With the "Holiday", Russia! With the “Holiday” we all deserve

269
Even before the premiere of the film "Celebration"many politicians and the public were condemned, therefore director Alexey Krasovsky decided not to try to get a license and put the film in open access to YouTube.


Hate and misunderstanding.



Frankly, hate dominates. Unfortunately.

Hatred of a man with reduced social responsibility, who shot a libel. Hatred of those who helped him. Three times I hate Tabakov's grandson, whose grandfather, Pavel Kondratievich Tabakov, is a virtuoso on his sanitary train No. XXUMX, taking out the wounded almost from the front line so that he became a legend. The Order of the “Red Star” and the Medal “For Courage” are proof of this.



Grandson ... Yes, grandson. Not an indicator.

Hatred of those who gave money for this coven. Dumb as those who "sacrificed", and merciless in their meanness. Hatred of those who watched and gave money too.

Paid spitting into the past. Albeit under the name of comparison with the current authorities.

Who paid? Who liked IT ???

The same who joked over Karbyshev and laughed at the mega-amusing joke.



Those who seem to be in their right mind think that local people and authorities are to blame for the non-burning Eternal Flame in Khmelnitsky in Ukraine, and a journalist who didn’t clean the monument and don’t bring money to Gazprom was to blame for the burning Eternal Flame in Rossosh.

I understand that the country is slowly but surely going crazy, but I do not understand why so confidently.

With the "Holiday", Russia. Deserved. All.

Yes, it's not over yet. While not allowed this crap on the screens. But this one, which the director has already said, that if he discards 4 a million, spent on a film, will collect on a new one. Begging is now well disguised by the import term "crowdfunding".

And it will collect. Already collected. Under the flag of "banned - it means the film is good," they carry money.

Where he, however, spent so much, is unclear. The film was shot by an iPhone in the apartment. Well, you shouldn’t go into someone else’s pocket; Krasovsky’s pocket stinks like that.

But never mind, we are still ahead. We took such a pace that it was nice to see. And catch up and overtake anyone. In the next world Goebbels in hysterics comes from emotion, looking at all that is happening.

And at this rate we will go very far.

We will erect a monument to Vlasov, ten to Solzhenitsyn, Shkuro, Krasnov and everyone whom we awarded with a rope, everything! And also SS-fighters for freedom from Stalin, White Czechs (hell, they tried already), Finns, Romanians, Hungarians.

Hungarian - in Voronezh and Korotoyak. Required.

Italians are already standing monuments than the rest worse?

But where are we all going if Krasovsky cheerfully reports on views and listings and makes plans for the future?

Oh, I kind of had to have a movie, right?

Yeah shit movie. Incompetent execution in all senses and plans. The team does not understand anything on the topic. He does not know about the blockade, he does not know where and how the secret objects were located, how they were guarded, how the leading experts were guarded. Yes, it does not need anyone.

Krasovsky's main task was to spit, yes, rather, in my past. In the past of the city, with which I could have very strong ties.

Before the beginning of the war in Leningrad, I had more than two hundred relatives. She survived the blockade (and not for long) alone. Emergency nurse №1117 (located on Pirogovskaya Embankment) Alexander Strelnikov.

The rest is clear where: Serafimovskoe (mostly), Piskarevskoe, Bolsheokhtinskoe.

And how can I even appreciate Krasovsky's “creation”? Than? Ruble? Rubil?

Surprise attempts to slander and spit. How many were petty tales about the feasts in Smolny during the siege and rums for Zhdanov. Which were either delivered to him by airplanes, or were baked in a special bakery shop.

What the hell are “rum women” if Zhdanov was a diabetic? And diabetes, coupled with a heart attack, clearly provoked by a well-fed and reassuring life in Leningrad, eventually ended Zhdanov in 52. In 1948. It is clear that the leaders of Leningrad did not starve, like the rest of the city’s population, but they didn’t eat anything.

And in general, a sufficient number of people survived the blockade in Leningrad, and many of them left us stories and memoirs. So a normal person is able to understand the picture of what was happening there. Heroism and fortitude.

But not about that flock of mean people trying to tell us. They, of course, need dirt, they must lie. I will explain why.

Because they can only remove what their brains are capable of. That is what they think about themselves. What are they capable of. To the best of his stupidity, and, believe me, Krasovsky’s order is with this. I will not go into details, but he has order. With stupidity.

It is clear that comedies about problems, for example, of a Jewish family in Dresden, under the bombs of the Allied aviationwe will not see. This is a taboo. This is a law that cannot be violated. And because the Jews, and because the Americans. Although the Jewish ghetto in Dresden was. TO TOY bombing.

But the stories about heroism, we will not see. Krasovsky need dirt.

Why talk about the exploits of the baker Kyutinen, who died of starvation? Why talk about how people from the Institute of Plant Industry died of starvation, but saved the elite grain? By the way, the 28 guardians died. On the grain.

Or is Krasovsky able to tell about Alexey Sudayev, who died in 35 years? Died from hunger, but managed to finish his offspring, PPS-43?

Not. Krasovsky is not able to remove it. The maximum is a fool who is not able to cook a chicken without servants, and her mother, who only eats and defecates, is very animating the plot.

Worms Parasitic worms and amoebaes applauding them and ciliates-slippers. Mokritsy, as our neighbor Tarakan would say.

They live like their heroes. Consuming and defecating. And, since Krasove cannot do anything else in life, but they don’t want to learn, they are carrying their own excrements “to the masses”.

Hate and bewilderment.

Hatred for the topic, bewilderment to the fact that these stool is interesting to someone.

With the "Holiday", Russia. Get it and sign it.

P.S.

I understand who should be responsible. Who finished off the system of state education, the state ideology, which was destroyed in 90. Just the point? Worms crawling in a cooked Krasov nutrient medium. Ciliates eat devouring amoebae. And this is called the modern culture of Russia ...

Deserved? Deserved.

In general, it's time to do something. And the way they started doing it in the Donbas. In 2014. Otherwise, honestly, in five years we will simply turn into a herd, nothing that can and will not. Shouting on the Internet on the subject of the fact that we are all going up and somewhere to break through. All recall, all ...

In general, the fact that it is necessary Krasous.
Our news channels

Subscribe and stay up to date with the latest news and the most important events of the day.

269 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. +90
    11 January 2019 05: 03
    But does anyone else have the habit of watching the current Russian cinema?
    The bar of movie quality in the USSR was raised very high, and the current
    squalor does not interest me. Generally.
    1. +8
      11 January 2019 05: 31
      With the "Holiday", Russia! With the “Holiday” we all deserve

      Quote from Uncle Lee
      The bar of movie quality in the USSR was raised very high, and the current
      squalor

      Why compare the incomparable? If any citizen of the country can enumerate dozens of masterpieces of Soviet cinema from memory, then the "drawn" plot pictures of the "greatness of the modern era" are remembered with difficulty. In the same way, the days of defenders, common to all days, the celebration of which are postponed to May, and the national unity, whose roots have long since dried up, hardly break through for themselves the right to exist.
      1. -31
        11 January 2019 08: 02
        Quote: ROSS 42
        and national unity, whose roots have long dried out.

        That's because for people like you the greatest events of our history have "dried up" and such disgusting films, these "holidays and matildas", are coming out! When Orthodox people opposed this Matilda libel against the Holy Tsar Passion-bearer, when they said that it offends their religious feelings, a Communist deputy and her comrades appeared on television with positive reviews ... Then, in general, leftists of all stripes, including communists and liberals straight ascent - well, how in the Orthodox it turned out to be tasty to spit! Then, as you said with shrunken roots - that you are happy, then tomorrow you will get the same! And here you are - a disgusting film about Stalin, and now there is such a general mockery of the tragedy of besieged Leningrad! Received? Moreover, the Orthodox and monarchists in general, unlike you, such films are also called a mockery of Russian history and the victims of the people!
        The Time of Troubles in Russia lasted from 1584 to 1613. In this difficult time for the country, threatening to simply erase Russia from the world map, Patriarch Germogen called on the Russian people to defend the state and expel the Polish invaders! A broad patriotic movement unfolded. At the head of the militias were real Russian patriots. This is the governor of Ryazan Prokopy Lyapunov and the Nizhny Novgorod Zemsky Warden Kuzma Minin and the Prince of Novgorod Dmitry Pozharsky and thousands of ordinary and not so Russian Orthodox people! So they, with their unity, saved our Motherland from death.
        This is your ross roots shrunk. Thanks to people like you, including people, all these filthy libel go to Russia and Russian people! They say that the deeper the roots, the taller the tree. We remember everything!
        1. +29
          11 January 2019 08: 30
          It’s your lousy kodla that hangs memorial plaques to Mannerheim, Kolchak, erects monuments for white-collar workers and glorifies collaborators, along with counting the Tsar - a rag holy.
          1. -11
            11 January 2019 08: 35
            No, Antonio, liberal Codla is yours, not ours! They fought hand in hand against the Russian Empire, then you traditionally shoot at each other! And now you are also rallying together. So, you look in the mirror more often, when once again you want to search for enemies of the people ...
            1. +1
              11 January 2019 08: 47
              What to expect from the Manyarchist.
              1. -6
                11 January 2019 09: 01
                Antonio - carefully in the mirror ... The human soul begins to recover when a person begins to see and realize his sins. Who knows, maybe you have not lost everything?
              2. +2
                11 January 2019 23: 11
                Monarchism is a diagnosis, incurable.
                1. 0
                  14 January 2019 13: 29
                  Well, why not immediately curable? There are two treatment options:
                  1. "Study, study and study again ..."
                  2. In the clinical form of the disease - a pill, 9 mm caliber at the base of the skull.
                  Unfortunately, such representatives do not like to learn and do not know how, otherwise they would not have appeared.
                  1. +1
                    20 January 2019 23: 31
                    Moreover, the current monarchies under the tsarist regime would not rise above the batman. But they have a concept.
        2. +4
          11 January 2019 09: 00
          Have you ever seen this "Matilda"? The film is a typical bakery splint, not a libel. Poklonskaya with the director just fueled the excitement.
          1. -11
            11 January 2019 09: 11
            No. I don’t have to plunge into excrement in order to determine what it is they are. But with your propaganda of the civil war in Russia here the other day, and even with the threats of physical reprisal against an opponent, I became acquainted. You ruigat, a low man. I will certainly render all possible help to Halado so that you can very clearly understand for yourself - you must answer for such propaganda and your personal baseness!
            1. -2
              11 January 2019 09: 17
              No. I don’t have to plunge into excrement in order to determine what it is they are.

              Yeah, I didn’t see the next one, but I condemn.
              But with your propaganda of the civil war in Russia here the other day, and even with the threats of physical reprisal against an opponent, I became acquainted.

              People like you and your masters from the Russian oligarchy will have to pay for the bullying of the common people and the betrayal of their ancestors. Of course, for your gang: "Don't rock the boat," because rats are sick.
              1. -4
                11 January 2019 09: 52
                Ruigat, you do not think that I will communicate with the likes of you? Are you healthy and sane? Are you aware that you are writing in public? Where do you do it? You are able to determine for yourself what actions aimed at inciting hatred or enmity mean, as well as at humiliating the dignity of a person or a group of persons ... as well as belonging to any social group committed in public, incl. using the media or information and telecommunication networks, including the Internet: a) with the use of violence or with the threat of its use ...? This is only part of what you allow yourself here. I will not replicate all the vileness that you allowed yourself in the topic "The United States has promised not to deploy military bases on the islands of the Southern Kuriles" dated 09.01.2019/XNUMX/XNUMX. Everyone is able to read it himself. Why are you still here - a mystery of nature. I hope the moderators just looked ... Were you asked to apologize? Proposed. You are kind enough to ignore this. Enough words. Here, even without Jalado Romane (Petra), there are enough competent people to evaluate your opuses and their compliance with the current legislation ... Otherwise, let the people figure out whose competence in accordance with their professional activities it belongs.
                1. +10
                  11 January 2019 12: 52
                  Ruigat, you do not think that I will communicate with the likes of you? Are you healthy and sane? Are you aware that you are writing in public? Where do you do it? You are able to determine for yourself what actions aimed at inciting hatred or enmity mean, as well as at humiliating the dignity of a person or a group of persons ... as well as belonging to any social group committed in public, incl. using the media or information and telecommunication networks, including the Internet: a) with the use of violence or with the threat of its use.

                  Hatred and enmity is aroused by your masters from the oligarchy of the Russian Federation, stripping common people like linden, while providing themselves with yachts, palaces and other nishtyaki, at the expense of the people. I did not humiliate Halado Romane, I only used the information about him provided by THE SAME. And from him only a screech and threats to surrender me. That during the 2nd civil war, we will most cruelly kill each other, for you a revelation? During her, I do not expect mercy from people like you, but I am not going to spare you either. I told Jalado Romane and I tell you. VO is not the fiefdom of the slaves of the oligarchy of the Russian Federation, the Bulkhrusts and Neovlasovites, but a patriotic site where people who are partial to the fate of the country share their opinions.
                  1. -7
                    12 January 2019 08: 31
                    Quote: ruigat
                    the oligarchy of the Russian Federation, stripping common people like linden, while providing themselves with yachts, palaces and other nishtyaki, at the expense of the people.

                    These are the slogans for
                    stupid cattle
                    Yes Which he eats with pleasure, and then wonders why it began to live so badly! And you began to live poorly because you were raped again and will have in the future! And it’s not realistic to explain something to you request but some for some reason try feel
                    1. +10
                      12 January 2019 08: 41
                      But you began to live poorly because they raped you again and will have them in the future! And to explain something to you, well, not really, but for some reason some are trying

                      Well, of course, Liza Peskova, Mara Baghdasaryan, Rogozin's son, etc., they are immensely talented and hardworking, therefore they immediately occupy high posts, they did not have and will not have in the future. But Vasya Pupkin from the village of Kukuevo, he is, of course, a priori, lazy and stupid, although he works from morning to night, but of course he does not have the means for a "beautiful life" and will have him. Your position in life is very clear.
              2. The comment was deleted.
                1. +16
                  11 January 2019 12: 57
                  Well, enlighten me, how exactly in the indicated period (from 1917 to 1953) did you suffer?
                2. +10
                  11 January 2019 23: 12
                  What hatred for the great-grandfather policeman gnaws?
              3. -5
                11 January 2019 12: 52
                Quote: ruigat
                oligarchy of the Russian Federation

                And what, the oligarchy of the Russian Federation - monarchists and "whiteguards" ?! New business, I thought that they were from the Komsomol ... request
                1. +9
                  11 January 2019 13: 07
                  And what, the oligarchy of the Russian Federation - monarchists and "whiteguards" ?! New business, I thought that they were from the Komsomol ...

