State Duma professionals. Who did they work before being elected as deputies?

91

The people's choice in Russia is a profession. If someone doubts, he can turn to Article 97 of the Constitution, where it is written in black and white that State Duma deputies are working on a permanent and professional basis. Nevertheless, before making the administration of legislative power in the country a matter of their lives, all these people were doing something. It's very interesting what exactly.

Naturally, I will not keep track of the entire work biographies of all 450 deputies of the State Duma of Russia of the VII convocation without exception. There will not be enough space, and you never know how many professions a person managed to change in his life. It is important, as a representative of which of them, he was elected to the highest authority in the country. I will try to paint a more or less objective picture, using some generalizations to save space.



For example, everyone who has held certain positions in government structures for most of their lives, I think, can be safely characterized by the well-known definition of “official”. There are 69 of them in the current Duma. It is clear that by the time of the election, almost all of them were leaders of various levels. There will be fewer executives in our parliament who have worked not in the state but in the private sector (directors of various enterprises, managers of concerns and corporations, heads of other commercial structures) - 57 people. Businessmen in their pure form, that is, people who have created and developed their own businesses in various industries, can be considered 60 Duma members.

There are 24 people who consider themselves professional politicians. Not so much for parliament, is it? Well, you can add to them three more trade unionists. There are even more teachers of various levels, from school teachers to university teachers, there are even more in the Duma - 34 deputies. There are also three dozen engineers and technicians. 23 doctors - from humble doctors to the former chief sanitary doctor of Russia Gennady Onishchenko. By the way, there is even one veterinarian - Valentine Saturday.

Alas, even fewer than professional politicians, we see professional economists in the State Duma. At the same time, mind you, 41 deputies have a scientific degree of candidate of economic sciences, and 15 are even doctors in the same field! How is this possible? Riddle ... With those whose occupation is jurisprudence in the domestic parliament, it is also sparse. The list of 13 lawyers-deputies, of course, is headed by the charming Natalya Poklonskaya, whose irrepressible energy is enough for ten. Several more representatives of agriculture, or, as they say now, the agricultural sector: 18 people.

But the situation is not bad with those who for most of their lives ensured the security of Russia and its defense. In the State Duma of the 18th convocation, we see XNUMX regular military personnel (one ex-commander of the Russian Airborne Forces, Vladimir Shamanov, is worth something!) And two dozen representatives of other law enforcement agencies. You can't take our parliament for fear! There is also a full-fledged detachment of cosmonauts - as many as five people, and most of them are representatives of the fair sex: Valentina Tereshkova, Svetlana Savitskaya, Elena Serova.

Finally, let us consider the presence in parliament of representatives of those professions that are traditionally called public. These are five public relations specialists and 19 journalists representing various media. There are, of course, enough people known throughout the country: TV presenters Oksana Pushkina, Pyotr Tolstoy, Evgeny Revenko, editor of the Kultura newspaper Elena Yampolskaya, journalist and writer Sergei Shargunov.

Their fellow athletes are slightly outnumbered by journalists-deputies. There are 18 of them in the Duma. Here, the composition, of course, is "star". Heavyweight boxer Nikolai Valuev, wrestler Alexander Karelin, hockey players Vyacheslav Fetisov and Vladislav Tretyak, gymnast Svetlana Khorkina. I will not list all of them, I will only note that, of course, there will not be enough people for the Olympic team, but on the whole the team is quite decent and versatile. There is also a coach - the most famous mentor of football players Valery Gazzaev.

Only one person from the deputies, Elena Drapeko, considers himself to be an acting class. But next to her sits Sergei, the son of the star of Russian cinema and stage Mikhail Boyarsky. Here, however, the point is not in the famous father, but in the fact that Sergei Boyarsky, prior to his election, was the general director of the St. Petersburg TV channel and adviser to the governor of the northern capital. There are two filmmakers in the State Duma: Yuri Kara and Nikolai Bortko. Also two professional musicians.

Somewhat depressing is the fact that, despite dozens of deputies with various scientific degrees in various fields (from medicine and technical sciences to sociology and psychology), there is only one professional scientist in the State Duma of Russia of the VII convocation. True, this is a world-famous luminary, Artur Chilingarov. But ... Somehow not enough, don't you think? However, they themselves chose!
Our news channels

Subscribe and stay up to date with the latest news and the most important events of the day.

