with such tolerances you do not know about the RAP.

                    I don't know - I had enough of my tasks on duty, where, by the way, we had direct channels with the "Guardsman", so why do I need your problems.
                    Quote: Nikon OConor
                    Although everyone has their own nuances - "every soldier should know YOUR maneuver" Something like this ...

                    I completely agree with this.
                    1. Nikon OConor
                      Nikon OConor 28 March 2021 21: 02
                      0
                      I do not know who you have and what was planning, but as far as I understand, you want to prove that you were all insane there, since you did not foresee the consequences of the launch.

                      My fault is that I did not explain the purpose of the RAP.
                      In their own words: The Autonomous Launch Calculation has the task of manually launching an ICBM if it is not possible to launch a regiment / division from a command post.
                      Those. Command posts have been destroyed, communication lines have been cut off and / or are under the control of the enemy's DRG. Then (the situation is full of seams) the RAP leaves as the last chance to start. It is envisaged that the area around is already full or partial radiation contamination. And yes, we were taught that the RAP are suicide bombers.
                    2. ccsr
                      ccsr 28 March 2021 21: 30
                      0
                      Quote: Nikon OConor
                      In their own words: The Autonomous Launch Calculation has the task of manually launching an ICBM if it is not possible to launch a regiment / division from a command post.

                      I don’t believe that it could have come to this - the GRU General Staff knew how to monitor the situation, and you would have had time to launch normally.
                      Quote: Nikon OConor
                      Those. Command posts have been destroyed, communication lines have been cut off and / or are under the control of the enemy's DRG.

                      You were so intimidated because it is all unreal.
                      Quote: Nikon OConor
                      And yes, we were taught that the RAP are suicide bombers.

                      It was not only in the Strategic Missile Forces - the submariners were in no way in the best conditions.
                      Quote: Nikon OConor
                      There is no one in the Rocket Mine, there are people there once a year during maintenance.

                      This is natural, but the calculation should be nearby in a protected, recessed room, as I understand it, and probably they have a common pattern. However, I do not presume to assert this, but we had this between the objects.
                    3. Nikon OConor
                      Nikon OConor 28 March 2021 21: 41
                      0
                      I don’t believe that it could have come to this - the GRU General Staff knew how to monitor the situation, and you would have had time to launch normally.

                      In the exercises, it was the DRG General Staff of the GRU who spoke against our PDRGs. The ratio of 1 GRU fighter against our 3 was losing the exercise. If there are fewer of ours (in open combat), we lost. But if a DRG fighter hung a ribbon on the grid of the 1st warning fence, it was considered that the launcher was captured by the enemy.
                      You were so intimidated because it is all unreal.

                      This is not intimidation, but normal combat training.
                      It was not only in the Strategic Missile Forces - the submariners were in no way in the best conditions.

                      I agree that our army does not serve for money, but protects the Motherland.
                      This is natural, but the calculation should be nearby in a protected, recessed room, as I understand it, and probably they have a common pattern. However, I do not presume to assert this, but we had this between the objects.

                      Near the missile silo there is a small concrete house with a turret machine-gun mount instead of a roof, where the calculation of the guard lives for a week, without an exit ... patern, as you said. This calculation has the task of informing the command post of the attack and holding out until the approach of heavy cavalry.
                      The calculation has no physical access to the mine ...
                2. Nikon OConor
                  Nikon OConor 28 March 2021 21: 05
                  0
                  He is not alone there, so I do not believe that the safety of the personnel was not taken care of.

                  There is no one in the Rocket Mine, people come there once a year during maintenance. And with a manual launch, the officer goes down there alone, while the soldiers and the sergeant are guarding the launcher at this time. The task is to hold out for 5 minutes - to make the launch.
                  You may not know, but the combat task of the guard on the launcher is to hold out for 10-15 minutes for the approach of calculating the gain, then you can die ...
  • Sidor Amenpodestovich
    Sidor Amenpodestovich 27 March 2021 11: 27
    +5
    Quote: paul3390
    And what - does anyone really believe that Putin will press the button?

    NATO, it turns out, believes, since it does not attack. Or is he not attacking for some other reason?
    1. paul3390
      paul3390 27 March 2021 11: 33
      -5
      What for?? What will it achieve, what will it get? Raw materials and resources - so they are successfully exported to them in exchange for candy wrappers .. Eliminate a competitor? So our bourgeoisie and so very successfully carried out a total de-industrialization of the country .. To acquire money? So they all have them. Eliminate the threat? Duc Putin is not a threat to them anyway. Why would they attack us? Meaning?
      1. Sidor Amenpodestovich
        Sidor Amenpodestovich 27 March 2021 11: 39
        +5
        Quote: paul3390
        Raw materials and resources - so they are successfully exported to them in exchange for candy wrappers .. Eliminate a competitor? So our bourgeoisie and so very successfully carried out a total de-industrialization of the country ..

        I want to remind you that we are talking about Russia, not about Ukraine.
        1. paul3390
          paul3390 27 March 2021 11: 50
          -7
          And - what? What a hell of a difference? If we didn't have oil and gas left over from Soviet times, everything would have been in Russia like in Tsegabonia .. And so - about the same, well - maybe a little better. Education with medicine is completely out, the people are in poverty, there is practically no production of goods, there is only one import everywhere, but what can you describe there - you yourself know everything, but for some reason you turn on the blonde. Once again, we just got a very large piece of the great Soviet legacy at the start. Which even highly effective Putin managers with the owners have not yet been able to screw up. That is why we are still somehow alive ...
          1. Sidor Amenpodestovich
            Sidor Amenpodestovich 27 March 2021 12: 05
            +1
            Quote: paul3390
            Education with medicine is completely out, the people are in poverty, there is practically no production of goods, there is only one import everywhere,

            This time you are about the United States.
            But we're talking about Russia.
            What kind of confusion and vacillation?
          2. Nikon OConor
            Nikon OConor 28 March 2021 20: 06
            +1
            Neighing:
            We would not have oil and gas left over from Soviet times

            For the special: Oil with gas is formed in the bowels for hundreds of millions of years.
            Tyrannosaurus comrade Stalin: Comrades !!! During the five-year plan, it is necessary to destroy billions of tons of organic matter and store them in different places so that our descendants have oil and gas! Execute comrades!
        2. Cosm22
          Cosm22 27 March 2021 12: 20
          -4
          It is about Russia that we are talking about.
          It is from Russia that resources and raw materials are exported in exchange for candy wrappers.
          Can you object to this? Evidence?
          1. Achilles
            Achilles 27 March 2021 13: 15
            +4
            Quote: Cosm22
            It is about Russia that we are talking about.
            It is from Russia that resources and raw materials are exported in exchange for candy wrappers.
            Can you object to this? Evidence?

