Military Review

Kudrin called the Russian economy caught in a "stagnant pit"

106
Indicators of the growth rate of the Russian economy suggest that it finds itself in a “serious stagnant pit.” This statement was made by Alexei Kudrin, who heads the Audit Chamber of the Russian Federation.




In particular, he noted that in the Russian storiessince the post-war years, there has not been such a long period that the growth rate of economic growth is more than 10 years at the same level and is 1%. This year, the overall growth potential of the economy will be lower than the official forecast and will not exceed 1,6%.

Kudrin noted that the slowdown in economic development is incapable of stopping even the double increase in oil prices. But it is precisely the price increase for oil that has always well spurred the Russian economy.

Back in May of this year, the Chairman of the Accounts Chamber said that it was the introduction of sanctions by the West against Russia was the negative factor that had a significant impact on the inhibition of economic growth in our country. Moreover, their influence increased dramatically after the United States introduced tougher measures in April, taking up to 0,5% growth in gross domestic product.

At the same time, Kudrin did not comment on the situation, which prevented the Russian economy from growing at a more impressive pace until the moment when the whole story began with US sanctions, and when the barrel of oil was above 120 dollars.
Photos used:
RASHIGS
106 comments
Ad

Subscribe to our Telegram channel, regularly additional information about the special operation in Ukraine, a large amount of information, videos, something that does not fall on the site: https://t.me/topwar_official

Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. Vend
    Vend 27 November 2018 15: 00
    -12
    Better stagnation than a steady economic downfall.
    1. For example
      For example 27 November 2018 15: 03
      +51
      Have you driven our economy into this hole?
      According to your rule, everything earned is driven into bucks.
      According to your rule, the money earned does not go to the Russian economy, but to the currency capsule.
      1. Herald of the Revolution
        Herald of the Revolution 27 November 2018 15: 19
        -17
        Quote: For example
        Have you driven our economy into this hole?

        Was Kudrin the president in Russia? Did he ever make final decisions? Have you forgotten which country you live in? Incidentally, Kudrin recently announced the best economist in the world.
        Quote: For example
        everything earned is driven into bucks.

        Well, Russia won a lot on this, the buck has been growing all this time against the ruble. The question can only be whether it was worth saving at all .... and the fact of investing in dollars turned out to be very beneficial for Russia. As well as investments in the US treasury bonds, Russia when she wanted to calmly return everything, and even welded on a percentage.
        Quote: For example
        According to your rule

        Do you seriously think that this is his "rule"? hi
        1. Tatyana
          Tatyana 27 November 2018 15: 26
          +23
          Kudrin called the Russian economy caught in a "stagnant pit"

          And who brought it there, if not Kudrin himself, moreover, with his pro-Western - pro-American - pseudo-"market economy" with its "monetarism" ?! Doesn't Kudrin want to be in the eye? The people can give!
          1. Leclerc
            Leclerc 27 November 2018 15: 37
            -2
            Quote: Tatiana
            Isn't Kudrin himself, moreover, with his pro-Western "market economy" and "monetarism" ?!


            It has long been noticed that you speak like a commissar, with loud baseless slogans. What is wrong with a pro-Western market economy and monetarism? In Germany, Japan and the United States live worse than in Russia? These are just household tools that you need to be able to use, preferably with straight hands. If you bought a drill and then come to complain that the drill is bad because it cuts firewood badly, so it’s your fault.
            1. Tatyana
              Tatyana 27 November 2018 16: 13
              +10
              Quote: Leclerc
              In Germany, Japan and the United States live worse than in Russia?

              You were there? They live differently.
              Quote: Leclerc
              What is wrong with a pro-Western market economy and monetarism?
              And what do you understand about this? Nothing.
              Check out "Capitalism and Freedom" by Milton Friedman, a professor in Chicago! Maybe then you will understand what the so-called. Friedman's supposedly "free" and "clean" market in the American way and what is "monetarism" in general (the pursuit of monetary gains) in his concept - and what is their place in society.

              Kudrin is an apologist for this enmity of the manipulative-anarchist theoretical concept of Friedman, implemented in practice in Russia as for a third world country.
              This idealistic, scientifically inconsistent ideological concept in political economy of M. was invented by him for the native suckers of different countries and manipulatively introduced in the world by the financial oligarch capitalists of the US Federal Reserve solely for their own enrichment and domination of the world.
              1. Leclerc
                Leclerc 27 November 2018 16: 24
                -4
                The slogans "free ... clean ... the pursuit of profits ... in the American way" were again used, which was required to be proved.

                The question was simple: do they live worse in the USA and Germany, not in different ways, but on the whole worse? The question is rhetorical, from here the conclusion directly follows that the problem is not in a market economy.

                Quote: Tatiana
                implemented in practice in Russia as for a third world country


                Well, how would you like if the emphasis is solely on resources, like in some kind of Nigeria, or is it Milton Friedman and Kudrin who conceived such an insidious plan.

                Quote: Tatiana
                This idealistic, scientifically inconsistent ideological concept in political economy of M. was invented by him for suckers and manipulatively supported in the world by financial oligarch-capitalists of the US Federal Reserve exclusively for their own enrichment and domination of the vskm world


                Blah blah blah ... No, seriously, how do you do it, such a set for washing and shaking? You would have come in handy in 1917 to some Trotsky. laughing

                PS
                Quote: Tatiana
                And what do you understand about this? Nothing


                I have an economic education, a higher education, something I understand.
                1. Tatyana
                  Tatyana 27 November 2018 16: 47
                  +5
                  Quote: Leclerc
                  I have an economic education, a higher education, something I understand.

