Military Review

On the blockade of Leningrad, they decided to shoot the comedy "Holiday". The sleep of reason ...

134
On the platform "Planeta.ru," accumulating funds for the implementation of various projects, posted a message about the project director Alexei Krasovsky. The project expects from sympathizers the collection of 1,5 million rubles as a means to create a film about besieged Leningrad. Very specific.


The director of all the plots about the Great Patriotic War decided to choose a plot about how in the “secrecy” mode the Leningrad family, which was in a “special position”, met the New Year offensive. The tape is conceived under the name "Holiday".



The author, who posted a message about the project on Planet.ru, did not hesitate to state that this is a film that will carry the genre (attention!) Of the black comedy.

From the statement of Mr. Krasovsky:
The whole “Holiday” action takes place in one place, and (...) for one night (from December 31 to January 1). Heroes in the frame - six, and behind the scenes, only one (but what!). And it is not terrible to admit this, but this is a comedy, sometimes black, but more often light and new year.

Applied to the material historical certificate of what kind of diet was supposed to be ordinary residents of the besieged Leningrad and, for example, for the instructor of the personnel department of the city committee of the CPSU (b) Nikolai Ribkovsky. His excerpts from diaries are given in which he writes that he ate for breakfast, lunch, dinner - reports about meatballs and stewed cabbage, vermicelli and porridge with butter and sweet tea.

The topic of food in besieged Leningrad is a difficult historical topic. It has been repeatedly discussed by historians and politicians. But what kind of “creative approach” should one have in order to declare a desire to remove a “black comedy” on this topic, also with the name “Holiday”?

There were no other topics for splashing out the creative potential in the comedy genre, except as an event in the besieged Leningrad, by the “artist” in no way?

From the material:
Most of the work has already been done. A suitable object was found, all the necessary equipment was prepared, the casting is now completed, and costumes and props are selected. Already this fall we are planning to start shooting. In winter, the film should be ready.


As users of the site "Planeta.ru," responded to the call for fund-raising for this "Holiday" - a few comments:

You need to go to France, Krasovsky! With Pavlensky live in the same ward, for you are completely frostbite


And about the Holocaust do not want to shoot a black comedy? BUT?..
Photos used:
https://planeta.ru/campaigns/91163/
134 comments
Ad

Subscribe to our Telegram channel, regularly additional information about the special operation in Ukraine, a large amount of information, videos, something that does not fall on the site: https://t.me/topwar_official

Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. Law abiding citizen
    Law abiding citizen 13 October 2018 11: 51
    +45
    Indeed, some sort of dream of reason ... No words. Literary ...
    1. The comment was deleted.
    2. Sandor Clegane
      Sandor Clegane 13 October 2018 12: 21
      +54
      Quote: Law Abiding Citizen
      No words. Literary ..

      it must be taken out on May 9 in St. Petersburg to the Admiralty, give a matyugalnik in your hands and made to talk about your film and about money (donations) ..... I think the Leningraders will simply drown him in the Neva
      1. 210ox
        210ox 13 October 2018 12: 23
        +23
        Stalin Joseph Vissarionovich is not on these ..
        1. Tatyana
          Tatyana 13 October 2018 13: 07
          +44
          We must not allow the liberal cynic Alexei Krasovsky — a offspring born in Nizhny Novgorod, who had never sniffed the Leningrad blockade in his family — to swing Russia now and spit in our history.
          For it is precisely such - MORAL PERFORMANCE - films of the liberal Russian TRAITORS-scriptwriters who just find their political admirers and PR patrons abroad, sticking out on the 1-th plan of moral freaks and leveling the historical feat of the ALL SOVIET people.

          Krasovsky, apparently, is not enough demolition of military monuments and the demolition of cemetery graves of Soviet soldiers-liberators of Europe from German fascism during WWII abroad ?! He clearly wants to EXCEPT everything else in the historical memory of people about the heroism of the Soviet past in our country.

          There is no and cannot be any moral justification for such a project of the black comedy by Alexei Krasovsky about the besieged Leningrad!
          1. zhekazs
            zhekazs 13 October 2018 17: 59
            +4
            Quote: Tatiana
            There is no and cannot be any moral justification for such a project of the black comedy by Alexei Krasovsky about the besieged Leningrad!

            The worst thing is that there will be sponsors of this black project, and what is even sadder, including among Leningraders, already the grandchildren of the blockade who grew up after the USSR, listen to some, it sometimes seems that the Maidan happened in our country, there are some, we met. People with some kind of altered consciousness. You don't have to go far for an example, you just have to remember the Field of Mars. The only good news is that the majority nevertheless adequately remembers and honors their own and their country's history. And "that" - every Krasovsky-Pavlensky, but God will judge them ...
            1. Vasilenko Vladimir
              Vasilenko Vladimir 13 October 2018 18: 18
              +7
              Quote: zhekazs
              The worst part is that there are sponsors for this black project

              55 rogues have already been found, though they collected only 127
            2. Shurik70
              Shurik70 13 October 2018 18: 21
              +5
              This is not a dream of Reason. This is a dream of conscience.
              Brother from "Charlie". There he belongs.
              I hope it will not live long in Russia.
              1. Vasilenko Vladimir
                Vasilenko Vladimir 13 October 2018 18: 28
                +18
                Quote: Shurik70
                This is a dream of conscience

                she has not been there since birth
                I don’t know how to joke about it
                1. Arh
                  Arh 13 October 2018 18: 49
                  +4
                  And where is the mind ???
                  1. Vasilenko Vladimir
                    Vasilenko Vladimir 13 October 2018 19: 39
                    +3
                    Quote: Arh
                    And where is the mind ???

                    not allowed
                  2. Zubr
                    Zubr 13 October 2018 20: 18
                    +1
                    And where is the mind ???

                    Well, it is not in vain that there is an opinion that if the Lord decided to punish someone, he takes away the mind of these people.
                    1. aybolyt678
                      aybolyt678 14 October 2018 00: 18
                      +4
                      Quote: Zubr
                      Well, it is not in vain that there is an opinion that if the Lord decided to punish someone, he takes away the mind of these people.

                      it would be better to deprive money, it would sober them up
                    2. Talgat
                      Talgat 15 October 2018 12: 09
                      +3
                      Unfortunately, all these liberals have a mind. And very poisonous. And is aimed at serving our opponents in order to denigrate history, desecrate exploits, and leave us nothing to be proud of.

                      Found poems of our akyn Jambul
                      LENINGRADS, MY CHILDREN!

                      Jambul

                      Leningrad, my children!
                      The people of Leningrad, my pride!
                      To me in the stream of a steppe stream
                      The reflection of the Neva jet is visible.
                      If along the snow ridges
                      With a senile gaze, I glide
                      I see the vaults of your bridges,
                      The light of the Baltic blue,
                      Lanterns of evening swarms,
                      The gilded roofs of the point ...
                      Leningrad, my children!
                      The people of Leningrad, my pride!

