Question on ticket - crisis: exam for the government of Mishustin


People, even those who are little interested in world problems, today it becomes clear that the world is changing. What this world will be tomorrow is impossible to predict. Experts give conflicting forecasts. Politicians are calling for multidirectional action. It became clear to everyone that one should not expect anything good in the near future.


Some part of the population, in horror, is stockpiling everything that will soon “disappear” from store shelves. Someone begins to buy up the currency, believing that the Russian rubles will soon turn into pieces of paper. But the majority, taught by the bitter experience of the past crises, is just waiting. If we discard several large cities, we can say: Russia is in a state of thought.

Is the economic crisis spawning a coronavirus pandemic?


It is ridiculous to observe the attempts of some politicians and economists to introduce the idea that the coronavirus is to blame for the collapse of the world economy. What is it? Full confidence in the stupidity of the bulk of their own fellow citizens? Or a lack of understanding of the changes that have occurred in the world? Even today, when the fruits of education reform have grown, the overall literacy of Russian citizens is quite high.

Forecasts of the crisis that will be in 2020 appeared long ago. A soap bubble cannot grow indefinitely. It is enough to look at the materials of any conference of economists in the past or the beginning of this year. Almost everywhere it refers to the global economic cataclysm. Here is one example of such forecasting, which was published on January 10 this year in the press:

What will be the consequences of the crisis for developing countries? Currency devaluation, decline in production, imbalance in the financial system, rising prices, increased tax burden on business and the public, layoffs and, as a result, social upheaval.

Moreover, economists have clearly described the further development of the situation. Unlike the first quote, we cannot verify the accuracy of the forecast yet. The crisis is just beginning. So we will take the forecast simply as a prediction.

Analysts attribute the mitigation of the economic crisis for Russia to the fact that the reserve fund exceeds debt obligations, the country has a surplus budget and low inflation. In addition, import substitution made Russia less integrated into Western economies, but this applies to agricultural production, and not to the technology sector, where the role of external suppliers is huge. These factors will help Russia in the event that the crisis is short-lived, playing the role of a kind of airbag.

If the crisis drags on, the burden of overcoming it will fall on the shoulders of small business and society, which will lead to a further deterioration in the quality of life in Russia.

The question may arise why the Russian government did not react to such forecasts. Obviously, those economists also participated in the work of such conferences, which then participated in the development of materials on the budget of the Russian Federation. And who said that there were no such calculations?

We traditionally say that Russia will calmly survive the fall in oil prices to $ 40 per barrel. It was this price that was budgeted for 2020-2022. But if you look at the materials for the draft budget, the calculations made by the Ministry of Finance taking into account changes in the cost of oil, you can see the project shock. The fall in the price of our oil to $ 10 per barrel.

In the first year, losses will amount to 5% of GDP. If the situation persists for ten years, the treasury will receive less than 70% of annual GDP.

So, the crisis did not come as a surprise to the governments of most countries. He was expected, which means that there was time for preparation and creation of conditions for “smoothing” the consequences for the population.

The Russian government knows the “goals” that the crisis will hit


We are often told that it is impossible to predict where the crisis will hit first. Moreover, the majority is simply sure that the main thing that you should pay attention to is tax and other budget revenues, the national currency exchange rate and population incomes. I will not argue. However, today ask a simple working person from Zamkadye about the dollar or euro exchange rate, and with almost 100% probability you will see a surprised look or hear the direction where he will advise you to go.

Budget revenues from the sale of hydrocarbons? Yes, they will shrink. And seriously enough. Before me is now the data for 2009. Then tax revenues collapsed by 61%! Indeed, oil is still the blood of our economy. In 2018, oil and gas revenues accounted for 46,3% of all revenues.

But look what happened then with other sectors of the economy. Let me remind you that in 2009 oil lasted only 5 months at a price below $ 70. Industrial production in Russia decreased by a quarter! Remember what our car plants turned into then. Drop three times! Engineering was halved. Construction has fallen by more than 30%!

Here they are, goals! By blocking access to “blood”, the crisis destroys not so much the oil and gas industry (it is clear that the price of hydrocarbons this year, if it does not return to the pre-crisis level, will be quite “digestible” for the global economy), the blow comes from industries that are difficult to revive. The plant can be restored, but returning to sales markets is problematic.

Option of the Russian government in a crisis period


Before starting to predict the possible actions of the Mishustin government, for which the situation became an exam, it is necessary to recall that all previous crises began exactly as it is happening now. The fall in oil prices. So it was in 1998. So it was in 2008. So it was in 2014. And the destructive consequences for the economy occurred only because Russia simply did not have the opportunity to respond to challenges. We did not have that notorious "airbag".

Today there is such a “pillow”. Today we have a reserve of time. We have the opportunity not only to preserve what has already been achieved, but also to change the existing reality. Just so, change reality in the economic sense of the word.

What is happening on the oil market today? The fall in prices almost halved the production of shale oil from the United States. Shale oil production at a price below $ 30 per barrel turned into an unprofitable investment. And no matter how the American president encourages the business to continue production, the business began to curtail shale oil programs.

