Chinese experts: In India, when developing an AMCA fighter, they decided to copy the Chinese J-31

45

Chinese military experts, characterizing the model of the Indian fighter of the 5th generation of the AMCA project presented at the exhibition, express, to put it mildly, not the most positive words about the Indian program.

The military information portal SINA writes that Indian developers decided to copy the layout of the Chinese J-31 fighter. This fighter continues to undergo a series of tests in China. The PLA command plans to turn the J-31 into a carrier-based fighter.



From the material:

The Indians clearly borrow the idea from the developers of the J-31. At the same time, it becomes more noticeable. If initially in India they tried to use the design of the fifth-generation American fighter F-22, now they decided to switch to Chinese development. The AMCA program, at least externally - at the glider and layout levels, is changing the concept.

In the Chinese expert environment, it is noted that the AMCA project switched to a flatter nose, elongated front ends of the air intakes (initially, it can be seen from the photo, the air intakes were different) and other components inherent in a Chinese-made fighter.

At the same time, the material says that what the Indian plane of the fifth generation will turn out to be and when it can be seen in the sky, the Indians themselves do not know yet.
    Our news channels

    Subscribe and stay up to date with the latest news and the most important events of the day.

    45 comments
    Information
    Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
    1. +3
      6 February 2020 12: 55
      Chinese experts: In India, when developing an AMCA fighter, they decided to copy the Chinese J-31


      What to copy? In the ability to somehow fly? laughing
      1. +11
        6 February 2020 12: 58
        Finally, the Chinese felt how bad it was to steal other people's ideas. That's just their assessment is gloomy. wink
        1. +11
          6 February 2020 13: 00
          Chinese experts: In India, when developing an AMCA fighter, they decided to copy the Chinese J-31
          sounds funny ... copy at xerox ....
          1. +1
            6 February 2020 15: 43
            Chinese military experts, characterizing the model of the Indian fighter of the 5th generation of the AMCA project presented at the exhibition, do not, to put it mildly, express the most positive words about the Indian program

            I don’t understand something ...
            The Chinese claim that their plane, which the Indians take as a basis, is not the best?
            Or scolding the Indians for acting like the Chinese?
            what
            1. +4
              6 February 2020 16: 16
              It’s not clear to everyone that even the fifth generation is trying to convince each other that they don’t see this stucco on radars. But in the end they are afraid to drive them next to real radars. In the cut world-wide. And Russia is criticized that it does not have such aircraft. It's funny
        2. +4
          6 February 2020 13: 03
          hi
          Not just bad, but lower back they burnt sickly laughing

          Although I don’t understand what the Chinaman are raging about? Identical goals lead to the same technical solutions.

          Many cars, for example, have four wheels and a steering wheel, and what, is this a reason to run into?))
          1. +3
            6 February 2020 13: 21
            Quote: Lord of the Sith
            four wheels and a steering wheel,

            And bibcal laughing
            This is the most important detail. laughing
          2. +1
            6 February 2020 14: 12
            Quote: Lord of the Sith
            Many cars, for example, have four wheels and a steering wheel, and what, is this a reason to run into?))

            In the late 70s in the magazine "Young Technician" there was an article under the heading something like "Technology news from abroad." There it was briefly written that "British scientists" have calculated the most optimal, from the point of view of aerodynamics, the shape of the car body - "banana" (even the drawing with humor was - a real banana on wheels). Several decades have passed - look at the world auto industry - only "bananas". Do you remember the cars of the 70s? ...

            Here they are, "trends" ...
        3. +2
          6 February 2020 13: 20
          Quote: bessmertniy
          Finally, the Chinese felt how bad it was to steal other people's ideas.

          It’s more pleasant to steal yourself laughing
          1. +1
            6 February 2020 14: 13
            Quote: Lipchanin
            Quote: bessmertniy
            Finally, the Chinese felt how bad it was to steal other people's ideas.

            It’s more pleasant to steal yourself laughing

            Or maybe they just stole from the same owner.
            1. -1
              6 February 2020 15: 04
              Quote: neri73-r
              Or maybe they just stole from the same owner.