                      Not then I lived,
                      That the robber smell stink;
                      It was not you, brothers, who served,
                      To climb a creeping reptile
                      The city is fabulous, in the city-garden;
                      Not then to Leningrad
                      Look Dzhambula charmed!
                      And then I lived in the world,
                      To the rabble Fascist thugs,
                      Not having had time to recoil back,
                      His wolf bones folded
                      Your sacred fences.
                      That's why the north run
                      Kazakhstan rail tracks,
                      That's why the Neva is protected
                      Your embankments edge,
                      Leningrad people, my children,
                      The people of Leningrad, my pride,
                      Your grandfathers remember Jambul,
                      Your great-grandfathers remembers:
                      They were exiled to his village,
                      And he heard a ringing in the shackle.
                      Having survived the four kings,
                      I have experienced their ferocity;
                      I wanted to fall fast
                      Their Petersburg fortress;
                      I'm under the roar of my string
                      Vospel, already turning gray,
                      The terrible course of the Baltic wave,
                      Where national anger was boiling.
                      It's in your slender houses
                      A glimpse of Lenin's word-rays
                      Played for the first time in the dark!
                      It's yours, and more nobody's,
                      The first onslaught of his speeches
                      And his hands first swing!
                      Your best machine tools gifts
                      Kirov brought us for a reason:
                      We are related to you from a long time,
                      Closer than 6rat, closer to the sister
                      Leningrad Alma-Ata.
                      It is no coincidence that the Baltic Fleet,
                      Glorious courage of two centuries,
                      Seafarers' delegations
                      Sends to Kazakhstan annually,
                      And no wonder their sons
                      From a young age to training we
                      Helmet to the Neva, to the basis of the basics,
                      Where, when men are married, minds are ripening.
                      What does Jambul hear now?
                      To you a steel door breaks,
                      Like an eternity hungry -
                      Distressed by losses
                      Many-headed greedy ...
                      He will die at your outposts!
                      Without teeth and without scales
                      There will be a snake in the croaks!
                      The nightingales will sing again,
                      Will be free our family,
                      Leningrad people, my children,
                      The people of Leningrad, my pride!
                      • • • •
                      Leningrad is stronger and more formidable,
                      Than in any of the previous years:
                      He is ready to reflect the pressure!
                      Do not split his stones,
                      Do not trample its gardens.
                      To Leningrad from all angles
                      Trains are sent,
                      See off their fighters
                      Our villages and cities.
                      The eyes of the country are storm-lead,
                      And I'm ready to bridle
                      To the rascally scoundrels.
                      From the depths of the Kazakh land
                      The rivers of oil flowed to you,
                      Black coal, red copper
                      And lead, that in time and in the opposite direction
                      The song of death is ready to sing.
                      Gangs, rushing to Leningrad.
                      Bread in a grain heavy as a fraction
                      With lead goes on a par.
                      Our best horses are offspring,
                      Piles of apples as sweet as honey
                      That should all help you.
                      Soul slings away.
                      Do not visit them in our homes!
                      Do not get fat on our raw materials!
                      • • • •
                      There are big battles,
                      But there will not be enemies of life!
                      I can’t sleep today ...
                      Let the help be, friends,
                      Songs to you on, my dawn,
                      Leningrad people, my children,
                      The people of Leningrad, my pride!

                      September 1941
                      Translation from Kazakh M. Tarkovsky


                      Russian translation (in abbreviation) of the improvisation song of the great Kazakh akyn Jambul (1846-1945).
                  3. The comment was deleted.
                2. basal
                  basal 13 October 2018 20: 34
                  +16
                  The creepy diary of Tanya Savicheva ...
                  And I have an aunt, God grant her health and many years, survived the Blockade at Tanya's age. He doesn’t tell anything, but if sometimes, under a glass, believe me, it’s better not to hear this Horror ...
                  Do you know the peculiarity of the Leningrad-blockade? They are unable to throw away food.
                  Moldy bread? Scraped off. Fried crackers. Fearfully...
                3. not main
                  not main 13 October 2018 21: 21
                  +1
                  Quote: Vasilenko Vladimir
                  Quote: Shurik70
                  This is a dream of conscience

                  she has not been there since birth
                  I don’t know how to joke about it

                  I gave you a plus ... I just don't know how to respond to such messages! Everything is correct, but at the same time very tragic! And if someone “seems” to be “comical” then God is their judge! By the way, for the judges did not grow up, but in the executioners with pleasure!
                  1. Vasilenko Vladimir
                    Vasilenko Vladimir 13 October 2018 21: 32
                    +4
                    Quote: non-primary
                    And if someone “seems” to be “comical” then God is their judge!

                    first you need to condemn them here, and only after the verdict may God understand
                  2. aybolyt678
                    aybolyt678 14 October 2018 00: 20
                    +2
                    Quote: non-primary
                    And if someone “seems” to be “comical” then God is their judge!

                    It would be good if the judges not only have God, but also a state with an article and the prosecutor’s grandson of the blockade.
            3. The comment was deleted.
        2. Ros 56
          Ros 56 13 October 2018 15: 28
          -2
          And what are you only pounding on the clave?
        3. Vasilenko Vladimir
          Vasilenko Vladimir 13 October 2018 17: 25
          +4
          Quote: 210ox
          Stalin Joseph Vissarionovich is not on these ..

          it would be in the 80s in the fool for this rolled up
      2. Rav Rav
        Rav Rav 13 October 2018 13: 05
        +9
        No, it’s not necessary in the Neva;
      3. Compasure
        Compasure 13 October 2018 14: 59
        +2
        I think the Leningraders simply drown him in the Neva

        And it will be divine, humane!
        1. Vasilenko Vladimir
          Vasilenko Vladimir 13 October 2018 18: 29
          +1
          Quote: Compasure
          And it will be divine, humane!

          but enough for her
      4. CALL.
        CALL. 13 October 2018 15: 40
        +14
        The author, who posted a message about the project on Planet.ru, did not hesitate to state that this is a film that will carry the genre (attention!) Of the black comedy.

        Cinema has always been one of the most powerful levers of influence on public consciousness. Many countries have repeatedly used it to promote their political doctrines. Throughout the Cold War, the countries of the West and the socialist bloc have repeatedly resorted to this lever in order to consolidate the negative view of each other among the masses. Even after the end of the cold confrontation between the superpowers, Russians in the Western consciousness continued to remain bloodthirsty villains. The most disgusting thing is that the same films are shot by Russian directors with Russian money. In these films, Russia (the USSR) appears to be a real Mordor, who spread rot and humiliate his citizens in every possible way, constantly arresting someone (of course innocent), forbid them to marry and treat sick relatives abroad, Russians constantly drink vodka and fight.
        How long will all sorts of moral hoaxes-anti-sovietists be cast out over the people and their history, and for our money?
    3. Ross_ulair
      Ross_ulair 13 October 2018 12: 22
      +20
      And about the Holocaust, do you want to make a black comedy?

      That's really ... What would they, people with fair faces, about their comedy story not shoot?
      1. Pirogov
        Pirogov 13 October 2018 12: 28
        +14
        Quote: ROSS_Ulair
        That's really ... What would they, people with fair faces, about their comedy story not shoot?

        Yes, these plague try throne, stink and howl will be for a decade. But it would not hurt to plant the director and we need to end up with liberal politics, and so all sorts of (CRANESHEINS) sat down on their heads ..........
        1. mole
          mole 13 October 2018 13: 14
          +7
          Quote: Pirogov
          Yes, these plague try throne, stink and howl will be for a decade.

          If you forgive, do not expect good.
          Therefore, indeed, for a long time "it is necessary to finish"!
          1. zhekazs
            zhekazs 13 October 2018 18: 09
            +1
            Quote: Mole
            If you forgive, do not expect good.

            Yeah, I’ll support it. It is time to punish one such dirty trick, in all severity, if you wish, you can easily draw this desecration of the memory of the victims of the Blockade and find an article. It would be a body ...
            And the cries of foreign and local liberals sang along with us a long time ago - immunity was developed by the people, they filled up sanctions and didn’t die, one more, one less ....
            1. mole
              mole 13 October 2018 19: 17
              +1
              Quote: zhekazs
              It is time to punish one such dirty trick, in all severity, if you wish, you can easily draw this desecration of the memory of the victims of the Blockade and find an article. It would be a body ...