91 comment
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. +58
    26 August 2020 10: 02
    Drones who bought themselves a warm place. In such a format, which was built by the guarantor, the State Duma is a worthless body that absorbs taxpayer money.
    1. +44
      26 August 2020 10: 05
      Absolutely right. A crowd of parasites and everyone else has a staff of "helpers", and we pay for the whole banquet
      1. +29
        26 August 2020 10: 12
        State Duma professionals. Who did they work before being elected as deputies?

        The author has clearly bypassed the topic of crime. Interestingly, there are such in the Duma? recourse
        1. +18
          26 August 2020 10: 35
          Of course there are, where did they go. And in the Federation Council too
          1. 0
            26 August 2020 10: 48
            Quote: Harry Cuper
            Of course there are, where did they go. And in the Federation Council too

            I didn't ask about the Federation Council !!! belay Yes
            1. +4
              26 August 2020 15: 59
              Well, this is me in the order of "initiative from the field" added laughing
        2. BAI
          +2
          26 August 2020 13: 13

          There is information that 10 people passed.
          There is one more question. The circles around the Duma are full of all kinds of mistresses. But are they directly in the State Duma?
          1. +4
            26 August 2020 21: 57
            Well, well, those parties that are in opposition to the authorities and have a smaller number than YEDROSOV, and suddenly more convicts. Fuck I believe.
          2. +1
            27 August 2020 13: 00
            Quote: BAI

            There is information that 10 people passed.
            There is one more question. The circles around the Duma are full of all kinds of mistresses. But are they directly in the State Duma?

            EDRO does not condemn its own?: D
      2. +35
        26 August 2020 10: 14
        It seems that here it would be possible to follow the path of the USSR, slightly improving the system - the deputies retain their places at the main place of work, with the possibility of their recall by voters. In their free time from sessions, the Dumas return to their collectives and work there.
        And the creation of a "professional" thought is simply a path leading to the formation of a new caste, which will be simply celestials.
        1. +29
          26 August 2020 10: 24
          Quote: RUnnm
          It seems that here it would be possible to follow the path of the USSR,

          I think in general it is necessary to turn on the path of the USSR .. taking into account the mistakes of the past .. Over the 30 years of capitalism, everything should already become clear ..
          1. +9
            26 August 2020 10: 35
            This is just unreal. Someone, even the same government, given that we live in capitalist reality, will lead to a change in the socio-political system? Of course not.
            So they will try to drive the population into a balance between the TV and the refrigerator, so that the "lower classes" would not want more, but also that they would not die of hunger.
            1. Aag
              +1
              28 August 2020 14: 29
              Quote: RUnnm
              This is just unreal. Someone, even the same government, given that we live in capitalist reality, will lead to a change in the socio-political system? Of course not.
              So they will try to drive the population into a balance between the TV and the refrigerator, so that the "lower classes" would not want more, but also that they would not die of hunger.

              Therefore, the system of forming the State Duma will not be allowed to touch.
          2. +12
            26 August 2020 10: 40
            First of all, this will mean a return to social ownership of the means of production. Such a candidate will not live to see the elections.
            1. +18
              26 August 2020 10: 41
              Quote: Harry Cuper
              First of all, this will mean a return to social ownership of the means of production. Such a candidate will not live to see the elections.

              Here it is difficult to disagree, the leader who will lead this movement will doom himself to enormous difficulties. But I am sure that there will be those who will not be afraid.
              1. +2
                26 August 2020 14: 43
                Quote: Svarog
                But I am sure that there will be those who will not be afraid.

                Moreover, in their absence, not many will be appointed, but that would be proud to declare the pluralism of opinions.
            2. +4
              26 August 2020 10: 50
              That's it. That is why I say that at this stage, this is just a dream that has no real prospects.
          3. +16
            26 August 2020 12: 16
            Quote: Svarog
            I think in general it is necessary to turn on the path of the USSR .. taking into account the mistakes of the past .. Over the 30 years of capitalism, everything should already become clear ..

            Yeah. Right now, our oligarchs will look at the mistakes of the past, sprinkle ashes on their heads and turn on the path leading towards the USSR. No one will voluntarily give up what was grabbed and dishonestly multiplied for free.
          4. -3
            26 August 2020 18: 59
            Quote: Svarog
            Quote: RUnnm
            It seems that here it would be possible to follow the path of the USSR,

            I think in general it is necessary to turn on the path of the USSR .. taking into account the mistakes of the past .. Over the 30 years of capitalism, everything should already become clear ..