In various sectors of the economy, there is a serious, on the verge of collapse, decline. The world economy is in a fever no worse than a patient during a crisis. Many corporations are seriously considering liquidating or selling part of the shares of unprofitable enterprises. Even understanding that the crisis is not eternal does not save companies from ruin.

Pull the ticket - the question is in the ticket: crisis. And it really can become an exam for the matriculation certificate for the Russian government. The actions of the government of Prime Minister Mishustin may enter history as an example of work for the state, an example of the ministry of Russia. But this government may disappear with time, like all previous ones. To melt like a morning fog, which is quickly forgotten ...

So what needs to be done today? Firstly, in the context of a breakdown in economic ties. caused by coronavirus, it is necessary to restore industrial enterprises in the regions as soon as possible. Moreover, it is necessary to recreate the system of ties between local industry and federal corporations. And it is quite possible.

Secondly, to continue financial support for agriculture in all regions of Russia. As life has shown, the country's food security comes to the fore. And in a situation where many experts predict a fall in agricultural production this year, such support provides some additional opportunities for profit from exports.

Thirdly, it is necessary to carefully monitor the international stock market of enterprises. It is no secret that a large number of Russian enterprises and corporations today, thanks to the liberalization of the 90s, belong to Western investors. It is necessary to promptly respond to the appearance at the auction of shares of Russian corporations and, if possible, return them to the ownership of Russia.

The situation when foreigners use our wealth is really absurd. Moreover, they even own shares of defense plants. This practice must be stopped.

Advising, of course, is easy. It is difficult to fulfill the plan. This is also difficult because there will always be those who scream with foam at the mouth in the style usual for our society: “Government is anti-people!” How many times have I heard and read that "it would be better if they gave this money to pensioners." Then, when the decision turned out to be right, such screamers disappeared somewhere.

In general, the situation in the economy today is really serious. And the world will be different. But how? And do we need to take care of the world? Today we need to think about our own country, about our own people. Let's see how our ministers, led by Prime Minister Mishustin, will cope with this.
Author:
Photos used:
http://kremlin.ru
Ctrl Enter

Noticed a mistake Highlight text and press. Ctrl + Enter

65 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must to register.

I have an account? Sign in

  1. Arlen 20 March 2020 07: 30 New
    • 31
    • 5
    +26
    Today we need to think about our own country, about our own people.

    The capitalists and the neo-bourgeoisie will not think about the people and their country. They only think about their pocket. And they remember about the people, only when they need to take away free money from people.
    Let's see how our ministers, led by Prime Minister Mishustin, will cope with this.

    No way. The new government will continue the policy of the old government of Medvedev.
    1. Arlen 20 March 2020 07: 34 New
      • 22
      • 6
      +16
      in order to lead the country out of the economic crisis, one must embark on the path of socialism. but power and the oligarchs will not go to replace capitalism with socialism. they are afraid of socialism, since under socialism the people will ask them for their affairs.
      1. kjhg 20 March 2020 08: 58 New
        • 19
        • 4
        +15
        do we need to take care of the world? Today we need to think about our own country, about our own people.
        Bravo! author love So much pathos. I see directly the picture, how, late at night, when illuminated in the Kremlin, Mishustin, Putin, Siluans, Sechin and Co., sit and discuss: how to help people in times of crisis. So the analogy from "our rush" is asked: "I have no time to rest, I need to think about Russia." One suggests raising salaries to state employees. The second advocates raising pensions. Sechin says he could cut gasoline prices at once. Putin categorically advocates a further increase in the welfare of citizens. Although much more if already today 70% of citizens belong to the middle class fellow.
        Of course we'll see. Where are we going? We do not want to like in Ukraine. So we still have a lot of time ahead, until 2036. Then we’ll definitely see if we survive of course.
      2. Krasnodar 20 March 2020 09: 29 New
        • 6
        • 3
        +3
        Quote: Arlen
        in order to lead the country out of the economic crisis, one must embark on the path of socialism. but power and the oligarchs will not go to replace capitalism with socialism. they are afraid of socialism, since under socialism the people will ask them for their affairs.

        We got up. Nationalized the oil industry. Nationalized metallurgy. Agricultural. Defense industry. Introduced a progressive tax to small and medium-sized businesses. Minimum wage set 30 thousand.
        Pensions were raised to 20 thousand. They introduced a planned economy for steel, hydrocarbons, and construction. What is your scenario of development of events at the current price of liquid and the level of development of domestic technologies?
      3. Ryaruav 20 March 2020 10: 36 New
        • 3
        • 1
        +2
        we are now far from socialism, but our capitalists do not want and cannot develop the economy; they have enough oil and gas
        1. Krasnodar 20 March 2020 10: 54 New
          • 7
          • 1
          +6
          Quote: Ryaruav
          we are now far from socialism, but our capitalists do not want and cannot develop the economy; they have enough oil and gas

