Military Review

FAS deals with pricing issues of food supply to Rosgvardia

150
Today, many information resources with reference to RBC publish information that the Federal Security Service is interested in the issue of food supplies for the needs of Rosgvardia. Recall that the scandal with inflated prices of these supplies manifested itself after the video of oppositionist Alexei Navalny, who spoke about the situation in his usual sharp manner. As you know, after that, a video of the head of Rosgvardia, General Viktor Zolotov, appeared in the Network, who “summoned a duel” to the offender, promising to turn him into a “cutlet”. After that, there was a response from Navalny, who was released after serving in the SIZO, and as a result, media activity began to subside.


Today, media activity has manifested itself in another direction. It is reported about the initiation of the FAS case related to the "presence of signs of violations" on the fact of procurement for the Rosguards. We are talking about identifying "possible violations" in the supply of food to the Rosgvardiyu by the Druzhba Narodov meat processing plant. At the moment, this meat-packing plant is the only enterprise from which Rosgvardia buys food for the military. The check began the main military prosecutor's office.

A letter with the initiative to clarify the issue was sent by the FSB officers to the Federal Antimonopoly Service.
So, in fact, everything that Navalny told in his video is repeated. In particular, we are talking about "corruption-intensive" actions, which led to an overvaluation of prices for goods.

FAS deals with pricing issues of food supply to Rosgvardia


If you believe the publication, the "Friendship of Peoples" acted not only the specific manufacturer and seller of their own products, but often also an intermediary. So, buying products in the form of wieners from the Meleuz meat factory at 270 rubles per kilogram, the plant supplied the same Rosguards sausages at the price of about 350 rubles. As a result, the contract amount “was unreasonably overstated” by almost 3,5 million rubles.

The Federal Antimonopoly Service has refused to comment on the letter from the FSB for the time being.

Navalny himself did not comment on the appearance of information about the initiation of proceedings in the media at the moment.
Photos used:
Facebook
150 comments
Ad

Subscribe to our Telegram channel, regularly additional information about the special operation in Ukraine, a large amount of information, videos, something that does not fall on the site: https://t.me/topwar_official

Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. GKS 2111
    GKS 2111 10 December 2018 14: 02
    +34
    Zolotov-well done! Glory to the cardinal’s guards! More positive in social networks! Do not rock the boat! Do you want to like in Ukraine?
    1. Roman070280
      Roman070280 10 December 2018 14: 18
      +32
      Or like in France ..))
      Yesterday I watched Kisel's report .. "The French, accustomed to going on vacation three times a year ...."
      And I thought to myself .. well, even if it became hard .. and I had to unexpectedly rest only twice in a year .. We won’t and once, far from everybody has a rest !! My parents, pensioners, haven’t crawled out of the dacha for 20 years already .. Yes, and there are plenty of young people who have been to the sea (our) once or twice in their life .. And nothing .. in the spring of 20% everyone swallowed gasoline and did not even squeak ..
      Khmm .. it’s still the French who didn’t raise their retirement age by 5 years at once .. otherwise I would have looked ..))
      1. Svarog
        Svarog 10 December 2018 14: 32
        +50
        Quote: Roman070280
        Khmm .. it’s still the French who didn’t raise their retirement age by 5 years at once .. otherwise I would have looked ..))

        In France, if there was a report like Navalny about Zolotov or Medvedev, 100% would have been an investigation and these individuals would have forgotten about their careers forever .. and maybe about freedom .. There is nothing to compare with us here, the laws do not work for us , more precisely, they only work when the authorities are profitable .. And if in France they lifted the retirement age by 5 years, they would have thrown off the government ...
        1. Stas157
          Stas157 10 December 2018 14: 48
          +33
          We are talking about identifying "possible violations" in the supply of food products to the Rosguard meat processing plant "Friendship of Peoples." At the moment, this particular meat factory is the only enterprise, which Rosgvardia buys food for the military.

          How was this the only meat processing plant from the village of Petrovka able to feed an army of 400 thousand people? What kind of miracle plants are such in the Crimea? And what is its competitive advantage ?? In price, in quality, in logistics ... what? It can only be that it really belongs to the people of Zolotov!
          1. ltc35
            ltc35 10 December 2018 15: 13
            -7
            So this meat factory could not fulfill the volume. I had to buy the missing from allies. It's quite normal. Our public procurement system is built in such a way that everyone has to somehow get out.
          2. Elephant
            Elephant 10 December 2018 15: 23
            +7
            I also don't understand where the sausages have gone? Who ate them? All my acquaintances, the National Guardsmen, did not even smell sausages! Maybe the sausages went to the markets or were they "put" in the WG only on paper? Well, in order to avoid any insinuations, an official statement from the Prosecutor's Office is required! soldier
            1. GibSoN
              GibSoN 10 December 2018 18: 30
              +3
              Well, in order to avoid any insinuations, an official statement from the Prosecutor's Office is required!
              Guess what the statement of the prosecutor’s office will be, even in the most favorable situation for the population? The maximum, they will find the extreme .. Like Vasya Pupkin deceived everyone .. No one could have thought .. But how could it be ...
            2. Welcome to hell
              Welcome to hell 11 December 2018 02: 07
              0
              were, reached us hi
            3. Baloo
              Baloo 11 December 2018 08: 44
              0
              Quote: Elephant

              I don’t understand where the sausages went. Who ate them? All my acquaintances of the National Guard were not even sniffing sausages!

              Fighters are fed sausages ??? belay belay belay for this alone it’s unfortunate to flog all those involved. Tigers need to be fed meat, not sausages. yes It is cheaper and better. yes . In the place of the Shtirlits, I would first of all take an interest in precisely this - who is that ingenious nutritionist-enemy of the people angry who thought of exactly this way to lower the defense capability of the Russian Guard. yes
              1. Lexa-149
                Lexa-149 11 December 2018 14: 23
                +1
                Yes, not only the WG feed them. And they are delivered to the troops.
        2. just exp
          just exp 10 December 2018 14: 51
          -12
          Yes ? and what government was thrown off there when they made a retirement age of 62,5 years for both men and women?
        3. SOF
          SOF 10 December 2018 14: 54
          -6
          Quote: Svarog
          And if in France for 5 years the retirement age was raised

          ... enlighten .... and what is the term of retirement in France ..... just do not send to Google .... okay? ...
          hi
          1. Svarog
            Svarog 10 December 2018 15: 36
            +11
            Quote: SOF
            Quote: Svarog
            And if in France for 5 years the retirement age was raised

