Realization of the possibility of Gagarin's stay in vacuum without gloves

31

Sealed gloves for spacesuit SK-1

For many people, the fact of the fundamental possibility of finding a person in a spacesuit with bare hands in conditions close to vacuum will be a revelation, and some will exclaim:

"This cannot be!"

But in the literature describing the SK-1 and SK-2 spacesuit, you can find an unremarkable phrase



"The cuffs were also attached to the rings of the sleeves, sealing the spacesuit when the gloves were removed."

(From the book "Space suits of Russia").

And we are not talking about sealing during splashdown, but in the case of depressurization of the KK cabin in conditions close to vacuum.

It turns out that "it can be."

But in order to understand why and under what conditions such a space flight regime was considered on the Vostok series spacecraft, it is worth referring to stories creation of spacesuits and physiological experiments carried out in Germany, the USA and the USSR at the dawn of high-altitude aviation and manned astronautics.

Spacesuits without hermetic gloves


The first domestic aviation suits (VSS series - VSS-04A, VSS-04M, VSS-05, VS-06, VSS-07 (VKS-1) (1953-1954)), developed by plant No. 918 (now NPP "Zvezda"), constructively did not provide for the presence of sealed gloves. And the sealing of the SC in the area of ​​the sleeves was provided by inflatable cuffs and compensating gloves, which was permissible for flights at altitudes up to 20-30 km.

The first aviation spacesuit with full-fledged sealed gloves in 1957 was the SI-3M.

However, a few years later, when designing a spacesuit for the first manned space flight, they again returned to the use of inflatable cuffs to seal the spacesuit. That at first glance looks strange and absurd. But despite this, it made common sense.

Reasons for using sealing cuffs on the sleeves of the SK-1 and SK-2 spacesuits


The first manned orbital flights under the Vostok programs did not provide for the removal of the spacesuit during the entire flight lasting up to several days. However, after the launch into orbit, the crew members were allowed to raise the helmet glazing flap and remove the sealed gloves.

In case of depressurization of the aircraft cabin, in the Soviet spacesuits "SK-1" for Yu.A. Gagarin and "SK-2" for V.N. Tereshkova created an overpressure of the order of 0,25 kgf / cm². When the pressure in the aircraft cabin drops to 430 mm Hg. Art. (equivalent to an altitude of 4,5 km)

“The contacts of the second group of the barrelay block were closed and the solenoid valve of the oxygen line was opened.

At the same time, voltage was applied to the pyromechanism for closing the helmet, and it was automatically closed. "

In such a situation, the cosmonaut could simply not have time to put on gloves, therefore, the emergency (spare) sealing of the first space suits (SK-1; SK-2) in the area of ​​the hands was performed by inflatable cuffs, a description of which is given in the literature rather sparingly.

They fit snugly around the astronaut's wrist. But the hands remained exposed and exposed to low atmospheric pressure, close to vacuum conditions.


Inflatable cuffs for the sleeves of the SK-1 spacesuit

Influence of low atmospheric pressure, close to vacuum conditions, on the hands that are without hermetic gloves.

The risk of such a situation was extremely small. But with the beginning of the era of high-altitude and space flights, it was not excluded. And they considered this option in all seriousness. Scientists in Germany (during the Second World War), and then the USSR and the USA, were faced with the task of determining the effect of a rarefied atmosphere on the human body as a whole, for which experiments were carried out in pressure chambers with the participation of experimental animals, and subsequently testers.

As for specifically bare hands, for this purpose, special experiments were carried out with the participation of people with ascents to heights of 25–35 km, where the barometric pressure is 5–15 mm Hg. Art.

As a result of these studies, the following became clear.

Firstly, due to the fact that the whole body is under an excess pressure of 0,25 kgf / cm², and the hands are in a rarefied atmosphere, the hands begin to swell and turn purple within a few minutes. Since the blood is squeezed into the zone of least pressure (laws of physics).

This disrupts the blood supply in the blood vessels of the hands. Bruises and petechiae appear. The person feels pain and numbness. And the mobility in the fingers and wrist joint is rapidly deteriorating.

