Military Review

What does Glazyev have to do with it, what does oil have to do with it?

314
What does Glazyev have to do with it, what does oil have to do with it?

To drag and not let go



In the Russian countryside, in this situation, they can say bluntly: "You either remove the cross or put on your underpants." And Great Russian chauvinism has nothing to do with it, all the more so since one of the authors of these lines, even when he was almost brought into the liberals, remained an internationalist, while the other generally never respected nationalism.

It’s just that when the majority of capable electorates only process things under the chatter and horror stories from all screens and web pages, they don’t ask anything, it usually ends badly. And God forbid us from the Russian revolt, certainly merciless, but hardly senseless anymore. It’s better to vote.

Almost five million Russian security officials and security guards, of course, will always vote in favor, but this is only as long as their frank idleness and monstrous unprofessionalism are well paid. But the electorate and can buck. He rebelled in the capital - he chose the naughty city duma, on which the mayor, however, while frankly spits with his "decrees".

However, and this, it seems, only for the time being. The central apparatus, which continues to make every effort to save its well-being, above all material, does not really care about anyone. The Duma is as obedient as a loyal dog, but at first there was only one decent person among the senators, but now they seem to have heard one more.

However, strangely enough, there were dissidents in the “center”, only at its edge - in the structures of the EAEU (Eurasian Economic Community). Sergei Glazyev, academician, adviser to the president, who has repeatedly held high posts, and now the post of Minister for Integration in the EAEU, even thought to moderate his criticism of whoever you think - the Central Bank itself! And this is in the midst of a brutal pandemic and strict quarantine!

So independent and so highly professional that it is recognized even by the IMF, the World Bank and, most likely, the Federal Reserve. Although what is the matter of global and American bankers to the Russian shtetl office, which does nothing, by and large, is not necessary, except to put signatures on billions of transfers abroad.

You were not mistaken, reader, precisely with translations, but how else to call the notorious investments in “highly liquid and absolutely reliable”, read: foreign, specifically American assets. Our investments with you, citizens, of the money earned by pumping out our Russian mineral resources for the sake of an “uninterrupted sugrev” of European inhabitants.

And what about the Russians, almost half of whom either do not have gas at all in their houses and apartments, or pay extraordinary money for it? The Russians are still not left with the most expensive alcohol for the “Sugrev,” but it will also work for the farmers. What does the Central Bank have to do with it? About two decades ago, Sergey Dorenko (now deceased) liked to ask about this. The Central Bank, of course, has nothing to do with it, because it always has nothing to do with it.

However, as it turned out, not always. Suddenly, as usual, it happened "suddenly." In our main credit institution, “suddenly” they were worried about the excessive media activity of not someone, but an acting official at the federal, even international level.

Scare but not kill


The Central Bank was criticized by Sergey Glazyev - one of the leaders of the Eurasian Commission managing the EAEU. In response, Glazyev still does not seem to have recalled only one thing: the fact that for many years he seriously claimed the position of head of the Bank of Russia. It is characteristic that his candidacy was invariably supported by such bison in banking as Viktor Gerashchenko and Sergey Ignatiev, who themselves headed the Central Bank of the Russian Federation for many years.

And those who headed, one cannot but admit, are quite successful. The first, rightly nicknamed Heracles, as you know, returned to the Bank of Russia as its chairman on September 11, 1998, and managed, or rather, severely dealt with the consequences of default. However, after putting the basic order in the financial sphere, Gerashchenko was dismissed without explanation.

The second, Sergei Ignatiev, was placed on the Central Bank immediately after Heracles as an “intermediate figure”, but he also fell into the fight against the crisis - already in 2008. The struggle was not the most successful, the ruble had to be weakened by almost a quarter, but it was nothing more than a return to realities after default.

Later, Ignatiev was not allowed to answer the sanctions, and the current Madame Chairwoman calmly doubled the ruble in 2014, which was presented to the people as retribution for the Crimea.


Academician S. Yu. Glazyev did not recall any of this to the current leadership of the Bank of Russia. He is worried about the current situation, which threatens Russia, and after it and the entire EAEU, the crisis is abrupt than default and later events. We must not forget that the Eurasian Minister Glazyev is a well-known opponent of economic liberalism (which, by the way, still rules the ball in our government, despite the change of prime minister).

And he didn’t fundamentally touch upon the main provisions of the current and approved monetary policy: in his position, this was not entirely appropriate. The academician speaks and writes about the specifics, decisions of the current moment and it is not by chance that he recalls that even American experts admitted: "Russia will be able to survive the long period when oil will cost $ 40-45 per barrel."

And the Germans have already meticulously calculated that at 15 dollars per barrel of Russia there will be enough accumulated reserves for two years. But this is under the condition that no one will “revive” anything, will not do anything at all - approximately as it is now. Although, after all, construction projects have not been stopped, and they will sow, and enterprises have not stood up.

Here you involuntarily share the alarm with Glazyev, who simply wants to understand why this is necessary at all. Belarus is somehow coping, while other members of the EAEU do not want to join the Russian hysteria. More precisely, not to the Russian, but to the hysteria of the Russian powers that be, starting with the guarantor. But why so many turned out to be those who are committed to the principle of "they scare us, but we are not afraid"? Glazyev, hopefully, of them.

Take and blame? Forget and grind ...


It is difficult to say that someone who has not yet completely lost the ability to think can be reconciled with the course of mercilessly pumping out blood, that is, last money, not only from the economy, but also from the pockets of citizens. Stalin's bonds, which critics of the Soviet system always subject to obstruction because they were “tricked” by almost forcefully, seem like a child’s game compared to current ideas.


In the meantime, from the Bank of Russia, as well as from its former branch - Sberbank, you only hear that you are reprimanded to those who want to "take everything and share." It’s nice, sometimes, to take and blame the broad masses for turning them into millions of ballpoints. And then make a modest proposal on the organization of a certain anti-crisis loan. Who to borrow from? Yes, people and small-medium-sized businesses, which have not yet drowned.

That's when the revenues to the treasury grow - to the envy of the former chief tax official, and now the head of the cabinet! Although why take a steam bath at all, which is easier - introduce penalties for going to the toilet or the kitchen, place security cameras in the apartments, and no loans will be needed. True, then everything will die out very quickly, and there will be no one to fine.

The notorious crisis of overproduction, especially in the oil sector, gives us a unique chance to finally get off the oil needle. That is exactly what Sergey Glazyev is alluding to quite transparently. He is well aware that the Eurasian community has a tremendous advantage over Russia in terms of self-sufficiency and independence of the economy. But this advantage is without the normal economic development of Russia, alas, it costs nothing.

But Glazyev’s criticism of the Central Bank is quite constructive, the authors agree with her at 100. It is hardly necessary to repeat here the provisions of the minister’s report presented last week and devoted to stabilization measures against the backdrop of the coronavirus pandemic. There is no doubt that the main thing that has hooked bankers, headed by Elvira Sakhipzadovna, is the proposal to introduce a currency exchange tax in the countries of the Eurasian Economic Union (EAEU), including Russia.

We are actually talking about the rejection of foreign exchange transactions in the EAEU and the notorious dedollarization. Not forced, but voluntary, which is precisely what the tax stimulates. The proposal, let's say, is not original: just the same thing was done once by Gerashchenko and Ignatiev. And it helped. But there was also tight currency control, and the return of export earnings, mandatory, by the way.

It seems that from the EAEU and this may be offered in the coming days. Offer simply because they want to live. To live and work.
Author:
Photos used:
smipressa.ru
314 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must to register.

I have an account? Sign in

  1. Grandfather
    Grandfather April 25 2020 05: 48 New
    53
    while we are flying by inertia, it’s even scary to think that by the fall-winter there will be .... "zero" apparently.
    1. DMB 75
      DMB 75 April 25 2020 06: 04 New
      69
      They will rob again, while condemning understanding and patience.
      1. My address
        My address April 25 2020 06: 57 New
        40
        hi
        And in continuation of your comment:
        All recent statements by the authorities can be replaced by the phrase: “No one will support you during the crisis like no one else”
        1. Stas157
          Stas157 April 25 2020 07: 18 New
          66
          Some kind of crap is going on! I have one contextual advertising on VO for several days offers a rope (jute rope) ?? And if then the soap begins to offer!

          Glazyev is our economist. We need him instead of Nabiulina, and Katasonova his deputy. But, I'm afraid that such an idea will not be to the taste of those in power!
          1. Zhan
            Zhan April 25 2020 07: 53 New
            50
            Quote: Stas157
            Some kind of crap is going on! I have one contextual advertising on VO for several days offers a rope (jute rope) ?? And if then the soap begins to offer!

            Glazyev is our economist. We need him instead of Nabiulina, and Katasonova his deputy. But, I'm afraid that such an idea will not be to the taste of those in power!

            hi
            Even if Glazyev and Katasonov agreed, these are decent, educated, intelligent people. Introducing them into this environment of banking jackals without an extensive team of loyal wolfhounds to them would be a big mistake. These from Glazyev and Katasonov would have made scapegoats, not by scientific methods, because they would not have enough intelligence, so much by political intrigues and purchased officials. Here radical measures are needed, stripping from recruited, corrupt and antisocial elements. And then under the protection I will give them the opportunity to work hard and productively, not forgetting the good financing of these people.
            1. Digital error
              Digital error April 25 2020 09: 05 New
              +8
              Quote: Zhan
              corrupt and antisocial elements

              Evil tongues and foreign agents say that additional protective structures appeared around the Kremlin ...
              1. Malyuta
                Malyuta April 25 2020 10: 38 New
                15
                Quote: DigitalError
                Evil tongues and foreign agents say that additional protective structures appeared around the Kremlin ...

                This is from mushroom pickers.
            2. lucul
              lucul April 25 2020 09: 59 New
              +8
              Here radical measures are needed, stripping from recruited, corrupt and antisocial elements.

              Are there anti-Semitism? )))
            3. Malyuta
              Malyuta April 25 2020 10: 40 New
              -18
              Quote: Zhan
              Even if Glazyev

              in 2019 he was an adviser to pvv and what did he advise?
              1. Revival
                Revival April 25 2020 15: 25 New
                20
                And kikie from his advice listened, applied?
                None
          2. Svarog
            Svarog April 25 2020 10: 15 New
            12
            Quote: Stas157
            Glazyev is our economist. We need him instead of Nabiulina, and Katasonova his deputy. But, I'm afraid that such an idea will not be to the taste of those in power!

            From the head you need to change. They won’t give it otherwise, and even if they give it under pressure, it won’t be for long ..
            1. Alexander I
              Alexander I April 27 2020 12: 51 New
              +1
              Ok, let's change my head, what kind of replacement do you propose? Everything is cleared, nobody is allowed to stick out (only to their own and to those under control)
          3. alone
            alone April 25 2020 12: 26 New
            14
            Quote: Stas157
            Glazyev is our economist. We need him instead of Nabiulina, and Katasonova his deputy. But, I'm afraid that such an idea will not be to the taste of those in power!

            And what? Think they’ll be given something to do? Such people are a hindrance .. They will start to fight against theft ... And this is not welcomed under the current system .. They have already given the go-ahead to sell gold .. I already remembered Gorbachev’s times .. Then, too, oil fell and started selling gold .. But money from where did gold go, nobody really knows
            As the old joke says: The whole system needs to be changed ...
          4. Aborigen4ik
            Aborigen4ik April 27 2020 03: 53 New
            +1
            To begin with, the article of the Constitution on the Central Bank must be changed, and then take on the leadership ...
        2. 210ox
          210ox April 25 2020 09: 04 New
          36
          Unfortunately, at the head of our state are open enemies. Even now, do not be shy in the open-shut up Glazyev mouth.
          1. Malibu
            Malibu April 25 2020 09: 11 New
            24
            Quote: 210ox
            Unfortunately, at the head of our state are open enemies. Even now, do not be shy in the open-shut up Glazyev mouth.

            In the open, all right, but how many hidden and silent, the same Chubais and K quiet and sabotage is engaged in arrogant red beast .. negative
          2. lucul
            lucul April 25 2020 10: 03 New
            -29
            Unfortunately, at the head of our state are open enemies. Even now, do not be shy in the open-shut up Glazyev mouth.

            Yes, it just shoots a lot of holes .....
            With the right course in economics, we would never be able to weaken the hegemon, and now - please, the indestructible broom of the Western world is scattered into separate twigs ....
            1. Nehist
              Nehist April 25 2020 11: 27 New
              21
              Respected! Please answer and where is the western world streaming?
              1. Fan-fan
                Fan-fan April 25 2020 15: 47 New
                13
                In the inflamed brain of the Kremlin boats, the West is constantly pouring, hourly and every minute, but it just does not crumble.
        3. Ross xnumx
          Ross xnumx April 25 2020 09: 52 New
          13
          Quote: My address
          hi All recent statements by the authorities can be replaced by the phrase: “No one will support you during the crisis like no one else”

          good I would put it a little differently:
          No one will support you during a crisis better and more reliable than no one ... yes

          Quote: Stas157
          Some kind of crap is going on!

          Quote: Stas157
          Glazyev is our economist.


          Quote: Stas157
          Some kind of crap is going on!

          It's true. Glazyev is your economist. It must be with Nabiullina ...
          Forgive my par dépit, which speaks in me. Long before! Glazyev, Nabiullina, Katasonova and other economists of the coveted liberal market economy and Gaidar's reforms were ... repeat Experience in integrating CMEA countries, where a conditional ruble was used instead of the dollar. There are many analogues of the monetary unit, which would be able to replace the dollar. Naturally, one cannot suddenly take and push the Bretton Woods agreement away, but no one can prohibit dollar spreads in a certain economic community. The world is not required to pay for the use of the products of the American printing house, regardless of who it belongs to.
          It is a completely different matter when those who control the printing press and who really benefit from the use of the dollar in the world — not secured by anything other than a conditional arrangement, the currency — are forced to use the dollar.
          1. Malibu
            Malibu April 25 2020 10: 08 New
            -13
            Quote: ROSS 42
            Experience in integrating CMEA countries, where a conditional ruble was used instead of the dollar. There are many analogues of the monetary unit, which would be able to replace the dollar. Naturally, one cannot suddenly take and push the Bretton Woods agreement away, but no one can prohibit dollar spreads in a certain economic community. The world is not required to pay for the use of the products of the American printing house, regardless of who it belongs to.

