Military Review

Dreams of the collapse of Russia

127
The author came across a curious article on the leading American resource The Hill. Janusz Bugaysky, a senior researcher at the Center for European Policy Analysis (CEPA) and the former director of the New European Democracy Program at the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS), was writing about the topic “Managing the Decay of Russia”. There he describes the measures to be taken in order for Russia to disintegrate and for conflicts to erupt on its territory.




Janusz begins with what the authors of many such anonymous articles usually begin with stories about the ongoing Russian attack on Ukraine (forgetting only to mention when our troops took Kiev, when they reached the western border, and in what filtration camps they keep Bandera and Nazis), well, with "subversive activities against Western states." They say that Russia failed to stop neither the United States, nor NATO, nor the EU, and only the former director of the pan knows something there. Moscow thinks that the West is weak and predictable, but in actual fact it is Moscow that is weak. And you just need to push a little bit and it will fall - Pan Janusch will be his German comrade in faith in this (the one with a characteristic bang and mustache) will not let you lie, he also thought so. And the Frenchman from Corsica alone thought so too.

Russia, according to a Pan Pole, was unable to modernize its economy (apparently, according to the Polish model, to ruin the industry and collect debts), but it is strong in disinformation, with which it portrays itself (!) As a leading world force on a par with the United States. In actual fact, the leading world power is Poland, I suppose? .. Polish neighbors from Ukraine, currently showing the whole world that there are no limits to diving to the bottom, and they can always knock at this very bottom, they are said about such: getting richer.

As evidence of his "rightness", the pan refers to the calculations of the military budget in dollars at the rate and per capita GDP also at the rate (because if we take in the same source the data obtained by recalculating the purchasing power, the argument will collapse, this is understandable). Of course, fairy tales are told about terrible corruption, poverty and so on. An equally wise conclusion is drawn from such a “truthful” assessment of the situation - Russia is moving towards decay, and we must help it.

Let us quote Pan Bugaysky:

The cumbersome Russian Federation consists of 85 “federal subjects”, of which 22 are republics representing non-Russian ethnic groups, including the North Caucasus and the Middle Volga, and numerous regions with a pronounced identity that are felt more and more alienated from Moscow.
Instead of decentralizing to accommodate regional aspirations, the Kremlin lowers their autonomy. This is evident in the new law on language, which is designed to promote "Russification" and plans to merge and liquidate several regions.
Pressure is growing across the country: growing anger at local governors appointed by the Kremlin, and outrage at Moscow appropriating their resources. Indeed, regions such as Sakha and Magadan in the Far East, with their considerable mineral wealth, could become successful states without exploiting Moscow.


That is, measures to strengthen statehood, consistently carried out by V.V. Putin all the time of his reign, of course, wrong, it was necessary to "give all the sovereignty as they can," just like in the "holy" 90-e, apparently.

Also, the pan "expert" believes that infrastructure is "rapidly" destroyed in Russia, and "the inhabitants of Siberia and the Far East of Russia will be even more separated from the center, which will stimulate demands for secession and sovereignty." Pan was generally in Russia or studied the situation in it according to articles on Ukrainian resources like “Censor” and “Observer” and on libelous political Ukrainians in LiveJournal and other blogs, say, “Evil Odessite” and others? Or on public tables in the VC, where the same figures, most often posing as patriots of Russia (or the USSR) with rags of different colors, post each other cheerful images, most often unrelated to Russia?

This is followed by tips from the slave transatlantic pan. Although the real pan would not listen to any sermons from the serfs and would order to bung the talkative in the stable. Washington "should return to the basic principles that accompanied the collapse of the Soviet Union, supporting democratization, pluralism, minority rights, genuine federalism, decentralization and regional self-determination among isolated regions of Russia and ethnic groups and should promote regional and ethnic self-determination within the Russian Federation."

Ban Janusz broadcasts from the pulpit:

"The rationale for the dissolution should be logically formulated: in order to survive, Russia needs federal democracy and a strong economy; without democratization on the horizon and deterioration of economic conditions, the federal structure will become increasingly uncontrollable."


Interestingly, as soon as in Russia, on the contrary, they began to quietly at first, and then more and more tightly “tighten the screws” and move away from the “real democracy”, which everyone ate from the belly in 90, so the structure became more manageable and conditions began to improve. Maybe Pan Bugaysky about some other Russia, from another, parallel space? With other laws of social development. Or is it just that the pan broadcasts what he wants to see, or what he gets paid for PLN 30?

We read further the revelations of blessed Janus:

"To manage the process of dissolution and reduce the likelihood of conflict that goes beyond state borders, the West needs to establish links with various regions of Russia and promote their peaceful transition to statehood."


That is, he wants the Western countries to openly stimulate separatism? But he does not understand that such actions are in themselves a “casus belli” and can lead those very countries of the abstract West to the disintegration of statehood, too, but caused by completely different reasons and with completely different, more serious consequences?

Ban Bugaysky even "distributed" some regions of our power with you:

"Some regions may join countries such as Finland, Ukraine, China and Japan, of which Moscow forcibly appropriated territories in the past. Other republics of the North Caucasus, the Middle Volga region, Siberia and the Far East may become fully independent states and establish relations with China, Japan, USA and Europe. "


The mental level of the “researcher” puts him on a par with the dreamers from the territory next to Poland, where they also dream of Kuban, Crimea, or march on Moscow, and that the United States will come, defeat Russia and put them above us with gauges and policemen .

He also writes about NATO, which "must ensure the security of Russia's neighbors in the event of its collapse." How it would have done if a nuclear superpower fell apart, he does not specify. Pan is not a tactician, he is a strategy specialist, as they say.

It would have been possible to simply ignore this Polish strategist - there are plenty of them, and there is a lot of scribbling from them, and the reality of everything they have written is exactly the same as their “knowledge” about us. But the problem is that such “researchers” of Russia, entrenched in various near-government “funds” and not knowing anything about us, give advice to people who also do not know about us, but who are already preparing papers for people who, again, nothing they do not know about Russia in particular, but they already have the power. And the problem is that the questions raised by such writers and proposed solutions can have fatal consequences if people with authority listen to them.

In addition, the extinction of "Sovietology" in the West (among which once there were indeed specialists in our country) led to the fact that in the United States they began to attract to "study" Russia and "consulting" on it those who, as it seems, are guys with Potomac, "knows his neighbors well." That is, the Baltic states, Poles, and others. The value of analysts from the West about Russia, unfortunately, is constantly falling, as is the intelligence ability of the United States and the West to reduce arrays of real data into something that reflects reality with a minimum of distortion. Western intelligence, in particular, the CIA, successfully overslept the collapse of the USSR, in the fall of 1991, they wrote reports on the future of the updated Union. And the Union took and fell apart thanks to three power-hungry figures (not only, unfortunately, it is easier to write off what was done to the "West's hand" than to admit that the Union was ruined mainly by ourselves, and not only by these three, but also by many, many ).

They also slept successfully and the restoration of sustainable statehood. And they overslept the nuclear-rocket and technological "spurt" of Russia, because in the middle of the 2000-s they came across materials about how to degrade Russia's nuclear potential to the level of 150-200 warheads (total). A lot of this happened from the pen of Russian authors, often because customers from the West wanted to see exactly this in the text.

And from such nonsense, conclusions were made at the very top, and decisions to withdraw from the ABM Treaty and the creation of a US NMD, which was unworkable in the end, were made on the basis of similar assessments. As well as measures that led to a serious rift in the nuclear weapons complex of America itself. You can still remember many such examples.

And God forbid, someone will follow the advice of Mr. Ban Bugaysky - this may cause a reaction from Russia not wanting to disintegrate that ... It's easier to say this: everyone who dreams of the disintegration of our state should study the half-lives of high-level radioactive elements, " rule of seven "and the striking factors of nuclear weapons.

In general, you will not wait for our collapse.
Author:
Photos used:
Artur janas
127 comments
Ad

Subscribe to our Telegram channel, regularly additional information about the special operation in Ukraine, a large amount of information, videos, something that does not fall on the site: https://t.me/topwar_official

Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. GKS 2111
    GKS 2111 April 15 2019 04: 57
    +14
    Someone’s dreams about the collapse of Russia exist as long as Russia itself exists in the world. Continue to dream, dreamers.
    1. Pessimist22
      Pessimist22 April 15 2019 05: 49
      +31
      Yes, but a little more than a hundred years ago, Russia was much larger, and then only lost its territory.
      The current economic situation and demographic alarming feelings about the future are causing.
      1. Stas157
        Stas157 April 15 2019 06: 43
        +13
        Why do we need to know what some Bugaychik writes there? Why even argue with the dried up and so upset about this?