            ... enlighten .... and what is the term of retirement in France ..... just do not send to Google .... okay? ...
            hi

            You still ask how much life expectancy in France, unemployment benefits, and actually the pension itself .. Well, if you compare everything like that .. right? After all, our pensioners occupied France .. as soon as they retire, they immediately begin to travel ..
            1. just exp
              just exp 11 December 2018 07: 43
              -1
              But, as far as France was concerned, so is the retirement age now no longer important, and now life span is important?
        4. GibSoN
          GibSoN 10 December 2018 18: 27
          +6
          And if in France they raised their retirement age by 5 years, then they would have thrown off the government ...
          Well, if objectively, most likely they would not have been thrown off .. Of course, there would be a lot of noise, this is indisputable. But I think they would have found some kind of compromise. The thing is that in France, in fact, the population is not so strongly "pressed" as in the Russian Federation. That is, there is still much to justify tightening the belts. But in Russia, when you work 10-11 hours 5 days a week, and even 2-3 Saturdays a month .. At the same time, there is not always enough money even for food and minimal needs (what a vacation! You can go to the sea only if in general to save on everything, or, there is still some kind of "hack" in addition to work)! At the same time, the Russian Federation is the leader in the stability of price increases for everything, regularly! There is certainly no time to compare with France. But apparently it rolls. I don’t even know .. Tolley people are like that, we really live in the Camp ...
        5. Konstantin Shevchenko
          Konstantin Shevchenko 11 December 2018 16: 13
          0
          Therefore, raised by 2,5 years. laughing 62,5 in men and women. am
      2. LeonidL
        LeonidL 10 December 2018 18: 51
        +1
        France is not Russia, the French are not Russians! ... They greedy there, corrupted by the capitalist way of life, didn’t sniff socialism, they became fat ... because of the extra three cents they gathered gas to suck up ... No way to the vineyards on Saturdays with choppers and buckets!
      3. Igoresha
        Igoresha 10 December 2018 22: 54
        0
        The French, accustomed to travel three times a year to relax on vacation
        ooo remember this citizen "Ukrainians have nothing to do on the Maidan, they already live well")))
    2. Svarog
      Svarog 10 December 2018 14: 20
      +30
      The results of this test will be interesting .. although the fact that you are interested is already good. Personally, I have no doubt that officer Zolotov has no honor and he is a thief.
      1. Greenwood
        Greenwood 10 December 2018 14: 23
        +31
        Quote: Svarog
        Officer Zolotov has no honor and he is a thief
        He’s Putin’s six and built his whole career on that alone.
      2. Henderson
        Henderson 10 December 2018 14: 47
        +15
        The results will be normal. Zolotov will go up.
        1. New Year day
          New Year day 10 December 2018 14: 49
          +8
          Quote: Henderson
          Zolotov will go up.

          Above is just the president! Zolotova for the presidency?
          1. Svarog
            Svarog 10 December 2018 14: 54
            +10
            Quote: Silvestr
            Quote: Henderson
            Zolotov will go up.

            Above is just the president! Zolotova for the presidency?

            Maybe Putin is preparing a receiver .. on New Year’s Day he will say .. I'm tired .. I’m leaving .. here in my place I offer the person with honor .. duelist, but restrained .. children abroad .. like me .. but a patriot. in general, will lead the country to a new stage of development .. We have a country of opportunities ..
            1. New Year day
              New Year day 10 December 2018 14: 56
              +10
              I won’t be surprised either! The main thing is devoted.
              Again trump to a duel can cause
            2. Henderson
              Henderson 10 December 2018 15: 06
              +1
              Not a successor, but a doll. To create the illusion of a change of leader, to go into the shade yourself and sit there pulling strings to death.
              1. DEDPIHTO
                DEDPIHTO 10 December 2018 16: 46
                +4
                Quote: Henderson
                Not a successor, but a doll. To create the illusion of a change of leader, to go into the shade yourself and sit there pulling strings to death.

                This is the most likely scenario, because the semblance of the Supreme Council has already been restored and even the first meeting was held.
                In the confusion with Zolotov, no one noticed another character - the well-known anti-corruption fighter and a regular show show at the center. TV channels of citizen Hinstein. From the wiki
                Alexander Evseevich Khinshtein (born October 26, 1974, Moscow, RSFSR, USSR) is a Russian journalist and politician. Advisor to the Director of the Federal Service of the National Guard Troops of the Russian Federation from October 24, 2016 to September 9, 2018.

                Member of the State Duma of the Federal Assembly of the Russian Federation IV-VI, VII convocations.

                On September 9, 2018, he was elected as a deputy of the State Duma of the Russian Federation of the VII convocation from the 158th constituency of the Samara region, a member of the faction of the party "United Russia" (2003—2016, since 2018) [1] [2]
                Let me remind you that Navalny’s revelatory material on the “cabbage case” came out in August 2018. Such numbers are interesting in the biography of a person who has never had any relation to the Samara region. winked About parliamentary immunity probably all in the know. hi
                1. SOF
                  SOF 10 December 2018 17: 25
                  -11
                  .... AU !!!!!!!!. MODERATOR! ...
                  .... but isn't it time to stop the bacchanalia .....
                  ...... "VRunishka" was removed ..... but with outright incitement to overthrow the existing system, that is, with the corpus delicti, due to the corresponding article of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation, we are not going to fight ...... no ....?
                  ...... sadness .....
                  1. DEDPIHTO
                    DEDPIHTO 10 December 2018 17: 42
                    +4
                    Judging by your posts, you are clearly not, in yourself, today. Come to VO in normal form.
                    1. SOF
                      SOF 10 December 2018 18: 14
                      -8
                      Quote: DEPHIHTO
                      Come to VO in normal form.

                      .... are you a moderator? .....
                      .... then ==> nach Hause ......
                      1. DEDPIHTO
                        DEDPIHTO 10 December 2018 18: 22
                        +5
                        No, not a moderator. You can justify yourself if you indicate where specifically the incitement to overthrow in my post, then I apologize for my suspicions about you.
                      2. SOF
                        SOF 10 December 2018 19: 03
                        -7
                        Quote: DEPHIHTO
                        No, not a moderator. You can justify yourself if you indicate where specifically the incitement to overthrow in my post, then I apologize for my suspicions about you.