            Eh Vasilyevich, as you correctly described everything and especially this photo speaks for itself .. Taught them to lie and dodge to undermine the economy of the USSR-Russia .. And Glazyev there I look at the company .. Then everything is clear! Thank you for the photo and despair .. And then the men began to get confused, who first to raise the forks ..
            1. Malyuta
              Malyuta April 25 2020 10: 54 New
              +8
              Quote: ROSS 42
              It's true. Glazyev is your economist. It must be with Nabiullina ...

              Quote: Malibu
              And Glazyev there I look in the company .. Then everything is clear! Thank you for the photo and despair .. And then the men began to get confused, who first to raise the forks ..

              Pitchfork is not our method, only an open, fast and fair people's court.
              Всё чётко и ясно [media=https://www.yapfiles.ru/show/1494781/27f3cc17798e23f47083eaa8040cb98b.mp4.html]
              [media=https://www.yapfiles.ru/show/1494783/f1d89c2362d5f44769b7aa68b108f4db.mp4.html?time=4.5118132]
              1. Malibu
                Malibu April 25 2020 11: 06 New
                -4
                Quote: Malyuta
                Pitchfork is not our method, only an open, fast and fair people's court.

                And to the wall? hi
                1. Malyuta
                  Malyuta April 25 2020 11: 16 New
                  14
                  Quote: Malibu
                  And to the wall? hi

                  "The wall" is too noble for them, for traitors the rope is relied on.
                  1. Malibu
                    Malibu April 25 2020 12: 21 New
                    -5
                    Quote: Malyuta
                    Quote: Malibu
                    And to the wall? hi

                    "The wall" is too noble for them, for traitors the rope is relied on.

                    How pitiful you are wink ..But I still agree with you!
                    Although for starters, you can .. soldier

                    Such are the things in the slaughter department .. hi
          2. Golovan Jack
            Golovan Jack April 25 2020 10: 14 New
            -18
            Quote: ROSS 42
            ... one cannot suddenly take and push the Bretton Woods agreement away ...

            good laughing good to tears... crying

            This agreement began to die in 1968 (two gold markets instead of one, where a troy ounce costs $ 35), and finally died in 1976 (the Jamaican currency system was adopted).

            And so yes - you can’t suddenly take it and throw it awayWell, forgive yes
            1. Ross xnumx
              Ross xnumx April 25 2020 10: 27 New
              17
              Quote: Golovan Jack
              to tears...

              You just do not cry - the beard comes off ...
              1. Golovan Jack
                Golovan Jack April 25 2020 10: 35 New
                -16
                Quote: ROSS 42
                Quote: Golovan Jack
                to tears...

                You just do not cry - the beard comes off ...

                Stop laughing - stop crying ... it's from laughter, mate good
                1. Malibu
                  Malibu April 25 2020 11: 08 New
                  -12
                  Quote: Golovan Jack
                  Quote: ROSS 42
                  Quote: Golovan Jack
                  to tears...

                  You just do not cry - the beard comes off ...

                  Stop laughing - stop crying ... it's from laughter, mate good

                  Funny you are watching Roman .. well, well! Have you come to hone your malignancy and humiliate your liberal laughs?
                  1. Golovan Jack
                    Golovan Jack April 25 2020 11: 09 New
                    -12
                    Quote: Malibu
                    liberal laughs

                    BUKAN, stop waving. Got it already.
                    1. Malibu
                      Malibu April 25 2020 12: 13 New
                      -10
                      Quote: Golovan Jack
                      Quote: Malibu
                      liberal laughs

                      BUKAN, stop waving. Got it already.

                      Yes, I just started. laughing drinks .
            2. Nehist
              Nehist April 25 2020 11: 34 New
              +5
              Oh my God! Not everything is lost! I always knew that you are a sober person! Stop trolling on the site only. And then you basically only have dives with several people. Write better such comments in essence and you will be respected and not stupid minuses.
              PS When you are engaged in frank trolling, I myself will gladly put down the cons. A clever man, why provoke that?
              1. Golovan Jack
                Golovan Jack April 25 2020 11: 41 New
                -13
                Quote: Nehist
                A clever man, why provoke that?

                I'm having fun. And then - sometimes "black trolls" are really pissed off, of which there have been divorced for the last year or two ... well, just like gophers belay
                1. Nehist
                  Nehist April 25 2020 11: 54 New
                  +3
                  Stop it, it doesn’t color you as a person. I wrote above that if I see a frank trolling minus. Yes, our opinions are sometimes the opposite, but I always respect sound comments on the topic as above. By the way, your opponents are not so wrong, they just quite emotionally express their point of view.
                  Where emotions prevail over the mind and this cocktail is difficult to understand, be indulgent.
                  PS Yes, I am also an opponent of the current government, somewhere even a radical, but life has taught me to soberly assess circumstances. Regards to you! Although we have an opposite opinion on many issues. Smart people will always find a compromise. Stop trolling it does not paint you. IMHO
                  1. Golovan Jack
                    Golovan Jack April 25 2020 12: 07 New
                    -9
                    Quote: Nehist
                    Stop trolling it does not paint you. IMHO

                    Thank you for your kind words, I will think about this topic at my leisure.
                    1. Nehist
                      Nehist April 25 2020 12: 08 New
                      -8
                      Plus sign from me. hi
                    2. Malibu
                      Malibu April 25 2020 12: 12 New
                      -11
                      Quote: Golovan Jack
                      Quote: Nehist
                      Stop trolling it does not paint you. IMHO

                      Thank you for your kind words, I will think about this topic at my leisure.

                      Think jack feline, otherwise you’ve already split up .. Has your whiskey taken too much or what's more interesting? laughing
                      Bored? Go to the censor. No, there you quickly pluck feathers crowd))))
          3. Svarog
            Svarog April 25 2020 10: 19 New
            +3
            The photo is really indicative.
        4. GriggoT
          GriggoT April 26 2020 21: 05 New
          0
          starving?
      2. Digital error
        Digital error April 25 2020 09: 01 New
        0
        Quote: DMB 75
        about understanding

        Yes. Recently, I heard this pearl from him again - work on errors by speechwriters has not been carried out.
      3. aybolyt678
        aybolyt678 April 25 2020 09: 03 New
        +2
        there will be regular monologues in the form of answers to questions .. only no one will ask the questioners - are you satisfied? do you understand
      4. TuM0305
        TuM0305 April 25 2020 10: 30 New
        0
        Specifically, what do you propose to do except write comments? How to resist, where to gather until the collapse has come?
        1. The comment was deleted.
          1. strannik1985
            strannik1985 April 25 2020 18: 22 New
            +2
            There is only one true and effective

            Interestingly, after a bunch of color revolutions, including the on / on 404, at least someone believes in this nonsense ???
            1. Alexander mosin
              Alexander mosin April 25 2020 21: 21 New
              -4
              What nonsense? For you, the desire of the people to choose an adequate power for themselves and not tolerate a corrupt authoritarian regime is rubbish? The alternative is bloody civil wars, or the corrupt kingdom of thief forever.
              1. strannik1985
                strannik1985 April 26 2020 07: 05 New
                +3
                What nonsense?

                Tell the Libyans, instead of the tyrant Gaddafi, they have gangs of democrats, slave markets and civil war, along with the Syrians, Egyptians and Khokhlov laughing
                1. Alexander mosin
                  Alexander mosin April 26 2020 21: 03 New
                  -2
                  So Gaddafi brought to rapture. Here, of course, they love idiotic tales about telling about the wonderful life in Libya and the popular love for the Dictator. So tell the Libyans that it was they who lived so happily and suddenly decided to arrange a civil war?)) In addition to Libya, there are other examples, Guzia, Tunisia, East Germany, Poland, there are plenty of positive examples. But I understand here the work of some, because they are trying for zeroed out and are ready to carry any nonsense to the masses, if only they would pay. Right now, a people without money, millions of beggars, when they bring to the hands of people that they will buck up and go on strike. Why do you think Putin brought the National Guard to himself and keeps the Kadyrovites in Moscow? Gaddafi in this case, in Tripolis, ordered just to shoot the demonstration, then the cadres flew around the whole world, the Americans, the State Department advised him to shoot the demonstrators? And you see, people with free thinking and a sense of their own dignity a priori cannot have the support of some kings who run the state as their personal shed and people as cattle, living in fabulous wealth, and people like that. People with serfdom, servile consciousness apparently do not understand this.
                  1. strannik1985
                    strannik1985 April 27 2020 05: 48 New
                    +2
                    So Gaddafi and led to rebellion.

                    Subsidies for a family member are $ 1000, for a newborn $ 7000, unemployment benefits $ 730, a lump sum mat for starting a business $ 20, education, medicine for free, rent and electricity are absent wink
                    So the tyrant of Gaddafi oppressed the poor Libyans laughing
                    And the driving force behind the coup was a group of extremists, the largest of which was the Muslim Brotherhood, with the support of NATO, the EU and the Arab League.
                    Bggg, compare Gaddafi with Bouteflika. He sent his opposition to the desert on an excursion, they are still walking, I probably liked it. The terrorists took the town of oil workers hostage, it was liberated by the regular army with tanks and attack helicopters, they laid a bunch of hostages. Anyone from the "free world" rebelled? wink
                    1. Alexander mosin
                      Alexander mosin April 28 2020 03: 43 New
                      -3
                      Quote: strannik1985
                      Family member subsidies $ 1000

                      Without the participation of the people, such an uprising is impossible! And the people will not get into the bullets due to the fact that some Muslim brothers (actually Muslim brothers in Egypt) said something, despite all these fabulous subsidies. Maybe he paid some security officials and staff to the apparatus, but hardly the majority. When a revolution or uprising takes place, always when the people no longer want to endure the authoritarian king and his methods of government. No one in prosperous countries will even think about rebellion and you won’t persuade him with anything. So all of these Gaddafi, Mubaraks, Assads are primarily responsible for the rebellion and civil war.



                      Quote: strannik1985
                      The terrorists took the oil town hostage, it was liberated by the regular army with tanks and attack helicopters, they laid a bunch of hostages. Anyone from the "free world" rebelled?

                      Some strange comparison, it is not clear what you want to tell me? Are you talking about a situation similar to Beslan?
      5. Paul Siebert
        Paul Siebert April 26 2020 08: 45 New
        +5
        Dedollarization, of course, is a good and necessary thing.
        But in my opinion - for us it is not of paramount importance.
        The author in the article touched upon another problem - the collapse of oil prices and the actual cessation of our export of oil to the West.
        Catastrophe?
        I think not.
        In America, oil export from the country has been banned for decades. Not because they created a strategic reserve in case of war.
        They developed their petrochemical industry.
        Plants for the production of plastic and plastics were built. polyethylene, other polymers.
        Millions of people got jobs. Oil was developed in the domestic market, and did not burn out in the engines of overseas machines.
        The return was received by the economy, and not by a unit of particularly wealthy citizens.
        Why not do it with us?
        Doesn’t fit into the modern Russian economy? When do excess returns on resource exports settle neatly in the pockets of oligarchs?
        It's time to change the attitude.
        The bony in the crown stands at the threshold.
    2. blackice
      blackice April 25 2020 07: 03 New
      25
      The plan of the red-headed owner of the Russian silicone valley in action.
      Now those who are sitting at home will turn their wallets clean. Then those who lost their jobs and did not find a new one will quietly go to another world through some method (drunkards, drugs, or gopniks in the gateway will accept, and again, any of the diseases). The result is by the fall, fewer pensioners, fewer before pensioners, and, as a result, fewer worries for the state.
      Redhead will announce that this gray mass has been digested by the market, so that everything is within the margin of error for the next breakthrough.
      The next re-election of the sun and the next - Everything goes according to plan.
      1. depressant
        depressant April 25 2020 08: 16 New
        24
        Zhan colleague!
        In your opinion, let's do nothing. Let's protect the cute, intelligent Glazyev and Katasonov from the bestial Nabiullins. By eliminating the cute ones from the decision field. And then they’ll eat the cute ones! Understand, the times when you can be a sweet and intelligent expert in your field without getting stuck in anything have passed. It's time to show your teeth. Let Glazyev and Katasonov get involved in the battle through Putin's decision. Or acting as independent fighters if Putin drifts. Lose? Not scary! Benefit will definitely be. At least in the form of diminishing the appetites of the offshore fraternity. Moreover, anti-offshore measures of the West, which are already gaining strength, are to help.
        1. Ingvar 72
          Ingvar 72 April 25 2020 08: 28 New
          19
          Quote: depressant
          Let's protect the cute, intelligent Glazyev and Katasonov from the bestial Nabiullins.

          It’s not about that, Lyudmila Yakovlevna. Putting Glazyev at the head of the Central Bank, he needs to give carte blanche on personnel issues and decision-making. Only in this case he will be able to solve something, going beyond the existing system. Otherwise, as Chan put it, from any saint they will make a scapegoat. hi
          1. Malibu
            Malibu April 25 2020 09: 22 New
            +1
            Quote: Ingvar 72
            It’s not about that, Lyudmila Yakovlevna. Putting Glazyev at the head of the Central Bank, he needs to give carte blanche on personnel issues and decision-making. Only in this case he will be able to solve something, going beyond the existing system.

            I agree with you! But this is a very dangerous matter, I remember in the 90s the head of the Central Bank was soaked and did not find a customer ...
            And the Primakov government, which literally stopped the complete collapse of financial Russia, taking emergency measures to stop the robbery of Russia ..
            Glazyev is certainly not a panacea, but I think so many in Russia .. It is necessary to take emergency measures otherwise, it will start again ..
            Quote: depressant
            Let Glazyev and Katasonov get involved in the battle through Putin's decision. Or acting as independent fighters if Putin drifts. Lose? Not scary! Benefit will definitely be.

