Military Review

In Iran, the defeat of the Ukrainian airliner was explained by “incorrect settings” of air defense

32
In Iran, the defeat of the Ukrainian airliner was explained by “incorrect settings” of air defense

The air defense complex, which shot down the Ukrainian airliner near Tehran, was previously relocated and not reconfigured, the organization’s civilian report says. aviation Iran dedicated to the investigation of the incident.


According to the report, at night, Iran launched a missile attack on an American military base in Iraq, after which "the level of readiness of the country's air defense" was changed. In preparation for the possible repulsion of an air attack, one of the air defense systems was moved, but no new tuning was carried out on it.

One of Tehran’s air defense systems was relocated. This led to a change in its geographical position and direction. (...) no migration was performed after the move

- the document says.

The report indicates that due to the movement of the air defense system and incorrect settings, the system of the complex mistakenly recognized the Ukrainian airliner as an object approaching Tehran, although in fact the plane was moving away from the Iranian capital.

The second mistake that led to the defeat of the aircraft was that there was no data exchange between the air defense system and the focal point.

The operator identifies the aircraft as an "enemy target" and, not receiving a response from the air defense coordination center, launches the first missile on the plane, after which the second

- the report says.

Recall that a Ukrainian passenger plane flying out of Tehran crashed on the morning of January 8, 2020. The accident killed 176 people. On January 11, the Iranian military announced that the airliner was shot down by accident, and the "human factor" was the cause of this.
32 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must to register.

I have an account? Sign in

  1. orionvitt
    orionvitt 12 July 2020 08: 51 New
    +2
    I said the lack of professionalism of Iranian air defense .. So from the alternatively gifted forum participants in the military, I learned a lot about myself here. They threw cons, from the heart. Well, how do you like this news now.
    reconfiguration failed
    Although, they may simply voice one reason to hide another.
    1. D16
      D16 12 July 2020 09: 34 New
      0
      I said the lack of professionalism of Iranian air defense ..

      Experience, the son of difficult mistakes. (C) This is not the first civilian plane shot down by mistake by the military. At least one rake Iranian air defense came.
      1. Mitroha
        Mitroha 12 July 2020 11: 30 New
        0
        All the same, my opinion is not the actions of the Iranian leadership and not an air defense error (although, of course, this is quite possible), but a well-planned setup.
        Too on time
        1. Tuzik
          Tuzik 12 July 2020 12: 30 New
          -1
          The Russians do not give up! smile
        2. 4ekist
          4ekist 12 July 2020 16: 26 New
          +1
          .... after moving the reconfiguration was not performed ......
          The operator identifies the aircraft as an "enemy target" and, not receiving a response from the air defense coordination center, launches the first missile on the plane, and then the second.

          The operator must be awarded, acted boldly and decisively.
  2. Victor_B
    Victor_B 12 July 2020 08: 53 New
    +3
    Howler...
    Out of the blue ...
    Typical "human factor".
  3. svp67
    svp67 12 July 2020 08: 59 New
    +1
    In any case, this is the fault of the Iranian side ...
  4. Poetry
    Poetry 12 July 2020 09: 06 New
    +3
    Innocent victims are the worst thing that can happen. It’s sad.
  5. Junior Warrant Officer
    Junior Warrant Officer 12 July 2020 09: 09 New
    +1
    Wait please!
    But what about US intervention?
    After the tragedy, here 90% of commentators based on information received from Kiselyov, Solovyov, Skabeeva, Simonyan - bombarded us with incontrovertible evidence of the American trace ...
    Although the incorrect settings of the Iranian air defense complex are American affairs (see this version on all federal channels tonight).
    1. ender
      ender 12 July 2020 09: 25 New
      -1
      only experienced Russian experts know the whole truth. gold reserve of the first channel

      1. Jack O'Neill
        Jack O'Neill 12 July 2020 16: 17 New
        0
        Pff ... From the beginning of the catastrophe, we began to excuse Iran.
    2. D16
      D16 12 July 2020 09: 26 New
      +1
      But what about US intervention?