                  The oligarch of the Russian Federation - Neovlasovtsy.
                  1. -4
                    11 January 2019 13: 18
                    Quote: ruigat
                    The oligarch of the Russian Federation - Neovlasovtsy.

                    What side of Vlasov (what, by the way, did he have a party affiliation before his betrayal and title?) To the monarchy and the white guard?
                    1. +17
                      11 January 2019 13: 42
                      What side of Vlasov (what, by the way, did he have a party affiliation before his betrayal and title?) To the monarchy and the white guard?

                      Vlasov - a former communist who betrayed the country and people, for the sake of foreign enemies, for the sake of material nishtyaks;
                      Specifics of the oligarchy of the Russian Federation are former communists who betrayed the country and people, for the sake of foreign enemies, for the sake of material nishtyaks, that is, NEO VLASOVETS.
                      Under the rule of the neovlasovites from the oligarchy of the Russian Federation, all sorts of monarchist circles, trends, etc., flourished in a violent color, monuments to the Kolchaks, Manerheims, Wrangels, Italian Alpine shooters and other enemies of Russia and the working people are being removed; Matilda "and so on. And the Great Soviet past is denigrated. Did you explain it clearly?
                      1. -7
                        11 January 2019 17: 57
                        Quote: ruigat
                        Vlasov - a former communist who betrayed the country and people, for the sake of foreign enemies, for the sake of material nishtyaks;
                        Individuals of the oligarchy of the Russian Federation are former communists who betrayed the country and people, for the sake of foreign enemies, for the sake of material nishtyaks, i.e.

                        In short - the Communists. Yes
                        Quote: ruigat
                        monuments to Kolchak, Manerheim, Wrangels, Italian alpine shooters and other enemies of Russia and the working people are being erected

                        Well, this is liberalism and democracy, for which many advocate, moreover, what about monarchism? (Not possible in Russia due to the lack of a monarchy as such, and it is unlikely that it will be possible to reconstruct it, there is nobody and nobody IMHO request )
                        Quote: ruigat
                        Under the rule, neovlasovists from the oligarchy of the Russian Federation blossomed in violent colors

                        Again, the former communists, by your own admission. Yes
                      2. +4
                        11 January 2019 18: 22
                        In short - the Communists.

                        Former Communists - Neovlasovtsy. You recall that the real communists did with Vlasov after the Second World War?
                        Well, this is liberalism and democracy, for which many advocate, moreover, monarchism?

                        Take away the paths, liberalism and democracy, only towards you - the Bulk Khrusts.
                      3. -5
                        11 January 2019 18: 24
                        Quote: ruigat
                        Say the ways, liberalism and democracy, only towards you - buncrust

                        Hamite ?! wink
                      4. +4
                        12 January 2019 03: 16
                        Hamite ?!

                        No. I answer your questions. The answers are not pleasant for you, but what can you do, the reality is depressing.
                      5. -2
                        12 January 2019 17: 00
                        Quote: ruigat
                        No. I answer your questions. The answers are not pleasant for you, but what can you do, the reality is depressing

                        Calling someone "bulkokhrust" is probably not rudeness for you, it's just such upbringing ... Yes
                      6. +3
                        12 January 2019 18: 38
                        Yes, they were never communists. They clung to the Communist Party because it was profitable. And now another is beneficial. Everywhere they seek only profit. They wanted to spit on communism both then and now. In one they are constant - in their vileness and thirst for profit.
                      7. 0
                        12 January 2019 18: 48
                        Quote: Hefty literate
                        They clung to the Communist Party because it was profitable. And now another is beneficial. Everywhere they seek only profit.

                        I won’t even argue here. I agree with that. Yes
                2. +4
                  12 January 2019 09: 09
                  Somewhere the photo slipped where the young Rogozin senior is standing with a poster ... white about unite !!! These are the children of those unfinished White Guards who suddenly became communists, and when the power of the communists weakened, they became capitalists .. rats, one word in a word!
                3. +3
                  13 January 2019 04: 51
                  Quote: Tank Hard
                  A new thing, I thought that they are from the Komsomol members ..

                  Wrong you thought and very liberally painted: they are not Komsomol members and not communists, not party and unpatriotic.
                  This virgin is a degenerate native of the party nobility, who put the helm on the right in time, and the greedy liberal view of the public domain.
                  1. 0
                    13 January 2019 18: 12
                    Quote: hydrox
                    they are not Komsomol members or communists,

                    Come on, descendants of Denikin or Kappel, or Shkuro or something? Komsomol members and communists - this.

                    .
                    Quote: hydrox
                    This bond is the degenerate native of the party nobility, who put the wheel to the right on time

                    And I completely agree with this statement.
              4. +11
                11 January 2019 12: 56
                Quote: ruigat
                For bullying ordinary people and the betrayal of their ancestors will have to pay such as you and your owners

                And then I remembered 17 year, it is necessary how everything converges in your words!
            2. +8
              11 January 2019 10: 33
              Quote: Cheslav Czursky
              I will certainly render Halad all kinds of help so that you understand very clearly for yourself

              Oh no no no... negative not like a man you seek to put pressure on the interlocutor. It is not good to repress with your hands the high ranks of a person with an opinion different from yours.
              Arguments and more arguments. At least "authoritative opinion".
              1. -8
                11 January 2019 10: 49
                Quote: Lycan
                Arguments and arguments again.

                I have given exhaustive arguments above. His opinion is not = permissiveness, the propaganda of civil strife in Russia and the threat of physical violence! And am I pushing? Allowing himself such ugly things must be responsible for this. Of course, I will not pass by and silently. Something doesn’t suit you?
                1. +6
                  11 January 2019 11: 06
                  There is no need to verbally accuse the suspect, just inform the moderator about the link to the page indicating a specific illegal comment.
                  And by conducting disputes with a suspect, you simply increase the intensity of passions and unnecessary chatter on the topic, attracting additional participants to the acute (and already smelling of litigation) topic. We will only make the porridge thicker, provoking many into non-parliamentary thoughts.
                  1. -5
                    11 January 2019 11: 12
                    I do not have to act as moderators, sorry. If you noticed then I didn’t start a conversation with this subject.
                    1. +2
                      11 January 2019 11: 59
                      Quote: Cheslav Czursky
                      I do not have to act as moderators sorry

                      Then why react and spoil your nerves? smile
                      Quote: Cheslav Czursky
                      If you noticed then I didn’t start a conversation with this subject

                      Even if you only reacted sharply, your role began to gain momentum. Who knows what can get to. A conscious or unconscious provocateur can spin you up to such pearls, from which subsequently (after a decline in courage) you will still have a cold sweat for a long time when you see a police officer / FSB officer. wink
                      1. -2
                        11 January 2019 12: 19
                        I have?! smile You are very mistaken. But the words of Julius Fucik, I allow myself to remind you. Fear the Indifferent! It is with their tacit consent that all evil on earth is done! And also him - To look at people with a broken conscience is even worse than the battered ones!
                      2. +5
                        11 January 2019 12: 52
                        Quote: Cheslav Tsursky
                        You are very mistaken.

                        It would be nice, but "Arrogance is the worst of indiscretions."
                        Quote: Cheslav Czursky
                        Fear the Indifferent! It is with their tacit consent that all evil on earth is done!

                        To be afraid or not is up to you, but what then remains if Moder does not respond? - execute one of the functions of the moderator, apparently: to keep a close eye on the potentially illegal "bazaar" of others, and to report, of course. But this is for individual initiators who do not mind taking on the next headache.
                        Although .. I was somehow curious - would you really mind working as an informant on resonant matters?
                      3. -5
                        11 January 2019 13: 23
                        Quote: Lycan
                        Although .. I was somehow curious - would you really mind working as an informant on resonant matters?

                        Alex, I think I’ve explained everything to you.
                      4. +2
                        11 January 2019 13: 43
                        It seems to be, but I hope you understand that your position:
                        Quote: Cheslav Tsursky
                        Of course, I will not pass by and silently.

                        and my conclusion:
                        Quote: Cheslav Czursky
                        But this is for individual proponents who do not mind taking on the next smut.

                        speaks about you to me - for himself. smile
                        No offense, ok? You - well done in your own way.
                2. -2
                  11 January 2019 13: 15
                  Quote: Cheslav Czursky
                  I have given exhaustive arguments above. His opinion is not = permissiveness, the propaganda of civil strife in Russia and the threat of physical violence! And am I pushing? Allowing himself such ugly things must be responsible for this. Of course, I will not pass by and silently. Something doesn’t suit you

                  You are absolutely right, you have every right. Yes
              2. +12
                11 January 2019 13: 10
                Quote: Lycan
                not manly

                laughing Oh come on! First, write bad as a bad boy, and then remember about manhood! Kindergarten laughing
                1. +2
                  11 January 2019 13: 37
                  Anyway, I think, hiding behind the backs of the moderators is not good if there ordinary dispute. what Although, I admit, if there is a potential sub-article, then - to report a response. persons (and have a load from the scammer to the performer of someone else's work) or let those who are called upon to do their thing.
              3. +3
                11 January 2019 13: 13
                Quote: Lycan
                It is not good to repress with your hands the high ranks of a person with an opinion different from yours.
                Arguments and arguments again.

                Many alternatively gifted individuals threaten reprisal on the Internet, and even on mass media resources (thereby completely laying out the entire evidence base against themselves). Completely not understanding what could threaten them ... request
                Read carefully here:
                [media = http: //www.kamprok.ru/prokuror-razyasnyaet-ugolovnaya-otvetstvennost-za-ugrozu-ubijstvom-ili-prichineniem-tyazhkogo-vreda-zdorovyu/]
                1. +1
                  11 January 2019 13: 26
                  Quote: Tank Hard
                  Many alternatively gifted individuals threaten reprisal on the Internet

                  And what - can we (ordinary citizens) now catch everyone by their tongue and / or report each of them to the police? There are competent authorities for catching such facts. And if they don’t do this, then the regular smut is toppled over the citizens for catching revealing or unstable schoolchildren.
                  Thanks for the article.
                  1. +3
                    11 January 2019 18: 08
                    Quote: Lycan
                    And what - can we (ordinary citizens) now catch everyone by their tongue and / or report each of them to the police?

                    To behave with dignity and rationally, and the punishment exists for this, so that the stubborn inadequacies do not clog the "ether" with themselves and know that the words can also be answered, and very harsh. There are already cases under this article, and they are quite real. It is worth knowing that even probation can spoil fate, try to get a job with it. And the attitude to the convict will be very specific. Yes
                    Quote: Lycan
                    or report it to the police for everyone?

                    But do not report to the moderator? (Double standards wink )
                    1. 0
                      12 January 2019 17: 34
                      Quote: Tank Hard
                      or report it to the police for everyone?
                      But do not report to the moderator? (Double wink standards)

                      Oh, I do not share - I think this is all from the same order.
                      I'm talking about something else - why do we need to do this now, if there is a special agency - "modernization"?
                      But if you nevertheless assume the function of this very Moder to identify - then:
                      1) it is no longer necessary to be ashamed of informants and (exaggerated) informers in their society;
                      2) accept that modernization cannot follow everyone and you have to spend your energy on it (by pointing to the citizen on incorrectness) and time
                      ---------
                      My question is - where is the timely tracking by the moderator?
                      I will explain why the question arose: visitors, taking on the function of the moderator, dampen it and begin a heated debate of a personal nature, where the causes of the dispute are very dimly viewed, which, however, extend from a completely different article - just from the one where modernization does not fulfilled and the radical visitor was not, at least, warned of the risk of going beyond the framework of the Criminal Code (I didn’t read that article, but Mr. Cheslav Tsursky told about his observations in the comments). Well, we can’t, in fact, continue to live like this, vigilantly following around in search of villains ... This is the task of a well-developed system.
                      1. 0
                        12 January 2019 19: 01
                        Quote: Lycan
                        My question is - where is the timely tracking by the moderator?

                        This question is clearly not for me ... request
                2. -4
                  11 January 2019 13: 31
                  I want to say one thing that those who try to threaten, threaten, incite hatred, propagandize and call for violent action, unrest and civil war should know about the inevitability of punishment. They will certainly be asked - why actually ?!
                  We can argue among ourselves. We can adhere to different political views. Everything is possible, but when these ruigates begin to replicate hatred, anger, separate people and pit people, propaganda civil strife, then all kinds of conversations must be stopped with them. They must be responsible and deserved by law. I will try very hard for this subject to respond in this way. The more people who put them in their place, the better we will all live no matter what political preferences we have! Call to fratricide from this evil spirits with impunity does not learn!
                  1. -3
                    11 January 2019 13: 49
                    It will not work because if these people are not abnormal then they are outright enemies. There is no third here!
                  2. +6
                    11 January 2019 15: 00
                    Call to fratricide from this evil spirits with impunity does not learn!

                    Are you my brother? Or maybe brother Chubais, Taburetkin, Mudko, Sechin and others?
                    Do I have something against ordinary workers, teachers, doctors, scientists, military, who honestly do their job? Your task, in every possible way to whitewash the thieves, treacherous and heinous actions of the oligarchy of the Russian Federation.
                    1. -4
                      11 January 2019 18: 12
                      Quote: ruigat
                      Your task, in every possible way to whitewash the thieves, treacherous and heinous actions of the oligarchy of the Russian Federation.

                      Do you know that about him exactly? Not slander, no? wink
                      1. 0
                        11 January 2019 18: 25
                        Do you know that about him exactly? Not slander, no?

                        Yes, here the other day, pension reform has occurred, according to which many people will lose their pensions, but this is, of course, my slander.
                      2. -1
                        11 January 2019 20: 12
                        Quote: ruigat
                        Yes, here the other day, pension reform has occurred, according to which many people will lose their pensions, but this is, of course, my slander.

                        What is this, Cheslav Tsurski "adventured" the pension reform ?!
                        Rude, slander (the usual thing, when there are no more reasonable arguments) ... Everything is clear with you. Yes
                      3. -2
                        12 January 2019 03: 23
                        What is this, Cheslav Tsurski "adventured" the pension reform ?!

                        The conversation seems to have been about the oligarchy of the Russian Federation and its "fluffiness". You were charged exclusively with the role of a sympathizer.
                        Do you know that about him exactly? Not slander, no?

                        But if you include yourself in the oligarchy of the Russian Federation, then what am I wrong about?
                      4. +2
                        12 January 2019 17: 05
                        Quote: ruigat
                        You were charged

                        That's when you are being charged, you will feel the difference.
                        Quote: ruigat
                        But if you include yourself in the oligarchy of the Russian Federation, then what am I wrong about?

