Understand the present and calculate the future. Where does efficiency come from?

The author has a classic Soviet engineering education, which allows analyzing in space and time, including the ability to see processes sometimes from an unexpected angle. There is a sad joke of the author’s generation: it’s time for those who have finished school before 1993 to graduate and who have completed vocational school well before 1993 to have a Ph.D.

The note is critical and written almost in the style of theses. Those who don’t like criticism and who are used to a measured coverage of issues should not read it.

Optimization or the path to collapse?

Optimization, as it is done in Russia, is the path to collapse. Slightly worse conditions, and the optimized industry can no longer cope. Accountants must calculate the savings. And experienced managers must decide. Leaders with positive experience, creators, but not theorists.

The momentary accountant will calculate the calculation and declare that it is cheaper for him to ruin his civil Aviation and buy Boeing and Airbus. What is cheaper for him to buy electronics and engines on the side. That it’s cheaper for him to collect all the ships in one bay, and all the planes at one airport. That a strategic supply of doctors, beds and medicines is not needed.

I repeatedly got involved in adventures with the development of new types of products. And he got involved with the team - with complex technology, the best result is obtained with the focus of the masses. God is on the side of the large battalions, as Marshal Turenne used to say. In production, we tried to run ahead of the engine, to be prepared for a worsening situation, and in the 90s we managed not to fall when the situation worsened, and even if external factors were constant, we developed. But this happened only with some reserves for development - material, financial, personnel.

I’m wondering: at the top we didn’t see where Ukraine was heading and what we could buy from it; what will happen after the beneficence of Norway a huge piece of the sea; how will the policy of "optimization" of their machine tool industry end? Not a lot of momentary accountants? And I ask you to keep in mind that at the beginning of 2017 it was not me, but the prime minister made the discovery that machine tool building was ruined.

There are good books by Andrei Parshev, including that due to the climate, our cost of production will be greater than in Europe, the Americas and China, all other things being equal. At our place, an employee needs to have winter clothes, a warm house with increased heating costs, a similarly warm workshop, and so on and so forth. But we have huge reserves of energy and generally everything that eliminates the uncomfortable climate and energy costs of production. That is bash on bash, in many ways we are self-sufficient! Go ahead and with the songs!

And now the saying and the joke.

Better to go than to run. Better to stand than to go. Better to lie than to stand. And it's better to die than to lie. Although in appearance it is more optimal to lie.

Hodja Nasruddin began to optimize the donkey, load more and feed less. Everything was going well, but once the donkey failed Hodge, he took it and died.

Who knows how and what

A huge number of countries need educated citizens, those who know how to do and what to do, understand the connection of phenomena, who understand the need to live with an eye to the past and calculating the future.

About thirty years old, I realized that it’s more effective, albeit harder, to work with caring, comprehensively competent and skilled people who will tell you about your mistakes. I think that the leader began to turn out of me when I figured out the appropriate position and removed the employee from the team leaders, telling me and others how wonderful I am. And then I realized that there are no incapable and nowhere needed people (of course, except for the scanty percentage of very sick people with a head), people need to be taught and interested. What kind of a bad employee should be answered by his immediate boss, who did not teach, did not interest, did not figure out whether this place was his. And we have videos on the Internet where elite people talk about millions of unnecessary ones that do not fit into the market. About the uselessness and danger of knowledge for the bulk of people and the need for school education of consumers. About the danger of inflation, if you help the poor in a pandemic ... And this was said because these people do not know what and how to keep people busy. They are momentary accountants. They are many 146 million in 17 million square meters. km Yes, and of those millions are engaged in unproductive labor, for example, we have an inexplicably huge number of guards and officials.

Proportionality to the place

Never judge a person by appearance or by the impression of a first glance. Vysotsky said well: “Never judge at first glance either a dog or a person. Because a simple mongrel can have a kind soul, and a man of pleasant appearance can be a rare bastard. " It is believed that beauty is a harmonious combination. And in my opinion, this is some kind of small asymmetric deviation from proportionality. And proportionality is clear from its name. From proportionality to the place, living conditions. And proportionality is pretty, causes sympathy.

I studied at UPI with a guy from Eastern Siberia, as he once said that he did not like Russian girls. They are ugly. Ugly they have: a long nose, large eyes, narrow cheekbones. And by the end of the second or third year he began to like them. For a couple of years, he got used to our girls and began to look almost with our eyes. According to the female beauty, Napoleon perfectly expressed himself when asked about his wives: “A beautiful wife is a jewel, and a good wife is a whole treasure.” By kind, he meant the first wife, unfortunately, childless, Josephine. Pay attention to the Hungarians. About a millennium ago, their ancestors were apparently not Tatars, not Kalmyks, but now? This is the result of a change in genotype from a change in habitat.