                  Judging by your statements, you, as an economist, only learned to count the "zeros" - an accountant and no one else.
                  And in philosophy and political economy - you are like statesman no one is the petty-bourgeois "Kudrinyat" offspring of Gorbachev and Yeltsin.
                  1. Leclerc
                    Leclerc 27 November 2018 18: 20
                    0
                    Quote: Tatiana
                    Judging by your statements, you, as an economist, only learned to count the "zeros" - an accountant and no one else


                    In fact, the answer did not wait, the same blah blah blah. You are not a philosopher and not a political economist, but a petty urapatriotic commissar-demagogue, with whom, unfortunately, modern Russia is famous. Everything is to blame, the oligarchs in power, the Anglo-Saxons, reptilians, masons, monetarism, and much more. Good luck with great bourgeois statehood laughing
                    1. Tatyana
                      Tatyana 27 November 2018 19: 28
                      0
                      Quote: Leclerc
                      In fact, the answer did not wait, the same blah blah blah. You are not a philosopher and not a political economist, but a petty urapatriotic commissar-demagogue, with whom, unfortunately, modern Russia is famous. Everything is to blame, the oligarchs in power, the Anglo-Saxons, reptilians, masons, monetarism, and much more.
                      It is clear that you will not wake up reading Friedman, that you are too lazy to work. What do you, as always, want to easily remove the fish from the pond!
                      Well, I’ll write to you, but I can only smell it; there will be no feed in the horse.

                      You have equated the concept of real capitalism with all its shortcomings with the doctrinal idea of ​​the American Milton Friedman in the form of a speculative social project, which is being put into practice, to build supposedly perfectly fair capitalism on Earth throughout the world. Due to what?
                      Due to the alleged existence in the world of some anarchist absolutely "free" from everyone and every person of the world market, which is supposedly absolutely "clean" of profanities and dishonesty both on the part of the participants in the capital market, goods (services) of labor, and from pressure on them a nation state. And at the same time, the author assumes that all market participants free from the state are initially at all times equal in life and can always become rich, if they just want it. This is pure utopia and bluff!
                      Behind this attempt to whitewash capitalism with Milton Friedman lies a very definite goal taken by Washington's apologists. Namely.
                      The purpose of this American bluff is to make the sovereign countries "indigenous" for the United States, uncontrollably and duty-free by their governments, mistakenly, free and defenseless from competition, open access for US multinational companies to their domestic markets for the sale of foreign goods and the purchase of "indigenous" wealth by foreigners , enterprises and natural resources.
                      At the same time, the reduction of native state property to the maximum - to "0" - is promoted by the "market people" exclusively as a public good. For the state supposedly does not need to control anything, there is no need to punish anyone, and there is no need to regulate trade and production either. That at the same time all members of society will become such honest and law-abiding entrepreneurs that therefore it will no longer be necessary to protect the population from swindlers, thieves, robbers and murderers. And therefore, the alleged national state, as an anachronism, will disappear by itself as unnecessary, and there is no need to defend it at all. Instead, distribution of material goods "from above" will not be required, because everything will be regulated by this "ideal" capitalist market. But those who did not fit into the market are already their problems. Let, they say, they survive on their own, as they can. These include in particular all the so-called. "superfluous" people: pensioners, disabled people, children, etc. - all those who "did not fit into the market." But they should be "happy" from their freedom from the fattening abstract bureaucratic state that has been pressing over them for centuries in the way that anarchists have always dreamed of it for centuries.

                      TOTAL. This whole ideology of Milton Friedman about the alleged existence of the so-called. "free" and "clean" market is the anarchist propaganda of the American establishment to decompose the national security of sovereign states to their complete elimination and subordination in favor of US multinational companies.
                      Unfortunately, this ideology is unofficially adopted by the Russian ruling elite as a state ideology. It is implemented in practice by the Government of the Russian Federation, the guarantor of the Constitution of the Russian Federation, in the State Duma and the Federation Council. And HSE is the forge of bourgeois young cadres in this comprador economy and its apologists.
                      REFERENCE
                      Compradorism (Spanish comprador buyer) is a way of doing business in which profit is derived from activities that undermine its national economy and reduce its ability to grow and ...
                      1. Leclerc
                        Leclerc 27 November 2018 21: 31
                        +1
                        Quote: Tatiana
                        It is clear that you do not wake up to read Friedman, that you are too lazy to work


                        Tatyana, well, honestly, I read (including Friedman) and wrote more than your hair on your head laughing

                        If there was time and desire, then it would go all over this bullshit above, a sort of demonic set of which it is not clear what, all in one heap, each letter would go through.

                        Here I will take at least just one moment of your opus.

                        At the same time, the reduction of native state property to the maximum - to "0" - is promoted by the "market people" exclusively as a public good. For the state supposedly does not need to control anything, there is no need to punish anyone, and there is no need to regulate trade and production either. That at the same time all members of society will become such honest and law-abiding entrepreneurs that therefore it will no longer be necessary to protect the population from swindlers, thieves, robbers and murderers.


