“The Kremlin lost”: Khodorkovsky spoke about a court decision in The Hague in the Yukos case

133

Mikhail Khodorkovsky commented on the decision of the Hague Court of Appeal in favor of Yukos shareholders, according to which Russia should pay shareholders $ 50 billion.

In 2014, the International Arbitration Court in The Hague assessed the actions of the Russian Federation as the actual expropriation of Yukos. Then this decision was quashed by the Hague district court, and now the court of appeal has already quashed the decision of the district court, thereby updating the decision of the international arbitration court again.



Now, Yukos shareholders plan to seize and seize the assets of the Russian state in other countries in the amount of $ 50 billion. This was stated by businessman Leonid Nevzlin, who now lives in Israel, and in Russia was sentenced in absentia to life imprisonment. Nevzlin, recall, is the main beneficiary of the company GML, which acts in the interests of the majority shareholders of Yukos.

Naturally, Mikhail Khodorkovsky also reacted to this event. A famous figure, a former in 1997-2004. co-owner of Yukos, Khodorkovsky spent more than 10 years by the sentence of a Russian court in prison, and after serving his sentence he immediately left for permanent residence in Europe.

Today, the Kremlin lost a court in The Hague to Yukos shareholders. I am not a shareholder or a participant in the process, but I am extremely pleased with this event. Since not only the procedure has been confirmed, but also the essence: “weaning of Yukos” is not about taxes, but about the fight against political opponents,

- Mikhail Khodorkovsky wrote on his Facebook page.

At the same time, Khodorkovsky did not forget once again to “stab” the Russian government. According to him, people are now concerned about the question, from whose pocket Russia will give these 50 billion dollars? So, according to Mikhail Khodorkovsky, power gives people only that which cannot but give and takes away everything that it can take away. The Russian government, according to Khodorkovsky, will not give money, but if it is forced, then it will be given at the expense of ordinary citizens.

What rejoices Mikhail Khodorkovsky? Indeed, even if one recognizes his point of view regarding the Russian authorities, it turns out that the obligation to return money to shareholders will put a heavy burden on the Russian budget and on ordinary Russians as well. But this disgraced oligarch is of little interest. In the first place are financial interests. On the second - the desire to harm Russia at all costs, while Vladimir Putin is at the head of our country.

For example, what is an “arrest of Russian assets abroad”? If so, they will not arrest “private” assets recorded in all kinds of front offices and front persons, but open, well-known assets of the Russian state, that is, property of Russia. The personal property of Russian officials and oligarchs is unlikely to be affected, although Khodorkovsky hopes that some hidden assets of the authorities will be revealed.

In his post on the social network, Khodorkovsky not only rejoiced at the decision of the court in The Hague, but also did not forget to once again call for mass protests against the existing system.

We all need to get rid of the hostage syndrome. Do not count on their pity, but create situations where it becomes a less risky choice to pay off, and in the end to leave,

- wrote Khodorkovsky.

What is meant by a situation when to leave is less risky, probably, it is not worth explaining. Domestic liberals and their foreign patrons like to cite the example of the fate of Gaddafi, Saddam Hussein, at best, Yanukovych. At the same time, the prospects for mass riots, civil war, the death of thousands of people, the destruction of infrastructure, a colossal blow to the economy, the possible exclusion of part of the territories from the country, they, apparently, are not afraid. The main thing is to “pick up,” as they like to put it, the Russian government that they hate.
Our news channels

Subscribe and stay up to date with the latest news and the most important events of the day.

133 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. +17
    19 February 2020 10: 41
    We don’t give a damn about the fate of our thieving bureaucrats and oligarchs, but the situation with the return of 50 yards. and the possible seizure of property of the Russian Federation and property of state-owned companies or property of companies where there is a share of the Russian Federation, very strained, and if you give 50 yards, then a precedent, and stretch walkers.
    1. +9
      19 February 2020 10: 44
      Here Deripaska can share experience.
    2. +24
      19 February 2020 10: 44
      The Russian government, according to Khodorkovsky, will not give money, but if it is forced to, it will still be given at the expense of ordinary citizens.

      Although this character is not pleasant to me deeply .. but the fact that everything will fall on the shoulders of ordinary citizens is a fact ..
      1. +9
        19 February 2020 11: 18
        Quote: Svarog
        Although this character is not pleasant to me deeply .. but the fact that everything will fall on the shoulders of ordinary citizens is a fact.

        Well, Yukos just did not dissolve, there are personalities whom he got after Hodor and the brothers. Here is the demand from them.
        1. +11
          19 February 2020 11: 26
          Quote: tihonmarine
          Here is the demand from them.

          Who will ask them? No, they will not be asked from them, they will be taken from ordinary citizens of Russia ... In the form of taxes, fines. hi
          1. +3
            19 February 2020 11: 34
            Yes, they’d throw an ible to them to minimize losses.
            1. +8
              19 February 2020 11: 45
              Exactly! They will arrange "tax holidays"!
              1. +1
                19 February 2020 16: 25
                Compensation to Yukos shareholders is a political tool against Russia. Lawyers are no longer being asked here.

                And Khodorovsky himself does not give up hope of becoming the president of Russia, therefore he makes himself infallible and fair, trying to distort the economic indicators of Russia.
          2. +2
            19 February 2020 11: 49
            Quote: Sergey Olegovich
            Who will ask them? No, they will not be asked from them, they will be taken from ordinary citizens of Russia.

            But there is no doubt about that. You can't take anything from the poor oligarchs, but from the "rich people" (there is no money, but you endure) it will be possible to rip them out. And thieves with life sentences have already rolled their lips.
        2. +2
          19 February 2020 12: 16
          Demand must be from the beneficiary
      2. +16
        19 February 2020 11: 27
        Quote: Svarog
        everything will fall on the shoulders of ordinary citizens is a fact ..

