Former commander of a tank battalion of the Armed Forces of Ukraine: "Armata" is a tank with zero prospects

133

The Ukrainian press published an interview with the ex-commander of a tank battalion of the Armed Forces of Ukraine, a former Ukrainian military instructor (who worked abroad), Nikolai Salamha. He was called “one of the main Ukrainian experts in tank sphere ".

The main topic of the interview was devoted to “how Ukraine will resist Russian tanks”. Among other things, there was a conversation about how Ukrainian tankers to resist the Russian "Armata".



Question from Ukrainian reporters:

How should Ukraine respond to Russian T-72B3, T-90M and T-14 Armata tanks?

It is noted that over the past few years, Russia has sent significant funds to the modernization of tanks, considering armored units as the strike basis of the ground forces. It is pointed out that in addition to the development of the latest T-14 Armata tank, Russia is also betting on the modernization of Soviet developments in tank building.

Nicholas Salamakha, who was called an "expert", announced that "Russia does not have fundamental science, only Soviet fragments remained of applied science."

Ukrainian "expert":

As a result, the Armata is a tank with zero prospects.


Criticizing the T-14, which Salamakha, as they say, did not see in his eyes, he said that “Belarus was involved in the creation of these tanks in order to gain access to French technologies”.

Salamaha:

There is no engine for this vehicle, the cannon is not 152 mm, but 125 mm, the crew was moved inside the hull and called it an "armored capsule", although it is just a protected compartment. But the main question is sights and fire control system ...

It is the French technology of the fire control system, as this person believes, “Russia wanted to get through Belarus”.

According to the ex-battalion commander of the Armed Forces of Ukraine, in such conditions, Russia had to simultaneously focus on modernizing the T-72 tanks.

Salamaha:

The Russians were faced with the fact that the fire control system works, receiving data from a digital sight. Its failure leads to the fact that it is necessary to stop and turn on the backup control system - the main old 1A40-4 sight that they left behind. We faced this problem on BM "Oplot" and we understand that this must be overcome. And in the Russian Federation this is already a massive phenomenon, which is already in combat units.

To "confront" Russian tanks, according to this "expert", Ukraine must in a short time increase the accuracy of firing and target detection range on its tanks, then equip the T-64B, T-72AV and T-80B with a panoramic sight with a magnification of 12. But about the prospects for updating the Ukrainian tank arsenal, how different they are from zero, Mr. Salamakha did not say ...
133 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. +155
    24 January 2021 08: 26
    Administration of VO. How long can you voice the opinions of any idiots and enemies of our state?
    1. +39
      24 January 2021 08: 30
      Quote: 210ox
      Administration of VO. How long can you voice the opinions of any idiots and enemies of our state?

      Ukrainian experts are in abundance here.)) Put this expert under the tank and see if he has zero perspective or not.
      1. +9
        24 January 2021 13: 05
        Why would it be so cruel to suddenly die? feel put his blunt little head near the muzzle and bang a little like that, maybe at least the remnants of the brain will fall into place laughing
        1. +2
          25 January 2021 16: 08
          And you are some kind of sadist, my friend! laughing Do you remember how the Sepay brits were sent to their gods? Yes
      2. +10
        24 January 2021 15: 18
        Quote: XXXIII
        Put this expert under the tank and see if it has zero perspective or not.

        He will have a liquid perspective. And smelly.
        1. +3
          24 January 2021 17: 10
          Quote: Zoldat_A
          Quote: XXXIII
          Put this expert under the tank and see if it has zero perspective or not.

          He will have a liquid perspective. And smelly.

          All the nonsense will squeeze out at once.))
    2. +66
      24 January 2021 08: 30
      Yes let. The heading "humor" should be in every even serious mass media.
      1. +9
        24 January 2021 08: 35
        Only all these fabrications appear in the news section.
        1. +9
          24 January 2021 09: 16
          I agree with you, Dmitry. You can press, but in a separate section with the correct name, where you enter meaningfully. And in this form, it already starts to support.
          1. +7
            24 January 2021 10: 52
            Quote: zadorin1974
            You can squeeze, but in a separate section with the correct name, where you enter meaningfully. And in this form, it already starts to support.

            Create a heading "Obvious and Incredible, Pass By."
          2. +9
            24 January 2021 11: 39
            There is no engine for this vehicle, the gun is not 152 mm, but 125 mm

            They are there, in the land of not frightened idiots, they generally know that they cannot make cannons in their suburbs, but continue to modernize our old ones)
      2. +32
        24 January 2021 08: 40
        Quote: Crowe
        Yes let. The heading "humor" should be in every even serious mass media.

