Recession in the Heads. Are there any hopes for economic growth in the country?

224

Scalding genius


It is incredible, but true: in Russia they again started talking about the possibility of a recession. For those who are too lazy or have no time to clarify every pseudo-crazy term that clogged our language beyond recognition, I’ll explain: this is nothing more than an economic downturn. True, there are other meanings in medicine, for example, but today we are interested in just that.





A certain forecast was made by a certain Institute of Growth Economics named after Stolypin, headed by the notorious business ombudsman (how many words were dragged into our language!) Boris Titov. According to experts, this same recession may be registered in Russia already at the end of the current year. Which is rather strange: according to the results of the first quarter of 2019, the growth of 0,5% was recorded, according to the results of the second official results they still haven’t been brought up, but they speak unofficially about 0,7% in relation to the same period last year. That is, even inferior, but growth.

So where did the woods come from, what happened to our economic miracle, which was about to cover us with absolute inevitability? Or what, all the victims, all the efforts were in vain ?! Or are we not all the recommendations of the best economists in the world followed ?!

No, really, let's figure it out!

Did we target inflation? Yes, even stupid to ask: for a good quarter of a century (without exaggeration, since about the mid-nineties) we are only doing this! We target her, damned, from all angles, we don’t give her a free breath! The best minds of the state fall asleep and wake up with the thought of whether inflation was well targeted! No, as you wish, but such an accusation, had it been voiced by anyone, would have sounded like blasphemy!

Could we have been in deficit budgets? Or at least deficit-free? So no, from year to year all the surpluses! Directly to the envy of both Europe and America - this is who should learn from our economic geniuses! And then, you know, every year they have a deficit of 3-4%, they place all kinds of bonds for coverage, they drive the state into the debt loop. Mediocrity and lack of courage, in a word, they need to organize an urgent course at the HSE!

Maybe they violated the budget rule ?! Well, no, the budget rule, this ingenious invention of the genius accountant Alexei Kudrin, has long been a sacred cow for us. We did not violate and we will not violate! On the contrary, time after time we lower the cut-off border so that the damned petrodollars do not go into our economy, which is already about to begin to grow by leaps and bounds, and settled in various funds where it would be stored to the best (that is, the worst, you’ll excuse me for a sudden paradox) of times.

And what about the funds, by the way? Have we eaten them? Have you taken any momentary stupid things like investments, national projects, reducing poverty, raising employment? No, everything is normal with them: they grow up, darlings, instilling in us legal pride and a feeling of deep satisfaction! Agree, it’s nice to realize that your state has accumulated a huge amount of money for your funeral, and they will be magnificent, solemn, beautiful?

Maybe we did little help to oil and gas companies? Also slander: helped a lot, actively, literally for any reason! And tax breaks, and soft loans, and the tax "maneuver" on demand - all for them, breadwinners! And it’s not only oil and gas workers in our honor: the state provided assistance to all oligarchs suffering from sanctions if they are close enough to the Kremlin and for this reason can be called “backbone”.

Or - horror! - we allowed an unjustified increase in salaries in the country ?! No, this is a real slanderous libel on our wonderful economic geniuses: we carefully listen to every moan about how difficult it will be for our economy without cheap workers from Central Asia, and we do everything so that guest workers enjoy our well-deserved honor and respect.

Again, the pension reform was carried out. Decisively, clearly, efficiently. They took away a million rubles from dear Russians of pre-retirement age, even though bins from money are breaking and surplus budgets are being accepted from time to time.

Is gasoline growing in price? Is growing. Not only that, oil companies are also promised compensation for lost profits, but they, you see, are not profitable to process oil domestically, they are more comfortable driving her crude for export. And this, mind you, instead of just raising the export duty at times and thereby ensuring an outstripping growth in the profitability of domestic oil refining for decades to come, as I would assure you, in any country with less intelligent (more precisely, less ingenious) economists.

Not growing, damned!


In general, one can go on ad infinitum: there is no limit to the genius of our “economic bloc”; over and over again, he comes up with something new, interesting, often never before seen in economic practice!

True, the economy still does not grow ... But this is understandable: sanctions, the damned bourgeoisie do not give cheap loans, and we do not invest our money in the economy - what else!

And now they’re talking about the recession. Damned Crimea! Or, as our unforgettable A. Ulyukaev (exactly before landing) said, "politicians create problems for the economy." By the way, I was even scared for him then: no one from the “vertical” kicked Putin so openly and clearly. Not for nothing, as it turned out, he was scared, but about this some other time ...

In general, we get some kind of strange economic reality. Around, wherever you spit, a genius sits on a genius and drives the Higher School of Economics. And a country that does not have real economic problems, in their true sense, still cannot get out of the economic ... Well, yes, the pit, that’s exactly what I had in mind.

Just in case, I’ll make one clarification. Smart ones do not need it, but, as practice shows, there are not so many of them. But the majority of the “slightly less intelligent” ones really like to seriously say something like “are you an economist, to criticize the government ?!” By the way, these people generally like to take deep thought and blurt out something like “Are you poet, what do you undertake to criticize poetry ?! Well, write better, and then blather! ”And so literally for any reason ...

So, my dear lovers blurt out something with a smart look ... In order to appreciate the work of a cook in a restaurant, you don’t have to be a great culinary specialist yourself. Believe me, your life experience is more than enough for this. And in order to appreciate the tailor who sewed a crooked jacket for you, it is not necessary to complete sewing-mechanic courses. Well, I’ll finish you off completely: the great Russian critic Vissarion Grigorievich Belinsky did not write poems comparable to Eugene Onegin and novels that overshadow Dead Souls. Nevertheless, his opinion on these and other works was very much in demand, and there were practically no idiots in the society who would shout to him “write yourself first!”

Therefore, let's agree that any of us living in Russia has a reason and the right to give an assessment of the activity to our highly respected (the law is the law, excuse me) government. Moreover, there was already enough time to make sure the quality of the work of our ministers and various "vice" ones. Already not only the flowers faded, but the fruits of their activities, we enjoyed to the fullest ...

And as Christ said, "by their fruits you will know them." That is, we have every reason to say that this is not a cultural, useful garden tree, but a blackthorn or burdock.

No matter how you shuffle the deck ...


No, don’t be alarmed; this is not a call to that. This is just a statement of the fact that the competence of our government and other economists has long been in question.

We will surely find a replacement for those ignoramuses who changed their plus or minus in their brains during the perestroika years (and vice versa), and they still live with Capital in their head. Unless what Marx considered bad, they now consider good, and vice versa.

Of course, some attentive reader will object to me: they say that Titov and his “institute” are another source. Everything is so, oh my careful reader, everything is so. Personally, Titov reminds me of a physiotherapy instructor who burst into a medical consultation and demanded to send a patient in need of emergency surgery and resuscitation to the gym.

But what about such information available in other sources:
In addition, the lowest indicators of the use of budget funds were recorded in national projects, which could have the greatest multiplier effect - “Increasing labor productivity and supporting employment” (budget implemented at 17,7%), “Safe and high-quality roads” (budget executed at 12,2 %), "Digital Economy of the Russian Federation" (budget executed at 8,3%).


But national projects really are the last hope for economic growth in modern Russia. Without them, there remains only the “budget rule” and the other “genius” mentioned above ...
Our news channels

Subscribe and stay up to date with the latest news and the most important events of the day.

224 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. Underwater hunter
    +57
    8 August 2019 15: 13
    We have problems absolutely everywhere (economics, politics, science, education, medicine, industry, etc.). Only blind people or trolls who work for money can not see this. But this is half the trouble, it’s completely a misfortune that Putin more Medvedev do not think so and do nothing ..
    1. +39
      8 August 2019 15: 26
      Why would they do anything if they vote for them anyway? Practice has shown that effective propaganda yields greater returns to retain power at a lower cost than effective governance. So they prefer to invest in propaganda.
      1. Underwater hunter
        +33
        8 August 2019 15: 33
        Quote: vasilii
        Why would they do anything if they vote for them anyway?

        I don’t believe that they are being voted for, I don’t believe that after the pension reform and the rest of the "nizhtyakov" 54% vote for Putin .. a clear confirmation that Edro have now hidden their party tickets and are going to the elections as self-nominated candidates.
        Therefore, in politics, as well as in economics, there is also a crisis ..
        1. +35
          8 August 2019 15: 39
          Quote: Underwater Hunter
          I don’t believe that they are being voted for, I don’t believe that after the pension reform and the rest of the niggas, 54% vote for Putin ..

          Check out the commentary on any article where the United States or Ukraine is affected in any way. There everyone rallies around the leader and prepares to march at least to Fashton, at least crush the fifth column. So it will work fine, once again they will lead an organ about the enemy at the gates and the ghost of Maidan, raise a degree of hysteria for the elections, and all the ranks will go and vote as expected.
          1. +34
            8 August 2019 15: 56
            - You promised to marry me, you gave your word ...
            - Previously, there was a different political and economic situation ...
            - Learned from Putin?

            ISIS banned in Russia does not want to take responsibility for the state of the Russian economy.
          2. +7
            9 August 2019 08: 25
            There everyone rallies around the leader and prepares to march at least to Fashton, at least crush the fifth column.
            Among those "amicably rallying" under such articles may suddenly turn out to be quite a few materially interested. The method of searching for specks in someone else's eye, widely used by propaganda, in the presence of logs in its own, is already weak. In addition, at the regional elections, you will not really nod at the intrigues of the "damned murikos". Therefore, under the guise of elections, the authorities switched to an open violation of the constitutional rights of citizens, as well as to the use of repressive judicial and police methods. You don't have to go far - "elections" for the governor of Primorsky Krai, "registration" of candidates for municipal elections in Moscow and the region.
            1. -1
              9 August 2019 11: 08
              Quote: vic02
              Among the "amicably rallying" under such articles may suddenly turn out to be many materially interested

              If payments are rallying, then they should be rallying more or less, regardless of the type of content being discussed. And when the reaction regularly changes depending on what is read, it seems to me that people do it out of duty.
              1. +7
                9 August 2019 11: 58
                they should rally more or less regardless of the type of content being discussed
                This is usually observed. Of course, one cannot exclude the blind faith of some, but to believe that the current bureaucratic oligarchic-police power is the salvation of Russia is beyond my comprehension.
              2. +2
                10 August 2019 04: 08
                Quote: vasilii
                And when the reaction regularly changes depending on what is read, it seems to me that people do it out of duty.

                The vane man, in my humble opinion, is even worse than the paid troll ...
        2. -9
          8 August 2019 17: 03
          Quote: Underwater Hunter
          Therefore, in politics, as well as in economics, there is also a crisis ..
          The problem is that there isn't much to choose from either. Who can not just replace Putin and Medvedev, but restructure the work of the entire government in a constructive manner, find optimal solutions for the economy, and reliably cement the authorities for the sake of overall growth? Where are they, determined, young, competent managers who have experience in civil service in high positions and who have not stained themselves with theft? Can anyone name by name? The clan system does not allow such to appear. And the fact that the present state REALLY managed to get out of the terrible pit of the nineties - remember - the collapsed army, the war in Chechnya, the chaos of crime, months without wages - makes people think: "The main thing is that it doesn't get worse." And I understand the concern of these people. Therefore, it will probably be as it is: a sluggish long-term slide to the next crisis, an increase in protest moods, then - God forbid - an explosion with bloody scraps and a new difficult crawling out of the abyss.
          1. +12
            9 August 2019 10: 06
            The problem is that there is also nothing to choose from. Who can not just change Putin


            It would seem, and where does Putin ..
            Oh yeah .. it’s more beneficial for him than anyone else if he has nothing to choose from ..
            1. -18
              9 August 2019 14: 00
              And what is the benefit of Putin? Remember, with what load of problems he accepted Russia: war, poverty, crime, lawlessness ... Want in the nineties? Me not. Putin will leave and remain a respected man, and rightly go down in history as the savior of Russia. Will he take care of a successor? I think that yes - and precisely so that what is done is not scammed, it will in every way prevent the arrival of the heirs of Yeltsin-Chubais-Gaidar and other borov and Germans. The wing of the left talkers with the banners of the Communist Party will also move over. As well as bulk. Undemocratic? May be. But the people are greedy for slogans - remember how they wanted Boriska to the kingdom? And this is without any internet! - And now you can drag anyone, even Navalny, even Galustyan, had money and access to the media. And therefore, I think, Putin will drag his own. And rightly so.
              1. +11
                9 August 2019 16: 37
                It’s just interesting, and how does this fit in your head? And most importantly, does everything fit into a neat mosaic there?
                It may be an unpleasant discovery for you, but let me remind you of something.
                Did you know that for 20 years, under Putin, the president’s irreplaceable adviser has been and now is Yumashev? And Yumashev is married to Dyachenko, to the daughter of Alkash. And he was married to Yumashev’s daughter (before the scandal with Rybka) - the Deripaska. This is one big friendly family of the Drunk. The Internet to help, if you do not believe me, it is checked all this easily. Remember the one who initially supported Putin-Chubais, where is he?
                Putin was reigned by the Alkash Family to preserve and increase Family values. And now FSB’s thieves and a circle of judokas have been added to Family thieves.
                You can write a lot about this about these scum, but there is no desire.
                1. -14
                  9 August 2019 19: 11
                  And I’m on the drum, who is married to someone. Do you need Bulk? Or another Chubais? Well, go, rally for them - maybe the head will be broken. What matters to me is not who is sleeping with whom, but what changes have taken place in the country after the nineties. And again in the nineties I do not want. Do you want Well, then go to Ukraine. Do you have a sensible candidate for president? Sound, do not be shy. Or just pat your tongue for all the good against all the villains?
                  1. -3
                    13 August 2019 09: 06
                    Quote: astepanov
                    Do you need Bulk?