        Russia, of course, is unlikely to agree to pay the amount, which, taking into account the accrued penalties, is already over $ 60 billion. If Russia refuses to recognize the court's decision, the plaintiffs will have to forcibly collect money from the country's assets abroad. A long, many years of struggle will begin, which will disintegrate. for many episodes, since there is no one asset that costs 50 lard of American rubles in one piece. Obviously, the plaintiffs will have to collect this amount in some small pieces. The plaintiffs will be able to seize property that belongs to the Russian Federation and which is not subject to immunity ( military, diplomatic and others) .Because note that the court's decision concerns only Russia, and "Rosneft", which is considered the successor of "YUKOS", formally has nothing to do with the case. That is, they will not tear the skin from the other, but from you and me as law-abiding taxpayers of the Russian Federation. That's what infuriates ..
        1. +7
          19 February 2020 11: 45
          Quote: GKS 2111
          After all, note that the court's decision concerns only Russia, and Rosneft, which is considered the successor of Yukos, is formally irrelevant to the case. That is, they will not tear the skin off from the skin, but from us, as law-abiding taxpayers of the Russian Federation. what infuriates ..

          If you look at the "money box", then it is approximately = the debt of Russian companies to the West. And then we just privatize income and nationalize expenses. And since a second oil in the form of plebs was found in the Russian Federation by the method of long drilling, this oil will be distilled into dead raccoons. Folk wisdom says that those who milk are milked.
    3. 0
      19 February 2020 10: 54
      Quote: Lamata
      Lamata (Igor)

      Do not worry, everything has already been invented - amendments to the Constitution. And I give free advice, privatize everything to hell and bring it to offshore, but there is no Hague court.
      1. +10
        19 February 2020 11: 19
        So there is another, completely opposite, option: to nationalize EVERYTHING-all-all to such a mother, and to force former oligarchs to send them to the West naked - that is how the social balance in Russia will be restored. laughing
        1. +3
          19 February 2020 11: 25
          Quote: hydrox
          hydrox (hydrox)

          This is exactly what I wanted to say, only in other words. Banter, however.
          Glad you understood me. good drinks
          1. 0
            19 February 2020 11: 30
            A good banter raises your tone well! laughing
            1. +1
              19 February 2020 11: 31
              Quote: hydrox
              A good banter raises your tone well!

              That's why the pike in the river, so that the crucian would not doze off laughing
        2. +3
          19 February 2020 11: 36
          Quote: hydrox
          and former oligarchs Forced to send naked to the West - this is how the social balance in Russia will be restored. laughing
          It smacks of anti-Semitism .. laughing
          1. +3
            19 February 2020 11: 53
            Come on, there’s an integral world international!
      2. +5
        19 February 2020 11: 26
        Quote: Stroporez
        . And I give free advice, privatize everything to hell

        Can all declare socialist property .. and wave at last ...
        1. +3
          19 February 2020 11: 33
          Quote: Svarog
          Can all declare socialist property .. and wave at last.

          Like, if we don’t go to revolution, then revolution will come to us? wink
          1. +6
            19 February 2020 11: 34
            Quote: Stroporez
            Quote: Svarog
            Can all declare socialist property .. and wave at last.

            Like, if we don’t go to revolution, then revolution will come to us? wink

            Well, yes .. the liberals so wanted to be friends with the West, that soon this friendship would leave us without pants .. Again, the socialists would pull the country out of ruins ..
            1. +4
              19 February 2020 11: 37
              Quote: Svarog
              Svarog (Vladimir)

              It would be something to pull out, otherwise they can get a lot of nerves in the end.
            2. +6
              19 February 2020 13: 45
              Quote: Svarog
              the liberals so wanted to be friends with the West, that soon this friendship would leave us without pants .. Again, the socialists would pull the country out of ruins ..

              And get it out! The main thing is that all these opponents of the people's democratic Soviet power cling under their feet.
              1. +4
                19 February 2020 16: 13
                Quote: Red
                so that under these feet all these

                they will interfere, they will envy our successes, they will prevent us from rebuilding Russia from capitalist ruins.
        2. +8
          19 February 2020 11: 56
          Quote: Svarog
          Can all declare socialist property .. and wave at last ...

          Nationalize and wave to capitalism, some may misunderstand you. hi
    4. -8
      19 February 2020 10: 54
      “The Kremlin lost”: Khodorkovsky spoke about a court decision in The Hague in the Yukos case

      The dog barks - the caravan goes .....
      1. +4
        19 February 2020 16: 22
        Quote: lucul
        The dog barks - the caravan goes

        I came across a poem on the Internet:

        The dog barks - the caravan goes on,
        Only a stupid quarrel in life is looking for.
        Tick ​​- a parasite, he drinks other people's blood,
        It’s hard to create food itself.

        There are parasites among people,
        They live, at the expense of others, seeking to rise.
        There are neither thoughts nor ideas in them,
        Where did they come from, in a worthless soul!

        God is their judge; I only wish one thing:
        So that once conscience found them.
        Not taking their evil, I forgive their worthlessness,
        And not in me, there is a drop of evil on them.

        Road tape, winding between the mountains,
        On the slope, the spruce is green, alive!
        It rumbles, as if a well-fed cat, a motor,
        And I will forget all my sorrows.

        The dog barks - the caravan goes on.
        Life goes on - spit on the parasites!
        Life is beautiful, the soul sings in verse
        And for friends, it is always open.
        Markovtsev Yu.
        https://www.stihi.ru/2011/02/07/8106
    5. +4
      19 February 2020 11: 54
      But was there no precedent? Recently.
      1. +2
        19 February 2020 12: 10
        With its lawsuits, Yukos has proven its anti-Russian nature. He is ready to ruin the people who gave him the opportunity to earn money. am
        1. +1
          19 February 2020 12: 30
          Quote: bessmertniy
          With its lawsuits, Yukos has proven its anti-Russian nature. He is ready to ruin the people who gave him the opportunity to earn money.

          strange you.
          Tomorrow the state will come. will take all the money from you. will pop out into the street - and to the cry for what 7 I bought this house with my labor and money in the account - with my sweat and blood.
          They will answer you - you have an anti-Russian essence. you drive the state that gave you the opportunity to earn.
          among Yukos shareholders were private. small ones. Russian investors - they also stole the same money.
          1. +5
            19 February 2020 16: 23
            Quote: Arpad
            Tomorrow the state will come. will take all the money from you. stick out on the street

            we were like this in the 90s after the collapse of the USSR
  2. -2
    19 February 2020 10: 43
    don't say gop until you jump over.
    1. +10
      19 February 2020 11: 01
      Well, yes.
      Six years ago, he also celebrated the victory.