        A laudatory article about how everything is in order in Russia, about scrapes, written through the denial of delirium of a madman.

        First we pull the owl on the globe (we give the opinion of the abnormal), then everyone together is outraged by this. A great welcome to praise Russia ... if it doesn't work out otherwise.
        1. SETSET
          SETSET April 15 2019 10: 09
          0
          No. It's easier to pull a globe on an owl, burying it.
        2. Nyrobsky
          Nyrobsky April 15 2019 10: 58
          +16
          Quote: Stas157
          Why do we need to know what some Bugaychik writes there?

          Forewarned is forearmed.
          Quote: Stas157
          Why even argue with the dried up and so upset about this?
          So immediately and "with the crazy." Think primitively. No respected, these are ardent enemies and Russophobes who say what they think and exactly what they want to come to - to the collapse of Russia. They will push through funding for this, maintain institutions and staffs, develop programs and manuals that will be distributed in the regions, hold seminars with representatives of ethnic "minorities" and, under a plausible mask, pump how to properly reform the brain of residents of different regions, creating intolerance towards representatives of other nationalities not the titular nation. This is all more than serious. His ethnic compatriot Zbigniew Brzezinski, entrenched in the United States, who today works as a "burning log" in hell, spent his entire life developing a strategy for the collapse of the USSR and Russia, and I must admit, he succeeded in something. What unites Brzezinski, Bugaysky and other Russophobes is that they do not stake on a military victory over Russia, but they stake precisely on breaking the "bonds" - by nationality, language and faith. Discord in a large family, and nearly 200 peoples live in Russia, is a win-win for the West, and therefore they will strive to strike precisely at these points, motivating the "awakening" of self-identity and, as a result, contribute to the incitement of separatism in the regions. It cannot be said that this is impossible, because the 90s and early 2000s showed how famously the local "elite" of some regions began to try on the "panama of the regional prince" and cut out a "scepter and orb" from scrap materials. We need a well-thought-out and balanced state policy aimed at rallying and uniting Russians, which, alas, is clearly not sufficient, and, to be honest, is a failure. By relying on building a vertical based on the principle of manual control of the heads of regions, the state is already losing sight of what is generally maturing and swarming at the level of local ministries and municipalities - absolutely. The only methods used by the government to unite all Russians one size fits all are initiatives to raise the retirement age, gas prices, VAT, increase fishing fines and an extra bunch of dill, etc. apparently according to the principle - "Common trouble unites". In the construction of a common "Territory of Happiness" the people did not catch our government and did not notice, but this was noticed by the "madman" from behind the hillock, who, looking for these "cracks", will strive to drive a wedge into them.
          1. Tatyana
            Tatyana April 15 2019 14: 24
            +9
            Nyrobsky
            Quote: Nyrobsky
            We need a well-thought-out and balanced state policy aimed at rallying and uniting Russians, which, alas, is clearly not sufficient, and to be honest, it is a failure. By betting on building a vertical line according to the principle of manual control by the heads of regions, the state is already losing sight of what is ripening and swarming at the level of local ministries and municipalities - absolutely.

            Absolutely true! And I’ll add to this one more. Namely.

            According to the Constitution of the Russian Federation, in modern Russia there is no place at all for recognizing the titularity of the Russian people as the founder and collector of the Russian state, while the Russian language is trampled on in the titular national administrative-territorial entities even as the MAJOR official language of the Russian Federation for interethnic communication and the HISTORICAL HERITAGE OF EXISTENCE of the Russian state . An example is Tatarstan, Yakutia, etc.

            All this in our country is not good!

            Russophobia and apartheid against the Russian people in the former national republics of the USSR we have already seen in 1990's and are now seeing. What this historically leads to, we also already know.
            1. Sergej1972
              Sergej1972 April 15 2019 15: 25
              -5
              Both in Yakutia and in Tatarstan, the Russian language is used more widely than the Yakut and Tatar languages. We have not used the term "titular people" for a long time, either on a federal scale or in relation to the subjects.
              1. Tatyana
                Tatyana April 15 2019 16: 53
                +9
                Quote: Sergej1972
                Both in Yakutia and in Tatarstan, the Russian language is used more widely than the Yakut and Tatar languages. We have not used the term "titular people" for a long time, either on a federal scale or in relation to the subjects.

                More than 15 years from Tatarstan from the Russian people constantly went to the government of the Russian Federation complaints about the oppression in the schools of Tatarstan of the study of the Russian language by ethnic Russians by Tatar nationalists in the legislative bodies! Things even reached Putin.
                And from Yakutia, students come to St. Petersburg to study at universities and secondary special educational institutions — moreover, in Yakutia, being excellent students in the Russian language, they do not speak Russian completely! And not perceiving lectures of teachers in Russian. As a result, they begin absenteeism, then not admission to exams and deductions after the 1-th semester. There already in some Russian families they do not even speak Russian at all.
                1. Tank jacket
                  Tank jacket April 15 2019 17: 50
                  +4
                  Tatyana, hi let's not forget yet the fact that mathematics and physics cannot be presented otherwise than in Russian. Just because of the lack of a conceptual framework. Here is such an incident — if we destroy the humanities in Russian — the slaughter of mathematicians and physicists.
                  1. Orlov
                    Orlov April 17 2019 17: 51
                    0
                    Quote: Tank jacket
                    Tatyana, hi let's not forget yet the fact that mathematics and physics cannot be presented otherwise than in Russian. Just because of the lack of a conceptual framework. Here is such an incident — if we destroy the humanities in Russian — the slaughter of mathematicians and physicists.

                    it is quite possible to use the international system in English, and it is even advisable to do so since a lot of technical documentation is suddenly not in Russian wink
                    for example, to train engineers in Russian without knowing all the terminology in English is already a waste of money, they are not competitive in the labor market.
                    1. Tank jacket
                      Tank jacket April 17 2019 18: 15
                      0
                      The conversation was about the multinational Russian people. Foreign languages ​​needless to be learned.
                  2. Ehanatone
                    Ehanatone April 18 2019 22: 04
                    +2
                    One misfortune is in the ocher ... sovereign Tatarstan they are very little aware of this!
          2. Stas157
            Stas157 April 15 2019 16: 01
            -3
            Quote: Nyrobsky
            Think primitively. No dear, these are ardent enemies and Russophobes, who they say what they think and what exactly they want to come to - the collapse of Russia.

            Yes, let them speak and think! Not tired of the ill-wishers listening? Why waste time on them?

            I’m trying to bring up a son (dependent on someone else’s opinion):
            - What difference does it make that someone might think about you? If they think something bad is their problem! But, if you pay attention to it, then these are your problems too. Do your thing. Do what you need. And if you are sure, then everything else is immaterial.

            But, somehow I still do not really succeed. Doubtful guy. He does everything with an eye on others.
            Quote: Nyrobsky
            They will break through funding for this, maintain institutions and staff, develop programs

            Is this a bugie then? Everyone will forget about it tomorrow.
      2. sniperino
        sniperino April 15 2019 09: 31
        -5
        Quote: Pessimist22
        a little more than a hundred years ago, Russia was much larger, and then only lost its territory.
        She returned the Crimea, settling in the Arctic ... But this is unknown to pessimists.
        1. For example
          For example April 15 2019 12: 13
          +6
          Optimist, appreciate the scale of your joy.
          Here is a map of our country in 1914.
    2. Mr Credo
      Mr Credo April 15 2019 06: 18
      +19
      Why dreams of the collapse of Russia !? Alaska at one time stupidly sold! In Russian-Japanese they gave half of Sakhalin. In Civil who collaborated with whom and what promised? Stalin returned part of the territory of the Republic of Ingushetia for future generations. How did the descendants dispose of the inheritance? What did the EBN say about sovereignty? Where does the current leadership lead Russia? What decay if upstairs speak of integration with them in their world !? We have already gone into religion many centuries ago. Why didn’t they defend their religion if there were such regular and patriots? Why didn’t the territories where literally yesterday (by historical standards) the Russian flag be hoisted be defended? Whose Alaska is today, but Berlin, and Paris, and Warsaw, and even Kabul? What's this? Defense? Or change?
    3. DPN
      DPN April 15 2019 08: 53
      +9
      The collapse of the Soviet Union during your life is not the collapse of Russia, and the worst part was destroyed by the Russians, the Gorbachev and Yeltsin, and the people supported. That we had 1/6 part of the world, now only 1/8 part, and we are holding only due to the nuclear shield of the Soviet Union.
      1. vlad106
        vlad106 April 15 2019 16: 33
        +5
        Quote: DPN
        The collapse of the Soviet Union during your life is not the collapse of Russia and the worst part was destroyed by the Russians-Gorbachev and Yeltsin

        either you are illiterate, or you're lying ...
        Why is Eltsin Russian? His uncle is a Chekist Boris Moiseevich Eltsin (Yeltsin), according to his patronymic, from the "God-chosen".
        Gorbaty has the same picture: "Raisa" "Maksimovna" Titarenko-Gorbachev from the same tribe.
        the children of both exporters are brought up in the appropriate spirit
    4. Vol4ara
      Vol4ara April 15 2019 10: 53
      +7
      Russia will be ruined from within by its "wise" politicians, the cup of patience is not endless
    5. Vladtrigu
      Vladtrigu April 15 2019 12: 49
      +5
      Quote: GKS 2111
      "Some regions may join countries such as Finland, Ukraine, China and Japan, of which Moscow forcibly appropriated territories in the past. Other republics of the North Caucasus, the Middle Volga region, Siberia and the Far East may become fully independent states and establish relations with China, Japan, USA and Europe. "