            Thank you Lyudmila, you are Russian women. We are sometimes superior in courage. love . In this critical situation, he will not be able to sit out any more. "Maybe he will carry it over .." It's time to act .. hi
            1. depressant
              depressant April 25 2020 10: 41 New
              11
              Thank you, colleagues, for your understanding and support. I think so. Putin, of course, will not go to strengthen Belousov. After all, this will also mean the political elevation of the Deputy Prime Minister, he will become a bone in the throat of an unbearable competition, jealous of the president’s alien political glory. So what remains for us to do? To demand from Glazyev and Katasonov a massive speech on popular resources with their ideas that are likely to be in demand, will receive a positive response and widespread support on the Internet. And not only. The unrest in the Caucasus and virtual rallies, barely gaining strength, should receive a distinct support, an economic tool in asserting their rights when talking with the authorities. But what can people say? Give me money! And there is no money! - the authority answers. You're lying! shouts the people. - There is money! Yes, not about your honor! - the government answers, and then, having come to some confusion from the prospect of rebellion, he reluctantly adds: okay, we’ll hand it out ... Pressure on the authorities allows us to bargain and get something. The trouble is that not all receive it and far from the promised volume. 12 130? No matter how! There are a lot of conditions that reduce the receipt to 1400 rubles.
              This one-handed Nabiullina gives direction. And the other immediately liberalizes the withdrawal of capital to offshore - so much so that already the customs officers howled. For what they planted last year, this year they are obliged to stroke the head, gently chide and only sometimes fine. These are the things that Glazyev and Katasonov should say, commenting on every step of our economic authorities every day in an accessible language that people understand, using simple examples to explain complex economic concepts. And then gradually support will begin to take shape, the protests will make sense.
              1. Malibu
                Malibu April 25 2020 11: 14 New
                -3
                Quote: depressant
                The trouble is that not all receive it and far from the promised volume. 12 130? No matter how! There are a lot of conditions that reduce the receipt to 1400 rubles.
                This one-handed Nabiullina gives direction. And the other immediately liberalizes the withdrawal of capital to offshore - so much so that already the customs officers howled. For what they planted last year, this year they are obliged to stroke the head, gently chide and only sometimes fine. These are the things that Glazyev and Katasonov should say, commenting on every step of our economic authorities every day in an accessible language that people understand, using simple examples to explain complex economic concepts. And then gradually support will begin to take shape, the protests will make sense.

                How have you not been banned for such bold statements?
                Well, here you still need to understand ... hi
            2. 2 Level Advisor
              2 Level Advisor April 26 2020 08: 00 New
              0
              The first time I hear .. This is someone soaked then? Enlighten please ..
          2. sniperino
            sniperino April 25 2020 10: 00 New
            +2
            Quote: Ingvar 72
            as Chan put it, they will make a scapegoat out of any saint
            It's like making Monsieur Jean, about
        2. Zhan
          Zhan April 25 2020 08: 41 New
          13
          hi Have a nice one you too.
          In your opinion, let's do nothing. Let's protect the cute, intelligent Glazyev and Katasonov from the bestial Nabiullins.

          I didn't really mean it. You perfectly remember the old adage: "There are many good people, but the bad are better organized", due to the absolute lack of the latter, moral values ​​and not scrupulous in the means to achieve the goal. I mentioned that Katasonov and Glazyev are not from this cohort of people, they need to clean the road, they are excellent specialists, but not fighters in the undercover games of politicians. And at the moment, people are required who already know the entire political elite in order to protect these people and provide them with the opportunity to work without engaging in political quirks.
          Putin is drifting. Lose? Not scary! Benefit will definitely be. At least in the form of diminishing the appetites of the offshore fraternity. Moreover, anti-offshore measures of the West, which are already gaining strength, are to help.

          Nobody had any benefit from losing. And the loss of death now is like ... and millions of lives are at stake.
          1. depressant
            depressant April 25 2020 09: 28 New
            14
            There is a force capable of protecting Glazyev and Katasonov. This is a former assistant to the president, and now Deputy Prime Minister Andrei Belousov. Putin brought him into the government to control Mishustin's "digital" impulses and the entire financial block. Mishustin, possessing an unmeasurable conceit, removed Belousov from control of Siluanov, Nabiullina's loyal detainee. And now bankers are offering loans from the population. Freezing of deposits amounting to 30 trillion rubles - I don't want to swim in free money! This is about 200 thousand rubles for each citizen. It is clear that this money actually belongs to small and mainly medium-sized businesses. Taking this money away from the people who provide jobs for the majority of the population will ruin the country. Why are they trying to take this money away? To ensure the smooth implementation of national projects, giving salaries to a few builders and an opportunity to fill the pockets of a few oligarchs. Putin must understand that in times of an unprecedented deafening and prolonged world crisis, Wishlist must either be pushed aside, or carried out at the expense of shaking and shrinking the oligarchic and banking strata. Belousov is a tough person. And if Mishustin pushed him aside, it was only with Putin's consent. So that Belousov also understands his place in the hierarchy. So, this is not the time to measure personal belongings. If Putin returns power in the government to Belousov, then it can be assumed that Glazyev and Katasonov will find protection in him. Since all three characters are people of the same ideological blood. If this does not happen, then the bankers will clearly show themselves as outspoken enemies of the state, and Putin as their patron. Time to choose. Time to ask the question "Who are you with, Mr. Putin?"
            1. Gardamir
              Gardamir April 25 2020 10: 07 New
              13
              Time to ask the question "Who are you with, Mr. Putin?
              He has already answered this question so many times. Suffice it to recall the enchanting "my own". The people then could not even think that for the head of state, the people are not their own.
            2. Revival
              Revival April 25 2020 16: 16 New
              0
              The answer to this question has already been given clearly and clearly.
            3. rruvim
              rruvim April 26 2020 16: 17 New
              0
              Putin is a typical Gauleiter of the occupation authorities. Or the International Secret Government ... Who you like. And no Belousov will correct the policy of the occupation authorities in relation to the Russian people (total annihilation). Only soften ...
        3. Digital error
          Digital error April 25 2020 09: 10 New
          +2
          Quote: depressant
          Lose? Not scary!

          It's not scary for you. And someone can invite them to billiards, and after a game under the table from Glazyev’s side, a basket suddenly appears with two million "marked" ones ...
        4. MstislavHrabr
          MstislavHrabr April 25 2020 09: 41 New
          +7
          Lyudmila Yakovlevna. Glazyev and Katasonov are managers, scientists, honest, decent people - but not heroes who are ready to rush to the embrasure ... And when you rush to the embrasure you need to know that your comrades are following you ... "To act as independent fighters" is like death ... Will Belousov cover them up? And do they need such a cover?
        5. Ross xnumx
          Ross xnumx April 25 2020 10: 10 New
          +7
          Quote: depressant
          In your opinion, let's do nothing. Let's protect the cute, intelligent Glazyev and Katasonov from the bestial Nabiullins. By eliminating the cute ones from the decision field. And then they’ll eat the cute ones! Understand, the times when you can be a sweet and intelligent expert in your field without getting stuck in anything have passed. It's time to show your teeth.

          good
          In confirmation, I can take a little fun:
          And Glazyev’s criticism of the Central Bank is quite constructive, the authors agree with her 100

          And criticism of the Communist Party towards Putin-is quite constructive ...
          MAYBE US SUCH "CRITICANS" AND "SPEAKING HEADS" ENOUGH? belay
          Quote: depressant
          ... if Putin drifts.

          As long as the country has an armed regime in support of the regime (Rosguard), while the people “get together on forums and websites”, while the “PUBLIC VOICE” broadcasts in a whisper of Bezrukov, creak of Mashkov, Esaul’s cry of Gazmanov and other “creators”, until someone spits on the face of the “nullifiers” and no one will throw a tomato on the white shirt-front of the liable official will drift. These are not people who are afraid of "show-offs." They are their creators.
          1. depressant
            depressant April 25 2020 11: 24 New
            +2
            So what do you suggest, colleague? The police, meanwhile, are already empowered to open cars and apartments of citizens who are not terrorists and other criminals. Well, let's limit ourselves to listing the crimes of power against our people - otherwise they themselves do not know about them! And when the riot begins, it turns out that an extra bunch of laws have been adopted quietly, allowing you to shoot at people, massively twist those who disagree with the subsequent award of long sentences by angry judges. This is instead of a constructive conversation with the authorities.
            Example.
            Power: a citizen has the right to walk along the street only with a pass. Otherwise, it restricts the rights and freedoms of other citizens.
            Internet: how does a person without a pass restrict the rights and freedoms of other citizens?
            The coronavirus is already forgotten, resting aside. Skipping, monitoring every step of the citizen comes to the fore. The virus has come and will go, the pass will remain.
      2. oligofren32
        oligofren32 April 25 2020 09: 42 New
        -10
        we somehow survived the 90s and those Soviet / Russian men in tweets and facebook on this score did not cry and did not write about how they eat the last x # r without salt or "chicken backbone", worked where they paid and thus found a way to feed their family. You spent a month or two at home and already there are three streams of tears: give me my million, over there in the west, the state is distributing million, etc. Nobody promised you socialism, and it would be high time to start thinking and planning the financial future of your family on your own, and it would be better already in your third decade, and the government's handouts in the form of subsidies, benefits, etc. should be taken as a bonus. And the global trend of excessive and universal consumption in the context of one's family, it would be worth rethinking too. Yes, it is difficult, I know, but this is exactly what distinguishes a Man from an over-aged infantile.
    3. Pravodel
      Pravodel April 25 2020 08: 57 New
      -5
      The big article is just the whole basement, but it makes no sense. Verbiage is one thing: Glazyev is VO !, and everyone else is BUT .... They teach the scribbler the beauty at the journal faculty: to speak a lot and say nothing in essence. What is Ciceronnen ... He lived a long time, and all is not true. Here, he surpassed everyone, including Cicero. Well, keep it up .... Now get ready to speak in the Duma or in the European Parliament. There you will find application to your verbiage.
      1. depressant
        depressant April 25 2020 11: 31 New
        +2
        The truth! People are looking for a leader. At least from media persons. At least someone who is able to defend their interests. Looking for something similar, discuss. The article is an occasion.
    4. Digital error
      Digital error April 25 2020 08: 59 New
      -2
      Quote: Dead Day
      we will "reset" apparently

      do not generalize smile
    5. smart ass
      smart ass April 25 2020 09: 58 New
      +2
      One gets the impression that this is the final and soon there will be serious changes, the summer will last and then the winter ...
  2. Far B
    Far B April 25 2020 05: 51 New
    28
    Glazyev's proposal is correct - thanks to such a measure (one of) Malaysia was the first of the "Asian Tigers" to get out of the Asian financial crisis at the turn of the century. True, then the Malay Prime Minister was also quickly dismissed from his post, as was Primakov in our country. Well, the current appeal of the Central Bank to "shut up" Glazyev (why through the Ministry of Industry and Trade? Better through Sportloto, since the days of Vysotsky they have got used to everyone) - pure freedom of speech in Putin's way. Peskov carries a blizzard with his mustache - another matter. He's his own.
    1. saigon
      saigon April 25 2020 08: 09 New
      22
      Gentlemen and comrades, I am a techie and therefore I am used to clear and understandable rules.
      Looking at our economists and not ours, I also have a strong feeling - economics is not a science!
      In geometry, there are theorems that need to be proved and axioms that are undeniable truth, in metal management everything is clear too, the laws of those mechanics are not subject to change depending on the political moment, but economics is not a field plowed for the flight of thought and various theories.
      It’s not clear to me why banks and resource swayers abroad are our priority.
      Why the hell is a vegetable a bunch of banks that there is no way to get along with three or four large and stable ones (lolashki about market competition is completely stupid)
      When it comes to the heads of decision-makers, the main industry, agriculture, science, education and now the need for medicine has arisen (and it has been optimized before)
      As long as there are five silos of militia in the country (an army is needed and a powerful one) there will be no sense, healthy men should not guard, keep and not let go, but work in production.
      1. Altona
        Altona April 25 2020 09: 12 New
        10
        Quote: saigon
        Looking at our economists and not ours, I also have a strong feeling - economics is not a science!

        -------------------------------
        In the current situation, it is definitely not science, but politics. We take away from these, we give. And without any explanation. This is supposed to, this is not supposed to. Naturally, such an "economy" will not last long.
      2. Digital error
        Digital error April 25 2020 09: 13 New
        +8
        Quote: saigon
        healthy men should not guard, keep and not let go, but work at the factory

        This is in the presence of trust between the "representatives elected by the people" and the people themselves. We have a different case.
      3. Sergey Samkov
        Sergey Samkov April 25 2020 09: 21 New
        +5
        At least you google - how many banks are not in the European Union, but only in Germany !!! 750! Apart from all kinds of small credit organizations .... The point here is not the number, but the capabilities of banks and strict regulation of their external activities ..
        1. saigon
          saigon April 26 2020 06: 41 New
          -2
          You want to say that Germany is a role model for us in the banking sector?
          Not sure - quantity is not synonymous with quality.
          Well, we have enough small credit sharags and that from this to someone other than the owners of sharag ray.
          What we call economics is anything but economics, but some kind of distortion on economic topics
          1. rruvim
            rruvim April 26 2020 16: 31 New
            0
            Germany can be a role model in the banking sector!
            On June 5, 1939, the Reichsbank Act was passed, which renamed the central bank of the Reich into the German Reichsbank and placed it directly under the authority of the “Führer and Reich Chancellor” Adolf Hitler.
            Since then, the Reichsbank credit policy has changed. He ceased to be independent of the German government and the interest rate was determined directly by the Reich Chancellor. The second industrialization of Germany began after 1933, when the council (board of directors) of the Reichsbank, specifically influential Jewish bankers, was abolished.
            1. saigon
              saigon April 27 2020 08: 07 New
              -1
              The novel is a very slippery example, with Nazi Germany, however, it confirms the banks must submit to the interests of the state.
              At least many people don’t like the Reich example.
      4. olimpiada15
        olimpiada15 April 25 2020 18: 33 New
        0
        Saigon, totally agree. The liberal economy is not a science, but a scam.
    2. depressant
      depressant April 25 2020 11: 38 New
      0
      Peskov ... Assuming that we are herbivores, Peskov put on his “coronavirus” badge - remember? This is how he indicated the government's intention to manipulate us according to the method of Alan Chumak in order to drive us into a stall. And then the people were sticking their heads through the bars. But it didn’t even occur to his own head, which thereby exposes the contents of the heads of power - sawdust!
      1. Golovan Jack
        Golovan Jack April 25 2020 12: 05 New
        -5
        Oh, how ... if I understood you correctly, all these self-isolation epidemics are invented only and specifically in order to

        Quote: depressant
        ... to manipulate us according to the method of Alan Chumak in order to drive us to the stall

        ? This is a question, if that yes
        1. martin-159
          martin-159 April 26 2020 07: 20 New
          -1
          I think that meant the moronic Peskov badge.
  3. Pessimist22
    Pessimist22 April 25 2020 05: 51 New
    20
    Clearly, the dollar will go up.
    1. Bacha
      Bacha April 25 2020 06: 34 New
      17
      And gasoline ...
    2. Stas157
      Stas157 April 25 2020 07: 41 New
      -1
      Quote: Pessimist22
      Clearly, the dollar will go up.

