Military Review

May decree is not a decree to us! Ministry of Economic Development predicts stagnation

98
While we are all looking with great interest at the World Cup that is taking place in our country, and at the same time we are also fighting with the insidious government, trying to sneak in the extremely unpopular version of pension reform, the Ministry of Economic Development of the Russian Federation announced the updated forecast for 2018- year, as well as some (so far unofficial) figures of the forecast for the period from 2019 to 2024.




This forecast is extremely interesting because almost all of the forecast indicators for such important areas as the economic growth of the country, the growth of salaries and total incomes, the growth of investments in fixed assets and so on are reduced. That is, almost everything positive, which is associated with the word "growth", expects a decline.

There are, of course, exceptions. In particular, it will increase ... the outflow of foreign capital. However, not so long: the department promises to reduce it to almost zero by the 2024 year. But otherwise news, frankly, not so hot ...

Not to be unfounded, I will give some basic figures. The economic growth rate in the current year is expected to be at the level of 1,9%, and not 2,1%, as was previously expected. The forecast for the next year is even worse: the economic growth in 2019 is expected to be only at the level of 1,4%, and not 2,2%. At 2020, growth is projected at 2%, and at 2021 - about three. True, the figures are not official, and it is very likely that they can be revised more than once. And what will happen to the 2021 year from the three percent, Oreshkin alone knows.

Real wages in Russia are also waiting for difficult times. If in the 2018 year they are expected to grow at the level of 6,3%, then in 2019 they will grow by only 1%. That is, somewhere at the level of statistical error or the usual safety net of officials who do not really want to voice negative numbers and lose their familiar places a year earlier.

Investment is expected to grow only 3,1%, compared to 3,5% in the current year and 4,4% in the past year.

In general, the numbers are not so catastrophic, but very, very dull. And it’s not at all clear how they fit in with the May presidential decree of President Putin, where we were promised, among other things, a two-fold reduction in poverty, acceleration of technological development, entry into the top five leading economies of the world, economic growth above average global rates, and all this while maintaining inflation is no higher than 4% per year.

Ministry of Economic Development puts an end to the May decree of Putin? Or does it still put an end to this government, the incompetence of which should be obvious, probably, even to the most patient and liberal Putin?

These are rhetorical questions, alas. After all, conclusions about the competence and professionalism of the “economic bloc” of our government could have been made five years ago, sending it in full force to where Ulyukaev was sent.

What are the reasons for such a significant deterioration in the forecast? But it deserves a separate study.

In fact, sources clearly indicate only two reasons: the increase in VAT on 2 percent. point and some "geopolitical instability", which will adversely affect the economy.

Well, this in itself is interesting. For example, the “experts” are beginning to look stupid somehow, who hastened to declare that such a slight increase in VAT will not affect the rate of economic growth. No, they say Mr. Oreshkin's wards, get a decrease in 0,3% and sign it.

As for the “geopolitical uncertainty”, the question immediately arises: do the experts from the Ministry of Economic Development understand the meaning of the term “geopolitics” in general?

The fact is that geopolitics refers to the policy of states, determined by geographic factors. And “geopolitical uncertainty” in the classical sense can only mean one thing - the expectation of war. The army is about to start moving, military blocks will be created and disintegrated, sea straits will be closed, world trade will become complicated, some resources will become inaccessible (for some it could be oil, and for someone tea and cocoa beans, for example) and etc. - this is, indeed, geopolitical uncertainty as it is.

So, we expect war? Okay, but where are the multiples of defense spending then? Where is the growth of investment in infrastructure? Where is the rapid recovery of the industry, littered with military orders?

But no, our “experts” understand geopolitical factors as “misunderstandings” with oil prices and, attention, trade wars that the United States is unleashing against its traditional partners. And if so, then it turns out that it is not so much about “geopolitical instability”, as though it is not understood, but about the banal absence of economic sovereignty from Russia, tied to the insane conditions of membership in the WTO and the absence of real levers of economic regulation international trade and cooperation.

The problem of the Ministry of Economic Development and Trade is that even the muddy formulation of “geopolitical instability” does not save the government from unpleasant issues related to the slowdown in business activity. And the main one: is it a coincidence that it coincided with the brilliant “victory” of the government and the Central Bank over inflation?

For a good thirty years, we have been told how wonderful we will live when inflation in Russia finally reaches four percent. And if less, then we will instantly come economic paradise with great savings, luxury consumption, cheap loans and high economic activity.

However, it turned out that it works only when the government and the Central Bank manage to reduce inflation to 4%, having a refinancing rate of at most three percent. In our country everything is somewhat different: the economy was strangled with a huge (against inflation) credit cost, reported on “outstanding success” and only now begin to understand what price the industry and the population will have to pay for it.

But if you thought that the author calls to disperse inflation, then nothing. Or maybe he wants to lower the rate of the Central Bank, hoping for the traditional Russian perhaps? Also by: the author does not want anything like that.

And he wants the government, which has repeatedly proved its incompetence by deed, to finally be dismissed homeless. And ideally - that graduates and employees of the HSE be banned from holding positions in the civil service.

And let the new economy take care of the Russian economy. The population of the country under 150 millions. Is it possible that Medvedev, Siluanov and Oreshkin brought together a white light?
Author:
Photos used:
http://www.globallookpress.com/
98 comments
Ad

Subscribe to our Telegram channel, regularly additional information about the special operation in Ukraine, a large amount of information, videos, something that does not fall on the site: https://t.me/topwar_official

Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. Bastinda
    Bastinda 4 July 2018 05: 37
    +24
    The army is about to move, military blocks will be created and disintegrated, sea straits will close, world trade will be complicated, some resources will become inaccessible (for some it may be oil, but for some tea and cocoa beans, for example) and etc.

