Military Review

HSE professor says Vladimir Putin is waging four wars

203

A book by the Russian historian and journalist, professor at the Higher School of Economics Sergei Medvedev, "Putin's Four Wars", dedicated to the Russian president, was published in France. The author of the book specializes in his research on post-Soviet stories our country.


He spoke about his book and his assessment of the activities and views of Vladimir Putin in an interview with the French edition of Le Figaro.

Sergei Medvedev's book consists of four parts. Each of them is dedicated to one of the "wars" waged by the Russian leader.

According to the author, Putin's first "war" is being fought over territorial space. The President considers one of his main tasks to compensate for the losses of Russia after the collapse of the USSR, which he calls the largest geopolitical catastrophe of the last century. The author compares Putin to a certain Moscow prince who collects Russian lands. He considers this approach to be the reason for the reunification of Crimea with Russia, which he himself calls "annexation", and the desire to unite with Belarus. Although the first steps in this direction are the proclamation of the Union State, made back in 1996, when not Putin at all was president, but Boris Yeltsin.

The second part of S. Medvedev's book is devoted to the "war of symbols". Here he cites as an example the unveiling of monuments, military parades at which “nuclear missiles are being dragged across Red Square,” the holding of the Olympics in Sochi. At the same time, the author of the book is sure that the awards of Russian athletes were won only due to the "massive use of doping." This says a lot about the author, as does his sensational statement at the time about the need to turn the Arctic into an "international territory", an "international reserve".

In the third part, he talks about Putin's struggle for a man, for an ordinary Russian citizen. S. Medvedev believes that the country's authorities are rudely interfering with the private life of people, trying to impose consumer and even sexual preferences on them.

Putin's fourth "war" is for memory. This was especially evident, in the opinion of the HSE professor, during the celebration of the 75th anniversary of the victory of the USSR in the Great Patriotic War. He believes that Victory has been turned into a religion in Russia. In his opinion, the desire of the authorities to present the country's history as a series of continuous victories is due to their inability to build a future for their citizens.

Medvedev concludes that Putin is a retrograde rivalry leader and a bad politician:

Spies make bad politicians, and Putin is still a KGB officer on a secret mission.

The historian sees opposition blogger Alexei Navalny as the only alternative to the current president, but doubts that he will return to Russia. Although today in the NYT it was announced that Navalny, who "felt better," was ready to return to Russia, but he opposed a joint (Russian-German) investigation into the "poisoning" case.
Photos used:
Russian President's website
203 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must to register.

I have an account? Sign in

  1. Livonetc
    Livonetc 15 September 2020 09: 55 New
    83
    HSE does not correspond to a higher educational institution, in the normal sense.
    It is rather a club of those crawling thirsty for the cherished feeders.
    Actually, the level of education there is questionable.
    More shop of vanity and corruption than a university.
    1. Zoldat_A
      Zoldat_A 15 September 2020 10: 16 New
      50
      Quote: Livonetc
      HSE does not correspond to a higher educational institution, in the normal sense.

      When will this stinking liberal rat's nest in full force be sent to cut down the forest? Some kind of hostile breeding ground. Gathered there a liberal get-together and shit on American manuals. And to listen to Sergei Medvedev - you will not respect yourself or your country. for example
      In an amicable way, Russia, as a failed and irresponsible host, has the Arctic to be taken away and put under international jurisdiction, like Antarctica, with a total ban on economic and military activities.
      Well I got a comment at the highest level
      Russian President Vladimir Putin, speaking to the heads of the United Russia branches, called Sergei Medvedev in front of the microphones "an idiot" and spoke in favor of expanding the Russian presence in the Arctic, and called the proposal to place it under the control of the international community, expressed earlier by Medvedev, "complete stupidity." as well as "unpatriotic" and "anti-popular"
      To which S. Medvedev reacted in a purely liberal style
      On his Facebook, Medvedev responded to the president's statement as follows: "I take personal insult to Putin as a reward." He stated that military activities, natural resource extraction, commercial fishing and transit commercial shipping should be abandoned in the region.
      As I understand it, he is calling for the abandonment of RUSSIAN "military activities, extraction of natural resources, commercial fishing and transit commercial shipping." The rest can.

      To choke with smelly socks such liberals, the Higher School of Economics in general and S. Medvedev in particular.
      1. Temples
        Temples 15 September 2020 10: 21 New
        17
        In the process of human activity, shit appears.
        In the process of life of our state, a whole institution of shit has appeared.

        Why not post shit interviews on this site?
        1. Zoldat_A
          Zoldat_A 15 September 2020 10: 24 New
          12
          Quote: Temples
          In the process of life of our state, a whole institution of shit has appeared.

          From one sharashkin office the stench goes all over the country. We need to do something about it ... am
          1. Tatyana
            Tatyana 15 September 2020 10: 46 New
            28
            The HSE is the blacksmith of the administrative staff of the pro-Western colonial liberalism in the Russian Federation. It was created by Gaidar with the money allocated to him by the West / USA.
            If we want a normal future for Russia and for the peoples living in it, the HSE must be closed, and its graduates' diplomas must be declared invalid in Russia.
            By the way, Nabiulina and her husband, the rector of the Higher School of Economics, will also get here.
            1. Arthur73
              Arthur73 15 September 2020 10: 53 New
              +4
              But who will do it and when? Apparently, there are no interested parties yet, despite the clearly anti-Russian position of some of its members.
            2. Alexey Sommer
              Alexey Sommer 15 September 2020 11: 08 New
              -5
              Quote: Tatiana
              HSE is the blacksmith of the administrative staff of the pro-Western

              And let's discuss the article in essence?
              1. The first war for the succession of the USSR. I think our leaders are losing it. the most striking example is Ukraine. Do not agree? .. Argument with words, not the "-" button.
              2. War of symbols .. I would look at it through modern Russian cinema ...
              A pitiful sight, you can't look without tears .. Basically, of course, there are exceptions, but they are few.
              3. You don't need to talk about an ordinary Russian citizen .. I think everyone understands everything after the pension reform ..
              4. Victory is sacred, there's nothing to say here ..
              Are we counting points? 3: 1 is not in our favor.
              Question..
              Does the president really play for our team?
              1. dragy52rus
                dragy52rus 15 September 2020 11: 36 New
                +6
                your thesis is correct, assuming that it really is. it is difficult to refute a false thesis submitted as an axiom.
                1. who said this war exists? And if we talk about Ukraine, then everything began much earlier. the economy of the Russian Federation was initially tied to the countries that were once part of the USSR. and there is no getting away from it.
                2. why cinema? What's wrong with opening monuments? Why is the Russian Federation Olympiad evil, but good in other countries?
                3.Now the echo of the 90s. those who were not born in the 90s are not giving birth now. where will the able-bodied population come from? why raising the retirement age in other countries is the norm, and in the Russian Federation is evil?
                1. Alexey Sommer
                  Alexey Sommer 15 September 2020 11: 42 New
                  -7
                  Excellent) Let's go in order.
                  Quote: dragy52rus
                  it is difficult to refute a false thesis submitted as an axiom.

                  Quote: dragy52rus
                  1. who said this war exists?

                  About this article isn't it? And indeed it is. Are you saying there are Elves walking around the lawn picking flowers?) I don't think so ..
                  Quote: dragy52rus
                  2. why cinema? What's wrong with opening monuments?

                  What monuments do you specifically mean? Let's say I immediately remembered about the Yeltsin Center .. Not a subject for pride ..
                  Quote: dragy52rus
                  3.Now the echo of the 90s. those who were not born in the 90s are not giving birth now. where will the able-bodied population come from? why raising the retirement age in other countries is the norm, and in the Russian Federation is evil?

                  What country do you mean specifically, as an approximate one? Ukraine?..
                  I'm looking up to Holland or Germany .. They want to introduce a 4-day working week.
                  1. dragy52rus
                    dragy52rus 15 September 2020 11: 52 New
                    +6
                    Quote: Alexey Sommer
                    I'm looking up to Holland or Germany.

                    Germany is 65/65 years old, in Russia it will be 65/60. what
                    1. Alexey Sommer
                      Alexey Sommer 15 September 2020 11: 55 New
                      -6
                      OK. Let's make 70?
                      Why do you like to retire later? Can you explain?
                      1. dragy52rus
                        dragy52rus 15 September 2020 12: 02 New
                        -1
                        let's not fantasize. let's dwell on what is and will not get personal. Why is 65 in Germany good, while in Russia 65 and 60 are bad?
                      2. Alexey Sommer
                        Alexey Sommer 15 September 2020 12: 12 New
                        +2
                        Because it was better than it was.
                        So see?
                      3. dragy52rus
                        dragy52rus 15 September 2020 12: 22 New
                        +3
                        not. this is from the category when I was small the trees were higher and the sky was bluer.
                        before Putin I had no children, now they are. Putin helped me.
                        before Putin I had no illnesses, now I have. it is Putin's fault.
                        this is your logic. everything has prerequisites and reasons. how to overcome the demographic hole of the 90s?
                        Germany is the standard for you and the age there for men is the same, what's wrong with being like the standard?
                      4. Alexey Sommer
                        Alexey Sommer 15 September 2020 12: 25 New
                        -4
                        Quote: dragy52rus
                        it is difficult to refute a false thesis submitted as an axiom.

