Bloomberg called Putin's achievements over 20 years in power in Russia

Bloomberg, an American news agency, sums up the results of Vladimir Putin’s 20-year stay in power. Recall that during a major press conference one of the journalists called this term the 20th anniversary of the presidency, ”to which Putin objected, noting that from 2008 to 2012 he was not the president of the Russian Federation.

The Bloomberg Information Service writes that Vladimir Putin’s main achievement over this 20-year period is Russia’s restoration of much of the influence that was lost after the collapse of the USSR.

The material says that Vladimir Putin during this time has done a lot to strengthen economic and political contacts with China. At present, China is the main economic partner for Russia. According to preliminary estimates, in 2019, trade between the Russian Federation and China will be a record $ 118 billion (in 2018, it was about 108 billion). Countries set as their goal in the near future to increase the volume of trade to $ 200 billion. The Power of Siberia gas pipeline is capable of contributing to this. It should be noted that in the last couple of years, trade between China and the United States has been declining due to the so-called trade war. In the first half of 2019, the volume of trade between these countries fell by almost 15 percent. However, in total they remain huge - about 400 billion dollars a year.

Putin’s achievements from 1999 to the present Bloomberg relates the increase in the territory of Russia due to the annexation of Crimea, the establishment of Russian supplies weapons to NATO - Turkey, strengthening influence in the Middle East, primarily through operations in Syria and diplomatic measures in the Gulf countries.

From the material:

Russia has become a major force in the Middle East. At the same time, it expands its influence on Africa. Also, Putin today manages to set the tone for the Norman Four summits.

The publication did not consider the problems during the 20-year term of Vladimir Putin’s stay in power.

Comments

[bessmertniy]

Russia's modest economic successes, the ongoing impoverishment of the population and many domestic problems - all this hampered achievements in the international arena. The country, as it has become a raw materials appendage of the developed economies of the world, remains a raw materials appendage with the exception of several industries, where there are still results that compel others to reckon with Russia.

[Sofa expert]

Right now, they will stick cons

[Basil50]

"Modest gains" is a creep from the poverty of the 90s.
Few people know, but RUSSIA of the 90s is the standard of living of Europe and the USA. * Reformers * as promised, arranged for ALL of us a standard of living * of the advanced west *. Do not be fooled. They copied EVERYTHING down to the level of crime.
Today in RUSSIA they are trying to preserve what is left of the SOVIET UNION and to develop further.
* Modest successes * only from the fact that until now neither murderers, nor traitors, nor thieves have been shot at, as it was in the past, when * GDP growth was up to 30% per year *.
And yet, the SOVIET UNION was the most advanced country in terms of basic science and of course in terms of the development of advanced technologies. Today, RUSSIA is developing new technologies to which neither Europe nor the other USA has yet grown, and this applies not only to the development of weapons .....
That's just about these advanced technologies that neither footmen from the stage nor those who in the media cover only such * giants of thought * and * fathers of RUSSIAN democracy * will be able to tell.

[bouncyhunter]

Good and right (IMHO) it says Basil50 ! I take off my hat and with the coming.

[Svarog]

I noticed that the worse the country, the more Western newspapers praise us and turn around ..

[Sarmat Sanych]

Modest economic success of Russia

Are you kidding? over 20 years, the GDP of the Russian Federation has grown 14 times, the data is confirmed by the IMF, the gold and foreign exchange reserves increased from $ 9 billion to $ 540 billion, gold reserves from zero to 2300 tons, the average salary compared to 99m increased 11 times, the number of private cars in the Russian population increased by 6 times, the annual consumption of meat, fish and fruit per capita in comparison with 2000 (I did not find information on the 99th) increased almost 2,5 times, the number of abortions per year decreased from 3 million (98 years) to 0,55 million (data from the World Health Organization), 2 million homeless children have disappeared from the streets, the volume of annual road construction has grown almost 18 (!) times, the volume of housing built annually has increased many times to 75-80 million square meters (the peak indicators of the RSFSR have long been exceeded), the annual collection grain broke all past records (120-135 million tons, it is better not to remember the numbers 91-99), the production volumes of poultry and pork soared many times and exceeded the indicators of the peak 2 years of the RSFSR (I am not talking about 3 at all), number of orphans in children's homes max decreased more than 90 times from almost 99 thousand to 10 thousand, infant mortality decreased almost 600 times to 50 per 3 births (one of the best indicators in the world, for comparison in the States 4,5 per 1000 births), etc. ... This list is long, it can be enumerated for a long time, from a manifold increase in defense capacity and the creation of the world's most powerful weapons to a manifold decrease in the number of murders and terrorist attacks on the streets, and from the headlines in the 5,5th newspapers "Russia asks America for some more food" to the current news that Russia is ousting America Russian companies supply poultry meat to the States from the Chinese chicken market pubs: https: //youtu.be/aQ1000MCG99MFXY

[Stas157]

Quote: Sarmat Sanych

Are you kidding? for 20 years Russian GDP grew 14 times, the data is confirmed

Yes, if you count in rubles. And, if in dollars, then immediately bullshit comes out. If the ruble crashed harder, it could have come out at 140.

In a similar outline and all the achievements of the freelance propagandists.

[Sarmat Sanych]

Stas157, when will you stop suffering from clip thinking and stop repeating nonsense from the Internet?) This is exactly in DOLLARS, and the annual Russian export has grown 10 times (up to $ 455 billion) also in dollars. And I'm wondering, but will you calculate the decline in the number of abortions from 3-4 million in the 90s to 0,55 million "in dollars"? Can we also estimate the increase in housing being built annually from 5 million square meters to 80 million square meters "in dollars"? Decrease in orphans in orphanages from 550 thousand to 50 thousand in what units would you like to count? The annual purchase of 1,8 million new cars by Russians alone (99 times higher than 8m), how can we recalculate? Suggest, amaze with intelligence). And the decrease in infant mortality in Russia from almost 11 per 1000 births to 3,5 will turn your language into $ count? And what about your height, weight, number of children, in what conditional terms? Stop suffering with nonsense.

[Stas157]

Quote: Sarmat Sanych

This is exactly in DOLLARS

What are you numbers to enjoy?
Russian GDP:
2000 - 7 trillion 305,6 billion rubles
2018 - 103 trillion 626,6 billion rubles
During Putin’s reign (if we take the achievements of Putin) GDP in rubles actually increased by about 14 times. Well, in dollars, respectively, less.

[Sarmat Sanych]

Stas157, pull up your educational level to speak with me in an equal dialogue. I wonder what courses $ counted? Do you have any idea what inflation was then, what is the exchange rate of $ for foreign exchange operators, how much did it differ in exchangers? And then the IMF and the World Bank considered our growth precisely in PPP? Enough already bustle like in a frying pan, you all understand.

[Stas157]

Quote: Sarmat Sanych

Stas157, raise your level of education to speak with me on an equal footing.

Usually shkolota in this vein leads a dialogue. Here it is, what it is.

[Sarmat Sanych]

Stss157, you imitate the presence of intelligence, do not disgrace

[Stas157]

Quote: Sarmat Sanych

Stss157, you imitate the presence of intelligence, do not disgrace

Quote: Sarmat Sanych

Bot not living in Russia

Quote: Sarmat Sanych

Such a bot job

Creative approach! You just crushed your pressure. Therefore to really don't disgrace communicating with you, I finish answering a rude interlocutor.

[Sarmat Sanych]

Stas157, do not mirror your own complexes. You have "blissful gopher syndrome" - a defensive reaction to what is happening

[Mountain shooter]

Quote: Sarmat Sanych

stop Internet?) It is in DOLLARS, also the annual Russian export has grown 10 times (to $ 455 billion) also in dollars. And I'm wondering, but

But it’s true! And it was precisely for this that the whole western shobla pulled into thirty-three languages ​​... to bark Russia, because it was not possible to divide into parts and to eat, like a flock of piranhas ...

[Mordvin 3]

Quote: Sarmat Sanych

This is exactly in DOLLARS

Sanych, and the salary also in dollars increased 11 times?

[Sarmat Sanych]

Mordvin 3, read carefully. Moreover, here "rubles" and "dollars", per capita income has grown 11 times compared to 99m in terms of purchasing power parity. What are we talking about, what are we comparing?) 98th year: Kinder surprise by the prime minister and salary of an electrician of pumping stations $ 6. And now it is impossible to park with your family on Friday and weekends to thousands of shopping centers throughout Russia - everything is occupied by millions of SUVs.

[WIKI]

Quote: Sarmat Sanych

when you stop thinking with clip thinking to stop repeating nonsense from the Internet?) This is in DOLLARS

1999 GDP of $ 209,77 billion, 2018 1 trillion. 630,659 billion dollars. It turns out 8, not 14. There is no longer a desire to analyze your numbers. If not for oil:

[Stas157]

It is significant that during the reign of Yeltsin, in just the five-year period 1995-2000, GDP increased in rubles already 7 times! But nobody sings the praises of the drunk for this "super achievement". The little casket just opens, during the same period there was a default in the country and ruble greatly lost in price. Everything is the same as with Putin, if you count this growth on Dollars, then the picture is already completely different.

[Vadim237]

And in Russia, what are the prices in dollars, do you pay in dollars in stores?

[Sarmat Sanych]

Stas157, read WIKI's answer, take the pan off your head and think.

[Sarmat Sanych]

WIKI, do you read it too? And here "oil" and other crap, oil and gas revenues in our gross product are only 8%, the IMF data confirms. The GDP grew 14 times in terms of PURCHASING POWER PARITY, and I am talking about 2019 and not about 2018. Now the GDP of the Russian Federation at PPP is $ 4,2 trillion, the 5th in the world (together with Germany), higher than that of Britain, Italy and France. Let it be known to you that, according to PPP, per capita output in Russia and, for example, in the United States is the same (we go to the Cia Factbook website, subtract the share of services in each of the economies from GDP by PPP and we are surprised).
In terms of industrial production (in $ PPP), Russia in 2018-2019 takes 4th place in the world (and 1st place in Europe). The GDP of most countries that occupy the top lines of world leadership has long been formed not due to the real sector, but due to price speculation. And this is very convenient, because thanks to such an assessment, it is completely unnecessary to admit that Russia in 2019 is ahead of Britain, Italy, France and the Federal Republic of Germany in terms of real production, and Canada is three times superior. It is much more pleasant to say that the GDP of the Russian Federation in current dollars (at par) is comparable to the Canadian GDP and inferior to English, formed due to the wonders of virtual statistics.
With regards to the United States and Britain, for example, they have 75% of GDP consists of manipulating company quotes on the stock exchange, plus a machine tool and a service sector. States in the GDP statistics even include the estimated rental income from buildings built earlier in 2 centuries (official facts, I emphasize), while some of these buildings, facilities and structures are not rented by anyone. The real sector accounts for only about 20% of the GDP of the States and Britain, France has about 30%, while in Russia in our GDP by PPP $ 4,2 trillion, the real sector accounts for about 90%. Look at your leisure about the "powerful American industry", you see that Caterpillar, Gm and Ford are on the verge of bankruptcy, coal and shale companies have collapsed and disappeared by 70%, Boeing suffers constant losses, Westinghouse went bankrupt and shrank to a small Mox fuel company, etc. Meanwhile, Rosatom is building 68% of the planet's new nuclear power plants.