                        Who is promoting this and where? Show me a statement, a statement of at least one leading economist where he does not even say this, but at least hints. Name at least one state that lives by these rules of yours. Who are these mythical "market people" of yours? What nonsense are you talking about, I was so ashamed to even think about what to write. wassat
                      2. Tatyana
                        Tatyana 27 November 2018 23: 48
                        0
                        .
                        Quote: Leclerc
                        Who is promoting this and where? Show me a statement, a statement of at least one leading economist, where he does not even say this, but at least hints. Name at least one state that lives by your rules. Who are your mythical "market people"?

                        Exactly! I’m saying that this is not for you horse feed!
                        It was written in plain text by Milton Friedman in his book Capitalism and Freedom, for which he received the Nobel Prize in Economics. And also Gaidar, Chubais, Yasin and others "market people" buzzed all the ears of Russians during the period of privatization of state property in Russia.
                        Quote: Leclerc
                        What kind of nonsense are you talking about, I was so ashamed to even think not what to write.
                        And we are ashamed and unsafe to live under their control with such "market-oriented" economists!

                        I have the impression that you left the USSR since 1990 and live in Israel, or in any case not in Russia. But in Russia you are like falling off the moon. So stop trolling!
                        If you have written mountains of works on economics, then only, probably, it is also not to the benefit of Russia, and science in general, since you defend the Russian "market people" - Kudrin and "kudrinyat" and do not understand the essence of their propaganda and deeds in the country.
                        There are no "free" markets, in principle. This is not even a socialist system for you, but a capitalist one! All markets under capitalism are protectionistically regulated. Trump alone with his American-protectionist "market" policy is now worth something! Wipe your eyes! Business to TMV comes with your "free" and "clean" market!
                      3. Tatyana
                        Tatyana 28 November 2018 00: 15
                        -1
                        Quote: Leclerc
                        Tatyana, well, honestly, I read (including Friedman)

                        And you didn’t understand anything in Fridman’s book. We have a Russian proverb about such readers - "Looks at a book, sees a fig!" (Joke.) yes
                        Re-read carefully for the internal logical consistency of the book "Capitalism and Freedom" by Milton Friedman! There, one does not have to go far to understand his philosophical concept in order to construct a supposedly ideal capitalist society - his entire financial ideology is set out in the first 20 pages.
                      4. Leclerc
                        Leclerc 28 November 2018 12: 03
                        0
                        Quote: Tatiana
                        Exactly! I’m saying that this is not for you horse feed!


                        If this is your feed, then you are a very strange horse laughing

                        Milton Friedman, not a trendsetter, not a standard bearer of the Western economy, he is one of thousands of economists, and the most important thing is that he did not write a word from the heresy that you attribute to him here, "Capitalism and Freedom" is a very useful book and is not clear in which orc translation did you read it (I read the original) - it is about the right balance between control and regulation of the state and the freedom of the market, and not only the market, it is about the fact that the market is less efficient if the state climbs into it with hands and feet.

                        But for the commissar, there are also enough reeds to catch on and procrastinate the topic of the bourgeoisie and dirty capitalists.

                        You are not an economist, not even close, you need to read more books and develop in different ways, and not stupidly bend your line, looking for rare passages that allow your brain to release hormones of joy.
                      5. Tatyana
                        Tatyana 28 November 2018 22: 15
                        -1
                        Quote: Leclerc
                        the most important thing is that he did not write a word from the heresy that you ascribe to him here, "Capitalism and Freedom"

                        No need to lie! Read his book - its philosophical component is skillfully.
                        Quote: Leclerc
                        You are not an economist
                        I have a second higher education with a degree in "manager of financial, economic and administrative divisions". Red diploma. So take it easy with your articles, which, as YOU say, you have more than my hair on my head. On this score, I can tell you: it is not so much the number of works that matters, but their quality and scientifically sound novelty.
                  2. Roman070280
                    Roman070280 28 November 2018 13: 59
                    0
                    Tatyana .. a man brought you real arguments .. jabbed his nose with what’s called .. For the sake of what you become in a pose, it’s not clear ..
                    I'd like to prove that the Germans live on the whole poorer than the Russians ?? Yes, at least beat the cake .. you yourself know that this is not so ..
                    1. Tatyana
                      Tatyana 28 November 2018 21: 34
                      -1
                      Quote: Roman070280
                      Tatyana .. a man brought you real arguments .. jabbed his nose with what’s called .. For what you’re getting into a pose, it’s not clear .. I really want to prove that the Germans live on the whole poorer than the Russians ?? Yes, at least beat the cake .. you yourself know that this is not so ..

                      And where does the Germans live by and large and the financial situation of Germany, if Bank of Germany is part of the US Federal Reserve? This is one financial office. Why will they live badly if they, like the USA, also rob other countries.
                      This is generally Leclerc completely incorrect comparison and juxtaposition! An elderberry garden, and an uncle in Kiev. He wants to say that the West has not robbed and does not continue to rob Russia.
                      The West is robbing Russia from the Gaidar-Yeltsin privatization reforms and even robbing!
            2. MMX
              MMX 27 November 2018 19: 54
              0
              Quote: Leclerc

              In Germany, Japan and the United States live worse than in Russia?


              What do you mean by "worse" or "better"?
              But they lived worse in the USSR than in the countries listed?
          2. Nyrobsky
            Nyrobsky 27 November 2018 19: 41
            +3
            Quote: Tatiana
            Doesn’t Kudrin want to do so? The people can give!