                    What do you know about Navalny?
                    1. 0
                      15 August 2019 11: 59
                      Question to question, how is it in Odessa? Charming.
                  2. 0
                    15 August 2019 11: 00
                    We now have "another bulk or Chubais" in power ..
                    Just his surname is different ..
                    And your lack of education only indicates that "they are doing everything right" ..

                    astepanov (Aleksey) August 9, 2019 14:00 p.m.
                    -18
                    And what is the benefit of Putin?


                    astepanov (Aleksey) August 9, 2019 19:11 p.m.
                    -13
                    Do you have a sensible candidate for president? Sound, do not be shy.


                    Even if it’s problematic to bring these two thoughts together in my head .. then there’s nothing to help here ..))
                    1. 0
                      15 August 2019 12: 05
                      Sir, I with you, it seems, did not drink on Brudershaft. Poke your grandmother, go. And your strange allusions that do not contain a single bit of specificity are really beyond my power.
                      1. -2
                        15 August 2019 12: 20
                        Look for sirs elsewhere ..))

                        You just stuck under your nose, who is most profitable that there is no one else to replace Putin except Putin ..

                        But you still wander in some of your allusions, asking
                        "What is Putin's benefit?"
                        "Do you have a sensible candidacy for the presidency? Speak, do not hesitate."


                        Therefore, I only have to repeat myself:
                        "Even if it is problematic to link these two thoughts together in your head .. then there is nothing to help here ..))"
                      2. 0
                        15 August 2019 12: 30
                        Sir, do you deign to write from Kashchenko?
                      3. -3
                        15 August 2019 12: 41
                        Do you have Kashchenko in England ?? Well, I'm happy for you ..))

                        But henceforth, try to still communicate on the topic ..

                        And if it comes to the topic with difficulty, then it doesn’t matter - I’ll also chew it for the fifth time ..


                        The problem is that there is also nothing to choose from. Who can not just change Putin


                        It would seem, and where does Putin ..
                        Oh yeah .. it’s more beneficial for him than anyone else if he has nothing to choose from ..


                        Try this time, before you "answer" something again - think a little .. I believe in you ..))
                      4. +1
                        15 August 2019 15: 13
                        Well, already, near Moscow, according to Roman, it turned out in England. How to warm, the enemy comes! The British occupied the throne! This is Putin's fault! Bulk to the kingdom!
                        Go already, sir, drink haloperidol, take an injection and oversleep.
                      5. 0
                        16 August 2019 10: 42
                        The title of the article is "Recession in the Heads" .. about people like you, apparently ..

                        And now back to the topic .. I will once again poke your nose into your stupidity, since you really like to make yourself a laughing stock ..

                        The problem is that there is also nothing to choose from. Who can not just change Putin

                        It would seem, and where does Putin ..
                        Oh yeah .. it’s more beneficial for him than anyone else if he has nothing to choose from ..


                        Chew well what you are talking about before swallowing .. otherwise you will be haloperidol, but Navalny raving ..))
          2. 0
            12 August 2019 12: 12
            For example, Sergey Galitsky. Talented economist and manager.
        3. -15
          9 August 2019 11: 18
          Vote! And I will vote because Putin is ACTING and I see the point in his actions. And next to only chatter.
          1. +12
            9 August 2019 12: 13
            The trick is that Putin does not act in the interests of the people, but in the interests of the political group, which actually nominated him, but Sobchak, Gaidar, Chubais, Berezovsky and other figures also belonged to her.
            1. -13
              9 August 2019 19: 20
              An empty set of words: You cannot substantiate this with anything. Hex!
              1. +7
                12 August 2019 11: 15
                Let's see specifically. The Putin government buys US debt and permits unlimited export of capital in the hundreds of billions of dollars, thereby investing in the US and EU economies instead of Russia. Raising the retirement age is actually the third robbery of our people after the monetary default of the early nineties and voucherization. So in the interests of the people do not act.
            2. -3
              10 August 2019 14: 46
              Quote: vic02
              Sobchak, Gaidar, Chubais, Berezovsky belonged to her, too ...

              ... out of four in this "set" - three are already dead. What is characteristic laughing
              1. -1
                12 August 2019 11: 17
                four in this "set" - three are already dead
                Are you implying that Putin has anything to do with their death?
                1. -5
                  12 August 2019 11: 51
                  Quote: vic02
                  Are you implying that Putin has anything to do with their death?

                  I’m hinting that it’s time for you to refresh the training manual. wink
                  1. +1
                    12 August 2019 13: 18
                    I am hinting that you have a very short memory, apparently because of your personal interest in this.
          2. +8
            11 August 2019 12: 22
            "In his actions." And how can you explain his chatter about pension reform, 25 million jobs, about the 5th economy in the world? The fact of the matter is that besides words, we no longer see anything. But in the news: "Putin arrived on a motorcycle in the Crimea." That's OK. And in Moscow there are 60 thousand with demands. The king has no time for servants. That is, he is right there for all sorts of "parties", but he is reluctant to react to an emergency on a national scale.
      2. AUL
        +16
        8 August 2019 15: 42
        Quote: vasilii
        Why would they do anything if they vote for them anyway?

        Replace the word "vote" with "count".
    2. -32
      8 August 2019 15: 42
      Everything is clear with industry - there will be sales markets and production growth, as long as we have from 3 to 6% per year
      1. Underwater hunter
        +18
        8 August 2019 15: 49
        Quote: Vadim237
        Everything is clear with industry - there will be sales markets and production growth, as long as we have from 3 to 6% per year

        And what are we producing now, which is really not inferior in quality to its Western counterparts? There will be markets if there is a competitive product. I worked in foreign trade for several years, so I can tell you with confidence that the problem is not in the sales markets, but in a product that can compete and is well presented .. of course, the problem is that they often do not know how to sell ..
        1. +3
          8 August 2019 21: 09
          We produce good goods, we do not know how to sell, we need to develop a dealer network, an after-sales service system, a spare parts supply system, Europeans and Americans do it well, and we even lose in this.
          1. -10
            9 August 2019 11: 26
            To produce, promote, sell domestic goods - these are OUR objectives, not Putin and Medvedev. This is not a clave click ...
            1. +6
              9 August 2019 21: 26
              Quote: Victor N
              To produce, promote, sell domestic goods - these are OUR tasks

              who else would teach to produce? Where are scientists thinking in production? you do not hear the arguments. It is Putin and Medvedev who must create the conditions for production and promotion !!! At least acceptable loans and tax exemption for the first time. Information and scientific support. And for the whole country - a change in the exchange rate !!!! to a profitable manufacturer !!!
              1. -6
                10 August 2019 11: 50
                Think over the words, or you will never get out of twos. "Industrial scientists" - why? There are production workers and entrepreneurs. Let scientists be engaged in science, specialization, you know. It is not a "tsarist business" for Putin and Medvedev to "produce and promote", to deprive those who are obliged to do it according to their job descriptions. "Information and scientific support" - what is this term? What you write further is an echo of grandmother's gatherings, no more.
                1. +3
                  10 August 2019 12: 50
                  Quote: Victor N
                  Think about the words

                  it is you who think. You confuse science and technology
                  .
                  Quote: Victor N
                  It is not a "tsarist business" for Putin and Medvedev to "produce and promote"

                  And Stalin, by the way, delved into all the subtleties of many industries.
                  1. -6
                    10 August 2019 22: 16
                    Neither Stalin nor Putin could communicate. Although Putin is more understandable, and is working hard - God forbid everyone, the work is complicated.
                  2. The comment was deleted.
                2. +6
                  11 August 2019 12: 29
                  They probably read you. Therefore, medicine, education are becoming increasingly paid. Well, not their business. What for? If there are such active citizens
            2. Alf
              +8
              10 August 2019 20: 42
              Quote: Victor N
              To produce, promote, sell domestic goods - these are OUR tasks,

              How many domestic products have you promoted?
              1. -5
                10 August 2019 22: 25
                Yes, it was possible - in accordance with its specialization. And there is something to report. Subordinates have more specific tasks and more visual results. But the director promotes the services of our organization as a whole, he is not allowed to exchange for trifles.
                1. Alf
                  +5
                  10 August 2019 22: 46
                  Quote: Victor N
                  Yes, it was possible - in accordance with its specialization. And there is something to report. Subordinates have more specific tasks and more visual results. But the director promotes the services of our organization as a whole, he is not allowed to exchange for trifles.

                  A more specific, without verbiage?
                2. +3
                  11 August 2019 12: 44
                  Quote: Victor N
                  he is not allowed to exchange for trifles.

                  smile as a rule, with insufficient attention to detail, they burn out on a large
              2. -7
                10 August 2019 23: 36
                Quote: Alf
                How many domestic products have you promoted?

                Buddy questions that adults cannot answer are called children's (C).

                In addition, in order to understand the answer, one must (at least slightly) own the subject. Do you have anything to do with sales? Let me doubt it wink

                What do you think - "to promote the product", do not announce?
        2. +2
          8 August 2019 22: 06
          Quote: Underwater Hunter
          There will be markets if there is a competitive product.

          Does competitive mean a certain quality but a little cheaper? What could it be? Maybe some kind of high-tech product? we have applied science only in the military commissariat, and you won’t bargain with it, especially since the entire population of the country cannot be attracted to production. Could it be agriculture? also not a camillepho .. In Europe, over 2 wheat crops are removed and one of them disappears in some places .. We have a cold, huge impassable country and under capitalism it is possible to establish such production only with the premises of a certain state policy, as in 30gg in the USSR or now in China. The only product that we can really sell is graphene.
          1. -9
            9 August 2019 14: 28
            It already exists: 3D printers, including for construction, nuclear reactors, fuel cells, isotopes, special alloys, optical instruments, construction equipment, cars, heat exchangers, cryogenic cameras, combines, tractors Rostselmash - 18% of the global market for agricultural equipment, medical equipment - SHVABE , machines ranging from turning to machining centers with CNC with a bed of 40 by 6 meters - STAN group, products of special instrumentation Rostekh, Roselektronika, KRET and much more.
            1. +9
              9 August 2019 15: 24
              3D printers, including for construction

              And what is domestic in them? From the control system to the software - everything is entirely imported. The case for the product is not considered.
              nuclear reactors fuel cells isotopes

              Glory to the USSR!
              special alloys

              Russia imports special alloys, including steel for barrels.
              optical instruments

              Even for tanks we buy in France
              construction equipment, cars

              You are joking? Nobody abroad is a domestic car. Vesta - normal, sorry, only all of the foreign components.
              medical equipment

              Something, there is, most, as well as medicines, are imported.
              machines ranging from turning to CNC machining centers

              You don’t need about the machines, only the cast-iron case is in them.

              Etc. etc.
              1. -7
                9 August 2019 21: 14
                "And what is domestic in them? From the control system to the software, everything is entirely imported. The case is not considered a product." From the beginning, you will take an interest in manufacturers and developers - before you drive a blizzard out of our only case.
                Russia imports special alloys - Of course, I haven’t observed a single imported alloy when purchasing alloy billets: niobium, titanium, nickel, steel, copper, bronze, brass, aluminum and others, foreign markings like: C 21000, AA3003, SUM21, 35S20 did not have.
                "Even for tanks we buy in France" - We have not bought them since 2010, they are produced by SHVABE and Rostec. Medical equipment is also produced by SHVABE - over the past 4 years, the line has expanded well.
                "There is no need for the machines, they have only a cast-iron body in them." - Instead of brains, you have cast iron.
            2. +5
              9 August 2019 16: 50
              3D printers, including for construction

              Before pronouncing such crap about construction, it would not be bad to think.
              How much will it cost, for example, even a country house from a 3D printer? So far, and probably for a very long time it will be much cheaper to make wood or with cement and brick. Although I agree, it will probably be possible to print self-tapping screws on the printer and then boast of them. If you want to use a 3D printer, then you can use various finishes for printing, expensive, but not for construction.
              1. -4
                9 August 2019 21: 24
                Before you roll such crap - understand the issue of 3D printing - at the moment. One of these domestic 3D printers designed for building battles
                - printing of structures made of cement M 400
                1. +2
                  10 August 2019 04: 29
                  Quote: Vadim237
                  - printing of structures made of cement M 400

                  Tin !!! How much does such an adaptation cost and how many people serve it? And before I remember it was necessary to mold a bathhouse ... when you come home from work, you made the formwork from a 40-forged board, mixed m400 in a trough, poured it ... went to watch TV. The next day he came, lifted the formwork and repeated the previous day. The bathhouse was "printed" in a week ...
                2. Alf
                  +7
                  10 August 2019 20: 45
                  Quote: Vadim237
                  One of these domestic 3D printers designed for building battles

                  How much is created? How many purchased?
                  1. -3
                    11 August 2019 00: 12
                    I saw 8 models of both construction and industrial - domestic production.
            3. +3
              9 August 2019 21: 05
              only for some reason, it all passes by our area
        3. +6
          9 August 2019 08: 57
          Quote: Underwater Hunter

          And what are we producing now, which is really not inferior in quality to its Western counterparts? There will be markets if there is a competitive product ...