                        Well, I am a noble oligarch and, in general, a monarchist - a messenger, and you are extremely intelligent. laughing
                  3. -3
                    11 January 2019 18: 10
                    Quote: Cheslav Czursky
                    must know about the inevitability of punishment. They’ll definitely be asked

                    That's right ...
                3. +2
                  11 January 2019 14: 18
                  Quote: Tank Hard
                  Many alternatively gifted individuals threaten reprisal on the Internet, and even on mass media resources (thereby completely laying out the entire evidence base against themselves). Completely not understanding what could threaten them ... request

                  And we must not threaten, but challenge to a duel, and in the presence of the right of the Guardians ...
                  1. 0
                    12 January 2019 11: 18
                    And take Zolotov in seconds? soldier
                    1. +1
                      12 January 2019 12: 33
                      Quote: volodimer
                      And take Zolotov in seconds?

                      Will not give a ride, he "lost face". If a person challenged another person to a duel, but refused the duel itself, then he must be driven with sticks (Peter-1, k / f The Tale of How Tsar Peter married the Arap)
        3. -2
          11 January 2019 21: 03
          Cheslav Tsursky (Cheslav Tsursky)
          That's because for people like you the greatest events of our history have "dried up" and such disgusting films, these "holidays and matildas", are coming out!
          When you choke on your own lies, I hope your lines pass before your fading consciousness hi
        4. 0
          13 January 2019 10: 40
          it is for YOU that the roots are shrunk, for US with roots and memory everything is fine.
    2. +33
      11 January 2019 05: 41
      Quote from Uncle Lee
      Cinema quality bar in the USSR


      Undeniable!

      And then. One size fits all is also not an option. There are good modern films. The only thing is me! I don't watch it, it's comedy with comedy club characters. Like Revva, Martirosyan and the rest. The level of vulgarity is over the top. "Yolki" did not look at one part and there is no desire. The irony of fate was re-shot - well, such nonsense (my personal opinion).

      Uncle lee hi
      1. +20
        11 January 2019 05: 51
        I honestly watched "Stalingrad" - it is sewn according to Western patterns, although there is a highlight with the bathroom. "Panfilov's 28" did not impress. "Brest Fortress", "Star" - I saw the originals, so they left impressions and showed the heroism and courage of the Soviet people. The participants in the war left, and they shot real films, although the front-line soldiers spat on them too.
        delights. And now - sculpt what you want, who will verify and condemn. hi
        1. +19
          11 January 2019 05: 57
          Quote from Uncle Lee
          they and filmed real movies


          And they also starred in them! Bykov, Pugovkin, Smirnov ...

          Legends leave, and take their place ... An unprintable word generally takes their place. The hero of the article for example.

          In general, I'd rather watch the movie epic "Blockade" or "Battle for Moscow".
          1. BAI
            -7
            11 January 2019 09: 14
            In the "Blockade" in the summer of 1941, does the IS-3 bother you?
            1. +2
              11 January 2019 14: 20
              Is-3 should not be embarrassing, is-3 should forever forbid the director to remove historical subjects for falsification and elementary incompetent work.
              1. +1
                12 January 2019 11: 30
                The IS-3 "Blockade" does not bother at all, as well as the T-34-85 and T-44 BTR-152, etc. in about many films of that time, they filmed what was in terms of technology, this is not your current computer graphics, when you can draw the necessary technique. But in those films, the scale is shown and naturalness ... But there is no mess with shitting pilots and meter standards on German tanks ... hi
                Here's where: "for the rest of his life to forbid the director to shoot a historical theme for falsification and elementary incompetent work ..."
            2. 0
              14 January 2019 03: 23
              Quote: BAI

              In the "Blockade" in the summer of 1941, does the IS-3 bother you?


              Personally, even the T-44/54 in the role of "Tiger" does not bother me. BRT from the 40th to 152 are also not confused.

              hi
    3. +9
      11 January 2019 07: 41
      The bar of movie quality in the USSR was raised very high


      In general, the answer to all this is simple, there was a state policy in relation to cinema and there was censorship, but now, neither politics nor censorship would just fall under the Criminal Code, in a word - dercratia.
      1. +19
        11 January 2019 08: 23
        there was a state policy in relation to cinema and there was censorship; now now, neither politics nor censorship would only fall under the Criminal Code

        And now the state’s policy ... A plate for Manerheim, a monument to Solzhenitsyn, the Yeltsin Center.
        If everything is distorted by the first persons, why not the "creative" Shelupone?
        If in the late USSR, school students stood on guard of honor at the eternal flame, now students are putting out them. These will watch and believe in delusional films.
        1. +5
          11 January 2019 17: 21
          Quote: passing
          And now the state’s policy ... A plate for Manerheim, a monument to Solzhenitsyn, the Yeltsin Center.
          If everything is distorted by the first persons, why not the "creative" Shelupone?
          If in the late USSR, school students stood on guard of honor at the eternal flame, now students are putting out them. These will watch and believe in delusional films.

          Alas, this ".ovno-cinema" will be filmed and the show, with vulgarity and blasphemy will continue to multiply. TNT is a rich channel, and the boys and girls participating in these shows, alas, are the "color" of today's youth. The show brings money, and this is the main thing, and over Karbyshev (Eternal Memory and Low Bow to him), joke, for whatever reason, the tanks bring these "jokes", so it is possible over Gastello, Maresyev, Matrosov and millions of Fallen - "joke", and what "jokes" can be arranged over the memory of concentration camp prisoners - for the current "golden youth" will not rise. And all this muck is focused on the current Internet generation, studying by tests and not thinking of existence without iPhones, from which this generation will take an example, from whom: from glamorous pr..k, excuse women with low social responsibility, from bandits, from oligarchs? From where they will draw their knowledge of history and be brought up in the spirit of patriotism - from endless talk shows, idiotic cartoons, endless serials about a well-fed rich life, why on the first channel, after the program "time" not to show war films, films are our domestic and old ones as well? I will not and do not want to enter into a political squabble, for me the History and Memory of those who fell in the Great Patriotic War-Holy, my family, like millions of others, she really touched it, two of my grandmother's three brothers died when the Blockade was lifted, the third remained alive Slava God, my grandmother went through the whole war, but many relatives died in the Blockade-on Piskarevka, now they ... This "business director" simply humiliated and trampled on Feat and Memory, those who died and died of hunger, those who are no longer can answer, you can not swear, but the moderators, forgive me, but what a rare brute, Alexei Krasovsky.
      2. +1
        12 January 2019 11: 15
        neither politics nor censorship would just fall under the Criminal Code, in a word - dercratia. ,,
        Now there is an ORDER. I hope they heard, “some galoshes,” but due to the fact that the performers are frankly mediocre, it turns out, then Matilda, then these holidays.
    4. The comment was deleted.
    5. +8
      11 January 2019 08: 05
      You don't have a habit, I don't, and many more, fortunately. But don't talk about "demand creates supply." Here is a proposal for those who do not have the habit of NOT "watching current Russian cinema." This is a generation of young, healthy OUR children and grandchildren. What should they watch? There are options? I do not have. It is the new generation that is systematically developing a persistent dislike for our past. Alas, it is enough to look at the repertoire of not only cinemas, but also theaters, and especially federal channels.
    6. +3
      11 January 2019 09: 24
      Quote from Uncle Lee
      But does anyone else have the habit of watching the current Russian cinema?

      extremely rare and that - not all
    7. +4
      11 January 2019 10: 00
      Quote from Uncle Lee

      The bar of movie quality in the USSR was raised very high, and the current
      squalor does not interest me. Generally.

      To understand that this is squalor, one must look at it. No? Or - "I have not read, but I condemn"?
      No, comrades, gopoda, we must watch and condemn. Condemn everywhere, and in VO too, at every corner. To turn the filmmakers into mold, into a fetid abscess. To shy away from them, so that they become "handshake".
      And if we do not look, we will not be able to condemn, and then such an abomination will multiply. And in the end it will fill all the screens. No, everyone should fight this, to the best of their ability. And we have one opportunity - to brand the shame of Medinsky and the filmmakers.
      We must go to the president’s website and demand the resignation of Medinsky. If there are millions of such appeals, I think it will work.
      1. +5
        11 January 2019 10: 53
        It is imperative to eat faeces in order to determine that they are not edible. I do not intend, suppressing the gag reflex to watch full-time libels, filmed by the kami for stupid cocks, in order to say: "Well, I told you ..."
        1. 0
          12 January 2019 00: 27
          Quote: AK1972
          It is imperative to eat faeces in order to determine that they are not edible. I do not intend, suppressing the gag reflex to watch full-time libels, filmed by the kami for stupid cocks, in order to say: "Well, I told you ..."

          Children's experience taught you how to recognize feces right away. In appearance, smell. But the film does not smell. It is necessary to determine whether it is worth spending time on it or not, to watch at least part of the film.
      2. +5
        11 January 2019 13: 55
        We must go to the president’s website and demand the resignation of Medinsky. If there are millions of such appeals, I think it will work.

        Will not work. The oligarch of the Russian Federation does not surrender. The stories of Taburetkin, Mudko, Zolotov and other individuals remind of this.
      3. +6
        11 January 2019 17: 22
        Quote: Krasnoyarsk
        We must go to the president’s website and demand the resignation of Medinsky. If there are millions of such appeals, I think it will work.

        Yes to pump the president on your appeals. Even a million. Really still do not understand. Beautifully, the Vlasovites led the people on a patriotic chaff. Putin is a great actor. I applaud.
      4. +5
        11 January 2019 17: 28
        Quote: Krasnoyarsk
        To understand that this is squalor, one must look at it. No? Or - "I have not read, but I condemn"?
        No, comrades, gopoda, we must watch and condemn. Condemn everywhere, and in VO too, at every corner. To turn the filmmakers into mold, into a fetid abscess. To shy away from them, so that they become "handshake".
        And if we do not look, we will not be able to condemn, and then such an abomination will multiply. And in the end it will fill all the screens. No, everyone should fight this, to the best of their ability. And we have one opportunity - to brand the shame of Medinsky and the filmmakers.
        We must go to the president’s website and demand the resignation of Medinsky. If there are millions of such appeals, I think it will work.

        As said, comrade ruigat:Will not work. The oligarch of the Russian Federation does not surrender. The stories of Taburetkin, Mudko, Zolotov and other individuals remind of this. I agree to all 100%. At the official level, we won’t achieve anything, at the household level, maybe yes, and even then I saw Krasovsky and his illy beat the tambourine in principle)))
    8. -2
      11 January 2019 10: 38
      Quote from Uncle Lee

      But does anyone else have the habit of watching the current Russian cinema?

      I watched the T-34 yesterday - I liked it, in general.
      1. +11
        11 January 2019 12: 25
        Quote: Gray Brother
        Quote from Uncle Lee

        But does anyone else have the habit of watching the current Russian cinema?

        I watched the T-34 yesterday - I liked it, in general.

        This is because you haven't watched Lark.
        1. +2
          11 January 2019 13: 07
          Quote: Krasnoyarsk
          This is because you haven't watched Lark.

          Why didn’t you look? I looked.
          It's just different movies.
    9. +8
      11 January 2019 10: 46
      Quote: Uncle Lee
      But does anyone else have the habit of watching the current Russian cinema?
      The bar of movie quality in the USSR was raised very high, and the current
      squalor does not interest me. Generally.
      "" ""

      Russia is imposed on the peoples and is imposed further alien culture for them for the money of these same peoples
    10. +5
      11 January 2019 11: 01
      We will not watch with you, but a generation is approaching for which the Great Patriotic War is the same as the First Punic for us. And these will be watching. Therefore, if we want that we have a future, it’s not enough not to watch such high-rises, We must really punish those who do it. How is a separate issue. The main thing is that everyone knows now and always that the production of such a client is a crime for which they will be punished.
    11. 0
      11 January 2019 12: 57
      I watched "Moving Up" three times with pleasure, so not all are finished as Krasovsky.
    12. +3
      11 January 2019 13: 18
      The bar of movie quality in the USSR was raised very high, and the current
      squalor does not interest me. Generally.

      it is this indifference that kills the country and the nation. instead of evaluating this shit, we just don't look in its direction. There is such a worker of arts A. Gradsky ... many remember ... I am indifferent to his work, but he has just a brilliant phrase about the collapse of the USSR: "We did not cope with the era ... because everything is for us ... yu "well, all people are great ... I guess I guess ...
    13. +1
      11 January 2019 14: 05
      It's not about the quality of the movie. The thing is the brains of a huge number of our fellow citizens. Dumb, lazy, herd, with pictures from all sorts of YouTube in the eyes instead of the mind ...
    14. +1
      11 January 2019 14: 17
      mockery of people who lost their lives, protecting the country from invaders, it seems to me, at least, a gross violation of public order and, in general, of high treason. I don’t care who these defenders are - the communists in ww2 who died in battles with Germans or Italians, Polish or Finnish recruits who fought against Austria, soldiers of the tsarist army who fell into the white movement and fought against the British near Murmansk or Khazars with guardsmen who helped in the war with the Livonian Order, or Koreans and Chinese, who helped against the Japanese on the territory of the CER. There is no difference between the two. All these people deserve elementary respect simply because they gave the most precious thing for the fact that now we can live in our country. And those ghouls who insult the dead both stupidly and heroically and obscurely deny us all the moral right to self-defense. Is it enough to threaten with my finger ah - yay?
      In my opinion, for this it is necessary to punish and punish indicatively. Can. it’s too much to beat with sticks, as in Iran, but cleaning up a territory with a broom or other socially useful work for several weeks during this could well cure brain liquefaction.
    15. +1
      11 January 2019 14: 53
      present poverty

      I would not say so about everything. Cartoons make great. we have.
    16. +1
      11 January 2019 16: 34
      If the scriptwriter’s head on his shoulders has grown correctly, the director’s hands and feet are growing from where, the actors are selected accordingly, then you won’t have to worry about the quality of the movie.
      I looked at the T-34 and I recommend it to you.
    17. -2
      11 January 2019 18: 08
      The first 5 minutes of the movie are enough to determine if it’s worth the time.
  2. -31
    11 January 2019 05: 10
    Is this hidden advertising? The comrade looked, criticized, you need to see what they criticize, spit on the company.
    1. +14
      11 January 2019 06: 57
      Re-read the article again, there he mentioned you, and more than once fool
    2. +14
      11 January 2019 06: 57
      Quote: Mikhail M
      The comrade looked, criticized, you need to see what they criticize, spit on the company.