      Although in reality we are witnessing a clear victory of politics over the law. After all, all the decisions of this strange court are based on the fact that Russia is obliged to comply with the treaty, which it has not ratified.
      1. -4
        19 February 2020 11: 22
        Soon ALL the oddities will end: just when the Constitutional Court adopts amendments to the Constitution prohibiting the establishment of an international law over a Russian one, especially under an unratified agreement.
        1. 0
          19 February 2020 12: 09
          What the liberda don't like "the law in the Russian order"?
          Looking at your active minus, it becomes clear - the correct and fairly Russian course has been taken! laughing
        2. +3
          19 February 2020 12: 13
          Oddities will never end. They go continuously from the creation of the world. And, no matter how we try to protect ourselves from them with a better constitution or other laws, they will cause us trouble.
        3. +4
          19 February 2020 13: 51
          The fact is that nothing will end. If Russia adopts the DOMESTIC law on the priority of its laws over international ones, then this does not play a special role. Most countries do not have our laws. We can take anything here, but overseas property of Russia will be arrested. And now they’ll make a present to them - they’ll give Sberbank to the Finance Ministry, and he has a bunch of branches abroad.
  3. -16
    19 February 2020 10: 44
    pseudo-shares and the liberda will now begin to sprinkle ash on their heads

    PS this moan will continue to sit abroad and whimper. In this, it does not differ from many offended Russians. Instead of money, he has a female genital organ on his collar.

    The payout will be exactly zero. Singers by the mouth ala Shevchuk or actress Akhidzhakova - will be sad and groan. Because again, Russia threw their comrade and friend through the penis.

    1. +8
      19 February 2020 10: 59
      An old harmless artist Liya Akhedzhakova and a truth-cuter Shevchuk have given you a master of gouging holes in rotten oak trunks with his jade rod ..
      1. -11
        19 February 2020 11: 01
        harmless artist Liya Akhedzhakova and Pravdorub-Shevchuk ..


        there they climbed wassat Pravdorub singer singer by mouth is strong. I think that you, too, like these characters, need Hodor! Take a video

        PS she’s not an artist, she’s third-rate I don’t know who, with the same roles and emotions. In general, she is the same artist as the singer Buzova. One discharge for two

        But the taste and color of course .. So enjoy the talents

      2. +6
        19 February 2020 11: 21
        Quote: Olya Tsako
        elderly harmless artist Liya Akhedzhakova and Pravdorub-Shevchuk ..

        Harmless grandmothers are sitting on benches and darn socks, and are not engaged in Russophobia.
    2. +6
      19 February 2020 11: 04
      in vain, sergeant, pour slop on Shevchuk and put it on a par with this "painful" one ...
      at least, Jura is much more honest and decent than many singers and actors, caressed by power ...
      1. -7
        19 February 2020 11: 05
        Yura is much more honest and decent than many singers and actors, caressed by power ...


        Well, the power to be caressed, this is of course bad manners. That hodor - this is a completely different matter.

        1. +9
          19 February 2020 11: 10
          yes, drop it ... what a bad manners is here ... as you lick, they caress ...
  4. +11
    19 February 2020 10: 44
    Certainly lost. Putin should not have amnestied this guano.
    1. -15
      19 February 2020 10: 47
      in prison he is a fighter - behind the cordon he is a whining dog, of which there are a million.
      1. +3
        19 February 2020 14: 24
        I'll see how these "dogs" in your opinion will bend the property of our country. And what measures will be taken. It's good if there is a "scarf in the bathroom", otherwise you may have to pay and repent. As with the supply of hydrocarbons through the ruin.
    2. +5
      19 February 2020 10: 58
      Quote: 210ox
      Certainly lost. Putin should not have amnestied this guano.

      This was stated by businessman Leonid Nevzlin, who now lives in Israel, and in Russia was sentenced in absentia to life imprisonment. Nevzlin, recall, is the main beneficiary of the company GML, which acts in the interests of the majority shareholders of Yukos.

      Interpol: Israel - a country of runaway thieves and bandits


      IA Ynet reports that Israel has become the champion of Interpol. This respectable organization published the names of 45 Israeli citizens declared wanted.

      It is strange that Likud has not yet blamed Interpol for leftism, anti-Zionism and anti-Semitism. This would be in the spirit of the speech of our prime minister at the congress of the ruling party.

      Our country is small, and world crime. Of those wanted by Interpol - most have not only Israeli citizenship. Most often, this is Russian citizenship.

      It is strange that Lieberman and the NDI still have not accused Interpol of Russophobia and discriminatory treatment of the poor Russian-speaking repatriate.

      By the number of wanted ones, our little Israel looks like a superpower. We outstripped the weird ones, which are many, many times superior to us both in territory and population. France has just 20 citizens on the international wanted list. Italy - the homeland of the mafia - is also 20 citizens. Japan, which was famous for its yakuza, borokudans, tekiya and bakuto groups ... There are only three citizens of Japan on the Interpol list. How they lagged behind us ...

      https://maxpark.com/community/politic/content/5965930
      A "bloody trail" has been following Nevzlin since the 90s.
      Regarding Hodor, the Guarantor gave slack, I repeat, it was necessary to "blame" in the zone. The air would be cleaner! hi
      1. -1
        19 February 2020 11: 47
        Regarding Hodor, the guarantor gave slack