            No, in the eye, he definitely does not want to))) He wants to shift some of his blame onto the most "effective" government of the LADY, who once expelled Kudrin from the government. In principle, the LADY did his job - he carried out unpopular reforms, resetting his rating and halving the presidential rating. Since he really doesn’t pull the prime minister’s cart, they will find a place for him. This requires at least an "honest and objective" analysis, which suddenly jumped out of L. Kudrin's department, despite the fact that when the "Prime Minister 2018" was appointed, the GDP noted the "good" work of the government. Replacing it will be greeted by the "grateful" people positively, and the GDP rating will be restored. Everyone is happy. Perhaps Lenya will soon head the government himself, which in general for Russia will be expressed in effect in the formula "Horseradish radish is not sweeter"
        2. spirit
          spirit 27 November 2018 15: 33
          +18
          Did Russia weld?)
          Here is a third of the currency, why is it in the banks of "our partners" who impose sanctions against us. Why? The Central Bank evades the answer. Most likely, everything welded on American traverses now constitutes a safety cushion for Putin's elite and this money has nothing to do with citizens, just like the accumulated gold. By the end of the year, the country has a budget surplus, but for some reason new taxes are introduced every month. The question is why?
          1. Herald of the Revolution
            Herald of the Revolution 27 November 2018 15: 41
            -15
            By the way, stagnation in the economy for 10 years already and this little coin has come in handy now ... It’s another matter how efficiently it is and where it’s all being spent now ... but this is not Kudrin’s problem, as we see now, the fact of saving turned out to be very far-sighted.
            1. Boris Nevzorov
              Boris Nevzorov 27 November 2018 15: 55
              +14
              The State Duma has once again extended the freezing of the cumulative part of the Russian pension to 2021. The relevant law was adopted on Thursday in the third final reading.

              "Zin, where's the money? And, Zin?"
              It is Kudrin & Co that creates economic problems for Russia ... under the tacit approval of the "guarantor" of everything and everyone ....
        3. Warrior with machine gun
          Warrior with machine gun 27 November 2018 15: 33
          +13
          And the minister of finance, he probably only received a salary? "A wonderful financier", but for some reason in Russia, this "wonderful" is not needed anywhere else, those people think he is good who would gladly bring our economy to a primitive communal one.
          1. Herald of the Revolution
            Herald of the Revolution 27 November 2018 15: 46
            -11
            Quote: Warrior with machine gun
            And the Minister of Finance, he’s probably only a salary

            If you have a short memory, I’ll remind you that Kudrin has been mercilessly criticizing the authorities all these years and was constantly in opposition to the president, because he was eventually fired. Almost everything that he proposed was always ignored, the only thing he could influence and, as we now see very even in time, was to save. hi
            1. Warrior with machine gun
              Warrior with machine gun 27 November 2018 15: 55
              +8
              It’s good to save, of course, but how and why, and they fired him for such a long time for such a non-living person in the government, he is an economist, there is a cow with dystrophy and hay that accumulates for her, but we’ll give her hay later (probably when she dies), and while we will save hi
        4. igorbrsv
          igorbrsv 27 November 2018 16: 09
          +4
          Kudrin was the Minister of Finance. Now it seems he wants to regain this chair by criticism. He can’t propose any real measures, and a place at the post of bread
        5. Ural-4320
          Ural-4320 27 November 2018 17: 16
          +7
          Yes, no matter how you call it, no matter how bad it is that there is no growth, but what a show off of GDP growth when ordinary citizens do not fall from it? They live on a meager salary, and these volumes of funds are spinning past them.
        6. not main
          not main 27 November 2018 23: 29
          0
          Quote: Herald of Revia
          Incidentally, Kudrin recently announced the best economist in the world

          This is annoying! When the enemies praise!
      2. Stas157
        Stas157 27 November 2018 15: 23
        +5
        Quote: For example
        Have you driven our economy into this hole?

        No, the one who put it.
        Kudrin called the Russian economy caught in a "stagnant pit"

        Can anyone object to the chairman of the Accounts Chamber? Maybe he does not boast of information? And then everyone proved to me that everything is fine with us in the economy!
        1. Andrey Chistyakov
          Andrey Chistyakov 27 November 2018 15: 30
          +3
          Quote: Stas157
          Quote: For example
          Have you driven our economy into this hole?

          No, the one who put it.
          Kudrin called the Russian economy caught in a "stagnant pit"

          Can anyone object to the chairman of the Accounts Chamber? Maybe he does not boast of information? And then everyone proved to me that everything is fine with us in the economy!

          And what, under his premiership, no one stole ?!
          1. atalef
            atalef 27 November 2018 15: 32
            +2
            Quote: Andrey Chistyakov
            Quote: Stas157
            Quote: For example
            Have you driven our economy into this hole?

            No, the one who put it.
            Kudrin called the Russian economy caught in a "stagnant pit"

            Can anyone object to the chairman of the Accounts Chamber? Maybe he does not boast of information? And then everyone proved to me that everything is fine with us in the economy!