            Do you even understand what you wrote?
            These candy wrappers, the budget is replenished, these candy wrappers and the military budget is replenished and new weapons are being developed. The whole world trades with each other in resources and raw materials, and who and the final product, all for the sake of these candy wrappers as you put it
            1. Lannan Shi
              Lannan Shi 27 March 2021 13: 38
              -2
              Quote: Achilles
              The whole world trades with each other in resources and raw materials, and who and the final product, all for the sake of these candy wrappers as you put it

              Um ... Do you really believe that NATO cannot, for example, bomb the United Arab Emirates and the Saudis in the Stone Age, evict them into the desert and calmly pump the same oil? Which there, for your information, is much more than ours, and which, again, is cheaper than ours. Iiii? Why are they not encroaching on Arab oil, but are going to climb into Siberia, where, in addition to oil, you can also dig up ICBMs?
              But in fact, everything is extremely simple. The fact that classical colonialism is less effective than the neocolonial system, and that to give the Papuan, be it African or Siberian, a hundred or thousand of installation passwords from windows, in exchange for an oil tanker, is much more profitable than driving this Papuan with tanks and helicopters, smart people understood half a century ago. yes And the tales about how evil capitalists with buckets and jugs for our oil sneak ... They are very convenient for the Papuan leaders, who are quite satisfied with the situation of the sale of their homeland, for admission to the bourgeois nishtyaks. yes
              1. Achilles
                Achilles 27 March 2021 16: 27
                +4
                Quote: Lannan Shi
                Um ... Do you really believe that NATO cannot, for example, bomb the United Arab Emirates and the Saudis in the Stone Age, evict them into the desert and calmly pump the same oil? Which there, for your information, is much more than ours, and which, again, is cheaper than ours. Iiii?

                Where did you get the idea that I believe in something? They talked about resources and raw materials that Russia sells for foreign currency, and some of the leaders here in VO consider this a very bad act of Russia. I just wrote, firstly, the whole world does it, and secondly, that it replenishes our budget, completely resulting in further payments in different directions.
            2. paul3390
              paul3390 27 March 2021 15: 56
              -5
              That is - you are seriously postulating that we are able to arm the army exclusively for dollars ??? belay
              1. Achilles
                Achilles 27 March 2021 16: 40
                +5
                Quote: paul3390
                That is - you are seriously postulating that we are able to arm the army exclusively for dollars ???

                What makes you think that I think so? Money comes to the budget of our country from different directions, where it is then distributed in different directions, including the defense industry. Remember the days when oil was worth more than $ 100? At that time, our military budget was twice as large, and during this period of time, large monetary resources began to be injected into the development of new weapons. And this does not mean that our defense industry is solely on dollars, it is one of the sources of replenishing the budget.
      2. qQQQ
        qQQQ 27 March 2021 13: 12
        -2
        Quote: paul3390
        What for?? What will it achieve, what will it get? Raw materials and resources - so they are successfully exported to them in exchange for candy wrappers .. Eliminate a competitor? So our bourgeoisie and so very successfully carried out a total de-industrialization of the country .. To acquire money? So they all have them. Eliminate the threat? Duc Putin is not a threat to them anyway. Why would they attack us? Meaning?

        You make schoolchildren think, and this is not tolerant, even more so - inhuman.
        1. evgen1221
          evgen1221 27 March 2021 15: 41
          -1
          And it goes against the policy of the party.))))
  • RealPilot
    RealPilot 27 March 2021 12: 15
    +7
    Professor Dmitry Gennadievich Evstafiev is a completely sane person. Until now, I have not been noticed in carrying nonsense, I am familiar with his rhetoric on radio (!) Programs, where, unlike television, they are more restrained and reasoned. He introduced an interesting course of action into public discourse that is worth considering.

    To some, his proposal may seem too radical, but it takes place as a kind of last safety valve, like a warning shot into the air.
    Not now, but if you suddenly need no alternative, then this is a powerful move!

    And it is necessary to prepare the population for this scenario, to hear public opinion. From this and the statement on the air of the federal TV channel.
    Well, and send a "signal", as they say all the time, to our "partners" ...
  • vlad.baryatinsky
    vlad.baryatinsky 27 March 2021 15: 35
    -6
    Hello !
    Quote: Mark Kalendarov
    The direction is correct

    Wrong!
    Your resume, you do not want to revive the arms race! ???
    I dare to remind you that WE are not in that position.
    Unless you personally can increase the military budget of the Russian Federation with your income.
    Quote: Mark Kalendarov
    This world only respects strength

    Before "saber", you need to have this "power".
    Over the past year, only in Moscow and the Moscow Region, the hole in the budget was RUB 1trl. (!)
    And what is going on outside the Moscow Ring Road ???
    Your "idol" is certainly comfortable.
    He, together with Nightingale and Co., is lured by Power.
  • atakan
    atakan 27 March 2021 16: 33
    -3
    Professor at the Higher School of Economics, political scientist

    You don't have to read further, although the idea is interesting.
  • iouris
    iouris 28 March 2021 12: 37
    0
    How else can you confirm the presence of nuclear weapons?
  • rocket757
    rocket757 27 March 2021 10: 45
    +1
    In this situation (...) we must

    And NATO will see ... the exercises are going !!!
    The striped whales are warned, and the gayropeans have a reason to think, because the striped whales will easily throw / push THEM, anywhere, in the performance of their "great ... wishes"!
    1. cniza
      cniza 27 March 2021 11: 30
      +1
      Explosions, not explosions, but it is necessary to resolve the issue somehow, they will become impudent until you spoil it ...

      Good day! hi
      1. hydrox
        hydrox 27 March 2021 11: 57
        -1
        The only question is WHERE to dig a hole so that its appearance would really have an effect on NATO members - and they already know that we can do it.
        Maybe he can help the Sultan in this, he has long wanted to break through the oncoming traffic through Ankara in addition to the Bosphorus ... It would be necessary for someone to talk to the Sultan on this topic - we have experience in such digging, at one time they dug something similar in Central Asia ...
        1. cniza
          cniza 27 March 2021 12: 02
          +1
          This is a difficult question, but they need to be reminded, otherwise many have already lost their fear ...
          1. rocket757
            rocket757 27 March 2021 12: 31
            +3
            The loaves are strong for a long time. New ones are being developed, but in real life they are not tested, only computer modeling ... this is also possible, BUT .... a real test, puts all the dots on it, this is the reality.
            1. cniza
              cniza 27 March 2021 12: 37
              +1
              Real tests are very dangerous and expensive ...
              1. rocket757
                rocket757 27 March 2021 12: 49
                +4
                When it comes to the security of the country, any costs are acceptable !!!
                Nuclear loaves are dangerous in general, even when they are in storage, tests are no more dangerous, with proper preparation.
                1. cniza
                  cniza 27 March 2021 16: 09
                  +1
                  Quote: rocket757
                  When it comes to the security of the country, any costs are acceptable !!!


                  You can't argue with that, I think experts are trying to take everything into account ...
            2. hydrox
              hydrox 27 March 2021 13: 53
              +1
              Mat. modeling is, of course, a good thing, but more for development, only testing by testing gives a reliable result, only now we are talking about the military-political interpretation of the PHYSICAL state of the language.
              This is about the same effect as drunkenness - banging your fist on the table - and the table in half! laughing
              1. rocket757
                rocket757 27 March 2021 14: 24
                0
                There are politicians, they have big heads, let them think about what can be done, how to do it and how to present it to "our partners."
                By the way, sometimes an action is not necessary to carry out, it is enough to outline it, designate and warn that under certain circumstances, it will be implemented, BY PLAN!
          2. Terenin
            Terenin 27 March 2021 14: 29
            +2
            Quote: cniza
            This is a difficult question, but they need to be reminded, otherwise many have already lost their fear ...

