On the grave crisis in contemporary Russian war cinema

279

The 75th anniversary of the Great Victory of the Soviet people over fascism in the Great Patriotic War of 1941-1945 is coming soon. There is no doubt that on the eve of the holiday we are expecting the premieres of new films and series dedicated to historical date. But you don’t feel any joy from this, but you expect new disappointments and mass indignation of the audience.

It's a strange thing, you look at the Soviet “At war as at war”, “Only old people go into battle” or “Baltic sky” and you believe in what is happening on the screen. And not just believe, but live along with the characters on the screen. And after watching the modern "Fighters", "Tanks"," T-34 "or" Indestructible "the soul remains a dirty feeling, as if in it, this very soul, screenwriters, directors, cameramen and actors spat in the most mocking way ...



It is even more strange that viewing, for example, foreign and modern "Pearl Harbor", "Midway", "Pacific Ocean" or "Brothers in arms"Evokes the same feeling of truthfulness shown on the screen, although you know for sure that a lot of them are either greatly embellished, or even a direct lie ...

The sense of objectivity in such films is caused by the details: for example, in the Pacific Ocean, one of the American heroes after the battle is amused by the fact that ... he throws stones at the half-demolished head of a dead Japanese soldier, frozen at the moment of death behind a machine gun. And besides, he rips out golden teeth from dead Japanese soldiers.


And in Brothers in Arms, an American soldier wears a whole bunch of watches on his wrist, taken from killed Germans.

In "Fury" the crew of one American "Sherman" fights off entire hordes of SS men, not forgetting to have some fun with German women, who then die during the shelling. And the youngest and inexperienced tanker is forced to shoot the prisoner ... He does it.

And even after 75 years, but this movie portrays the enemy as the enemy, and his soldier as the hero.


In modern Russian military films, with the possible exception of a few (“28 Panfilovites” or “Brest Fortress”), there is no truth about that great war. They actually do not answer the question that torments us more and more after years: WHY AND HOW WE STAND, WHY WIN?

Modern Russian military films interpret the great past as follows: yes, they won, but they did it almost by accident, and ... contrary to all commanders and commanders, starting from the company commander and ending with the Supreme Commander-in-Chief Stalin.

Such a surreal, treacherous, fictional idea has been created and continues to be planted, destroying the connection between generations and the foundations of modern society.


It will not be about the details over which the audience, who at least have some understanding of military affairs, are already tired of laughing: inconsistencies in the form of clothing and insignia, military equipment to the historical truth, explosions from 82 mm caliber mines, from which it dies with each break almost a company, girls snipers painted around the clock, and other "mistakes", of which there are so many ...

It will be about the concept that has been driven into the heads of Russian citizens for many years with the help of these “movie-making” created with funds from the Russian budget. And that means our money: after all, in the credits in the overwhelming majority of films about the Great Patriotic War it is indicated everywhere that this or that cinema opus was created with the support of, for example, the Russian Ministry of Culture, the “Cinema Fund”, etc.

What does the viewer see in such films? Politruk, an idiot, a sadist counterintelligence agent and necessarily a character who has served a certain number of years, of course, “for no reason”, in the camps. Well, another stupid colonel or general, manically sending subordinates to slaughter.



Anyone who personally communicated with the front-line soldiers, and perhaps even managed to fight in subsequent wars, knows very well that in fact such chances for political commanders or Smershovites to survive or at least remain on the front lines would not exist ...

Accidental shrapnel or a bullet that arrived “from nowhere” would have ended such a “career” very soon ... And, as the front-line soldiers themselves said, higher commanders simply removed these “commanders” from sin immediately when an unhealthy situation arose in the front-line units.

War always carries out its own natural selection.


And yet: during the years of World War II, about 35 million people passed through the active Red Army. If you compare this number with the number of even all prisoners in the same period, it is obvious that if the former ZK got into operation, then there was a completely insignificant number of them.


Or, perhaps, the officials of the Ministry of Culture, as well as the producers, together with the directors and scriptwriters, were all sitting on their own? And now their memories of this unforgettable period of their lives are transferred to the screen? But this is unlikely ...

Does all this say that political idiots, mortalists, sadists and convicts were not at the forefront?


Of course no. They had a place to be. But this was not a mass phenomenon. More precisely, it was a single occurrence, otherwise it simply would not have been a victory, because it is impossible to win such a war with stupid generals and colonels, lieutenants and captains, political officers, goats and counterintelligence-paskuda. Well, there were no such precedents in the history of military art ...

Much more, by orders of magnitude, there were cases when political officers or military counterintelligence, when the commander died, took command. But about this in modern Russian military films there is not a word, not a word ...

As there are no films about real heroes, and not about characters composed in fever delirium who allegedly fought.

For example, Sergeant Sirotinin or Private Perederius, who were left alone with their guns to cover the retreating comrades, one in Belarus and the second in Krasnodar ... Or the pilot Mamkin, who took the P-5 enemy 13 out of the enemy’s fire, burnt out of the fire (! ) children from the enemy rear who landed the plane on the airfield and died of burns in a week ...

On the grave crisis in contemporary Russian war cinema

There are thousands and thousands of such examples of mass heroism, but there are no films about them ...

So who installed this “filter” for modern “film works” about the Great Patriotic War? And who allocates money for this vile lie? Addresses, surnames, appearances? And why repeat it from film to film?

Separately about the enemies. The very Nazis who killed, raped, killed and sent to death in a concentration camp about 15 million civilians of the Soviet Union.


In today's Russian war cinema, they almost always appear ironed, glazed, elegant characters, fighting the Soviet "cattle" aristocratic and even intelligent ...


The enemy is the enemy. Hollywood gives the right to a foreign audience to consider fascists as enemies, and domestic apprentices from the cinema do not give such a right to the descendants of the winners !!!

They sincerely wanted these individuals with a swastika to free the unfortunate Russians from the Bolshevik concentration camp, but the saduk political officers, NKVD detachment detachments, and personally the maniac Stalin filled up the unfortunate Europeans with corpses and did not allow “to bring the light of freedom to Soviet soil”.

Even beautiful actors, playing in these lying movie opuses, know very well that they are participating in grandiose cinema. And therefore, we see not the human characters of the heroes, but miserable walking stereotypes, stamped with a carbon copy and having nothing to do with the historical truth about the war. Well, you can’t make a real talent play sincerely even for the biggest money!

Konstantin Stanislavsky in such cases angrily exclaimed “I do not believe!” Having watched at least one (one!) Contemporary Russian war film, he probably would not have found censored expressions ...

Good gentlemen, filmmakers of all stripes and officials involved in these acts! Why are you faking the truth about the war? Why, after 75 years, are you repeating fabrications again and again? Who or what makes you do it?
Our news channels

Subscribe and stay up to date with the latest news and the most important events of the day.

279 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. +83
    April 14 2020
    - Do not watch modern war films!
    “But there are no others?”
    - Here are no and do not look.
    Look Soviet. You don’t know about the current ones, either laughing, crying, or launching something on the TV.
    1. +30
      April 14 2020
      The 75th anniversary of the Great Victory of the Soviet people over fascism in the Great Patriotic War of 1941-1945 is coming soon. There is no doubt that on the eve of the holiday we are expecting the premieres of new films and series dedicated to the historical date.
      We can be sure that we will again turn on American Hollywood stuff. I bet you will. It’s so tolerant, first to show the Victory Parade, and then the "ordinary Ryan". this is the whole current system.
      1. +11
        April 14 2020
        Is not a fact. I noticed that in recent years, just before the Victory Day, our Golimut has started spitting "miscarriages" on the topic of war. Cheap films are miniseries that you can't even remember the names of. Only that the plot and the acting - kaka!
        Here "Rzhev" came out. I read the story. The first half - everything according to the book, and then ... They muddied, smoothed and ruined.
        According to the book of the special police officer, they just shot them in the back, and the battalion commander in the last attack drove the remains of the company drunk ...
        But the director decided not to "dirty" the script with the truth and the special officer was killed by the Germans, and the battalion commander explained for a long time to the company commander that a big offensive at the front depends on his attack ...
        1. +6
          April 14 2020
          I think these pseudo films about the Second World War need to be treated with indifference, and not get on your nerves. Recently in Kaluga during a distance lesson on the basics of Orthodox culture on one of the platforms, fifth-graders were shown a pornographic video. So, here are modern films about the war are the same pornographic videos that can be watched with beer and popcorn. Society has degraded, so such films correspond to its needs.
          1. I do not want to agree with you, dear Bashkirkhan! ,, Indifferent, to the villains is not necessary. Neatly, putting in place, as the author of the article did, is another matter. Otherwise, ordinary nonhumans will think that PEOPLE are over. And it will be more convenient to settle on the neck of the obedient, homo sapiens,. With ,, pivas and popcorn ,, in your hands.
            ,, Society has degraded ,,? It has been gradually degrading for thousands of years. But everyone should do his own thing. Servants of Darkness - dirty tricks, people serving Goodness should strive to relieve dirty tricks
        2. +38
          April 14 2020
          Chief of the Redskins (Nazarius)
          According to the book of the special police officer, they just shot them in the back, and the battalion commander in the last attack drove the remains of the company drunk ...
          So maybe the book is that shit? I'm not saying that there was no such case at all, but this is exactly a SINGLE case. And it is precisely this single case that is introduced as something that is self-evident, as commonplace. And then modern youth, brainwashed by the Unified State Exam, and not only young people, foaming at the mouth, begins to prove that this is exactly what happened. Once I almost fell out, when a friend of mine (not a stupid woman in life), after watching the film "Bastards", said with the aplomb of a connoisseur that they were like sadists in the USSR, poor street children were forced to die. And this is an adult lady who studied in a Soviet school, but what can we say about young people?
          In general, about this one:
          Good gentlemen, filmmakers of all stripes and officials involved in these acts! Why are you faking the truth about the war? Why, after 75 years, are you repeating fabrications again and again? Who or what makes you do it?
          I want to say that both filmmakers and officials fulfill a very specific task of the country's leadership in denigrating our glorious Soviet past. This is the focused policy of our modern state! Our state is afraid that the people will finally remember what successes they achieved under the Soviet system and what these successes turned into under the modern management system. So they pour tons of dirt, because they understand that they are less than microbes compared to Stalin. That's why they shamefully drape the Mausoleum, at the foot of which the flags of the defeated Reich were thrown. That's why they hang tablets on the killers in the city, which suffered from these killers. Therefore, monuments to the Nazis in Rossosh put.
          But at the same time, we are intensely distracted, and look what they are doing with the monuments in Ukraine and what they are doing in Europe with them. Yes, you look at yourself that you are in your own country with your own story create tricks.

          P.S. We are preparing for the 75th anniversary, watching old Soviet cinema, and we are not ill for all enemies of evil!
          1. +8
            April 14 2020
            Quote: Varyag_0711
            I think these pseudo films about WWII need to be treated indifferently

            No, comrade! It is necessary to conduct counterpropaganda against this anti-popular art, to identify the true customers of each such "cultural product". Those. you need to have an alternative ideology and apparatus, including critics.
            Fear the indifferent: crimes are committed with their tacit consent.
            "In impoverished and illiterate Russia, cinema is the most important of the arts!" Because it systematically destroys the spiritual connection between generations.
            1. +5
              April 14 2020
              Sorry, but I have this
              Quote: Varyag_0711
              I think these pseudo films about WWII need to be treated indifferently
              did not write. This was written by the commentator above under the nickname Bashkirkhan. I’m just for trampling all this anti-Soviet rot and propaganda in the bud. So your comment is not at the address.
              1. +1
                April 14 2020
                Please accept my deepest apologies for the inattention. In my defense, I can note that there is a quote from the "primary source".
              2. +8
                April 14 2020
                to condemn bastard directors and scriptwriters, and beat them affordably - this is their only weak point
            2. 0
              April 14 2020
              Quote: iouris
              Those. you need to have an alternative ideology and apparatus, including critics.

              Representatives of alternative ideology will soon leave for another world, and the new generation, brought up on the films "Bastards" and "Penal Battalion" and who does not read books, are no longer interested in all this. For them, the Second World War is about the same as the Battle of Kulikovo. I read something like "Shadows in Paradise" by Erich Maria Remarque. Actions take place at the end of the war. The main character, Robert, is forced to flee Nazi Germany and emigrate to the United States. Robert explains to the film crew in Hollywood the mentality of the Germans. What do those who kill in concentration camps look like? Not animals, with a face twisted with rage, as the directors thought. And honestly, scrupulously, with all responsibility, not forgetting to diligently fill out reports, they carry out the tasks of their superiors, not feeling guilty, but on the contrary, proud of a job well done. Just as before, they tried and took pride in working as accountants. "I explained to him that the largest industrial concerns in the country entered into agreements with concentration camps for the supply of cheap labor, that is, simply slaves who worked until they were unable to work, and then their ashes flew out of the crematorium chimney with smoke." To which the director told Robert that the audience would not believe him and the film would not be a commercial success. Since Hollywood makes superficial films and the director just wants to make money.
          2. +16
            April 14 2020
            So maybe the book is shit? I am not saying that such a case did not exist at all, but this is the ONLY case.

            It’s more difficult with the book, the author is a front-line soldier who fought under Rzhev, a WWII disabled person. And, judging by the award sheet, he fought well.
            https://pamyat-naroda.ru/heroes/podvig-chelovek_nagrazhdenie10516377/

            I think they’re giving me a nudge now, and to hell with him, I can’t keep silent.
            I think that it’s better not to touch the book and the author.
            This is his personal look. Single case? It is possible, I even agree with you, only the author came across this isolated case, it turns out, since he has this left. Couldn’t it be like that?
            It is not right now for a front-line soldier, who has long been dead, to indicate that he wrote something about the front, he cannot answer. Not what he expected from the descendants, when near a village near Rzhev, a sergeant raised a company under a hurricane of fire under machine guns and mortars instead of the deceased commander, shouting "Let's destroy the fascist reptile - forward to the enemy!" He could be wrong, or over the years perceive everything differently, in black colors, and we may disagree three times with him, and we will be right, and we are not obliged to agree with him, but he deserved his right to make a mistake and his delusions there, near the village of Ovsyannikovo, April 7, 1942, under fire on the battlefield.

            But there is another side to the issue.
            After all, no one forced him to make films according to his book. This is a completely different matter
            There are a lot of memoirs and art books of authors - war veterans, I think it’s the authors of the film and I need to ask why they decided to shoot an isolated case, what determined the choice of this book?
            But the authors of the film already have a lot of questions on this part ....
            Well, let's minus now .....
            hi
            1. +4
              April 14 2020
              Well, why immediately minus? Plus to you from me! hi In fact, you are right and I do not argue with you. In war, as in war, everything happened. Only now it really raises the question, why was this particular product chosen? Why are negative moments chosen? Why do we consciously pour on the head the ears of that trench truth (here without irony) that accompanies any war?
              The feat itself is blurred, and deliberately blurred, with this very trench truth. You see, here's the thing. If you show the same crap and trench truth, then you won't bring up any heroes on this truth, but you will bring up a generation a la "and I need such happiness, I won't go to fight, let others go."
              My grandfather went through more than one war, but I never heard anything negative from him. NEVER he talked about the war, as about something terrible, but in fact he had this and was abundant. He even spoke about the terrible start of the war and the retreat from Belarus. And every year he was invited to our school to tell us about the war before May 9th. He probably perfectly understood and realized that we did not need all that terrible truth about the war.
            2. +5
              April 14 2020
              Why minus? Everything was in that war. Only now the current activities from cinema and not only are looking for only the bad. And "our" power pays for it.
          3. 0
            April 16 2020
            I will subscribe for every word!
          4. -5
            April 17 2020
            With the drapery of the Mausoleum, people like you, as usual, go too far ... Our grandfathers threw the enemy banners at the foot of the Mausoleum, not to please Blank-Ulyanov-Lenin, but at the feet of the Supreme Commander-in-Chief. Stalin I.V. So, at least my grandfather told me ... The parade was held with a filled podium of the Mausoleum and it was repeatedly explained to neocommics that the passage of troops, with the release of a military salute with the current leadership of the country standing on the podium on such significant days looks ridiculous and inappropriate ... Moreover, Ilyich had nothing to do with that war, so that the best units near his crypt would switch to a marching step. But until now, the pseudo-red does not reach, they only do what they ask - Why are they draping ?. Why don't you ... not whine about the drapery, but demand the inscription of the Mausoleum - "Lenin. Stalin" to start returning, then at least some sense of the draped whining appears ...
        3. 0
          April 15 2020
          You know, this was not only written in books, but it really was. My grandfather went through the whole war as a part of 359 OPR, 2722 SD of the Karelian Front. In August 1942, his group withdrew from the rear of the Finnish front-line scouts, who later became Heroes of the Soviet Union, both posthumously. So when crossing the front line, or rather, when crossing the Svir River, one of the girls was shot by our machine gun crew, and there was a drunken political instructor behind the machine gun. Grandfather shot the political instructor, they didn’t give him a tower, they gave him 3 months of a free company, and the whole group.
        4. 0
          April 15 2020
          If the last year is 10 years, then yes.
          "Serving the Soviet Union" - in 2012. "
          "Documentary investigation" of Suvorov-Rezun exactly on June 22, 2011 (or 2012)
      2. +15
        April 14 2020
        Quote: Dead Day
        there is no doubt that we will again include American hollywood

        I can't watch American films about the Second World War. As Stanislavsky said, "I don't believe"
        But domestic modern ones do not really shine. You can count good films on the fingers of one hand ..
        For me, a good film is when you watch several times and after a while, still ready to watch ..
        1. +2
          April 14 2020
          Are there American films about the Great Patriotic War ?? Thought only about the second world .. Sealed up?
          Check out the good old McHaley Fleet. They knew how to play before ..
          1. Alf
            +5
            April 14 2020
            Quote: Tavrik
            Are there American films about the Great Patriotic War ??

            There is. A wonderful series called the Unknown War. That's just a hassle in the fact that he is the 1975 edition.
          2. -4
            April 15 2020
            "The enemy is at the gate."
          3. -2
            April 18 2020
            "The Enemy at the Gates", about the sniper Vasily Zaitsev, is a decent film without pathos!
      3. 0
        April 14 2020
        You're right. It is impossible to have a good cinema when half the people under 30 do not know the history of their native country.
        When millions go on
        "The best film" in cinemas. This is a degeneration of art.
        The last more or less worthy film that I saw
        "9 Rota". Not without bloopers, but decently filmed.
        Then the abyss ...
        1. +12
          April 14 2020
          Here is a really complete shit Bondarchukovskaya. Better "Storm Gate". Bondarchuk's roof was blown off altogether. "Stalingrad" - that's uyo ... e. And "Sniper", "Penalties" ... filmed in a drunken stupor? Boys like Kolya from Urengoy are taken as consultants.
          1. +3
            April 14 2020
            It's simple, in Soviet times there was a hudsovet, which everyone scolded, but this hudsovet did not miss the obvious bullshit, filtered. And now there is some kind of filter, no, that’s what they’re driving false and mediocre films.
      4. +2
        April 14 2020
        They do not wait for May 9th. Now, for whom self-isolation, for whom quarantine. What do TV-ki "twist" the people, with scanty exceptions (mainly the "Zvezda" channel), again for the "staff" they save the WORLD on super starships and THEIR supertechnology "Unattainable" by some RF, but severe, but " skillful "REMBO (played by Stalone, who has deviated from service to his homeland) mows down the" bad "Russians (Soviet) in Afghanistan, saving the ancient" civilization "! Slaves of the United States to reshoot the sequel, like Rembo, having lost his old age (performed by the same stalone), now helping the same Afghans, is fighting American rangers in Afghanistan. On sclerosis mistaking THEM for Soviet soldiers. I am sure there will be success.
        Already their mothballs nonsense, not everyone in the United States is watching. And we have TV-ki for our bored children (grandchildren) about us and about Russia hanging nasty things on their ears. What to be surprised if you say to young animals and NOT only, instead of Russia, for example Rashka. Here is "khuta tkhent aghesively sown by menachers .." How many good Soviet films, popular science films, incl. according to the school curriculum was not only literature, physics, etc. hi
      5. -4
        April 15 2020
        That you t-34 and the Indestructible attacked. It is possible to see once. The same Midway shot somehow against the backdrop of the film Torah. Torah. Torah. And 28 Panfilov’s men are generally a normal film. I remember back in the 70s I watched a movie so even modern tanks calmly appeared there
    2. +10
      April 14 2020
      I do not like this character - Professor Preobrazhensky. But with such an interpretation of his words I agree to 100.
    3. +18
      April 14 2020
      I am joining. Watch old Soviet films in which the truth about the war is really the truth, and not the fiction of the director or screenwriter.
      Example: in one of the series about partisans, the radio operator falls in love with a captured fascist and goes to the city to meet with this fascist when he escapes from the detachment. Brad, which is even impossible to imagine drunk. And such in modern films, darkness, darkness, and again darkness.
      What is the reason? In the filthy unloved by the liberalists Union, scoop films were created by artists for whom art was art and not earning money. Now the opposite is true: there is no art without dough. Everything that is done, which is put on by modern directors, is written by modern scriptwriters - this is handicraft, the purpose of which is to earn dough, to chop the dough. Under these conditions, there’s no need to talk about any art. And the truth of life, so do not care about it at all. The main thing is that the loot fell, even better in green candy wrappers when selling fakes for art to the west. Who will buy and watch in the West if there are no bloody commissars tearing up the stomachs of pregnant women, there are no sadists of NKV despots, KGB officers mocking soldiers, prisoners, residents, there are no ghouls of commanders sending soldiers to machine-gun mowing, there are no drunk red, Russian soldiers, without exception raping all the unhappy German women ... So we have what we have.
      The main question: how to fix our art ?! There is only one answer: art cannot be unprofitable. Unprincipled art gives rise to chimeras, which devour its creators, it would be good only for creators, but also the people, our people, to whom such art is fed.

      "People-State-Fatherland" - this is the slogan of every Russian patriot. A strong state, a united people, a prosperous Fatherland, which cannot be broken by internal and external enemies.
      1. +12
        April 14 2020
        Quote: The Truth
        So we have what we have.

        And what do you want to have when the Mausoleum, from the rostrum of which the Victory Parade was received, is shuttered, and the Supreme Commander-in-Chief and the Minister of Defense accept the parade while sitting in armchairs? What is pop, such is parish.
    4. +4
      April 14 2020
      Quote: DMB 75
      - Do not watch modern war films!
      “But there are no others?”
      - Here are no and do not look.

      - Do not watch our television
      - And which watch?
      - Do not look
      I watch sports and some entertainment programs myself.
      Everything else is in Tynet
      Well, some more series
      Of the latter, I like "Cipher" very much I look forward to continuing
    5. +5
      April 14 2020
      Quote: DMB 75
      - Do not watch modern war films!
      “But there are no others?”
      - Here are no and do not look.
      Look Soviet. You don’t know about the current ones, either laughing, crying, or launching something on the TV.

      You can’t say better - I watched a movie the other day ... and everything seems to be nothing but! .. when I saw that the letters in the envelopes were brought to the front - I switched, I don’t even say how and what awards are hung on the characters in these remakes - horror.
      1. +2
        April 14 2020
        So this is from the effective movie managers from the movie. The economy must be economical. No need to invite knowledgeable professionals who would hang out all the medals as expected and reject the unnecessary shape, etc. After all, sometimes you watch a movie, life in the trenches, and the shape with a needle, clean, new helmets, the paint glistens without a scratch.
        1. +5
          April 14 2020
          And vodka and women - and completely makeup. Form - they are too lazy to open old photos, I generally keep quiet about the awards - who is in what is much. About the artists in general I am silent - they seem to be recruited from advertisements in brothels - whose legs are longer. A series about combat swimmers ???? !!!!!!!!!!!!! Mura, Schura, Cat, Bagheera .... Ussa ... it is easier. Cellular communication a hundred wounded. The captain points to the counter-admiral. They fly wherever I want, when I want and on what I want ... An utter madhouse. This seems to be to support the pants for unclaimed artists. Recently I saw a "piece" about some kind of control unit "Bullfinch" - three times went to the toilet with laughter. I've seen enough of such insanity. Even "Stalingrad" is resting.
          1. +2
            April 14 2020
            Quote: begemot20091
            ! Mura, Schura, Cat, Bagheera .... Ussa ... it is easier. According to one hundred cell phone wounds. The captain indicates to the rear admiral. They fly where I want, when I want and on what I want ... The madhouse is utter.

            But the funny thing is that most of the series they fight on land, they’re not close to water laughing
            They even drifted somewhere into the desert laughing
          2. +9
            April 14 2020
            Recently I had the misfortune to watch the film "Tanks" about the legendary run of two T-34s from Kharkov to Moscow. In this "masterpiece" of modern war cinema, the only truth is that this run took place in history. And so everything is there, stopping tanks by the NKVD horse patrol, shelling a column by the Red Army of 45s, cutting armor with autogenes on the move, betrayal of a crew member and an offer to Koshkin to surrender to the Germans, a woman crew member who passed the entire march in a snow-white blouse without a single spot ( it's in a tank), the action takes place in the summer, not a word about Koshkin's illness. For such films, directors and screenwriters should be imprisoned and imprisoned for a long time, as for ideological sabotage (and I have no doubt that these figures are deliberately distorting history). I would also like to see bureaucrats from the Ministry of Culture who signed a rental certificate in places not so distant to them.
            1. 0
              April 14 2020
              Quote: AK1972
              female crew member

              Too shy to ask feel
              In what quality? feel
              1. +2
                April 14 2020
                I didn’t understand this from the film, I didn’t watch it completely with gagging, switched to another channel, but still forced myself to watch until the end. However, I had read before that the woman really was a EMNIP mechanic (not a driver mechanic).
                1. +3
                  April 14 2020
                  Quote: AK1972
                  However, I had read before that the woman really was a EMNIP mechanic (not a driver mechanic).

                  Grandfather said that they had a woman in the carriage. The shooter is a radio operator.
                  On the Kursk Bulge, together with the entire crew, she fought with the Germans on daggers.
                  Our tank commander died
                  German crew cut out the whole
                  1. +1
                    April 14 2020
                    Having no name of conscience. You did not make me worse with your "minus," you insulted the memory of my grandfather, a front-line soldier.
                    Shame on your smelly head !!!!!! -
                    1. +2
                      April 14 2020
                      Dear Sergey! If anything, minus is not mine. Compensate with a plus.
                      1. +2
                        April 14 2020
                        Quote: AK1972
                        Dear Sergey! If anything, minus is not mine. Compensate with a plus.

