Kudrin told about the volume of corruption and theft from the budget of Russia

155

The volume of corruption in Russia amounts to trillions of rubles, and this figure has not been reduced recently.

This was stated by Chairman of the Accounts Chamber of the Russian Federation Alexei Kudrin in an interview with news agency RIA News.



He believes that this phenomenon is detrimental to the economy of our country by distorting incentives and inhibiting economic growth. And this, in turn, reduces the growth rate of citizens' incomes, investments and other things.

As regards theft from the state budget, Kudrin considers his criminal case volumes "not to exceed 2-3 billion rubles annually." Things are much worse with financial irregularities that are not criminal offenses. About a third of these violations relate to accounting, the same amount is related to the organization of procurement.

Alexei Kudrin believes that the Accounts Chamber needs additional powers to fight corruption. At the moment, the agency has the right to only notify law enforcement authorities of the violations identified. And they themselves decide whether to qualify them as corruption crimes.

According to Kudrin, the Accounts Chamber should gradually move from identifying individual financial irregularities to auditing systemic problems in the financial sector. The reform of the management system of the department is planned to be completed by the middle of this year. Users have already joked about this: "It seemed that he was about to ask for more funding for the Accounts Chamber itself."
    Our news channels

    Subscribe and stay up to date with the latest news and the most important events of the day.

    155 comments
    Information
    Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
    1. +14
      14 January 2020 14: 19
      Something the figure presented by Kudrin looks painfully insignificant. Somehow I can’t believe it. They steal more, more.
      1. +18
        14 January 2020 14: 27
        Only in the apartment of Zakharchenko was three times more.
        1. +4
          14 January 2020 14: 44
          The answer in the article is MUCH WORTER than things are with financial irregularities NOT CRIMINAL CRIMES. About a third of these violations relate to accounting, the same amount is related to the organization of procurement.
          1. +4
            14 January 2020 15: 22
            with procurement

            "Sawing" and dragging, like the last time ...
            "Wedding in Malinovka", film (1967)
        2. +4
          14 January 2020 17: 39
          Do you think that this money belonged to Zakharchenko? As if to the colonel, such amounts are not by rank. You can still believe in millions, but not in billions. Polkan milked big business? Yes, he can't reach the udder from the stepladder, for the big one he is - "hey you, colonel" But the fact that he casters for a small share is closer to the truth. Well, or the holder of some common fund.
          1. +2
            15 January 2020 03: 15
            I believe that this money is stolen from the state. The rest is not interesting. It’s not interesting to whom Cherkalin’s money belonged and why Arashukov could steal for so many years, I wonder why this didn’t interest anyone. And who are they hey colonel or Mr. Colonel do not care.
            1. -1
              15 January 2020 09: 45
              When you give the traffic cop a paw, does the state budget suffer? When I "negotiate" with the same firefighter or labor inspector, am I getting into the pocket of the state? There is money from private individuals that they agree to pay for solving their problems and they have nothing to do with the state.
              1. 0
                15 January 2020 12: 24
                These are your problems. Let's negotiate with the official on your paw, and if you have extra millions to pay taxes
      2. +19
        14 January 2020 14: 29
        Quote: depressant
        Something the figure presented by Kudrin looks painfully insignificant. Somehow I can’t believe it. They steal more, more.

        He did not include the affairs of his team there ..
        1. +12
          14 January 2020 14: 33
          He did not include the affairs of his team there ..

          He excluded from there "family" cases and other "untouchables".
        2. -1
          14 January 2020 14: 36
          Quote: Svarog
          He did not include the affairs of his team there ..

          Here Putin is constantly criticized, but he is a liberal and disgusting Minister of Finance Kudrin, attached to the necessary business. Let Kudrin shock corruption, all will be good.
          1. +16
            14 January 2020 14: 37
            Quote: Siberia 75
            Let Kudrin shock corruption, all will be good.

            Other agencies must fight corruption .. and not Kudrin ..
            1. +7
              14 January 2020 14: 40
              Bees versus honey!
              1. 0
                14 January 2020 15: 14
                Quote: Romka
                Bees versus honey!

                That's why the pike is in the pond, so that the crucian "does not doze". Pike Kudrin - crucian Medvedev. Always asleep, while his ministers and party members babosy tyat. It is not necessary to expand the powers, but to introduce Confiscation, then there will be less tyrit.
                1. +5
                  14 January 2020 15: 29
                  And what to confiscate? The Skif trailer? laughing
                  1. -1
                    14 January 2020 17: 02
                    Which Skiff?
                    Zakharchenko either took two, or three KamAZ trucks ...
                    ALL cases in excess of a million must be made criminal, but simply expelled without serving a sentence and a 5-year ban on occupying the state. or muc. posts
                2. +1
                  14 January 2020 19: 26
                  .... And the death penalty, too.
                  1. +3
                    14 January 2020 19: 32
                    Quote: 4ekist
                    .... And the death penalty, too.

                    Yeah. At least five years, for those who especially distinguished themselves. As an alternative to execution - full reparation of damage and a dozen on public construction sites. Yes
                    1. 0
                      14 January 2020 21: 17
                      Here's another thought and realized that you can steal "in the backlog" (to print the money box after serving). Therefore, the confiscation of d. not for the amount of proven guilt (corruption or theft), but in FULL for any amount that the thief could not document.
                      And abolish the presumption of innocence in theft, fraud and corruption cases. In such matters, it is not income that matters, but EXPENDITURE!
                      1. +2
                        14 January 2020 21: 20
                        Quote: hydrox
                        Here's another thought and realized that you can steal "in the backlog" (to print the money box after serving).

                        On this "budget vorovayki" and hope.
                        1. +2
                          15 January 2020 04: 34
                          So they wrote SUCH a law for themselves!
                          I spent my 8 months and ran to Landon, where a dozen, two, five million dollars are waiting for the owner!
            2. +3
              14 January 2020 14: 47
              Quote: Svarog
              Other agencies must fight corruption .. and not Kudrin ..