          Under the Union, they decided to accelerate production by creating new, more advanced means of production. The result - to create new machines (say) we need new volumes of metal production. Increased iron ore production. New energy capacities. Against this background, prices for Soviet everything are falling - i.e. there was nothing to pay for modern oil and infrastructure. The transition to light industry and electronics was sabotaged in the mid-70s due to the expansion of production of oil that had suddenly risen in price - as a result, the Communists got into an economic puddle, for the sake of access to Western technology and loans, they went closer to the States and others. What we learned from this - we know.
          IMHO - not in the state system, but in competent planning and economic management.
    2. siberalt 20 March 2020 07: 37 New
      • 14
      • 23
      -9
      It seems that the Mishustin government is starting to work in the mode of mobilizing the nation, and this is a good sign. Zadolbalo Medvedev swamp! At least some hope for a better change has arisen. Ahead is inevitably a great cleaning of the managerial staff and a new organization of work. But all this, along with changes in some provisions in the constitution, seems to be a kind of intermediate stage.
      1. bessmertniy 20 March 2020 07: 49 New
        • 11
        • 0
        +11
        The device must be reduced at least twice. Too many have turned up unnecessary bureaucracy, which does nothing, but is guaranteed to receive good salaries and social support. hi
        1. Ryaruav 20 March 2020 10: 38 New
          • 10
          • 1
          +9
          so in April they will introduce the State Council, another superstructure and salaries there will be oh la la
      2. Malyuta 20 March 2020 08: 20 New
        • 33
        • 8
        +25
        Quote: siberalt
        It seems that the Mishustin government is starting to work in the mode of mobilizing the nation, and this is a good sign. Zadolbalo Medvedev swamp! At least some hope for a better change has arisen.

        I wonder what your hopes are justified and on what basis they grew up? Who is Mishustin? It is the flesh of the flesh born of a rotten system and is rather a technical zits-chairman. Even if he wants, he has nowhere to take experienced managerial anti-crisis personnel. The essence of the issue is that of about 3 trillion. of the collected taxes, 1,2 trillion are paid by “poor” people, that is, more than 1/3, respectively, nothing else can come up with this new “genius” of Putin’s RF from “squeezing” money from the inhabitants. Why again deceive yourself with the illusions of breakthroughs and breakthroughs, if there are no prerequisites for this under Putinism.
        1. Snail N9 20 March 2020 08: 46 New
          • 13
          • 4
          +9
          At the very beginning, when they put Mishustin as “prime minister,” I wrote here that this is “ffm not casual” —the goal is to get Medvedev out of the onslaught of the impending “priests” of the crisis (something is being prepared and obviously very very bad, very crisis and "ruble-landslide"), and substitute a new "kinder surprise" for this blow - in order for him to introduce "tough" measures to squeeze money out of everything and everyone, he’ll get out, well, don’t get out, all the dogs on him hang, not a pity. Well, yes, the subject has already announced, even at the last meeting, that in the context of impending crisis in the economy due to falling production and coronovirus, the main task of the government will be to extend the tax burden to other sectors of production and entrepreneurship and business in the country, as well as to further tighten tax discipline (read-pressure) of both legal entities and physicists.
        2. lucul 20 March 2020 09: 55 New
          • 3
          • 14
          -11
          The essence of the issue is that of about 3 trillion. taxes collected, 1,2 trillion are paid by "poor" people,

          Well HOW poor people can pay SUCH taxes to the budget? They are yours - earn a penny)))
          If half of today's sanctions were applied to the USSR, then it would not have collapsed in 1991, but in 1970.
          And then we live, practically in a war - and they all cry that the economy is bad. It’s like in 1942, in Leningrad people would cry for Stalin that he does not give them the opportunity to buy jamon ....
          1. Kronos 20 March 2020 11: 00 New
            • 12
            • 0
            +12
            Do you know that from the USSR until the mid-20s no one recognized, did not trade, and did not have any business? And then almost immediately after the Second World War, they imposed sanctions much harder than those of bourgeois Russia
            1. Serg65 20 March 2020 13: 24 New
              • 2
              • 7
              -5
              Quote: Kronos
              Do you know that from the USSR until the mid-20s no one recognized, did not trade, and did not have any business?

              And do you know that if it were not for American help during the famine of 21-23 years, then there would be no Soviet power in the early 20s?
              1. naidas 20 March 2020 14: 24 New
                • 1
                • 0
                +1
                Quote: Serg65
                And do you know that if it were not for American help during the famine of 21-23 years, then there would be no Soviet power in the early 20s?

                This is nonsense. The famine was both under the tsar and under Stalin (in the next 1924 famine in 9 regions). RI did not collapse due to hunger, while the USSR, in the presence of hungry regions, lived to see 1991.
                1. Serg65 20 March 2020 14: 56 New
                  • 2
                  • 3
                  -1
                  Quote: naidas
                  This is bullshit

                  From 4 to 5 million dead are certainly nonsense! Yes, and 72 million then-real pennies!
                  Quote: naidas
                  RI fell apart not because of hunger

                  But it was the bread riot of St. Petersburg women that became the trigger of the February revolution!
                  Quote: naidas
                  at the same time, the USSR, in the presence of hungry regions, lived to see 1991.

                  But it was after the "fat" seventies that the hungry years of the second half of the 80s recaptured the people's desire to defend Soviet power!
                  1. naidas 20 March 2020 16: 31 New
                    • 3
                    • 1
                    +2
                    Quote: Serg65
                    From 4 to 5 million dead are certainly nonsense!