      "Some regions may join countries such as Finland, Ukraine, China and Japan, of which Moscow forcibly appropriated territories in the past. Other republics of the North Caucasus, the Middle Volga region, Siberia and the Far East may become fully independent states and establish relations with China, Japan, USA and Europe. "
      Quote: GKS 2111
      Someone’s dreams about the collapse of Russia exist as long as Russia itself exists in the world. Continue to dream, dreamers.

      vile Americans and their slime-assertions, claiming that our regions have been unlawfully appropriated by us, forget about the territory that the Indians have appropriated on which they now live
    6. Civil
      Civil April 15 2019 14: 52
      -1
      I haven't been for a long time, oh, how all the evil is here. A couple of unpopular reforms and again "uncle" is to blame) and not the notorious Vysotsky parrot))).
    7. tihonmarine
      tihonmarine April 21 2019 18: 19
      +1
      For more than a thousand years, Russia has existed and constantly during this period it has been waging wars for its independence and identity, and it is still Russia, although during this time a lot of new states of the USA, Latvia, Estonia, Ukraine have appeared in the world. And how many of them went into oblivion, many of them ascended to the sky and burned in an instant, and no one knows who, where and when will stumble and fall.
  2. Uncle lee
    Uncle lee April 15 2019 05: 11
    +6
    "the inhabitants of Siberia and the Russian Far East will be further separated from the center, which will stimulate demands for secession and sovereignty."
    That we already passed in the holy nineties! Let this pan go with his advice on ..... Specify the road from Susanin!
    1. Errr
      Errr April 15 2019 05: 50
      +1
      Well, in general, - he goes through the forest. laughing
      1. Uncle lee
        Uncle lee April 15 2019 06: 10
        +8

        Direction indicated, can follow!
    2. Mr Credo
      Mr Credo April 15 2019 06: 23
      +21
      But why then did Moscow separate from Russia? If Moscow is Russia, then why are the living standards different? Or is Moses Susanin leading Russia? I don’t understand anything!
      1. Alber
        Alber April 15 2019 13: 17
        +5
        Quote: Mr Credo
        But why then did Moscow separate from Russia? If Moscow is Russia, then why are the living standards different? Or is Moses Susanin leading Russia? I don’t understand anything!

        Right! Moses, I don’t know what surname leads the country. Hell knows where.
        Purpose: so that his people live well, at the expense of indigenous peoples
      2. naidas
        naidas April 15 2019 18: 14
        -2
        The standards are different in the USA, is New York separated from the USA?
    3. Alber
      Alber April 15 2019 06: 35
      +6
      Р
      Quote: Uncle Lee
      "the inhabitants of Siberia and the Russian Far East will be further separated from the center, which will stimulate demands for secession and sovereignty."
      That we already passed in the holy nineties! Let this pan go with his advice on ..... Specify the road from Susanin!

      To disassemble the country into small pieces and put their rulers there to govern is the old, wet dreams of the "chosen of God"
    4. The comment was deleted.
  3. YOUR
    YOUR April 15 2019 05: 14
    -2
    Dreaming is not harmful. If a person dreams, then he is alive. And these are still alive. Until they begin to realize their dreams.
  4. Ali Kokand
    Ali Kokand April 15 2019 05: 19
    +24
    Any workable system created under certain conditions also has the conditions for its destruction. In the West, they are purposefully seeking conditions that can lead to the collapse of Russia; everything is logical and understandable. There may well be new people like Gorbachev and Yeltsin, the technologies are worked out. In the days of the USSR, people were sure that the KGB and the army would not allow the collapse of the USSR. Allowed .. Therefore, do not underestimate such scenarios, prepare countermeasures. But who and what, this is the main question.
    1. depressant
      depressant April 15 2019 07: 14
      +30
      Ali Kokand, this is the correct formulation of the question. I am categorically against the disintegration of Russia and I believe that all colleagues here, at VO, need to carefully analyze the possible reasons for the collapse of our country - without the false patriotic squeals of "You will not wait!", Without drooling and snot. It is in order to identify pain points and do everything possible to neutralize them.
      In my humble opinion, one of the reasons for the collapse of Russia may be the exorbitant appetites of our oligarchs, senior and middle officials and the attitude of the political leadership of the country - that is, in recent years that has led to the deaths of tens of thousands of important industrial enterprises, depriving hundreds of thousands or maybe millions of skilled people work. For example, having lusted the other day about the closure of the last bearing plant, I immediately find out that the Vladimir Tractor is closed ...
      This is instead to help these plants with public finances and keep them as strategically important. And how many such strategically important and in many ways unique closed! This is instead of upgrading them. They say that the state does not have the appropriate funds to help these plants withstand competition in the global market. Let's see why. Here are the dry numbers. Of the excess profits from the sale of oil to the state development funds of different countries invested:
      Qatar - $ 320 billion;
      Kuwait - 592 billion;
      Saudi Arabia - 804 billion;
      Norway - 1 trillion 54 billion;
      United Arab Emirates - 1 trillion 154 billion dollars.
      And finally, Russia. You will not believe! Only $ 59 billion! .. And this despite the fact that Russian oil workers transferred them to their personal offshore accounts - in words! - one trillion dollars! Personal accounts! This is in addition to yachts, palaces, estates, clubs, islands and others. Naturally abroad. And that's just for oil. If we assume that the population of Russia is 140 million people (just for the convenience of the account), then each of us has more than $ 7. But we don't need this money, the industry categorically needed it for its modernization. Now there is nothing to modernize. And the offshore trillion dollars have been sanctioned. The oligarchs' accounts were arrested. The oligarchs are "poorer"! And what is our "tandem" doing to help the poor fellows - oil and others? But what ...
      To pay the fee for "Platon", just go to any branch of Sberbank. From there, as you naively believe, this money will go to the Road Fund to invest in the road network. But no! First, they go to a company like "Horns and Hooves" called LLC "RTITS", and only then to the Road Fund. And what is this company doing? But nothing! Just a staging post. For this, the owners of the company, which are the rich gentlemen Rotenberg and Chemizov, are weighed out from the state treasury 11 billion rubles a year ... And here is Mr. Usmanov - also not poor ... What is a barcode, you know? Now a barcode will be plopped on any item produced in Russia. Slap right - 0.5 rubles. On a national scale, billions. Mr. Usmanov will collect this tax in his own pocket. And that's just what you hear! Not a cherry - a weighty pineapple on a consoling oligarchic cake was added by President Putin, signing a law on tax exemptions for those oligarchs and officials who "suffered" from Western sanctions. To do this, it is enough for them to become non-residents of Russia. That is, all the proceeds should be sent to those offshores that have not been reached by Western sanctions. Do you think not? And in order to make up for the non-receipts in the state treasury, the population was imposed additional taxes and the retirement age was raised. And it, the population, has been squeezed out almost dry. And when there is absolutely nothing to take from us, it is not we who are the oligarchs and the higher officials who will start dividing the country, feeling not the slightest gratitude to either Putin or Medvedev. They don't remember us about us - they don't even know that we exist. Hence the conclusion: urgent nationalization of the subsoil and the entire extractive industry.
  5. Ross xnumx
    Ross xnumx April 15 2019 05: 45
    +35
    Russia is the successor to the Byzantine Empire. Therefore, the lessons of the fall of the millennial state are also relevant for us:

    Quote: GKS 2111
    Someone’s dreams of the collapse of Russia exist as long as Russia itself exists in the world. Keep dreaming, dreamers.

    Did you live in the USSR in the 50-60s? At a time when the Soviet people who turned the head of the fascist hydra built and rebuilt? When they worked in three shifts, when the buses could not cope with the flow of passengers going to work? When did schools work in three shifts (first, second and evening)? When did you cancel coupons, when did you listen to the satellite signals and looked for it in the sky? ...
    Then also was:
    Union of the indestructible republics free
    Great Russia forever.
    Long live the people's will
    A single, mighty Soviet Union!

