Military Review

The anthem of Russia on YouTube was "privatized" by an American company

176

The network is actively discussing a situation that any adequate person perceives as nonsense. The point is that YouTube video hosting users have noticed the following, to put it mildly, oddity. When trying to upload video content with the Russian anthem to their channels, bloggers were faced with warnings that this allegedly violates the copyrights of some American copyright holders.

Blogger Yuri Khovansky tried to figure out the situation when he was faced with a warning from the video hosting about “controversial content”.

It turned out that the music of the Russian anthem, written in Soviet times by the composer Alexander Alexandrov, was somehow "privatized" by the American corporation BMI. Bloggers note that now, in order to use the video with the anthem of Russia on your YouTube channel, you must submit an application to the "copyright holder". Phantasmagoria…

A detailed study of the situation revealed that this is not only the case with the Russian anthem on YouTube. It turned out that a few months ago this video hosting showed a tendency in which Western companies, including those in the music business, submitted data on the "ownership" of a number of Soviet songs, marches, etc. Thus, the American company The Orchard Music "registered rights "to the Soviet musical compositions" Victory Day "and" Holy War ". This was followed by a whole ninth wave of American "privatization" of Soviet cultural heritage on YouTube. The "rights" of American companies were registered in respect of those songs of Soviet performers who had the largest number of streams on the Internet.

Thus, it should be stated that American video hosting is actually trying to legitimize outright digital raiding or even piracy, while also encouraging it. This is another example of how far the American digital giants have gone, considering themselves the right to dispose of not only user accounts, but also culturalhistorical heritage, to which they themselves have nothing to do.
176 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. Vladimir_2U
    Vladimir_2U 2 February 2021 06: 38
    +54
    There is an insult to the state symbols of the Russian Federation. Casus belli as it is.
    1. Pessimist22
      Pessimist22 2 February 2021 06: 45
      +16
      You need to threaten them with leaving YouTube, Instagram and Twitter, how many bloggers will go around the world smile
      1. Lipchanin
        Lipchanin 2 February 2021 07: 09
        +32
        Quote: Pessimist22
        We must threaten them with leaving YouTube, Instagram and Twitter.

        Do not threaten, but really close access to them
        In a week, they will scream and themselves will cancel all this "privatization"
        1. NDR-791
          NDR-791 2 February 2021 07: 22
          +20
          Do not threaten, but really close access to them
          They do not want to close our access to anything. It's like our automatic stations and moon rovers on the moon let them privatize. Better let us privatize the air over the states until some cunning figured it out. And let them bash !!! am
          1. Lipchanin
            Lipchanin 2 February 2021 07: 25
            0
            Quote: NDR-791
            They do not want to close our access to anything.

            It's not about being reluctant
            The fact is that they can also block a lot of things for us.
            Here is a double-edged club
            Everything must be carefully calculated
            1. NDR-791
              NDR-791 2 February 2021 07: 45
              +16
              Everything must be carefully calculated
              To control "K" is an immeasurable field of activity. In general, a good programmer, if there are codes from YouTube, will insert such a link "at once". Most likely they did it themselves. And not the fact that the privatization is real. They can just cut the dough from suckers, then apologize for the oversight. And here the most ambush will be if ours keep silent. Then we can really wake up tomorrow with a receipt for air. And privatization will be real.
              1. Lipchanin
                Lipchanin 2 February 2021 07: 49
                0
                Quote: NDR-791
                To control "K" is an immeasurable field of activity.

                Most likely they already work
                Time has passed too little to judge what has been done
                1. KAV
                  KAV 2 February 2021 09: 08
                  +18
                  I think this is not a matter of "privatization" itself. This was done, first of all, to prevent the spread of the symbols of our patriotism on the sites. Well, plus to this, this is a spit from the United States in the direction of our history, pride, feats and other significant things.
                  1. Lipchanin
                    Lipchanin 2 February 2021 09: 11
                    +4
                    Quote: KAV
                    to prevent the spread of the symbols of our patriotism on the sites.

                    May 9 is approaching and so as not to watch the "Immortal Regiment", they concocted this muck
                    Well, plus to this, this is a spit from the United States in the direction of our history, pride, feats and other significant things.

                    They never denied themselves this.
                    1. Sling cutter
                      Sling cutter 2 February 2021 10: 23
                      +10
                      Quote: Lipchanin
                      May 9 is approaching and so as not to watch the "Immortal Regiment", they concocted this muck

                      Quote: Lipchanin
                      This was done, first of all, to prevent the spread of the symbols of our patriotism on the sites

                      Everything is loaded and played quite calmly and there is no need for hysterics!

                      1. Lipchanin
                        Lipchanin 2 February 2021 10: 25
                        -5
                        Quote: Stroporez
                        Everything is loaded and played quite calmly and there is no need for hysterics!

                        And where did you see the tantrum?
                        We are discussing an article
                      2. Sling cutter
                        Sling cutter 2 February 2021 10: 35
                        +13
                        Quote: Lipchanin
                        And where did you see the tantrum?
                        We are discussing an article

                        I have already said that you are constantly writing gems of cosmic scale and cosmic stupidity, although of course you write, you will amuse us, but believe me, there are too many of you. laughing
                      3. Lipchanin
                        Lipchanin 2 February 2021 15: 55
                        -2
                        Quote: Stroporez
                        I have already mentioned,

                        Brad, these are not yet intelligible words
                        that you are constantly writing gems of a cosmic scale

                        Yes, what nonsense you sometimes talk about, I can't think of such a thing from the deepest hangover
                        will amuse us

                        So you have group art there?
                        Do you answer with the whole house? laughing
                        Now a lot has become clear to me ...
                        , there are too many of you.

                        Well, how far is it for us laughing
                      4. Vladimir Mashkov
                        Vladimir Mashkov 3 February 2021 20: 35
                        +1
                        The Americans have become insolent to lawlessness, to cosmic proportions !!! Not only do they declare the entire globe a zone своих interests, not only have they filled up the whole world with their NOT secured with gold green paper under the guise of world money, not only do they judge citizens of the whole world by their laws, not only did they declare the moon a zone своих interests (their own!), so they also brazenly steal Soviet-Russian intellectual property and declare it theirs! It's time to hold them accountable !!!
                2. Sentinel-vs
                  Sentinel-vs 2 February 2021 11: 05
                  +6
                  Quote: Stroporez
                  Everything is loaded and played quite calmly and there is no need for hysterics!