I had a childhood friend. A wonderful person and smart. Low, the face is said to be rustic like that of Dr. Roshal. In his village kin, everyone was like that. By the way, my village grandmother said "basky" about a beautiful girl. I had in mind normal features, a normal figure, smooth movements, neatness and nothing more. And grandmother often said that a person should be judged by deeds, not by words.

I paraphrase a good expression a little: I look at our proud, well-groomed, successful elite, and I feel a warm feeling: a coiled-up teacher from the backwoods; surprisingly conscientious cleaning lady, cleaning my porch with my daughter; Dr. Roshal; the unsociable and groomed mathematician Perelman; cool team leaders from my production.

Comments

[Ross xnumx]

Understand the present and calculate the future. Where does efficiency come from?

You should immediately determine the thieves' (speculative) “effectiveness”. It’s all simple: I took it from a sucker, pecked it into the common fund and live on without “shining.” Even the future calculated: “No matter how much you twist ...” The effectiveness in this case is determined by the length of the period and the skill of “hanging noodles on the ears” .
It is in this environment that such notions as honor, decency, responsibility, competence are not popular ... Everything that Mikhail Mikhailovich said is true:

There is no phrase: "Let me take it upon myself" or: "It's difficult for you, let me ..." And the phrase: "I directed you, I will be responsible for everything" is just a stake in my throat. And this: "My place is not dear to me, our business is dear" - it turns out only in parts. It has become difficult for the time being to play an erudite, thinking person, and although the performer wrinkles his forehead and squints, such a skewed face does not convince. Costumes and shoes have survived, but when we see the face and head of a barmaid of a modern anti-aircraft school over the old noble clothes, something prevents us from believing in her Latin.

[Sling cutter]

Quote: ROSS 42

Efficiency in this case is determined by the length of the period and the skill of "hanging noodles on the ears."

The only thing that definitely cannot be denied to Putinism is the cynical, incredible and total lie always and in everything.

[Crowe]

Optimization. Fashionable state word by which people are misled.
From the word "optimal". Any criterion is suitable for summing up a situation under this term. This is usually economic feasibility. The state pretends to be in the economy, and therefore everything happens through one well-known place. Nobody optimizes prices at gas stations or ministerial staff of officials. Optimizing schools and hospitals. It is not profitable to keep an entire first aid post in a village where 500 people live. Some of them may die due to lack of first aid, but still give birth. Too expensive. How to extinguish massive forest fires. In words, we always have a person - the most important thing, but a person can be understood in different ways. For the government, this is not all individuals of the human sex; it is a narrow circle of oligarchs and officials.

[Mavrikiy]

Quote: Crowe

This is usually economic feasibility.

Actually, there should be responsibility for the affairs. And strict. He didn’t have her at all. And we get a mess at the exit. From here legs grow.

[My address]

What's this! Pay attention to statements about extra people, about the uselessness of a decent education, about other things. Does this remind you of anything from history?

[vVvAD]

Social Darwinism and ordinary Nazism.

[Ilya-spb]

Efficiency is a fusion of experience and innovation based on quality education.

[vVvAD]

Not certainly in that way. What you have indicated does not conflict with expediency.
If you judge by your opinion, then with efficiency we are just doing well, judge for yourself: Experience? Of course - the current liberals have been at the helm for several years, this is their second generation - after the Yeltsin ones. Innovation? Certainly - advanced technologies of personnel management come from Europe and the USA. Quality education? Of course - obtained in the most prestigious American and European universities. And what's the output? "Effective" managers optimize, cut in a lively way, disregarding any losses and broken destinies, because they are only interested in profit here and now and a report on it, regardless of the deferred consequences and impact on the national economy and the social situation in the country. People are batteries.
Compare: in China, a change of doctor who worked with COVID-19 is 4 hours. We have 12. Because it was "optimized" earlier. Result: Doctors fall ill and die more often than others. The bed fund is overflowing and confiscated from specialized areas with serious illnesses, such as: oncology, AIDS, diabetes mellitus, multiple sclerosis, asthma, parkinson ... you can go on for a long time. Because previously "optimized". Result: hospitals are hotbeds of morbidity, people with serious illnesses cannot receive timely help, the course of their illnesses is aggravated. It is virtually impossible to receive emergency medical care, to register a disability, or to undergo a planned operation. I believe that the scale of mortality against the background of the impossibility of obtaining medical care for other diseases and cases due to the ill-considered measures introduced, we will not know soon. Total, China: about 100 thousand. sick, victory over infection in a few months, the economy is already recovering, Russia: the "European" way: almost 400 thousand, and not a fact that 500 thousand. stop. The economy was practically stopped all over the country for 2 months (why?), And not focal, we realized - we are launching in connection with the prospect of its complete destruction. It is already clear that a long recession is guaranteed.
Efficiency is not born on its own - it is the product of a scientific approach with its evidence, verifiability and repeatability of results. Such an approach was formed in the USSR, but it began to collapse under Khrushchev-Brezhnev. And it was called SCIENTIFIC THEORY OF MANAGEMENT.