        By the way, I suggested for a long time news from Ukraine, as well as the opinions of various Ukrainian experts to be placed in a separate heading, such as "You can't think of it on purpose", or "Smiled", or something like that ...
        1. +4
          24 January 2021 09: 19
          Aha, "brothers addicts-fresh arrival" or "another quirk"
          1. 0
            24 January 2021 09: 36
            Quote: zadorin1974
            Aha, "brothers addicts-fresh arrival" or "another quirk"

            "Purely funny" laughing
            1. -2
              24 January 2021 10: 07
              Kind Sergei. Somehow trivial, "Purely funny" is closer to our thought))))
              1. 0
                24 January 2021 10: 41
                Hi hi
                Is there a difference? laughing
                1. 0
                  24 January 2021 10: 45
                  Yes, in percentage terms, we have less patients laughing
                  1. -1
                    24 January 2021 10: 57
                    I mean the quality of the statements laughing
        2. +1
          24 January 2021 17: 42
          or, News from the country of not frightened idiots ... fellow
      3. +4
        24 January 2021 11: 50
        Quote: Crowe
        Yes let. The heading "humor" should be in every even serious mass media.

        ========
        From the language removed! drinks For a long time already suggested to start on "VO" a section called "Humor"! Well, or - "Insanity" !!!
      4. +1
        24 January 2021 12: 21
        Many of us have something to share from the cycle "Army or police tales".
    3. +1
      24 January 2021 08: 33
      Quote: 210ox
      Former commander of a tank battalion of the Armed Forces of Ukraine: "Armata" is a tank with zero prospects

      darn we were scared ...
    4. +26
      24 January 2021 08: 34
      Come on. It's interesting! And imagine such infoy Ukrainians have been fed for decades, then a healthy person will already begin to doubt laughing
      1. +4
        24 January 2021 08: 38
        Not interesting at all. I understand this is a trend in our country. Here, look what boobies there are! But this already causes the gag reflex.
      2. +14
        24 January 2021 08: 57
        Quote: Cool but not Igor
        It is interesting!

        And it's even more interesting to read the reviews about the entoy article! It's interesting ... hi
        1. +4
          24 January 2021 09: 37
          Quote from Uncle Lee
          And it's even more interesting to read the reviews about the entoy article! It's interesting ...

          Yes, sometimes the article itself is much more boring than comments. laughing
    5. +18
      24 January 2021 08: 35
      He was called "one of the main Ukrainian experts in the tank field."

      Breshut! The main iksperd at Svidomo is a seventh-grader who built tanks from cardboard. Yes
      1. +10
        24 January 2021 08: 43
        Breshut! The main iksperd at Svidomo is a seventh-grader who built tanks from cardboard. yes

      2. +5
        24 January 2021 09: 39
        Quote: LIONnvrsk
        this is a seventh grader who built tanks out of cardboard.

        And taught adults laughing
        1. +1
          25 January 2021 09: 34
          Excellent. )))
    6. +7
      24 January 2021 08: 40
      We are waiting for the leader, when he tells us that the Ukrainians are not so stupid, and we laugh in vain.
      1. +3
        24 January 2021 10: 13
        Quote: Quadro
        We are waiting for the leader, when he tells us that the Ukrainians are not so stupid, and we laugh in vain.

        Are you saying that all Ukrainians are stupid? If yes, then what is your level of intelligence?
    7. +11
      24 January 2021 08: 42
      Quote: 210ox
      Administration of VO. How long can you voice the opinions of any idiots and enemies of our state?

      I consider it reasonable to introduce filtering by tags.
      For example, by blocking the tag "Ukraine", the user stops seeing all the materials with its mention.
      A similar thing is implemented on many sites. It would be useful here too.
    8. +8
      24 January 2021 09: 09
      winked Let them voice it. Is it bad? There is no "Humor" section. Even though we laugh so, we look at the fool.
    9. +1
      24 January 2021 10: 05
      Well, how nice it is to know different opinions
    10. -7
      24 January 2021 10: 06
      Quote: 210ox
      How long can one voice the opinions of any idiots and enemies of our state?

