Military Review

Is comedy compatible with blockade? Listeners of "Echo of Moscow" distinguished themselves

123
The radio station Ekho Moskvy decided to ask their radio listeners about their opinion on the repeatedly discussed film The Holiday. Recall that we are talking about the project of art films, telling about the meeting of the family "in a special position" of the New (1942-th) year in the besieged Leningrad. The director himself announced his film “black comedy”, and reported on the collection of popular donations to complete the preparation of the film.


Against the background of broadcast blatant blunders (the country house where the New Year was celebrated in the film, was in the territory occupied by the Nazis), the filmmakers accuse those who spoke critically about the film: "... you must first watch the comedy, then criticize." In a discussion of the very idea of ​​the film, its authors, apparently, initially refused.

The combination of “black comedy” and the blockade of Leningrad caused a wide public response in the country. The country, in almost every family of which there were or are people facing the horrors of Nazism, is extremely sensitive to the ideas of modern creative directors who, strangely enough, cannot find other themes for their comedic creative, except for the Leningrad blockade.

And this is the same poll on the radio station Echo of Moscow with its very remarkable results:
Are black comedy and история besieged Leningrad?


More than 20 thousand Echo listeners voted through Internet resources. Most of them said that this cannot be combined: 58%. At the same time, more than a third of respondents believe that it is possible and necessary to combine (34%). The rest of the survey participated, but they were unequivocal to answer.

Even more remarkable are the survey results, for which radio listeners used telephony tools to respond. In this case, 51% believes that the combination of a black comedy with a blockade theme is a completely “normal” phenomenon. The rest are not ready to agree with this point of view. It should be noted that only 100 people voted by phone on "Echo".

Is comedy compatible with blockade? Listeners of "Echo of Moscow" distinguished themselves


"Military Review" decided not to conduct such a survey, as it believes that the very discussion of the compatibility or incompatibility of the director's creative comedy in the genre with the tragedy of Leningrad and the whole country is already something inappropriate. Perhaps one of our readers has a different opinion on this matter.
Photos used:
screen "Echo of Moscow"
123 comments
Ad

Subscribe to our Telegram channel, regularly additional information about the special operation in Ukraine, a large amount of information, videos, something that does not fall on the site: https://t.me/topwar_official

Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. 210ox
    210ox 21 October 2018 07: 05
    +67
    We know this "audience" So everything is natural. Fifty moral monsters ..
    1. LSA57
      LSA57 21 October 2018 07: 21
      +20
      they were even given a definition. obscene
      1. krot
        krot 21 October 2018 07: 33
        +35
        For those who believe that such comedies can be released, let them think about how it would have happened if they had removed Hochma and how their parents are dying .. It would be funny if they were interested?
        As we say: "The family has its black sheep!"
        1. LSA57
          LSA57 21 October 2018 07: 49
          +3
          Quote: krot
          As we say: "The family has its black sheep!"

          it looks like a big family
          1. Boris55
            Boris55 21 October 2018 08: 06
            +23
            Quote: LSA57
            it looks like a big family

            Yes, not very, about 0,0001% of the total population, they just can’t get out of the screens, and it seems that there are a lot of them. laughing

            In general, no matter what anyone writes, this is an advertisement for this muck. There would not be these articles on the forum, I would not know about that. They brought it once to the attention and okay, but the constant muslin of the same thing - this already leads to bad thoughts.
            1. Arh
              Arh 21 October 2018 21: 20
              +3
              Where is their morality? Conscience? Yes, the same mind? People come to your senses !!!
          2. AlexVas44
            AlexVas44 21 October 2018 09: 44
            +1
            Quote: LSA57
            it looks like a big family

            And, accordingly, they have a lot of freaks. Proportional to the number. fellow
            1. LSA57
              LSA57 21 October 2018 12: 54
              0
              Quote: AlexVas44
              And, accordingly, they have a lot of freaks. Proportional to the number.

              here I am about it. according to a saying
        2. Detective
          Detective 21 October 2018 12: 49
          +9
          Quote: krot
          As we say: "The family has its black sheep!"

          Quote: LSA57
          it looks like a big family

          No, this is not our family! These are random neighbors who hate Russia, the Russian people, our history and the exploits of our ancestors! The heroic defense of Leningrad, the victory in the Great Patriotic War, the feat of the heroes of Panfilov’s and Alexander Matrosov and many, many nameless heroes of the history of our Fatherland stand across their throats because they themselves are not capable of such things! Moreover, realizing their own insignificance, they hate all of us citizens of Russia their lives without Russia not thinking! They need to belittle all of us and humiliate everything in what we believe! They need to monetize all this and make it mercantile! They sincerely do not understand how this young Russian girl Zoya could so proudly and fearlessly look into the face of her tormentors! They cannot understand this because on their knees they would beg for mercy, and with ease and joy would betray everything and everyone! They need to justify themselves, their not even cowardice, but soullessness and therefore they just need to declare Zoya crazy! Not only that - we are all crazy for them! We have a crazy story! Our ancestors defended the country really to the last drop of blood and to the last breath! They don’t understand this! They would sell everything and betray in the dream of Bavarian beer!
          THEY JUST ARE AFRAID OF US! THEY ARE COMPETING AWARE OF THE GREATNESS OF OUR COUNTRY AND OUR PEOPLE!
          What to do with them? We just need to become ourselves! Know who we are! To realize and feel that over Russia the Protection of the Mother of God! We must know that -
          "If there is only one farm for the Russians, then Russia will be reborn too!" Nikolay Gogol
          "I am far from delighted that I see around me ... but I swear on my honor that no matter what in the world I would not want to change my Fatherland or have another history, except for the history of our ancestors, the way God gave it to us!" Alexander Pushkin
          Nature has produced Russia only one. She has no rivals. We are Russian, we will all overcome! Alexander Suvorov
          Our haters, unfortunately, sometimes know better than many of us. They know and therefore are afraid!
        3. siberalt
          siberalt 21 October 2018 13: 03
          0
          During the Second World War, the military comedy "Zhenya, Zhenya and Katyusha" was released. Everyone laughed, so what?
          And how they laughed at "Wedding in Malinovka, although it is about the most terrible civil war? It's not about the genre, but the content. Something like that." winked
          1. Pimply
            Pimply 21 October 2018 14: 21
            +4
            Quote: siberalt

            During the Second World War, the military comedy "Zhenya, Zhenya and Katyusha" was released. Everyone laughed, so what?