        Completely FOR. Most likely, the Western "partners" cheated, like Obama and Ukraine. In the same place, the guarantee was at the level of Genscher (in my opinion). I believed them. And for "throwing down" - this ... Hodor sat there quieter than water, cut out and scribbled mittens, he was afraid to fart again.
  5. 0
    19 February 2020 10: 50
    What legal value does this judicial authority in The Hague have? How many countries recognize it? What is the possible ultimate authority in this process? Why do tax crime cases become the subject of international review? With the factual evidence base of the defense, isn’t it easier to start a counter process to recognize conspiracy, an act of fraud and regular criminal activity for the purpose of enrichment? On the basis of the beginning of the review, to demand stoplisting of national prosecutors for anti-state actions against the Russian Federation. So we have that criminal case played in the archive. And it will not matter to us that the owner of Yukos will be declared innocently affected. The management of their assets was carried out by criminal methods with criminal purposes. That's all...
  6. +8
    19 February 2020 10: 52
    “The Kremlin lost”: Khodorkovsky spoke about a court decision in The Hague in the Yukos case
    Sadly, but I agree with him ... Khodorkovsky was released ahead of his jail term on the condition that he no longer conduct political activities, but he leads it, and judging by the results, it is successful, many people are replicating his videos from various Internet services, I don't even think about what goals this person adheres to ... so that "the Kremlin really lost this round." Moreover, I am absolutely sure of the fate of the appeal we filed, in this case - the West has clearly taken a course to bankrupt Russia, cause social protest and a new revolution. Now Naftogaz is filing a new claim for 8 billion against Russia ... and so on and so on ... I think that soon we will find out that the "Eurobonds" of Ukraine, in relation to Russia, are not securities, but "candy wrappers" ...
    1. -15
      19 February 2020 10: 53
      It is not regrettable, but I agree with him ...

      laughing
      what a gloom

      a lot of people are circulating his videos from various Internet services

      very many are 2% sick minions. More mentally ill than stubborn liberda, praising Khodorkovsky. (although there is a list plus minus one)

      Although I would not be surprised if there are some fans of communism here - in the depths of their souls they wish the Hodor victory to write: "I told you! I told you! Capitalist Russia will wash itself !! 11"

      Even here (!) There is no clown who openly says that he is for Hodor and against Putin
      1. +19
        19 February 2020 11: 03
        Quote: s-t Petrov
        who will openly say that he is for Hodor and against Putin

        I am against Putin, only Khodor has nothing to do with this, why are you provoking people?
      2. +4
        19 February 2020 11: 04
        Quote: s-t Petrov
        very many are sick minions 2%

        Alas, far away, much more ... A lot of ordinary people, who previously could not stand the spirit of Khodor, are now replicating videos of his "Crimea realities", "Open Russia", "New Time", various bloggers, the same Dudya, " oppositionists "like Navalny and Sobol ... The network is huge and" cleverly created ", it cannot be easily destroyed.
        Quote: s-t Petrov
        Even here (!) There is no clown who openly says that he is for Hodor and against Putin
        Well, why, in Israel there are so many and some of them often visit our site.
        1. -14
          19 February 2020 11: 11
          videos of his "Crimea realities"


          This is a division of BBS. On (BBS) CrimeaRealies the mandatory tax is paid by the British.

          The web is huge and cleverly built


          and vomit-financed like a hod and birch

          I am against Putin, only Khodor has nothing to do with this

          how is it? one trench for two. Twin wrestling. With you PusiRiot, Pompeo and all sorts of balts with other low social responsibility transformers. This is well known data. Even in the company at the trench, you are offended by Svidomo Ukrainians who are against Putin and other people: Katz, Shats, Shenderovichi, Gozmans, Svarog and Gardamir with Stas157

          Well, a separate place for Russophobia bots from this site. They are also united with you in the struggle.

          It happens. Here minus do not minus - I did not lie anywhere.
          1. -6
            19 February 2020 11: 23
            about BBS was wrong.

            Crimea.Realities - part of the international non-profit information organization Radio Free Europe

            Radio Free Europe is an international nonprofit broadcasting organization funded by the US Congress. The trustee is the United States Global Media Agency.

            Well, in general, everything is clear
          2. +9
            19 February 2020 11: 25
            Quote: s-t Petrov
            I am against Putin

            Quote: s-t Petrov
            how is it? one trench for two

            your brain abilities raise a lot of questions, since the list -
            Quote: s-t Petrov
            . With you PusiRiot, Pompeo and all sorts of balts with other low social responsibility transformers.
            you forgot to add Medvedev, Sechin, Miller and 90% of the government that was anti-people
            1. -6
              19 February 2020 11: 26
              Sechin is a warrior of the Empire, who crawled with a machine gun in Africa for several years on the instructions of the Kremlin.



              So it’s better for me and Sechin to be in the trenches than with your siblings.

              We have already chosen your part, dear Tiksi, with excellent brain abilities.
              1. +12
                19 February 2020 11: 29
                Quote: s-t Petrov
                So it’s better for me and Sechin to be in the trenches than with your siblings

                do you even know one? just do not ascribe to me
                Quote: s-t Petrov
                Sechin is a warrior of the Empire,

                you need to oversleep
                1. -13
                  19 February 2020 11: 29
                  do you even know one? just do not ascribe to me


                  I have listed the part of Codla with which you are united in one struggle. Do not disown the twin cities, because you have one struggle for all

                  you need to oversleep

                  why? Was Sechin in Angola on the instructions of the Empire?

                  Clear. Well, I can send you blinders by mail, so it will be more convenient to stagger the Kremlin.
                  1. +7
                    19 February 2020 11: 31
                    Quote: s-t Petrov
                    I have listed the part of the codes you are united with in one fight

                    it’s you who have listed your accomplices whom you threw so you’ve become on different sides
                    Quote: s-t Petrov
                    why? Was Sechin in Angola?