                    It is you who distort, you want to earn money on deaths, to you in Zen, they love such people there. Write nonsense that hunger leads to the overthrow of power. Power is not overthrown by the hungry, but by the well-fed that they did not feed.
                    1. Golovan Jack 20 March 2020 17: 31 New
                      • 6
                      • 4
                      +2
                      Quote: naidas
                      Power is not overthrown by the hungry, but whose well-fed did not feed

                      Not certainly in that way. Well-fed, who believe that they are underfed laughing
    3. Mordvin 3 20 March 2020 08: 41 New
      • 16
      • 3
      +13
      Quote: Arlen
      The new government will continue the policy of the old government

      And if he doesn’t manage, then there is always an old, experienced government in stock. They satisfactorily worked. There is nothing for them to wipe their pants in the Security Council. Homeland is in danger.
    4. Svarog 20 March 2020 08: 49 New
      • 24
      • 4
      +20
      Quote: Arlen
      No way. The new government will continue the policy of the old government of Medvedev.

      Definitely no .. There is a problem not even in personalities, but in the system ..
      The economy is focused on the sale of hydrocarbons .. and at the low price of oil, they will not do anything.
      That's when the price was $ 100 per barrel, there was a chance. It is necessary to develop industry, pharmacology, machine tools, electronics. In general, strive to produce a product with high added value .. But for this there must be advanced science .. So the circle has closed.
      If nothing has been done in 30 years, then at a low oil price, a miracle will not happen.
      For myself, I have long understood that the model that our capitalists are trying to fit into is not working for Russia. Our place in this model is gas stations ..
      To change the situation, we need to remember our great past, where we were successful in everything. And taking into account mistakes, develop the state.
      1. Krasnodar 20 March 2020 11: 02 New
        • 5
        • 1
        +4
        Quote: Svarog

        Definitely no .. There is a problem not even in personalities, but in the system ..
        The economy is focused on the sale of hydrocarbons .. and at the low price of oil, they will not do anything.
        That's when the price was $ 100 per barrel, there was a chance. It is necessary to develop industry, pharmacology, machine tools, electronics. In general, strive to produce a product with high added value .. But for this there must be advanced science .. So the circle has closed.
        If nothing has been done in 30 years, then at a low oil price, a miracle will not happen.
        For myself, I have long understood that the model that our capitalists are trying to fit into is not working for Russia. Our place in this model is gas stations ..
        To change the situation, we need to remember our great past, where we were successful in everything. And taking into account mistakes, develop the state.

        They were successful in space, in physics, in the military-industrial complex, in education BEGINNING. HSE - only mathematics, physics and teaching.
        For high-tech production - it’s not a problem to create the world's largest generic drug - the same Teva (the largest generic company in the world, owned by tiny Israel), has developed for its entire existence no more than three drugs. Machine tool construction is even easier. Patents in the world - the sea)). Create a commission on the purchase, put the Germans and Swedes there - and life was a success fellow The question is business security, i.e. control over state structures, and, to a greater extent, the mentality of the country's population.
        1. naidas 20 March 2020 14: 26 New
          • 4
          • 0
          +4
          Quote: Krasnodar
          put there the Germans-Swedes

          Here the problem is not even in personalities, but in the system ..
          So they will put their trusted person on the cash flows.
          1. Krasnodar 20 March 2020 14: 47 New
            • 4
            • 1
            +3
            This is definitely
    5. DMB 75 20 March 2020 10: 37 New
      • 12
      • 2
      +10
      The course of the new government was immediately declared the same, so I do not expect anything good.
  2. Million 20 March 2020 07: 39 New
    • 19
    • 5
    +14
    Most likely, in Russia, a small group of people who are especially close to the emperor will receive profit from the coronavirus. The rest, as always, will remain with their nose ...
    1. depressant 20 March 2020 09: 13 New
      • 13
      • 3
      +10
      Million colleague, absolutely agree.
      Here, look. Just yesterday or the day before yesterday, in general, the other day, Putin worriedly said that it was time to print out the “little egg” of the National Welfare Fund (NWF) in favor of SOME categories of the population. But he did not specify in favor of which particular categories. I will not be mistaken in the assumption that in favor of the oil and gas magnates, in order to compensate them with lost income. The carrier price fell catastrophically, China refused to buy Russian oil, the Power of Siberia was put to “repair” even earlier (to save face?). And since the oligarchs' shortfall in income is huge, the notorious "little egg" is equally catastrophically empty. And then, so that in the short term, the middle class, which will quickly reach where its taxes will flow away and a significant part of which is small trade, does not grumble, rampaging from injustice, Mishustin orders to reduce the number of tax and customs inspections. In fact-- stop completely. What does this mean? Set the prices you want. The people realized right away, the people rushed to buy everything. But you won’t save yourself for life. And the prices ... They have already gone up. This is a concession for shopkeepers to shut up. And to shut up large retail chains, which last year have a serious shortfall in revenue. Like, get it! The customs will not check what is exported, what is imported. I think a lot will be exported. The people on the Web are laughing: the fur stores will be empty, the middle class will take itself to foreign alternate aerodromes. But the thing is that many small industries out of a few still somehow breathing can die (the import of Chinese components and tools is blocked). And when the rush demand drops, and it drops, when the personal skinny people's capsules are empty, the old people's salaries in response to rising prices will force the people to growl. And the shopkeepers screech. For no one will refund to them the lost income. So what? But nothing! More than 50 people are not going to a bunch! This is the order from above - the coronavirus!