            Let's collapse again like the USSR.
          5. +6
            27 August 2020 04: 55
            Quote: Svarog
            I think in general it is necessary to turn on the path of the USSR .. taking into account the mistakes of the past .. Over the 30 years of capitalism, everything should already become clear ..
            Who will give you something to do this? Oligarchs? Bees versus honey?
            30 years of capitalism ?! Who told you this? We have neo-feudalism: in fact, there are estates.
        2. +18
          26 August 2020 10: 48
          Quote: RUnnm
          And the creation of a "professional" thought is simply a path leading to the formation of a new caste, who will be just celestials.

          stop Considers, dear friend, considers himself celestials, the elite of society. Although the bulk of these lawmakers did not show themselves in any significant way. And by voting on the pension reform and amendments to the constitution (for zeroing the deadlines), she crossed out past merits.
          1. +2
            27 August 2020 05: 00
            Quote: ROSS 42
            And by voting on the pension reform and amendments to the constitution (for zeroing the deadlines), she crossed out past merits.
            Pension reform, or rather, raising the age, would have been pushed through anyway. "Zeroing" is the least evil of all amendments, because you can still not vote FOR "zeroed".
            Merit? A lot of them?
            1. +1
              27 August 2020 12: 57
              And how would they push through the pension reform without voting for it?
              1. 0
                27 August 2020 20: 19
                Quote: Revival
                without voting for?
                Did not understand you. Vote "for" after massive campaigning, for example.
                1. +1
                  27 August 2020 22: 39
                  He wrote in response to this: "The pension reform, or rather, raising the age, would have been pushed through anyway."

                  I meant that without their vote "for" they would not have gotten through. I mean within the "law"
                  1. 0
                    28 August 2020 21: 17
                    Quote: Revival
                    I meant that without their vote "for" they would not have gotten through. I mean within the "law"
                    Under what law? What have you just done with the Constitution? Changed corrected, right? Has it gotten better? I just think not.
                    1. 0
                      29 August 2020 00: 36
                      So I put it in quotes precisely because of such circumstances.
                      Moreover, as a lawyer I can still cite fresh examples of "finished", which are stitched together in spite of everything, because "so it is necessary for anyone.
                      You just gave the most famous example
                      1. 0
                        29 August 2020 19: 04
                        Quote: Revival
                        which are molded in spite of everything
                        For example, our believers are more equal than equals.
                        And now there is power.
                      2. +2
                        29 August 2020 19: 43
                        There is also a more mundane example.
                        The law on the financial commissioner, which destroys the meaning of compulsory insurance and hull insurance for people. Now the insurance company dictates whether to pay you or not and how much to pay, and the right to file a claim in court is actually prohibited for a person. Checkmate. Purposefully!
        3. +11
          26 August 2020 10: 52
          Quote: RUnnm
          And the creation of a "professional" thought is simply a path leading to the formation of a new caste, which will be simply celestials.

          And who will openly lobby the interests of big capital, for it is not for the poor people to please them
        4. +4
          26 August 2020 14: 41
          Quote: RUnnm
          And the creation of a "professional" thought is simply a path leading to the formation of a new caste, which will be simply celestials.

          Already created.
          1. The comment was deleted.
          2. +7
            26 August 2020 15: 25
            Deputies of the State Duma, ideally, should have the skills of working in the field of law and economics, moreover, the skills developed in obtaining higher legal or economic education and the practice of applying this education before being elected to the State Duma. I believe that this is necessary because the goal of the State Duma is to create laws and adopt budgets.

            But in the State Duma there are so few persons with theoretical and practical training and competencies in the listed areas of knowledge precisely because professionals in the State Duma are not desirable for the Kremlin. And those few professional lawyers who are in the State Duma are the Kremlin mongrels, such as the former Minister of Justice P. Krasheninnikov, who has tarnished himself with corruption and possession of a multimillion-dollar fortune from nowhere.

            G. Duma is a "frenzied printer" that annually adopts as many laws as all other parliaments of Europe take in a year combined. Every year, the Duma "on the mountain" issues about 300 new laws and about 1000 laws-amendments to the previously adopted ones (in fact, they sign that the previously adopted laws were defective). And the Duma dares to be proud of the number of adopted laws.

            Of course, with such a crazy speed of adoption of laws, the deputies have not only the skill of understanding their work, but also the time to fully familiarize themselves with the adopted draft laws. Yes, the Kremlin does not need it. Indeed, in 95% of the adopted federal laws, either the President of the Russian Federation or the Government of the Russian Federation is the initiator. Although the formal stages of the adoption of laws are respected. Therefore, the deputies can only resignedly vote for the draft laws written in the bowels of the executive branch.