      You do not know, in connection with which "the level of readiness of the country's air defense" was changed? This Carapace would have stood in the same place, there would have been no tragedy. I do not take responsibility for the slovenliness of the local air defenses. But the circles on the water went from a stone thrown by the Americans. But after the incident, the Iranians will definitely not confuse the cardinal points. Charters are written in blood.
      1. alone
        alone 12 July 2020 11: 19 New
        +4
        Quote: D16
        This Carapace would have stood in the same place, there would have been no tragedy.

        There stood the SAM Tor. The shell was not there
        1. D16
          D16 12 July 2020 11: 20 New
          0
          Sorry. Of course Thor. laughing
    3. Terenin
      Terenin 12 July 2020 09: 42 New
      0
      Quote: Junior Ensign
      Wait please!
      But what about US intervention?

      Yes, calm down, get off your knees and drink some water ...
      USA, this is holier than all saints! winked
  6. Avior
    Avior 12 July 2020 09: 29 New
    +6
    Honestly, a question arises.
    The plane was shot down because they did not make a topographic reference and mistakenly determined that it was flying to Tehran.
    But, it turns out, if everyone had tuned in, would they have shot down some sort of plane landing at Tehran?
    I also remember when they recognized the downed one, they said something else. That supposedly the plane suddenly turned on the protected air defense facility.
    When will we still hear the final version?
    1. alone
      alone 12 July 2020 11: 17 New
      +5
      Quote: Avior
      When will we still hear the final version?

      I never think. Yes, and this is not surprising. In Iran there is no unified air defense system. It is divided into air defense systems that are subordinate to the IRGC U, and there is air defense which is subordinate to the Ministry of Defense. Moreover, the Ministry of Defense does not have a decree for the IRGC .. The IRGC is subordinate to the religious leader of Iran .. the relationship with the Ministry of Defense is very controversial. In words it is, but in the case it’s the other way around. Each acts at its discretion. hi
  7. alone
    alone 12 July 2020 10: 00 New
    +4
    Hence the conclusion: It’s dangerous to fly to Tehran ... Well, let's take into account
    1. Revolver
      Revolver 12 July 2020 19: 07 New
      0
      It’s dangerous in Iran. They will appoint them guilty for anything, and you will end up in their prison as pretty. Or maybe you will hang, it will become from them. The truth is basically like the former Iranian citizens who came to visit relatives.
      1. alone
        alone 12 July 2020 19: 11 New
        +1
        Quote: Nagan
        Iran is finally dangerous. They will appoint them guilty for anything, and you will be guilty in their prison as cute. Or maybe you will hang, it will become from them. The truth is basically like the former Iranian citizens who came to visit relatives.

        That's right. They can punish you with sticks in the back 80 times, chop off the brush if something else is upset, and at worst hang on a white crane on a truck crane .. Iran is governed by Sharia law (in the Iranian version)
  8. huntsman650
    huntsman650 12 July 2020 10: 21 New
    +1
    Complete nonsense, crap. Typically, a firing sector is assigned, with decentralized management. Those. they were transferred, but the shelling sector did not change?))))
  9. Dmitry Makarov
    Dmitry Makarov 12 July 2020 11: 59 New
    +2
    Just after the assassination of Suleymani and the destruction by the Iranians of the American base in Iraq, the Iranians with Canadian citizenship, were afraid of the war, and decided to dump in Canada.
    For these purposes, Bandera sowing was called from Ukraine, on which they intended to leave their homeland.
    But the hand of the Iranian anti-aircraft gunner did not flinch, and the enemy board, filled with traitors, collapsed to the ground.
    1. Cristall
      Cristall 12 July 2020 12: 51 New
      -3
      Quote: Dmitry Makarov
      Just after the assassination of Suleymani and the destruction by the Iranians of the American base in Iraq, the Iranians with Canadian citizenship, were afraid of the war, and decided to dump in Canada.
      For these purposes, Bandera sowing was called from Ukraine, on which they intended to leave their homeland.
      But the hand of the Iranian anti-aircraft gunner did not flinch, and the enemy board, filled with traitors, collapsed to the ground.