      Yes, in the United States in 2008, the government reimbursed the lost revenue to some large corporations. But unlike us, the Fed there simply printed the right amount of dollars. In our country, the NWF will be spent completely, where taxes from the entire population were formed. NWF will be empty. But there will be a record number of dollar billionaires - the nouveau riche. In the long run, a catastrophe is seen - both economic and political.
      I suspect that well-calculated. Novak could not act independently in negotiations with the sheikhs. Question: from which group of persons was he ambassador to those negotiations? And what did this group of people have in mind?
  3. vic02 20 March 2020 07: 42 New
    • 18
    • 7
    +11
    This exam is not for the government, but for all citizens of Russia. It must be understood that neither this government, nor this president, nor the current ruling party, which led Russia to the current crisis, can rule the country and give a corresponding assessment - “no” to their actions in the elections and voting on changes to the Constitution.
    1. Nyrobsky 20 March 2020 10: 45 New
      • 5
      • 0
      +5
      Quote: vic02
      This exam is not for the government, but for all citizens of Russia. It must be understood that neither this government, nor this president, nor the current ruling party, which led Russia to the current crisis, can rule the country and give a corresponding assessment - “no” to their actions in the elections and voting on changes to the Constitution.

      In fairness, it should be noted that this crisis is not exclusively Russian. Shakes and sausages the entire planet. The question is how, in the absence of debts and the presence of not weak gold reserves, our "geniuses" from the economy will be able to overcome this crisis? If the economy is reoriented to the domestic market, Babos pour in the development of their own production, this is one thing, and if they throw up reserves to support the banking sector and save big business and the oligarchy, covering the treasury losses by increasing the tax burden for the population, then everything will be stupid and falling as always living standards of most Russians.
      1. Svarog 20 March 2020 11: 45 New
        • 11
        • 5
        +6
        Quote: Nyrobsky
        and if reserves are thrown to support the banking sector and save big business and the oligarchy, covering the treasury losses by increasing the tax burden for the population, then everything will be as usual - stupidity and a drop in the standard of living of most Russians.

        So there is no doubt that it will be so .. power has repeatedly walked along this path, so why will it suddenly turn off?
        In fairness, it should be noted that this crisis is not exclusively Russian. Shakes and sausages the entire planet.

        The ruble is the most volatile currency in the world .. the whole world has chills .. but we are only really shaking ..
        1. depressant 20 March 2020 13: 35 New
          • 4
          • 3
          +1
          Forced myself to go up and go shopping. It’s hard for me - it still sways from side to side, Quincke’s syndrome, chronic, from nerves. Previously, it was just periodically swollen, but now with nausea, catastrophic dizziness, in general, it dragged itself on. The prices for perishable products are the same; shopkeepers and the Five are not interested in spoiling them. And cereals ... Colleagues, do not believe it! A pack of steamed rice, which cost 56 rubles on March 11, today costs 108! The shelves are really empty. No salt, no buckwheat, no naughty, no toilet paper! Laundry soap, "Whiteness" disappeared completely. But the meat and sausages - the sea, but not a single buyer at the shelves. People buy vegetables.
          Do you remember how the USSR fell? Food shortage! Now it’s hard for Putin: how to make the shopkeeper refuse to trade in food, and even at non-rising prices? But very simple. Not later than today, a recommendation was received, it is an order from the government of the Moscow Region - to large networks to stop trading. Presumably, in other areas, large networks have received a similar order. And if this is so everywhere, then this is more than serious.
          1. Golovan Jack 20 March 2020 13: 44 New
            • 4
            • 8
            -4
            Quote: depressant
            Remember how the USSR fell? Food shortage! Now it’s hard for Putin: how to make the shopkeeper refuse to trade in food, and even at non-rising prices?

            Oh, how ... and here Putin is to blame - it turns out he has a blue dream - to ruin the Russian Federation ... Cool winked

            Quote: depressant
            Not later than today, a recommendation was received, it’s an order from the government of the Moscow Region - to large networks to stop trading

            Give a reference to the source. They have already written that they will close Moscow, until they have closed it and are not going to.
            1. naidas 20 March 2020 14: 38 New
              • 1
              • 0
              +1
              Quote: Golovan Jack
              order, from the government of the Moscow region - to large networks to stop trading

              Around 00:40 Moscow time, the document disappeared from the site of the regional government. RBC sent a request to the administration of the Moscow region.

              Read more at RBC:
              To recommend the owners of shopping centers, shopping malls, multifunctional shopping and entertainment centers, outlet centers during high alert for the governing bodies and forces of the Moscow regional emergency warning and response system to suspend the operation of these facilities



              https://www.rbc.ru/society/19/03/2020/5e73d41f9a7947fa550df7f4
              1. Golovan Jack 20 March 2020 15: 37 New
                • 2
                • 7
                -5
                Quote: naidas
                ... shopping centers, shopping malls, multifunctional shopping and entertainment centers, outlet centers ...