      I will not look. I can't: the tragedy was too great to shoot the "holidays" ...
      1. +3
        11 January 2019 23: 17
        The first reasonable comment from monarchism.
    3. 0
      11 January 2019 16: 46
      Quote: Mikhail M
      Is this hidden advertising?

      probably ... I'm watching, watching ....
  3. +3
    11 January 2019 05: 21
    as it were simpler to say ... I didn’t watch the movie and am not going to, but ... all that happens is the purest PR move we all fell for. I don’t want to offend the author, but he also contributes to the promotion of this movie. initially without even a movie with the phrase comedy about the blockade raised hype. and away we go. we ourselves unwind it all paying so much attention to it. I understand that you can’t react. but modern technology must be considered. they are not stupid people running around. they achieved their goal. they attracted to the full .... close attention of people. the distributors don’t care for what reason people watch a movie. no matter if you want to make sure that it’s ug or you are curious. they sold the goods. and we all helped them.
    1. +5
      11 January 2019 07: 39
      Quote: Bull Terrier
      . all that happens is the purest PR move we all fell for

      Well, I don’t know ... I did not get involved. I don’t watch films about which they talk a lot and which are discussed in society. Since childhood, such a position I have developed.
      1. +1
        11 January 2019 07: 45
        believe you are in the minority. I did not hear about this film and this director before the first article in VO. and now there’s a print of his photo for some reason, and I know in his face) an ideal way to promote people unknown to anyone.
        1. 0
          11 January 2019 17: 45
          laughing I was blamed for such a comment. laughing
  4. +11
    11 January 2019 05: 30
    And what did you want? If there is no clear position on the event of the Great Patriotic Role of the CPSU (B.) Of the Soviet people. Communist ideology.
    Capitalism ... pluralism of opinions. And generally do not give a damn about someone else's opinion. Strength in grandmas and not in truth ...
    1. +10
      11 January 2019 06: 20
      Quote: apro
      And what do you want? If there is no clear position on the event of the Great Patriotic War. The role of the CPSU (b). Soviet people. Communist ideology. Capitalism .....
      And how can this clear position be, because if we talk about the role of the CPSU (.b.), Then we should talk about changes in the party along with the name. Also, if we talk about the role of the CPSU (b) in the Second World War, then the role of the CPSU (b) in the revolution is not far, and that only the revolution has preserved the country.
  5. +4
    11 January 2019 05: 34
    So a normal person is able to understand the picture of what was happening there.

    I don’t think that being of sound mind and bright memory you can understand everything that happened in those days in Leningrad ...

    We do not understand ...

    Otherwise, honestly, in five years we will turn ...

    And here, it seems to me a very interesting moment. Our main thing is just a nickel left ...
  6. +15
    11 January 2019 05: 58
    My father lived with her aunt throughout the war in besieged Leningrad. She served in the air defense forces (in fact, it saved her from death). Sometimes they came to visit her, slept in a tiny room (in a communal apartment, you see, it was a bourgeois closet). It was remembered when the receiver did not turn off (memory of an air alert). It was felt, with my children's mind, the person suffered SCARY !!! And for today's young people, can all this be somehow conveyed ??? Media, TV, the Internet, history books ... doubts begin to creep in, especially after the appearance of such opuses ...
  7. +7
    11 January 2019 05: 59
    Yes, the film "Holiday" is still shit and it will live exactly as long as there will be information "waves", which are very skillfully raised by someone. The story of "Matilda" is being repeated. And this film is not interesting, not funny and raises great doubts about some kind of talent of its director, apparently "The Collector" was just an accident.
    1. +10
      11 January 2019 06: 08
      Money was found for stupid films, and children sick on TV all over the world have to collect.
      1. +7
        11 January 2019 08: 50
        Quote: Reptiloid
        Money was found for stupid films, and children sick on TV all over the world have to collect.

        The fact is that the money for this "video paskville" was not allocated from the budget, but was collected together. The worst thing in this situation is that there were "sponsors" who helped Krasovsky realize the scenario and mock the memory of tens of thousands of Leningraders who died of hunger. I doubt that these sponsors would allocate money for the treatment of sick children, but here, hey, you were honored ... It is even more disgusting that this "film" will gather its audience, which, without thinking about the common tragedy of Leningraders, will laugh over the plot and bring to the masses that it was not all that bad. If he took off something like that in humorous tones about "not starving" Jews in the Holocaust, he would instantly become "not shaking hands and not entering a certain country", but here ...... "the artist sees this" or "don't judge the pianist, he plays as best he can. " Our Ministry of Foreign Affairs always moves notes of protest over acts of vandalism against monuments to the fallen Soviet soldiers abroad, but here ........ I'm wondering why the Prosecutor's Office does not see an act of vandalism in relation to the dead and deceased citizens of Leningrad, although neither it cannot be called anything else.
        1. The comment was deleted.
      2. +6
        11 January 2019 10: 02
        Those children who collect, mainly !, not all, parents certainly want to treat in Germany or Israel. There you see more guarantees. A rare exception when we cannot carry out a similar operation. But these parents staring plaintively say that they don’t have money, but they need to go to Germany. I will never ask for anything either for myself or for my children. Or help here, or die. Itself used to help
        1. +7
          11 January 2019 13: 38
          Quote: igorbrsv
          I will never ask for anything either for myself or for my children.

          Have your children died on your hands?
          1. +5
            11 January 2019 14: 02
            Pah-pah. And what operations will we not take? Count on the fingers. There may be a queue, but they are not trying to pay for an operation here that they themselves would have pulled. I have a neighbor. Doesn't work, baby cerebral palsy. She regularly knocked out money for treatment, knocked out help to buy an apartment, a car, went to deputies, but nothing can be done from the word here at all. Then she also collected help for treatment somewhere through the media. But he treated the child again here, for free. For the difference, I bought another car, a new one, an SUV, it does not fit in our yard.
            If I happen to be in trouble, I’ll go to sell my ten-year-old viburnum, I will lay the flat, I will get a second and third job, I will take a loan and treat the children within my means. By my means. On which I will pull. Those people who ask basically could find the money themselves. They just do not want to part with comfort. They know that even through the media they will collect money. And they don’t have to spend it themselves. And they definitely need all the best
            1. +9
              11 January 2019 14: 11
              Quote: igorbrsv
              Those people who ask basically could find the money themselves. They just don't want to part with comfort.

              Do not judge everyone by your neighbor!
              1. +4
                11 January 2019 15: 00
                I say that not all. I myself sometimes send SMS. If you can really help, people are not well-groomed. But since then I’m not helping a neighbor
              2. +2
                11 January 2019 18: 43
                Do not judge everyone by your neighbor!

                Alas, it is not unique. Such fraud is becoming common.
        2. +2
          11 January 2019 17: 01
          Quote: igorbrsv
          Those children

          I think that you are wrong. Often I saw on TV that they asked me to raise money for a single woman from some distant village, from where I could not get to the district center. It is often said that the operation itself is free, and paid --- prosthetics, and they show these of our doctors and this hospital. There is a concept of quota. I heard that sometimes quotas await for several years. Also often showed large families living very modestly. They could not insist --- only abroad !!!
          1. +2
            11 January 2019 17: 09
            About the sponsors of the film ---- this is an opportunity to get into an artistic (or liberal, or even kayu) party
          2. 0
            11 January 2019 17: 18
            I agree. In these cases, you can help. But the prosthesis is also a prosthesis. You can change it once a year (free), or you can be too shy to put money for the money
            1. +1
              11 January 2019 21: 05
              In fact, we do not know under what conditions such ads are given. Once I read a long time ago in "Kommersant" that for such announcements they should provide specific information and directions. There are also certain rules for free prosthetics (I don't know the truth ..)
    2. +1
      11 January 2019 06: 21
      Judging by the photo and he is "Brutus". Here again, by chance, right? Coincidence of the purest water.
  8. +8
    11 January 2019 06: 11
    Absolutely honest article - in fact, honesty and epilogue.
    "Straightening the brains" of the last two generations has become an almost hopeless task.
    1. +14
      11 January 2019 06: 31
      Recently, one great journalist by the name of Posner said that until all generations associated with the "union" are gone, nothing will change for the better. Only now their side clearly does not coincide with ours.
      1. +6
        11 January 2019 07: 02
        Quote: tracer
        Posner, said that until all generations are gone, connected at least somehow with the "union"

        Here we need to clarify one important point - he had in mind those who are in power, and not the people.
  9. +8
    11 January 2019 06: 21
    I watched the Sobibor film .... And I remembered the father of the past German concentration camp ... In the film, the bias was on effects, graphics ... Similar to the stage .... solid Kirkorovs and Viagra ..... solid humor Petrosyanovschina ... I recall the USSR when the films were not vulgar and the humor was subtle ...
    1. +12
      11 January 2019 07: 42
      The film "Sobibor", as for example once "Come and See", did not cause me personally deep shock. The horror of the concentration camp atmosphere is not shown. In this regard, the "Gray Zone" is much more tragic and evokes much more emotions. I sincerely respect Khabensky, but, in my opinion, the film does not touch the soul. Like "Panfilov's 28" - excellent special effects, historically correct weapons and equipment, but "Hot Snow" is emotionally much richer.
      1. +9
        11 January 2019 09: 28
        Quote: andrey-ivanov
        but Hot Snow is emotionally much richer.

        and Liberation? I believe that the cycle is still unsurpassed either in terms of its emotional state or its scale.
        "The battalions are asking for fire" is simply a masterpiece
        1. +3
          11 January 2019 12: 07
          I won't even argue. These films were filmed and filmed in them by those who themselves went through the crucible of war. Therefore, falsehood and idiotic "humor" were initially inappropriate there.
        2. +3
          11 January 2019 13: 44
          Quote: Silvestr
          "The battalions are asking for fire" is simply a masterpiece

          what Hmm, and during the Union they didn’t want to let him hire, considering the circus booth!
      2. +1
        11 January 2019 12: 45
        So that the 28 Panfilov’s men would suffocate like old films, it was necessary to shoot it by the acting and production team sitting under fire, sniffing gunpowder, and with the last grenade under the tank to throw. Most old war movies take a choke for a simple reason. The actors, the directors, either saw the war, or very closely communicated with people who saw closely. They did not play, but rather relived the horrors of war in the frame. Therefore, the soul takes. Modern actors can’t play like that. And it's not a lack of talent. They just don’t know what to play. They don’t know what people are experiencing horror.
        Panfilov’s good film. Thanks to those who shot and starred. There is something that will be shown to children about that war filmed now.
        1. 0
          11 January 2019 17: 23
          But on the other hand, it’s good to see modern actors not playing like that.
          It’s good that they didn’t see the war!
          1. 0
            11 January 2019 19: 37
            But wars go on. And modern youth, shouting about authenticity, do not see horror in the eyes of the dying soldiers. 90 percent of today's youth do not understand the concept of "killed in action" simply cannot understand it. They don't realize how awful it is when artillery works in residential areas. A good film with good acting makes you think. And some old films are so terrifying at times. Not just watching, not just empathizing, but as if sitting next to me in the trench. With the well-fed faces of the concentration camp prisoners and the calm soldiers under fire, this will not be achieved.
      3. +2
        11 January 2019 13: 42
        Quote: andrey-ivanov
        Film "Sobibor"

        Before the film, how many in Russia knew about Pechersky, for example, did you know about him?
        Quote: andrey-ivanov
        for example, once "Come and See", did not cause me personally deep shock

        Is there a little blood?
        1. 0
          11 January 2019 19: 41
          Well, the current Sobibor is far from the first. And before that the film was. And not only films should inform about exploits. There is such a science. Story. She is taught at school. And the newest and especially heroic history should be an element of culture as a whole.
  10. +7
    11 January 2019 06: 26
    Skororokhov of course, sometimes, disputes things gives out. But this time I would subscribe to every word.
    1. +4
      11 January 2019 07: 05
      Quote: andrey-ivanov
      Skororokhov, of course, sometimes, disputes things

      Controversial for whom? For you? For most citizens? For whom? is he not obligated and should not to think exactly like you. He writes his point of view. Thank you very much for the article.
      1. +6
        11 January 2019 07: 33
        And no one says that the author should think like me. And the fact that he expresses his point of view is wonderful. Like me mine. Therefore, I consider your annoyed remark absolutely inappropriate. Calm need to relate to others and their opinion.
    2. 0
      11 January 2019 07: 23
      There is no doubt that something needs to be done. But not like in the Donbass. There it was necessary to act urgently and relying on intuition and luck
  11. +1
    11 January 2019 06: 41
    With all due respect to the author, it’s even broke for me to read an article about this cinematic ... uh ... how to say, so as not to be banned ... in short, you understand.
  12. 0
    11 January 2019 06: 44
    Those who seem to think in their right mind ... are to blame for the journalist who did not clean the monument and did not bring money to Gazprom.

    As one of the participants in that very discussion, I have to argue. It is not true, no one wrote that the journalist was to blame. The journalist has done his job, for which he is paid. To clean or not to clean a star from snow is his own business ... Only here ... The same Nikolai Savchenko. He has been fighting this "Italian hat" for fifteen years. He goes somewhere, holds meetings, writes letters. After all, there are all kinds of committees, prosecutors - they are paid money for this, why should he?
  13. +17
    11 January 2019 06: 51
    We will erect a monument to Vlasov, ten to Solzhenitsyn, Shkuro, Krasnov and everyone whom we awarded with a rope, everything! And also SS-fighters for freedom from Stalin, White Czechs (hell, they tried already), Finns, Romanians, Hungarians.
    Isn’t it time, my friends, for us to swing at William, you see, our Shakespeare? And sweep! And what? .... So they have already waved ... The Soviet period of history, carefully extorted .. From October 1917 to June 21, 1941 it is bad, from June 22, 1941 to September 1945 it is good, from September 1945 to August 1991 it is again bad, there was a bright spot Gagarin flew into space .. By the way, in March, April, articles will appear on many Internet resources on the topic, oh, it's time to take Lenin out of the mausoleum, this is a long tradition ... I did not watch the holiday, and I do not want ... I found the strength to watch the T-34 ... I won’t discuss this film .. I touched one episode .. the enemies shook hands with each other ... Cried .. The Show Must Go On .... In the literal and figurative sense. ..
    1. +9
      11 January 2019 08: 00
      It is very simple to explain the extinction of the Soviet period since it is impossible to reconcile with the current liberal democratic history. These are mutually exclusive concepts.
      If in 1916 Faberge received the largest number of orders in RI, then in 2016 ---- the largest number of yachts were built in the Russian Federation.
  14. +6
    11 January 2019 07: 01
    Meanness was, is and unfortunately will be. It hurts that the interpretation of historical events in their own interpretation or to please those who have been trying for many years to discredit and denigrate everything that happened in Russia is completely indifferent to the authorities. Raging "oppositionists" are expelled for their pleasure, knowing full well that they will not be touched, moreover, they will even remove dandruff from some so that the suit fits. More than once he wrote that by their behavior towards the presumptuous detractors of Russia, the authorities are strenuously digging a hole for themselves. Come on, power (the concept is coming), but not the first generation of those who do not know the history of their country at all, who immediately believe in the "liberal" talkers, are growing up.
  15. +3
    11 January 2019 07: 01
    The point is not only the worthlessness and mediocrity of the enemies of the communists, who seriously imagined that they are more than the communists and their supporters worthy of owning the country, but, in particular, that they are the only ones in world history that DO NOT have a positive history of their country, theirs " history "is anger and hatred, slander about the history of your country, justification of the invaders of your country - the interventionists and the Nazis, praise of the collaborators of your country. And only because of this, they are a priori unable to create a normal State.
  16. 0
    11 January 2019 07: 19
    The author's pain is understandable. But Russia is a huge territory, this is not Donbass. Even in 1917, when everything seemed to be envisaged, up to the duplication of the state apparatus and military support, it was not possible to avoid a civil war and subsequent intervention. Of course, Russia was weakened by the war, but now the same threat. And some people sleep and see when the power will weaken at least a little, and take advantage of the situation to gain independence. And the West will help them, he is. It is necessary to change the situation without breaking the system, especially in such unsuitable conditions. And this is not done from the "bay-flounder". Power, good or bad, is what keeps us all together. The whole vast territory.
    I expressed my opinion
    1. -1
      11 January 2019 10: 11
      Here you are, the 4 people who minus the author of this post, can you somehow justify your opinion?
    2. +1
      11 January 2019 14: 00
      It is necessary to change the situation without breaking the system, especially in such unsuitable conditions. And this is not done from the "bay-flounder". Power, good or bad, is what keeps us all together. The whole vast territory.