                  Duck you read the article or, as usual, through the heading diagonally?
                  For people with low attention I will repeat the thesis: It is loaded and played, but it does not allow using it in its videos without the permission of the copyright holder, which, suddenly, are American companies.
                3. Sling cutter
                  Sling cutter 2 February 2021 11: 20
                  +12
                  Quote: Sentinel-vs
                  but does not allow to use it in its vidos without the permission of the copyright holder, which, suddenly, are American companies.

                  It's just too lazy to cut and "fill" now, look for fresh in yupub and find. This news just stinks of glass wool used to raise the morale of couch fighters.
                  And now a question for you, who do you think is the copyright holder of the anthem of any country in the world?
                  for example, "Internationale".
                4. ProkletyiPirat
                  ProkletyiPirat 2 February 2021 13: 02
                  +2
                  Quote: Sentinel-vs
                  Quote: Stroporez
                  Everything is loaded and played quite calmly and there is no need for hysterics!

                  Duck you read the article or, as usual, through the heading diagonally?
                  For people with low attention I will repeat the thesis: It is loaded and played, but it does not allow using it in its videos without the permission of the copyright holder, which, suddenly, are American companies.

                  Well, you are a pancake and a master to explain so that you will confuse even more.
                  Because of this sound "ownership", the copyright holder can
                  1) require the video to be muted
                  2) request the suspension of video monetization until the disputes are resolved
                5. three
                  three 2 February 2021 13: 18
                  +5
                  "demand suspension ..." can only be in the controlled territory, the extraterritoriality of rights will not work here. Hence, there are two ways for us: to look for real levers (reduce the speed, if not, then turn it off, if not, cut it off) and the second - create our own, and then in the fight for the client all these rights will be quickly "forgotten". And, in general, America is on this, there is nothing to be surprised at, since we got into the cap. relations, you have to be more subtle, it is not for you to dictate prices to pensioners, here your unfinished lawyers are not quoted, gentlemen from the government.
                6. Dart
                  Dart 2 February 2021 15: 16
                  0
                  what do you want from the "proletarian", for him it sounds like Chinese)))
            2. Peaceful SEO
              Peaceful SEO 4 February 2021 13: 21
              +1
              The Chukchi is not a reader, the Chukchi is a writer .... You can download it, you can use it, but you have to apply for the use of some American devil. And yes, if the hell does not approve of the application, in the video, while the unapproved melody sounds, there will be silence, complete, even if someone's speech (a speaker, for example) is there, then YouTube will turn it off too.
              And if they approve, by the way, watching videos with an approved melody will collect money for advertising on the accounts of devils. Something like this
        2. for
          for 2 February 2021 12: 07
          +1
          Quote: KAV
          I think this is not about "privatization" itself.

          Yes, no one did not privatize it, they have rights to their own version with changes. You can do the same with the American anthem.
  2. Crimean partisan 1974
    Crimean partisan 1974 2 February 2021 08: 33
    -7
    It is necessary to calculate everything carefully ... and what is all the fuss ... it is not clear ... if you think pragmatically, then a piece of music is a product, the same as gas and oil, etc. and so on, and this product is mastered by the buyer for his territory as your own, for example .... gas to Germany crossed the meter and after the meter it is German, using German gas, you pay to the German treasury ... everything seems to be so ... and in the virtual space ... from the owners of YouTube in this space is a slice of territory. what gets there is assigned, but on other virtual territories youtube is not in any way ... Duc explain what such a commotion is ...
    1. Thrall
      Thrall 2 February 2021 09: 22
      +15
      4 days ago, the owner of Youtube Google admitted that BMI's claim against the Anthem of Russia through the Content ID system was unfounded.
      Not a word about this in the article.
      1. Crimean partisan 1974
        Crimean partisan 1974 2 February 2021 09: 42
        -6
        through the Content ID system is unreasonable ... but it doesn't matter, even if it was justified. what does it change ... well, let's say there are rights on this platform, well, and make money on the product ... but on another platform you don't have such rights ... I don't understand what's the trouble ..... yes, it's far and away to dig don't ... subscribe to the site and subscribe to the site rules, for breaking the ban ... dumped on another similar one ... for example, besides VO, there are many similar ones .. for example, Everything about weapons ... the rules of VO do not apply there .. ... although everything is the same ... but more liberal to subscribers ... I can't understand what is the commotion
      2. Paranoid50
        Paranoid50 2 February 2021 10: 11
        +3
        Quote: Thrall
        Not a word about this in the article

        Well, they grabbed the delay and squeezed it here with a shift for three days. And here the swamp is already boiling. fellow laughing
        1. Sling cutter
          Sling cutter 2 February 2021 10: 27
          +5
          Quote: Paranoid50
          Well, they snatched out the delay and squeezed it here with a shift for three days. And here the swamp is boiling

          No longer boils, but boils and bubbles laughing
          And to press two buttons on the keyboard, the putriots do not have enough thinking wassat They will be gundos, and check ..... like this in everything.
          1. lucul
            lucul 2 February 2021 10: 58
            +3
            No longer boils, but boils and bubbles laughing
            And to press two buttons on the keyboard, the putriots do not have enough sobriot wassat They will be gundos, but check ..... like this and in everything.

            Dear, where were you a week ago when it was impossible to do? )))
            And now, when the ban was lifted 4 days ago, you present it as a false article.
            A spoon is expensive for dinner, if that.
            1. for
              for 2 February 2021 12: 56
              +5
              A spoon is way to dinner, if that

              So this article was dear 4 days ago.
          2. Sentinel-vs
            Sentinel-vs 2 February 2021 11: 07
            +3
            So what did you check then?
            You insert the anthem into your YouTube video without the permission of the copyright holder. Talk about it, stupid place.
            1. for
              for 2 February 2021 13: 00
              +3
              Quote: Sentinel-vs
              Insert a hymn into your YouTube video without permission

              And how to check if the restrictions have been removed?
          3. yehat2
            yehat2 2 February 2021 16: 30
            +4
            stupid lyrics and good music. The text should be returned as it was.
            1. Vladimir_2U
              Vladimir_2U 2 February 2021 16: 44
              +3
              Quote: yehat2
              stupid lyrics and good music.