                        You wrote this very correctly.

                        Quote: dragy52rus
                        before Putin I had no children, now they are. Putin helped me.

                        Do not be absurd.
                        By God ..)
                      5. dragy52rus
                        dragy52rus 15 September 2020 12: 31 New
                        +2
                        I showed you that you are taking it to the point of absurdity.
                        Why is 65 in Germany good, while in Russia 65 and 60 are bad?
                      6. Yves762
                        Yves762 15 September 2020 13: 34 New
                        +3
                        Because in the conditions of the Russian Federation, a pensioner is not equal to a German pensioner in terms of "quality" (the sum of functions) of the "life span" (to the Medvedev government, Hello! laughing ) .; and will not be equal either at 65, or at 70, or at ... after ... "survival" repeat
                        And the point is not in the mythical influence of demographic pits (the events of the first half of the twentieth century are an abyss altogether, and nevertheless ...), but in the "quality" of the personnel of the Russian government.
                      7. Dart2027
                        Dart2027 15 September 2020 19: 13 New
                        +1
                        Quote: Yves762
                        (the events of the first half of the twentieth century are generally an abyss, and nevertheless

                        Firstly, then there were no contraceptives, and secondly, there was a time when abortion was legally prohibited, so they gave birth.
            3. Zoldat_A
              Zoldat_A 15 September 2020 12: 15 New
              +7
              Quote: Alexey Sommer
              OK. Let's make 70?
              Why do you like to retire later? Can you explain?

              Quote: dragy52rus
              let's not fantasize. let's dwell on what is and will not get personal. Why is 65 in Germany good, while in Russia 65 and 60 are bad?

              Believe it or not - for example, I don't care what time I personally retire. It is still impossible to live on a pension, to support a house, a family. As long as I walk, move, think, I will work. My father created a family business, put half of his life on it, worked to the last, until he collapsed. And I am destined to do the same. And there is someone to transfer the case to. I don’t count on the state handout in the form of a pension, and therefore the increase in the retirement age does not seem to concern me personally. Anyway, I can't just sit at the window at home.
            4. Alexey Sommer
              Alexey Sommer 15 September 2020 12: 19 New
              -1
              Quote: Zoldat_A
              Do not believe me - for example, I don't care,

              Probably you won't believe it, but I won't believe it ..
              Firstly, not everyone can do it as you do.
              Secondly, I think you have relatives besides your father who would like to retire.
              Well, thirdly
              Quote: Zoldat_A
              I don’t count on the state handout in the form of a pension, and therefore the increase in the retirement age does not seem to concern me personally.

              Sorry .. But people are not judged by themselves. hi
            5. Zoldat_A
              Zoldat_A 20 September 2020 00: 52 New
              0
              [quote = Zoldat_A] I don’t count on a government donation in the form of a pension, and therefore the increase in the retirement age does not seem to concern me personally. [/ quote]
              Sorry .. But people are not judged by themselves. hi[/ quote] And I don't judge by myself. Just independence from the state handout in the form of a pension you need to earn. hi I just earned it. I didn’t sell it, I bought it, I didn’t steal it, I privatized it, I rolled it back. It just worked. And no one bothers anyone and does not bother to make money - the construction market is large, there will be enough space and work for everyone. My father, too, did not immediately become the general director and owner of the company - a lieutenant colonel, a military pensioner, worked as an auxiliary at a construction site. And I didn’t replace my father right away - I waved my spade to my heart's content, and shook my way around the country on business trips. AND sitting in an office or in an office and then wondering why the pension is good, but small is the easiest way.
          2. Rage66
            Rage66 19 September 2020 17: 22 New
            +1
            As long as you walk ... this is so for everyone. But what if you can't walk and don't die?
            Thinking about it?
          3. Zoldat_A
            Zoldat_A 20 September 2020 00: 42 New
            +1
            Quote: Rage66
            As long as you walk ... this is so for everyone. But what if you can't walk and don't die?
            Thinking about it?

            I thought. There are children, nephews, grandchildren, since the children are properly brought up. And most importantly - there is WHAT to carry the pots for me. And when there is something, then to WHOM to carry - the problem is secondary.
          4. Rage66
            Rage66 20 September 2020 09: 34 New
            +1
            The position is clear and logical ... This is what my friend thought and said ... And when he fell ill, there was something and to whom to carry the pots.
            But they fumbled a little and got tired ... It's easier to help get to heaven
    2. Siberian54
      Siberian54 16 September 2020 15: 19 New
      0
      At least because at the time of the adoption of the law in KRASNOYARSK REGION, the AVERAGE LIFE EXPANSION for men WAS 65,6 YEARS !!!!! TRAM !!! there!!!! THERE"""
    3. Rage66
      Rage66 19 September 2020 17: 13 New
      0
      Dear, you have outdated information ... In Germany, 67 and this is bad in the opinion of the Germans (I spoke personally) ... But it is clear there that the Arabs need to be supported ... And who should be supported with us? It's simple - the ideal citizen should work until 65, retire and die ... So good. And when I worked until 60, I went out and died it's bad ... And nothing personal wassat
  • Alexander Chirukhin
    Alexander Chirukhin 15 September 2020 12: 00 New
    +2
    I equate in Russian
    1. Alexey Sommer
      Alexey Sommer 15 September 2020 12: 04 New
      -4
      Thank you, but in essence?
  • dragy52rus
    dragy52rus 15 September 2020 11: 53 New
    +4
    Quote: Alexey Sommer
    About this article isn't it? And indeed it is. Are you saying there are Elves walking around the lawn picking flowers?) I don't think so ..

    what are you talking about now? the stream of consciousness could not master.
    1. Alexey Sommer
      Alexey Sommer 15 September 2020 11: 58 New
      -1
      In general, I'm talking about territories .. For which, according to your words, there is no war.
      And how! The whole history of mankind is about this.
      Vladimir. Do you understand me now?
      1. dragy52rus
        dragy52rus 15 September 2020 12: 04 New
        +4
        wars are for markets and resources. by elves, you mean the United States, which brings democracy where there is material benefit?
      2. Alexey Sommer
        Alexey Sommer 15 September 2020 12: 06 New
        -1
        Quote: dragy52rus
        by elves you mean the USA,

        Not. by elves, I mean those who believe that wars are not being fought over territories now.
      3. dragy52rus
        dragy52rus 15 September 2020 12: 12 New
        -2
        for which territories is the war going on now?
      4. Alexey Sommer
        Alexey Sommer 15 September 2020 12: 15 New
        +5
        Listen, Vladimir .. I can hardly restrain myself from the transition of personality ..
        Where do you live, on Mars or what?
        Donbass for example, as a piece of Ukraine, is a vivid example.
        There are tons of less bright ...
        Yes, in general for the legacy of the USSR. Truth has been pissed away already basically, but not yet completely.
      5. dragy52rus
        dragy52rus 15 September 2020 12: 28 New
        -2
        going personal is not only an insult.
        in Ukraine there is an ordinary civil war, which is no different from others like they were and what they are now. civil wars are not for territory.
        so what territories is the war going on now?
      6. Alexey Sommer
        Alexey Sommer 15 September 2020 12: 31 New
        +2
        Quote: dragy52rus
        so what territories is the war going on now?

        I understood. Do you like being fed?
        This is very thick Vladimir. )
      7. dragy52rus
        dragy52rus 15 September 2020 12: 35 New
        -1
        again you attribute your actions to me. read the definition of civil war and see what is now in Ukraine, especially who is being exchanged for whom.
        so what territories is the war going on now?
      8. bayard
        bayard 15 September 2020 14: 23 New
        +5
        Vladimir, do you really think the way you write?
        Or is this your job?
        Is there a civil war or foreign intervention in Syria?
        Or a combination of both?
        Are the troops of the USA, England, Turkey, before France and Germany present on its territory?
        So what is this war for?
        For the sales market?
        For resources?
        Or for a TERRITORY, which is both a market and a resource (to wire pipelines, to shake a little oil ...)?
        Why are the same USA and Turkey SO holding on to TERRITORY? In Syria?
        And in Ukraine?
        Is it a purely civil war there?
        Didn't foreign special forces and PMCs from several jurisdictions take part in the coup and on the Maidan?
        And didn't these PMCs and special forces of several NATO countries fought in the Donbas?
        Weren't 11 Apache helicopters based at the previously abandoned airfield in Mayskoye? Was there a secret base in Gvardeyskoye (Dnepropetrovsk region)?
        Are not their combat and reconnaissance aircraft flying over the territory of the "Square"?
        And isn't it based there periodically?
        Is there a purely internal conflict in Belarus?
        Poland, Lithuania, Ukraine, England, Germany, USA and other well-wishers ... definitely have nothing to do with it?
        Do they not finance, do not send in, do not hide, do not blackmail, do not clatter their armor at the borders?
        So in Belarus, this is a war for markets lol , or for the territory and everything, even in it?
        Crimea Russia returned as a market? smile
        Or as territory?