Secondly, at altitudes over 25 km with an external pressure of about 16 mm Hg. Art. and below, after the first minute of exposure to a rarefied atmosphere, high-altitude emphysema occurs, which leads to even greater swelling of the hand after the first minute of being in a rarefied atmosphere.

There is a feeling of tension in the skin and "aches" in the hand (according to the recollections of the testers). After the descent, the hand turns out to be tense and cold to the touch, the capillaries of the nail bed overflow with blood. And then their contours became blurry. And the blood flow was indistinguishable, paresthesias occurred.

Despite this, within one and a half, maximum two minutes after "explosive decompression" or a rapid drop in pressure, the cosmonaut still had the opportunity to put on hermetic gloves on his own, although his fingers did not always fit into the gloved finger spaces. But even in this case, after a few days, the above symptoms disappear without a trace.

This is what one of the leading specialists in the field of high-altitude physiology and medical problems of the development of means of protection and rescue of flight personnel, doctor of medical sciences, professor, retired colonel of the medical service, a tester of aviation and space equipment, who has worked for more than 45 years in NIITs AKM and VE - Mikhail Vyacheslavovich Dvornikov, who participated in the seventies in ascents to a height of 30 km in a pressure chamber without gloves, who was interviewed:

“The research you asked about has been done.

They are still of great theoretical and practical importance for altitude physiology and aviation medicine.

I had to not only participate in the development and testing of the hypothesis, but also personally participate in the experiments.

At 25 km, the number of testers was more than 10, and five climbed to 30 km.

An interesting physiological fact was obtained in these studies. I specifically went to the experiment without compensating gloves. The absence of counterpressure on the hands showed that uncompensated excess pressure in the tissues of the hands is quite tolerable.

The hands were swollen, I did not feel any discomfort, there were no dysfunctions in the fingers.

At about the fifth minute of stay at an altitude of 30 km, signs of local vapor-gas emphysema appeared.

The skin is swollen, creaking when pressed on the surface of the hand. There was no pain.

As we descended, all phenomena disappeared. There were no residual phenomena on earth.

From a physiological point of view, I can explain this phenomenon as follows.
The lack of backpressure on the hand led to the deposition of blood and fluids in this area, and skin turgor partially served as a means of compensating for excess pressure in the tissues of the hand.

The compensation was incomplete, the pressure in the subcutaneous tissue reached an equivalent height of 19–20 km, maybe more.

The temperature of the liquid in this area could also be below 37 degrees, which led to vapor-gas emphysema, that is, interstitial boiling of liquid at a temperature under reduced pressure. "

There was a separate paragraph in the instructions for the cosmonauts, which indicated that in the event of a cabin depressurization at altitudes up to 30 km and above, in the absence of sealed spacesuit gloves on the cosmonaut's hands, he had to wear gloves within the first two minutes after the spacecraft cabin was depressurized.

Currently, the above problem has lost its relevance due to the high reliability of the spacecraft tightness and the mandatory use of a sealed rescue spacesuit at the stages of spacecraft launching and landing.

A similar attempt was made to use cuffs on the Orlan-D spacesuit.

However, the result of this idea is extremely controversial: the available literature does not indicate that the Orlan-D spacesuit was equipped with inflatable cuffs that provide protection for the astronaut in the event of damage to the spacesuit glove.

According to aviation doctors who were directly involved in the development of the SK, they persistently proposed the use of cuffs, but the proposal remained unrealized.

At the same time, one of the leading Orlan designers insists that cuffs were still present in Orlan-D.

It can be assumed that if the cuffs for the Orlan-M spacecraft really existed, they were used at the discretion of the cosmonaut.
31 comment
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. +5
    7 March 2021 15: 18
    in a rarefied atmosphere,

    Author, you have a spelling error - atmosphere cutеwife, (rarefaction). And the note is very interesting, respect!
    1. +2
      7 March 2021 15: 52
      Quote: Aviator_
      you have a spelling mistake

      There, under the article, especially for the attentive, an ad hangs:
      Noticed an error
      Select the text and press Ctrl + Enter
      1. +1
        7 March 2021 16: 42
        Well, then for the attentive
      2. +5
        7 March 2021 17: 24
        Space doctors are of course extreme! belay With such a "pressure" blood is simply KIPIT! Cellular fluid in tissues too! The laws of physics have not yet been canceled. But what to do, it is better to return to Earth without hands, but alive! But as to the fact that within a few minutes the hand can withstand all this - I did not know and did not even think about it. Sorry to the author for the informative article! good hi
        1. +4
          7 March 2021 21: 18
          With such a "pressure" blood is simply KIPIT!