      Good. How to change the power system of the oligarchy of the Russian Federation, in an easy way? Your suggestions.
      1. +1
        11 January 2019 14: 20
        The thorny and longest, but bloodless way, is to use your rights to the fullest. To organize parties, look for like-minded people, take part in the elections, propose a real program to get the country out of stagnation, and not gather a crowd around it with slogans. Cast their votes and participate in public life. Come to power. And if you still maintain independence in decision-making - change to health fellow
        Another variant. Without changing the structure of the system, change all management positions at a time, with the support of the army and all law enforcement agencies. Then gradually build a new government structure and form of ownership. That is a coup. But I did not offer it wassat But in this case, years of devastation are inevitable anyway. Civil war and a repetition of intervention are also possible.
        I would suggest waiting for someone to come to Putin's place. If instead of the president there is an obvious scumbag - I will serve cartridges
        1. +3
          11 January 2019 14: 34
          The thorny and longest, but bloodless way, is to use your rights to the fullest. To organize parties, look for like-minded people, take part in the elections, propose a real program to get the country out of stagnation, and not gather a crowd around it with slogans. Cast their votes and participate in public life.

          Will not work. The oligarch of the Russian Federation has created a system in which a simple person, just to be tolerant of life, needs to plow like dad Carlo and what kind of political activity is there? In addition, the ideology of tribulation developed in our society allows the Russian oligarchy to outbid dangerous opponents (Rogozin, Uncle Zyu, Zhirik, etc.).
          1. -2
            11 January 2019 15: 22
            Maybe you don’t get up. Or not right away. For an oligarch, power is a feeding trough. For his soldering will bite. But it is possible to influence political processes by creating parties, public organizations, denunciations, and the right to vote. Or people are still not happy with the social system. Then why is socialism hayut?
  17. +8
    11 January 2019 07: 29
    People show their attitude to the memory of the war best on May 9 !!!!!!!
    And now we recall how liberals scolded this holiday during their reign.
    They say we must "repent", etc. etc.
  18. +3
    11 January 2019 07: 31
    these mares right now in the cold without clothes-look ridiculous they will be ali
  19. +9
    11 January 2019 07: 50
    Otherwise, honestly, in five years we will simply turn into a herd, powerless and wanting nothing.

    Already ... have become a herd of "moyahataskrayniks"!
    Example? Yes, easily!
    A lot of us (you) came out in 2018 to protest the anti-people actions of the current ruling government? In Omsk, the city of a millionaire, at an authorized rally (a witness himself, and wrote about this more than once), there were only! several thousand dissenters (LDPR, Communist Party and others) who wanted to try to change something at least! So where were you, dear, everyone was, under what shop were you hiding?
    Well, no, on the VO and in the media the heralds-kremlebots howled that Navalny had kicked out the young "nerds" for the money, what the "adversary" was doing!
    I am wrong?
    This is how the powers that be are cracked down on us, because everyone is fucking happy!
    And until each person decides for himself that he still has to do something in this life (before it's too late), so we (including myself, because I could not do more) will turn into a "cattle" herd of slaves and beggars!
    I do not call for unlawful actions, I judge by what kind of infantile slave people we have ... otherwise, excuse me, I cannot say. We deserve the kind of government that has us! And this "vyser" from the above-mentioned director is proof of that!
    I have the honor!
    Come on, minus it!
    1. -1
      11 January 2019 08: 26
      Quote: Clear
      I have the honor!

      What vulgarity, dear sir!
    2. +5
      11 January 2019 10: 18
      And did it not occur to you that not everyone is so negatively inclined on this issue, since they did not go to rallies?
      But "... what an infantile slave people we have ...".
    3. +2
      11 January 2019 10: 39
      We had a meeting organized by the Communist Party. I didn't go because I worked. There were few people at the meeting. Most likely for the same reason as mine. There was an attempt to compromise the meeting. It was organized by a group of young people. They put on masks, grabbed stones, but were pacified and expelled by the protesters themselves. Do not go and for what purpose, let everyone decide for himself. But some "guys" have different goals. There was a call to hold a meeting against the government, but was against the reform. The goals and ways of achieving are different. As you put it, the "heralds" tried to warn you about this. And for you all who are not with you that bot? And the Kremlin is a symbol of power for you, or is it the country? Who planted such an association the Kremlin and the bot? Think
  20. +6
    11 January 2019 07: 54
    Absolutely right, Roman - crush these Krasovskie larvae with a boot
    1. 0
      11 January 2019 10: 23
      Quote: Nonna
      crush these Krasovskie larvae with a boot

      Old folk wisdom: "You can't beat a thought with a butt"
  21. -1
    11 January 2019 07: 59
    Before the war in Leningrad, I had more than two hundred relatives, from the author of the article.
    Not too many relatives?
    By the way, in Chelyabinsk, in this harsh city of steelmakers, back in 2011, a monument to the whites was erected on the forecourt and nothing - no one was hysterical, and now they are not.
  22. +8
    11 January 2019 07: 59
    Eh, it was good that there was censorship before, especially before the shooting the plot was coordinated with the corresponding comrades. Of course, this is also unnecessary, but at least from such "vomit" the citizens of our country would be protected. They would protect people who consider themselves directors from venality and perversion of thoughts and visions. sad negative
    1. -4
      11 January 2019 08: 50
      Quote: K-50
      before censorship was

      This is one option. There is another thing - to make a distinction to the people, so that he himself understands where the lie is, and where the truth is and then this abomination will never appear. Censorship is needed in totalitarian societies that keep people in the dark, where any ray of light, or darkness, can lead to excitement of the crowd. This is one of the management tools. Depending on what kind of result is needed, people are shown either light or darkness.
    2. 0
      14 January 2019 11: 38
      Quote: K-50
      Eh, it was good that there was censorship before, especially before the shooting the plot was coordinated with the corresponding comrades. Of course, this is also unnecessary, but at least from such "vomit" the citizens of our country would be protected. They would protect people who consider themselves directors from venality and perversion of thoughts and visions. sad negative
      -That's just a nuance-defended too zealously ....
      "And how many films were on the shelf / cut - offhand:
      "Gone with the Wind" (for the life of me I don't understand why), Commissioner, Intervention, Ivan Vasilyevich changes his profession (cut 10 minutes !!!), Kin-dza-dza, Holmes, Volga-Volga (!!!), Mimino, Old people - robbers, Pokrovsky gate, The meeting place cannot be changed (of the 7 series, 5 (!!!!))-
      "The scene of the arrest of" The Black Cat "was also censored. During the filming, Govorukhin suggested that Bortnik, who was playing the Blotter, should improvise, and that suffered - he began to struggle, sang a thug song, spat in the face of Zheglov-Vysotsky, and generally entered the character so well that those who were among extras, the real veterans of the post-war militia attacked him, seriously twisted his arms and beat him.
      But the curator from the Ministry of Internal Affairs, General Nikulin, demanded to cut back on amateur performance: "What kind of character is this? Take it away. Otherwise, tomorrow there will be a blotter in every yard." ""
  23. +8
    11 January 2019 08: 06
    In fact, I do not watch modern cinema, a very low level.
    With regards to the military theme, the level of acting and the general quality of the films "They Fought for the Motherland", "Seventeen Moments of Spring", "Officers" is simply unattainable for modern directors and actors!
  24. +1
    11 January 2019 08: 22
    Quote: R. Skomorokhov
    Moreover, as they began to do in the Donbass. In 2014.

    That's just how in the Donbass is not necessary. There is no second Russia, no one will send us humanitarian aid.

    Again, you are trying to overcome the highest management priorities with the help of lower ones. This does not happen. The lower ones always depend on the higher ones. First thought, then action. It is not possible to interrupt a thought by force. A convinced person (fanatic) will not be stopped by any force. You can fight against thought only with thought.

    Only by changing the concept of living arrangements in Russia, you can put an end to all this abomination and lies. It is necessary to change the social system, but in no case in a revolutionary way. Revolutions are usually financed from abroad and the results of the revolution are used by those who financed it. The people, as a result, are being transferred to more sophisticated forms of exploitation.

    Methods of changing the social system in an evolutionary way, without bloodletting and lowering the country into the Stone Age, have long been described.
    1. +8
      11 January 2019 09: 00
      They say that we have no ideology ... We have an ideology! Her task is to systematically lower the bar of our morality. For defeating the people without a rudder and sails is a trifle task. I remember, back in Soviet times, a group of schoolgirls beat a schoolgirl in Zelenograd, Moscow Region. The incident at that time was so wild that they could not hide. U-turn article in the central press. The country shuddered, was horrified ... And then - perestroika, everything can be done! You are a free person, you are who you are - show your true nature! And they began to show that which was not previously permitted, but which, to one degree or another, was in everyone — his own inner beast. Now the beating of schoolgirls by schoolgirls is our way of life. It’s still terrifying when schoolgirls cut kittens. Then we'll get used to it - this is our ideology. And here you are - about the movie. It is strictly in the current ideological channel.
      1. +1
        11 January 2019 09: 41
        Quote: depressant
        They say that we have no ideology ... We have an ideology! Her task is to systematically lower the bar of our morality

        Cinema is one of the tools of ideological power. The bearers of ideologies are parties. EP, who won the Duma elections and defends the interests of the exploiting class, adopts the laws by which we all live, including the laws in the field of culture.

        Quote: depressant
        I remember back in Soviet times

        The generation that has gone through perestroika has the opportunity to compare socialism with a human face with the beastly grin of capitalism. Young people have no such life experience, and all this abomination from TV screens is designed specifically for them. As the saying goes: "To defeat a strong enemy, raise his children." So they are trying their best to put Russia under the feet of their masters.

        While the people are illiterate
        of all the arts, the most important for us are cinema and the circus

        (Complete comp. Op. - 5-th ed. - T. 44. - S. 579: Conversation of V.I. Lenin with A.V. Lunacharsky)

        1. -2
          12 January 2019 08: 45
          Quite right. How to raise a child, what is good and what is bad. Such an abomination pours from the TV screen. And also the "creative intelligentsia" yells about the inadmissibility of censorship and control over product quality.
    2. +4
      11 January 2019 12: 50
      It is necessary to change the social system, but in no case in a revolutionary way.
      Honestly, I am surprised at your naivety. Do you think that those who are now in power voluntarily, at a loss will want to change this very system?
      Revolutions are usually financed from abroad and the results of the revolution are used by those who financed it.
      I understand this stone in the garden of the Great October Revolution? Can you tell me, because of such a milestone, was it funded? The request is only to do without delirium about the fact that the Bolsheviks were financed from Berlin.
      The people, as a result, are being transferred to more sophisticated forms of exploitation.
      Can you tell me what kind of sophisticated forms of exploitation the people were transferred as a result of the October Revolution? It must be assumed that with an eight-hour working day and a six-day working week, could the people be exploited much more sophisticatedly than with the 14-16 hour working day, which was practiced under the tsar, as well as fines for any reason and other delights of capitalism?
      1. -1
        11 January 2019 13: 05
        Quote: AnderS
        Do you think that those who are now in power voluntarily, at a loss will want to change this very system?

        Not. Voluntarily, they would never want to change the existing situation. That is why all revolutions are organized from behind a hill. Those that are not from behind the hillock are called popular riots, which are usually spontaneous and poorly organized.

        Quote: AnderS
        I understand this stone in the garden of the Great October Revolution?

        And she is the same. Trotskyists created open genocide of the Russian people.

        Quote: AnderS
        It must be assumed that with an eight-hour working day and a six-day working week,

        There was an exception - this is the so-called "quiet" revolution carried out by Stalin in 1924. As a result of his "Lenin recruitment" to the party, the number of Bolsheviks significantly exceeded the number of Trotskyists in it, which made it possible to prepare the country for the bloodiest war of the twentieth century.

        We have experience without mass massacre, collapse of the economy and the removal of some from power and the coming of others to others ... including the experience of perestroika, we only need to change the vectors of the goals of the next perestroika. This is one of the reasons why there is still no research into why and who and how ruined the USSR, since this experience can (should) be used by us in the struggle for our future, future of our children and grandchildren.
        1. -1
          11 January 2019 14: 13
          Voluntarily, they would never want to change the existing situation. That is why all revolutions are organized from behind a hill.

          Well, let's say a foreign enemy state organized a revolution in a neighboring country in order to squeeze out part of the territory using anarchy. And it was even outdated, but here the power that came as a result of the revolution mobilizes the country (carries out industrialization, collectivization, scientific and technological revolution, etc.) and destroys the state that organized the revolution. And there were such examples (owners of the Fed and 3 Reich).
          1. 0
            11 January 2019 14: 36
            Quote: ruigat
            but here the power that came as a result of the revolution mobilizes the country

            In order to mobilize the country, we had to conduct another revolution - the 1924 of the year.

            Quote: ruigat
            And such examples were (the owners of the Fed and 3 Reich).

            The 3 Reich was not destroyed by the Fed, but by the Red Army. The Fed's task was to ensure that there would be only one printing press on the entire planet Earth. They solved this problem in a different way, not by force. First, Brezhnev began to sell oil for dollars, but he could have for rubles, and there were plenty of people who wanted to buy it for rubles. Then the hunchbacked one completely put us under the dollar ... the truth took more than a year, but they achieved their goal - almost all the banks in the world are branches of the Fed.
            1. -1
              11 January 2019 14: 47
              In order to mobilize the country, we had to conduct another revolution - the 1924 of the year.

              You confuse revolution with internal party struggle.
              The 3rd Reich did not destroy the Fed, but the Red Army.

              Yes, but the Golem (1 Reich) struck 3 blow at its creators, the owners of the Fed in April 1940.
              1. 0
                11 January 2019 15: 46
                Quote: ruigat
                You confuse revolution with internal party struggle.

