Military Review

Kudrin: There is no alternative to investing in American debt today

239
Approved as head of the Accounts Chamber of Russia, Alexey Kudrin, the day before, came to a meeting with deputies of the United Russia faction in the State Duma of the Russian Federation. Kudrin deputies asked questions related to the macroeconomic situation in Russia and in the world. One of the questions concerned the continuing US investments in US debt securities against the background of US sanctions. Kudrin asked if it’s time to stop practicing this kind of investment.


Kudrin's answer from the words of State Duma Deputy Vladimir Gutenev leads RIA News:
In a mild form, he (Kudrin) made it clear that he considers the placement of gold reserves and state savings in American securities to be quite acceptable. He said that, of course, political risks should be taken into account when making decisions, but at the moment he does not see any alternatives.


Kudrin: There is no alternative to investing in American debt today


Recall that by the end of 2017, the share of Russia's gold and foreign exchange reserves in US dollars increased from 40,4% to 45,8%. At the same time, the share of gold and foreign currency reserves in euro has significantly decreased. Thus, the Russian financial system continues not only to invest in American debt, but also to increase these investments. And it is unlikely in the medium term the situation in this regard will somehow change. This makes it clear and former Finance Minister Alexei Kudrin, whom the United States at one time called almost the best finance minister in the world.
Photos used:
Facebook
239 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. ANCIENT
    ANCIENT 16 May 2018 06: 46
    +81
    I offer Kudrin to give free of charge - irrevocably the USA! We won’t be able to do any better “ownership” than to fuse it there! !!
    1. Andrey Yuryevich
      Andrey Yuryevich 16 May 2018 06: 50
      +109
      Kudrin was returned by Putin, it remains Serdyukov and Vasilyeva to return to the MO, then certainly there will be a “breakthrough” ... at all seams.
      1. teu
        teu 16 May 2018 07: 17
        +35
        Quietly everyone will be returned who was involved in the destruction of the Russian Federation, it remains to wait ...
        1. For example
          For example 16 May 2018 07: 37
          +19
          Oh, offended activated. laughing Putin is to blame for everything !!! wassat
          Just as Kudrin can carry all kinds of blizzards, you blame Putin for YOUR own problems.
          Freedom of conscience! wink
          The dog barks, the caravan goes.
          The bridge, for example, is already open. The dagger is armed. Etc.......
          1. Ingvar 72
            Ingvar 72 16 May 2018 07: 57
            +43
            Quote: For example
            About offended activated. Putin is to blame for everything !!!

            No damn it - the boyars are bad! good
            P.S. Are you a fan of Kudrin and investments in T-bills of the USA? Before you there was only one such one was Golovan Jack, he was a cat beckon, he is Kisa. Are you his hypostasis, or a separate bot? wink
            1. just exp
              just exp 16 May 2018 08: 20
              +16
              that would not scratch about kudrin but he is an expert specialist. and he can and will offer something. they keep him behind this. but they will accept what he offers or not depends on the president.
              Let me remind you that it was Kudrin who proposed creating a small pillow (reserve funds) and without them we would have started the new 2014 year in 1985 (when the Saudis brought down oil prices and the USSR began to take some positions in Europe for loans)
              1. mr.Vain
                mr.Vain 16 May 2018 08: 36
                +2
                I also disagree with this, but where to invest then? There is not so much physical gold, the same dollar in euros, well, where to invest the money so that inflation would not eat them?
                1. Gardamir
                  Gardamir 16 May 2018 08: 42
                  +46
                  and where to invest then?
                  in production, science, education, medicine ....
                  1. mr.Vain
                    mr.Vain 16 May 2018 08: 50
                    +5
                    Quote: Gardamir
                    and where to invest then?
                    in production, science, education, medicine ....