[Malyuta]

Quote: My address

Pay attention to statements about extra people, about the uselessness of a decent education, about other things. Does this remind you of anything from history?

In our country, people have been talking about extra people since 1991.

[Keyser soze]

I have not read such cute articles for a long time. Thanks for the work.

[New Year day]

Quote: Crowe

Optimization. Fashionable state word by which people are misled.

So Sobyanin optimized Moscow health care, and then he began to build hospitals in the open field and recruit gatsrbeiter doctors. Money is not your own, you can spend, and you can also earn extra money for managers. For such optimization capital punishment laid

[Alexander Sosnitsky]

You cannot enter the same river twice, because everything that has flowed further. It used to be good, but there was no Samsung with its washing machines, but they opened up globalization, you have to compete with the entire "developed" world, where "man is a wolf" in the conditions of the unfinished 5th column, which will never be finished off in the absence of developed own immunity. The world has reached a level where no one understands anything, even Chabad with its utopia. The author is right that it is necessary to teach everyone and everywhere, and scientists pay good money just like that, because they try to think, otherwise everyone is hapless. We got into such a mess. And then there is nuclear weapons, which is very easy to start with one button. This is really a topic for conversation, and not about vocational schools.

[Alexander Sosnitsky]

In general, optimization in science means improvement, and those in power are stupidly using this term for deterioration, they have not learned enough at small stages of development. Although if in the criterion we change the sign to minus (f (x) -> - f (x)), then they get what they want.

[Mavrikiy]

What is cheaper for him to buy electronics and engines on the side. That it’s cheaper for him to collect all the ships in one bay, and all the planes at one airport. That a strategic supply of doctors, beds and medicines is not needed.

Wonderful! Only then will we give the right to optimization to the state. Optimized their enterprise, industry, well done. Used aircraft are falling. To the camp, not pioneer. Beds are optimized, but they could not cope with the epidemic, there is a yellow ticket for life. Then they will be engaged in optimization, rather than cutting people and the country alive.

[depressant]

And all because the country is governed by people who were not initially noticed in activities that were of any use to society. Gray, professionally faded and even worthless, not able to give rise to at least some necessary economic idea. It is for this reason that they began to be promoted upward - they are useful not to the country and people, but to the authorities. For the time was such, for whatever you take, under the auspices of the chief thief, you will be able to steal. And if the boss is a bandit, you’ll get to kill. Both that and another will be made so that does not go beyond the powers assigned to the performer. Very helpful people! Proceeding from the fact that they do not publicly shine, it means that they do not overshadow the brilliance of the radiant bossy person, who is ruthless from the stands. Therefore, they were selected for leadership of a huge country because of the time-tested habit that became an unconditioned reflex of the habit of not having an opinion, acting at the direction of, and Russia, formatted in the 90s as a raw-material colony of the collective West, continued to expose its back to the IMF whip, therefore USA. Continues and continues. For these people do not know how to do anything else. Maybe they want to. But to step over their own natural data and the experience gained in bending their own backs in an obedient bow, therefore, they are not able to bend Russia.
... I recalled a movie about the Wolf and the Hare. In the museum. The wolf, aiming at the Hare, gets a club, taken, notice, from the dummy of a primitive man, into an ancient bronze vessel. He turns into another, also ancient, then - into the third and so on. This is how we will exist. In the form of a historical relic. This is if we do not crumble under the next external blow. The strength of the material has a limit.

[New Year day]

Quote: depressant

... the country is ruled by people who were not initially noticed in any activity that was useful to society. Gray, professionally faded and even worthless ...

this was immediately clear when the cardiologist became the Minister of Agriculture and the Minister of Health.
After 20 years, it began to reach someone who was doing something wrong.

[depressant]

Yeah, we saved the medicine. Reducing it in 30 years to the level of the Soviet 30s of the last century. And how long will we reach the level of the second half of the same century? It is doubtful that we will reach at all. And it will be "pull-pull, we can't pull it out."

[Sayan]

This is so, only educated masses are not needed for any grefs in power, they need gluttonous and stupid people, because it’s easy to manage

[knn54]

Efficiency for the ruling elite consists in ONE-maximum "pump out" from Russia. For this, first of all, clerks-managers are needed.