      While the ruble is being held, preliminary dropping to 75, and selling at a billion dollars a week. But, it is clear that they will not be held back for a long time. But what will happen next? 90s?
      1. Malibu
        Malibu April 25 2020 07: 51 New
        -20
        Quote: Stas157
        While the ruble is being held, preliminary dropping to 75, and selling at a billion dollars a week. But, it is clear that they will not be held back for a long time. But what will happen next? 90s?

        We’ll start shaking further than our oligarchs and other swindlers. Now the point is, the borders are closed and they will not go anywhere .. And Mishustin, a former tax official and info, owns who and how is taking capital out and who has how much .. Waiting for a team!
        1. Deniska999
          Deniska999 April 25 2020 07: 58 New
          13
          No, deposits are more likely to be frozen and bonds will be exchanged with an obligation to return someday.
          1. The comment was deleted.
        2. Sergey Gavrilov
          Sergey Gavrilov April 25 2020 08: 10 New
          13
          The oligarchs have their own planes and their own border ...
          1. Malibu
            Malibu April 25 2020 08: 22 New
            -7
            Quote: Sergey Gavrilov
            The oligarchs have their own planes and their own border ...

            How is Berezovsky ..? bully
        3. Altona
          Altona April 25 2020 09: 13 New
          +9
          Quote: Malibu
          And Mishustin is a former tax and info owner

          ------------------------
          Yes, yes, and "crystal clear" too. The system pushes up the most soiled, so that there is a mutual guarantee.
      2. DEDPIHTO
        DEDPIHTO April 25 2020 08: 13 New
        12
        Yes, it’s probably foolish to expect that the Central Bank will ruin the entire dollar coin for supporting the ruble, which has remained for only six months of such injections, at the current price of oil, at which there are practically no foreign exchange earnings. So the bottom of the bottom of the ruble is yet to come. But formally the power of social. fulfill obligations, impoverished wrappers.
        1. Digital error
          Digital error April 25 2020 09: 15 New
          +3
          Quote: DEPHIHTO
          formally the power of social. fulfill obligations

          They won't. You cannot build "national projects" on candy wrappers, and this is the very breakthrough (social obligations) promised in exchange for an increase in pension age and VAT.
          1. DEDPIHTO
            DEDPIHTO April 25 2020 09: 23 New
            11
            Oh yes, national projects, but who now recalls them upstairs? Now they are not up to the projections, they would save their heads. Think about why right now the security forces are expanding their powers up to shooting to kill for crunching a plastic cup. hi
            1. Digital error
              Digital error April 25 2020 09: 27 New
              +4
              Quote: DEPHIHTO
              Who remembers them upstairs now?

              they were initially not going to be implemented, since between the "May decrees" of 2018 and the plan for implementation passed a year out of six allotted for execution. 1/6 of the time per plan is cool.
              Quote: DEPHIHTO
              down to kill

              They want to do a lot of things under the guise of coronavirus. For example, EFIR - have you heard? And in general, I think, we may soon be told that the dictatorship is the most acceptable "state system" hi
              1. Alf
                Alf April 25 2020 17: 44 New
                +5
                Quote: DigitalError
                we may soon be announced that the dictatorship is the most acceptable "state system"

                Not only.
                1. Lexus
                  Lexus April 25 2020 18: 53 New
                  +1
                  Elementary.
              2. Alexander mosin
                Alexander mosin April 25 2020 20: 52 New
                -1
                Quote: DigitalError
                And in general, I think, we may soon be told that the dictatorship is the most acceptable "state system"

                I have strong nerves and sometimes at work I listen to "Time Will Show", "Meeting Place" and similar freak shows .., so there has not been such a thought for years. But in fact, when the people in power have the only and most important goal to maintain power, a slide into dictatorship is inevitable.
  4. depressant
    depressant April 25 2020 06: 04 New
    35
    Glazyev - for state planning, as in the USSR. There was planning, there was development. No planning - the main thing ... no, not the market - the Central Bank, which puts Russia in colonial dependence on the IMF and the US Federal Reserve. The Central Bank is a tool for pumping out resources from our country, vitality from the population in favor of the West. Glazyev - for the responsibility of the government to the country, and not to the Central Bank. The era of the coronavirus revealed all the cards, broke the scenery, exposing the indecent subordination of the supreme power of Russia to the Central Bank, which means the West. Glazyev - against the Central Bank. He is a patriot. Hence the hatred of Glazyev on the part of bankers in general and Nabiullina in particular.
    1. Dmitry from Voronezh
      Dmitry from Voronezh April 25 2020 06: 34 New
      18
      Planning is good and right. At the same time, for it to work efficiently, you need state control over most of the financial flows, control over the Central Bank. Then the country will have the means to implement the tasks set in the planning. Without this, economic management is impossible.
      1. depressant
        depressant April 25 2020 07: 01 New
        21
        Glazyev was supposed to control the Central Bank. He was a contender for the role of its head. But Putin "equidistant" Academician Glazyev under pressure not so much from the West as from his "friends", eager not only to stack currency in Western offshore areas, but also to actively invest in the economies of foreign and even hostile countries. What would Glazyev actively discourage by promoting investment in Russia. The Central Bank has such tools! Having followed the lead of the "friends", wishing the favor of the Western "partners" and his own political courage, Putin replaced Glazyev with the accountant Nabiullina, pleasing to the West and "friends", who opened wide the doors to capital flight from Russia. But since Glazyev is still a significant political figure (Minister for Integration and Macroeconomics of the Eurasian Economic Commission - EEC), that is, a systemic politician whose services the President can resort to at any time, in the dire conditions of an economic crisis disguised as a coronavirus, Nabiullina became nervous and made an official denunciation of Glazyev, demanding to shut him up. This is generally a circus! So much for liberalism! Will some of the liberals now remember the 37th?
        1. Dmitry from Voronezh
          Dmitry from Voronezh April 25 2020 07: 31 New
          17
          It is evidently not in vain in the West that Nabiullina is praised, even as it was recognized as the best Head of the Central Bank. Once praised, then everything is doing right from the point of view of non-partners.
        2. Igoresha
          Igoresha April 25 2020 20: 11 New
          0
          Nabiullina became nervous and made an official denunciation of Glazyev, demanding to shut his mouth.

          there is an opinion that for this: "In his report on overcoming the crisis in the EAEU, he (Glazyev) proposed to introduce the so-called" Tobin Tax "on foreign exchange transactions." https://norg-norg.livejournal.com/642813.html
        3. flicker
          flicker April 26 2020 22: 38 New
          +1
          Nabiullina became nervous and made an official denunciation of Glazyev
          A memo is called, not an official denunciation.
          Another question is why is she made public?
          ---
          It cannot be ruled out that both Glazyev's report and the "memorandum" and its publication are links in the same chain.
          At least so many tensed.
    2. Servisinzhener
      Servisinzhener April 25 2020 08: 20 New
      +9
      Glazyev - for state planning, as in the USSR
      As far as I read his speeches, he is for a combination of planned and market economies. It depends on which type of activity which one will be more effective. And not for creating a second Gosplan regulating everything from the amount of cast iron needed to pies in a roadside eatery.
      1. Ingvar 72
        Ingvar 72 April 25 2020 08: 30 New
        10
        Quote: Servisinzhener
        he is for a combination of planned and market economies.

        Yes, it's called an integrated economy. Chinese version. hi
      2. tatra
        tatra April 25 2020 09: 36 New
        +8
        There is no market economy in the world, and what is called a market economy has shown its monstrous inefficiency compared to the planned one, especially during the constantly recurring economic crises of capitalism.
    3. tihonmarine
      tihonmarine April 25 2020 08: 23 New
      10
      Quote: depressant
      Glazyev - against the Central Bank. He is a patriot. Hence the hatred of Glazyev on the part of bankers in general and Nabiullina in particular.

      I'm interested in the chairman of the Central Bank Nabiullina. Since the beginning of its activity from 1991 to 2012, she, like a dragonfly, jumped from place to place 16 times (i.e. 16 positions) and this in 21 years, and at the same time still managed to study at Yale University. Although all the positions were not "feeble".
      And here is what her classmate and liberal Sergey Aleksashenko, head of the HSE Development Center, says about her
      Scholarship holder Karl Marx, who loved Marxist-Leninist political economy, who firmly believed in the ideals of communism, is one of the first students to be admitted to our party - In general, an exemplary Soviet man. I think she never intended to pursue such a public career. Now, of course, the views have changed: he looks at life soberly, understands how it works.
      These are all the paradoxes of personality development. At first, the ideals of communism are above all, and even in the CPSU, the institute accepted, and also with the same ease switched to liberals, taking the path of opponents of Marxism, but defenders of capitalism, in general, the old people said - today with the "reds", tomorrow with the "whites", the day after tomorrow with the "anarchists".
      1. Digital error
        Digital error April 25 2020 09: 17 New
        +4
        Quote: tihonmarine
        jumped from place to place 16 times (i.e. 16 posts) and this is for 21 years

        Check out the biography of former Deputy Minister of Industry and Trade Dmitry Ovsyannikov. Negative personnel selection, I suppose.
        1. tihonmarine
          tihonmarine April 25 2020 09: 27 New
          +3
          Quote: DigitalError
          Negative personnel selection, I suppose.

          Now it is very close. There is nothing to be surprised at, nepotism, illiteracy, dullness. Dumb and illiterate are easy to command.
      2. MstislavHrabr
        MstislavHrabr April 25 2020 09: 53 New
        +7
        Well, she's just an executive, systemic person. The only question is whose orders Nabiullina is executing, and what system it serves ... The position "both ours and yours" may not work today ...
      3. Svarog
        Svarog April 25 2020 10: 29 New
        +9
        Quote: tihonmarine
        At first, the ideals of communism are above all, and even in the CPSU, the institute accepted, and also with the same ease switched to liberals, taking the path of opponents of Marxism, but defenders of capitalism, in general, the old people said - today with the "red", tomorrow with the "white" the day after tomorrow with the "anarchists".

        There are all shifters. And for such people, the main thing is not an idea, not a result. One thing is important to them - money. And what personally amazes me is that for several generations it has provided itself, it would seem, work for people, bring benefits, and if you can’t get away with dignity .. But no, they’ll suck to the last drop of blood ..
        1. Alf
          Alf April 25 2020 17: 48 New
          +3
          Quote: Svarog
          And what personally amazes me is that for several generations it has provided itself, it would seem, work for people, bring benefits, and if you can’t get away with dignity .. But no, they’ll suck to the last drop of blood ..

          While a person is in the System, he is protected, but as soon as he comes out of it, everyone starts biting him from all sides and very often his own.
          1. Svarog
            Svarog April 25 2020 17: 49 New
            0
            Quote: Alf
            Quote: Svarog
            And what personally amazes me is that for several generations it has provided itself, it would seem, work for people, bring benefits, and if you can’t get away with dignity .. But no, they’ll suck to the last drop of blood ..

            While a person is in the System, he is protected, but as soon as he comes out of it, everyone starts biting him from all sides and very often his own.

            Yes there is such a thing .. I agree .. BUT any system can be changed and add add-ons .. there would be a desire.
            1. Alf
              Alf April 25 2020 17: 53 New
              +4
              Quote: Svarog
              BUT any system can be changed and add add-ons .. there would be a desire.

              Vladimir, you are not quite right. It makes no sense to add add-ons, since the very basis of the system remains untouched. The little bear flew out, Mishustin sat on his chair. Has the system changed?
              1. Svarog
                Svarog April 25 2020 17: 55 New
                -3
                Quote: Alf
                Quote: Svarog
                BUT any system can be changed and add add-ons .. there would be a desire.

                Vladimir, you are not quite right. It makes no sense to add add-ons, since the very basis of the system remains untouched. The little bear flew out, Mishustin sat on his chair. Has the system changed?

                Of course not. Medved, Mishustin .. everything is in the system and plays the role that has been prepared. Only a guarantor can change the system .. but everything suits him ..
                1. Alf
                  Alf April 25 2020 17: 59 New
                  +2
                  Quote: Svarog
                  Only a guarantor can change the system ..

                  The guarantor is the System. The system can nominate to a leading (but not managing) position only one of its ranks and only one who will support this system.
                  1. Svarog
                    Svarog April 25 2020 18: 03 New
                    0
                    Quote: Alf
                    Quote: Svarog
                    Only a guarantor can change the system ..

                    The guarantor is the System. The system can nominate to a leading (but not managing) position only one of its ranks and only one who will support this system.