              The text was adapted by a talented opportunist, but it was not Stalin who edited the text. The music is great!
          4. Kart
            Kart 3 February 2021 16: 24
            -1
            But komunizdy only 2 buttons and learned. And let's crush them!
    2. Sling cutter
      Sling cutter 2 February 2021 10: 48
      +8
      Quote: Crimean partisan 1974
      We need to carefully calculate everything ... but what is all the fuss ... it's not clear ..

      The whole fuss is only that the gullible putriotic-tuned co-citizens take any fake at face value and it started not yesterday, but with the Kashpirovsky-chumak. They can easily charge three-liter cans from the TV and be treated with a cucumber, pushing it into an obscene place.
      You can also stump
      Who cares, can combine the two exercises (no ads) wassat wassat wassat
      1. Crimean partisan 1974
        Crimean partisan 1974 2 February 2021 10: 58
        +3
        from the Kashpirovsky-Chumak ...... well people like that. as the grandmother whispered so it will be, ... the roots are too deep ... go for a lot of fools and not enough hare
        1. Sling cutter
          Sling cutter 2 February 2021 11: 01
          +12
          Quote: Crimean partisan 1974
          from the Kashpirovsky-Chumak ...... well people like that. as the grandmother whispered so it will be, ... the roots are too deep ... go for a lot of fools and not enough hare

          laughing Lack of critical thinking and complete reluctance to consider cause-and-effect relationships, from here we live and chew our bread.
          1. Crimean partisan 1974
            Crimean partisan 1974 2 February 2021 11: 18
            0
            Lack of critical thinking ... so I don't understand why the feeling among the people that something was stolen from him so sharpened ... it is quite normal in bourgeois society ... or every "paganini" in a pedestrian crossing by the scruff of his neck and to court for copyright infringement ... some kind of nonsense ... but why would this YouTube fit in .... I need to download "Victory Day" and download it through the sub-buffer every morning and do not care what a misunderstanding has some rights
            1. Mikhail m
              Mikhail m 2 February 2021 19: 43
              0
              Quote: Crimean partisan 1974
              do not care that some kind of misunderstanding has some rights

              It is the misunderstanding that is right. https://www.vesti.ru/article/2121921
              The story is old, but it took place. And everything is according to the law.
            2. Crimean partisan 1974
              Crimean partisan 1974 2 February 2021 19: 57
              0
              I ask you not to send me vague exiles. especially since I didn’t ask them to send them .... and a misunderstanding has one option ... to challenge ... but it’s unlikely that a misunderstanding will succeed
        2. Roman123567
          Roman123567 2 February 2021 12: 00
          +3
          Lack of critical thinking


          When I hear the phrase "Well, people vote for Putin" - I immediately remember that the same people voted for Medvedev .. and for Yeltsin .. already twice !!
          If the Kremlin wants to tomorrow, the people will vote for Kashpirovsky too.
          1. Sling cutter
            Sling cutter 2 February 2021 12: 03
            +11
            Quote: Roman123567
            When I hear the phrase "Well, people vote for Putin" - I immediately remember that the same people voted for Medvedev .. and for Yeltsin .. already twice !!
            If the Kremlin wants to tomorrow, the people will vote for Kashpirovsky too.

            I will say more, not only will he vote, but he will also frantically drown for his "choice" and explain the inexplicable.
          2. Kart
            Kart 3 February 2021 16: 26
            0
            Your minds do not have enough people to tell them. And it will never be enough.
            So they will vote for Putin.
  3. Paranoid50
    Paranoid50 2 February 2021 10: 59
    +5
    Quote: Stroporez
    All the fuss

    Oooh ... This is quite a disaster ... wassat Perhaps the revival of the institutions of punitive psychiatry is necessary. yes
    1. Sling cutter
      Sling cutter 2 February 2021 11: 24
      +9
      Quote: Paranoid50
      utter disaster ... Perhaps, the revival of the institutions of punitive psychiatry is necessary.

      Good idea! good
  4. sniperino
    sniperino 2 February 2021 12: 57
    +1
    Quote: Stroporez
    to be treated with a cucumber, pushing it into an obscene place.
    My son has a club, which I "police" into the accessible holes, a folk healer has cucumbers ...
    If this is not an anal fixation, where else would such an unhealthy interest in the topic come from ...
    1. Sling cutter
      Sling cutter 2 February 2021 17: 22
      +12
      Quote: sniperino
      how else to get such an unhealthy interest in the topic ...

      Colleague, everything is in order for me, my preferences are completely traditional and in vain you pull words out of context, it does not paint you. (I am expressing myself as correctly as possible) hi
  • Pensive Lawyer
    Pensive Lawyer 2 February 2021 17: 25
    0
    A piece of music has a twofold value.
    Value as a material medium or electronic information containing music itself - here your analogy with oil is correct.
    But there is also value as an object of intellectual property. In essence, it represents the rights to a work, that is, something that cannot be felt, since it is an abstract category.
    They are worried precisely for the immaterial part. It can only have one copyright holder. These prioizovaniye passed into the public domain. However, here some private trader, and even under the jurisdiction of a hostile state, tried to appropriate ours and restrict our rights on a popular video hosting site.
  • yehat2
    yehat2 2 February 2021 16: 29
    +3
    everything is trite - for attempts to privatize the Soviet legacy - multibillion-dollar lawsuits against lovers of free privatization for a number of factors. The basis of the lawsuit is an attempt at independence and oppression on a formal basis. This is our heritage and nobody else's.
  • Pavlos Melas
    Pavlos Melas 2 February 2021 18: 39
    0
    It's not about being reluctant
    The fact is that they can also block a lot of things for us.
    Here is a double-edged club
    Everything must be carefully calculated

    The best option, in my opinion, is to promote your platform.
  • Uncle lee
    Uncle lee 2 February 2021 07: 36
    +10
    Type in the words "US Anthem" on YouTube and listen carefully to the first verse. And then find a song about an old mountaineer: "Khasbulat is daring, your saklya is poor ..." Do you recognize? The melody is the same.
    So who, roughly speaking, whistled the music?

    That's where the dog needs to dig!
    1. Pereira
      Pereira 2 February 2021 11: 18
      +2
      Already rummaged. The notes are different.
      1. Uncle lee
        Uncle lee 3 February 2021 01: 11
        +1
        Quote: Pereira
        The notes are different.