                    I was in Vilnius in 90. Can I also rob the country?
                    1. -13
                      19 February 2020 11: 32
                      it’s you who have listed your accomplices whom you threw so you’ve become on different sides


                      open your mind sharp

                      I was in Vilnius in 90. Can I also rob the country?


                      laughing the logic of the patriot with VO

                      Those. Do you know about the facts of the robbery of the country by Sechin and still hide them from the people? Oh, this opposition. Did you go to the police with a statement? Have you decided to fight? Or write about robbery on the forum, because in the heat of the struggle you can suffer for the idea?)
                      1. +8
                        19 February 2020 11: 34
                        Quote: s-t Petrov
                        open your mind sharp

                        Quote: s-t Petrov
                        Those. Do you know about the facts of the robbery of the country by Sechin and still hide them from the people? Oh this opposition

                        It's all a flood, write in a personal
              2. +5
                19 February 2020 11: 33
                in the trench with Rosneft and Gazprom it is really more convenient and safer ...
                I "approve" you for your choice ...
                1. The comment was deleted.
          3. +5
            19 February 2020 12: 05
            What I’ve crossed the road for you is that you won’t go to bed before you remember me.
            The Shenderovichs and Gozmans are not to me their Kremlin supports.
            In general, I'm sitting listening to a group of Sopranos, beautiful girls and they sing beautifully.
            1. -9
              19 February 2020 12: 11
              I’ve crossed the way for you


              you could not cross my path. I cite you as an example - as an ideological fighter on the other side of the information front - there are many of you there, because those offended by Russia over the edge
              1. +7
                19 February 2020 12: 27
                You know how to hook. Russia is my homeland. I loved her until 1991, I love her after this year. And I am offended by these gentlemen,

                Potanin
                Usmanova
                Timchenko
                Ismailova
                Nevzlin.
    2. +5
      19 February 2020 11: 28
      Quote: svp67
      Not only that, I am absolutely sure of the fate of the appeal we submitted, the West in this case has clearly taken a course to bankrupt Russia, provoke social protest and a new revolution.

      Everything goes to this. The consequences will be devastating.
    3. -6
      19 February 2020 12: 10
      social protest? he will not be forced to pay at least a trillion
  7. +2
    19 February 2020 10: 53
    Here is the recognition of the primacy of Western legislation in Russian.
    The Constitution of the Russian Federation, part 4 of article 15: “Generally recognized principles and norms of international law and international treaties of the Russian Federation are an integral part of its legal system. If other rules are established by an international treaty of the Russian Federation than stipulated by law, then the rules of the international treaty shall apply. ” See in aggregate, with paragraph 1 of Art. 23 of the Federal Law of 15.07.1995 N 101-ФЗ “On international treaties of the Russian Federation”: “An international treaty or part of a treaty may be applied temporarily by the Russian Federation until it enters into force, if this is provided for in the treaty or if an agreement has been reached with the parties who have signed the contract. " Plus Art. 11 and others of the same Federal Law.
    And ordinary people will be paid through taxes, etc. It remains to recognize the primacy of the decision of the elder of the Tumba Yumba tribe! laughing
    1. +9
      19 February 2020 11: 03
      The main thing is to believe that one line in the constitution is to blame, yes. So we would send everyone to the forest, but again, the damn constitution gets in the way. It’s ridiculous.
      1. +2
        19 February 2020 11: 05
        It's not the line to blame, the people who committed this are to blame! This is sad.
        1. +9
          19 February 2020 11: 12
          These people, when they need to, put the device on the constitution, and now (suddenly!) They can’t.
    2. +4
      19 February 2020 11: 29
      Quote: Alexey 2020
      And ordinary people will be paid through taxes, etc.

      It’s just killing a power.
      1. -6
        19 February 2020 12: 11
        will not, have nothing to take
        1. -2
          19 February 2020 12: 17
          Quote: Nastia Makarova
          will not, have nothing to take

          Well, if there was nothing to take, then they would not have climbed to Russia.
          1. -1
            19 February 2020 13: 11
            they know that they won’t be paid anything, but to do this and create the background, they do
        2. +5
          19 February 2020 16: 31
          Quote: Nastia Makarova
          nothing to take

          will find. to come up with an extreme
      2. +4
        19 February 2020 16: 31
        Quote: tihonmarine
        It’s just killing a power.

        few understand. the country is already on the verge.
        1. -3
          20 February 2020 07: 25
          on the verge of what? riot will not care
    3. +2
      19 February 2020 12: 23
      Read again v. 23 of the Federal Law of 15.07.1995 N 101-FZ "On international treaties of the Russian Federation" and, in addition, the Resolution of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation of March 27, 2012 N 8-P city of St. Petersburg "in the case of checking the constitutionality of paragraph 1 article 23 of the Federal Law "On international treaties of the Russian Federation" in connection with the complaint of citizen ID Ushakov ".
      The Russian Federation has not made a decision on the temporary application of the ECT, the ECT and the decision on the temporary application has not been officially published; accordingly, the ECT cannot be applied to the Russian Federation, since this would contradict Article 45 of the same ECT.
  8. +6
    19 February 2020 10: 55
    In a war, as in a war, they will begin to seize the property of Russia, begin to seize the property of those countries that will allow it to be done on their territory and impose sanctions on, say, the supply of energy
    1. -6
      19 February 2020 11: 14
      Quote: Chaldon48
      In a war, as in a war, they will begin to seize the property of Russia


      It will not work. In Russia, private firms, and the property of states (well, which will arrest Russian property) in the country to a minimum.
      But presenting an ultimatum (with the possibility of using the Armed Forces) to the country that committed the seizure of property is significant (few people want to get involved, especially the exiled West).
      But for that. it is necessary to get out of those international obligations that Russia has undertaken.
      1. -6
        19 February 2020 12: 14
        and what state property does Russia have in other countries?
        1. +4
          19 February 2020 12: 35
          Didn't you go to school at all? Embassy buildings, trade missions. Remember long ago the case of the Noga firm when they tried to arrest Kruzenshtern, moments and sous did not fly to la bourget ... they can arrest the accounts of the embassies, despite diplomatic immunity
          1. -3
            19 February 2020 13: 20
            in order to arrest each object, a court is needed, but it doesn’t last long and indeed the cost of these embassies is a penny, and most importantly, violation of dip property will not go for the sake of a private person, in Russia they will also be thrown out of the embassy where they will be arrested
            1. +5
              19 February 2020 16: 35
              Quote: Nastia Makarova
              in Russia, too, thrown out of the embassy where they are arrested