                    Any system has a manager, otherwise there is no system. We can say that this is a guarantor, we can assume that he is only a puppet or a talking head, but there is a true leader and he must firstly be the head of state, and secondly, really head the system. Well, actually be the creator of this system. If this is not so and when it is not, then everything is bad and everything is rotten and everything needs to be changed. It is unacceptable for the tail to twist the dog .. unless of course I correctly understood your idea. hi
                    1. Alf
                      Alf April 25 2020 18: 11 New
                      0
                      Quote: Svarog
                      but there is a true leader and he must first be the head of state,

                      No way. Until recently, it was like that — all victories from Putin, all failures — from bad Medvedev. And the real leaders of the System and its creators are always in the shadows.
                      Quote: Svarog
                      then everything is bad and everything is rotten and everything needs to be changed.

                      It's time.
                      Quote: Svarog
                      It is not permissible for the tail to twist the owner ..

                      Pay attention to the US political system. There, the president is not the master of the country, but only the interim manager. You can draw such an analogy. The President is the captain of the ship, he was appointed to manage the ship by the owners of the board. The captain is given the end point of the route, he is free to take a little left-right, but he is obliged to bring the trough exactly to the point that the ship owners assigned him.
                      In Russia, the same management system.
                      1. Svarog
                        Svarog April 25 2020 18: 16 New
                        -2
                        Quote: Alf
                        In Russia, the same management system.

                        Maybe. Even sooner, I agree with you. And with high probability this is so. But this is not easier for us. In any case, it is necessary to change the system and it does not matter who is behind it, it is important that it does not work ..
                      2. Alf
                        Alf April 25 2020 18: 24 New
                        +2
                        Quote: Svarog
                        In any case, it is necessary to change the system and it does not matter who is behind it, it is important that it does not work ..

                        No arguing against this.
                2. Lexus
                  Lexus April 25 2020 18: 09 New
                  0
                  Cat rats cannot grow.
                  1. Alf
                    Alf April 25 2020 18: 15 New
                    +1
                    Quote: lexus
                    Cat rats cannot grow.

                    good
  5. Altona
    Altona April 25 2020 09: 59 New
    +9
    Quote: depressant
    Glazyev - for state planning, as in the USSR.

    ---------------------------
    Lyudmila Yakovlevna, the whole charm is that we have neither a market, nor a state. There are oligopolies with a wild monopoly of prices for everything where they rule their close ones. There would be a market, there would be competition, prices would fall. There would be a state, there would be employment, there would be more powerful social support in the form of housing, education and medicine. But we have it as it is.
  • Dmitry from Voronezh
    Dmitry from Voronezh April 25 2020 06: 05 New
    22
    The most important thing is to stop or at least reduce the outflow of capital abroad. For 20 years, money has been steadily withdrawn from the country, and in the upper echelons of power they are surprised by the low economic growth. The country makes money by exporting oil, gas, metals, foodstuffs, etc. Sometime more, sometime less, but one cannot say that we are completely poor, but most of this money settles on the accounts of oligarchs and "effective managers" and is withdrawn to offshore. Money is simply not invested in the national economy. GDP growth should be stimulated by something: either internal or external investments or loans in the external market, and when money leaves the country, the economy stagnates.
    1. Far B
      Far B April 25 2020 06: 27 New
      12
      20 years steadily withdraw money from the country
      Yes, far from 20 years. At least one and a half times longer.
      GDP growth should be stimulated by something
      The stimulator must certainly be the direct stimulus in its original sense (lat. Stimulus - A sharp metal tip on the pole used to drive a buffalo (a bull pulled into a wagon). And this stimulus should be in the hands of the authorities, who feel responsible for the country, and not for their pockets. But external investment is, in fact, the same subsequent withdrawal of capital abroad, however, in the current state of affairs, external investments are not very different from external ones.
      1. Malibu
        Malibu April 25 2020 07: 56 New
        +4
        Quote: Dalny V
        Yes, far from 20 years. At least one and a half times longer.

        Exactly so, even during the time of the hunchback, the pumping of currency from the country began, as the Titovs, Khodorkovskys and other "businessmen" know well ... Read their memoirs, the hair on your head will move and your teeth will grind off from anger and resentment, as they robbed the great country of the USSR!
        1. depressant
          depressant April 25 2020 08: 34 New
          12
          I generally demand a criminal investigation into the activities of Nabiullina. How it is? Nabiullina sanitizes one bank after another, its representatives delve into the papers of each of the banks for months, physically present at their premises, and bankers at that time transfer citizens' savings to bucks, shove someone else's good in their offshore pockets and flee abroad. Did the inspectors of Nabiullina go blind? Deaf, buried in paper? Didn’t see what was happening under their nose? Can I assume that blindness and deafness are a good bribe? Including - personally Nabiullina?
          Yes, I didn't stand with a candle. But, given the realities of our capitalism, which has rotted right at the root, I can assume this. And now, to cover the "punctures" of the Central Bank from the National Wealth Fund in the amount of allegedly 700 billion rubles, the Russian government will buy Sberbank from the Central Bank. It's already a song!
      2. depressant
        depressant April 25 2020 12: 00 New
        +1
        The Code of Administrative Offenses, article 15.25, provides for liability for violation of currency legislation in a whole range of cases.
        So, from April 1, 2020, instead of fines - warnings. That has greatly facilitated for almost 25 days the export of currency earned by the illegal export of our resources, all sorts of frauds, has facilitated the illegal withdrawal of capital. Scoundrels do this on an industrial scale! And now - a free corridor.
    2. The comment was deleted.
    3. Uncle lee
      Uncle lee April 25 2020 07: 04 New
      24
      Quote: Dmitry from Voronezh
      stop or at least reduce capital outflows

      1. Malibu
        Malibu April 25 2020 07: 58 New
        +5
        The correct picture that explains the entire financial system of the State Bank of Russia .. Where is the money Zin?
      2. Pavel57
        Pavel57 April 25 2020 08: 12 New
        +4
        And the Central Bank’s ransom of Sberra is there a form of payment to the West?
    4. tihonmarine
      tihonmarine April 25 2020 07: 54 New
      +7
      Quote: Dmitry from Voronezh
      The most important thing is to stop or at least reduce the outflow of capital abroad.

      At this time and in this situation, this will not happen.
    5. Digital error
      Digital error April 25 2020 12: 30 New
      +1
      Quote: Dmitry from Voronezh
      in the upper echelons of power are surprised at small economic growth

      they are not surprised there, they "target inflation", there is no time to be distracted by nonsense
  • Operator
    Operator April 25 2020 07: 04 New
    -2
    I did not understand from the article "associate professors with candidates", but what exactly did the professor suggest and why is it good? laughing

    And from what side is Glazyev "Minister for Integration into the EAEU"?

    PS In the Russian Academy of Sciences, former adviser Glazyev is the chairman of the non-scientific "Council on Complex Issues of Eurasian Economic Integration, Modernization, Competitiveness and Sustainable Development."
    1. Mordvin 3
      Mordvin 3 April 25 2020 07: 32 New
      +2
      Quote: Operator
      And from what side is Glazyev "Minister for Integration into the EAEU"?

      He was an adviser to Putin in the 90s
      1. Operator
        Operator April 25 2020 07: 57 New
        0
        The key word was "was" (by the way, it is not comme il faut to confuse the position of an adviser with a minister for a Ph.D.).
        1. Digital error
          Digital error April 25 2020 12: 36 New
          -1
          Quote: Operator
          Keyword "was"

          Keyword - "Putin" smile
          Glazyev, Ulyukaev, Chubais and Shokhin did an internship in Austria under the program of the US State Department - I can’t assess the truth, but even the photo in the article is https://imperialcommiss.livejournal.com/1724149.html
          1. Operator
            Operator April 25 2020 12: 44 New
            0
            Exactly - passed (I have already posted a photo of theirs gop-company on the "refresher courses" under the US program in Austria, it is also available in the comments to this article).

            But Glazyev, apparently, developed an allergy to liberal methods laughing
    2. depressant
      depressant April 25 2020 07: 34 New
      +8
      Glazyev’s position is called differently. But is that the point? I understand where you are driving. And I will bow it like that.
      Putin has a very cunning internal policy, manipulating the population. Here, for example, his "self-isolation", which instantly jarred me: for whom does he take me? If he said that everyone is susceptible to coronavirus infection, especially politicians with their huge number of contacts, and the country cannot be left without control, waking him, Putin, will get sick, and therefore he, Putin, goes into self-isolation, but thanks to modern means of communication He does not let go of the thread of control - I would understand him and approve of such a decision. But taking me for a mentally retarded, Putin is putting on a play with a visit to Kommunarka, which seems to provide a natural reason for his self-isolation. And then I will shout "He averted at a moment dangerous for the country!" And so in everything. Including in relation to Glazyev and Nabiullina. When it was necessary to show off, please "friends" and the West, Nabiullina. When a very bad moment comes, and it will come, if the terrible story with oil continues, Glazyev will be pulled out of his sleeve. That is, Putin has no clear domestic policy. Galley without rudder and sails. Where the curve will take.
    3. Nyrobsky
      Nyrobsky April 25 2020 07: 49 New
      12
      Quote: Operator
      I did not understand from the article "associate professors with candidates", but what exactly did the professor suggest and why is it good?

      Maybe not exactly, but something like this ..... He suggested that something like that should be taxed for speculators who like to play currency exchange swings (rubles / dollars) which can give up to 30 billion a year, and the ingenious speculators heard this and choked on morning coffee and began to demand to shut up Glazyev, since he had bitten a holy thing and was so offended that the caviar did not go into his throat.
      1. Operator
        Operator April 25 2020 07: 59 New
        0
        Maybe so, or maybe not.

        But I had in mind something else - where can I read the relevant opinion of the authors of the article?
        1. MstislavHrabr
          MstislavHrabr April 25 2020 12: 03 New
          0
          https://www.youtube-nocookie.com/embed/TCDElKSUwXI?rel=0
    4. Digital error
      Digital error April 25 2020 09: 21 New
      +1
      Quote: Operator
      sustainable development

      The development of what - foreign production? This phrase scares where it is necessary and not necessary. So, there is a certain paradigm.
    5. Sergej1972
      Sergej1972 April 25 2020 09: 32 New
      +2
      He takes this post. Go to the website of the Eurasian Commission. There are several ministers.
      1. Operator
        Operator April 25 2020 09: 52 New
        +1
        The Eurasian Economic Commission is a permanent body of the Eurasian Economic Union of the Russian Federation, Kazakhstan and Belarus. The commission is headed by a panel of the chairman and members, one of which is Glazyev.
        1. Sergej1972
          Sergej1972 April 25 2020 09: 58 New
          +3
          Just visited the site. The members of the college are officially referred to as "members of the college (ministers)".
          1. Operator
            Operator April 25 2020 10: 20 New
            -2
            Let there be a "minister of the collegium" laughing
  • Chaldon48
    Chaldon48 April 25 2020 07: 13 New
    +6
    Central Bank, our sacred cow?
    1. Ros 56
      Ros 56 April 25 2020 07: 51 New
      +9
      It's time for this cow to give horns. And make milking for domestic consumption. fellow
      1. Digital error
        Digital error April 25 2020 12: 48 New
        +1
        Quote: Ros 56
        And make milking

        That the cow ate less and gave more milk - it is necessary to feed less and to milk more yes The Federal Tax Service seems to have adopted this slogan ...
    2. tihonmarine
      tihonmarine April 25 2020 07: 51 New
      +9
      Quote: Chaldon48
      Central Bank, our sacred cow?

      Most likely "someone else's cow".
  • alekSASHKA-36
    alekSASHKA-36 April 25 2020 07: 16 New
    +7
    [quote] The Russians are still not left with the most expensive alcohol for “sugreva,” and quote and moonshine will fit / quote] ,. And you can collect deadwood.
    1. Chaldon48
      Chaldon48 April 25 2020 12: 14 New
      -1
      Sun, air, and water are our best friends!
  • Mordvin 3
    Mordvin 3 April 25 2020 07: 29 New
    12
    We have the same erysipelas was the boss. I expressed to her in full. I was fired then ...
  • rocket757
    rocket757 April 25 2020 07: 50 New
    +6
    To offer, simply to move, key and not very, figures of MANAGERS .... maybe not a complete waste of time!?!?!? just will not change anything in the FINAL ACCOUNT!
    Because those who rule everything in this state ..... a comprador, both scientifically and simply ........ pi pi pi.
    Our Tail controls the Dog! This is both sad and DANGEROUS!
  • tihonmarine
    tihonmarine April 25 2020 07: 50 New
    +9
    Gerashchenko
    rightly nicknamed Hercules, as you know, he returned to the Bank of Russia as its chairman on September 11, 1998, and managed, or rather, severely dealt with the consequences of default. However, after putting the basic order in the financial sphere, Gerashchenko was dismissed without explanation.
    "Hercules" are not needed by the IMF and the world financial system. Therefore, they are removed.
  • Andrey Mikhaylov
    Andrey Mikhaylov April 25 2020 07: 53 New
    +8
    In 2004, he voted for Glazyev, then no comment.
  • samarin1969
    samarin1969 April 25 2020 08: 01 New
    11
    A very understandable article. True, an unusually "ruffled" style. Probably - "mouth of anger of the day."

    There are no questions with criticism. Lighted up.
    [quote Although what matters to the world and American bankers to the Russian small town office, which by and large does not need to do anything, except to put signatures on billions of dollars in transfers abroad.] [/ quote] is very realistic.

    Commentators reproach that there are few proposals from Mr. Glazyev himself. I saw two.
    1) "But this is on condition that no one and nothing will" revive ", will not do anything at all - like now ..." - a hint of the development of domestic production.
    2) Hard currency control.

    Currency control is an effective measure, it was successfully applied in the Russian Federation and Ukraine. Even taking into account the loopholes, she kept her course pretty well. The appetites of export-import speculators were curbed by administrative measures. Critical imports were allowed through, and all sorts of "consulting services" were slowed down.

    Since the time of the KRO, Mr. Glazyev has been trumpeting for "domestic production". Commendable! But protectionism is indispensable here. If you do not accept the policy of "AntiVTO" - nothing will work! Well, "suddenly the patriots" will take funds "out of the box" and create production with a very high level of localization. In the conditions of the WTO, Kamaz and VAZ will lose to any Hyundai and KIA. And the Russian Samsung will remain technologically dependent Samsung. Money will be wasted - factories will be unprofitable.