          This is the eternal problem of the former USSR - they pretend that they pay us a salary, we pretend that we try. This vicious circle must somehow be broken. And here is only one way - to stop living one day. No one is watching tomorrow, and it is up to the state to create conditions for this. Inflation will never be defeated, because the Ministry of Finance plans it, and he does it in order to easily balance without effort, because his goal is not to make life better and make a profit in the state. scale, and to balance, which is easy and fun on currency speculation, you don’t even need to get up from a chair. Naturally, no one invests and does not give all the best, everyone is sawing money now quickly and over the hill, because no one wants to lose on inflation.
          So if we discard all the verbal husks about the growth of exchange rates, etc., then everything is simple:
          Nat Bank and Ministry of Finance - the goal is to reduce the balance to +, and no more;
          The business has a goal - money now and quickly, then quickly to a safe place (and this is abroad), and they need to be saved not only from inflation, but also from .... (here I left a place for - you guess bully )
          And the thought is to speculate about patriotism - and remember the election was about the foreign accounts of Grudinin? So, if a businessman does not have them, then he is idiot.
          1. -3
            9 August 2019 14: 29
            Tomorrow - only loafers are not looking - everyone else has planning and goals for the future.
            1. +8
              9 August 2019 16: 52
              Tomorrow - only loafers are not looking - everyone else has planning and goals for the future.

              That's for sure. And this is not about our government.
          2. Alf
            +5
            10 August 2019 20: 46
            Quote: Max Otto
            And the thought is to speculate about patriotism - and remember the election was about the foreign accounts of Grudinin?

            I wonder if anyone tried to search for foreign accounts of the Tandem? And how did it end for him?
            1. 0
              10 August 2019 20: 51
              Quote: Alf
              I wonder if anyone tried to search for foreign accounts of the Tandem?

              Putin’s accounts, remember, the Americans were looking for.

              Quote: Alf
              And how did it end for him

              Deep disappointment request
              1. Alf
                +3
                10 August 2019 21: 12
                Quote: Cat Man Null
                Quote: Alf
                I wonder if anyone tried to search for foreign accounts of the Tandem?

                Putin’s accounts, remember, the Americans were looking for.

                Quote: Alf
                And how did it end for him

                Deep disappointment request

                In the early 90s, the government of the dead hired a well-known American firm specializing in just such cases to search for the "party gold". And the Americans found this money. They brought detailed documents "how much, where, to what account, who is the OWNER" to the Kremlin. They accepted the documents, paid for the services of the company, and BELIEVED to FORGET about it.
                1. -1
                  10 August 2019 21: 38
                  A beautiful fairy tale ... why did you say that now?

                  To your previous question and my answer to it all this mayya has nothing to do with ... well, that is, no request
        4. -3
          13 August 2019 09: 08
          Quote: Underwater Hunter
          And what are we producing now,

          In our country, only artisanal production is growing, and the time-delayed one is in place
    3. +30
      8 August 2019 16: 07
      Quote: Underwater Hunter
      But this is half the trouble, the trouble is that Putin and even more so Medvedev do not think so and do nothing ..

      You say we have problems. Who is it with us? Do we have public ownership of the means of production and a classless state? No.
      So this is your problem, but the citizens of Putin, Chubais, Sechin, Miller, etc. no problem.
      They are more than happy with everything, and they are just very actively making efforts so that everything remains the same.
      1. -9
        9 August 2019 11: 31
        Private problems will always be and everyone should solve them exclusively himself. And the problems of the COUNTRY are separate, do not be confused.
        1. +13
          9 August 2019 13: 02
          Dear Victor. I don't quite understand what you mean by the particular problems and problems of the country. Raising and raising a child is a private or public problem? Is taking care of the health of a citizen of Russia a private or state problem? Etc. Any Russian citizen has problems. As the saying goes: "No man, no problem." But if there are no people, there will be no state. Citizens of Russia pay taxes to the state so that the state has the resources to solve internal economic problems. Citizens of Russia, through elections, delegate their rights to the President of the country so that he can use these resources to improve the lives of his citizens. But if this does not happen, then the words of the Nobel laureate in physics come to mind: “If a citizen is forced to pay for education and medical care, to accumulate a pension from his own funds, to pay housing and utilities in full, at market prices, then why do I need such a state ?! Why on earth should I still pay taxes and maintain an insane army of officials? I have always said at all levels that health care, education and science should be provided from the budget. If the state dumps this concern on ourselves, let it disappear, it will be much easier for us! "- Zhores Ivanovich Alferov
          1. -6
            9 August 2019 14: 30
            Divide the problems 50 by 50.
          2. -10
            9 August 2019 19: 30
            Raising children, taking care of their health and well-being should be each SAM. When MY ancestors created this state in hard work, they deliberately shared what they could, wanting only protection from the state for themselves and their relatives. No one had in mind to wait for favors! On the contrary, they went to protect sacrificing themselves. My ancestors served and believed that I would continue their work. Maybe your ancestors were hoping for retirement?
    4. +24
      8 August 2019 16: 31
      A month ago, an increase in meat prices was officially announced - remember? -- on 10%. Then - for sugar. Well, the sugar in the warehouses, you see, the rubble, we ourselves produce in abundance, there are reserves, so for now we must trade with the previous margin - in accordance with invoices. However, the greedy "Pyaterochka" immediately rushed to raise the price to 50 or more rubles per 1 kg, but either she was besieged, or she whipped herself. Nevertheless, as soon as the stocks according to the documents run out, sugar will go up in price.
      Further, a very recent message is that prices are rising for cheese. Here is a very interesting story. It turns out palm oil was taxed with grace
      VAT at 10%, and now it has been increased to equal with all other imported products. The press warned: in connection with the increase in VAT for palm trees, expect a price increase not only for cheese, but for all milk and confectionery, because palm trees are not added! But the increase in prices for these foods has already taken place since the beginning of the year. So more?
      And now, no later than today, there was a sharp increase in prices for brown bread. Emphasized: sharp!
      But the price of black bread has already risen from 27 rubles to 32 immediately after the New Year, and the size of the loaf has decreased! At least where I live. And when I reported this here, in VO, they waved their hands at me, they say, is not true. So somewhere in the bakeries in stocks were stocks of flour, purchased at past prices.
      It turns out that every week, quietly and inconspicuously, prices are consistently, steadily, and quite officially raised for one group of products, then for the second and so on. The government message flashed in the news and immediately disappeared, almost unnoticed by anyone, and the average man thinks: where does the money go? Why were they missing?
      So, quietly and imperceptibly, the recession creeps into each family, but only the poorest segments of the population notice its arrival. As well as Oreshkin, Siluanov, Nabiulina and others, who are anxiously looking at the graph of the economy’s sliding, they say: it’s necessary! They were expecting her in the 21st, well, at worst, in the 20th, and she - here she is! And they complain: joining the oligarchs to the development of money, the injection of which into Putin’s national projects, of which 12 is expected by the end of the year, could be the beginning of the development of these funds, therefore, revive the economy, slow down the recession, or even eliminate it, but the oligarchs Do not rush to participate. Do not want? Seem to be.
      1. -4
        9 August 2019 14: 32
        Palm oil has risen in price - it’s good, less will be added to this dairy in all dairy products.
      2. +4
        9 August 2019 16: 57
        I don’t know, maybe for some it will be a revelation, but palm oil in huge quantities goes to mayonnaise. Keep in mind.
        1. -3
          9 August 2019 21: 26
          Obviously not a technical palm oil in mayonnaise.
          1. +2
            9 August 2019 22: 33
            A little bit about palm oil.
            He has the main characteristic of harmfulness - a certain peroxide. In Europe, palm oil with a peroxide value of up to 0,5 is allowed; in perfumery - up to 2; in fuel production - up to 2,5.

            In Russia, it is allowed to add palm oil with peroxide up to 10 (!) In food.
            Read the telegram.
            1. -3
              9 August 2019 22: 41
              Quote: vasiliev yu
              In Russia, it is allowed to add palm oil with peroxide to 10 in food

              The link to the document by which it is "allowed" - to the studio. At the same time - where does the data about Evr, opu come from and what kind of "peroxide" is there.

              Otherwise blah blah blah request

              Quote: vasiliev yu
              Read Telegram

              Do not pull the mouth byak, spit immediately laughing

              PS: "with peroxide up to 10" - ten of what? Meters, tons, percent ??
              1. +4
                9 August 2019 22: 57
                “You can do without coffee.
                Can.
                And without good cars, is it possible?
                Can.
                And without good clothes you can.
                And without quality porcelain.
                You can without good cheese and without good cigarettes.
                It is possible without good chocolates and good roads.
                You can without good panties and without good lipstick.
                Without good, high-quality spirits, it is possible without a good sausage.
                Without good medicine and without good shoes ....
                But I don’t understand - in the name of what?
                What do we get in return?
                Why were we forced to do without all this? Why are we slowly but surely again driven into the Soviet Union, where there is the word "get it"?
                Why do people write to me in the comments - do you want us to send you good products?
                Am I in a blockade? What ... organized this blockade for me?
                After all, when the union collapsed, in the nineties, with which everyone here so frighteningly frightened us, all this was and now all of this was again taken away from us.
                In the name of what?
                Is there a war here? Everything for the front, everything for the victory?
                No.
                Or can we eat, drink, wear shit and deny ourselves quality treatment in order to build schools and hospitals in the country with the money saved?
                No.
                Or maybe we are building some incredibly expensive strategically important object for the country like a hydroelectric power station? And all the money there?
                No.
                So what ... they write to me that I can live without it?
                Who decided this?
                I want to know who decided that I can and should take smelly Russian palm oil instead of chocolate?
                Who?
                And why are you telling me this?
                Do you agree?
                Your right. Eat at least earthworms. This is your consonant, and you can do anything with you, stuffing your pockets, scaring you from the nineties and forcing you to see enemies in all adequate countries.
                What am I to do with it?
                I do not see the purpose of all this sacrifice at the cost of my comfort. I don’t want to live in the name of Putin and his close associates, who definitely do not drink Russian coffee and eat no Russian shit. ”
                From the Telegram.
                Do you consider yourself smart? So get a little smart and look at any search engine for 'palm oil peroxide'.
                1. -7
                  9 August 2019 23: 13
                  Oh, water has flowed ... and what kind of crying is Yaroslavna, may I ask? wink

                  Quote: vasiliev yu
                  look in any search engine 'palm oil peroxide'

                  For the words, that is, we do not want to answer? My friend, I am a physicist by first education ... "palm oil peroxide" - nothing, there is no such thing in nature request

                  And, yes, buddy ... on you - with drinking companions. Here - on you, please. It’s accepted here Yes
                  1. +2
                    9 August 2019 23: 22
                    So, after all, does a smart chemist lack the intelligence of a search engine?
                    1. -3
                      9 August 2019 23: 32
                      Quote: vasiliev yu
                      So, after all, does a smart chemist lack the intelligence of a search engine?

                      Trolling is bad, buddy laughing

                      And with what fright will I seek confirmation of your words? You said - you and prove that not blah blah blah Yes
                      1. +3
                        10 August 2019 05: 05
                        Why don't you prove it blah blah blah?
                        Or doesn’t it fit in your head?
                        What is your correct speech ... The right kid from the gateway.
                        It was necessary to add: And for the words, will you answer? Give a tooth?
                      2. -3
                        10 August 2019 08: 43
                        Quote: vasiliev yu
                        Why don't you prove it blah blah blah?

                        Russell's Teapot - have you heard of this?

                        I do not have to prove that the opponent said stupidity. On the contrary this approver is required to prove that he said no stupidity. In a decent society, it’s accepted that way, you are now in a decent society, try ... to comply Yes

                        Quote: vasiliev yu
                        It was necessary to add: And for the words, will you answer? Give a tooth?

                        This is implied, glad that at least you understood this. laughing

                        So,

                        Quote: Cat Man Null
                        Quote: vasiliev yu
                        In Russia, it is allowed to add palm oil with peroxide to 10 in food

                        The link to the document, which is "allowed" - to the studio

                        Otherwise, blah blah blah request
    5. +3
      9 August 2019 07: 53
      Quote: Underwater Hunter
      We have problems absolutely everywhere (economics, politics, science, education, medicine, industry, etc.). Only blind people or trolls who work for money can not see this. But this is half the trouble, it’s completely a misfortune that Putin more Medvedev do not think so and do nothing ..