              Who! As soon as an anti-corruption body is created, it becomes a hotbed of corruption (see Zakharchenko). Here either put up or put on a stake.
              1. +1
                14 January 2020 17: 05
                Quote: Siberia 75
                Here either put up or put on a stake.

                "You won't jail everyone!" (c) from some famous movie
            3. +4
              14 January 2020 15: 26
              Quote: Svarog
              Other agencies must fight corruption .. and not Kudrin ..

              Kudrin is not fighting corruption. he only tells "other departments" what and to whom they should pay close attention.
              Of course, I would like it to be that way.
            4. +1
              15 January 2020 10: 28
              Other agencies must fight corruption .. and not Kudrin ..

              For some reason, Russia is in no hurry to apply the Singapore method of fighting corruption. They destroyed corruption in a couple of years. It would be a desire.
          2. +9
            14 January 2020 16: 26
            Quote: Siberia 75
            Here Putin is constantly criticized, but he is a liberal and disgusting Minister of Finance Kudrin, attached to the necessary business. Let Kudrin shock corruption, all will be good.

            -----------------------------------
            Kudrin himself spawned corruption. In addition, Kudrin created a budget rule, according to which part of the funds for the sale of resources is invested in American securities, supposedly in retirement and social programs. We have already seen pensions and social programs; personally, I will never forgive 5 years of correctional labor from the state for anything. So to everything that Messrs. Kudrin and Putin are doing, I have a great understanding that they are in fact carrying out the dismantling of the country and the genocide of the people.
            1. -6
              14 January 2020 16: 37
              Quote: Altona
              Kudrin himself spawned corruption.

              Directly spawned. What a world-wide parent. Maybe the reason is more serious than Kudrin. For example, capitalism.
              Quote: Altona
              Kudrin created a budget rule, according to which part of the funds for the sale of resources is invested in American securities

              Russia dropped all these treasuries and the like to zero. (You read at least a little)
              Quote: Altona
              So to everything that Messrs. Kudrin and Putin are doing, I have a great understanding that they are in fact carrying out the dismantling of the country and the genocide of the people.

              I advise you to watch "Time Ahead" Issues five.
              1. +5
                14 January 2020 16: 42
                Quote: Siberia 75
                Russia dropped all these treasuries and the like to zero. (You read at least a little)

                --------------------------------
                You understand at least a little and do not teach others. The Treasuries were dropped quite elegantly, just shifted from balance to balance. From the balance of the Ministry of Finance to the balance of the Central Bank. As you yourself noticed, everything is within the system. Since the Ministry of Finance can hardly be called Russian like the Central Bank. As for corruption, it is the budgetary rule and all kinds of money-boxes of "people's welfare" that give rise to super-corruption, and not gratitude to "chocolates", corny mediocre kickbacks. I will not advise you anything, because I look and analyze more information than yours, you cannot master this.
              2. 0
                14 January 2020 17: 14
                Quote: Siberia 75
                Maybe the reason is more serious than Kudrin. For example, capitalism.

                So after all, they steal, proceeding not from the form of state structure, but thieves’s rules are used by the power layer, which exercises power over a given period of time .. And if this layer, having taken power in the 90s, immediately created a block of thieves laws that are in effect today, then it only speaks about the stability of power, but not about its crime. Those who steal today did not themselves invent and enforce thieves' laws.
                This is the whole point: "I AM NOT GUILTY!"
        3. +3
          14 January 2020 16: 04
          Meant per day. Not counting himself.
      3. +3
        14 January 2020 14: 31
        As for the theft from the state budget, Kudrin considers its volume in criminal cases "not exceeding 2-3 billion rubles annually."

        Really funny numbers. Did Tretzakharchenko steal? laughing
      4. +12
        14 January 2020 14: 31
        As for the theft from the state budget, Kudrin considers its volume in criminal cases "not exceeding 2-3 billion rubles annually." The situation is much worse with financial violations that are not criminal offenses.

        And the privatization of profitable and successful state-owned enterprises is not a crime ?! For this, in general, only one article should be - for life! And it should be applied to the designers of such privatizations, and not just to the buyers!
        1. +10
          14 January 2020 14: 34
          Quote: Starover_Z
          And the privatization of profitable and successful state-owned enterprises is not a crime ?! For this, in general, only one article should be - for life! And it should be applied to the designers of such privatizations, and not just to the buyers!

          As a matter of fact, and the withdrawal of capital .. which is in the public domain mastered .. If everything is calculated correctly, I'm afraid the scale will not be conceivable ..
          1. +4
            14 January 2020 14: 43
            Accounts Chamber needs additional powers
            The shooting of the bribe takers!
            Kudrin in a leather jacket and with Mauser!
          2. +14
            14 January 2020 14: 43
            If translated into understandable language, then in fact, theft-inappropriate-ineffective use was revealed for 804 billion rubles (almost a trillion), but only 2-3 of them disappeared without a trace (the difference in a billion is insignificant, you think, there is a billion for "successful managers" - fi) a billion - everything else is of the type, nevertheless, "mastered", albeit with violations (what garbage) - well there: double-entry bookkeeping and purchases at many times overpriced, payment-overpayment to numerous one-day firms, consulting firms and endless audit firms and other subcontractors and intermediaries for unnecessary work by anyone, but this is not a violation, everything is within the law. Also today, the figure of 1,12 trillion (if I am not mistaken?) Of "unused" budget funds was announced. Thus, it turns out that almost 2 trillion rubles were withdrawn from the Russian budget due to the “underdevelopment” and “ineffective use”. That is, the economy and the country did not receive this money for their development, they remained partly in the "money boxes", and the other part went into the pockets of "enterprising" citizens. They say there is not enough money for retirement? wink
            1. +10
              14 January 2020 16: 07
              Lenin wrotethat nothing corrupts an official like an unjustified salary... (it seems in the article How to reorganize RABKRIN) ... Miller’s salary is about 900 thousand bucks a year .. (what I found on the internet) plus bonuses, benefits and other income .. in comparison, the president of the poorest country in the USA - earns 443 thousand (the highest salary of an employee) .. Obama was able to buy his first property only after leaving his post ... for royalties from a book ... Sinul Matvienko became a billionaire in 2-3 years in St. Petersburg ... this is not corruption ? Baturin? Assigning salaries to yourself .. is this not corruption? And dumb-headed sons and relatives in office (Rogozin,
              Serdyukov, etc.) is this not corruption? Alas, this is politics ...
          3. +3
            14 January 2020 20: 14
            Quote: Svarog
            As a matter of fact, and the withdrawal of capital .. which is in the public domain mastered .. If everything is calculated correctly, I'm afraid the scale will not be conceivable ..