            Shadarakhnem necessarily, and more than once, the whole world in dust, but then ...

            Hi hi
            1. cniza
              cniza 27 March 2021 16: 12
              +3
              hi

              It is not better to demonstrate, and then let them think what will happen ...
      2. rocket757
        rocket757 27 March 2021 12: 27
        +1
        Welcome soldier
        Unfortunately, this is no longer just arrogance, it is an impact / pressure strategy.
        You just can't stand it .... you have to hit back.
        1. cniza
          cniza 27 March 2021 12: 36
          +3
          So we are just scratching our turnips and expressing concern, they only get even more impudent from this ...
          1. rocket757
            rocket757 27 March 2021 12: 47
            0
            Not everything is so simple, but, on a global scale, we alone cannot resist always and everywhere.
            1. cniza
              cniza 27 March 2021 16: 06
              +4
              Do we have a choice? who is with us? , China he is just a fellow traveler and then ...
              1. rocket757
                rocket757 27 March 2021 16: 47
                +1
                In light of recent events, China is the most relevant, most serious travel companion. How long can our joint journey last .... we'll see.
                1. cniza
                  cniza 27 March 2021 17: 26
                  +3
                  And we need to use it 100% ...
                  1. rocket757
                    rocket757 27 March 2021 18: 19
                    +1
                    If the sultan, the fellow traveler, is very conditional ... then China is serious and for a long time.
                    1. cniza
                      cniza 27 March 2021 19: 05
                      +3
                      Let's hope that for a long time, our "partners" are doing everything for this ...
                      1. rocket757
                        rocket757 27 March 2021 19: 25
                        +1
                        Yes, the minke whales drove over this time, as an adult and, it seems, are not going to stop.
                        Boom to see.
                      2. cniza
                        cniza 27 March 2021 21: 12
                        +2
                        They work for us for free ... lol
  • Hwostatij
    Hwostatij 27 March 2021 10: 45
    +2
    Why waste time on trifles, let's just to intimidate some Switzerland from the globe at once
    1. Nikon OConor
      Nikon OConor 27 March 2021 11: 08
      +6
      why did the climbers not please you?)) There are many other interesting places on the ball, especially in Geurope))
      1. Hwostatij
        Hwostatij 27 March 2021 11: 22
        +3
        Actually, it was sarcasm.
        1. Nikon OConor
          Nikon OConor 27 March 2021 11: 27
          +3
          as I understand it) just a strange choice of target for a visitor VO))
          Best regards hi
          1. Hwostatij
            Hwostatij 27 March 2021 13: 20
            0
            And what, in your opinion, should have been chosen by a faithful visitor to VO?)
            1. Nikon OConor
              Nikon OConor 27 March 2021 14: 53
              +3
              Nuuu .... tribalism (VNAU, Poland) is corny and bad for us, I respect the Germans more than the whole of Europe together, France .... and that France is so neutral)). Oo islands !!! They are certainly not Europe, as it were, but why is it not a goal for a faithful visitor?))
              1. Hwostatij
                Hwostatij 27 March 2021 15: 53
                +1
                Well, why do we need radioactive zombies in Siberia). You need to look at the problem more broadly and think more globally))
                1. Nikon OConor
                  Nikon OConor 27 March 2021 17: 17
                  +2
                  radioactive zombies are moving from the northern sea through the arctic route to Siberia.
                  Pancake! this is the plot of a new blockbuster!)) drinks
                  1. VORON538
                    VORON538 28 March 2021 10: 08
                    0
                    If the islands are Japanese, then no zombies in Siberia :))) And the question with their grief about the "northern territories" will be closed for them completely :)))
        2. Nikon OConor
          Nikon OConor 27 March 2021 11: 29
          0
          What is it threw you minuses?)) Liberals woke up?
    2. The comment was deleted.
  • krops777
    krops777 27 March 2021 10: 45
    -2
    Since the United States does not accept methods of persuasion other than forceful methods in order to "cool the hotheads in the West," Yevstafiev suggests "to slow down their pace, to bring down their breath." To do this, Russia needs to temporarily withdraw from the Nuclear Test Ban Treaty and conduct a series of nuclear explosions, combining them with any major NATO exercises.


    I support it unequivocally, the USSR at one time regularly conducted tests, cooled hot heads well.
    1. Troll
      Troll 27 March 2021 11: 11
      +2
      Carried out. But I did it only until the signing of the contract. After, not once.
  • Well done
    Well done 27 March 2021 10: 46
    +3
    Radically, but he is partly right. The "partners" began to forget what "Kuz'kina's mother" is. The whole world is in dust?) Nafig need?
    1. prior
      prior 27 March 2021 11: 33
      +3
      They want to destroy us, but we are ashamed to show "Kuzka's mother" ?! belay
      It's not democratic angry
  • Dimka75
    Dimka75 27 March 2021 10: 47
    +5
    carry out a series of nuclear explosions

    and this professor at the Higher School of Economics did not add - WHERE was he going to bang?
    Semipalatinsk in Kazakhstan, if that
    1. WHAT IS
      WHAT IS 27 March 2021 10: 54
      +9
      This professor at the Higher School of Economics needs to cool his head himself. These HSE professors have already advised them in economics, now they are still climbing into politics. In a mansion on his personal plot, let him carry out a series of 20-25 demonstration nuclear explosions.
    2. Vol4ara
      Vol4ara 27 March 2021 11: 00
      +5
      Quote: Dimka75
      carry out a series of nuclear explosions

      and this professor at the Higher School of Economics did not add - WHERE was he going to bang?
      Semipalatinsk in Kazakhstan, if that

      The new land
      1. Dimka75
        Dimka75 27 March 2021 11: 03
        -3
        Of course, the Totsk polygon is the same
        Can repeat
        And again in a circle
        1. Nikon OConor
          Nikon OConor 27 March 2021 11: 42
          +6
          Fuck the Totsky training ground, we are here in the Orenburg region and we live so normally, we can do without demonstrations. On the new land, or better in Greenland, no one needs it except the states))
      2. prior
        prior 27 March 2021 11: 29
        +1
        Why shit on your territory - there are enough strangers.
        A reason to organize like two fingers ... wassat
    3. Runway
      Runway 27 March 2021 11: 00
      +2
      This is the category of "political workers".
    4. Klingon
      Klingon 27 March 2021 11: 05
      +2
      probably New Earth meant. So that Norgam immediately gets hot wassat
    5. Nikon OConor
      Nikon OConor 27 March 2021 11: 12
      +2
      why do Kazakhs again?)) the new land seems to be closer to the Eurogeys, it will be more useful
    6. Paragraph Epitafievich Y.
      Paragraph Epitafievich Y. 27 March 2021 11: 20
      -5
      Quote: Dimka75
      Semipalatinsk in Kazakhstan, if that