    The 21st century, however, the war is already underway, and we are financing it ...
    An “enemy” container ship with sheets from China and textile enterprises in ruins came to our port. The “enemies” brought the televisions, and they covered a whole industry with a direct hit. And we still paid for it.
    Glory to the president’s wise economic policy! WTO glory! laughing
    “Is white light converging on Medvedev, Siluanov and Oreshkin?”
    So maybe send the president hodak? And then he does not know?
    1. Vard
      Vard 4 July 2018 06: 04
      +11
      Thank God at least they imposed sanctions ... Otherwise, it would be completely kirdyk ...
      1. Boris55
        Boris55 4 July 2018 08: 06
        +3
        Quote: Vard
        Thank God at least they imposed sanctions ... Otherwise, it would be completely kirdyk ...

        Thank you for this to Putin, who is implementing such a foreign policy that has such a beneficial effect on domestic policy.
        1. solzh
          solzh 4 July 2018 09: 06
          +17
          Quote: Boris55
          Quote: Vard
          Thank God at least they imposed sanctions ... Otherwise, it would be completely kirdyk ...

          Thank you for this to Putin, who is implementing such a foreign policy that has such a beneficial effect on domestic policy.

          Lavrov is engaged in foreign policy, and Medvedev is engaged in internal politics.
          Boris, are you trying to artificially cultivate a personality cult? wink
          1. Boris55
            Boris55 4 July 2018 09: 07
            +3
            Quote: solzh
            Our foreign policy is Lavrov,

            I get it. Does this mean that Trump meets Lavrov, not Putin? laughing
            Lavrov - the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, pursuing a state policy, within the framework defined by the head of this state i.e. Putin.
            Boris, are you trying to artificially cultivate a personality cult?

            The first commandment: “I am the Lord your God ... May you not have other gods before My face” (Exodus 20: 2-3).
            There should always be one who is worth following.
            1. Dimmedroll
              Dimmedroll 4 July 2018 19: 51
              +1
              And if the person is not a believer or Muslim. Or God forbid a Jew. What the Divine Scriptures Say To This
              1. For example
                For example 5 July 2018 16: 34
                0
                So read them at least once in your life. What is the problem? And there will be no "if."
                Everything is better than nonsense. wink
        2. Nyrobsky
          Nyrobsky 4 July 2018 10: 19
          +10
          Quote: Boris55
          Thank you for this to Putin, who is implementing such a foreign policy that has such a beneficial effect on domestic policy.

          Yes, with foreign policy, things are still not bad with us, but with the internal one it is full of tryndets. The financial and economic bloc of the government should be renamed the "Center for the development and implementation of the strategy of economic underdevelopment of Russia", then everything will fall into place - "The center is working, the economy is skidding."
          1. vadsonen
            vadsonen 4 July 2018 15: 06
            +14
            Yes, with foreign policy, things are still not bad with us, but with the internal one it’s full tryndets

            Even children know that foreign policy is a continuation of domestic policy, and they are determined by the same people. Therefore, there is no success and cannot be in foreign policy. Or do you consider success to help the fraternal Syrian people (read the interests of Sechin and Miller)?
            1. Dimmedroll
              Dimmedroll 4 July 2018 19: 52
              +1
              Not all that you wrote is not a fact.
    2. Uncle lee
      Uncle lee 4 July 2018 06: 15
      +1
      the government, which has already proved its incompetence more than once, was finally dismissed home without severance pay
      As soon as possible ! fellow
    3. Xander
      Xander 4 July 2018 11: 24
      +17
      They chose Putin together and then with great surprise - How Medvedev ?! Again?! Such a surprise! laughing

      Until the country is strong and healthy opposition - the rulers will not work hard and change something, since they are not afraid to lose their chair. Everything will be by inertia, somewhere better, somewhere worse, but you don’t have to answer for the result, so the people accustomed. hi
      1. Boris55
        Boris55 4 July 2018 11: 49
        +1
        Quote: Xander
        They chose Putin together and then with great surprise - How Medvedev ?!

        United Russia was united in the Duma and one should not be surprised at the fact that it approved its leader, Medvedev, as head of the government. I hope you do not think that the EP could have approved the leader of another party for this post and are not trying to convince us of this?
        1. AA17
          AA17 4 July 2018 12: 16
          +9
          Dear, Boris55 (Boris). "They united EP into the Duma and one should not be surprised at that ...". If the GDP itself supported the EP before the election, then the people meekly trusted the President. "On the eve of the State Duma elections, Vladimir Putin continues to demonstrate support for United Russia. On Wednesday (20.04.2016/XNUMX/XNUMX) he met with participants in the primaries of EP ..."
          P.S. I don’t remember him supporting other parties like that.
          1. Boris55
            Boris55 4 July 2018 12: 22
            0
            Quote: AA17
            If GDP itself supported the EP before the election

            You know, I knew that the EP would win the Duma elections and Medvedev would be the chairman of the government, after the EP won almost everywhere in the local and regional elections (I wrote about this on the site before the Duma elections) . I do not think that the president is dumber than me and did not understand this. Any leader cannot ignore the force with which he has to work, and even more so if he has to confront it.
            1. Bastinda
              Bastinda 4 July 2018 12: 35
              +8
              Any leader cannot ignore the force with which he has to work, and even more so if he has to confront it.
              "I gave birth to you! I will kill you!" N.V. Gogol ...
              Putin is far from him ... and he does not abandon his "friends."
              1. Boris55
                Boris55 4 July 2018 12: 46
                0
                Quote: Bastinda
                he does not abandon his own.