                    That is, to spend everything, and if the rainy day comes? And I see from my own data that it is coming, and 2008 will seem like a storm in a glass compared to what awaits us.
                    1. Gardamir
                      Gardamir 16 May 2018 08: 56
                      +34
                      Is a rainy day coming?
                      and he will come, if not to invest in the development of the country. Or do you believe that the Americans will return the money?
                      1. mr.Vain
                        mr.Vain 16 May 2018 09: 04
                        +11
                        I am opposed to investing in their debt, it is necessary to invest in the development of the country, but there should be a small egg, the question is what to keep it in?
                      2. NordOst16
                        NordOst16 16 May 2018 09: 17
                        +3
                        In order to invest money, we need tight control by society, i.e. where, how much and how. And for this it is necessary to bother a little power, so that she was afraid of her people (probably as it was in Novgorod)))
                      3. just exp
                        just exp 16 May 2018 09: 29
                        0
                        the money is not with the Americans, but with us this money is just dollars.
                        this is if you invest in the traderis (debt obligations) mattresses can throw.
                        and bucks only if you keep them in state banks. but they are not kept there.
                    2. DenZ
                      DenZ 16 May 2018 09: 10
                      +20
                      Quote: mr.Vain
                      And I see from my own data that it is coming, and 2008 will seem like a storm in a glass compared to what awaits us.

                      Well, yes, if our assets abroad are frozen, then the very day you are talking about will come. In the meantime, we are diligently investing in these assets thanks to people like Kudrin.
                      And yet it is better to meet a rainy day with your developed economy than up to a rainy day to support the enemy.
                      1. NordOst16
                        NordOst16 16 May 2018 09: 19
                        +1
                        Focus on development and what's next? About 30-35 percent will get to the point, the rest will go into the pockets of officials, from there to the States and Europe. There is no big difference, and at least there will be more legal protection.
                  2. NordOst16
                    NordOst16 16 May 2018 09: 16
                    0
                    I am not a visionary, but I can say with 80% certainty that, God forbid, 30–35 percent of this money will go to the good, the rest will go into the pockets of officials, and from there to Europe or the States. So it’s better that way because the USA always paid its debts (although there was a case with Iran, we don’t intend to attack the diplomatic consulate of the USA - that is, the territory of the USA).
                  3. just exp
                    just exp 16 May 2018 09: 27
                    +1
                    if we are now when oil prices can collapse again at any moment (the price of oil is essentially fixed. It does not depend on the cost of production and other things, this is a purely political decision, it will be necessary to drop the price, it will be necessary to skyrocket) we will put in all that You have listed (and they invest a lot in these positions), it’s just that at a critical moment for the economy, everything can collapse due to external factors.
                    while the fat dries, the thin dies.
                    the egg-pod should be and should be big.
                    1. mr.Vain
                      mr.Vain 16 May 2018 11: 50
                      0
                      I absolutely agree with you, from today oil will only fall, ahead of difficult times.
                  4. Vadim237
                    Vadim237 16 May 2018 10: 35
                    +1
                    "In production, science, education, medicine." On this and so every year, spend more than two trillion rubles.
                  5. the most important
                    the most important 16 May 2018 13: 36
                    +8
                    Quote: Gardamir
                    and where to invest then?
                    in production, science, education, medicine ....

                    Are you stunned ??? What is the use of science, education and medicine? You need to invest in yachts, in vineyards in Tuscany, in charity funds, in a cello, in a residence, in sneakers !! This is the most necessary! and the rest is just noodles on our ears about our (or rather them) happy tomorrow!
                2. Dam
                  Dam 16 May 2018 11: 19
                  0
                  Into your own infrastructure
                3. Mstislav Udatny
                  Mstislav Udatny 16 May 2018 13: 41
                  0
                  "Well, where to invest money so that inflation would not eat them?"

                  Need to eliminate inflation
                  1. Vadim237
                    Vadim237 16 May 2018 15: 47
                    +1
                    A lot of inflation will gobble up when it is 2,5%
                4. Oleg14774
                  Oleg14774 17 May 2018 10: 38
                  0
                  Quote: mr.Vain
                  I also disagree with this, but where to invest then? There is not so much physical gold, the same dollar in euros, well, where to invest the money so that inflation would not eat them?

                  And didn’t you think about the fact that you can build factories, provide people with jobs and salaries, sell finished products and earn profits several times, even by orders of magnitude greater than from the sale of oil and gas?
                  In general, who said that we should fight for markets for oil in Europe? Do not like the prices of oil and gas, electric energy and rare earth metals? We will not be lost with all this, and let Europe buy from the USA and elsewhere.
              2. Pax tecum
                Pax tecum 16 May 2018 08: 56
                +14
                Kudrin is a complete liberal. It is a fact!
                And as a liberal - an active supporter "liberal monitor policy".
                Those. knows how to count. Now he has supervisory function.
                Nobody will let him go close to making government decisions, even advising him.
                The financial sector and especially the real sector of the economy are closed to it. And the interaction of these sectors is even more so.