      forgot to add that the course was changed by the Pentagon to Kiev
      Ukraine Airlines International Airlines (UIA) Boeing 737-800 airliner operated PS752 international flight from Tehran to Kiev, but about 3 minutes after take-off it was shot down by two ground-to-air missiles launched from the IRGC bases.
      At the same time, the Canadians, Swedes, Ukrainians, the British, and the Afghan people were blown up by the “traitors” ..
      so for sure!
      Retribution overtook the “traitors" after 3 minutes .. Operationally!
      Now it’s clear why RENT TV is resting.
  10. Old26
    Old26 12 July 2020 12: 42 New
    +2
    I do not quite understand what “reconfiguration” means in the context of this tragedy. According to Iran
    that due to the movement of the air defense complex and incorrect settings, the system of the complex mistakenly recognized the Ukrainian airliner as an object approaching Tehran, although in fact the plane was moving away from the Iranian capital.

    The airport is located south of Tehran. The takeoff direction does not even come close to the capital. In fact, the plane was moving in the direction of the air defense system. To approach the capital, he must move perpendicular to the real direction of flight. I would like to know the opinion of those who served in the air defense about all these "settings"
  11. Shahno
    Shahno 12 July 2020 13: 55 New
    0
    Strange information .. Well then they are surprised that they cannot protect their nuclear program. Look as they say in your ranks.
    Ps. And we are always ready to help our friends ... Here recently, lightnings "bombed" them, and the base is not nearby. Once again overslept "settings" ...
  12. iouris
    iouris 12 July 2020 13: 55 New
    0
    I think that the operator still got a muzzle.
    The carrier is responsible for the safety of passengers. In that situation it was possible to fly, but it was possible not to fly, to wait for discharge. Who and what conclusions will be drawn from what happened is a matter of political orientation.
  13. Evil 55
    Evil 55 12 July 2020 13: 56 New
    -3
    Everything that belongs to UKRALINE has been perceived by potential citizens of the world as potentially dangerous or enemy for more than five years ..
  14. Zaurbek
    Zaurbek 12 July 2020 14: 45 New
    +1
    Grenades they have the wrong system ....
  15. Jack O'Neill
    Jack O'Neill 12 July 2020 16: 13 New
    -2
    Another otmaza Iran. Interesting.
    One of Tehran’s air defense systems was relocated. This led to a change in its geographical position and direction. (...) no migration was performed after the move

    Why then didn’t they hit the airliners that took off before?
    But what about the version of the "secret object"? What is not relevant already?
    The Iranians, as if in a frying pan, wriggle, do not know what to think of already.

    I wonder what happened to the people who posted on the Internet video with missiles in Boeing? What is their fate? I think that unenviable ...
    1. Revolver
      Revolver 12 July 2020 19: 16 New
      0
      Quote: Jack O'Neill
      Why then didn’t they hit the airliners that took off before?

      And therefore. This flight finally had to fly a day earlier, but somewhere someone was imported with something, and the departure was postponed the next morning. This board took off first on that particular day.
      1. Jack O'Neill
        Jack O'Neill 12 July 2020 20: 43 New
        -1
        And therefore. This flight finally had to fly a day earlier, but somewhere someone was imported with something, and the departure was postponed the next morning. This board took off first on that particular day.

        Flight rescheduling is a normal practice. We do not shoot down liners that took off a few hours or half a day later.
        1. Revolver
          Revolver 12 July 2020 23: 48 New
          0
          Quote: Jack O'Neill
          Flight rescheduling is a normal practice. We do not shoot down liners that took off a few hours or half a day later.

          Nevertheless, he took off first after a long delay in take-offs and landings caused by the fear of the Persians to receive an attack that did not take place.