                AND! Well, it’s about junk and amusement that ... There is not a word about grocery, about which the esteemed "depressant" wrote.
                1. naidas 20 March 2020 16: 17 New
                  • 1
                  • 1
                  0
                  Do not quibble. Real and Auchan are not just about brahla.
  4. bessmertniy 20 March 2020 07: 46 New
    • 11
    • 0
    +11
    Coronavirrus in times of crisis is a remission to which the world's state elites can blame all their mistakes, muhlezh and crimes. negative And this is the remission of sins by them now committed under the guise of fighting the crisis. hi
  5. Livonetc 20 March 2020 07: 52 New
    • 2
    • 4
    -2
    Our budget is no longer in surplus.
    And we no longer have time.
    However, this does not mean the need to immediately reveal a miracle.
    We work calmly and take care of ourselves and loved ones.
    1. Mestny 20 March 2020 09: 25 New
      • 5
      • 14
      -9
      Well what are you. ETOGES have to work yourself.
      Here, some are already voting with foam at the mouth - no to reforms, down with power.
  6. polar fox 20 March 2020 07: 53 New
    • 10
    • 4
    +6
    Then, when the decision turned out to be right, such screamers disappeared somewhere.
    here from this moment in more detail ... although this is from which side to look: from the side of the "guarantor" and its organized criminal group, or from the people ...
  7. novel66 20 March 2020 07: 55 New
    • 6
    • 1
    +5
    waiting for the phrase - two! Sit down!
  8. samarin1969 20 March 2020 08: 01 New
    • 14
    • 2
    +12
    I support the assessment of the situation and the “three recipes” from Staver.
    But I don’t believe in radical measures of Mishustin’s people. They will not want to quarrel with local elites and Western corporations. And without this, all "anti-crisis measures" will again be props.
    We need, perhaps the worst, but our own technologies, standards, components, seed stocks, machine tools, machines ...
    We need draconian measures against offshore companies, financial surrogates, non-critical imports (without whiskey, Bali and jamon).
    But this is fantastic! "Mishustins" even with Gaster and thieves do not want to quarrel. And then you need to disobey the Moloch globalization. bully
    1. Malyuta 20 March 2020 09: 09 New
      • 16
      • 5
      +11
      Quote: samarin1969
      We need draconian measures against offshore companies, financial surrogates, non-critical imports (without whiskey, Bali and jamon).

      Mouse vs cheese is funny.
  9. Boris55 20 March 2020 08: 15 New
    • 6
    • 13
    -7
    Crises are a natural state of capitalism. The race between raising salaries and prices is a "game", the purpose of which is to make people work sutra until the evening, 7 days a week, without days off and holidays.

    The biggest crime of capitalism is to give the people a dream that they can quickly earn a "million" and do nothing else. So that a situation does not happen that all around suddenly become idlers and they have no incentive to work, there is a mechanism such as a crisis that nullifies all the accumulations of workers and people again have to drag the strap of capitalism until the next financial cataclysm, a date which no one can predict a "learned" economist, but which financiers know for sure - it is they who, through bank deposits, track the accumulations of citizens and, with certain accumulations of them, start the next mechanism to reset them. There are no unmanaged processes. Nothing happens by itself.

    The global crisis, and Russia is part of the global economy, has superimposed on social transformations within Russia, on strengthening its sovereignty and in this regard, the reaction of the West to us - sanctions, the price of oil + kronovirus ... Our liberals are not far behind them, with their calls not to vote for social transformations in the Constitution aimed at the benefit of each of us and the country as a whole.

    ps
    Under Stalin, there were no crises due to the fact that under it, prices were reduced, and not salaries were raised.
    1. Ross xnumx 20 March 2020 09: 22 New
      • 10
      • 4
      +6
      Quote: Boris55
      Our liberals are not far behind them, with their calls not to vote for the social transformations in the Constitution aimed at the benefit of each of us and the country as a whole.

      Without this fragment, a worthy replica.
      Do you know what I’ll tell you? We don’t have to offer a bag of cats. If you have not yet figured out how an amendment to the constitution should be adopted (each individually, before the president signs them as having entered into force ...) then do not hang up noodles about anonymous liberals. Us on the second channel "fish-Skabeeva"

      all the brains are eaten ...
      1. Boris55 20 March 2020 11: 22 New
        • 0
        • 2
        -2
        Quote: ROSS 42
        how should an amendment to the constitution be adopted (individually,

        Who would argue, and I'm for it, BUT!

        "State policy and management in a crowd-elite society is an agreement reached on the possibilities of various clan-corporate groups in using the state structure and system to achieve their narrowly corporate goals."