[WIKI]

Quote: Sarmat Sanych

GDP has grown 14 times according to the purchasing power, and I'm talking about 2019 and not about 2018. Now the RF GDP at PPP $ 4,2

2000 GDP of the PPP 2 trillion. $, 2019 $ 4,2 trillion. It turns out only 2 times. The main thing is not how much oil and gas revenues are from GDP, but how our life depends on them. At the moment, they make up 43% of budget revenues. The question is, what is the rest of the economy doing, bringing 57% to the budget? GDP (PPP) per capita. It is believed that this indicator shows the real strength of the economy. Russia is in 49th place.

The real sector accounts for only about 20% of US GDP

[Sarmat Sanych]

WIKI, in 2000m GDP of the Russian Federation by PPP was $ 2 trillion?)))) At degrees on January 1, they wrote at the table? In 2000, our GDP at parity was less than $ 400 billion, while the gigantic public debt was higher than the nominal GDP and zero in gold reserves, we had nothing and we had more than the entire country was searching for in a year, and now Russia has the 5th largest PPP GDP on the planet , one of the world's largest gold reserves and gold reserves, as well as almost zero public debt.
Then you have according to the principle "I heard a ringing I do not know where it is." Oil and gas revenues - do you know what this term includes? Do you know at least that Russia is in the 3rd place in the world for the production of petroleum products, in the 2nd place in the world for gas chemistry, in the 1st place in the world for the production of helium and most other inert gases (an extremely high-tech industry, by the way)? So all this is also included in the concept of "Oil and Gas Revenues", these are thousands of small and large factories throughout the country, these are millions of jobs. By the way, in terms of GDP PPP per capita, in 2019, we are not in 49th but in 46th place, while in 99th, if I am not mistaken, we were not even included in the first hundred.
And about the last picture, learn the materiel, in our category "services" includes transport (any from railway to air), the generation and sale of electricity and much more, but the United States has it all in industry, while services are crammed with various garbage from services brokers, financiers, lawyers and other speculators to medical services and real estate services.

[WIKI]

Quote: Sarmat Sanych

In 2000, our parity GDP was less than $ 400 billion.

https://ru.wikipedia.org/wiki/Список_стран_по_ВВП_(ППС)

[Loess]

Quote: Stas157

Yes, if you count in rubles. And, if in dollars, then immediately bullshit comes out.

Do you count the number of abortions, orphanages, the reduction in infant mortality in dollars?

[Stas157]

Quote: Less

Do you count the number of abortions, orphanages, the reduction in infant mortality in dollars?

Don't worry you so! The propagandists will count everything correctly and serve beautifully. Moreover, in any denomination. If our officials have reached the heights in anything, it is in the presentation of the "correct" statistics.

[Loess]

Quote: Stas157

If our officials have reached the heights in anything, it is in the presentation of the "correct" statistics.

Well, up to some local commentators, officials still have to grow and grow.

[Sarmat Sanych]

A bot who does not live in Russia can be shown white and he will see black, you can show the streets of the 90s with millions of homeless and homeless children and the current streets with new interchanges and millions of off-roaders without a single neglected child - but the bot will still say "Niver!". This is the bot’s job).

[AU Ivanov.]

Do you see street kids on the street? I personally do not. And drinkers are much less than 20 years ago. No propaganda - with my own eyes.

[yang174]

Loess
population decline how to count? in abortions or babies?
and if we subtract the annual growth of citizens with citizenship granted .... but this year this did not help either. minus 200 thousand people

[Loess]

Quote: yang174

population decline how to count? in abortions or babies?

You can, for example, think so. In 1999, the population decline was about one million people. Abortions, written above, are 6 times more. Infant mortality is halved.

Quote: yang174

and if you subtract the annual growth of citizens with issued citizenship

And this is an indicator that conditions are better in Russia than where these citizens come from. By the way, do you have statistics on applying for citizenship for the second half of the 90s?

[yang174]

I understand that with Samali and where else the thread can be invited. We have better conditions ...
you just want to live by indicators, and that’s why everything happens badly for us, because of the race for indicators. The stupid people in the leadership at all levels try to feed everyone with indicators, but the situation doesn’t change much. I got 99-10k rubles at 12m working as a loader + all sorts of buns. I had to plow the truth. and the cabbage soup is minimal, and they work for it at the same level.
Putin has successes, no doubt. in the foreign office, I am in favor of domestic politics, especially economic

[Loess]

Quote: yang174

I'm in 99m working as a loader received 10-12k rubles + all sorts of buns

And I'm in the defense industry for 800 rubles. Design engineer. No buns. And the housing is rented. And you say "Somalia" ... But you were also offered as a loader. For 2500. What are you loading in 99 for that kind of money?

[yang174]

fruits and vegetables. 12-16 hours a day, without days off, holidays and sick leave. this is not an engineer to keep your posture

[Sarmat Sanych]

yang174, do not repeat the whining from the Internet and start thinking. The population of Russia is 146,8 million people, almost the same as in 91, increased by 99 million people from 4m. With regard to the "decline", we have already analyzed this topic hundreds of times, it has been decreasing in our country only for the last 3 years, before that there was an annual growth for 15 years in a row, the case is EXCLUSIVELY with the demographic pit of the 90s, while the fertility rate per woman in Russia is 1,6 child, higher than the European average. But what in Europe does not scream from every iron that they "die out".

[yang174]

subtract the annual number of citizenship .... God's dew

[Sarmat Sanych]

I was on vacation and a long business trip, so I do not immediately respond to your release. About 200 thousand applicants are granted citizenship per year, and that’s the last 5 years (thanks to Ukraine and Belarus), before, there were no more than 100-150 thousand annually. Plus, do not forget that they also emigrate from Russia, although much less. In the 90s, emigration was monstrous, and from the beginning of the 2016s to 90 its population grew and leveled the emigration of the 83s. By the way, according to the latest census in Russia, 5% of Russians and XNUMX million Russians in Donetsk will increase this percentage even more.

[yang174]

https://countrymeters.info/ru/Russian_Federation
I am more aware, because I follow periodically. and on the street everything is completely Slavic faces .. aha
How do you differ from stubborn in Ukraine?

[Sarmat Sanych]

Why is your link to the left unofficial site?) Moreover, with incorrect data, as of December 31, 2019, there are 146,65 million people in Russia, and this is without, according to the Ministry of Internal Affairs of the Russian Federation, 80 thousand Russian LDNR who received passports in November and December. And in January-February, the issuance of passports of the Russian Federation accelerated significantly, it was announced that during this GTD all 4 million Russians of the LDNR would become Russians. With regards to "I am on the streets", firstly, the streets are not only in Moscow and St. Petersburg, and secondly, if you ride in a subway car and see three Chinese at different ends of this car for 70 people, then it will seem to you that half of the Chinese are in the subway , our consciousness is so arranged that it exaggerates the number of strangers, although the Chinese in that carriage were less than 4%. When acquaintances traveled around Paris, they said "there is a third of blacks, a third of Arabs, the rest is not clear who and 10% of whites", although according to the French Ministry of Internal Affairs (and there, as it were, they do not suffer from nonsense), the black and Arab population in total is less than 15% of Paris. the rest is white French. I also trust the annual statistics of our Ministry of Internal Affairs on those who received passports of the Russian Federation more of your "feelings of a troll on the street."

[yang174]

I ride a minibus, well, there is no metro ... and more than 50% of them were driven by migrants from the "former" Asian republics, and at a construction site the same thing, and in many other areas .. tell me, when did they start issuing passports in Donbass? 2000s by chance? Why are you writing a blizzard? You don’t like the site? Well, go to the Rosstat’s office site. What’s the problem? Empty-headed Buratino ...

[Sarmat Sanych]

Again imitate the presence of intelligence?) The official data of Rosstat are just higher for you and are given, streamline. By the way, according to the latest census in Russia, 83% of Russians. And how many minibuses are there throughout the country? Well, let 20 thousand, even a third of them non-Russians, so these 7 thousand - a drop in the ocean. And since 2008 I have been working in the construction industry, I personally know the head of many construction companies from Kamchatka to Kaliningrad, you can choose any region - I’ll name the leaders of the transport, energy and housing sectors, name the directors, founders of these companies, I’ll write even the first few numbers of them cell phones. Do not believe? Write your region of residence, I will surprise with the companies of your city. You don’t understand who you are talking to, I know the construction market of the workforce and who they are recruiting for work, so among the welders, BIM technologists, installers of normal classes and many other construction specialties - there are practically NO emigrants at all. Moldovans, Kyrgyz, Ukrainians, Uzbeks and Belarusians are recruited only for laying bricks, working with concrete mixers, shovels and other plasters. So in modern construction this is required less and less, technology replaces and cheaper. Regarding passports, you are provided with official data from the Ministry of Internal Affairs on the granting of citizenship to who and where from last year. Here I am touched by such subjects who make global conclusions about the whole country from their small-town perception)). Massly passports to Donbass Russian Ukraine began to issue in the summer of 2014. At the same time, from the 91st, millions of Russians from Ukraine, Belarus (I am one of them), Kazakhstan, Moldova, the Baltic states and Central Asia also moved to Russia. But if we disaggregate by year, then until 2014 Russia issued no more than 100 thousand passports per year to new arrivals, and they were from all over the CIS, then not only the situation changed, but also the FMS leadership, from 2014 they began to issue 200-250 thousand per year , more than 80% accounted for Donbass and Ukraine. And last year, thanks to a well-known decree of Putin, they issued half a million passports, almost 90% - residents of LDNR. The Central Asians simply were not needed, and therefore they are squealing now in the relevant forums that they have slowed down. By the way, over the past 6 years, they began to go less to Russia to work, the Ministry of Internal Affairs and the Ministry of Labor reduced the quota by almost 30%.

[yang174]

and I’ve been in the field since 2005 ... and I’ve been hustling around in offices, I am signing CSK. and pour the monolith, and they cook and install it. And they finish 60 percent of all of them. And until 2014, who was given citizenship? Why are you Donbass poking all the holes? go to the markets, take the minibuses, look at the objects who are generally engaged in. he knows the directors ...
at least how much you write me your garbage, based on fake reports and your speculations, you can’t turn off my eyes. And some demographic buns will not help the government in the form of benefits until there is decent wages, and it will not work until the casters work for us. Well, and you are further fantasies, what ...