            I think that it is better not to count, because the scales from the unthinkable will pass into the category designated by the symbol "∞" -infinity. We have not created the conditions for foreign capital to rush to Russia as to Switzerland, and the accumulated capital not to drain from Russia. The maximum amount in the bank that is insured by the state and will be reimbursed to the depositor in the event of bank bankruptcy is 1,4 million rubles. All. Everything that was above this amount will be "forgiven" you with a feeling of sorrow on your face. Just imagine how lucky you are in the sense that you did not win the New Year's billion! Where can this heap of money in our conditions be attached? I put a lard in the bank, the bank went bankrupt, they gave you 1,5 lemons and run to the kiosk for new tickets. I didn't put it in the bank, then the "bald pioneers with tattoos" came and, manipulating the iron and soldering iron, they took everything, leaving the money for the pharmaceutical plaster. So the outflow of babos continues and will continue in echelons until the banking policy in Russia changes and becomes attractive. And something suggests that this will not happen soon simply because it is very profitable for someone to keep Russia on a hungry financial ration.
        2. +2
          14 January 2020 17: 24
          Quote: Starover_Z
          And the privatization of profitable and successful state enterprises is not a crime

          This is a crime from your point of view, but it is a good thing from the point of view of the IMF, only for some reason this business (which, incidentally, is personally led by Dimon) has been stagnating for a year ...
          It seems that those who are annoying with their mouths, for example, at Russian Railways, or RosKomFlot, or at AeroFlot or their mouths are painfully small, or there is not enough money for privatization, or the spiders cannot share the inheritance ...
          1. 0
            14 January 2020 20: 52
            Asheshipk gave: liberoids want to privatize OWLComFlot
      5. +3
        14 January 2020 14: 56
        Quote: depressant
        Something the figure presented by Kudrin looks too insignificant

        If they steal 2-3 lard rubles (not bucks) a year from the treasury, then we can assume that there is no theft in Russia.
      6. +7
        14 January 2020 15: 16
        "... As for the theft from the state budget, Kudrin considers its volume in criminal cases" not exceeding 2-3 billion rubles annually ... "
        If we add the phrase "to each official" to this conclusion of Kudrin, then it is quite plausible.
        1. -9
          14 January 2020 15: 43
          The main theft in Russia is leaving or cheating with taxes, as well as the shadow economy - 15 20 trillion rubles a year.
          1. +5
            14 January 2020 16: 19
            Quote: Vadim237
            The main theft in Russia is leaving or cheating with taxes,

            Not quite so, the main theft is the overstatement of the cost, work, goods, services that government agencies at various levels consume.
      7. +7
        14 January 2020 15: 33
        Quote: depressant
        Something the figure presented by Kudrin looks painfully insignificant. Somehow I can’t believe it. They steal more, more.

        Pan Kudrin does not read newspapers.
        2016 year - Colonel Zakharchenko. Only one currency worth 8,5 billion rubles.
        Year 2019 - FSB officers Cherkalin and Frolov. Jewelry worth 12 billion rubles.
        2019 - Arshaukov and K. Suspicion of theft of 30 billion rubles.
      8. +9
        14 January 2020 16: 14
        They steal more, more.
        It is only those who did not share with him, those who share, do not steal.
      9. +5
        14 January 2020 16: 38
        Quote: depressant
        Something the figure presented by Kudrin looks painfully insignificant. Somehow I can’t believe it. They steal more, more.

        He is a fighter against corruption, like I Yuri Gagarin. Mentally remove Putin from the Kremlin, and then trot these chubais and curls, there Zakharchenko will seem like just a petty thief.
      10. +3
        14 January 2020 17: 59
        Quote: depressant
        Something the figure presented by Kudrin looks painfully insignificant. Somehow I can’t believe it. They steal more, more.

        Quote: YOUR
        Only in the apartment of Zakharchenko was three times more.
        Reply

        Shy guy! A direct copy of the “blue thief - Alexander Yakovlevich” from “12 chairs”
        KUDRIN: Vladimir Vladimirovich! We conducted an analysis of the use of the expenditure side of the budget and revealed a lot of theft ...
        PUTIN: Report, Alexei Leonidovich ...
        KUDRIN: In the whole country, the figures for the misuse of budget funds, and in some cases direct embezzlement, look very depressing ...
        PUTIN: Alexei Leonidovich, start at your department ...
        KUDRIN: Things are worse with financial irregularities that are not criminal offenses. About a third of these violations relate to accounting, the same amount is related to the organization of procurement. In the Accounts Chamber of criminal cases revealed no more than 2-3 billion rubles per year ....