        We accept amendments package for one reason only, these are agreements reached between clan groups. In Soviet times, it was called: inside the party struggle, under carpet games, etc.
    2. AA17 20 March 2020 12: 08 New
      • 2
      • 0
      +2
      Dear Boris. Crises are a natural state of capitalism. This phrase of yours confirms that once you studied K.Marx and V.I. Lenin. I want to remind you another work of M. Gorky in the modern version.
      "The crisis of the clouds collects"
      “The crisis is gathering clouds over the financial system. Illiquidity proudly roars between the dollar and the euro, confiscation is similar.
      Either collapsing markets, or surging rates, Illiquidity triumphs - speculators sense death in its cries of loud.
      In this groan - a thirst for money! The collapse of quotes, the economic downturn and confidence in bankruptcy are heard by the markets in this scream.
      Stupid Ministry of Finance before the storm timidly rushing around the markets, devalued, ready to hide the fear of default.
      The oligarchs are also groaning - oligarchs cannot enjoy the daring market, the wonderful market element: their ruin scares them.
      More and more gloomy and lower, the index falls above the stock exchange, and capitals run away, dropping rates into the abyss. ...
      Illiquidity shouts with a cry, black lightning is like an arrow piercing exchanges, sending banks into the abyss.
      The crisis rushes like a demon - a proud, black demon of the market - and laughs and laughs ... laughs at bankers, laughs at the government! ... The press is howling ... Children are crying. And investors cry ...
      Stock exchange quotes are glowing with red flame. And trillions burn: - Crisis! Soon the crisis will strike!
      It boldly and freely roars the spirit of the Elements of the Market over the roaring angry world; then the prophet of victory shouts: - Let the CRISIS strike more strongly! .. "
      (Folk crisis work https://rb.ru/article/krizis-tuchi-sobiraet/5539117.html)
  10. rocket757 20 March 2020 08: 32 New
    • 3
    • 2
    +1
    Question on ticket - crisis: exam for the government of Mishustin

    One thing is clear, this is an exam for ALL who are at the helm!
    It seems that everyone will take it .... on their own! because like the "united west" as it is self-insulated, from each other ....
    Ours, by definition and circumstances, will have to do everything ourselves .... not the first time.
  11. Mordvin 3 20 March 2020 08: 35 New
    • 6
    • 2
    +4
    with almost 100% probability you will see a surprised look or hear the direction where he will advise you to go.

    Oh well. We have been living at the market for 30 years. Grandmas will explain to you the rise in price of garden parsley with the dollar exchange rate.
    Industrial production in Russia decreased by a quarter! Remember what our car plants turned into then. Drop three times! Engineering was halved. Construction has fallen by more than 30%!

    And now it will be reduced. And dumped on the mouse virus.
  12. Stirbjorn 20 March 2020 09: 04 New
    • 9
    • 2
    +7
    And the destructive consequences for the economy occurred only because Russia simply did not have the opportunity to respond to challenges. We did not have that notorious "airbag".
    Today there is such a “pillow”. Today we have a reserve of time. We have the opportunity not only to preserve what has already been achieved, but also to change the existing reality. Just so, change reality in the economic sense of the word.

    I re-read it three times, but didn’t understand why there is a pillow now, but there wasn’t before request
    Thirdly, it is necessary to carefully monitor the international stock market of enterprises. It is no secret that a large number of Russian enterprises and corporations today, thanks to the liberalization of the 90s, belong to Western investors. It is necessary to promptly respond to the appearance at the auction of shares of Russian corporations and, if possible, return them to the ownership of Russia.
    When in 2014 the dollar jumped twice, out of the blue, conspiracy theorists just explained this by the fact that because of the depreciation of the ruble, our authorities bought up the shares of our enterprises from Western owners. Then the truth is that everything was somehow forgotten, and the main version remained in the form of speculation at the very top. So on this occasion I see no reason to have hope.
  13. cniza 20 March 2020 09: 11 New
    • 4
    • 0
    +4
    In general, the situation in the economy today is really serious. And the world will be different. But how? And do we need to take care of the world? Today we need to think about our own country, about our own people.


    In short, a fun time, they will rob us again.
  14. nikvic46 20 March 2020 09: 19 New
    • 3
    • 0
    +3
    Maybe I misunderstood the author. But I realized that the main goal is to achieve the starting point. Each article of the Constitution should be conveyed in such a way that it gives the people and the country. For some time we are engaged in construction and repair without a guarantee. "Signed, and from the shoulders Down with".
  15. Stalnov I.P. 20 March 2020 09: 26 New
    • 5
    • 0
    +5
    And the high inmates in the Kremlin and the White House, what place they think that analytics and forecasting are completely absent. Until the roasted cock in the ass bites, fairy tales will procrastinate. With such an attitude to our duties and decisions, we will not go far. It is already seen that the knowledge of the economy and its development in the highest armchairs is completely absent.
    1. 72jora72 20 March 2020 10: 08 New
      • 7
      • 0
      +7
      With such an attitude to our duties and decisions, we will not go far.
      I'm afraid that we have already arrived.
  16. Ross xnumx 20 March 2020 09: 53 New
    • 9
    • 5
    +4
    Write about:
    The Russian government knows the “goals” that the crisis will hit