[Sarmat Sanych]

You are boring, your thought goes in a circle, phrases are slogans of a learned agitprop, a set of cliches, your next outburst can be predicted. What "goodies", dozens of countries around the world prove that material well-being does not in any way affect the birth rate, which is proved by the countries of Europe, where the EU average fertility per one fertile woman is LOWER than in Russia. Even in the States, where whites live on average 2,5 times higher than non-colored ones - but their birth rate is much lower, so White Anglo-Saxons (WASP) now only 25% in the United States, although back in the 1950s it was more than 50%. And we have Russians, according to the last census, 83%, Russians enter their nationality at their own will, do you want to refute them? I am already silent that with all our difficulties we have never been better than now, I have been in the White World for four decades and can compare. Yes, and 600000 mother capital is clearly not a "bun" but real help, in no other country on the planet there has never been such a thing. I repeat - don’t go where you don’t understand, look at the statistics of the Ministry of Internal Affairs at least for a number of people killed in the same accidents of minibuses, there, according to individual accidents, lists of the dead are formed, for some reason 95% are Slavic names. Tragic examples of course, but you can't prove it to whiners otherwise. Take any catastrophe, the same Airbus with the Russians over Sinai or Boeing over Kazan, the lists are available - 95% Slavic surnames, even Tatar minimum. Non-Russians don't fly on airplanes and don't use minibuses as passengers? It's like in a fairy tale about the forest where they accidentally noticed a black hare and people began to say that black hares, along with white ones, began to be found. And yes, until 2014, no more than 100-150 thousand people were accepted into Russian citizenship per year, even if we imagine that half of them are non-Russians, it will still be a penny for this period. I have no non-Slavs at the entrance of a 14-story building, a Kyrgyz lived with his wife before - since 2018 I have not seen him. In 2020 there will be a new census, with numerous UN observers, by the way, you can see the results.

[Siberia 75]

Quote: Sarmat Sanych

Are you kidding? over 20 years, Russia's GDP has grown 14 times

It is very pleasant among zradnikov and all-mutters to see an adequate, documented commentary. I have something to add, but I can’t convince people with pots on their heads, and smart people themselves understand everything

[Sarmat Sanych]

Siberia 75, do not pay attention to them, 80% of these zradniks are ordinary bots, often not even bulkers or pseudo-lovers, but ordinary pots from behind a mound.

To understand the plans of the West, suffice it to say that in 2015, the 77th brigade of the Kingdom's Armed Forces, numbering 1,5 thousand people, began work in Britain. The structure consists of a number of military personnel "with experience in journalism", knowledge of "Slavic languages" and, as it was written in the press release, "who understand the methods of working in social networks." In the same period, the American Embassy in Lithuania launched a program to train Russian-speaking citizens in "investigative journalism" to work on the Russian Internet space. The NATO Cyber ​​Center in Tallinn, the Hybrid War Center in Riga and other lesser-known structures are engaged in similar manipulations. About $ 6 billion is allocated annually for these operations through various channels. Large-scale work from tens of thousands of accounts is carried out in Russian on media sites, in comments to blogs, under videos of well-known hosting, and so on. These workers themselves pose as Russians. Their maxims traditionally support any anti-Russian position and zealously denigrate the pro-Russian positive.
Plus, don't forget about such a thing as IPSO. This is a structure in the Ukrainian Armed Forces, its task is to work in social networks with the aim of destabilizing society, it is supervised from the States. Let's pay attention - as soon as the question of retirement age surfaced, how quickly did the pseudo-red aki multiply? This ISSO, their work, does not even burn. It is enough to type in the search engine "TsIPso Brovary Ukraine" and find out a lot of new (old) about "the daughters of an officer from the Crimea"

[Mordvin 3]

Quote: Siberia 75

adequate, documented comment.

It is generally not confirmed by anything. Take at least GDP. Where does this figure come from - 14 times?

[Mordvin 3]

Quote: Siberia 75

It is very pleasant among zradnikov and all-mutters to see an adequate, documented commentary.

Hold on, Siberia. I seem to have guessed.

But what a crap ...

Eat noodles from Sanych further.

[Vadim237]

And what did you bring these two graphs to?

[Mordvin 3]

Quote: Vadim237

And what did you bring these two graphs to?

Moreover, the dollar has fallen in price by 20 times in relation to gold over 4 years (according to the second chart). And roughly the same has increased Russia's GDP (in the first). Can’t you see?

[Sarmat Sanych]

Mordvin 3, why are you bothering to climb where nicherta does not fumble? What nafig "gold", it looks like it's time to disperse your whiners' chicken coop. Read carefully, in case of misunderstanding - by syllables. GDP grew by 14 times by parity of purchasing power. Now the GDP of the Russian Federation at PPP is $ 4,2 trillion, the 5th in the world (together with Germany), higher than that of Britain, Italy and France. Let it be known to you that, according to PPP, per capita output in Russia and, for example, in the United States is the same (we go to the Cia Factbook website, subtract the share of services in each of the economies from GDP by PPP and we are surprised).
In terms of industrial production (in $ PPP), Russia in 2018-2019 takes 4th place in the world (and 1st place in Europe). The GDP of most countries that occupy the top lines of world leadership has long been formed not due to the real sector, but due to price speculation. And this is very convenient, because thanks to such an assessment, it is completely unnecessary to admit that Russia in 2019 is ahead of Britain, Italy, France and the Federal Republic of Germany in terms of real production, and Canada is three times superior. It is much more pleasant to say that the GDP of the Russian Federation in current dollars (at par) is comparable to the Canadian GDP and inferior to English, formed due to the wonders of virtual statistics.
With regards to the United States and Britain, for example, 75% of their GDP consists of manipulating company quotes on the stock exchange plus a machine tool and a service sector. States in the GDP statistics even include the estimated rental income from buildings built earlier in 2 centuries (official facts, I emphasize), while some of these buildings, facilities and structures are not rented by anyone. The real sector accounts for only about 20% of the GDP of the States and Britain, France has about 30%, while in Russia in our GDP by PPP 4,2 trillion $ the real sector accounts for about 90%. Take a look at the "powerful American industry", you see that Caterpillar, Gm and Ford are on the brink of bankruptcy, coal and shale companies collapsed and disappeared by 70%, Boeing suffers constant losses, Westinghouse went bankrupt and shrank to a small company producing Mox-fuel, etc. Meanwhile, Rosatom is building 68% of the planet's new nuclear power plants.
PS Gold reserves of the Russian Federation are now 2300 tons, one of the largest on Earth, while in 91m there were only 340 tons for the entire Union, even under Brezhnev there were less than 1 thousand... And this is one Russia, not "15 fraternal republics" with 2 times more resources and population.

[Mordvin 3]

You got your parity. That in 2000 I paid a third of the salary for housing and communal services, which is now the same. And you can climb under the wheel of your favorite jeep, on cell phones in general parity has grown hundreds of times.

[Sarmat Sanych]

Mordvin 3, I apologize for the vacation and the long business trip, I do not immediately respond to your release. Although it makes no sense to react, we all EXCELLENTLY remember what happened 20 years ago. 98 year - 2 million hungry children of street drug addicts throughout the country (now zero), defaulted in the treasury $ 8 billion (now $ 700 billion), 4 million abortions per year (now less than 0,5 million), miners with helmets and helmets at the Kremlin protesters in stalls plant onions like on a maidan in Kuev, there are no army and navy, 99% of families eat only macaroni with tomato paste a month, debts on sn and pensions for regions up to TWO YEARS, murder rate EIGHT TIME higher than now, Kinder surprise Premier and RFP train driver $ 9. And now Russia annually builds 90 million sq. M of new housing, it is more than the whole Union with its 290 mln. and several years earlier), every year Russians buy 15 million only new cars (the third in Europe car sales), annually 74 million Russians rest abroad plus 2019-1,8 million in Crimea and 3 million in Sochi, the Russian market for Apple - The fourth in the world in terms of sales, 35 trillion rubles are stored in the accounts and deposits of individuals in Russian banks. And finally, general economic indicators, in 6 the length of all the federal routes of the RSFSR was 7 thousand km, now it is more than 13 thousand km, at 4 m (at the peak of the Soviet GDP) all ports of the Union transshipped 30 million tons of products per year, now the ports of Russia alone tranship to year ONE BILLION TONS. You can double-check all of the above data in the sources of the International Energy Agency, the European Business Association, the UN, the IMF, the Russian Builders Association, and the International Union of Tour Operators.

[The popuas]

Over 11 times increased .. ??? Who? And how much inflation has eaten from these ... 11 times! In dollars, so she slipped 2 times ... I'm talking about ordinary hard workers! Now about the prices, about the prices write how much they have grown ...?

[Sarmat Sanych]

By the way, you have a nickname, you can not even make excuses. Cut on your nose - average sn increased 11 times according to the purchasing power parity. And do not mirror the 90s with their inflation of 100-300%, even in the zero ones it was from 20 to 50%, and for the last 6 years we have a record low 28% for 3 years, for a number of goods (in particular poultry, Internet, pork, sugar ) prices are reduced even a couple of years in a row due to overproduction.

[Professor]

Quote: Sarmat Sanych

Modest economic success of Russia

Are you kidding? over 20 years, the GDP of the Russian Federation has grown 14 times, the data is confirmed by the IMF, the gold and foreign exchange reserves increased from $ 9 billion to $ 540 billion, gold reserves from zero to 2300 tons, the average salary compared to 99m increased 11 times, the number of private cars in the Russian population increased by 6 times, the annual consumption of meat, fish and fruit per capita in comparison with 2000 (I did not find information on the 99th) increased almost 2,5 times, the number of abortions per year decreased from 3 million (98 years) to 0,55 million (data from the World Health Organization), 2 million homeless children have disappeared from the streets, the volume of annual road construction has grown almost 18 (!) times, the volume of housing built annually has increased many times to 75-80 million square meters (the peak indicators of the RSFSR have long been exceeded), the annual collection grain broke all past records (120-135 million tons, it is better not to remember the numbers 91-99), the production volumes of poultry and pork soared many times and exceeded the indicators of the peak 2 years of the RSFSR (I am not talking about 3 at all), number of orphans in children's homes max decreased more than 90 times from almost 99 thousand to 10 thousand, infant mortality decreased almost 600 times to 50 per 3 births (one of the best indicators in the world, for comparison in the States 4,5 per 1000 births), etc. ... This list is long, it can be enumerated for a long time, from a manifold increase in defense capacity and the creation of the world's most powerful weapons to a manifold decrease in the number of murders and terrorist attacks on the streets, and from the headlines in the 5,5th newspapers "Russia asks America for some more food" to the current news that Russia is ousting America Russian companies supply poultry meat to the States from the Chinese chicken market pubs: https: //youtu.be/aQ1000MCG99MFXY

Now compare what China has achieved in 20 years. Just do not shoot right away.

[Nasrat]

Still, Russia would have so much money and technology from the west, as China ... then it would be possible to compare ...

[Professor]

Quote: Nasr

Still, Russia would have so much money and technology from the west, as China ... then it would be possible to compare ...