        feel
        Then they shook a trillion rubles - they asked “Whose?” And Alexei Leonidovich called the exact figures of 2-3 billion ... feel So two or three? For a billion, you can build 5 kindergartens for 420 patients per shift or 14 kindergartens with a capacity of 280 children per shift ...
      11. +5
        14 January 2020 20: 49
        Is it a Military Review or an Echo of the Matzah? The second article on some left topic! If I want to read news about the economy and pension reforms, I go to look at a businessman and others. Here is a site with a military theme! Why this srach on kudrotemy? Maybe it's time to be renamed the Economic Review? Dispatch everyone and give everyone deputy badges ??
      12. The comment was deleted.
    2. +12
      14 January 2020 14: 21
      "As regards theft from the state budget, Kudrin considers his criminal case volumes "not to exceed 2-3 billion rubles annually." Things are much worse with financial irregularities that are not criminal offenses. About a third of these violations relate to accounting, the same amount is related to the organization of procurement."
      Yes, because an official of any level, from impunity, believes that he is a king and a god. The servants of the people think that the people are themselves, and so they serve themselves little by little ...
      1. +9
        14 January 2020 14: 31
        Quote: GKS 2111
        Yes, because an official of any level, from impunity, believes that he is a king and a god. The servants of the people think that the people are themselves, and so they serve themselves little by little ...

        Little by little it was a long time ago ... now they serve themselves to the fullest .. We don’t give our own .. so why be afraid.
      2. +18
        14 January 2020 14: 49
        Things are much worse with financial irregularities, non-criminal offenses.

        Financial violations for trillions, it turns out - "that's right, little things, it's okay." An orphan who stole a chocolate bar from a store - according to the Russian Themis - is a real criminal / criminal ...
        What today has a place to be is a parody of justice. request
        1. +4
          14 January 2020 16: 21
          It has long been known that "a raven-raven will not peck out an eye."
      3. +4
        14 January 2020 15: 02
        Quote: GKS 2111
        Yes, because an official of any level, from impunity, believes that he is a king and a god. The servants of the people think that the people are themselves, and so they serve themselves little by little.
        In the novel "On this occasion, you can quote from the book" Animal Farm "by George Orwell:
        "All animals are equal, but among them there are more equal"
    3. +3
      14 January 2020 14: 23
      At the moment, the agency has the right to only notify law enforcement authorities of the violations identified.

      Why are they all only able to notify? it's some kind of nonsense ..... or a lie.
      1. +4
        14 January 2020 14: 32
        What's the point? Checked, time spent s / n employees transferred the case and the authorities closed (((
        1. +1
          14 January 2020 14: 45
          Quote: Clever man
          What's the point? Checked, time spent s / n employees transferred the case and the authorities closed (((

          It's time to restore the "financial inquisition", with special powers. And at the head of the "cardinal in pince-nez" to plant! Oh yes, even the "frontal" place will clean up from all sorts of different things, so that you would always be ready!
          1. +1
            14 January 2020 14: 46
            That cardinal and will lose the most steal))))
            1. +2
              14 January 2020 14: 52
              Then, comrade in a penny SEARCH!
              1. 0
                14 January 2020 17: 32
                It was like that, but the liberoids did not like it - they shot it!
          2. 0
            14 January 2020 16: 02
            A "financial inquisition" to take bribes and protect
      2. +8
        14 January 2020 15: 02
        Yes, you see, what’s the matter ...
        Those who must stop themselves steal. Colonels Zakharchenko and Chekalin are already the day before yesterday. Yesterday - the lieutenant general of the customs service Kizlyk, grabbed so much that the ten of Zakharchenko and Chekalin could not be carried away. And the hero of our day, Lieutenant General Chvarkov, is really a "shy girl". This is just about the appropriation of salaries of employees in the amount of several million rubles. But mind you! Security officials. Kudrin is afraid to come up and find out the real figure.
        The only question is: where are our civilian "heroes"?
        1. +2
          14 January 2020 15: 11
          Quote: depressant
          The only question is: where are our civilian "heroes"?

          The system ... known - He who guards, he has.
          The citizens will look, look and remember that before, very earlier, the "upper" and those in control were not so greedy ... The SYSTEM did not allow, suppressed many base human vices. For the time being, for the time being, of course, because any established / stagnant system begins to recruit those vices itself!
          Not a vicious circle, but something like that.
        2. +6
          14 January 2020 16: 33
          Quote: depressant
          But mind you! The siloviki.

          --------------------------
          What are you! The siloviki are of prime priority and crystal clear patriots. There is no spirituality in you, Lyudmila Yakovlevna, as General Zolotov says. laughing laughing
          In fact, the siloviki never carried and do not carry such spirituality, contrary to the prevailing opinion here. Moreover, having the right to violence, the security forces carry out for the most part their selfish interests, squeezing out business and resolving some financial issues of huge amounts of money. Look at the boards of the missing, petty crime. They have not been doing this for a long time to the extent necessary. And they are unlikely to cope, because there is only an ideology of enrichment at all costs.
    4. +11
      14 January 2020 14: 24
      The king is not guilty.
      The boyars are bad, but there is no one to replace
      1. +10
        14 January 2020 14: 30
        Quote: balunn
        The king is not guilty.
        The boyars are bad, but there is no one to replace

        And it will be like in Paris ..
      2. +9
        14 January 2020 14: 54
        Yes, and the people of the king got one more ..
        1. -4
          14 January 2020 16: 32
          Yes, and the people of the king got one more ..
          And really! Such a patient servile (insult is not considered, ask the official Zhirinovsky, he will confirm) there is nowhere, in truth has no analogues in the world ... and they don’t want to change anything, especially gifted people also dream of returning to the Soviet concentration camp.
      3. +3
        14 January 2020 15: 11
        Quote: balunn
        The boyars are bad, but there is no one to replace

        Boyar Ivan the Terrible was beating, Peter the Great, Lenin, Stalin, and since 1953 no one has been beating, so the offset then is to write.
      4. -4
        14 January 2020 15: 48
        How cashless operations using AI to track and audit the use of budget funds will be introduced in all regions - then the theft shop of state funds will close. We’ll come to this soon.
      5. +4
        14 January 2020 16: 37
        Quote: balunn
        The king is not guilty.
        The boyars are bad, but there is no one to replace

        -----------------------
        Yes, they make a fool of the tsar’s father as they want, but he pities them with a disease, hangs up the order, doesn’t allow the progressive dues to be introduced, the state tax on the export of the wealth of the people to the Germans is canceled, the people tell tales. laughing laughing
    5. +7
      14 January 2020 14: 26
      What theft ??? Everything is in accordance with the law ... of a capital-test society. And all sorts of exceptions to the rules .. did not share.
    6. +4
      14 January 2020 14: 27
      . About a third of these violations relate to accounting, the same amount is related to the organization of procurement.