        So do not pour nonsense on the manual, it looks dull and not smart.
        Keeping territories under control is now accepted through control of markets, finance and elites. And through the same tools to pump out the resource.
        But all these resources are located on the TERRITORIES, for which they are going, and going, will go - WARS.
      9. hydrox
        hydrox 15 September 2020 19: 53 New
        +3
        Quote: bayard
        Crimea Russia returned as a market?
        Or as territory?

        I returned it, as YOUR territory, illegally seized.
        But not a market at all, since the investments made in Crimea by Russia over the years are unlikely to pay off in the next quarter of a century, and taking into account the fact that funds continue to pour in there, even half a century will not be enough.
        But that's only when it comes to funds and markets.
        In principle, the return itself, as a fait accompli, is priceless for us, no matter what the liberda and others like her squeal ...
      10. Snail N9
        Snail N9 16 September 2020 13: 20 New
        +2
        Look how it is, Mikhalych ... Subject, it turns out already! four wars! Now it is clear why the country and its people (with the exception of the herd chomping at the state feeder) are in deep ass and hopelessness - he has no time to deal with the country, he has to fight on four fronts ...
        And yes, well done dude from the Higher School of Economics knows how to competently and subtly lick ... yes
    2. your1970
      your1970 17 September 2020 07: 27 New
      0
      Quote: bayard
      Is there a civil war or foreign intervention in Syria?
      Or a combination of both?
      Are the troops of the USA, England, Turkey, before France and Germany present on its territory?
      So what is this war for?
      For the sales market?
      For resources?
      Or for a TERRITORY, which is both a market and a resource (to wire pipelines, to shake a little oil ...)?

      Based on your position, no Civil War exists in nature, in principle ...
      Neither ours - where there were a bunch of invaders, nor the American, where there were advisers from other states, nor the Spanish ...
      You have fun with history, however ... Nations cut each other from ideological beliefs - and it turns out that the territory was divided ...
    3. bayard
      bayard 17 September 2020 10: 44 New
      0
      Quote: your1970
      The peoples cut each other out of ideological convictions, and it turns out that territories were divided ..

      So all the ideas are just about who owns the territory and its resource to develop.
      And there are no civil wars without external interests. Do not help the Entente Denikin and Wrangel, and the United States and so on. Kolchak, how long would the civil war last?
      If most of the General Staff was on the side of the Reds?
      And from a third to a half of the officers.
      And as soon as the supply of food and ammunition to Kolchak was stopped, then his front collapsed. All the way to Primorye.
      This is a little for you to assess the role of interventionists and foreign curators in civil conflicts.
      Quote: your1970
      Based on your position, no Civil War exists in nature, in principle ...

      By no means, there are enough of them at the present moment in history, but almost any civil conflict is a foreign interested person. And as an example to you, even the French, even all the Russians, even the history of the Syrian conflict, Iraq, Egypt, Libya, the coup and the civil war in the former Ukraine, disorder in Belarus.
  • dragy52rus
    dragy52rus 15 September 2020 12: 29 New
    -1
    Quote: Alexey Sommer
    Truth has been pissed away already in the main, but not yet completely.

    Are you talking about polymers or the nuclear industry now?
  • hydrox
    hydrox 15 September 2020 19: 44 New
    -2
    They said nonsense: there is a civil war going on in Donbass not for the territory, but for the destruction (or expulsion) of the Russian-speaking ethnic group, which has been living in this territory from time immemorial.
    Therefore, the territory will only be a PRIZE for the winning side.
  • Rage66
    Rage66 20 September 2020 09: 31 New
    0
    A striking example is Belarus ... Here you have both resources and a sales market, like China
  • dragy52rus
    dragy52rus 15 September 2020 11: 56 New
    +2
    Quote: Alexey Sommer
    What monuments do you specifically mean? Let's say I immediately remembered about the Yeltsin Center .. Not a subject for pride ..

    why cinema? do not answer questions to a question.
    1. Alexey Sommer
      Alexey Sommer 15 September 2020 12: 02 New
      -1
      Quote: dragy52rus
      why cinema? do not answer questions to a question.

      You just amaze me))) Well, for example, because "Of all the arts, cinema is the most important for us" "for example ..
      My question was about a specific monument. I gave you an example. And you did not answer my question.
      1. dragy52rus
        dragy52rus 15 September 2020 12: 11 New
        -3
        This is not an answer. it is an attempt to turn the conversation into another direction.
        at the opening of the monument everyone stood and spat at it? Or was it a positive moment for someone? for a part of the population this is a positive moment.
        so why movie?
      2. Alexey Sommer
        Alexey Sommer 15 September 2020 12: 29 New
        +2
        Quote: dragy52rus
        so why movie?

        For you, cinema is not important .. I get it.
        What is your example of Putin's victory in the war for symbols?
      3. dragy52rus
        dragy52rus 15 September 2020 12: 37 New
        -2
        Quote: Alexey Sommer
        What is your example of Putin's victory in the war for symbols?

        it is in your head Putin is waging a war for symbols. how can I give an example of something that exists only in your head?
      4. Alexey Sommer
        Alexey Sommer 15 September 2020 13: 47 New
        +1
        Quote: dragy52rus
        Quote: Alexey Sommer
        What is your example of Putin's victory in the war for symbols?

        it is in your head Putin is waging a war for symbols. how can I give an example of something that exists only in your head?

        Vladimir! Re-read the article again. And you are very good at posing as the opposite of an intelligent person. good
  • Piramidon
    Piramidon 15 September 2020 12: 32 New
    +2
    Quote: dragy52rus
    What's wrong with opening monuments?

    It depends on what monuments. What good is the opening of monuments to the traitors and accomplices of the fascists?
    https://proza.ru/2014/05/06/1865
    1. dragy52rus
      dragy52rus 15 September 2020 12: 40 New
      +1
      are these monument now? where exactly did they open geographically?
      the article is a common manipulation.
  • frog
    frog 15 September 2020 12: 06 New
    -1
    Does the president really play for our team?

    What, however, cynical questions do you ask?))) Is he alone? That is, all the others here are mimoprohodily ??? Well, if, suddenly (Hottabych is there, what a gilded crucian))), they start for the country .... to please ..... Are you sure that society will like it ....? Well, or to the electorate ??)))
    1. Alexey Sommer
      Alexey Sommer 15 September 2020 12: 08 New
      0
      Quote: frog
      What, however, cynical questions do you ask?))) Is he alone?

      Duc is an ancient question, like the poop of a mammoth ..
      "The king is good, the boyars are bad" ..
      1. frog
        frog 15 September 2020 12: 10 New
        0
        Duc, after all, is the answer of a comparable age category ...
  • Mariana Poladashvili
    Mariana Poladashvili 16 September 2020 23: 00 New
    0
    Whose team do you play with?) Is it Medvedev?
  • your1970
    your1970 17 September 2020 07: 16 New
    0
    Quote: Alexey Sommer
    Does the president really play for our team?

    If he played against - he would be praised like EBNa.
  • Doliva63
    Doliva63 15 September 2020 18: 13 New
    +3
    Well, let's close the HSE - what will change in the country? Will the results of loans-for-shares auctions be canceled? Will Capitalism Be Abolished? No, after all. And while we are playing with them on the "same field", they will squeeze all the juice out of the country - with or without HSE.
    1. hydrox
      hydrox 15 September 2020 20: 05 New
      +1
      Incorrect approach, almost Trotskyist :: GuVSHey is a forge of personnel for the authorities (together with the RAS HIGS), that is, officials and functionaries, and for the pseudo-elite (after all, sixes and infantry are always needed.
      Yes, they will begin to besiege Yale and Oxford to replace the "educated", but they will not be able to completely replace the losses.
      On the other hand, there are also problems, because there are absolutely no NONLiberdyan universities in Russia - so the GDP is forced to pick up something that was not useful for the rank and file and the pseudo-elite - also nothing good - there is no one to retrain and nowhere.
  • Andrey Yves
    Andrey Yves 15 September 2020 20: 10 New
    +2
    Gaidar would not have had enough intelligence to create HSE, this is also a gift from Andropov.
  • Zhan
    Zhan 15 September 2020 22: 40 New
    0
    Quote: Zoldat_A
    Quote: Temples
    In the process of life of our state, a whole institution of shit has appeared.

    From one sharashkin office the stench goes all over the country. We need to do something about it ... am

    hi
    No no, let them be. Otherwise we will strangle everyone, we will not know what is going on in the rear. And so there, they write books, swear loudly. And we listen and shake our heads about who came there to the HSE, why, with what intentions. These idiots give themselves up with giblets.
  • The comment was deleted.
  • Lipchanin
    Lipchanin 15 September 2020 10: 49 New
    11
    Quote: Temples
    In the process of human life, shit appears

  • tihonmarine
    tihonmarine 15 September 2020 10: 52 New
    +5
    Quote: Temples
    Why not post shit interviews on this site?