And who is the doctor for you? Make friends with the West and you will have everything. Joke. You already have everything. And money is not measured and people are more literate than the Chinese. And we transferred our factory to China, and not to Russia, not at all because of Russophobia, but for the sake of pragmatism. Our factory in China is not a nightmare and no one will wring out, and even the rules of the game will not change.

[Nasrat]

The French and Germans work in Russia, they don’t squeeze anyone out - but they squeezed you out ... It’s you from Ukraine, let’s run away (for the umpteenth time in your life from Ukraine?) Good luck, friend, in China!

[Mordvin 3]

Quote: Nasr

French and Germans work in Russia, they don’t push anyone

Spiridonych, and who do you work for, for the Germans, or the French?

[Nasrat]

I work for myself, unlike you ...

[Professor]

You contradict yourself:

Quote: Nasr

French and Germans work in Russia

Quote: Nasr

Still, Russia would have so much money and technology from the West, as China.

[Nasrat]

And where is the contradiction? I repeat once again - if so much money and technology were swelled to Russia, as to China - then they would be compared ...
But you modestly kept silent that your production was transferred from Ukraine to China ... and not from Russia ... Have you been to Kiev for a long time ??? Hehe ... pulls ... pulls not only Kiev ... pulls you Scoop (you yourself ran away from Ukraine in the 90s? And where to go to Oleg Sokolov? - Clear business - he is a Jew - means to Israel !!! ) .... if you hang around on this resource, and besides, discuss similar topics (with Ukrainian explanations ...) - one explanation - pulls, pulls you this ...

[Professor]

Quote: Nasr

And where is the contradiction? I repeat once again - if so much money and technology were swelled to Russia, as to China - then they would be compared ...
But you modestly kept silent that your production was transferred from Ukraine to China ... and not from Russia ... Have you been to Kiev for a long time ??? Hehe ... pulls ... pulls not only Kiev ... pulls you Scoop (you yourself ran away from Ukraine in the 90s? And where to go to Oleg Sokolov? - Clear business - he is a Jew - means to Israel !!! ) .... if you hang around on this resource, and besides, discuss similar topics (with Ukrainian explanations ...) - one explanation - pulls, pulls you this ...

Production was transferred from Israel to China, and not to the Russian Federation. I have not been in Kiev for 100 years. What did I forget there?
You have a lot of money, but the result ...

[Vadim237]

To compare Russia and China is idiocy, since the market economy with Western money appeared there in the early 70s, and the rapid growth of their economy is primarily associated with cheap large labor force and very cheap energy carrier-coal, everything else worked out and got better unlike Russia, there was no fifteen-year economic collapse with a jump from a planned system to a market system.

[Professor]

Quote: Vadim237

To compare Russia and China is idiocy, since the market economy with Western money appeared there in the early 70s, and the rapid growth of their economy is primarily associated with cheap large labor force and very cheap energy carrier-coal, everything else worked out and got better unlike Russia, there was no fifteen-year economic collapse with a jump from a planned system to a market system.

You always have someone to blame for your failures. Who prevented you from making a breakthrough in the last 20? People were prepared, the dough was unmeasured. Why was there no jerk? Why did you lose a whole generation?

[Sarmat Sanych]

You always have someone to blame for your failures

Is this from whom we hear? From the chosen ones, who have been whining for millennia that they are being driven from everywhere, offend, and already the last century, from each iron, ears are pricked. You would generally keep quiet, whining advisers were found.

[Professor]

Quote: Sarmat Sanych

You always have someone to blame for your failures

Is this from whom we hear? From the chosen ones, who have been whining for millennia that they are being driven from everywhere, offend, and already the last century, from each iron, ears are pricked. You would generally keep quiet, whining advisers were found.

Did this influx of emotions happen after you, following my advice, compared the achievements of China and your own?

[Sarmat Sanych]

I knew that you would light up. No, I compared the achievements of China and the worthless achievements of your favorite piece of land

[Professor]

Quote: Sarmat Sanych

I knew that you would light up. No, I compared the achievements of China and the worthless achievements of your favorite piece of land

It’s really better not to compare with us, but why don’t you compare with China or the United States?

[Sarmat Sanych]

Professor, it’s even ridiculous to compare any Uzbekistan with your Zionist under-state, the Union gave you land on a silver platter, and then for decades there were so many hundreds of billions of dollars in your scrap and Mattress and Zionists from all over the world have invested, so many fugitive, picky hucksters brought dough to you - that already per capita GDP should be above Luxembourg to be. But in the end, it’s not horse feed, and even set up all the enemies around you and live forever with sirens.
And what does Matrasia have to do with its printing presses for tens of trillions of dollars in Nasharu, unlike them we live on our own, while building 68% of the planet's new nuclear power plants and keeping 50% of the world's uranium enrichment (25% of Matrasia's generation depends on us), and Westinghouse in the meantime, he successfully cocked). Well, comparing with China with its 1,5 billion population is generally the top of "intelligence".

[Professor]

Quote: Sarmat Sanych

Professor, it’s even ridiculous to compare any Uzbekistan with your Zionist under-state, the Union gave you land on a silver platter, and then for decades there were so many hundreds of billions of dollars in your scrap and Mattress and Zionists from all over the world have invested, so many fugitive, picky hucksters brought dough to you - that already per capita GDP should be above Luxembourg to be. But in the end, it’s not horse feed, and even set up all the enemies around you and live forever with sirens.
And what does Matrasia have to do with its printing presses for tens of trillions of dollars in Nasharu, unlike them we live on our own, while building 68% of the planet's new nuclear power plants and keeping 50% of the world's uranium enrichment (25% of Matrasia's generation depends on us), and Westinghouse in the meantime, he successfully cocked). Well, comparing with China with its 1,5 billion population is generally the top of "intelligence".

Nuclear power plant say? And why with a bare back then? Why are you miserable and collect money for the treatment of children in Israel?

[Sarmat Sanych]

L- Logic You there that with bare asses like baboons chtol in the zoo running? Stop mirroring your complexes. Such "poverty" in Russia, that it is impossible with a family on Friday and weekends to drive up to thousands of shopping centers across the country - everything is occupied by millions of SUVs. What a nafig "the whole world" if they bring you 0,001% of the sick, so only for certain medical indications. Show by the way how in the same States or Europe they collect sms for treatment? Or can you remind us that we have insurance medicine for any Russian citizen free of charge, including operations? And now compare with the situation around the rest of the world.
By the way, the standard of living in Russia is the same as in Western countries. In detail and with numbers:
https://youtu.be/SpymAiJCZjw

[Professor]

Quote: Sarmat Sanych

... Such "poverty" in Russia, that it is impossible with a family on Friday and weekends to drive up to thousands of shopping centers across the country - everything is occupied by millions of SUVs.

Rosstat: more than 18 million Russians live below the poverty line

Quote: Sarmat Sanych

What a nafig "the whole world" if they bring you 0,001% of the sick, so only for certain medical indications. Show by the way how in the same States or Europe they collect sms for treatment? Or can you remind us that we have insurance medicine for any Russian citizen free of charge, including operations? And now compare with the situation around the rest of the world.

So why are all social networks full of fundraising announcements for treating children abroad?

Quote: Sarmat Sanych

By the way, the standard of living in Russia is the same as in Western countries.

Did Prigozhin give you such an installation?

[Sarmat Sanych]

Bgggg... "18 million" The poverty line in the Russian Federation is an income of less than 21 thousand rubles (this is at our minimum prices for everything). And name at least one really large state where there are no millions of poor? In the same Matrasia, according to the UN, there are 46 million beggars and homeless people, despite printing trillions of dollars. What social networks, believe everything that is written on the Internet?)) In social networks, they will tell you that rear-wheel drive marriages are the norm and women with beards are in the order of things, but how will this affect reality? Prigogine, why not Valeria and Leontiev, we love to listen to music? Where do you climb with your meanders? A set of stamps, a thought goes in a circle, your next surge can be predicted.

[Professor]

Quote: Sarmat Sanych

BGGG. "18 million" The poverty line in the Russian Federation is an income of less than 21 thousand rubles (this is at our minimum prices for everything).

Do you learn to lie so rudely there at the troll factory?

The subsistence minimum for the first quarter of 2019 for the entire population of Russia is set at 10 rubles (average). For the able-bodied population, this value in the first quarter of 444 is 2019 rubles, for pensioners - 11 rubles ($138), and for children - 10390 rubles.
https://www.26-2.ru/art/354854-projitochnyy-minimum

The number of Russians living below the poverty line has reached 21 million
https://www.znak.com/2019-07-30/chislo_rossiyan_zhivuchih_za_chertoy_bednosti_dostiglo_21_milliona

A quarter of children in Russia were below the poverty line:
https://www.rbc.ru/economics/07/08/2019/5d4985b39a79472d5365f1fd

say marashki?

Quote: Sarmat Sanych

And name at least one really large state where there are no millions of poor?

Millions of poor people are not in the countries of Europe, Japan, Israel, Taiwan, Australia and other developed countries.

Quote: Sarmat Sanych

In the same Matrasia, according to the UN, 46 million poor and homeless, despite the printing of trillions of $.

You do not compare ... with a finger. Your middle class dreams of living as poor in the USA.

https://www.brookings.edu/research/who-is-poor-in-the-united-states-a-hamilton-project-annual-report/
There, families with incomes less than $ 12,140 or 18 rubles per month per person are considered poor. Then you are surprised that American unemployed have their own cars.

Quote: Sarmat Sanych

Prigogine, why not Valery and Leontyev, do we like listening to music?

He is your boss. True, he is mean. He spares money on educated trolls.

Quote: Sarmat Sanych

Where do you climb with your meanders? A set of stamps, a thought goes in a circle, your next surge can be predicted.

Where am I to you with such pearls: "By the way, the standard of living in Russia is the same as in Western countries"?

[yang174]

Glazyev here publicly told the story: a peasant opened a factory, took a loan on bail from Sberbank. The conditions of the loan were changed, the peasant sat down I don’t remember how much. And this is just what comes up. And how many we don’t know?

[Vadim237]

Glazyev tells good tales.

[yang174]

Well then you can boast of your education, unlike Glazyev ...
Listen to Siluanov with Medvedev and Oreshkin, they speak the truth

[Sarmat Sanych]

yang174, do not read newspapers and infantile Glazyev at breakfasttrust the facts. And the facts are such that now in the Russian Federation industrialization is like under Stalin (but without the GULAGs and millions of slave labor):
https://youtu.be/amWcDufOHHM
Gigantic factories are being built:
https://youtu.be/tQFMzwX-9Z8
They make world-class machines:
https://youtu.be/zyAEut2aYbQ
Here is another for understanding:
https://youtu.be/qXTzVzjUXO0

[yang174]

MDA. Open customs reports that are imported to us, and see the manufacturers yourself in the shops. Here is the make-up, and where is your brother?

[yang174]

in the eye. I’m usually with you right now, no way ...