            And what, under his premiership, no one stole ?!

            was Kudrin the prime minister?
            1. Andrey Chistyakov
              Andrey Chistyakov 27 November 2018 15: 44
              +3
              Andrey Chistyakov (Andrey Chistyakov) 1 Today, 15:42

              0
              I repent. Kudrin was not prime minister. Your truth. He was Minister of Finance for 11 years.
              1. Tank jacket
                Tank jacket 27 November 2018 20: 31
                0
                And the deputy prime minister?
        2. Gray brother
          Gray brother 27 November 2018 15: 40
          +5
          Quote: Stas157
          Can anyone object to the chairman of the Accounts Chamber?

          I can. We are talking about slowing growth, and this is the sacred cow of all stock market speculators - there is nothing to speculate growth on. Byad-byad.
          The rest do not care that the profit of the capitalist merchants does not worry only the capitalists themselves.
          1. Stas157
            Stas157 27 November 2018 16: 23
            +4
            Quote: Gray Brother
            I can. It's about slowing down, and this is the sacred cow of all exchange speculators - no securities growth nothing to speculate on. Byad-byad.

            And what does the exchange and securities have to do with it? It's about the whole economy! This applies to GDP growth, as the main economic indicator:
            Economic Growth Indicators Russia is told that it ended up in a “serious stagnant pit”. This statement was made by Alexei Kudrin, head of the Accounts Chamber of the Russian Federation.

            So don't try to be smarter than the former finance minister. Maybe he, as a liberal strategist, led the housekeeper into the abyss (although here the "patriots" consider the years of Putin's rule to be brilliant!), But he can assess the real state of affairs and call things by their proper names as a professional. Which he demonstrates at the moment.
            In particular, he noted that in Russian history, since the post-war years, there has not been such a long period so that the economic growth rate was kept at the same level for more than 10 years and amounted to 1%.

            Here Russia is ahead, it was this circumstance that allowed Kudrin to judge the Russian economy as a stagnant pit.
            1. Gray brother
              Gray brother 27 November 2018 22: 58
              0
              Quote: Stas157
              It's about the whole economy!

              This economy does not concern me; other people are enriching themselves.
        3. Leshy1975
          Leshy1975 27 November 2018 16: 05
          +13
          Quote: Stas157
          Quote: For example
          Have you driven our economy into this hole?

          No, the one who put it.
          Kudrin called the Russian economy caught in a "stagnant pit"

          Can anyone object to the chairman of the Accounts Chamber? Maybe he does not boast of information? And then everyone proved to me that everything is fine with us in the economy!

          I put you a plus, but they will minus, let them throw me a minus too.
          I, too, read the comments and go nuts. In our country, Putin (within the framework of the system that has developed after 91 years) has been in charge of the country for almost two decades, but individual officials, who do not determine the course of foreign and domestic policy, are still responsible for problems in the state. performers in the framework of posts and duties. But the state’s system is never to blame, and God forbid, Putin is not to blame (after all, he hangs noodles so nicely from a TV from his TV set, and, for a simple reason, he starfishes). Aw, fellow citizens, wake up (who has not done this yet)!
      3. Evgeniy667b
        Evgeniy667b 28 November 2018 15: 42
        +1
        Since 2000, more than 70 thousand enterprises have ceased to exist in the Russian Federation. What to rely on for net and gas, if the real sector of the economy is reduced to a minimum. The people themselves who previously produced material products prefer not to improve its quality, but to buy !!! produced in the same China Earlier, for example, very good silk fabrics were produced in Orenburg, now on the site of this plant is the shopping and entertainment center "Armada". What comments can there be? While the country is sitting on a raw material needle to please Miller, Sechin and others like them, there can be no question of any economic growth!
    2. kjhg
      kjhg 27 November 2018 15: 27
      +12
      Quote: Wend
      Better stagnation

      Stagnation is better than a fall, but the problem is that the economy is so structured that after a long stagnation a catastrophic fall occurs.
      Who is the finance minister today? Former Deputy Kudrina Anton Siluanov. In general, the main responsibility of the current state of the economy lies with Putin. It is he who is to blame for the fact that the economy is in a stagnant pit, as Kudrin put it.
    3. SlavaS
      SlavaS 27 November 2018 16: 53
      +5
      Stagnation is a fall, maybe. others go forward while you are standing.
    4. zloybond
      zloybond 27 November 2018 22: 17
      0
      Better The ultimate measure in embezzlement on public procurement. The rest is a talking room.
  2. Loess
    Loess 27 November 2018 15: 01
    +5
    But what offers?
    1. Horon
      Horon 27 November 2018 15: 27
      +5
      "Katz offers to surrender!" (C)
  3. pvv113
    pvv113 27 November 2018 15: 05
    +15
    A pair of such curls - and no enemies
    1. Sayan
      Sayan 27 November 2018 15: 19
      +19
      Yes, there are more than a couple of them in the government, the current of the passport with other surnames and not only there, all of its HSE is a hotbed of pseudo-economic pests
      1. pvv113
        pvv113 27 November 2018 15: 30
        +2
        Unfortunately, I can not agree request
  4. SlavaS
    SlavaS 27 November 2018 15: 05
    +24
    Taxes still need to be raised, but electricity and benz prices must be increased, interest rates on loans raised, and you see the high-tech production will rise, but how much will it go!
    1. Turist1996
      Turist1996 27 November 2018 19: 44
      0
      This is quite the topic: https://youtu.be/MFnd5QJ7Dmg
  5. Captain Pushkin
    Captain Pushkin 27 November 2018 15: 05
    +11
    Thanks to people like Kudrin, our economy is in this, to put it mildly, pit.
    What to do? Change all this audience to competent and adequate people. Such in the Russian Federation are available.
    1. The comment was deleted.
    2. Stas157
      Stas157 27 November 2018 17: 01
      +7
      Quote: Captain Pushkin
      Thanks to people like Kudrin, our economy is in this, to put it mildly, pit.
      What to do? Change all this audience to competent and adequate people. Such in the Russian Federation are available.