                        I know it hi
                        I even know who did it. I forgot his nickname.
                        But I know for sure that he does not leave comments where I comment
                        But minus everything is mine.
                        I wrote so
                        "Not having a name and conscience "
                        Well, for the end of self-isolation drinks
                      2. +3
                        April 14 2020
                        Quote: Lipchanin
                        Well, for the end of self-isolation

                        Go!!! Although she did not touch me, thank God, we work even on Saturdays. The entire staff of the enterprise special permits.
                        And as for the minusers, so I also have 2 such fans, even they make absolutely neutral comments minus without explaining the reasons, they don’t catch up with what I do not care about their horizontal sticks and virtual shoulder straps, especially since the captains are quite fine with me, t .to. match my rank as stock captain.
                      3. +4
                        April 14 2020
                        Quote: AK1972
                        And as for the minusers, so I also have 2 such fans, they even sculpt on a completely neutral comment for minus without explanation

                        I have more laughing
                        Although she did not touch me

                        Yes, and I'm not bored lol
                      4. +2
                        April 14 2020
                        So they’re not reporting me at all !!! drinks
                      5. 0
                        April 14 2020
                        Quote: AK1972
                        So they’re not reporting me at all !!!

                        And to someone they shift laughing
            2. Alf
              +3
              April 14 2020
              Quote: AK1972
              And so there is everything, a tank stop by the NKVD equestrian corps, a shelling of a 45-ok Red Army column, autogenous cutting of armor on the move, a crew member’s betrayal and Koshkin’s offer to surrender to the Germans, a female crew member,

              + the emergence of German sabotage in the center of the USSR ...
            3. 0
              April 15 2020
              Quote: AK1972
              had the misfortune to watch the movie "Tanks"

              This is trash and comedy. The genre is
        2. Alf
          +5
          April 14 2020
          Quote: Ros 56
          After all, sometimes you watch a movie, life in the trenches, and the shape with a needle, clean, new helmets, the paint glistens without a scratch.

          And the smell of cologne and perfume almost from the screen rushing.
    6. +1
      April 14 2020
      And the TV, moreover, do not offend him. fellow
      1. 0
        April 14 2020
        Quote: Ros 56
        And the TV, moreover, do not offend him.

        He is angry with us laughing
    7. +4
      April 14 2020
      And why be surprised if the Soviet Union, Stalin criticized at the top?
      There are no shrines, no ideology. There are no directors. There are no OUTSTANDING actors. As in the West, there are "stars" of serials. And not REALLY honored, folk.
      In film schools, they also pay not for studies, but for sessions.
      The result is on the screens.
      1. +2
        April 14 2020
        Quote: knn54
        And why be surprised if the Soviet Union, Stalin criticized at the top?

        Not only Stalin, but Lenin, Putin kicked.
    8. 0
      April 14 2020
      Quote: DMB 75
      Look Soviet. You don’t know about the current ones, either laughing, crying, or launching something on the TV.

      This, of course, is correct.
      But that is not what we are looking at.

      The main question is what young people are watching ...
      And then a state decision is needed.
      Really - censorship is needed. For the topic raised from the same series as drugs, child molestation, the spread of extremist infection ....
    9. +1
      April 14 2020
      the main problem of modern Russian war cinema is the lack of competent consultants and, oddly enough, the lack of censorship. Each shot of the Soviet film was hosted by several organizations. Censorship was on top.
      I will list all the organizations that participated in the acceptance of the film. This is the scenario art council, the art association of the cinema association, in which the film was directly shot, then the studio's general art council, then the film was accepted at the Goskino, then it was accepted in the ideological department of the Central Committee of the party. In the case of republican films was still the Central Committee of the party of a particular republic. As a rule, all flaws and shortcomings were removed at the level of discussion of the picture at the studio artistic council.
    10. 0
      April 16 2020
      If the Mausoleum is draped during the parade, doesn’t the author know who orders these films. The USSR will not be bad; you won’t get good money.
  2. +10
    April 14 2020
    And our film production system is built in this way, or you’ll take off what you’ll give or eat in six months. Plus, the lack of any kind of intelligible propaganda for what and with what aspirations fought. My clumsy propaganda of the Second World War has infuriated me like in a kindergarten the neighboring group to play war games and we won, the description ends and then emptiness. Yes, and in the minds of the ideology of double vision the same fact was reduced to critical reflection - plus a lot of myths from the series everyone knows, plus total savings on consultants and reading books in favor of restorers and re-enactors in the role of these consultants, well, the eternal one will do, they get paid, and the money from the goskino is paid, and the rental fees and the popularity of the next uncorruption doesn’t bother anyone because they still give Trend. The T-34 review says.
  3. +8
    April 14 2020
    Previously, films were made for the people, but now for money, that’s the whole difference.
    1. +11
      April 14 2020
      In Soviet times, people who went through that very war or who were touched very closely by it were filming, and now those who were touched by the dashing 90s are filming. Here are different concepts of war. The second ones got their hands on stupid crime series about the showdown of the brothers, all sorts of cool "undeservedly served" against the "system" and so on - they filled the screen with all of this, so they couldn't do anything else. Indeed, how can they understand why they won then. Moreover, the same West where they would love to for permanent residence ..
    2. +4
      April 14 2020
      Previously, famous artists, directors, screenwriters lived in communal apartments or "Khrushchevs", rode the subway or tram, stood in lines for sausage .... That is, they lived in the country, personally communicated with people of different social and financial conditions, and not in a fenced "elite" moral and physical environment. Contemporary cultural figures (culture?) Are primitive in their cultural needs, and they transfer this to their "imperishable". Considering, moreover, that they are better versed in everything than specialists.
    3. +1
      April 14 2020
      Quote: Pessimist22
      Previously, films were made for the people, but now for money, that’s the whole difference.

      So they take money from the people. But the people are different. And the majority of the people, no matter how regrettable it may be, arrange all kinds of "Houses ..." and shows with peeking under someone else's blanket. And the greatest box office fees are collected not by "Stalker", but by all sorts of "boobs-pee ... ki and blood like a river with shooting crazy", seasoned with black stuff and dirt on their grandfathers ("you see, they see it that way"). In Soviet times, in order to get on the screen, any, even a cartoon, passed a detailed examination, mainly ideological and useful cultural, I would say. The Ministry of Culture pulled the people with it "towards bright ideals", and today the Ministry of Culture is following the needs of the people, but these needs do not always fit into the censorship vocabulary. That's the whole difference.
  4. +3
    April 14 2020
    So who installed this “filter” for modern “film works” about the Great Patriotic War? And who allocates money for this vile lie? Addresses, surnames, appearances? And why repeat it from film to film?

    Here, really, I would like to know!
    1. +7
      April 14 2020
      Everything is written there, with financial and media support from the Ministry of Culture of the Russian Federation. Addresses and appearances on their website.
  5. +10
    April 14 2020
    On the grave crisis in contemporary Russian war cinema


    As long as the state finances and TV channels buy this guano, they will be filming until then. Watch the Zvezda TV channel, funded by the Ministry of Defense. By the number of anti-Soviet and anti-Russian films, one might think that the owner of the TV channel is the Pentagon.
  6. +5
    April 14 2020
    Nothing to add:
  7. +11
    April 14 2020
    This crisis of the idea is due to the nature of the conditions in which the citizens are placed. And it concerns not only Russia, any film of the CIS space, look, you can shout I do not believe from the very first shots, with the exception of authentic simple stories "from the hinterland", not strongly affected by modern realities.
    I would generally forbid making war films and any remakes of an old movie. Let them practice on simple stories for now. When I start to believe and sincerely experience a simple family history, I can go further.
    And for a woman in a tank and an obligatory sekas "because otherwise the people will not go to the cinema" generally 15 years of hard labor. On TV, nothing at all except Baskov, Buzova and the defective clowns of the Petrosyano theater are 20 years old, and they want to educate good taste? This is already beyond good and evil, an experiment to stupefy and destroy the essence of the Russian soul and faith.
  8. -1
    April 14 2020
    It seems to me that there are good films, well, do not blame everything.
    1. +2
      April 14 2020
      Quote: Free Wind
      It seems to me that there are good films, well, do not blame everything.

      Maybe there is ... But I have not met them. Name it. Maybe, Shtrafbat, Bastards, The last armored train, Love at gunpoint, etc.?
      1. +1
        April 14 2020
        I personally liked: Narkomovsky convoy, Greetings from Katyusha, Thirst, Without the right to make a mistake, Military unit, Yalta, Disappeared, In August 44th, 28 Panfilovites, etc.
  9. +14
    April 14 2020
    You watch a movie like this and think how we could win such a fierce war. If someone else leads there, then it’s nothing. Then you will switch to another program and Zuleikha will open your eyes to the essence of Soviet society. If you hate your past then you won’t have a future. You just throw mud on your parents.
    1. +3
      April 14 2020
      and GDP like it, if it weren’t like, then such films wouldn’t be in turmoil. And we would not have seen them.
  10. -13
    April 14 2020
    The author of this article, somehow unpretentiously and rusticly, advertises Hollywood, and also highlights his opuses in large and bold type.
    1. +4
      April 14 2020
      And with what do not agree?
      1. -7
        April 14 2020
        About how, after 75 years, this movie portrays the enemy as the enemy, and the hero as the hero. And, further, in the same vein. This, you so respectfully speak of Hollywood cheapies.
        1. +12
          April 14 2020
          You did not understand. Hollywood cheapies for their viewers draw their soldiers heroes. Our cheap things draw our soldiers to our viewer cattle.
          1. -7
            April 14 2020
            Quote: avia12005
            You did not understand

            Saving Private Ryan, Spielberg himself, a comedy film, and without our political instructors.
            1. +8
              April 14 2020
              And the fact that for one privates the whole team was sent is definitely a comedy))
              1. 0
                April 14 2020
                And the fact that for one privates the whole team was sent is definitely a comedy))

                Not sent. The Ryan-Fred Niland prototype was simply sent home from the front to the United States to serve as a military police officer.

                In the states there was
                The policy of the “last survivor” is US Department of Defense directive No. 1315.15, titled “Special Rules for Regulating Survivors,” which describes a set of rules in the armed forces designed to protect members of a family who have already lost their families from military service and conscription.
                1. Alf
                  +1
                  April 14 2020
                  Quote: Arzt
                  In the states there was
                  The policy of the “last survivor” is US Department of Defense directive No. 1315.15, titled “Special Rules for Regulating Survivors,” which describes a set of rules in the armed forces designed to protect members of a family who have already lost their families from military service and conscription.

                  And then Roosevelt and the US Commander-in-Chief in Europe after January 45th were unpleasantly surprised that the troops did not show the proper stamina, but simply flee.
                  1. 0
                    April 14 2020
                    And then Roosevelt and the US Commander-in-Chief in Europe after January 45th were unpleasantly surprised that the troops did not show the proper stamina, but simply flee.

                    And how is it that the last son and the stamina of the troops were not sent to war? Under the tsarist regime, the last breadwinner was not taken to the army at all.
                    Or was it necessary, as under the regime of the "father of nations" - to knock out 7-8 sons, to the last, and then hang the "mother-heroine"?
                    1. Alf
                      +3
                      April 14 2020
                      Quote: Arzt
                      Or was it necessary, as under the regime of the "father of nations" - to knock out 7-8 sons, to the last, and then hang the "mother-heroine"?

                      A more specific about the mother-heroine?
                      And it’s connected very simply, they did not perceive the war as our people, and therefore they draped without any remorse.
                      1. -2
                        April 14 2020
                        A more specific about the mother-heroine?

                        Epistinia Stepanova, Praskovya Volodichkina, the Gadzanov brothers.

                        And it’s connected very simply, they did not perceive the war as our people, and therefore they draped without any remorse.

                        We know that they were draping, but we were not draping, but then again, how is this connected with the fact that the last breadwinner was not sent to the war?
                      2. Alf
                        +2
                        April 14 2020
                        Quote: Arzt
                        but again, how does this relate to the fact that the last breadwinner was not sent to war?

                        I speak once. If you do not understand, your headache.
                        In the USSR, ALL the people stood up and went to war, no one said, I am the last, so I won’t go. There was a calculation of ZIS-3 from six brothers, all went to war, no one was left. And there were many such examples, no one stayed at home.
                      3. Alf
                        +3
                        April 14 2020
                        Quote: Arzt
                        Gadzanov brothers.

                        The Gazdanov brothers (Osset. Gzdænty æfsymærtæ) are the seven Gazdanov brothers who died at different times in the battles of World War II. All brothers were born in the village of Dzuarikau (North Ossetian Autonomous Soviet Socialist Republic, RSFSR, USSR) and were called up to the front from their native village. Their mother - Tasso Gazdanova (Vanieva) - died after the third funeral. Asahmat's father lived to see the end of the war, but died after receiving the last funeral [specify] [style] [1].

                        Where is the hanged heroine mother here?
                      4. Alf
                        +3
                        April 14 2020
                        Quote: Arzt
                        Epistinia Stepanova,

                        Epistinia Fedorovna Stepanova (1882-1969) - a Russian woman, whose eight sons died in the war, holder of the orders "Mother Heroine" and World War I degree.

                        And this one was "hanged" ..
                        Praskovya Volodichkina

                        They also hung bloody NKVD-shniki.
                        Before the Great Patriotic War, the Volodichkin family lived in the village of Alekseevka: the head of the family Pavel Vasilyevich Volodichkin (died in 1935), his wife Praskovya Eremeevna Volodichkina (1874-1943) and nine sons - Alexander, Andrei, Peter, Ivan, Vasily, Mikhail, Konstantin , Fedor and Nikolai. When the war began, all nine Volodichkin sons went to the front.
                        Five of them - Nikolai, Andrey, Fedor, Mikhail, Alexander - died in 1941 - 1943, Vasily - in January 1945. Peter, Ivan and Konstantin returned after victory in the village with heavy wounds received during the war, which soon brought them to the graves. Their mother, Praskovya Eremeevna, did not wait for the return of her three last sons - her heart could not stand the loss.
                      5. -1
                        April 14 2020
                        Epistinia Fedorovna Stepanova (1882-1969) - a Russian woman, whose eight sons died in the war, Knight of the orders "Mother Heroine" and World War I degree.

                        I managed to get it.

                        Their mother, Praskovya Eremeevna, did not wait for the return of her three last sons - her heart could not stand the loss.

                        I did not have time to get it.

                        What the problem is, I do not understand. And what does the NKVDshniki have to do with it.
                      6. Alf
                        +2
                        April 14 2020
                        Quote: Arzt
                        What the problem is, I do not understand.

                        Your words ?
                        Or was it necessary, as under the regime of the "father of nations" - to knock out 7-8 sons, to the last, and then hang the "mother-heroine"?
                      7. -1
                        April 14 2020
                        Your words ?
                        Or was it necessary, as under the regime of the "father of nations" - to knock out 7-8 sons, to the last, and then hang the "mother-heroine"?

                        Конечно.
                        To keep at least one child in the family alive in the war is capitalism.

                        It is mercilessly to throw all the children into the meat grinder to the last and, as compensation and consolation, hang a medal - this is socialism.
                        I’ll clarify: socialism in its Stalinist sense.
                    2. 0
                      April 24 2020
                      Even as they took in 1853-4 in the family of my ancestors they took the breadwinner for the Crimean War, leaving my 1,5-year-old ancestor and his 1 month old. sister in the care of mother (breadwinner's wife) and grandmother. The only thing is that upon loss of the breadwinner, the family (until the son of the breadwinner has come of age) was paid annual maintenance in the amount of 75 rubles.
        2. Alf
          +3
          April 14 2020
          Quote: bober1982
          About how, after 75 years, this movie portrays the enemy as the enemy, and the hero as a hero.

          In Hollywood films, there are two points that fundamentally distinguish these films from the masterpieces of the USSR.
          1. American soldiers perceive war as work, without hatred for the enemy - "we were sent to fight as to work."
          2. Too often in Their films, the Germans are presented simply as "the soldiers from the other side", and there are often times when an American and a German soldier act together.
          In addition, American films are very, albeit imperceptibly, distort the story. In the Brothers in Arms, one of the GG says to Winters-We allowed the Russians to take Berlin.
          1. 0
            April 15 2020
            Correctly, German punishers did not carry out executions of hostages (20 for 1) in the quarters of San Francisco or Detroit ..
  11. +11
    April 14 2020
    By the identity of equipment, equipment, and especially weapons, I like movies from Belarusfilm!
    The state border is a series, a series about the beginning of the Second World War, the outpost commander is armed with the PPS-40 and not the PPS-41, which appeared in the fall of 1941. German tanks are replicas from the BMP-1 in the Brest Fortress, but there’s nothing wrong with that, etc.
    I was pleased with the film by 28 Panfilov’s, the armament corresponds to the time, especially the participation of the SVT-40! Deprived in the Soviet cinema!
    1. +7
      April 14 2020
      "Dnieper frontier". The same Belarusfilm and well-worked details.
    2. +8
      April 14 2020
      By the way, 28 Panfilov’s people were withdrawn with public money without the participation of the Ministry of Culture.
      1. Alf
        +2
        April 14 2020
        Quote: Old Partisan
        By the way, 28 Panfilov’s people were withdrawn with public money without the participation of the Ministry of Culture.

        Therefore, it turned out to be a film about the War.
    3. NKT
      +2
      April 14 2020
      The proper use of weapons and equipment of that time is aerobatics. To new “directors” at least learn how to use the correct form, and read about the status of orders and medals from both our and the German side.
  12. +9
    April 14 2020
    Corruption. A gang of hackers who cut dibs and they do not give a damn about all dates. Business and nothing personal. So they were taught and what is there to be surprised.
  13. +1
    April 14 2020
    This article would be in the eyes of Putin.
    1. Alf
      +1
      April 14 2020
      Quote: Jurkovs
      This article would be in the eyes of Putin.

      He was somehow already surprised. Why is there a little positive in social networks? How fell from the moon ...
  14. +4
    April 14 2020
    And as an indicator of government procurement and a litmus test of the needs of our leaders, this (filmmaking) of our Nikita without you, we will lose Mikhalkov, that's a brilliant sculptor of any government. Compare him to Sibiriada and Tired mother to his sun, Here's how to subtly feel the moment and order, as well as talented to fulfill his mother at the highest level. In general, as in Kin Dza-ja, if society does not have an idea, then there is no goal, there is no goal, there is nothing to strive for and create, there is no goal, so we are standing still merrily spinning in one place, which gives excellent prospects for manipulation. It is brilliant to forbid ideology in a society where, without a high goal, its very existence is inconceivable.
    1. +4
      April 14 2020
      His brother Andron removed Siberia.
    2. Alf
      +4
      April 14 2020
      Quote: evgen1221
      And as an indicator of government procurement and a litmus test of the needs of our leaders, this (filmmaking) of our Nikita, without you, we will disappear Mikhalkov — that’s an ingenious sculptor of any government.

  15. +11
    April 14 2020
    What state, such films, desovetization, in a word ...
  16. +5
    April 14 2020
    The author on his own wave.
    It is even more strange that viewing, for example, foreign and modern Pearl Harbor, Midway, Pacific or Brothers in Arms evokes the same sense of truthfulness displayed on the screen


    The author compared, of course. It’s just that PX and Midway cause great irritation to people in the subject - they have the same disregard for real people and real history as in domestic crafts. The Pacific and the Brothers, yes, works of a slightly different nature.

    Why are you faking the truth about the war?


    The truth is not needed.
    1. +2
      April 14 2020
      It evokes a sense of truthfulness, and not compliance with historical truth. This is not the same thing)
      1. +1
        April 14 2020
        Quote: avia12005
        Evokes a sense of truthfulness

        It causes you.

        Not for people who are interested in Pacific history.

        Separate conversation, what exactly do you have evokes a sense of truthfulness... In the western cinema, give you raped German women and shootings of prisoners, and, for example, "Only old men go to battle" You, as I understand it, are ready to eat without it.
        1. +5
          April 14 2020
          Can you read? I'm talking about something completely different. The fact that in their western films their soldiers are always heroes, and in our contemporary films our soldiers are a dumb herd. Now it is clear?
          1. +3
            April 14 2020
            Quote: avia12005
            The fact that in Western films their soldiers are always heroes

            )))

            No. Far from it.

            Quote: avia12005
            and in our modern day our soldiers are wordless

            In general, it’s hard for me to imagine a goodie in modern Russian commercial cinema. Even St. Vladimir turned out, to put it mildly, strange for the saint.

            However, I follow badly.
  17. +4
    April 14 2020
    It is necessary to introduce quotas for criminals and priests in the Red Army in the cinema for a year. In the archives, see how much it was, and as a percentage, show the same amount in a movie.
    If there is no archival evidence of the events in the war movie. "Bastards", for example. Below for the entire film there are credits "The film is a lie, there has never been anything like that in the Red Army. Watching the film is harmful." like a pack of cigarettes.
    Distributors of pirated content could do this for their homeland.
    1. Alf
      +1
      April 14 2020
      Quote: hhhhhhh
      Distributors of pirated content could do this for their homeland.

      Then the torrent persecutors would not pursue it out of duty (so-so), but fiercely, at the behest of the soul. And the first out of their pants would be a sweet couple of Bondarchuk Mikhalkov.
      1. 0
        April 14 2020
        For the obligatory inscription to entrust the office of Mikhalkov, the author.))) There is no evidence of the attack of the cuttings, the inscription "Lies" for the entire film.
  18. +4
    April 14 2020
    Soviet films about the Second World War have always consulted the military (from the lieutenant colonel and above), mainly those who passed it. And now they are filming by "specialists" grown in Hollywood.
    1. +3
      April 14 2020
      To the point! Now even instead of "Yes" they answer "Yes, exactly."
      I am ashamed ...
      1. AAK
        +3
        April 14 2020
        Colleague, alas, but both answers are statutory and from the times of the USSR, only "is" is the fleet, and "yes," is land ..
        Well, about the quality and reliability - just look at the mass of videos widespread on the Web about which of our favorite artists fought (or, for the youngest of that generation, survived the war in childhood) ... the vast majority turns out, hence the reliability, sincerity, vitality ... look "They fought for the Motherland .." or "Belorussky Station", there is no need to say anything, everything is clear and so ...
        1. +1
          April 14 2020
          Wrong about fleet and land. The construction charter is one for all
          1. AAK
            -1
            April 14 2020
            I don’t know, colleague, I served in the air defense and answered “that's right”, my cousin is naval, he served on “singing frigates”, they always answered “have” on the ship, probably according to the Ship's Regulations ...
    2. +2
      April 14 2020
      Quote: Horst78
      And now they are filming by "specialists" grown in Hollywood.

      And, judging by their products, they never served in the armed forces. Not a single person from the whole composition.
    3. +5
      April 14 2020
      Oh, if grown up in Hollywood, rather modern "cultural figures" take an example from Bollywood ... The same examples given by the author were filmed or produced by none other than Steven Spielberg, who set himself the task of showing the Americans, most of whom the war touched only indirectly why war is really SCARY. And he did it. Both Brothers in Arms and Pacific Front and Saving Private Ryne are very powerful films. Moreover, the first two can be called commercially successful with a big stretch. they could be seen only by cable viewers who have an HBO channel or by those who bought the DVD. And this at a cost of $ 120 million each! And it became the assertion that Americans make movies purely for the sake of making money is not as straightforward as it might seem at first glance.

      In Soviet cinema, there was a different approach. The Soviet person did not need to explain why the war is SCARY, he knew this from his own experience, from the history of his family. There was no point in traumatizing such people with the horrors they had suffered once again. However, Soviet directors even managed to put such a powerful message into their abstracted image of hostilities that for a long time it worked no worse than the obviously more realistic works of their Western colleagues. However, over time, as the roar of the weapons of that war recedes, the memory of it fades in the minds of new generations, and we, following the Americans, also have a need to depict the war as realistically as possible. So that the new citizens of our country could appreciate what their ancestors went through and how valuable they got the freedom that has become so familiar. But we didn't have our own Spielberg, and Soviet directors either have already died or retired. And the current clip-makers like Bandarchuk, who replaced them, can only create a beautiful picture, completely forgetting that it must also be endowed with the appropriate meaning. And what sense can there be in purely commercial projects? At the same time, they do not understand that the box office success of the same Spielberg is nothing more than an indicator of a job well done, gratitude from the studio audience and the director, while for modern Russian "filmmakers" making money is an end in itself. And in this we have truly surpassed Hollywood.
  19. +5
    April 14 2020
    I could not help but return to the topic ... Recently I looked at "YouTube" our next "masterpiece" about the youngest son of the regiment. He was six years old, it seems.
    And interestingly, a historical fact. As indicated in the article, you can shoot based on heroics. Moreover, there are many examples. A lot ... But HOW to remove that? !!!
    They took the story with this boy and "smeared" snot on the table with a thin layer. The battalion commander's love line was inserted, everybody was dressed "with a needle," the actress was picked up more sympathetically ... And the main feat of this guy was allocated a couple of minutes at the end of the film and so blurred that those who don't know the story probably thought it was an ordinary event !
  20. bar
    +4
    April 14 2020
    All these supposedly "historical" popular films were shot on the same plot. Like a war, always with women on the front line. Like the love of anxious rabbits under bombing / shelling. Only the scenery changes - in a tank, in an airplane, just in a trench. There is not even a talk about the reliability. What is the next incorruptible "Fighters" with Dyuzhev and "Jackson" worth. Those "fighters", both under 2 meters tall wassat
    And now all these contributions, which are supposedly supposedly to educate the patriotism of the younger generation, are paid from the budget, i.e. our money. All this is disgusting No.
  21. +7
    April 14 2020
    On this subject, as I already wrote a comment - all modern Russian cinema about WWII is just shit. The commissar is a fanatic, a special bastard, a commander, and also some kind of kral, really constantly painted walks.
  22. +5
    April 14 2020
    Quote: Pecheneg
    On this subject, as I already wrote a comment - all modern Russian cinema about WWII is just shit. The commissar is a fanatic, a special bastard, a commander, and also some kind of kral, really constantly painted walks.

    1. 0
      April 14 2020
      Cinema and the Germans!
    2. +1
      April 14 2020
      Great illustration to the above. I have no words. Censored.
  23. -2
    April 14 2020
    "The sense of objectivity in such films is caused by the details: for example, in the Pacific Ocean, one of the American heroes after the battle is amused by the fact that ... he throws stones at the half-demolished head of a dead Japanese soldier, frozen at the moment of death behind a machine gun. And besides, he rips out golden teeth from dead Japanese soldiers."

    The author, in my opinion, you turned down about objectivity!
    I understand you, that if in our films the fighters after the battle tore the golden teeth from the killed SS men, this would greatly enhance by you sense of objectivity.
    And if at the same time they were still Cossack swords, shouting "Eh-ma!" cut the wounded enemies in half, then for you would it be almost 3D? So?