[yang174]

Even the minuses were instructed ... strange. The first time I agreed with the professor and on you ... who understood what was written? What for "in the eye"?
and where is he wrong ?:
"And who is your doctor? Make friends with the West and you will have everything. It's a joke. You already have everything. And the money is not measured and people are more literate than the Chinese. And we transferred our plant to China, and not to Russia at all because of Russophobia, but pragmatism for the sake of. Our factory in China will not be a nightmare and no one will squeeze it out and even change the rules of the game. "

[Sarmat Sanych]

yang174, you are a bot program or write under the degree? It’s really impossible to read your stream of consciousness, my nephew of the younger class writes more clearly.

[yang174]

not in the eyebrow but in the eye .... well, it happens that you don’t have time for the thoughts of others. in blinkers and on stereotypes. I’m at least a bot, how can I classify you? Eat twice in it

[Sobol]

Quote: professor

... And we transferred our factory to China ..

Correctly! It is better for the Chinese to give jobs than to their citizens.

[Professor]

Quote: SoboL

Quote: professor

... And we transferred our factory to China ..

Correctly! It is better for the Chinese to give jobs than to their citizens.

1. The salary in China was $ 80, we have $ 800. Now the salary in China is $ 1000, we have $ 1200. No longer translating, and then it was the only way to survive. The salary of an engineer in China today is greater than in Israel, and the quality is lower than in Israel. This is where to compete.
2. Production was harmful and it is good that we no longer have it.

[Sarmat Sanych]

SoboL, the Chinese are absolutely not needed, there are enough of them. By the way, in Russia only 150 thousands of Chinese are working, this is 4 times less than Belarusians work here. That’s who occupied it - it’s the ugrogaster, there are more than 4 million of them in Russia.

[Basil50]

professor
Do not give an example of China. Only the Americans and the English-French can overtake the Chinese in a lie.
There, even with the number of people, they cheat quite officially, and they don’t know about the economy so much about retention as about their own history.
At the same time, the Chinese are fully aware that they are lying and they know that in the world they know about their lies.

[Professor]

Quote: Vasily50

professor
Do not give an example of China. Only the Americans and the English-French can overtake the Chinese in a lie.
There, even with the number of people, they cheat quite officially, and they don’t know about the economy so much about retention as about their own history.
At the same time, the Chinese are fully aware that they are lying and they know that in the world they know about their lies.

In a lie, the Kremlin is ahead of the rest. Together.

I have been working with China for 11 years. I can see what they have achieved. I see what apartments my colleagues live in what cars they drive. I know their current salary. Our hard worker earned $ 80 a month. Now> $ 1000. Mechanical engineer with 3 years of experience ~ $ 3. Why not official statistics?

[Basil50]

80% of Chinese people live somewhat differently than the statistics describe them. I had the opportunity to see for myself. But how they live in central and western China are generally kept secret, to the extent that entire regions are closed not only from foreigners, but also from fellow citizens. DID NOT KNOW?

[AU Ivanov.]

China began to achieve this back in the early 80s, with the beginning of Deng Xiaoping's reforms. And there was no disaster with subsequent Yeltsin in China. So, not for 20, but for 40 years.

[Sarmat Sanych]

Professor, well, compare someone else with China). And yes, China did not have a gigantic population outflow in the 90s, nor actually the 2nd Civil War in the 90s, nor check privatization, while the West invested more than $ 5 trillion in investments from China from the beginning of the 80s to 2019. Draw conclusions.

[Professor]

Quote: Sarmat Sanych

Professor, well, compare someone else with China). And yes, China did not have a gigantic population outflow in the 90s, nor actually the 2nd Civil War in the 90s, nor check privatization, while the West invested more than $ 5 trillion in investments from China from the beginning of the 80s to 2019. Draw conclusions.

Compare. USA.

I still don’t understand what prevented you from developing over the past 20 years? Stable power led by an irremovable leader, trillions of petrodollars, skilled personnel and further on the list. And at the exit ...

[Sarmat Sanych]

Are you pulling an owl on the globe again?) Despite the total opposition of the West over the past 20 years, we have been developing rapidly and now our GDP at PPP of $ 4,2 trillion, the 5th in the world, is higher than that of Britain, Italy and France, the most powerful strategic nuclear forces on the planet, hypersonic weapons, gold reserves of $ 540 billion, almost zero public debt, a huge surplus in foreign trade and gold reserves of 2300 tons. Suffer)

[Professor]

Quote: Sarmat Sanych

Are you pulling an owl on the globe again?) Despite the total opposition of the West over the past 20 years, we have been developing rapidly and now our GDP at PPP of $ 4,2 trillion, the 5th in the world, is higher than that of Britain, Italy and France, the most powerful strategic nuclear forces on the planet, hypersonic weapons, gold reserves of $ 540 billion, almost zero public debt, a huge surplus in foreign trade and gold reserves of 2300 tons. Suffer)

What am I to suffer from? I am happy for you and would be even more glad if your achievements were real and your people would live better.
1. GDP- $ 4,016,000,000,000, 6th place in the world. GDP per capita is $ 27,900, 74th in the world.
2. The most powerful strategic nuclear forces on the planet, you cannot smear hypersonic weapons on bread.
3. Gold reserves $ 540 billion, almost zero public debt, a huge surplus in foreign trade and gold reserves of 2300 tons do not make the life of an ordinary citizen better.

Indicators directly related to the lives of ordinary Russians:
1. Infant and maternal mortality.
2. Life expectancy.
3. Revenue growth.
4. Housing affordability
5. Level of medical care
etc.

That's what you had to spread, and not the number of tons of steel smelted per capita.

[Sarmat Sanych]

Professor, again imitate the presence of intelligence, it is not interesting with you. And even juggling with numbers, the RF GDP by PPP for 2019 is $ 4,2 trillion, the 5th in the world, the GDP by PPP per capita for 2019 is the 46th in the world, this is all the data of the International Aviation Administration and World Bank. The most powerful strategic nuclear forces and hypersound in the world allow us to protect our homeland, and you too are torn, if necessary, run under the wing again. Russia, after all, the Generous Soul not only protected you from extermination during the Second World War, few say that Europeans have expelled Jews since the Middle Ages, as a result, by the beginning of the 80th century, XNUMX% of your population were sheltered in the Republic of Ingushetia. Therefore, blather less and remember who turned off the stove in Auschwitz and hundreds of other concentration camps.
With regard to infant mortality, it is one of the lowest in the world, 4,5 per 1000 births, the average life expectancy is 74 years - the maximum in the entire history of our state, our housing is an order of magnitude more affordable than in most Western countries, in Russia 89 % of citizens own their homes and for example in Europe and the States, only 1%, according to the same IMF. And yes, unlike America itself, we do not have millions of homeless people living in tents on the streets of all major cities, you won't even find one tent with a bomb in Russia. Better rejoice for the "dad" from across the ocean with his tens of trillions machine tool:

This is San Francisco, a city in the style of DISCO - once we sang ...
A friend of mine who moved to San Francisco noticed that Russians usually worry that in California they will be embarrassed by gays and they will not be able to tolerate them enough. But it’s really hard to be tolerant of homeless people! Yes, San Francisco is famous for its homeless people. There are thousands of people in the city center, and it’s impossible to walk a couple of blocks so as not to meet a person sleeping in dirty rags.
But homeless people in the center are still flowers. Because real tin is happening in the Tenderloin area. I was in different places of the world, but I did not see such a tin like here. People wallow in the street in their own shit, every second has a syringe in their hands, plus the people are extremely aggressive. Any San Francisco resident will tell you a story about a robbery in the area.
Tenderloin is located in the heart of San Francisco. The city hall, the conservatory, museums and libraries, the headquarters of Twitter and Uber are a stone's throw from here. And in the midst of all these centers of social life there is a total hell.
The district got its name either from a good clipping that only unclean policemen could afford before, or from the hips of the prostitutes that Tenderloin was once famous for. In 2011, zoodefenders launched a campaign trying to rename the area, but the locals, led by the mayor, just neighing and waved at them.
It used to be the center of nightlife, but after World War II, downtown San Francisco was severely depopulated. But since the 70s, refugees from Southeast Asia began to settle here - Vietnamese, Lao, Cambodians, etc. Often they were packed into small studios by several people, so that the houses with such apartments were called "vertical villages" by the police. Over time, part of the area even received the nickname "Little Saigon".
Although Tenderloin has been a historic district since 2008, it is also known as San Francisco's most dangerous and dirty district.
In the 60s and 70s, the Filipino gang Bahala Na Gang (BNG), which specialized in racketeering, drug trafficking and contract killings, operated here. Now there are smaller gangs that are mainly involved in the sale of drugs and buying stolen goods.
In Tenderloin, crimes such as theft (especially from parked cars), robbery and "aggravated assault" are common. Most crimes are drug related. Here they are sold right on the streets in broad daylight, and not legalized marijuana in California, but in general everything, mainly crack, heroin and various types of amphetamines.
All this happens in the very center of the city! Here is the San Francisco City Hall building. There is parking, tourists, and on a nearby street, hundreds of heroin addicts are spoiling for themselves ...

[Professor]

You can’t count everyone as fools? We can check the numbers.
Let's go:
1. RF GDP $ 4.016 trillion - 6th place in the world, in front of you Germany, Japan, USA, China and India. But it's like a livestock. From this, the ordinary Hindu and the Russian are neither warmer nor nourishing. It will be more interesting further.
2. The growth of GDP, the Russian Federation at 173rd place in the world.
3. GDP per capita (and this is what they go to the store with) Russia with $ 27,900 in 74th place in the world. Petrodollars do not help either.
4. You can’t cover the SNF and you can buy medicines for the children. North Korea also has an atomic bomb, but there is nothing.
5. Russia in the Second World War did not protect anyone since it was formed only in 1991.
6. By the beginning of the twentieth century, the Russian Empire occupied the territories in which the Jews lived and awarded them with pogroms and a Pale of Settlement. Russia has not sheltered anyone. Not a single Jew. The USSR refused to accept the Jews when Eichmann offered it to him. Then the Jews were sent to gas chambers. Of the millions of Jews who once lived in Russia, about 150 remain today. Given the pace of emigration, there will soon be no emigration at all. You will be judenfrey. Moreover, in 000, thousands of Russians applied for political asylum in Israel. From January to September 2019, 2019 people applied for asylum. In 3010, there were 2018 such requests. In 2772 - 2017. In 635 - 2016. In 395 - 2015. In 14 - 2013. http://newsru.co.il/israel/1oct27/refuge_2019.html
7. We remember who turned off the furnaces in Auschwitz and we remember how the USSR only for more money gave the Jews escape from Nazi Germany through the territory of the USSR to Japan. Those who had no money were sent to gas chambers.
8. With regard to infant mortality, it is NOT one of the lowest in the world, 6.7 per 1000 births, 162th place in the world, between Kuwait and Chile. In Israel, 3.4 per 1000 births. Half as much as you.
9. Maternal mortality is 17 per 100 births, 000th in the world. In Israel, 130 per 3. 100 times less. Why aren't you surprised that your wealthy ladies go to give birth abroad?
10. Life expectancy is 71.3, 155th place in the world. Israel is in 10th place in the world with 82.7. 11 years longer, Karl !!!
11. Is your housing much more affordable than in most Western countries? Whence, if you have a mortgage interest 10 (ten) times higher than in Israel? About 22,6% of Russia's population does not have access to centralized sewage. Most of these families use cesspools, according to a Rosstat study on living conditions in the country. But your strategic nuclear forces are the most powerful. https://www.rbc.ru/economics/02/04/2019/5ca1d7949a79475d1c2f6e4a.
12. In Russia, 89% of citizens own their own housing, and for example in Europe and the United States, only 1%, data from the same IMF? But their toilet is not in the yard.