      It should be understood that they spoke so carefully about competent comrades who maneuver very effectively in cash flows and remain in the shadows.
    7. +4
      14 January 2020 14: 33
      Kudrin knows that his friends are stealing his friends.
    8. +2
      14 January 2020 14: 35
      Arranged some (according to "Fobs"), a competition in greed. Now they steal, they cannot stop.
      1. +2
        14 January 2020 15: 29
        And don’t talk! A feast of shark business. There is no kraken on them.
    9. +14
      14 January 2020 14: 39
      the author of a wretched economic model lamented the problem, which is its integral part, and what?
      1. +5
        14 January 2020 15: 32
        So the view does that she is not his.
        I'm not me, and the model is not mine, Chubais is to blame!
        1. +2
          14 January 2020 15: 35
          well, yes, from him, lately, I have only heard about the welfare of the people, full of sorrow and pain, compassionate, and not gu at all about how such a thing came to life
    10. +7
      14 January 2020 14: 40
      Alexei Kudrin believes that the Accounts Chamber needs additional powers to fight corruption. - A leather jacket and a gun !!! ???
      1. +7
        14 January 2020 14: 56
        Why does he need "additional" powers? Vaughn Sergei Vostretsov has already found the main culprits of the "budget shortfall" and the poverty of teachers, doctors and others - this is ...... housewives! And he suggested taxing housewives as "self-employed." The next, obviously, in the queue for taxation will be dogs and cats - they enjoy the benefits of living with the owners for free and do not pay taxes, and even the poop and toilets of their housing and communal services must be disposed of. All right, comrades are on the right path!
        1. +2
          14 January 2020 15: 52
          Quote: Snail N9
          Vaughn Sergei Vostretsov has already found the main culprits of the "budget shortfall"

          The man said what he was instructed to say.
          So the topic is being discussed ...
      2. 0
        14 January 2020 15: 14
        Quote: Sergey 23
        Leather jacket and gun !!!?

        First of all, increase funding, they then steal not by status.
        1. +3
          14 January 2020 15: 55
          No, Snail, it's different.
          Against the background of a package of discriminatory laws adopted at the end of last year and from which citizens still have to shudder, the law on taxation of housewives in the minds of citizens, rejected by United Russia, is noisy, with advertised indignation, should have the following:
          do you see? The Duma does not adopt stupid laws, because the upcoming tax repressions against citizens are reasonably necessary.
          1. +2
            14 January 2020 15: 57
            Quote: depressant
            smartly, with publicized indignation, the law on taxation of housewives in the minds of citizens, rejected by United Russia, should have the effect

            Housewives will be imposed anyway, but the oligarchs will again be forgotten.
            1. +4
              14 January 2020 16: 28
              I already here, jokingly suggested, automatically, after reaching the age of 18, to assign the status of "self-employed" to all citizens of Russia and oblige them to pay tax at a fixed rate, according to the patent system, and let the citizens themselves, then, every year prove in the tax that they are either not yet subject to taxation, as students or employees, or they are already paying tax somewhere, as employees or entrepreneurs. I offered it as a joke, but some liked this approach - like, right, a sensible proposal! I was already scared ... sad
              1. +1
                14 January 2020 20: 46
                Quote: Snail N9
                He offered it as a joke, but some liked this approach, like, correctly, a sensible proposal!

                No, you just looked at the point. Do you think the officials have not guessed this, they just do not yet know how and when to bring it. But in a year they will bring it. So do not reproach yourself.
    11. +3
      14 January 2020 14: 46
      Kudrin told about the volume of corruption and theft from the budget of Russia

      Does he also consider the contents of his wallet?
    12. +2
      14 January 2020 14: 49
      He said and said. Who cares? Everyone is happy with everything.
    13. +2
      14 January 2020 14: 51
      Well .. and Shenderovich in a neighboring topic still compares us with some Germany there ..))
      I doubt that while Hitler in the country, trillions of people were plundered ..
      1. +2
        14 January 2020 15: 18
        Quote: Roman070280
        Well .. and Shenderovich still compares us with Germany there.

        So soon he will agree that Jews were destroyed in the USSR.
    14. -1
      14 January 2020 14: 54
      Under Kudrin, go and did not know the word to steal ....
      1. 0
        14 January 2020 14: 58
        Andrei Chistyakov, when they were kudrin, they just stole silently! !!
      2. +2
        14 January 2020 15: 11
        Quote: Andrey Chistyakov
        Under Kudrin, go and did not know the word to steal ....

        Just then there were fewer people reached by Internet access.
        1. +1
          14 January 2020 15: 57
          Cry out!
    15. +1
      14 January 2020 14: 57
      And in his reign as minister, to the budget, apparently, all sorts of corrupt officials and criminal authorities carried the money en masse, they gave their last, with tears in their eyes? ??
      1. -3
        14 January 2020 15: 00
        Quote: Thrifty
        And in his reign as minister, to the budget, apparently, all sorts of corrupt officials and criminal authorities carried the money en masse, they gave their last, with tears in their eyes? ??