    In "Fighters" there is an episode when a pilot, after receiving money from her, is decided to rob 2 bandits. She kills one, leaves the other alive ...
    There you have it, author, and the feeling of that objectivity in the details for which you drown ...
    Or is it not for you?
    Maybe you don’t have enough torn gold teeth from the killed bandit?
    1. +1
      April 14 2020
      Read it again. Everything is relative.
  24. +2
    April 14 2020
    And there is no need to go to cinemas for all sorts of "Stalingrad" and watch all sorts of "Penal Battles" on TV. Well, and whine about how, under Stalin, they were allegedly dispossessed for nothing too.
  25. +8
    April 14 2020
    Problems in the cinema, military ???
    I don’t even want to discuss it. A clear program for denigrating the great history of the Soviet Union.
    Who rules the "ball" everywhere? To whom do all sorts of figures go as servants? The ruling class, those who now have power and money, and to them our Soviet history is like a sickle in the innermost, i.e. over them on stolen / appropriated wealth!
    In general, there is nothing to discuss.
    I just want to remember "get up branded curse ......"
    It is high time to get up and become one whole, for our bright life, for the future of our descendants ...
  26. -6
    April 14 2020
    As for the intelligent, aristocratic Germans in modern Russian cinema ... The film "Seventeen Moments of Spring" does not bother the author how the Germans are portrayed there?
    What's not to like about the movie "Indestructible"? Well, yes, a woman mechanic, and even fighting in a tank. Well, this is all a feature film, not a documentary.
    Personally, I don't like the film "Only Old Men Go to Battle" - well, it tastes and colors ... I don't understand why it is shown all the time on May 9 - it is not a military man at all.
    1. +3
      April 14 2020
      This "mechanic" looks like a catwalk on the front lines. A fight over her between two officers in front of the soldiers is pure nonsense. Okay, we could give it one-on-one in the face ... He gets out from under the engine clean and painted, I won't say anything at all
    2. 0
      April 14 2020
      So there Stirlitz is the same, and not the front, but in Berlin.
    3. -3
      April 14 2020
      Quote: Prometey
      Personally, I don't like the movie "Only Old Men Go to Battle"

      This is because L. Bykov was a brilliant actor (Petya Mokin and others), and he was weak as a director - directing is weak, naive and not true, by the way, I also do not like the film. Of course, pioneers and Komsomol members (today's young people) should watch this film for patriotic education. Not more than that.
      1. -1
        April 15 2020
        There is no need to write nonsense. An ingenious movie in which there is a clear understanding of what was shot and why, the historical truthfulness could, if necessary, be corrected by real WWII pilots.
        1. -1
          April 15 2020
          Quote: EvilLion
          There is no need to write nonsense.

          I did not understand anything from what you said.
          Read the memories ....... real WWII pilots, nothing to do with this brilliant film.
    4. +1
      April 14 2020
      Quote: Prometey
      Personally, I don't like the film "Only Old Men Go to Battle" - well, it tastes and colors ... I don't understand why it is shown all the time on May 9 - it is not a military man at all.

      This something happened tastefully ...
  27. +6
    April 14 2020
    In today's Russian war cinema, they almost always appear ironed, glazed, elegant characters, fighting the Soviet "cattle" aristocratic and even intelligent ...

    The authors of such films are downright sympathetic to the SS and the Wehrmacht. But from watching such opuses it becomes so disgusting. We, the generation that grew up on Soviet films about the war, cannot be brainwashed, but kids. I do not specifically include these "masterpieces" with my own, let first "Come and see" look for example.
  28. +1
    April 14 2020
    We have a crisis around, and you're all about CINEMA.
    1. AAK
      +1
      April 14 2020
      A colleague, just in time of crisis, when people are sitting at home and watching TV video, they need to leave at least some trace in their souls left, now people have a little time to think, comprehend ...
  29. +3
    April 14 2020
    You talked about the main thing. The distortion of history, the abuse of demshiza over our grandfathers bears fruit first of all among the grand recipients. While paying, there will be stupid people commissars from our glorious pederasts ...
  30. +4
    April 14 2020
    "Come and see", as they say (the strongest film, very difficult). All this is understandable, I absolutely agree with the author, but this is all clear to any "thinking person" (who does not just watch films with "beer"). It's scary in fact ... for us, citizens of Russia, the successors of the USSR paint the image of a disgusting state (the USSR, if anyone does not understand), in which people fought against the Nazis and Fascists in spite of ... just going to the slaughter, atoning with blood, at gunpoint TT political instructor or personally L.P. Beria, and this is being filmed by Russian people if that !!! As the grandson of a veteran of the Great Patriotic War who liberated Sofia, Budapest and Vienna - I'm ashamed ... From the latter, if you want to smear yourself with the fierce anti-Sovietism and terror of Stalin and Beria, look (if you can) Rzhev and the completely new Zuleikha opens her eyes ... Your eyes and ears will bleed.
    1. -1
      April 15 2020
      Why watch it when you can just read the documentary evidence of the atrocities of the Nazis?
  31. +4
    April 14 2020
    From Western films about the Soviet Army I saw only "K-19" and "Enemy at the Gates". Our military has sharply criticized them for the inconsistency of details and lack of historical truth. And these films amazed me. And you know what? Great respect, I would even say, reverence for our submariners and defenders of Stalingrad. Jude Law in the role of sniper Zaitsev generally looks like a saint. There is no such attitude towards our soldiers in modern Russian films. I tried to look, it didn't work. Adventures in the setting of war. Heroes do not cause empathy. The directors are mediocre and, in addition, Russophobes. Just grant eaters. They don't understand what audience the film is for. Or vice versa - they understand very well, but have the goal of entangling the audience with a Russophobic ideology, forming out of it a gathering of common people, each of whom is on his own.
    1. +1
      April 14 2020
      Quote: depressant
      From Western films about the Soviet Army I saw only "K-19" and "Enemy at the Gates".

      I agree - K-19 falls out of the satire line of Western films about our military.
    2. +4
      April 14 2020
      Quote: depressant
      From Western films about the Soviet Army I saw only "K-19" and "Enemy at the Gates". Our military has sharply criticized them for the inconsistency of details and lack of historical truth. And these films amazed me. And you know what? Great respect, I would even say, reverence for our submariners and defenders of Stalingrad.

      Into the account "K-19".
      The crew member was telling ...
      A woman came to the director, showed the script to the submariners ... They gave advice, told how it was ...
      Then she came again, so that the first spectators were crew members ...
      She was smashed for distorting reality ....
      She almost burst into tears .... Her argument was very simple. If you show, then what they say:
      1. In America, no one will watch - not interesting.
      2. Recognize the film as "red propaganda".

      I myself, the first time I could not watch it - it was disgusting.
      The second time I began to look in order to identify lies. After 20 misgivings, the account went astray ...
      There, even the epaulets of the protagonist have problems - in different episodes, different ranks ...

      By the way, the film begins with the boat being pushed out of the factory with imperfections and without a full test cycle. This is a lie. But, for example, the American "Thresher" died for this very reason.
      Metamorphoses ...
      And who cares ...

      And about the fact that Korchilov went into radiation as a volunteer, this amers will never understand. He no longer served in the reactor compartment, but knew the equipment better than others.
      Our Heroes have eternal memory. And we are responsible so that this memory does not go away with us.
    3. +1
      April 15 2020
      If "K-19" is an attempt at a film about Americanized Soviet submariners with typical Hollywood techniques, then I don't remember what is respectful about "Enemy at the Gates". The usual anti-Soviet propaganda.
  32. +4
    April 14 2020
    And so I can advise (although if a person, person, not biomass), see old Soviet films. Epic movie Liberation, Some old people go into battle, And the dawns here are quiet, Officers, They fought for their Motherland, Cranes are flying, Go and see (everyone should see to know and remember ...), Ati-bats were soldiers, Father of a soldier, In war as in war, Shield and sword, Battalions ask for fire, Hot snow, Lark, Chronicle of a dive bomber .... this list is very long.
    1. 0
      April 14 2020
      Of the modern ones, I can recommend the documentary series "The Great War" of 2011. The filmed is very interesting, I reviewed it many times. The company star-media has a great thing.
    2. Alf
      +4
      April 14 2020
      Quote: Konatantin 1992
      And so I can advise (although if a person, person, not biomass), see old Soviet films. Epic movie Liberation, Some old people go into battle, And the dawns here are quiet, Officers, They fought for their Motherland, Cranes are flying, Go and see (everyone should see to know and remember ...), Ati-bats were soldiers, Father of a soldier, In war as in war, Shield and sword, Battalions ask for fire, Hot snow, Lark, Chronicle of a dive bomber .... this list is very long.

      And perhaps the most piercing film is Ordinary Fascism.
    3. -4
      April 15 2020
      Do not watch "Liberation" in any case. to teach materiel according to normal historical documents. I tried to watch "Shield and Sword", I dropped it, but I don't really like the movie about spies.

      "And the dawns here are quiet" can hardly be called a military one, after all, a big war is somewhere on the sidelines, leaving the history of the foreman already unfit for combatant at the front and 5 girls with whom he has to stop the superior enemy group. In this regard, he is even further from the war than "The Ballad of the Soldier", where the GG at least actually does not leave the front.
      1. 0
        April 15 2020
        Is Living and Dead good?
  33. DPN
    +3
    April 14 2020
    Yes, they became anti-Soviet, starting with the film; Bastards "to this day.
  34. +3
    April 14 2020
    One might think that the rest of "contemporary Russian cinema" is not a crisis.
    Stupid films, often stupidly worsened, copied from the west.
  35. +8
    April 14 2020
    Well, how can our directors and producers get out if there is a clear installation of soldiers and people are heroes and power is crap. There is victory, but everything was bad in the Soviet country. If you make truthful films, you must immediately say that there were good and bad ones. But the plants worked The military quickly learned and soon surpassed the German, the Russian soldier is the best in the world, the Russian commanders too, and Stalin the inspirer and organizer of victories.
  36. +7
    April 14 2020
    In the Brest Fortress, the NKVD schnick was well removed, in the heat of battle split the German saboteur, fought with his subordinates to the end, died as a hero in battle. No icons, policies, cuttings from shovels and stupidity like Nikita Sergeevich.
  37. +5
    April 14 2020
    Somehow I accidentally saw a slapstick film about the creator of the T-34 tank, Koshkin. It's called "Tanks". It's just a scribe! I was sick for a week.
    https://yandex.fr/video/preview/?filmId=9054205279851615549&text=фильм%20Танки&path=wizard&parent-reqid=1586845941432597-161829324765486141700324-production-app-host-vla-web-yp-107&redircnt=1586845959.1
    1. -2
      April 15 2020
      In fact, the T-34 was designed by another person, Koshkin was just an administrator who sat down on the finished project, and the designer was taken in for execution, so the tank had so many "children's sores, the remaining people did not pull the job.
  38. +4
    April 14 2020
    Discussion, miracles on bends. It is necessary to scold the defective managers, but not to hurt the power under which these menagers flourish.
  39. +1
    April 14 2020
    And who generally watches modern war films ??? Well, let's start with the fact that not many people love war films, and those who love know that the best films about the Second World War were shot in the USSR and only a few are being advertised, or they specifically watch modern feces to discuss later on.
  40. 0
    April 14 2020
    It's a strange thing, you look at the Soviet “At war as at war”, “Only old people go into battle” or “Baltic sky” and believe in what is happening on the screen.
    What is the feeling after watching "Die Hard" or "Sergeant Tsybuli's Country Trip"?
    1. +2
      April 14 2020
      Normal. Now, if 90 percent of films on this topic were "Country Trips" or "Die Hard", then I would feel sick.
      1. -1
        April 14 2020
        Quote: avia12005
        Normal. Now, if 90 percent of films on this topic were "Country Trips" or "Die Hard", then I would feel sick.

        And the fact of the matter is that since that time all the "slag" "crumbled and settled" and "diamonds" remained, the same will happen with modern films over time.
        1. 0
          April 14 2020
          What will happen to those who form their view of the war on the basis of such "diamonds"? And what will happen to the country and to us? Salt.
          1. +1
            April 14 2020
            Quote: avia12005
            What will happen to those who form their view of the war on the basis of such "diamonds"?

            I think that "Panfilov's 28", "Rubezh", I really hope that "Podolsk cadets" will be excellent "diamonds"
            1. 0
              April 14 2020
              Exactly! God grant that it be so.
  41. 0
    April 14 2020
    "Behold at the root!" (Kozma Prutkov)
    Art is a superstructure phenomenon related to the sphere of ideology. Having not solved the fundamental issue of ownership and methods of distribution of the material and spiritual goods produced, it is impossible to create an alternative ideology and new art that adequately reflects the goals and objectives of the people!
    The proposed text is another "lament of Yaroslavna".
    1. 0
      April 14 2020
      Correctly! We read the work of Lenin about partisanship in literature.
  42. +1
    April 14 2020
    Somehow, the theme of the characters is touched on casually.
    But we all see how the presence of a huge number of representatives in carpet-tunic tunics and hats with a blue top is an inalienable attribute of modern vernal cinema.
    NKVD is our FSE.
    Moreover, front-line counterintelligence agents are also shown in this form, which the spirit did not have.
    And they are half the action of the films ...
    1. Alf
      +1
      April 14 2020
      Quote: U-58
      But we all see how the presence of a huge number of representatives in carpet-tunic tunics and hats with a blue top is an inalienable attribute of modern vernal cinema.
      NKVD is our FSE.

      The well-known artist Peter Dennis.

      So they represent our soldiers. Apparently, the stereotype is once a political instructor, then a Jew.
  43. -3
    April 14 2020
    Yes, and in Soviet films there were enough tricks.
    "Aty-bats, soldiers were walking." A heroic, not bad movie overall. But the plot itself hurts the eye. 1944, the Red Army inflicts crushing blows on the Wehrmacht ... and bam - like in 1941, a platoon of tank destroyers, armed only with an anti-tank rifle, is at the forefront of the attack of the breakthrough Germans. I understand that it was necessary to show the heroism of Soviet soldiers. But, damn it, this is already 1944. What are grenades and anti-tank weapons in the fight against tanks? Not a single anti-tank gun. Why the heck was to lower the command of the Red Army, showing that for 3 years nothing has changed in the war and the Red Army men are throwing themselves under tanks with grenades near Moscow in 41? Moreover, there even "Tiger" rolled out from somewhere. And he almost needs to be stopped with his bare hands. Well, those films. "Hot snow" and "Battalions are asking for fire" - our everything.
    1. +2
      April 14 2020
      Everything happened at the front. The main thing is the pitch. This is respect and gratitude, not dousing.
    2. +2
      April 14 2020
      Quote: Prometey
      But, damn it, it's already 1944. What grenades and PTR in the fight against tanks? Not a single anti-tank gun. Why the heck was it to omit the command of the Red Army, showing that for 3 years nothing had changed in the war and that the Red Army men, like in Moscow, in 41, were rushing under tanks with grenades?

      Do you think that this could not be in 1944? I watched the German Chronicle and 44 and 45, and some of our descriptions of the fighting. Believe me, everything happened there. Wehrmacht had small-town successes. They beat off settlements, stations, ambushes were arranged, prisoners were captured. Another thing is that they generally did not exert any influence on the events as a whole.
    3. Alf
      +1
      April 14 2020
      Quote: Prometey
      Aty-bats, soldiers were walking. "A heroic, not bad film in general. But the plot itself hurts the eye. 1944,

      Stop. What side is this 1944th year?
      1. 0
        April 14 2020
        Quote: Alf
        Stop. What side is this 1944th year?

        Well, with this - according to the script of the film. Well, something even looks like a breakthrough from the Iasi-Chisinau boiler.
        1. Alf
          +2
          April 14 2020
          Quote: Prometey
          Quote: Alf
          Stop. What side is this 1944th year?

          Well, with this - according to the script of the film. Well, something even looks like a breakthrough from the Iasi-Chisinau boiler.

          And where is the 44th in the film?
  44. +5
    April 14 2020
    In recent years, I don’t watch "Russian" films at all ... Sometimes I tried ... on "recommendations" (!), But it happened that I turned it off in the "middle of the film"! "Attraction" (wife and granddaughter "twisted" their hands and led ...) ... "absurdities" in the film were enough for "impressions"! When my wife and granddaughter tried to "drive" me to f. "Invasion", I put up "fierce resistance", and they had to retreat ... Now, "on TV" they advertise some kind of "pro-Tatar" film ... I just had to "look" at the fragments of the "movie" (animals-nkvdeshniki ... inhuman camp conditions - everything is in the "spirit" of Solzhenitsyn!) to decide that I will not watch this film!
  45. +1
    April 14 2020
    It's a strange thing, you look at the Soviet “At war as at war”, “Only old people go into battle” or “Baltic sky” and believe in what is happening on the screen. And you do not just believe, but live along with the characters on the screen.


    Those who caught the war, whose young parents fought, left the cinema. Remained Mikhalkovskie fosterlings extra chromosomal medina. What to expect from them?
  46. +5
    April 14 2020
    Quote: Prometey
    Yes, and in Soviet films there were enough tricks.
    "Aty-bats, soldiers were walking"

    The prototype was a platoon of Lieutenant Shironin, who defended the railway crossing near the village of Taranovka in the Kharkov region in March 1943. All platoon fighters and the commander were awarded the title Hero of the Soviet Union. The film is of course an art
  47. +4
    April 14 2020
    And from my childhood I remember the book "A Man Does Not Give Up" where a young political instructor finds himself right on the eve of the war in the border unit and then leads the soldiers out of the encirclement. That's where the heroism is! Until now, under the impression - as if he himself walked through the Belarusian forests to the Berezina.
  48. 0
    April 14 2020
    In modern Russian military films, with the possible exception of a few (“28 Panfilovites” or “Brest Fortress”), there is no truth about that great war.
    There is also a good film "STAR", my granddaughters watched it several times, at that time all the artists were normal people (I'm talking about A. Panin)
    1. -1
      April 18 2020
      Awesome shit. And how do you remember it? Panin was normal. Probably, somewhere far away they shot and they couldn’t run for a bottle. Is he actually an artist? I had the opinion that this fool from a psychiatric hospital was released for hype, and then his directors noticed: but mine and ... Well, the yoke into the movie.
  49. +4
    April 14 2020
    The topic raised is relevant. Immediately I remembered the phrase about one director-actor (youngest)))) "Fedya, where are the boobs ?!" Zadolbal Bondarchuk Jr. is seen by many that they walked on him like that ...
    The phenomenon is probably that the wrong people go to art, there are possibly talented people, but only scum find sponsors (like themselves) and create "masterpieces". Worship of everything Western, deviation from the norm (both in thinking and sex - role), perversion of natures and stupidity, wretchedness passed off as insiderism and creatism - can create something that people and eats ((((((It's a shame, like that, however ((
  50. +1
    April 14 2020
    My aunt’s husband walked from Kursk to Berlin. I could not watch films about the war, and I always said that there was no truth at all from the word at all. And he was talking about Soviet films, and as far as I know, many front-line soldiers had such an attitude to cinema. This is the question of generations. Today's youth has a completely different story and teaches and perceives. Give them a hype. Here are the directors and try. They need a cash register first of all, they don't give a damn about the rest.
  51. +5
    April 14 2020
    I was especially “surprised” by the selection of films and series on TV at the present time. This is the impression, and from the 1st, for a long time now, I have been confident that they work for other powers hostile to us and serve their interests. So Russia 1, at a time when everyone is at home, on the eve of the significant date of the Great Victory, is launching a series saturated with anti-Sovietism and Russophobia, inciting nationalism and enmity. The craft “Zuleikha opens her eyes” received, at one time, prizes and recognition exclusively abroad in the wake of rabid Russophobia, now, having picked the moment, with active and aggressive advertising and banners on the floor of the screen, they are planting it on us. In a normal country, for such “tricks” the producer and head of the channel would have been sent for “location” filming at the same stage, headed by the relevant ministry in full force, essentially for a direct call for national hatred, distortion of historical facts, rewriting history and ardent anti-Sovietism, disgracing the country and the people, state security agencies, it is unclear where the prosecutor’s office is looking, etc., the relevant services, I am tired of seeing and hearing all this. I have already said for a long time that it is not possible for modern figures in the arts with a formal education of “advanced consumers” to create masterpieces in any areas, and even more so historical and military ones, kept women and nepotism, loot, complete impunity and permissiveness, under the guise of their mediocrity, such as such a vision of the “artist”, completely killed creativity and banal common sense.
  52. 0
    April 14 2020
    Quote: Prometey
    a platoon of tank destroyers armed only with anti-tank rifles.

    in 41 (relevant until the end of the war) the anti-tank gun was a very formidable weapon against German technology, including aviation, akin to a modern RPG or ATGM. For the PTRD-41 and PTRS-41 anti-tank rifles alone, Simonov and Dektyarev should have monuments erected in the most significant places in our country. The feat of the Pamfilovites is also a platoon of anti-tank soldiers.
    1. 0
      April 14 2020
      Quote: seacap
      in 41 (relevant until the end of the war) the anti-tank gun was a very formidable weapon against German technology, including aviation, akin to a modern RPG or ATGM.

      More like rifle grenades. Especially considering that the mass-produced B-32 cartridge did not penetrate the 30-mm armor of German tanks, and the BS-41 cartridge was extremely scarce. According to a report from the winter of 1942, one of the divisions had 26 anti-tank rifles and 100 BS-41 rounds for them.
      Quote: seacap
      Monuments to Simonov and Dektyarev should be erected in the most significant places in our country.

      ...comparative shooting from PTRS and PTRD showed that extraction from these guns is also unsatisfactory. The quarter-automatic PTRD never fired even once in 5 rounds; ejection was done manually. For the “automatic” PTRS, cartridges were ejected using a ramrod, and on the second shot it was not possible to extract the cartridges at the firing position
      Leningrad Artillery Research Experimental Test Site of the Red Army, summer 1942.
      The practice of using PTR in the troops, especially in summer conditions, shows that even if the rules for preparing shotguns for shooting in accordance with paragraph 1 are observed, shotguns that do not provide free extraction can be found.
      To eliminate delays in reloading the rifle arising in this case, allow the troops to use a wooden mallet
      © Main Artillery Directorate of the Red Army. Directorate of Small Arms. June 3, 1942.
      July 10-12, 1942 at the NIPSVO, tests of anti-tank rifles were held, which were attended by the deputies of the Main Art Directorate, People's Commissar of Armaments, as well as both creators of the PTR - Degtyarev and Simonov.
      1. Experienced PTRD of plant No. 74. 610 shots were fired from a shotgun with various cartridges under various conditions, with 189 cartridge cases being emitted (31%) using a mallet.
      The report noted that the PTR "under all conditions, works unsatisfactorily."
      2. Another gross PTRD from this plant, with improved processing of the chamber, was rated “works extremely unsatisfactorily under any conditions.” Out of 275 shots, the mallet was required to eject 264 times (96%).
      3. The third PTRD was able to “surpass” this result. “The survivability of the gun was determined in 43 shots. After each shot, the sleeve was knocked out with a mallet. When knocking out the 43rd sleeve, the handle broke off at the shutter. ”
      © Andrey Ulanov
      Poor extraction of cartridges, due to their frequent jamming, does not allow the fighter to quickly reload the gun at the right moment in the battle, and the fighter does not have time to use a wooden drift when the target (tank, armored personnel carrier) is at a distance of 50-100 meters. Thus, at a critical moment, the fighter cannot take the fight.
      High recoil and imperfect wooden parts (especially shoulder pads) lead to the fact that the fighter cannot fire for a long time.
      The recommended lubrication of cartridges as a remedy for jamming is not practical, because in battle, a fighter does not have time to do this.
      © Artillery Commander of the 40th Army
    2. 0
      April 14 2020
      Quote: seacap
      in 41 (relevant until the end of the war) the anti-tank gun was a very formidable weapon against German technology, including aviation, akin to a modern RPG or ATGM.

      In 1943, not all Soviet guns hit German tanks head-on, but yes - PTR is a formidable weapon.
    3. 0
      April 15 2020
      In general, in 41, the anti-tank rifles were mainly from Polish trophies.. And ours, which we see on the screens in relatively large quantities (the Commander-in-Chief, like machine guns, distributed individually along the fronts) closer to November (participated in the parade) December 1941
  53. -3
    April 14 2020
    Of course no. They took place. But this was not a mass phenomenon.

    Oh really?
    The author is also a storyteller, let’s turn to his memoirs:
    Ragged, overgrown and hungry, they were finally among their own, at home! The joy that overwhelmed them was overwhelming, immeasurable, but... it turned out to be short-lived. Delivered to headquarters, they were immediately disarmed and sent under escort to the NKVD camp, designed to check the reliability of those returning from the front line. Many such camps were opened in December 1941 and were filled by summer. Several days passed before Tarelkin somehow managed to give the signal to freedom.

    Major Tikhonov found an airfield on the map very close to the camp’s location and ordered the squadron commander, Captain A.I. Galkin, equipped with all possible powers, to immediately fly on a combat aircraft to the camp area and deliver the crew to the regiment.
    We ran into the wrong ones!
    Despite the request, persuasion and cool turns of phrase in the bass registers, the camp authorities under no circumstances intended to give in to Galkin. He shook the documents, swore and swore - like he was hitting the wall!
    - Not allowed. There is an order!


    As a result, the prisoners were taken out of the camp, but...
    The story of the escape of Tarelkin and Dedushkin from the NKVD camp, reaching General Golovanov, seriously worried him and prompted him to intervene in this delicate and dangerous matter. In terms of chances of ending up in Dante’s new-found “purgatory,” the flight crew of long-range aviation had many “advantages” - our crews were larger than those of other types of aviation, and we had to operate at great depths above enemy territory, and if you consider that the combat strength of the ADD was not massive and literally every crew was accountable at Headquarters, then the commander’s anxiety will become understandable: these “camp events” could have a sensitive impact on the combat capabilities of long-range bombers.

    Alexander Evgenievich made a bold request to Stalin - to allow him, Golovanov’s crews, to be sent directly to his headquarters after crossing the front line. Golovanov assured Stalin that he vouched for his pilots and took full responsibility for their reliability.

    Stalin did not immediately, but agreed with this, and an important exception for ADD pilots and navigators came into force, although it did not affect those who were returning after escaping from captivity.
    1. 0
      April 14 2020
      Who told you that all memoirs can and should be trusted to the last point? Anything could happen in war. Nitok is not going to whitewash the NKVD bastards. But for some reason, films are almost always only about such people. Why? Were there more of them? Were there no normal ones at all? Or were they? But they don’t film about them? In general, they don’t make films about normal, ordinary people.