                PS Do not forget that Putin, by his own admission, is a convinced liberal.
                It’s not customary to recall this in the elections, or what?
                1. hrych
                  hrych 16 May 2018 10: 01
                  +1
                  Quote: Pax tecum
                  Nobody will let him go close to making government decisions, even advising him.
                  The financial sector and especially the real sector of the economy are closed to it.

                  This is the most important thing to note in the discussion laughing
                  At the expense of reserves, the main commodity circulation is in dollars and this is a fact, for example, for the time being, it takes dollars to purchase Korean machine tools, equipment, pharmaceuticals, etc. We still do not forget that even though the currency share is growing, the overall investment in gold is growing. Those. the growth of the currency mass is not due to the sale of gold, but simply this mass grows naturally as a result of trade, also due to the depreciation of the ruble and import substitution. No need to say what we invest in American debt, the Fed does not belong to the USA as a state, it is a supranational structure of world order.
                2. dvina71
                  dvina71 16 May 2018 11: 02
                  0
                  Quote: Pax tecum
                  convinced liberal.

                  There is subtlety. Liberalism. A very broad concept .. From classical to neoliberalism. Convinced is not a classification. But Kudrin is a neoliberal.
                3. bsk_mna54
                  bsk_mna54 16 May 2018 18: 51
                  +1
                  Who said that they would not allow him to enter the economy? He himself will fit into the economy, or rather, that as such the economy does not exist! Otherwise, he will not be Kudrin.
              3. NEOZ
                NEOZ 16 May 2018 10: 35
                +1
                Quote: just explo
                I remind you that this is Kudrin

                I’ll also remind you that investments in the US government debt bring 0.5-1% per annum with a minimum term of 5 years, the Russian Federation themselves issue securities (borrowed) in foreign currency at 5-6% per annum .... and of course we do not forget about the depreciation us dollar, remember that 100 dollars 10 years ago and 100 dollars now are completely different purchasing abilities ......
              4. Viltor
                Viltor 16 May 2018 17: 10
                0
                We have in football, too, like "experts are not bad," but as they enter the field, write is gone! Nobody needs a good specialist today without the support and professional associates, only as a controller!
                1. Oleg14774
                  Oleg14774 17 May 2018 10: 44
                  0
                  Quote: Viltor
                  We have in football, too, like "experts are not bad," but as they enter the field, write is gone! Nobody needs a good specialist today without the support and professional associates, only as a controller!

                  We have good specialists, but they are not allowed to enter the field. There is the same mafia as in the stage. I never believed and never believe that in such a huge country like Russia there are no worthy football players. Spain, Italy, England ... these are not big countries and as a percentage of our players are definitely there.
                  Watch the show "Voice of Russia" and go nuts! Next to ordinary talented people, the Kirkorovs, Galkins, Arbokaitovs didn’t even lie nearby!
              5. Oleg14774
                Oleg14774 17 May 2018 10: 35
                0
                Quote: just EXPL
                that would not scratch about kudrin but he is an expert specialist. and he can and will offer something. they keep him behind this. but they will accept what he offers or not depends on the president.
                Let me remind you that it was Kudrin who proposed creating a small pillow (reserve funds) and without them we would have started the new 2014 year in 1985 (when the Saudis brought down oil prices and the USSR began to take some positions in Europe for loans)

                Yes, I see you are an expert, especially if you think about what you wrote. So the Saudis are to blame for the collapse of the USSR and the collapse of industry? Ukraine still won’t get rid of the Soviet legacy. Everything steals, squanders, and much more remains.
                Do not connect Kudrin with those merits that do not belong to him, I would say even more. Contrary to him!
            2. I am Russian
              I am Russian 16 May 2018 09: 23
              +4
              aka Romanov, or inadequate novels by himself?
            3. Nyrobsky
              Nyrobsky 16 May 2018 10: 51
              +1
              Quote: Ingvar 72
              No damn it - the boyars are bad!
              P.S. Are you a fan of Kudrin and investments in T-bills of the USA? Before you there was only one such one was Golovan Jack, he was a cat beckon, he is Kisa. Are you his hypostasis, or a separate bot?