            "Zhenya, Zhenechka and Katyusha" came out much later. At the same time, there were enough comedies in the Great Patriotic War - "Two Soldiers", "Heavenly Slow Mover", "Restless Economy"
          2. LSA57
            LSA57 21 October 2018 14: 41
            +1
            Quote: siberalt
            During the Second World War, the military comedy "Zhenya, Zhenya and Katyusha" was released.


            “Zhenya, Zhenechka and Katyusha” - a Soviet color feature filmtragicomedy, shot at the Lenfilm film studio in 1967 by director Vladimir Motyl. The action takes place during the Great Patriotic War (1941-1945). The film tells about the love of an intelligent young man, Zhenya Kolyshkin, an ordinary guard, and the harsh signalman Zhenya Zemlyanikina.
          3. basal
            basal 21 October 2018 16: 16
            +13
            sibiraltu (Oleg)

            Of course, let's laugh!

            Almost a million dead in Leningrad, not so much from bombs and shells as from hunger and cold. Fun!
            You walk along the street, and on the roadsides dead corpses lie. Cool!
            My aunt, God give her health, the girl survived the Blockade. I saw everything myself. Let's invite her, fun, let her laugh.

            What about Stalingrad? Some guys, instead of calmly drinking vodka after the Volga, for some reason, all rushed through the Volga. Died by thousands, in the city not a single whole house was left. Well, aren't they stupid and strange? Let's talk about them like the Simpsons. We will heartily laugh over the wretched!

            Oh yes - Khatyn! Generally expanse for creators!
            Imagine, plumbers from the Sonderkommando Aborigines were introduced to civilization, they were heated. It was a pity the inexperienced were overdone with a gasoline. How many villages did they burn in Belarus?
            Nevermind. But how funny the natives squealed when they burned alive. Scream!

            What are we all about the USSR. And how are there small and narrow-eyed?
            Well, those on which the Great Overseas Uncle conducted the experiment? Laughing, looking what is left of them - body prints on the remains of the walls of Hiroshima and Nagasaki, isn’t it funny? Dali and Picasso could not even think of such a creative - masilki.
            Samurai truths also excelled - 30-40 million Asians (mostly Chinese) chopped. But this is a different story.

            You know, Oleg. That's your business. But it seems to me that in history there are very sore moments when laughter is inappropriate. I don’t argue, you can shoot good and life-affirming films, even seasoned with humor, but very carefully, with understanding and respect for the Memory. Thank!

            PS
            Dear Author, or someone from the Administration. Please correct the title. In Russian, the word "blockade" has several meanings. As applied to Leningrad, Blockade is a proper name and is written exclusively with a capital letter. Looking forward to understanding ...
        4. milton
          milton 21 October 2018 18: 54
          +2
          Quote: krot
          For those who believe that such comedies can be released, let them think about how it would have happened if they had removed Hochma and how their parents are dying .. It would be funny if they were interested?
          As we say: "The family has its black sheep!"

          Seems to me degrots who "expressed" their opinion, quite seriously tell you why not! Think back to the freaks from Charlie Hebdo angry
        5. LeonidL
          LeonidL 22 October 2018 07: 15
          +1
          Listeners of "Echo" with the joy of creative liberalists eat a comedy about the death of their own parents. So what? It's "cool" for them!
      2. Volozhanin
        Volozhanin 21 October 2018 14: 17
        +1
        ehony ...
    2. samarin1969
      samarin1969 21 October 2018 07: 33
      +11
      Quote: 210ox
      We know this "audience" So everything is natural. Fifty moral monsters ..


      Maybe not, and not boors. But definitely strangers. What do they need the suffering of Leningraders and the price of our Victory. The reaction to such "projects" should definitely be no less harsh than to the "caliphate" forbidden to mention.
      1. Pete mitchell
        Pete mitchell 21 October 2018 11: 30
        +4
        Quote: samarin1969
        definitely strangers. What is the suffering of Leningrad residents and the price of our Victory

        And this is precisely the desire to challenge the concept itself our victory and instill doubt into consciousness; then just by the forces of such filmmakers to grow the generation of the discovery channel- what they say is history.
        Quote: samarin1969
        The reaction to such "projects" should definitely be no less harsh than to the "caliphate" forbidden to mention.