      Right. You only need to know the opinion of your friends. But where can I get them? And enemies can say something that we do not like, and therefore it is not necessary to know this opinion, so as not to inadvertently ruin the mood. How many adversaries scoffed at, say, "Admiral Kuznetsov", and all that was business was to nip these stories in the bud in order to maintain peace of mind. A specific proposal: let us continuously broadcast the songs "Armor is strong, and our tanks are fast", "You are lying, you are lying, Tsar of Germany", "The foreign adversary will be afraid of raising his pikes" - and that is quite enough.
      1. Urs
        +3
        24 January 2021 23: 01
        Well, why just friends and "friends" need to listen and hear. But normal technically competent specialists. And the fact that this type of expert expressed here is more like nonsense.
        About the sights and about the SUV in general, the car I saw in the picture and that of poor quality. Well, about the engine, well, yes, there was a problem, maybe there is, but I'm not sure about that. Back in 85, I saw an X-shaped motor at the stand of the ChTZ tank shop. And I even heard how it growls, and for this reason I do not believe that to this day we have not been able to solve all the problems of his "growing up".
        Ivot the surname of this esperd seems familiar to me, for a hike this is one of the Losers in the 88g KVTIU
    11. +1
      25 January 2021 15: 36
      Quote: 210ox
      How long can one voice the opinions of any idiots and enemies of our state?

      You need to know who has been "at war" with us for how many years.
    12. 0
      25 January 2021 17: 15
      The armor is strong, our cars are fast.
      And I changed one more machine gun for these pants
    13. 0
      27 January 2021 11: 34
      Good question, but as the proverb says: a crow will not gouge out a crow's eyes.
  2. PN
    +6
    24 January 2021 08: 28
    Why print thoughts out loud to such "experts"? Please do not litter the content.
    1. +2
      24 January 2021 08: 32
      Can I send the correspondent to the psychiatric hospital right away? Every day there will be material for printing!
      1. -6
        24 January 2021 10: 10
        Quote: ASAD
        Can I send the correspondent to the psychiatric hospital right away?

        Right. Send, Nikolay!
  3. +8
    24 January 2021 08: 35
    "Belarus was involved in the creation of these tanks in order to gain access to French technologies."
    You don't have to listen to this "expert" any further. The same Natsik, like the rest of the running screaming - we are at war with Russia, everyone I will win, Russia will be washed in blood, the Armed Forces of Ukraine are the strongest army in Europe, etc.
  4. -10
    24 January 2021 08: 42
    Yes, yes, just like that, shut up everyone's mouths so that they blow into our ears only about our "superiority" and do not destroy "tightness". Just like in the times of "these": "It's time to stop sabotage talk about replacing a horse with a machine!" ... Yes
    1. nnm
      +13
      24 January 2021 08: 56
      And then shut up? It's just one thing if they criticize on the case, with calculations, justification, and another thing is when you opened your mouth and rushed a stream of delusional consciousness.
      1. -4
        24 January 2021 10: 41
        Have you seen a lot of articles here with calculations, calculations, scientific justification? Not to mention the comments. At best, commentators say that they are expressing their own point of view, and there are no arguments as such.
        1. nnm
          +4
          24 January 2021 11: 30
          Yes many. Otherwise, the site would not have enjoyed such popularity. And you shouldn't be talking about the commentators. We love to laugh, but when a serious discussion begins, there are sure to be pros in many issues. And that's great. Look, for example, headings on weapons, history, etc.
  5. +8
    24 January 2021 08: 43
    Of course, against the armored flying saucers of Ukrainian production with vertical takeoff and landing at Armata, you yourself understand ... And if specifically, Armata's problems in financing the project and the economy.
    1. 0
      24 January 2021 10: 01
      Quote: tank64rus
      Of course, against the armored flying saucers of Ukrainian production with vertical takeoff and landing at Armata, you yourself understand ... And if specifically, Armata's problems in financing the project and the economy.