          Can you ask a question? On the surface of the palm, zero. But why would he be zero in a closed artery, vein, capillary? Okay, the artery has expanded a little, boiling has begun - immediately the pressure will rise and the boiling will stop. Like a transparent gas lighter.
          So what is the actual pressure in the vessels? Once a person after the descent did not experience any consequences, but "The laws of physics have not yet been canceled“then there was nothing to worry about. Americans out there in general under partial pressure of oxygen (260 mm Hg.) fly without spacesuits - and not a fig.
          1. -1
            7 March 2021 23: 07
            Quote: dauria
            With such a "pressure" blood is simply KIPIT!


            Can you ask a question? On the surface of the palm, zero. But why would he be zero in a closed artery, vein, capillary? Okay, the artery has expanded a little, boiling has begun - immediately the pressure will rise and the boiling will stop.

            I would advise you to bare your hands in conditions close to vacuum and hold them for 3 - 4 minutes, thereby accomplishing a feat for future astronauts who will be confident that in such a terrible situation there is a chance of salvation. Read the article carefully.
        2. 0
          7 March 2021 22: 59
          In fact, it is very close to sous vide cooking. And the restoration took place because, after all, there was no irreversible destruction of proteins - the cells were dehydrated, injured, but not completely destroyed.
          On the other hand, the absence of pain and the temporary preservation of the mobility and sensitivity of the hands in a vacuum - these are new opportunities and ideas - the possibility of accurate, minor and vital repairs in space, impossible in a scaffold gloves - took off the glove and took out debris from electrical contact or precise mechanical transmission or soldered a capacitor to replace the spoiled one, taken from another device; carried out adjustments and calibrations, etc. Of course, new, reusable cuffs will be needed, and then pressure compensating gloves can be invented - for example, leaving only the tip of the finger uncompensated; a microbaric chamber, in which the hand can be quickly returned to working condition and give it a rest - right in conditions of depressurization and continue to work, etc. For example, this will be useful during expeditions to the Moon and Mars - in case of an accident there is nowhere to go and, for survival, it is necessary to be repaired to the last breath, like a long-range on a winter polar route, and, for example, the same wrist hyperbaric chamber - it will rather be a simple and uncomplicated piece of iron, the size of a can, mated with a scaffold sleeve, which will surely remain operational in any space catastrophe.
  2. +4
    7 March 2021 16: 51
    In good-quality hard sciense fiction, emergency cuffs in spacesuits are often mentioned, but limbs that have split from instant freezing at absolute zero are not. )))
    1. 0
      10 March 2021 21: 22
      Will your hands freeze? There is no substance in a vacuum, since there is no substance either, so absolute zero does not threaten them, they will end up like in a thermos, and they are not threatened with freezing.
      But the problem of low pressure is more complicated.
      1. 0
        11 March 2021 03: 15
        Quote: Avior
        Will your hands freeze?

        In bad fiction, yes, and even scatter into small pieces. But I wrote about good science fiction, don't you notice?
        1. 0
          11 March 2021 07: 46
          I just prefer to ask a clarifying question rather than guessing
          hi
  3. +8
    7 March 2021 17: 50
    Quote: Lesovik
    Quote: Aviator_
    you have a spelling mistake

    There, under the article, especially for the attentive, an ad hangs:
    Noticed an error
    Select the text and press Ctrl + Enter

    What's the use of this opportunity? A dozen times (not in this article) I sent this "trick" an error message. Perfectionism works, especially for interesting materials :)
    Nothing has ever been fixed. Possibly the following:
    - the feature does not work normally and the message does not reach the author;
    - the author does not care about the errors found;
    - the author does not care about me personally (please, I’m not of royal blood :))
    - other, inaccessible to me for understanding)
    In any case, it is a long time ago to stop "being clever" and fluttering about the errors found.
    The aviator decided to resolve this issue directly, through comments. It is also an option :)
    1. +2
      7 March 2021 23: 08
      Possibly the following:

      The author, i.e. I just sealed myself - this happens, and especially often when you type in the blind, i.e. 10 fingers. It has its own specifics, since printing runs parallel to thought, then mistakes often arise from the principle "as it is written (thought), so it is printed. And then you simply do not notice even the most elementary mistakes with a blurry eye. In addition, before publishing the article, 10 moderators read its check and corrected some little things, but no one noticed this error either.
      I would be glad to fix it, but firstly, I don’t know how, and secondly, didn’t anyone have time to use the controller? )))). And thirdly, practice shows that all sorts of nagging like "here is a mistake, but there the indentation is not the same" begin exactly at the moment when there is nothing to say in essence ((((
  4. +9
    7 March 2021 17: 58
    I was the only one who saw a discrepancy between information in the title of the article and the text of the article itself?
    In the title:
    "Realizing the possibility of Gagarin's stay under vacuum without gloves "
    And in the article itself, the experience was considered exclusively in "in the conditions close to vacuum". And without considering additional factors of a sharp drop in temperature, which would be logical if we talk about the conditions of the space vacuum. But in fact, the article contains research and work on the subject of solving possible problems of an astronaut at the take-off / landing stage, and at altitudes" up to 30 km and higher "(in theory - higher here - this is about 35-40 km, and not up to orbit altitude). Hence, it is logical that various" nuances "that would arise directly under a" real "vacuum were left behind.
    1. +4
      7 March 2021 23: 10
      "Realization of the possibility of Gagarin's stay in vacuum without gloves"
      And in the article itself, the experience was considered exclusively in "in conditions close to vacuum"

      Believe me, the pressure is 5 mm Hg. Art. or 0,5 no longer plays any fundamental difference)))). And the concept of "vacuum" in low orbits is also a relative concept.
      1. 0
        9 March 2021 00: 21
        And where did you get the idea that there is no difference?
        1. +1
          9 March 2021 10: 14
          And where did you get the idea that there is no difference?
          for the human body is suitable habitat at a pressure of 760 mm Hg. maximum 400 (5 km and then with adaptation). 7,6 mm Hg (more than 30 km) is only 1% of the norm, 0,76 mm Hg, respectively, 0,1%. The difference between these values ​​is less than one percent. If we consider these indicators, then the difference is less than the percentage of error of many measuring instruments.
  5. +2
    7 March 2021 21: 39
    It is always interesting to learn new things. Thanks to the author!
  6. 0
    8 March 2021 11: 18
    I still do not understand - is it enough to wear ordinary rubber gloves to enhance the natural turgor, or is it necessary to pump gas inside?
    1. +3
      8 March 2021 16: 25
      I still do not understand - is it enough to wear ordinary rubber gloves to enhance the natural turgor, or is it necessary to pump gas inside?

      Any glove that provides squeezing can significantly compensate for the pressure drop. I did not indicate in the article, but within the framework of the same work, attempts were made to use ordinary fabric gloves, but they did not create a strong enough compression since were stretched.
      At the first VKK (VKK-1) there were interesting gloves made of poorly stretchable fabric with lacing, like VKK itself. But I don’t know if all the models had additional airbags.
      Then they began to make compensating gloves without lacing, but they have an air cavity inside (a chamber with air). With a drop in pressure, the volume of the cavity increases according to the Boyle-Mariotte law, pulling the fabric of the glove and providing additional squeeze of the hands.
      1. +9
        9 March 2021 06: 13
        Thanks to the author for an interesting article!
      2. 0
        10 March 2021 21: 26
        that is, it turns out that the tightness of gloves for a relatively short stay in a vacuum is not necessary?
        Is it enough that they fit snugly around the brushes?
        or did I get it wrong?
        1. 0
          10 March 2021 22: 12
          that is, it turns out that the tightness of gloves for a relatively short stay in a vacuum is not necessary?
          Is it enough that they fit snugly around the brushes?