                The change in the alignment of forces in the party took place primarily in the lower echelons, it was there that thousands of workers and peasants joined the ranks of the party. If in 1918 the number of party members was about 350 thousand, then by 1932 it had already amounted to about three million. At that time, party meetings were open and both party and non-party people took part in them. Can this be called internal party squabbles, when they essentially affected the entire society? That is why I called it a "quiet" revolution.

                For a bloodless change in the social system, we need to analyze all our previous experience and show the people that in order to change power it is not necessary to run into rudeness and face each other to make our enemies happy.

                These questions are not this topic. Therefore, I am finishing. hi
        2. +1
          11 January 2019 14: 56
          And she is the same. Trotskyists created open genocide of the Russian people.
          WHAT!? Was it the Trotskyists who carried out genocide? And the fact that these same Trotskyists have never been in the majority in the party does not bother you? Yes, before the victory of the Stalinist course in 24-40 years, there was a struggle within the party, but for the Trotskyists to pursue a purposeful policy of genocide of the Russian people ... Maybe they would have begun to conduct it if they had been given the opportunity ... I don't even know how to react to what you wrote ... And the Trotskyists, for some reason, distinguished the Russian people from, say, the Tatar people? Or from Georgian? Or are you a member of the "genocide of the Russian people by Soviet power" sect - an analogue of the "Holodomor" sect in Ukraine? I will not mention the fact that under the tsars, regardless of nationality, more people died every year, including from such a "humane" cause as hunger, as well as as a result of exorbitant infant mortality, lack of a health care system, etc. your beloved Bolsheviks ... And if we take specifically the famine, then the Soviet power is the first power in the history of Russia which managed to defeat hunger.
          We have experience without mass massacre, collapse of the economy and the removal of some from power and the coming of others to others ... including the experience of perestroika, we only need to change the vectors of the goals of the next perestroika.
          WHAT!? belay belay belay Do you yourself understand what you wrote? Was this restructuring without mass massacre, collapse of the economy, removal of some from power and the coming to power of others? Are you sure that we are talking about the same perestroika?
      2. -5
        12 January 2019 08: 51
        In numerous IPs, this is practiced. A working day is more than 8 hours, one day off, vacation two weeks a year, half-wage bonus, CT is not paid. Kidalovo with a salary. Sharaga went bankrupt and disappears. Salary in an envelope and you are self-employed.
  25. +2
    11 January 2019 08: 27
    So many emotions and not a word about the plot, not a word about what caused such emotions. Is this such a sophisticated advertisement? Like, I wonder why it’s so emotional - then see for yourself what kind of movie it is.
    posted the film publicly on YouTube.
    Well, now let's discuss every video or every pseudo-film from this garbage dump. They only need this. the more rumors, the more views.
    It would be better here to spread the article:
    about the feat of baker Kyutinen, who died of hunger

    how people from the Institute of Plant Growing starved to death but retained an elite grain

    about Alexei Sudaev, who died in 35 years
    1. +3
      11 January 2019 10: 03
      A rare case when I agree with you hi , and another example of what you always need to remember - we are not enemies to each other here.
    2. -2
      11 January 2019 11: 29
      Just the author got tired of social injustice. The film is another irritant. He fought in the Donbass, therefore he is sensitive to this topic. Only injustice is never satisfied. There at the end of the article ... You can endure, but you can fist on the table. I often hit the table with my fist, though at home. Sometimes he regretted later. I would not want to have like in the Donbass
      1. +5
        11 January 2019 17: 03
        Quote: igorbrsv
        ... He fought in the Donbass, therefore he is sensitive to this topic ...

        I'm sorry, sir.
        I understand everything perfectly - you like the author. I also sometimes read his articles. Sometimes I even find something useful in them. Only here is yours "he fought"may turn out to be a disservice to the author.
        Since when is the delivery of humanitarian aid, collected together and the tour of the trenches called "he fought"?
        1. +1
          11 January 2019 19: 30
          From the Ukrainian site. I thought he was in the know. This is the information from there. I don’t know where she comes from. Therefore, at a loss. You can warn, warn. Give a link?
          1. +4
            11 January 2019 19: 44
            Quote: igorbrsv
            ... from the Ukrainian site ...

            Then it is clear.
            There, all male Russians from 16 to 60 are either occupiers or potential occupants.
            The source of information is awful.
            There is no one in "Peacemaker": from journalists to volunteers and church priests. Those who actually offered armed resistance to the Nazis - at least. The rest were recorded in bulk - for "extras".
            1. 0
              11 January 2019 19: 48
              For some reason they didn’t record me. I really was not there
              1. +5
                11 January 2019 19: 50
                Quote: igorbrsv
                ... For some reason I was not recorded. I really was not there ...

                Defective bastards laughing
                1. 0
                  11 January 2019 19: 53
                  But I'm moving out somehow. They have underfunding chtoli request
  26. +1
    11 January 2019 08: 42
    the author has too many emotions about this creation. with my heart, then I agree with him, but with my head .... well, you are walking along the street, and there is a piece of dog droppings. grimace and pass by. it does not deserve more.
  27. +2
    11 January 2019 09: 05
    The author is right ...., and it's not about watching today's Russian cinema, it's the same dullness as the Western one, only with a Russian accent, but it's basically ..., for all my ambiguous attitude towards Jews, I sincerely admire their consistency in defending "our" historical truth ..., we need our own law on "denial of the Holocaust", if necessary, then there must be our own "hagada", the people are alive by memory, the past is also created like the future, but do we have a future with such "remake" is a serious question ....
  28. -10
    11 January 2019 09: 29
    And in general, in Leningrad, a sufficient number of people survived the blockade, and many of them left us stories and memoirs.

    Do not fantasize and rewrite history when there are terrible diaries and memories of the inhabitants of Leningrad.
    According to various sources, between 600 thousand and 1,5 million people died during the blockade, of which 3% were from bombing and 97% from hunger.
    Nikolai Ribkovsky, the instructor of the personnel department of the VKPb district committee, kept a diary and described his food in the hospital of the city party committee in 1942:
    “Food here is like in peacetime in a good holiday home.
    Every day, meat: lamb, ham, chicken, goose, turkey, sausage.
    Or fish: bream, herring, smelt, and fried, and boiled, and aspic.
    Caviar, balyk, cheese, pies, cocoa, coffee, tea, three hundred grams of white and the same amount of black bread per day, thirty grams of butter and fifty grams of grape wine, good port for lunch and dinner ... ,,

    A resident of Leningrad, Nina Spirova, who worked the entire blockade in the Yeliseyev secret special distributor, told who and how received food in the besieged city when other residents died of hunger.
    The special distributor had apples, pears, plums, grapes.
    All the freshest. And so - the whole war.
    Meat section. Several varieties of sausage, ham, sausages.
    Near the pastry shop - sweets, chocolate.
    The woman’s words are confirmed by the doctor of historical sciences Nikita Lomagin, author of the book “Unknown Blockade”.
    https://lenta.ru/articles/2018/12/02/leningrad/
    1. +8
      11 January 2019 09: 38
      Quote: alta
      The instructor of the personnel department of the district committee of the VKPb Nikolai Ribkovsky kept a diary

      A very mysterious person, this instructor, by the way and no less a mysterious diary.
      The notorious Soros Foundation provided very active assistance in the publication of this "diary".
      1. +3
        11 January 2019 09: 46
        extremely valuable remark ..., this is how archives and annals are created, so the story is written ....
    2. BAI
      +3
      11 January 2019 10: 37
      1. Here is how Ribkovsky describes his life in the besieged Leningrad (in letters):
      Ribkovsky’s life is saved by the fact that on December 5, 1941, he was hired by the personnel department of the Leningrad City Committee. Now he has a small but solid salary, and most importantly - high-quality food in the dining room of Smolny. Here is how he describes his food on December 9, 1941: “For the first soup with vermicelli, for the second pork with stewed cabbage. In the evening, for those who work, there is a free cheese sandwich, a white bun and a couple of glasses of sweet tea. ” At the same time, he notes that the coupons in the dining room are cut out only for bread and meat, so that using the cards “it will be possible to buy groats, butter and other things that are supposed to be bought in stores and to feed a little at home.”

      However, even on such feeding, Nikolai Andreyevich looks at himself in horror - during his dependency, he turned into a walking skeleton: “Even doubt has taken: is this my body, or has someone replaced it with me? Legs and hands, like a child ... belly failed. The ribs almost got out(13.12.1941).

      2. Meals at the holiday home.
      Everything becomes clear when you consider the following. Ribkovsky:
      “Before leaving for the hospital in the Smolny library I met my friend - the writer Evgeny Fedorov. He prompted me to read his novel The Demidovs. So he took it up with attention and passion. "
      We read the novel:
      “Wagons were arranged on the squares, livestock — chickens, turkeys, fresh and salted fish in bags, bags of grain and groats, pork and lamb carcasses ... The host and guest after a busy day ate chicken, pork, noodles and pies with appetite. The clerk washed down the food with strong wine, but did not get drunk. ” “On the table - unwise food: cabbage soup with lamb, pie with beef. The blacksmith went up to the hill, pulled out a silver ladle gifted by the king and poured grape wine».
      And compare with the menu of the holiday home. We get - just the dreams of a hungry person, even the terminology is the same.

      We can definitely say that party workers ate better than ordinary Leningraders (in the end, not a single starvation), on the other hand, there were no particular excesses. Paulus in the Stalingrad boiler did not starve either.
      1. +2
        11 January 2019 12: 09
        Quote: BAI
        Here is how he describes his food on December 9, 1941: “For the first soup with vermicelli, for the second pork with stewed cabbage. In the evening, for those who work, there is a free cheese sandwich, a white bun and a couple of glasses of sweet tea. ” At the same time, he notes that the coupons in the dining room are cut out only for bread and meat, so that using the cards “it will be possible to buy groats, butter and other things that are supposed to be bought in stores and to feed a little at home.”

        Yeah ... and after a couple of months of such nutrition, Ribkovsky was in the hospital of the city party committee.
        1. BAI
          +1
          11 January 2019 13: 40
          And in the summer of 1944 - he died.
    3. +1
      11 January 2019 11: 41
      . The special distributor had apples, pears, plums, grapes.
      All the freshest. And so - the whole war.
      Meat section. Several varieties of sausage, ham, sausages.
      Near the pastry shop - sweets, chocolate.

      And where would it all come from ?! Tomorrow they will say that Leningrad was not in such a blockade? Where did the fruits come from in the winter to the war, if only in the winter more or less delivery could be arranged. Of course, I saw in a movie how a truck of tangerines was driving there, ice cream by the way, and he didn’t get there, he left under the ice. But in this bullshit with all sorts of marzepans I won’t believe
  29. +1
    11 January 2019 09: 44
    I agree with you completely. So what to do? For starters, just call a spade a spade. Including shit that you actually do. Well, the fact that such a thing is supposed to be flushed down the toilet, and then another, and washed, so this is known to all. Not everyone, however, is accustomed ... But there's nothing you can do. One hope that maybe even with time they will mature.
  30. +3
    11 January 2019 09: 49
    What is everyone dissatisfied with? We have long been living in two Russia. Some hang boards of Mannerheim, shoot the film Holiday, are going to privatize Belarus. And you with whom. I was amazed how the whole site yesterday, no matter how the person positioned himself before this article, red and white, supporters of the oligarchs and people, pro-Western and pro-Russian, monarchists and communists all united in a single impulse sided with the Russian oligarchs pouring mud on Lukashenko. .
    I’m not hard to ask again, with whom are you with those who raise the retirement age, sell resources to our potential opponents, and shoot anti-Russian films? Or with the people? So be consistent!
    1. +2
      11 January 2019 10: 26
      And the above is inconsistent Cheslav Tsursky. Like, people should be poked into the past dirt of the country. Say, we will recover morally. Not true! It's just that the cat will stop shitting, wherever, if you poke his nose you know what. If you constantly and even on the rise to assert a person in the opinion that our past is worthless and nothing, well, absolutely nothing good was there, and all past achievements are presented as a bluff and defamation, then among the mass of the people self-esteem will sharply drop, which means the nation will lose its will to life. And signs of this are already being observed. Yes, "Kuban Cossacks" was a beautiful fairy tale, but the people loved this fairy tale and is still loving it today. Because a fairy tale gives hope! She inspires, raises tone, encourages to do good, to love! And such a truth about Leningrad, seasoned with a fair amount of lies, which the stupid director is going to present to us, is killing the nation.
      1. -1
        11 January 2019 11: 13
        These smart cats stop shitting after the procedure you described, and there are those that immediately shit on you in slippers, hide under the sofa and observe with deep satisfaction how you put these slippers on. It is useless to educate such people, in a bag and in a garbage dump away from home.
    2. 0
      11 January 2019 11: 58
      . What is everyone dissatisfied with? We have long been living in two Russia. Some hang Mannerheim boards, shoot the film Holiday, are going to privatize Belarus

      We all live in one Russia. The other was not and will not be. A separate handful of sold-out officials protected by oligarchs cannot be called another Russia. Just don't row with the same brush. Aren't there honest doctors, military men, cops, and even officials? Then who does not save lives for money and lay down his own? And even honest bureaucrats I came across. Do not destroy everything in despair. But I don’t know what to do with those who perpetuate the "Mannerheims"
    3. +2
      11 January 2019 14: 22
      Quote: Gardamir
      I’m not hard to ask again, with whom are you with those who raise the retirement age, sell resources to our potential opponents, and shoot anti-Russian films? Or with the people? So be consistent!