    And those who rule the country today were born at the same time. But the Union collapsed. So "by chance". And no one dreamed of surviving such a collapse. I do not see the forces (in power) ready to unite the nation. I do not see. A bunch of krakhobor, who ate belly and goiters, talking about the weakness of the USSR and the greatness of the West, traveling the world in search of "likes" and investments, complaining about the backwardness and downturn of the electorate ... You still do not see the edges of the Moscow Empire, which put a with your 2 billion budget to the regions floundering in debt? Tell me here that this is not so, and that in our country everyone lives the same way, everything is beautiful and wonderful with prosperity, employment, and the environment ... I'm not saying that the regions are dying out - these are statistics. Stupefying by primitive labor activity for a piece of bread - are these highly skilled jobs? Do you know why the crap is shown on TV? Because it is rather problematic to show modern production in the country with all its nuances. It is hard to talk about the benefits of the exam when graduates do not know the names of great historical figures. It is difficult to treat sick children when it is possible to "vegetate" on the salary of a nurse and a doctor ...
    I don’t want disintegration either, but I don’t believe in the sincerity of such thoughts of those who have already built a family nest in Spain or elsewhere ...
    hi
    1. vladimirZ
      vladimirZ April 15 2019 06: 36
      +22
      I don’t want disintegration either, but I don’t believe in the sincerity of such thoughts of those who have already built a family nest in Spain or elsewhere ...
      - ROSS 42

      Great comment, ROSS 42. The reality of the collapse of Russia following the example of the USSR, unfortunately, exists under the current regime of compradors, corrupt officials and kleptocracy who are ready to turn everything in for a Western gesheft.
      Yes, and the economic weakness of our state, generated by this pro-Western power liberalism, causes concern, and most importantly, the political and social tension among the people is a source of public and state disasters.
      I don’t understand only the uri-kaloks, who, instead of serious concern about the current situation, analysis and suggestion of measures to correct it, are marked by hat-writing comments.
      1. Mestny
        Mestny April 15 2019 09: 12
        -16
        Is your concern helping you solve real problems?
        No.
        The only thing she does is destroys the mood of those who really work.
        And there are many who work, really many. Our country is big, and it lives.
        But people like you, with your eternal concern, crawl into all the holes of your verbosity and fantasy worlds.
        Constant concern is the diagnosis. Go to the doctor. It will be easier for us to work, and they will help you.
        1. AA17
          AA17 April 15 2019 12: 00
          +10
          Dear, Mestny (Sergey). Your words: "... But people like you, with your eternal concern, crawl into all the holes of your verbosity and invented worlds." - very WISE and ACTUAL. Really why worry. The bulk of the people have nothing to worry about. The people must work and work "a lot, really a lot." And 3% of the richest Russians will take care of the rest of the Russian citizens:
          "... 3% of the richest Russians own almost all the cash savings and financial assets in the country," Kommersant reports, citing the results of a study by analysts from the Higher School of Economics and the Institute for Research and Expertise of Vnesheconombank. ... "
          Indeed, Russian citizens do not need to worry that "... Rusal will help an American company build a plant in the US. UC Rusal, recently freed from US sanctions, will build with US Braidy Industries the first US aluminum plant in 30 years. Its cost is estimated at $ 1,7 , XNUMX billion .... ". This begs several questions: "... It turns out that we are building a plant in America at our own expense, supplying it with raw materials, leaving the profit there, and all this is in the interests of Russia?"
          If so, what are they, these interests?
          And if not, it may not give permission for this transaction?
          After all, America at one time did not allow the purchase of Opel, stating that it was contrary to the interests of America ... "(c)
          P.S. And who is generally worried that investments go not to Russia, but to other countries? "... Chairman of the Russian Accounts Chamber, ex-Minister of Finance Alexei Kudrin assessed the possibility of implementing a plan to increase investment in fixed assets in Russia to 25% of GDP. Such a task, in his opinion," most likely "will not be accomplished. Kudrin shared with journalists in Washington, RBC reports. ... "And who will be responsible for this?
        2. vlad106
          vlad106 April 15 2019 12: 32
          +8
          Quote: Mestny
          Is your concern helping you solve real problems?
          No.
          The only thing she does is destroys the mood of those who really work.
          And there are many who work, really many. Our country is big, and it lives.
          But people like you, with your eternal concern, crawl into all the holes of your verbosity and fantasy worlds.
          Constant concern is the diagnosis. Go to the doctor. It will be easier for us to work, and they will help you.

          There is practically no work in the country. hundreds of thousands of factories are plundered and destroyed by your tribesmen.
          And it is dangerous to go to doctors now. those who mainly support the current predatory system "work" vigorously. Stalin at one time decided to deal with these fraudulent poisoners (The Doctors' Case), and they got ahead of him. poisoned
    2. Mr Credo
      Mr Credo April 15 2019 06: 59
      +16
      Bravo ROSS! And who of the current leadership speaks of the revival of Russia or the Russian Empire? They say about the infusion into the global economy. They say about the inefficiency of state administration. They are talking about selling state property to private hands. They speak of Russia as a regional country. Russia does not set the task of becoming an empire! Russia sets the task of becoming a country of the modern world! Bravo! What does this mean in translation into Russian !? Russia sets the task to integrate into the Western world on its terms! What a conquest of Russia if the leadership is already trembling with desire to be built into their system! Already since the 90s they have thrown to the altar of integration! Sanctions!? Yeah! From the 90s they were eager for the West, and now they are suddenly offended! And what offended !? Yes to your dream! It turned out there, in addition to gloss and neon, there are requirements! And offense went. They bend us! Guys! Well, you and there were torn there in the 90s! And for what their grudge gnaws! Not for the Power! For your bank accounts! And what did those offended do !? Withdrew all their money there and invested here !? Yeah! All the same groans about pressure on Russia through their wallet! Well, for what and for whom is our leadership worried? People! Help! Bullies are robbing money! So what? Did your money help you? Why call the people for help if the bet was made on money ???
      1. Mestny
        Mestny April 15 2019 09: 16
        -18
        Help the story! Help take the wallet from the inside!
        You see - the west is not managing? The country is still standing.
        Help the west - destroy it from the inside.

        This is the essence of all your ideas, and your concern.
        1. Vladtrigu
          Vladtrigu April 15 2019 12: 56
          +10
          Quote: Mestny
          Help the story! Help take the wallet from the inside!
          You see - the west is not managing? The country is still standing.
          Help the west - destroy it from the inside.

          This is the essence of all your ideas, and your concern.

          The West, with its puppet agents, has already destroyed the country.
          destroyed up to 95% of enterprises, destroyed agriculture. Even kindergartens and educational institutions were reduced in speed, so that the Russian people could not and did not want to give birth and increase the population and develop
          Now it's time to gather the country and rebuild the industry
  6. samarin1969
    samarin1969 April 15 2019 06: 17
    +6
    Where the Time of Troubles - there are Poles. Perhaps the only thought of the article.
    As for the rest, the author “corrects” himself in such a way that it is difficult to understand his conclusions.
    1. vlad106
      vlad106 April 15 2019 12: 39
      +4
      Quote: samarin1969
      Where the Time of Troubles - there are Poles. Perhaps the only thought of the article.