      Problems in everything, the source of problems is one.
    6. +6
      9 August 2019 09: 24
      Why do something? They are "stone". And let the plebs hold on. Only the phrase "women are still giving birth" in these realities no longer works. There is nothing to give birth to.
    7. -5
      9 August 2019 11: 13
      The underwater of the hunters! Reread yourself: EVERYTHING sees problems, and only Putin and Medvedev should take measures ?!
      1. +5
        9 August 2019 11: 36
        Quote: Victor N
        Reread yourself: EVERYTHING sees problems, and only Putin and Medvedev should take measures ?!

        CAN I answer your question (especially since I also wear a mask and a neoprene suit) - you know, when social changes in the country go from below, then this is usually a revolution, when development is set from above it usually has an evolutionary character .. .
        When a reformer (Ekaterina2, Petr1, Stalin) is at the head of the state, sets the pace and sets an example, it usually gives a stream of positive energy that creates change. From below, only a demolition of an established design is possible. The more changes are made from below, the more unstable the state structure is (remember the revolution of 17g.)
        1. -6
          9 August 2019 14: 37
          Of revolution, the lot of the herd of fools, he was one, is and will forever. Revolutions have never led to anything good, an ode to devastation, robbery and collapse in all spheres of society — its true germs.
          1. +5
            9 August 2019 21: 07
            Quote: Vadim237
            An ode to devastation, robbery and collapse in all spheres of the life of society are its true germs.

            sometimes you have to cut down a forest to build a city
            1. -6
              11 August 2019 00: 17
              Cutting down the forest is a pitfall for everyone, they will burn it like they did in 1917, like in 1991, like 2011 in Syria, like in 2014 in Ukraine - a fire burns the forest and spreads to the city - as a result, everything burns down.
        2. -8
          9 August 2019 19: 35
          Aybolit, well, why did you forget all so stupidly? OUR ancestors built the state from below. And everyone wishing to break broke off the horns ruthlessly, until in 1917 they relaxed: remember this!
          1. +3
            9 August 2019 21: 08
            Quote: Victor N
            until in 1917 they relaxed: remember this!

            something I did not fully understand your idea? who relaxed at 17?
      2. -2
        9 August 2019 17: 00
        Well, give me a gun and write out a license to shoot bureaucrats, I can take measures as much as I can.
        1. +1
          9 August 2019 19: 39
          Very unhealthy thoughts, very! The doctor can figure out and spank. And rightly so! One already promised to punish other people's children ......
        2. 0
          11 August 2019 17: 26
          You don't need a lot of cleverness for this, but you definitely won't do it when it comes to the "dick" sofa?
    8. +8
      9 August 2019 11: 51
      Quote: Underwater Hunter
      But this is half the trouble, the trouble is that Putin and even more so Medvedev do not think so and do nothing ..

      I will assume that Putin and Medvedev have no troubles.
    9. +3
      9 August 2019 12: 22
      Of course, when Gorbachev was better, they heard ... they hung noodles on their ears ... They were happy about democracy and new thinking wink .And even better was under Yeltsin ... laughed. But. survived ... What do you want from the "children of the democrat" Sobchak? and their liberal ideology.
      Who do you want for the highest power?
      Zyuganov. Zhirinovsky.? So these are the children of the same papa. Only both graze on the same field. One threshes under the Marxist. The other is clearly against Marxism. But the slogans are all Leninist .. Who?
      Understand. In whose hands the Russian economy is now .. its financial system .. media .....
      1. +1
        9 August 2019 14: 27
        Quote: To be or not to be
        Understand. In whose hands the Russian economy is now .. its financial system .. media .....

        +++ would you advise what and where to read?
    10. 0
      11 August 2019 17: 17
      These problems are relevant for the vast majority of states, incl. and "civilized" and they depend not only on the authorities of individual states, but on the development of the world economy. Only trolls can not know about this .......
  2. -17
    8 August 2019 15: 18
    So, my dear lovers blurt out something with a smart look ...
    And what is the article about?
    No, really, let's figure it out!
    Where is the promised parsing?
    Or the whole article was conceived just for the sake of this phrase:
    Damned Crimea!
    ?
    1. +7
      9 August 2019 09: 26
      An article about life in Wonderland. And Crimea has nothing to do with it.
  3. +22
    8 August 2019 15: 19
    It is felt that the author writes about a sore point, a rather harsh, even evil article, but ... But that’s how it really is.
  4. +23
    8 August 2019 15: 23
    “For many years, a lot of defense industry enterprises, instead of investing in development, have been forced to engage only in servicing interest to creditor banks, unwittingly programming their scientific, production and technological backwardness. At the end of the 90s, Defense Minister Igor Sergeev actively prevented this, but his mission soon was completed, after which the process went along the predetermined path. Consequences - large-scale impoverishment of many enterprises of the defense industry. The principle of optimization of credit and financial relations began to dominate industrial policy. Along with this, its primary and integral part - science - became a bargaining chip in the struggle for zones of influence between various power and clan structures. The symptoms of man-made disease for the vast majority of defense industry enterprises were refusals to conclude contracts or postponement of their execution to a later date, increasing debt obligations and maximum restrictions on access to the required amount of credit resources, in the morning at a competitive advantage in terms of wages, personnel aging, a decrease in the level of competence, etc. "
    Nikolay Mikhailov, Doctor of Economics, laureate of the USSR and RF State Prizes. The newspaper "Military Industrial Courier", No. 30 (793), August 6, 2019.
    1. -17
      8 August 2019 15: 53
      Lack of orders, lack of knowledge of market economy guidelines and lack of competitive products for the civilian sector destroyed most of the factories, as well as the defense industry enterprises, in the 90s and early 2000s. In the USSR, all equipment was operated until it fell apart, a vivid example of which are two dozen machines manufactured in Germany in 1937 at a pilot plant in the Volgograd Region - which I saw in 1999.
  5. BAI
    +7
    8 August 2019 15: 25
    in Russia they again talked about the possibility of a recession

    There is no and there can be no recession. All officials at the very top said this responsibly and returned 10% of the salaries to government officials. And if the decline, then what ?:
    1. It turns out that someone before the president brought the wrong information.
    2. it is necessary to select 10% back.
    It is obvious to everyone that it is completely impossible to recognize and do the above.
    1. -19
      8 August 2019 15: 56
      For Russia, "May Decrees" worth 27 trillion rubles, until 24, is now a locomotive and hope for economic growth.
      1. +6
        8 August 2019 20: 49
        Vadim .. You are a straight joker .. when this social sphere was "a locomotive and hope for economic growth" social sphere is the norm as a result of development, but not a locomotive .. In the sense of the fact, the question is that in the May decrees about the economy, in your opinion, is in a straight line implementation? The question is direct, clear and requiring the same answer .. I am really interested in the answer - where in the May decrees is seen ALREADY a driving locomotive of development? do not consider it difficult - conduct an educational program
        1. -5
          9 August 2019 14: 47
          You know what would provide a social network - and these are hospitals, kindergartens, health centers, equipment for them, you need materials, means of production jobs and much more - than not the development of production, with industry, science, transport infrastructure, agriculture the same without new production facilities - nothing of the above will be. 27 trillion in May decrees - this is our modern industrialization.
    2. +7
      8 August 2019 17: 18
      BAL, adding salaries to officials does not increase inflation. They take out most of their money for shopping and leisure abroad - their salaries allow this. Or they put them in offshore, buy real estate, start their own business abroad. This is how this layer of the population extinguishes possible inflation from higher wages. And you try, increase the pension and not as it is now, but much more significantly. So an irresponsible pensioner will immediately run after shopping and finally get enough of food, as well as buy new clothes instead of old ones, which have been frayed for more than 10 years.
      This morning, the throaty old woman from the next entrance, torturing me with a scream under my kitchen window (I’m sick, warming myself with gas), in two visits told different people that she was 82 years old (now I know!), And she had to deny herself everything to buy a good one food for his dog - there is a dog with a gulkin nose. And what kind of trips are there abroad to extinguish inflation in the native land!
      1. -2
        9 August 2019 11: 43
        Starve yourself, but feed the dog (kitty) - these are symptoms of acute mental illness! But there are so many of them, huge! There isn’t enough hospital at all. A large amount of advertising - this is because of the large revenues. (who's talking about beggars here?).
      2. 0
        9 August 2019 13: 06
        Quote: depressant
        BAL, adding salaries to officials does not increase inflation.

        Apparently you think this is the best way to fight inflation ...
      3. -3
        9 August 2019 14: 48
        We have such officials - 10 thousand maxim, the rest do not possess such means.
  6. +11
    8 August 2019 15: 29
    To discuss such a question is the same as a polemic about the health of a deceased ...
  7. -19
    8 August 2019 15: 38
    Therefore, let's agree that any of us living in Russia has both the basis and the right to give performance evaluations to our esteemed government

    This technique of trying life experience on things that cannot be measured by this experience was criticized a lot in Suzhorov (Rezun) kryzhonka.
    The government is engaged in a number of things that are not measured by any philistine experience, and also are not always advertised. Therefore, the majority can evaluate the government only at the household level - in the part where they see its direct influence (and not everyone sees it).
    I can speak out about pension reform, but about the capacity of the oil derivatives market - I can’t.
    I can’t say what percentage of GDP should be deducted for medicine.
    Therefore, the author of the article, we can’t evaluate everything, but we can evaluate the final influence of the government on our lives - from the most intrusive advertising, megayachts of oligarchs to microloans for the purchase of bread.
    1. +9
      8 August 2019 17: 11
      How can we evaluate the work of the government regarding the prices and quality of FISH in our stores?
      For many years they have been "pounding water in a mortar", but selling "over the hill" is easier!
      Recently from the "zombie" -
      No one will sell COD for $ 2 per KG in Russia if abroad gives 5!
      We cannot fight this! MARKET

      Just how BAD!
    2. +6
      8 August 2019 20: 52
      I mean, in the government of which demigods we do not understand? why not understand - there are not enough brains, information, the Internet? broader idea please state ...
    3. 0
      9 August 2019 11: 45
      And his own influence on his life: is everyone able to objectively evaluate?
  8. -9
    8 August 2019 15: 40
    "In addition, the lowest indicators of the use of budget funds were recorded in national projects that could have the greatest multiplier effect -" Increasing labor productivity and supporting employment "(the budget was executed by 17,7%)," Safe and high-quality roads "(budget executed by 12,2%), "Digital economy of the Russian Federation" (budget executed by 8,3%) ". Only in how many years would the effect of this appear.
    1. +4
      8 August 2019 18: 17
      Yes, I also made an attempt to figure out what is happening, what is wrong with us.
      Unwinding back along the chain, I got on the production sharing law. The beginning of the development of the law is February 95. The main role in its creation was assigned to the Yabloko Duma faction. So, it was Yabloko, contrary to the opinion of the Duma members, who consistently gave the law a form that put our country in the position of an official colony of the West and especially the United States. And they, the United States, were already in full control and completely exported valuable military and other enterprises and secret documentation on the latest developments. Yeltsin was a dancer with them and exerted terrible pressure on the Duma. The Duma members resisted, over and over again, rejecting the law. But in December 95 the law was pushed through by Yeltsin, the Duma members surrendered. After all, they still remembered the shooting of parliament in 93, it was fresh, and the drunken Yeltsin was not immune from bouts of inadequacy. From that moment on, Russia became a colony of the West, and 264, if I am mistaken - correct, the largest and most valuable mineral deposits were transferred to the West. In all the companies for their development, Western capitalists became the main ones, and the local ones were introduced to the boards of directors to communicate with the "natives" workers. At the same time, many did not unfasten anything to the Russian budget, motivating them with constantly growing costs. And this was allowed by the law! In order to somehow live, Russia got into debt and could not unfasten the interest in time, there was a default. Primakov saved the day. But Yeltsin found himself in a dire situation. The future oligarchs made demands on him: for what did we surrender the USSR? To give the wealth of Russia to foreigners, and not get it yourself? The disadvantaged people made claims to him: where is the promised capitalist paradise? Unable to resolve the situation, fearing universal anger, the traitor Yeltsin gave the presidency to Putin. To avoid reprisals. Quite simply, he chickened out. For as many as two years - from 2003 to 2004 - Putin pushed through amendments to the production sharing law and pushed through, which made it possible to somewhat soften the colonial position of Russia. Part of the income from the activities of foreigners in our territory began to flow into the budget. But even this part would be enough for an explosive growth of the economy, if, according to the production sharing law, which provides for the presence of foreigners on the board of directors of any of our large enterprises and large medium-sized ones, it did not turn us into a colony deprived of the right to make independent economic decisions.
      The production sharing law should be repealed.
    2. +4
      9 August 2019 07: 59
      "In addition, the lowest indicators of the use of budget funds were recorded in national projects that could have the greatest multiplier effect -" Increasing labor productivity and supporting employment "(the budget was executed by 17,7%)," Safe and high-quality roads "(budget executed by 12,2%), "Digital economy of the Russian Federation" (budget executed by 8,3%) "