                        .... I am not a judge ... as well as YOU ALL regarding Zolotov and the entire current government in the Russian Federation, at the moment .....
                        ... such issues should be dealt with by the relevant authorities .... and if the moderator is present on this top, and he is present, due to the fact that he deleted my message, exposing the falsity of the statements of one of the "fighters" (who, before the elections, vehemently for the communists, with Grudinny, and after these, he began to sing praises to Navalny), he was obliged, at least to stop the madhouse in this top, and as a maximum, to pay the attention of those very bodies ...
                        .... reasonably affordable ....?
                      3. DEDPIHTO
                        DEDPIHTO 10 December 2018 19: 24
                        +2
                        laughing If you remember (we had a conversation before the March elections), then I also drowned for Grudinin and also expressed my attitude towards Navalny-, I have to admit that now Navalny is an ally of the Communists (revelatory articles) but to the first intersection.. you can’t let him into power ,, (c) Enjoy! laughing
                        And the rest is clear to you.
                      4. SOF
                        SOF 10 December 2018 19: 37
                        -4
                        Quote: DEPHIHTO
                        but to the first intersection ..

                        ... of course, of course .... the enemy of my enemy is my friend ...... we know, we know, passed .... let him be a dog son, but he is beneficial to us ....
                        .... bring the country to the blood, and then .... then whoever used to shoot someone in the back of the head ........
                        .... everything is clear with you too .....
                        ..... it is not clear with the local authorities ....
                      5. LeonidL
                        LeonidL 12 December 2018 04: 00
                        0
                        Alas, a lot of insane ... You just do not understand.
                      6. LeonidL
                        LeonidL 12 December 2018 04: 00
                        -1
                        You are a conformist, however! With Provalny to the crossroads, and there ... some Kamenev, Zinoviev, when they drowned Trotsky with Koba, Bukharchik was a smart boy, when Kamenva, Zinoviev and Trotsky were drowned with Koba to the crossroads ... such as before the crossroads ... Now with the completely finished Grudinin and Provalny? Come Failed to power, he will dance on "fellow travelers" like Batu on the prince's bones!
            3. The comment was deleted.
      3. Doliva63
        Doliva63 10 December 2018 18: 26
        +1
        Quote: Svarog
        The results of this test will be interesting .. although the fact that you are interested is already good. Personally, I have no doubt that officer Zolotov has no honor and he is a thief.

        Zolotov is not an officer, but an officer of the National Guard.
        1. gunnerminer
          gunnerminer 10 December 2018 20: 19
          +2
          Let him eat sausages at 500 rubles per kilo. If there were no rallies.
      4. LeonidL
        LeonidL 10 December 2018 18: 52
        -7
        An officer can only be blamed for a court of officer honor, the rest is an unproven blunder in the spirit of Failure. If there are facts - bring to court.
        1. LeonidL
          LeonidL 12 December 2018 04: 05
          +1
          It is interesting how people are contorted at the mere mention of the normal procedure for bringing officer honor to court, about the need to present evidence, and about protecting the honor. This can be explained only by pettiness of character - envy of success, hatred of the corporal of the reserve for general lompas, frustrated ambitions ... I am ashamed, very ashamed for you, gentlemen-comrades! Dishonestly kind of behavior! However ... correspondence in absentia is safe for the judge, especially under a nickname ... well, like a maidan under a balaclava! It seems like he amused the little soul and didn’t get it in the ass.
    3. 210ox
      210ox 10 December 2018 14: 22
      +1
      You, the SCS forgot to insert a smiley face. And then the meaning of what you have stated is lost .. request
      1. kjhg
        kjhg 10 December 2018 15: 04
        +4
        Quote: 210ox
        You, the SCS forgot to insert a smiley face. And then the meaning of what you have stated is lost .. request

        Such "thick" sarcasm is difficult not to distinguish.
    4. dauria
      dauria 10 December 2018 14: 26
      -3
      Zolotov, well done!

      This is Lyokha Navalny. Now we have a kind of monetary reward for snitching. Let him demand from the treasury, he deserves it honestly.
      1. Svarog
        Svarog 10 December 2018 14: 33
        +18
        Quote: dauria
        Zolotov, well done!

        This is Lyokha Navalny. Now we have a kind of monetary reward for snitching. Let him demand from the treasury, he deserves it honestly.

        Squealing is not the right word .. he conducted an investigation and put it in the public domain ..
        1. dauria
          dauria 10 December 2018 15: 01
          -4
          Squealing is not the right word here


          Well, for "denunciation". Both are in quotes. It seems that it is necessary to discard the motives, Navalny's past, evaluate only the act and say - "I did the right thing, I did it with courage." Yes, the language does not turn. The first question - "investigation" is not a cheap thing, and not for individuals. Where does the money come from, Zin? No, everything is simpler here. One rascal cannot forgive others that he was "thrown" and not recorded in his own. And it is not holy people who invest money in Lyosha. I doubt even that they are ours, and not because of the hillock.
          1. Svarog
            Svarog 10 December 2018 15: 41
            +8
            Quote: dauria
            Well, for "denunciation".

            Who did he tell? The public?
            Quote: dauria
            The first question - "investigation" is not a cheap thing, and not for individuals. Where does the money come from, Zin?

            This question is better for officials to address .. in which the RFP does not grow together with expenses ..
            Quote: dauria
            Where does the money come from, Zin? No, everything is simpler here. One rascal cannot forgive others that he was "thrown" and not recorded in his own. And it is not holy people who invest money in Lyosha. I doubt even that they are ours, and not because of the hillock.

            Navalny has a fund for which our citizens transfer money to him .. many of them are businessmen ..
            But to me personally, it doesn't matter what money he spends investigating, because he is the ONLY person in Russia who does this ... who else would tell you about Medvedev, Zolotov and other "honest" ones ..
          2. AUL
            AUL 10 December 2018 16: 51
            +3
            Quote: dauria
            It seems that it is necessary to discard the motives, Navalny's past, evaluate only the act and say - "I did the right thing, I did it with courage." Yes, the language does not turn. The first question - "investigation" is not a cheap thing, and not for individuals. Where does the money come from, Zin?

            Are you trying to divert the conversation from the topic? The article is not about Navalny at all! So the translation of the arrows is awkward!
            1. dauria
              dauria 10 December 2018 22: 58
              0
              The article is not about Navalny at all!