              I agree, absolutely necessary! But there is no need to look for an article on purpose, administrative and social levers are quite enough. If such an attitude of individual individuals will be condemned by society as unconventional, then those who wish to express their "special" so-called. less will be.
              1. zhekazs
                zhekazs 13 October 2018 19: 39
                +4
                Quote: Mole
                quite enough administrative and social leverage.

                I believe that a "soft influence" on such a person will not have any effect, will not give a result, a relapse will be even worse and disgusting. It is necessary immediately, to the fullest extent.
                Quote: Mole
                But do not look for an article specifically

                And what to look for, we also have criminal liability for desecrating the memory of the victims of the Second World War. It’s just that it is unlikely that those in power will even bring this scum to court, fearing further sanctions and tantrums from the west. And it would be necessary, indicatively and instructively for all other liberals, to condemn one thing and thereby show that you guys have played up to your Western values ​​to the point that you did not notice how you have completely scraped ...
                Quote: Mole
                will be condemned by society as unconventional

                Well, and in our country there are few of these LGBT people after such public moral censure? They climb even more out of their skin - give them a parade to hold and to influence the minds of minors.
                Any infection must be crushed in the root:
                Quote: zhekazs
                I suppose, however, that this product is not only of our era. Weeds need to weed. The Second World War and the years of Stalin's reign are confirmation of this - about traitors and agents, various pests are by no means invented.
                1. mole
                  mole 13 October 2018 19: 44
                  +3
                  Administrative levers are sometimes worse than criminal ones. Hit this "passenger" on the pocket and other "hares" will immediately realize that you have to pay for the trip!
                  And if necessary, you can always create conditions under which the good of the Fatherland will begin to think!
                  1. zhekazs
                    zhekazs 13 October 2018 20: 04
                    +1
                    Quote: Mole
                    Hit this "passenger" pocket

                    That's what you are talking about ... I agree, for those who don’t smell like money, and the character being discussed among them, pocket is the most painful place. And let the whole Petersburg file lawsuits against him, he will be provided with a life-long total debt.
                    1. mole
                      mole 13 October 2018 20: 37
                      +2
                      Quote: zhekazs
                      I agree, for those who do not smell like money, and the character under discussion of such, a pocket is the most painful place. And let the whole Petersburg file lawsuits against him, he will be provided with a life-long total debt.

                      In, in, and I'm talking about too. Why "this" at the expense of taxpayers to feed in the "zone"?
    4. Detective
      Detective 13 October 2018 13: 05
      +19
      If the article is true, then this is what I want to say. This is not a dream of reason! This phenomenon has another name - demonic! This is a mockery of demons over the feelings of people! 872 days of the siege of Leningrad went down in the history of the Second World War as the most tragic events. At the Nuremberg trials, the Soviet side announced 630 deaths during the blockade, but there are other studies on this issue and the figure is likely much higher! This is a tragedy for our people, but for the demons, of course, a holiday! Dance on bones and on human grief! Why have they lost their fear ?! Why can't they laugh at the horrific tragedy in the history of the USSR? After all, they may not respect the feelings of tens of millions of Orthodox believers in Russia! And not only in Russia, but all over the world filming the disgusting film "Matilda". After all, not only the religious feelings of believers are violated there, but also the Russian statehood itself! This apotheosis of vulgarity insults the patriotic feelings of the Russians! Today they laughed at the revered saint of the Tsar Passion-Bearer, tomorrow at the defenders of Leningrad, the day after tomorrow ... We are all very different. There are monarchists and communists, non-partisans, believers and not ... But if we are Russians, then we should not allow mockery of our great history! Over the feat of our compatriots, over our saints! Because otherwise we won't have tomorrow because there will be nothing sacred! There is a very interesting expression in monasticism - to pick up a passenger. Those. devil! Today, whole buses are scurrying through the streets of our cities carrying "passengers" who spit in our souls, walking on their dirty paws into our houses and churches! How long are compatriots ?! Can we remember that we are a great and glorious people, not inventing, but making history ?! By our silence and connivance, we lose ourselves and dishonor our great ancestors!
      1. mole
        mole 13 October 2018 16: 04
        +10
        Quote: Detective
        Today we laughed at Tsar the Passion-bearer revered saint, tomorrow at the defenders of Leningrad, the day after tomorrow ... We are all very different.

        As for the Passion-Bearer King ... indeed "we are all very different." I never recognize him as a saint, as well as a number of others who in our time would be called bandits. Nicholas II was appointed saints. What followed the execution of the Romanov family was only the destruction of the followers of the monarchy. Most of the clergy were her followers.
        As for the "passengers", you are really right, but these characters are not "buses", but just these characters consider themselves passengers in Our state. You don't have to pay for the fare, you can leave at any time.
        1. Detective
          Detective 14 October 2018 11: 19
          +2
          I regret that I could not answer you yesterday, but in this case it is better late than never! You also unfortunately just did not understand what I said! No one asks you to recognize the king as a saint or not, just as they do not require you to believe in God! This is your personal affair and from this multimillion-dollar Orthodox flock it is neither warm nor cold. Regret ... yes! All these are your personal problems and to fix them or not and the answer is to keep you! But here is the fact that here you have managed to throw a stone hidden in the bosom of the believers and that the shooting of the Romanov family and the further destruction of the followers of the monarchy, including and clergymen is FOR YOU ALL ONLY ..., says absolutely that you are no better than this director! It’s just that your color is not yellow - the green is marsh, like his, and the blood red is even just bloody! It will not work for you to divide the tragedy of the Russian people into good or bad! Normal people take out from the tragedy the truth of understanding the reasons that led to it! Well, and people are not smart, as you know, that on the forehead, that on the forehead everything is the same!
          1. mole
            mole 20 October 2018 04: 44
            0
            Quote: Detective
            But here is the fact that here you have managed to throw a stone hidden in the bosom of the believers and that the shooting of the Romanov family and the further destruction of the followers of the monarchy, including and clergymen is FOR YOU ALL ONLY ...,

            No stone was hidden. The annihilation of the followers of the monarchy is only TOTAL, a tragic, but historical fact.
            Quote: Detective
            says absolutely that you are no better than this resereshka! It’s just that your color is not yellow - the green is marsh, like his, and the blood red is even just bloody!

            For the director, "thank you", but that's your opinion. But contemporaries called Nicholas "bloody".
            Quote: Detective
            It will not work for you to divide the tragedy of the Russian people into good or bad! Normal people take out from the tragedy the truth of understanding the reasons that led to it!

            I don’t share the tragedy of my people, but I consider the actions (including inaction) of the Romanovs as the main reason, and the rest is only their consequences.
    5. The comment was deleted.
    6. Alexkorzun
      Alexkorzun 13 October 2018 20: 13
      +7
      Krasovsky ... Jew? Let him take off such a comedy about Jews in Auschwitz .... They will strangle his own.
      And we all play tolerance. No wonder they imposed it on us.
      1. Starover_Z
        Starover_Z 13 October 2018 20: 35
        +2
        Quote: Yuyuka
        you need to give him this right in places not so remote

        In places not so distant, he needs to be given the volume of work of a healthy person for the balance when performing! And that little to cut! So that he then gobbles up his shoes and a belt!
        At least 5 years old he could exist in the zone! But to survive, a set of bones and skin no more than 30 kg! And then let him shoot "black comedies"!
      2. georggy
        georggy 15 October 2018 09: 41
        +1
        No, he will have Sobibor - 2. and not like comedy, atragedia. Holocaust
    7. Faceless
      Faceless 15 October 2018 09: 45
      +3
      It is very difficult for me, as an indigenous Leningrader, to find censored words. My two grandfathers and great-grandfather fought in World War II, my grandmother and grandmother lived in Leningrad. Grandmother refused to evacuate ...