      Vadim, do you know what this is talking about? That all these national projects were fiction, the same as the newly made "May decrees", nothing to do with the real state of affairs.
      1. -2
        9 August 2019 14: 52
        Why, all of them are being carried out just not as fast as we would like - one of them is housing construction, 82 million square meters are built in Russia a year.
  9. +4
    8 August 2019 15: 47
    There is money in the country, you can see the desire of the country's leadership to improve something (after all, it’s not far from the next swamp area) and intelligent managers (ineffective managers) are not enough. The basic principle of personnel selection in state structures is “stupid but loyal” or by tribal nepotism, contests for filling vacant executive positions are sheer fiction and everything stretches along the entire vertical from the government to the very land it is necessary to change the system of public administration radically otherwise we will be trailing in the tail
    1. 0
      9 August 2019 12: 26
      Putin came up with the competition "Leaders of Russia" to mobilize managers, uses the ONF ..... That's right! How else to select personnel? I, now, did not come up with ...
  10. +11
    8 August 2019 15: 49
    If in the State Duma, EP will be in the minority, then there will be hope for economic growth. If not, we are waiting for a revolution.
    1. -2
      9 August 2019 12: 33
      Weak grounds for your hopes ..... And about the revolution ...... Re-read the classics - "Walking through the agony", "Quiet Don" ..... Only thoughtfully: people endured tremendous anguish, the country was falling into ashes .. ... No more revolutions!
    2. 0
      9 August 2019 14: 57
      Unfortunately, there will not be - for the economy to grow, it is necessary to increase production - of all, and for this it is necessary to find those who will be interested in these products - there will be no these guys, no growth whatsoever, at least whom you put in the State Duma and the government.
  11. +4
    8 August 2019 15: 49
    The recession ... Inflation targeting ... Titov with Kudrin ... Excuse me, Viktor Kuzovkov, but this is an economic essay-pichchikato, and it seems to me that the author decided to just make himself clear to us. Curse Marx, who laid out everything long ago. Overthrow the theorists of the economics of the socialist system from heaven and hope for growth ...
    Just explain with a few sentences in a dialect popular in Russia how growth is possible in the created way. Naturally, I cannot deny that there should be growth, but only among the narrow circle in whose jurisdiction the right to distribute ...
    But after all national projects really are the last hope for economic growth in modern Russia.

    If you think that national projects are a panacea, a growth stimulator, then let's decide what you mean by them?
    If this is some kind of theory "to live happily ever after" proposed from below, then "OH"! fellow
    And if these are the next "supreme" breakthroughs, monthly decrees, orders of a teacher of Roman law or the development of a manager - a hired specialist in the distribution of public goods - then there will be something that has been going on for a long time, but the results are frail ...
    hi
  12. +1
    8 August 2019 15: 54
    A certain forecast was made by a certain Institute of Growth Economics named after Stolypin, headed by the notorious business ombudsman (how many words were dragged into our language!) Boris Titov.
    The Stolypin Institute for Growth Economics was established on the basis of the Stolypin Club, it is preparing a program for the development of the Russian economy until 2025. The issue of bringing the Russian economy to a growth rate not lower than the world average was initiated by the President of the Russian Federation. The head of state instructed the development of relevant proposals to the Ministry of Economic Development, the Center for Strategic Research headed by Alexei Kudrin and the Stolypin Institute for Growth Economics. The Institute is working on its mid-term program at the analytical center under the government of the Russian Federation. According to the Institute, building a "Growth Economy" model in the country is a chance to keep Russia among the world's leading countries. So, this is not some kind of Institute, the President himself blessed it for the feats of economic growth and development. This is not an NGO, some kind of you understand ... Everything grows here and blooms, but there are some drawbacks, there are few parking lots, but there is no place to put cars. And the "national projects" are the most, the most .. How will they earn. The time has not come yet.
  13. The comment was deleted.
    1. -1
      9 August 2019 15: 01
      Where is outside the Moscow Ring Road - in what region, if you have devastation there on the ground - I must say thank you to myself and to my own guys in the "localities": district, regional, city, rural municipalities.
      1. +4
        9 August 2019 23: 42
        Can you imagine! All of Russia outside the Moscow Ring Road .. and our region is even more so. "Thank you" every day we say for the resources of our vast and gone into oblivion city and weight sold for hundreds of trillions of dollars. And our patient people, they endure everyone, regional and regional, and city, and others ... There is no money, but you hold on there!
        1. -3
          11 August 2019 00: 23
          You don’t need to talk about all of Russia - you weren’t all over Russia, but I was: Moscow, St. Petersburg, Volgograd, Sochi, Astrakhan, Novosibirsk, Kazan, Yamal, Yekaterinburg, Irkutsk, Khabarovsk - everywhere my partners and customers of the products. There are enough changes for the better.
  14. -24
    8 August 2019 16: 54
    In the comments, all the prowlers expectedly amicably voted.
    Especially for them:
    They vote not because there are no problems, but because they believe in their solution. Believe in the country.
    and you do not believe. In any case. regardless of the presence of problems.
    1. +11
      8 August 2019 20: 55
      Sergey .. You believe another 25 years .. but for example I already want pleasant facts .. faith is the case .. like in Santa Claus .. you believe you believe ... and then I realized .. there is none, my friend .. not at all
      1. -4
        9 August 2019 12: 43
        Vasya n - believe only in yourself !!! Do not expect anything from wow - well, there is no reason for this! To help specifically - NOBODY is required. If something falls into a particular citizen, then only from the redistribution of public goods (bread, circuses) which can never be much. Roman plebs hung on them - and disappeared .....
        My home is my castle! In all senses. The other is deception and self-deception.
        1. +2
          9 August 2019 21: 04
          Victor, I believe in myself, I have not expected anything from anyone in this world for a long time and I provide myself .. but does this mean that this is the merit of the officials, and not my many years of round-the-clock work? or does this mean that I should not care about what is happening in the country, since I have enough for myself? why it shouldn’t matter to me that I spent my life several years to achieve something, and someone who built on a warm place for a couple of months doesn’t get his money, which could be spent in the hole in my yard, and not for his vacation in Courchevel to go? or all of the above is normal and there is no need to think about them, is everything all right at home?
          1. -2
            10 August 2019 22: 05
            You are right in everything. Just think less about officials. And so: our country, the soul hurts, you can’t steal .... from the beginning of the centuries. It is necessary to speak out, but only when there is something to offer to improve the order. And oh, how difficult!
    2. +6
      9 August 2019 08: 08
      Quote: Mestny
      In the comments, all the prowlers expectedly amicably voted.
      Especially for them:
      They vote not because there are no problems, but because they believe in their solution. Believe in the country.
      and you do not believe. In any case. regardless of the presence of problems.


      but because believe in their decision
      You need to believe in temples. They suck out faith from your finger. And as for the state’s structure, you need to know. You need to have knowledge. A person with knowledge is a hundred times more difficult to fool. Therefore, they want to replace knowledge with faith.
      1. -3
        9 August 2019 15: 04
        Believe in yourself, your decisions and actions.
  15. -5
    8 August 2019 16: 59
    Quote: Fevralsk. Morev
    If in the State Duma, EP will be in the minority, then there will be hope for economic growth

    there will be hope anyway, but why didn’t it grow under Putin before the organization of United Russia?
    Is there a batch in stock?
    1. +13
      8 August 2019 17: 21
      Resurrected Stalin in our era, comes to a meeting of the Duma. All were numb, silent. He says:
      - So, shoot all Democrats, and repaint the mausoleum in green!
      From the back rows, someone timidly asks:
      - And why in green?
      Stalin:
      - I thought that on the first question there will be no disagreements
  16. -17
    8 August 2019 17: 10
    What growth is there when everything is in sanctions and surrounded by NATO! Stability is already an achievement in our position ..
    Remember Obama said to the whole world "Russia's economy is torn to shreds" hehe
    We hold on to men, we are stubborn Russians and remember the 90s .. hi
  17. +14
    8 August 2019 17: 18
    Putin and the government have long been dismissed!
    1. +3
      9 August 2019 10: 13
      It’s time for Zakharchenko ..
    2. -4
      9 August 2019 15: 06
      And it’s time to send you to work along the way.
  18. +1
    8 August 2019 17: 23
    Inflation is a terrible beast and unkillable, at least target it, at least torpedo it, it is growing like the most malicious weed and there is no need to water it. That's just salaries and pensions well, not like growth does not want. It’s a pity to look at the poor economists, they began to look like driven horses. Maybe they already need help?
  19. +8
    8 August 2019 17: 44
    Quote: hohol95
    We cannot fight this! MARKET

    the struggle ends elementarily in a matter of months.
    rewriting the conditions of licenses and quotas for fishing, entering and fulfilling conditions under which it is not profitable to deceive, losing the license for fishing, the state contractor for guaranteed purchase and harvesting of fish and the general contract for delivery in the network in combination with the obligation of the networks to keep a share of the frozen fish assortment.
    all. a few months and the process will go. This is the regulation of the market at the level of 2 course econom. more qualifications and no need.
  20. +2
    8 August 2019 17: 48
    Quote: astepanov
    Where are they, determined, young, competent managers with experience in public service in high positions and not stained by theft?
    What far to go - the Minister of Agriculture of Russia - is determined, relatively young, competent manager, had experience, theft spots on him are not visible lol You can also give examples of "determined, young, literate".

    And the Titov Institute has a strange name: not the growth of the Economy, but the economy of Growth. Moneylenders ...
    1. -1
      9 August 2019 12: 00
      Quote: Azis
      Minister of Agriculture of Russia - determined, relatively young, competent manager, had experience, theft spots on him are not visible

      Do not scare ahead of time, otherwise God forbid it will be with agriculture, as with a bank under his leadership.
    2. -2
      9 August 2019 15: 09
      With agriculture, everything is better than everyone - the only 40000 bee families died this summer - and most likely this was due to weather conditions, and not pesticides - they used the same thing last year, but there were no such bees.
  21. -13
    8 August 2019 17: 58
    To all pseudo-liberals and all-crawlers and not only !!!! Read the memoirs of E. Primakov
    "8 months plus." Interesting reading! He is, of course, a diplomat-intelligence officer and you will not find any sensations there .. But "the devil is in the details" .. Much can be understood in economic and political terms, even in the current situation .. Read, analyze, reflect .. hi
    A strong and independent Russia is feared to death in the west and especially inside the country "bloodsucking bugs" This is my slogan as usual fellow ... Should break through, but not an easy thing, judging even by our site .. hi
  22. +11
    8 August 2019 18: 11
    "But what about this information available in other sources:" now they will explain to you that:
    1. Sources lie
    2. This is the heavy legacy of the "Yeltsin gang"
    3. These are unbridled liberals in the government
    4. All yards are lined with cars
    5. "I am the daughter of an officer and I live well on a social pension in Moscow ..."
    6. Look at the USA, England ... (any western country as desired)
    7. The author pours water on the mill of the State Department.
  23. +1
    8 August 2019 18: 31
    Why did I say that?
  24. Quote: Vadim237
    Everything is clear with industry - there will be sales markets and production growth, as long as we have from 3 to 6% per year


    You have some kind of your own Rosstat ... what country do you live in?
    Russian GDP in 2018 grew by 2,3%. This first assessment was published on Monday by Rosstat.
    In 2017, Russia's GDP grew by 1,6%, in 2016 increased by 0,3%, in 2015 fell by 2,5%, in 2014 increased by 0,7%, in 2013 increased by 1,8 %, in 2012 jumped by 3,7%.
    I’m translating the SPEAKING-LANGUAGE of Rosstat into the RUSSIAN LANGUAGE, I consider:
    2011- 100%, 2012-103,7%, 2013-105,3%, 2014-106%, 2015- 103,4%, 2016-103,7%, 2017-105,3%, 2018-107,6 %
    Total: in 2018, we produced 7% more than in 2011.
    1. -2
      8 August 2019 19: 09
      Read carefully:

      Quote: Lieutenant Colonel of the USSRF Air Force in reserve
      production growth

      и

      Quote: Lieutenant Colonel of the USSRF Air Force in reserve
      Russian GDP grew

      - these are slightly different "growths".

      Quote: Lieutenant Colonel of the USSRF Air Force in reserve
      Total: in 2018 year we produced 7% more than in 2011 year

      It is not true. Go google what GDP is request
      1. -3
        8 August 2019 19: 16
        Quote: Cat Man Null
        It is not true. Go google what GDP is

        Are you a troll here again? wassat In vain you send them to Google and Vika .. This is the same as to send to the "godfather" in the operative department to ask when they will release me)))))
        1. 0
          8 August 2019 19: 53
          Quote: koks
          Are you a troll here again?

          I told you a hundred times already - Bukhan, tie a wave request
          1. 0
            8 August 2019 20: 36
            Quote: Cat Man Null
            Quote: koks
            Are you a troll here again?