        Since the state plays liberalism, citizens will have to “vote in rubles” so that decent people from the film factory shun such projects.
        Many years ago, Yulian Semenov in 'Expansions' clearly outlined what was happening: the housewife does not want to see the horrors of reality, but what we / filmmakers / she will prepare for her will become known through generations as history
    3. Mr Credo
      Mr Credo 21 October 2018 07: 34
      +33
      And where did this audience come from? If this audience becomes larger, then Russia is losing ground more and more! And you have to admit the effectiveness of the Dulles plan. The point is to ridicule the resistance of 1941. Why did they resist in the 41st if they surrendered in the 91st? Would give up then, even earlier would have moved to Mercedes and began to travel abroad! But in fact, in the 90s the country was stupidly surrendered! And many today are insanely happy about this fact. And why, and why then wonder today !? Everything goes according to plan! Many certainly resist this. But the process is inexorably going on. And there is no resistance to it from our leadership. Somehow the news was that someone defended it seems the thesis on the hero of Vlasov. Well, what doubts can there be then? Vlasov hero, Kolchak hero, Mannerheim hero, opponents of the Soviets heroes, Romanov victim! They recognized the Poles as victims of the regime, recognized the work of the Memorial (financed from there) as necessary, opened the board, named the street and the year after the name of the truth-teller. Why are you surprised !?
      1. kitt409
        kitt409 21 October 2018 08: 26
        +3
        Well, not everything is so gloomy, in my opinion, the leadership is really not really torn, but it was not yesterday that they blocked the flow of sorosomania in grants, and the textbooks have changed, and those who teach mainly tell what was, and not what that the main battle of WWII occurred at the atoll of Midway, or at El Alamein, for now that’s enough. but you need to continue and need to expand.
        So what about the fact that "the process is going inexorably" - in my opinion, it is said too much ...
        1. samarin1969
          samarin1969 21 October 2018 08: 38
          +6
          Quote: kitt409
          Yes, and the textbooks have changed

          ... O..oooooooooo! ... Just not about "textbooks" !!! ... There is a complete "echo"! .. wassat wassat belay
          1. kitt409
            kitt409 21 October 2018 10: 26
            +1
            Compared to what WAS - although I admit that once the most odious samples were shown to me)
        2. NordUral
          NordUral 21 October 2018 14: 15
          0
          The textbooks are almost the same, and where did the teachers go, who have those textbooks in their heads?
      2. PalBor
        PalBor 21 October 2018 08: 58
        +15
        For a year now we have been in Ryazan in an orgy of ecstasy over the imminent opening of "the world's largest" Solzhenitsyn museum. Comments are superfluous.
        And he is the largest in the world because no one remembers him in this very world. Worked on the blackening of their homeland, get a nickle on vodka (Nobel) and went out of here.
        1. kitt409
          kitt409 21 October 2018 10: 31
          +4
          We have had a group for many years ... they are eager to erect a monument, and only in the center of the city - Rostov-on-Don, and when their administration sends to the city’s microdistrict, there is a prospectus named after him, they don’t want to, well, so far there is no monument and I don’t need him - in my opinion.
    4. Alexkorzun
      Alexkorzun 21 October 2018 07: 38
      +6
      Quote: 210ox
      We know this "audience" So everything is natural. Fifty moral monsters ..


      There are fifty "God's chosen" freaks!
    5. siberalt
      siberalt 21 October 2018 08: 56
      -15
      At first, the march "Victory Day" was not perceived by many either. And also the song "A platoon is dying near the village of Kryukovo" accompanied by a waltz with a dance. And nothing, everything is gone. And in general, how can you discuss something that you have not seen, heard, tried, touched? As Zhvanetsky said, back in the Soviet years: "Let's argue about the taste of pineapple with those who ate them."winked
      1. Tersky
        Tersky 21 October 2018 11: 20
        +11
        Quote: siberalt
        And in general, how can you discuss something that you have not seen, heard, tried, or felt?

        Another defender of the work of hypocrites and scoundrels?
        Quote: siberalt
        "Let's argue about the taste of pineapple with those who ate it."
        "Holiday" is another rotten "pineapple" with the taste of "Four days in May", "Serving the Soviet Union" and "Bastards". Plots of "pineapples" I will not recall, because they cause vomiting.
      2. NordUral
        NordUral 21 October 2018 14: 14
        +3
        Oleg! You cannot touch the blockade with dirty hands.
      3. The comment was deleted.
    6. StudentVK
      StudentVK 21 October 2018 09: 36
      +4
      Not remembering moral kinship
    7. NEXUS
      NEXUS 21 October 2018 12: 41
      +3
      Quote: 210ox
      We know this "audience" So everything is natural. Fifty moral monsters ..

      These polls Echo of Moscow is a monitoring of the situation and moods in the country, it is known to anyone interesting. In a country where EVERY family was affected by war in one way or another, these figures are like betrayal of their grandfathers.
      As for the film ... so what is it not a mockery of the shrine? So when Pusi Wright shook his slender little bodies on the pulpit of the temple, the whole country was outraged, and here we are discussing something else.
      Give the Cossacks these directors and scriptwriters, so that they unfasten them with their whips, and then drag them to the court by the nostrils.
      Article 214 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation. Defilement can be expressed in mockery of the feelings of believers, generally recognized moral values ​​or historical events. For example: the application of fascist symbols on the monuments dedicated to the participants of the Great Patriotic War or the destruction of religious shrines, burials, mosques, synagogues.
    8. Yura
      Yura 21 October 2018 16: 38
      -1
      Quote: 210ox
      Fifty moral monsters ..