            And for such purely clerical work and the appearance of democracy, (and in fact, "plutocracy), even an ordinary deputy receives a monthly salary, which includes his salary, the salary of assistants, expenses for activities, including 2 offices (in the State Duma building and in the region), travel , sanatoriums, etc., about 2 million rubles, which is slightly more than 17 thousand rubles of a representative of the "middle class" in the Russian Federation. am
            1. +2
              26 August 2020 21: 00
              The Peter Principle in Action ...
      3. +14
        26 August 2020 10: 16
        and so everything is clear!
    2. +29
      26 August 2020 10: 12
      The Duma is a fucking parliament. It will only have a decisive voice in words, but in reality it will only have an advisory vote, for the upper house and the government, armed to the teeth, will stand over it as censors. The manifesto directly states that not a single resolution of the Duma can be implemented if it is not approved by the upper house and the tsar.
      The Duma is not a people's parliament, it is the parliament of the enemies of the people, for the elections to the Duma will not be universal, nor equal, nor direct, nor secret.

      I.V. Stalin


      It was written 100 years ago, but not a fig has changed .. Deja vu is straight ...
      1. +5
        26 August 2020 10: 40
        Quote: paul3390
        It was written 100 years ago, but not a fig has changed ..

        Or returned in a spiral 100 years later to square one.
    3. +33
      26 August 2020 10: 28
      We are great talents
      But clear and simple.
      We are singers and musicians
      Acrobats and jesters.
      This is some kind of our common misfortune. Something went wrong, as a result of which sportsmen, actors, entertainers and representatives of other, frankly speaking, not very intellectual professions appeared en masse in politics. With the work on the laws of the "stars" so-so: episodic and optional. The same is with local authorities. Another yesterday's star of world sports or a supernumerary singer constantly pops up in some regional government, city committee.
      1. +9
        26 August 2020 11: 04
        State Duma professionals. Who did they work before being elected as deputies?
        they were kind and sympathetic uncles and aunts, ingratiatingly looking into the eyes of the "electorate"!
    4. +10
      26 August 2020 12: 54
      Quote: Svarog
      Drones who bought themselves a warm place. In such a format, which was built by the guarantor, the State Duma is a worthless body that absorbs taxpayer money.

      They were elected, no one protested, did not want to Maidan ... so there is nothing to attack United Russia, there is a ring of enemies around, 20 Polish agents are pumping Belarus, the CIA has poisoned Failed Lechaim.
      Moreover, new elections to the State Duma are coming soon, you will elect them again and you cannot go to the Maidan, what do you want like in Ukraine? Or to the Swamp White Ribbons?
      Silently endure the hardships and deprivation of service in the capitalist republic.
    5. +2
      26 August 2020 14: 18
      Genesis chapter 6:
      19 Bring also into the ark, of all animals, and of all flesh, in pairs, so that they may remain alive with you. male and female, let them be.

      20 Of birds after their kind, and of cattle after their kind, and of all that creep on the earth after their kind, of all of them, a couple of them will come in to you to keep them alive.
    6. +4
      27 August 2020 08: 19
      Quote: Svarog
      Drones who bought themselves a warm place. In such a format, which was built by the guarantor, the State Duma is a worthless body that absorbs taxpayer money.

      That's right, the Duma is not needed. Leave the Federation Council as an advisory body. And the laws may well be written by a special commission of lawyers under the President, and by his decrees they will come into force.
  2. +17
    26 August 2020 10: 09
    At this point in time, neither the Council nor the Federation Council makes sense, only a giant hole in the budget! It is clear to everyone that the commander-in-chief said that and no one will utter a word, especially the pocket opposition.
  3. +13
    26 August 2020 10: 10
    And Zhores Alferov has passed away for a year now, the author needs to check what you publish.
  4. +15
    26 August 2020 10: 15
    The overwhelming majority did not work for a single day in production. And some didn't really work at all.
    1. +10
      26 August 2020 10: 49
      Quote: Van 16
      The overwhelming majority did not work for a single day in production. And some didn't really work at all.

      good
      They don't know the price of a labor ruble ...
      1. +8
        26 August 2020 11: 28
        Quote: ROSS 42
        They don't know the price of a labor ruble ...

        The point is ... I remember how the locksmith Shandybin regretted that he did not have 11 million dollars to buy a deputy's chair when he blew out the elections.
  5. +8
    26 August 2020 10: 16
    There are also only two professional scientists in the State Duma of Russia of the VII convocation. True, these are world-famous luminaries: Zhores Alferov and Artur Chilingarov. But ... Somehow not enough, don't you think? However, they themselves chose, didn't they?