      We have recently shot one "comedy". "Death of Stalin" was called. Something from the same series is planned. The plot is difficult to retell - just look at the description. a Russian person would not even think of such a thing, let alone take it off.

      And the director is ready to throw a good idea to the entertainer: let him go to the graves of his ancestors, mock them freely and make a comedy about it. Leave the insinuations to his taste.
    8. Vend
      Vend 15 October 2018 15: 29
      +1
      Quote: Law abiding Citizen
      Indeed, some sort of dream of reason ... No words. Literary ...

      Interestingly, he has already collected a lot. There were those for whom the topic of the blockade of Leningrad is ridiculous?
  2. keeper03
    keeper03 13 October 2018 11: 52
    +20
    Crush this pimple until it crawls out! negative And so that others would not be habituated! fool
    1. jjj
      jjj 13 October 2018 12: 13
      +4
      In an interview, this director said that he, as an artist, has such a vision and he has the right to do so.
      1. Serge Gorely
        Serge Gorely 13 October 2018 12: 24
        +15
        Why be surprised? How many filthy filmmakers like that did they make? "Gu-ha" (the story, by the way, is quite good), "Bastards" (where the evil NKVDs sent the kids to slaughter, and the kind fascists pitied the kids), finally the "epic" "Penal Battalion", where almost everything is nonsense.
        1. The comment was deleted.
      2. 210ox
        210ox 13 October 2018 12: 24
        +18
        Let him realize his vision as an artist pushing the ice from the coast on the Lena, somewhere near Yakutsk.
      3. Nikolay Fedorov
        Nikolay Fedorov 13 October 2018 12: 49
        +21
        Quote: jjj
        In an interview, this director said that he, as an artist, has such a vision and he has the right to do so.

        I am also an artist, and I also have a vision, as a crowd of artists, inspired by a frantic creative impulse, drowns the artist Krassovsky in the Neva. And on the seafront there is another unobtrusive artist standing in the distance and is crying quietly from the fact that he dreamed of trapping Krassovsky as a Novice and becoming famous as Pavlensky, but now it will not work ... crying
      4. Tatyana
        Tatyana 13 October 2018 12: 50
        +14
        Quote: jjj
        In an interview, this director said that he, as an artist, has such a vision and he has the right to do so.

        And we have the right, this is his "right of cynical self-permissiveness" to PROHIBIT!
        And do not let the offspring come from Nizhny Novgorod, who had never sniffed anyone in the family and never had the Leningrad blockade to rock the country now and spit in our history.
        For it is precisely such films of the liberal Russian TRAINERS-scriptwriters who find their political admirers and PR patrons abroad, sticking out on the 1-th plan of moral monsters and leveling the historical feat of the people themselves.


        Alexei Krasovsky forgot that with good intentions the road to hell is sometimes paved.
        There is no such moral black comedy project about the besieged Leningrad and there can be no moral justification!
      5. edmed
        edmed 13 October 2018 13: 53
        +6
        as an artist, he has such a vision and he has the right to it. Does he have no responsibilities as an artist and a citizen? Maybe for his deeds, at another time, they anointed his forehead with brilliant green so that the infection would not be brought, or that the infection would not get out.
      6. SHURUM -BURUM
        SHURUM -BURUM 13 October 2018 14: 00
        +4
        he, as an artist, has such a vision and he has the right to do so
        How I would like to wish him that he would be at that most terrible time in Leningrad. And so that he would come across a couple with hungry eyes, who, offering him candy, said: "Come with us, boy, it's not far here ...". And that he should go with them. Maybe there would be no more "outstanding" artist, no such aftor vision. The incident did take place, but the boy (later - the author of those lines) was lucky to guess and avoid a terrible fate (somewhere I once read about this, sorry, I don't remember).
      7. Reptiloid
        Reptiloid 13 October 2018 14: 49
        +1
        Quote: jjj
        In an interview, this director said that he, as an artist, has such a vision and he has the right to do so.

        And I, as a cartoonist, I have the right to draw a vile, dead animal (disgusting insect), without a head and with released internals, and completely AT YOUR OWN FUNDS !!!
        I wonder who wants to lick ?????????????
        1. kitt409
          kitt409 16 October 2018 07: 38
          0
          As for licking, he was more likely going over a hill, but not just like that, but as a victim of the regime, so that sometimes they feed there, Russophobia is still in price, alas
      8. Yuyuka
        Yuyuka 13 October 2018 17: 25
        +1
        Quote: jjj
        In an interview, this director said that he, as an artist, has such a vision and he has the right to do so.


        No problem! you need to give him this right in places not so remote - on the scaffold of the club somewhere on the outskirts of our country! there they will help with the script - they will make some changes ... we don’t have an article for defiling memory and revising history? or punishment only when sausages are fried on the Eternal Flame? immediately aggravating shaft typed!
  3. free
    free 13 October 2018 11: 59
    +23
    Pay special attention to those actors who star in such films, they are akin to those who shoot them, because they are ready for everything for money. Society must make sure that they do not receive a ruble.
    1. Pete mitchell
      Pete mitchell 13 October 2018 12: 22
      +8
      Quote: free
      Society must make sure that they do not receive a ruble.

      It is simply vital to learn how to "vote with the ruble" so that sponsors shy away from such projects.
      And most importantly protect the growing from such rubbish ...
    2. Paranoid50
      Paranoid50 13 October 2018 12: 28
      +19
      Quote: free
      make sure they don’t get a ruble.

      It looks like they have already merged. I went to the "Planet", in the section "movies, videos" this hat is not. There is a feature-length film "The Leningrad Suite" about the life of ballet dancers during the Siege (directed by Svetlana Nikolaenko). The film has been filmed for several years and it takes only 300 thousand to complete the next stage. I got acquainted with the plot. Well, if everything is as planned, then good luck. As for the "comedy", it seems that these creepers have already reacted, and properly. But damn it, what kind of syphilis-stricken brain could get such an "idea"? Here is rot ...
      1. Alf
        Alf 13 October 2018 16: 44
        +2
        Quote: Paranoid50
        It looks like they have already merged. I went to "Planet", in the section "movies, videos" this hat is not.

        In the search on the website you drive Holiday and you are led to this ... creation. I am glad only one of the required one and a half lemons scored only 127 thousand.
        1. Paranoid50
          Paranoid50 13 October 2018 17: 43
          +6
          Quote: Alf
          and you are led to this ... creation.

          Here, they have hidden it. Found it after three transitions, but it is marked "project completed". Okay, now I’ll ask questions to the inspiring organism. And Tsapnik, after participating in all this, is a venal whore. However, like many of his "colleagues in the shop".
          1. Vasilenko Vladimir
            Vasilenko Vladimir 13 October 2018 18: 18
            +1
            Quote: Paranoid50
            However, like many of his "colleagues in the shop"

            there are many
          2. Alf
            Alf 13 October 2018 18: 37
            +2
            Quote: Paranoid50
            And Tsapnik, after participating in all this, is a venal whore. However, like many of his "colleagues in the shop".