            I told you a hundred times already - Bukhan, tie a wave request

            Well, "google or look in the wiki" is already an insult in the internet .. Only affects young people ..))) So what's good here to promote Yavolt?
  25. Quote: Azis
    theft

    ***
    Siz emas politics - economy belasan!
    Tkachev - former governor of the Krasnodar Territory!
    Krasnodar Territory - Kushchevka!
  26. Quote: astepanov
    Quote: Underwater Hunter
    Therefore, in politics, as well as in economics, there is also a crisis ..
    The problem is that there isn't much to choose from either. Who can not just replace Putin and Medvedev, but restructure the work of the entire government in a constructive manner, find optimal solutions for the economy, and reliably cement the authorities for the sake of overall growth? Where are they, determined, young, competent managers who have experience in civil service in high positions and who have not stained themselves with theft? Can anyone name by name? The clan system does not allow such to appear. And the fact that the present state REALLY managed to get out of the terrible pit of the nineties - remember - the collapsed army, the war in Chechnya, the chaos of crime, months without wages - makes people think: "The main thing is that it doesn't get worse." And I understand the concern of these people. Therefore, it will probably be as it is: a sluggish long-term slide to the next crisis, an increase in protest moods, then - God forbid - an explosion with bloody scraps and a new difficult crawling out of the abyss.

    ***
    "The problem is that there isn't much to choose from either. Who can not just replace Putin and Medvedev, but restructure the work of the entire government in a constructive manner, find optimal solutions for the economy, and reliably cement the authorities for the sake of overall growth?"

    Well, yes, out of 140+ million there is no one! You have now called 140+ million Russians idiots! Found irreplaceable and irreplaceable!
    Well, come on, let's look for "Varangians"!
    Xi Jinping will do?
  27. Quote: koks
    What growth is there when everything is in sanctions and surrounded by NATO! Stability is already an achievement in our position ..
    Remember Obama said to the whole world "Russia's economy is torn to shreds" hehe
    We hold on to men, we are stubborn Russians and remember the 90s .. hi


    ***
    Sanctions ... so much for the benefit, argued not so long ago ....
    Reminded of an old joke ...
    Paratroopers are jumping. Everyone jumped out, one does not jump.
    Senior - to the paratrooper:
    “Why don't you jump?”
    - Yes, I jumped 10 times and the parachute did not open.
    “Nothing, this time it will open,” says the elder and pushes the guy.
    At this time, a meeting is taking place on one of the collective farms.
    The chairman scolds the people: "What kind of business is this? The cows are not milked, the meadows are not mowed, the forage is not delivered ... (here the crash of a collapsed roof is heard from the neighboring barn) ... and this paratrooper zadolbal !!!"
  28. +7
    8 August 2019 19: 37
    Recession, inflation, targeting, economics ... With other words, we disperse hands like fog. When will you get tired of chewing this chaff? Why does a foreign American expert on global strategies and international relations E. Luttvak tell us - “If I were the president of Russia, I would measure my achievements in the number of people born in the country”?
    1. -2
      8 August 2019 19: 43
      Quote: Alexander Ra
      Why does a foreign American expert on global strategies and international relations E. Luttvak tell us - “If I were the president of Russia, I would ...

      ... I would be for the father king
      Gave birth to a hero ...

      Inspired request

      And the "expert" says this for one simple reason: he is not the President of the Russian Federation, and never will be. The Russian Federation has a lot of problems, and the demographic one is just one of many.
      1. +5
        8 August 2019 22: 04
        Yes, there are a lot of problems, they are dealt with, but the task is not to eliminate them. Since they are naturally inherent in the "proposed" lifestyle. Alien lifestyle, alien vocabulary. It was also inspired - as in the story of Khazanov - "We entered into ... igO."
        1. -4
          8 August 2019 22: 10
          Quote: Alexander Ra
          they are being dealt with, but the task is not to eliminate them

          Eliminate - what, sorry?

          Quote: Alexander Ra
          Alien lifestyle, alien vocabulary

          The way of life, yes, has changed abruptly ... with the lexicon all the rules - the word "galosha" was not always originally Russian either request
          1. +2
            9 August 2019 06: 20
            Quote: Cat Man Null
            Eliminate - what, sorry?

            Generalized - pathogenic factors that threaten the existence of our population. Elimination, first of all, using the template - “predators of overwhelming power”, not physically, but the conditions of their appearance. You yourself can continue a number of these factors.
            The way of life is not just abruptly changed, but catastrophically - the ratio of information between one's own and that of another is unacceptable for adaptation.
            1. -4
              9 August 2019 07: 09
              Quote: Alexander Ra
              Generalized - pathogenic factors threatening the existence of our population

              Clear. Again "for all the good."

              The ways of such transformations are real - see? Me not.

              Quote: Alexander Ra
              Elimination, first of all, using the template - “predators of overwhelming power”, not physically, but the conditions of their appearance

              It seems not a child, according to the judge. And believe in fairy tales.

              Useless conversation. About nothing request
              1. +2
                9 August 2019 07: 43
                If you do not see such paths - it does not matter, someone else will see. Any sorceress grandmother will easily explain the technique: parasites are either crushed or driven out, there is no need to invent a bicycle.
                Russians in "fairy tales" have always lived, except for the last three decades. Before Christianity there were no masters in Russia. Under Peter, 1 was 8; before the revolution, 6; in the USSR, 4-6. Today is 16-30. Over 10 - slavery, 10 - a qualitative transition in the pyramid of energies, these are not my personal intellects, but biology and environmental laws.
                1. -4
                  9 August 2019 07: 58
                  Here is a funny pattern: if fans of "all the best" ask about the specifics, they immediately either start throwing slogans or get abstracted laughing

                  You - from the second, it seems.

                  Quote: Alexander Ra
                  Any sorceress grandmother will easily explain the technique

                  Have you already explained?

                  Quote: Alexander Ra
                  parasites either crush or expel

                  Fine good

                  Let's crush-banish. We get the same 90s when nothing worked, and the salary was paid ... than it should and irregularly. About pensions, yes, you can immediately forget - where did the money come from, Zin? wink

                  Do you want this, or are you hoping for a miracle? Optimist, damn it ...

                  Quote: Alexander Ra
                  decipher

                  And the words are kind of correct ... just about anything. I repeat:

                  Quote: Cat Man Null
                  The ways of such transformations are real - see? Me not

                  There is no quick fix. Slow - are implemented, but take time. Not everyone will survive (s).
              2. +2
                9 August 2019 08: 36
                Quote: Cat Man Null
                Quote: Alexander Ra
                Generalized - pathogenic factors threatening the existence of our population

                Clear. Again "for all the good."

                The ways of such transformations are real - see? Me not.

                Quote: Alexander Ra
                Elimination, first of all, using the template - “predators of overwhelming power”, not physically, but the conditions of their appearance

                It seems not a child, according to the judge. And believe in fairy tales.

                Useless conversation. About nothing request


                With those who defend their parasitic existence at all costs, there really is nothing to talk about.
                1. -2
                  9 August 2019 10: 15
                  Quote: free
                  With those who defend their parasitic existence at all costs there really is nothing to talk about

                  Are you to yourself? I praise, self-criticism is a sign of growth Yes

                  It won't shine for you to stick this "image" on me, vyunosh - I (unlike, it seems, from you) work. Benefit, panimaiti, I bring. I've been working for a long time, I'm used to it laughing
                  1. 0
                    9 August 2019 11: 45
                    Quote: Cat Man Null
                    Quote: free
                    With those who defend their parasitic existence at all costs there really is nothing to talk about

                    Are you to yourself? I praise, self-criticism is a sign of growth Yes

                    It won't shine for you to stick this "image" on me, vyunosh - I (unlike, it seems, from you) work. Benefit, panimaiti, I bring. I've been working for a long time, I'm used to it laughing


                    It all depends on what is your profession?
                    1. -3
                      9 August 2019 12: 14
                      Quote: free
                      It all depends on what is your profession?

                      I have several of them. And yes, I repeat: why did you decide that you have the right to ask me some questions, boy?
                      1. 0
                        9 August 2019 17: 08
                        Quote: Cat Man Null
                        Quote: free
                        It all depends on what is your profession?

                        I have several of them. And yes, I repeat: why did you decide that you have the right to ask me some questions, boy?


                        Something you often began to slip. Are you losing your grip?
  29. Quote: Cat Man Null
    Read carefully:

    Quote: Lieutenant Colonel of the USSRF Air Force in reserve
    production growth

    и

    Quote: Lieutenant Colonel of the USSRF Air Force in reserve
    Russian GDP grew

    - these are slightly different "growths".

    Quote: Lieutenant Colonel of the USSRF Air Force in reserve
    Total: in 2018 year we produced 7% more than in 2011 year

    It is not true. Go google what GDP is request

    Quote: Cat Man Null
    Read carefully:

    Quote: Lieutenant Colonel of the USSRF Air Force in reserve
    production growth

    и

    Quote: Lieutenant Colonel of the USSRF Air Force in reserve
    Russian GDP grew

    - these are slightly different "growths".

    Quote: Lieutenant Colonel of the USSRF Air Force in reserve
    Total: in 2018 year we produced 7% more than in 2011 year

    It is not true. Go google what GDP is request


    1) Why should I google when https://www.interfax.ru/business/649097 do I indicate the source of these numbers?
    Here are
    Last week, the Ministry of Economic Development published an estimate of Russia's GDP growth in 2018 at 2%. The ministry explained the higher growth for the year than was predicted (1,8% - IF) and than the previous estimate for January-November 2018 (also 1,8% - IF), a significant revision of Rosstat construction data upward. As a result, the Ministry of Economic Development revised the GDP growth of the Russian Federation in the I quarter of 2018 to 1,8% from 1,3%, in the II quarter - to 2,2% from 1,9%, in the III quarter it remained unchanged at 1,5%. In the fourth quarter of 2018, the ministry estimated growth at 2,2% in annual terms, including in December - by 1,9%, in November - by 1,8%, in October - by 2,9% .https: / /www.interfax.ru/business/648296
    3) Well, and how much has your production increased in 2018 by 6%? Link
    1. 0
      8 August 2019 20: 12
      Quote: Lieutenant Colonel of the USSRF Air Force in reserve
      1,3

      1. I repeat once again - industrial production growth and GDP growth are different, (introductory word), things wink
      3. Question to Vadim, these are his figures. I said only what is written in p. 1.
    2. -1
      9 August 2019 15: 15
      I wrote to you about the growth of industrial production - but not about the growth of the country's GDP.
  30. Quote: Cat Man Null
    Quote: Lieutenant Colonel of the USSRF Air Force in reserve
    1,3

    1. I repeat once again - industrial production growth and GDP growth are different, (introductory word), things wink
    3. Question to Vadim, these are his figures. I said only what is written in p. 1.

    Industrial production growth is part of GDP growth. That's all. As far as I know, only construction showed an increase of 4,6%. The Ministry of Economic Development does not say which projects could provide such an investment in buildings and structures. Https: //www.interfax.ru/business/648296
    I did not find more growth in the industry.
    1. +1
      8 August 2019 20: 26
      Quote: Lieutenant Colonel of the USSRF Air Force in reserve
      Industrial production growth is part of GDP growth

      Uh-huh. Only in this case, this "part" (as a percentage) can be either more or less than GDP growth over the same period.

      Because once again, the extreme - I repeat: GDP growth and industrial production growth are two different things.

      That's all, I'm tired of you already laughing
      1. +3
        9 August 2019 08: 55
        Quote: Cat Man Null
        GDP growth and industrial production growth are two different things.


        Gross domestic product gross domestic product cost all final goods and services.
        Industrial production is a manufacturer of goods and services (simplified).
        These are two different sides of the same coin.
        Production is growing, and GDP is growing.

        In our case, production is not growing, or maybe even falling. Where does the GDP growth come from?
        GDP can grow not only due to the growth of production but also due to an increase in surplus value. The very value that is thrown by the producer (the owner, which is very important in this case) on the cost of goods and services.That is, the cost of goods and services has grown. Now re-read again what GDP means and you will understand that GDP growth due to surplus value is just our case.
        People live worse from month to month and GDP is growing according to official data. Lies? Maybe it's true, but it's crafty truth.The purpose of this "truth" is for people to continue to believe.
        And people should, must know.To know, not to believe.
        1. 0
          9 August 2019 12: 01
          The purpose of this "truth" is for people to continue to believe.
          To believe that everything will work out is still necessary to tolerate that the sanctions are to blame, Trump, Erdogan or something else there.
          And people should, must know.
          That with this capital system in which we now live, there will never be order. All the contradictions that are observed in the economy are unavoidable contradictions of the capital system. You can only remove them by abandoning the capitalist model of social structure.
        2. +3
          9 August 2019 12: 09
          Quote: free
          Where then is the GDP growth?

          due to the growth of services.
          For example: a state-owned office serviced an object for 0 rubles (they forced the masters to spin). Then they transferred the object to an organization for 1 million rubles, an unequivocal increase in GDP, with the same result.
  31. Quote: Cat Man Null
    Quote: Lieutenant Colonel of the USSRF Air Force in reserve
    Industrial production growth is part of GDP growth

    Uh-huh. Only in this case, this "part" (as a percentage) can be either more or less than GDP growth over the same period.