    Yes, he even writes his libels not in the Russian press, but told in an interview with the French edition of Le Figaro. People like S. Medvedev work for the West and West, where they will be approved and understood. They receive grants not from Russia, but from the West.
    1. figwam
      figwam 15 September 2020 11: 09 New
      +3
      Quote: tihonmarine
      Such as S. Medvedev, work for the west and west,

      Such pseudo-professors are created to fight against our country for Western money, like a professor, ah.
    2. Lipchanin
      Lipchanin 15 September 2020 11: 13 New
      +6
      Quote: tihonmarine
      Such as S. Medvedev, work for the west and west,

    3. hydrox
      hydrox 15 September 2020 20: 11 New
      +2
      Well, so someone is lucky, but someone is not very lucky: if in Russia the GDP promised long ago, but did nothing in terms of social reform of the economy, then what good word can you praise it? (True, he still has two weeks, but it is very doubtful that Belousov will be in time with the final copy of the reform plan ...)
  • Nevolnik
    Nevolnik 15 September 2020 10: 27 New
    10
    Quote: Zoldat_A
    To choke with smelly socks such liberals, the Higher School of Economics in general and S. Medvedev in particular.

    Igor agrees! The better for Russia, the more the howl rises down with, etc ... How they are still tolerated in Russia .. In the United States, they would have closed it long ago, for undermining statehood for such opuses.
    And HSE is the aspen nest of the State Department and other special services of Western
    1. Zoldat_A
      Zoldat_A 15 September 2020 10: 33 New
      +6
      Quote: Nevolnik
      The United States would have closed it long ago for undermining statehood for such opuses.

      In "the most democratic democracy of all democracies," and for much smaller mischiefs, you can be shocked not like a child. Only they firmly remember the most, in their opinion, democratic principle - "Quod licet Jovi, non licet bovi". Naturally, they put themselves in the role of Jupiter. Well, and the rest of the world ... Well, how will it turn out ...
      1. Nevolnik
        Nevolnik 15 September 2020 10: 45 New
        +2
        Quote: Zoldat_A
        In "the most democratic democracy of all democracies," and for much smaller mischiefs, you can be shocked not like a child.

        Don't say Igor! In the west, only exes begin to reason more or less adequately, and then with an eye .. Sometimes it’s even funny to look at this "crap" that dance to the same tune .. But in our country they throw mud at everything they can and they even pay huge grants for this .. Now, thank God, these NGOs have shrunk the mute.
        1. Zoldat_A
          Zoldat_A 15 September 2020 10: 46 New
          +5
          Quote: Nevolnik
          Now, thank God, these NGOs have shrunk a little.
          Do not press them - you need to PLANT.
          1. Nevolnik
            Nevolnik 15 September 2020 10: 57 New
            +4
            Quote: Zoldat_A
            Quote: Nevolnik
            Now, thank God, these NGOs have shrunk a little.
            Do not press them - you need to PLANT.

            It's easy to say, if Ephraim was already in prison and what a howl ...
            1. Zoldat_A
              Zoldat_A 15 September 2020 11: 46 New
              +5
              Quote: Nevolnik
              It is easy to say that if Ephraim was already in prison and what a howl was

              Not the topic of the article - except perhaps to recall Makarevich and Akhedzhakova. But was Efremov imprisoned for his convictions? Has committed a criminal offense - sat down. In any other country, isn't it? I do not understand the liberal howl about Efremov. Only now it is not clear - how the liberals also did not fasten Efremov to the "Nord Stream"?

              In our cottage village, the caretaker Stepanich is always moderately screwy, loyal to all branches of government. As a superfluous sign, above the usual rate, swearing ditties sings and scolds everyone - from the chairman of the village government to the President. It's good that no one sees him except those living in the village. If the liberals had seen it, they would have reported to the West that we are mocking Stepanich, do not give him too much to drink and in such a cannibalistic way strangle the opposition. And, of course, sanctions for Stepanych against SP-2. And how is he worse than Podvalny or Efremov? The same drunk, the same citizen of the Russian Federation ...
        2. tihonmarine
          tihonmarine 15 September 2020 10: 55 New
          +3
          Quote: Nevolnik
          .And in our country they throw mud at everything that is possible and they even pay huge grants for this .. Now, thank God, these NGOs are dumb.

          Yes, at least take this Navalny, now if this appeared in the United States, what would they do with him? I think it wouldn't even have come to a "beginner" there,
          1. Nevolnik
            Nevolnik 15 September 2020 11: 18 New
            +1
            Quote: tihonmarine
            Yes, at least take this Navalny, now if this appeared in the United States, what would they do with him? I think it wouldn't even have come to a "beginner" there,

            There, with an electric chair, the whole thing would have ended Vlad !!!!
            It's even scary to imagine if an anti-corruption fund was created in the USA)))) lol The same Snowden a little bit told how and what .. So everyone rushed to catch him, he lives in Russia and seems to even get married and does not live badly.
  • Lipchanin
    Lipchanin 15 September 2020 10: 44 New
    +8
    Quote: Zoldat_A
    To choke with smelly socks such liberals, the Higher School of Economics in general and S. Medvedev in particular.

  • Cyril G ...
    Cyril G ... 15 September 2020 11: 04 New
    +6
    Quote: Zoldat_A
    When will this stinking liberal rat's nest in full force be sent to cut down the forest? Some kind of hostile breeding ground.


    It is for sure that not a month after another HSE "professor" has been profusely defecating on the Internet on yet another delusional liberal Russophobic topic. Can still bulldoze this place and concretize it from above ... And send the professors to Altai to comprehend the basics of economics ...
    1. Crash
      Crash 15 September 2020 11: 37 New
      +6
      bulldoze this place and concrete on top

      I'd also sprinkle dust on top just in case ...
  • depressant
    depressant 15 September 2020 11: 56 New
    +3
    She laughed))) I think there are many who will gladly provide their socks for such a good purpose - strangling S. Medvedev.
    1. Nevolnik
      Nevolnik 15 September 2020 12: 06 New
      +4
      Quote: depressant
      She laughed))) I think there are many who will gladly provide their socks for such a good purpose - strangling S. Medvedev.

      good bully The line will stand and push elbows Lyudmila clever love
  • The comment was deleted.
  • Victorio
    Victorio 15 September 2020 10: 26 New
    +4
    Quote: Livonetc
    HSE does not correspond to a higher educational institution, in the normal sense.
    It is rather a club of those crawling thirsty for the cherished feeders.
    Actually, the level of education there is questionable.
    More shop of vanity and corruption than a university.

    ===
    browsed the page with the HSE reporting. plan of financial and economic activities for 20 years. even such a document has not been brought to mind / normal readability !? this is a file with the pdf extension, and here it is not loaded, I can not put it out, only a link to the page - https://www.hse.ru/info/financial I spent just a couple of minutes to make this report readable (tables are rotated and saved in this form), which is why it has not been done. maybe little things, but since there is such a star in their foreheads, they also need to raise the bar for themselves
  • frog
    frog 15 September 2020 10: 28 New
    +5
    HSE was established by a decree of the Russian Government. The head of the HSE is Yaroslav Kuzminov, the permanent rector who participated in the creation of the university. The governing bodies are various councils: scientist, supervisory, trustee, international expert. The Supervisory Board is headed by Sergei Kiriyenko, before him was Vyacheslav Volodin. The Board of Trustees headed by German Gref is responsible for raising finance, and also includes Viktor Vekselberg, Arkady Volozh, Mikhail Zadornov, Leonid Mikhelson, Vadim Moshkovich and Mikhail Prokhorov.

    The co-founder of HSE, former Minister of Economics Yevgeny Yasin, holds the position of the university's scientific director and represents the university in other scientific organizations. The president of the university is former Deputy Prime Minister Alexander Shokhin; his duties include representing HSE in government agencies. Since 2016, Igor Agamirzyan, who previously held a post on the RVC board of directors, has been in the post of vice president. Economists Vadim Radaev, Alexander Shamrin, Leonid Gokhberg and Lev Yakobson are currently the first vice-rectors of HSE.

    Aunt Vika, by the way. And from there you can find out who, for example, the wife of the rector, the very unforgettable Kuzminov repeat
    So all questions are for the government of the Russian Federation ...
    1. Zoldat_A
      Zoldat_A 15 September 2020 10: 39 New
      +4
      Quote: frog
      So all questions are for the government of the Russian Federation ...