                Do you think that for so many years there are still “yours” in EP?
                1. Bastinda
                  Bastinda 4 July 2018 12: 57
                  +11
                  Well, one million, thief and villains, this is not a civil war. Can be outweighed in working order. laughing
                  1. New Year day
                    New Year day 4 July 2018 16: 51
                    +7
                    Good idea
                    1. Igoresha
                      Igoresha 5 July 2018 10: 11
                      +1
                      Where only then to take the good ones, instead of the ones outweighed. You won’t get enough rope
    4. Conductor
      Conductor 5 July 2018 05: 33
      0
      And He has not been in the know for a long time.
  2. rotmistr60
    rotmistr60 4 July 2018 06: 52
    +3
    Ministry of Economic Development predicts stagnation
    In the brains and professionalism of the Ministry of Economic Development, stagnation.
    1. Conductor
      Conductor 4 July 2018 07: 00
      +2
      Well, where did you see professionalism in this government, Chew on you.
    2. populist
      populist 4 July 2018 09: 48
      +7
      Ministry of Economic Development predicts stagnation
      The Ministry of Economic Development of the Russian Federation without much ado announced the updated forecast for 2018, as well as some (so far unofficial) forecast figures for the period from 2019 to 2024.

      This forecast is real. This government is unable to develop the country. negative What it has proved in the past 6 years.
      1. Vadim237
        Vadim237 5 July 2018 00: 58
        0
        The real forecast is 3% per year.
  3. vlad007
    vlad007 4 July 2018 07: 00
    +2
    In our country, almost all sectors (agricultural, industrial production) are developing normally (4-7%), except for construction. There has been a decline in construction, so the overall performance in the country is not very high. The author needs to study the situation in the economy in more detail BY INDUSTRY!
    1. solzh
      solzh 4 July 2018 10: 18
      +11
      Quote: vlad007
      In our country, almost all sectors (agricultural, industrial production) are developing normally (4-7%), except for construction. There has been a decline in construction, so the overall performance in the country is not very high. The author needs to study the situation in the economy in more detail BY INDUSTRY!

      Where did you get such data? Even Rosstat, after a recent obscure recount of growth indicators, does not have such figures.
      1. vlad007
        vlad007 4 July 2018 16: 28
        +1
        Quote: solzh
        Where did you get such data? Even Rosstat, after a recent obscure recount of growth indicators, does not have such figures.

        I advise you to regularly look at the "Made with us" site. There is a statistics section - there are a lot of interesting things about the country's economy and do not read all sorts of idiotic articles WITHOUT NUMBERS or at least SCHEMES! I give the address of the site and the statistics section:
        https://sdelanounas.ru/blogs/?search=статистика
        1. solzh
          solzh 4 July 2018 18: 02
          +7
          Do not read such sites, do not.
          From the site:
          Editor-in-chief: Kovrigin R.V.
          Phone: +7 928 611 44 ​​74
          E-mail: [email protected]
          Distribution: free;
          I like this Kovrigin R.V. not known. The first time I hear about him. I always use trusted sites and portals.
          1. vlad007
            vlad007 4 July 2018 18: 23
            0
            Quote: solzh
            I like this Kovrigin R.V. not known. The first time I hear about him. I always use trusted sites and portals.

            So write the address, so as not to be unfounded!
            1. solzh
              solzh 4 July 2018 18: 55
              +5
              To verbales what? Want a link? Catch:
              http://economy.gov.ru/minec/main
              https://www.minfin.ru/ru/
              http://www.cbr.ru
              http://www.klerk.ru
              https://www.cfin.ru
              https://www.rbc.ru
              http://www.pravda-tv.ru
              https://www.politforums.net
              https://oko-planet.su
              http://minpromtorg.gov.ru
              https://www.rosminzdrav.ru
              http://www.gks.ru
              http://www.othist.ru/index.html
              https://topcor.ru
              https://ru.wikipedia.org - без нее никуда
              http://paraparabellum.ru
              http://w.histrf.ru
              http://www.aif.ru
              http://wpered.su
              http://skpkpss.ru
              http://army.armor.kiev.ua
              http://www.rotfront.su
              http://www.stihi.ru
              http://msoffice-nm.ru
              http://militera.lib.ru
              http://pdsnpsr.ru
              fakel-history.ru
              http://samlib.ru
              http://voenhronika.ru
              http://www.ekportal.ru
              https://ecouniver.com
              http://www.dist-cons.ru
              I can still throw, it is necessary?
              In general, you yourself will figure out where the sites are about economics, where about politics, where about history, where about industry, where are the entertainments, etc.
      2. Alecsandr
        Alecsandr 5 July 2018 15: 01
        0
        Our economy, probably, is masking and deliberately giving out underestimated data in order to mislead the Western "partners" regarding the growth of economic development indicators. And then, bam, we are ahead of the rest. (Joke)
    2. spektr9
      spektr9 4 July 2018 15: 20
      +8
      Almost all sectors (agricultural, industrial production) are developing normally in our country.