      You won’t understand))) Golovanov turned to Stalin, who approved. WHY hasn't a movie been made about this??? That is, you see the camp authorities, but you don’t see that there was justice after all. And after they were shot down, the pilots must be checked if they were behind the front line. There are also memoirs that there were pilots who went over to the enemy’s side, then returned to their units and tried to persuade their comrades to fly to the enemy’s side. Seek and ye shall find.
      1. -3
        April 14 2020
        Quote: avia12005
        Who told you that all memoirs can and should be trusted to the last point?


        I specially wrote to you - the memoirs of the future commander of long-range aviation of the USSR - this is someone you can trust, and you cannot deny competence, unlike your nonsense.
        1. +1
          April 14 2020
          Dear, I didn’t poke you. Again, how do you work with Radio Liberty? Get off topic. About films, you covered yourself with Reshetnikov like a priest in a bathhouse fellow Basically, tell me, do you like “Fighters”? Political officer and special officer too? Well, YOU?

          If YOU are so smart, provide links to your scientific articles on the topic. I'll read it with pleasure.
    2. +1
      April 14 2020
      Quote: Dmitry Vladimirovich
      Let's look at the memoirs:
      Whose memoirs are they? All military personnel who emerged from encirclement and were released from captivity underwent mandatory testing in the NKVD testing and filtration camps. In total, from December 1941 to July 1944, 375 people of the “special contingent” passed through the special camps of the NKVD, 368 people (11%) were arrested and convicted. My father-in-law was captured in July 658, released from a concentration camp in 3,1, went through a check, went to the hospital and fought until the Victory. 1941% of those tested returned to the Active Army. The “dashing” act of the “flyers” is hooliganism.
      1. 0
        April 14 2020
        Quote: Pushkar
        Quote: Dmitry Vladimirovich
        Let's look at the memoirs:
        Whose memoirs are they? All military personnel who emerged from encirclement and were released from captivity underwent mandatory testing in the NKVD testing and filtration camps. In total, from December 1941 to July 1944, 375 people of the “special contingent” passed through the special camps of the NKVD, 368 people (11%) were arrested and convicted. My father-in-law was captured in July 658, released from a concentration camp in 3,1, went through a check, went to the hospital and fought until the Victory. 1941% of those tested returned to the Active Army. The “dashing” act of the “flyers” is hooliganism.


        That is, about 10 percent of those who were captured passed the special check. This is what a brutal “Bolshevik” regime is...
      2. +2
        April 14 2020
        Quote: Pushkar
        In total, from December 1941 to July 1944, 375 people passed through the NKVD special camps

        In the "Certificate on the progress of verification of former encirclements and prisoners of war as of October 1, 1944." there were detailed statistics:
        In total, the former Red Army soldiers who left the encirclement and were released from captivity, 354592 people, including officers of 50441 people, passed through the special camps.
        From this number it is checked and transferred:
        a) to the Red Army 249416 people.
        including:
        in military units through the military registration and enlistment offices 231034 - "-
        Of these, 27042 are officers -"-
        For the formation of assault battalions 18382 -"-
        Of these, 16163 are officers -"-
        b) to the industry under the regulations of GKO 30749 - "-
        including 29 officers -"-
        c) on the formation of convoy troops and the protection of special camps 5924 - "-
        3. Arrested by the authorities "SMERSH" 11556 - "-
        of them are intelligence and counterintelligence agents of the enemy 2083 - "-
        of these - officers (for various crimes) 1284 -"-
        4. Departed for various reasons for all time - 5347 died in hospitals, infirmaries - "-
        5. They are in the special camps of the NKVD of the USSR in the 51601 inspection - "-
        including 5657 officers -"-
        From among the officers remaining in the camps of the NKVD of the USSR, 4 assault battalions of 920 people each were formed in October."

        Point “c)” is especially helpful smile
    3. 0
      April 15 2020
      The massive deployment of defectors and saboteur agents by the Germans and huge losses in NKVD personnel (the border guards who were supposed to be engaged in catching and filtering in the near rear ended up in battle) dictated such measures. And only with such draconian methods was it possible to neutralize the efforts of the German special services.
  54. +2
    April 14 2020
    Remember, brothers and sisters, the servant of God Alexander, who laid down his soul for his little children. The kingdom of heaven to him!
    My poem dedicated to the feat of Alexander Petrovich Mamkin: https://stihi.ru/2016/04/15/6846
  55. +1
    April 14 2020
    Modern power is in a split world - you want to rely on heroic history - and this is the Soviet period. Cognitive dissonance arises, hence the insanity towards political instructors, commanders and Smershevites.

    Art is a reflection of the authorities' order for historical representation of the Soviet period.
  56. -2
    April 14 2020
    Igor Matveev is completely unaware of the issue and is forming another myth.

    About regimental operas from the same memoirs:

    That we were all shrouded in a surveillance system, like a web, is clear. But what kind of people were raging in it? Do they have normal human feelings: honor, shame, decency, sympathy... Somewhere deep inside a few, it seems, they still rested.

    Somewhat later, in Stalin’s last winter, sitting in my office, another detective, Lieutenant Colonel Verchik, suddenly began to cry quietly, with his arms stretched across the table and his head bowed low. He regularly came to me to inquire in detail about all sorts of statutory violations, misdeeds, and even emergencies, if they happened, trying to dig out in them at least some signs of enemy actions. But there, to his chagrin, there was no smell of anything like that.

    - What to do, what to do? - he sobbed, shaking his shoulders. “I was ordered to expose one enemy of the people every year.”

    It sounded scary. The hunt was carried out blindfolded for anyone. Anyone could become a victim - either through a careless word or through the revenge of the fiscal.

    - How can I help you? — I sincerely sympathized with Verchik. “You know the regiment as well as I do.” Well, someone from the barracks can go AWOL, end up getting cut up from the heart, or even punch someone in the face due to drunkenness. And I don’t expect anything upsetting from the officers at all. But what does this have to do with enemies of the people?

    This not only did not console him, but plunged him into terrible hopelessness, for which he could pay for himself.

    The unfortunate opera was saved by the death of Stalin. And not only him...
    — Or maybe they were mistaken in accusing Lepekhin of mortal sins? — I asked Fedotov carefully.

    - Our people are not mistaken! — the operator instantly snapped.

    My seemingly innocent question did not melt into space. A week or two later, the division commander, General Tikhonov, took me aside, severely reprimanded me for my carelessness and, at the end of the lecture, whispered angrily:

    - Keep your mouth shut, soar!
    Vasily Gavrilovich was not the last authority where my conversation with Fedotov reached. The head of the special department of the air army, Colonel Gaiduk, also knew about it, and once “appropriately” reminded me of my dangerous question at a meeting of the army’s military council, where I was “regulated” on a completely different matter.


    "What happened, happened"
    Reshetnikov Vasily Vasilyevich - Honored Military Pilot of the USSR, GSS, 307 combat missions, Colonel General, ADD regiment commander, division commander, corps commander, commander of long-range aviation of the USSR (1969-1980), deputy commander-in-chief of the USSR Air Force (1981-1986).

    Such memoirs are more credible than the conclusions of unremarkable dreamers of worthless articles.
    1. -3
      April 14 2020

      The NKVD major who interrogated Heveshi and Lepekhin was not so simple as to let both of them go free without exposing them for “living well.” according to his vile calling and “duty of service”, at least one of them as an enemy of the people.

      In the complex vicissitudes of Lepekhin’s camp life, the major managed to cut loose and throw accusations at them, incriminating the disruption of a group escape and betraying military secrets to the enemy, since the coded logbook of radio traffic was in the hands of the Germans.

      The punishment tribunal was quick: 10 years!

      Then, in 46, this was the maximum term, beyond which - execution. A year later they were already given 25, and it was as if they soldered it to Lepekhin, which was reported with genuine triumph to me, at that time the regiment commander, by our operative officer of the special department of the KGB, Captain G. Fedotov - “George the Victorious,” as she called him in a chant, glowing with adoration , an old shtetl mother, not suspecting that this name had already taken root as a poisonous underground nickname among everyone who knew this ubiquitous opera. [263]
      Is it worth describing the circles of hell through which the combat pilot Tero of the Soviet Union, Captain Gavriil Vasilyevich Lepekhin, who was deprived of all awards and titles, went through in the hard labor camps of the Gulag? At all levels of our iron party and state power, no one wanted to hear his mournful long-term plea to reconsider the “case”, to understand the monstrous injustice of his conviction.
      Only in 1956, three years after the death of Stalin and the execution of Beria, at the “thaw” of the XNUMXth Party Congress, his turn came: innocent! But he came out of our native places of detention as a seriously and deeply ill, physically and mentally suffering man.

      Lepekhin worked at Voronezh enterprises for a long time, was awarded labor orders, but until the end of his days, struggling with ailments, he never overcame them.

      The counterintelligence officers did not take their eyes off Hevesy. [265]

      It is so easy to escape punishment for being captured - this is too much! And the nets were laid. Where is the evidence that the first two months were spent recovering and on the way to Polotsk, and not in a fascist intelligence school where spies are trained? Akosh Akosevich fought for a long time with his pursuers, but did not fall into despondency.
      He took the train, landed at the familiar village of Slabadai near Vilkovishkis, not far from which he landed by parachute, and again walked on foot all the way to Polotsk, collecting certificates and certificates along the way, signed by eyewitnesses of that spring cross-country in 18 and certified by the authorities. The alibi turned out to be one hundred percent. Hevesi just didn’t know who he was dealing with. The prosecutor of the ADD (at that time of the XNUMXth Air Army), General Nikolaev, had new accusations in store - of supporting, protecting and almost complicit in the “crimes” of Lepekhin, exposed as an “enemy of the people.” Hevesi became disheveled, resisted investigative provocations for a long time and stubbornly, knocked out all their trump cards and managed to defend himself. Nikolaev fell silent.

      Who wrote? GSS Reshetnikov Vasily Vasilievich -
      1. +1
        April 14 2020
        Quote: Dmitry Vladimirovich
        the coded logbook of radio traffic ended up in the hands of the Germans.

        That is, you're welcome??
        1. -2
          April 14 2020
          Quote: avia12005

          That is, you're welcome??


          "Yeah - taiga taiga, I'm a birch..."
          changes weekly

          Try to destroy a magazine in a downed and falling plane - the surprise is that it survived.
          1. +1
            April 14 2020
            If you understood something about this, you would know that even now there is also responsibility for the loss of such documents. And criminal. Even when maintaining a database.
            1. -1
              April 14 2020
              Quote: avia12005
              If only you understood something about this, that even now there is also responsibility for the loss of such documents.


              I had the opportunity to work with clearances and my materials were “secret” at one time and I was familiarized with and informed of the responsibility, but you are the only one who understands :))

              By the way, there have been no logs for a long time; communication encryption systems operate on different algorithms.
              1. +1
                April 14 2020
                So you are younger than me. I also found equipment from those times.
        2. -1
          April 14 2020
          Quote: avia12005
          That is, you're welcome??


          Under Lepekhin's plane was East Prussia - the most natural Germany. The left engine was on fire and the connection was lost. It was not possible to put out the flames by sliding. The height was lost rapidly. The commander gave the command to leave the plane with a light signal, pressing all three multi-colored buttons at once. He waited a little, opened the canopy and, sharply pushing the steering wheel away from himself, flew out of the cockpit. The high boots, like Garankin’s, were not fastened and flew off when the parachute opened. The plane quickly reached the ground and burst into flames. To avoid a possible collision with the Germans, attracted by the fire, Lepekhin began to energetically slide away from it, but, having missed the moment of meeting the ground in the darkness, he did not have time to release the lines and landed at a very high vertical speed.

          I woke up on the bed, completely broken and riddled with unbearable pain. There were German soldiers in the room. In the evening, a truck appeared, and the soldiers, throwing the motionless body into the back, shook it, experiencing severe suffering with every jolt, to the Moritzfeld camp. He was dragged for interrogation - he could not stand. Lepekhin began posing as an air gunner, but in the same camp his gunner-radio operator Mikhail Burenok was already sitting, and Lepekhin’s identity card was dangling in the hands of the Germans. The legend did not happen.


          Teach me how to destroy a magazine if you are a pilot and the gunner-radio operator is sitting in the fuselage of an IL-4?
          1. +1
            April 14 2020
            What should I teach you? Where does the navigator sit on the IL-4? And there were 4 shooters on the IL-2.
            1. +1
              April 15 2020
              Reshetnikov writes that Lepekhin flew on a mission without a shooter. The author of the memoirs did not explain why he did this (whether it was a violation or this was allowed in the ADD).

              A German fighter approached the bomber and, taking advantage of the gunner’s absence, attacked Lepekhin’s plane with impunity.

              From Reshetnikov’s memoirs it follows that the standard altitude at which IL-4s flew bombing was 4500 meters, it is likely that Lepekhin’s IL was attacked by a German fighter at a similar altitude. This is confirmed by Lepekhin’s attempt to knock out the flames from the burning engine by “sliding” and only after the failure of this attempt did the crew leave the plane.
              Therefore, he had a reserve of altitude and time to bring the magazine into an “unreadable” state.

              Were there any instructions (orders) on what to do with secret documentation in such situations? I suppose so.
              Were they fulfilled? No.
            2. -2
              April 15 2020
              Quote: avia12005
              What should I teach you? Where does the navigator sit on the IL-4? And there were 4 shooters on the IL-2.

              Ignorant.
              The navigator does not conduct radio communication; on the IL-4, only the gunner-radio operator operates the key.
              It is impossible to get into his cabin from the commander's cabin.
              What this coded journal was like was described

              Memoirs Redyushev Andrey Fedorovich gunner-radio operator IL-4:
              A.F.: The plane takes off, and until I establish contact, it circles over the airfield, during the flight I maintain contact, I listen more. The operating mode was Morse code; one’s station was determined by its tonality - the radio operator had to have a “musical” ear. And in combat conditions the codes changed all the time - before departure, I had to learn them like a poem. To reach the goal, communication is one-sided: I am only at the reception, after completing the task, and I report the completion, ask for bearings, etc. We have developed codes for almost all standard and non-standard situations. Messages consisted of three numbers or letters. A.F.: Sometimes light was needed at the workplace to look at the cheat sheet - you can’t remember all the code tables.

              That is, the operator found fault with the loss of the magazine - which did not carry any useful information, a tactical set of encodings - almost disposable. The operative earned a medal - to incriminate an “enemy of the people.”
              1. +1
                April 15 2020
                Fabulous. As a great “teacher,” doesn’t the fact that after the loss of such codes from the cruiser Ausburg during the First World War and its transfer into the hands of Great Britain by Russia, tell you anything, the Germans lost a lot of ships and people? And the successful hunt for Enigma during World War II brought the same result.

                Well, yes, we must immediately prove with all our might that Reshetnikov and Lepyokhin are all in white, and that SMERSH, the NKVD, etc. committed atrocities at the front. So why did Lepyokhin fly without a shooter, huh? And who was in touch? Did he fly without HF communications at all? Who is to blame for the loss of the combat vehicle? The pilot himself, the command of the regiment and division? But you don’t care, it’s the opera’s fault. In fact, for such a tribunal and sending to a penal battalion would be too lenient an outcome.
                The icing on the cake: the flight crew was required to hand over documents and military awards before a combat mission. Your Lepyokhin managed not to do this, and brought his ID to the Germans...
                1. -3
                  April 15 2020
                  Quote: avia12005
                  And the successful hunt for Enigma during World War II brought the same result.


                  You are comparing the incomparable - what is the ADD radio operator transmitting?
                  ...weather on the route, above the target, the target is closed, I'm going to a backup target, the mission is completed, attacked by a fighter, the right engine is on, the left engine is on... etc. - that is, the log contains three-digit entries of uninteresting tactical information - this is the level of the tactical link, it is absolutely not encryption-proof, since it is not interesting for hacking and it is easier to change it weekly!
                  You are trying to compare with enigma - which is a higher level of strategic management and is incomparably more encryption resistant.
                  I’m more than sure that you should distinguish such concepts, but you still persist in your ignorance, although after you mentioned the deputy commander of the Air Force Reshetnikov, what can you expect?
                  "militant patriot" and nothing more.
                  1. 0
                    April 15 2020
                    Talking to you is the same as talking to a wall. You don't answer questions, but repeat the same thing. Arividerchi. Not interested.
      2. +2
        April 14 2020
        Naturally, there were enough fools in the authorities, and there were also scoundrels. My mother, who went from Stalingrad to the Elbe as part of the 104th OBDES (road maintenance service), said that one day one of their platoon came to the dugout, all bawled, and said: “all the girls, I can’t - the special officer recruited me today, nickname Chamomile gave." Everyone fell silent, and one said, “Forget-me-not for me.” and And everyone vied with each other - “and I have Buttercup”, “and I have Rose”. In short, he “recruited” everyone and called them flowers. But these are isolated cases.
    2. 0
      April 14 2020
      You write according to the methodology of Radio Liberty. You take memoirs or statements and draw conclusions about everyone and everything.
      1. -2
        April 14 2020
        Quote: avia12005
        You write according to the methodology of Radio Liberty. You take memoirs or statements and draw conclusions about everyone and everything.


        Yes, yes - the inferiority of some scribblers is limited to insulting others by writing according to manuals, indicating the poverty of their own thinking.

        Reshetnikov Vasily Vasilyevich wrote so that it would become clear to the poor -
        according to his vile calling and “duty of service”
        ,.
        1. +1
          April 14 2020
          Oh, how polite you are. In fact, you have nothing to say.

          Without getting personal, I will say that Reshetnikov was far from being an angel who should be blindly trusted. We are all humans. And everyone makes mistakes.
          1. -2
            April 14 2020
            Quote: avia12005
            Oh, how polite you are. In fact, you have nothing to say.


            Personally, I did not insult you in any way - the accusations of fantasizing are obvious.
            I deliberately cited the memoirs of the highest military commander, who was familiar with the methods of the NKVD firsthand both in the war and in the post-war period.
            If you read his memoirs, this is not an exceptional case of the dominance of the NKVD operatives - this is a system of surveillance/terror that had developed and flourished before Stalin’s death.
            1. +1
              April 14 2020
              What is obvious to you is not obvious to history. And others. Essentially, the article asks the question of how truthful and ethical modern Russian war cinema is. My answer is no way. In "The Living and the Dead" there is another special officer. It's a lie? And the German saboteurs in the Urals, former soldiers of the Red Army, who landed there, are also lies? Was it necessary to catch them?
          2. -2
            April 14 2020
            Quote: avia12005
            I will say that Reshetnikov was far from an angel


            Well, as expected, persist in your ignorance - usually people like you start, “Who wrote this, he’s an agent himself...”
            No, my dear, dear Vasily Vasilyevich, a “professional patriot,” definitely wrote about you:
            Some “official” persons were very wary of NATO smiles and welcome gestures captured in the photo, not without reason believing that they were not left without the same response from our pilots, which was seen as a loss of the proper level of vigilance and insufficiently educated hatred for world imperialism. And it was not known that hatred, the upbringing of which "professional patriots" worked so hard, abstractly, by itself, cannot settle in the soul of a normal person, for it is born only out of love - love for the fatherland, for one’s people, for one’s life, to the family finally. Good and love live in the soul of a patriot, not evil and hatred.

            Reshetnikov V.V.
            "What happened, happened"
    3. +1
      April 14 2020
      In how smile Were all regimental operas like this? In all parts? Well well. A common sign of not having your own thoughts is the use of quotes.

      There was one case that I witnessed, when a person with general’s shoulder straps did not behave very decently in a canteen in Monino after the Air Force Military Council towards the waitress. And another person with the same shoulder straps hit him in the face. After which he calmed down. Does it follow from this that all the pilot generals were drunkards and massacres? This is how you judge everyone. So, after all, how do you like modern domestic films about the war, and not opera in them?
  57. +4
    April 14 2020
    Quote: Varyag_0711
    after watching the movie "Bastards"

    After watching it, I just want to say - “Bastards” was made by bastards.
  58. +6
    April 14 2020
    On the grave crisis in contemporary Russian war cinema
    Is it only in the military? And in other genres do people have the happiness of seeing masterpieces?
    The author is already trying to present modern Russian cinema in general and “military” cinema in particular as a kind of thing in itself that stubbornly runs counter to the demands of society.
    It doesn't happen that way. Cinema is a direct reflection of the socio-cultural state of society. We won’t talk about arthouse, this is a separate phenomenon. We are talking about mass commercial cinema.
    Since society and time require not masterpieces for centuries, but perishable, bright one-day films to pass across the screens, shine and be thrown into the trash, then these will be filmed. If the needs of society require not sculpting, but cooking, they will cook. Moreover, these processes take place not only in films. Maybe it’s different in music, fine arts, literature? No, exactly the same. Nothing amazing, nothing powerful, nothing memorable. Painting naked male and female loins on camera, on stage and in books is not art.
    So it's not because of bad filmmakers. To paraphrase a well-known maxim, every society has the cinema it deserves.
    1. 0
      April 15 2020
      Quote: Undecim
      So it's not because of bad filmmakers. To paraphrase a well-known maxim, every society has the cinema it deserves.
      Strange. There is no one among my friends who would dream of such a movie. Am I that bad? Or do all site visitors dream of a pile of crap on the heads of their ancestors? Or just self-justification - I’m all white and fluffy, but the neighbors are soooo! No, dear, it’s just an order, just an order to the waiter in a restaurant “make it beautiful for me, brother, with special effects and make Kolchak in white.” “Certainly, sir, this moment!” And the sex director runs and the waiter-actor makes a courageous face with hidden sadness. Capitalism on the street, dear. He who pays calls the tune.
      1. +1
        April 15 2020
        Who pays, he orders the music.
        They just pay for the litter exclusively. What's so?
  59. +1
    April 14 2020
    Quote: novel xnumx
    to condemn bastard directors and scriptwriters, and beat them affordably - this is their only weak point

    This foul play is so sick and tired that among the people there was a strong desire to hit not only the pocketbook!
  60. +2
    April 14 2020
    I watch Soviet films. The remakes do not reflect the spirit of the war and post-war times.
  61. 0
    April 14 2020
    Let's just say that the filmography of the USSR about the Second World War was different:
    1) During the war and immediately after - the Germans were shown to be idiots - see the feat of a scout, but ours were shown differently, but with elements of propaganda - Two fighters, etc.
    2) In the 60s, the picture changed - they began to study people in war - the Germans and ours are already normal people, as for the polished Germans - see the film Shield and Sword request
    As for now, cinema is perceived either as in the war - propaganda (28 Panfilovites) or they study a person... The problem is that both approaches have already been studied earlier - therefore epigonism, and people were different then, and artists judge by themselves ... request
    There are exceptions: We are from the future, White Tiger and Citadel...
    The attempts are different, but interesting... that’s why they cause either complete rejection or delight... hi
    In general, it’s time to stop making films about the Second World War, except documentaries about forgotten heroes... feel
  62. +1
    April 14 2020
    On the grave crisis in contemporary Russian war cinema

    This is not a cinema crisis, but the fulfillment of a social order from a certain part of our elite.
  63. +1
    April 14 2020
    We need folk films, not fakes for a lot of money! for example, 321 rifle... I still can’t wait
  64. 0
    April 14 2020
    Today's movie businessmen have no morals at all. Making money at any cost and in any form is their credo.
  65. +1
    April 14 2020
    Quote: begemot20091
    And the series about combat swimmers????!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Mura, Shchura, Cat, Bagheera.... It's easier for Ussa. For a hundred wounds, cellular communication. The captain points to the rear admiral. They fly wherever I want, when I want and on whatever I want... An utter madhouse.