[Mavrikiy]

Quote: Sayan

they need gluttonous and stupid,

Especially voracious. Buy, buy, more and more. Consumer. Creeping caterpillar. Vile, green, greedy ....

[samarin1969]

The author was deigned to talk about politics, and about the soul! ... If the conventional "Medvedev" cannot sleep, he can read "what the people think about." And the poet Mishustin could find a source of inspiration. Still, intelligence and style ... And not the wretched monologues of "bohemians" on channels with expensive air.

[Strashila]

“The accountants should calculate the savings.” This is immediately a mistake, the planners should calculate the economists, bring financial and material flows in time into a single model.

[My address]

Allow me to disagree. Even in a small business unit, the accountant is usually subordinate to the economist / planner. And in a large enterprise, the chief accountant, usually submits and receives tasks from the deputy director / chief economist. He knew the situation when the director closed the chief accountant on himself and the workshops howled. And this chief accountant was a stubborn fan and believed that the enterprise was for accounting, and not vice versa. The document flow became complicated and I can’t write out of the warehouse became a problem. The stock of materials was reduced and simple maintenance was turned into a nightmare. Somehow the situation was resolved.

[Svarog]

Quote: My address

Allow me to disagree. Even in a small business unit, the accountant is usually subordinate to the economist / planner.

There is no difference between an accountant and an economist. These are people of one mindset who is focused on optimization. You are absolutely right when you cited examples from your personal life .. this is exactly the case. I had examples when the owner of the enterprise listened to an accountant in my place and received bankruptcy at the exit.

[Malyuta]

Quote: Svarog

There is no difference between an accountant and an economist.

To become an accountant, you can finish the courses of accountants, and to become an economist you need to unlearn 5 years at a university.

[Svarog]

Quote: Malyuta

To become an accountant, you can finish the courses of accountants, and to become an economist you need to unlearn 5 years at a university.

There are few courses, more precisely, after the courses this accountant will only be able to conduct IP, and then, in the realities of our taxation, it will not be entirely successful, and he will not be able to work with VAT exactly after the courses. My wife has an accountant, she graduated from high school.

[Malyuta]

Quote: Svarog

in the realities of our taxation, it’s not entirely successful, and it will not be able to work with VAT exactly after the courses.

In our modern life, much has been turned upside down.
Earlier, before the coup, each technical university had a faculty of Economics and Organization of Production and they graduated quite serious specialists, because it was impossible to imagine an enterprise without a planning and economic department. Without them it is difficult to build a strategy for the development of an enterprise, but an accountant is extra ...
And the worst thing in our history is that now the camp is managed by accountants who think of themselves as economists.
PySy. I am very sorry, this has nothing to do with your wife.

[New Year day]

Quote: Malyuta

To become an accountant, you can finish the courses of accountants, and to become an economist you need to unlearn 5 years at a university.

obtaining a diploma is not a guarantee of professional suitability! No matter how you studied, it is important how you got married!

[Krasnodar]

Quote: Svarog

There is no difference between an accountant and an economist ..

Micro and Macro)).

[depressant]

Putin introduced Deputy Prime Minister Belousov, a heavyweight, to the government compared to digital accountant Mishustin. Belousov is blocked with another deputy prime minister - General Borisov. Both cool specialists in their own areas. Belousov is a hereditary macroeconomist, a recognized master of forecasting. The activities of General Borisov as a specialist in electronics raises questions. He has been in government for a long time - and where is our electronic industry? Issues microchips for payment cards, Chinese TVs, washing machines, now and then go bankrupt? So, here are the questions.
But let's say the Belousov-Borisov bloc is real and useful. But he is hardly capable of withstanding the Siluanov-Nabiullina bloc. They say that they would add Glazyev as head of the Central Bank, and then the economy will be able to sparkle with new colors. Well, this is unlikely! But already inspired by the idea of ​​dividing the government into blocs, Putin hints that a new socio-economic policy is coming soon, such that wow! Only the president's inspiration, in my opinion, is not due to the fact that economic happiness will suddenly fall on Russia right under the heavy managing heel of the IMF and sanctions, but to the fact that in any case there will be someone to blame for the failure.

[parusnik]

Hmm ... "about how many wonderful discoveries for us" our government prepares for us ... Everything is going according to plan, we fit into the world economy, where the place of Russia has already been determined ...