      And Novaya Zemlya?))
      In general, it is strange that Shorty Shapiro invited a teacher from the Higher School of Economics to his propaganda sabbath. As far as I know, this office of the Putinists does not shake hands. It is clear that such populist crap will find a warm response from the people. Still, not all Kuz'kin mothers were shown to the foe laughing
    7. bk0010
      bk0010 27 March 2021 19: 45
      -1
      Quote: Dimka75
      and this professor at the Higher School of Economics did not add - WHERE was he going to bang?
      Semipalatinsk in Kazakhstan, if that
      I remember that somewhere near Las Vegas there was a suitable training ground. And in Nevada.
  • iouris
    iouris 27 March 2021 10: 50
    -3
    Finally, at least someone supported me on this issue. Less than three years have passed. But if this business is progressing at such a pace, then the question will disappear by itself.
  • Tank jacket
    Tank jacket 27 March 2021 11: 02
    +1
    The professor reminded me of someone bad ... And stupid ... Ah, for sure ... - a provocateur goat wink
    Let's kind of confirm that Russians are maniacs. Crazy rushenz internationally negative
    And we will become like "partners" who, as Lavrov said, have forgotten about diplomacy ...
    1. iouris
      iouris 27 March 2021 11: 20
      -6
      When you become a professor, then you will be able to enter into a discussion on an equal footing with a professor who has been dealing with these issues all his life and is a recognized expert.
      But I am sure that you are not in danger of being accepted into the scientific community.
      1. Tank jacket
        Tank jacket 27 March 2021 11: 27
        +3
        Put it on the shelves or figure it out yourself?
        Please read carefully how super systems are managed.
    2. Paragraph Epitafievich Y.
      Paragraph Epitafievich Y. 27 March 2021 11: 25
      -1
      Quote: Tank jacket
      Let's kind of confirm that Russians are maniacs.

      So he's from the Higher School of Economics. Local uryakly applaud the populist proposal to "bang", but they do not see beyond this nose.
      1. Tank jacket
        Tank jacket 27 March 2021 11: 31
        -2
        Quote: Paragraph Epitafievich Y.
        Quote: Tank jacket
        Let's kind of confirm that Russians are maniacs.

        So he's from the Higher School of Economics. Local uryakly applaud the populist proposal to "bang", but they do not see beyond this nose.

        Study, study and study again ... (c)
        Plus for you ... hi
  • Klingon
    Klingon 27 March 2021 11: 03
    0
    Quote: Hwostatij
    Why waste time on trifles, let's just to intimidate some Switzerland from the globe at once

    no need to touch Switzerland, it is at least beautiful there, and Suvorov would be offended (by the way, a monument to him still stands in Andermatt along with the Russian flag), but some kind of Ivano-Frankivsk could be exponentially cut
    1. Dimka75
      Dimka75 27 March 2021 11: 10
      -1
      ) but some kind of Ivano-Frankivsk could be exponentially cut

      you definitely need to become a professor at the Higher School of Economics
      1. Klingon
        Klingon 27 March 2021 11: 11
        +1
        and then! let's get a diploma wassat good
    2. Paragraph Epitafievich Y.
      Paragraph Epitafievich Y. 27 March 2021 11: 36
      -1
      Quote: Klingon
      could be revealingly cut

      What, did you not cut with a jigsaw as a child?
      1. Klingon
        Klingon 27 March 2021 13: 03
        -1
        Yes, in general, a paragraph is going on wassat
    3. Military77
      Military77 27 March 2021 11: 54
      +4
      What for? We have not signed a peace treaty with the Yapas, you can send them a gift, straight to the symbol of the country, to the crater of Fujiyama. At the same time, we will resolve the issue with the Kuriles, and if they are against, we will repeat it until they become "for"
  • Flashpoint
    Flashpoint 27 March 2021 11: 06
    +2
    Overkill. It resembles a little girl who falls on someone's castle in the sandbox from resentment. It is necessary to show strength more gracefully.
  • Igor Viktorov
    Igor Viktorov 27 March 2021 11: 06
    0
    There is an atomic test site on Novaya Zemlya. It is designed for such tests; there is a military unit that monitors this test site. Just right to bang with a hydrogen bomb.
  • arhitroll
    arhitroll 27 March 2021 11: 08
    0
    I am for. Of course, it is desirable that the petrel fly around the planet for a couple of months, but you can also bang (naturally experiencing something). Because the nuclear is our last hope - people -0,5 million a year - here either the Crimea every 6 years is attached, or the red line is carried out, otherwise a bribe ...
  • Troll
    Troll 27 March 2021 11: 09
    -5
    Wrong. Russia is not the kind of gentleman who scatters words and takes back his words according to his mood.
    No "temporary". Either quit altogether or not quit. Took to carry the burden - carry it.
    1. Nikon OConor
      Nikon OConor 27 March 2021 11: 47
      +5
      well, carry it ... and those passing by will spit in your back. Sometimes you need to throw the bag, silently turn around and kick in the face, then you can lift the load and silently carry on.
  • xorek
    xorek 27 March 2021 11: 16
    -3
    "Knock down NATO's breathing" by temporarily withdrawing from the Nuclear Test Ban Treaty and conducting a series of nuclear explosions, suggested a professor at the Higher School of Economics

    I don't believe this from the Higher School of Economics, there is a "hornet's nest of the State Department" ..
    They obviously want to frame Russia! We are working in the same mode.
    1. iouris
      iouris 27 March 2021 11: 33
      -3
      Quote: xorek
      They obviously want to frame Russia!

      What do you mean? That the Russian Federation is not a great power?
      The United States long ago withdrew from all agreements with the USSR that were holding them back.
      1. xorek
        xorek 27 March 2021 11: 56
        -3
        Quote: iouris
        What do you mean? That the Russian Federation is not a great power?

        No, but the authorities are too patient for all these provocations
        Quote: iouris
        The United States long ago withdrew from all agreements with the USSR that were holding them back.

        This is too provocative a statement, especially from the Higher School of Economics (they have no time to deal with economics and have gotten into geopolitics))) .. It has long been known who settled there .. I would understand if this statement from the Russian Ministry of Defense had been said!
        And so everything is clear ... hi
        1. iouris
          iouris 27 March 2021 12: 20
          -1
          And who "sat down" in the MO? From there, no one will say anything for sure on this issue. "Metal wars" are being waged there. Do you know what this is?
          1. xorek
            xorek 27 March 2021 12: 59
            -2
            Quote: iouris
            And who "sat down" in the MO? From there, no one will say anything for sure on this issue. "Metal wars" are being waged there. Do you know what this is?

            Yes I know ! Why are you so excited .. HSE does not touch anyone yet, let him say
            It’s just worth thinking that they have imagined themselves there, that they are already dictating what to do to the Russian Defense Ministry and our Head of State .. And this is not the first time!
            1. iouris
              iouris 27 March 2021 15: 28
              0
              I have known Evstafiev for a long time from his performances. Explain what does HSE have to do with it? Who is "turned on"?
              There is a principle: flies - separately, cutlets - separately. Otherwise, great harm will be done to health.
  • Viktor Sergeev
    Viktor Sergeev 27 March 2021 11: 18
    +3
    Yeah, to spend several tens of millions of dollars just for what ... in general, it is not clear why. I would blow the brain of this political scientist, so that he would not carry nonsense.
    1. hydrox
      hydrox 27 March 2021 12: 16
      -1
      So storage and separation of this Pu is more expensive for us than it is once dirty.
      bang ...
      There the NATO members bombed Belgrade powerfully with inactive uranium bombs - 400 children alone. died ...
      1. Viktor Sergeev
        Viktor Sergeev 27 March 2021 17: 46
        0
        Dirty? It is forbidden, and it is useless to pollute your territory.
    2. iouris
      iouris 27 March 2021 16: 10
      +1
      Quote: Victor Sergeev
      I would blow this political scientist's brain