      You can even clarify: in troubled times (in troubled waters), not just Poles.
      And the Poles are Jews. Where they are, there is devastation, robbery, civil war or revolution
  7. parusnik
    parusnik April 15 2019 06: 19
    +8
    To such articles, all the same, you need to be more serious, draw conclusions and take measures so that once again you do not step on the rake ...
    1. Reptiloid
      Reptiloid April 15 2019 10: 24
      +5
      When I hear (read) about agglomerations, conglomerations, thoughts about some kind of division into zones already get into my head. !!! And if you recall the changes in the railway message .....
      Quote: parusnik
      To such articles, all the same, you need to be more serious, draw conclusions and take measures so that once again you do not step on the rake ...
  8. Andrey Chistyakov
    Andrey Chistyakov April 15 2019 06: 22
    +3
    But he was too shy to write about the partition of Poland. All about us. Oh well.
    1. Den717
      Den717 April 15 2019 11: 27
      +2
      Quote: Andrey Chistyakov
      And about the partition of Poland he was too shy to write

      You can write about the partition of Poland. Do you think it was just taken and divided? With her "love of freedom", noble arrogance and hatred of her "cattle", she created such an internal mess that it began to influence the border regions of neighboring countries. So Poland was divided in order to bring its population into "peace and harmony." The joint declaration of Russia and Austria of December 23.12.1794, XNUMX says: "Two monarchs, convinced by the experience of the past in the decisive inability of the Polish Republic to arrange a similar (firm and strong) rule in itself, or to live peacefully under the auspices of laws, being in a state of any independence , recognized for the good in terms of preserving the peace and happiness of their subjects, that it is imperative to undertake and carry out a perfect division of this republic between three neighboring powers. "I think that when they wrote this declaration, they knew very well why and why this division was carried out. Pan Bugaysky did not reveal anything new about the question of the partition of Russia, but only recalled the conceptual idea of ​​the Prometheus organization, born of the ardent anti-Russian nationalist Józef Pilsudski. Nothing new, no creativity. Researchers from the centers of the strategy of the West have diminished. One naphthalene. Although, in contrast to this Bugaysky, the former Polish ambassador to Russia wrote an article in which she recognized the need to establish cooperation with Russia in the economic, political and humanitarian spheres. These are the turbulences in the Polish political class. They have different winds in their heads there ... There are more Russophobic people.
  9. Bator
    Bator April 15 2019 06: 26
    -1
    regular pshek
    1. Same lech
      Same lech April 15 2019 06: 52
      +4
      Such Poles are the worst enemies of our country ... one Zbigniew Brzezinski, which cost Russia ... with his poison of Russophobia, he infected many people in the world.
      It is imperative to have a vaccine against this for such Poles.
      1. Reptiloid
        Reptiloid April 15 2019 10: 31
        +2
        But the Poles are afraid that the Germans will say ---- give ours! And they can’t answer, they quarreled with Russia, how can I refer to the Victory! And they understand that Russia after Russophobia will not take care of them! Looking for a patron! And who can put pressure on Germany? Only the states.
        Quote: The same Lech
        Such Poles are the worst enemies of our country ... one Zbigniew Brzezinski, which cost Russia ... with his poison of Russophobia, he infected many people in the world.
        It is imperative to have a vaccine against this for such Poles.
    2. Alber
      Alber April 15 2019 13: 24
      +1
      Quote: Bator
      regular pshek

      I think that the pshek of the "chosen" breed
      Quote: The same Lech
      Such Poles are the worst enemies of our country ... one Zbigniew Brzezinski, which cost Russia ... with his poison of Russophobia, he infected many people in the world.
      It is imperative to have a vaccine against this for such Poles.

      And Bzdezhinsky of the same blood
  10. Dimy4
    Dimy4 April 15 2019 06: 29
    +2
    Another poisonous Pole, one specialist was already super poisonous. I.z.doh.
  11. Plague doctor
    Plague doctor April 15 2019 06: 30
    +6
    If you consider that since the time of the Russian
    The empire had lost a huge amount of territory, then the collapse of Russia is quite possible. In Russia, there are a lot of reasons for internal conflicts, there are gaps in salaries, and a bunch of migrants which the local population does not like, and a war in the Caucasus that could be unleashed again. In Russia, the people have no common ideas, faiths, goals, patriotism, people are very motley. Probably about the collapse of RI. and the USSR, too, no one thought
  12. polar fox
    polar fox April 15 2019 06: 31
    +9
    external threats, as history has shown, are not particularly scary for the Russians ... but the internal enemies of the people, these will do everything to amuse their own ego. starting with Khrushche and to this day, examples are just a twig, but in industry and cartoons, what is he not right? in Poland at least there is an agricultural enterprise, but in our country, apart from Tkachev and his "affairs", what?
  13. Far B
    Far B April 15 2019 06: 35
    +6
    Why is THIS in analytics? Where is the analytics here? An article by some stupid Pole on some incomprehensible resource is being smashed in the tail and in the mane ... To smash stupid in absentia is five, yes. (In person, it is more difficult, because the dumb, as a rule, are also stubborn, and you will have to descend to their level, where they will crush them with their experience ... In general, everything is according to the classics). And on what basis did the author bring out his masterpiece "Western intelligence services, in particular the CIA, have successfully slept through the collapse of the USSR" ??? Was the author admitted to the secret archives of the CIA? The fact that they wrote some kind of reports about the renewed union state - for general review, i.e. screen. And the fact is that EBN first of all called Bush-papa and reported for 20 minutes that "the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics, as a geopolitical reality, has ceased to exist ...". Western intelligence services, of course, have nothing to do with this, not ...
  14. rotmistr60
    rotmistr60 April 15 2019 06: 59
    +2
    Janusz Bugai
    Another Polish Russophobe entrenched in warm European offices dreams, rolling his eyes to the sky, about how Russia will fall apart. Yes, there are a dime a dozen of such "Janusz" all over Europe and not only. One Yakob Koreyba is on our TV for two - he pours Russia as he wants, threatens with punishment, boasts of his European affiliation, friendship with the United States, and for this he also receives money from us. For a long time this "guaido" does not surprise, it is just that sometimes it is a shame that we ourselves allow them to do it.
  15. Alex66
    Alex66 April 15 2019 07: 12
    +8
    How to destroy Russia is to turn to our officials for experience. Here in the Urals, a guy gave back to the Armenians, stood up for the girl and went to prison. When I started working, I knew when I would retire, and now the rulers have taken and retroactively changed the conditions, so that they are "gentlemen lied." Courts we have one house arrest with walks for theft of million rubles. the other two years for a bag of compound feed. We are divided in different ways, so long as we are not together. And take the same Donbass as soon as it sounded folk It became clear to the republic in such a format that they are not needed, suddenly a chain reaction will follow them. So it’s more dangerous than our government, for the collapse of Russia, there’s nothing. So did the rulers of the USSR.
    1. Alber
      Alber April 15 2019 13: 34
      +4
      Quote: Alex66
      How to ruin Russia, so it is necessary to turn to our officials for experience. Here in our Urals, the guy gave back to the Armenians, stood up for the girl and went to prison.

      Yes! I heard about this story. The feeble bespectacled kid did the right thing to intercede for the Russian woman from the arrogant Armenian migrant chaos, and gave a boar a snot. And that Armen drew up a complaint, probably inflating 282 anti-Russian article. The guy needs to be supported! We should all write a letter of request together for his release
  16. knn54
    knn54 April 15 2019 07: 18
    +5
    I will say at once, such articles "became frequent" before the collapse of the USSR. Then Western analysts admit that if the Union had endured for 4-5 years, the West would have collapsed, which was saved by the resources of the collapsed Power.
    Now the same thing is happening: "New" is the invitation of the PRC (previously only the West and Japan.
    Now, regarding Alisher’s comment: the gendarmes (special services) did not save the Empire — look how many of them (including at the top) were in the Cheka. The same can be said about the KGB.
    After all, the worst enemy is the inner one. For "the buy is bad who does not dream of becoming a khan / emir" ...
  17. Million
    Million April 15 2019 07: 58
    +15
    The main enemy of Russia today is its current power.
    1. Obem
      Obem April 15 2019 08: 25
      +11
      Quote: Million
      The main enemy of Russia today is its current power.

      right now they will zaminusut you. we have bad hunchbacks, Yeltsin, and Putin and his friends are good. anyway, do not rock the boat)
      1. Million
        Million April 15 2019 08: 32
        +10
        A little later. They still have not arrived at the service)
    2. Mestny
      Mestny April 15 2019 08: 32
      -19
      Do not reduce the intensity of the struggle!
      It helps your western friends to know the real Russia.
    3. Boris55
      Boris55 April 15 2019 08: 36
      -12
      Quote: Million
      The main enemy of Russia today is its current power.

      And which one:
      - conceptual power;
      - ideological power;
      - legislature;
      - executive power;
      - judicial investigative authority?

      Does Russia have the first two powers or is it dictated to us from outside?
      Where do we start?

      As long as we do not have sovereignty and domestic politics are determined from outside, then the delirium of the Pole may well become a reality. The only ones who defend the independence of Russia are the siloviki, whose representative in power is Putin.
      1. Million
        Million April 15 2019 08: 42
        +7
        We must stop lying!
        1. Boris55
          Boris55 April 15 2019 08: 43
          -6
          Quote: Million
          We must stop lying!

          Everyone has their own truth, and the truth is the truth of many. How to be

          1. Million
            Million April 15 2019 08: 49
            +6
            Black should be called black, and white-white.
            1. Boris55
              Boris55 April 15 2019 08: 51
              -7
              Quote: Million
              Black should be called black, and white-white.