      It remains to tell this to people working in these industries, as they say, a minute of laughter prolongs life, and at such a pace we will reach 65 wink
      1. vlad007
        vlad007 4 July 2018 16: 31
        +1
        Quote: spektr9
        It remains to tell this to people working in these industries, as they say, a minute of laughter prolongs life, and at such a pace we will reach 65

        And I advise you to write specifics on the topic of the article, and not comments on the comments of other participants.
  4. Sotskiy
    Sotskiy 4 July 2018 07: 26
    +11
    And he wants the government, which has repeatedly proved its incompetence by deed, to finally be dismissed homeless. And ideally - that graduates and employees of the HSE be banned from holding positions in the civil service.

    To want is not harmful, it is harmful not to want, because those who are in the cemetery do not want anything.
    This raises the question of how to cross the Wishlist of the people and "we don’t hand over our horses and we don’t change our horses at the crossing" of the Guarantor, if the people themselves gave carte blanche to the Guarantor to continue this very "path", which means that we don’t give our own in it is present as an integral option . Or does someone still believe that Medvedev and Putin are not one team? lol
    And what is the people hoping for? People who have grown up with the idea “But in civilized countries”, suddenly something clicks and they will build a social State, based on the experience of previous generations?
    Why all of a sudden? They themselves call themselves "reformers", and in Russian realities according to Tolik Chubais this means scrapping, collapse and "the last nail in the lid of the coffin."
    So in the breakdown of social ideology, they succeeded more than ever and are rightly called effective.
    But what about the people, you ask. About the people, too, it was announced very clearly back in the 90s, if it didn’t even come to anyone then: “Well, 30 million will die out, what to worry about - new ones will grow!”
    So everything goes according to the chosen strategy, steadily and progressively! lol
    1. Boris55
      Boris55 4 July 2018 07: 53
      0
      Quote: Sovetskiy
      if the people themselves gave carte blanche to the Guarantor for the continuation of this same "path", which means "we don’t give our

      And it doesn’t mean at all. This is the same people that gave carte blanche to Garant, just like that it gave carte blanche to the current government along with Medvedev. He would vote for the Communist Party in the Duma elections - and there would be neither this government, nor Medvedev.
      Quote: Sovetskiy
      Or does someone still believe that Medvedev and Putin are not one team?

      Can you imagine there are such.
      There are no friends. There are only corporate interests, representatives of which are Putin and Medvedev. These groups have different interests. Your attempt to cross a hedgehog with a hedgehog is an attempt to shift Medvedev’s planned “jambs” to Putin. Figs to you - you won’t get anything!
      1. Sotskiy
        Sotskiy 4 July 2018 08: 02
        +8
        Quote: Boris55
        Can you imagine there are such. There are no friends. There are only corporate interests, representatives of which are Putin and Medvedev. These groups have different interests. Your attempt to cross the hedgehog with the hedgehog is an attempt to shift Medvedev's "schools" to Putin.

        Made laugh! good Thanks for the morning humor and uplifting. laughing
        Hope and faith, as they say, die last? Believe it! Whoever believes, he will always find, in an attempt to cross the "hedgehog with snake"!laughing
        1. Boris55
          Boris55 4 July 2018 08: 13
          0
          Quote: Sovetskiy
          Hope and faith, as they say, die last

          With faith and hope - this is the church.
          There are objective realities that a sane person cannot ignore. The confrontation of these clan-corporate groups more than once came out for all to see. Last time: on May 7, Putin confirms his opinion on the retirement age, on May 14, Medvedev announces a desire to raise him. You can continue to believe that they are friends.
          1. Sotskiy
            Sotskiy 4 July 2018 08: 20
            +4
            Quote: Boris55
            You can continue to believe that they are friends.

            Well, again, raise the "affairs of bygone years", or quarreled yesterday, on the basis of pension reform? lol
            1. Boris55
              Boris55 4 July 2018 08: 33
              0
              Quote: Sovetskiy
              Well, again, raise the "affairs of bygone years", or quarreled yesterday, on the basis of pension reform?

              If this is not enough for you, here is another example of their "friendship." Where is Libya when was President Medvedev and where is Syria when is president Putin. One slave another - a statesman.

              We see only what is already pouring over the edge. We can only guess what is really going on.
              1. Sotskiy
                Sotskiy 4 July 2018 08: 45
                +6
                Quote: Boris55
                If this is not enough for you, here is another example of their opposition:

                And what does that prove? lol
                Yes, every day at work we argue about "approach points" to solving production problems, and this does not prevent us from remaining in the same team and being friends, because we have one goal. tongue laughing
                1. Boris55
                  Boris55 4 July 2018 08: 52
                  0
                  Quote: Sovetskiy
                  at the same time, this does not prevent us from remaining in the same team and being friends, because we have one goal.

                  Your problem is that you equate your production relations with the interests of clans that have come to rule the country. Unlike your tasks, which have a general idea of ​​the final result, these clans have completely different ideas about the future of Russia. The Medvedevs dream of putting Russia at the owner’s feet for allowing them to lick their boots, while Putin’s want to determine their own fate and the fate of Russia.
                  You, trying to tie Medvedev’s “shoals” to Putin, are acting in the interests of the State Department, who wants to “knock down” Putin and put your man in control of Russia.
                  1. Sotskiy
                    Sotskiy 4 July 2018 09: 35
                    +11
                    Quote: Boris55
                    You, trying to tie Medvedev’s “shoals” to Putin, are acting in the interests of the State Department, who wants to “knock down” Putin and put your man in control of Russia.