              Three times in the article the surname "Navalny" is repeated, once "Zolotov", and of course we are talking about Muravyov the Apostle. Translation of arrows? Both stand each other and the others will not be.
          3. Greenwood
            Greenwood 10 December 2018 17: 00
            +6
            Quote: dauria
            The first question - "investigation" is not a cheap thing, and not for individuals. Where does the money come from, Zin?
            Well, that is no secret. See:
          4. GibSoN
            GibSoN 10 December 2018 18: 55
            +3
            The first question - "investigation" is not a cheap thing, and not for individuals. Where is the money
            Are you really interested in where he has money from? Or is the essence of truth interesting? Yes, at least Trump and Obama personally chipped him! To me, for example, generally on the drum! From where he got the money, the essence will never change! If this is true, you must be punished for it! And who finances this truth, in fact, does not matter what! Because personally, for example, no one forces you to love or vote either for Trump, not for Obama! Think with your own head.
        2. LeonidL
          LeonidL 10 December 2018 18: 56
          -6
          In my opinion, everything that Lyokha Provalny investigates and preaches is directed primarily against Russia and its interests. All over the activity of Provalny is the activity of a sent Cossack. It is from this point of view that it is worth evaluating all the "achievements" and "exposures" of Provalny. Or does anyone have doubts?
        3. LeonidL
          LeonidL 12 December 2018 04: 06
          0
          And you took it and believed it? Failing something?
    5. Cananecat
      Cananecat 10 December 2018 14: 26
      +18
      Quote: GKS 2111
      Zolotov-well done! Glory to the cardinal’s guards! More positive in social networks! Do not rock the boat! Do you want to like in Ukraine?

      They don’t tell her, they chop oars for firewood. (Such as Zolotov)
    6. SOF
      SOF 10 December 2018 14: 56
      -8
      Quote: GKS 2111
      Zolotov, well done!

      ... how dumb-awkward it doesn't look belay , but well done ...... Bulk ???? request .
      1. kjhg
        kjhg 10 December 2018 15: 09
        +9
        And what, no, not well done? It is clear that he is fighting for power, but if such a struggle allows us to identify such large-scale forms of theft of the country's top leaders, then we can only welcome this. I do not propose that everyone vote for Navalny, but his investigations reveal patterns of theft of budget money by representatives of the current regime.
        1. SOF
          SOF 10 December 2018 15: 49
          -3
          Quote: kjhg
          I do not propose that everyone vote for Navalny, but his investigations reveal patterns of theft of budget money by representatives of the current regime.

          ....... yes no - I said something bad about Leshenka .... ??? .... cool kid ..... well, that's Browder's sycophant ....... but this Well, nonsense, when he diligently reveals the schemes and pours butter into the frying pan to the fighters against the regime, like Svarogam ... and you are so passionate, here, swinging with a blower - to the left "plus sign", to the right "minus sign" ... .... and you look ...... wake up tomorrow !!!! ..... and outside the window MAIDAN! .... kaaaaaaya lovely !!! FORWARD to the barricades !!! - against everything bad !!! for all the good!!!! Hurray comrades !!!
          ........... you just forget one thing ...... as in 1917, "sponsors of the revolution", in the 21st century it will not be possible to throw it ...... you will not have time to blink as they will force to teach American MOV ...... "and who will not take - we will turn off the gas" .....
          ..... BUT THIS IS ALL FIGS - the main thing is the FIGHT! .... I wish Lesha was happy, if he climbed into this topic to read wassat wassat wassat
          .... TRUE Dorga go comrades !!!! ....
          1. Greenwood
            Greenwood 10 December 2018 17: 08
            +6
            Quote: SOF
            and outside the window Maidan! .... kaaaakaaya charm !!! GO to the barricades !!! - against all the bad !!! for all the good!!!! Hurray comrades !!!
            How old are you? Only honestly.
            1. SOF
              SOF 10 December 2018 17: 18
              -9
              Quote: Greenwood
              How old are you? Only honestly

              .... indicate the direction to you? ONLY HONEST? ... or will you find yourself ....?
              1. The comment was deleted.
      2. Svarog
        Svarog 10 December 2018 15: 54
        +7
        Quote: SOF
        Quote: GKS 2111
        Zolotov, well done!

        ... how dumb-awkward it doesn't look belay , but well done ...... Bulk ???? request .

        It's amazing yes, how the paradigm is changing .. until recently, Navalny was perceived by a clown and how everything is changing .. Just a couple of initiatives from our government and I won’t be surprised if people drag him into the Kremlin .. Although I wouldn’t want to ..
        1. SOF
          SOF 10 December 2018 16: 42
          -7
          Quote: Svarog
          Until recently, Navalny was perceived by a clown and how everything is changing

          ... as he was a clown, he remained without any paradigms ... the only difference is that in the theater in which he was appointed the prima ballerina of the audience more and more .....
          .... and I don’t presume to discuss the tastes of the audience, but I don’t pretend to bother with the contemplation of the plaque on the facade of the theater - the height of idiocy .... there it is in black and white, in plain English it says "Washington" .....
          ..... to the Kremlin ..... now ..... Rosguard, I hope it is not in vain that expensive sausages eat ....
          1. Henderson
            Henderson 10 December 2018 16: 54
            +8
            It's just that people also want normal sausages. And they slowly become unimportant, Bulk or the devil from the bottom of the sea. If only something has changed.
            1. Stevev
              Stevev 11 December 2018 05: 33
              +1
              Quote: Henderson
              It's just that people also want normal sausages

              It seems to have already passed in 91?
              1. Henderson
                Henderson 11 December 2018 11: 11
                0
                Apparently they didn’t learn the lesson. People still want normal sausages.
          2. Greenwood
            Greenwood 10 December 2018 17: 10
            +7
            Quote: SOF
            Washington
            I see your paranoia develops from the word "Washington". You would be more afraid of the inhabitants of the Kremlin than the Capitol Hill. The former harms Russia much more than the latter.
            1. SOF
              SOF 10 December 2018 17: 16
              -5
              Quote: Greenwood
              I see your paranoia develops from the word "Washington".