              Not excluded laughing
        4. 0
          6 February 2020 13: 54
          Quote: bessmertniy
          Finally, the Chinese felt how bad it was to steal other people's ideas. That's just their assessment is gloomy. wink

          Chinese military experts, characterizing the model of the Indian fighter of the 5th generation of the AMCA project presented at the exhibition, express, to put it mildly, not the most positive words about the Indian program.

          The military information portal SINA writes that Indian developers decided to copy the layout of the Chinese J-31 fighter. This fighter continues to undergo a series of tests in China.

          Ha, I didn’t like it! Strange ... And we used to say:
          "A thief stole a club from a thief!" And here a copy of it was stolen from a world copier ...
        5. -1
          6 February 2020 14: 04
          Quote: bessmertniy
          Finally, the Chinese felt how bad it was to steal other people's ideas.

          On the contrary! laughing Self-esteem increases. laughing

          Once they steal, it means that we are doing something good. After all, we are not stealing the same Kalashnikov, but from us.
        6. -1
          6 February 2020 19: 15
          It certainly is. But it’s unlikely that anyone will be able to shave like the Chinese did.
      2. +1
        6 February 2020 13: 14
        For what they fought for it and ran into it, the Chinese can do everything, but the Indians cannot. Here they say that the Japanese honestly bought up patents around the world. More Indians copy coronoviruses?
        1. +1
          6 February 2020 13: 34
          lately, "Chinese experts" on the degree of schizoidism began to catch up with the "English scientists" ...
    2. +5
      6 February 2020 12: 56
      The Indians clearly borrow the idea from the developers of the J-31. At the same time, it becomes more noticeable.
      Rzhu, I can’t, but nothing that this "Chinese Gyrfalcon" is very, just very similar to the F-35
      1. +2
        6 February 2020 13: 05
        Keep "laughing, I can't": the American F-35 is a close copy of the Soviet Yak-141, especially since the documentation of the latter was sold to the Americans during the Yeltsin "revelry of democracy."
        1. +6
          6 February 2020 13: 51
          The American F-35 has about as much in common with the Yak141 as it does with the Harrier. Of course, the Americans wisely used our achievements, but they got a completely different plane
          1. +3
            6 February 2020 14: 09
            And the Indians will get "completely different".
            1. +2
              6 February 2020 15: 05
              Quote: Magog
              And the Indians will get "completely different".

              With a trunk? belay lol
              1. 0
                7 February 2020 05: 34
                Quote: Lipchanin
                With a trunk?

                And in blanket ...
      2. +2
        6 February 2020 13: 52
        In what place? :))) In the silhouette from afar? You at least take a look at the performance characteristics
    3. +3
      6 February 2020 12: 59
      Given that on many Chinese products, only a name tag with the name corresponds to the country of manufacture, and the ideas, equipment and the brand itself are registered thousands of kilometers from the place of production, the Chinese simply need to be silent for the best! They are not stolen from us! Those of our Su27, which they turned at home, but the name was changed! So, the Indians in terms of plagiarism to the Chinese further than from the Sun to Neptune!
    4. +2
      6 February 2020 13: 00
      And then, if it were not for the Chinese and aviation, no one would have. fellow
    5. +3
      6 February 2020 13: 01
      Information portal SINA in the military section writes that Indian developers decided to copy the layout Chinese fighter J-31.