    For currency control and the domestic market, political will is needed! .. Otherwise, we will continue to wait for the mythical "investor" for four decades. Since the time of Gaidar, the authorities have been scaring: "quieter, quieter" - "investors" will not like it ... Therefore, while the "princes of silence" are in power, it makes no sense to even offer something.
    1. NordUral
      NordUral April 25 2020 08: 56 New
      +3
      Therefore, while the "princes of silence" are in power, it makes no sense to even offer something.
      I agree.
  • Fedorov
    Fedorov April 25 2020 08: 08 New
    -11
    I read komenty and article and came to the conclusion that it is banal - there are no such Leaders as Stalin and Beria, and at least Andropov.
    The GDP seems to be normal, but the environment does not allow it to fully "unfold, but it is to some extent dependent on different forces for the full power of the same. That is why we have what we have.
    1. NordUral
      NordUral April 25 2020 08: 54 New
      +5
      I read komenty and article and came to the banal conclusion - there are no such Leaders as Stalin and Beria,

      I agree, but only to the point.
    2. Digital error
      Digital error April 25 2020 09: 22 New
      +2
      Quote: Fedorov
      there are no such Leaders as Stalin and Beria, and at least Andropov.

      and will not be as long as the supplier of management personnel is the "Kiriyenko school"
    3. tatra
      tatra April 25 2020 09: 42 New
      +8
      Again fairy tales about "good Tsar" Putin and "bad boyars". Just as the enemies of the communists after the capture of Russia have "to do with" everything they got, and "have nothing" to do with responsibility for the capture of Russia and for everything that they did to Russia and its people, so did Putin among his admirers "at what "to all the good things that happen during his reign, and" nothing to do "with everything bad.
    4. Leshy1975
      Leshy1975 April 25 2020 09: 45 New
      12
      Quote: Fedorov
      I read komenty and article and came to the conclusion that it is banal - there are no such Leaders as Stalin and Beria, and at least Andropov.
      The GDP seems to be normal, but the environment does not allow it to fully "unfold, but it is to some extent dependent on different forces for the full power of the same. That is why we have what we have.

      Do not be offended. But it’s real, it’s already enough to read this nonsense, that someone doesn’t allow GDP to do something. All give him and help and do. Only in the interests of a narrow group. But the population, and they wanted to spit on us, we are only the source of their income, following natural resources, nothing more. And the attitude towards us is the same - to pump more from us.
      How much can you already hover in the clouds, about the good king, who simply does not know. Not a kindergarten, in fact.
      1. Svarog
        Svarog April 25 2020 18: 27 New
        +1
        Quote: Leshy1975
        How much can you already hover in the clouds, about the good king, who simply does not know. Not a kindergarten, in fact.

        Well, why .. many are still naive, like children .. and someone for the money .. hi
    5. rocket757
      rocket757 April 25 2020 10: 24 New
      +3
      GDP is a product, part of the SYSTEM that rules the country. There is nothing further to discuss, we ourselves can look at the results.
      We put the scales and see what will outweigh?
  • Sergey Gavrilov
    Sergey Gavrilov April 25 2020 08: 13 New
    +8
    Liberals from the Central Bank are trying to silence Glazyev. But what about democracy, freedom of speech, tolerance, etc. How dare they sweep at the "core values" of Western liberalism?
    1. Malibu
      Malibu April 25 2020 08: 31 New
      -2
      Quote: Sergey Gavrilov
      How dare they sweep at the "core values" of Western liberalism?

      As if Glazyev was not imprisoned at all, for such impudence))))
      1. CT-55_11-9009
        CT-55_11-9009 April 26 2020 20: 50 New
        -1
        Quote: Malibu
        As if Glazyev was not imprisoned at all, for such impudence))))

        Landing is half the trouble. No matter how "removed" in the fall, his opponents are capable of this ...
  • nikolaj1703
    nikolaj1703 April 25 2020 08: 18 New
    +7
    Let's see what will happen to the petrodollar at the end of 2020. Now the real losses of the United States amount to 15 trillion - the volume of depreciation of securities, job cuts, bankruptcies and so on. At the same time, the US Federal Reserve does not give money to everyone, but only to "approximate" and the government. This will lead to the devaluation of the dollar. Oil has become a common commodity.
    1. Digital error
      Digital error April 25 2020 12: 52 New
      -1
      Quote: nikolaj1703
      15 trillion - the value of depreciation of securities

      Well, they'll print them again. And we will again place NWF funds in "high-quality foreign assets" for the sake of "future generations."
  • Golovan Jack
    Golovan Jack April 25 2020 08: 27 New
    -9
    Blood, sweat, sand and girl's tears.

    I translate: "disobedient Moscow City Duma", the unprofessionalism of security officials and security guards (and the army is the siloviki, or where? There is also "unprofessionalism?" at 15 dollars per barrel, Russia will have enough accumulated reserves for two years "(laughing like a horse. $ 15 per barrel will not be enough, Brent is now $ 21,58, and two years is lots of... not everyone will survive), "with a course of ruthless pumping of blood, that is, the last money, not only from the economy, but also from the pockets of citizens" (ff) - all in one bottle. Hell, I tell you, a mixture belay

    But this one especially delivered:

    which is simpler - introduce penalties for going to the toilet or the kitchen, place security cameras in the apartments, and no loans will be needed

    Also, the cow virus was dragged here. Fuck, do not get up.

    In short - deep and comprehensive analysis marvelous sketch for morning warm-up on the site. Clicks are provided.

    (aside): I wonder if I’ll collect a hundred minuses, or will I fail again? what
    1. Mordvin 3
      Mordvin 3 April 25 2020 08: 39 New
      11
      Quote: Golovan Jack
      Russia will have enough accumulated reserves for two years "(laughing like a horse. $ 15 per barrel will not be enough, Brent is now $ 21,58, and two years is a lot ... not everyone will survive),"

      Roman Batkovich Are you not drunk by accident?
      1. Golovan Jack
        Golovan Jack April 25 2020 08: 46 New
        -10
        Quote: Mordvin 3
        Roman Batkovich Are you not drunk by accident?

        I don’t drink, I don’t crawl out of health. What is wrong in your quote?
        1. Mordvin 3
          Mordvin 3 April 25 2020 08: 52 New
          +3
          Quote: Golovan Jack
          What is wrong in your quote?
          Reply

          All wrong . Wow, I'm drunk on the board
          1. Golovan Jack
            Golovan Jack April 25 2020 08: 55 New
            -6
            Quote: Mordvin 3
            All wrong

            (dreamily): specifics would winked

            Quote: Mordvin 3
            Wow, I'm drunk on the board

            And this is already in the morning ... although - I understand, probably. My condolences, Vladimir, believe me - sincerely sad
  • Malibu
    Malibu April 25 2020 08: 28 New
    -1
    We are actually talking about the rejection of foreign exchange transactions in the EAEU and the notorious dedollarization. Not forced, but voluntary

    M. Gadaffi, I remember something he wanted to do, but did not have time .... hi
    1. Mordvin 3
      Mordvin 3 April 25 2020 09: 22 New
      +2
      Quote: Malibu
      We are actually talking about the rejection of foreign exchange transactions in the EAEU and the notorious dedollarization. Not forced, but voluntary

      M. Gadaffi, I remember something he wanted to do, but did not have time .... hi

      Vital, Premier Taba
      1. Malibu
        Malibu April 25 2020 09: 43 New
        -6
        Quote: Mordvin 3
        Vital, Premier Taba

        Taki yes ... laughing drinksClearly have I disguised myself? wassat
    2. PSih2097
      PSih2097 April 25 2020 13: 51 New
      +3
      Quote: Malibu
      M. Gadaffi, I remember something he wanted to do, but did not have time ....

      Gaddafi wanted to introduce a gold dinar (or the gold standard) for interstate settlements, which the United States and Co. did not like.
      1. Malibu
        Malibu April 25 2020 14: 26 New
        +1
        Quote: PSih2097
        Quote: Malibu
        M. Gadaffi, I remember something he wanted to do, but did not have time ....

        Gaddafi wanted to introduce a gold dinar (or the gold standard) for interstate settlements, which the United States and Co. did not like.

        And Gadfi was soaked ... The same Sarkozy (France), who borrowed a hundred million for his election campaign .. The first one gave the order to bomb Libya, and then the United States joined with a smile .. Here is the tact !!! So much for "democracy" in all its glory .. Well, now they are bothered to act like this. Russians have entered the game again !!! soldier
  • Horst78
    Horst78 April 25 2020 08: 46 New
    -6
    In the meantime, from the Bank of Russia, as well as from its former branch - Sberbank, you only hear that you are reluctant to "take everything and share." It’s nice, sometimes, to take and blame the broad masses for turning into millions ball. And then make a modest proposal on the organization of a certain anti-crisis loan. Who to borrow from? Yes, people and small-medium-sized businesses, which have not yet drowned.

    That's when the revenues to the treasury grow - to the envy of the former chief tax official, and now the head of the cabinet! Although why bother with it at all, which is easier - introduce penalties for going to the toilet or the kitchen, place security cameras in the apartments, no loans will be needed. True, then everything will die out very quickly, and there will be no one to fine.
    Well, a worthy lexicon of Doctor of Economics Further and read I do not consider it necessary.
  • GRIGORIY76
    GRIGORIY76 April 25 2020 08: 47 New
    +7
    Quote: Malibu
    But Mishustin, a former tax specialist and info, owns who and how is taking out capital abroad and who has so much .. Waiting for a team!

    You need to shake him.
  • NordUral
    NordUral April 25 2020 08: 51 New
    +4
    If a people withdraws from the struggle for a fair social structure of the country and the state, then the corporation of thieves offers them to isolate themselves and be silent in a rag.
    Isolate not the cause, but the effect.
  • Sotskiy
    Sotskiy April 25 2020 09: 01 New
    +8
    The notorious crisis of overproduction, primarily in the oil sector, gives us a unique chance to finally get off the oil needle.

    And how is the hope of the raw material economy of the Russian Federation doing there - the millennium construction site, "Northern Stream 2"? Something not heard reports of breakthrough achievements. They write that there was only one pipelayer and that he moved somewhere to the south. Breshut, are we really diversifying into other sawing projects?
    1. Golovan Jack
      Golovan Jack April 25 2020 09: 08 New
      -8
      Quote: Sovetskiy
      ... the only pipe layer and that one went somewhere to the south. Breshet ...

      Verily. Breshet. Here it is, darling:



      1. Sotskiy
        Sotskiy April 25 2020 09: 16 New
        +4
        [quote = Golovan Jack] [quote = Sovetskiy] ... the only pipe layer and he went somewhere to the south. Breshet ... [/ quote]
        Verily. Breshet. Here it is, darling:



        Decipher the final destination of the darling: GB ABD?
        1. Golovan Jack
          Golovan Jack April 25 2020 09: 24 New
          -5
          Quote: Sovetskiy
          Decipher the final destination of the darling: GB ABD?

          1. Sotskiy
            Sotskiy April 25 2020 09: 30 New
            +5
            Yes, with the yugas on the net, they have gone wrong. lol In Aberdeen, he rushed for pipes, and whether so, he’ll stock up with products for the further transition? Do not know?
            1. New Year day
              New Year day April 25 2020 10: 56 New
              +7
              Quote: Sovetskiy
              Yes, with the yugas on the net

              don't lie!
              The pipelayer goes along the most intricate and longest route possible. On February 10, the ship left the port of Nakhodka and headed for Singapore. But, before reaching Singapore, Chersky changed course and went to the port of the capital of Sri Lanka Colombo.
              But did not arrive. "Chersky" changed his mind and changed course again and headed for the Egyptian port of Suez. However, then “Chersky” again “changed his mind” and went to the Mozambique Strait.
              Then "Chersky" headed for the Canary Islands, but passing them, appointed the port of arrival of the Egyptian Port Said.
              "According to the data portals MarineTraffic and Myshiptracking, which track the movement of ships, the vessel changed the intermediate port of destination from Egyptian Port Said in Scottish Aberdeen. " request
              1. Golovan Jack
                Golovan Jack April 25 2020 11: 04 New
                -9
                Quote: Silvestr
                don't lie!

                Lies, lies ...

                Quote: Sovetskiy
                They write that a single pipelayer and that one went somewhere to the south

                "Write" = "bullshit" in this case.

                Quote: Silvestr
                The pipelayer goes the most intricate and longest route possible

                Curved road closer (s). Agree that now it is much closer to the goal than, say, a month ago.

                And why he walks like this - neither you nor I know for certain. Only you all the time, ahem, pedal, but I do not. That’s the whole difference between us. Doctor yes
                1. New Year day
                  New Year day April 25 2020 11: 09 New
                  +5
                  Quote: Golovan Jack
                  That’s the whole difference between us.
                  the difference is that you hate your opponent, maybe remember your opus because of which you flew to the ban! "how I hate you!" - your words. And find similar from me.
                  1. Golovan Jack
                    Golovan Jack April 25 2020 11: 13 New
                    -10
                    Quote: Silvestr
                    can remember your opus because of which they flew to the ban! "how I hate you!" - your words

                    (dreamily): a reference would be ... I go here for a minute, there is no time to look ... I have porridge cooked there, on the Internet, at work request

                    Quote: Silvestr
                    you hate your opponent

                    As for you and the other Stasiks, you are all deeply indifferent to me. But, when you substitute - I will cling, sorry.

                    With "Chersky" you specifically set yourself up, now you are turning out. Have a good exercise yes
                    1. New Year day
                      New Year day April 25 2020 12: 13 New
                      +3
                      Quote: Golovan Jack
                      As for you and the other Stasiks, you are all deeply indifferent to me.

                      And how much you are indifferent to all! We sat for a month in a bathhouse in peace and silence. You have one srach. Go in peace
              2. Malyuta
                Malyuta April 25 2020 11: 14 New
                +4
                Quote: Silvestr
                The pipelayer goes along the most intricate and longest route possible.