        Not at all. They were sent en masse to the USA. Well, the main part of the "savings" was taken out of the USA.
    16. +2
      14 January 2020 15: 00
      The student will read the article and ask why financial irregularities are not considered a criminal offense, because here lies the Diaol. Set the bar at what amount the criminal prosecution begins and onward to landings and confiscations. and it’s going to be more fun.
      1. +1
        14 January 2020 15: 43
        So established - 10 000 rubles.
    17. +3
      14 January 2020 15: 02
      Official estimates should be multiplied by pi.
      1. +2
        14 January 2020 15: 17
        They have not yet come up with the number by which official estimates must be multiplied.
    18. +2
      14 January 2020 15: 04
      If "corruption in Russia amounts to trillions of rubles", but "volumes in criminal cases "do not exceed 2-3 billion rubles annually", then anyone familiar with arithmetic will easily notice that stealing is an extremely profitable business today. Of course! 3 billion from at least 1 trillion is 0,003%

      To understand, the chance to get caught is the same as to win the jackpot in the lottery - an apartment, a car, or whatever you play there.

      In other words, today only those who do not have such an opportunity do not steal. Let's talk about patriotism.
    19. 0
      14 January 2020 15: 04
      If you know who is tying, where are the statements to the Ministry of Internal Affairs .... or with them for one.
      1. +5
        14 January 2020 15: 14
        Everyone knows everything ..
        And the Ministry of Internal Affairs itself should work, and not wait until you get there, with a statement on Putin to write out a pendal in response ..
        1. 0
          14 January 2020 15: 42
          It does not work, but earns
    20. +6
      14 January 2020 15: 05
      Theorist is faced with reality! And I wanted to integrate Russia into the world economy as a raw materials appendage! What does a person think? fool wassat Brotherhood in the global economy, it's like a goat in the garden! hi
      1. -2
        14 January 2020 15: 28
        Quote: fif21
        ! I wanted to integrate Russia into the global economy as

        Apparently, you did not understand. The task to build in was. And at that moment it did not contradict anything. But after 2008 (and in fact, after Munich 2007), Russia declared that the era of plunder and collapse was over.
        So I had to rebuild the entire system "on the fly" ...
        1. +1
          14 January 2020 17: 48
          Well, schaz, you generally agree that the authorities in all this have nothing to do with it! laughing
    21. +2
      14 January 2020 15: 18
      This suggests that this entire system of tenders has seriously cut off the possibility of budget theft through inflating prices and estimates. And even more - "cashing" was strangled ... Kickbacks are really nowhere to take ... Try to drag at least something from the treasury account. The payment just won't work. So the budget surplus was drawn.
      The trouble with the use ... All the time delay transfers ... well, the suppliers "get in the position" and credit with trust ...
      1. +3
        14 January 2020 15: 31
        The conclusion is through controlled firms and overstatement of the cost of services, the competition cannot be won, because no mother of pearl buttons.
        1. -1
          14 January 2020 16: 20
          Quote: 75Sergey
          The conclusion is through controlled firms and overstatement of the cost of services, the competition cannot be won, because no mother of pearl buttons

          Apparently, you have never participated in contests. How is the primary pricing procedure going on, and how are the tenders. They are OPEN, you can APPEAL to the result of bidding for violations, and this is a frequent occurrence - when the results are canceled due to a violation ...
          1. 0
            14 January 2020 18: 55
            Quote: Mountain Shooter
            They are OPEN, you can APPEAL to the result of bidding for violations, and this is a frequent occurrence - when the results are canceled due to a violation ...

            Theoretically, everything is correct. But in fact, less and less willing to get budget crumbs from the master's table. And whoever received it saves on the salaries (solid scammers) of the quality of the work done (who will do the job well for a penny?) And about kickbacks three times hee hee hee, the schemes became more complicated and more inventive. Which once again proves that all theories are broken about reality. hi
            1. 0
              14 January 2020 22: 18
              Quote: fif21
              solid) the quality of the work performed (who will do the job well for a penny?) and about the kickbacks three times hee hee hee, it just became more complicated circuit and inventive. Which once again proves that all theories are broken about reality

              You are a theorist. Obviously did not participate in competitions? And I'm not a theorist ...
    22. +4
      14 January 2020 15: 25
      This character, Kudrin, especially amuses me.
      One of the founders of the liberal economy was appointed head of the Accounts Chamber.
      This is how to appoint Dracula as the main donor ...
      1. 0
        14 January 2020 18: 14
        He himself chose a position!
        Looks like he has such a vocation - to control ALL and point to ALL with his finger ...
        After all, he does nothing and is not to blame for anything!
    23. 0
      14 January 2020 15: 29
      Obviously modest ....
      And someone he suddenly became for the truth, marks for president, so there Valentina already took a place.
    24. +6
      14 January 2020 15: 31
      . The agency has the right to only notify law enforcement authorities of the violations identified. And they themselves decide whether to qualify them as corruption crimes