        The dog does not understand the notes ... The notes may be different, but the melody is the same ... No.
  • The comment was deleted.
  • Stas157
    Stas157 2 February 2021 08: 01
    +3
    We were not told all the "truth" in this story. The main question was left outside the brackets. Who sold the rights to our musical works to the Americans? How did they become copyright holders?
    And perhaps in this way we will go to our huckster.
    1. The leader of the Redskins
      The leader of the Redskins 2 February 2021 08: 34
      +4
      Bad news. Immediately reminded of the nineties with "privatization". When everyone seemed to be telling them some examples they had given, and then "by chance" it turned out that their own enterprises either already someone privatized, or that your document turned out to be in some kind of "horns and hooves", which is gone.
      1. Thrall
        Thrall 2 February 2021 09: 26
        +6
        Quote: Stas157
        Who sold the rights to our musical works to the Americans? How did they become copyright holders?

        Nobody sold, if you are registered on the video hosting Youtube, then you can also claim the rights to play the Anthem of Russia through the automatic Content ID system. Another thing is that your application will not pass. smile
    2. Lipchanin
      Lipchanin 2 February 2021 09: 08
      0
      Quote: Stas157
      Who sold the rights to our musical works to the Americans?

      No one sold
      Aleksandrov, was somehow "privatized" by the American corporation BMI.

      How did they become copyright holders?

      These are their laws
    3. Kart
      Kart 3 February 2021 16: 28
      0
      Who sold the rights to our musical works to the Americans?

      Wait olesha with kichi will tell Pravda to everyone.
      Well, you already know, right?
  • antivirus
    antivirus 2 February 2021 09: 20
    +3
    and where, for a week, hamsters will be attached? ..................... will howl
    1. Lipchanin
      Lipchanin 2 February 2021 09: 26
      +1
      Quote: antivirus
      and where, for a week, hamsters will be attached? ..................... will howl

      Down the branch they are already howling laughing
      Wives can't live without YouTube laughing
  • Pereira
    Pereira 2 February 2021 11: 17
    +3
    Foreign shutdowns of the Russian segment will not be noticed. Within the planet, this is an elusive small value.
    Only our fifth column will notice.
  • Torins
    Torins 3 February 2021 17: 35
    0
    American bloggers don't care at all, our bloggers and our users will suffer.
  • Svetlana
    Svetlana 2 February 2021 07: 40
    +8
    There is no need to threaten anyone with anything. It is necessary to sue these privatizers, more thieves are not threatened, thieves are chopped off.
    1. nsm1
      nsm1 2 February 2021 07: 47
      -9
      Stupid and completely pointless.
      They will say in our jurisdiction this way - the melody is privatized, and where it is used by foreigners is not important.
  • Aleksandr1971
    Aleksandr1971 2 February 2021 07: 53
    0
    We need to threaten them with Ramon Mercader.

    And so that with an ice pick in the head not only the enemy, but also his relatives up to the 7th knee!
    1. Pereira
      Pereira 2 February 2021 11: 23
      +4
      And instead of being scared, they will ask who is Mercader?
      I imagine this conversation:
      - Who is this, Mercader? - they will ask.
      - Spanish artist
      - And what?
      - He killed Trotsky
      - Who is Trotsky?
      - Communist
      - Wow, this is a cool dude Mercader. Let him come to the USA. We need such people.
  • Sofa batyr
    Sofa batyr 2 February 2021 08: 06
    +2
    Quote: Pessimist22
    We must threaten them with leaving YouTube, Instagram and Twitter.

    Quote: Lipchanin
    Do not threaten, but really close access to them


    Then you just need not to waste your time on trifles, but to take it and decisively implement it "Liberal's nightmare"- its own national segment of the Internet.

    Following the example of the PRC.
    1. military_cat
      military_cat 2 February 2021 08: 54
      0
      Quote: Divan-batyr
      "Liberal's nightmare" is its own national segment of the Internet.

      Hurry. I can't wait to see this happiness and the general joy about it.
      1. Pereira
        Pereira 2 February 2021 11: 24
        +1
        We will launch fireworks and dance in the squares.
    2. Lipchanin
      Lipchanin 2 February 2021 09: 27
      -4
      Quote: Divan-batyr
      its own national segment of the Internet.

      It had to be done yesterday
    3. sniperino
      sniperino 2 February 2021 14: 07
      -1
      Quote: Divan-batyr
      own national segment of the Internet
      And let him in from behind the hill one by one after a thorough check of documents, "ringing" and a test for coronavirus.
  • for
    for 2 February 2021 11: 57
    +1
    We must threaten them with leaving YouTube, Instagram and Twitter,

    Want to overpower those Medvedevs in classmates, well, well.
  • marchcat
    marchcat 2 February 2021 06: 46
    +2
    Interestingly, in which "office" it is so easy to "grab" the Soviet legacy. Are they there that henbane overeat?
    1. Lipchanin
      Lipchanin 2 February 2021 07: 12
      -2
      Quote: marchcat
      Interestingly, and in which "office" it is so easy to "grab" the Soviet legacy.

      In any Russophobic, and there are such bulk
    2. sergo1914
      sergo1914 2 February 2021 07: 35
      +11
      Quote: marchcat
      Interestingly, in which "office" it is so easy to "grab" the Soviet legacy. Are they there that henbane overeat?


      Only Soviet? Go to the site of the amusing organization "Russian Authors' Society". Non-profit. Who owns Mendelssohn's wedding march? They tried to use the registry offices for illegal performance. Metallica and Deep Purple were fined for illegal performance of songs on the territory of the Russian Federation. The songs of these groups do not belong to these groups. And RAO. Bach,
      Beethoven, Mozart ...
      1. Intruder
        Intruder 2 February 2021 08: 15
        +6
        The songs of these groups do not belong to these groups. And RAO. Bach,
        Beethoven, Mozart ...
        well ... most likely these groups worked under a contract with their producers, and they acted as legal entities and there it was written to whom they transferred their exclusive rights !? But Beethoven, Mozart and Bach, lived in a slightly different era, when copyright still did not apply to the author's works of composers at that time, maybe then immediately - 7 notes to privatize both the frequency of sounds, and truncated, although this is illegal, even in Russian legislation .... (Resolution of the Plenum of the RF Armed Forces on April 26, 2007, No. 14 "On the practice of court consideration of criminal cases on violation of copyright, related, inventive and patent rights, as well as on illegal use of a trademark")!
        1. Thrall
          Thrall 2 February 2021 14: 48
          0
          Quote: Intruder
          Beethoven, Mozart and Bach lived in a slightly different era, when copyright did not apply to the author's works of composers at that time.