[Scharnhorst]

The author was sore, I agree and empathize. I will add one more example in the style: "all ships are on the same airfield and planes are in the same bay ...". One tenth of the country's population in Moscow and the region feeds on taxes and resources of the entire state. Even the salaries of teachers across the country differ significantly! Arranged a nest of bloodsuckers with a "decent standard of living" for glamorous bastards. According to statistics, there are continuous subsidized regions with an endangered population around Moscow. Where did the virus epidemic come from across the country? From Moscow! When the entire elite with pumped lips and boobs and the same wallets rushed to Moscow winter apartments from the Courchevels of the Cote d'Azur, fleeing European medicine. And as soon as Sobyanin (God grant him health and a rich mistress) began to close all this liberalism in burrows, a million cars a day from Moscow dissipated in the regions! Moscow was not loved in the Soviet Union either, but now, in general, hatred is comparable to the Americans ...

[Paul Siebert]

Respect, Scharnhorst!

[depressant]

Elections, elections, the result is hand-drawn!

[Antokha]

A tenth of the country's population in Moscow and the region is eating at the expense of taxes and resources of the entire state.

It’s not worth it about Moscow. Most Muscovites, like everywhere else, are working and exhausted people. Scum and their sysyandry - it is, oddly enough, visitors or their children, but there are not so many of them. What does a person who has stolen in his region who has robbed you? He goes to Moscow and takes root there. After 20 years, he has children like Muscovites. You hate us, and we have to endure the foam from all over the country. The worst representatives of all regions come here. And they are leaving you! Yes, you live much poorer, but to me representatives of all other cities. with whomever I talked, they said that their people are kinder. Make your own choices. You can come to Moscow. You do not want? Do not come. Freedom. Those who came to conquer Moscow are heard a mile away in dialect; there are a lot of them. And it’s not bad, it’s just that. Moscow has its own dialect, in other places it is different. Moscow accepts everyone. Ordinary people come here to work because they work in Moscow. It is simply the largest city, work here. This is the misfortune of our country, but not the fault of Moscow and Muscovites. No one here is chewing, except for those who steal. And in the regions they manage to steal so that Muscovites are surprised.
My brother says on behalf of a hypothetical visitor: Moscow is a terrible city! He walked along the bastard, stumbled on a bar of gold. They are everywhere lying around. The nose broke. He wiped it with a 5th bill, which someone dropped and was too lazy to pick it up. All taxis Rolls Royces, no variety, I don’t know where to spend the money, they don’t end there.
Here is some idea of ​​how we are here. Well, come.

[Hypatius]

A short fantastic future, if not optimizing the main thing, in my enterprise.
Better under the root, up to 7 knees, is to optimize. In our country, only the management office apparatus needs optimization. Whose activity is similar to the liquidation commission, sold quietly of the enterprise to be closed. Everything that can be converted into loot is sold or optimized. Already the employees who were shareholders were transferred to the category of guest workers (individuals, plebos, migrants). After all, raiders and pieces of paper have fake ones, and the whole team will be acquainted with the whole team in the near future with the new 20th edition of their charter. Let them shout at each other, shareholders (citizens) still vote, not physical workers. Workers are subject to dismissal and expulsion from the territory of the enterprise (in 2025), so as not to interfere with the raiders on forged documents, but also to sell land from under the former enterprise. For these dismissed migrants, the humanists are already empty cities, prepared in the Gobi Desert, which is a branch of the occupied enterprise. Even if they rejoice in this, commoners don’t dare to demand the raiders back their shares and company assets. Yes, and the security of the enterprise (police) was replaced by private security agencies with a 5-7-fold increase in staff. They will give fizrabs vMrot, and let them thank the fabulous leadership for kindness, which has not yet vaccinated to death.
PS The tale is a lie, but a hint in it. Honest Workers lesson!

[depressant]

Colleague, what a 25th year! The Government Decree of December 31, 2019 number 3260-r, which I never tire of recalling, has already been adopted. In 2020 - 2022, everything will be privatized!
Crop production and livestock and related services
Fishery
Fish farming
Crude oil and gas production (!!!)
Production:
Textiles
wood products and materials for weaving
paper, chemicals, chemical products
medicines, medical materials
computers optics
electrical equipment
machines
furniture
car repair
And so longer. Everything that comes to mind and at least some of its part belongs to the state. Huge list.
And land reform is being prepared.
For 30 years, predators have been raised in the country. They will seize everything and destroy it. So that the Soviet Union and its social achievements do not even have a memory. And the president, like a siren, sings and sings a sweet song to us, but simply blows in his ears about the upcoming wonderful socio-economic changes. Great for anyone?

[Hypatius]

Suppose we have a well-functioning enterprise, say with a profit of 6%, what is the most efficient way to proceed? Two types of efficiency: 1) Modern. Close, hand over everything unprofitable. Convert all resources to money, and withdraw from accounts. Workers to dismiss and expel from the territory. To sell the land from under the enterprise and rent it out.
2) Boring. Invest in machines, technologies. Invest in the training and life of the team. Build a sanatorium, kindergarten and so on. illiquid. Slowly raise profits from 6 to 12%.
It is clearly seen which "efficiency" is more effective.