                    Oh! lol Somewhere I already heard it. And, I remembered: "Do not rock the" boat ", otherwise we'll drown the mustache"? laughing
                    It is strange why Putin, as a member of the Party and an employee of the special services whose duties state "the integrity of the State," instead of fulfilling their direct duties, handed over their party cards and allowed the collapse of this very "boat", which incidentally was sworn to the USSR Constitution? Why didn’t you shout in the 90s about the “licked boots of the owners” and didn’t remember about the “boat”?
                    Yes, and do not explain to those who are incomprehensible how foreign owners differ from local ones, if both have interests and goals the same?
                    And on the account of industrial relations, isn’t the State including one of them? But we forgot not the relations of production in strategy, but the "free hand of the Market"! laughing So why be surprised then at such vivid examples of the "market" as the "uncontrolled" rise in fuel prices? At the same time, your idol every year expresses concern about this, but only strokes the "hand of the market"lol
                    1. Boris55
                      Boris55 4 July 2018 09: 41
                      0
                      Quote: Sovetskiy
                      It is strange why Putin, as a member of the Party and as an employee of the special services whose duties are spelled out

                      You do not seem to have served and are not familiar with the text of the oath. Here is an excerpt from you: "... I am always ready, on the orders of the Soviet Government, to defend my homeland - the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics ..."
                      Now tell me - was the government order to protect the USSR?
                      1. Sotskiy
                        Sotskiy 4 July 2018 09: 53
                        +4
                        Quote: Boris55
                        You do not seem to have served and are not familiar with the text of the oath. Here is an excerpt from you: "... I am always ready, on the orders of the Soviet Government, to defend my homeland - the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics ..."
                        Now tell me - was the government order to protect the USSR?

                        Why not quote further? lol
                        "... I swear to defend her courageously, skillfully, with dignity and honor, not sparing my blood and life itself to achieve complete victory over enemies ..."
                        In your opinion, if in the 41st “they hadn’t given an order”, would they have smoothed military bribes? lol
                        I forgot! According to a new liberal ideology, the USSR was an under-state; therefore, the USSR should be defended without an order - neither, nor?
                      2. Boris55
                        Boris55 4 July 2018 10: 07
                        0
                        Quote: Sovetskiy
                        Why not quote further?

                        Only after there is an order. An order is the basis of the army, without an order it is the worst collective farm
                        We have deviated too much from the stated topic. That's all. hi
                      3. Conductor
                        Conductor 5 July 2018 05: 39
                        0
                        YA now tell me, such a thing as a reasonable initiative is familiar to you, or so far there is no order. so you can not defend the homeland.
                  2. Maverick1812
                    Maverick1812 4 July 2018 12: 32
                    +6
                    Boris, do you write in your mind or at gunpoint ?! Still believe in the "good king" ?! And who suggested this Pokemon to the post of prime minister ?! Or also at gunpoint at the temple ...
              2. forty-eighth
                forty-eighth 6 July 2018 10: 21
                0
                Ohohoh, where is South Ossetia and Abkhazia, and where is the DPR and LPR?
                You would listen to yourself from the outside - it's ridiculous! GO-SU-DAR-STVEN-NIK laughing
      2. solzh
        solzh 4 July 2018 09: 23
        +2
        Quote: Boris55
        There are only corporate interests, representatives of which are Putin and Medvedev. These groups have different interests.

        Are you here to prepare us for the new oprichnina? Too often you talk about a good president and bad officials.
        Quote: Boris55
        This is the same people that gave carte blanche to Garant, in the same way he gave carte blanche to the current government along with Medvedev

        You see, even the people believe that Putin and Medvedev are one team, and you are all different groups and different interests ...
        1. Boris55
          Boris55 4 July 2018 09: 26
          0
          Quote: solzh
          Too often you talk about a good president and bad officials.

          I am only talking about their different interests. I like the interests of the country more than the interests of the State Department.
          Quote: solzh
          people believe that Putin and Medvedev are one team

          The people may be mistaken, say, as in Ukraine, they believed the talkers and ended up in a civil war. With us, they believed EP and got Medvedev.
          And on the topic: If Medvedev does not plan financial support for the May decrees of Putin, they will not be implemented. So who rules the country?
          1. spektr9
            spektr9 4 July 2018 15: 25
            +5
            I like the interests of the country more than the interests of the State Department
            Well, if you look at the decision of our authorities, then a couple it seems that they are lobbying the interests of the State Department ...
            If Medvedev does not plan financial support for the May decrees of Putin, they will not be implemented. So who rules the country?
            The country is ruled by power, and one team or different groups in tandem is deeply spit there, the result is one
  5. Ingvar 72
    Ingvar 72 4 July 2018 07: 43
    +6
    In particular, the outflow of foreign capital will increase.
    Do we really need them? According to Putin, Russian investment in Austria for 2018 is 25 billion. Euro. This is despite the fact that in 2011 they were about 2 billion euro. That is, for 7 years we have invested 23 billion in Austria. Euro. And if you take into account other Russian investments abroad? request
  6. parusnik
    parusnik 4 July 2018 07: 46
    +8
    Is white light converging on Medvedev, Siluanov and Oreshkin?
    .... Apparently converged ... There is no alternative to these respected people, day and night thinking about how to boost the Russian economy .. wink And the statement of the Ministry of Economic Development on the stagnation of the economy, says only one thing and will continue to rob, introduce new taxes .. And where else can the money be taken not from the oligarchs ... They already have a heavy burden ... to plunder the country .. There is such a profession ... smile
  7. Alex66
    Alex66 4 July 2018 08: 44
    +2
    The Ministry of Economic Development would have to study the experience when we had the highest growth rates without outsiders and due to what, but this is a taboo, which means that we are doomed to degrade with the rest of the third world, no one will give us markets, at cost with southerners we will not be able to compete with gas and energy we sell to our consumers at market prices, but rather at domestic preferential prices. In short, our system is not so that the economy grows.
    1. udincev
      udincev 6 July 2018 15: 51
      +1
      Quote: Alex66
      ... when we had the highest growth rates and without investors from ...