      There are problems with working hands, but the management has problems. And money has always been in the country, only the wrong mind is used.
  6. +12
    24 January 2021 08: 45
    Let this uncle tell what industry the USSR left to Ukraine, and what debris now remains of it
    There is nothing to blame on the mirror, if the mug is crooked.
  7. +3
    24 January 2021 08: 50
    Kharya is greasy, not an expert
    1. Zug
      +2
      24 January 2021 08: 56
      One might even say-STUGGED
  8. +8
    24 January 2021 08: 53
    It's great that there was censorship in the USSR.
    She protected our heads from ugliness, excesses and delirium.
    As soon as Gorbachev announced publicity, everything fell apart.
    And it is still pouring in. Confirmation of this is this article.
  9. Zug
    +2
    24 January 2021 08: 56
    They will soon switch to BT-7 and T-34 themselves, because their "fragments" of Soviet fundamental science were sold out and buried back in 90-20 years. Went to inspect your trash, there you have no business to do.
    1. +4
      24 January 2021 09: 43
      Quote: Zug
      They will soon switch to BT-7 and T-34

      Already preparing a transplant
      Hoopoe angry
  10. bar
    +5
    24 January 2021 09: 02
    The next nonsense from the crypt 404. Is there more to VO and nothing to write? negative
  11. +9
    24 January 2021 09: 06
    "Our person! He forgot to add that the T-14 is made of plywood! Now it is also being "found out" from plywood using French technology taken in Belarus.
    1. +1
      24 January 2021 10: 45
      Quote: Dmitry Potapov
      "Our person! He forgot to add that the T-14 is made of plywood! Now it is also being "found out" from plywood using French technology taken in Belarus.
      Is it from the same plywood that flew over Paris? lol
  12. +1
    24 January 2021 09: 10
    Interesting information, note. Now, if this ex was not an ex, but a fully functioning battalion commander, it would be half a trouble, but now we can conclude that a more sane commander is in command of the tank battalion instead.
  13. +2
    24 January 2021 09: 12
    Interestingly, this expert, hothotyaby in WOT has playing experience, or so just to yip nasty with a clever look
    1. +4
      24 January 2021 15: 25
      Quote: Petrograd
      Interestingly, this expert, hothotyaby in WOT has playing experience, or so just to yip nasty with a clever look

      The article already says "instructor" (who worked abroad). It is interesting - whom and where he "instructed" and what war his listeners won. I suspect he instructed the Georgians. There seems to be no one else ... Well, if only ISIS ...
  14. -2
    24 January 2021 09: 14
    Former commander of a tank battalion of the Armed Forces of Ukraine: "Armata" is a tank with zero prospects
    but we ourselves do not know him ... where do you come from?
  15. +1
    24 January 2021 09: 15
    The T-14 campaign will undergo tests right up to 2030 AD + another ten years to think about its future tank ..
  16. -20
    24 January 2021 09: 21
    It seems that the Ukrainian expert was still quite mildly expressed about the next cut of the project. All the main systems come from the USSR. In general, this whole gop company from the Ministry of Defense and the military-industrial complex will bring the country to the zugundera, there is no need for enemies. Peacekeepers in Karabakh drive a 2-year-old BMP-40 but with churches and Mercedes-Benz General de Russis everything is ok. We also have an excess of three-kopeck patriots ...
    1. -2
      25 January 2021 15: 22
      Obviously an emigrant from France. Comment va, mon vieux?
  17. +2
    24 January 2021 09: 26
    A creature with a drunken face and brains, making inarticulate sounds ...
  18. +1
    24 January 2021 09: 30
    And this is a misunderstanding. What technique does he serve? When it arrives at the bochin from Armata, then we'll talk.
  19. +2
    24 January 2021 09: 37
    Combat expert ... Well, yes, yes ...
  20. -1
    24 January 2021 09: 38
    Well, so far, the tank is not in service with the Russian Federation and it means there is nothing to discuss.
  21. -16
    24 January 2021 09: 43
    Quote: ximkim
    The T-14 campaign will undergo tests right up to 2030 AD + another ten years to think about its future tank ..

    I agree. T14, T50, Poseidons and other superweapons exist only on paper. And all the talk about them is about nothing.
    1. -2
      25 January 2021 10: 26
      Quote: well
      Poseidons and other superweapons exist only on paper