          This is used by modern and not very modern performers, using very short the most successful excerpts (samples) from these classics.
  • Finches
    Finches 2 February 2021 06: 56
    0
    Not surprising! Anglo-Saxons in their repertoire - a complete lack of conscience, honesty, decency ...
  • PN
    PN 2 February 2021 07: 07
    +8
    In return, we are on our side to legitimize audio / video piracy to private companies. Let the losses incur.
    1. Lipchanin
      Lipchanin 2 February 2021 07: 14
      -2
      Quote: PN
      In return, legitimize audio / video piracy to private companies on our side

      Desirable at Bassmanny Court.
      Then they will dance
      But they have a powerful lever to shut down the internet for us
      1. NDR-791
        NDR-791 2 February 2021 07: 25
        +1
        But they have a powerful lever to shut down the internet for us
        It seems that our servers from Israel were moved to us long ago. That is, if they close, the Russian segment will remain
        1. Lipchanin
          Lipchanin 2 February 2021 07: 28
          -1
          Quote: NDR-791
          That is, if they close, then the Russian segment will remain

          International can close
          The same "Swift". Have long been threatened
          1. NDR-791
            NDR-791 2 February 2021 07: 31
            -1
            The same "Swift". Have long been threatened
            And the dog is with him. Do you have a lot of transactions abroad? For the internal user "Mir" is done, it is working. If they close Swift, they won't get a liter of oil and gas - they won't be able to pay.
            1. Lipchanin
              Lipchanin 2 February 2021 07: 36
              0
              It's not all that simple. There are a lot of things tied to it. It's not about private transactions, where the state interests are tied.
              They just won't threaten
          2. dmmyak40
            dmmyak40 2 February 2021 09: 23
            -1
            In response, we will close flights to Russia. For specific countries, and let China fly. Then they will feel the difference.
            1. Lipchanin
              Lipchanin 2 February 2021 09: 30
              -1
              Quote: dmmyak40
              In response, we will close flights to Russia. For specific countries,

              There are many things you can do. But this takes time. Thorough analysis of impact and response
          3. sniperino
            sniperino 2 February 2021 14: 12
            +1
            Quote: Lipchanin
            The same "Swift". Have long been threatened
            As soon as it becomes profitable for them in terms of weakening and collapse of the Russian Federation, they will do it immediately, without waiting for any reason. This used to require provocations, such as the assassination of the Archduke, priest Gapon, etc.
        2. Mordvin 3
          Mordvin 3 2 February 2021 07: 49
          +3
          Quote: NDR-791
          That is, if they close, then the Russian segment will remain

          And what? Try uploading an excerpt from a Soviet film here, most likely we'll see that "this content belongs to Mosfilm, which banned ..."
      2. Horon
        Horon 2 February 2021 08: 46
        -2
        But they have a powerful lever to shut down the internet for us

        It's like stopping broadcasting Western channels in Russia in return. They will not do it.
  • iouris
    iouris 2 February 2021 11: 10
    -1
    Who owns the "RF" brand?
    By the way, where is the founder's family (Voloshin, Yumashev with Dyachenko (or Dyachenko with Yumashev)?
  • for
    for 2 February 2021 13: 25
    +2
    There is an insult to the state symbols of the Russian Federation

    And this is not an insult. Or is it an insult from anyone. And what kind of blogger is needed, looking for exactly their interpretation without taking the official version or was afraid. Why does he need it.
    v = K4CX5ynpeFE
  • vladimirvn
    vladimirvn 2 February 2021 13: 54
    +1
    It's strange. Just checked it out. Everything is loaded and rolled. There are no references.
  • Captain Pushkin
    Captain Pushkin 2 February 2021 16: 17
    0
    Just a clear desire to block any music content from Russia under a very dubious pretext.
    It's time for the Russian government to file a class action lawsuit on behalf of the real rightholders.
  • zenion
    zenion 2 February 2021 20: 23
    0
    Vladimir_2U (Vladimir). The American madhouse can come up with worse. They can consider everyone who has entered YouTube as their slaves, and so on.
  • seregatara1969
    seregatara1969 2 February 2021 06: 45
    -1
    They deprive us of everything! And cultural heritage and past historical and territorial integrity. How long will our government pray for the world bourgeoisie? We are not brothers or relatives for them, we just occupy a place where there are many resources.
    1. military_cat
      military_cat 2 February 2021 06: 56
      +6
      Who is talking about what, and lousy about the bath. Some people found a hole in the mechanisms of YouTube and decided to earn extra money. YouTube is probably already aware of the hole and will close it in the near future. This is where it ends.
      1. Dimonst
        Dimonst 2 February 2021 08: 16
        +4
        There is also a video on YouTube with an analysis of this situation by Vesti 24. Google apologized and decided the issue in favor of the Russian Federation. There are no problems here, globalization in all its glory. The music identification software mistook the Anthem of Russia for the music (identical but in a different performance) that the BMI registered to itself upon download.
        1. three
          three 2 February 2021 13: 32
          -1
          That's a normal situation. The age of capitalism - wherever it smells of a dollar, by hook or by crook they will try to cheat you for money, just test for resistance. We must calmly understand and react.
  • rotmistr60
    rotmistr60 2 February 2021 06: 48
    +5
    allegedly violates the copyright of some American copyright holders.
    And what does this mean, and how did it become possible? Even from the examples given "Anthem of Russia", "Victory Day", "Holy War", it is clear that "copyright" refers to state symbols (anthem) and patriotic works, which can now be posted on social networks only with permission, allegedly of the copyright holders. And who will give permission for the Russian patriotic to sound on the air, well, if only for money. Do you think to deal with this chaos? Or are there no good lawyers, which means you need to take it for granted? Unrequited arrogance knows no bounds.
    1. Lipchanin
      Lipchanin 2 February 2021 07: 21
      -1
      Quote: rotmistr60
      Do you think to deal with this chaos? Or are there no good lawyers, which means you need to take it for granted?