              will not be thrown out, but will give time to leave. accustomed to mirror responses in the west. if Russia acted in advance, then the effect was, and so ...
              1. -2
                20 February 2020 07: 27
                let's wait and see what happens, what about the payment is not clear, there will be courts that last for years
  9. +3
    19 February 2020 10: 58
    Yukos at least formally entered the state-owned Rosneft, another question is who and how there is tying money and drawing huge salaries, but Khodor tells us that Yukos is mine, and not yours, Russians, my oligarchic - that’s what he can cause in principle people? only juvenile boobies and liberds
  10. +4
    19 February 2020 11: 03
    The eyes in the photo, the former secretary of the district committee are frightened, afraid of a bloody red.
  11. +4
    19 February 2020 11: 04
    And what did you think when you dragged Yukos property to affiliated companies? In full view of everyone.
    This, you, is not Kolchak’s gold, quietly smuggled to Czech banks, but on the sly, in the whirlpool of the Civil War or hidden the Party Gold, eliminating all the treasurers, along with the documentation.
  12. +2
    19 February 2020 11: 05
    Mikhail Khodorkovsky commented on the decision of the Hague Court of Appeal in favor of Yukos shareholders

    Nail, pliz, this rat, so that the air does not poison.
    When he was released from prison, he swore and swore that he would no longer engage in political activities. The price is worthless, according to him, therefore it is punishable !!! am
  13. +3
    19 February 2020 11: 06
    The name itself is:
    "MAJORITY SHAREHOLDERS"
    liked... good
    Aha wassat To every "major" - according to "major" ... laughing
    Quote: Svarog
    Although this character is not pleasant to me deeply .. but the fact that everything will fall on the shoulders of ordinary citizens is a fact ..

    Something will fall on the shoulders of ordinary citizens, but someone can lie down to a depth of 2 meters ... belay Right along with billions of "farthing" ...
    Outlawed people and criminally prosecuted in Russia cannot a priori make claims against the country.
    It’s time for Khodorkovsky to understand that the rest of his life can be spent not on “making slippers,” but in the close circle of patients with tuberculosis ... or infected with coronavirus ... feel
    I’m sure, for $ 50 you can come up with such options that the Hague itself will owe Russia these billions ...
  14. 0
    19 February 2020 11: 08
    Quote: svp67
    it’s not regrettable, but I agree with him ... Khodorkovsky was released earlier than his term of imprisonment on the condition that he would no longer conduct political activity


    Is it Putin or Khodorkovsky who told you personally? :)) By the way, is blogging a political activity? Heck . where you do not spit on YouTube, some politicians :)))))))
  15. +2
    19 February 2020 11: 09
    Indeed, even if one recognizes his point of view regarding the Russian authorities, it turns out that the obligation to return money to shareholders will put a heavy burden on the Russian budget and on ordinary Russians as well.
    And why should ordinary citizens even worry about the well-being of domestic socially responsible businessmen? What so, what commercials - we will be in the red. Or, if Hodor loses, will they share with us? I doubt it.
  16. +2
    19 February 2020 11: 13
    Quote: Olya Tsako
    And what did you think when you dragged Yukos property to affiliated companies? In full view of everyone.
    This, you, is not Kolchak’s gold, quietly smuggled to Czech banks, but on the sly, in the whirlpool of the Civil War or hidden the Party Gold, eliminating all the treasurers, along with the documentation.


    Hush, hush, don’t say here how Yukos was taken (one of the largest and most successful companies of that time), otherwise they will google, be surprised. We adhere to the party’s policy - Yukos was legally torn, Khodorkovsky is a criminal, we won’t pay anything, he went to jail - he lost business, etc.

    p / s On my own behalf - Hodor is a criminal, but with one big BUT! The remaining fat basses are also not white and fluffy, and they should have been sitting next to him. But not only do they not sit, they have directly grown together with power, and this is bad :(
    1. +4
      19 February 2020 11: 35
      Quote: Bad
      Quote: Olya Tsako
      And what did you think when you dragged Yukos property to affiliated companies? In full view of everyone.
      This, you, is not Kolchak’s gold, quietly smuggled to Czech banks, but on the sly, in the whirlpool of the Civil War or hidden the Party Gold, eliminating all the treasurers, along with the documentation.


      Hush, hush, don’t say here how Yukos was taken (one of the largest and most successful companies of that time), otherwise they will google, be surprised. We adhere to the party’s policy - Yukos was legally torn, Khodorkovsky is a criminal, we won’t pay anything, he went to jail - he lost business, etc.

      p / s On my own behalf - Hodor is a criminal, but with one big BUT! The remaining fat basses are also not white and fluffy, and they should have been sitting next to him. But not only do they not sit, they have directly grown together with power, and this is bad :(

      good The most realistic commentary at the moment. I also liked El Murid on this subject:
      First, the former Komsomol members stole the oil industry from the people, then the criminal lads who rose from the garbage dumps squeezed from the Komsomol members what they stole from the people, and Komsomol members now demand compensation from thieves. Which, of course, will be paid by the people from whom this oil industry has already been stolen once.
      As a result, thieves will remain with oil, Komsomol members with 50 billion, and people will pay twice for this holiday of life. Both. Also commission to the court. Who is the loser here is an unnecessary question.