      Tell me what it's like to live without a brain?
      1. Viktor Sergeev
        Viktor Sergeev 27 March 2021 17: 45
        0
        And why do you need it, don't you have enough experience? But especially for you, as soon as I find a second person like you, I will definitely ask him and give him to you.
  • Knell wardenheart
    Knell wardenheart 27 March 2021 11: 20
    +7
    For our hike from the neighboring country, they brought us "international experts".
    Who do we want to scare there? The EU, with the world's top combined economy, buying our resources? The United States, the top not the aggregate economy of the planet and a country ten times superior to us in defense spending (for decades), navy, aviation, the number and quality of allies? Maybe we want to scare Japan, a country that is 45 times smaller than ours and at the same time whose GDP is 30% more than ours?
    Here some rednecks are flaunting with an overused phrase like "in the world they only respect strength" - in the world, gentlemen, they respect Wealth, Success And Strength. And when all and sundry are scrambling out of the country, and on the streets people in uniforms disperse teenagers and pensioners with clubs, and every single day amusing stories about the billion-ten-billion dollar theft of officials and just some kind of muddy dudes - and this has not impressed anyone for a long time, no , such a country will not be "respected", even if we blow up the Tsar Bomb again, even if we do it on the Moon, the harp is vigorous!
    1. mark1
      mark1 27 March 2021 13: 58
      +1
      And there is no need to respect - fear comes immediately, and respect comes gradually. Now we have enough fear (preferably an animal) and we will work on respect on a regular basis, - we will abandon competitions under the white flag, from humiliation in the Council of Europe (etc. to the horizon), we will learn to respect our country ourselves (most importantly, in including for you).
      1. Knell wardenheart
        Knell wardenheart 27 March 2021 15: 00
        -1
        Somehow you overlooked an interesting alternative for the West for the Fear & Respect that you are writing about. The West simply quietly trod the paths of the civilized world bypassing us. It sounds sad, but the world can do without us, our share in the world economy is about 3%, our market is not comparable in attractiveness to the markets of half of Asia and all countries of the "golden billion" without exception. The world has long been accustomed to our rumbling of the lid, as it is accustomed to the rumbling of the lid from the DPRK or Ukraine. Already twice before the eyes of the calm, progressively developing West, our country was falling apart, just yesterday radiating pathos and indicative potency - there they are already accustomed to the fact that we will brown and brown and once again sour like fermented baked milk.
        And by the way - why "respect your country"? Well, objectively, removing the lyrical strata aside. Over the last century, all our epic attempts only widened the gap between us and the West ... in favor of the West, of course. It got to the point that in Asia, rogue and eternally hungry 80 years ago, people ALREADY live better than us - the Chinese average and minimum salary exceeded ours, there is nothing to say about Korean / Japanese. What have we been doing for a hundred years so fucking efficiently that we now see this gap? Oh yes, we were building the future for people, for a person, a country where it would be free to breathe and live well. And why, did we build it? Not. Not once, not a second time. Even close. And now we continue to fool the ears of these beggars, most of the people, and they continue to eat it and believe that we are the coolest - in terms of nuclear weapons per capita. Why love our country - because you, as a citizen of the Russian Federation, own a twenty centimeter soil layer under your private property? Maybe because your retirement age is growing in parallel with the growth of the wealth of our billionaires and palaces? Probably, our country should be respected for the fact that in the News for 10 minutes they are begging for the treatment of children abroad - but of course we will sing deferamba to domestic medicine, biology and genetics. Can we have a cool life expectancy? Not. Maybe a human development index? And again, no - we have long and habitually wiped their feet on people with their heads and hands. Maybe we have a better education? And again, no - Moscow State University was not included in the Top 100 universities of the planet. Why love us - for our history? The very story in which we gnawed a window to Europe with an army of slaves who eventually fell into pitiful crumbs from the master's table? For the fact that we were preparing so powerfully and efficiently for the Second World War that in the first months we lost millions of prisoners in defense and tens of thousands of destroyed and abandoned equipment? Our science is perhaps worth being proud of, and even then, the one that was "once there." Give me objective reasons to be proud, it will be interesting for me to listen!
        1. Light
          Light 27 March 2021 16: 53
          0
          Do not meddle with us, and no one will "rattle the lid".
        2. bk0010
          bk0010 27 March 2021 19: 56
          0
          Quote: Knell Wardenheart
          10 minutes of news are solicited for the treatment of children abroad
          This is a business. It is indirectly related to the treatment of children.
          Quote: Knell Wardenheart
          And again, no - Moscow State University was not included in the Top 100 universities of the planet.
          Who makes the rating, he decides who to include. And there is no need to cheat, you just need to correctly define the evaluation criteria.
          Quote: Knell Wardenheart
          For the fact that we were preparing so powerfully and efficiently for the Second World War, that in the first months we lost millions of prisoners in defense and tens of thousands of destroyed and abandoned equipment?
          Wow, here is France - yes, she is prepared. And England! Already Dunkirk turned out. Not that we ...
          1. Knell wardenheart
            Knell wardenheart 27 March 2021 21: 11
            0
            It's not about France or England - it's about this country in which colossal resources were thrown into the defense and society was pressed for years by its readiness for war with the entire mass of the world bourgeoisie. As a result, we barely pulled one Germany. Well, yes, okay, in alliance with such titans of the ring as Finland, Romania, Hungary. After the war, 20 years later, life in the Federal Republic of Germany was already better than ours, and 40 years later, better, and 60 years later. That's what I mean - our whole history is saturated with a mass of heroic efforts of a very specific orientation, but we take any moment and find that the fruit of these efforts was pathos and trash for the most part. Defeats didn’t make us smarter, victories didn’t make us richer, efforts didn’t create conditions in which tomorrow we would need less efforts, and a good scientific or industrial school both came and left us, constantly feeding foreign countries with ideas. We are the builders of the tower of Babel.
  • Alien From
    Alien From 27 March 2021 11: 20
    0
    Here, like in a movie "maybe bang, the whole world is in dust? We will bang for sure! But then ..." "
  • Free wind
    Free wind 27 March 2021 11: 21
    +3
    Test this bomb in your apartment. Sit on it and test it.
  • Cool but not Igor
    Cool but not Igor 27 March 2021 11: 22
    +1
    This guy is some kind of provocateur to propose to conduct nuclear tests during a NATO exercise
  • Observer2014
    Observer2014 27 March 2021 11: 23
    -3
    The resumption of nuclear tests will be the last argument. Further there will be only a nuclear war. You can memorize these words. And even write them down. Although they immediately laughed at my vanging for many years. And after all, I "rode the nuclear theme" wink Well, now look at Russian politics in general. Has it straddled the nuclear topic? The nuclear topic is the only thing that modern Russia can declare to the whole world. We simply have no other arguments.
    1. BDRM 667
      BDRM 667 27 March 2021 11: 36
      +3
      Quote: Observer2014
      The resumption of nuclear tests will be the last argument. Further there will be only a nuclear war. You can memorize these words. And even write them down. Although they immediately laughed at my vanging for many years. And after all, I "rode the nuclear theme"

      Ridiculous yes Do you want your pretentious and pompous "vanging", in the common people - charlatanism, to pass off as a balanced and concentrated analysis?