      You, a colleague, are categorical as always! good We are the people! In order to be consistent, it is not necessary to say, you can simply do what you did - this is the definition of the direction of movement. Most do not like what is happening in the country, but how to influence our power, we also do not understand! I am sure that the majority of those who voted for GDP during the elections hoped that the eternal Medvedev team would change, but this did not happen! And what to do? There are worthy and competent people who can replace mediocrities, but who can remove these mediocrities and dummies from there - they are relatives, friends, debtors, etc. those who put them there. It is necessary to change the system, but how?
    4. -5
      12 January 2019 09: 02
      Privatization of Belarus. All right. The masters of life breed, in Russia everything is distributed. Need new territory.
  31. +3
    11 January 2019 09: 59
    Dehumanizing sales slowly, it's scary, it's dangerous!
    As in Eisenstein's film, "Battleship Potemkin" ", when the mutinous sailors were covered with a tarpaulin, Schaub the same sailors fired at the tarpaulin, not fellow sailors !!!
    We are going through the next tests and the way we come out of them will determine our future destiny.
  32. 0
    11 January 2019 09: 59
    A laborer to reward guys, or a trip to sunny Chukotka!
  33. BAI
    +4
    11 January 2019 10: 23
    1. As you know - the younger the blogger, the worse he lived under Stalin.
    2. Why be surprised? It didn't start today. You could say the Overton Window in action. The substitution of moral values ​​began in the "holy 90s", when the glorification of criminality ("Brigade") and the appearance of the first films about "Rashka-shit" began. All this was allowed and then it went on increasing. On the topic of war turned off. Except for the veterans, no one reacted to Hitler Kaput, the process started, and everything went to a natural, quite expected and predictable result.
    1. +1
      11 January 2019 10: 37
      Quote: BAI
      The substitution of moral values ​​began in the "holy 90s"

      This substitution of moral values ​​began much earlier with regard to cinema - the real pogrom was launched at the V Congress of Cinematographers of the USSR (the so-called revolutionary congress), which took place in the Grand Kremlin Palace and the congress was supervised by the Propaganda Department of the CPSU Central Committee and the largest party members. They smashed Soviet cinema, Bondarchuk, Rostotsky, Matveev and others.
      The people fell on Little Faith и Intergirls
      1. +1
        11 January 2019 12: 04
        I remember these films. Around this time, the substitution began.
  34. +1
    11 January 2019 10: 37
    They just need to be stupidly banished.
  35. +2
    11 January 2019 10: 47
    Our trouble is that we, unlike the Arabs, are not able to tear our ass off the couch, and go, like them, to tear to shreds the newspaper’s editorial board, which dared insult the prophet when we can do it, or catch such artists will immediately bounce back ..
    1. -1
      11 January 2019 12: 06
      Exactly. And no revolution would be needed
  36. +3
    11 January 2019 10: 53
    If only this nasty movie was the problem! The main problem is the equally foul television. What do we see there? In the morning on weekdays, endless brainwashing on the topic of bad Ukraine and the west, beautiful Russia. Further, digging in dirty laundry and arguing about who slept with whom, why and what he wants from it. Then the most vulgar serials with "text reading". From Friday and weekend, endless shows of dances, voices, 3-hour memories of the artist's life or how the film was shot and the constant, round-the-clock rzhach. And all THIS is on federal channels, mixed with news releases with inapplicable mention of the sun (at least 2 stories) and about where it exploded, burned down, crashed. A movie like this is no wonder the beast of an official TV screen splattered with cum and saliva.
    1. +4
      11 January 2019 11: 07
      Quote: UMA-UMA
      What do we see there?

      What is the problem ? Do not look, judging by your stories from the TV you do not come off.
      None of my current workmates know who Krasovsky is, and they have not heard about films.
      1. -1
        11 January 2019 11: 18
        Well, of course, the world consists only of me, you and your comrades. Truth? There are no children or other people in it. It's that simple - don't like it, don’t look, yeah.
        1. +1
          11 January 2019 11: 33
          I agree with you that it’s hard not only not to be able to watch all the current dregs, but nowhere to go, you walk along the street — everywhere you see raunchy ads, sit at work — turn on the radio with some mockingbirds, and you won’t be able to shut your ears.
          As the Holy Fathers teach, one must be able to cut off all unnecessary and harmful information.
          1. +1
            11 January 2019 11: 49
            Quote: bober1982
            As the Holy Fathers teach, one must be able to cut off all unnecessary and harmful information.

            How to cut it off - this is understandable, but they teach how to distinguish the necessary from the unnecessary? laughing

            “A wise man once addressed a warning to humanity.
            “A day will come when all the water in the world, except that which will be specially collected, will disappear.” Then another water will appear in its place, and people will go crazy from it.

            Only one person understood the meaning of these words. He gathered more water and hid it in a safe place. Then he began to wait for the water to change. On the predicted day, all the rivers dried up, the wells dried up, and that man, retiring to his refuge, began to drink from his supplies. But then some time passed, and he saw that the rivers had renewed their course; and then he went down to the other sons of men and found that they were speaking and thinking quite differently than before, that something had been warned about them, but they did not remember it. When he tried to talk to them, he realized that they mistook him for a madman, showing him hostility or compassion, but not understanding. At first, he did not touch new water, returning to his supplies every day. However, in the end, he decided now to drink new water - because the behavior and thinking that distinguished him from the rest made his life unbearably lonely. He drank new water and became just like everyone else. And completely forgot about his stock of other water. The people around him looked at him as a madman who miraculously recovered from his madness.

            Among all methods of transferring information, video recording is one of the best in terms of speed / cost ratio, but often it gives only a superficial idea. To dig deeper, you have to work harder on your own. "

            ps under the terms water should be understood knowledge.
          2. 0
            11 January 2019 12: 36
            The vast majority of people do not know how to cut it off. Alas.
    2. +1
      11 January 2019 13: 21
      What is the problem? You do not like to watch domestic TV, see Euronews, the Air Force and further on the list, but if you are a patriot in your soul. but a critic of the authorities, watch Match TV, MuzTV, History, Retro, Spas, Zhivach planet, Big Asia - where the soul lies - and the fiery heart will calm down.
      1. 0
        11 January 2019 13: 50
        Thanks for such kansalting, especially free. Personally, I have 300 channels, two cinemas. I’m not discussing passionate preferences with you in the kitchen, but talking about state policy in the field of telecommunications. This policy cannot suit a normal person.
      2. +2
        11 January 2019 17: 49
        Quote: mikh-korsakov
        What's the problem?

        The problem is, Michael, that millions are watching and want to watch it.
    3. -3
      12 January 2019 09: 09
      On every channel there is a transfer, something like a good morning. Several presenters are positively drinking coffee from empty mugs. The running line contains 80% of negative information: died in a fire, road accident, suicide, a murderer was convicted, a corpse was found. I wanted to hear "news from the fields". Yes, the fields are overgrown
  37. +2
    11 January 2019 10: 59
    Many thanks to the author for reminding us all about Our Heroes, famous and unknown, about their Feat for the sake of the Motherland, for the sake of Honor, for the sake of descendants. I watched a video from TNT and waited, waited for a whistle, waited for a shout, waited for at least some kind of negative reaction from the audience - in vain, and it was not a stupid impromptu but a prepared "performance", an abomination! Somehow it has become too much, soon we are waiting for "jokes" on the topic "For the boys! And Serve brothers !? What have we turned Our Country into? Or what have we allowed to turn it into?"
  38. +9
    11 January 2019 11: 02
    Quote: Michael m
    Is this hidden advertising? The comrade looked, criticized, you need to see what they criticize, spit on the company.

    And here is what Sergey Petrovich Kapitsa said - a Soviet and Russian scientist - a physicist

  39. +1
    11 January 2019 11: 32
    Yes .... there is little hope for children ... I will raise my granddaughters .. Maybe they will be able to convey the truth about the Great Patriotic War.
  40. +1
    11 January 2019 11: 33
    Scum mock people’s memory, history, unparalleled victims of the past. The question is why is it so easy for them? But because those who sit in thoughts, advice and other things are profitable! Their goal is the further and maximum atomization of society, and with the hands of such imbeciles this is done. Itself with the highest tacit approval.
    And also because we dutifully and silently endure it.
  41. +3
    11 January 2019 11: 44
    A person who positively assesses the period of the USSR’s existence seems to be the easiest way to fully agree with the article and most of the comments.
    But there are several "BUT" - which I will sound ...
    1. "Everyone is to blame!" - the thesis is of course effective, and carries a certain message of hidden self-criticism ..... :)
    ..... BUT, - as a person who personally took part in a number of successful actions against attempts to "creep de-Sovietization" such as the abolition of the street names "Ataman Krasnov" and "Ataman Shkuro" (replaced by GSS Pliev and Kirichenko), removing the surname from the monument Nazi henchman Turkul, the cancellation of the renaming of the park to them. Lenin Komsomol, etc. etc., WHY should I be among the "guilty ones"? Psychological "driving" into a "guilt complex" of course sometimes contributes to an increase in political activity, but it also stimulates a certain degree of "hysteria of consciousness", somehow I am somehow better with adequate consciousness ....... :)
    2. "Discussing all together" post-Soviet Russian cinema is quite counterproductive. Viewers will still watch new films, and it's not a fact that young people, having given up watching Russian films, will rush to watch Soviet, rather "Western" ones, where "Western" values ​​are mainly promoted, respectively (although there are some amusing exceptions, for example I highly recommend watching "The Imaginarium of the Doctor Parnassus ").
    Among the post-Soviet Russian cinema there are also good films, IMPHO - "Flowers from the Winners", "Trio", a series about Makhno, a remake of "Zvezda", etc. Moreover, in terms of the reliability of historical details (weapons, uniforms), they are really "more correct" than Soviet ones, although with the drama and acting they are often sadder .......
    By the way, from the Soviet films about the Second World War, I would also like to note the less well-known "Light of a Distant Star" and "Wild Honey".
    3. Does it make sense to widely discuss libel that has not been rented? After all, "black PR is also PR." I urge everyone not to watch this "film" even out of curiosity, or "for criticism." As a last resort, from third-party resources, so as not to make a rating on YouTube for this ugly director. But his photo in the article is correct .... :) I would still live in St. Petersburg, - I would try to find, and then let him sue, - "light bodily" now seems to be in general the Code of Administrative Offenses ..... :)
  42. +3
    11 January 2019 11: 46
    The film is an exact copy of how officials in today's Russia eat, chicken in besieged Leningrad, in today's Russia - a beggarly pension, pasta, advice "to eat less", dead wood and all this against the backdrop of the palaces of generals, planes, yachts and storage for fur coats. " businessmen "and officials ... Of course, officials are" painful "to watch such a film.
    1. +4
      11 January 2019 12: 18
      Tomich3. In besieged Leningrad, it was not officials who lived, but speculative snouts that profit from the people's grief. But these, unlike the current moment, were identified and, having revealed, were shot. Therefore, to compare the besieged Leningrad with the current state of affairs is blasphemy. apparently you thoroughly brainwashed Krasovsky.
  43. +3
    11 January 2019 11: 50
    I read the article. Great written. So it is necessary to give lovers a lot to eat and defecate in the face. I wanted to add blockade facts from my family's stories. Yes, he changed his mind. Everything is so clear. Better than the author will not say. The main lesson to our authorities. All our nineties authorities practiced contempt for our party. This led to mockery of honest communists, of whom there were an absolute majority, including Putin's father. .
  44. +3
    11 January 2019 11: 51
    Yes, put for such nonsense the director for 25 years .....! am
    1. +3
      11 January 2019 17: 37
      Take this Kant and Solovki.
  45. +3
    11 January 2019 11: 55
    I stopped watching domestic cinema for a long time) I read our classics, now I re-read Tolstoy.
  46. +2
    11 January 2019 12: 05
    The cinema is bad, absolutely useless cinema. Starting from the acting, ending with "directing". So, if it was an order of revanchists from Germany or someone else, then at the NATO intelligence school in Garmisch-Partenkirchen, apparently, for this opus they put a fat "unsatisfactory".
    However, it is incorrect to say that a stone was thrown into the history of our people, into power into veterans and patriots. A stone was specifically thrown at our so-called "intelligentsia" or "middle class" (whatever you like), whose behavior, if such events happened now, in some moments may correspond to the concept of the film. We all remember the speeches of some of our citizens in the Bundestag, we all remember "public opinion polls" on the radio, "clownery" on the bones on TV, pseudo-historical novels, and written under a pseudonym by someone unknown, etc. But these citizens express not only their opinion, but also the opinion of certain-minded strata of society. Often, others listen to them. How many soldiers did General Vlasov have in his so-called ROA? 120-130 thousand (as of April 1945). And the policemen, traitors, informers? And those who in the rear profited from human grief and hunger? In this regard, the cinema simply shouts that, in fact, these days this number, unfortunately, may not decrease during the so-called "special period". Another thing is that looking through the open door at the filthy restroom is really disgusting!
  47. +2
    11 January 2019 12: 11
    Thank you for the article! I completely agree with the last paragraph. Only now there is no leader to lead the action ...
    1. +3
      11 January 2019 12: 33
      no leader
      Sukhov may be found, but he needs Vereshchagin, who does not take a bribe, because he is offended by the State.
      1. +3
        11 January 2019 14: 34
        It would be good if we all were sorry for the state ..
  48. +2
    11 January 2019 12: 34
    Strongly written, even wanted to see. You just need to add something else about filmmaking, which, as a rule, is forgotten: in Russia, cinema, as well as throughout the world, is now producer.
    It is the producer who chooses the script, gets the money, and chooses the director, who is obliged to shoot in a given way, so Krasovsky or non-Krasovsky decided which script to put into production, this is not the last question.
    One more thing: the producer chooses the scenario, guided either by ideology (then this is ideological processing or ideological sabotage), or the mood of the viewer, as the producer sees him on the basis of research. Sometimes both at once. Hence the assumption that the producer and Krasovsky believe that the viewer is ready to accept the story just like that. It may well be if you look at the reaction to the disgusting scene about the spirit of General Karbyshev. Then this film is a mirror showing the mass Russian audience of our time.
  49. +2
    11 January 2019 12: 34
    Quote: BAI
    As you know - the younger the blogger, the worse he lived under Stalin.

    100% true!
  50. +1
    11 January 2019 12: 46
    Are we spitting? And this "holiday" will also pick up "prizes", as in due time "bastards" ... And it is not a fact that this time Menshov will be invited to present the "prize" so that he once again threw the envelope on the floor. So wait for the next "triumphal procession" of this abomination for prizes from "our film academy".
  51. +2
    11 January 2019 12: 51
    Quote: Cheslav Czursky
    A broad patriotic movement developed

    Wake up. Late Middle Ages. What kind of patriotism are you talking about when there are vassals, there are overlords and a lot of interests of certain circles. Yes, we were on the verge of death. Yes, history turned out exactly like that.

    Quote: Cheslav Czursky
    Holy King Passion-Bearer
    Thanks to the fascist collaborators of the Western Orthodox Church. They were the first to canonize. Should I quote you what the Orthodox patriarchs wrote about the Passion-Bearer when he renounced?

    “The old system was abandoned, a new life began to bubble and bubble in our fatherland. Everyone and everyone began to work to create new living conditions; in this, we, church people, should not lag behind.

    God help you, gentlemen! There are many creative forces among the sons of the Orthodox Church; they only need to unite in order to do a common task to organize church and national life.

    I will tell you in the words of the great teacher St. Apostle Paul: “Let there be no strife among you” [2 Cor. 12, 20]. Let us leave the old abacus for this time.

    The old has passed and will not return. Let’s work together, amicably, and for such work I invoke God’s blessing.”

    From the speech of Archbishop Tikhon (Vasilevsky) of Kursk and Oboyan before the opening of the Kursk diocesan congress
    Source: http://yakov.works/acts/20/1917_19/babkin_03.htm

    so who to believe?

    Quote: Cheslav Czursky
    and thousands of simple and not so Russian Orthodox people!