Do not run up. You are funny.

[D-ug]

Quote: professor

1. GDP

Another ignoramus who has no idea what GDP is and what this indicator means.

[Liam]

Quote: professor

and for example in Europe and the States only 1%,

This is nonsense nonsense

[Sarmat Sanych]

Thank you, someone selected, pleased. I opened the comments, and then your vashenskie bucks - a good mood for the whole day is guaranteed... Put your "statistics" in one place and see the official one. GDP of the Russian Federation at PPP for 2019 is $ 4,2 trillion, 5th in the world on a par with Germany. And it’s not your militaristic piece of land donated by the Union to talk about such lofty matters, when big geopolitical players talk, little satellite mongrels sit silently under the skirt of the owner.
What the hell is the "growth of GDP in the world" if the whole West consists only of a printing press and manipulation of stock quotes on the stock exchange?)) We have it, though small, but REAL, plus for many years a stable industrial growth of 3-4%, and the same Italy, for example, industrial production has been falling for 20 years, Matrasia's real industrial production has grown by only 10% in 8 years. GDP in PPP per capita in the Russian Federation for 2019 is in 46th place, this is the official data of the IMF, suffer. I will not even comment on the strategic nuclear forces, you and your underdeveloped subsonic several missile launchers, a pair of antediluvian medium-range ballistic missiles and bombs will not understand the size and scale.
Then someone's chosen "blissful gopher syndrome" begins - a defensive reaction to what is happening... The Russian state for MORE THAN A THOUSAND HUNDRED YEARS has existed since the time of Rurik, and it was Russia and the Russian people who saved your ruinous ungrateful lying tribe in WWII and during the Republic of Ingushetia. Yes, you yourself understand that). Even Zhukov at 45m said: "We released them and they will never forgive us for this." This also applies to the Zionists, and tell your fellow tribesmen in the ward after a collective injection of haloperidol to tell the fables about the "Eichmans" and other stories about the winners. Whom did the Russian Empire "occupy", my small homeland Belarus and the homeland of my maternal ancestors Little Russia?) Drink valerianki, these are the original Russian lands, but what your circumcised tribe ran there from all over Europe is really incomprehensible. At least sometimes you yourself wondered why you were driven from Spain, Portugal, France, Czech Republic and further to the East with pissing rags from the early Middle Ages, so that only in “bad” Russia did you find a place despite all the fables about “pogroms”? And links to a blizzard like "newsru.co.il" - finally an epic zashkvar, still Pikabu here zatulit.
Further, the infant mortality rate in the Russian Federation in 2019 is 4,5 per 1000 births, and 6,7 was in the middle of zero, read the report of the Ministry of Health of the Russian Federation and see for yourself. It’s not worth mentioning about your piece of gigantic funding from overseas, with such grandmas with a chic climate, you could have done zero, but the owners of your mattresses had 6,5 deaths per thousand born, and by the way, there was also a superclimate plus there was no Civil war and total plunder of the 90s, and we also have 60% of the country in the Arctic Circle, the most severe conditions on the planet. Life expectancy at the end of 2019 is 73,8 years, in the same place from the report of the head of the Ministry of Health of the Russian Federation. The average% on mortgages in the Russian Federation is 9% at the end of 2019, according to the Central Bank, the cut is that 0,9%?) And in Russia, not all housing is mortgaged, while every year Russians buy 80 million square meters of housing, which is confirmed by the IMF ... And this fake about "22% of cesspools" has already been dismantled hundreds of times on the shelves and subjected to complete abstructions, firstly, in Russia, only 9% of the population live in villages and in villages, it does not beat in any way, only a really sick person will think to imagine toilets on the streets in Krasnodar, St. Petersburg, Kazan, Novosibirsk and other cities. Secondly, they distorted the report only on private houses and presented it as a complete picture, while forgetting what is in the dachas and dry closets, water closets and so on. Otherwise, it turns out that in the same States more than 60% of the population goes to cesspools and does not have access to the central sewage system)))).

[Professor]

Once again on the shelves. Reread and give you a link to the source skin. Only spray less saliva and sewer into the house spend, and then with your climate still freeze something.

1. GDP RF $ 4.016 trillion 6 place in the world, in front of you Germany, Japan, USA, China and India. But it's like a livestock. From this, the ordinary Hindu and the Russian are neither warmer nor nourishing. It will be more interesting further.
2. The growth of GDP, RF by 173rd place in the world.
3. GDP per capita (and this is what they go to the store with) Russia from $ 27,900 to 74th place in the world. Petrodollars do not help either.
4. You can’t cover the SNF and you can buy medicines for the children. North Korea also has an atomic bomb, but there is nothing.
5. Russia in the Second World War did not protect anyone since it was formed only in 1991.
6. By the beginning of the twentieth century, the Russian Empire occupied the territories in which the Jews lived and awarded them with pogroms and a Pale of Settlement. Russia has not sheltered anyone. Not a single Jew. The USSR refused to accept the Jews when Eichmann offered it to him. Then the Jews were sent to gas chambers. Of the millions of Jews who once lived in Russia, about 150 remain today. Given the pace of emigration, there will soon be no emigration at all. You will be judenfrey. Moreover, in 000, thousands of Russians applied for political asylum in Israel. From January to September 2019, 2019 people applied for asylum. In 3010, there were 2018 such requests. In 2772 - 2017. In 635 - 2016. In 395 - 2015. In 14 - 2013. http://newsru.co.il/israel/1oct27/refuge_2019.html
7. We remember who turned off the furnaces in Auschwitz and we remember how the USSR only for more money gave the Jews escape from Nazi Germany through the territory of the USSR to Japan. Those who had no money were sent to gas chambers.
8. With regards to infant mortality, then it’s NOT one of the lowest in the world, 6.7 per 1000 births, 162 - place in the world, between Kuwait and Chile. In Israel, 3.4 per 1000 births. Half as much as you.
9. Maternal mortality you have 17 per 100 births, 130 place in the world. In Israel, 3 per 100. 000 times less. Why aren't you surprised that your wealthy ladies go to give birth abroad?
10. Lifespan you have 71.3, 155th place in the world. Israel is in 10th place in the world with 82.7. 11 years longer, Karl !!!
11. Is your housing much more affordable than in most Western countries? Whence, if you have a mortgage interest 10 (ten) times higher than in Israel? About 22,6% of Russia's population does not have access to centralized sewage. Most of these families use cesspools, according to a Rosstat study on living conditions in the country. But your strategic nuclear forces are the most powerful. https://www.rbc.ru/economics/02/04/2019/5ca1d7949a79475d1c2f6e4a.
12. In Russia, 89% of citizens own their own housing, and for example in Europe and the United States, only 1%, data from the same IMF? But their toilet is not in the yard.

Count together where affordable housing, in yours or in the USA? How many salaries do you need and how much do they need for their housing?

[Professor]

I repeat for those who do not understand from the 3rd time:
1. RF GDP $ 4.016 trillion - 6th place in the world, in front of you Germany, Japan, USA, China and India. But it's like a livestock. From this, the ordinary Hindu and the Russian are neither warmer nor nourishing. It will be more interesting further.
2. The growth of GDP, the Russian Federation at 173rd place in the world.
3. GDP per capita (and this is what they go to the store with) Russia with $ 27,900 in 74th place in the world. Petrodollars do not help either.
4. You can’t cover the SNF and you can buy medicines for the children. North Korea also has an atomic bomb, but there is nothing.
5. Russia in the Second World War did not protect anyone since it was formed only in 1991.
6. By the beginning of the twentieth century, the Russian Empire occupied the territories in which the Jews lived and awarded them with pogroms and a Pale of Settlement. Russia has not sheltered anyone. Not a single Jew. The USSR refused to accept the Jews when Eichmann offered it to him. Then the Jews were sent to gas chambers. Of the millions of Jews who once lived in Russia, about 150 remain today. Given the pace of emigration, there will soon be no emigration at all. You will be judenfrey. Moreover, in 000, thousands of Russians applied for political asylum in Israel. From January to September 2019, 2019 people applied for asylum. In 3010, there were 2018 such requests. In 2772 - 2017. In 635 - 2016. In 395 - 2015. In 14 - 2013. http://newsru.co.il/israel/1oct27/refuge_2019.html
7. We remember who turned off the furnaces in Auschwitz and we remember how the USSR only for more money gave the Jews escape from Nazi Germany through the territory of the USSR to Japan. Those who had no money were sent to gas chambers.
8. With regard to infant mortality, it is NOT one of the lowest in the world, 6.7 per 1000 births, 162th place in the world, between Kuwait and Chile. In Israel, 3.4 per 1000 births. Half as much as you.
9. Maternal mortality is 17 per 100 births, 000th in the world. In Israel, 130 per 3. 100 times less. Why aren't you surprised that your wealthy ladies go to give birth abroad?
10. You have a life expectancy of 71.3, 155th place in the world. Israel is in 10th place in the world with 82.7. 11 years longer, Karl !!!
11. Is your housing much more affordable than in most Western countries? Whence, if you have a mortgage interest 10 (ten) times higher than in Israel? About 22,6% of Russia's population does not have access to centralized sewage. Most of these families use cesspools, according to a Rosstat study on living conditions in the country. But your strategic nuclear forces are the most powerful. https://www.rbc.ru/economics/02/04/2019/5ca1d7949a79475d1c2f6e4a.
12. In Russia, 89% of citizens own their own housing, and for example in Europe and the United States, only 1%, data from the same IMF? But their toilet is not in the yard.

Count together where affordable housing, in yours or in the USA? How many salaries do you need and how much do they need for their housing?

[stalki]

Are you kidding? over 20 years, Russia's GDP grew 14 times, the data are confirmed by the IMF, gold and foreign currency reserves rose from $ 9 billion to $ 540 billion, gold reserves from zero to 2300 tons, .....

You know, I somehow did not expect to see other comments besides criticism and ulcers here. You are probably an exception.