      To do this, you must first change Putin. He set them and is not going to change them. However, many here look at GDP as an icon, at the same time scolding what the light is worth of all its associates. Here's what to call it? Absolutely dense, undeveloped, rigid thinking, zombie, ossified gray mass.
      1. Consultant
        Consultant 27 November 2018 17: 52
        -3
        Quote: Stas157
        dense, undeveloped, rigid thinking, zombie, ossified gray mass

        So you look back at the mass, this one, as it is ... ossified. Well, tea, not mass, but an ind-vid-duum, progressive ... Go ahead, change everyone and change Putin, to the heap wink
  6. svp67
    svp67 27 November 2018 15: 08
    +14
    Back in May of this year, the Chairman of the Accounts Chamber said that it was the West’s imposition of sanctions against Russia that was the negative factor that had a significant impact on the economic slowdown in our country.
    And Mr. Kudrin is not ready to admit his contribution to "digging this hole"? Why in the "fat years", when he was "feeding the authorities", we did not modernize and develop the economy?
    1. Ugolek
      Ugolek 27 November 2018 15: 45
      +1
      Back in May of this year, the Chairman of the Accounts Chamber said that it was the West’s imposition of sanctions against Russia that was the negative factor that had a significant impact on the economic slowdown in our country.


      And he still put the money to count in the accounting chamber? the negative factor that has a significant impact on the inhibition of economic growth in our country is this whole oligarchic gang and spies like Kudrin.
      1. Roman070280
        Roman070280 28 November 2018 14: 07
        +1
        Yes, it was the State Department that put him there .. or Navalny ..))
    2. Roman070280
      Roman070280 28 November 2018 14: 06
      0
      So he admitted everything in this article !!
      Or are you now waiting for him to say directly - I was digging a hole, but still I have been in power for so many years thanks to Putin ??
      So after such a confession, nothing will change in the head .. Anyway, everyone will continue to believe that Kudry is villains, and the president is innocent ..
  7. Alexey-74
    Alexey-74 27 November 2018 15: 15
    +15
    While all this gang of 90s and zero in power, people can not see the money, salaries and pensions. The economy itself will not rise, and financial manipulations do not raise the economy, but only systematize cash flow. And if you imagine that the country has no natural resources? What then would be? They can’t think otherwise. Therefore, for the West we are still the world gas-gas column.
  8. solzh
    solzh 27 November 2018 15: 16
    +12
    Drive all these curls, chubais from the country. These are not economists; it is unknown what.
  9. Yeraz
    Yeraz 27 November 2018 15: 17
    +3
    And what in the end do ???
    And why the DOUBLE increase in oil prices Kudrin noted that a slowdown in economic development is unable to stop even a double increase in oil prices.
    It conditionally gives oil $ 50 billion, and will give $ 100 billion, at least it should affect the STOP of the decline.
    1. Henderson
      Henderson 27 November 2018 15: 23
      +10
      If the money is put in a small pill, then it should not. In order for them to influence something, they need to be INVESTED in development.
      1. Yeraz
        Yeraz 27 November 2018 15: 36
        +2
        Quote: Henderson
        If the money is put in a small pill, then it should not. In order for them to influence something, they need to be INVESTED in development.

        but why completely put all the additional income into the bottle? Well, put 30-40% of the rest on development and at least the decline will definitely stop.
        1. Henderson
          Henderson 27 November 2018 15: 38
          -1
          It just doesn’t stop, but you can slow down. Income too low compared to how much you need to reinvest. Fixed assets are very worn out. It is only if Stalin's methods used to drive everyone to the factories for a crust of bread.
          1. Yeraz
            Yeraz 27 November 2018 17: 31
            0
            Quote: Henderson
            Income too low compared to how much you need to reinvest.