    I'll stand up for the Sea Devils. I know that it’s one continuous “jamb”, starting with nicknames and ending with the admiral, who personally saves the world with his fists. Including super-duper communications and automation that works in any tunnel. Including the ancient hardware rack (in the background) in their state-of-the-art control center. But, despite all this, he is somehow kind and naive, this is a series.
  66. +2
    April 14 2020
    Among the mystical ones on the theme of the Second World War, the White Tiger is interesting, and “Brest Fortress” is very good.
    I would advise you to watch the television series “According to the Laws of Martial Time” based on the Second World War.
    But modern films are now based on the Second World War and WW2, either dirt on the blessed memory of all those who died for a just cause against the Nazis and their minions... or whitening their “true” history and pressure on pseudo-patriotism, no matter what country we are talking about.
    If the director, actors, and crew do not put their soul into the film... then it turns out to be another “patriotic movie” for laundering the invested money.
    1. -1
      April 25 2020
      The destruction of the entire Russian Soviet civilization began a long time ago and continues to this day. If anyone thinks that the war that the Anglo-Saxon Zionists unleashed against the USSR at the hands of Hitler’s Germany, to which, according to their plan, ambitious Japan should have joined, then if someone thinks that this war ended on May 9, 1945, he is very mistaken . That old war, unleashed for the sake of the immense enrichment of the non-humans who rule the Western world, not only did not end, it intensified even more, this war simply began to be waged in a completely different dimension and took on different forms. However, it is well known as the cold information war.
      Has anyone ever wondered why the former “allies” of the USSR in the war with Nazi Germany, supported by the combined power of all occupied Europe, suddenly became enemies of the Soviet Union after the victory over it? But this is obvious - they have always been enemies of the Russian people, since they have long dreamed of taking control of the lands rich in natural resources on which the Russian people lived and live. And it was planned to do this back in 1917, when the tsarist government was overthrown by the hands of the corrupt bourgeoisie.
      But then nothing came of it - power was wrested from the hands of the bourgeoisie by the Bolsheviks and Lenin’s party, which was supported by almost the entire Russian people. In the shortest period by historical standards, just a quarter of a century, the only real (and not fake like the USA) superpower on our planet was created from a former peasant agrarian country. By the beginning of the 50s, a good half of the entire Earth was on the side of the Soviet project. Just a little more - and our red project would become worldwide. Alas, this did not happen, although we were only a step away from it, if Stalin’s course had been continued by his successor.
      It was with the Khrushchev counter-revolutionary coup, carried out in the cold summer of 1953, that the gradual and systematic destruction of the great country and the only correct for the world of the Russian global red project of building an alternative fair, humane, crisis-free world order began, in which, according to the plan of its creators, only the honest work of everyone for the benefit of all should would be in demand and valued.
      Here is part of my review of the series "The Great War", in which I explain why I categorically do not recommend ALL modern films about that war...
      In those years, the soldiers of the Red Army and the working Soviet people defended their Motherland in the name of a future in which they would never be dominated by the corrupt and vile power of the bourgeoisie, ready to commit any crimes against the people for the sake of profit and their well-being. Only once in human history, not ordinary traditional revolutionaries who sought to seize power for the sake of redistributing the sweet pie, but real ideological people who were ready to work selflessly and selflessly for a completely different future, in which there will be no oppressors and the oppressed, came to power in a huge country. in which people will not be divided into first and second class, into those who have everything and those who have nothing at all.
      And now in the modern Russian Federation the power of transnational occupation capital reigns...
      Western parasites, the financial elite of the USA and Great Britain, who have long wanted to conquer the richest lands of the Russian people, drew conclusions from the results of World War II and realized that the Russian people cannot be conquered by force.
      They acted much simpler - they recruited traitors from the top of the CPSU, starting with the scoundrel Khrushchev and since then the USSR, and now, after its collapse and destruction, Russia is firmly captured by immensely greedy non-humans working for the USA and Britain.
      There is no independent government in Russia, because we are ruled by IMF puppets and proteges of Western transnational corporations. They do not have their own will at all, because even the “return” of Crimea was just a gambit by the West to strengthen the rating of its appointee and successor of Gorbachev’s work - Yeltsin, whose popularity began to decline by 14. In the wake of Crimea, an ironclad justification for the systematic decline in living standards appeared - after all, they say, sanctions. This is just a show for suckers. What kind of fight with the West?
      The entire “elite” of the Russian Federation are collaborators and accomplices of the occupiers. The overwhelming majority of this “elite” have accounts in foreign banks, real estate abroad, and even businesses established there. And all of them, as one, call for rallying around President Putin to protect Russia from external enemies... Many of these Gavriks don’t even live here, they just come to look after them and take money over the hill.
      No external enemies would ever do what the internal traitors did, for the sake of their cookies in the form of foreign accounts, luxury cars, yachts and mansions abroad, they betrayed their country and its people.
      For the best effect, a non-obvious form of occupation was chosen specifically for Russia and its mentality. There are no NATO troops marching through the city streets, there are no curfews, there are no gas chambers or death camps, there are no tortures and mass executions, that is, everything that would immediately cause rage among the people, a wave of indignation and, as a result, resistance to the occupiers.
      That is why there is nothing except the Russian government itself, which is quietly implementing the Ost plan, which was not implemented by Hitler. It’s high time to realize this, but the people who stupidly bought a handful of beads in the form of foreign cars and an abundance of imported goods have yet to realize this terrifying truth. But that's it for now. No amount of media tricks and babble can erase the truth of life. So, all the same, the people will be forced to wake up and come out of the world of illusions into which they fell from the moment when all the USSR media were captured by the enemies of the Russian Soviet people. And this happened in the cold summer of 1953.
      It’s a pity that I don’t have the opportunity to speak out to the whole country yet. In general, this would have to be conveyed to all people on the planet, because there is no alternative for humanity at all.
      “Without theory we are dead.” These were precisely the last words of Stalin during his lifetime, which were preserved for posterity. Communism is definitely not a religion, it is absolutely an achievable future, into which you can get from socialism with the help of a long-term education of a new person from childhood. Only people for whom honest work and the realization of all their abilities for the benefit of society will be able to build a communist economy. It is possible if any form of parasitism on the work of others is unthinkable, simply impossible for the people of the future. Then everyone, including officials, will really work for the good of society. Indeed, with the help of science, it is indeed possible to completely automate production and eliminate many of the unpleasant professions of today. If in the society of the future there will be no parasites left - those who live better than everyone else and at the expense of everyone else, without working. without creating, inventing, teaching or treating, in short, all the worthless creatures that now rule both Russia and the rest of the world - then communism is quite possible without money, which has long ceased to be the equivalent of LABOR, as they were originally conceived for the possibility of exchanging one labor for another . Now money is being printed out of thin air, and this has been going on for more than half a century. And the richest became so through financial speculation, and not through the exploitation of workers.
      But even now the technological level allows us to quickly create conditions for people to live under communism.
      It is enough to remove money from people’s consciousness, to create such conditions that the need for money and its endless accumulation disappears - and the world will be transformed beyond recognition. There will be no desire to accumulate money if everything necessary for a normal life is already available, and almost all crimes and criminals will immediately disappear. If there is no desire to make a business out of the suffering of billions, the alcohol and tobacco business will disappear, drug cartels and drugs will disappear without a trace. There will be no terrorism and wars, which means there will be no need to maintain a huge staff of military and security officials who do not create anything but only consume.
      The progress of science and everything else will incredibly increase - after all, all the productive and scientific efforts of billions will go not to creating ever new types of weapons, but to the prosperity of everyone.
      Only then will humanity really be able to spend enormous resources on fundamental science, and only then will the road to other planets and star systems truly open, and people will be able to truly live, without the daily race to earn a living.
      Personally, I see, moreover, I am deeply convinced that a world in which the main ideal for the majority is to have a large amount of money in their accounts and the desire to do nothing, but to receive more than others is doomed. This is a dead end from which humanity will not be able to get out if most people do not learn to think, analyze, or at least trust and follow those who know how to do this.
  67. +3
    April 14 2020
    For example, Sergeant Sirotinin or Private Perederia, left alone with their guns to cover their retreating comrades, one in Belarus, and the second in Krasnodar

    It’s better not to talk about Sirotinin - the story there is dark, not confirmed by documents, and appeared 20 years after the war. Moreover, with each subsequent publication, Sirotinin’s score only grew.
    And most importantly, in exactly the same place and at the same time, the 2nd Battalion of the 409th Infantry Regiment of the 137th Infantry Division took on the battle with the Eberbach Kampfgruppe. Commander - Nikolai Andreevich Kim (Chong Phung), captain.
    A full-blooded battalion (six hundred people, one stray 122 mm howitzer, four 45 mm anti-tank guns and twelve machine guns) delayed the Germans for four hours, after which they were forced to retreat.

    If you are going to film about a feat, then you need to take a 146% reliable fact in advance, confirmed from both sides. Like this:

    Ilyinsky lines. 1941 One artillery bunker and one anti-aircraft gun knocked out a company of German Pz.38(t), reinforced by a pair of Pz.IVs, in ten minutes. One of the “fours” is regularly identified in photographs as a “stug” - due to the detonation of its ammunition, its turret flew off. smile
  68. +1
    April 14 2020
    So I call on you to “fry” the military film industry of the above-mentioned kind with the entire proletarian. Just watch and fry from the first day. There are hundreds of us all over the country. Thousands will read and reflect. Maybe more... Look, the guys will go broke. But, I want to note that a good action movie about the war with our heroic fighters and special effects is really needed. The population of the Russian Federation is not alone in forty-year-old slackers.
  69. +1
    April 14 2020
    - Yes... Our comments are a ready-made script for a film about the work of “their” ideological saboteurs against our memory...
    - I don’t remember who called for looking for stupidity or negligence in everything that happens before intentional harm!
    - Too many years have passed, and too few eyewitnesses of past events remain, and less and less can one hope for the memory of those living today. Memoirs are a separate article altogether.
    - It’s very easy to trace the degradation of films over time: The further from the war, the less realistic (from our point of view, again) the events and experiences of the characters become. There is no one to advise and suggest...
    - They started talking about the authenticity of the plots already at the end of the Union - the 80s... I remember how in one of the programs a veteran gave the filmmakers a phrase that if the Germans were so stupid and half-drunk, we would not have fought with them for four whole years and so many people would not have died... And what an honor to defeat such an unlucky enemy!
    - The situation in films about the Great Patriotic War is not difficult to understand if you look at what films have been made about events that are closer in time: Afghanistan, Chechnya, Transnistria... Has at least one film been made about which people living today (and in firm memory) They said: “YES! That’s how it all happened... From the first to the last minute!”
    - If no one removes the truth about this now, it will be impossible to remove them later... Generations will change, and together with them the worldview will change.
    - Speaking about American films on the theme of war (more modern, of course), it is worth noting that the best of them were filmed in collaboration with bearers of the memory of the events (The Pacific Ocean and Brother in Arms).
    - A separate short film was actually shot about the preparation and filming of the film “We Were Soldiers and We Were Young....” At that time, Hal Moore was alive and consulted on the film.
    - To be honest, I generally doubt the great value of films made about the war with scrupulous accuracy...-
    - How will a modern viewer react to blood, dirt, the stench of corpses, lice, and the death of masses of people for reasons obscure to him? It is precisely the “obscure” that changes the worldview...
    - A simple question: If you were given the opportunity to make a film about your service, would it be of interest to the viewer, or at least to your loved ones?
    -
    1. -1
      April 14 2020
      You know, there is a film by Leonid DavIdovich Lukov, “Two Fighters.” Many people admire him. The film features great actors - Andreev, Bernes, etc. But, my father told me, there is no truth here..., in Sasha-from-Uralmash I believe in a Jew, I don’t. Although I am almost twice as old as my father, he is an authority for me!
      1. 0
        April 15 2020
        - Heroic... At the time when the film was made, it couldn’t have been any other way. Ideology was the basis of the state and society....
    2. 0
      April 25 2020
      The destruction of the entire Russian Soviet civilization began a long time ago and continues to this day. If anyone thinks that the war that the Anglo-Saxon Zionists unleashed against the USSR at the hands of Hitler’s Germany, to which, according to their plan, ambitious Japan should have joined, then if someone thinks that this war ended on May 9, 1945, he is very mistaken . That old war, unleashed for the sake of the immense enrichment of the non-humans who rule the Western world, not only did not end, it intensified even more, this war simply began to be waged in a completely different dimension and took on different forms. However, it is well known as the cold information war.
      Has anyone ever wondered why the former “allies” of the USSR in the war with Nazi Germany, supported by the combined power of all occupied Europe, suddenly became enemies of the Soviet Union after the victory over it? But this is obvious - they have always been enemies of the Russian people, since they have long dreamed of taking control of the lands rich in natural resources on which the Russian people lived and live. And it was planned to do this back in 1917, when the tsarist government was overthrown by the hands of the corrupt bourgeoisie.
      But then nothing came of it - power was wrested from the hands of the bourgeoisie by the Bolsheviks and Lenin’s party, which was supported by almost the entire Russian people. In the shortest period by historical standards, just a quarter of a century, the only real (and not fake like the USA) superpower on our planet was created from a former peasant agrarian country. By the beginning of the 50s, a good half of the entire Earth was on the side of the Soviet project. Just a little more - and our red project would become worldwide. Alas, this did not happen, although we were only a step away from it, if Stalin’s course had been continued by his successor.
      It was with the Khrushchev counter-revolutionary coup, carried out in the cold summer of 1953, that the gradual and systematic destruction of the great country and the only correct for the world of the Russian global red project of building an alternative fair, humane, crisis-free world order began, in which, according to the plan of its creators, only the honest work of everyone for the benefit of all should would be in demand and valued.
      Here is part of my review of the series "The Great War", in which I explain why I categorically do not recommend ALL modern films about that war...
      In those years, the soldiers of the Red Army and the working Soviet people defended their Motherland in the name of a future in which they would never be dominated by the corrupt and vile power of the bourgeoisie, ready to commit any crimes against the people for the sake of profit and their well-being. Only once in human history, not ordinary traditional revolutionaries who sought to seize power for the sake of redistributing the sweet pie, but real ideological people who were ready to work selflessly and selflessly for a completely different future, in which there will be no oppressors and the oppressed, came to power in a huge country. in which people will not be divided into first and second class, into those who have everything and those who have nothing at all.
      And now in the modern Russian Federation the power of transnational occupation capital reigns...
      Western parasites, the financial elite of the USA and Great Britain, who have long wanted to conquer the richest lands of the Russian people, drew conclusions from the results of World War II and realized that the Russian people cannot be conquered by force.
      They acted much simpler - they recruited traitors from the top of the CPSU, starting with the scoundrel Khrushchev and since then the USSR, and now, after its collapse and destruction, Russia is firmly captured by immensely greedy non-humans working for the USA and Britain.
      There is no independent government in Russia, because we are ruled by IMF puppets and proteges of Western transnational corporations. They do not have their own will at all, because even the “return” of Crimea was just a gambit by the West to strengthen the rating of its appointee and successor of Gorbachev’s work - Yeltsin, whose popularity began to decline by 14. In the wake of Crimea, an ironclad justification for the systematic decline in living standards appeared - after all, they say, sanctions. This is just a show for suckers. What kind of fight with the West?
      The entire “elite” of the Russian Federation are collaborators and accomplices of the occupiers. The overwhelming majority of this “elite” have accounts in foreign banks, real estate abroad, and even businesses established there. And all of them, as one, call for rallying around President Putin to protect Russia from external enemies... Many of these Gavriks don’t even live here, they just come to look after them and take money over the hill.
      No external enemies would ever do what the internal traitors did, for the sake of their cookies in the form of foreign accounts, luxury cars, yachts and mansions abroad, they betrayed their country and its people.
      For the best effect, a non-obvious form of occupation was chosen specifically for Russia and its mentality. There are no NATO troops marching through the city streets, there are no curfews, there are no gas chambers or death camps, there are no tortures and mass executions, that is, everything that would immediately cause rage among the people, a wave of indignation and, as a result, resistance to the occupiers.
      That is why there is nothing except the Russian government itself, which is quietly implementing the Ost plan, which was not implemented by Hitler. It’s high time to realize this, but the people who stupidly bought a handful of beads in the form of foreign cars and an abundance of imported goods have yet to realize this terrifying truth. But that's it for now. No amount of media tricks and babble can erase the truth of life. So, all the same, the people will be forced to wake up and come out of the world of illusions into which they fell from the moment when all the USSR media were captured by the enemies of the Russian Soviet people. And this happened in the cold summer of 1953.
      It’s a pity that I don’t have the opportunity to speak out to the whole country yet. In general, this would have to be conveyed to all people on the planet, because there is no alternative for humanity at all.
      “Without theory we are dead.” These were precisely the last words of Stalin during his lifetime, which were preserved for posterity. Communism is definitely not a religion, it is absolutely an achievable future, into which you can get from socialism with the help of a long-term education of a new person from childhood. Only people for whom honest work and the realization of all their abilities for the benefit of society will be able to build a communist economy. It is possible if any form of parasitism on the work of others is unthinkable, simply impossible for the people of the future. Then everyone, including officials, will really work for the good of society. Indeed, with the help of science, it is indeed possible to completely automate production and eliminate many of the unpleasant professions of today. If in the society of the future there will be no parasites left - those who live better than everyone else and at the expense of everyone else, without working. without creating, inventing, teaching or treating, in short, all the worthless creatures that now rule both Russia and the rest of the world - then communism is quite possible without money, which has long ceased to be the equivalent of LABOR, as they were originally conceived for the possibility of exchanging one labor for another . Now money is being printed out of thin air, and this has been going on for more than half a century. And the richest became so through financial speculation, and not through the exploitation of workers.
      But even now the technological level allows us to quickly create conditions for people to live under communism.
      It is enough to remove money from people’s consciousness, to create such conditions that the need for money and its endless accumulation disappears - and the world will be transformed beyond recognition. There will be no desire to accumulate money if everything necessary for a normal life is already available, and almost all crimes and criminals will immediately disappear. If there is no desire to make a business out of the suffering of billions, the alcohol and tobacco business will disappear, drug cartels and drugs will disappear without a trace. There will be no terrorism and wars, which means there will be no need to maintain a huge staff of military and security officials who do not create anything but only consume.
      The progress of science and everything else will incredibly increase - after all, all the productive and scientific efforts of billions will go not to creating ever new types of weapons, but to the prosperity of everyone.
      Only then will humanity really be able to spend enormous resources on fundamental science, and only then will the road to other planets and star systems truly open, and people will be able to truly live, without the daily race to earn a living.
      Personally, I see, moreover, I am deeply convinced that a world in which the main ideal for the majority is to have a large amount of money in their accounts and the desire to do nothing, but to receive more than others is doomed. This is a dead end from which humanity will not be able to get out if most people do not learn to think, analyze, or at least trust and follow those who know how to do this.
  70. +2
    April 14 2020
    Soviet cinema was destroyed, but they didn’t create their own to replace it! Copying the Western turns out to be pathetic......all about our cinema “in three words”!
    1. 0
      April 25 2020
      The destruction of the entire Russian Soviet civilization began a long time ago and continues to this day. If anyone thinks that the war that the Anglo-Saxon Zionists unleashed against the USSR at the hands of Hitler’s Germany, to which, according to their plan, ambitious Japan should have joined, then if someone thinks that this war ended on May 9, 1945, he is very mistaken . That old war, unleashed for the sake of the immense enrichment of the non-humans who rule the Western world, not only did not end, it intensified even more, this war simply began to be waged in a completely different dimension and took on different forms. However, it is well known as the cold information war.
      Has anyone ever wondered why the former “allies” of the USSR in the war with Nazi Germany, supported by the combined power of all occupied Europe, suddenly became enemies of the Soviet Union after the victory over it? But this is obvious - they have always been enemies of the Russian people, since they have long dreamed of taking control of the lands rich in natural resources on which the Russian people lived and live. And it was planned to do this back in 1917, when the tsarist government was overthrown by the hands of the corrupt bourgeoisie.
      But then nothing came of it - power was wrested from the hands of the bourgeoisie by the Bolsheviks and Lenin’s party, which was supported by almost the entire Russian people. In the shortest period by historical standards, just a quarter of a century, the only real (and not fake like the USA) superpower on our planet was created from a former peasant agrarian country. By the beginning of the 50s, a good half of the entire Earth was on the side of the Soviet project. Just a little more - and our red project would become worldwide. Alas, this did not happen, although we were only a step away from it, if Stalin’s course had been continued by his successor.
      It was with the Khrushchev counter-revolutionary coup, carried out in the cold summer of 1953, that the gradual and systematic destruction of the great country and the only correct for the world of the Russian global red project of building an alternative fair, humane, crisis-free world order began, in which, according to the plan of its creators, only the honest work of everyone for the benefit of all should would be in demand and valued.
      Here is part of my review of the series "The Great War", in which I explain why I categorically do not recommend ALL modern films about that war...
      In those years, the soldiers of the Red Army and the working Soviet people defended their Motherland in the name of a future in which they would never be dominated by the corrupt and vile power of the bourgeoisie, ready to commit any crimes against the people for the sake of profit and their well-being. Only once in human history, not ordinary traditional revolutionaries who sought to seize power for the sake of redistributing the sweet pie, but real ideological people who were ready to work selflessly and selflessly for a completely different future, in which there will be no oppressors and the oppressed, came to power in a huge country. in which people will not be divided into first and second class, into those who have everything and those who have nothing at all.
      And now in the modern Russian Federation the power of transnational occupation capital reigns...
      Western parasites, the financial elite of the USA and Great Britain, who have long wanted to conquer the richest lands of the Russian people, drew conclusions from the results of World War II and realized that the Russian people cannot be conquered by force.
      They acted much simpler - they recruited traitors from the top of the CPSU, starting with the scoundrel Khrushchev and since then the USSR, and now, after its collapse and destruction, Russia is firmly captured by immensely greedy non-humans working for the USA and Britain.
      There is no independent government in Russia, because we are ruled by IMF puppets and proteges of Western transnational corporations. They do not have their own will at all, because even the “return” of Crimea was just a gambit by the West to strengthen the rating of its appointee and successor of Gorbachev’s work - Yeltsin, whose popularity began to decline by 14. In the wake of Crimea, an ironclad justification for the systematic decline in living standards appeared - after all, they say, sanctions. This is just a show for suckers. What kind of fight with the West?
      The entire “elite” of the Russian Federation are collaborators and accomplices of the occupiers. The overwhelming majority of this “elite” have accounts in foreign banks, real estate abroad, and even businesses established there. And all of them, as one, call for rallying around President Putin to protect Russia from external enemies... Many of these Gavriks don’t even live here, they just come to look after them and take money over the hill.
      No external enemies would ever do what the internal traitors did, for the sake of their cookies in the form of foreign accounts, luxury cars, yachts and mansions abroad, they betrayed their country and its people.
      For the best effect, a non-obvious form of occupation was chosen specifically for Russia and its mentality. There are no NATO troops marching through the city streets, there are no curfews, there are no gas chambers or death camps, there are no tortures and mass executions, that is, everything that would immediately cause rage among the people, a wave of indignation and, as a result, resistance to the occupiers.
      That is why there is nothing except the Russian government itself, which is quietly implementing the Ost plan, which was not implemented by Hitler. It’s high time to realize this, but the people who stupidly bought a handful of beads in the form of foreign cars and an abundance of imported goods have yet to realize this terrifying truth. But that's it for now. No amount of media tricks and babble can erase the truth of life. So, all the same, the people will be forced to wake up and come out of the world of illusions into which they fell from the moment when all the USSR media were captured by the enemies of the Russian Soviet people. And this happened in the cold summer of 1953.
      It’s a pity that I don’t have the opportunity to speak out to the whole country yet. In general, this would have to be conveyed to all people on the planet, because there is no alternative for humanity at all.
      “Without theory we are dead.” These were precisely the last words of Stalin during his lifetime, which were preserved for posterity. Communism is definitely not a religion, it is absolutely an achievable future, into which you can get from socialism with the help of a long-term education of a new person from childhood. Only people for whom honest work and the realization of all their abilities for the benefit of society will be able to build a communist economy. It is possible if any form of parasitism on the work of others is unthinkable, simply impossible for the people of the future. Then everyone, including officials, will really work for the good of society. Indeed, with the help of science, it is indeed possible to completely automate production and eliminate many of the unpleasant professions of today. If in the society of the future there will be no parasites left - those who live better than everyone else and at the expense of everyone else, without working. without creating, inventing, teaching or treating, in short, all the worthless creatures that now rule both Russia and the rest of the world - then communism is quite possible without money, which has long ceased to be the equivalent of LABOR, as they were originally conceived for the possibility of exchanging one labor for another . Now money is being printed out of thin air, and this has been going on for more than half a century. And the richest became so through financial speculation, and not through the exploitation of workers.
      But even now the technological level allows us to quickly create conditions for people to live under communism.
      It is enough to remove money from people’s consciousness, to create such conditions that the need for money and its endless accumulation disappears - and the world will be transformed beyond recognition. There will be no desire to accumulate money if everything necessary for a normal life is already available, and almost all crimes and criminals will immediately disappear. If there is no desire to make a business out of the suffering of billions, the alcohol and tobacco business will disappear, drug cartels and drugs will disappear without a trace. There will be no terrorism and wars, which means there will be no need to maintain a huge staff of military and security officials who do not create anything but only consume.
      The progress of science and everything else will incredibly increase - after all, all the productive and scientific efforts of billions will go not to creating ever new types of weapons, but to the prosperity of everyone.
      Only then will humanity really be able to spend enormous resources on fundamental science, and only then will the road to other planets and star systems truly open, and people will be able to truly live, without the daily race to earn a living.
      Personally, I see, moreover, I am deeply convinced that a world in which the main ideal for the majority is to have a large amount of money in their accounts and the desire to do nothing, but to receive more than others is doomed. This is a dead end from which humanity will not be able to get out if most people do not learn to think, analyze, or at least trust and follow those who know how to do this.
  71. Eug
    +2
    April 15 2020
    I don’t believe the current actors, some of them are too sleek... Such a beauty crawls in a miniskirt with tattooed eyebrows, silicone lips, hairstyle, sparkling her bare knees... I don’t believe it! And the heroes - as soon as they leave the gym... And the directing is generally crap! The psychosis in the relationships of the characters, whipped up by Bondarchuk and others, in my opinion, does not in any way correspond to reality... When the front-line soldiers were still consultants, there was authenticity, but now the impression is that, with rare exceptions, the model is not the best Hollywood production...
    P.S. my favorite film about the war is “In War as in War”, and the song from it is simply fantastic...
    1. -1
      April 25 2020
      The destruction of the entire Russian Soviet civilization began a long time ago and continues to this day. If anyone thinks that the war that the Anglo-Saxon Zionists unleashed against the USSR at the hands of Hitler’s Germany, to which, according to their plan, ambitious Japan should have joined, then if someone thinks that this war ended on May 9, 1945, he is very mistaken . That old war, unleashed for the sake of the immense enrichment of the non-humans who rule the Western world, not only did not end, it intensified even more, this war simply began to be waged in a completely different dimension and took on different forms. However, it is well known as the cold information war.
      Has anyone ever wondered why the former “allies” of the USSR in the war with Nazi Germany, supported by the combined power of all occupied Europe, suddenly became enemies of the Soviet Union after the victory over it? But this is obvious - they have always been enemies of the Russian people, since they have long dreamed of taking control of the lands rich in natural resources on which the Russian people lived and live. And it was planned to do this back in 1917, when the tsarist government was overthrown by the hands of the corrupt bourgeoisie.
      But then nothing came of it - power was wrested from the hands of the bourgeoisie by the Bolsheviks and Lenin’s party, which was supported by almost the entire Russian people. In the shortest period by historical standards, just a quarter of a century, the only real (and not fake like the USA) superpower on our planet was created from a former peasant agrarian country. By the beginning of the 50s, a good half of the entire Earth was on the side of the Soviet project. Just a little more - and our red project would become worldwide. Alas, this did not happen, although we were only a step away from it, if Stalin’s course had been continued by his successor.
      It was with the Khrushchev counter-revolutionary coup, carried out in the cold summer of 1953, that the gradual and systematic destruction of the great country and the only correct for the world of the Russian global red project of building an alternative fair, humane, crisis-free world order began, in which, according to the plan of its creators, only the honest work of everyone for the benefit of all should would be in demand and valued.
      Here is part of my review of the series "The Great War", in which I explain why I categorically do not recommend ALL modern films about that war...
      In those years, the soldiers of the Red Army and the working Soviet people defended their Motherland in the name of a future in which they would never be dominated by the corrupt and vile power of the bourgeoisie, ready to commit any crimes against the people for the sake of profit and their well-being. Only once in human history, not ordinary traditional revolutionaries who sought to seize power for the sake of redistributing the sweet pie, but real ideological people who were ready to work selflessly and selflessly for a completely different future, in which there will be no oppressors and the oppressed, came to power in a huge country. in which people will not be divided into first and second class, into those who have everything and those who have nothing at all.
      And now in the modern Russian Federation the power of transnational occupation capital reigns...
      Western parasites, the financial elite of the USA and Great Britain, who have long wanted to conquer the richest lands of the Russian people, drew conclusions from the results of World War II and realized that the Russian people cannot be conquered by force.
      They acted much simpler - they recruited traitors from the top of the CPSU, starting with the scoundrel Khrushchev and since then the USSR, and now, after its collapse and destruction, Russia is firmly captured by immensely greedy non-humans working for the USA and Britain.
      There is no independent government in Russia, because we are ruled by IMF puppets and proteges of Western transnational corporations. They do not have their own will at all, because even the “return” of Crimea was just a gambit by the West to strengthen the rating of its appointee and successor of Gorbachev’s work - Yeltsin, whose popularity began to decline by 14. In the wake of Crimea, an ironclad justification for the systematic decline in living standards appeared - after all, they say, sanctions. This is just a show for suckers. What kind of fight with the West?
      The entire “elite” of the Russian Federation are collaborators and accomplices of the occupiers. The overwhelming majority of this “elite” have accounts in foreign banks, real estate abroad, and even businesses established there. And all of them, as one, call for rallying around President Putin to protect Russia from external enemies... Many of these Gavriks don’t even live here, they just come to look after them and take money over the hill.
      No external enemies would ever do what the internal traitors did, for the sake of their cookies in the form of foreign accounts, luxury cars, yachts and mansions abroad, they betrayed their country and its people.
      For the best effect, a non-obvious form of occupation was chosen specifically for Russia and its mentality. There are no NATO troops marching through the city streets, there are no curfews, there are no gas chambers or death camps, there are no tortures and mass executions, that is, everything that would immediately cause rage among the people, a wave of indignation and, as a result, resistance to the occupiers.
      That is why there is nothing except the Russian government itself, which is quietly implementing the Ost plan, which was not implemented by Hitler. It’s high time to realize this, but the people who stupidly bought a handful of beads in the form of foreign cars and an abundance of imported goods have yet to realize this terrifying truth. But that's it for now. No amount of media tricks and babble can erase the truth of life. So, all the same, the people will be forced to wake up and come out of the world of illusions into which they fell from the moment when all the USSR media were captured by the enemies of the Russian Soviet people. And this happened in the cold summer of 1953.
      It’s a pity that I don’t have the opportunity to speak out to the whole country yet. In general, this would have to be conveyed to all people on the planet, because there is no alternative for humanity at all.
      “Without theory we are dead.” These were precisely the last words of Stalin during his lifetime, which were preserved for posterity. Communism is definitely not a religion, it is absolutely an achievable future, into which you can get from socialism with the help of a long-term education of a new person from childhood. Only people for whom honest work and the realization of all their abilities for the benefit of society will be able to build a communist economy. It is possible if any form of parasitism on the work of others is unthinkable, simply impossible for the people of the future. Then everyone, including officials, will really work for the good of society. Indeed, with the help of science, it is indeed possible to completely automate production and eliminate many of the unpleasant professions of today. If in the society of the future there will be no parasites left - those who live better than everyone else and at the expense of everyone else, without working. without creating, inventing, teaching or treating, in short, all the worthless creatures that now rule both Russia and the rest of the world - then communism is quite possible without money, which has long ceased to be the equivalent of LABOR, as they were originally conceived for the possibility of exchanging one labor for another . Now money is being printed out of thin air, and this has been going on for more than half a century. And the richest became so through financial speculation, and not through the exploitation of workers.
      But even now the technological level allows us to quickly create conditions for people to live under communism.
      It is enough to remove money from people’s consciousness, to create such conditions that the need for money and its endless accumulation disappears - and the world will be transformed beyond recognition. There will be no desire to accumulate money if everything necessary for a normal life is already available, and almost all crimes and criminals will immediately disappear. If there is no desire to make a business out of the suffering of billions, the alcohol and tobacco business will disappear, drug cartels and drugs will disappear without a trace. There will be no terrorism and wars, which means there will be no need to maintain a huge staff of military and security officials who do not create anything but only consume.
      The progress of science and everything else will incredibly increase - after all, all the productive and scientific efforts of billions will go not to creating ever new types of weapons, but to the prosperity of everyone.
      Only then will humanity really be able to spend enormous resources on fundamental science, and only then will the road to other planets and star systems truly open, and people will be able to truly live, without the daily race to earn a living.
      Personally, I see, moreover, I am deeply convinced that a world in which the main ideal for the majority is to have a large amount of money in their accounts and the desire to do nothing, but to receive more than others is doomed. This is a dead end from which humanity will not be able to get out if most people do not learn to think, analyze, or at least trust and follow those who know how to do this.
  72. +4
    April 15 2020
    I watched Stalingrad, I have never seen greater nonsense...
    1. 0
      April 25 2020
      And I left my review on this nonsense. At first it hung on check for 2 months, then it became visible, but only for me personally and not for others. Now it seems to be visible to everyone. This is simply politics in an occupied country.
      The destruction of the entire Russian Soviet civilization began a long time ago and continues to this day. If anyone thinks that the war that the Anglo-Saxon Zionists unleashed against the USSR at the hands of Hitler’s Germany, to which, according to their plan, ambitious Japan should have joined, then if someone thinks that this war ended on May 9, 1945, he is very mistaken . That old war, unleashed for the sake of the immense enrichment of the non-humans who rule the Western world, not only did not end, it intensified even more, this war simply began to be waged in a completely different dimension and took on different forms. However, it is well known as the cold information war.
      Has anyone ever wondered why the former “allies” of the USSR in the war with Nazi Germany, supported by the combined power of all occupied Europe, suddenly became enemies of the Soviet Union after the victory over it? But this is obvious - they have always been enemies of the Russian people, since they have long dreamed of taking control of the lands rich in natural resources on which the Russian people lived and live. And it was planned to do this back in 1917, when the tsarist government was overthrown by the hands of the corrupt bourgeoisie.
      But then nothing came of it - power was wrested from the hands of the bourgeoisie by the Bolsheviks and Lenin’s party, which was supported by almost the entire Russian people. In the shortest period by historical standards, just a quarter of a century, the only real (and not fake like the USA) superpower on our planet was created from a former peasant agrarian country. By the beginning of the 50s, a good half of the entire Earth was on the side of the Soviet project. Just a little more - and our red project would become worldwide. Alas, this did not happen, although we were only a step away from it, if Stalin’s course had been continued by his successor.
      It was with the Khrushchev counter-revolutionary coup, carried out in the cold summer of 1953, that the gradual and systematic destruction of the great country and the only correct for the world of the Russian global red project of building an alternative fair, humane, crisis-free world order began, in which, according to the plan of its creators, only the honest work of everyone for the benefit of all should would be in demand and valued.
      Here is part of my review of the series "The Great War", in which I explain why I categorically do not recommend ALL modern films about that war...
      In those years, the soldiers of the Red Army and the working Soviet people defended their Motherland in the name of a future in which they would never be dominated by the corrupt and vile power of the bourgeoisie, ready to commit any crimes against the people for the sake of profit and their well-being. Only once in human history, not ordinary traditional revolutionaries who sought to seize power for the sake of redistributing the sweet pie, but real ideological people who were ready to work selflessly and selflessly for a completely different future, in which there will be no oppressors and the oppressed, came to power in a huge country. in which people will not be divided into first and second class, into those who have everything and those who have nothing at all.
      And now in the modern Russian Federation the power of transnational occupation capital reigns...
      Western parasites, the financial elite of the USA and Great Britain, who have long wanted to conquer the richest lands of the Russian people, drew conclusions from the results of World War II and realized that the Russian people cannot be conquered by force.
      They acted much simpler - they recruited traitors from the top of the CPSU, starting with the scoundrel Khrushchev and since then the USSR, and now, after its collapse and destruction, Russia is firmly captured by immensely greedy non-humans working for the USA and Britain.
      There is no independent government in Russia, because we are ruled by IMF puppets and proteges of Western transnational corporations. They do not have their own will at all, because even the “return” of Crimea was just a gambit by the West to strengthen the rating of its appointee and successor of Gorbachev’s work - Yeltsin, whose popularity began to decline by 14. In the wake of Crimea, an ironclad justification for the systematic decline in living standards appeared - after all, they say, sanctions. This is just a show for suckers. What kind of fight with the West?
      The entire “elite” of the Russian Federation are collaborators and accomplices of the occupiers. The overwhelming majority of this “elite” have accounts in foreign banks, real estate abroad, and even businesses established there. And all of them, as one, call for rallying around President Putin to protect Russia from external enemies... Many of these Gavriks don’t even live here, they just come to look after them and take money over the hill.
      No external enemies would ever do what the internal traitors did, for the sake of their cookies in the form of foreign accounts, luxury cars, yachts and mansions abroad, they betrayed their country and its people.
      For the best effect, a non-obvious form of occupation was chosen specifically for Russia and its mentality. There are no NATO troops marching through the city streets, there are no curfews, there are no gas chambers or death camps, there are no tortures and mass executions, that is, everything that would immediately cause rage among the people, a wave of indignation and, as a result, resistance to the occupiers.
      That is why there is nothing except the Russian government itself, which is quietly implementing the Ost plan, which was not implemented by Hitler. It’s high time to realize this, but the people who stupidly bought a handful of beads in the form of foreign cars and an abundance of imported goods have yet to realize this terrifying truth. But that's it for now. No amount of media tricks and babble can erase the truth of life. So, all the same, the people will be forced to wake up and come out of the world of illusions into which they fell from the moment when all the USSR media were captured by the enemies of the Russian Soviet people. And this happened in the cold summer of 1953.
      It’s a pity that I don’t have the opportunity to speak out to the whole country yet. In general, this would have to be conveyed to all people on the planet, because there is no alternative for humanity at all.
      “Without theory we are dead.” These were precisely the last words of Stalin during his lifetime, which were preserved for posterity. Communism is definitely not a religion, it is absolutely an achievable future, into which you can get from socialism with the help of a long-term education of a new person from childhood. Only people for whom honest work and the realization of all their abilities for the benefit of society will be able to build a communist economy. It is possible if any form of parasitism on the work of others is unthinkable, simply impossible for the people of the future. Then everyone, including officials, will really work for the good of society. Indeed, with the help of science, it is indeed possible to completely automate production and eliminate many of the unpleasant professions of today. If in the society of the future there will be no parasites left - those who live better than everyone else and at the expense of everyone else, without working. without creating, inventing, teaching or treating, in short, all the worthless creatures that now rule both Russia and the rest of the world - then communism is quite possible without money, which has long ceased to be the equivalent of LABOR, as they were originally conceived for the possibility of exchanging one labor for another . Now money is being printed out of thin air, and this has been going on for more than half a century. And the richest became so through financial speculation, and not through the exploitation of workers.
      But even now the technological level allows us to quickly create conditions for people to live under communism.
      It is enough to remove money from people’s consciousness, to create such conditions that the need for money and its endless accumulation disappears - and the world will be transformed beyond recognition. There will be no desire to accumulate money if everything necessary for a normal life is already available, and almost all crimes and criminals will immediately disappear. If there is no desire to make a business out of the suffering of billions, the alcohol and tobacco business will disappear, drug cartels and drugs will disappear without a trace. There will be no terrorism and wars, which means there will be no need to maintain a huge staff of military and security officials who do not create anything but only consume.
      The progress of science and everything else will incredibly increase - after all, all the productive and scientific efforts of billions will go not to creating ever new types of weapons, but to the prosperity of everyone.
      Only then will humanity really be able to spend enormous resources on fundamental science, and only then will the road to other planets and star systems truly open, and people will be able to truly live, without the daily race to earn a living.
      Personally, I see, moreover, I am deeply convinced that a world in which the main ideal for the majority is to have a large amount of money in their accounts and the desire to do nothing, but to receive more than others is doomed. This is a dead end from which humanity will not be able to get out if most people do not learn to think, analyze, or at least trust and follow those who know how to do this.
  73. -1
    April 15 2020
    In principle, the author is right! But! Recently there have been signs of recovery, for example the film T-34, at least you can watch it without heartburn...
    1. +1
      April 16 2020
      Especially the moment with the handshake between the Soviet tankman and the SS man at the end - very sweet, the tears just flow!
  74. BAI
    +1
    April 15 2020
    They sincerely wanted these individuals with a swastika to free the unfortunate Russians from the Bolshevik concentration camp, but the saduk political officers, NKVD detachment detachments, and personally the maniac Stalin filled up the unfortunate Europeans with corpses and did not allow “to bring the light of freedom to Soviet soil”.