      So the year of foundation is 1992. Do you remember what, if I may say so, "government" was then? There was no rat-catcher with a pipe on them so that he could take them all somewhere ...
      1. frog
        frog 15 September 2020 10: 41 New
        +3
        True? Is there no government now? Or does he have no authority? Or what isn't there yet? And these characters have nothing to do with the government? Well, we won't talk about the rector's wife no
    2. dauria
      dauria 15 September 2020 11: 00 New
      +4
      who, for example, is the spouse of the rector, the very unforgettable Kuzminov


      I had to climb ... Well, that's how difficult it was for you to write - Nabiullina, Elvira Sakhipzadovna .
      1. frog
        frog 15 September 2020 11: 04 New
        +4
        Sorry, she-she, sorry hi I somehow forgot that not everyone knows this. Once again - call))) But to increase knowledge is not bad ?? Well, at the same time, some other questions may become somewhat clearer now. repeat
        1. dauria
          dauria 15 September 2020 11: 26 New
          0
          But isn't it a bad idea to increase knowledge?


          This is where "Happiness in Ignorance" comes in. hi But the “related tree” of our entire “elite” with all metastases would look interesting. Interesting and scary.
          1. frog
            frog 15 September 2020 11: 30 New
            +1
            Life experience suggests that not always wink Another thing is how it relates to this very ... repeat It is not at all necessary to go into a binge or even how ... to be upset laughing But sudden ..... fewer surprises lol hi
            1. dauria
              dauria 15 September 2020 11: 39 New
              0
              Another thing is how it relates to this very ...


              How, how .... How to tomography of a patient with cancer in the fourth stage.
              1. frog
                frog 15 September 2020 11: 40 New
                0
                Why is it so sad ??))))
          2. frog
            frog 15 September 2020 11: 52 New
            +1
            Do you think - only ours? This is quite a common phenomenon, we are not much different from everyone else here. As well as in many other things, by the way. True, of course, "your tooth hurts more", but that is .... And again, how many people care about this? Except, of course, conversations "under the stop" wink that "they are all bastards" .....
    3. tihonmarine
      tihonmarine 15 September 2020 11: 17 New
      +2
      Quote: frog
      And from there you can find out who, for example, the wife of the rector, the very unforgettable Kuzminov

      Well, rarely, who does not know what ..
      Yaroslav Ivanovich Kuzminov and Elvira Sakhipzadovna Nabiullina met in the mid-80s in Moscow. He then taught at the Faculty of Economics of Moscow State University, she was one of the best graduate students. Our heroes had a wedding back in 1988.
      1. frog
        frog 15 September 2020 11: 22 New
        +2
        Duc here they chided ..... Az, sinful, somehow missed that not all (happy people) are interested in this ...... biocenosis. Although, in our case, probably everything is biogeocenosis .... Alas, man is imperfect, and I myself am not the least .... I often forget that the obvious and well-known to me is not at all obvious to anyone else. And a big problem at the same time is to find a proof person)))) Bo, often, you need to put so many things in a heap ... repeat And a lot - and you can't add wink
  • venik
    venik 15 September 2020 10: 30 New
    +4
    Quote: Livonetc
    HSE does not correspond to a higher educational institution, in the normal sense.

    =========
    drinks And they won't cover this stinking one "sorosyat"!!! am But it would be high time!
  • hydrox
    hydrox 15 September 2020 10: 30 New
    +3
    You are right.
    In addition, it should be borne in mind that the overproduction of shitty economists in Russia is now maybe 1000% and the only "economy" that they have to deal with every day in stalls is calculating the percentage (in rubles) that the owner should spit out for 5 pairs of lousy shoes sold today in a day sitting in a tent at a flea market.
    1. Grandfather
      Grandfather 15 September 2020 10: 34 New
      +5
      I'm not a fan of Putin, but HSE is a specific infection that is time to pour bleach.
      1. hydrox
        hydrox 15 September 2020 20: 22 New
        0
        So after all, the SU HSE is not Putin's economy, but a liberoid one (Putin has already taken a noticeably more to the right (more conservative) for 2 years now: Putin simply did not read Bismarck, who said that it is not generals or armies that win wars, but school teachers.
        And with our teachers only to train janitors (just like doctors are graduated, suitable at best for the position of nurses).
  • Civil
    Civil 15 September 2020 11: 26 New
    -5
    Oh, that's who canceled pensions and dropped the ruble ... HSE is to blame for the country's decline.
  • Mountain shooter
    Mountain shooter 15 September 2020 13: 57 New
    +2
    Quote: Livonetc
    HSE does not correspond to a higher educational institution, in the normal sense

    Choice ... dirty trick, sorry. HSE - will soon become a BRAND. Do you have a HSE diploma? You have no right to occupy any positions related to management and government positions !!!
  • halpat
    halpat 15 September 2020 14: 47 New
    0
    Quote: Livonetc
    HSE does not correspond to a higher educational institution, in the normal sense.
    It is rather a club of those crawling thirsty for the cherished feeders.
    Actually, the level of education there is questionable.
    More shop of vanity and corruption than a university.

    Hasanov was fired so that he could train to speak "wretched and cloach" Russian on free bread, not at public expense.
    And it's time to send this bastard ... let him work in Figaro, who will they take :)
  • RealPilot
    RealPilot 15 September 2020 15: 50 New
    0
    HSE ... This place is filled with such "professors"!

    Sexual preferences are imposed on him, how does he write? Or maybe the whole point is this? Such is the vile reason for pathological deceit.
    Or just plain venality ...
  • Shiva83483
    Shiva83483 15 September 2020 18: 49 New
    0
    HSE does not correspond to a higher educational institution, in the normal sense.
    It is rather a club of those crawling thirsty for the cherished feeders.
    Actually, the level of education there is questionable.
    More shop of vanity and corruption than a university.
    not a club, but a graveyard ... as for me
  • BAI
    BAI 15 September 2020 09: 55 New
    10
    Professor at the Higher School of Economics

    interview with the French edition of Le Figaro.

    There are 2 signs at once that the material will be aimed at spoiling Russia.
    1. Pete mitchell
      Pete mitchell 15 September 2020 10: 00 New
      +7
      Quote: BAI
      Professor at the Higher School of Economics

      interview with the French edition of Le Figaro.

      There are 2 signs at once that the material will be aimed at spoiling Russia.

      Not in the eyebrow, but in the eye. This character is allowed to be raised young and immature ? Troubled ..
    2. Lipchanin
      Lipchanin 15 September 2020 11: 17 New
      +1
      Quote: BAI
      There are 2 signs at once that the material will be aimed at spoiling Russia.

  • Mavrikiy
    Mavrikiy 15 September 2020 09: 56 New
    +5
    HSE professor says Vladimir Putin is waging four wars
    Who is asking VSHu Medvedev?
    1. hydrox
      hydrox 15 September 2020 10: 33 New
      +3
      VSha Medvedev is accountable for the received grant (only this is not advertised).
  • Andobor
    Andobor 15 September 2020 09: 57 New
    +6
    They screech something like that all the time,
    - why give it out as news?
    1. Mavrikiy
      Mavrikiy 15 September 2020 16: 04 New
      0
      Quote: Andobor
      They screech something like that all the time,
      - why give it out as news?

      Well, if someone is digging and watering a substance, then someone really needs it. (Not Saint-Exupery)
  • APASUS
    APASUS 15 September 2020 10: 00 New
    +1
    In the third part, he talks about Putin's struggle for a man, for an ordinary Russian citizen. S. Medvedev believes that the country's authorities are rudely interfering with the private life of people, trying to impose consumer and even sexual preferences on them.

    It is a little unclear what the author wanted to say. Is this the government that is promoting gay parades, tolerance to perverts of various kinds?
    1. Rubi0
      Rubi0 15 September 2020 10: 19 New
      +4
      No, rather, on the contrary, the government imposes traditional values, and does not cover progressive Western LGBT people at all, which irritates the author of the book.
      1. tatra
        tatra 15 September 2020 10: 32 New
        -5
        Some strange Putin has - traditional values ​​- to slander the USSR, to blame the USSR for the fact that the Russian enemies of the Communists with their power created a miserable raw material economy, to blame Lenin for the fact that his enemies are separatists, many decades after Lenin's death divided the country among themselves.
        1. Rubi0
          Rubi0 15 September 2020 10: 52 New
          -9
          So in essence he is right. Or will you refute that from 17 to 40s, perhaps, these are the most shameful years in history, also seasoned with communist insanity. I advise you to visit the main naval cathedral in Kronstadt, which under Lenin was simply dazed, the hair stood on end as it was possible to drain all traditions into the toilet, and in the literal sense of the word, when on the site of memorial plaques to sailors and symbolically frescoes in the form of marine life in the colors of Andreev They put the flag on the walls, and instead of a cross on the dome they wanted to put up a monument to Lenin, since they didn't have enough brains to implement this plan.
          1. tatra
            tatra 15 September 2020 11: 04 New
            -2
            Yes, for you, enemies of Lenin, it is better what you did with Russia and the Russian people, ruined ALL branches of Russia, enriched at the expense of Russia and the Russian people, at the expense of the money taken from Russia and its people, poked tens of thousands of churches and temples , mosques, synagogues, fabulously enriched your priests, proving by their own example that religion does not make people honest, decent, kind, they do not make people out of those who wish all the best for their country and people, they have significantly reduced the number of schools and hospitals for the people, and you yourself send your kids to study in the West, you yourself are treated in the West.
            1. Rubi0
              Rubi0 15 September 2020 11: 21 New
              -6
              Dear, let me remind you that Trotsky and his followers were the first to advocate foreign concessions for the ports of the plant and factories, for which he was successfully sent by Stalin to the next world, otherwise you would have seen all of the above 100 years ago
              1. tatra
                tatra 15 September 2020 11: 31 New
                -1
                Lenin's enemies are incorrigible. EVERY time on all accusations of THEM, they "turn the arrows" to the communists. This is their whole ideology, who seriously imagined that they deserve to own the country more than the communists and their supporters - not FOR themselves, FOR what they did, but AGAINST the Bolshevik-communists and their supporters, AGAINST what they did.
                1. The comment was deleted.
                2. Ilya Nikitich
                  Ilya Nikitich 15 September 2020 21: 11 New
                  -1
                  Madame, you yourself have someone and where did you get your education? Your style of formulating thoughts makes your brain boil. You would learn Russian and read classical literature, so to speak, you would learn from the classics how to arrange words in the correct order ...
      2. APASUS
        APASUS 15 September 2020 11: 52 New
        +2
        Quote: Rubi0
        No, rather, on the contrary, the government imposes traditional values, and does not cover progressive Western LGBT people at all, which irritates the author of the book.