            Yes, you just need to use it rationally. And not an object worth $ 1 million with a budget allocated 10. Clear business, the whole problem doesn’t consist of this, but if you solve problems, solve the problem of Money Theft and spend more wisely on necessary projects, and not on knowingly unprofitable situation can be improved.
            1. Henderson
              Henderson 27 November 2018 18: 05
              0
              Not much is stolen nationwide. And these amounts are absolutely not enough to upgrade fixed assets. The problem is much deeper.
    2. Ural-4320
      Ural-4320 27 November 2018 17: 28
      +1
      Yes, what will it affect if there is no one to build, do, develop for elementary? Who will buy this made / developed? SSJ-100 did, but how many sales? Are the customers happy with these SSJ-100s? How many are in flight condition? Money flowed into the VAZ, but where is the exhaust? The exhaust was obtained from Nissan Renault when it put its development on the conveyor. Do you think GAZ leaked cars because of a whim? No, the Gazelle is more profitable. ZIL was generally sawn into square meters and elitism ...
      I don’t care how much money they are ready to invest somewhere / in something, they should pay off in a short period of time, because the technologies are no longer ancient, you can build and implement faster than 10 years ago.
      And you don’t need to build entire micro-districts of a big mind - over time, all apartments will be sold. Only the state’s economy is neither cold nor hot.
  10. Leclerc
    Leclerc 27 November 2018 15: 22
    +2
    It is not very clear how Russia, with its enormous potential, is not a self-sufficient country. And sanctions are generally a "cheap excuse", no economic theory can explain why everything is so bad.
    1. Tank jacket
      Tank jacket 27 November 2018 16: 04
      +3
      It’s a pity that you don’t understand. I suggest. CBR, IMF, Fed.
    2. Warrior with machine gun
      Warrior with machine gun 27 November 2018 16: 30
      +1
      But one practice may be, the practice of quieting theft and do not care for this theft
    3. SlavaS
      SlavaS 27 November 2018 16: 57
      +3
      The answer is simple, Russia is not allowed to do whatever it wants. Although this is a self-sufficient country, it is not independent.
  11. Horon
    Horon 27 November 2018 15: 25
    +8
    Kudrin needs to lobby for the interests of transnational companies, and therefore bleats about the losses from sanctions, point blank noticing that he needs to raise his own production protecting him from import dumping. An idea such as him, with dragging Russia into the WTO on enslaving terms for Russian manufacturers, was the same lobbying for the interests of multinational companies.
  12. nafanal
    nafanal 27 November 2018 15: 33
    +8
    Curly wise men wise curls- while all this liberal bastard will hang around in the Kremlin, there will be no economic growth. Lord .. well, why liberals of all countries are patriots of their countries and Russian liberals just right to smear forehead with greens. To everyone. Not one decent
  13. pepel
    pepel 27 November 2018 15: 37
    +7
    About the stagnant pit says the team of excavators who tirelessly dug this very pit with persistence worthy of a better application. wassat
  14. vladimirvn
    vladimirvn 27 November 2018 15: 40
    +1
    Everything is going according to plan, as promised.
    1. SlavaS
      SlavaS 27 November 2018 16: 58
      +2
      Maybe even as Margaret Thatcher wished.
  15. The comment was deleted.
  16. 1536
    1536 27 November 2018 15: 43
    +7
    The Accounts Chamber has become just a second government? By the way, I.V. was appointed the People's Commissar of the Workers 'and Peasants' Inspection in 1920. Stalin remained in this post until 1922. The chairman of the SNK (Council of People's Commissars) was V.I. Lenin. NEP was carried out in the country. There was someone to control. In 1923, Lenin even wrote an article "How We Can Reorganize the Rabkrin".
    Today is 2018 year. The Americans called the space probe a spaceship, launched it on Mars, put it there yesterday and already get pictures of Mars. And at least it’s time for us to start reading Lenin again.
    1. Selevc
      Selevc 28 November 2018 14: 05
      0
      Today is the year 2018. The Americans called the space probe a spaceship, launched it on Mars
      Americans at the current level of development of video and computer technology can at least tomorrow cook up any photo or video on the subject of space on a computer and call it Martian for example an expedition - for example Apollo 19 !!!. How to verify the authenticity ??? And who will check ??? Is Rogozin really ??? )))
  17. Elephant
    Elephant 27 November 2018 15: 43
    +7
    Nevertheless, Kudrin, one of the few, is trying to somehow stir up the Medvedev government, but they are in deep hibernation, and the Russian economy is deeply ****! Personally, I am for the power and the people are offended.
  18. JD1979
    JD1979 27 November 2018 15: 47
    +4
    I would put some leading economists in a cesspool.
    1. Elephant
      Elephant 27 November 2018 15: 52
      +6
      But there are no other economists. There are still children of the Russian elite who are now studying in England and are improving their knowledge, especially how to increase the family budget in Russian open spaces ...
  19. alexhol
    alexhol 27 November 2018 15: 50
    +5
    The country is a gas station. wink
    1. SlavaS
      SlavaS 27 November 2018 17: 00
      +1
      Well, it’s straight - a gas station - and gas, and wood, and metals, and even burial grounds with imported radioactive waste.
      1. alexhol
        alexhol 27 November 2018 17: 05
        +3
        Exactly. Without "thinking", blurted out. good
        By the way, can anyone else a couple of islands unnecessary? So inexpensive, if that.
  20. Wolf
    Wolf 27 November 2018 15: 52
    0
    There is only one question for Kudrin and the Central Bank, can they logically answer why they do not conduct foreign trade in Rubles?
    1. Wolf
      Wolf 27 November 2018 15: 54
      0
      It’s understandable why the CA makes the sale of oil in $, and why does Russia do it?
    2. Elephant
      Elephant 27 November 2018 15: 55
      +2
      This is not interesting! Because the money of the Russian oligarchs is mainly in foreign. currency and in foreign banks.
  21. Gerklim
    Gerklim 27 November 2018 15: 56
    +5
    That's because of people like Kudrin, our economy was in a hole, and sanctions are a reason for excuse.
  22. skeptic31
    skeptic31 27 November 2018 15: 57
    +4
    Our Russian outrage. Surprise in the eyes of one of the main advisers, the culprit of stagnation - "and why should it, because I advise so well." Or "my hut from the edge, I'm not guilty."
  23. Yuriy Malyshko
    Yuriy Malyshko 27 November 2018 16: 05
    +5
    Kudrin would not hurt to look in the mirror - he would see one of the main authors of this stagnation.
  24. Boris Nevzorov
    Boris Nevzorov 27 November 2018 16: 21
    +7
    Kudrin, whose cow would mumble, but yours would be silent ... just remember the Russian Pension Fund, which is stored abroad ...
    Theft in a pension fund, venality of the Central Bank, etc., etc. cover up the most senior members of the government and the State Duma.
  25. 320423
    320423 27 November 2018 16: 33
    +2
    The dead horse said (they do not change horses at the crossing), by the way, he is flesh from the flesh of the Medvedev government, I no longer believe in this circus. Chet is incomprehensible so he is promoted more recently.
  26. snake
    snake 27 November 2018 16: 39
    +1
    Indicators of the growth rate of the Russian economy suggest that it finds itself in a “serious stagnant pit.” This statement was made by Alexei Kudrin, who heads the Audit Chamber of the Russian Federation.