    This is what a political instructor should look like, and what fascists should look like.

  75. 0
    April 15 2020
    Whoever pays is the one who orders the appropriate films.
  76. +1
    April 15 2020
    I haven’t watched anything fresh from a movie for a long time... and now I’ve become humorous. I watched the American series about military pilots - "Catch 22". The genre is a military comedy and yet I saw in the film HEROES who beat the ENEMY!
    In ours, alas and ah... it’s better to remain silent, otherwise there’s only swear words on the tongue.
  77. +1
    April 15 2020
    While we are walking under the Vlasov flag instead of the original Russian Flag - Red and brazenly hiding the Mausoleum, at the foot of which, at the feet of the people who FOREVER changed our Planet - Lenin and Stalin, they threw Nazi-Hitler banners and standards, even on the 75th anniversary of the Great Victory - Mother Rus' will only rot and degrade (primarily the youth - the future of any state). EVEN PETER THE FIRST, WHO DEFEATED THE SWEDES NEAR POLTAVA AND ENDED THEIR CLAIMS FOR EUROPEAN POWER (IN FACTUAL WORLD POWER), WALKED UNDER THE Red Banner!
    1. Alf
      +2
      April 15 2020
      Quote: Viktor HanelisBogatishev
      EVEN PETER THE FIRST, WHO DEFEATED THE SWEDES NEAR POLTAVA AND ENDED THEIR CLAIMS FOR EUROPEAN POWER (IN FACTUAL WORLD POWER), WALKED UNDER THE Red Banner!

      Can you be more specific about the red flag?
    2. 0
      April 25 2020
      The destruction of the entire Russian Soviet civilization began a long time ago and continues to this day. If anyone thinks that the war that the Anglo-Saxon Zionists unleashed against the USSR at the hands of Hitler’s Germany, to which, according to their plan, ambitious Japan should have joined, then if someone thinks that this war ended on May 9, 1945, he is very mistaken . That old war, unleashed for the sake of the immense enrichment of the non-humans who rule the Western world, not only did not end, it intensified even more, this war simply began to be waged in a completely different dimension and took on different forms. However, it is well known as the cold information war.
      Has anyone ever wondered why the former “allies” of the USSR in the war with Nazi Germany, supported by the combined power of all occupied Europe, suddenly became enemies of the Soviet Union after the victory over it? But this is obvious - they have always been enemies of the Russian people, since they have long dreamed of taking control of the lands rich in natural resources on which the Russian people lived and live. And it was planned to do this back in 1917, when the tsarist government was overthrown by the hands of the corrupt bourgeoisie.
      But then nothing came of it - power was wrested from the hands of the bourgeoisie by the Bolsheviks and Lenin’s party, which was supported by almost the entire Russian people. In the shortest period by historical standards, just a quarter of a century, the only real (and not fake like the USA) superpower on our planet was created from a former peasant agrarian country. By the beginning of the 50s, a good half of the entire Earth was on the side of the Soviet project. Just a little more - and our red project would become worldwide. Alas, this did not happen, although we were only a step away from it, if Stalin’s course had been continued by his successor.
      It was with the Khrushchev counter-revolutionary coup, carried out in the cold summer of 1953, that the gradual and systematic destruction of the great country and the only correct for the world of the Russian global red project of building an alternative fair, humane, crisis-free world order began, in which, according to the plan of its creators, only the honest work of everyone for the benefit of all should would be in demand and valued.
      Here is part of my review of the series "The Great War", in which I explain why I categorically do not recommend ALL modern films about that war...
      In those years, the soldiers of the Red Army and the working Soviet people defended their Motherland in the name of a future in which they would never be dominated by the corrupt and vile power of the bourgeoisie, ready to commit any crimes against the people for the sake of profit and their well-being. Only once in human history, not ordinary traditional revolutionaries who sought to seize power for the sake of redistributing the sweet pie, but real ideological people who were ready to work selflessly and selflessly for a completely different future, in which there will be no oppressors and the oppressed, came to power in a huge country. in which people will not be divided into first and second class, into those who have everything and those who have nothing at all.
      And now in the modern Russian Federation the power of transnational occupation capital reigns...
      Western parasites, the financial elite of the USA and Great Britain, who have long wanted to conquer the richest lands of the Russian people, drew conclusions from the results of World War II and realized that the Russian people cannot be conquered by force.
      They acted much simpler - they recruited traitors from the top of the CPSU, starting with the scoundrel Khrushchev and since then the USSR, and now, after its collapse and destruction, Russia is firmly captured by immensely greedy non-humans working for the USA and Britain.
      There is no independent government in Russia, because we are ruled by IMF puppets and proteges of Western transnational corporations. They do not have their own will at all, because even the “return” of Crimea was just a gambit by the West to strengthen the rating of its appointee and successor of Gorbachev’s work - Yeltsin, whose popularity began to decline by 14. In the wake of Crimea, an ironclad justification for the systematic decline in living standards appeared - after all, they say, sanctions. This is just a show for suckers. What kind of fight with the West?
      The entire “elite” of the Russian Federation are collaborators and accomplices of the occupiers. The overwhelming majority of this “elite” have accounts in foreign banks, real estate abroad, and even businesses established there. And all of them, as one, call for rallying around President Putin to protect Russia from external enemies... Many of these Gavriks don’t even live here, they just come to look after them and take money over the hill.
      No external enemies would ever do what the internal traitors did, for the sake of their cookies in the form of foreign accounts, luxury cars, yachts and mansions abroad, they betrayed their country and its people.
      For the best effect, a non-obvious form of occupation was chosen specifically for Russia and its mentality. There are no NATO troops marching through the city streets, there are no curfews, there are no gas chambers or death camps, there are no tortures and mass executions, that is, everything that would immediately cause rage among the people, a wave of indignation and, as a result, resistance to the occupiers.
      That is why there is nothing except the Russian government itself, which is quietly implementing the Ost plan, which was not implemented by Hitler. It’s high time to realize this, but the people who stupidly bought a handful of beads in the form of foreign cars and an abundance of imported goods have yet to realize this terrifying truth. But that's it for now. No amount of media tricks and babble can erase the truth of life. So, all the same, the people will be forced to wake up and come out of the world of illusions into which they fell from the moment when all the USSR media were captured by the enemies of the Russian Soviet people. And this happened in the cold summer of 1953.
      It’s a pity that I don’t have the opportunity to speak out to the whole country yet. In general, this would have to be conveyed to all people on the planet, because there is no alternative for humanity at all.
      “Without theory we are dead.” These were precisely the last words of Stalin during his lifetime, which were preserved for posterity. Communism is definitely not a religion, it is absolutely an achievable future, into which you can get from socialism with the help of a long-term education of a new person from childhood. Only people for whom honest work and the realization of all their abilities for the benefit of society will be able to build a communist economy. It is possible if any form of parasitism on the work of others is unthinkable, simply impossible for the people of the future. Then everyone, including officials, will really work for the good of society. Indeed, with the help of science, it is indeed possible to completely automate production and eliminate many of the unpleasant professions of today. If in the society of the future there will be no parasites left - those who live better than everyone else and at the expense of everyone else, without working. without creating, inventing, teaching or treating, in short, all the worthless creatures that now rule both Russia and the rest of the world - then communism is quite possible without money, which has long ceased to be the equivalent of LABOR, as they were originally conceived for the possibility of exchanging one labor for another . Now money is being printed out of thin air, and this has been going on for more than half a century. And the richest became so through financial speculation, and not through the exploitation of workers.
      But even now the technological level allows us to quickly create conditions for people to live under communism.
      It is enough to remove money from people’s consciousness, to create such conditions that the need for money and its endless accumulation disappears - and the world will be transformed beyond recognition. There will be no desire to accumulate money if everything necessary for a normal life is already available, and almost all crimes and criminals will immediately disappear. If there is no desire to make a business out of the suffering of billions, the alcohol and tobacco business will disappear, drug cartels and drugs will disappear without a trace. There will be no terrorism and wars, which means there will be no need to maintain a huge staff of military and security officials who do not create anything but only consume.
      The progress of science and everything else will incredibly increase - after all, all the productive and scientific efforts of billions will go not to creating ever new types of weapons, but to the prosperity of everyone.
      Only then will humanity really be able to spend enormous resources on fundamental science, and only then will the road to other planets and star systems truly open, and people will be able to truly live, without the daily race to earn a living.
      Personally, I see, moreover, I am deeply convinced that a world in which the main ideal for the majority is to have a large amount of money in their accounts and the desire to do nothing, but to receive more than others is doomed. This is a dead end from which humanity will not be able to get out if most people do not learn to think, analyze, or at least trust and follow those who know how to do this.
  78. -2
    April 15 2020
    on the contrary, they started making cool films about the war, now they’re spectacular, they haven’t reached the dream factory yet, but at least there’s something already
    1. 0
      April 15 2020
      bully bread and circuses, that's right
    2. +1
      April 15 2020
      We haven’t caught up with the “dream factory” yet, but we’ve already caught up with House 2.
  79. +1
    April 15 2020
    Yesterday I decided to watch the domestic action movie “Hero”, born in 2019. with Mashkov and Khodchenkova. To be honest, I haven’t seen anything like this for a long time. I only had 15 minutes of this “masterpiece”
  80. +2
    April 15 2020
    Good gentlemen, filmmakers of all stripes and officials involved in these acts! Why are you falsifying the truth about the war? Why, 75 years later, are you repeating fabrications again and again? Who or what is forcing you to do this?