[smart ass]

I'm afraid what kind of "greatness"
Russia is paid by taxpayers and this is a merit of us all and not Putin

[Sarmat Sanych]

So naturally, everything is built and done by millions, everything is won on the international arena, "Poseidons" with "Daggers", "Prometheus" and "Vanguards" themselves appeared, even in the Crimea and Syria everything was organized by itself... At least you understand that without understanding the essence you are repeating the manuals of the same liberals who say that "the Great Patriotic War was won by the people and the commander-in-chief is not here"?

[smart ass]

Do not go to the store? Do not pay utility bills? Do not buy gasoline? You do not receive a pension?

[Sarmat Sanych]

Wise guy, you took such a nickname to laugh from yourself? Our gasoline is 2-3 times cheaper than in Europe, even one and a half times lower than in the neighboring impoverished Outskirts, a communal apartment is 3-5 times lower than in Europe and even 2 times lower than in the neighboring Outskirts, more questions? It’s funny about the store, even though it’s aware that in Russia food is one of the cheapest in the world? For example, due to the Russian overproduction of poultry, sugar and pork for these products, prices have not risen for the fifth year, but for example, sugar, pork and the Internet are reduced, which was generally impossible to imagine before. About the 5s to Putin with their galloping inflation of 90-50% per year, I am generally silent. In particular, the Russian sugar industry is undergoing a revolution, since the 500s it increased production by almost 2000 gas, becoming the 5nd largest sugar producer in the world, domestic sugar prices in Russia have been decreasing for a year in a row:
https://youtu.be/u5MRtH00QW8
And here's another one for fun:
https://youtu.be/SpymAiJCZjw

[smart ass]

When you compare prices in Europe, do not forget about s / n, otherwise it looks funny)))

[Sarmat Sanych]

Wise guy, when you compare s / n in Europe and the States, do not forget to subtract taxes and insurance from there, otherwise it looks ridiculously funny)))

[Yves762]

Quote: Sarmat Sanych

Poseidons "with" Daggers "," Prometheus "and" Vanguards "themselves appeared, even in the Crimea and Syria, everything organized itself.

About the wunderwuffly, - Yes. "From the Union regiment" they would not have gotten to life without "the very" (and then, when "they" were pretty much pinned ... )
About Crimea, Syria (and Georgia) - These are generally "crutches" for "his" foreign policy of the period 2000-2008 / 2014 (and this is still narrow).
About manuals, - And how do you, apparently, know what is written there?

[Sarmat Sanych]

Iv762, what is

wunderwaffle

? Move away from the mirror urgently, do not disgrace yourself. And tie a violin about the "allied regiment", otherwise the pseudo-leftists have this imaginary Soviet backlog, I look, will last for centuries? The Russian state has existed since Rurik, didn’t they know? RUSSIA FOR MORE THAN A HUNDRED YEARS STANDS AND MOVES FORWARD AS AN ATOMIC ICE-BREAKER (by the way, only Russia builds them in the world, others are not capable), defeated at least Swedes at least Prussians at least Persians, at least one Chinese Teutons, even one Teutonic Napoleon, Even before the 45th, we took Berlin TWICE, but the comics of the campaign have no Fatherland. You are red sectarians on Earth brought aliens with a shot of aurora.
And Crimea, by the way, is just the beginning of correcting the errors of the commies, which divided the living Russian lands into different artificial "ukraine", "kazakhstan", "lithuania", "estnonia", "moldavia" and other "belorussia". Better not even mention Syria, otherwise I will remember Afghanistan. Russia, on its own, quickly and effectively liberated 90% of the SAR, confronting the entire West and its Middle East satellites, while losing only 101 of our soldiers (plus 4 military aircraft and 4 helicopters), and the Union fled the gigantic contingent beaten from Afghanistan, having lost about 20 thousand Soviet soldiers and about 500 military aircraft and helicopters. In general, we showed fiction, for comparison, the States lost in the Iraqi campaign about 5 thousand of their killed soldiers through the Pentagon, about 35 thousand American mercenaries through PMCs, plus about 100 crashed and downed American helicopters and planes. And now the pro-Iranian government in Iraq, all the Iraqi oil fields were taken from the Americans and given to the Russian, Chinese, Indian and European corporations, and the American embassy is being smashed so that they can evacuate quickly? Does it mean tens of thousands of American mothers received a funeral in vain?

[bessmertniy]

One can admire the gold reserve, the decline in mortality, which at least somehow brightens up the birth defects, 200 thousand rubles (five average salaries) of per capita savings on deposits in banks. But the feeling that we began to live better than in the past is not. There is no certainty that you will have the same work tomorrow, that there will be enough money for expensive treatment, that you will not have to leave somewhere in a degrading region or locality, that once again you will not be deceived by scammers or your native state. You raise children, and there is no certainty that they are protected from harmful influences and will grow up as worthy people. There is no Russian state idea itself, which is already tired of arguing. Here more than one year it is necessary to row the galleys so that there are real achievements.

[Snail N9]

Actually, modern Russia is well characterized by the only slogan that replaced the "state ideology": "Everything for sale!" It's funny, but this winter, even, the snow has disappeared somewhere:

[orionvitt]

Quote: bessmertniy

the feeling that we began to live better than in the past, no.

The memory is short. Man is a strange creature, no matter how hard you give it, it doesn't matter, everything is bad for him, everything is not enough for him. I live in Ukraine, and in comparison with today's "successes" of Ukraine, the 90s already seem to me almost paradise. What do you have to complain about?

[Sarmat Sanych]

bessmertniy, you can be humanly understood, in the past years was your youth, you were healthy, beautiful, the girls loved and so on. And I rejoice at the present time, without Soviet censorship, without Soviet total deficit, without that disgusting clothing and eternal Soviet long-term construction, without insane banditry and terrorist attacks in the 90s, without galloping inflation of 300% in the 90s, without the Soviet Iron Curtain, without dying gerontocratic general secretaries , without millions of homeless children in the 90s, without feeding in 3 throats 14 "fraternal republics" exclusively at the expense of the RSFSR, with the Russian Crimea and the largest bridge in Europe, with dozens of other Russian bridges built over the past 19 years, with an increased length of federal highways compared to 91m from 39 to 81 thousand kilometers, etc. Believe me, after 20 years we will remember the Putin era with much greater joy than the late Brezhnev era.

[smart ass]

Excellent said

[orionvitt]

Quote: bessmertniy

Modest economic success of Russia

Blind or what? Or didn’t live in the 90s?

[bessmertniy]

I lived in the 60s, 70s, and 80s. You can talk as much as you like about what is better or worse economically in our country, but the main thing that is lost is the people. And not only in that very "demographic hole" they are lost, which has opened up since the beginning of the 90s, but in that spiritual emptiness, which for many has replaced the vector of romance and a positive attitude to life.

[orionvitt]

Quote: bessmertniy

emotional emptiness, which many have replaced the vector of romance and a positive attitude towards life

Ah, romantic, but romanticize further. We are talking about specific things. About the pit from which Russia got out with such difficulty. But no, people are always dissatisfied with everything. People, for your information, in Russia are not lost yet, look at Europe, or America (which everyone is praying for), and draw the right conclusion. And romance, no matter how good it was, but you won’t be fed up with it, and you won’t add verses to an empty stomach, and you won’t sing a song.

[bessmertniy]

Yes, you won’t be full of romance. But when others were shining with happiness next to you, and are always ready to help each other, then you feel happy. No worse than the Abramovichs, Khodorkovsky, etc. And the stories that were hungry, there was nothing to wear - this is from the field of fairy tales. Although, of course, they could not boast of disposable diamonds.

[smart ass]

Blind chtoli or in 1946 did not live? Actions by this method, I will turn any disaster into a positive !!

[Good wise]

In Russia, for a long time, internal economic problems have been in second place for the country's leadership: "you there yourself slowly cope with the economy, and we would have found strength on the external front against the adversary."

Then the Swedes in 1240, then the Germans in 1242, then against Genghis Khan, then against the Turks under Young, then again against the Swedes near Poltava, then the war with the French in 1812, then with the naglitsami, French, Turks, Italians, Germans, Swedes in 1854, then o5 with the Germans in 1914-17 and 1941-45.

And now, starting from the 40s, the eternal arms race with the United States, so as not to bomb our cities and villages, like Hiroshima and Nagasaki.
And there is no end and end to this arms race in terms of protecting the Russian land.
Ever since the time of the Prophetic Oleg, exorbitant costs for the defense of the native land fell on the shoulders of the common people.

https://ru.wikipedia.org/wiki/%D0%9A%D0%B0%D1%82%D0%B5%D0%B3%D0%BE%D1%80%D0%B8%D1%8F:%D0%A1%D1%80%D0%B0%D0%B6%D0%B5%D0%BD%D0%B8%D1%8F_%D0%A0%D0%BE%D1%81%D1%81%D0%B8%D0%B8

[Air force]

Bloomberg did not write about the main achievement, that Putin saved Russia from the collapse, which was facilitated by Western countries, although therefore he did not write. He won’t write that after the collapse of the USSR, we almost destroyed the Russian Federation, set fire to the Caucasus, planned and gradually carried out an economic explosion, continued to reduce the population at an accelerated pace, pumped out both natural and human resources everyday and without fuss, threw the IMF stranglehold and have already prepared for the dismemberment of the territory and the subsequent division. But Putin came and broke us the whole game. The result, the main achievement of Putin V.V. it’s breaking the paradigm for the collapse and capture of Russia. For some reason today many people forget about it.

[Siberia 75]

Those who have something to remember, they remember.

[bessmertniy]

Well yes. Putin came and saved us orphans, but wretched. But don’t you feel that the fact that you managed to break the 90s and the collapse is an achievement of the people who have found the strength to stop at the cliff and not fall.

[Air force]

Well, first of all, there is an article about Putin's achievements, and my commentary on the article is about his role as president. You write sarcastically about the "old and wretched" people, thereby belittling the role of Putin, even Bloomberg did not twist this topic as you did. No one says that the people are not the same, and as they used to say, each nation is worthy of its ruler, it is said in both a bad and a good way. A worthy people (without sarcasm) had unworthy rulers and where did they lead the people , in the 90s? But Putin changed the situation and helped the worthy people find the strength to stop at the cliff in time. What is the contradiction? PS Now it will start Putin stole everything, promised a lot and did not fulfill it, oil needle, ask ... (n) ali polymers and other blah, blah, blah about the Ozero cooperative and others like that. Only for some reason they do not want to see the changes since the 90s, that even the oil needle was not there, there was a different needle. (although the comment above "Siberia75 (Alexey)" gives an answer why they do not see the changes. Yes, there is much more that needs to be done, not without it, but what would have happened if instead of Putin, Yavlinsky had come for example, or any other of this crowd? Did they lead the people in the right direction?

[Yves762]

He's a direct hero of the bourgeois fighters of the same 90s: he came and taxied everything, and everything is ONE. Pharaohs (!) - at that time the gods on earth - did not build pyramids alone, but "he" .. .. same Crimean bridge.
Much easier.?.
Maybe all the same "spiders agreed"?