              Do you know that the purest light is black and the dirtiest is white? Do not believe? Ask the artists. laughing
              1. Million
                Million April 15 2019 08: 53
                +9
                Let's go without allegories.
                1. Mestny
                  Mestny April 15 2019 09: 01
                  -13
                  This is not an allegory. This is reality, strictly according to the laws of physics.
                  It's like you come up with worlds for pink horses in a vacuum. And then they argue - which is better. What variant of communism must be built.
                  Yes, you will not build any. Nobody built it, and you certainly won’t build it.
                  1. Million
                    Million April 15 2019 09: 08
                    +7
                    stop hysterics
                  2. Mestny
                    Mestny April 15 2019 09: 19
                    -13
                    A tantrum?
                    In your fictitious world of a spherical socially fair horse in a red vacuum, you can come up with any rules and definitions.
                    In the real world, just do not pop.
                2. Boris55
                  Boris55 April 15 2019 09: 01
                  -5
                  Quote: Million
                  Let's go without allegories.

                  Let's. True, lies are relative concepts. The previous question (from my first comment) is to what authority do you have complaints?
                  1. victor50
                    victor50 April 17 2019 09: 50
                    -1
                    Quote: Boris55
                    what authority do you have claims to?

                    Scientist Boris came out? As always, with claims to knowledge that does not possess ?!
                    There is no judicial investigative authority. There is a trial! A investigative refers to the executive. Conceptual is, apparently, RenTV too ?! And, claims, I think, to you - to your inexhaustible demagogy.
          2. tatra
            tatra April 15 2019 08: 51
            +8
            According to the "truth" of the Kremlin bots' manuals, there was no point in voting for Putin, because firstly, according to your manuals, it turns out that he is the head of the colonial administration, and secondly, his "bad boyars" do not obey him, but do what they do he pleases, and it is he who obeys what they have done.
            1. Boris55
              Boris55 April 15 2019 08: 57
              -1
              Quote: tatra
              he is the head of the colonial administration

              Yes it is.
              We all live according to the colonial Constitution, written to us in the State Department.

              Quote: tatra
              it is he who obeys what they did

              Yes it is.
              We all live by the laws adopted by the Duma. To whom does she serve:


              1. tatra
                tatra April 15 2019 09: 03
                +13
                Ha, thanks for confirming my words. So what, are you all the same for this power, including Putin and edrossov?
                1. Boris55
                  Boris55 April 15 2019 09: 05
                  -7
                  Quote: tatra
                  You are all the same for this power

                  For which one (see my first comment)?

                  Quote: tatra
                  including Putin and edrossov

                  Give flies separately, and cutlets separately.
                  The chairman of the EP party is Medvedev.
                  Putin refused the services of EP in the 2012 year.
                  1. tatra
                    tatra April 15 2019 09: 13
                    +12
                    Well, a cowardly twisting of one kremlebot began, and from below another kremlebot rushed to his aid, trying to discredit me. All according to the manuals. The authorities understand that their attempts to extol themselves and to excuse themselves from responsibility for what is happening in Russia no longer work, so all the forces of their paid propagandists are thrown into an attempt to discredit dissidents. Thank you, kremlebots, for not enrolling me as an "agent of the State Department" yet.
                    1. Mestny
                      Mestny April 15 2019 09: 23
                      -15
                      What are you?
                      Discredit?
                      And who are you? What do you know about power, real, and not invented by people like you?
                      You don't even understand how ridiculous and primitive your childhood nonsense "about power" is. And everything was fine - they read it, laughed, and parted.
                      So no, you’re adults, you’re not enough, you still have to pull the sleeve.
                      So you are politely pushed out of the way, or even simply asked to step aside.
              2. Mestny
                Mestny April 15 2019 09: 03
                -13
                Listen up. Well, it seems like an adult. Well, it’s primitive to troll - even teenagers begin to notice something.
                Here on this site for whom is writing?
                1. Boris55
                  Boris55 April 15 2019 09: 08
                  -5
                  Quote: Mestny
                  Here on this site for whom is writing?

                  If your ideas about life are illusory, then the consequences of these illusions will be quite specific.
      2. Blaster
        Blaster April 15 2019 08: 47
        0
        What kind of nonsense? Putin and security forces defend independence, but Russia is controlled from outside .....
        1. Boris55
          Boris55 April 15 2019 08: 48
          -6
          Quote: Blaster
          What kind of nonsense?

          Read my first koment. What power does not suit you?
        2. AU Ivanov.
          AU Ivanov. April 15 2019 09: 10
          -5
          If Russia was controlled from outside, then Crimea would not be ours.
          1. Obem
            Obem April 15 2019 09: 17
            +8
            Quote: AS Ivanov.
            If Russia was controlled from outside, then Crimea would not be ours.

            so in fact he is not ours anyway) except that on our map he is with us, and so - no. there is not even sber.
          2. Vladtrigu
            Vladtrigu April 15 2019 16: 06
            +1
            Quote: AU Ivanov.
            If Russia was controlled from outside, then Crimea would not be ours.

            Whose? Mikoels? They will still remind of themselves after some time.
      3. Lannan Shi
        Lannan Shi April 15 2019 09: 13
        +13
        Quote: Boris55
        The only ones who defend the independence of Russia are the siloviki, whose representative in power is Putin.

        Interesting such defenders. Well, with them the country is dying then? - 450 thousand last year, January of this - minus another 50 thousand. Half a million for 13 months. 30-40 years still protect, and there will be no one to protect.
  18. AlexSam
    AlexSam April 15 2019 08: 18
    +8
    Well, about the breakup, the guy, of course, got excited, a well-known item on his collar, and not a breakdown, but about the fact that the Moscow state lives off of the regions, that all the money is pumped out of there, and then the regions are subsidized, that the Moscow boyars are furious with fat , measuring the regions of their lactation, a miserable salary (because everything was bought upright by the boyars), inflating the prices of fuel, energy and a communal apartment, giving free rein to large networks with shareholders in some Dutch and Belgian countries to draw price tags for products as they please, unless he not right? or is it that the people of Moscow are appointed as governors to monitor the successful collection of taxes and suppress the discontent of the population, is he also wrong?

    PS. I’m only interested in one thing: will the people ever run out of patience, or will we still wipe the spit from our faces and give thanks for it? I watched about Chubais at night, it turns out that the person is a deeply conspiratorial hero like Serdyukov! or does anyone doubt it? you see, the day will come when he will be awarded the title of Hero of Russia))
  19. rocket757
    rocket757 April 15 2019 08: 23
    +2
    Yes, there are "sages" in the strip and the corresponding plans / manuals are written! Babosiki to tomuzha stand out very not small! One-piece "Advice ...." works!
    We should all remember, know and work strictly against.
  20. Mestny
    Mestny April 15 2019 08: 31
    -14
    So what is it, it turns out our omnipotent people, when they vote about Russia, are they also doing a good deed? Launch the process of disinformation of the enemy?
    Excellent!
  21. Andrey VOV
    Andrey VOV April 15 2019 09: 04
    -1
    Another nonsense of a Polish citizen who has been recorded at the genetic level.
  22. Mestny
    Mestny April 15 2019 09: 06
    -9
    Quote: tatra
    According to the "truth" of the Kremlin bots' manuals, there was no point in voting for Putin, because firstly, according to your manuals, it turns out that he is the head of the colonial administration, and secondly, his "bad boyars" do not obey him, but do what they do he pleases, and it is he who obeys what they have done.

    Does not work.
    But you don’t understand this, in principle.
    The key here is to vote. Not for Putin, but for another. Not for the other - it's so easy to ruin the newsletter. Show your civic position according to the laws of the state.
    But people like you do not go to the polls at all. Nobody is chosen. Just download on the Internet.
    Is your country an internet?
  23. Artavazdych
    Artavazdych April 15 2019 09: 23
    0
    To be honest, Poland is one of the most successfully developing countries in Europe. In vain the author is sarcastic about this. Look at the growth of its GDP and industrial production.
    But that is not the point. Look at her minimum wage and her average salary. 520 and 1200 euros respectively.
    And compare with us.
    I hate this word - hatred. What would replace it?
    1. BAI
      BAI April 15 2019 09: 58
      +3
      For 10 years of membership in the EU, Poland received 101,3 billion euros of assistance (for 2014).
      During the same time (first 10 years), Poland paid EUR 33,3 billion to the joint EU budget. That is, only under this program Poland's gesheft about 70 billion euros in 10 years. And the country is slightly smaller than Ukraine and its population is 38 million.
      This is from 2004 to 2014. Further:
      As UNIAN reported in 2014, the 2004-million-strong Poland, which joined the European Union in May 38, remains the largest recipient of European aid among all 28 countries of the association. In the current seven-year budget for 2014-2020, 105,8 billion euros of assistance is provided for it.