              ..... what are you ????? ..... seriously? ... and in Iraq, and in Libya, and in Egypt, and in Turkey, and banderalia ..... everywhere paranoia !! !! ... and surname Browder is not talking about anything ??? ..... or "you're all lying" ???? .....
              .... maybe even at least ONE of the local wrestlers tell me why the navalnych has nothing about Chubais? ..... well, let's ... comrades .... burn! .....
              .... and generally .... you have .... shtatovskih .... here the word - last thing......
              1. LeonidL
                LeonidL 10 December 2018 19: 01
                -4
                It seems that periodically there are a lot of mishandled Cossacks who do not quite understand who they work for and whose mill they pour water on.
                1. SOF
                  SOF 10 December 2018 20: 17
                  -3
                  Quote: LeonidL
                  who do not quite understand who they work for and whose mill they pour water on

                  ... they all understand perfectly - one has already opened up above .....
                  ..... and this is not an impression - it is a fact of work under the state ....
                  ... as they like to say: "but under Stalin they would have been put up against the wall" ....
                  1. Greenwood
                    Greenwood 11 December 2018 03: 59
                    +1
                    Quote: SOF
                    and under Stalin they would have been put to the wall
                    Under Stalin, they would first shoot Yeltsin, his successor Putin and all their organized crime groups from the Lake cooperative for betraying the party and the communist idea, as well as turning the country from a superpower into a slurred corrupt entity with an unclear future.
                    1. LeonidL
                      LeonidL 12 December 2018 04: 07
                      0
                      And if a funnel had followed you at night ... Do you want to repeat the lesson?
                      1. Greenwood
                        Greenwood 13 December 2018 03: 43
                        0
                        Quote: LeonidL
                        And if the funnel rode after you at night
                        I didn’t come for my great-grandfather. Amazingly true? And in general, funnels just like that and people rode, they had no other activities. Soon Solzhenitsin will begin to quote.
                      2. LeonidL
                        LeonidL 13 December 2018 21: 21
                        0
                        You are not original, you didn’t come for anyone in my family either, but they took a good neighbor and a sympathetic person - a plumber. They talked about it. Counter-revolutionary Trotskyist! I wrote a lot about my attitude towards Solzhenitsyn and those like him in the comments on VO, look if not lazy. But nowadays, the times are different and therefore the old recipes, which at first glance seem so simple and omnipotent, no longer work. At one time, I delved into the protocols of many interrogations and did not find any facts of "espionage and sabotage" activities of either the military, or the engineering staff, or scientists. For example, at the UFTI, researchers who were engaged in direct-flow discharge in gases were arrested right from work and disappeared - they were accused of sending high voltage discharges in the tubes to Hitler in Morse code! Complete nonsense, but people are gone. If the repressions concerned only the talkers of politicians and politicians (bickering in the party) and did not affect professionals and specialists - military and civilians, then there would be no special troubles for the state as such (not talking about personal tragedies), but when the country was completely deprived of to the far-fetched accusations of professionals from the military to collective farmers and plumbers, this is already a disaster. The politician closed his mouth and finished his work - and a good plumber he is worth his weight in gold!
                2. Stevev
                  Stevev 11 December 2018 05: 34
                  +1
                  Quote: LeonidL
                  the impression is that periodically a mass of mishandled Cossacks appears periodically
                  and I’m sure about it already
              2. Greenwood
                Greenwood 11 December 2018 03: 57
                +3
                Why are there so many dots in front of each phrase? laughing The impression is that you are hysterical. However, when there are no arguments and there is nothing to cover, all that remains is to splutter and yell "WASHINGTON !!! AMERICA !!! LIBERASTS !!! TRADERS !!! BROWDER !!!!" Have a drink, it might make you feel better.
                Quote: SOF
                maybe even at least ONE of the local wrestlers tell me why the navalnych has nothing about Chubais? ..... well, let's ... comrades .... burn! .....
                About Chubais, and so everyone knows everything. What do you learn about him new?
    7. gunnerminer
      gunnerminer 10 December 2018 20: 18
      +2
      If only not as in Ukraine. If only not as in Syria, or in Venezuela.
  2. BAI
    BAI 10 December 2018 14: 08
    +14
    Well, what about the duel now?
    1. GKS 2111
      GKS 2111 10 December 2018 14: 13
      -1
      Quote: BAI
      Well, what about the duel now?

      Yes, no one knows
      The Federal Antimonopoly Service has refused to comment on the letter from the FSB for the time being.
      The opponent himself also disappeared somewhere-
      Navalny himself did not comment on the appearance of information about the initiation of proceedings in the media at the moment.

      Fun.Rzhunimagu.
      1. Svarog
        Svarog 10 December 2018 14: 41
        +15
        Quote: GKS 2111
        Fun.Rzhunimagu.

        But I’m not at all funny .. a thief on a thief drives a thief .. our money also steals and taxes are raised for us .. retirement age .. I don’t see anything funny ...
        1. LeonidL
          LeonidL 10 December 2018 19: 03
          -7
          The retirement age is being raised all over the world and by no means as softly as in Russia. What taxes do they raise? Maybe they confused France with the Russian Federation? Or Ukrainian tariffs with Russian?
    2. Rzzz
      Rzzz 10 December 2018 14: 20
      +3
      The age of the duel of the head of the FAS and the FSB at the same time. Of both cutlets will do. Or sausages for 350 rubles.
    3. Svarog
      Svarog 10 December 2018 14: 21
      +9
      Quote: BAI
      Well, what about the duel now?

      It would be nice if he were identified in the zone and there would be a duel ... although this will not happen .. we will not hand over your ..
      1. private person
        private person 10 December 2018 14: 59
        +6
        Yeah, to Tsepovyaz, and then he’s tired of just one caviar and crabs.
    4. populist
      populist 10 December 2018 14: 38
      +12
      BAI
      Well, what about the duel now?

      Herr will now have to summon General Zolotov to challenge the FAS and the FSB one by one. belay But most likely the well-known bretre srefit. wink This is not Bulk to call "on the patty" during its next day. These guys may not answer childishly. lol
      1. private person
        private person 10 December 2018 15: 02
        +5
        Complains to dad, dad will shake his finger and everything will be hushed up, and the order will be given "For Merit" and what they will come up with.
    5. Tiksi-3
      Tiksi-3 10 December 2018 14: 44
      +3
      The Federal Security Service took an interest in the issue of food supplies for the needs of the Federal Guard of Russia even the FAS would have sorted out the issue of procurement for preschool and school cots .....
    6. Severok
      Severok 12 December 2018 12: 55
      0
      Well, what about the duel now?
      But no way. With gold, mercantile interest prevailed - sues Leha, wants a million. True to the sausages are not enough.
  3. Roman070280
    Roman070280 10 December 2018 14: 13
    +13
    As expected - the general turned out to be exaggerated .. "did not return from the battle" ..
    1. Gray brother
      Gray brother 10 December 2018 14: 33
      -13
      Quote: Roman070280

      As expected - the general turned out to be exaggerated .. "did not return from the battle" ..