[dauria]

Maybe all the same "spiders agreed"?

A short phrase, but puts everything in its place. Yes, we realized that further collapse and without pants around the world. We agreed, kicked out the dissenting Hodor, Birch, Gusinsky. We have established a worldwide rule - "We do not gnaw our own people, we do not gnaw others." And in 99 they hid behind a screen, simultaneously exterminating all sorts of "independent" (from their dough) media with all sorts of "Dolls". But this is so all over the world. It would seem - why be sad? But you want a sort of saint with a halo. Not by ourselves, through the trade unions, strikes, the newspaper Iskra, "Bloody Sunday," the Lena execution .... But through Isus, to take, and "did justice." They just forget that Jesus was crucified, and not appointed to the presidency.
Think about it - after all, even doctors can go on strike only by mass dismissal. What then to talk about?

[Vyacheslav Viktorovich]

Quote: Air Force

everyday and without fuss pumped out both natural and human resources

Now everything has changed. Infrastructure construction for pumping out natural resources began to be declared "geopolitical victories".

[Snail N9]

Actually, you can juggle figures in rubles, like something has grown by ... 1,5-2,5% ..., but if you look at the "achievements", translating them from "rubles" to "dollars" , then it turns out, so-o-o-ov a whole different picture:

[Vadim237]

You look from the year 2000 and keep in mind that in 2008 there was a global economic crisis, Russia partially got out of it only in 2011, and in 2014 another hit: trade wars, sanctions, falling oil prices, slowing down the global economy - we still get out of it and thanks to Kudrin thanks to his Stabilization Fund accumulated over the 2000s, the country lived until 2017, covering holes in the budget from the failure of the economy.

[Departure]

Nobody forgot about it, but not everyone looks at it from your angle. I see it this way, a group of people whose interests are represented by GDP decided that it would be more profitable for them and their offspring to preserve the country, crush profitable industries for themselves and make money on this in a large country.
What did the Americans give to humpback and Yeltsin for losing their positions? nothing, in general, but these gentlemen have everything they wish with a margin for both children and grandchildren.
so for me this is not so much a merit as a single coincidence of the interests of the entire country with the interests of this group of people. lucky, so to speak. on the rest of the points, I disagree with you, the pipe, social sphere, education, migration policy show that this is where people's luck ended. before that, the "gentlemen" from the commander-in-chief's entourage do not care about the word at all. 20 years have clearly shown this.

[kepmor]

PS inspired ... for the 20th "anniversary" it would be nice to release the Complete Collection of Promises of V. V. Putin ... from "she drowned" to "please treat with understanding" ...
I think that the Booker Prize will be guaranteed ... and maybe the Nobel Prize in science fiction ...

[Aerodrome]

Quote: kepmor

PS inspired.

20 years on troubles.

[smart ass]

From 100000 thousand jobs to 5th place in the world of economies)))

[rocket757]

Putin’s achievements from 1999 to the present

as they say, to us, actually, POF!
As we say .... FOR MISCELLANEOUS and there are objective reasons.

[Stas157]

. called this term the 20th anniversary of the presidency, ”to which Putin objected, noting that from 2008 to 2012 he was not the president of the Russian Federation.

But 20 years in power!

Putin is a formalist. He put in his place a purely nominal and weak figure for 4 years (hold a place), he himself continued to rule the country at that time. And he thinks that no one will notice. With all the cunning, the cunning, really, is kind of unpretentious and distinguishable by all.

[bistrov.]

Quote: Stas157

Putin is a formalist.

Who cares? Did people vote? Thank God that people like you WHINKERS are a tiny percentage.

[Ross xnumx]

Quote: bistrov.

What's the difference? Did people vote? Thank God that people like you WHINKERS are a tiny percentage.

Say what?
People, say, voted?
And people on their knees begged him not to raise the minimum wage to 25 rubles. Stands in full height, eats food without salt and asks that if the "native government" cannot help raising, then at least 000 rubles ... Let it be 850 ... Shura Balaganov, for complete happiness, was content with 12 .. ...
This is for you, the mincer minuscule. Because a normal person cannot enjoy poverty, and there are more than 20 such people in Russia ...
That dollar millionaires became about 240. And more recently, 000 ...
Yes, as much as you can about a sore mouth. The very fact that:

Putin’s achievements from 1999 to the present Bloomberg relates

talks about the great love of the speakers. For people say something completely different:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SHo2Iyj5vpY
But who needs them - these rogues. Behind the glass of a car, a window or just behind the glass, everything is relatively calm:

[Vadim237]

Due to what they raise the minimum wage to 25000 - everywhere speculators and greed, they simply transfer the double minimum wage to the final cost of goods and services - for state employees it is possible - only the government will have two options either to raise taxes or reduce costs for all programs.

[ShM05]

Another achievement of Putin. RIA News. The fortune of Russian billionaires in 2019 increased by $ 52,9 billion. This is a record for the last four years, reports the publication of RBC owned by Grigory Berezkin, citing Bloomberg calculations.

The list includes 23 Russian participants in the Bloomberg Billionaires Index rating (BBI, 500 of the richest people in the world). Most of the past year, the co-owner of Norilsk Nickel Vladimir Potanin became rich. His fortune grew by $ 8,5 billion to $ 28,2 billion.

Following is the president of Lukoil Vagit Alekperov (growth - 6,2 billion, state - 22,3 billion) and co-owner of NOVATEK Leonid Mikhelson (growth - 5,2 billion, state - 24,6 billion). Also among the five leaders is another shareholder of the above companies Gennady Timchenko (growth - 4,3 billion, state - 18,2 billion) and the head of NLMK’s board of directors Vladimir Lisin (growth - 3,5 billion, state - 21,3 billion).

[Vadim237]

This growth is primarily due to the fact that the price on the market of all their assets and property of movable and non-movable has increased.

[Gardamir]

The question is to help people, but what if the enemy scolds, then we are doing everything right? Here, an enemy voice clearly works to raise the rating.
By the way, before the elections, they very carefully scolded the former president. Here a new young man asked to be treated with understanding and immediately everyone was younger.

[Loess]

Quote: Gardamir

But what if the enemy scolds, then we are doing everything right? Here, an enemy voice clearly works to raise the rating.

Already absolutely nothing to cling to?

[Gardamir]

Yes, I do not cling. One must be proud of real deeds, for example, increasing the well-being of the people. Real boost, not tsiferki.

[Loess]

Quote: Gardamir

One must be proud of real deeds, for example, increasing the well-being of the people

The well-being of the people is a thing ... hmm ... strange. People didn’t pay wages, there was nothing - it’s bad. They began to pay, stopped starving - it’s good. Six months or a year passed, and this is not enough, I wanted to furnish the apartment with new furniture and household appliances. Furnished. It's good. Six months or a year has passed and it’s somehow not comfortable to ride the bus, you need a car. Bought. And good again! But not for long. It’s necessary that the car is more impressive and the phone is more fashionable ... And so without end. There is such a fairy tale. Pushkin’s. About the goldfish. Yeah. Everything is essentially the same there. An old man who does not need anything for nothing. And the old woman, whom no matter how much you give, is still not enough for her. Putin is far from a goldfish, of course. But it is foolish to deny his merits.

[Gardamir]

About salaries, as it were, I agree, but why remember the 90s, when there is a Soviet past. And salaries and stability were all.
And now people lived, eating bread with butter and caviar. And suddenly, at the whim of officials, everything collapsed. Without prospects. They got out alright, creaking, but you can live, but you had to get into loans. Who would take such loans in the USSR?
And people are different, take one out and put the car in the yard, and the other is the process of implementation itself.
And Putin just makes the goldfish rich richer, and the poor poor.

[Loess]

Quote: Gardamir

About salaries, as it were, I agree, but why remember the 90s, when there is a Soviet past.

Alas, the 90s are also our past and Putin came to power precisely after the 90s.

Quote: Gardamir

. Who would take such loans in the USSR?

Many relatives in the Union saved up money and, in principle, could and wanted to buy some cars, some tractors, but the problem was that there were no cars or tractors on sale. As a result, everything that has been accumulated has turned into dust. And you cannot blame Putin for this either. And loans ... People for various reasons take loans.

Quote: Gardamir

makes the rich richer, and the poor poor.

Some especially "rich" under Putin were even taken on state support. Ulyukaev for example. Although others are still more lucky. Hopefully for now.
It was not a small number of the poor who began to live like human beings under Putin. You yourself agreed on the "salaries".

[Gardamir]

You yourself agreed on the "salaries".

I do not refuse my words, Putin started powerfully. and then it was as if replaced.
Then there was no car in free sale, now there is no money, again inaccessible.
As for the 90s, it was the bottom and the fact that Putin just got up a little, doesn’t say anything, if he climbed to the same peaks that were under the Union, he would take a new one, then there is something to be proud of, but for now, alas ...

[Cheerock]

Quote: WIKI

No more desire to analyze your numbers. If not for oil:

Well, look at oil prices in 2000 and now. In 2000, they were at the level of $ 30, in 2018 - $ 60 on average. The difference in oil price is 200%, the difference in GDP is 400%.

[fa2998]

Quote: bessmertniy

The modest economic successes of Russia,

And I would say, an economic failure! Everyone looks from his window. 20 years ago, dozens of enterprises worked in the city, tens of thousands of jobs. EVERYTHING collapsed.
"Success" can only be in the external arena. But there are no more friends, We live under sanctions.
Especially the end of the year, the pipeline was stopped, Ukraine is already paying money. Doubtful success.

[16112014nk]

But the people don't get anything from these "achievements".

[georggy]

I’m going to voice what Russia lost during Putin’s stay in power.

[Lenin]

Well, judging by the howling and tantrums of the West .. Russia has achievements!
And they all want the humpbacked Judah and ebn .. in power ..
No gentlemen, do not wait

[fa2998]

Quote: Lenin

tantrums of the West .. Russia has achievements!

Well yes! For budgetary funds. Whatever it may be. Trillions go to incomprehensible "goals", "achievements." The price of many projects (even to compare with foreign projects) is several times more expensive. Due to the poor population. For shitty health care, and the poor pensioners, etc.

[Guards turn]

Vladimir Vladimirovich! We do not need Armenogorsk instead of Solnechnogrsk, these comrades have completely filled the whole city, we Russian people are asking you to introduce Belarusians or Russian people there.

[Guards turn]

Vladimir Vladimirovich, please figure it out, it seems to me there are only Armenians running the Ministry of Economic Development and Trade, there is no wish for the Russian people to be in charge. This greyhound is tired of them, please put the Russian store "pancakes or Cossack settlement" - I am a Don Cossack asking you about this.

[LVMI1980]

Happy New Year
How did you get the "all-props" who either do not want to remember the end of the 90s or walked under a table.
I remember well the beginning of the 90s and their end, I remember how the salary for life was hardly enough, how it gradually became easier.