      Fifty-one bottles of the cheapest drunk bums, but what is the result, fifty-one percent!
  2. Zampolitruk
    Zampolitruk 21 October 2018 07: 10
    +21
    It should be noted that only 100 people voted on the phone on the "Echo"

    I hope they have already figured out ..? bully
    "Echo of the State Department" is a vile radio station, a drop of poison drips into the soul of the people every day ..
    Here's another question: "Wouldn't it have been better to surrender Leningrad, would you have saved so many lives?"
    Do you understand how thinly bastards are picking their hearts ..?
    1. 210ox
      210ox 21 October 2018 07: 20
      +19
      Paid losses, what can you take from them. I am more and more convinced that it is better to live in a "not free country", where these characters would be busy. Pushing the ice from the bank of the Lena
      1. Zampolitruk
        Zampolitruk 21 October 2018 07: 35
        +9
        Quote: 210ox
        I am more and more convinced that it is better to live in a "not free country", where these characters would be busy. Pushing the ice away from the Lena bank

        good You are not the only one who thinks so ... The country begins to wake up from the "lawlessness of the 80-90s"
        There is something to compare already, such clickers cruelly deceived us ..
        1. Andrey Yuryevich
          Andrey Yuryevich 21 October 2018 07: 48
          +8
          Quote: Zampolitruk
          ... The country begins to wake up from the "lawlessness of the 80-90s"
          There is something to compare already, such clickers cruelly deceived us ..
          Vitaly, but now is not chaos?
          1. Zampolitruk
            Zampolitruk 21 October 2018 08: 37
            +2
            Quote: Andrey Yurievich
            Vitaly, but now is not chaos?

            Berezovsky, Khodorkovsky, Gusinsky, Abramovich, etc. ... fled, laughing it became a little easier to breathe!
            And how many more secretive ..?
            1. siberalt
              siberalt 21 October 2018 13: 13
              +2
              It can become easier to breathe, but only to those who have not yet escaped, but continue to steal as well as those who escaped.
              Hi Vitaliy! hi
    2. Gardamir
      Gardamir 21 October 2018 08: 38
      +11
      "Echo of the State Department"
      alas you were mistaken, this is an echo of the Kremlin. For the money of the Kremlin and not the State Department.
      1. Vinnibuh
        Vinnibuh 21 October 2018 09: 26
        +5
        That's for sure. Pocket opposition. As in "our" talk shows.
    3. sds87
      sds87 22 October 2018 12: 49
      +1
      Echo is not the State Department, but Gazprom. Gazprom-Media is Echo's main official financier. Foreign funding is quite likely, but there is an official statement from Gazprom-Media, which denies this information.
      http://www.gazprom-media.com/ru/press-release/show?id=1384
      The enemies are already sitting in Russia and doing their job. And then everything is kicked at the US State Department and other foreign "partners".
  3. novobranets
    novobranets 21 October 2018 07: 11
    +27
    Have survived. Regarding the obvious blasphemy to arrange polls, instead of the so-called "director" knocking on the snout properly. Let this figure bequeath to make a comedy about his own funeral, and only to bring their business closer.
    1. ltc35
      ltc35 21 October 2018 07: 38
      +7
      For such, "tapping on the snout" will not help. Send to Magadan. There, people will appreciate the creativity of the director and his actors. By the way, about the cast - successful people, but the brains are clearly not enough. Or are you tired of people's love? ..
      1. novobranets
        novobranets 21 October 2018 09: 58
        +3
        Such "knocking on the snout" will not help. Send to Magadan.
        It's like pounding. And the venue of the event does not matter much, although your option is preferable good
        Or tired of folk love?
        The answer is simple-money.
  4. Andrey Chistyakov
    Andrey Chistyakov 21 October 2018 07: 12
    +6
    Echo Moskvy listeners will say black 99% in white.
    1. Sadko88
      Sadko88 21 October 2018 10: 36
      +5
      I agree. Because of Medinsky, we are losing media space. Can not manage. And I do not believe in his patriotism. Especially his work. Is he really the best of the president’s entourage who can trust her, culture, and trust? Under him, neither culture nor culture propaganda develops. And the moment that the TV channels did not consider it necessary to join the mourning for those who died in Kerch, especially the culture in the media shows.
  5. loginovich
    loginovich 21 October 2018 07: 13
    -3
    They are promoting themselves, then the darkened one will forbid and the rating is again above 100%. Just like with "Death of Stalin"
  6. tatra
    tatra 21 October 2018 07: 14
    +21
    If after World War II the Germans were forcibly turned from anti-people, non-people into normal people, then the enemies of the Communists after the capture of the USSR they forcibly turn normal people into the same as non-people, non-people.
    The enemies of the communists on the territory of the USSR are a "cancerous tumor" of mankind, who rejected many of the rules and values ​​of mankind, who turned out to be capable of such meanness, crimes that no one had ever been capable of in world history before.
  7. Vard
    Vard 21 October 2018 07: 15
    +5
    The boomerang is returning ... I think that soon something similar will be removed about Auschwitz ...
    1. 210ox
      210ox 21 October 2018 07: 29
      +12
      Uh, no! This is a taboo. Here the bonds of comrades from the Middle East can suffer! This is not the tragedy and heroism of the defenders and residents of Leningrad.
      1. Krasnodar
        Krasnodar 21 October 2018 08: 13
        +4
        You read how many Jews died during the siege of Leningrad and how many were among the defenders of the city. And if you think that the Second World War is not a tragedy for us, then look at the statistics on the Soviet Jews who fought and died.
        1. 210ox
          210ox 21 October 2018 17: 47
          +2
          You, fellow countryman, did not understand my commentary. I can imagine HOW MANY Jews died in Leningrad, and indeed at the front defending the Motherland. But they do not fall under the notion of "Holocaust" .. And that means you can mock them by filming something like that. About Auschwitz this is not removed.
    2. Altona
      Altona 21 October 2018 08: 56
      +7
      Quote: Vard
      I think that soon something similar will be removed about Auschwitz ...