      Also from experts are coming out?
  22. +3
    24 January 2021 09: 55
    Uff ... well, how long can this "verbal diarrhea" be passed off as news ?! I don't even read such articles, I just go to look at the comments, sometimes it's funny wink
  23. +7
    24 January 2021 10: 12
    Yes Yes Yes. The song about the painted Crimean bridge is no longer relevant, you have to look for other topics for a similar motive ...
  24. +2
    24 January 2021 10: 16
    Yes, how much can you print on any nonsense ????
  25. +3
    24 January 2021 10: 28
    why put this slag here
  26. 0
    24 January 2021 10: 34
    panoramic sight with a magnification of 12
    well, yes, the most important thing was almost forgotten. He chief an expert on tanks, some kind of nounname.
  27. +2
    24 January 2021 10: 37
    Another "Maidan dreamer". And as always, he judges what he has not even seen.
  28. +2
    24 January 2021 10: 40
    Children in the sandbox will tell more interestingly about "Armata". Where does the opinion of this misunderstanding come from?
  29. +6
    24 January 2021 10: 46
    It remains only to ask the former battalion commander of the Armed Forces of Ukraine: "in which" boiler "did you serve?"
  30. +3
    24 January 2021 11: 53
    VSUShny expedition for 7 boilers?
    And nevertheless, from all the irons "" - you can only hear, ARMATA-Armata, why does it haunt the Western countries if it is not a problem for them.
  31. +2
    24 January 2021 11: 54
    Expedd never saw anything else laughing
  32. +7
    24 January 2021 12: 30
    This former battalion commander, the adviser does not understand where and from whom he is very suitable according to the maxim - he heard out of the corner of his ear, saw out of the corner of his eye, realized with a piece of his brain and already spoke in full language
  33. -4
    24 January 2021 13: 04
    One thing is not clear - why is all the text covered with stinging quotes? If we separate the author's personality from the meaning of the theses expressed by him and examine them soberly and objectively, then, for example, the thesis that “Russia does not have fundamental science, only Soviet fragments remained of applied science” will be quite true if we compare the level of development of science in general and production culture in particular with the USSR. The fact that the scientific and engineering industry has dramatically slid down is clearly visible in projects that are, as they say, developed from scratch, most of which are openly slipping. There is no point in talking about the Armata tank. Today such a tank does not exist. It will be possible to talk seriously about Armata after at least 0 tanks have entered the army, several years have passed, practical experience has been gained, after which it will be possible to draw the first conclusions about their real operational characteristics.
  34. +6
    24 January 2021 13: 25
    I'm thinking who's cooler? British scientists or Ukrainian ikspErd)))))))
  35. +3
    24 January 2021 13: 30
    Former commander of a tank battalion of the Armed Forces of Ukraine: "Armata" is a tank with zero prospects


    Sax-commander of the Bandera tank battalion of the Armed Forces of Ukraine: I am an asshole with zero potency, and carrying crap))

    Kombat Salom-mahal))
  36. +1
    24 January 2021 13: 43
    It's funny to see how some of the local staff still believe him.
  37. +4
    24 January 2021 15: 01
    Ukraine is a country with zero potential. We don't have to talk about tanks at all.
  38. +3
    24 January 2021 15: 41
    He works out his "silversmiths". I'm sure it's not even 30. What can this "ex-perD" say? A positive review? Come on .... from the territory of 404 this will not happen. And there is nothing to comment on.
  39. 0
    24 January 2021 17: 47
    Quote: UgoChaves
    Why would it be so cruel to suddenly die? ... put his blunt little head near the muzzle and bang a little so, maybe at least the remnants of the brain will fall into place laughing

    This is inhuman! Maybe it's easier, in the old fashioned way - a shot in the knee and a control shot in the head? ... do you? wink
    ... that's it! Then what is the bazaar about?
  40. 0
    24 January 2021 17: 58
    Quote: Zoldat_A
    "... instructor" (who worked abroad). I wonder who and where he "instructed" ...