      Those. from 2004 to 2020 will receive 207.1 billion euros. This is only from the EU. And there is the United States and the IMF.
      And compare with us.
      I hate this word - hatred. What would replace it?

      Mb - by calculation?
      And if the program is not extended, what will happen in 2021?
      1. g_ae
        g_ae April 15 2019 10: 57
        +8
        But I wonder how much money was taken out of Russia during the same time? And how were the funds "used" in the country? Why the Poles were smart enough to properly dispose of help and create a reserve for development, while Russian "effective managers" somehow do not impress, to put it mildly.
      2. Artavazdych
        Artavazdych April 15 2019 13: 17
        +2
        Poland's gesheft about 70 billion

        I don’t know such a word in Russian as a gesheft, but I can guess from the meaning - the benefit.
        Well, we also got loans at one time ... and?
        Rather, not us, but those who are now very successful - sitting, for example, at the right hand of the President, or heading all kinds of people.
  24. lopvlad
    lopvlad April 15 2019 09: 34
    +5
    With today's liberal policy inside Russia with the slogan "more power and authority to transfer to the regions," these dreams of the West do not look like dreams at all. Especially considering that such conclusions in the West are made not from scratch, but based on the fact that Russia is still excellent various Western NGOs feel and work.
    The collapse of Russia in 1991, it was the collapse of Russia since the primordially Russian lands left into other states, it was because Lenin actually transferred more power and authority to the regions by creating a whole bunch of republics. We still have two people in Russia with a post of the president (the president of Russia and the president of Tatarstan).
    I would work in the regions of the Americans on the topic of creating many new republics within Russia (the Ural Republic, the Far Eastern Republic, the Siberian Republic, etc.) and the worst thing is that they are already working on it, while the Kremlin continues to lower more authorities in the regions.
  25. Nestorych
    Nestorych April 15 2019 09: 41
    -1
    Discussion of Polish vysers, this is not serious.
  26. BAI
    BAI April 15 2019 09: 47
    +1
    1. Bugaysky is haunted by the Brzezinski Lavra. A vacant place must be taken.
    2. I.e. the fact that separatism is in Ukraine and vitally important federalization for Russia.
  27. The comment was deleted.
  28. Tank jacket
    Tank jacket April 15 2019 10: 05
    +4
    The rate on the collapse of Russia, according to information from the General Staff, is placed on the "Trojan Horse". Those. NGOs, Jehovah's Witnesses, Soros foundations, Scientologists, sects, ISIS (the irregular US army is banned in the Russian Federation), animal welfare funds, greenpeace, football fans ... Ie. all who are capable of organizing a coup. And for this case, funds are allocated from the American budget. Now it is clear why Mama's corners sat down ... Jehovah's Witnesses are being pressed, etc.
  29. Major48
    Major48 April 15 2019 10: 39
    +2
    Alive, smoking room, it turns out. I thought that this professional anti-Soviet and mental Russophobe had already come to an end. A Pole born in Britain simply cannot but be Russophobe. But it is necessary to listen, such specialists in the USA, from among those who have come in, are very active and prolific, they must always get ahead of the Americans in order to earn extra money.
    1. Vladtrigu
      Vladtrigu April 15 2019 16: 10
      +2
      Quote: Major48
      A Pole born in Britain simply cannot but be Russophobe.

      I think he is the same Pole as Obama is a Chinese
  30. 1536
    1536 April 15 2019 12: 36
    +4
    If you do not maintain order in the house, do not repair, do not change something rotten or outdated with a new or progressive one, then the house may first come into disrepair and then begin to collapse. However, one needs to watch what is happening outside the window. Because if you have some scoundrel urinating under the fence or throw cigarette butts at the woods, it means that such a person must be driven away so that he does not urinate and does not throw cigarette butts. A simple worldly logic that applies to each individual house, household, family and the whole country as a whole.
    The USSR collapsed due to the indifference of some, the malicious intent of others and the will of others from outside. You cannot repeat this error. Therefore, with regard to all sorts of Poland, one must act very tough.
  31. Saffron
    Saffron April 15 2019 13: 01
    +3
    regions such as Sakha and Magadan in the Far East, with their significant mineral wealth, could become successful states without the exploitation of Moscow.

    Any region of the world with significant mineral wealth will never be ignored by "Western democracy". In this case, he will lose independence and calmness.
    1. g_ae
      g_ae April 15 2019 17: 35
      +4
      And why should Western democracies bother? Moscow authorities themselves are doing pretty well. Where do these very mineral resources of the regions flow? Just in time for these very democracies. And where does the revenue from their sale go? Also in bank accounts in the countries of these democracies. And how is it now with calm and independence, for example, in the same Yakutia? And especially in the light of the latest repressive laws, the current situation for such regions is certainly not an occupation regime, but also not sugar. That is, its own central authority sucks out almost all resources from the regions, and liquid rations come back. To support the pants. And what enchanting burgomaster and officials he puts to feed. Song.
      1. Saffron
        Saffron April 16 2019 09: 26
        0
        The only difference is that the country is one, and not several fragmented "principalities" floating with the flow without an independent policy and future
        1. g_ae
          g_ae April 16 2019 09: 51
          +1
          I remember very well that in 89 and even 90 nobody believed that the USSR would fall apart. However, we have what we have. Too frightening analogies. A president who dwells in parallel space, creates a government of all kinds of indecency, and even there is an appropriate party. Guiding and guiding. Kodla extraordinary and successful individuals. Well, the people there, somewhere below, are swarming. He does not understand his happiness. Shelupon, as the governor of Arkhangelsk put it.
  32. viktorish007
    viktorish007 April 15 2019 13: 20
    0
    serious people will not write such nonsense, probably Putin ordered the yellow western newspaper the material about Russia to write
  33. nikvic46
    nikvic46 April 15 2019 14: 50
    +1
    They don’t know a damn thing about our man. They walk around our cities and see our kind, hospitable, and even gentle people. If they could imagine ours in a moment of danger. I think they would write differently.
  34. Sergej1972
    Sergej1972 April 15 2019 15: 48
    +1
    This "specialist" is not even aware that in a good half of the republics of the Russian Federation, Russians either absolutely predominate or are the largest group of the population. Even in a quarter, they are not the largest, but, nevertheless, the second largest population group. And in the four autonomous okrugs that remained after the enlargement processes, and in the Jewish Autonomous Region, Russians constitute the absolute majority of the population.
    And the names of the Khanty-Mansiysk Autonomous Okrug and the Jewish Autonomous Region generally sound mocking. That Jews are in the EAO, that the Khanty and Mansi in the Khanty-Mansi Autonomous Okrug (one of the richest raw material subjects of the Russian Federation) make up a tiny fraction of the population of these entities. The situation with Karelians in the Republic of Karelia and with Khakasses in the Republic of Khakassia differs slightly from them.
    However, we have a significant part of our fellow citizens, including those leaving comments on the HE, vaguely represent the ethnic composition of the population of the country as a whole, and its individual subjects. Or they don’t understand the differences in the national composition of the population between the former USSR (Russians about half of the population) and the Russian Federation (Russians about four fifths of the population). Among them there are many 40-60-year-olds, who, according to them, are not victims of the USE, but received a good education.) Looks like problems with teaching geography were still in the Soviet era.
  35. kot28.ru
    kot28.ru April 15 2019 15: 52
    +1
    In general, you will not wait for our collapse. hi
    1. vlad106
      vlad106 April 15 2019 16: 50
      +2
      they will not sleep peacefully
  36. Svyatoslav Khorobry
    Svyatoslav Khorobry April 15 2019 22: 18
    0
    There is a rigid systemic plan of world Zion for the destruction of both the Russian World and the Russian people - the goy. The Russian state is practically gone. In Europe, more and more people write about today's Russia as "Israel-2".
    But so far, for the majority of the organized, dying Russian zombie people, this does not reach. When it comes, it will be too late.
  37. g1washntwn
    g1washntwn April 16 2019 06: 49
    +3
    With Brzezinski gone, everyone is in a hurry to pick up his aquila of Russophobia. But there is not enough originality in the voiced ideas of how to defeat Russia. The Pentagon and the State Department carry too much of the "Trojan horse" with footcloths.
  38. Lieutenant Colonel of the USSR Air Force in stock
    0
    Quote: vlad106
    Quote: DPN
    The collapse of the Soviet Union during your life is not the collapse of Russia and the worst part was destroyed by the Russians-Gorbachev and Yeltsin

    either you are illiterate, or you're lying ...
    Why is Eltsin Russian? His uncle is a Chekist Boris Moiseevich Eltsin (Yeltsin), according to his patronymic, from the "God-chosen".
    Gorbaty has the same picture: "Raisa" "Maksimovna" Titarenko-Gorbachev from the same tribe.
    the children of both exporters are brought up in the appropriate spirit