    Zhores Ivanovich Alferov - Soviet and Russian scientist-physicist, politician. Nobel Prize Laureate in Physics. Vice President of the Russian Academy of Sciences from 1991 to 2017. Chairman of the Presidium of the St. Petersburg Scientific Center of the Russian Academy of Sciences. Academician of the USSR Academy of Sciences. Honored Power Engineer of the Russian Federation.
    Born: March 15, 1930, Vitebsk, Belarus
    Died: March 1, 2019, St. Petersburg
  6. +6
    26 August 2020 10: 16
    State Duma professionals. Who did they work before being elected as deputies?

    what nafig difference ??? if in these faces, almost everyone, nothing of the definition of "people's choice" is left in the blink of an eye, as soon as they receive a "trust mandate" !!!
  7. +16
    26 August 2020 10: 21
    As Mark Twain said, if something depended on our choice we would not be allowed to vote. Where workers, engineers, and their peasants now do not allow them to simply not pass the filter before the vote, the authorities have reliably fenced off from the people. All these dependents voted to rob pensioners and took 5 years of their lives, or even more.
    1. +4
      26 August 2020 10: 34
      I agree, it is said very accurately and well, you can add Socrates, something like this, and many politicians repeated after him in different tones: "Democracy is the worst form of government."
      1. +2
        27 August 2020 21: 15
        Socrates said this, presumably, in the transmission of Plato, but how he actually believed it seems not very well known. Integral works of Socrates have not survived. Well, and Plato - what about Plato? Dionysius the Younger called him twice and drove him out twice, but still he died not as Socrates, but safely in his home. Aristotle brought up, and Aristotle educated Alexander the Great. It would be strange if Plato, being in the service of Dionysius and having such connections, would praise democracy.
  8. +3
    26 August 2020 10: 21
    Reduce the staff by at least half, and what kind of savings should be, unless of course you save ... I also tend to think that this is a windbag "organ" ..
    If they are not at the same time with the head of state, then the result is a swan, cancer and pike. No one is hot, not cold, everything is at his own (it was under E.B.N.) ...
    If the Duma is at the same time with the head of state, then there is no sense from them either, the head is already in his opinion (now) ...
    Awesome parasites ...
  9. +7
    26 August 2020 10: 33
    The state policy of Russia is not formed in the Duma. So you can safely recruit circus performers there.
    1. -4
      26 August 2020 10: 53
      It seems to me that you are not quite right. If you take a closer look at this very policy, validity, timeliness, efficiency, etc., it becomes clear. that somewhere there all this is formed
      1. +1
        26 August 2020 15: 43
        There, "this" is only voiced
    2. Aag
      +1
      28 August 2020 15: 11
      Quote: Harry Cuper
      The state policy of Russia is not formed in the Duma. So you can safely recruit circus performers there.

      Then maybe it's better to scatter the Duma around the circuses?
      1. 0
        28 August 2020 20: 38
        A good idea. But they will not voluntarily go to circuses, they have already worked there. Profit is not the same
  10. +2
    26 August 2020 10: 38
    There are 24 people who consider themselves professional politicians. Not so much for parliament, is it?

    It is better that they are not in the Duma at all.
  11. +1
    26 August 2020 11: 22
    And not a single professional priestess of love? (with reduced social responsibility) belay
    As it is not tolerant ...
    1. +5
      26 August 2020 12: 35
      Quote: Bastinda
      As it is not tolerant ...

      And at least a couple of Negroes laughing
  12. +3
    26 August 2020 11: 27
    They did not work and are not going to work.
  13. +4
    26 August 2020 11: 32
    A real freak show, which, sitting at the feet of the sovereign's throne, picks out the laws against the people and the future of Russia.
    1. 0
      26 August 2020 15: 44
      Yes, the Emperor also makes these laws to sign.
      1. +2
        26 August 2020 16: 03
        God save the king
  14. +5
    26 August 2020 11: 35
    We didn't choose them. They were assigned without us. And elections are a show for the people. So that the people think that they are choosing someone.
  15. +2
    26 August 2020 11: 37
    How was it in the USSR? I would like to compare, with examples of production leaders traveling from the provinces to the next meeting ... The ratio of the salaries of the current elect with their colleagues in the Soviet Union
    1. +6
      26 August 2020 14: 53
      Quote: Igor Polovodov
      How was it in the USSR? I would like to compare, with examples of production leaders traveling from the provinces to the next meeting ... The ratio of the salaries of the current elect with their colleagues in the Soviet Union

      In accordance with the Constitution of the USSR, People's Deputies of the USSR
      exercise their powers, as a rule, without breaking with official or
      production activities.
      People's Deputies of the USSR have the right to be exempted from
      official or work duties for the period required
      deputy for the implementation of deputy activities.