      ----------------------------------
      About Sobibor have already removed the shnyaga, where the actors play prisoners with their muzzles and abdomen.
    3. Vinnibuh
      Vinnibuh 21 October 2018 09: 30
      +2
      A hexagonal lobby will not. Or give? Everything depends on dividends, that financial, that political.
      1. Krasnodar
        Krasnodar 21 October 2018 11: 26
        -2
        The Italians took off. It is called "Life is beautiful." I recommend to see.
  8. faiver
    faiver 21 October 2018 07: 17
    +9
    Perhaps one of our readers has a different opinion on this matter.
    - there can be no other opinion with normal moral values ​​by definition ... hi
  9. midshipman
    midshipman 21 October 2018 07: 33
    +23
    I have already suggested that the deputies of the ZKS St. Petersburg sue the director of this libel. He should be judged, deprived of Russian citizenship and executed.
    My father is a major artilleryman. Killed on 27.12. 1941 on the Leningrad front. He created the artillery that did not allow the Nazis at Pulkovo to group even two tanks to attack our positions. My teacher Vekslin I.M. created the first radar station in the USSR, which on September 23, 1941, at a position in B. Izhora, recorded a star raid of 386 Nazi bombers on the KBF and Leningrad. Thanks to the actions of the air defense of the Leningrad Front, the Nazis lost 76 aircraft in three days of these raids. The losses of the Red Army were: one submarine, a tug and the bow of the battleship "Marat" was damaged.
    Here is one deputy of the ZKS SPB at one time sued and the memorial plaque of the fascist mannerheim was removed, which in the glorious city of Leningrad was hanged by the Minister of Culture in 2017 on the rear of the Academy building.
  10. 22 dmdc
    22 dmdc 21 October 2018 07: 34
    +7
    From the echo of matzah, one would expect a survey on the compatibility of black comedy and the Holocaust.
    1. Krasnodar
      Krasnodar 21 October 2018 08: 20
      -8
      I am touched by people for whom the Echo of Moscow and the liberals are associated with Jews. Among the opposition, of course, there are Jews, but the bulk are Russians and other titular nations of the Russian Federation. The funny thing is that 90% of the Russian Jews I know are comfortable with the situation in Russia, but 90% of the non-Jews with whom I speak are not. )) And it doesn’t matter who they are - "liberals", pro - and around - the communists, but they can not be unhappy.
      1. Usher
        Usher 21 October 2018 10: 00
        +6
        It seems to me just the opposite, 90% of Jews are liberals.
        1. Krasnodar
          Krasnodar 21 October 2018 10: 08
          +2
          Quote: Usher
          It seems to me just the opposite, 90% of Jews are liberals.

          If you look at the media - Venediktov, Gozman, Shanderovich - liberals. Soloviev, Satanovsky, Yermolnik - no. You know about conditionally Jews - Gazmanov, Timati, Makarevich.
          My acquaintances are immediate people, mostly businessmen, doctors, lawyers. Everyone is happy, or rather, they don’t bother with politics, preferring to solve the problems and develop professionally.
          1. Altona
            Altona 21 October 2018 12: 02
            +3
            Quote: Krasnodar
            If you look at the media - Venediktov, Gozman, Shanderovich - liberals. Soloviev, Satanovsky, Yermolnik - no. You know about conditionally Jews - Gazmanov, Timati, Makarevich.

            ------------------------------
            Solovyov, Satanovsky-latent Zionists, constant topics are the Middle East, it is necessary to deploy almost the entire army there and "dictate our will to the world" so that Israel can see it better. Solovyov drowns for "statehood" and "against the evil West," which does not prevent him from sitting in his private villa in Italy. Gazmanov and other artistic huskies - these serve any power, change their shoes in the air in whoever you want - patriots, Cossacks, whites. red. Soviet, anti-Soviet. "Ataman. (Apparently Krasnov) Why did you abandon the horse?" and then "I was born in the USSR". Socially low responsibility is evident.
            1. siberalt
              siberalt 21 October 2018 13: 16
              +3
              Why the hell are they latent if they say several times each program that they are Jews and Jews in religious practice? belay
      2. Dart
        Dart 21 October 2018 12: 16
        +4
        and 99% of my friends are not satisfied with the Jews in Russia .. you will be surprised? but 99% of the population IN no, no surprise. The period of living together seems to end, sooner or later.
        1. Altona
          Altona 21 October 2018 12: 41
          +3
          Quote: Dart
          and 99% of my friends are not satisfied with the Jews in Russia .. will this surprise you?

          --------------------------
          Jews, in principle, suit me. It is not the Jews, but the fact that the people of Russia are multinational and their representation should be proportional everywhere-in art, in science, in government, which they tried to do in the USSR. And it turns out that all spheres are captured by ethnic mafia. Culture and media-Jews, trade-Azerbaijanis, catering-Armenians, and so wherever you take it. Then we wonder where that comes from.
        2. Pimply
          Pimply 21 October 2018 13: 11
          -2
          Quote: Dart

          and 99% of my friends are not satisfied with the Jews in Russia .. you will be surprised? but 99% of the population IN no, no surprise. The period of living together seems to end, sooner or later.