      Who are you, another Nostradamus, with a confusion of katrans, each of which can be interpreted in thousands of variants?

      One thing is certain about you yes that you will not die of modesty yes
      1. Observer2014
        Observer2014 27 March 2021 11: 56
        -4
        And I'm not standing in line here for modesty. And I don't grovel for likes like you. But I clearly and clearly explain this or that political-military problem. I am no longer interested in likes. I am interested in the conclusion of this or that topic of the article. I am interested to find confirmation to my judgments. to my. And not to be interesting to the stupid crowd of like fans. And I love it when my own ideas and thoughts are confirmed.
      2. Nikon OConor
        Nikon OConor 27 March 2021 17: 35
        -3
        You want your pretentious and pompous "vanging", in the common people - charlatanism, pass it off as a balanced and concentrated analysis

        Whom do you consider common people here? We are the victorious people, the people are toilers, and not the common people
        Do you look like a deputy?
    2. evgen1221
      evgen1221 27 March 2021 11: 37
      0
      The usual behavior of ignorant power in Lower Volta with missiles.
    3. iouris
      iouris 27 March 2021 15: 30
      0
      After testing nuclear weapons, they had to negotiate with the USSR.
      1. Observer2014
        Observer2014 27 March 2021 15: 36
        -4
        Quote: iouris
        After testing nuclear weapons, they had to negotiate with the USSR.

        Yes. It happened with the USSR. But not with modern Russia. For these are completely different concepts, opportunities, power if you want .. Then and now.
  • cniza
    cniza 27 March 2021 11: 26
    +1
    To do this, Russia needs to temporarily withdraw from the Nuclear Test Ban Treaty and conduct a series of nuclear explosions, combining them with any major NATO exercises.


    There's something about it...
    1. hydrox
      hydrox 27 March 2021 12: 26
      0
      For a long time on Earth, nuclear radiation was not carried out, a whole generation has already lived without that, which did not feel a small disgusting trembling of organisms after the nuclear radiation.
      1. Avior
        Avior 27 March 2021 12: 48
        +1
        The last time nuclear tests were carried out in 2017
        Here is the test site with an asterisk
        1. hydrox
          hydrox 27 March 2021 13: 25
          0
          I doubt something because 100-200 KTn on Novaya Zemlya will bother someone ...
          1. Maikcg
            Maikcg 27 March 2021 18: 41
            +1
            When Kim banged ten times easier, there was a natural fire in a brothel.
            1. hydrox
              hydrox 27 March 2021 19: 48
              0
              Today they lost their Compass and they lost their shores, but the jokes are over and to play with bombs with the Russian Federation - this must be complete and clinical ...
      2. mark1
        mark1 27 March 2021 14: 03
        -1
        Quote: hydrox
        did not feel a small disgusting tremor of the organisms after the nuclear radiation.

        Not any tremors, neither small nor large, nor did anyone feel (well, maybe except you). A normal life was going on and the nuclear forces were a part of our life.
        1. hydrox
          hydrox 27 March 2021 14: 32
          0
          Or maybe you visited Kurchatov, but they forgot you there - it looks like you got out by self-propelled ...
          1. mark1
            mark1 27 March 2021 14: 42
            0
            And do not confuse the private with the general.
            P.S. Haven't been, but had a chance in the late 70s
  • Soldatov V.
    Soldatov V. 27 March 2021 11: 30
    +2
    In general, the HSE is opposed as an apologist for capitalism, and these statements of the professor are very interesting. What he offers is another not even latent denigration of Russia. All my life we ​​have been fighting for peace and here on you. We have not experienced explosions with America. But cool hot heads. In what way? These are launches of strategic missiles with training warheads. And not within our own territory. These are launches into the Atlantic through Europe, into the Indian Ocean, into the Pacific through Japan to the Bikini Atoll. It seems to me that there is no better tub of water.
  • SVD68
    SVD68 27 March 2021 11: 33
    +4
    There are ordinary fools. They will be born themselves.
    And there are specially trained fools. The latter are collected and trained at the HSE.
    On the merits of the question. A test for the sake of demonstration will tell only about the psychological unpreparedness of our leadership for the real use of nuclear weapons.
  • evgen1221
    evgen1221 27 March 2021 11: 35
    +1
    I agree, but only on his personal estate with all his relatives and family living on this territory for life and eating from this dirty territory. We can stop spoiling the earth, there is so little of it.
  • A. Privalov
    A. Privalov 27 March 2021 11: 57
    +4
    In one institution, where the sorrowful patients will be held back, the news spread: it turns out that there is a serious danger that a hairdresser will come and cut everyone's hair. For a long time the poor fellows there pondered how to avoid such a misfortune, and one of them suggested hammering nails into their heads. When the hairdresser comes and starts work, the scissors will break and everyone will be saved.
    They wrote about this in the local wall newspaper and hung a pencil on a string. Those who were against hammering in nails put a plus, and those who were for - a minus.
    Why not the other way around, sages !! ??, - shouted one part of the inmates there and put pluses. You yourself are crazy !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
  • pytar
    pytar 27 March 2021 12: 05
    0
    "Knock down NATO's breath": Russian political scientist proposed to conduct a series of nuclear tests

    There are many inadequacies. fellow
    1. iouris
      iouris 27 March 2021 15: 31
      0
      And even in Bulgaria? What are the names?
  • steelmaker
    steelmaker 27 March 2021 12: 08
    -2
    In Grudinin's program, in the first point, there is the nationalization of enterprises. And this for the USA and NATO is a hundred times cooler than nuclear tests. The political scientist can be seen in front of the program, his head was hit on the joint. His brains are in the wrong row!
    1. Maikcg
      Maikcg 27 March 2021 18: 39
      -1
      In the first paragraph, Grudinin has a fine of one billion rubles for fraud. It is not for him to write programs, but to Navalny's neighbors, two pair of boots.
  • Yaro Polk
    Yaro Polk 27 March 2021 12: 14
    -1
    It's a good idea, to blow up one more KUZKINA DAD, this time by 100 m / ton, so that these smelly NATO Russophobes remember how scary it is ...
  • Evil 55
    Evil 55 27 March 2021 12: 15
    0
    Even among the professors, you can find a rare idiot ..
  • iouris
    iouris 27 March 2021 12: 22
    -2
    The minority is sometimes right. Most are always wrong.
  • bar
    bar 27 March 2021 12: 30
    +3
    Political scientist Dmitry Yevstafiev, a professor at the Higher School of Economics, suggested “to knock down NATO's breath” by temporarily withdrawing from the Nuclear Test Ban Treaty and carrying out a series of nuclear explosions.

    These are the professors from the Higher School of Economics. sad
  • Victor Tsenin
    Victor Tsenin 27 March 2021 12: 36
    0
    Fabulous political scientist Evstafiev.
  • Thompson
    Thompson 27 March 2021 12: 54
    +1
    Quote: Insurgent
    What has always been the practice of holding such events ...