      What is the problem then? What does Kudrin cry and require additional powers and financing? Let any department qualify them, in any case, the prosecutor's office checks the correctness of the qualification and changes it. Reveal, excite and plant. Another question is why this is not done !?
    25. +2
      14 January 2020 15: 49
      And in whatever spit, he will definitely be called a "patriot". Why steals? So deserved, "patriotism", you need to understand wassat
    26. +2
      14 January 2020 15: 52
      Kudrin downplayed something in the Krasnoyarsk Territory alone in one branch of the forest 47 billion rubles were stolen.
    27. -2
      14 January 2020 15: 52
      Kudrin told about the volume of corruption and theft from the budget of Russia
      How to trust him? If he is dripping. request
    28. +3
      14 January 2020 16: 05
      The presumption of guilt - i.e. The apparent difference between income and expenses should be a mandatory reason for the visit of those who replace the current OBHSS. Otherwise, it is a matter of time before the country becomes - they will sell everything and everyone, in the bud. And what - and you can’t dream?
    29. +2
      14 January 2020 16: 17
      Apparently, being Prime Minister Kudrin, he did not know about corruption, then his eyes opened .. wink
    30. +1
      14 January 2020 16: 23
      There is already a quite reasonable initiative to equate embezzlement from the state budget with crimes in the field of national security.
      1. 0
        14 January 2020 18: 18
        This initiative in our liberoid world will die non-embodied (i.e., single and barren!) ...
        1. 0
          14 January 2020 20: 22
          Let's hope for the election of 21 years.
    31. Hog
      +1
      14 January 2020 16: 23
      There is no money, but you hold on)))
    32. 0
      14 January 2020 16: 24
      Well, now let him say who exactly steals, nicknames, appearances, passwords. Said A, speak B, but you can only hear it, you need it, you have to, and who will do it specifically?
      To name the names of those who steal, what other powers are needed? Or afraid of what?
      I strongly doubt that he would have stayed in office if he had simply stated on the board of directors that our profits had fallen because they were stealing and did not name specific characters.
      1. +2
        14 January 2020 17: 56
        Quote: sir_obs
        Well, now let him say who exactly steals, nicknames, appearances, passwords. Said A, speak B, but you can only hear it, you need it, you have to, and who will do it specifically?
        To name the names of those who steal, what other powers are needed? Or afraid of what?

        He was frightened, to put it bluntly ... Putin was not casual enough to offer this post almost forcibly .. It’s like, what to use language with liberals, go work and identify if you’re not afraid ..
        Then crack his fist on the table, as under Stalin it will not work! Russia’s financial flows have been tightly wrapped, and even before the World War one can come to an agreement if everything is openly expressed .. That's it! This is not a quick thing, I will say so .. But the work is ongoing and very painstaking ..
    33. +4
      14 January 2020 16: 27
      Kudrin directly reported the news .. Over at the colonel’s house, only 9 lards found cash!
      The fight against corruption in Russia is like direct fishing .. Caught, counted, weighed, released laughing
      1. +1
        14 January 2020 17: 45
        And you turn on the brain. Such an amount to the colonel is not of rank. Not for Ivashka shirt. Who is a Colonel for Krupnyakov? Dandruff, no more.
        1. +1
          14 January 2020 17: 48
          Quote: AS Ivanov.
          And you turn on the brain.

          Yes, it has been included for a long time since the 90s yet ..
          Quote: AS Ivanov.
          Such an amount to the colonel is not of rank. Not for Ivashka shirt. Who is a Colonel for Krupnyakov? Dandruff, no more.

          And who is the "big guy" in your understanding? heh heh
          1. +1
            14 January 2020 17: 52
            Big business for example. Or persons related to the upper echelons of power. For them, he is "hey, colonel, run here!" The looking common fund or the cashier is closer to the truth.
            1. +2
              14 January 2020 18: 30
              Quote: AU Ivanov.
              Big business for example. Or persons related to the upper echelons of power. For them, he is "hey, colonel, run here!" The looking common fund or the cashier is closer to the truth.

              Well the identification of "friend or foe" you passed hi .. Look at the root!
              Although even deeper, the global shadow capital in Russia is being dug in and very successfully .. They are buying up everything and everyone and funding is unlimited .. That's dangerous! negative
              1. +1
                14 January 2020 18: 32
                Why world? We have an excellent own "school" of the shadow economy, nurtured by the Soviet Union, in the days of the guilds.
                1. +1
                  14 January 2020 19: 20
                  Quote: AU Ivanov.
                  Why world? We have an excellent own "school" of the shadow economy, nurtured by the Soviet Union, in the days of the guilds.

                  Well, in the Soviet Union there it is clear ....
                  Now, alas, everything is more complicated
                  Remember the 90s, mortgage auctions, where did our Jews (former lobarants, etc.) suddenly get a lot of money that they started buying up? Well, of course there are all sorts of thieves and cashing schemes .. But to buy such the largest enterprises of the USSR to seven Jewish bankers? .. Here the question is very interesting negative
                  They were dispersed, but how many were still quiet?
    34. +1
      14 January 2020 16: 53
      Please treat this with understanding!
    35. +2
      14 January 2020 17: 09
      This was how it was conceived, when this whole circus was affectionately called democracy and the "prison" of the backbones - the Soviet Union - was thrown down. For 30 years now, this innocent, elegant bulging-eyed face has not left high-ranking officials: "Wow - they are stealing!" And they seem to be unaware that at this hour, on this fine New Year's day, Mr. Premier is sweating his brow on his nickel-plated room guillotine to cut the next 3600 "old-regime codes", among which, don't go to your grandmother, there are those that laid the anti-corruption foundation then a young state. There is everything: experience, legal assessments and law enforcement, analyzes and assessments - 70 years in various variations - from devastation, war, to a peaceful, calm life. Blow off the tares - collect the grains! But no, from year to year the same thing: "They steal," and empty fish eyes.
    36. 0
      14 January 2020 17: 12
      What power they steal
    37. +2
      14 January 2020 17: 20
      Something no one is looking for "Kudrin's treasure". Bandyukov should be connected to the search for a "percentage". bully
      1. +2
        14 January 2020 18: 06
        Yeah, otherwise the boys have been idle since the 90s.
        1. +2
          14 January 2020 18: 33
          Quote: Kuzmitsky
          Yeah, otherwise the boys have been idle since the 90s.