            Maybe it’s a lie, but, they say, when Kolchak took the city, he issued an order — When artists, cabmen and prostitutes enter the city, they should not be shot, they serve any government.
    3. Tersky
      Tersky 13 October 2018 12: 59
      +6
      Quote: free
      Pay particular attention to those actors who star in such films,

      "
      Alexei Krasovsky - a native of the Avtozavodsky district of Nizhny Novgorod, dental surgeon by education and first profession "
      What is the "director", so are the actors
  4. RitaNik
    RitaNik 13 October 2018 12: 01
    +12
    If this is true, then moral degradation is evident ...
    1. RitaNik
      RitaNik 13 October 2018 12: 09
      +7
      I can not believe it. Truly, in our time, not everyone has the desire to remain human ...
  5. stariy
    stariy 13 October 2018 12: 07
    +12
    Comedy about Babi Yar is left to wait, kozlyyyyy!
  6. NEXUS
    NEXUS 13 October 2018 12: 19
    +20
    And about Auschwitz, Buchinwald or Dochau, why not shoot a comedy comedy? fool His grandfather, this Krasovsky, with a linden ulcer in the rear, was apparently sitting out, since such a miracle had hatched in this family.
  7. AleBors
    AleBors 13 October 2018 12: 25
    +7
    Yeah .. Edak and get to the musical about Auschwitz ... Isn’t it time for the director to change his place of residence and express himself there?
    1. Beringovsky
      Beringovsky 13 October 2018 17: 17
      +3
      Well, you, holocaust-auschwitz is holy to them!
      How can it be!
  8. Angelica
    Angelica 13 October 2018 12: 26
    +9
    Bastard - the most capacious definition for such figures. am
  9. Lexeus
    Lexeus 13 October 2018 12: 43
    +4
    These kovs are then called "victims of the regime" ......
  10. The Siberian barber
    The Siberian barber 13 October 2018 12: 44
    +8
    Several years ago, in one of the Siberian cities, there was a scandal. The young "artist" staged the opera "Eugene Onegin", as he "sees": Onegin, in her, a person of gay wassat
    I think that periodically arising scandals around art are planned actions that fit into the concept of the census of History.
    Guys with enviable persistence do their job (
  11. midshipman
    midshipman 13 October 2018 12: 44
    +32
    In our country, everything is allowed now. And until when? The Minister of Culture arrives and hangs a memorial plaque to the fascist mannerheim. A guard of honor, whose grandfathers and great-grandfathers died near Leningrad at the hands of this fascist, is marching. What a disgrace.
    My father is a major gunner who died on 27.12/1941. 1944 on the Leningrad Front. My mother and I returned to Leningrad from evacuation in 1945. I remember the New Year of XNUMX. My aunt (mother’s sister) took me to her company at the Christmas tree. Two tangerines gave me a present. I hid them on my chest in a coat and brought them home. That was our gift.
    Then in 1946 I remember. Execution of fascist generals on the square near the Gigant cinema. That was a holiday.
    Already at the age of 19, I was a lieutenant. A number of hot spots have passed and I cannot allow the authorities to mock the memory of Leningrad residents in such a way.
  12. Shelest2000
    Shelest2000 13 October 2018 12: 45
    +13
    A worthy sequel to the films "Bastards", "Penal Battalion" and "White Tiger" ...
    We are probably the only country in the world where power is affectionate and with a smile, stroking the head, looking at those who slop the past of the great country. Not for nothing. Of envy, apparently ...
    1. Nikolay Fedorov
      Nikolay Fedorov 13 October 2018 13: 30
      +2
      Quote: Shelest2000
      A worthy sequel to the films "Bastards", "Penal Battalion" and "White Tiger" ...
      We are probably the only country in the world where power is affectionate and with a smile, stroking the head, looking at those who slop the past of the great country.

      And what do you dislike about "White Tiger" ?! recourse
  13. Simon
    Simon 13 October 2018 12: 57
    +7
    This is sacrilege to make a comedy about people in distress in besieged Leningrad. Heroes are those people who at that time were in the besieged Leningrad. Hero films about them need to be removed, not comedy! fool
  14. UltraRed
    UltraRed 13 October 2018 12: 58
    +9
    Quote: Shelest2000
    A worthy sequel to the films "Bastards", "Penal Battalion" and "White Tiger" ....

    Well, "tiger" is not admissible from this series (although I did not like it).

    I’m also wondering, is it really possible that among people who at least somehow personally know this “director” there was no person who simply gave him a face for such an “idea”?
    I will definitely give, if by chance I meet of course.
    1. Alf
      Alf 13 October 2018 16: 46
      +3
      Quote: UltraRed
      I’m also wondering, is it really possible that among people who at least somehow personally know this “director” there was no person who simply gave him a face for such an “idea”?

      Are you sure that the people around him are not like him?
  15. Altona
    Altona 13 October 2018 12: 59
    +9
    I tweeted about this topic. The postmodern madhouse is already so clinical that it wants to stomp not just on the bones, but on the holy and the great tragedy. Come on, director, if you burn, then burn to the end, cut the actors right in the frame, and we will laugh in black. Well, actors should accept death as a necessary sacrifice to art, if this can be called art.
    In general, such thrash and hardcore already goes beyond creativity, since it is inhumane in essence, but today's solders from art have long spit on moral standards, they want to reach the bottom of degradation.
    1. zhekazs
      zhekazs 13 October 2018 18: 48
      +1
      Quote: Altona
      today's solders of art for a long time do not care about moral standards, they want to reach the bottom of degradation.

      Such people are called with one capacious phrase: moral ypods. Where did they all come from? Either these "people" have such an upbringing, or they cannot earn money in any other way, it doesn’t fit in my head. They are real traitors to their country and their people. For them, money doesn't smell at all? Where is their conscience, finally?
      I suppose, however, that this product is not only of our era. Weeds need to weed. The Second World War and the years of Stalin's reign are confirmation of this - about traitors and agents, various pests are by no means invented.
      1. Altona
        Altona 13 October 2018 20: 20
        +4
        Quote: zhekazs
        Where did they all come from?

        ----------------------------
        In the USSR, art was directed to serve a great purpose. Actually this is the purpose of art, to reach the crown of creation and serve the people. Today, all this has been thrown to the sidelines and ministers of muses have hit on making money, and accordingly in decadence and vulgarity. There is no internal and external censorship except the installation of the producer, he pays for this whole booth.
        1. Vasilenko Vladimir
          Vasilenko Vladimir 13 October 2018 21: 28
          0
          Quote: Altona
          In the USSR, art was directed to serve a great purpose.

          Quote: Altona
          Today, all this has been thrown to the sidelines and ministers of muses have hit on making money, and accordingly in decadence and vulgarity

          can not argue

  16. newcomer
    newcomer 13 October 2018 13: 21
    +2
    Mother Russia is generous with heroes, geniuses, poets. sorry, sometimes you get bastards.
    1. Nikolay Fedorov
      Nikolay Fedorov 13 October 2018 13: 33
      +3
      Quote: newbie
      Mother Russia is generous with heroes, geniuses, poets. sorry, sometimes you get bastards.

      So here you are - BEGINNER ... fellow
      1. newcomer
        newcomer 13 October 2018 13: 36
        +2
        what did you like?
        1. Nikolay Fedorov
          Nikolay Fedorov 13 October 2018 13: 52
          +2
          Quote: newbie
          what did you like?

          Get fucked up! For the first time in my life, I’m just talking like that with a BEGINNER!
          1. newcomer
            newcomer 13 October 2018 14: 04
            +1
            why not talk, my dear man.
  17. sib.ataman
    sib.ataman 13 October 2018 13: 42
    +2
    This already smacks of the blackening and spitting of the results of the II MB! Black humor is already a caustic satire! No need to play with words, but you need to call a spade a spade! If this bunny imagines himself to be Mephistopheles, who is allowed everything, then he already needs to force the scrotum to be nailed next to that star-headed figure who is now steaming in a French prison!
  18. The comment was deleted.
  19. Dezinto
    Dezinto 13 October 2018 15: 08
    +11
    "Overton Window" in all its glory. It was incredible to think about fifteen years ago! And to come up with, but no one would have thought of this !! A few years later - "well, just an eccentric trick."