    Apparently those who force the Mausoleum to be closed at the Victory Parade, to which fascist standards were thrown on June 24, 1945. The modern “elite” is probably ashamed for this and for the victory in general.
    1. 0
      April 25 2020
      The destruction of the entire Russian Soviet civilization began a long time ago and continues to this day. If anyone thinks that the war that the Anglo-Saxon Zionists unleashed against the USSR at the hands of Hitler’s Germany, to which, according to their plan, ambitious Japan should have joined, then if someone thinks that this war ended on May 9, 1945, he is very mistaken . That old war, unleashed for the sake of the immense enrichment of the non-humans who rule the Western world, not only did not end, it intensified even more, this war simply began to be waged in a completely different dimension and took on different forms. However, it is well known as the cold information war.
      Has anyone ever wondered why the former “allies” of the USSR in the war with Nazi Germany, supported by the combined power of all occupied Europe, suddenly became enemies of the Soviet Union after the victory over it? But this is obvious - they have always been enemies of the Russian people, since they have long dreamed of taking control of the lands rich in natural resources on which the Russian people lived and live. And it was planned to do this back in 1917, when the tsarist government was overthrown by the hands of the corrupt bourgeoisie.
      But then nothing came of it - power was wrested from the hands of the bourgeoisie by the Bolsheviks and Lenin’s party, which was supported by almost the entire Russian people. In the shortest period by historical standards, just a quarter of a century, the only real (and not fake like the USA) superpower on our planet was created from a former peasant agrarian country. By the beginning of the 50s, a good half of the entire Earth was on the side of the Soviet project. Just a little more - and our red project would become worldwide. Alas, this did not happen, although we were only a step away from it, if Stalin’s course had been continued by his successor.
      It was with the Khrushchev counter-revolutionary coup, carried out in the cold summer of 1953, that the gradual and systematic destruction of the great country and the only correct for the world of the Russian global red project of building an alternative fair, humane, crisis-free world order began, in which, according to the plan of its creators, only the honest work of everyone for the benefit of all should would be in demand and valued.
      Here is part of my review of the series "The Great War", in which I explain why I categorically do not recommend ALL modern films about that war...
      In those years, the soldiers of the Red Army and the working Soviet people defended their Motherland in the name of a future in which they would never be dominated by the corrupt and vile power of the bourgeoisie, ready to commit any crimes against the people for the sake of profit and their well-being. Only once in human history, not ordinary traditional revolutionaries who sought to seize power for the sake of redistributing the sweet pie, but real ideological people who were ready to work selflessly and selflessly for a completely different future, in which there will be no oppressors and the oppressed, came to power in a huge country. in which people will not be divided into first and second class, into those who have everything and those who have nothing at all.
      And now in the modern Russian Federation the power of transnational occupation capital reigns...
      Western parasites, the financial elite of the USA and Great Britain, who have long wanted to conquer the richest lands of the Russian people, drew conclusions from the results of World War II and realized that the Russian people cannot be conquered by force.
      They acted much simpler - they recruited traitors from the top of the CPSU, starting with the scoundrel Khrushchev and since then the USSR, and now, after its collapse and destruction, Russia is firmly captured by immensely greedy non-humans working for the USA and Britain.
      There is no independent government in Russia, because we are ruled by IMF puppets and proteges of Western transnational corporations. They do not have their own will at all, because even the “return” of Crimea was just a gambit by the West to strengthen the rating of its appointee and successor of Gorbachev’s work - Yeltsin, whose popularity began to decline by 14. In the wake of Crimea, an ironclad justification for the systematic decline in living standards appeared - after all, they say, sanctions. This is just a show for suckers. What kind of fight with the West?
      The entire “elite” of the Russian Federation are collaborators and accomplices of the occupiers. The overwhelming majority of this “elite” have accounts in foreign banks, real estate abroad, and even businesses established there. And all of them, as one, call for rallying around President Putin to protect Russia from external enemies... Many of these Gavriks don’t even live here, they just come to look after them and take money over the hill.
      No external enemies would ever do what the internal traitors did, for the sake of their cookies in the form of foreign accounts, luxury cars, yachts and mansions abroad, they betrayed their country and its people.
      For the best effect, a non-obvious form of occupation was chosen specifically for Russia and its mentality. There are no NATO troops marching through the city streets, there are no curfews, there are no gas chambers or death camps, there are no tortures and mass executions, that is, everything that would immediately cause rage among the people, a wave of indignation and, as a result, resistance to the occupiers.
      That is why there is nothing except the Russian government itself, which is quietly implementing the Ost plan, which was not implemented by Hitler. It’s high time to realize this, but the people who stupidly bought a handful of beads in the form of foreign cars and an abundance of imported goods have yet to realize this terrifying truth. But that's it for now. No amount of media tricks and babble can erase the truth of life. So, all the same, the people will be forced to wake up and come out of the world of illusions into which they fell from the moment when all the USSR media were captured by the enemies of the Russian Soviet people. And this happened in the cold summer of 1953.
      It’s a pity that I don’t have the opportunity to speak out to the whole country yet. In general, this would have to be conveyed to all people on the planet, because there is no alternative for humanity at all.
      “Without theory we are dead.” These were precisely the last words of Stalin during his lifetime, which were preserved for posterity. Communism is definitely not a religion, it is absolutely an achievable future, into which you can get from socialism with the help of a long-term education of a new person from childhood. Only people for whom honest work and the realization of all their abilities for the benefit of society will be able to build a communist economy. It is possible if any form of parasitism on the work of others is unthinkable, simply impossible for the people of the future. Then everyone, including officials, will really work for the good of society. Indeed, with the help of science, it is indeed possible to completely automate production and eliminate many of the unpleasant professions of today. If in the society of the future there will be no parasites left - those who live better than everyone else and at the expense of everyone else, without working. without creating, inventing, teaching or treating, in short, all the worthless creatures that now rule both Russia and the rest of the world - then communism is quite possible without money, which has long ceased to be the equivalent of LABOR, as they were originally conceived for the possibility of exchanging one labor for another . Now money is being printed out of thin air, and this has been going on for more than half a century. And the richest became so through financial speculation, and not through the exploitation of workers.
      But even now the technological level allows us to quickly create conditions for people to live under communism.
      It is enough to remove money from people’s consciousness, to create such conditions that the need for money and its endless accumulation disappears - and the world will be transformed beyond recognition. There will be no desire to accumulate money if everything necessary for a normal life is already available, and almost all crimes and criminals will immediately disappear. If there is no desire to make a business out of the suffering of billions, the alcohol and tobacco business will disappear, drug cartels and drugs will disappear without a trace. There will be no terrorism and wars, which means there will be no need to maintain a huge staff of military and security officials who do not create anything but only consume.
      The progress of science and everything else will incredibly increase - after all, all the productive and scientific efforts of billions will go not to creating ever new types of weapons, but to the prosperity of everyone.
      Only then will humanity really be able to spend enormous resources on fundamental science, and only then will the road to other planets and star systems truly open, and people will be able to truly live, without the daily race to earn a living.
      Personally, I see, moreover, I am deeply convinced that a world in which the main ideal for the majority is to have a large amount of money in their accounts and the desire to do nothing, but to receive more than others is doomed. This is a dead end from which humanity will not be able to get out if most people do not learn to think, analyze, or at least trust and follow those who know how to do this.
  81. +1
    April 15 2020
    There are creative “parties” that have a unique view of the Patriotic War of our people and “ostracize” everyone with different views.
    1. -1
      April 25 2020
      Yes, not creative parties - this is the official policy of the authorities, who are not working for the Russian people at all. This is a continuation of the information war that has been waged against Rus' - Russia for centuries.
      The destruction of the entire Russian Soviet civilization began a long time ago and continues to this day. If anyone thinks that the war that the Anglo-Saxon Zionists unleashed against the USSR at the hands of Hitler’s Germany, to which, according to their plan, ambitious Japan should have joined, then if someone thinks that this war ended on May 9, 1945, he is very mistaken . That old war, unleashed for the sake of the immense enrichment of the non-humans who rule the Western world, not only did not end, it intensified even more, this war simply began to be waged in a completely different dimension and took on different forms. However, it is well known as the cold information war.
      Has anyone ever wondered why the former “allies” of the USSR in the war with Nazi Germany, supported by the combined power of all occupied Europe, suddenly became enemies of the Soviet Union after the victory over it? But this is obvious - they have always been enemies of the Russian people, since they have long dreamed of taking control of the lands rich in natural resources on which the Russian people lived and live. And it was planned to do this back in 1917, when the tsarist government was overthrown by the hands of the corrupt bourgeoisie.
      But then nothing came of it - power was wrested from the hands of the bourgeoisie by the Bolsheviks and Lenin’s party, which was supported by almost the entire Russian people. In the shortest period by historical standards, just a quarter of a century, the only real (and not fake like the USA) superpower on our planet was created from a former peasant agrarian country. By the beginning of the 50s, a good half of the entire Earth was on the side of the Soviet project. Just a little more - and our red project would become worldwide. Alas, this did not happen, although we were only a step away from it, if Stalin’s course had been continued by his successor.
      It was with the Khrushchev counter-revolutionary coup, carried out in the cold summer of 1953, that the gradual and systematic destruction of the great country and the only correct for the world of the Russian global red project of building an alternative fair, humane, crisis-free world order began, in which, according to the plan of its creators, only the honest work of everyone for the benefit of all should would be in demand and valued.
      Here is part of my review of the series "The Great War", in which I explain why I categorically do not recommend ALL modern films about that war...
      In those years, the soldiers of the Red Army and the working Soviet people defended their Motherland in the name of a future in which they would never be dominated by the corrupt and vile power of the bourgeoisie, ready to commit any crimes against the people for the sake of profit and their well-being. Only once in human history, not ordinary traditional revolutionaries who sought to seize power for the sake of redistributing the sweet pie, but real ideological people who were ready to work selflessly and selflessly for a completely different future, in which there will be no oppressors and the oppressed, came to power in a huge country. in which people will not be divided into first and second class, into those who have everything and those who have nothing at all.
      And now in the modern Russian Federation the power of transnational occupation capital reigns...
      Western parasites, the financial elite of the USA and Great Britain, who have long wanted to conquer the richest lands of the Russian people, drew conclusions from the results of World War II and realized that the Russian people cannot be conquered by force.
      They acted much simpler - they recruited traitors from the top of the CPSU, starting with the scoundrel Khrushchev and since then the USSR, and now, after its collapse and destruction, Russia is firmly captured by immensely greedy non-humans working for the USA and Britain.
      There is no independent government in Russia, because we are ruled by IMF puppets and proteges of Western transnational corporations. They do not have their own will at all, because even the “return” of Crimea was just a gambit by the West to strengthen the rating of its appointee and successor of Gorbachev’s work - Yeltsin, whose popularity began to decline by 14. In the wake of Crimea, an ironclad justification for the systematic decline in living standards appeared - after all, they say, sanctions. This is just a show for suckers. What kind of fight with the West?
      The entire “elite” of the Russian Federation are collaborators and accomplices of the occupiers. The overwhelming majority of this “elite” have accounts in foreign banks, real estate abroad, and even businesses established there. And all of them, as one, call for rallying around President Putin to protect Russia from external enemies... Many of these Gavriks don’t even live here, they just come to look after them and take money over the hill.
      No external enemies would ever do what the internal traitors did, for the sake of their cookies in the form of foreign accounts, luxury cars, yachts and mansions abroad, they betrayed their country and its people.
      For the best effect, a non-obvious form of occupation was chosen specifically for Russia and its mentality. There are no NATO troops marching through the city streets, there are no curfews, there are no gas chambers or death camps, there are no tortures and mass executions, that is, everything that would immediately cause rage among the people, a wave of indignation and, as a result, resistance to the occupiers.
      That is why there is nothing except the Russian government itself, which is quietly implementing the Ost plan, which was not implemented by Hitler. It’s high time to realize this, but the people who stupidly bought a handful of beads in the form of foreign cars and an abundance of imported goods have yet to realize this terrifying truth. But that's it for now. No amount of media tricks and babble can erase the truth of life. So, all the same, the people will be forced to wake up and come out of the world of illusions into which they fell from the moment when all the USSR media were captured by the enemies of the Russian Soviet people. And this happened in the cold summer of 1953.
      It’s a pity that I don’t have the opportunity to speak out to the whole country yet. In general, this would have to be conveyed to all people on the planet, because there is no alternative for humanity at all.
      “Without theory we are dead.” These were precisely the last words of Stalin during his lifetime, which were preserved for posterity. Communism is definitely not a religion, it is absolutely an achievable future, into which you can get from socialism with the help of a long-term education of a new person from childhood. Only people for whom honest work and the realization of all their abilities for the benefit of society will be able to build a communist economy. It is possible if any form of parasitism on the work of others is unthinkable, simply impossible for the people of the future. Then everyone, including officials, will really work for the good of society. Indeed, with the help of science, it is indeed possible to completely automate production and eliminate many of the unpleasant professions of today. If in the society of the future there will be no parasites left - those who live better than everyone else and at the expense of everyone else, without working. without creating, inventing, teaching or treating, in short, all the worthless creatures that now rule both Russia and the rest of the world - then communism is quite possible without money, which has long ceased to be the equivalent of LABOR, as they were originally conceived for the possibility of exchanging one labor for another . Now money is being printed out of thin air, and this has been going on for more than half a century. And the richest became so through financial speculation, and not through the exploitation of workers.
      But even now the technological level allows us to quickly create conditions for people to live under communism.
      It is enough to remove money from people’s consciousness, to create such conditions that the need for money and its endless accumulation disappears - and the world will be transformed beyond recognition. There will be no desire to accumulate money if everything necessary for a normal life is already available, and almost all crimes and criminals will immediately disappear. If there is no desire to make a business out of the suffering of billions, the alcohol and tobacco business will disappear, drug cartels and drugs will disappear without a trace. There will be no terrorism and wars, which means there will be no need to maintain a huge staff of military and security officials who do not create anything but only consume.
      The progress of science and everything else will incredibly increase - after all, all the productive and scientific efforts of billions will go not to creating ever new types of weapons, but to the prosperity of everyone.
      Only then will humanity really be able to spend enormous resources on fundamental science, and only then will the road to other planets and star systems truly open, and people will be able to truly live, without the daily race to earn a living.
      Personally, I see, moreover, I am deeply convinced that a world in which the main ideal for the majority is to have a large amount of money in their accounts and the desire to do nothing, but to receive more than others is doomed. This is a dead end from which humanity will not be able to get out if most people do not learn to think, analyze, or at least trust and follow those who know how to do this.
  82. +3
    April 15 2020
    If the Americans save the private, then our filmmakers, with a fig in their pocket, flooded the trenches and special services with women to the fullest! The female medical instructors look especially cool in the trenches with magnificent makeup (thank God, no false nails yet) in minis and tights, and it turns out that for them there is only love, necessarily a caricatured special officer fighting with the personnel (uncle, shell shock and two serious ones, met victory in the hospital after being wounded in Budapestek, while drunk, he told my father: (I was spinning under my feet and for some reason I remembered this chatter for the rest of my life) they had a new person during the battles in Bessarabia, he began to spread rot for anecdotes and trench jokes, and had a habit in front of the planned German with shelling to the rear, and he was somehow a sentry and spotted him moving to the rear and hit him in the back of the head with a German rifle and he saw women only in the rear hospital and during marches through populated areas..
  83. 0
    April 15 2020
    The truth of the film lies in its creators. If they have any idea about the weapons and ranks of that time, then most likely they will succeed. Sometimes you look and feel they are deceiving you, showing some nonsense instead of the original equipment... I try not to look anymore..
  84. +3
    April 15 2020
    Quote: Oleg1
    for example the film T-34, at least you can watch it without heartburn...

    It’s absurd nonsense, not amenable to logic or common sense, the producers and directors, like the whole group, have no idea of ​​the topic at all, don’t even suspect psychology, the environment and elementary logic, i.e. about the historical context from the perspective of those years. From the realities there is only one tank - it’s real, it’s made of steel, and even then not always.
    1. 0
      April 25 2020
      The destruction of the entire Russian Soviet civilization began a long time ago and continues to this day. If anyone thinks that the war that the Anglo-Saxon Zionists unleashed against the USSR at the hands of Hitler’s Germany, to which, according to their plan, ambitious Japan should have joined, then if someone thinks that this war ended on May 9, 1945, he is very mistaken . That old war, unleashed for the sake of the immense enrichment of the non-humans who rule the Western world, not only did not end, it intensified even more, this war simply began to be waged in a completely different dimension and took on different forms. However, it is well known as the cold information war.
      Has anyone ever wondered why the former “allies” of the USSR in the war with Nazi Germany, supported by the combined power of all occupied Europe, suddenly became enemies of the Soviet Union after the victory over it? But this is obvious - they have always been enemies of the Russian people, since they have long dreamed of taking control of the lands rich in natural resources on which the Russian people lived and live. And it was planned to do this back in 1917, when the tsarist government was overthrown by the hands of the corrupt bourgeoisie.
      But then nothing came of it - power was wrested from the hands of the bourgeoisie by the Bolsheviks and Lenin’s party, which was supported by almost the entire Russian people. In the shortest period by historical standards, just a quarter of a century, the only real (and not fake like the USA) superpower on our planet was created from a former peasant agrarian country. By the beginning of the 50s, a good half of the entire Earth was on the side of the Soviet project. Just a little more - and our red project would become worldwide. Alas, this did not happen, although we were only a step away from it, if Stalin’s course had been continued by his successor.
      It was with the Khrushchev counter-revolutionary coup, carried out in the cold summer of 1953, that the gradual and systematic destruction of the great country and the only correct for the world of the Russian global red project of building an alternative fair, humane, crisis-free world order began, in which, according to the plan of its creators, only the honest work of everyone for the benefit of all should would be in demand and valued.
      Here is part of my review of the series "The Great War", in which I explain why I categorically do not recommend ALL modern films about that war...
      In those years, the soldiers of the Red Army and the working Soviet people defended their Motherland in the name of a future in which they would never be dominated by the corrupt and vile power of the bourgeoisie, ready to commit any crimes against the people for the sake of profit and their well-being. Only once in human history, not ordinary traditional revolutionaries who sought to seize power for the sake of redistributing the sweet pie, but real ideological people who were ready to work selflessly and selflessly for a completely different future, in which there will be no oppressors and the oppressed, came to power in a huge country. in which people will not be divided into first and second class, into those who have everything and those who have nothing at all.
      And now in the modern Russian Federation the power of transnational occupation capital reigns...
      Western parasites, the financial elite of the USA and Great Britain, who have long wanted to conquer the richest lands of the Russian people, drew conclusions from the results of World War II and realized that the Russian people cannot be conquered by force.
      They acted much simpler - they recruited traitors from the top of the CPSU, starting with the scoundrel Khrushchev and since then the USSR, and now, after its collapse and destruction, Russia is firmly captured by immensely greedy non-humans working for the USA and Britain.
      There is no independent government in Russia, because we are ruled by IMF puppets and proteges of Western transnational corporations. They do not have their own will at all, because even the “return” of Crimea was just a gambit by the West to strengthen the rating of its appointee and successor of Gorbachev’s work - Yeltsin, whose popularity began to decline by 14. In the wake of Crimea, an ironclad justification for the systematic decline in living standards appeared - after all, they say, sanctions. This is just a show for suckers. What kind of fight with the West?
      The entire “elite” of the Russian Federation are collaborators and accomplices of the occupiers. The overwhelming majority of this “elite” have accounts in foreign banks, real estate abroad, and even businesses established there. And all of them, as one, call for rallying around President Putin to protect Russia from external enemies... Many of these Gavriks don’t even live here, they just come to look after them and take money over the hill.
      No external enemies would ever do what the internal traitors did, for the sake of their cookies in the form of foreign accounts, luxury cars, yachts and mansions abroad, they betrayed their country and its people.
      For the best effect, a non-obvious form of occupation was chosen specifically for Russia and its mentality. There are no NATO troops marching through the city streets, there are no curfews, there are no gas chambers or death camps, there are no tortures and mass executions, that is, everything that would immediately cause rage among the people, a wave of indignation and, as a result, resistance to the occupiers.
      That is why there is nothing except the Russian government itself, which is quietly implementing the Ost plan, which was not implemented by Hitler. It’s high time to realize this, but the people who stupidly bought a handful of beads in the form of foreign cars and an abundance of imported goods have yet to realize this terrifying truth. But that's it for now. No amount of media tricks and babble can erase the truth of life. So, all the same, the people will be forced to wake up and come out of the world of illusions into which they fell from the moment when all the USSR media were captured by the enemies of the Russian Soviet people. And this happened in the cold summer of 1953.
      It’s a pity that I don’t have the opportunity to speak out to the whole country yet. In general, this would have to be conveyed to all people on the planet, because there is no alternative for humanity at all.
      “Without theory we are dead.” These were precisely the last words of Stalin during his lifetime, which were preserved for posterity. Communism is definitely not a religion, it is absolutely an achievable future, into which you can get from socialism with the help of a long-term education of a new person from childhood. Only people for whom honest work and the realization of all their abilities for the benefit of society will be able to build a communist economy. It is possible if any form of parasitism on the work of others is unthinkable, simply impossible for the people of the future. Then everyone, including officials, will really work for the good of society. Indeed, with the help of science, it is indeed possible to completely automate production and eliminate many of the unpleasant professions of today. If in the society of the future there will be no parasites left - those who live better than everyone else and at the expense of everyone else, without working. without creating, inventing, teaching or treating, in short, all the worthless creatures that now rule both Russia and the rest of the world - then communism is quite possible without money, which has long ceased to be the equivalent of LABOR, as they were originally conceived for the possibility of exchanging one labor for another . Now money is being printed out of thin air, and this has been going on for more than half a century. And the richest became so through financial speculation, and not through the exploitation of workers.
      But even now the technological level allows us to quickly create conditions for people to live under communism.
      It is enough to remove money from people’s consciousness, to create such conditions that the need for money and its endless accumulation disappears - and the world will be transformed beyond recognition. There will be no desire to accumulate money if everything necessary for a normal life is already available, and almost all crimes and criminals will immediately disappear. If there is no desire to make a business out of the suffering of billions, the alcohol and tobacco business will disappear, drug cartels and drugs will disappear without a trace. There will be no terrorism and wars, which means there will be no need to maintain a huge staff of military and security officials who do not create anything but only consume.
      The progress of science and everything else will incredibly increase - after all, all the productive and scientific efforts of billions will go not to creating ever new types of weapons, but to the prosperity of everyone.
      Only then will humanity really be able to spend enormous resources on fundamental science, and only then will the road to other planets and star systems truly open, and people will be able to truly live, without the daily race to earn a living.
      Personally, I see, moreover, I am deeply convinced that a world in which the main ideal for the majority is to have a large amount of money in their accounts and the desire to do nothing, but to receive more than others is doomed. This is a dead end from which humanity will not be able to get out if most people do not learn to think, analyze, or at least trust and follow those who know how to do this.
  85. +1
    April 15 2020
    Yes, Madynsky tried his best
  86. +1
    April 15 2020
    “Good gentlemen, filmmakers of all stripes and officials involved in these acts! Why are you falsifying the truth about the war? Why, 75 years later, are you replicating fabrications again and again? Who or what is forcing you to do this?”
    Alas, the voice of one crying in the wilderness.
    And the article is 200 percent correct. I completely agree with the author.
    1. 0
      April 25 2020
      The destruction of the entire Russian Soviet civilization began a long time ago and continues to this day. If anyone thinks that the war that the Anglo-Saxon Zionists unleashed against the USSR at the hands of Hitler’s Germany, to which, according to their plan, ambitious Japan should have joined, then if someone thinks that this war ended on May 9, 1945, he is very mistaken . That old war, unleashed for the sake of the immense enrichment of the non-humans who rule the Western world, not only did not end, it intensified even more, this war simply began to be waged in a completely different dimension and took on different forms. However, it is well known as the cold information war.
      Has anyone ever wondered why the former “allies” of the USSR in the war with Nazi Germany, supported by the combined power of all occupied Europe, suddenly became enemies of the Soviet Union after the victory over it? But this is obvious - they have always been enemies of the Russian people, since they have long dreamed of taking control of the lands rich in natural resources on which the Russian people lived and live. And it was planned to do this back in 1917, when the tsarist government was overthrown by the hands of the corrupt bourgeoisie.
      But then nothing came of it - power was wrested from the hands of the bourgeoisie by the Bolsheviks and Lenin’s party, which was supported by almost the entire Russian people. In the shortest period by historical standards, just a quarter of a century, the only real (and not fake like the USA) superpower on our planet was created from a former peasant agrarian country. By the beginning of the 50s, a good half of the entire Earth was on the side of the Soviet project. Just a little more - and our red project would become worldwide. Alas, this did not happen, although we were only a step away from it, if Stalin’s course had been continued by his successor.
      It was with the Khrushchev counter-revolutionary coup, carried out in the cold summer of 1953, that the gradual and systematic destruction of the great country and the only correct for the world of the Russian global red project of building an alternative fair, humane, crisis-free world order began, in which, according to the plan of its creators, only the honest work of everyone for the benefit of all should would be in demand and valued.
      Here is part of my review of the series "The Great War", in which I explain why I categorically do not recommend ALL modern films about that war...
      In those years, the soldiers of the Red Army and the working Soviet people defended their Motherland in the name of a future in which they would never be dominated by the corrupt and vile power of the bourgeoisie, ready to commit any crimes against the people for the sake of profit and their well-being. Only once in human history, not ordinary traditional revolutionaries who sought to seize power for the sake of redistributing the sweet pie, but real ideological people who were ready to work selflessly and selflessly for a completely different future, in which there will be no oppressors and the oppressed, came to power in a huge country. in which people will not be divided into first and second class, into those who have everything and those who have nothing at all.
      And now in the modern Russian Federation the power of transnational occupation capital reigns...
      Western parasites, the financial elite of the USA and Great Britain, who have long wanted to conquer the richest lands of the Russian people, drew conclusions from the results of World War II and realized that the Russian people cannot be conquered by force.
      They acted much simpler - they recruited traitors from the top of the CPSU, starting with the scoundrel Khrushchev and since then the USSR, and now, after its collapse and destruction, Russia is firmly captured by immensely greedy non-humans working for the USA and Britain.
      There is no independent government in Russia, because we are ruled by IMF puppets and proteges of Western transnational corporations. They do not have their own will at all, because even the “return” of Crimea was just a gambit by the West to strengthen the rating of its appointee and successor of Gorbachev’s work - Yeltsin, whose popularity began to decline by 14. In the wake of Crimea, an ironclad justification for the systematic decline in living standards appeared - after all, they say, sanctions. This is just a show for suckers. What kind of fight with the West?
      The entire “elite” of the Russian Federation are collaborators and accomplices of the occupiers. The overwhelming majority of this “elite” have accounts in foreign banks, real estate abroad, and even businesses established there. And all of them, as one, call for rallying around President Putin to protect Russia from external enemies... Many of these Gavriks don’t even live here, they just come to look after them and take money over the hill.
      No external enemies would ever do what the internal traitors did, for the sake of their cookies in the form of foreign accounts, luxury cars, yachts and mansions abroad, they betrayed their country and its people.
      For the best effect, a non-obvious form of occupation was chosen specifically for Russia and its mentality. There are no NATO troops marching through the city streets, there are no curfews, there are no gas chambers or death camps, there are no tortures and mass executions, that is, everything that would immediately cause rage among the people, a wave of indignation and, as a result, resistance to the occupiers.
      That is why there is nothing except the Russian government itself, which is quietly implementing the Ost plan, which was not implemented by Hitler. It’s high time to realize this, but the people who stupidly bought a handful of beads in the form of foreign cars and an abundance of imported goods have yet to realize this terrifying truth. But that's it for now. No amount of media tricks and babble can erase the truth of life. So, all the same, the people will be forced to wake up and come out of the world of illusions into which they fell from the moment when all the USSR media were captured by the enemies of the Russian Soviet people. And this happened in the cold summer of 1953.
      It’s a pity that I don’t have the opportunity to speak out to the whole country yet. In general, this would have to be conveyed to all people on the planet, because there is no alternative for humanity at all.
      “Without theory we are dead.” These were precisely the last words of Stalin during his lifetime, which were preserved for posterity. Communism is definitely not a religion, it is absolutely an achievable future, into which you can get from socialism with the help of a long-term education of a new person from childhood. Only people for whom honest work and the realization of all their abilities for the benefit of society will be able to build a communist economy. It is possible if any form of parasitism on the work of others is unthinkable, simply impossible for the people of the future. Then everyone, including officials, will really work for the good of society. Indeed, with the help of science, it is indeed possible to completely automate production and eliminate many of the unpleasant professions of today. If in the society of the future there will be no parasites left - those who live better than everyone else and at the expense of everyone else, without working. without creating, inventing, teaching or treating, in short, all the worthless creatures that now rule both Russia and the rest of the world - then communism is quite possible without money, which has long ceased to be the equivalent of LABOR, as they were originally conceived for the possibility of exchanging one labor for another . Now money is being printed out of thin air, and this has been going on for more than half a century. And the richest became so through financial speculation, and not through the exploitation of workers.
      But even now the technological level allows us to quickly create conditions for people to live under communism.
      It is enough to remove money from people’s consciousness, to create such conditions that the need for money and its endless accumulation disappears - and the world will be transformed beyond recognition. There will be no desire to accumulate money if everything necessary for a normal life is already available, and almost all crimes and criminals will immediately disappear. If there is no desire to make a business out of the suffering of billions, the alcohol and tobacco business will disappear, drug cartels and drugs will disappear without a trace. There will be no terrorism and wars, which means there will be no need to maintain a huge staff of military and security officials who do not create anything but only consume.
      The progress of science and everything else will incredibly increase - after all, all the productive and scientific efforts of billions will go not to creating ever new types of weapons, but to the prosperity of everyone.
      Only then will humanity really be able to spend enormous resources on fundamental science, and only then will the road to other planets and star systems truly open, and people will be able to truly live, without the daily race to earn a living.
      Personally, I see, moreover, I am deeply convinced that a world in which the main ideal for the majority is to have a large amount of money in their accounts and the desire to do nothing, but to receive more than others is doomed. This is a dead end from which humanity will not be able to get out if most people do not learn to think, analyze, or at least trust and follow those who know how to do this.
  87. +1
    April 16 2020
    Good gentlemen, filmmakers of all stripes and officials involved in these acts! Why are you faking the truth about the war? Why, after 75 years, are you repeating fabrications again and again? Who or what makes you do it?
    Who, who? It is known who... . sad
  88. -1
    April 16 2020
    The word “money” is repeated in this article with enviable consistency. Why the article was written and what the author’s life priorities are - there is no need to rack your brains.
  89. 0
    April 16 2020
    Quote: DMB 75
    - Do not watch modern war films!
    “But there are no others?”
    - Don’t look at any...
    Look Soviet. You don’t know about the current ones, either laughing, crying, or launching something on the TV.

    Oops... that is, all Soviet standards...
    Just try to remember films about the war... And it turns out that you have 15-20 films in your memory and that’s it...
    And next to mountain of bullshit(!!!!!!) like "Die Hard" (with Solomin) and "Special Forces". A lot of films about the war were made in the USSR and 4/5 of them were tripe, especially from republican studios.
    You look at one of them and understand that the war could have ended in August 1941 - and the Wehrmacht kindergarten (junior group!!) is on a walk...