      People's Deputies of the USSR are reimbursed for expenses related to
      deputy activity, in the amount of 200 rubles per month, not
      taxed with income tax.
      In the event that a People's Deputy of the USSR is at the same time
      a people's deputy of a union or autonomous republic, he is compensated
      expenses related to parliamentary activities, only as a national
      Deputy of the USSR.

      200 rubles is at that time, in fact, the average salary .. These are expenses associated with parliamentary activities .. and so for the month of work received salary. That is, now the deputy should receive 30 rubles. for expenses .. and the rest at the main place of work ..
  16. +1
    26 August 2020 12: 01
    Quote: Ragnar Lothbrok
    We are great talents, But clear and simple. We are singers and musicians, acrobats and jesters.

    how does the blonde in the underwear differ from the blonde in the underwear ??
    - standard of living
    https://otvet.mail.ru/question/28156016
  17. +14
    26 August 2020 12: 20
    450 stupefied with impunity and dough, completely irresponsible ghoul with their states and kept women, necessary solely to imitate the notorious pseudo-democratic institution, it seems like we also have something like humans. A completely uncontrolled and irresponsible organization from its voters, many so-called deputies, even in the region that they did not represent, are in no way connected and do not depend on the standard of living and development of this region, and therefore are not interested in its development. There are still parallel structures and crowds of parasites, such as all sorts of so-called. popular fronts and other "public" organizations. You can just as well add to this pack of parasites the extremely incomprehensible office of the Federation Council, the nest of the "boyar class", as a rule, with a "murky" past, all kinds of "reserves", exs, councils and funds. This whole huge pack of all kinds of deputies, representatives of everything and everyone, feeds and feeds, from one feeding trough at the expense of the country and people, whom they despise and hate, and most importantly, they do not associate their future and their servants with them, therefore they are not interested in them. development. I will not forget how they jumped up with a standing ovation, when a shabby overseas deputy accidentally wandered over to them, well at least they didn’t fall on their knees. There are, of course, decent and honest people there, but there are very few of them and their voice is not heard. But in general, this is a useless, inert and parasitic structure, without initiative and often even hostile to the state, intellectually incapable of any progressive activity and development ...
  18. BAI
    +4
    26 August 2020 12: 54
    At the same time, mind you, 41 deputies have the scientific degree of candidate of economic sciences, and 15 are even doctors in the same field! How is this possible? Riddle ...

    There is no mystery. There is such an office - RANHIGS, one of the tasks of which is the gradualization of representatives of the highest echelon of power and business.
    They would have asked better how Khorkina defended her candidate without leaving big sport (where, as you know, all the time - for training). In 2002. She entered RANHIGS after 2010. And, in general, infa slipped that she was already a doctor. At least in 2003 it was announced that she was going to write her doctorate.
    1. -1
      27 August 2020 07: 07
      Quote: BAI
      They would have asked better how Khorkina defended her candidate without leaving big sport (where, as you know, all the time - for training). In 2002. She entered RANHIGS after 2010.

      In fact, she finished her postgraduate studies at the Russian State Academy of Physical Culture and defended herself there. How? Was not present. If you have valid arguments, write to the Higher Attestation Commission under the Ministry of Education and Science of the Russian Federation. Collecting gossip is not the most respected occupation. The argument that she should hang on the crossbars all her life (sports) without interruption and there should be no time for study is ridiculous. In that academy, almost all students and graduate students are active athletes, many of them very titled. The people are trying their best. Sports success in sports is achieved by the most stubborn. This character trait manifests itself in any business, so I do not have any questions about their ability to achieve their goals. They do not sit on VO, but are engaged in a real business, sometimes even a loved one ... laughing
      1. 0
        27 August 2020 10: 19
        Don't talk nonsense, she already hurts. It just so happened that I studied at the Faculty of Physical Education. It is clear that we had not bad athletes either. It is also clear that they were far from Khorkina's level, but they stood out strongly in the general mass of students of the faculty. So, we saw them only during the session, and even then for 2-3 days. Fly "passed" tests and exams - excellently, and again - training camps, competitions.
        1. 0
          27 August 2020 10: 30
          Quote: val43
          So, we saw them only during the session, and even then for 2-3 days. Fly "passed" tests and exams - excellently, and again - training camps, competitions.