    Five years later, it turns out that the Soviet Union - "not very much and took part in the Second World War" ... so only slightly helped Brad Pete to destroy five thousand Nazis on one tank.

    What say kpets! this is all sad! ..... recourse Watch out for good children, teach them, do not let these streams of rot seep into their heads!
  20. faterdom
    faterdom 13 October 2018 15: 14
    +6
    A generation of semi-literate self-confident cynics has grown. Have you laughed for a long time that the schoolchildren do not know who Gagarin is (they answered that they are definitely not Pokemon, because they are well versed in those). And now they are now making films for us, they are sculpting a new Hollywood story for the next generations. These are Pokemon.
    Although ... how can we condemn them against the backdrop of the state-funded Yeltsin Center and Dozhd? Mannerheim promoted by the Ministry of Culture in the form of a memorial plaque in Leningrad ??? I studied the question about Mannerheim - an interesting and controversial person, but ... Leningrad owes the northern part of the blockade to the Finns and Mannerheim! And he has a memorial plaque in this city ???
    So, everything has its own reasons and sources, and they are much higher located than those muddy with Polish surnames - Krasovsky, Pavlensky, Ganopolsky and so on ...
  21. Jerk
    Jerk 13 October 2018 15: 24
    +6
    I propose to make a comedy about the Baotan fugitive, General Douglas MacArthur, who left the army and escaped from defeat on a destroyer in a single. The funniest episodes will be the Ba'athan death march, with historical documents

    Have a good laugh? There, by the way, perished much less, and only military personnel, so there are more reasons for laughter
  22. Mihail28
    Mihail28 13 October 2018 15: 57
    +3
    Interestingly, the Criminal Code did not write a suitable article against "Kolya Saprykin"?
    And not only the thief should sit.
  23. anjey
    anjey 13 October 2018 16: 11
    +6
    Hollywood in the empty heads and hearts of new generations is scary ...
  24. gurzuf
    gurzuf 13 October 2018 16: 32
    +2
    For this it is not necessary to discuss, but in a friendly way ..
  25. earloop
    earloop 13 October 2018 16: 41
    +3
    The words of the director Krasovsky: "And as it is not scary to admit it, but this is a comedy, sometimes black, but more often bright and New Year's." - "Nugget" from the direction, Lexey, decided to scoff at the blessed memory of the Leningrad blockade, whose memory has now remained physically unprotected?
  26. general.bnw
    general.bnw 13 October 2018 16: 43
    +2
    Lord! Vulgarity and meanness - that’s what I can say about this * joke *!
  27. Moonsund
    Moonsund 13 October 2018 16: 46
    +3
    If this is true, then the idea is so-so. I'm not a prude, but there are some reasonable frameworks. Events not 300 years ago, these are our grandparents, it happened, just "stretch out your hand." If you want to laugh, make a movie about the war of 1812! Let's neigh together! And this action, disgusting, shameless, vulgar and allow this x.e. p nude is irresponsible. I, of course, understand the director's idea of ​​earning points on shocking (well, since there are no other talents), and then hammering into the wall, pouring snot on it, that it is an artist, we poison him, and his highly moral movie is just a new look at events. In short, such nonsense should be prohibited and a criminal case initiated.
    1. pacific
      pacific 14 October 2018 02: 02
      +2
      If you want to laugh, make a movie about the war of 1812! Spawn together!

      Krasovsky and his ilk are not allowed to shoot comedies.
      Although there are plenty of comedies about the war to make: "Hussar Ballad", "Heavenly Slow Mover", "Country Trip of Sergeant Tsybuli". This is just a glance from memory. But these films are kind, bright, which you want to watch more than once.
  28. Vasilenko Vladimir
    Vasilenko Vladimir 13 October 2018 17: 24
    +3
    Lord, where do these come from? !!!!
    But if you beat him in the face on the street, he also sue and the court will stand on the side of the degenerate
  29. lucul
    lucul 13 October 2018 17: 45
    +1
    And about the Holocaust do not want to shoot a black comedy? BUT?..

    In granite. Also, the first reaction was such a thought.
    The very existence of Russians casts doubt on the God-chosenness of some, as the long-suffering people themselves.
    So they are furious. This is such a "creative" response to the supply of S-300s to Syria.
  30. Vasilenko Vladimir
    Vasilenko Vladimir 13 October 2018 18: 22
    +5
    Found a good idea on the network, this .... and the same actors from the film, for 900 days to transfer to the blockade ration
    1. zhekazs
      zhekazs 13 October 2018 19: 11
      +1
      The idea is correct, but something just tells me that our authorities will not go to "aggravate the situation with human rights in Russia", the ECHR commissions and the like. Our law enforcement officers, prosecutors, sk-police, are always waiting for a shout from above, even in the most egregious cases. And here ... I don't believe it. Even if there is an active citizen and write a complaint to the procurator, so that they check the activities of this underdirector, release everything on the brakes, find no corpus delicti, or something else ...
      Oh, wait for the authorities that the people will assume the function of justice ...
  31. pepel
    pepel 13 October 2018 18: 30
    0
    It seems that the CPC has a corresponding article for such comedians. And what is Mannerheim's fan keeping quiet !? am fool angry
  32. The comment was deleted.
  33. The comment was deleted.
    1. zhekazs
      zhekazs 13 October 2018 20: 57
      +6
      The freedom of one individual ends where the rights of another begin. And here the rights of not one but millions of people are affected, whose ancestors desecrate such works by the memory and this is already a criminal offense. What is freedom of speech here? Let then, as many here suggest, let them make a comedy about the Holocaust in a concentration camp with Jews. The Holocaust for the Jews is sacred as a memory of tortured relatives. For Leningraders, the same is the blockade of Leningrad, we honor each year. About the Holocaust around the world they trumpeted it and it’s been driven into everybody’s so beautiful that this topic is a taboo for antics, and only the older generations know about the Blockade in the former USSR, and then outside of Russia. So there are all sorts of moral yodi, arranging dances on the bones. Such a heresy, along with ridiculing patriotic ideas and humiliating the dignity of the nation, should be burned with a hot iron, we will not burn it today, tomorrow we can be forgotten as a nation .....
      Quote: Anti
      if people want to eat feces, let them open the kaloelena and do it voluntarily indoors.