    Considering the quantity binding films about the war then (by dates, according to plan, etc.) and the number of films about the war now - maybe there will be equality in the release of REAL films
    Take any year of the USSR, look at the number of films released this year and you will see that YOU you know 1,2, well, maximum 3 films out of a bunch of films about the war made this year
    And yet, naturally, the quality of films about the war will decrease. There were few actors who fought and knew the war not from books, but from their own skin, even by the end of the USSR, they died....
    1. 0
      April 25 2020
      Can't you guess why even in the USSR most of the films about the war were tripe? It's so simple if you think about it a little.
      The destruction of the entire Russian Soviet civilization began a long time ago and continues to this day. If anyone thinks that the war that the Anglo-Saxon Zionists unleashed against the USSR at the hands of Hitler’s Germany, to which, according to their plan, ambitious Japan should have joined, then if someone thinks that this war ended on May 9, 1945, he is very mistaken . That old war, unleashed for the sake of the immense enrichment of the non-humans who rule the Western world, not only did not end, it intensified even more, this war simply began to be waged in a completely different dimension and took on different forms. However, it is well known as the cold information war.
      Has anyone ever wondered why the former “allies” of the USSR in the war with Nazi Germany, supported by the combined power of all occupied Europe, suddenly became enemies of the Soviet Union after the victory over it? But this is obvious - they have always been enemies of the Russian people, since they have long dreamed of taking control of the lands rich in natural resources on which the Russian people lived and live. And it was planned to do this back in 1917, when the tsarist government was overthrown by the hands of the corrupt bourgeoisie.
      But then nothing came of it - power was wrested from the hands of the bourgeoisie by the Bolsheviks and Lenin’s party, which was supported by almost the entire Russian people. In the shortest period by historical standards, just a quarter of a century, the only real (and not fake like the USA) superpower on our planet was created from a former peasant agrarian country. By the beginning of the 50s, a good half of the entire Earth was on the side of the Soviet project. Just a little more - and our red project would become worldwide. Alas, this did not happen, although we were only a step away from it, if Stalin’s course had been continued by his successor.
      It was with the Khrushchev counter-revolutionary coup, carried out in the cold summer of 1953, that the gradual and systematic destruction of the great country and the only correct for the world of the Russian global red project of building an alternative fair, humane, crisis-free world order began, in which, according to the plan of its creators, only the honest work of everyone for the benefit of all should would be in demand and valued.
      Here is part of my review of the series "The Great War", in which I explain why I categorically do not recommend ALL modern films about that war...
      In those years, the soldiers of the Red Army and the working Soviet people defended their Motherland in the name of a future in which they would never be dominated by the corrupt and vile power of the bourgeoisie, ready to commit any crimes against the people for the sake of profit and their well-being. Only once in human history, not ordinary traditional revolutionaries who sought to seize power for the sake of redistributing the sweet pie, but real ideological people who were ready to work selflessly and selflessly for a completely different future, in which there will be no oppressors and the oppressed, came to power in a huge country. in which people will not be divided into first and second class, into those who have everything and those who have nothing at all.
      And now in the modern Russian Federation the power of transnational occupation capital reigns...
      Western parasites, the financial elite of the USA and Great Britain, who have long wanted to conquer the richest lands of the Russian people, drew conclusions from the results of World War II and realized that the Russian people cannot be conquered by force.
      They acted much simpler - they recruited traitors from the top of the CPSU, starting with the scoundrel Khrushchev and since then the USSR, and now, after its collapse and destruction, Russia is firmly captured by immensely greedy non-humans working for the USA and Britain.
      There is no independent government in Russia, because we are ruled by IMF puppets and proteges of Western transnational corporations. They do not have their own will at all, because even the “return” of Crimea was just a gambit by the West to strengthen the rating of its appointee and successor of Gorbachev’s work - Yeltsin, whose popularity began to decline by 14. In the wake of Crimea, an ironclad justification for the systematic decline in living standards appeared - after all, they say, sanctions. This is just a show for suckers. What kind of fight with the West?
      The entire “elite” of the Russian Federation are collaborators and accomplices of the occupiers. The overwhelming majority of this “elite” have accounts in foreign banks, real estate abroad, and even businesses established there. And all of them, as one, call for rallying around President Putin to protect Russia from external enemies... Many of these Gavriks don’t even live here, they just come to look after them and take money over the hill.
      No external enemies would ever do what the internal traitors did, for the sake of their cookies in the form of foreign accounts, luxury cars, yachts and mansions abroad, they betrayed their country and its people.
      For the best effect, a non-obvious form of occupation was chosen specifically for Russia and its mentality. There are no NATO troops marching through the city streets, there are no curfews, there are no gas chambers or death camps, there are no tortures and mass executions, that is, everything that would immediately cause rage among the people, a wave of indignation and, as a result, resistance to the occupiers.
      That is why there is nothing except the Russian government itself, which is quietly implementing the Ost plan, which was not implemented by Hitler. It’s high time to realize this, but the people who stupidly bought a handful of beads in the form of foreign cars and an abundance of imported goods have yet to realize this terrifying truth. But that's it for now. No amount of media tricks and babble can erase the truth of life. So, all the same, the people will be forced to wake up and come out of the world of illusions into which they fell from the moment when all the USSR media were captured by the enemies of the Russian Soviet people. And this happened in the cold summer of 1953.
      It’s a pity that I don’t have the opportunity to speak out to the whole country yet. In general, this would have to be conveyed to all people on the planet, because there is no alternative for humanity at all.
      “Without theory we are dead.” These were precisely the last words of Stalin during his lifetime, which were preserved for posterity. Communism is definitely not a religion, it is absolutely an achievable future, into which you can get from socialism with the help of a long-term education of a new person from childhood. Only people for whom honest work and the realization of all their abilities for the benefit of society will be able to build a communist economy. It is possible if any form of parasitism on the work of others is unthinkable, simply impossible for the people of the future. Then everyone, including officials, will really work for the good of society. Indeed, with the help of science, it is indeed possible to completely automate production and eliminate many of the unpleasant professions of today. If in the society of the future there will be no parasites left - those who live better than everyone else and at the expense of everyone else, without working. without creating, inventing, teaching or treating, in short, all the worthless creatures that now rule both Russia and the rest of the world - then communism is quite possible without money, which has long ceased to be the equivalent of LABOR, as they were originally conceived for the possibility of exchanging one labor for another . Now money is being printed out of thin air, and this has been going on for more than half a century. And the richest became so through financial speculation, and not through the exploitation of workers.
      But even now the technological level allows us to quickly create conditions for people to live under communism.
      It is enough to remove money from people’s consciousness, to create such conditions that the need for money and its endless accumulation disappears - and the world will be transformed beyond recognition. There will be no desire to accumulate money if everything necessary for a normal life is already available, and almost all crimes and criminals will immediately disappear. If there is no desire to make a business out of the suffering of billions, the alcohol and tobacco business will disappear, drug cartels and drugs will disappear without a trace. There will be no terrorism and wars, which means there will be no need to maintain a huge staff of military and security officials who do not create anything but only consume.
      The progress of science and everything else will incredibly increase - after all, all the productive and scientific efforts of billions will go not to creating ever new types of weapons, but to the prosperity of everyone.
      Only then will humanity really be able to spend enormous resources on fundamental science, and only then will the road to other planets and star systems truly open, and people will be able to truly live, without the daily race to earn a living.
      Personally, I see, moreover, I am deeply convinced that a world in which the main ideal for the majority is to have a large amount of money in their accounts and the desire to do nothing, but to receive more than others is doomed. This is a dead end from which humanity will not be able to get out if most people do not learn to think, analyze, or at least trust and follow those who know how to do this.
      1. 0
        April 25 2020
        Do you understand that you are contradicting yourself? What do you write first?
        Quote: Sergey 1968
        That old war, unleashed for the sake of the immense enrichment of the non-humans who rule the Western world, not only did not end, it intensified even more, this war simply began to be waged in a completely different dimension and took on different forms. However, it is well known as the cold information war.
        - I agree, but this
        Quote: Sergey 1968
        So all the same, the people will be forced to wake up and get out of the world of illusions into which they fell from the moment when everything The USSR media found itself captured by the enemies of the Russian Soviet people. And this happened still in the cold summer of 1953.

        that is, everything that was done in the post-Stalin era was a complete mess with the consent of the authorities???
        so what kind of communism as you described then could be?
        Quote: Sergey 1968
        Communism is definitely not a religion, it is absolutely an achievable future, into which you can get from socialism with the help of a long-term education of a new person from childhood.
        - if it turned out to be impossible under any leader other than Stalin???

        You understand - which Are you talking anti-Soviet? If at Soviet power(!!!!!) all media were captured enemies of the people and Soviet power - What kind of communism are you raving about when you live in CAPITALIST country??? If in your opinion the people in the USSR were fooled during the
        Quote: Sergey 1968
        Khrushchev's counter-revolutionary coup,
        - What kind of revolution can we even talk about now???
        From your own speeches, it turns out that Soviet power is absolutely unviable in the absence of normal successors!!!!
        And then there’s generally faith in something incomprehensible:
        Quote: Sergey 1968
        If there is no desire to make a business out of the suffering of billions, the alcohol and tobacco business will disappear, drug cartels and drugs will disappear without a trace. There will be no terrorism and wars, which means there will be no need to maintain a huge staff of military and security officials who do not create anything but only consume.

        That is, in your opinion - ideological component y terrorism and wars completely absent - all exclusively for the sake of money??? That is, all revolutionaries of all times and peoples, including ours in 1917, died exclusively for money?? All our military personnel who died in all wars were exclusively consumers??

        ZY it feels like you overdid it... these are not alcohol glitches - this is heroin on the level of “all people are brothers, let’s destroy money and there will be happiness for everyone in the whole world”
        Well, or spring has a bad influence on you - but this option can be treated (although not always)...
  90. +1
    April 17 2020
    Quote: Avior
    The author is a front-line soldier who fought near Rzhev, disabled by the Second World War.

    So, after all, the ideologist of the murder of the USSR is a certain Yakovlev, a member of the Politburo of the CPSU Central Committee, also a front-line soldier and a war invalid. Physical disability does not justify disability of conscience!
    1. 0
      April 25 2020
      The destruction of the entire Russian Soviet civilization began a long time ago and continues to this day. If anyone thinks that the war that the Anglo-Saxon Zionists unleashed against the USSR at the hands of Hitler’s Germany, to which, according to their plan, ambitious Japan should have joined, then if someone thinks that this war ended on May 9, 1945, he is very mistaken . That old war, unleashed for the sake of the immense enrichment of the non-humans who rule the Western world, not only did not end, it intensified even more, this war simply began to be waged in a completely different dimension and took on different forms. However, it is well known as the cold information war.
      Has anyone ever wondered why the former “allies” of the USSR in the war with Nazi Germany, supported by the combined power of all occupied Europe, suddenly became enemies of the Soviet Union after the victory over it? But this is obvious - they have always been enemies of the Russian people, since they have long dreamed of taking control of the lands rich in natural resources on which the Russian people lived and live. And it was planned to do this back in 1917, when the tsarist government was overthrown by the hands of the corrupt bourgeoisie.
      But then nothing came of it - power was wrested from the hands of the bourgeoisie by the Bolsheviks and Lenin’s party, which was supported by almost the entire Russian people. In the shortest period by historical standards, just a quarter of a century, the only real (and not fake like the USA) superpower on our planet was created from a former peasant agrarian country. By the beginning of the 50s, a good half of the entire Earth was on the side of the Soviet project. Just a little more - and our red project would become worldwide. Alas, this did not happen, although we were only a step away from it, if Stalin’s course had been continued by his successor.
      It was with the Khrushchev counter-revolutionary coup, carried out in the cold summer of 1953, that the gradual and systematic destruction of the great country and the only correct for the world of the Russian global red project of building an alternative fair, humane, crisis-free world order began, in which, according to the plan of its creators, only the honest work of everyone for the benefit of all should would be in demand and valued.
      Here is part of my review of the series "The Great War", in which I explain why I categorically do not recommend ALL modern films about that war...
      In those years, the soldiers of the Red Army and the working Soviet people defended their Motherland in the name of a future in which they would never be dominated by the corrupt and vile power of the bourgeoisie, ready to commit any crimes against the people for the sake of profit and their well-being. Only once in human history, not ordinary traditional revolutionaries who sought to seize power for the sake of redistributing the sweet pie, but real ideological people who were ready to work selflessly and selflessly for a completely different future, in which there will be no oppressors and the oppressed, came to power in a huge country. in which people will not be divided into first and second class, into those who have everything and those who have nothing at all.
      And now in the modern Russian Federation the power of transnational occupation capital reigns...
      Western parasites, the financial elite of the USA and Great Britain, who have long wanted to conquer the richest lands of the Russian people, drew conclusions from the results of World War II and realized that the Russian people cannot be conquered by force.
      They acted much simpler - they recruited traitors from the top of the CPSU, starting with the scoundrel Khrushchev and since then the USSR, and now, after its collapse and destruction, Russia is firmly captured by immensely greedy non-humans working for the USA and Britain.
      There is no independent government in Russia, because we are ruled by IMF puppets and proteges of Western transnational corporations. They do not have their own will at all, because even the “return” of Crimea was just a gambit by the West to strengthen the rating of its appointee and successor of Gorbachev’s work - Yeltsin, whose popularity began to decline by 14. In the wake of Crimea, an ironclad justification for the systematic decline in living standards appeared - after all, they say, sanctions. This is just a show for suckers. What kind of fight with the West?
      The entire “elite” of the Russian Federation are collaborators and accomplices of the occupiers. The overwhelming majority of this “elite” have accounts in foreign banks, real estate abroad, and even businesses established there. And all of them, as one, call for rallying around President Putin to protect Russia from external enemies... Many of these Gavriks don’t even live here, they just come to look after them and take money over the hill.
      No external enemies would ever do what the internal traitors did, for the sake of their cookies in the form of foreign accounts, luxury cars, yachts and mansions abroad, they betrayed their country and its people.
      For the best effect, a non-obvious form of occupation was chosen specifically for Russia and its mentality. There are no NATO troops marching through the city streets, there are no curfews, there are no gas chambers or death camps, there are no tortures and mass executions, that is, everything that would immediately cause rage among the people, a wave of indignation and, as a result, resistance to the occupiers.
      That is why there is nothing except the Russian government itself, which is quietly implementing the Ost plan, which was not implemented by Hitler. It’s high time to realize this, but the people who stupidly bought a handful of beads in the form of foreign cars and an abundance of imported goods have yet to realize this terrifying truth. But that's it for now. No amount of media tricks and babble can erase the truth of life. So, all the same, the people will be forced to wake up and come out of the world of illusions into which they fell from the moment when all the USSR media were captured by the enemies of the Russian Soviet people. And this happened in the cold summer of 1953.
      It’s a pity that I don’t have the opportunity to speak out to the whole country yet. In general, this would have to be conveyed to all people on the planet, because there is no alternative for humanity at all.
      “Without theory we are dead.” These were precisely the last words of Stalin during his lifetime, which were preserved for posterity. Communism is definitely not a religion, it is absolutely an achievable future, into which you can get from socialism with the help of a long-term education of a new person from childhood. Only people for whom honest work and the realization of all their abilities for the benefit of society will be able to build a communist economy. It is possible if any form of parasitism on the work of others is unthinkable, simply impossible for the people of the future. Then everyone, including officials, will really work for the good of society. Indeed, with the help of science, it is indeed possible to completely automate production and eliminate many of the unpleasant professions of today. If in the society of the future there will be no parasites left - those who live better than everyone else and at the expense of everyone else, without working. without creating, inventing, teaching or treating, in short, all the worthless creatures that now rule both Russia and the rest of the world - then communism is quite possible without money, which has long ceased to be the equivalent of LABOR, as they were originally conceived for the possibility of exchanging one labor for another . Now money is being printed out of thin air, and this has been going on for more than half a century. And the richest became so through financial speculation, and not through the exploitation of workers.
      But even now the technological level allows us to quickly create conditions for people to live under communism.
      It is enough to remove money from people’s consciousness, to create such conditions that the need for money and its endless accumulation disappears - and the world will be transformed beyond recognition. There will be no desire to accumulate money if everything necessary for a normal life is already available, and almost all crimes and criminals will immediately disappear. If there is no desire to make a business out of the suffering of billions, the alcohol and tobacco business will disappear, drug cartels and drugs will disappear without a trace. There will be no terrorism and wars, which means there will be no need to maintain a huge staff of military and security officials who do not create anything but only consume.
      The progress of science and everything else will incredibly increase - after all, all the productive and scientific efforts of billions will go not to creating ever new types of weapons, but to the prosperity of everyone.
      Only then will humanity really be able to spend enormous resources on fundamental science, and only then will the road to other planets and star systems truly open, and people will be able to truly live, without the daily race to earn a living.
      Personally, I see, moreover, I am deeply convinced that a world in which the main ideal for the majority is to have a large amount of money in their accounts and the desire to do nothing, but to receive more than others is doomed. This is a dead end from which humanity will not be able to get out if most people do not learn to think, analyze, or at least trust and follow those who know how to do this.
  91. -2
    April 18 2020
    Quote: Nikolaevich I
    In recent years, I don’t watch "Russian" films at all ... Sometimes I tried ... on "recommendations" (!), But it happened that I turned it off in the "middle of the film"! "Attraction" (wife and granddaughter "twisted" their hands and led ...) ... "absurdities" in the film were enough for "impressions"! When my wife and granddaughter tried to "drive" me to f. "Invasion", I put up "fierce resistance", and they had to retreat ... Now, "on TV" they advertise some kind of "pro-Tatar" film ... I just had to "look" at the fragments of the "movie" (animals-nkvdeshniki ... inhuman camp conditions - everything is in the "spirit" of Solzhenitsyn!) to decide that I will not watch this film!

    And I looked at a piece...... It's shit, it's so stinking. I am a Siberian and have seen many exiles. The author, or rather the author, should have studied better. Better yet, go work as a cleaner. In our time (in the USSR) they wouldn’t even read such shit. I remember trying to master Solzhenitsyn in the magazine publication “One Day...” I understood - he should have been given to the Americans right away - I wonder if he would have written at least something. If anyone hasn’t watched Zuleika or Zulihanka, don’t waste your time. A piece was enough for me to understand - it was shit.
    1. 0
      April 25 2020
      My review of a movie called “The Great War,” purchased by Britain, which, by the way, organized this war together with the United States. Doesn't it give you any ideas?
      I absolutely do not recommend it. Because under the victorious government of the corrupt bourgeoisie in the Russian Federation, they cannot make at least one truthful film about the Great Patriotic War. This film uses game and production elements stylized as a chronicle, colorization and other special effects are used, the number of staged shots exceeds the number of documentary chronicles, “there are no experts, but there are a lot of references, infographics, computer animation and other special effects”... The series of films was purchased by the international television channel The History Channel and fully dubbed into English. The project was called Soviet Storm: World War II - In The East.
      And now I will explain why I categorically DO NOT RECOMMEND...
      All modern film productions pursue one single goal - to hide the real essence of the events that took place in that war behind beautiful special effects.
      In those years, the soldiers of the Red Army and the working Soviet people defended their Motherland in the name of a future in which they would never be dominated by the corrupt and vile power of the bourgeoisie, ready to commit any crimes against the people for the sake of profit and their well-being. Only once in human history, not ordinary traditional revolutionaries who sought to seize power for the sake of redistributing the sweet pie, but real ideological people who were ready to work selflessly and selflessly for a completely different future, in which there will be no oppressors and the oppressed, came to power in a huge country. in which people will not be divided into first and second class, into those who have everything and those who have nothing at all.
      And now in the modern Russian Federation the power of transnational occupation capital reigns...
      Western parasites, the financial elite of the USA and Great Britain, who have long wanted to conquer the richest lands of the Russian people, drew conclusions from the results of World War II and realized that the Russian people cannot be conquered by force.
      They acted much simpler - they recruited traitors from the top of the CPSU, starting with the scoundrel Khrushchev and since then the USSR, and now, after its collapse and destruction, Russia is firmly captured by immensely greedy non-humans working for the USA and Britain.
      There is no independent government in Russia, because we are ruled by IMF puppets and proteges of Western transnational corporations. They do not have their own will at all, because even the “return” of Crimea was just a gambit by the West to strengthen the rating of its appointee and successor of Gorbachev’s work - Yeltsin, whose popularity began to decline by 14. In the wake of Crimea, an ironclad justification for the systematic decline in living standards appeared - after all, they say, sanctions. This is just a show for suckers. What kind of fight with the West?
      The entire “elite” of the Russian Federation are collaborators and accomplices of the occupiers. The overwhelming majority of this “elite” have accounts in foreign banks, real estate abroad, and even businesses established there. And all of them, as one, call for rallying around President Putin to protect Russia from external enemies... Many of these Gavriks don’t even live here, they just come to look after them and take money over the hill.
      No external enemies would ever do what the internal traitors did, for the sake of their cookies in the form of foreign accounts, luxury cars, yachts and mansions abroad, they betrayed their country and its people.
      For the best effect, a non-obvious form of occupation was chosen specifically for Russia and its mentality. There are no NATO troops marching through the city streets, there are no curfews, there are no gas chambers or death camps, there are no tortures and mass executions, that is, everything that would immediately cause rage among the people, a wave of indignation and, as a result, resistance to the occupiers.
      That is why there is nothing except the Russian government itself, which is quietly implementing the Ost plan, which was not implemented by Hitler. It’s high time to realize this, but the people who stupidly bought a handful of beads in the form of foreign cars and an abundance of imported goods have yet to realize this terrifying truth. But that's it for now. No amount of media tricks and babble can erase the truth of life. So, all the same, the people will be forced to wake up and come out of the world of illusions into which they fell from the moment when all the USSR media were captured by the enemies of the Russian Soviet people. And this happened in the cold summer of 1953.
  92. -2
    April 18 2020
    Quote: diletant
    There are creative “parties” that have a unique view of the Patriotic War of our people and “ostracize” everyone with different views.

    Call it by its proper name: a bunch of liberals - p...v. Here's who farts loudest.
  93. 0
    April 25 2020
    My review of a movie called “The Great War,” purchased by Britain, which, by the way, organized this war together with the United States. Doesn't it give you any ideas?
    I absolutely do not recommend it. Because under the victorious government of the corrupt bourgeoisie in the Russian Federation, they cannot make at least one truthful film about the Great Patriotic War. This film uses game and production elements stylized as a chronicle, colorization and other special effects are used, the number of staged shots exceeds the number of documentary chronicles, “there are no experts, but there are a lot of references, infographics, computer animation and other special effects”... The series of films was purchased by the international television channel The History Channel and fully dubbed into English. The project was called Soviet Storm: World War II - In The East.
    And now I will explain why I categorically DO NOT RECOMMEND...
    All modern film productions pursue one single goal - to hide the real essence of the events that took place in that war behind beautiful special effects.
    In those years, the soldiers of the Red Army and the working Soviet people defended their Motherland in the name of a future in which they would never be dominated by the corrupt and vile power of the bourgeoisie, ready to commit any crimes against the people for the sake of profit and their well-being. Only once in human history, not ordinary traditional revolutionaries who sought to seize power for the sake of redistributing the sweet pie, but real ideological people who were ready to work selflessly and selflessly for a completely different future, in which there will be no oppressors and the oppressed, came to power in a huge country. in which people will not be divided into first and second class, into those who have everything and those who have nothing at all.
    And now in the modern Russian Federation the power of transnational occupation capital reigns...
    Western parasites, the financial elite of the USA and Great Britain, who have long wanted to conquer the richest lands of the Russian people, drew conclusions from the results of World War II and realized that the Russian people cannot be conquered by force.
    They acted much simpler - they recruited traitors from the top of the CPSU, starting with the scoundrel Khrushchev and since then the USSR, and now, after its collapse and destruction, Russia is firmly captured by immensely greedy non-humans working for the USA and Britain.
    There is no independent government in Russia, because we are ruled by IMF puppets and proteges of Western transnational corporations. They do not have their own will at all, because even the “return” of Crimea was just a gambit by the West to strengthen the rating of its appointee and successor of Gorbachev’s work - Yeltsin, whose popularity began to decline by 14. In the wake of Crimea, an ironclad justification for the systematic decline in living standards appeared - after all, they say, sanctions. This is just a show for suckers. What kind of fight with the West?
    The entire “elite” of the Russian Federation are collaborators and accomplices of the occupiers. The overwhelming majority of this “elite” have accounts in foreign banks, real estate abroad, and even businesses established there. And all of them, as one, call for rallying around President Putin to protect Russia from external enemies... Many of these Gavriks don’t even live here, they just come to look after them and take money over the hill.
    No external enemies would ever do what the internal traitors did, for the sake of their cookies in the form of foreign accounts, luxury cars, yachts and mansions abroad, they betrayed their country and its people.
    For the best effect, a non-obvious form of occupation was chosen specifically for Russia and its mentality. There are no NATO troops marching through the city streets, there are no curfews, there are no gas chambers or death camps, there are no tortures and mass executions, that is, everything that would immediately cause rage among the people, a wave of indignation and, as a result, resistance to the occupiers.
    That is why there is nothing except the Russian government itself, which is quietly implementing the Ost plan, which was not implemented by Hitler. It’s high time to realize this, but the people who stupidly bought a handful of beads in the form of foreign cars and an abundance of imported goods have yet to realize this terrifying truth. But that's it for now. No amount of media tricks and babble can erase the truth of life. So, all the same, the people will be forced to wake up and come out of the world of illusions into which they fell from the moment when all the USSR media were captured by the enemies of the Russian Soviet people. And this happened in the cold summer of 1953.

"Right Sector" (banned in Russia), "Ukrainian Insurgent Army" (UPA) (banned in Russia), ISIS (banned in Russia), "Jabhat Fatah al-Sham" formerly "Jabhat al-Nusra" (banned in Russia) , Taliban (banned in Russia), Al-Qaeda (banned in Russia), Anti-Corruption Foundation (banned in Russia), Navalny Headquarters (banned in Russia), Facebook (banned in Russia), Instagram (banned in Russia), Meta (banned in Russia), Misanthropic Division (banned in Russia), Azov (banned in Russia), Muslim Brotherhood (banned in Russia), Aum Shinrikyo (banned in Russia), AUE (banned in Russia), UNA-UNSO (banned in Russia), Mejlis of the Crimean Tatar People (banned in Russia), Legion “Freedom of Russia” (armed formation, recognized as terrorist in the Russian Federation and banned)

“Non-profit organizations, unregistered public associations or individuals performing the functions of a foreign agent,” as well as media outlets performing the functions of a foreign agent: “Medusa”; "Voice of America"; "Realities"; "Present time"; "Radio Freedom"; Ponomarev; Savitskaya; Markelov; Kamalyagin; Apakhonchich; Makarevich; Dud; Gordon; Zhdanov; Medvedev; Fedorov; "Owl"; "Alliance of Doctors"; "RKK" "Levada Center"; "Memorial"; "Voice"; "Person and law"; "Rain"; "Mediazone"; "Deutsche Welle"; QMS "Caucasian Knot"; "Insider"; "New Newspaper"