    If one of the "implicated" openly speaks about it, then it seems that the matter is exactly the seams.
  27. APASUS
    APASUS 27 November 2018 17: 15
    +7
    And before the sanctions and after, the main inhibiting factor in the Russian economy is the economic policy of the government! It's funny to hear about the growth of the Russian economy and at the same time invest in the US economy
    1. shura7782
      shura7782 27 November 2018 19: 21
      0
      Quote: APASUS
      It's funny to hear about the growth of the Russian economy and at the same time invest in the US economy

      What is the meaning of the president when he spoke about the upcoming breakthrough? No new jobs are observed. Then what is the secret?
  28. shura7782
    shura7782 27 November 2018 17: 23
    -2
    Gentlemen !!!
    Get ready! Here, here we go for a breakthrough with a throw. As a result, we skip. So the GDP warned ..
    Caution. Doors are closing.
    Fasten seat belts!
  29. Ivan Ivanov
    Ivan Ivanov 27 November 2018 17: 30
    +1
    Self-critical. the author of the reforms reported on the results of his activities.
  30. lucul
    lucul 27 November 2018 18: 01
    +3
    The growth rate of the Russian economy suggests that it has found itself in a “serious stagnant pit”. This statement was made by Alexei Kudrin,

    AAA, I laugh at the voice.
    Where is your famous song of the liberals about the "invisible hand of the rynka" which will rule everything ??? !!!! After all, how did the liberals squeal? Give us freedom in the economy and the market will rule everything. Has it settled?
    In the 90s they sang how? We need start-up capital for the business - when it appears, then the return will go. For the sake of this, predatory privatization was carried out in order to create a layer of business-elite who would begin to raise the economy.
    What actually happened? The Jews, using greater financial literacy, before the Russians received privileged access (not being the titular nation in this country !!!!!) to this "feeding trough". They grabbed money and took it abroad, but now they say the economy is not growing. And why should it grow, if the financial elite of Russia is foreigners, and Russia is viewed only as a lamb, from which it is necessary to cut its wool, and it is not necessary to feed it.
    1. LeonidL
      LeonidL 27 November 2018 19: 57
      +1
      The song of the liberals is akin to the song of sea sirens leading ships to the rocks - ears need to be waxed up when the curls are blown out!
  31. Graz
    Graz 27 November 2018 18: 03
    +2
    thanks to this breeze, it ended up in stagnation, instead of investing in its economy for 25 years they kept money in US bonds, so all claims to this comrade
  32. Reserve buildbat
    Reserve buildbat 27 November 2018 18: 34
    +4
    He simply reported to the owners that everything was going according to plan, he would not allow economic development. And reported on the progress achieved in this field.
  33. kefan
    kefan 27 November 2018 19: 46
    +2
    Including this and the great merit of Kudrin himself.
  34. LeonidL
    LeonidL 27 November 2018 19: 56
    0
    When Kudrin broadcasts, it’s better to plug the ears
  35. wooja
    wooja 27 November 2018 20: 04
    +1
    Kudrin-- not the head ...., his task is to open his mouth, puff out his cheeks and poke his eyes
  36. faterdom
    faterdom 27 November 2018 20: 27
    0
    she ended up in a "serious stagnant pit." This statement was made by Alexei Kudrin

    With a sense of legitimate pride in a job well done.
  37. earloop
    earloop 28 November 2018 13: 11
    +1
    It is strange that this "accountant" is still head of the Accounts Chamber. The "accountant" does not think what he should. He, too, was one of the "diggers" of the "serious stagnant pit".
    1. fif21
      fif21 29 November 2018 08: 12
      0
      good
      Quote: earloop
      The "accountant" does not think what he should.
      It's time for the "accountant" to dig trenches, from the fence to the morning! wassat
  38. Roman070280
    Roman070280 28 November 2018 13: 44
    +3
    "At the same time, Kudrin did not comment on the situation with the fact that prevented the Russian economy from growing at a more impressive pace until the moment when this whole story with American sanctions began, and when a barrel of oil was worth more than $ 120."

    I will be responsible for Kudrin .. When there was more money, they just stole more .. Therefore, the growth was not more impressive ..
    When there is less money, then to steal the same amount as before - you have to raise prices, abolish pensions, increase VAT, etc.
  39. fif21
    fif21 29 November 2018 08: 10
    0
    Mr. Kudrin does not want to notice the obvious. His line - to sell the Russian economy to foreign investors is obvious. And his horror stories are not convincing. hi