      Listen, why reinvent the wheel? For a long time, there are closed rooms for such patients, we are in no hurry to identify and treat them with us ...
      1. The comment was deleted.
        1. Vasilenko Vladimir
          Vasilenko Vladimir 13 October 2018 21: 33
          +1
          Quote: Anti
          Young people always go against the dogma, it is better to let them go and then spit than forbidden fruits to them, and then 10-20 thousand will come down and with the ban millions will start downloading on the Internet.

          when will we allow child prostitution? !!!
          Quote: Anti
          not a single mayor of London or Paris would eat three hari if the city was starving, I can’t imagine such a thing.

          imagination is bad? !!!
          1. The comment was deleted.
            1. Vasilenko Vladimir
              Vasilenko Vladimir 13 October 2018 21: 44
              +1
              Quote: Anti
              Do not distort, your anger is what marketers expected

              Do you really think that you can make a stir on this? !!!
              this is not a "mocha" with bare tits looked and forgot, this is an OFFENSE for this they killed
              honestly, if this rubbish is suddenly shown at us (which is very unlikely) somehow the movement came, I’ll personally stuff the operator’s face
              Quote: Anti
              Anyway, I repeat, you have to look like Matilda

              tell me if your mom will be joked, what will you do ?!
              Quote: Anti
              After such lively experiments with saints and heroes - I want more and more power of funny clowns and fools than saints and heroes, perhaps the first ones in a difficult time will turn out to be more humane and decent.

              you need to be treated
              1. The comment was deleted.
                1. Vasilenko Vladimir
                  Vasilenko Vladimir 14 October 2018 07: 07
                  +2
                  Quote: Anti
                  In America, the hate speech (insult and blasphemy) is recognized as freedom of speech

                  they can at least deal with mom and dad than what it is violet to me, I live here and it is not permissible to insult the dead HERE and if you do not understand this, go to America
                  Quote: Anti
                  they simply won’t go to such films and the authors go bankrupt.

                  you are either stupid or sick, and they will walk and that the worst attitude to the tragedy will be changed - it will not hurt yet it will not be scary it will be FUN
        2. zhekazs
          zhekazs 14 October 2018 01: 11
          +4
          Quote: Anti
          In no way offends the memory of millions or ancestors. It will hurt people only in a separate room who voluntarily paid money to the cashier.

          And why even allow lewdness to take place even in a closed room? What else can you call the desecration of the memory of the dead? Why even allow (the state, police, society) to lead to the appearance of such "cultural products"? Why can't society work out for itself some moral and ethical standards when there are topics - taboos, forbidden for film adaptation, print? Why should society tolerate the propaganda of all kinds of homo perverts?
          Quote: Anti
          No matter how terrible it is, but this is freedom of speech

          What the fuck is freedom of speech? Stomping on bones - is this your freedom of speech?
          This is not freedom of speech - this is a moral perversion and degradation of the individual. Freedom of speech should not affect the feelings and rights and freedoms of other people, no matter what scientific or pseudo-scientific methods it will be determined by. Any society must have constraints, otherwise it cannot be considered a society (the first lecture and one of the first concepts in political science in any educational institution, absolutely everything must be remembered). When a society loses its moral constraints, it turns into an ordinary herd of humanlike animals. No one will argue with the thesis that children cannot be eaten - this is a moral limiter. And the "wiser" the society, the more such constraints become. Animals have them, though not a lot.
          You, there, below, in the comments, cite the states as an example. What the hell? Their society is only 300 years old. And do not remember that they are all immigrants from .., their society was developing from scratch in the New World. Yes, somehow it hasn’t happened yet. Consider, 50 years ago, in total, their slavery of blacks was abolished in their heads. Unlike them to us.
          You need to know the measure in everything. Otherwise, we will get to the point where we will kill each other in the streets and say that this is freedom. Only this freedom will be freedom from reason. Also with this director. And the article should have been called not "a dream of reason", but "freedom in everything, including from reason." It is by reason that we differ from animals. And it is the mind that allows us to set ourselves moral limits and restrictions (you don't pee in the elevator in the morning when you go to work? - these are restrictions), so you should not confuse freedom of speech and the usual desertification of the individual.
    2. Vasilenko Vladimir
      Vasilenko Vladimir 13 October 2018 21: 37
      +4
      Quote: Anti
      No matter how terrible it may be, but it’s freedom of speech, I’m sure in America many films have been shot about, for example, the Civil War, where there were also quite a lot of sad and wild facts

      Well, well, try in the states to give a hint about the atrocities of blacks
      Quote: Anti
      If someone doesn’t like it - don’t go and don’t look, adults are not children

      in it all begins
      Quote: Anti
      Well, there are such facts, and it can be removed well, black comedies are also different and it will be completely different as the readers of the site think, but if it’s bad, everyone will forget and that's all.

      there are things you can’t laugh at, NOT ON BLACK OR ON WHITE and if you don’t understand it, I’m sorry for you
      and I would gladly give this director-dentist in the face
  34. UltraRed
    UltraRed 13 October 2018 20: 36
    +2
    Quote: Jerk
    I propose to make a comedy about the Baotan fugitive, General Douglas MacArthur, who left the army and escaped from defeat on a destroyer in a single.

    Well, let's say not on a destroyer, but on a torpedo boat of the RT-20 type. And not from Baotan, but from Correhidor (although Baotan still held on, this hero was safer in the adits of Correhidor).
  35. UltraRed
    UltraRed 13 October 2018 20: 53
    +4
    Quote: Anti
    No matter how terrible it was, but this is freedom of speech, I am sure in America that many films have been shot about, for example, the Civil War, where there were also quite a lot of sad and wild facts.

    Try-on - to the studio!
    For example, about Sherman's "march to the sea", and about the show it в southern states?
    Quote: Anti
    If someone doesn’t like it, don’t go and don’t look, adults are not children, if people want to eat feces, let them open a caloe bed and do it voluntarily indoors.
    Feces, let them eat. But this is no longer a food diet, but the cannibalism of historical memory. "Freedom" in your understanding extends to cannibals?
    Quote: Anti
    Well, there are such facts, and it can be removed well, black comedies are also different and it will be completely different as the readers of the site think, but if it’s bad, everyone will forget and that's all.

    Those. subject "hfilmy" is not taboo for you ??
    Everything! Got it! Hello Alexey! We are "glad" to welcome you to VO ...... :)
    Comment - MINUS!
    1. Aunt
      Aunt 13 October 2018 21: 21
      +1
      In the states, the ball rules the ball, they didn’t show it, because no one would come, that's all, they rent it for private money at private risk, it’s only in Russia all the films are rented for taxes.
      1. The comment was deleted.
      2. RitaNik
        RitaNik 13 October 2018 21: 45
        +2
        Can you imagine that in the States they shot and released a comedy about Pearl Harbor? Do you think that our youth is able to recognize and evaluate historical facts, drawing them from the base and vulgar chernukha? And the most terrible tragedies of the country are sacred cows and dogmas in the understanding of the young? Then I’m scared for you ... There will be no country
        1. The comment was deleted.
          1. The comment was deleted.
            1. The comment was deleted.
              1. RitaNik
                RitaNik 13 October 2018 22: 25
                +1
                Are you inviting everyone to go down to the bestial level? And someone will work on "chernukha".
                1. The comment was deleted.
              2. UltraRed
                UltraRed 14 October 2018 00: 35
                +1
                In "your" country, maybe. Illinois? (Russian is too well delivered for Bahrain)
          2. earloop
            earloop 14 October 2018 00: 03
            +3
            Anti: "Let the fools be fools, do not save other people's souls, it will end even worse." Project what you have written onto yourself. Answer in your words: "it will end even worse."
            There are a lot of things in the States. But no one tries to mock those who are buried in Arlington Cemetery. And over those whose remains lie at the Piskarevskoye cemetery can all "fools" be mocked?
        2. zhekazs
          zhekazs 14 October 2018 01: 35
          +1
          Quote: RitaNik
          There will be no country

          Calm down, everything will be. wink
          Quote: RitaNik
          Do you think that our youth is able to recognize and evaluate historical facts, drawing them from the base and vulgar chernukha? And the most terrible tragedies of the country are sacred cows and dogmas in the understanding of the young?

          Believe me, such conclusions are single and not of a mass nature. Our society, however, is basically traditional. Yes, you can see the slice of our society by the comments on the VO and draw your own conclusions. Otherwise, it has long been
          Quote: RitaNik
          There will be no country
      3. zhekazs
        zhekazs 14 October 2018 01: 29
        0
        Quote: Anti
        it’s only in Russia that all films are filmed for taxes.