    Um ... apparently in Poland, Moldovans, how cleaner to remove the push, so that the pan does not get into shit. lol
  41. +1
    24 January 2021 18: 10
    Of course, there is no prospect. All the Armats were burned in the Donbass. New ones cannot be riveted, there is no finance.
    And Navalny will win, so in general he will transfer technology to the nicest army in Europe so that they can better defend the eastern borders of European civilization.
  42. +3
    24 January 2021 18: 55
    Most of the problems in Ukraine are due to such expert Natsiks. First, fairy tales are told to raise spirits, how everything is heading with them, and among Muscovites, devastation and glass breakage. After that they themselves believe in it. As a result: and we are in favor of sho, but how is it ... rusia, and why Europe / USA did not help. Mriyali about the second France, but ended up in the most impoverished country in Europe without Crimea and Donbass.
  43. +2
    24 January 2021 20: 48
    A dull howl, nothing more. this person does not have oil in his brain.
    Those who have at least some notion understand everything perfectly!
    comments are not needed here!
  44. +1
    25 January 2021 00: 15
    An expert ... can voice anything ... there will never be a new tank on the "Ukraine". All ... KMDB and
    ZiM are living out their last years ... who could design are long gone, but for "Svidomo" no one will return ... so Read and Think.
  45. The comment was deleted.
  46. +2
    25 January 2021 01: 22
    There is a much terrible tool against them, which is in the first place in terms of slaughter. On the way of the tank, it is enough to throw a few rakes and three pitchforks onto the road. The tank drives up to the rake and gets one blow with a rake, from which the tankers fill the habitable space in the tank and it becomes uninhabited, the second hitting the tank loses the gun, it tries to break through and gets on the pitchfork, which it carefully removes from the tank tracks, which will come in handy on the farm. The crew has no choice but to raise their hands, if they can peel off their jobs, surrender. The tankers are led to the river to bathe, and the tank, throwing a match inside, is burned. Who needs tanks that are killed by a rake and a pitchfork. A cannon is a good thing in the economy. If the cannon is carefully screwed onto the ax handle, you get a coil for the moonshine still.
  47. -1
    25 January 2021 06: 15
    the main problem is that they do not know how to make thermal imagers
    and will agree with Belarus
    1. 0
      28 January 2021 05: 09
      In May 2018, the Ministry of Defense of the Russian Federation approved a document "On the procedure for introducing domestic-made thermal imaging cameras into sighting systems of T-72BZM, T-80BVM ..." products. The same problem was solved for other thermal imaging devices used in domestic military equipment ... We have chosen the average cost version of the domestic cooled matrix on indium antimonide (range 3-5 microns) with a resolution of 640x512 elements. Sights with such a thermal imaging module TPK-K are already used in mass production of armored vehicles

      https://t.me/s/Viktor_Murakhovskiy
      1. 0
        28 January 2021 08: 57
        not bad
        but it would be interesting to compare with Flir for example in contrast
  48. +2
    25 January 2021 08: 28
    Well, tell me, what's the point of publishing the opinion of the poor? Homeless people will soon be quoted.
  49. 0
    25 January 2021 09: 24
    The fabulist Krylov is immortal. Article "ukroeksperta" straight from the fable "Fox and grapes."
  50. +1
    25 January 2021 10: 23
    What are the reprints from the "yellow press". In Ukraine, any vuiko is an expert in all areas of knowledge. Better he will tell about the fate of the tank "Azovets", the public will be more interesting.
  51. 0
    25 January 2021 14: 33
    So, they killed all the Almaty back in 2014
  52. +1
    25 January 2021 15: 35
    "Armata" - a tank with zero prospects