      Thief stole a baton from a thief. wassat
      1. +2
        6 February 2020 13: 15
        Comrade, you stole my comment. drinks
        1. 0
          6 February 2020 13: 23
          Sleight of hand and no fraud! drinks
    6. 0
      6 February 2020 13: 02
      This dimension is the most popular .... in the 5th generation. Japanese, South Koreans, British, Turks .... and Hindus. Everyone wants a fighter of this size with two turbojet engines. And only the United States made the F35 in this weight, but with one powerful turbojet engine. I hope that the Russian Federation will begin to design a light fighter.
      1. +1
        6 February 2020 13: 37
        Why, what is its strategic meaning?
        1. 0
          6 February 2020 19: 47
          Mass, replacing aircraft from neighboring classes.
    7. +1
      6 February 2020 13: 06
      Copy copy?
    8. +2
      6 February 2020 13: 08
      Oh, that's it! Look who's Talking. Already someone, and the Chinese to complain about "copy-paste" is a sin in the square. We would have already sat with their technical clones, of which the legion and a small cart, and kept silent in a rag. But no, you have to yap. Hypocrites!
    9. +5
      6 February 2020 13: 20
      Two blondes at the reception:
      - Ahh! Why are you in the same dress as me?!?!?
      “Not the same.” Now, I still haven't torn the price tag out of the store, but you don’t have one.
      - ...Well then fine.
      laughing
    10. 0
      6 February 2020 13: 36
      Well, whoever would be silent about stolen and copied technologies ....
    11. +2
      6 February 2020 13: 46
      About copying is not to talk to the Chinese ... although, maybe on the contrary, they are recognized masters!
    12. 0
      6 February 2020 13: 47
      They need to design a plane of this dimension together with the MiG.
    13. Ham
      0
      6 February 2020 14: 09
      pirated copy of a pirated copy? the result will not be very ...
    14. 0
      6 February 2020 15: 59
      Well, it’s necessary laughing Oh, how the Chinese do not like it when they are copied tongue And they themselves are not shy in copywriting.
    15. 0
      6 February 2020 17: 36
      Explicitly judged by themselves. They are afraid that Indians will do better. bully
    16. 0
      6 February 2020 18: 28
      A parody of a parody. Tank already done, now the plane. The Chinese are not very successful, but experience is available.
    17. 0
      6 February 2020 22: 09
      The Indians clearly borrow the idea from the developers of the J-31. At the same time, it becomes more noticeable. If initially in India they tried to use the design of the fifth-generation American fighter F-22, now they decided to switch to Chinese development. The AMCA program, at least externally - at the glider and layout levels, is changing the concept.

      Well, saints, it’s not the Chinese that copy everything and give it out for their know-how, the largest world serox is in China and only China do all the copies without embarrassment!
    18. 0
      7 February 2020 05: 59
      Quote: Andrey from Chelyabinsk
      In what place? :))) In the silhouette from afar?

      How many non-experts will distinguish where "Gyrfalcon", and where "Lightning"?




      And distinguish them from Korean and Japanese prototypes



    19. 0
      7 February 2020 16: 43
      Copied copied
    20. 0
      8 February 2020 00: 23
      But I wonder if intelligence is better in India than in other countries of the world?

    "Right Sector" (banned in Russia), "Ukrainian Insurgent Army" (UPA) (banned in Russia), ISIS (banned in Russia), "Jabhat Fatah al-Sham" formerly "Jabhat al-Nusra" (banned in Russia) , Taliban (banned in Russia), Al-Qaeda (banned in Russia), Anti-Corruption Foundation (banned in Russia), Navalny Headquarters (banned in Russia), Facebook (banned in Russia), Instagram (banned in Russia), Meta (banned in Russia), Misanthropic Division (banned in Russia), Azov (banned in Russia), Muslim Brotherhood (banned in Russia), Aum Shinrikyo (banned in Russia), AUE (banned in Russia), UNA-UNSO (banned in Russia), Mejlis of the Crimean Tatar People (banned in Russia), Legion “Freedom of Russia” (armed formation, recognized as terrorist in the Russian Federation and banned)

    “Non-profit organizations, unregistered public associations or individuals performing the functions of a foreign agent,” as well as media outlets performing the functions of a foreign agent: “Medusa”; "Voice of America"; "Realities"; "Present time"; "Radio Freedom"; Ponomarev; Savitskaya; Markelov; Kamalyagin; Apakhonchich; Makarevich; Dud; Gordon; Zhdanov; Medvedev; Fedorov; "Owl"; "Alliance of Doctors"; "RKK" "Levada Center"; "Memorial"; "Voice"; "Person and law"; "Rain"; "Mediazone"; "Deutsche Welle"; QMS "Caucasian Knot"; "Insider"; "New Newspaper"