      This, unfortunately or joy, is no longer with us.
  8. GRIGORIY76
    GRIGORIY76 4 July 2018 09: 21
    +3
    Is white light converging on Medvedev, Siluanov and Oreshkin?

    What do you want Putin to appoint a statesman as prime minister? Do you want our economy to have effective managers fighting for the development of domestic production? What do you want so that after some successful reforms the “irremovable” becomes a pale shadow of a strong prime minister and his economic team?
    Remember, while the guarantor of the violation of the constitution "drives" to the Kremlin, you will not see any bright person there (well, except for gentleman Lavrov and his dabilov ***, and General Shoigu, who did not even serve urgently, but wears such stars.
  9. populist
    populist 4 July 2018 09: 23
    +2
    Where is the growth of investment in infrastructure?

    There will be investments in infrastructure - in the bridge to Sakhalin and in the lunar orbital station. Like these ones fellow investments in the next pyramids of Cheops laughing laughing laughing Buried folk money for the umpteenth time negative
  10. Whowhy
    Whowhy 4 July 2018 09: 39
    +6
    Of course, I repeat myself, but is it not time to finally decide - the economy in Russia is a science, or Ostap Bender's list of methods for relatively honest withdrawal of money from the population ???
    If this is science, then why is the Russian government cynically ignoring it? Why did China crawl out of its deepest rival into world leaders, and Russia with a good starting point is sliding there deeper and deeper?
    If there are some fraudsters gathered, is it not the time to put them in the furnace ???
    1. prior
      prior 4 July 2018 11: 06
      +8
      "Why has China climbed out of its deepest backs to world leaders, and Russia with a good starting point is sliding back deeper and deeper?"

      Because China develops real production, and shoots bribes and corrupt officials.
      And our Naibulins and Siluanovs are engaged in mathematical fraud and manipulation of interest.
      Until we buy everything in China, up to buttons and pins, everything will remain that way.
      And so that something changes (read paragraph 1) - you need to change the system .....
      Return with .. USSR! (I did not say the CPSU ....) Although China and the CCP are not a hindrance.
      1. aybolyt678
        aybolyt678 4 July 2018 15: 37
        +2
        Quote: prior
        Return with .. USSR! (I did not say the CPSU ....) Although China and the CCP are not an obstacle

        for some reason tsarist Russia is considered a different country than the Stalin Union, and the USSR of the Brezhnev period is different than the period of Putin. The country is one, at least Russia, different leaders.
        China prays to Stalin, studies the causes of the collapse of the USSR, and does not scatter the Communist Parties.
    2. aybolyt678
      aybolyt678 4 July 2018 15: 39
      0
      Quote: whowhy
      is the economy in Russia a science, or Ostap Bender's list of methods for relatively honest withdrawal of money from the population ???

      because Democracy is not the power of the people but the AUTHORITY OF THE AMERICAN PEOPLE.
  11. The comment was deleted.
  12. akudr48
    akudr48 4 July 2018 10: 34
    +4
    The problem of the Ministry of Economic Development is that even the muddy wording “geopolitical instability” does not save the government from unpleasant issues associated with a slowdown in business activity

    How many switchmen can be searched for, without even mentioning that the entire country's power system has only one goal - to keep power in a narrow circle close to the president, to rip 7 skins from the people and to push the people gathered in this narrow circle.

    The Ministry of Economic Development is not a problem, but a symptom of a problem.

    Search above, author.
  13. asiat_61
    asiat_61 4 July 2018 10: 45
    0
    Found an interesting thing. https://www.kramola.info/vesti/novosti/vnezapno-v
    -konstitucii-zakreplyon-pensionnyy-vozrast ...... uh
    then about the retirement age in the constitution of the Russian Federation.
    1. Boris55
      Boris55 4 July 2018 11: 11
      +3
      Quote: asiat_61
      Found an interesting thing. ..to about the retirement age in the constitution of the Russian Federation.

      Have you read my koment there? There he is:
      "The Constitution should be read in its entirety, and not pulled out of it, just what you liked.
      Constitution of the Russian Federation. Article 55, paragraph 3. The rights and freedoms of man and citizen may be limited by federal law only to the extent that it is necessary in order to protect the foundations of the constitutional order, morality, health, rights and legitimate interests of others, to ensure the defense of the country and the security of the state.
      I will explain. The rights and freedoms of man and citizen may be limited by federal law only to the extent that it is necessary for the purpose ..., rights and legitimate interests of others, ....
      Other persons should be understood as persons from the Forbes magazine list. So there’s NO violation of the State Department Constitution! "
      1. aybolyt678
        aybolyt678 4 July 2018 15: 34
        +1
        Forbes magazine does not like to be restricted. Because, in their opinion, limited people cannot be interesting and good.
  14. sib.ataman
    sib.ataman 4 July 2018 11: 00
    +1
    All this gang-brethren deserves only one tribunal and eternal hard labor beyond the Arctic Circle! This is the most optimistic forecast!
  15. prior
    prior 4 July 2018 11: 26
    +1
    According to the results of activities, the renaming of the Ministry of Economic Development to the Ministry of Economic Declineation suggests itself.
  16. Maverick1812
    Maverick1812 4 July 2018 12: 26
    +2
    And what, the last of May completely fulfilled ... or the year before .... .... No, I did not see!
  17. Altona
    Altona 4 July 2018 13: 12
    +8
    Quote: Boris55
    Thank you for this to Putin, who is implementing such a foreign policy that has such a beneficial effect on domestic policy.