    Well, it will be the same here, plus a bonus to the exercises! I see no problem
  • Maks1995
    Maks1995 27 March 2021 12: 54
    0
    Wah.
    Plump. Smooth. Glossy.
    The "expert-political analysts" have a good life.
    Blah blah in the right direction for PR people, and no responsibility.
    You don't even need to know the hardware ...
  • Old man
    Old man 27 March 2021 12: 57
    0
    First, our authorities (and professors with political scientists, too) need to understand how Russia differs from the West and China ("The Concept of the Core and Periphery"), and only after that plan such actions.
    1. nznz
      nznz 27 March 2021 22: 34
      0
      what are you talking about? when it was necessary to project 700 from scratch, they decided quickly. The resettlement of the non-tsennts and that's it, they built what they needed and zhahnuli.
  • SIRIUS
    SIRIUS 27 March 2021 13: 48
    0
    It is high time to strike a preemptive blow !!!
    1. A_Mazkov
      A_Mazkov 27 March 2021 14: 47
      0
      Let's!
      Where?!)))
  • Grognag
    Grognag 27 March 2021 13: 52
    0
    Everything is correct, of course, and we will also return to the rods at school, a whip for those who think about people, you can stone prostitutes and burn a couple of liberals publicly on the square, so they will immediately understand everything in NATO, and in general, so that it is discouraging
  • A_Mazkov
    A_Mazkov 27 March 2021 14: 02
    0
    This "expert" expressed his "brilliant idea" on Solovyov's program, so we disagree)))
  • Zaurbek
    Zaurbek 27 March 2021 14: 21
    +1
    There is something in this ... but you need to approach it wisely
  • dgonni
    dgonni 27 March 2021 14: 47
    0
    Hmm. You can't be a little pregnant!
    Here or or.
    It is because of such stupid proposals that the sanctions will tighten the screws.
    Nobody thought about swift? Or does everyone already understand what is around the corner?
    And this is + 15% to the price of any contract.
    1. Maikcg
      Maikcg 27 March 2021 14: 55
      0
      Justify. Does Swift give a 15% discount for payments through itself?
      1. dgonni
        dgonni 27 March 2021 15: 02
        0
        Not! Its absence gives a markup of at least 15%, and this is godly!
        1. Maikcg
          Maikcg 27 March 2021 18: 30
          +1
          Explain where and with what finger did you pick out these 15%?
          Swift is such a karmic jade rod, which is smeared on by non-brothers, it will be disconnected from the swift and "the end of the rashka". Uh-huh. Well, they turned off Iran and? Have you stopped trading? Maybe you found 15% there? Maybe there will be problems in the regional bank of Nizhny Gadyukin, and even a teletype can be found in the head offices if you look well. Yes, the payment will be processed in 3 days (there will be no proofs, and up to 15, if the USSR remember when there was only a telephone with a telegraph) instead of 1 second with a hook through Belgium (and a bonus with logs to the NSA =)). A physical person with purchases on Ali will be sad, you can't argue, state trade generally sneezes, they can even bring cash with KAMAZ, no problem. And we will agree with Ali, the Chinese will connect the World to the transfer options and the payments will go at the same speed.
          1. bk0010
            bk0010 27 March 2021 19: 59
            +1
            Quote: MaikCG
            Yes, the payment will be processed in 3 days
            Much faster. They will decide everything through the main Internet channels, even there were trainings.
          2. nznz
            nznz 27 March 2021 22: 32
            0
            Well, Ali, too, will not sit. They are now already opening points of issue bypassing our mail .. speeds up delivery at times. They will come up with their own payment system ruble-yuan, well, there will be no ATMs in the EU, do not care, payments will go
          3. dgonni
            dgonni 28 March 2021 00: 41
            0
            Well, you basically described everything! Cash, 3 days for payment at a minimum. And the most important thing is that any deal can be closed under a microscope. And blocked!
            Therefore, 15% minimum increase in the price of payment.
            Iran is just one example.
            And they still couldn't agree on over for many years!
            1. Maikcg
              Maikcg 28 March 2021 00: 44
              0
              Will there be 15% proof? A reference to a contract, they say, so and so, in connection with your failure to connect, the Republic of Iran buys at a price of X + 15%. And sells at a price of X-15%.
              1. dgonni
                dgonni 28 March 2021 02: 17
                -1
                Contact your bankers. They will draw on your fingers!
                1. Maikcg
                  Maikcg 28 March 2021 06: 15
                  0
                  I suspected that you are from the same place this is the same.
        2. nznz
          nznz 27 March 2021 22: 27
          0
          and Swift is the only system? Of course, it is convenient to take money off at any ATM. But there is a world ... yes, there are fewer terminals, but with the coronavirus it is somehow not very relevant.
          1. Maikcg
            Maikcg 28 March 2021 00: 33
            +1
            Calm, only calm, domestic transactions have long been domestic (or at least most of them), at least turn on, the terminals will be in order.
  • opuonmed
    opuonmed 27 March 2021 15: 20
    0
    it would be cool to test and show on video!
    1. iouris
      iouris 27 March 2021 15: 56
      +1
      YouTube will ban these videos. The seismic wave must be heard.
    2. nznz
      nznz 27 March 2021 22: 29
      -1
      and what will you see there? firstly, they showed them 100 times. Secondly, underground ones simply shake the whole visual effect, it is a circular wave running along the rocks and raising moss and lichens. Not as spectacularly as a mushroom will not roll for 100 km.
  • Jaromir
    Jaromir 27 March 2021 17: 22
    +6
    Russian political scientist proposed to conduct a series of nuclear tests