        Watching our television, you can't tell. Only House-2 is worth something, in a place with the main oppositionist!
    2. hydrox
      hydrox 15 September 2020 10: 39 New
      -3
      No, the government has taken a different position: it ALLOWS, or PROHIBITS, but forbids from under the gun, and allows for denyushka. There is one more position - not to notice - it costs the most, since the most hungry people are on SUCH grant
  • antivirus
    antivirus 15 September 2020 10: 00 New
    0
    I am glad of this level of HSE "analytics". let them steer their lawn mowers at dachas (or country mansions) - it works better.
    Why are academicians and professors given titles? I didn't understand the humor of RAS
    1. Pessimist22
      Pessimist22 15 September 2020 10: 05 New
      0
      Yes, the old man needed money, so he fulfilled the order.
  • Alexander X
    Alexander X 15 September 2020 10: 01 New
    +8
    Well, HSE, as a hotbed of "democracy" in the fledgling minds of young people, is long overdue to cover up, and to reeducate the teachers, to bring down the taiga for about 5 years. I had an office not far from this gadyushnik and I dined either in a yakitoriya or in a hamburger next door. Naturally, the students also hung out there. Conversations, exclusively, that they will unlearn and dump abroad ... And everything is bad here ... and so on. In the same spirit. My opinion is that HSE is a hidden agent of influence, preparing the "fifth column" ...
  • GREG68
    GREG68 15 September 2020 10: 01 New
    0
    The fact that Russia is full of problems, we know without you, dear professor. We also know that the irremovability of power is not gut at all. But the fact that the only candidate for the presidency is Comrade Navalny, here you are offended. We don't need such a fruit.
    1. hydrox
      hydrox 15 September 2020 10: 51 New
      +1
      Well...?
      Our heaped louse will receive its 10 liberoid percent, like the Tikhanovskaya louse in Belarus, and the performance will close.
  • 7,62h54
    7,62h54 15 September 2020 10: 01 New
    +2
    And for this louse they set aside a champagne bottle
    1. hydrox
      hydrox 15 September 2020 10: 53 New
      +1
      Such a goal requires high accuracy and a confident hand of a medic. laughing
      1. 7,62h54
        7,62h54 15 September 2020 11: 00 New
        +1
        It will punish itself
  • rotmistr60
    rotmistr60 15 September 2020 10: 04 New
    +2
    In France a book by a Russian historian and journalist, professor Higher School of Economics Sergei Medvedev
    The cornerstone of this is the selection. And as an apotheosis - Navalny is an alternative to the president. Point arrived.
    1. hydrox
      hydrox 15 September 2020 10: 59 New
      +1
      No, they haven't arrived yet :: the Ave has 2 more weeks, during which it is necessary to publish a clean copy of economic reforms, discuss it, adopt it at the Duma and launch it as a document for study with further execution from July 21. I think that Belousov there in Prospect is now working as a high-voltage dynamo and running around with a bare wire at workplaces. yes lol
  • Victorio
    Victorio 15 September 2020 10: 05 New
    +1
    not enough revelations / ideas for a book, could have done with an article.
  • Sergst
    Sergst 15 September 2020 10: 06 New
    +2
    Lord, what squalor!
  • nnm
    nnm 15 September 2020 10: 07 New
    +7
    The President considers one of his main tasks to compensate for the losses of Russia after the collapse of the USSR, which he calls the largest geopolitical catastrophe of the last century.

    ... and this is bad because ...?
    The second part of S. Medvedev's book is devoted to the "war of symbols"

    I completely agree!! No symbols of your own! Only a hamburger on all banners, repentance on their faces! The bast shoe country cannot be proud of something! Whether it's the hail on the hill, shaking hands to save everyone and everything! No Victory Banner! No pride in your history - all this is a lie!
    the author of the book is sure that the awards of Russian athletes were won only thanks to the "massive use of doping"

    - and do not care that Rodchenkov has already been officially caught for forging documents, do not care that all the winners have clean doping tests - just ask for forgiveness and repent - that's the lot of Russians!
    believes that the country's authorities grossly interfere with people's private lives, trying to impose consumer and even sexual preferences on them

    Quite right! These are not American providers not only collecting all information about us, but already modeling and moderating our consumer behavior and psychology, this is what we have a "patriotic act", its replacement, "train", secret prisons! This is the same here, people break through the knee, forcing them to believe that homosexuality is cool, that it should be in films, schools, we have crazy rules imposed on Oscars!
    He believes that Victory has been turned into a religion in Russia.

    And how would such professors want to forget about the 27 million victims, about the fact that the USSR saved the whole of Europe from the brown plague, consisting of representatives of almost all enlightened and bright countries ... how you want to pay and repent for this !!

    I have one question - why does IT work in a state university ?! Why do we admit THIS to the process of forming the consciousness of OUR CHILDREN ?!
    1. Zoldat_A
      Zoldat_A 15 September 2020 10: 44 New
      +4
      Quote: nnm
      I have one question - why does IT work in a state university ?!

      Please formulate more correctly and more broadly - "why is THIS considered a state university ?!" This is not a university, especially a state one, but a ready-made team of fellers in a state correctional institution.
    2. hydrox
      hydrox 15 September 2020 11: 06 New
      +1
      It is possible to look at another way :: why GOS. The university is a gadyushnik-settler of various Russophobic bastards (an Azeri-Russophobe with a professorial rank and a big scoundrel in the part of the Russian language has just been fired) - and again SU HSE is different!
  • tralflot1832
    tralflot1832 15 September 2020 10: 09 New
    +4
    He does not yet live in free Europe on Repperbahn, which means he will. For one interpretation of the Victory Day parades, he needs only European citizenship. It's time to close this HSE. As they say, If a brothel does not work well, you should not rearrange the beds, change the staff .This is the third scandal at the HSE. fool
  • Fedorov
    Fedorov 15 September 2020 10: 09 New
    +5
    I would comment on the "work" of the Yeltsin Center, where cartoons in 4 minutes. show children how wretched we were before the arrival of Yeltsin. And the fact that they launched into space and built nuclear power plants with a bang, the first in the world there, and like the world's first station "Mir. I am silent about icebreakers."
    I would have this "historian for the eggs and for the birch, but she bends. hi
  • A. Privalov
    A. Privalov 15 September 2020 10: 16 New
    -3
    You still need to read the book, and not listen to other people's translations of other people's articles in someone else's presentation. Maybe the opposite is true.

    Found this article at Le Figaro. Indeed, there is a lot of Russophobia, for example:
    Désespéré de bâtir l'avenir, l'État se rêve un passé héroïque, créant le mythe selon lequel l'histoire russe est une ligne ininterrompue de victoires.

    Something like "Desperate to build a future, the state dreams of a heroic past, creating the myth that Russian history is a series of continuous victories."
    1. hydrox
      hydrox 15 September 2020 11: 14 New
      -1
      And this is how to interpret it: after all, it can be said that no country in the world has experienced so many wars, destruction and casualties in 100 years as has fallen to the lot of Russia, and how much effort and money was spent not on improving the lives of citizens, but on providing them with a minimum level of comfort, at least slightly different from the level of Zemlyanovsky and barracks.
      Do you agree with THIS interpretation of the material of your own quote?
      As for the State, it simply changed the social-capitalist vector of the movement to the liber-thieves 'one in order to provide means for its thieves' elite, fused with the power.
      1. A. Privalov
        A. Privalov 15 September 2020 12: 40 New
        +1
        Quote: hydrox
        And this is how to interpret it: after all, it can be said that no country in the world has experienced so many wars, destruction and casualties in 100 years as has fallen to the lot of Russia, and how much effort and money was spent not on improving the lives of citizens, but on providing them with a minimum level of comfort, at least slightly different from the level of Zemlyanovsky and barracks.
        Do you agree with THIS interpretation of the material of your own quote?
        As for the State, it simply changed the social-capitalist vector of the movement to the liber-thieves 'one in order to provide means for its thieves' elite, fused with the power.