                It's simple, the Argentinean "cement" ends, and the tasks need to be solved "large and complex", treat this with understanding. wassat
              3. Sotskiy
                Sotskiy April 25 2020 11: 33 New
                +2
                Quote: Silvestr
                The pipelayer goes along the most intricate and longest route possible.

                Thanks for the details. hi I read about this about the movement of "Chersky" to the south.
  • Alexander S.
    Alexander S. April 25 2020 09: 08 New
    +3
    Why is this article in the analytics section and not opinion? I didn’t see the analysts here.
    1. vargo
      vargo April 25 2020 11: 29 New
      -3
      I was looking for at least one mention of the style of the article. It is simply impossible to read, this is not a description of the situation, but a complete shock! Solid phrases causing emotions in the reader from scratch. The purpose of the article is not to provoke indignation with a logical narrative, but to make the reader hate something simply because of the narrative and the stinging manner of speech. I agree to all 100% here is not analytics, but purely personal emotional opinion of the author.
  • ximkim
    ximkim April 25 2020 09: 11 New
    +3
    Not entirely lost, but nevertheless. The trouble of replenishment is not solved .. Oil oil oil
    [/ quote] The notorious crisis of overproduction, primarily in the oil sector, gives us a unique chance to finally get off the oil needle.
    In Russia, there are seven large oil companies that generate income. You do not have to wait for a crisis in the oil sector for a unique chance. Companies prefer to keep their income offshore rather than investing or investing in projects (if they exist, of course) in the country in which they get and make a profit (if they remember this of course, it’s not a sin to reproach)
    [Quote]
    There is no doubt that the main thing that hooked bankers, headed by Elvira Sakhipzadovna, is the proposal to introduce a tax on currency exchange in the countries of the Eurasian Economic Union (EAEU), including Russia.
    request They can’t agree among themselves, but things are apparently doing poorly ..
  • Million
    Million April 25 2020 09: 27 New
    +5
    This Putin does not know, otherwise he would have asked them all! ...
  • awdrgy
    awdrgy April 25 2020 09: 47 New
    +2
    Who do they hope for ??? They are on their own, we are ourselves. Since the 90s it was clear to us. We have been driving it into our heads for more than 10 years Forgot? Someone grabbed a piece of pie in the XNUMXs and rejoiced like a child (now we’ll live)? Especially who’s small business (they’ve given the coronavirus tomorrow, or some other invented tops, they took away) So there is nothing to discuss here. "the news is neither cold nor hot. It is necessary to think for ourselves what to do, what would the family have?
  • Terenin
    Terenin April 25 2020 10: 06 New
    +2
    What does Glazyev have to do with it, what does oil have to do with it?
    then, "where does the Military Review?" request with these eye, chubais, nabiullins ...
    Although the whole
    A. Ivanov, Doctor of Economics, Professor ...
    about the main contingent of VO, expressed "deep scientific thought"
    Almost five million Russian security officials and security guards, of course, will always vote “for”, but this is only so long as their frank idleness and monstrous unprofessionalism are well paid
    contrasting us with some other electorate.
    And right there, some, singing along from behind the "hillock" shout: "Stop sitting. It's time to act ..." am .
    Well, so go and act, let's see how much imagination is enough to wave "arguments" in front of "idlers" in the square yes
    1. Nikolai Grek
      Nikolai Grek April 25 2020 17: 24 New
      +1
      Quote: Terenin
      then, "where does the Military Review?" with these Glazyevs, Chubais, Nabiullins ...

      local screamers make excuses, they say, the army is politics !!! wassat lol
      1. Mordvin 3
        Mordvin 3 April 25 2020 17: 25 New
        0
        Quote: Nikolai the Greek
        army is politics !!!

        And what is wrong?
        1. Nikolai Grek
          Nikolai Grek April 25 2020 17: 30 New
          +1
          Quote: mordvin xnumx
          Quote: Nikolai the Greek
          army is politics !!!

          And what is wrong?

          not so ... especially in the case of ... would be called a political review (not forgetting to mention that they are drowning for the "communists"), where military topics would be inserted among political articles, and there would be no questions !!! request wassat
          1. Mordvin 3
            Mordvin 3 April 25 2020 17: 36 New
            0
            Quote: Nikolai the Greek
            all the more so in the case of ... would be called a political review (

            I have never been political.
            1. Nikolai Grek
              Nikolai Grek April 25 2020 18: 41 New
              +3
              Quote: mordvin xnumx
              Quote: Nikolai the Greek
              all the more so in the case of ... would be called a political review (

              I have never been political.

              what I did not write about you in this case !!! wassat
              1. Mordvin 3
                Mordvin 3 April 25 2020 19: 36 New
                -2
                Quote: Nikolai Grek
                Quote: mordvin xnumx
                Quote: Nikolai the Greek
                all the more so in the case of ... would be called a political review (

                I have never been political.

                what I did not write about you in this case !!! wassat

                Thank you. I rode a Greek across the river, sees a Greek in the river crayfish ...
      2. Terenin
        Terenin April 25 2020 22: 33 New
        +4
        Quote: Nikolai Grek
        Quote: Terenin
        then, "where does the Military Review?" with these Glazyevs, Chubais, Nabiullins ...

        local screamers make excuses, they say, the army is politics !!! wassat lol

        How do they know winked that if the army is politics, then this is not the army
        1. Nikolai Grek
          Nikolai Grek April 25 2020 22: 39 New
          +5
          Quote: Terenin
          Quote: Nikolai Grek
          Quote: Terenin
          then, "where does the Military Review?" with these Glazyevs, Chubais, Nabiullins ...

          local screamers make excuses, they say, the army is politics !!! wassat lol

          How do they know winked that if the army is politics, then this is not the army

          Well they in any area eksperty !!! wink laughing wide-profile masters in narrow circles !!! wassat lol
  • Razvedka_Boem
    Razvedka_Boem April 25 2020 10: 27 New
    -5
    How many times, and on VO too, articles appeared with the message - "Everything is lost" ..
    In a couple of months, everything will be clear.
    1. New Year day
      New Year day April 25 2020 10: 49 New
      0
      Quote: Razvedka_Boem
      In a couple of months, everything will be clear.

      What do you mean?
    2. Gardamir
      Gardamir April 25 2020 12: 10 New
      +1
      In a couple of months, everything will be clear.
      And so every couple.
  • New Year day
    New Year day April 25 2020 10: 49 New
    +5
    And the Germans have already pedantically calculated that at 15 dollars per barrel of Russia, enough accumulated reserves for two years will suffice.

    this is in case this money IS! Who can rely on them that they haven’t been plundered like the money of a pension fund?
    And then, as a rule, the government supports its co-religionists, it doesn’t care about the deep people
  • wellaut
    wellaut April 25 2020 10: 49 New
    +2
    Only this was immediately remembered when I read the article - “The circle of these revolutionaries is narrow. They are terribly far from the people. But they woke Herzen, and Herzen began the revolution ”From the article“ In Memory of Herzen ”(1912) by V. I. Lenin (1870-1924) -
  • rotkiv04
    rotkiv04 April 25 2020 10: 58 New
    +4
    This is a voice into the void, it is unclear why they believe that the new head of government is an independent official, the guarantor directs everyone, and he is the same Eltsin only sober, which is even worse, because he makes all decisions in adequate condition
  • kolchinab
    kolchinab April 25 2020 11: 15 New
    0
    Some kind of stream of consciousness
  • cniza
    cniza April 25 2020 12: 51 New
    +4
    Who to borrow from? Yes, people and small-medium-sized businesses, which have not yet drowned.


    Where did you see him, but the people will be robbed ...
  • demo
    demo April 25 2020 13: 03 New
    +3
    The notorious crisis of overproduction, primarily in the oil sector, gives us a unique chance to finally get off the oil needle.

    If one comes to a meaningful approach to understanding the term "getting off the oil needle", then the following should be borne in mind.
    It is necessary to gradually replace "potent drugs" with less "potent" ones.
    This is in theory.
    In practice, everything looks much more complicated and worse.
    In nature, just those intermediates that could relieve asthenic syndrome may simply be absent.
    And further. Those who yesterday offered us potent drugs will also not be idle.
    This is an allegorical version.

    In fact, everything looks even darker.
    The restructuring of the economy from one type / type to another type / type is a very serious and extremely painful process.
    And to pass it is not given to everyone.
    It requires the will of the leader, a strong and united team, awareness of responsibility for the country and people, strategic goals and tactics, and a host of other, equally important attributes.
    Well, who in the Kremlin meets these criteria?
    Getting off the "oil needle" is a simple matter.
    Ceased to extract oil, and all.
    But what will eat all those who sat on Olympus, forever and ever?
    We will somehow feed ourselves.
    But they are used to the fact that we must feed them.
    This is the hassle.
  • Junior Private
    Junior Private April 25 2020 13: 31 New
    +2
    Quote: saigon
    I am a techie and so I’m used to clear and understandable rules.
    Looking at our economists and not ours, I also have a strong feeling - economics is not a science!

    In principle, economics can and should be considered only in conjunction with other sciences. In the modern world, the economy can be easily equated with all sorts of astrology and other palmistry. Well, as a techie techie, I understand your justified annoyance at the lack of any logic in the current market virtuality. It's like living every day with a new multiplication table. And this is what an entire army of so-called economists is doing, I still cannot understand. However, like psychologists, and managers, and others like them.
    Quote: saigon

    In geometry, there are theorems that need to be proved and axioms that are undeniable truth, in metal management everything is clear too, the laws of those mechanics are not subject to change depending on the political moment, but economics is not a field plowed for the flight of thought and various theories.

    No need to try to find common sense in stock-bond rates and the cost of polymers common sense. He is minimal there.
  • 16112014nk
    16112014nk April 25 2020 14: 01 New
    +2
    Bashkirka is afraid that Glazyev would not accidentally reveal her plans, for example, on monetary reform. Talk about this was back in 2019.
  • kriten
    kriten April 25 2020 14: 44 New
    +1
    Russia needs to be patient. The US residency cannot yet select a replacement for the Central Bank, with the same potential for wrecking our economy. And who is listening to Glazyev? He is not the agent of the owners ...
  • fif21
    fif21 April 25 2020 16: 09 New
    +1
    Mattresses want to reset their debt to China. belay And our "effective managers" are buying US debt. request They spread the "Guidens" on their heads. And another question. Why can the state of the Russian Federation have reserves in gold, but the citizens of the Russian Federation do not? Where is the gold ruble? People are not interested in virtual deposits in gold, there is no faith in bankers. Jewelry gold is a complete profanation. hi
    1. Golovan Jack
      Golovan Jack April 25 2020 16: 21 New
      -2
      Quote: fif21
      Why can the state of the Russian Federation have reserves in gold, but not the citizens of the Russian Federation?

      Why? Here you are:



      Quote: fif21
      Where is he the golden ruble?

      Absolute stupidity, this "golden ruble". This is, in short yes
      1. fif21
        fif21 April 25 2020 16: 40 New
        +2
        Quote: Golovan Jack
        Absolute stupidity, this "golden ruble". This is, in short

        And will I have this piece of yellow metal in the store? wassat Yes, the bank will "weld" on it two times, the first time when I will buy, and the second when fiat money is needed. What if
        in short, it is disadvantageous to the state of t. to black cash. ! And yet, it’s more profitable to fool people with pieces of paper painted by presidents and cities tongue As well as bitcoins, and other virtual heresy. hi
        1. Golovan Jack
          Golovan Jack April 25 2020 16: 45 New
          +2
          Quote: fif21
          And will I have this piece of yellow metal in the store?

          No. But you wanted gold - here is gold for you. Rises in price - get rich, cheaper - you're in flight. Game with request

          Quote: fif21
          Yes, the bank will "weld" on it twice, the first time when I will buy, and the second when fiat money is needed

          This is what you said correctly. What do you want? wink

          Quote: fif21
          and another virtual heresy

          Chet, you knead the broth densely, I don’t stick anymore, sorry. Okay, you asked - I answered, and we’ll finish, perhaps hi
          1. Nikolai Grek
            Nikolai Grek April 25 2020 17: 27 New
            +2
            Quote: Golovan Jack
            Chet, you knead the broth densely, I don’t stick anymore, sorry.

            he simply assumed that there would be essentially no answer !! and in the end, porridge is issued in response !!! wink in your case - broth !!! lol
          2. fif21
            fif21 April 25 2020 17: 31 New
            +1
            Quote: Golovan Jack
            Okay, you asked - I answered, and we’ll finish, perhaps

            Thanks for answering ! Good luck. hi
  • Dmitriyag
    Dmitriyag April 25 2020 16: 36 New
    +2
    These people are not stupid at all. Without coordination and miscalculations of all the options, they won’t open their mouths. Moreover, they depend on someone (positions, material well-being, business of relatives, etc.) This is a multi-way, trial balloon.
  • flicker
    flicker April 25 2020 16: 58 New
    -2
    The best in this article is:
    author: ... Doctor of Economics, Professor


    For everything else is about nothing.

    The main thing that has hooked bankers, headed by Elvira Sakhipzadovna, is the proposal to introduce a tax on currency exchange in the countries of the Eurasian Economic Union (EAEU), including Russia.

    We are actually talking about the rejection of foreign exchange transactions in the EAEU and the notorious dedollarization. Not compulsory, but voluntary, which is precisely what the tax stimulates.

    People do not seem to understand what Glazyev was talking about request
  • Hagen
    Hagen April 25 2020 17: 10 New
    0
    Almost five million Russian security officials and security guards, of course, will always vote in favor, but this is only as long as their frank idleness and monstrous unprofessionalism are well paid.

    First, the "siloviki and security guards", whom the authors accused of "monstrous unprofessionalism" on some borders of our Motherland, quite successfully defend it, that is, ours and the authors, including security. Therefore, one can, of course, make allowances for the emotionality of these "doctors" of some sciences, but one can also doubt their professional suitability. For unsubstantiatedly throwing mud at some power structures, the authors confused the sovereign with commercial structures, which have different goals and objectives, as well as the success of their decisions. Obviously in a creative fervor, they did not see these differences.
    Sergei Glazyev, academician, presidential adviser, who has repeatedly held high posts, and now the post of Minister for Integration in the EAEU, even thought to moderate his criticism of whoever you think - the Central Bank itself! And this is in the midst of a brutal pandemic and strict quarantine!