      Well, firstly it started not a month or a week ago, but later
      Secondly, you need to carefully understand the situation, and this takes time
      Thirdly, such things are not solved "with a saber bald". We must calculate all the options
      Fourth. It is necessary to prepare claims to the courts, and they will certainly be, and this also takes time.
      And there is still a lot to do and everything takes time
    2. Polite Moose
      Polite Moose 2 February 2021 07: 31
      +4
      Quote: rotmistr60
      And what does this mean, and how did it become possible?

      Why are you surprised? These guys even banned the American president.
      But our Ministry of Foreign Affairs, and together with the GP, probably should ask the "copyright holders" of the anthem: where, when, under what circumstances they received these rights.
      1. Blackmokona
        Blackmokona 2 February 2021 07: 43
        +5
        Google does not approve of every additive in licensed content, and acts through appeals in case of problems. As the Gym was privatized, it was nationalized back on the same day. Well, the company that added licenses to the list needs to be sued.
        1. Polite Moose
          Polite Moose 2 February 2021 07: 48
          +2
          Quote: BlackMokona
          Well, the company that added licenses to the list needs to be sued.

          I am for any of our actions, if only those who spit in our direction do not remain without an answer. hi
    3. nsm1
      nsm1 2 February 2021 07: 50
      0
      Quote: rotmistr60
      And who will give permission for the Russian patriotic to sound on the air
      In their jurisdiction, they do not require permits from foreigners.
  • carstorm 11
    carstorm 11 2 February 2021 06: 50
    +1
    With a hymn, the topic will be closed quickly. State symbols. Who got the rights without them and will remain. But for the songs ... the authors' descendants apparently do not really care about the inheritance. But through the courts they will easily beat them off. Or maybe these companies have already sold the rights quietly.
    1. nnm
      nnm 2 February 2021 07: 02
      +17
      1. YouTube 29.01.21/XNUMX/XNUMX admitted the error of the American company, which claimed the copyright.
      2. The main part of the "old" songs, even in Soviet times, had a copyright holder - "melody", "State Television and Radio", etc. Relatives have nothing to do with it. And we must not forget about the established period of transfer to common ownership - 50 years for phonograms and 70 for the works themselves. So we first need to see if the modern dealers of the conventional "Gosteleradio" actually sold the copyright to many of our songs
      3. You must understand that such "injections" will be constant and systemic. And learn to respond to them asymmetrically and strongly. And power for the United States is money. This means that it is necessary to respond to this with huge fines. That would come a couple of times.
      4. It is necessary to develop your internal Internet resource. Like the same China - analogs of YouTube and so on. But to do it efficiently.
      1. Lipchanin
        Lipchanin 2 February 2021 07: 22
        0
        Quote: nnm
        You need to develop your internal Internet resource

        It should have been done yesterday
    2. Lipchanin
      Lipchanin 2 February 2021 07: 11
      0
      Quote: carstorm 11
      the authors' descendants apparently do not really care about the inheritance

      Most likely they don't know yet
  • Moonsund
    Moonsund 2 February 2021 06: 56
    +3
    Well, what, you need to get copyright for childbirth or, say, for the breathing process. Some kind of madness, that's the answer whose internet is at all
    1. evgen1221
      evgen1221 2 February 2021 08: 00
      -3
      Tc, be quiet. And then what other official reads and issues on the mountain a bill on taxation of the breathing process in connection with the struggle for the environment (how much CO2 is exhaled into the atmosphere, how many budgets can be mastered on the exhalation of citizens) RF is a country of opportunities, everything is possible !!! Quiet, otherwise it will come true, these can))))
      1. sniperino
        sniperino 2 February 2021 14: 48
        0
        Quote: evgen1221
        Tc, be quiet. And then what other official will read
        Hey! You are no longer in Tik-Tok.
        1. evgen1221
          evgen1221 2 February 2021 16: 59
          +1
          By the way, I advise you, a minute of humor on the phone and a guaranteed income in well. The province helps to survive in our time of grave stability.
          1. sniperino
            sniperino 2 February 2021 17: 44
            -1
            Quote: evgen1221
            in our time of grave stability
            Your time for stable burial has not come yet
  • Lech from Android.
    Lech from Android. 2 February 2021 06: 59
    +4
    Those who wanted to warm their paws on it put on the Soviet legacy ... It all started back in the 90s and continues to this day. This includes everything ... from cartoons and books to various inventions, money, as they say, does not smell. This is very well manifested in various prohibitions to download and copy from the Internet. Knowledge and culture should be available to the people and monetization will lead to bad things, we have a very sad picture with this. Abroad they love to appropriate the Soviet heritage and then sell it to us as from the legitimate owners ... crooks.
  • Van 16
    Van 16 2 February 2021 07: 01
    +4
    Wow .. is this even legal? On the good, all these "owners" would not hurt to sue for serious reasons, whatever it was. Fuck what's going on ..
  • Lipchanin
    Lipchanin 2 February 2021 07: 04
    -3
    "Rospotrebnadzor" to close access to YouTube
    Sparing no expense to hire the best lawyers and flood the courts in court with lawsuits.
    And don't talk about soft Faberge
    This is already a matter that affected all of us
    There is an insult to the state symbols of the Russian Federation

    Absolutely agree with you
    1. evgen1221
      evgen1221 2 February 2021 07: 55
      +1
      And your wife will not eat you for this, because she will lose the cooking guides, and the builders will not bury you? For the same reason (lack of guides for transferring experience) .Myah, he is such urapopulism.
      1. Stirbjorn
        Stirbjorn 2 February 2021 08: 34
        +3
        Quote: evgen1221
        And your wife will not eat you for this, because she will lose the cooking guides, and the builders will not bury you? For the same reason (lack of guides for transferring experience) .Myah, he is such urapopulism.

        Close ?! But what is there to waste time on trifles, immediately inflict a preventive nuclear strike! "The whole world is in dust" wassat
        1. The comment was deleted.
      2. Lipchanin
        Lipchanin 2 February 2021 09: 21
        -1
        Quote: evgen1221
        Opensource projects, eh, he is such urapopulism.