        Why not? Could be so.
        Looking at Germany, from where the victorious countries exported everything they could reach for reparations, one can also talk about "the improvement of the life of citizens, to provide them with a minimum level of comfort, at least slightly different from the level of Zemlyan and barracks."
        The countries of Europe have long forgotten the times when they were in ruin, because 75 (seventy-five!) Years have passed.
        The same period has passed in Russia. Destruction and sacrifice were left behind. For 75 years there has been no war in the country, enemies do not bomb it.
        History should be studied, of course, not to forget the lessons of the past, but it is useless to look back all the time .... There, nothing has changed.

        As for your definition of the State, then you know better. hi
        1. Essex62
          Essex62 16 September 2020 08: 18 New
          0
          The definition is rather strange. Contrasting what is essentially what does not exist in principle.
  • BABAY22
    BABAY22 15 September 2020 10: 23 New
    10
    Book by Russian historian and journalist, professor at the Higher School of Economics Sergei Medvedev

    The professorial title at the university is awarded for a high contribution to science - an important discovery or implementation of a scientific proposal related to solving economic, social, financial problems of state and regional significance

    Does Medvedev's "professor" have this title? Are you sure?
    Judging by the publication, this is not a title, but it drove him, as he is called in the circle of interests "The West will help us."
    1. hydrox
      hydrox 15 September 2020 11: 19 New
      +2
      The first paragraph of your commentary is the prerogative of the RAS (it is the RAS that serves everything related to science), and where it took the right to confer the professorship at the HSE's gadyushniks - this needs to be investigated - it may well turn out that this is self-will or underground ...
    2. Tank hard
      Tank hard 15 September 2020 15: 03 New
      +1
      Quote: BABAY22
      Does Medvedev's "professor" have this title? Are you sure?
      Judging by the publication, this is not a title, but it drove him, as he is called in the circle of interests "The West will help us."

      This Medvedev is generally the same.
      Here is how VVP said about him:
      On October 3, Russian President Vladimir Putin, speaking to the heads of United Russia branches, called Sergei Medvedev in front of the microphones "a jerk" and spoke in favor of expanding the Russian presence in the Arctic. ", As well as" unpatriotic "and" anti-national "[1

      repeat
  • Reserve buildbat
    Reserve buildbat 15 September 2020 10: 24 New
    +5
    When will all these "VSH" professors-academicians be transplanted? In the "beacon of democracy" they would have been polishing bunks with their backs for a long time, but here everything is swarming and stinking. And the whole "VSHU" should be burned out with a hot iron, as a breeding ground for Russophobic propaganda. This is not a university, it is just a training center legally operating in Russia for provocateurs and Russophobes who are supposed to destroy the country.
  • Sidor Amenpodestovich
    Sidor Amenpodestovich 15 September 2020 10: 28 New
    +4
    One gets the impression that people with the surname Medvedev are a little, to put it mildly, strange.
    This professor, I will not mention someone. Roy Medvedev, if anyone remembers, was such an extremely controversial character. However, it is still there.
    Completely trendy former KVNshitsa Medvedev, who blurted out about Karbyshev.
    As the Chukchi said in one joke: "The trend, however."
    (no offense to the rest of Medvedev)
    1. depressant
      depressant 15 September 2020 18: 31 New
      +2
      Colleague, in my opinion, you forgot to add someone to this row)))
    2. Sidor Amenpodestovich
      Sidor Amenpodestovich 15 September 2020 18: 36 New
      +1
      Quote: Sydor Amenpospestovich
      I will not even mention someone

      Didn't forget if you meant it.
  • Operator
    Operator 15 September 2020 10: 30 New
    +1
    Another professor, who no one can call him, has published another opus - so what?

    The professional's job is to generate a bukoff stream (thank God, now in electronic form without transferring trees to waste paper).
  • Alf
    Alf 15 September 2020 10: 32 New
    -2
    According to the author, Putin's first "war" is being fought over territorial space. The President considers one of his main tasks to compensate for the losses of Russia after the collapse of the USSR,

    Spitsbergen, Damansky ...
    The second part of S. Medvedev's book is devoted to the "war of symbols". Here he cites the opening of monuments as an example,


    Putin's fourth "war" is for memory. This was especially evident, in the opinion of the HSE professor, during the celebration of the 75th anniversary of the victory of the USSR in the Great Patriotic War.


    the authorities' desire to present the country's history as a series of uninterrupted victories stems from their inability to build a future for their citizens.


    Putin is best at waging war with his own country and people.
  • Yurahip
    Yurahip 15 September 2020 10: 33 New
    +1
    And you need to give it something to smell and welcome to the club of the un-poisoned!
  • askort154
    askort154 15 September 2020 10: 36 New
    +6
    Spies make bad politicians, and Putin is still a KGB officer on a secret mission.

    If Putin was such, he would have covered this hornet's nest long ago. HSE was founded in 1992 with funds from the Soros Foundation. The head of the Soros Foundation in Russia, then Yaroslav Kuzminov, was then appointed by Gaidar to the post of HSE Rector. The curator was Yasinsky. Kuzmin's wife, head of the Central Bank of the Russian Federation, Elvira Nabiullina. What kind of economic breakthrough can you expect from the nursery of the Soros Foundation ?! This is worse than the "fifth column" negative
  • rocket757
    rocket757 15 September 2020 10: 37 New
    +1
    The historian sees opposition blogger Alexei Navalny as the only alternative to the current president, but doubts that he will return to Russia.

    the Fuhrer of the master's ducks will be pushed back! they simply DO NOT have anything better ...
    but at the expense of the ALTERNATIVE ??? .... entot historian absolutely go / E \ t or pretend to be such ???
  • tatra
    tatra 15 September 2020 10: 37 New
    -1
    This is Medvedev and therefore longs for Navalny to become the President of Russia, that he understands that under Navalny, as under Putin, liberals will always be outside the jurisdiction of "chocolate".
  • north 2
    north 2 15 September 2020 10: 39 New
    +3
    watched two lectures of the historian S.A. Medvedev. This is a lecture "War of Monuments" and a lecture "Is there a way out." In my opinion, this is a purely liberal propagandist lecturer, not a historian. What is it worth in the lecture "Is there a way out" constant repetitions about the Russian State, even in
    the times of the Romanovs, even now. The historian should know that since the time of Peter the Great
    and up to the present time there was not and there is no Russian state, but there was and is the Russian state. So
    what kind of historians are there and what kind of history is taught at this HSE, this is still a big question ...
    1. Campanella
      Campanella 15 September 2020 11: 05 New
      +1
      Yes, the quality of the liberal professors is encouraging! There will be more such guardians and there will be no need to fight them, they will trample themselves.
  • K-50
    K-50 15 September 2020 10: 41 New
    +2
    Is this "professor" still a professor at the Higher School of Economics?
    It is high time to reconsider this issue.
    HSE, instead of really engaging in economics, climbs into politics! Maybe it's time to cover up this abscess, which already exists on the money of the state, which in every possible way cheats, and to issue invoices for the money spent !!! am
  • Prisoner
    Prisoner 15 September 2020 10: 45 New
    +1
    One goat from this almshouse was recently cleaned out, but it looks like there is a whole goat incubator.
  • iouris
    iouris 15 September 2020 10: 48 New
    +2
    The Vlasovites have become more active - this is the main war. At the symbol level, it is played.
    Let Navalny stay in Germany. Homeland is the place where your analyzes are located.
  • taiga2018
    taiga2018 15 September 2020 10: 48 New
    +1
    The first "war" for territorial space. Any self-respecting country wages such a struggle, just some do it by returning the territory to their composition, while others place their military bases there ...
    The "war" of symbols ... It's funny, because it is in the West, and not in Russia, that some monuments are being demolished and others are being erected in their place ...
    "War" for a person ... That is, in the West, sexual preferences are not imposed, when they openly demand what percentage of perverts should take part in making films ...
    The "war" for memory ... But did we start this "war", do we attempt to rewrite history and present white as black and black as white ...
    Navalny is the only alternative? How much does this man despise his country and people, if he believes that there are no other candidates besides the half-dead liberalist, how does he differ from those who say "if not Putin, then who."
    1. iouris
      iouris 15 September 2020 11: 22 New
      0
      Quote: taiga2018
      The "war" of symbols ... It's funny, because it is in the West, not in Russia

      And where is the monument to Dzerzhinsky?
      1. taiga2018
        taiga2018 15 September 2020 11: 45 New
        +1
        Quote: iouris
        And where is the monument to Dzerzhinsky?

        And who was then president ...
      2. taiga2018
        taiga2018 15 September 2020 11: 45 New
        +1
        Quote: iouris
        And where is the monument to Dzerzhinsky?

        And who was then president ...
        1. iouris
          iouris 15 September 2020 12: 16 New
          +1
          What has changed?
  • Roman13579
    Roman13579 15 September 2020 10: 54 New
    -12
    The author compares Putin to a certain Moscow prince who collects Russian lands.
    It is necessary to drive such collectors with a stick ..