      PS By the way, in our country, as is known in the freest country in the world, it would be forbidden to engage in politics well only for Khodorkovsky. Then Kvachkov again fell out of favor. And he can hardly be blamed for unpatriotism. Here we have such a clear country under V.V. Putin. Watch from 1 minute.
  17. +3
    19 February 2020 11: 19
    A beginner doesn’t get into it, there will be a lot of stink. But the ice ax, the old fashioned way. Well, in extreme cases, the slippery floor in the bathroom
  18. -1
    19 February 2020 11: 22
    "fun" ... offer those guys a finger, they'll cut it off at the most, at the most ... however, it was necessary to carry out everything within the limits of its legislation or to implement everything according to garlic ...
    if we are about our "justice" in great doubts, then over the hill it is not quoted in any way above the plinth.
    Everything will be DIFFICULT!
  19. 0
    19 February 2020 11: 29
    not bad. stole, robbed. killed, also for 50 premium lards
  20. -5
    19 February 2020 11: 33
    Is not a fact. Moscow can appeal, and there is a change in the constitution of the Russian Federation and hello ...
  21. -4
    19 February 2020 11: 35
    According to him, people are now worried about the question, from whose pocket Russia will give these 50 billion dollars?
    And why did this horse decide that Russia intends to give away these billions by decision of a court that does not understand? laughing
    And our court will charge $ 100 billion from the "international" arbitration court in The Hague, and we will pay out of them.
    laughing
  22. +1
    19 February 2020 12: 01
    If Khodorkovsky was to blame, why was the whole Yukos bankrupt?

    In South Korea, the head of Samsung was arrested, but no one backdated the company itself.
    1. -2
      19 February 2020 12: 38
      Do not compare incomparable
    2. +1
      23 February 2020 11: 08
      And to cut in favor of new shareholders as you think? And so that their names are not sacred?
  23. +3
    19 February 2020 12: 08
    Rosneft will suffer .... privatize, probably not to give. When they left the country and gave jurisdiction to The Hague, they had to think with their heads, not with booty.
  24. +2
    19 February 2020 12: 46
    It seemed that Gorbi gave everything. An, no: it remains to lose to the Hague court. Purely specific.
  25. -2
    19 February 2020 13: 05
    Khodorkovsky needs to send a postcard with a photograph of Trotsky! To remember. That also "agreed" in due time.
    1. -1
      19 February 2020 15: 11
      Quote: astronom1973n
      send a postcard with a photograph of Trotsky!

      And $ 50 billion. Send a postcard from your beloved.
      1. 0
        20 February 2020 06: 38
        Quote: iouris
        And $ 50 billion. Send a postcard from your beloved.

        From 50 billion, indigestion will begin.
    2. +1
      21 February 2020 23: 51
      "there are few real violent, and there are no leaders" From the word, in general.
  26. +3
    19 February 2020 13: 07
    I believe that blogger El Murid described the situation around Yukos very subtly. Here's a quote:
    "The court in The Hague returned to the YUKOS case and ruled that Russia still must pay the majority shareholders of YUKOS $ 50 billion. The story is actually very simple: first, the former Komsomol members stole the oil industry from the people, then the criminal gang that rose from the garbage dumps squeezed the Komsomol members what they stole from the people, and the Komsomol members are now demanding compensation from the thieves, which, of course, will be paid by the people, from whom this oil industry has already been stolen. 

    As a result, thieves will be left with oil, Komsomol members - with 50 billion, and the people will pay twice for this holiday of life. Both. Also commissions to the court. Who is the loser here is an unnecessary question. "
  27. -2
    19 February 2020 13: 27
    Prior to the bankruptcy of the Yukos oil company on August 1, 2006, more than 50% of its shares were controlled by the group company Menatep Limited (subsequently renamed GML) through a chain of subsidiaries (Yukos Universal, Isle of Man; Hulley Enterprises, Cyprus). Another 10% of the shares belonged to the Cyprus company Veteran Petroleum.
  28. +1
    19 February 2020 13: 29
    On April 20, 2016, The Hague Circuit Court ruled that the arbitration established under the Permanent Court of Arbitration did not have jurisdiction over the Yukos case. In the summer of 2016, the ex-shareholders of the oil company filed a lawsuit in The Hague Court of Appeal to annul the decision of the district court and restore arbitral awards to pay $ 50 billion.The Russian side sent a memorandum to the Hague Court of Appeal with a detailed response to the appeal. According to the Russian side, the contract could not be applied to the Russian Federation, therefore, the arbitration did not have competence to consider claims. In addition, the memorandum expanded the arguments about unlawful acts committed during and after the privatization of Yukos. In particular, examples of manipulations and collusion during mortgage auctions, bribery of state managers, creation of an extensive network of shell companies to minimize taxes and the transfer abroad of illegally acquired assets, concealment of the true beneficiaries of allegedly foreign companies that filed lawsuits in The Hague against the Russian Federation are given.
  29. 0
    19 February 2020 13: 51
    In the first place are financial interests.


    So he is not a shareholder. He will not fall
  30. 0
    19 February 2020 13: 53
    It seems that world Zionism went on the attack on all fronts.
    wink
    So they are scared that they have taken decisive action, and yet we have not even waved for a response crack. bully
    ZY Now let's count how many "Zionists" we have here fellow
  31. +1
    19 February 2020 13: 53
    How will his former Komsomol friend Guryev react? Which took everything from him.
  32. +3
    19 February 2020 13: 57
    According to the charter of the Hague International Arbitration Court, he cannot investigate cases involving tax arrears of one of the parties, which was the main charge in the Yukos case. Nevertheless, the arbitral tribunal went beyond its competence and thereby made its decision unenforceable.

    Plus, the arbitration court ruled on the basis of an international treaty, which Russia has not ratified and, accordingly, did not become a party to it. If we follow the Dutch, tomorrow we will be assigned 100, 200, etc. billions on the basis of any regulatory acts of Western countries, which we did not ratify, but did not know about their existence.

    Russia should not only ignore all other decisions of the Dutch courts of any level, but also open a criminal case against arbitration judges and the leadership of the arbitration court on the fact of complicity in fraud, and also send to Interpol a request for the extradition of Dutch citizens for a criminal court in the Russian Federation.