          Bad friends are no reason to be proud. How did the predominance of those in Germany who did not like Jews and other nationalities end up? History apparently teaches nothing
          1. Dart
            Dart 21 October 2018 18: 14
            0
            best friends. I didn’t say that they are bad, you said so.
            And Kristallnacht and the defeat of Germany are unrelated things, history has nothing to do with it, they call it "they themselves interrogated."
            And for information, my aunt has a Jewish husband, they both worked in the design bureau in Kaliningrad-2, I respect him and her immensely. But he is like a pearl, which can be said about a number of Soviet Semites.
  11. begemot20091
    begemot20091 21 October 2018 07: 37
    +2
    pangs of creativity "echo"
  12. Mylenef
    Mylenef 21 October 2018 07: 42
    +9
    "you must first watch a comedy, then criticize"
    Those. initially refuse in common sense, and offer to get dirty first?
    And if (even for sure) this dirt is harmful?
  13. universe1
    universe1 21 October 2018 07: 52
    +9
    Collect all these black comedians and their sympathizers and put them on the Leningrad rations of those years for a year, and a year later to conduct a survey.
  14. askort154
    askort154 21 October 2018 08: 24
    +14
    Everything is clear with the director. He is not of Russian blood. My family and I, now we wake up to despise those actors who agreed to star in this "comedy".
  15. anjey
    anjey 21 October 2018 08: 25
    +5
    Imbicillas from cinema, the US State Department and the British Parliament are constantly throwing ideas for "black comedies" to you, some creaked what they cost ...
  16. XXXIII
    XXXIII 21 October 2018 08: 26
    +13
    Is comedy compatible with blockade? Listeners of "Echo of Moscow" distinguished themselves
    Vile mediocrity and complete lack of brains .... hi
    During the years of the siege of Leningrad, people did not think and did not divide themselves into belonging to either side; they survived by drawing water from the Neva. But there were traitors even in those days and they were less fortunate, the current jesters were also not very lucky, history did not add brains .....
    "The Siege of Leningrad" Unique Documentary. Director Sergei Loznitsa
  17. Million
    Million 21 October 2018 08: 29
    +8
    In the USSR, the director would have been imprisoned for such a comedy. Now everything is possible ....
    1. anjey
      anjey 21 October 2018 08: 40
      +9
      I don’t know about everything, but let these creatives try to film "an orgy in the Kremlin, the Yeltsin period" - then you understand they miss the poor ...
    2. Rostislav
      Rostislav 21 October 2018 11: 26
      +3
      in the USSR it would simply not exist.
    3. Pimply
      Pimply 21 October 2018 13: 09
      -3
      Quote: Million
      In the USSR, the director would have been imprisoned for such a comedy. Now everything is possible ....


      No, I wouldn't have been. Because in the USSR they shot comedies about the war and were not particularly afraid of it. Sometimes, thanks to this, real masterpieces appeared, such as "Zhenya, Zhenechka and Katyusha"
  18. Dimy4
    Dimy4 21 October 2018 08: 34
    +5
    Military Review decided not to conduct such a survey, since it believes that the very discussion of the compatibility or incompatibility of the director’s creative work in the comedy genre with the tragedy of Leningrad and the whole country is already something inappropriate.

    I absolutely agree that I already noted in the comments on this topic. And these creative guys need to try at the funeral, for example, to go to a neighbor's dance or start to joke on funny jokes. What interesting reaction will relatives?
  19. Terenin
    Terenin 21 October 2018 08: 47
    +16
    The Echo of Moscow radio station decided ...
    Yes, this Russophobic structure itself did not decide anything. It operates in strict accordance with the instructions of the Anglo-Saxon "information war headquarters" with Russia. Only, there is practically no reaction of our committees of the legislative assemblies of the regions and the Federation Council of the Russian Federation, all kinds of departments and directorates to counter new challenges and threats, under the ministries there is practically no. We have inf.the war, and "our" liberals, in the specified departments, play with them (Ehi, doggies, bulkheads ...) at democracy.
    As a result, they may scream again that the Russian revolt is the most senseless and merciless. Only it was never meaningless.
  20. The Siberian barber
    The Siberian barber 21 October 2018 08: 50
    +7
    It should be noted that only 100 people voted on the Echo telephone.

    ... and 95 people. of this amount, was Venediktov laughing
    Here are the ghouls: why continue to "chew" this topic ?! am
  21. Maclay
    Maclay 21 October 2018 09: 14
    +8
    I listened to "Echo of Tel Aviv" like that .. Sheer malice, giggling, malicious hatred of Russia ...
    You can, of course, cover up this "dental office", but it's better not "you need to know the enemies by barking and howling" (just kidding!)
  22. Altona
    Altona 21 October 2018 09: 25
    +3
    A rental certificate not to give this movie hat and all business. Beat financially only. By the way, Soviet cinema was orders of magnitude more profitable than the current one, with ticket prices no more than 20 kopecks and no advertising for "related products". And now in the network of channels there are multiplying channels that shamelessly exploit Soviet cinema - Favorite cinema, Rodnoe cinema, Dom Kino, Moscow-Doverie, Zvezda.
    1. kitt409
      kitt409 21 October 2018 10: 39
      -1
      As for profitability, you forget that at that time there was no competitor that the Internet ...
      1. Altona
        Altona 21 October 2018 11: 55
        0
        Quote: kitt409
        As for profitability, you forget that at that time there was no competitor that the Internet ...