    At the same time, the author of the book is sure that the awards of Russian athletes were won only due to the "massive use of doping." This says a lot about the author.
    Well, as if the author is absolutely right .. this has already been proven and recognized ..

    about Putin's struggle for a person, for an ordinary Russian citizen ... trying to impose consumer and even sexual preferences on them.

    Well, I won't say about sexual ones .. but about consumerism the professor got to the point ..
    Take mortgages, loans .. as much as you like .. most importantly, bring us your money ..

    in Russia, Victory was turned into a religion. In his opinion, the desire of the authorities to present the country's history as a series of continuous victories is due to their inability to build a future for their citizens.
    Well, here in general, only a complete idiot has not noticed this himself before ..

    Shl .. it's even strange that in such a sharaga like the HSE there are also adequate, sane professors ..
    1. dragy52rus
      dragy52rus 15 September 2020 11: 44 New
      -1
      Quote: Roman13579
      Well, as if the author is absolutely right .. this has already been proven and recognized ..

      recognized but proven. on the other hand, in "normal" countries, doping is good and for it is not punished and medals are not taken away.
      Quote: Roman13579
      but the professor got to the point about consumerism.
      Take mortgages, loans .. as much as you like .. most importantly, bring us your money ..

      you are absolutely right this is only in the Russian Federation. in the West and overseas, they have not heard about loans and consumerism.
      Quote: Roman13579
      Well, here in general, only a complete idiot has not noticed this himself before ..

      Again, I agree with you, only a complete idt can see. for normal people it is just a holiday. By the way, is NG a religion too?
    2. Ilya Nikitich
      Ilya Nikitich 15 September 2020 21: 20 New
      +1
      Quote: Roman13579
      Shl .. it's even strange that in such a sharaga like the HSE there are also adequate, sane professors ..

      Well, for you, then "professor" Medvedev is adequate.
  • aleksr2005
    aleksr2005 15 September 2020 10: 55 New
    +2
    Does he see Navalny as the leader of a nation, such a complex country as Russia? If he does not understand the importance and benefits for the country, why we tried to hold the Olympiad, why did we join Crimea, then I can imagine what kind of books there are.
  • Country Councils
    Country Councils 15 September 2020 10: 55 New
    +1
    If the wicked old professor has given birth to a scandalous book, then Putin is doing everything right. Especially regarding the restoration of the borders of the USSR https://mmanificarum.blogspot.com/2020/09/blog-post_11.html
  • Operator
    Operator 15 September 2020 11: 01 New
    -1
    "Historian" Sergei Medvedev is a journalist with a diploma from Moscow State University, in 1990 he graduated from Columbia University in the USA (since that time he has been an American agent of influence). In 1999-2004 he worked at the American intelligence center - the European Center for Security Studies named after M. George Marshal in Garmisch-Partenkirchen (FRG).

    In 2004 he was transferred to Russia, hired at the Higher School of Economics, and combines with the work on the Russian Dozhd TV channel and the American Radio Liberty.

    In September 2013, Sergei Medvedev wrote on Facebook:
    "In an amicable way, Russia, as a failed and irresponsible owner, should take the Arctic away and transfer it under international jurisdiction like Antarctica with a complete ban on economic and military activities."
    On October 3, 2013, Russian President Vladimir Putin in a public speech called Sergei Medvedev a jerk, and called the proposal to place her under the control of the international community as complete stupidity, unpatriotic and anti-people.

    Nevertheless, Nabiullina's husband and part-time rector of the HSE still ardently supports his deputy dean of the political science department, like many other Russophobes in the leadership of this state institution.
    1. boni592807
      boni592807 15 September 2020 15: 41 New
      0
      Russia is being abused by a BIG friend of our "partners". So that's good! Our affairs will become worse if PRAISE starts. hi
  • Campanella
    Campanella 15 September 2020 11: 01 New
    +1
    Especially narrow-profile view. The main reason why these wars are being fought is not said. War for the sake of war is nonsense. But maybe the professor just wanted to consider the details of what he sees. You have to write about something, it's money, maintaining your reputation again.
  • jovanni
    jovanni 15 September 2020 11: 01 New
    +2
    ... the country's authorities rudely interfere with people's private lives, trying to impose consumer and even sexual preferences on them.
    Well, it seems like most HSE professors have long-standing sexual preferences. And they are far from traditional ...
  • Ratmir_Ryazan
    Ratmir_Ryazan 15 September 2020 11: 04 New
    -1
    A politician from Putin is 1000 times better than a journalist and historian from Medvedev.

    At the HSE, this is the CIA station.
  • Cyril G ...
    Cyril G ... 15 September 2020 11: 07 New
    +1
    To the president, the historian sees the opposition blogger Alexei Navalny, but doubts that he will return to Russia.

    Will return where to go. The ITC is already crying over him.
    By the way, has Lesha ever personally managed something successfully? Have you created anything?
  • vavilon
    vavilon 15 September 2020 11: 09 New
    +2
    Also an alternative to me))) provocateur-Navalny "should be in prison and will sit"
    And the French are better off looking at human rights, they have already begun to clear the way for the next presidential election for Macron
  • zwlad
    zwlad 15 September 2020 11: 13 New
    0
    Dogs bark, and the caravan moves on.
    Isn't it time to revoke the license of this institution under some formal pretext. Well, the premises do not correspond to fire safety standards. and?
  • Asad
    Asad 15 September 2020 11: 20 New
    +1
    Lived, and did not know that there is another LADY! I read it and regretted that I learned! Why is THIS here?
  • tank64rus
    tank64rus 15 September 2020 11: 23 New
    +1
    I always said that HSE is an offshoot of foreign intelligence services in the Russian Federation. The nest of liberals and LGBT people in Russia and, strangely enough, the reins of managing the education and upbringing of our youth are in the hands of the natives of this Gaidar nest.
  • 1536
    1536 15 September 2020 11: 29 New
    +1
    It seems that only the Vlasovites survived the war and multiplied. What is it? It's like some kind of hydra: you chop off its head, and instead of one, two grow at once. Where is the Hercules that will bring order to Russian education? Where is the conscience and honor of a teacher, teacher, teacher, if such people are born in their environment and live well? It is one thing when books are written and published by some eccentric from the "M" class, and another thing when hundreds of students absorb toxic, viscous dirt about their country, its leader and its people.
  • Dym71
    Dym71 15 September 2020 11: 35 New
    +1
    He spoke about his book and his assessment of the activities and views of Vladimir Putin in an interview with the French edition of Le Figaro.

    It would be great for VO editors to attach links to the originals of publications and their translations to such news.
    1. Conveniently familiarize yourself with the original source.
    2. Comments on the original are sometimes more informative than the article itself.
    3. Some of our fellow citizens of exemplary democratic states will not "burn out" that we are being fooled, duped, substituted for concepts, thus forming a rejection of the light of peace and kindness towards their civilization. hi
  • kriten
    kriten 15 September 2020 11: 42 New
    +2
    There is nothing else to expect from HSE teachers except hatred of their native country, its history and people. This is a poisonous nest of traitors and traitors to the Motherland, an incubator for the fifth column to replenish. They have made a tremendous contribution to the destruction of education and medicine, calling sabotage reforms. And we will overcome their contribution to the destruction of the economy, especially industry, for another 20 years.
  • Moskovit
    Moskovit 15 September 2020 11: 50 New
    +2
    Independence is very expensive. Therefore, Russia is full of such "professors" whose task is to destroy the state foundations of our country. The Western countries cannot take us in the usual military way, they work through such agents of influence.
  • Radikal
    Radikal 15 September 2020 12: 07 New
    0
    Quote: Alexey Sommer
    Quote: Tatiana
    HSE is the blacksmith of the administrative staff of the pro-Western

    And let's discuss the article in essence?
    1. The first war for the succession of the USSR. I think our leaders are losing it. the most striking example is Ukraine. Do not agree? .. Argument with words, not the "-" button.
    2. War of symbols .. I would look at it through modern Russian cinema ...
    A pitiful sight, you can't look without tears .. Basically, of course, there are exceptions, but they are few.
    3. You don't need to talk about an ordinary Russian citizen .. I think everyone understands everything after the pension reform ..
    4. Victory is sacred, there's nothing to say here ..
    Are we counting points? 3: 1 is not in our favor.
    Question..
    Does the president really play for our team?

    Forgot about the annually draped Mausoleum. hi
  • The comment was deleted.
  • Radikal
    Radikal 15 September 2020 12: 15 New
    -1
    Quote: Civil
    Oh, that's who canceled pensions and dropped the ruble ... HSE is to blame for the country's decline.

    If it (HSE) exists, does it mean it is beneficial for someone? belay lol
  • Whirlwind
    Whirlwind 15 September 2020 12: 36 New
    0
    And what can this professor still say if ESE is supervised and paid for by the World Bank.
    The one who pays and dances the professora ...