        This is not Ur patriotism, this is patriotism.
        And you can clearly explain to your wife that it's not about her cutlets, but about that. that in this way they insult Russia
        Your post reminds me of a recent story told on the site.
        41 years old, the beginning of the war. A truck arrives at the warehouse for shells. The warehouse is closed. It turns out that the warehouse manager has a day off
        1. evgen1221
          evgen1221 2 February 2021 10: 31
          -1
          What's stopping you from downloading the anthem and listening 24/7? On YouTube, howling from Khovansky due to the fact that, because of the anthem, he was cut off monetization from the video, and this is bucks. You need to understand. YouTube itself is full of contradictions to its own rules. One monetization for boobs of a counter character in the game is cut off (sekass is not allowed) But at the same time, on request tant yoga we contemplate porn.
    2. Lech from Android.
      Lech from Android. 2 February 2021 08: 15
      -1
      It is easy to close, but what we get in return. After all, there is no analogue of YouTube on Russian resources ... It turns out we will shoot ourselves in the foot.
      1. Lipchanin
        Lipchanin 2 February 2021 09: 23
        -2
        Quote: Lech from Android.
        It is easy to close, but what we get in return.

        You won't live without YouTube
        And in return, create something similar and everyone will go there.
        Russian-speaking
        1. evgen1221
          evgen1221 2 February 2021 10: 34
          -1
          No one will go there, Rutyub was, they won't pay at all, but why should a blogger who lives off commercials do it for free (live on what?) Rutyub didn't take off and died quietly.
  • Andy
    Andy 2 February 2021 07: 14
    +3
    but our medveps put a school teacher from the village for pirate software ...
  • safar gafarov
    safar gafarov 2 February 2021 07: 36
    0
    And who sold the rights to possession? It cannot be that they came and appropriated the content arbitrarily. If all the same, so to find out the origins of the scam and in court. Separately punish the one who sold everything and the Motherland and even her songs
    1. Lipchanin
      Lipchanin 2 February 2021 07: 46
      -4
      Quote: safar gafarov
      It cannot be that they came and appropriated the content without permission.

      They have everything there to make a mess of Russia
    2. rocket757
      rocket757 2 February 2021 07: 48
      +5
      Ha, how many times have they sold - bought, the same Eiffel Tower, and other national symbols !!!
      1. cniza
        cniza 2 February 2021 10: 05
        +3
        But she remained in Paris, and the National Anthem ...
        1. rocket757
          rocket757 2 February 2021 10: 30
          +2
          Quote: cniza
          and the National Anthem ...

          And our anthem is with US! They will suppress, in the end, from their cunning and insolence.
          1. cniza
            cniza 2 February 2021 10: 44
            +3
            They can't even imagine for a second how we don't give a damn about their claims ...
            1. rocket757
              rocket757 2 February 2021 10: 48
              +1
              Quote: cniza
              we don't care about their claims ...

              unfortunately, in the digital space, it is mainly they who rule. You will have to take this into account, or break everything ... in a splash and in half.
              1. cniza
                cniza 2 February 2021 10: 57
                +3
                Yes, but it seems to me that a solution can always be found ...
                1. rocket757
                  rocket757 2 February 2021 11: 26
                  +1
                  That's right, you can break EVERYTHING!
                  1. cniza
                    cniza 2 February 2021 11: 38
                    +3
                    Moreover, there is experience ...
                    1. rocket757
                      rocket757 2 February 2021 11: 39
                      +1
                      Let's see how it goes, come true.
                      1. cniza
                        cniza 2 February 2021 11: 41
                        +3
                        It seems to me that it is not difficult at all, you need to have a desire, and the goal is clear ...
    3. Horon
      Horon 2 February 2021 08: 58
      +3
      In the United States, they sell the surface of the moon, did someone sell it to them too?
      1. rocket757
        rocket757 2 February 2021 10: 29
        +2
        Quote: Horon
        In the United States, they sell the surface of the moon, did someone sell it to them too?

        Ha, movies about the Martians they shot to hell ... they will say that Mars they ALREADY RECOVERED! Colt and "a kind word".
  • Stirbjorn
    Stirbjorn 2 February 2021 07: 43
    -4
    It seems that the public is being prepared for the closure of YouTube. In general, I don't understand, what harm is there to a specific user from these machinations ?! They do not give the Russian anthem to listen to on YouTube, or are they forced to pay for listening ?! I enter in a search engine, no problem fellow Why is everyone bombing here ?!
    1. nsm1
      nsm1 2 February 2021 07: 52
      +2
      The Rutracker has been closed for many years, but the attendance has not suffered.
      All these "closings" are bypassed one line in the settings.
      Really one.
    2. Lech from Android.
      Lech from Android. 2 February 2021 08: 20
      0
      Bombs from bad presentiments ... You know ... This has never happened and now again. smile
  • 7,62x54
    7,62x54 2 February 2021 07: 44
    +2
    The Americans joined the fight against the Soviet legacy, waged by the so-called elite of Russia. They opened a "second front".
  • rocket757
    rocket757 2 February 2021 07: 46
    0
    Thus, it should be stated that American video hosting is actually trying to legitimize outright digital raiding or even piracy, while also encouraging it.

    The question is - what can you do with them?
    They just have to hang price tags on the solar system and cuckoo! "master" sir.
    1. Blackmokona
      Blackmokona 2 February 2021 07: 51
      +3
      Video hosting itself does not hang anything anywhere, such an occupation that is extremely harmful and costly for the storage itself.
      Copyright holders hang him, but where did they get their rights and why they shove the national treasure of Russia into the list of rights?
    2. cniza
      cniza 2 February 2021 10: 04
      +3
      Good time! hi

      Who should be doing this? it is not at what gate ... a digital war is coming.
      1. rocket757
        rocket757 2 February 2021 10: 22
        +2
        Quote: cniza
        a digital war is coming.