      What is your evidence?
      1. Gray brother
        Gray brother 10 December 2018 14: 51
        -7
        Like he personally bought sausages or what?
        1. Roman070280
          Roman070280 10 December 2018 14: 54
          +12
          No, he has nothing to do with it .. His duty is to receive a salary .. The rest, of course, does not concern him ..
          Threat ... it’s even strange that he began to run into Alyoshka with duels .. he would simply say that he doesn’t personally buy anything .. And the question is closed ..

          Zy .. By the way, Putin and Medvedev also do not personally buy anything .. so poke the nefig in their direction ..))
          1. Gray brother
            Gray brother 10 December 2018 15: 45
            -6
            Quote: Roman070280
            zy .. By the way, Putin and Medvedev also personally do not buy anything ..

            Once I knew one person who in the fuel and lubricants warehouse stably every six months allowed one delivery to the left - she didn’t even go to the warehouse, I put everything in print. Probably it was necessary to plant a gender director for this. laughing

            You do not know a damn life. Pioneers
            1. Roman070280
              Roman070280 10 December 2018 15: 57
              +6
              What, is it straightforward for two fuels and lubricants and left every six months to the left ??
              I think that here you are still right .. the general director should have been involved in that case .. And not just him !!
              1. Gray brother
                Gray brother 10 December 2018 16: 06
                +1
                Quote: Roman070280
                What, is it straightforward for two fuels and lubricants and left every six months to the left ??

                Do you know Russian? Can't you tell the delivery from the composition?
                Quote: Roman070280
                . the general director should be involved in this case

                And for what? He does not work in the warehouse, there are special people for this, financially responsible.
                1. Roman070280
                  Roman070280 11 December 2018 11: 35
                  +2
                  Do you know Russian?
                  Or is Zolotov attributed 300 grams of sausages ??
                  Aby blurt out ..


                  Are there materially responsible people ??
                  So I wrote "the general director should have been involved in that case .. AND NOT HIS ONE !!"
                  Was it really difficult to master two lines ..
                  The CEO is just because he has financially irresponsible people working ..
        2. private person
          private person 10 December 2018 15: 07
          +2
          You wrote great about the requirements of the French, but here it’s not very. It’s kind of like the former Minister of Defense Serdyukov is not to blame, but it's all Vasilyeva.
          1. Roman070280
            Roman070280 10 December 2018 15: 21
            0
            I wrote this, but "Gray Brother" .. Read carefully ..))
            1. private person
              private person 10 December 2018 15: 27
              0
              Your comment came out while I was typing I did not see it
          2. Gray brother
            Gray brother 10 December 2018 16: 21
            -4
            Quote: private person
            It’s kind of like the former Minister of Defense Serdyukov is not to blame, but it's all Vasilyeva.

            Serdyukov brought more benefits than stole, for which he is forgiven.
            I tell you that in any more or less complex structure, things can be stirred up without the knowledge of the authorities. The investigation will show how to say it.
            And you just ran into an option that you personally like, that's all.
      2. LeonidL
        LeonidL 10 December 2018 19: 07
        -5
        Why do they need proof? For one, for a catchphrase, to mix a person with dirt, especially if the general, and the losers themselves are ordinary, then just a balm for the soul. Others - to work out a pretty penny, again to stomp for free and safely on the general. third, even Provalny is good with his shkolota, wet-crochets and "investigations" ... For many, it seems to me, this triggers the dissatisfied feeling of Napoleon Bonoparte ... a sort of couch strategist-generalissimo. Elementary envy of losers to people who are successful and successful.
        1. private person
          private person 10 December 2018 19: 48
          +2
          The elementary envy of losers to successful and successful people.
          Well, yes, my father and mother are simple hard workers and in the 90s they did not rob the country, therefore they did not make a fortune. You open the eyes of whom you consider successful those who snatched a piece from a huge pie called the USSR. Or do you think the owners of factories, tracks, steamboats built everything themselves?
          1. Gray brother
            Gray brother 10 December 2018 20: 02
            -2
            Quote: private person
            Well, yes, dad and mom I have simple hard workers and in the 90s did not rob the country

            On the topic have something to say?
            Give the proof to the studio. I need proofs. Now they don’t believe anyone’s word - such a time.
          2. LeonidL
            LeonidL 10 December 2018 20: 25
            -5
            But Putin’s father and mother were academics, general secretaries, generals ... commodity experts finally ??? Or did he achieve everything with his mind and work? Who's stopping you? And what about dad and mom? Honor and praise! But there are always leaders and there are middle peasants, there are outsiders ... And, believe me, be a leader, make decisions. managing a team or commanding is always harder than simply following orders.
  4. Chicha squad
    Chicha squad 10 December 2018 14: 17
    +9
    Soon Zolotov will probably have to stand again on the barricades, only on the other side.
    1. Roman070280
      Roman070280 10 December 2018 14: 20
      +16
      What difference does it make to where to stand .. If only not to work ..
      1. LeonidL
        LeonidL 10 December 2018 19: 10
        -4
        Do you work successfully? Up to the general epaulettes modified at least something? Something in my life I have commanded ... well, except for my wife, children, mother-in-law ...
        1. Roman070280
          Roman070280 11 December 2018 11: 37
          0
          What did you want to say ??
          Do you want to discuss me ?? Find a suitable forum, create a theme there .. and forward ..
  5. ALARI
    ALARI 10 December 2018 14: 20
    +13
    And how much pathos and righteous anger were, and they dug a little deathly silence.
  6. Ampere
    Ampere 10 December 2018 14: 20
    +7
    It turns out that Navalny passed the FSB factory after staying in jail !?
    1. kepmor
      kepmor 10 December 2018 14: 38
      +16
      if my memory serves me, there was infa that this factory belongs to a former subordinate of Zolotov ... if so, then the fact of corruption "all over the face" ...
      I wonder who this time the chief guard will challenge to a duel ??? ... is it possible that the entire FAS leadership ??? ....
  7. Greenwood
    Greenwood 10 December 2018 14: 25
    +24
    No matter how he feels about Navalny, over and over again he turns out to be right in his investigations. And no matter how much the "putriots" make noise about this, he is doing very, very useful work.
    1. Svarog
      Svarog 10 December 2018 14: 35
      +12
      Quote: Greenwood
      No matter how he feels about Navalny, over and over again he turns out to be right in his investigations. And no matter how much the "putriots" make noise about this, he is doing very, very useful work.