          Those who study for the "crust" and appear only on tests do not go to science. We don’t need all one yardstick ... Olympic gold doesn’t work at the Higher Attestation Commission. At seven or three I defended myself, I saw these defenses ... The leaders (and almost the leaders) of the oil enterprises bend like children. And then the VAK must check and approve the result in absentia. "Stalder feet apart" is not protected.
  19. +4
    26 August 2020 13: 45
    I hope that some time will pass and almost the entire composition of this thought will be remembered as a nasty anecdote ...
    1. 0
      26 August 2020 16: 57
      Quote: Million
      I hope that some time will pass and almost the entire composition of this thought will be remembered as a nasty anecdote ...

      and the next and the next and so on ad infinitum laughing
  20. +7
    26 August 2020 13: 51
    The most interesting thing is that no one elected half of the deputies, they are not elected representatives of the people - they were appointed by the parties that went to the Duma.
  21. 0
    26 August 2020 14: 27
    State Duma professionals. Who did they work before being elected as deputies?


    By and large - athletes and whistle-dancers.
  22. +4
    26 August 2020 14: 58
    interesting .. here they are without the Federation Council (which is generally cool in composition) - 450 carcasses + a couple of thousand servants .. but if you leave 45? besides saving 10 times, what will change? Or at least establish that the nominee from the region must be registered there for at least 10 years, otherwise they are elected from the constituencies in which they were not really, represent their interests, and the passage on party lists is generally super, almost anyone can be dragged into Duma ..
    As my teacher, the professor said, to halve the Federal Duma, to disperse the rest, nothing will change ..
    1. -1
      27 August 2020 08: 03
      Quote: Level 2 Advisor
      interesting .. here are them without the Federation Council (which is generally cool in composition) - 450 carcasses + a couple of thousand servants .. and if you leave 45?

      Federation Council - 170 members. 2 from each subject + President's quota.
      Quote: Level 2 Advisor
      to establish that a nominee from the region must be registered there for at least 10 years, otherwise they are elected from the districts in which they were not really, represent their interests

      Five years of settled life is established. Why do you need 10 years of registration. A third of Moscow lives with a residence permit from all over Russia. And what does it solve? They are appointees of regional authorities and fulfill the will of those who appointed them there. So everything is in the hands of the governors.
      Quote: Level 2 Advisor
      but the passage on party lists is generally super, almost anyone can be dragged into the Duma ..

      The EP, so far the only one of all, began to conduct the so-called. "primaries", i.e. election of candidates from the party. You may well participate in the formation of the list. What is the problem? By the way, the communists have not yet come to this. Probably, they have part of the mandates for commercial projects. wassat
      Quote: Level 2 Advisor
      As my teacher, the professor said, to halve the Federal Duma, to disperse the rest, nothing will change ..

      After all, we all once dreamed of democracy ... So we got what we wanted. The fact that a significant part of the population "votes without regaining consciousness" does not fall as a blot on the electorate. You have to think when we put the checkbox. Do you (or your professor) propose to return to the USSR and vote unanimously for any proposal from the Politburo? The golden time was then. The Central Committee (allegedly elected by someone) was removed from the law and even from the control of the almighty KGB. Why aren't you gods? Do you want that democracy? Dispersal of parliament usually begins troubled times in which a lot of innocent blood is shed. This is history. You have to learn from it. And to exclaim about "drones who bought warm places" without productive proposals to control their work can only be envious losers or "specialists on the salary of the US Embassy", because they fulfill their task - to sow confusion and enmity between parts of society. Some, foolishly, out of closeness, meet their posts with applause. Well, we shit our own choice. Who got better? Have you shown that everything you choose and what you fight for is a complete insignificance? This is how you describe yourself as a voter. Or do you want all those who criticize their own Duma to say that they have chosen these mediocrities without you? So you are twice mediocre - you didn’t choose the smart ones yourself, and gave you the choice of idiot. You've plunged yourself into shit. Delicious, huh?
  23. -5
    26 August 2020 15: 38
    At the time of writing my comment, I specifically looked at the number of predecessors - 51 sofa experts - all noteworthy percussionists of labor and doctors of related sciences, judging by the time of the working day and the ability to pound the keys without letting go of the pick from the calloused hands! Be ashamed ... And Natalia Poklonskaya is a people's deputy, and I voted for her! It is better to analyze who you have chosen, otherwise you are used to blaming the mirror!
  24. +2
    26 August 2020 16: 55
    However, they themselves chose!
    I have never voted for all of the above, as well as for "United Russia" - no need to generalize.
  25. Lew
    0
    26 August 2020 17: 01
    limit the professions of people who can apply for election to the Duma ...
    for example, to completely exclude the possibility of getting into the Duma as a deputy:
    unemployed
    lawyer
    actor
    artist
    the writer
    graduates of all stripes of managerial and managerial universities, as well as political institutions
    work experience in the profession received must be real, after graduation from a school or institute at least 10 years
    this is in brief ..... anyone interested, I can expand the list of restrictions ..
    Why do the latter go to lawyers? .. Yes, because the duty of lawyers to comply with laws and help write new ones, and not to invent and justify nonsense. One lawyer has ruled the government for 20 years and where are the results?
    1. -1
      27 August 2020 08: 08
      Quote: Lew
      limit the professions of people who can apply for election to the Duma ...