    ----------------------------------
    What is beneficence? Yesterday I watched the movie "1984" based on Orwell's novel. And this beneficence is all thanks to the "hour of hatred" on the TV "Russia" from Solovyov or Kiselyov, and on the First the same garbage. Internal problems are blurred, all Ukrainians are enemies, Belarusians are half-allied, and so on, right up to the vile State Department, which prevents us from growing cucumbers.
    1. aybolyt678
      aybolyt678 4 July 2018 15: 32
      +5
      Quote: Altona
      What is beneficence?

      very relevant! on the one hand there is no war! on the other hand, it is only economic, and we lose it very stably i.e. Slow.
  18. Altona
    Altona 4 July 2018 13: 14
    +5
    Quote: Maverick1812
    And what, the last of May completely fulfilled ... or the year before .... .... No, I did not see!

    ---------------------------
    "May decrees" is a screen, non-binding words to which you can rob a country.
  19. aybolyt678
    aybolyt678 4 July 2018 15: 30
    +3
    The reason for the disappointing forecast is simple: there are no executions for disrupting the task of state IMPORTANCE.
  20. andrew42
    andrew42 4 July 2018 15: 41
    +4
    The current monetarist economists in the government led by DAM are a direct legacy of the era of Yegor Gaidar with accomplices. Flesh from the flesh. They can still redistribute the tax blanket, create new sources of income, alas. To do this, it is necessary to engage in the real economy, and not to inflate GDP at the expense of the service sector, where they suck each other's funds pulled from real sectors, which are already hobbling on one broken leg. We need a socialist “oprichnina” in the economy — state-owned enterprises with a dignified attitude to the person of work — competitors of business holdings. Then it will become clear for whose products the people will bear the money, where the staff will flow. Without "sovereign factories" (and not only factories), Russia has always been unable to live. What is needed is a “socialization" of the economy, at least partial, where monetarist methods are secondary. and know their place "under the bench."
  21. nikvic46
    nikvic46 4 July 2018 15: 46
    +2
    Quote: solzh
    Quote: vlad007
    In our country, almost all sectors (agricultural, industrial production) are developing normally (4-7%), except for construction. There has been a decline in construction, so the overall performance in the country is not very high. The author needs to study the situation in the economy in more detail BY INDUSTRY!

    Where did you get such data? Even Rosstat, after a recent obscure recount of growth indicators, does not have such figures.

    Rosstat has growth indicators, but apparently the growth is so small that he is afraid to advertise it.
  22. klm-57
    klm-57 4 July 2018 15: 47
    +1
    Who specifically recommends the author? Under whom does he want to "make room"? And then behind the words there is no way to solve problems. The article can be described in two words, everything is bad.
    1. akula
      akula 4 July 2018 17: 26
      +2
      And what’s good? Besides the mundial, nothing.
      1. Vadim237
        Vadim237 5 July 2018 01: 03
        0
        Everything else is good. - we develop no matter how.
    2. Conductor
      Conductor 5 July 2018 05: 45
      0
      Duc and how good about seeing if n cleared the whole field. Sechin chtoli toad-shaped moving.
  23. nikvic46
    nikvic46 4 July 2018 16: 02
    +3
    Everyone probably forgot the words of Chubais after the collapse of the USSR "We decided to destroy criminal communism, and decided
    to build gangster capitalism ".." How to proceed further we had no plans. "Not bad he spoke about the coffin
    communism and the nails that they boarded up in this coffin (read into the country). Thank you for your frankness.
    1. Vadim237
      Vadim237 5 July 2018 01: 04
      0
      Communism ruined itself - a tablecloth is dear to him.
  24. PValery53
    PValery53 4 July 2018 16: 22
    +1
    Rename the Ministry of Economic Development into the Ministry of Economic Regress, and let the name justify itself. All the same, they are of benefit, as with a goat - milk.
    1. Vadim237
      Vadim237 5 July 2018 01: 06
      0
      And what good is it from you - if not from the Ministry of Economic Development?
  25. Sasha_Sar
    Sasha_Sar 4 July 2018 16: 49
    +1
    Sotskiy,
    I applaud while standing, the opponent is defeated, his arguments are over, the training manual is worn down to holes laughing
  26. akula
    akula 4 July 2018 17: 20
    +1
    Quote: Boris55
    The first commandment: “I am the Lord your God ... May you not have other gods before My face” (Exodus 20: 2-3).
    There should always be one who is worth following.
    Reply Quote Complaint