        -----------------------
        So what? Well, now there are all sorts of competitors, but what's the use of these "competitors"?
        1. kitt409
          kitt409 21 October 2018 16: 13
          0
          Didn't you write that in the days of the USSR, cinema was profitable, despite the price of a ticket of 20 cents?
          SO THERE IS NOW ON THE INTERNET, which was not in the times of the USSR, and except in the cinema then there was nowhere to watch a movie either - now there is, in the internet, a house on the couch, that's all)
          1. oldzek
            oldzek 21 October 2018 17: 25
            +3
            an amazing thing! good Soviet films ALL TV channels drive into the night, and day and early evening such turbidity. as for this echo, but they want in the blessed 90s that I remember only obscenely. about the Jews my father said that there are Jews and there are .i.d.y. for a Jew he would give his remaining leg, and f.i.d. is in any people .and I agree with him.
            1. kitt409
              kitt409 21 October 2018 18: 04
              -1
              I'm embarrassed to ask, what prevents this from "fighting" in the most elementary way - just write down what you need?)
  23. Maclay
    Maclay 21 October 2018 09: 28
    +4
    In general, in Russia, as far as I have noticed, immunity has developed to such provocations of liberalists .. In the 90s, I read enough and saw enough of the tonsils. It's time to collect stones and such provocateurs from "Echo of Israel", we have already learned to despise and not touch them and it greatly enrages them .. Because they so dream of becoming a "victim of a bloody regime" ha ha ha
    We read men and analyze ..Now there is something to compare with the older generation, but for the souls of youth you need to fight ..! And then how it will turn out from the USSR to destroy our children and grandchildren from the inside .. Although the generation is growing, it’s not bad and understands EVERYTHING already!
    1. Krasnodar
      Krasnodar 21 October 2018 11: 34
      +1
      Vitaly, write from two accounts? )))
      Creative
    2. Altona
      Altona 21 October 2018 11: 56
      -1
      Quote: Maclay
      We read men and analyze

      --------------------------
      Vitaly, finish virtually "multiplying". laughing
  24. Vkd dvk
    Vkd dvk 21 October 2018 10: 28
    +4
    The author of this CRIME (I can not name otherwise), received financial assistance for his craft. It would be nice to follow the monetary movements in his address and deal with assistants. In Russian. Unfortunately, this is not available to me. To trace. And I could participate in the disassembly.
  25. Rostislav
    Rostislav 21 October 2018 11: 15
    +4
    Only one question - who came up with the idea to call such moral monsters "creative directors"?
    This is how the "Overton windows" open. It seems like they are scolding, but the topic continues to be discussed, and even the creators of this mockery are ranked among creative people.
    1. The Siberian barber
      The Siberian barber 21 October 2018 11: 27
      +3
      Quote: Rostislav
      Only one question - who came up with the idea to call such moral monsters "creative directors"?
      This is how the "Overton windows" open. It seems like they are scolding, but the topic continues to be discussed, and even the creators of this mockery are ranked among creative people.

      All this reminds, feeding a child with porridge that he hates, through his teeth. After all, what is happening on TV and in cinema does not have a request from the bulk of society. But, for some reason, this horror continues for us (for the most part)
    2. japs
      japs 21 October 2018 12: 21
      +5
      Dear Rostislav, the definition of "creative" has long been negative. And now it applies to many types of activities. "Kreakly" is now everywhere. Especially among "managers" from culture, administration and so on. In Belarus, the forge of "creative managers" is the Academy of Management under the President. The most ridiculous decisions, including personnel decisions, are made by these "creakles"
      An example is the "pension reform" imposed on us, "a scientifically grounded increase in utility tariffs," "the cost of energy resources." Further, we should probably expect the introduction of taxes on beards, an air tax ...
      This bacchanalia is mainly connected with the fact that leading positions are occupied by people from the "ilitarny" ruling circles, who are not at all burdened with good education and intelligence. For 25 years, the concept of "blat" has not at all become obsolete in our society.
      1. Rostislav
        Rostislav 21 October 2018 15: 07
        +3
        I am from Minsk myself with the "miracle" that the Academy of Management is producing. One of these "managers" came to me. Didn't last long.
  26. mikh-korsakov
    mikh-korsakov 21 October 2018 12: 03
    +6
    I would force the author of this film to change the scene from the besieged Leningrad to the territory occupied by the Nazis (for example, in Peterhof, and make Mr. Venediktov, Kudrin, Gozman, Albats and other characters as his heroes (as if they were transported in a time machine, like in the movie "--- from the future"). etc. That would be great.
    1. anjey
      anjey 21 October 2018 12: 14
      +1
      Black comedy about the Holocaust, it remains to remove these hoopoe ...
      1. Pimply
        Pimply 21 October 2018 13: 03
        -2
        Quote: anjey

        Black comedy about the Holocaust, it remains to remove these hoopoe ...

        If you don't know - they shot it, Oscar for the best foreign film, great movie. "Life is Beautiful" by Roberto Benigni. There was a place for everything - drama, humor, and good cinema
  27. Pimply
    Pimply 21 October 2018 13: 02
    -4
    Bronzing is never beneficial to anyone or anything. It is for this reason that from the fact that it was filmed on all the pseudo-patriotic templates about the war, in fact there are no films that can be revised again.

    About War, about the blockade, about the Holocaust, you can and should shoot comedies, farces, vaudeville, whatever, as long as it was all really good movies. Examples of mass and in the Soviet cinema, and in the world.

    Roberto Benigni "Life is Beautiful" - a comedy about the Holocaust. With tears, with pain, with tragedy. But comedy.
    "Zhenya, Zhenya and Katyusha" - a comedy about the Great Patriotic War
    "Suitable for non-combatant", "Heavenly slug", "Country trip of Sergeant Tsybuli", "Restless economy" - USSR
    "Uncle Adolf, nicknamed the Fuhrer", "Big Walk" with Defunes, "The Great Dictator Chaplin" - comedy about the war, the Blockade, all this can and should be filmed.