    Do you know what a simple man is for a medieval warrior? Lubricant for sword and spear.
    And by the way, the Tatars were there too. Not all of them, but there were some.
    1. 0
      11 January 2019 13: 15
      Quote: RuslanD36
      From the speech of Archbishop of Kursk and Oboyansky Tikhon (Vasilevsky)

      A renovationist, he never returned to the fold of the Orthodox Church (he refused to repent), a kind of secular bishop.
      To which he gave up, listen to him some more.
      1. +2
        11 January 2019 14: 53
        Open the link. There are a lot of sayings there
  52. -1
    11 January 2019 12: 52
    This is what always happens after a defeat, the winners write history and create a corresponding mindset. The winners are humane, generous, endowed with a conscience (the children themselves had nothing to eat, the German old men and women were fed and warmed), something that the evil spirits of the trade are deprived of by definition. The generation of Soviets will leave power, “pasta” will come, Victory and sacrifices will be forgotten. We are integrating into Western genderless values, erasing national identity.
  53. +5
    11 January 2019 13: 00
    Krasovsky decided not to try to get a distribution certificate and posted the film in the public domain on YouTube.

    "Don't watch YouTube before lunch!"
    Actually, what did you expect to find in this cesspool?
    And this is called modern Russian culture...

    Eh, no, no... There is a culture in Russia, there is even a modern one, and this is by no means Krasovsky.
  54. +2
    11 January 2019 13: 20
    Quote: Serg65
    Quote: Lycan
    not manly

    laughing Oh come on! First, write bad as a bad boy, and then remember about manhood! Kindergarten laughing

    And the main male advice is to tell the moderator! laughing
    1. +1
      11 January 2019 13: 35
      Quote: Tank Hard
      And the main male advice is to tell the moderator!

      The most interesting thing that followed this...
      Quote: Lycan
      Would you really be willing to work as an informant on high-profile cases?

      good Complete split consciousness!
  55. +3
    11 January 2019 13: 47
    It’s interesting to imagine what Leningraders would have done with the author of the film and the film crew if they had shown this film in Leningrad in 1970?
    1. +4
      11 January 2019 17: 11
      I don’t know how it was in the 70s, but in the 90s. They could have "overwhelmed" the entire gop company.
      From personal experience.
      In the summer of 98 I was at a “bride show” in an apartment on Petrogradka. The owners are an elderly couple and their son, an acquaintance of mine, with a “purely concrete” appearance. There is a conversation about what needs to be done and how, demolish, build, this and that, fifth and tenth... We go into the kitchen, and there is a stove! Brick! Three squares in area and a meter high! In cracked tiles. Well, I say, this thing probably needs to be demolished. The old people looked at me as if I had offered to bury them alive! Later, their son, the actual customer, whispered to me in the hallway, through clenched teeth: “I understand everything, but don’t say that in front of your parents again. This is the memory of the Blockade!” That's how it sounded, with a capital letter.
  56. 0
    11 January 2019 13: 55
    In general, it's time to do something. And the same way they started doing it in Donbass. In 2014.

    Thank you, Roman! I brought up a topic such that we’ll argue for a week! I want to tell you that hatred is a strong feeling, you shouldn’t direct it at people like Krasovsky, he doesn’t deserve it, especially from normal people! Yes, such things didn’t happen in/in Ukraine, they worked on monuments there, rewrote history textbooks, mostly worked quietly, but in Russia everything always happens somehow too much! Both in the 90s and now, although the current burp is precisely from the grub that everyone was treated to in those years, and the crap you wrote about, too! I have no desire to look at this work, but I think that with your “review” you have encouraged many to do so, although I’m not sure that they will watch it all to the end, but the author of this libel has achieved his goal - they are talking about him! Take care of yourself and your mental strength, or else there will be more, colleague, in attempts to divide the people and sow confusion with the aim of further collapse of the once truly Great Russia! hi
  57. +2
    11 January 2019 15: 25
    Evil.... Yes, evil is written, but the theme is such that without anger you cannot even talk about the “creations” or “creations” of the current “engineers of human souls”. But the notorious “masters of culture”, who are unclear with whom, are really “engineers of human souls” and what will such, God forgive me, “engineer” do in the souls of young people? But this did not start yesterday, not with the showing of “films”, it began several years ago, when some smart guy began to mathematically prove what and how much could be produced in besieged Leningrad, how much energy was required for the machines, etc. etc. and all this with links to archives. So I sometimes think, maybe the Soviet government did the right thing when it didn’t let those who were especially idle go anywhere without getting into it, and for slander and denigration of the system they assigned them to the “yellow house,” huh? After all, life was calmer, they said that this was a hero, and that a traitor, and everyone agreed with everything, everyone clapped their hands and approved. The author mentioned Solzhenitsyn in the article, and our strategic partner, Comrade Xi Jinping, signed a decree declaring Solzhenitsyn’s books harmful, Solzhenitsker himself a traitor, and everyone who reads him will be sent to prison, literally. like in the USSR in the 70s. Great? Probably, what’s at stake is China’s younger generation and the question of where it will go. Directly according to Vysotsky: “And where, in what distances, on what other route will these lies take us along the stage?” Only one thing is not clear: the bulk of the country’s leadership comes from Leningrad, many of their parents know firsthand what a blockade is, and if they (the leadership) don’t give a damn about such an attitude towards the memory of their own parents, then well..... “Sowing the Wind” , will reap the storm." Or, like in China, do you end up in prison? For prevention. What will our Western “partners” say to this?
  58. +4
    11 January 2019 16: 26
    Otherwise, honestly, in five years we will simply turn into a herd, powerless and wanting nothing.

    but I remember 1985-89!
    and in these years the population of the USSR was just a herd, unable to do anything and wanting nothing...
    and everyone wanted chewing gum/jeans/Marlboro and were ready to sell everything in the world for it!!!!
    I remember all this...
    we definitely deserved what we got in the 90s......
  59. +2
    11 January 2019 17: 09
    "We will erect a monument to Vlasov, ten to Solzhenitsyn, Shkuro, Krasnov and everyone whom we awarded with a rope, everything! And also SS-fighters for freedom from Stalin, White Czechs (hell, they tried already), Finns, Romanians, Hungarians."

    Yes Easy...
    Mr.. hmm.. there are more than enough “true patriots of Russia” at the top today.
    At least eat it with a spoon!

    Remember that at the opening all Mannerheimo-Solzhenitsyn boards always there is someone close to "you know who"...

    Is not it, lord Putin?
    1. 0
      11 January 2019 18: 05
      Isn't it true, Mr. Putin? Shh. Don't lose the office. This task
  60. +2
    11 January 2019 18: 03
    This work was filmed on the principle: I am an ARTIST. As I see, so I create. But seriously, what prevents parliament from passing a law that regulates what can and cannot be shown (a terrible word for ARTISTS) in historical films. So that there would not be such a G in the form: citadel, predstvovanie, saboteur, smersh, penal battalion, Kolovrat, 1612. In Soviet films there was always a consultant present. In the film "Gentlemen of Fortune" consultant police commissioner 1st rank (i.e. general)
  61. 0
    11 January 2019 18: 11
    Based on film crafts. I haven't watched it and won't.
    According to the article. +
    About
    Shouting on the Internet about the fact that we will force everyone and break through somewhere.

    Excuse me, VO’s calling card until 2018.
  62. 0
    11 January 2019 18: 57
    excellent article neither take nor add
  63. +3
    11 January 2019 19: 04
    A lot of nasty things have happened here in Russia. General Karbyshev, eternal Memory and Glory to him, responded to the former General Vlasov on his offer to enter the service of the Germans: “My convictions did not fall out along with my teeth due to the lack of vitamins in the camp diet.” This Real Man was frozen alive in Mauthausen. Ask on the street who General Karbyshev is, to our shame, young people don’t know this, so who will be responsible for this unconsciousness.
  64. +3
    11 January 2019 19: 11
    All this cesspool beau monde, the poorest, most uneducated, most immoral layer of our society, all the dirt and foam are collected in this cesspool called pop music, television and cinema, pop art, turning into an inherited immoral class with a claim to the ultimate truth, stupefied by dough and corrupted by complete irresponsibility and impunity, encouraged by the state machine at our own expense. TV is a separate song, rather Yaroslavna’s cry or an animal howl. ki finished without a bright spot after the deaths of a glorious and beloved generation of creative and talented people, and if there is anyone, they are not visible in this dirt, the system that produces stench and mold will not allow them to bloom and shine.
  65. 0
    11 January 2019 19: 16
    Worms Parasitic worms and amoebaes applauding them and ciliates-slippers. Mokritsy, as our neighbor Tarakan would say.
    - worms - flukes.
  66. The comment was deleted.
  67. +4
    11 January 2019 22: 27
    In general, I don’t understand very well why such a coven of abomination occurs in our country and the abomination does not bear any responsibility for this coven? Of course, I understand that in our country we have democracy and freedom of speech and so on, so on, so forth. But not to the point of Homeric cynicism. On the one hand, we seem to care about the remaining veterans, but on the other hand, we allow stupid and narrow-minded idiots to mock our memory, our fallen and dead, and the few remaining heroes who defended our country and us from the Nazi invasion. If we became Ivans - not remembering kinship, then obviously not everyone. Look at the Immortal Regiment. Here's your answer. This means that all this abomination of stupid girls from the comedy club and TNT, mediocre and stupid directors and other obscene public should bear CRIMINAL RESPONSIBILITY for the betrayal of their Motherland, for the BETRAYAL TO THE HEROIC MEMORY OF OUR PEOPLE. These subhumans are much worse than dysentery and typhoid. These miasmas of humanity do not hide at all; they have the audacity to humiliate and trample on the dignity of normal people. The question arises. How much longer will we endure all this scum? Isn't it time to sweep all the dirt into the "slop bucket" and pour it into the cesspool with sewage. There's a place for all this trash.
  68. +2
    12 January 2019 08: 22
    No matter how hard you try not to get dirty, without hygiene the mandavos will multiply and devour. The same principle applies here. Already multiplied...
  69. +2
    12 January 2019 09: 13
    I only regret one thing, that I don’t live where these media figures exist! But I can’t even reach them! True, I gave one visiting liberal a slap in the face after his fiery speech. But somehow it didn’t make it into the media space...
  70. +1
    12 January 2019 12: 34
    Quote: tank64rus
    Ask on the street who General Karbyshev is, to our shame, young people don’t know this, so who will be responsible for this unconsciousness.


    Fortunately, not all young people are like this. Those parents who remember the history of their country themselves have children who grow up to be Humans. And there were enough stupid cattle, “not remembering kinship,” even in Soviet times. So their children grew up accordingly, and grandchildren... request
  71. The comment was deleted.
  72. +1
    12 January 2019 16: 36
    Without artistic advice, all our directors show only how out of touch they are with reality and do not understand what really worries people in the country.
    Sometimes something works out, but judging by the periodicity of it, as well as by the way the sequels come out later. Just a stupid finger in the sky.

    The environment determines consciousness, and if you have never worked anywhere other than the theater in your life, then what kind of environment will it be? So you get this kitsch that’s not interesting to anyone
    1. The comment was deleted.
    2. -4
      12 January 2019 17: 03
      In my opinion, the film was shot very realistically. Timofey Tribuntsev is a very talented actor. If interested, watch his performance in the film: The Monk and the Demon.
      1. The comment was deleted.
  73. +1
    12 January 2019 18: 31
    In general, it's time to do something. And the way they started doing it in the Donbas. In 2014. Otherwise, honestly, in five years we will simply turn into a herd, nothing that can and will not. Shouting on the Internet on the subject of the fact that we are all going up and somewhere to break through. All recall, all ...
  74. -1
    12 January 2019 21: 22
    An excellent film about officials, about their moral decline, which is why members of United Russia opposed showing the film.
    Krasovsky himself stated that “this movie tells more about our day than about the past,” about how “officials and other people” are still fattening on people’s misfortunes.
    By the way, the film was partially financed by Zudina, Tabakov’s widow....
    1. 0
      13 January 2019 23: 01
      "a film about officials" Sorry, but you didn't watch the film carefully. There is no mention of officials there. The microbiologist created bacteriological weapons. Yes, of course, he was fed according to distribution. So what am I talking about? About how you can create something with your head full of thoughts, about a hungry, dying family. Yes, of course, it was needed and had to work. And here, I completely agree with you “this movie tells more about our day than about the past.”
  75. +1
    13 January 2019 12: 04
    Looked this up. The fact that the director has nothing sacred is a fact. But I had a slightly different opinion about the actors.
    And, by the way, it’s strange why the film didn’t come out as planned on December 31st, could the tragedy in Magnitogorsk somehow influence these...
    1. The comment was deleted.
      1. The comment was deleted.
  76. 0
    15 January 2019 11: 37
    Hats off to the author for this article. This is the rare case when I agree 100% with Roman Skomorokhov. hi
  77. +1
    15 January 2019 15: 43
    Loot defeats Good. - The modern ideology imposed on Russian society is a gift from the ruling class of privatizers, “creative managers” and other “strong business executives” of the Chernomyrdin type. Putin made it very clear at the press conference: “There will be no return to socialism,” and here you are surprised at the movie.

"Right Sector" (banned in Russia), "Ukrainian Insurgent Army" (UPA) (banned in Russia), ISIS (banned in Russia), "Jabhat Fatah al-Sham" formerly "Jabhat al-Nusra" (banned in Russia) , Taliban (banned in Russia), Al-Qaeda (banned in Russia), Anti-Corruption Foundation (banned in Russia), Navalny Headquarters (banned in Russia), Facebook (banned in Russia), Instagram (banned in Russia), Meta (banned in Russia), Misanthropic Division (banned in Russia), Azov (banned in Russia), Muslim Brotherhood (banned in Russia), Aum Shinrikyo (banned in Russia), AUE (banned in Russia), UNA-UNSO (banned in Russia), Mejlis of the Crimean Tatar people (banned in Russia), Legion “Freedom of Russia” (armed formation, recognized as terrorist in the Russian Federation and banned), Kirill Budanov (included to the Rosfinmonitoring list of terrorists and extremists)

“Non-profit organizations, unregistered public associations or individuals performing the functions of a foreign agent,” as well as media outlets performing the functions of a foreign agent: “Medusa”; "Voice of America"; "Realities"; "Present time"; "Radio Freedom"; Ponomarev Lev; Ponomarev Ilya; Savitskaya; Markelov; Kamalyagin; Apakhonchich; Makarevich; Dud; Gordon; Zhdanov; Medvedev; Fedorov; Mikhail Kasyanov; "Owl"; "Alliance of Doctors"; "RKK" "Levada Center"; "Memorial"; "Voice"; "Person and law"; "Rain"; "Mediazone"; "Deutsche Welle"; QMS "Caucasian Knot"; "Insider"; "New Newspaper"