[depressant]

Before the previous (not this year) message from the president, I varied here in VO - where, they say, is my machine tool building ?! After all, machine tool construction is the basis of the industry. Meanwhile, the production of CNC machine tools fell 25 times compared to the Soviet period! In disputes, we here have broken more than one button accordion. The president promised in a message: there will be a machine tool! And what do I discover after? Yes, the Japanese, through the Germans, built an enterprise in Siberia, but they took a subscription that we did not slam the used digital know-how from them. They started to build in the Volga region and in the south of Russia, but it is no longer interesting to me in such a humiliating and useless aspect for the country. On our territory, but not ours.
And the president ... He promised a lot of things in that message. I falsely outlined.

[Svarog]

A wonderful article and very true ... but it would be possible to go through tougher managers today.

[populist]

I’m wondering: at the top we didn’t see where Ukraine was heading and what we could buy from it; what will happen after the beneficence of Norway a huge piece of the sea; how will the policy of "optimization" of their machine tool industry end?

It seems that they have not seen. Upstairs there are two categories of officials - self-interested and incompetent. Very often, these characteristics are combined in one person.
Wrong people in power. Poor and toxic.

[Eug]

To fend off crisis situations, it is necessary to have certain reserves, but they come into conflict with the concept of efficiency - for the saving in a crisis is a surplus during normal functioning. This is regardless of the scope of application, aviation is the simplest example: an excess margin of safety is laid in the chassis, during an emergency landing, it is this margin that is salvation, in everyday operation - excess weight, leading to a drop in fuel efficiency. It is the same in everything ... A crisis-free existence does not work, it is too expensive to have stocks (according to "effective" managers) .. Keeping foresters in Siberia is expensive, but this is if we assume that there will be no fires without them. everyone can give a lot of examples. And the task of the authorities is to find a balance between redundancy and everyday efficacy.

[Krasnodar]

Cute. A phased specifics? )))

[7,62x54]

The country needs educated people, but they are not needed by the tapeworms who have stuck to the body of the country. They need dumb, dumb consumers.

[alone]

The poor brain of the average citizen can not understand what is happening in the present .. Because what is being done now defies any logic ..
As for the future, I’ll write in brief so that people don’t bother to read: It is very foggy .. Knowing the state of the educational and health system. (I believe that without these two systems, there will be no progress in the future)

[Operator]

The basis of Asian Hungarians before they arrived in Europe was R1b carriers - blood relatives of European Celts. Plus, the Pannonian lowlands around Lake Balaton, where the Hungarians settled, were inhabited by white Croats - carriers of R1a.

And the fact that the Hungarians speak the Finno-Ugric language is called cultural-linguistic assimilation by the Altai while the Hungarians were there.

[Slippery]

Quote: Hypatius

2) Boring. Invest in machines, technologies. Invest in the training and life of the team. Build a sanatorium, kindergarten and so on. illiquid. Slowly raise profits from 6 to 12%.
It is clearly seen which "efficiency" is more effective.

You forgot to add, slowly raise profits while fighting with raiders, officials. Ultimately, the owner spits on everything and chooses item 1.

[Hypatius]

Ultimately, the owner spits on everything and chooses item 1.

Not so much. The raider who claims to be the owner chooses p1. The collective, equal shareholders, the owner (de jure, owning to this day) of the enterprise will choose n2.
Different owners, different goals and different "efficiency", IMHO.

[NordUral]

I paraphrase a good expression a little: I look at our proud, well-groomed, successful elite, and I feel a warm feeling: a coiled-up teacher from the backwoods; surprisingly conscientious cleaning lady, cleaning my porch with my daughter; Dr. Roshal; the unsociable and groomed mathematician Perelman; cool team leaders from my production.

An article that you need! Only the upper "elites" do not need it.
And we are such "leaders! To me, for sure."

[Ros 56]

The author is well done, the topic is burning, but the problem is that the Chubais, Medvedev, Illarionovs and others on a horse or were on it and dumped over a hill, and we can only think with a smart look at the front door. Just like Nekrasov’s.

[faterdom]

Do you think Peter got the elite better? She was generally generally hostile to him; childhood lived in with fucking and humiliation.
But he had a harmonious system in his head for a start: what he wants to build and what. Under these tasks, a new elite has already been created, and self-development has been laid (the duty of serving the nobility and education). Yes, excesses, but the treasury was empty during the Northern War, yes, a lot of people were killed - but there is a result, therefore - Great.
And now why are we hunching? Gorbachev was glad that Baroness Margaret kissed and patted her cheek, Yeltsin was a slave of visions from her bottle. Putin cannot formulate himself to either the people-Kamo coming? What do we want to build? Football stadium for Jani Infantila? Herman Electronic Concentration Camp? A pipe to China, which, they say, has yet to be explored by gas sources?