      I agree with you, Navalny is a good criminal journalist .. and as a person .. with iron eggs laughing
      1. kepmor
        kepmor 10 December 2018 14: 44
        -2
        oh ... he has iron "Faberge" for the time being ... until the Kremlin allows them to be worn ...
        1. ALARI
          ALARI 10 December 2018 16: 01
          -1
          So they do not have any iron from him, nor from me, nor from you. As the doctors say there are no healthy people, there are not up to the examined. The main thing is who will ask and HOW.
      2. SOF
        SOF 10 December 2018 14: 57
        -7
        Quote: Svarog
        and as a person .. with iron eggs

        ..... still ... so many years to the left to sell forest ..........
        .... and his eggs are really iron - American .... bully
        1. Svarog
          Svarog 10 December 2018 15: 45
          +9
          Quote: SOF
          Quote: Svarog
          and as a person .. with iron eggs

          ..... still ... so many years to the left to sell forest ..........
          .... and his eggs are really iron - American .... bully

          And who is domestic? laughing We have, as it turns out, almost all of the "elite" in general has citizenship of other countries .. or double, so what? and for Navlny in this regard, only that he studied in the United States .. So Peskov has a son in England, a daughter in France, a US wife and nothing .. okay.
    2. Moore
      Moore 10 December 2018 17: 42
      +2
      Ololesha is just a clown in the game of big and serious uncles. The modern pop Gapon, which is used by one of the parties there, above - the parties of near-grand nobles.
      They throw him material against competitors, which cannot be voiced in any other way, and they initiate checks after his speeches, and cover up from possible "adversities". Tell me, who has the right to leave the Russian Federation with a suspended sentence? Answer: nobody but Lechaim.
      I believe that this cardboard fool after Yale University really thought that he had grabbed God by the beard. Well, those serious uncles took him into circulation. So our Alekhan stands with one foot on the quiche, the other in the place indicated.
      Extremely comfortable figure. They will take care of it. Until Jan 9th ... until the right time.
      1. dauria
        dauria 10 December 2018 23: 27
        0
        So our Alekhan stands with one foot on the quiche, the other in the place indicated.


        A sensible hypothesis explains a lot. This means that our "oligarchy" is not so homogeneous, the fuss with redistribution goes on, the building crackles. And I could not understand everything how Alyoshenka feeds. It turned out painfully primitive - they say, in the United States, he receives a pay directly. The horns would be kicked off quickly. But no, he lives.
  8. Moskovit
    Moskovit 10 December 2018 14: 31
    +8
    Not all Zolotov that glitters. We must choose sausages as a weapon in a future duel.
  9. 777-3-59-97
    777-3-59-97 10 December 2018 14: 34
    +5
    Navalny himself did not comment on the appearance of information about the initiation of proceedings in the media at the moment.


    Already commented.

    Will Zolotov challenge the FSB duel?
    https://navalny.com/p/6028/
  10. Roman070280
    Roman070280 10 December 2018 14: 37
    +8
    Quote: Gray Brother
    Quote: Roman070280

    As expected - the general turned out to be exaggerated .. "did not return from the battle" ..

    What is your evidence?

    And, exactly ... tomorrow, the FAS will report that it did not reveal any violations ..))
  11. rocket757
    rocket757 10 December 2018 14: 39
    +3
    That’s what they take \ give \ steal at the top, we are so sure.
    Shaw further, the investigation, the court will threaten with a finger .... and let's see.
  12. Corsair71 (Anatoly)
    Corsair71 (Anatoly) 10 December 2018 14: 45
    +6
    The parasites of the Russian Guard, only spend money on them.
  13. bratchanin3
    bratchanin3 10 December 2018 14: 47
    +4
    Maybe bulk are needed for such a case - so that the cat does not sleep ?!
  14. New Year day
    New Year day 10 December 2018 14: 52
    +14
    So it turns out: They are Navalny in jail, and he is normal sausages. If Navalny improves the nutrition of the Russian Guard, then the guards will carry it in his arms.
    It seems that Navalny alone is doing the work of the prosecutor's office, the FSB, the Ministry of Internal Affairs. So it’s not far from popular love
    1. Elephant
      Elephant 10 December 2018 15: 29
      +3
      And what a funny vidyuhi Navalny on YouTube !!! lol
    2. Svarog
      Svarog 10 December 2018 15: 47
      +5
      Quote: Silvestr
      It seems that Navalny alone is doing the work of the prosecutor's office, the FSB, the Ministry of Internal Affairs. So it’s not far from popular love

      You know, two years ago, I could not stand him .. and now I like him more and more .. of course, if you do not consider him as a politician ..
  15. 3vs
    3vs 10 December 2018 15: 04
    +6
    Taki, Navalny opened an abscess.
    Let’s see how comrades Zolotov and Medvedev respond to this ...
    And so, it seems, all over the country ...
    1. Greenwood
      Greenwood 10 December 2018 15: 21
      +12
      Quote: 3vs
      how comrades Zolotov and Medvedev will answer this
      About Medvedev and his property was a big investigation movie with tens of millions of views. And Medvedev, in addition to a slurred moo, no longer reacted to this.
  16. mag nit
    mag nit 10 December 2018 15: 16
    +5
    Just like that ... Chain Putin's dogs fed cheap sausages? And Zolotov did not dream about it, nor in spirit ...
  17. loginovich
    loginovich 10 December 2018 15: 18
    +3
    Guards sausages do not report! Such is the homespun truth.
    1. New Year day
      New Year day 10 December 2018 15: 30
      +5
      Quote: loginovich
      Guards sausages do not report! Such is the homespun truth.