    ***
    And from the fright that you are breaching. At the same time, stupidly and brazenly.
    1) Yeltsin. He is absolutely Russian, a Russian village person, moreover a typical one. According to all your anti-Semitic canons, he is Russian. Already there is simply no more Russian appearance. Ilya Muromets had to draw from him https://russian7.ru/post/kem-po-nacionalnosti-byl-boris-elci/ and you won’t send any of his UNCLE - Chekists. And there is no evidence.
    Here are the repressed Yeltsins - look, they are entirely Russian http://lists.memo.ru/index6.htm, and here is his father on the lists of repressed: Yeltsin Nikolai Ignatievich Born in 1906, Ural region, village of Basmanovo; Russian; carpenter, industrial district, z-d No. 124 .. He lived: Kazan, p. Dry river.
    Arrested on April 29, 1934. Sentenced: three GPU TASSR May 23, 1934, equip: according to Art. 58-10.
    Sentence: 3 years ITL. Rehabilitated in June 1989. Source: Book of memory of the Republic of Tatarstan.
    What kind of Jews could be born there in the Ural (Sverdlovsk) region, in the village of Basmanovo, near Talitsa in 1906, where there are no Jews even today, when Jews were settled and Jews were FORBIDDEN to engage in farming, and some experiments of Nikolai 1 Pavlovich in the SOUTHERN regions The Russian Empire did not produce results, but completely ceased by the 1840s. Find at least one proof of the presence of Jews in the Ural (Sverdlovsk) region, in the village of Basmanovo, near Talitsa in 1906, peasant Jews! Fucking Jews - NIKOLAI IGNATIEVICH and KLAVDIA VASILIEVNA. (virgin. Starygina, 1908-1993 [10]), from peasants, a dressmaker. And what is the relationship between the Urals Nikolai Ignatievich and the Ukrainian Boris Moiseevich (Mikhailovich) Eltsin, who was born in Ukraine in 1875 31 years before Nikolai Ignatovich?
    Even if Naina Yeltsin is Jewish (probably it is) from this Yeltsin did not become a Jew.
    If the Prophet Muhammad had two wives Jewish, he did not become a Jew.
    2) As for Gorbachev and Titarenko, there’s even greater stupidity.
    3) I understand that for stupid nationalists to recognize Russians and Ukrainians who are objectionable to them as Jews, the mind is not required .... like evidence.
    1. Old warrior
      Old warrior April 17 2019 18: 19
      0
      The so-called "Russian" nationalists are real Russophobes because they are fighting on the side of our enemies and support them morally in every possible way. And who are they, after that? These same-sex advocates ...
  39. Lieutenant Colonel of the USSR Air Force in stock
    0
    Quote: Svyatoslav Khorobry
    There is a rigid systemic plan of world Zion for the destruction of both the Russian World and the Russian people - the goy. The Russian state is practically gone. In Europe, more and more people write about today's Russia as "Israel-2".
    But so far, for the majority of the organized, dying Russian zombie people, this does not reach. When it comes, it will be too late.

    ***
    Wei Wei Wei!
    1) And the main Jew on TOPVAR is a certain Svyatoslav Khorobry, RUSOFOB, who lowers the Russians to some herd under the control of Jewish shepherds.
    2) Of course, he has a grudge against his own Jews:
    - Jews deprived his parents;
    - Jews took away their shelter;
    - Jews did not give him education;
    - Jews did not give him education;
    - Jews did not give him a career;
    - his wife was taken away by the Jews:
    - His children ate the Jews;
    - the house was taken from him by the Jews;
    - Jews made a loser;
    - Jews accustomed to thump, smoke and inject;
    - Jews infected with AIDS;
    - the brain was stolen by Jews.
    3) He claims that 1 Jew per 860 non-Jews is a shepherd of gentiles. Consequently, the Jews have some outstanding abilities, while the rest of these abilities do not ..
    4) He claims that the Russian people are zombies and that he is one, an unbombed clever man.
    5) Based on 2) he is very unhappy, and if 2) is wrong, then he is definitely a Jew or Shabesh-goy! Ouch!
  40. NordUral
    NordUral April 16 2019 14: 31
    0
    There were many of you like that, and now, apparently, such dreamers have not gone extinct. But as nothing has happened at all times, nothing will come out now. Only for this, Russia must return its glorious Soviet content, having rid itself of, at the same time, the shortcomings of the post-Stalin years. Yes, and the Stalinist period to comprehend and make the best in relation to the present.
  41. Serhiodjan
    Serhiodjan April 16 2019 14: 51
    0
    Somehow it turns out that all the ideas of the West against Russia ultimately play against themselves. So go ahead Monsieur Pole, burn
  42. Major_Vortex
    Major_Vortex April 16 2019 14: 56
    +1
    The fish rots from the head. No one has done more harm to Russia in the history of the state than stupid leadership. The person below is easily blocked if it poses a threat to the state. Foreign intelligence agencies and intelligence services are also being watched, and I will block their activities if they begin to pose a threat to the state.

    But only one do-goo in power, surrounded by a bunch of toadies and Chaldeans who will never say a word across to him, have selective blindness in selfish and career interests, protected by the police, army and special services, could ruin Russia in 2 accounts, as Yeltsin did, and how similar characters in the history of Russia repeatedly did before Yeltsin did it.
  43. Old warrior
    Old warrior April 17 2019 18: 13
    0
    Russia collapsed in December 1991. Just the vastness of our immense, as it turned out, even more than it seemed. Even without a heap of land, it became not much less. winked soldier drinks
  44. Lieutenant Colonel of the USSR Air Force in stock
    0
    Quote: Old Warrior
    The so-called "Russian" nationalists are real Russophobes because they are fighting on the side of our enemies and support them morally in every possible way. And who are they, after that? These same-sex advocates ...

    ***
    Absolutely agree:
    1) The nationalists, led by the chief revolutionary of Russia Nikolai 2 (Black Hundreds), destroyed the Russian Empire. Empire: Poland, Latvia, Lithuania, and Estonia scattered across national apartments;
    2) Revolutionary Gorbachev and nationalists led by the elders Yeltsin, Shushkevich, Kravchuk plus the Baltic and Caucasian nationalists destroyed the USSR and the republics fled to national apartments.
    3) Russian nationalists are ruining the Russian Federation. Russian nationalists forget that there are also Caucasian, Tatar, Bashkir, Yakut, Tyvinci, Kalmyk, etc. nationalists and behind the slogan "Russia is for the Russians!", you can hear the voices "Chechnya, Ingushetia, Ossetia, Kabardino-Balkaria .... etc. - for .... indigenous peoples!" ... By the way, in some regions of the Russian Federation there are no longer any Russians ...
  45. Lieutenant Colonel of the USSR Air Force in stock
    0
    Quote: Old Warrior
    Russia collapsed in December 1991. Just the vastness of our immense, as it turned out, even more than it seemed. Even without a heap of land, it became not much less. winked soldier drinks

    Between 1/6 and 1/8 of the globe, the difference is significant .... Area: 22 km² and 402 km², population 200 million and 146 (?) Million the difference is significant ....
  46. Lieutenant Colonel of the USSR Air Force in stock
    +1
    Quote: Mayor_Vikhr
    comments

    ***
    Two revolutionaries-- Nikolai 2 and Gorbachev destroyed two empires.
    Now another revolutionary with thoughtless anti-people’s decisions is rocking the boat of the Russian Federation ...
    "Strange as it may seem, but the government is today the body that prepares the revolution; the people do not want it, but the government uses all possible measures to make as many discontent as possible, and it does well in this. We are witnessing an unprecedented spectacle of revolution from above, not below. "
    Letter to. Prince Alexander Mikhailovich to Nicholas II, from December 25, 1916 - February 4, 1917.
  47. Lieutenant Colonel of the USSR Air Force in stock
    -1
    Quote: Svyatoslav Khorobry
    comments

    Do not bring nonsense, the Jews are leaving, in 20-30 years they will not remain in Russia. Now 120 thousand, of which 90% of mixed marriages.
    One Jew of the Khorobrykh will remain ... stir up the water ...
  48. pafegosoff
    pafegosoff April 18 2019 05: 25
    0
    How?
    And I was banned just for a word about Catholicism!
    Do not mention Byzantium and Orthodoxy!
    Do not mention Byzantium and Constantinople!
    Dance in the Temples of Russia, but do not touch the Catholic cathedrals!
    These are the morals of this site!
  49. Overko
    Overko April 21 2019 11: 22
    0
    I didn’t read it. Such nonsense that I was tired of laughing