Military Review

Indian claims that HAL Tejas will defeat J-20 in close combat have been ridiculed in China

33
China zealously reacted to the arguments of Indian military experts that after the discovery of Chinese J-20 by Su-30MKI Indian Airborne radars, the reputation of Chinese "stealth" was tarnished.




In particular, a statement is made by Indian military expert Anil Bakshi, who stated that after stories with the Su-30MKI, the Chinese J-20 fighter can be compared to the Indian LCA, the 4 multi-purpose fighter of the HAL Tejas generation. The statement says that composite materials are used in the HAL Tejas hull, which makes the aircraft light and maneuverable, and therefore "if he approaches the Chinese J-20, he will win in aerial combat, he has every chance of it."

From Indian material:

The LCA project has important advantages over the Chinese melee aircraft.

Resource Sina Military, in response to these statements, published a critical article in which it ridicules the statements of Anil Bakshi and other Indian experts comparing the lightweight HAL Tejas to the heavy J-20.

Chinese edition:

The opinion of Indian military experts is clearly untenable. In terms of modern aviation technology, the small size of the aircraft does not mean at all that he has high maneuverability. In a real battle, the Indian LCA simply would not have caught up with the J-20 if its pilot had decided to do so. The J-20 has an undeniable advantage over the Indian aircraft. This is also an advantage in the maneuverability provided by the special tail of the fighter.
It was launched back in the 80 years.

From the article:

The program did not take into account any characteristics associated with the stealth of the aircraft. Therefore, their statements are simply nonsense.

In the material of the Chinese resource with pathos, it is noted that India will have to wait another 30 years to create a plane that at that time will surpass the J-20.
33 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must to register.

I have an account? Sign in

  1. Livonetc
    Livonetc 8 November 2019 15: 15 New
    +7
    Colorful measurements of the east.
    Here is a Bollywood movie about the invincible Indian apparatus that will be shot and all questions will be removed once and for all.
    1. cost
      cost 8 November 2019 15: 40 New
      +8
      India will have to wait another 30 years to create a plane that at that time will surpass the J-20.

      But .... but .... but the Indians are better at singing and dancing. Here laughing
      1. marshes
        marshes 8 November 2019 15: 47 New
        0
        Quote: Rich
        But .... but .... but the Indians are better at singing and dancing. Here

        And a whole channel on cable and satellite TV laughing
        Now China is friends, but Chinese films are rare.
        1. Shurik70
          Shurik70 8 November 2019 21: 41 New
          +1
          Someone will win - a purely theoretical question. That is Mesilovo on February 27, when a crowd of Pakistani planes collided with several Hindu ones - it is for more massive aircraft. And super-expensive toys will be protected, kept away from the landfill.
          There will be no "if it comes closer". So the "invisible", if they start to measure "who is who", will exchange exclusively missiles, the machine gun will not be used. So the question "who is faster and more agile" is meaningless.
          soldier
          I want to note that with all the ambitious statements of the Indians, they got their way — the Chinese were hurt by their statement, they reacted once, and even so violently.
        2. 72jora72
          72jora72 9 November 2019 04: 29 New
          0
          Now China is friends, but Chinese films are rare.
          Have you tried to watch Chinese films (exactly the ones they shoot for their domestic market)?
      2. TermNachTer
        TermNachTer 8 November 2019 18: 20 New
        +2
        Then you need to dance faster, because the gap, and not only in the air force, is growing more and more.
    2. antivirus
      antivirus 9 November 2019 04: 23 New
      0
      yes .. the other Himalayas are higher - Chinese or from India? - that's the main question - maybe someone else's plane won't fly over "their" mountains then
  2. Nycomed
    Nycomed 8 November 2019 15: 18 New
    +5
    "because "if he gets close to the Chinese J-20, he will win in aerial combat, he has every chance of that"."
    And he will be given closer?
    1. Invoce
      Invoce 8 November 2019 15: 45 New
      +1
      Quote: Nycomed
      "because" if he gets close to the Chinese J-20, he will win in aerial combat, he has every chance of that. "

      Yeah! If the pilot of the Indian super plane will be a boxer, and the Chinese kung fuist, then after approaching each other it is unclear who kicks someone in the bowls .... Indeed, who will give him the closer ..
      1. Vlad.by
        Vlad.by 8 November 2019 18: 00 New
        +1
        In the event of a skirmish between China and India, Drying will fight on both sides in the end.
        It is necessary to transfer the dispute from the plumage of the aircraft to the coloring of the helmets of the pilots. Those who are brighter will be spotted earlier.
        Well, then - Krishna with the Buddha will find out the relationship
  3. Etsma
    Etsma 8 November 2019 15: 21 New
    +2
    Each sandpiper praises its swamp.
    1. Cut Samshitov
      Cut Samshitov 8 November 2019 15: 28 New
      +6
      Chinese is the best
      1. marshes
        marshes 8 November 2019 15: 53 New
        0
        Quote: Sawing Boxwood
        Chinese is the best