      Do they catch Navalny on an empty stomach?
  18. ALARI
    ALARI 10 December 2018 15: 34
    +7
    With what Zolotov will go down in history - Burnt on sausages, challenged a blogger to a duel, but he didn’t come)) Fine. Whether the case is Colonel Zakharchenko - He kept several billion rubles and several million in foreign currency at home. You can feel the style and scope. The colonel kept the general clean.
    1. Elephant
      Elephant 10 December 2018 15: 43
      +1
      And that someone carried out searches at Zolotov?
      1. ALARI
        ALARI 10 December 2018 15: 47
        +3
        Where? At the cottage of Mikoyan-Zolotov?
      2. Adimius38
        Adimius38 10 December 2018 19: 40
        +2
        and who will conduct searches at the king’s nobleman
  19. Hypatius
    Hypatius 10 December 2018 15: 52
    +1
    It is already interesting to see if there will be any sense. FAS Sinekura or executive authority. Unlike other supervision, the FAS staffing level is adequate - 2 units, compared with other countries. But the PHOT - 315 52 thousand rubles is suspiciously small. Those. average salary = 735,3 rubles. http://www.garant.ru/products/ipo/prime/doc/22/#780
    1. Mordvin 3
      Mordvin 3 10 December 2018 18: 33
      +2
      Quote: Hypatius
      It is already interesting to see if there will be any sense.

      There will be no sense from FAS.
  20. New Year day
    New Year day 10 December 2018 16: 12
    +8
    Zolotov is the first general in Russia who burned on sausages. What was ruining before? -Vodka, money, girls. Then the cottages went into the arsenal. And here, sausages! It was necessary to take Zolotov Medvedev, Mirotorg would help him with meat, only the guards
  21. Spine
    Spine 10 December 2018 16: 59
    +6
    Although I’m not very much to Navalny, the infection keeps our swindlers in power in suspense ..
    They steal because they are not shy!
  22. LeonidL
    LeonidL 10 December 2018 18: 48
    0
    You will answer for the sausage! Mustard and pickled cucumbers are next in turn!
  23. Adimius38
    Adimius38 10 December 2018 19: 39
    +2
    and Alyosha was right, and now who wants to make a chop of gold and said that Alyosha is a nonsense.
  24. taiti3000
    taiti3000 10 December 2018 20: 14
    +2
    After all, there are those who defend Zolotov. They need to personally raise the retirement age to 80.
    1. LeonidL
      LeonidL 12 December 2018 04: 21
      0
      We are not talking about protecting Zolotov. You, dear, think very primitively. The point is that to take on faith the next "investigation" of the sent Cossack Provalny (or do you have any doubts?) In relation to the current officer, general. For a person in the officer corps, this act is an inherently unacceptable thing. For a non-officer, this rejection may not be clear. It is not known to an officer that there is such a concept of "Officer's honor", which can be discussed and removed from a person only by the Court of Officers' Honor, after proceedings with the provision of facts and arguments by both parties. It is simply stupid to take on faith the "investigations" of Provalny, and he was a failure in the cases and results of previous investigations. Or do you think, if earlier from Provalny's affairs it smelled like manure, but the general snatched and immediately smelled of roses? All the attacks here, in my opinion, are just a sort of old-fashioned dislike of the private for the general, smelling of petty envy of losers. An investigation must be carried out, this is primarily in the interests of the general, otherwise his uniform will be smeared with mud and splashes of Provalny. That is why he filed a lawsuit. To kick in the face, most likely, he was simply not allowed. Well, the rationale behind Provalny's spitting direction is clear - against the National Guard - against the support of state power. State power is always not to someone's liking, it seems to be undersupplied by some, it seems to others that it does not seem to allow much to roam, and so on. Screams about pensions are generally ridiculous for those who really read the legislation and know the state of affairs with pensions around the world. It is profitable for the failed one to undermine the power, but why should he cheer up on VO in this fifth column?
  25. faterdom
    faterdom 10 December 2018 22: 52
    0
    Bulk against the friendship of peoples. Zolotov - for the friendship of peoples!
    All is clear.
  26. kunstkammer
    kunstkammer 10 December 2018 23: 18
    +2
    What a vile agent of imperialism Navalny ... burned our darling, paw, Zolotov’s Kysanka!
    Do not forget - do not forgive!
    Shame on American mercenaries ...
    Hold on Vityok, we do not change the goats at the crossing. Have a bite ...
    Dimon will not let you lie.
  27. Waldemar
    Waldemar 11 December 2018 00: 00
    0
    There are two options. Either a rollback, or sausages went to the Russian guard not by MOT but by guest. That is, to put it mildly, different tastes.
  28. Yuri VO
    Yuri VO 11 December 2018 02: 57
    0
    Semi sausages of such a strange color and where do they get it?
  29. PFT
    PFT 11 December 2018 05: 55
    0
    Navalny again turned out to be RIGHT and do not put everything in a heap here Ukraine, France.
    1. Waldemar
      Waldemar 13 December 2018 23: 40
      0
      rightness must be proved and not told. it’s me that I’m not so stupid as to take a word or make sure from video presentations
      fans of bulk one characteristic - the threshold of critical thinking is missing.
      all the diploma is without drinking and analysis
  30. GTYCBJYTH2021
    GTYCBJYTH2021 11 December 2018 09: 11
    +1
    Sausages for 270 Russian rubles, with spices and other pseudo-food ingredients .... I have been living in Krasnoyarsk, since the spring I have ordered 50-60 kg pigs from a farmer ....... Come, choose any ..... Two hours- the carcass is tarred, chopped ...... 200 rub kg ...... And the jellied meat was cooked, and the liver for the pies was wrapped ....
  31. GTYCBJYTH2021
    GTYCBJYTH2021 11 December 2018 09: 29
    0
    Quote: Roman070280
    Khmm .. it’s still the French who didn’t raise their retirement age by 5 years at once .. otherwise I would have looked ..))

    In the last century, the year 94-96? French firefighters increased their retirement age ..... they united in picket-fires, extinguished as required, but after the service they protested, installing their cars in front of the ADMINISTRATIONS (town halls?) of the authorities ..... The authorities were tired of this and they attracted the police to stop the riots ..... The police began to bomb protesters, both firefighters and hippies, and others who were dissatisfied with tear gas ..... But the French firefighters were trained, unlike ours, Russian, and ours serve preferential terms! -to deal with the riots-from fire engines water, foamed drove the gas back to the police ..... streams of water brought down attacks on themselves ..... The age limit for firefighters was left unchanged ......
    1. LeonidL
      LeonidL 12 December 2018 04: 28
      0
      Do you consider the whole RPF population to be firefighters? Do not confuse the seniority of people with particularly dangerous professions and opychnye pensions. Nobody encroaches on benefits and privileges - read the Law!