    The Armata tank has only zero prospect of being destroyed by the Ukrainian Armed Forces.
  53. 0
    25 January 2021 15: 39
    The branch is lovely! When I worked in the ANDR in their school, I saw our T-34s, on which cadets from the tank department were having fun with RPG-7s. Well, the holes are really beautiful! Who knows why there are niches on the Armata tower?
  54. 0
    25 January 2021 18: 15
    Credit to us for the opinion of idiots.
  55. 0
    25 January 2021 20: 16
    damn...I love this kind of work.....if they also pay for it.....it’s probably better to just be the prosecutor of the Ukrainian Crimea and the like
  56. wow
    0
    25 January 2021 20: 29
    Your damn cow hasn't mooed yet!
  57. 0
    25 January 2021 20: 48
    Colleagues, did a revolution like the Maidan take place on the VO website?
    The admins from the nval-trench and the Maidanists made their way to the top?
    Some kind of uk..r. propaganda articles regularly with pseudo specialists.
  58. The comment was deleted.
  59. +1
    25 January 2021 21: 55
    The phrase “Ukrainian expert” is nonsense. Such words cannot be used together in the same context. Some kind of savagery.
  60. 0
    25 January 2021 22: 11
    “Fundamental science” It’s not clear, comrade, an expert in theorphysics, mathematics, or perhaps in historical and mathematical mathematics?
  61. -2
    25 January 2021 23: 13
    However, the fact that Armata actually has a lot of foreign components is not news. And this is precisely what determines the high cost of production and its vulnerability to various kinds of sanctions.
    1. +1
      26 January 2021 16: 23
      Please list foreign components.
      1. -1
        26 January 2021 22: 10
        Maybe it would be better for you to indicate the presence of domestic ones, since you are so in control of the situation that you know every component? )
        1. 0
          27 January 2021 04: 44
          That is, you have nothing to say. Q.E.D.
          1. -1
            27 January 2021 23: 04
            Well, so do you too, the great prover of empty empty spaces))
            The use of foreign components in Armata was often criticized in sources.
            1. 0
              28 January 2021 04: 47
              These are the kind of babbles that were criticized.
              1. 0
                30 January 2021 15: 27
                Is everything really localized there?
  62. -1
    26 January 2021 03: 36
    ***
    The armor is strong and our tanks are fast,
    And our people are full of courage
    Buryat tank crews are in formation,
    Sons of their great Motherland ...
    ***
  63. -1
    26 January 2021 07: 48
    Everything is true about the engine and the gun.
  64. 0
    26 January 2021 08: 16
    Who in the world cares about the opinion of Ukrainians?
  65. +1
    26 January 2021 09: 34
    Another idiot in the position of battalion commander, whose level is maximum control and knowledge of the performance characteristics of the T-64 tank, still made in the Soviet Union.
  66. -1
    26 January 2021 12: 41
    What did Salamaha say wrong?
    There is no scientific and experimental base - this is true
    key components france and china - true
    They were in a hurry and didn’t really think through the aiming system - true
    there is no 152mm gun, but there is a 125mm with shells that are very conditionally effective against NATO tanks - true.
    The price of the car due to foreign components is equal to a starship - true
    the PR associated with the armored capsule and a number of other solutions is also overdoing it, to put it mildly - it’s true
    You don’t have to be an expert here; these conclusions are accessible even to schoolchildren.
    Which is not true - he has no idea about the prospects of the project, he did not say a word that Armata is a stripped-down older project, i.e. There is a prototype that you can grow to very quickly if you wish.
    1. 0
      26 January 2021 16: 26
      What are the key components? The matrices and electronics are our own, although not serial.
      Serial domestic TPV matrices have already been used since last year for the T-72B3 and T-80BVM, if that happens.
      Do you have the name of specific parts and components?
  67. +1
    26 January 2021 18: 02
    ARMATA is not even in combat units of the Russian Armed Forces; the tank was released as an experimental batch and continues to be tested and corrected.
    How can this pea miracle know anything specifically important or secret...
  68. 0
    26 January 2021 19: 34
    Well, you can’t publish the opinions of inappropriate “experts” from Ukraine. This is not respecting yourself and your readers. But I’m old and had no idea that in Russia there is no science, neither fundamental nor applied. Thank you, the Ukrainian expert enlightened me....... And you can also attract experts from violent clients to mental dispensaries, they will generally tell about the fantastic progress in their defense industry. Just listen. Like rolling combined armor plates from cardboard and tin and building aircraft carriers with oars.
  69. The comment was deleted.
  70. 0
    27 January 2021 18: 15
    Or MAYBE there is no need to comment! After all, Ukraine is our country! No need to separate! Zelensky gained popularity in Russia in KVN and still makes people laugh!
  71. 0
    27 January 2021 20: 46
    “APU expert” sounds a bit wild.
  72. 0
    27 January 2021 21: 37
    My greatest fear was that these personnel would attack Donbass in winter. That's what they did last time. The steppes of Ukraine are flat, visibility during the day is 20-30 km. The T-72 is gassed, you can see it 10 km away. Sit and prepare a “Bassoon” or Corvette, there is still time for coffee.
    And they also comment on something and give ratings. I never try to offend the poor.
    I am oh dear editor, and I am writing to you about this.
  73. 0
    28 January 2021 04: 04
    As the “experts” are, so is the entire Armed Forces of Ukraine. It is no coincidence that teachers, mechanics and miners kicked their butts and would have reached Kyiv if not for Putin’s strange decision.
  74. 0
    28 January 2021 09: 17
    Just as a private judges the actions of a marshal, so does a battalion commander judge the prospects of a NEW tank!
    What kind of commander was he, how long and how was he? Well, most importantly, he, like all of us here, do not fully know MUCH about Armata... In general, he “pours water”, and in the direction he needs.
  75. +1
    28 January 2021 10: 27
    Why is he an ex-battalion commander? Why was he expelled from the Ukrainian Armed Forces? Who is he, a battalion commander, even a tank expert. Rave. What does he know about a tank that he has never seen and how can he talk about what he has not seen? Not long ago my son asked me a question that I couldn’t answer. I honestly told the child, “Son, I don’t know.”
  76. 0
    31 January 2021 08: 16
    A ha ha ha ha!