    A possible seizure of Russian assets abroad will bring only a few billion to former Yukos shareholders, but it will make it possible to seize Dutch assets in Russia in the form of tens and billions of dollars worth of oil and gas companies.
    1. 0
      23 February 2020 11: 04
      But only under our power the snout was down, therefore they will merge under a patriotic howl about the unity of the people, around a united Russia in the fight against the adversary. And of course I would have cleaned up the snout! Look, Kemsku parish wanted. Blowing soap in one place. But these are dreams, our elite have more in common with this Western tolerance than with their own people. Billions to the West, and with their guaranteed minimum wage ,!
  33. +1
    19 February 2020 14: 03
    You’re bespectacled! It's you in the deep ... well. If property seizures begin, then this will affect the most unprotected ones, and even then sideways. For Russia, this is a lifting amount; for you, this is kirdyk! You scum, this will not be forgotten.
  34. 0
    19 February 2020 14: 08
    "Now the Yukos shareholders plan to secure the arrest and seizure of assets of the Russian state in other countries in the amount of $ 50 billion."
    HODOR, HODOR - your cinema namesake was even smarter: your ears are from a dead donkey and not 50 watermelons!
    And if so brave - come to Nefteyugansk - they will quickly explain to you - how much are the cones in the forest.
    bursting!
  35. +5
    19 February 2020 16: 48
    Quote: tihonmarine
    Here is the demand from them.

    And those thieves, and these thieves. Prosto took away from some "favorites" and gave them to others. And the debts were hung on Russia, on the budget, on the people. hi
  36. 0
    19 February 2020 17: 15
    The question is much more complicated (or simpler): MN-17 was shot down on the eve of the trial, now a new round and the trial in the MN-17 case. When the Hague court makes a "positive" decision in the MN-17 case, it will be easier from the point of view of business interests (of Gazprom) to re-establish the state. Oh, it was not in vain that the judge of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation spoke!
  37. +2
    20 February 2020 03: 41
    If so, they will not arrest “private” assets recorded in all kinds of front offices and front persons, but open, well-known assets of the Russian state, that is, property of Russia. The personal property of Russian officials and oligarchs is unlikely to be affected
    Well, that's all there is to understand from this news. A few “alone,” a handful of pro-Western “patriots,” who hide stolen goods there, were squeezed out and appropriated, and most of the others who were not at all involved in this will pay off.
    "It's a matter of everyday life!" (FROM)
  38. +1
    20 February 2020 09: 51
    How could he steal so much, being so stupid? "It was not the people who lost, but the Kremlin" this is a pure epicrisis. It is clear that payments (if any) will fall on the budget, on us in you, even if the GDP goes out right tomorrow, ordinary, ordinary people will still have to pay and will pay - we are with you, this is obvious.
  39. 0
    20 February 2020 17: 42
    Zhidovin! Remember how he sewed mittens, useful when they return to the logging site. tongue
  40. +1
    21 February 2020 12: 08
    In vain Putin released him.
    1. 0
      23 February 2020 10: 58
      Putin can see the good conditions set, could not refuse. And for us, as an act of humanism, it was a ride. What we really did not know. I’m not tracing his humanism as such anywhere.
  41. +1
    23 February 2020 10: 50
    And all due to the fact that the remaining saw cutters of the people’s good A la Khodorkovsky are in power, the shareholders are wounded.
    After all, if you turn the business of Khodorkovsky, you will have to cut the branch on which they are sitting.
    But the people remember why our "billionaires" swelled. Scoundrels! You still cannot escape the court. And we pay for this abomination with the fate of millions of citizens.
  42. 0
    24 February 2020 21: 12
    "The Russian government, according to Khodorkovsky, will not give money, but if it is forced to, it will still be given at the expense of ordinary citizens."

    And what? Is not it?
    Do you think that Putin and his faithful Putiners will pay out of pocket?
    No matter how! Again they will strain our people under any plausible pretext.
    They already have everywhere after flight today: Syria, frozen pipelines, enslaving contract with Ukraine, expenses for changing the Constitution, which for some reason urgently needs to change nosebleeds (of course ... we all understand that this is not at all because Putin needs an airbag in which case ... Everything is entirely in the interests of the people ...)
    They’ll come up with new laws, new taxes to FOR OUR ACCOUNT pay for your own mistakes! Maybe the retirement age will be raised once more and Putin will make a sad expression on his face again. You can expect everything from "these" wonderful "specialists" in the "management" of the state!

    Still, this cartoon is immortal!

  43. 0
    25 February 2020 13: 23
    10 years, this is a lot (a lot of thoughts, a lot of losses, a lot of revenge), All people are different, who forgives (only the saints), someone takes revenge, and undermines the view, as if nothing to do with, the stupid immediately try to look for the "truth", without courts, and lose. No need for revolutions, No need for war ... we already do not live very richly ...
  44. 0
    26 February 2020 07: 12
    The stupidity of the Zradavites does not allow them to come up with something new.

"Right Sector" (banned in Russia), "Ukrainian Insurgent Army" (UPA) (banned in Russia), ISIS (banned in Russia), "Jabhat Fatah al-Sham" formerly "Jabhat al-Nusra" (banned in Russia) , Taliban (banned in Russia), Al-Qaeda (banned in Russia), Anti-Corruption Foundation (banned in Russia), Navalny Headquarters (banned in Russia), Facebook (banned in Russia), Instagram (banned in Russia), Meta (banned in Russia), Misanthropic Division (banned in Russia), Azov (banned in Russia), Muslim Brotherhood (banned in Russia), Aum Shinrikyo (banned in Russia), AUE (banned in Russia), UNA-UNSO (banned in Russia), Mejlis of the Crimean Tatar people (banned in Russia), Legion “Freedom of Russia” (armed formation, recognized as terrorist in the Russian Federation and banned), Kirill Budanov (included to the Rosfinmonitoring list of terrorists and extremists)

“Non-profit organizations, unregistered public associations or individuals performing the functions of a foreign agent,” as well as media outlets performing the functions of a foreign agent: “Medusa”; "Voice of America"; "Realities"; "Present time"; "Radio Freedom"; Ponomarev Lev; Ponomarev Ilya; Savitskaya; Markelov; Kamalyagin; Apakhonchich; Makarevich; Dud; Gordon; Zhdanov; Medvedev; Fedorov; Mikhail Kasyanov; "Owl"; "Alliance of Doctors"; "RKK" "Levada Center"; "Memorial"; "Voice"; "Person and law"; "Rain"; "Mediazone"; "Deutsche Welle"; QMS "Caucasian Knot"; "Insider"; "New Newspaper"