[Million]

Everything is written correctly, only the current government doesn’t need anything. They gouge with oil, gas, weapons. They don’t care for the rest. They are not owners, but temporary managers

[123456789]

Quote: vVvAD

Quality education? Of course - received in the most prestigious American and European universities.

American universities are the place where Russian professors teach Chinese students in English

[123456789]

Quote: Hypatius

Suppose we have a well-functioning enterprise, say with a profit of 6%, what is the most efficient way to proceed? Two types of efficiency: 1) Modern. Close, hand over everything unprofitable. Convert all resources to money, and withdraw from accounts. Workers to dismiss and expel from the territory. To sell the land from under the enterprise and rent it out.
2) Boring. Invest in machines, technologies. Invest in the training and life of the team. Build a sanatorium, kindergarten and so on. illiquid. Slowly raise profits from 6 to 12%.
It is clearly seen which "efficiency" is more effective.

At a similar fork is the flagship of the USSR Petroleum Engineering N-Neftemash. First, Great Goodwin gave it to his coach. Then one brother sacrificed to another during the construction of the construction site of the century (sorry for the tautology). And now they have sent a team of crisis managers from Moscow who will optimize the flagship of the USSR’s oil engineering industry, the city-forming enterprise N-Neftemash. Both the oil crisis and the coronavirus are just a convenient excuse for them.

[Tests]

Brought up in the KGB of the USSR, he knows only one way to manage his subordinates - the presence of compromising evidence on everyone, regardless of position and rank. After all, you can always get a daddy with announcements, photos, audio and video recordings and give a couple of pages to read to anyone who takes a step aside. And the person has a choice - to shut up and do as ordered, but stay in office, the opportunity to steal, have two mistresses and the child will remain in a not dusty place, but you can, like having lost trust, go nowhere and sweat from every phone call - suddenly to the investigator will be invited ... The scheme works on all levels of power in the Russian Federation, regardless of the region and the branch of the national economy, the system has been polished for 20 years. The main thing in it is not to stick out, send lacquered reports to the top on time and you will have a municipal or federal pension, a warm office, a secretary, bonuses, and maybe an order will be hanged ... A couple of days ago I wrote in the "Analytics" section like me and mine my wife learned that we are covid-19 infected. And today TASS was born: https://tass.ru/obschestvo/8588483?utm_source=yxnews&utm_medium=desktop&utm_referrer=https%3A%2F%2Fyandex.ru%2Fnews
Stroporez (Private Airborne Forces) you are right by 202%! It turns out that it is not the chief sanitary doctor of TsGiE No. 58 of the FMBA of the Russian Federation that the GRCAS enterprises are serviced, and not the directors of SEVMASH, Zvezdochka and Arktika that brought people to full working days in April are to blame. All factory workers say that Mr. Budnichenko was given a task: to hand over the "Prince Vladimir" to the fleet in May! The order was also promised a prize. As an order from the sea went-dozens of sick people at the plant. Only in the Central Medical Unit No. 58 of the FMBA of the Russian Federation, not a single covid bed was deployed. And very few tests for coronavirus were brought ... Now the city is discussing the story of Irina Sukhanova: https://vk.com/wall-39644772_3254218
And our wise acting The governor was splashing saliva from the screen that he would buy 200 electronic bracelets to control those with a mild form of covid and are treated at home (our criminals are sick covid-19!). And whoever doesn't like it - everyone is in the hospital, there will be enough beds! The wise GMO Severodvinsk, Mr. Skubenko, did not come up with anything smarter than how to block the traffic police with an auto patrol and a "No entry" sign to enter Yagrinsky pine forest. And so the traffic police for an accident, people wait for 5 hours, they were also optimized ... The governor of the Arkhangelsk region, Tsybulsky is a typical nestling ... In Karelia, a wind power plant is being built near Kem, 2 Beloporozhsk hydroelectric power plants will soon be commissioned, they are starting to build hydroelectric power plants at Segezha - they understand that the basis is energy. In the Arkhangelsk region they are just waiting for Belkomur to be extended, although they have not decided whether to a small port in Arkhangelsk with expensive icebreaker guiding, or in Indiga in the NAO an ice-free port will be built sometime ... ... But Trutnev, along with the acting The governor of the NAO on TV sweetly sang what industrial and scientific potential Severodvinsk, Arkhangelsk, Novodvinsk have, we say the gate to the Arctic, tourism potential, agriculture is taking off, the owner of the Arkhangelsk PPM Krupchak - a citizen of Ukraine from Vienna is ready to build almost a second PPM, etc. etc ... Looks like nice guys like acting Governor of NAO Yu.V. Barren and acting Governor of the Arkhangelsk Region A.V. Tsybulsky, not connected with the district and the region, knowing neither the region nor the district for the tsar and needed, it is easy and simple to manage them ...