    Express your opinion:
    Well, we will carry out a nuclear explosion. What's next? The Americans will begin to conduct their tests, followed by the French and the British, the Chinese will catch up there, and looking at all this leapfrog other countries will begin more active development of nuclear weapons ... If someone thinks that the West has forgotten that we have weapons of mass defeat, he is deeply mistaken. They remember and know. So what's the point of testing? Toughness is needed when negotiating, as well as when responding to attacks from the West, but not mirroring. Mirror, and in fact our kindness, they perceive as weakness.
    1. Maikcg
      Maikcg 27 March 2021 18: 34
      +3
      There will be fewer catastrophic earthquakes. Testing and non-proliferation modes are two big differences. Non-proliferation did not prevent different Israelis from tying materials in American centers.
    2. nznz
      nznz 27 March 2021 22: 24
      +1
      Why are you so fearful? The ball is not in the game yet, and there are already so many preoccupations, and not about us, but about the enemies.
      The fact that we are surrounded by enemies follows from the doctrine they call us there. You have to be naive and extremely delicate when calling them partners after that. except for sparring. let the ball be on the side, we spent. And let them scratch their turnips. This is their problem. I don’t think they’ll quickly decide something, purely for politics. They have no need. States can, they print money as much as necessary. We need to work proactively, so that they all the time have to come up with not nasty sanctions, but urgently solve the tasks that we will set them. Then they won't have time for anything else. Now we react only after them, this is a vicious tactic. As in a fight. While you are waiting for an answer, if you get punched in, you can grab it to the fullest.
  • Sergey Sfiedu
    Sergey Sfiedu 27 March 2021 20: 36
    +1
    Moron, not a political scientist.
  • Pavel57
    Pavel57 27 March 2021 21: 42
    0
    The West must realize that Russia is resolute and strong. Only then are negotiations and recognition of equality possible.
  • nznz
    nznz 27 March 2021 22: 18
    +2
    In my memory (I lived on Novaya Zemlya from 80-83 and 86-90), there were many tests or, as we called them, there were many events. In 90, the moratorium and, as you know, the test site has not worked since then for its intended purpose ... ...
    Under contracts, charges up to 150 kt can be tested.
    2-3 events were held a year. It depended on the weather and on the tasks. I honestly say that I was not a military man, and had no direct relationship. But on myself, like all the inhabitants of the garrison, of course I felt it.
    If the professor proposes to conduct 20-30 explosions, it will take time. At least for the de-mothballing of the landfill. Now there are marines. Common tasks are the protection of the borders, those air defenses, and so on. The garrison and life in it have greatly lost their intensity. For events, specialists are required, just like that, the clapperboard will tear off your fingers.
    For events, it is necessary to build adits, they are not simple, my friend worked, an order bearer, even a tnauk candidate was a welder in the brigade, he welded ceiling seams on stainless steel. I don’t know whether it’s difficult or not, I think it’s not easy. I told you so. The fact that there are soils of a rocky category does not need to be reminded.
    The process itself sometimes causes abnormal situations - during my time, the mountain cracked and ejected, people caught something. This is what I mean to freeze, just unfreeze, it's like rebuilding.
    People need to be accommodated, provided with housing and food, well, many. And the provision of the event itself requires the involvement of very many services, which are now either tied up or they are minimal. From the place of events (settlement Severny, Matochkin Shar) 300 km to Belushka, not so far, given that the winds there are dark with hurricane speeds. the shock wave comes very quickly. we knew about the start indirectly. As with cosmonauts, when senior officials, for example, an air defense general or someone else, took over on duty on such a day, they usually put on a movie in a row until 5 in the morning, Ivan Vasilyevich and the white sun of the desert. Then a shock came - powerfully rocked the concrete foundation, the building began to hum and the stretching steel bandages in the basements, the cables hummed and clicked.
    There is no need for powerful charges, but there are probably questions of a calibration nature, the development of some technologies and devices that cannot be 100% checked without a real test.
    This is what we can continue to do. New delivery vehicles should probably also be tested in terms of interaction between the carrier and the warhead. These are my fantasies.
    I can't say anything about the number of 20 in a row, it's difficult, just digging out of even. The technique has stepped forward, but it is a rock, and it’s a rock in Africa, it seems to me that even 2-3 years of preparation will be required ..
    The fact that it is necessary to do it, I support, only this question arises, why is this nix, it is easier to withdraw from the contract and do everything in 5-10 years. It’s just necessary. Then freeze. And so it turns out like a show, something like in a hurry and just a couple of three-one costs and the distraction of specialists.
  • Dikson
    Dikson 27 March 2021 23: 30
    -2
    I propose to send this gentleman from a warm Moscow television studio to Novaya Zemlya with a crowbar and a shovel .. - let, instead of provocative chatter, for which he is paid money, he himself will take an active part in the very events of "knocking down the breath" .. let's see how much he has breath is enough ..
    1. nznz
      nznz 28 March 2021 10: 27
      +1
      NZ is not a walk-through courtyard. A political scientist as a political scientist. With your approach, you can do all of them .. on the Solovki.
      And Churchill also said: not literally: A politician is the one who will explain how and what should happen, and when it doesn't happen, why didn't happen. That's all. Let this pretty sweet man work for himself. Look at the ukropolitologists, you'll vomit in an instant.
      1. Dikson
        Dikson 28 March 2021 17: 00
        0
        My family, a mother pregnant with an older brother, were very well acquainted at one time with the tests on Novaya Zemlya .. - when they shied off the hydrogen one - the people on Dikson, without further ado, were simply driven into a ravine near the village ... - sort of like on just in case .. The radiologists got interesting pictures .. And my parents told me a lot about bald bears covered with ulcers from radiation sickness .. Of course, since 62, a lot of water has flowed under the bridge, and the polygons on Novaya Zemlya have been rebuilt more seriously .. The tests simply will not lead to anything .. - the people in the world have already lost their fear of nuclear weapons so much that, apart from the excited Greenpeace employees, no one will be afraid of explosions on the distant Russian Arctic land .. But if in the same Syria to slap a tactical charge .. exactly what is ostentatious .. - then it will reach many ... and without balaboloks in television studios ... By the way, I had a classmate on Novaya Zemlya also in 86-90 .. I was on a business trip .. I will not say the exact date. . It builds there were fir trees ..
        1. nznz
          nznz 28 March 2021 22: 49
          +2
          I knew from the builders Slava Shalyavin and the military Slava Mikhailov. The latter was sent there and hid to, he is a boxer, he drove someone in the jaw for a woman. The commander said, Glory to the NZ, there is a length of service for two years, you will not waste time and will forget about the incident. He was a good guy. In an accident of 90, he plowed water for days. He was from St. Petersburg. On Dikson, my father’s friends (practically my second parents) —Stepanov Igor Stepanovich worked in a hydrographic unit — went through the war in a penal battalion, a sailor, was wounded, then after During the war, he worked as a long-distance sailing captain and a captain as a mentor. He was everywhere - from Sovgavan to Tiksi. His wife Stepanova Vera Konstantinovna worked as a local radio announcer. I often visited them in Piteor. We smoked with Vera Konstantinovna in the kitchen, Stepanich brought her in blocks of Marlboro, so I drank for free, and she Belomor loved Uritsky's factories. Stepanych died in the arms of my brother, for 9 days they arrived in Nizhny to us. I also flew in from the NZ, barely had time to take out the weather, then urgently in Moscow to get a military man on board, and Stepanych died in agony, bent down to fix his pillow And that's all. Stop machine. As for the events, yes, air and ground were dangerous. Underground ones are not dangerous. They measured more than once with meters on the covers of concrete adits. Not higher than in the MSC. Yes, and my sister's husband was involved as an expert - he was a participant in 85 trials, the Red Banner in 1976. He was in the epicenter in the group of the first throw, he collected sensors from the field, and a veteran of the group of special risk. Died in 2013, full of energy, fell in the hospital (flu) And as they said, he fell himself. Well, he left at the age of 83.
          1. Dikson
            Dikson 30 March 2021 10: 50
            0
            Mine worked in the Seaport .. And in Hydrobase I remember at Alekseev's on "Hals" as it was on measurements in navigation .. near Vilkitsky, in my opinion, a mine surfaced under the stern ..- the diesel engine was blown off in the car, the guys were concussed ... it's just that they survived .. Serega was then written off to the shore .. - he never recovered ...
  • richard the lionhert
    richard the lionhert 28 March 2021 00: 37
    +1
    Baran, The USA, France, England, etc. also have nuclear weapons. And they, too, will begin to test it, and this is correct, since such idiots will have to be put in their place in the stall!
    1. nznz
      nznz 28 March 2021 22: 51
      +1
      so what Let them experience on Bikkitney Atoll, in Nevada, where else?
      everything underground today is nothing on the surface. What is the fear?
  • iouris
    iouris 28 March 2021 13: 27
    +1
    The discussion showed that NATO has too many allies.
  • Drugov
    Drugov 28 March 2021 19: 42
    +1
    Channel One experts are as incomparable as English scientists!
  • Oleg Aviator
    Oleg Aviator 28 March 2021 23: 18
    0
    Yes ... There is no other way. So that they would understand that with the hands of their jackals they will not achieve anything and will scoop out themselves to the fullest. This should calm you down.