        Well, why lie in return at the very bottom of the branch? Do you think no one will read? In Russia, cinema has long been self-sustaining and is by no means poor. Do not believe? Turn on the TV.
        1. Mordvin 3
          Mordvin 3 14 October 2018 01: 46
          0
          Quote: zhekazs
          In Russia, cinema has long been self-sustaining and is by no means poor.

          Are you kidding me? Yes, Migalkin would have taken off his last shorts long ago, he had not one movie that was not justified.
          1. zhekazs
            zhekazs 14 October 2018 02: 08
            0
            Quote: Mordvin 3
            Are you kidding me?

            Turn on the TV at least occasionally. What is not the season, then the new series, about the five tricked by the trace. I’m generally silent. They live on money from advertising and do not live in poverty.
            Quote: Mordvin 3
            Yes, Migalkin would have long been

            If you're talking about Mikhalkov - well, it's not a horse feed, let him change his profession, since his "masterpieces" at the box office do not pay off. We already unfasten everything to him from each sold media (flash drives, disks, all types of memory). Personally, I have not seen anything interesting or instructive in any of his last films, "masterpieces".
            1. Mordvin 3
              Mordvin 3 14 October 2018 02: 14
              0
              Quote: zhekazs
              Turn on the TV at least occasionally

              Yes, I don’t watch it. So, it’s worth the type in the surroundings.
              Quote: zhekazs
              If you're talking about Mikhalkov - well, it's not a horse feed, let him change his profession, since his "masterpieces" at the box office do not pay off

              Well, yes, he will change how.
              1. zhekazs
                zhekazs 14 October 2018 02: 22
                +1
                Quote: Mordvin 3
                Yes, I don’t watch it.

                And you leave yourself two channels of Culture - there old films are shown, and the Match is only a sport and no politics.
                1. Mordvin 3
                  Mordvin 3 14 October 2018 02: 27
                  0
                  Quote: zhekazs
                  A match is only a sport and no politics.

                  There films are sometimes shown. Well them.
  36. 1536
    1536 13 October 2018 21: 00
    +1
    Absolutely brutalized.
  37. yasvet
    yasvet 13 October 2018 21: 01
    +2
    a dream of reason ..., no business project, the director received an award for the "collector", soared so to speak, why not remove a "black" comedy. But the topic is besieged Leningrad ..., and suddenly it will ride, almost 80 years passed, maybe they already forget (it is natural for a person to forget), "everything flows, everything changes."
    Shish, director, remember!
    PS I will add, projects like this, check for "rot"
  38. ODERVIT
    ODERVIT 13 October 2018 21: 29
    +1
    My mother was stolen food cards, she was sixteen years old. The family was doomed. However, the Almighty helped, the elders sent packages from the front, enough for a month. If everything that is written in the article is believable, then the authors of the project will not say hello. What a comedy? I don’t understand what, does cynicism allow you to invade the holy for the city and country?
    1. Vasilenko Vladimir
      Vasilenko Vladimir 13 October 2018 21: 38
      0
      Quote: ODERVIT
      If everything that is written in the article is believable, then the authors of the project will not say hello.

      The worst thing is that they won't get anything, and if someone doesn't even fill it, but just spits in the face, such a howl will rise from the "Akhedzhakovs"
      1. kitt409
        kitt409 16 October 2018 08: 09
        0
        To paraphrase - to be afraid of the "Akhedzhakovs", not to go to the forest, they will not wait for this, I also have a sample and are lined, yeah, schazzz bully
  39. Machito
    Machito 13 October 2018 21: 42
    0
    It is necessary to close such subjects in the cage, so that the comedy is shot to themselves. And instead of a fee - a balance of fats
  40. Igor Polovodov
    Igor Polovodov 13 October 2018 22: 28
    0
    Oh yes, about the colohost, the statement will not even reach the media ...
  41. sgapich
    sgapich 13 October 2018 23: 41
    +1
    But in this act clearly visible signs falling under part 2 of article 282 of the Criminal Code.
  42. dok123
    dok123 14 October 2018 00: 51
    +1
    And where is the Government looking, President? Well, yes ... they’re liberal too ...
  43. The comment was deleted.
  44. Zheleznostop
    Zheleznostop 14 October 2018 14: 19
    +1
    What are we arguing about? When even the beskogon Nikita managed with his Citadels and Previsions to drag the people on the head of shit, and then wait for something from the liberals.
  45. Amur
    Amur 14 October 2018 16: 11
    +1
    These filmmakers completely lost their heads.
  46. NordUral
    NordUral 14 October 2018 16: 55
    +1
    Mat is prohibited on IN! But in vain - it is only with the help of the mat can be described! Or an article from the Criminal Code.
  47. kitt409
    kitt409 16 October 2018 08: 14
    0
    My opinion is that this, like a bae director, decided to follow the path of leaving himself, offended by a lack of understanding abroad of our Motherland, in order to teach us from there how we need to live and how bad we all live here - there are already examples and did not appear yesterday - the same "artist ", with nailing to paving stones, or a historian who is trying to prove that Vlasov is the blessing of our history, in our country he will not become a doctor, but outside of it it is easy, here is another one, like a" fighter " am
  48. Jerk
    Jerk 16 October 2018 09: 05
    0
    This is not a dream of reason, this is ordinary human meanness. The director, or rather, ROGE-SERAH, from the word, sorry for my French. In any war, heroism and baseness go by the drawbar, in any army there are heroes and scum, and not in the army, and even more so. One blockade, a Jew by the way, wrote well about Leningrad. Boris Natanovich Strugatsky.
    Here in Leningrad <...> it was cold, eerie, ferocious, and the freezing ones screamed in the icy porches - more and more quietly, for a long time, for many hours ... He fell asleep, listening to someone screaming, woke up all under the same hopeless cry and it cannot be said that it was scary, rather sickening, and when in the morning, wrapped up to the eyes, he went down the stairs to fetch water, filled with frozen shit, holding the hand of his mother, who was dragging a sled with a bucket tied, this one who was screaming was lying below near the elevator cage, probably in the same place where he fell yesterday, probably in the same place - he himself could not get up, crawl too, and no one came out to him ... And no ripples were needed. We survived only because my mother used to buy firewood not in summer, but in early spring. The firewood saved us. And cats. Twelve adult cats and a little kitten that was so hungry that when I wanted to pet him, he threw himself on my hand and greedily gnawed and bit my fingers ... You should go there, you bastards, Andrey thought about the soldier with unexpected malice. This is not an Experiment ... And that city was worse than that. I would have gone crazy there. It saved me that I was small. The little ones just died ...
    And the city, by the way, was never surrendered, he thought. Those who remained little by little died out. They stacked them in piles in wood sheds, tried to take the living out - the authorities still functioned, and life went on as usual - a strange, delusional life. Someone just died quietly; someone committed heroic deeds, then also died; someone worked hard at the factory until the last, and when the time came, he also died ... Someone got fat, bought pieces of bread for jewelry, gold, pearls, earrings, then he also died - they brought him down to the Neva and shot, and then they got up without looking at anyone, throwing rifles over their flat backs ... Someone hunted with an ax in the alleys, ate a man, tried to even sell a man, but also died anyway ... There was nothing more ordinary in this city than death. But power remained, and while power remained, the city stood.
    Interestingly, they felt sorry for us? Or didn’t they just think about us? Just carried out the order

    So let this one laugh at this. After all this venture, isn’t he afraid of walking along the streets of the city on the Neva?