    Because once again, the extreme - I repeat: GDP growth and industrial production growth are two different things.

    That's all, I'm tired of you already laughing

    Get used to it.
    I did not say that GDP growth and industry growth are one and the same. He pointed to the growth of industry, I pointed to the entire GDP.
    Although the indicated industry growth is 6% from the ceiling, this is indicated.
    1. 0
      9 August 2019 15: 18
      In my production, the growth for the first half of the year is 23%.
  32. +7
    8 August 2019 20: 38
    The devil knows him. Recession-compression, innovation, nanotechnology ...
    I am an old sick man. Mnu hurts everything for a long time. But when I come to work, I try to do it as efficiently as possible. Despite the fact, a little flesh, a lot of flesh. I work the same way. Well paid a little, offensive of course (well, that).
    So what am I always leading to ?! Everyone in their own particular place should do their job honestly. And then there will be order, then it will not give a damn about all these recessions.
    Maybe I don't understand why, but when three "work hard", and seven are sitting or stupidly portraying some kind of work, happiness will never come.
    1. +5
      9 August 2019 08: 20
      Quote: Petrol cutter
      The devil knows him. Recession-compression, innovation, nanotechnology ...
      I am an old sick man. Mnu hurts everything for a long time. But when I come to work, I try to do it as efficiently as possible. Despite the fact, a little flesh, a lot of flesh. I work the same way. Well paid a little, offensive of course (well, that).
      So what am I always leading to ?! Everyone in their own particular place should do their job honestly. And then there will be order, then it will not give a damn about all these recessions.
      Maybe I don't understand why, but when three "work hard", and seven are sitting or stupidly portraying some kind of work, happiness will never come.


      You understand everything correctly. But the Russian economy is speculative today, and the speculator cannot a priori perform work qualitatively. Because he does not do any work at all, he makes money from the air, he steals money, including from you.
    2. +1
      9 August 2019 12: 20
      Quote: Petrol cutter
      Everyone in their own particular place should do their job honestly.

      Do not state reason. It’s apolitical. On cash flows and the control button, there should be reliable people, acquaintances, relatives, up to children. And when a person got a lot of free money, why should he work at all, they pay in management and cash flows not for work, but for the position.
  33. +3
    8 August 2019 21: 55

    No, don’t be alarmed; this is not a call to that one. This is just a statement of the fact that the competence of our government and other economists has long been in question

    They are quite competent specialists, their capital only confirms this. winked
    Well, is not a competent economist who does not know how to launder money properly be able to accumulate such wealth?
  34. +4
    9 August 2019 04: 33
    Here is also a problem in the minds, everyone always says that we need goods for sale abroad, and so that the super-duper. And the fact that you first need to saturate your market with your own goods and then something may appear among them and worthy because it’s more difficult to think up a superpuper than producing an ordinary thing, all the more so for yourself with guaranteed sales. The same Chinese, Korean Japanese cars first went to their market and went abroad as the quality improves. What is stopping us? And then it comes to senility, sewing needles and those from China, while plasticine and blunt and relatives of the union of which there are few left, still sharp, from the Russian Federation have not seen on sale.
    1. +6
      9 August 2019 08: 26
      Quote: evgen1221
      Here is also a problem in the minds, everyone always says that we need goods for sale abroad, and so that the super-duper. And the fact that you first need to saturate your market with your own goods and then something may appear among them and worthy because it’s more difficult to think up a superpuper than producing an ordinary thing, all the more so for yourself with guaranteed sales. The same Chinese, Korean Japanese cars first went to their market and went abroad as the quality improved.What is stopping us? And then it comes to senility, sewing needles and those from China, while plasticine and blunt and relatives of the union of which there are few left, still sharp, from the Russian Federation have not seen on sale.


      Our rulers seem to be built into the world system as a gas station. That's the very thing that is stopping it. A gas station should not have production, it should not be a competitor. It should simply supply resources, in every sense of the word.
    2. -2
      9 August 2019 15: 21
      It is much more profitable to push goods abroad - now most manufacturers do so.
  35. +3
    9 August 2019 06: 34
    I will write only by the title of this post. There is heavy rain on the street. And then there was watering. For what?
    Most likely for the report, for the work done. In words, we are very rational. And in life, we are mired in papers.
    1. 0
      9 August 2019 13: 03
      And to catch the driver of that watering-say Putin is to blame. And macroeconomics.
  36. +3
    9 August 2019 06: 41
    Thanks to the author !!! It's funny ... and I want to cry !!!! There is no Gogol on us ... where does the troika carry Russia?
    And these people go to temples ... they put candles ... will it be counted ???
  37. +6
    9 August 2019 06: 53
    Quote: Vadim237
    In the USSR, all equipment was operated until it fell apart

    Is it really only our plant was an exception ??? When I was young I was in Narodny Kontrol - in the wall newspapers right at the checkpoint we "pulled" the bosses, who were slowly installing NEW equipment ... it was poor in boxes, covered with snow !!! Then the problem was to master the money allocated for the purchase of new machines. Programmed machines were inferior to their Western counterparts, but they were designed with us, from our "fillings" and some were produced in our city !!! Naturally. many factories have already been ditched ... and we take imports. So, do not really care about the past ...
    1. +3
      9 August 2019 09: 02
      Here some of our colleagues say: "Why are you here all the scatters gathered? Why" Ur-r-ah! "Do not shout?"
      Well, first of all, to shout “Hurray!” We have a special state body - ROSSTAT. This is his task. But do you know who was in the forefront of the surrender of the USSR? Many Komsomol leaders! The ones who shouted "Hurray!" and forced to do this ordinary Komsomol members. This is instead of a critical analysis of the situation and an appeal to senior party comrades with a demand to change something for the better in the political realities of the Union. They preferred to change their personal lives for the better within the framework of the opportunities provided by senior party comrades who chose capitalism. Having long-established strong ties with those comrades. Khodorkovsky to help you as an example! Therefore, I instinctively do not trust those who shout "Hurray!" I just want to ask: "What are you up to? Am I already afraid or can I postpone?"
      Secondly, we are on the analytical section of VO, and our task is, if possible, to show what is wrong with us and how different layers of the population react to it not "so" - the very population whose presence in plans for economic development prefers to ignore our gallant government. Doesn't take into account! And now the economy is shrinking and dying ...
      If until 2014 in the morning on the staircase of my staircase there was a many-footed clatter of people rushing to work, and a hasty stream of the same people flowed past the windows, cars started up, the engines hummed, and parking lots quickly ran along the house, now it’s silence. Only the wind rustles in the crowns of trees. Cars are funny, and there are fewer of them due to unpaid loans. They are even handed over to a pawnshop in order to somehow get out of current expenses, and unscrupulous pawnshops attribute a delay in returning funds and take away the car. And sometimes it is useless to sue. Insolent time. It’s like the 90s are coming back.
      And we have to give either an analysis or an offhand picture of what is happening. This is instead of "Hurray!"
      And by the way. Tajik cleaners returned to my village, and locals were fired. They put a gadget in our ear. Tidying up the stairs, he happily ruffles on the phone.
    2. -1
      9 August 2019 15: 27
      In Russia there are now 57 factories of machine-tool manufacturers - and taking import into account is the customers preference; I personally like DMG machines - I recently ordered four domestic 3D printers that are produced in St. Petersburg.
  38. +10
    9 August 2019 07: 15
    Yes, we see very well that over a quarter of a century, the country is gradually degrading, that the government is led by a midget, that when the last time Mutko was appointed minister, the ministers and deputies of the United Russia themselves were neighing. So what? Russia does not have a single chance with them, they only care about a handful of the elected people and will not give anything to change, not for that they took power. Only a catastrophe will save Rossib when the rats flee the boat.
  39. +2
    9 August 2019 08: 24
    Great article, with a sparkling banter on the case! Those. for 5 years will pull laughing
    It is only a pity that it can still be significantly expanded and deepened, glory to the geniuses! laughing
    1. 0
      9 August 2019 10: 28
      Well, the article doesn’t let me go! Having analyzed the past, I turned to the present. Why, having enormous resources, even under the current production sharing law, which puts us under the control of the same IMF, is the country's economy slowly fading?
      But because there is no life in the country. For example, political.
      Imagine an amazing picture.
      The year before the presidential election, the candidates are announced: Putin, Grudinin and Sobchak.
      Grudinin crawls out of the TV and begins his campaign in the country with his program. Arrives in Chukotka, in Anadyr. The population was shocked by an unprecedented phenomenon and the crowds fell on a meeting, throws the candidate questions, he enters into a discussion, learning about himself a lot of new things and as much about the real life of people. His political and economic headquarters, who arrived with him, is working hard to create solutions. Then Grudinin leaves for Petropavlovs-Kamatsky, and after him letters from Chukotka fly with proposals that the headquarters also works with, adjusting the previously created ... Next - Yakutsk, Norilsk, Vladivostok, Blagoveshchensk, Irkutsk, Krasnoyarsk, Tomsk, Yekaterinburg, large the cities of the Volga region, the Kuban, the Caucasus, Central Russia and - Kaliningrad! Grudinin was tired, tense, but gradually a feeling came to him that he had grown up as a politician, a feeling of a bunch of problems and a bunch of responsibility for the country and its people ..
      What about the people? And the people begin to understand that he, the people, is not a decoration, that the country needs him, because the presidential candidate is talking face to face with him! That without him, the people, in no way, and people's self-awareness rises, there is a boil in individual foci, gradually merging into a general boil. And now life has begun! She’ve gone! The people are emboldened, sharp presentations begin to local presumptuous bureaucrats, and those, frightened, begin to come to life, do something in accordance with their official duties and do it right ...
      Meanwhile, among Kremlin analysts, concern is growing: "Vladimir Vladimirovich, we will lose!" Well, really, here is Putin on TV at an Austrian wedding, but here he is eating caviar with comrade Xi, drinking tea with children, catching such fish, playing hockey giveaways, watching football ...
      I can’t even imagine about Sobchak’s tour ...
      We need political life, that’s what. For only she is able to lead the people out of a lethargic dream, reanimate their creative abilities, force the authorities to favorable economic changes.
  40. -1
    9 August 2019 10: 38
    "... far away, into the sky-high reach" the author took us with a vile macroeconomic analysis - and we went with our heads up ... But we ought to take a closer look at our feet and look around: which of our neighbors and colleagues is sparing no effort in moving our economy? And not to see: they sit decorously on sofas and profoundly analyze, analyze .... And they condemn the nouveau riche, speculators, oligarchs who dream of drinking the people's blood: we will not give it! We won't give it to anyone! - And they don't give it ... And the fact that the economy does not have an entrepreneurial drive and that is why it stagnates - so it is, purely, the Government and the President ... And, also Chubais ...
  41. +3
    9 August 2019 10: 45
    Is gasoline growing in price? Is growing. Moreover, the oil industry also compensation promise for lost profitsotherwise it’s unprofitable for them to process oil inside the country, it’s more convenient for them to drive crude for export.


    A great example of a brilliant economy !!
    By the way, has anyone ever considered real compensation and damage to a country ??

    For simplicity, we say that in the state gas costs 10 rubles .. And outside the country (there are other prices, tariffs, salaries) - gas costs 100 rubles ..
    Now our LLC Pisyabayprodaksion, selling to us gasoline for 10 rubles .. receives compensation for the lost profit .. How much does she need to "compensate" ?? 90 rubles each ?? Well, if it is necessary, then it is necessary .. If the herd is correctly presented, then it seems like it is quite "fair" ..))
    And where do these 90 rubles come from ?? Who will cover them ?? That same herd .. Only in other ways they will be taken from them .. in the form of the same taxes, understated pensions and salaries ..