    Do not make yourself idols! It looks like you have something with the psyche.
  27. serge siberian
    serge siberian 4 July 2018 17: 34
    +1
    The last two paragraphs are right on target.
    1. Vadim237
      Vadim237 5 July 2018 01: 06
      0
      Then everything flew into milk - the article is a dummy.
  28. 16112014nk
    16112014nk 4 July 2018 18: 33
    +1
    For our reappointed resident, the light came in a wedge on Medvedev, Siluanov, Oreshkin, Kudrin and Elvira Sakhipzadovna, etc. Moreover, when these reappointers were examined, all the bones were washed, but they did not say a word about Elvira Sakhipzadovna. I wonder why ? Someone banned? request
    1. Bigbraza
      4 July 2018 20: 16
      +2
      Quote: 16112014nk
      Moreover, when they considered these reassignors, all the bones were washed, but they did not say a word about the elvira saipzadovna. I wonder why ? Someone banned? request

      You will not believe it, but it is the only one in our “economic bloc” who knows and knows at least something. If it were not for her rough work to clean up the banking sector before the crisis (and she cleared up the 350 order of "laundries" in a year and a half), then in 2014-2015 years we would have been waiting for such a financial hurricane that would have fallen over Putin. And she covered the government, taking on all the negative about the devaluation of the ruble. The fact that devaluation was inevitable because of the lack of talent of the government is pointless to explain. Therefore, they hanged everything on her, and she drags and does not complain.
      Maybe this is why they take care that the Medvedevs and the Siluanovs were not lying around.
      1. 16112014nk
        16112014nk 5 July 2018 14: 01
        0
        I will answer with the words of Stanislavsky: "I do not believe!"
  29. vladimirvn
    vladimirvn 4 July 2018 20: 13
    +1
    Yesterday on Kutuzovsky Prospekt, a black Bentley with three sevens on a license plate crashed into a traffic police car, after which the traffic police car disappeared into an unknown direction.
  30. New Year day
    New Year day 4 July 2018 20: 56
    0
    VTsIOM: 25% of Russians assess their financial situation as “bad” or “very bad”. This is a third higher than the level of 2017. (18%) and is a record since the crisis of 2009, when 28% of Russians complained about financial problems. The economic expectations index collapsed to its lowest level since 2008: 26% of survey participants said they expect further deterioration in their financial situation. The share of pending improvements fell from 33% to 24%, which also became a historic low.
    42% of Russians believe that the country is moving in the wrong direction, while 43% are ready for street protests.
    From 2013 to 2016, the number of tours sold to the Russian population decreased by 38%: from 5,4 million vacation packages in 2013 to 3,4 million in 2016. In 2017, the market won back this drop of 10%, but still did not rise to the pre-crisis level.
    The average cost of a foreign tour in 2014-2018 increased by 45,5%, from 68 thousand rubles to 99 thousand, and real incomes of the population over the same period fell by 11%. Russians have no time for tourism
    1. aybolyt678
      aybolyt678 4 July 2018 21: 31
      +1
      without any VTsIOM - recently visited Chelyabinsk, Kurgan, Omsk and Barnaul everywhere the same thing: commercial real estate is for sale, rented out in the busiest places. Amazing Yes, and of course. Big shops came that ate little shops. Interesting consumer goods arrived, a huge amount, our galoshes have no place there. The remains of production are killed.
      Quote: Silvestr
      42% of Russians believe that the country is moving in the wrong direction

      non progredy est regredy (lat) - lack of progress is regression. 42 percent think? 95 percent think so! for the rest 5 there is no data. But these are those who are hiring foreign capital. They are not recognized. They are agents. Only not traitors. They just work for the sake of the most holy - money! After all, they have real estate abroad !! and these are the roots. Native roots rotted. About patriotism is not clear. It seems there is a law on patriotic education. But if a person has real estate there - is it possible to trust him in a state post or work in the media, why is this not in the Law ??? how to educate young people if the media impose a consumer attitude on life. The discussion of many political issues begins with the phrase: - I, as a consumer, .... and further it is explained that it is better to buy import than to be tormented with my native Russian, because importing is more convenient. Why have I never heard - I, as a citizen, prefer Russian !?
  31. Vadim237
    Vadim237 5 July 2018 00: 56
    0
    Author You are not a macroeconomist - everything is much more complicated and contradictory there than it seems at first glance. And such articles "screams from scratch" to write each and every one.
  32. Brigadier
    Brigadier 8 July 2018 08: 37
    0
    Everything goes according to the IMF plan ... Putin's "bros" firmly know what they are doing ...
    It is unlikely that they would act so shamelessly without the support of their "godfather" !!!

    1. Golovan Jack
      Golovan Jack 8 July 2018 08: 41
      +1
      Correctly! More demotivators, good and different!
      I don’t have my own thoughts request
      Quote: Brigadier
      Putin "bros" know what they are doing ...
      It is unlikely that they would act so shamelessly without the support of their "godfather"

      And here I also sometimes sadly recall the Union ... with the Union of such "courageous" as you, at least in the White Poles, determined to be forced.
      But now - democracy and freedom, (censorship), words ... any, practically. "What I want is screaming."
      Ugh, I'm sorry, Goss negative
  33. ASASHOKA
    ASASHOKA 10 July 2018 18: 58
    +1
    Gentlemen in one world live and they have their own aspirations, and the rest of the electorate in another world vegetates.
    Where can we make our way to a brighter future! There are masters, no builders.
  34. VB
    VB 10 July 2018 20: 08
    0
    Comrade Stalin, such a government in its entirety would have been encouraged by a bullet in the basement. And this is absolutely correct. Took on tug ... bear responsibility