    And who is this Sergey Glazyev? How practical was he noted in the life of the country, so that all as one stand up to protect him from the Central Bank? Which collective farm did he raise from his knees? What province did he bring from recipients to donors? He didn’t even command a shoe shop. Professional theorist.
    And Glazyev’s criticism of the Central Bank is quite constructive, the authors agree with her 100

    I would also like to ask the authors, how did they in practice confirm their high titles of "Doctor of Economics", so that I, for example, could join him right off the bat? Our universities graduate economists in hundreds a year. Most of them work as waiters and sales managers in hypermarkets. Our economy did not shine under the USSR, and even more so under the Russian Federation. It is ruled by economists, obviously brought up by the authors of the article. Draw conclusions. I think a professor, if he is a real, "practitioner," should be published somewhere in scientific journals and have a "pretty" citation rating, and not in publications for retired veterans of ice battles. The level is not the same ... Yes, and with the justification of their arguments is rather weak. More precisely, not at all. IMHO
    1. Cyril G ...
      Cyril G ... April 25 2020 21: 23 New
      +2
      Glazyev may be Zero. But the fact that the Central Bank of the Russian Federation acts contrary to the interests of the Russian state is quite visible with the naked eye.
      1. Hagen
        Hagen April 25 2020 21: 37 New
        0
        Quote: Cyril G ...
        But the fact that the Central Bank of the Russian Federation acts contrary to the interests of the Russian state is quite visible with the naked eye.

        Remember the parable about the blind sages and the elephant? What part of the Central Bank do you know thoroughly, so much that you can evaluate its work? Would you like to familiarize yourself with the Dunning-Krueger effect? Useful reading for the night ...
    2. flicker
      flicker April 25 2020 21: 52 New
      0
      think professor if he is real ...

      This is you in the top ten laughing
      Russia is great and Ivanov cannot be counted in it ... and professors with such a surname, that's just not a single scientific work of the professor, Doctor of Economics Anatoly Ivanov did not find. request
      Neither the content of the article, nor the vocabulary of the text in any way draws on the fact that the author is its professor, Doctor of Economics
      It seems that "Professor D.E." - this is a technique aimed at giving the article "SCIENTIFIC POWER", "persuasiveness".
      By the way, Glazyev himself did not respond to the claims of the Central Bank (perhaps he realized that he was wrong) - but not a word about this in the article.

      It’s just that this topic has become the subject of speculation - larger figures are beginning to show dissatisfaction with the activities of the Central Bank (or rather, the fact that he pursues a grammatical credit and banking policy in a pandemic - they would like a default, but will not have it), it seems that they are starting to bake one place yes
      1. Cyril G ...
        Cyril G ... April 25 2020 22: 03 New
        +3
        Collapsed from scratch, exchange rates, followed by an increase in the price of food and medicine and a drop in living standards, of course, doesn’t count? This is how many times already collapsed at least remember? From the point of view of an ordinary citizen, I really don't like this business ...
  • Hagen
    Hagen April 25 2020 17: 14 New
    +2
    The article has been placed in the "analytics" section. And where is the analysis of the arguments of the parties to the dispute? Only emotions...
  • aglet
    aglet April 25 2020 19: 21 New
    +2
    Quote: depressant
    So, from April 1, 2020, instead of fines - warnings. That has greatly facilitated for almost 25 days the export of currency earned by illegal export of our resources, various kinds of frauds, facilitated the illegal withdrawal of capital

    but from April 1, increased fines for violations of self-isolation. it’s more important, and will surely fill the budget, and from then on, try to recover, show a bent arm, and continue the process. what they do all this time
  • Cyril G ...
    Cyril G ... April 25 2020 21: 20 New
    +2
    Right on target! And the central bank was already twitching. He cannot essentially answer.
  • Tank jacket
    Tank jacket April 25 2020 21: 32 New
    0
    Interested in the question, but does Elvira Sahipzade know how to sew gloves? Well, or is there a uniform for Rosgvadia? And Siluanov knows how to plan furniture? Well, or can Siluanov make a stool? ... Prepare yourself ...
    1. Tank jacket
      Tank jacket April 25 2020 21: 57 New
      -2
      All relatives of Nabiullina (incredibly successful businessmen) should have problems. My nephews should have drugs in their pockets. Father and mother have explosives ...
    2. Cyril G ...
      Cyril G ... April 26 2020 11: 07 New
      +2
      Do not know how to teach, do not want to force. (p.) Let them get ready. Zadolbali ruble roll regularly. They must answer in full for the 14th year and for the 20th and the 8th. Collapsed just like that. For they decided to earn a little pennies.
  • demo
    demo April 25 2020 22: 28 New
    +1
    What surprises me and, at the same time, does not surprise me is why the reasonably clever Glazyev passed by obvious phenomena visible to the naked eye.
    And he did not give them an appropriate rating.
    Corona virus - what is it?
    A disease, the treatment of which is associated with certain difficulties.
    And as a result, with the death of people.
    However. In the world there are many other diseases, the mortality rate from which is much higher than the current infection.
    This is by the way.
    Now to the point.
    In the existing world, nothing just happens.
    And conspiracy theory has nothing to do with it.
    There must always be in any case the one who becomes the beneficiary.
    Who today is unprofitable such a state of the global economy?
    Almost everyone.
    All countries, to varying degrees, experience enormous pressure on their institutions. Huge amounts of money are being spent. Countries do not receive, but only spend.

    Which industries suffer the most?
    Naturally - oil production, oil refining, sale of oil products.
    Next.
    All modes of transport suffer.
    Vehicle manufacturers are suffering.
    Metallurgy suffers.
    Petrochemicals are suffering.
    This is a listing of the "big sufferers."

    What happens in such cases with the valuation of these companies?
    The price of them begins to fall. Sometimes hard. Rarely, but can drop to zero.
    And there are examples - US shale.
    Who needs them today?
    To nobody!
    You are mistaken. They decided not to bankrupt, but to redeem.
    For US taxpayer money.
    If someone buys something, then he has such a reason.
    Tomorrow, these companies will either start working, or the value of these assets will skyrocket (again from the fact that they can start to make a profit).
    Small oil companies around the world are in a state of clinical death.
    And their shares fell 40-50-60%.
    Or maybe today someone is buying them, to the noise?
    It is not excluded.
    Even major players in this market did not remain a “safe haven."
    And it affected them.
    And large stakes may have been thrown onto the market.

    Come on.
    Refiners today sit and tear their hair in the place where they sit.
    Stopping a large refinery takes about 30 days. The launch is about the same.
    Loss on loss.
    Staff sent to the street.
    When to start the plant?
    Who knows.
    The shares of this and similar plants are also falling in price.
    The distribution network cannot provide itself with the necessary cost of living.
    And they have a desire to get rid of toxic assets.

    Automakers are shocked by overstocking.
    It is necessary to reduce the rate of release.
    Up to the stop of the assembly line.
    People on the streets.
    Stocks are falling in price.

    And so on.

    It remains to understand who is the one who can take advantage of this situation?
    These are those who are called "owners of money."
    It is clear that these people do not live in Russia, and not in Europe.
    These are US bankers.
    Only they can afford to bear tremendous expenses, with an eye to the future.
    But to bankers all these actions are completely useless.
    They are only interested in the “pure product” - money.
    But above the bankers or on a par with them there is also another, no less powerful layer of people, the so-called secret government.
    These are those who can and want to change the established "rules of the game."
    And their power allows much more to be done than the power of the US president allows.

    Could these people “organize” the corona virus?
    No problem!
    Could they start to “help” this infection spread around the world!
    No problem!
    Could they create in the world media a wave of hysteria, horror, fear?
    No problem!

    Все.
    The switch in their hands.
    When you need to turn on, when necessary, turn off.
    When the redistribution of property is completed, about a dozen major world experts will flock to the surface who will tell you how to and can fight this infection.

    Все.
    A curtain.

    Last thing.
    Russia's place in this world vaudeville.
    And nobody asked us or warned about anything.
    Only the inborn “modesty” of GDP did not allow him to stand up front and declare that all this is crap.
    And he decided to use the situation for his own benefit and harm.

    At the same time, the global crisis will force our authorities to unleash a moshna and begin to do at least something.
    Thus, Russia is struck like a very strong blow.
    But this is not for the sake of finishing us off. It's just that we are a cog in the global distribution and consumption system.
    And if the whole unit went into the runaway, then the gadget complained with no hands.


    This is what lies on the surface.
    Maybe Glazyev does not see this?
    I doubt it.
    I think he sees, but is afraid to say.
    The consequences for him may be too transiently lethal.
    1. rruvim
      rruvim April 26 2020 19: 15 New
      0
      Publishers of printed materials and booksellers also suffered from this "self-isolation". But there are no "vacations" for production according to OKVED 58.11. deferrals, etc. did not spread. The government is deliberately destroying this industry. And all government decrees practically do not affect the "scrotum" of the so-called NWF stash.
      1. Vacations on payments by the Federal Tax Service from some affected sectors are not a burden on the budget, because it is a simple delay;
      2. Zero interest on obtaining a loan from banks to enterprises for salary workers (6 months) is not a burden on the budget. For this is not for everyone, and most importantly: that it is actually a loan at 30% per annum, because from this, the so-called zero credit, you have to pay 30% of taxes (PIT + FMS + PFR), even taking into account the halving of the PFR.
      3. Increase unemployment benefits from 7000 to min. salary generally funny! Not more than 7-8 billion for the whole country.
      4. The reduction in the contributions of all organizations to the FIU and the FMS by half has some kind of budget burden, but no one can figure out which one. In any case, this is several tens of billions of rubles.
      5. Issuance to all children under the age of 3000 rubles. - This is generally funny. For a budget, a mere penny!
      Therefore, I do not understand what 1.5 trillion. rubles will the government spend on supporting small and medium-sized businesses?
      1. rruvim
        rruvim April 26 2020 19: 31 New
        0
        Let’s say a part of the bills will go to support state employees who are in quarantine. If doctors or teachers are offline, then this is understandable. Customs officers and tax officials are also understandable (bring revenue to the budget). We are not talking about the military - they are outside quarantine. And the rest? All sorts of structures: like Multifunctional centers, cadastral offices, Rosreestr, Gorona, small officials of city and village administrations, ending with officials in sports and culture. What they are, what they are not. And s / n must be paid by decree of the president. But the fact that they are, that they are not, in any case, the burden on the budget is the same. They do not produce anything, therefore they do not affect the level of GDP.
  • Lekz
    Lekz April 26 2020 00: 11 New
    -2
    What I think. There are two extreme options for the country's development. First, the rejection of dependence on the dollar (in fact, the United States), which will inevitably lead to the reconstruction of the USSR (represented by Russia +) in version 2.0. But I apologize, the capabilities of Russia (even with a +) are far from the power of the USSR. Both economic and military, with an understandable outcome that has nothing to do with the expected and desired satiety. Another, integration into the world economy in full at the position of the gas station. For anything else, the "world community" does not need us. We have already gone through this. For a short time, in part, but the meaning is clear. There are also a large number of supporters of both the first and second development options. Both in the establishment and among the population. Putin's policy, as I see it, is to maneuver between these two extremes. This is dictated by both internal and external reasons. Therefore, the advice and wishes may be different, the most obviously good, but there is a but, which I have already described.
  • Brigadier
    Brigadier April 26 2020 07: 39 New
    +2
    "...and how else to call the notorious investments in "highly liquid and absolutely reliable", read: foreign, specifically American assets."

    I always had the full feeling that "наш"Since the time of Borka, the Central Bank has been working under the tight leadership and control of the US Federal Reserve.
    This is equivalent to how, if, before 1941, the USSR would invest to the maximum in German securities, and even at an unprofitable rate. One to one!

    Interesting - who needs it upstairs?
    And most importantly - why?
    1. Cyril G ...
      Cyril G ... April 26 2020 08: 40 New
      +1
      Exactly .... And ours is clearly in quotation marks.
    2. Mite
      Mite April 26 2020 09: 48 New
      0
      Quote: Brigadier
      I have always had the full feeling that "our" Central Bank since the time of Borka has been working under the tight leadership and control of the US Federal Reserve.

      That's exactly what it was and now the same thing ... In general, the US Federal Reserve in most countries holds control of all state-owned banks. If someone resists, then the punishment is a collapse of the national currency and other sanctions
      1. Carnifexx
        Carnifexx April 26 2020 21: 04 New
        -1
        Whose wake are you, GCD or air defense? But seriously, it can be more specific how the Fed keeps state banks under control and how (well, who) collapses national currencies?
  • Sergey Afanasyev_2
    Sergey Afanasyev_2 April 26 2020 09: 36 New
    +2
    Here, too, I have a secret behind seven seals! And you did not pay attention to the fact that Putin is a protege of EBEn? And who was EBN do not remember? I suggest - Beale's best friend. And what happened to Russia from this friendship, also recall? The conclusion is simple - as long as Putin is in power, Russia will not move to sustainable growth. As vividly confirmed by the last 20 years, 0,5-1,5% are allowed to us. But not more! Otherwise, we’ll start living well, but the hegemon, who has been sitting on our neck for 30 years and who lives on due to the robbery of our economy, is not.
    1. Mite
      Mite April 26 2020 09: 44 New
      -5
      Quote: Sergey Afanasyev_2
      The conclusion is simple - while Putin is in power, Russia will not move to sustainable growth.

      I'm tired of already asking a question like you .... Who do you think should stand at the head of Russia? And whose second will you be ..?
  • Yuri Kozlov
    Yuri Kozlov April 26 2020 12: 05 New
    +2
    what are we talking about? Nabiulina, Gref, Siluans are the obvious enemies of Russia. And where is the FSB and the prosecutor's office and the Federation Council, the State Duma, the Council of National Brainlessness. No wonder they call the United States our partners. In the media, some slogans of one place do not discuss a single important issue, except for an independent Ukraine.