[faterdom]

I will only add that "The History of a City" by M.Ye. Saltykov-Shchedrin in the Arkhangelsk region is developing creatively and floridly.
So the previous three governors:
1. Kiselev - hit the Internet with a video, like a chopstick for risk, he carefully puts money in a cutlet in an envelope. What is interesting is that at that very time, Klebanov’s envoy was pushing through the deputies of ZAKS (catching them directly in slippers from the beach and summer cottages), they should vote for Kiselyov, because they decided that way (it was like the election of a governor). They voted, but since it was not possible to hush up the scandal with the video, they removed it, they offered another - a fugitive mayor of Yakutsk (who had all the deputies there, but he wasn’t there), a certain Medvedev’s protege Ilya Mikhalchuk.
2. This pepper grabbed the central market of Arkhangelsk for his sons, tried to lay his hands on money to restore the Solovetsky complex, drove the region into hellish debts (together with his friend Edros Pekhtin) to TGK-2 with the head of Yaroslavl for some "investment programs", where Then Isam went to work, when the United Russia took the last place in the ranking among all of them in the next elections! subjects of the Russian Federation.
3. Next - Igor Orlov. One could call the time of the reign the most calm so far, but ... here the demon beguiled. In Moscow, "garbage reform" burst out, they dirtied everything around them, began to think - what to do next. But the Arkhangelsk region, some kind of Shies, and the governor agrees, for two lard for the region, this is money! And there is a piece of iron there, and from Moscow in terms of distance it is tolerable, and the place is deaf, between Komi and the Arkhangelsk region, and, most importantly, the drain is not in Moscow-Oka-Volga, but in the North. Dvina, Mezen and Pechora. And people don't live there. Or so-so people, and their life is so-so, in short - have found a solution. And to please the Guarantor - only he ordered to "deal with the garbage" - figured out, and inexpensively.
Only when the scandal began to swell, the forest was already cut down without any expertise for garbage, and even the first echelon with garbage was already sent, talking about "unprecedented investments", "environmental growth" - they ran into a real popular protest - they began to raise the price. Already by two, and four, then six lard! Yeah, let's poison you and your descendants for six lard to someone there for something there ... Huber dispelled the excitement: he clearly explained that everyone around is great, only the "Shelupon" kindles excitement, well, to rock the boat .. And that we will certainly carry out an environmental examination (one year after the attempt to send the first echelon!). Doesn't subside.
4. In the brothel they continue to change their beds - they appoint an acting governor of a certain Tsybulsky, who, like, will correct the situation, create the Northern Territory, arrange prosperity and raise the image of Moscow from the puddle where it lies ...
But for now, something is going wrong. Not that it’s not quite so, but I would say that it’s not at all.
Or maybe you need to see in Moscow - PEOPLE live here too? And stop wasting waste here, garbage and management?

[Boris ⁣ Shaver]

also a Ph.D.

I speak within the framework of my specialty. Leafing through the works of your generation, which once brought degrees to their authors, the idea overcomes that nowadays in a decent university a diploma will not be issued, not that degree. Science (I’m talking about my field) has changed a lot - it has become more complicated, more dynamic, more ramified. And this is understandable, in the era of information technology, there can be no other. The only thing that was definitely better in our science at that time was financing.

[iouris]

Quote: "Hodja Nasreddin began to optimize the donkey, load more and feed less. Everything went well, but one day the donkey let Hodja down, took it and died." End of quote.
This example shows how unnecessary donkeys are "optimized".
Donkeys have no future, and everything is fine with optimization. You just did not raise the question of who Nasruddin is.

[ser56]

The observations are reasonable, but the lack of conclusions spoils ...

[Mikhail3]

Engineer? Really?! In life I would not have thought ...
What is efficiency? The first question is the effectiveness of what? The author has a bundle of boasting and tales, and nothing else is in the article. And so, since the author is floating in a pink fog, not relying on anything, let's find out at least the subject of the problem. The effectiveness of what, what process would the author want to consider? Maybe the production efficiency of something? Yes, it seems not, the author only writes some kind of "notes of a naturalist" about production.
Does management effectiveness mean? Maybe, or maybe not, everything is too foggy and vague. Author, are you apparently a symbolist poet? I don’t understand anything from the article.