    it means just lying.
    Insanity is to slam the door in the face of world oil producers when the world economy slides into the pit of crisis. And these are not Cossacks “sent from the West”, but the representative (NOVAK) of the new “Mishustin government”.
    Judging by the events of the week, nothing positive expects us. The appreciation of the dollar and the decline in oil prices marked the "priorities" of the ever-frightened Russian inhabitants. Low-cost, long-term storage products slowly disappear from stores. Retailers complaining about the low purchasing power of Russians are rubbing their hands with pleasure, watching grandmothers and grandfathers “stick” shopping bags and push carts with once “slow-moving” goods. Suddenly, everyone remembered that they had run out of flour, salt, sugar, buckwheat, semolina, vervishel and pasta, and very little was left until the second coming.
    If this "coronavirus-oil-trade" conspiracy has no artificial origin, then it JUST WAS TO BE THINKED !!!
    The most “pleasant news” for the Russian authorities will be that those who “doubt” both on the issues of voting amendments and on the question of perpetuating the Supreme Ruler of Russia will slowly flow into the category of “consonants”. And they can be understood, they have the sad experience of the 90s, when morality was replaced by thieves' concepts. It was then that the EBN organized crime groups were not satisfied with the Soviet constitution, it was then that they imposed on the people exactly such a path, precisely such rails (on which the EBN never laid, by the way), along which we had to "fit" into the world market.
    Congratulations! Fit in! fellow And what can now be expected from those who write laws and regulations with sympathetic ink? Yes, they will simply give up their words and promises, making us and you stupid people, people "misunderstood", people "misunderstood" ...
    Everything will again fall on our shoulders: depreciation of savings, employment costs, outstanding loan obligations and mortgages ... And no one will do anything from what you expect from them. Finger does not move. But most importantly:
  17. Chaldon48 20 March 2020 10: 08 New
    • 2
    • 1
    +1
    The nouveaux riches in the government have always thought and will think first of all about their own wallet.
  18. Dr. Watson 20 March 2020 11: 16 New
    • 3
    • 4
    -1
    It is enough just to look at the well-fed and touching faces of those in power in the photograph preceding the article, to immediately understand in which direction they will wag their tail, and in which winds they will let.
  19. Mikhail3 20 March 2020 12: 18 New
    • 3
    • 0
    +3
    The government is already responding. At times, increased activity in collecting various kinds of debts to the budget. In the conditions of a vertical drop in demand for everything and everything, in a matter of weeks it will lead to the closure of thousands and then hundreds of thousands of enterprises and organizations. Our government is responding, don’t worry ...
  20. prior 20 March 2020 12: 43 New
    • 1
    • 1
    0
    I remembered the unforgettable: - "How are you Maestro?" - "It's okay. I'm falling ...."
  21. Kapellan23 20 March 2020 13: 24 New
    • 4
    • 0
    +4
    Today we need to think about our own country, about our own people. Let's see how our ministers, led by Prime Minister Mishustin, will cope with this.

    What kind of people will Mishustyan think about?
  22. bandabas 20 March 2020 13: 43 New
    • 2
    • 0
    +2
    This "government" is the full tracing of the previous one, unfortunately.
  23. parusnik 20 March 2020 18: 43 New
    • 0
    • 0
    0
    In 2008 there was a crisis, then in 2014, now again, with a frequency of 6 years ...
  24. faterdom 20 March 2020 20: 37 New
    • 0
    • 0
    0
    This exam is not for Mishustin. And for someone else. If he manages to fly both Americans and Saudis at the same time (we don’t even consider Europeans, not actors) - and the people will feel it in their budget - well done - go for at least a seventh term.
    If, besides chatter, nothing again - then stop, the wheels - that's enough! "Tired - I'm leaving." There are undoubted merits, a place in History - also, do not spoil everything.
  25. serge siberian 20 March 2020 20: 39 New
    • 2
    • 0
    +2
    Prince of Moscow, Alexei, after the feuds ended in Russia, which led to inter-war wars. I raided other "vorogs." it became scarce, and after some time it’s also, as they say today, has found both a surplus and a “safety cushion.” But for current ruling people it’s too tough for the people. soldier
  26. iouris 21 March 2020 14: 46 New
    • 0
    • 0
    0
    “Crisis” is a test for Nabiullina. There is a war. If the state is not ready for this war, then no government can cope.
  27. domokl 22 March 2020 19: 58 New
    • 0
    • 0
    0
    I read all the comments on 19-50 on 22.03 ... And what did we become comrade officers? I’m not talking about youth who grew up under the post-Soviet government. I'm talking about the Soviet ... Tell me, how can one live, fight, win, if all commanders are traitors and dumbasses. If the commander in chief leads the wrong way. And you yourself do not believe in victory. Do not believe at all. Neither today, nor tomorrow, never. Why then do we need you?
    Honestly, I do not believe that Soviet and Russian officers are like that ... I myself know the Soviet ones, only by talk, but I remember those who died in Syria and other hot spots. In general, I think they are no worse.
    It is necessary to win, win or perish. Let the other commander celebrate the victory.
  28. faterdom 22 March 2020 21: 44 New
    • 1
    • 0
    +1
    Quote: domokl
    Tell me, how can one live, fight, win, if all commanders are traitors and dumbasses.

    You are not the first. Some guy already formulated everything about the "herd of lions led by a ram," and what it really costs.
    I say honestly: I do not believe a penny Medvedev, Serdyukov, Siluanov, Gref and the like! And therefore I do not trust the one who appointed them.
    He served for a long time, he saw commanders much better in any areas.
    Therefore, I join the question: "How can I?" Only let us address it not to soldiers, and not to major captains, they always pulled our Motherland from all dangerous and uncomfortable positions.
    Let us turn this question to the one on whom the answer depends.