      You can only choose a cleaning lady from a soap factory from your list. laughing You are not called Adolf in the world? laughing You forgot to mention the Jews, Gypsies, Slavs ... Did you understand what you were calling for?
  26. +2
    26 August 2020 18: 07
    State Duma professionals. Who did they work before being elected as deputies?

    Zhirinovsky headed the "Zionist organization" of Moscow in the early 90s ..)))) And then he became the main anti-Semite accusing them of all the sins of Russia ha ha ha
    And Zyuganov fled the White House under the pretext of collecting miners for defense in 93 ..
    Lebed was a good commander, his very rival Grachev! But as politicians, nothing and even worse .. The list is long, I’m already silent about the bandits and murderers who were legalized in this way ..
    The Duma needs to be changed and drastically, it stinks like hell ... hi
  27. +2
    27 August 2020 00: 02
    To put them all on a living wage and a median wage, you look and sense would be
    1. +1
      27 August 2020 11: 11
      How cruel you are.))) They won't even live a month if they go to work.)))
  28. +3
    27 August 2020 11: 13
    But seriously, I don’t understand why the hell do you need so many loafers.)
  29. +2
    27 August 2020 14: 51
    True, this is a world-famous luminary, Artur Chilingarov. But ... A little bit, don’t you think? However, they themselves chose!
    Forgot to write who exactly "chose"! We certainly have nothing to do with it!
  30. -1
    30 August 2020 09: 20
    I did not choose these and did not vote for them.
  31. 0
    1 September 2020 09: 12
    I like Italian parliamentarians better! At least they do not hide the fact that they are workers of the most ancient profession. Chichelina for example. And in general, about the deputies of the Russian Federation, either good or nothing (they adopted this wassat ) We are waiting for the elections! And there we will give an assessment. hi
  32. 0
    2 September 2020 03: 59
    professional politicians ..., it is understandable ..., but in simple terms - persons of facilitated social responsibility--, the nomenclature is updated ..., irresponsible workers ..., cloaca ..., if there are exceptions, then only those who score usually ..., the foam of modern Russian society.

"Right Sector" (banned in Russia), "Ukrainian Insurgent Army" (UPA) (banned in Russia), ISIS (banned in Russia), "Jabhat Fatah al-Sham" formerly "Jabhat al-Nusra" (banned in Russia) , Taliban (banned in Russia), Al-Qaeda (banned in Russia), Anti-Corruption Foundation (banned in Russia), Navalny Headquarters (banned in Russia), Facebook (banned in Russia), Instagram (banned in Russia), Meta (banned in Russia), Misanthropic Division (banned in Russia), Azov (banned in Russia), Muslim Brotherhood (banned in Russia), Aum Shinrikyo (banned in Russia), AUE (banned in Russia), UNA-UNSO (banned in Russia), Mejlis of the Crimean Tatar people (banned in Russia), Legion “Freedom of Russia” (armed formation, recognized as terrorist in the Russian Federation and banned), Kirill Budanov (included to the Rosfinmonitoring list of terrorists and extremists)

“Non-profit organizations, unregistered public associations or individuals performing the functions of a foreign agent,” as well as media outlets performing the functions of a foreign agent: “Medusa”; "Voice of America"; "Realities"; "Present time"; "Radio Freedom"; Ponomarev Lev; Ponomarev Ilya; Savitskaya; Markelov; Kamalyagin; Apakhonchich; Makarevich; Dud; Gordon; Zhdanov; Medvedev; Fedorov; Mikhail Kasyanov; "Owl"; "Alliance of Doctors"; "RKK" "Levada Center"; "Memorial"; "Voice"; "Person and law"; "Rain"; "Mediazone"; "Deutsche Welle"; QMS "Caucasian Knot"; "Insider"; "New Newspaper"