    If you unravel all this tangle .. then "compensation for lost profits" is nothing more than a direct price of 100 rubles per liter .. as over a hill .. (well, we will modestly keep silent about salaries)
    1. +1
      9 August 2019 12: 04
      By the way, in tsarist Russia there was an almost complete ban on the transportation of crude oil. Some insignificant percentage was allowed for export. They mainly exported redistributions - gasoline, kerosene, fuel oil, etc.
  42. +1
    9 August 2019 11: 40
    In the framework of today's economic model, with today's insignificance, starting with Vovka, nothing will change, we will break through bottom after bottom, fortunately not for long, it has its end.)).
    The direct reason for the deterioration of life was Putin's "national projects", the withdrawal of funds for them entailed a pension reform, an increase in VAT, a reduction in social services and other and other "nishtyaks", the beneficiaries of which will be an approximate pack of the "throne"!
    1. -2
      9 August 2019 15: 39
      This is compared to the fact that Stalin in the 28th year made a game in the sandbox - then your howl, that something was robbed from you, etc., no one would have heard - because there was no one to hear, and you would be quickly shut up. Stalin carried out industrialization and Putin's May Decrees will pass by 24 - most of them will be implemented.
  43. +5
    9 August 2019 11: 55
    Quote: parusnik
    The issue of bringing the Russian economy to growth rates not lower than the global average

    and how is this growth measured?
    GDP growth? growth in volume of natural units of production? Numerically in rubles excluding inflation?
    You know, GDP growth is numerically very easily led out to world leaders, if you just keep inflation above the real fall of the economy by 30-40 percent.
    These goals, voiced by Putin, are just bullshit, which the Rosstat draws in 1 day without using anything else. Now, if Putin set goals to achieve objective indicators that are not easy to manipulate with, that’s another question.
    For example, the goal is to provide, within the 40 hour week, the average median salary in the country, not lower than the consumer basket of a family of 4 people (minimum demographic requirements). The minimum cost of an hour should be equated with some sane indicator, and not some abstract 5 rubles.
    Etc. That's when such indicators appear, then there will be a movement.
  44. +4
    9 August 2019 12: 09
    Quote: Nestorych
    The direct reason for the deterioration of life was Putin's "national projects", the withdrawal of funds for them led to a pension reform, an increase in VAT, a reduction in social services

    Putin's projects have nothing to do with screw tightening. You don’t understand anything at all, but you dare to make global statements
  45. +2
    9 August 2019 12: 41
    What can I say, all domestic policy in the country has failed miserably, especially the economy and cadres, this is already seen by all and the main reason is the low professionalism of the work of senior officials, nepotism, licentiousness, corruption flourishes magnificent, in addition to cynicism, verbiage, lack of discipline, order , responsibility. Yes, born to crawl, flying can not apply to most of the country's top managers.
  46. +4
    9 August 2019 12: 53
    In short, the fosterlings of the fat Gaidar in the "economic" (???) block of the Government should be sent to the guillotine, as in France in the 18th century in the month of Thermidor. And the graduates of the Higher School of Economics in general should not be admitted to the civil service !!! Maybe then something will move ...
    1. -1
      9 August 2019 15: 44
      But who are you going to change for? And in general, what is the likelihood that with your substitutes the economy will not fall at a steep peak?
  47. +1
    9 August 2019 16: 17
    Quote: astepanov
    And what is the benefit of Putin? Remember, with what load of problems he accepted Russia: war, poverty, crime, lawlessness ... Want in the nineties? Me not.

    is there no poverty today?
    and the law directly helps you find justice very much?
    there is no crime ???
    war ... oh yes, there’s no war, only the indigenous population of the country is declining as if machine guns are working in every locality.
  48. +1
    9 August 2019 16: 22
    Quote: Vadim237
    they used the same thing last year, but there wasn’t such a morale of bees

    sorry, I want to clarify, did they "use them": bees, pesticides, or all together?
    so can bees die from the use of bees?
    1. -2
      9 August 2019 21: 45
      These are pesticides - and, accordingly, the bees were also taken out, and to the same places as last year. If these pesticides are so powerful - why didn’t they affect the rest of the insects, animals, vegetation in the end - a troubled story however.
  49. Quote: Vadim237
    It already exists: 3D printers, including for construction, nuclear reactors, fuel cells, isotopes, special alloys, optical instruments, construction equipment, cars, heat exchangers, cryogenic cameras, combines, tractors Rostselmash - 18% of the global market for agricultural equipment, medical equipment - SHVABE , machines ranging from turning to machining centers with CNC with a bed of 40 by 6 meters - STAN group, products of special instrumentation Rostekh, Roselektronika, KRET and much more.

    ***
    Yes, "It's good here where we are not. Here, where we are not, heroic deeds are happening and amazing people live. Here, where we are not, unprecedented harvests grow and one after another goes to death. Here, where we are not, women love once and the pilots are incredible. How a festival was a success, where we weren't. How good are the recipes for dishes that we have not seen. How accurate the machines on which we do not work. How many different institutions do for us. And we are not there. at this time we are somewhere not there. Or are they looking for us somewhere not there? "
    "but already there (somewhere): 3D printers, including for construction, (and cheap houses are built by these printers) nuclear reactors (move planes), fuel cells (fill electric circuits with cheap energy and move all kinds of mechanisms) isotopes (work wonders in appliances), special alloys (fuse in a single rush), optical instruments (looking into the depths of space and molecules), well, and so on ... "
    "And people come out and tell how they renovate, rebuild, transfer, expand for the convenience of the population. For the convenience of the population, the population, the population - where is this population ... niyam ... niyam? .. And it is wildly insulting that all this somewhere here. Here it is somewhere completely here. Well, right in the same city with us this is happening - you do not sleep at night, you all jump out - where? Yes, right here. Yes, here, literally. "
    1. -1
      9 August 2019 21: 38
      It is all there - where you do not work, but maybe you live, but you don’t notice all this because it’s not interesting to you all. Russia is a huge country, where it is, where it is not, in one place the local authorities deal with problems, in another place the authorities put all the problems, ordinary people do the same - some people live in cleanliness and decoration, they keep order, others in moreover, this garbage can be bred and everyone around is to blame except themselves.
    2. -2
      9 August 2019 21: 52
      Until recently, I didn’t know that in the suburbs there is a production of pistons, connecting rods, sleeves, liners made of titanium alloys, for German sports cars - the guys supply this product to Europe for tuning.
  50. Quote: Vadim237
    It is all there - where you do not work, but maybe you live, but you don’t notice all this because it’s not interesting to you all. Russia is a huge country, where it is, where it is not, in one place the local authorities deal with problems, in another place the authorities put all the problems, ordinary people do the same - some people live in cleanliness and decoration, they keep order, others in moreover, this garbage can be bred and everyone around is to blame except themselves.

    ***
    Eh, Vadim, I’m just curious about everything, I’m curious and get to the bottom of it. I don’t believe anything until I check it myself.
    My son and my friend work at KGOK Vanadiy Evraz ... mining and beneficiation technologies have not changed, at least since the 1970s .... And this is in a cost-effective, very cost-effective metallurgy.
    We have backward production. Low labor productivity.
    South Korea - 338 robots per 10 thousand employees ...
    RF-3 robots for 10 thousand workers ....
    When you look at success on TV, one thing, when you compare it with the success of others, it's different.
    It’s a shame for the Power.
    1. -1
      11 August 2019 00: 27
      But metallurgy has changed - all open-hearth furnaces have been replaced by electric arc furnaces. Robotics in Russia is now well developed. Do you want people to be replaced by robots?
  51. -1
    9 August 2019 23: 47
    - What about our population’s income?
    - They are falling.
    - This is not a patriotic formulation.
    - Well... There has been negative income growth.
    - Better. But I need the words of a true patriot.
    - Uh... Here! The decline in revenue growth has slowed!
    - Perfect.
  52. +2
    11 August 2019 06: 16
    No matter how many smart articles you write, the result will be the same. As long as the current gentlemen (or comrades) are at the head of the country, no forward movement should be expected from the word at all.
  53. Quote: Vadim237
    But metallurgy has changed - all open-hearth furnaces have been replaced by electric arc furnaces. Robotics in Russia is now well developed. Do you want people to be replaced by robots?

    ***
    I) Since the 1970s, new open-hearth furnaces have no longer been built in the world. Karabasov et al., 2014, p. 186.
    In many advanced countries, all open-hearth furnaces were long ago replaced by electric arc furnaces in the years 1970-2000.
    There are practically no countries left in the world where this method is used; the last open-hearth furnaces operate only in Russia (small furnaces), Ukraine and India. Russia is one of the last to leave this club.
    https://sdelanounas.ru/blogs/104567/
    This means that sooner or later we will either have to make production modern or fall behind in some industries.
    II) Did I give you figures about the number of robots in South Korea and the Russian Federation? This was data from previous years...
    You made me look at more recent data. Below is about 2018-2019.
    2018:
    1. China accounts for 30% of global sales of industrial robots.
    2. Preliminary IFR data: Sales volume - 421 thousand industrial robots
    3. During the year, 860 industrial robots were introduced in Russia, this is 0,2% of those introduced in the world.
    Total in the world - 384 thousand.
    2019 April
    4. Countries with the highest penetration of industrial robots:
    First place in the ranking was taken by South Korea, which has 10 robots per 710 thousand workers. The top three included Singapore (658 robots) and Germany (322). Russia is not on the list, like other non-robotic countries. www.tadviser.ru/index.php/Article:Industrial_robots
    In other lists, Russia is at the very bottom of the list for robotization of production.
    5. 1)-4) are based on research by IFR (International Federation of Robotics)
    I hope that you have studied the language of one of the potential opponents (English), here is the IFR study https://ifr.org/downloads/press2018/Executive_Summary_WR_2018_Industrial_Robots.pdf
    6. Do I want to replace, do I want to replace people with robots, is equivalent to whether I want or do not want to have a cold Ural summer in 2019 or not...
    The quantity, quality of products, labor productivity, and cost in a competitive world depend on the modernity of production equipment.
    And a number of professions of physical and mental labor will disappear in the near future, whether I want it or not.
  54. 0
    12 August 2019 00: 14
    Spain and Greece spent a lot. Literally for all the articles that the author names. And it didn't end well.
    “Warming up” demand through inflating the money supply would lead to a blunt increase in imports in Russia.
    Actually, Mr. Kuzovkov practices irony and satire.
    There is no economic content.
  55. 0
    14 August 2019 06: 26
    Crisis of the Institute of Management Personnel. Hence the completely senseless use of budget money, embezzlement, and corruption. Hence the recession if there is sufficient finance in the country. The attitude instilled by the amers in the 90s is that my money, above all else, works one hundred percent in the state apparatus and among legislators. And another reason for our troubles is the reluctance to work for the development of Russia. Only for your own pocket. A few statists don’t count; they don’t make a difference at this stage of our history.
  56. 0
    14 August 2019 23: 44
    Somehow I don’t want to make jokes about the economy. This is the swamp that can destroy us all. We are still able to figure out the rest, but the economy, or more precisely what they call it, does not give us any chance to get out of the quagmire. This area in Russia is firmly occupied by people who know and know only one thing: to kill the economy of real affairs, i.e. real economy. Give them a flourishing oasis as their patrimony, they will turn it into a trash heap, not to mention a problematic country like ours. Liberal "economists" are an evil that corporately attacks everything living and present, life itself, and, ultimately, work, as the only healthy source of good. It distorts, ridicules, replaces it with the cult of enrichment, showing us, as in Soviet times, beautiful clippings from foreign magazines. And we follow their lead, because we are too lazy to work, and even to defend the results of our work. We entered into a deal with them, selling the future cheaply, just so as not to sweat in the present. Although you will still have to sweat, if not something worse. Because after liberalism usually comes communism or fascism.
  57. 0
    15 August 2019 08: 20
    But national projects really are the last hope for economic growth in modern Russia.
    National projects are the main brake on the economy! They are built on the principle “we take money from the budget and spend it.” Neither about how to replenish the budget (except for raising the retirement age, taxing beards and grandmothers with a bunch of onions), nor about where to get resources (special human resources, which require not money, but time to prepare), nor about how these projects will correlate with each other; the authors of these projects have no idea, as well as simple state planning. What held the USSR together - the planned economy - was destroyed as the basis of its power. Baby talk about the self-regulating hand of the market economy made itself felt from the very first steps of Gaidar (there should be a word here denoting persons of non-traditional market and sexual orientation). Since some planning was still needed, the idea of ​​“national projects” arose. The only alternative can only be comprehensive planning of economic development, taking into account all factors, personal responsibility of decision makers and those responsible for the result, abandonment of the pro-Western liberal vector towards traditional Russian values.

"Right Sector" (banned in Russia), "Ukrainian Insurgent Army" (UPA) (banned in Russia), ISIS (banned in Russia), "Jabhat Fatah al-Sham" formerly "Jabhat al-Nusra" (banned in Russia) , Taliban (banned in Russia), Al-Qaeda (banned in Russia), Anti-Corruption Foundation (banned in Russia), Navalny Headquarters (banned in Russia), Facebook (banned in Russia), Instagram (banned in Russia), Meta (banned in Russia), Misanthropic Division (banned in Russia), Azov (banned in Russia), Muslim Brotherhood (banned in Russia), Aum Shinrikyo (banned in Russia), AUE (banned in Russia), UNA-UNSO (banned in Russia), Mejlis of the Crimean Tatar People (banned in Russia), Legion “Freedom of Russia” (armed formation, recognized as terrorist in the Russian Federation and banned)

“Non-profit organizations, unregistered public associations or individuals performing the functions of a foreign agent,” as well as media outlets performing the functions of a foreign agent: “Medusa”; "Voice of America"; "Realities"; "Present time"; "Radio Freedom"; Ponomarev; Savitskaya; Markelov; Kamalyagin; Apakhonchich; Makarevich; Dud; Gordon; Zhdanov; Medvedev; Fedorov; "Owl"; "Alliance of Doctors"; "RKK" "Levada Center"; "Memorial"; "Voice"; "Person and law"; "Rain"; "Mediazone"; "Deutsche Welle"; QMS "Caucasian Knot"; "Insider"; "New Newspaper"