          laughing good Those who remained alive remained in the business .. But compared to the world bandigans, the kindergarten is still .. But they are already being trained!
    38. 0
      14 January 2020 18: 23
      Something upstairs gathered a lot of indecent people.
    39. +3
      14 January 2020 18: 42
      Nevertheless, the Chinese, or rather, the Soviet version of the fight against speculators and thieves suits me more .. soldier
      Now this is not just theft, but Treason is coming! There is already a state security at risk ..
      It’s time to shoot, but first we would close the borders ..
      1. +1
        14 January 2020 20: 21
        And who will restore order. The oligarchs? Governors? The prosecutor’s office? Rosguard? Who??? They are all in business.
    40. +1
      14 January 2020 19: 11
      And who did form this entire system of financial and economic relations do not remember?
      1. 0
        14 January 2020 20: 14
        Of course we remember !!! And who led - remember?
    41. 0
      14 January 2020 19: 15
      Kudrin told ..... That's when the Interior Minister will tell us how much has been planted and for how long, how many have been returned and confiscated. Then it will be good
    42. 0
      14 January 2020 20: 13
      From the speech of Kudrin:
      1. "About 2-3 billion rubles are stolen from the federal budget every year."
      2. "... last year the department revealed such violations for about 804 billion rubles."
      Even a student knows that these numbers are almost the same - 2-3 and 804.
      But Kudrin did not know about this: "18 tons of gold and $ 100 million in cash were seized from the deputy head of customs for energy of the Russian Federation."
      1. +1
        14 January 2020 20: 18
        Quote: AKS-U
        From the speech of Kudrin:
        1. "About 2-3 billion rubles are stolen from the federal budget every year."
        2. "... last year the department revealed such violations for about 804 billion rubles."
        Even a student knows that these numbers are almost the same - 2-3 and 804.
        But Kudrin did not know about this: "18 tons of gold and $ 100 million in cash were seized from the deputy head of customs for energy of the Russian Federation."

        Did you take the data from Navalny? Let's .. wassat
        1. 0
          14 January 2020 20: 37
          Central Press. Lead RU. All from open sources.
          https://www.vesti.ru/doc.html?id=3229178
          1. +1
            14 January 2020 20: 43
            Quote: AKS-U
            Central Press. Lead RU. All from open sources.
            https://www.vesti.ru/doc.html?id=3229178

            Yes, the same garbage .. They are all there under the control of the media .. hi
            It is time to introduce the death penalty, as before, for especially large ones and with confiscation from all relatives. (If he escapes to London or Israel). Well, maybe things will get off the ground .... And so one chatter!
        2. 0
          14 January 2020 20: 41
          1. https://www.tks.ru/reviews/2020/01/14/01
          2.https://youtu.be/Q5ALjLBOHII
          This infa on a cart rolled 2-3 more back. Now it is filtered out in the media
    43. 0
      14 January 2020 22: 18
      Something Kudrin's PR is not childish. Where do they want to shove it? And for what?
      A fighter against corruption from him .... as their friend Gref.
      An apologist for joining the WTO, a separate pacifism for Russia, and he is also a lobbyist for raising the retirement age. Not to mention his ingenious notion - a "budget rule" that allows, in addition to the budget, to have one more - a dull, dark, incomprehensible purpose (to stabilize the ruble exchange rate and stable fulfillment of social obligations ... type. Yeah).
    44. 0
      15 January 2020 02: 04
      Why was corruption minimal in the USSR? Because it was controlled by the Soviets of Workers' Deputies. It was the surest way to defeat corruption. Then, when the Soviets themselves degraded under the pressure and penetration of officials, corruption increased sharply. Because the power ceased to be in fact Soviet. And in the late 80s it took on alarming proportions.
      If our society wants to deal with corruption, Public Councils on the fight against corruption should be organized with a strict selection of candidates with positions no higher than the heads of sections and without interruption from the main job (this is absolutely a key point, otherwise the meaning is completely lost) and the authority to receive absolutely any information. A person who refuses to provide information should be automatically held accountable.
    45. 0
      15 January 2020 15: 39
      Kudrin told about the volume of corruption and theft from the budget of Russia

      But Karaulov told about the amount of money spent in RUSNANO:
    46. 0
      15 January 2020 23: 13
      money zakharchenko people if you do not understand it is money from controlled structures. those entrepreneurs who are ruined by the board, etc. where does the budget of the Russian Federation.

    "Right Sector" (banned in Russia), "Ukrainian Insurgent Army" (UPA) (banned in Russia), ISIS (banned in Russia), "Jabhat Fatah al-Sham" formerly "Jabhat al-Nusra" (banned in Russia) , Taliban (banned in Russia), Al-Qaeda (banned in Russia), Anti-Corruption Foundation (banned in Russia), Navalny Headquarters (banned in Russia), Facebook (banned in Russia), Instagram (banned in Russia), Meta (banned in Russia), Misanthropic Division (banned in Russia), Azov (banned in Russia), Muslim Brotherhood (banned in Russia), Aum Shinrikyo (banned in Russia), AUE (banned in Russia), UNA-UNSO (banned in Russia), Mejlis of the Crimean Tatar people (banned in Russia), Legion “Freedom of Russia” (armed formation, recognized as terrorist in the Russian Federation and banned), Kirill Budanov (included to the Rosfinmonitoring list of terrorists and extremists)

    “Non-profit organizations, unregistered public associations or individuals performing the functions of a foreign agent,” as well as media outlets performing the functions of a foreign agent: “Medusa”; "Voice of America"; "Realities"; "Present time"; "Radio Freedom"; Ponomarev Lev; Ponomarev Ilya; Savitskaya; Markelov; Kamalyagin; Apakhonchich; Makarevich; Dud; Gordon; Zhdanov; Medvedev; Fedorov; Mikhail Kasyanov; "Owl"; "Alliance of Doctors"; "RKK" "Levada Center"; "Memorial"; "Voice"; "Person and law"; "Rain"; "Mediazone"; "Deutsche Welle"; QMS "Caucasian Knot"; "Insider"; "New Newspaper"