        Welcome soldier
        Any war consists of many, many episodes, small, large, all of them are important and cannot be lost there.
        1. cniza
          cniza 2 February 2021 10: 26
          +3
          hi

          Yes, otherwise the animal will creep up slowly but surely ...
          1. rocket757
            rocket757 2 February 2021 10: 37
            +2
            Now it depends ... on many reasons and people. But the fundamental, depends on the top and how WE will relate to this!
            1. cniza
              cniza 2 February 2021 10: 46
              +3
              Let's hope that in unison, so that they will get sick ...
              1. rocket757
                rocket757 2 February 2021 10: 49
                +1
                In unison, on the same wavelength, ALL TOGETHER!
                So be it.
                1. cniza
                  cniza 2 February 2021 10: 58
                  +2
                  And do not let our tops relax, otherwise they will quickly begin to rely on their laurels ...
  • evgen1221
    evgen1221 2 February 2021 07: 51
    +1
    Can't we privatize America's anthem in any way?
  • Boromir1941
    Boromir1941 2 February 2021 08: 01
    +1
    scribe, this is arrogance. can we privatize their entire defense industry? laughing
  • askort154
    askort154 2 February 2021 08: 03
    +3
    Our pro-Western "elite" is growing in the country like a cancerous tumor. There is an internal decay of the country, with an emphasis on the younger generation. Television does not carry culture and knowledge, but outright immoral filth. Moreover, the more it is in the plot, the longer it is kept on the air.
    They showed the new Minister of Education - a very young "protegeist", he read his first, 1 minute presentation on TV, from a piece of paper. We are losing in the information war not only due to the more powerful Western MEDIA, but also due to the internal, mediocre policy of educating the post-Soviet generation. Collecting a couple of thousand at the stadium and chanting - "we are together!", This is not enough for
    national unification of the generation. What to expect good from young people raised on the Internet and advertising garbage TV. We even have the president’s press secretary, he doesn’t like to speak to the camera, but mutters something obscure in the audio recording against the background of his photo.
  • Ros 56
    Ros 56 2 February 2021 08: 11
    +4
    I don’t understand, in the country that there are no IT specialists who would put all these masters of social networks in place? Call the hackers, pay the men, since they themselves are strained with brains. And then they are arrested over the hill and tried for breaking various secrets, but there is no work at home. Wonderful are your works, O Lord.
  • Mavrikiy
    Mavrikiy 2 February 2021 08: 17
    0
    The anthem of Russia on YouTube was "privatized" by an American company
    It's time to privatize YouTube in Russia. repeat
  • Cottodraton
    Cottodraton 2 February 2021 08: 21
    +1
    We must threaten them that all their rights and patents will not be valid on the territory of the Russian Federation. This is the most effective
    1. hhhhhhh
      hhhhhhh 2 February 2021 08: 29
      0
      Do you pay for movies on the Internet?
  • hhhhhhh
    hhhhhhh 2 February 2021 08: 29
    0
    The Bolsheviks are guilty and bloody slaughter, they did not register the rights.
  • prior
    prior 2 February 2021 08: 39
    +2
    "The anthem of Russia on YouTube was "privatized" by an American company"

    This means that we urgently need to privatize America in the Basmanny Court, together with YouTube, together with the company that privatized Anthem. And you can also privatize planet Earth.
    And that's it, the problem is solved.
  • nikvic46
    nikvic46 2 February 2021 08: 45
    +4
    "This helmet is of historical value for you. But for them it is just a piece of gold." By signing the copyright law, we will receive even less surprises. The owners have acquired the right to most of our art. And now it is not difficult to imagine that this owner has taken foreign citizenship. And all this is no longer ours. "Before entering the river, feel bottom".
  • Million
    Million 2 February 2021 09: 22
    +2
    Or maybe our young reformers sold the anthem?
  • cniza
    cniza 2 February 2021 10: 03
    0
    This is another example of how far the American digital giants have gone, considering themselves the right to dispose of not only user accounts, but also cultural and historical heritage, to which they themselves have nothing to do.


    And what to do with it, how to deal with it?
    1. Sands Careers General
      Sands Careers General 2 February 2021 12: 33
      +2
      Quote: cniza
      This is another example of how far the American digital giants have gone, considering themselves the right to dispose of not only user accounts, but also cultural and historical heritage, to which they themselves have nothing to do.


      And what to do with it, how to deal with it?

      Very simple. Raise a pood fist, twist the muzzle and poke the cracked Yankees into the American bottomless hawalnik.

      And it's high time to create your own platform for video hosting. And actively promote. Still nothing.
      1. cniza
        cniza 2 February 2021 14: 02
        +1
        Quote: Sands Career General

        And it's high time to create your own platform for video hosting. And actively promote. Still nothing.


        And to begin with, ask why they didn't start doing this earlier?
  • Gray-haired Zinnik
    Gray-haired Zinnik 2 February 2021 10: 50
    +1
    Ie, wiped off as always? You didn't even express concern? How miserable our foreign ministers have become ...
  • for
    for 2 February 2021 11: 44
    0
    Now downloaded, shared, etc. not any warnings
  • iouris
    iouris 2 February 2021 11: 55
    -1
    Who owns the song "Get up, the country is huge?"
  • Sands Careers General
    Sands Careers General 2 February 2021 12: 30
    +1
    Typical Americanism, no surprise.
    He stole, paid tax, and to the American tax service, she is still the mafia, as a result, everything is yours.
    Though the Russian anthem, even though the planet is in Alpha Centauri.
  • for
    for 2 February 2021 13: 06
    0
    I am sure that 146% of opponents of YouTube (as well as inst. Social networks) actively use them.
  • poquello
    poquello 2 February 2021 14: 58
    0
    it is YouTube that needs to be fined, since the rights of some American companies in Russia are up to 80cm to the floor of Vovochka's mother
  • APASUS
    APASUS 2 February 2021 15: 15
    0
    In this case, YouTube acts as a tool for incomprehensible offices.
    YouTube ends on the territory of the Russian Federation and the case will be solved in a couple of days!
  • Igor Polovodov
    Igor Polovodov 2 February 2021 15: 29
    0
    Litmus paper - how we react ...
    but in general in the information war all means are "good" ...
    for them...
  • gorunov
    gorunov 2 February 2021 16: 04
    0
    We must stop using this bad pipe.
  • Victor Tsenin
    Victor Tsenin 2 February 2021 18: 34
    0
    Nothing is said about the measures taken, the courts, etc. Are there no measures again?
  • MakStVik
    MakStVik 2 February 2021 20: 20
    +2
    I put a big bolt on them. I used cracked Windows and other software, and I will continue. And I won't pay these freaks! Let them continue to rage. Spit on them!
  • Diesel 72
    Diesel 72 4 February 2021 08: 44
    0
    Amer flag must be privatized