    And the bombastic bronze does for the War one evil deed - it turns a real feat, a real tragedy and a real life into splints.
    1. tank64rus
      tank64rus 21 October 2018 19: 06
      +1
      It’s time to make a comedy about Chernobyl, but what about it. Just before you allow these idiots to shoot, you need to shoot them in a trench full of dirt, firing blanks mixed with live ammunition, running around in a tank, crawling to eat a pot mixed with earth, etc. Who served will understand. And only then allow to make a film.
  28. bmv04636
    bmv04636 21 October 2018 13: 09
    +2
    and the black comedy about the Holocaust at the type of rezerer does not want to remove or sykatno
    1. Pimply
      Pimply 21 October 2018 14: 17
      -4
      Quote: bmv04636
      and the black comedy about the Holocaust at the type of rezerer does not want to remove or sykatno
      I advise you to watch the film by Roberto Benigni "Life is Beautiful". This is an Oscar-winning black comedy about the Holocaust
      1. Referent
        Referent 21 October 2018 17: 09
        +4
        This film is European .... The French cried when the Germans walked around Paris ...... and ..... EVERYTHING .... Then the Fritz ate croissants on the boulevards with the Parisians and discussed Picasso ..... time in the USSR .... burned people in locked barns whole villages. And here is the question - how are Fritz treated in Europe, but how in Russia!
  29. Strategia
    Strategia 21 October 2018 15: 12
    +5
    It’s interesting, how heated we are discussing things that in the previous (Soviet) years were absolutely incompatible with the norms of HUMAN morality!
    1. siberalt
      siberalt 21 October 2018 19: 27
      0
      And how does morality differ from morality in concept? belay
      1. Strategia
        Strategia 22 October 2018 20: 57
        0
        Nuances:
        Morality (lat. Moralitas, from lat. Mores “generally accepted traditions”) - accepted in society ideas about good and bad, right and wrong, good and evil.
        Morality is the moral quality of a person, certain rules that guide a person in his choice.
  30. Referent
    Referent 21 October 2018 17: 05
    +3
    Interesting is the age of the scoundrel-director and, accordingly, his education .... Having highlighted this data, everything will fall into place.
  31. Referent
    Referent 21 October 2018 17: 12
    +3
    That's interesting ... to shoot a "black comedy" about how Hitler still took Great Britain and publicly "fucked" the Queen? Did you like this movie (by European standards) in Europe ???
  32. kunstkammer
    kunstkammer 21 October 2018 17: 30
    +4
    combining black comedy with a blockade theme

    Given the predominance of a certain nationality in the staff of this station and its listeners, I would like to know their attitude to the creation of a black comedy on the Holocaust?
    And how “wonderful” it would be to laugh, looking at how funny children and women get confused in their underpants undressing in front of the machine guns of the fascists in Babi Yar ... Isn't it, gentlemen Venediktov, Shenderovich, Latynina and other evil spirits?
    Ugh on you!
  33. APASUS
    APASUS 21 October 2018 17: 37
    +3
    Yes, democracy has flourished with pluralism of opinion!
    Previously (under the USSR) one could sit down for a joke, but now they are making cabarets from the besieged Leningrad.
  34. faterdom
    faterdom 21 October 2018 18: 42
    +1
    More than 20 thousand Echo listeners voted through the Internet

    There are about so many of them in general. And even among them there are only 34% complete mutants. But then they are contenders for the expression of "public opinion". Only who appointed them there is unknown.
  35. DPN
    DPN 21 October 2018 18: 45
    +1
    It was impossible in the USSR, now for money and for the sake of money, it is possible EVERYTHING is the goal of today's Russian,
  36. kunstkammer
    kunstkammer 21 October 2018 18: 46
    +1
    Quote: Terenin
    This Russophobic structure did not decide anything. It acts in strict accordance with the instructions.

    it’s just the mouthpiece of one of the towers of the Kremlin. Where their patrons dug in.
  37. tank64rus
    tank64rus 21 October 2018 18: 59
    0
    This is beyond ideological liberals. have come to the end. The rest is incorrect Russian.
  38. 16112014nk
    16112014nk 21 October 2018 19: 43
    0
    51 two-legged creatures with the letter "M" on "Echo"
  39. Petr_Smirnov
    Petr_Smirnov 21 October 2018 19: 54
    0
    Check for lice.
  40. nikvic46
    nikvic46 21 October 2018 20: 08
    +1
    Let the directors of this film go hungry for twenty days, and we laugh.
  41. perm23
    perm23 22 October 2018 05: 38
    0
    well, they won’t make a black comedy about the life of blacks in the United States. and how the KU-Ku clan burned them.
    1. The comment was deleted.
  42. lukewarm
    lukewarm 22 October 2018 12: 38
    0
    I expected something like that. I myself learned about the "film" from a friend's news on VK, where he criticizes the future "masterpiece". All waited - when will Yeho check in. Well. It is done. How to evaluate - HZ. Even!!! among THIS audience, 58% are still against. Echo in its own style - "tolerantly" discussed whether it is possible to dance on the graves or not. IMHO the correct position at VO
    the discussion of the compatibility or incompatibility of the director’s creative work in the comedy genre with the tragedy of Leningrad and the whole country is already something inappropriate.
  43. Al_lexx
    Al_lexx 22 October 2018 14: 49
    0
    I had to ask a question, on the live broadcast of the "echo of matzah", what they think about the new movie-buff-comedy on the Holocaust theme, in which little Moishe didn’t stand by screwing his head to his toy Golem, as his parents were called into the shower, in Auschwitz?
    Something tells me. that in this place all their tolerance would end and the process of violent defecation would begin. ;)
  44. Anchonsha
    Anchonsha 22 October 2018 18: 30
    0
    Well this is idiocy. Such voting could be organized by not quite normal people. These are boobs from the Echo of Moscow. Moscow, listen to people, and the head is the first to start to stink when it spoils
  45. Russian
    Russian 23 October 2018 01: 14
    0
    What are they thinking of laughing there?
  46. mr_Flint
    mr_Flint 23 October 2018 02: 17
    0
    exactly. I didn’t watch the film, but I condemn it.