          Let's reformulate it as follows: a single hand can be in conditions close to vacuum for 1-2 minutes, but how it will be isolated is another question.
          If the pilot or cosmonaut is in the VKK, then the VKK still has height restrictions up to 30 km, maybe a little higher, but already on the verge of a foul, i.e. hypoxia. If the astronaut is in a spacesuit, then the rest of the body should be isolated in the spacesuit, for example, using cuffs.
          And second: if we talk about vacuum, then it is more correct to say nevertheless "close to vacuum" (here I agree that if you really find fault, then in the title of the article the word "vacuum" should really be replaced by "conditions close to vacuum") because ... during depressurization, the pressure will still drop for a certain time, and the less it becomes, the more the drop rate will slow down, therefore, in the ship, the pressure can collapse from 760mm to 7,5mm. say in 20 seconds, then from 7,5 to 0,7 in 40, and from 0,7 to 0,007 for another half hour. By the way, the Americans on Mercury, Gemini and Apollo used a pressure of 0,3 kgf / cm2 with pure oxygen just including. and for this reason, since in case of depressurization, the leak rate was less than if the pressure was 1 kgf / cm2 with the same hole area.
          1. 0
            10 March 2021 22: 20
            no, I'm not really talking about this, not about the difference between the concepts of vacuum and close to vacuum.
            meaning that if the glove is leaky but tightens on the wrist (and the suit is, of course, sealed with cuffs), will this be sufficient to temporarily compensate for the problems associated with low pressure? Say, a thin rubber glove that fits the brush with effort?
            1. 0
              11 March 2021 09: 31
              will it be in order to temporarily compensate for the problems associated with low pressure? Say, a thin rubber glove that fits the brush with effort?

              Theoretically, yes, because under a sealed glove, you still wear ordinary cotton, at least somehow, but it also compensates. But here the question is about a couple of minutes and what to do next is a big question. It is necessary not only to get to the ship and switch back, there is one 30m sublimator to dry, to connect the power supply block from the board and the electrofal. It seems to me that the hand does not fall, only life. But in a life suit, there really are more chances.
              1. 0
                11 March 2021 09: 36
                I ask why - some work, even in conditions of risk of depressurization, may need to be done without a glove - it is thick and unsuitable for delicate work.
                Could it be temporarily replaced with a relatively thin rubber wedge that protects the brush for the time it takes to wear sealed gloves in case of need?
                A bare hand is certainly better for delicate work, but a thin rubber glove is incomparably better than a thick, sealed one and safer than a bare hand.
                Millet thought out loud.
  7. +2
    9 March 2021 00: 02
    Thanks to the author for describing this topic. Our scientists did a good job on the spacesuits!
  8. 0
    9 March 2021 00: 22
    That is, Gagarin was going to fly 35 km?
    1. +3
      9 March 2021 10: 34
      That is, Gagarin was going to fly 35 km?
      no, "Vostok-1" gained 327 km at its apogee. But from a physical and physiological point of view, the processes at altitudes of 30 km and above are hardly distinguishable. If you are interested, then look at the layers of the atmosphere and their features, then read books on altitude and space physiology. I did not set myself the goal of solving these questions, but simply described the methods of protection and the results of experiments
      1. +1
        9 March 2021 11: 07
        A very interesting article. And about a question that is usually covered very sparingly. I remember from Discovery there was a program about test free-fall jumps and subsequent landing with a parachute from the stratosphere (more than 30 km). It was mentioned that the jumping tester unsuccessfully hooked on the glove and the hand was depressurized. It was said that the brush was greatly inflated. But in the end, there were no long-term consequences. Actually on the topic of depressurization and everything that I heard.
        The following was always interesting: in the case of depressurization in the descent sections, how quickly and strongly does the temperature regime inside the spacecraft change? And how were the engineers supposed to fend off this?
    2. 0
      10 March 2021 22: 03
      Gagarin did not land from Vostok, but with the help of a catapult he made a landing with a parachute and landed from a height of 7 km. Perhaps they admitted the need for ejection at a higher altitude.
      Of course, 35 km is a bit too much (although there are such jumps), but, probably, they allowed ejection at a sufficiently high altitude.
  9. The comment was deleted.