        Tracking M-6 cross-country boots, not bad. Oil-Benzo persistent not soaked. Yes and cost not much.
        For those who still serve the strap pull.
  4. knn54
    knn54 8 November 2019 15: 33 New
    0
    Against the J-15 will pull. Opposite the J-20 ... and wait for the version of the MK-2.
  5. Good_Anonymous
    Good_Anonymous 8 November 2019 15: 41 New
    -15
    if he comes closer to the Chinese J-20, then he will win in aerial combat, he has every chance of it


    Almost Su-35 vs F-22.
    1. Tommy
      Tommy 8 November 2019 15: 58 New
      11
      Almost Su-35 vs F-22!

      As always, bilious illiteracy ... Su-35 with the help of the Irbis radar will detect the F-22 with the AN / APG-77 radar much earlier and will be guaranteed to destroy the RVV-BD R-37M missile before the AIM-120 deployment line. Learn your lessons further!
      1. Good_Anonymous
        Good_Anonymous 8 November 2019 15: 59 New
        -6
        Quote: Tommy
        Su-35 with the help of the Irbis radar will detect the F-22 with the AN / APG-77 radar much earlier and will be guaranteed to destroy the RVV-BD R-37M missile


        Flawless victory!
  6. Invoce
    Invoce 8 November 2019 15: 43 New
    -1
    Outwardly - a weak likeness of the MiG-23, especially without a variable sweep of the wing. Perhaps Avionics and avionics at a higher level, but aircraft engines can currently be made by the EU, Russia and the USA ... all the rest are measured by a causal place and puff out their cheeks
    1. IL-18
      IL-18 9 November 2019 00: 06 New
      +1
      Quote: Invoce
      weak likeness of the MiG-23, especially without variable sweep

      And the J-20 still has a PGO: a weak likeness of the Su-30 laughing
  7. Lord of the Sith
    Lord of the Sith 8 November 2019 15: 48 New
    +1
    When these two countries begin to measure their dignity, I immediately recall the axiom of Escobar laughing
  8. Pavel57
    Pavel57 8 November 2019 15: 50 New
    0
    Measured by stealth. Who has less.
  9. Vladimir_2U
    Vladimir_2U 8 November 2019 16: 20 New
    +2
    That "Shinima x ... nya", that this "Shinima x ... nya".
  10. Retvizan 8
    Retvizan 8 8 November 2019 16: 55 New
    +1
    Twinkle no bags grumble!
    And how in battle will be unknown.
  11. Yigal Kaganov
    Yigal Kaganov 8 November 2019 17: 05 New
    +1
    They would hope that their Tejas, even with J-7 Pakistani on equal terms, will be able to compete
  12. Mark9103
    Mark9103 8 November 2019 17: 47 New
    -4
    They also laugh at us in the West when we declare that the Su-35 will "tear to shreds" F-22)))
    1. Tommy
      Tommy 8 November 2019 17: 57 New
      +9
      Quote: Mark9103

      They also laugh at us in the West when we declare that the Su-35 will "tear to shreds" F-22)))

      Are you sure that the Su-35S will not break the F-22? They do not know how to count!
      1. Inokenty
        Inokenty 8 November 2019 21: 23 New
        +8
        No one doubts the victory of the Su-35S, but everything will be decided by a real battle!
  13. Eug
    Eug 8 November 2019 17: 57 New
    0
    And did anyone doubt the "glow" of the J-20 on the screens of radars and thermal imagers? Its HELL circuitry screams about it, and the thermal shielding of the motors is hardly better than that of the Su. With TEJAS on the so-called "stealth" is the same.
  14. Ros 56
    Ros 56 8 November 2019 18: 24 New
    +1
    Yes, let them have fun, in disputes the truth is born. lol
  15. rocket757
    rocket757 8 November 2019 18: 31 New
    0
    In principle, a meaningless pick.
    1. Ugolek
      Ugolek 8 November 2019 19: 07 New
      +2
      "because" if he gets close to the Chinese J-20, he will win in aerial combat, he has every chance of that. "
      And he will be given closer?


      Do not forget, there the Himalayas and other mountain systems and sneak up very even not noticeably, receiving information from AWACS. Thus, the Chinese can be taken aback easily.
  16. Zaurbek
    Zaurbek 8 November 2019 21: 43 New
    +1
    Its direct competitor is FT17 ... and with modernization it will be quite imagined.
    1. Nycomed
      Nycomed 8 November 2019 23: 13 New
      0
      Absolutely right! Why all this argument?