              No, well, and if you really look at the topic, then it’s finally not clear why people are more worried about the State Department, which is always worried and for any reason. Well, there is an opinion of Kudrin. What's next? He is a bookkeeper and is not allowed to invest in "extra" babos. Decisions are made by other people. Well, Kudrin has been rubbing the same thing since 2011, but for the past 7 years after his resignation from the government, shuttles in the run mode went to paper or to paper in a deposit range of 114 billion - 86 billion - 108 billion. with him and Kudrin, let him now look after Dimon, his case is the Accounts Chamber.
            4. The_X_Factor
              The_X_Factor 20 May 2018 11: 25
              0
              And what difference does Kudrin say? This is the Accounts Chamber, and it is not for her to decide where to invest or not to invest.
          2. Dr_engie
            Dr_engie 16 May 2018 08: 08
            +13
            I don’t need either your bridge or a dagger. I just would like to have a normal job in the region, and in general to live not like in a big village, in the oil and gas producing region either.
            1. Victor N
              Victor N 16 May 2018 09: 21
              +5
              It all depends on you personally: choose a profession that is in demand and well-paid and upgrade your qualifications. Nobody will do this for you!
              And do not want to live in a village - move. Everything in life is simply arranged, if you do not poison yourself with freebie chimeras.
              1. Severok
                Severok 16 May 2018 09: 28
                +7
                Specialties are full hands, from metalworking to assembly-adjustment machines. They just pay so that you have to leave your family and live in the same mug, there is not enough salary for a bigger one. From that I had to leave the security forces.
                1. Dr_engie
                  Dr_engie 16 May 2018 13: 35
                  0
                  By the way, yes. The most demanded "industry". The junior security inspector in the FSIN receives 18 thousand here. In order to get so much in other areas, you need to be the head of the department, or the main specialist.
                2. The_X_Factor
                  The_X_Factor 20 May 2018 11: 27
                  0
                  Why start a family if you can’t support her?
            2. NEOZ
              NEOZ 16 May 2018 10: 38
              +4
              Quote: Dr_Engie
              I don’t need either your bridge or a dagger.

              the fact is that to have normal work in the region, we need both the Crimean bridge and the "dagger" and much more ... it's a pity that you do not understand this ...
              1. Paranoid50
                Paranoid50 16 May 2018 11: 30
                +1
                Quote: NEOZ
                it’s a pity you don’t understand this ...

                Yes, it seems, a program or just a troll .. yes I looked at the comments - there are no dialogs, only throw-in throws. So you are right - does not understand. laughing
                1. Dr_engie
                  Dr_engie 16 May 2018 13: 36
                  0
                  Yes Yes. When lard is poured into the unfortunate bridge, and then they say to teachers they do not pay allowances, because the treasury is empty.
                  1. The_X_Factor
                    The_X_Factor 20 May 2018 11: 28
                    0
                    The bridge is more useful than most of these teachers. Fact.
            3. Nyrobsky
              Nyrobsky 16 May 2018 10: 54
              +4
              Quote: Dr_Engie
              I don’t need either your bridge or a dagger. I just would like to have a normal job in the region, and in general to live not like in a big village, in the oil and gas producing region

              Do not lose heart - the West will help you. Better yet, do not wait for help from him, go there right now.
            4. Alexey g
              Alexey g 16 May 2018 12: 14
              +2
              Quote: Dr_Engie
              I don’t need either your bridge or a dagger.

              Just like a child’s, "I don’t need to be your dagger." It’s not difficult to “google” what they do with those who lose the war. This is all exactly what to scream in the Second World War - "I do not need your T-34s, IL-2s and Katyushas." These things were not created for show-offs, but in order to survive, and those who say that this is not necessary have not far gone in terms of intelligence from the log.
              Although, apparently, the author of the quote is a foreigner with a cracked back seat.
              1. Dr_engie
                Dr_engie 16 May 2018 13: 38
                0
                And what about war? Where?
                In addition to those places where they themselves climbed.
                And so yes, let's rivet even more tanks and generally take a break from hunger ourselves, no one will even have to attack.
                1. zoolu350
                  zoolu350 16 May 2018 16: 45
                  +3
                  Our war is in full swing and it is everywhere: in politics, in economics, in ideology, in sport, in science and in the oligarchy of the Russian Federation this war is losing. You are right in one thing that in this situation even a million tanks will not help because there is no Idea, Plan and Will.
          3. Vadivak
            Vadivak 16 May 2018 08: 23
            +10
            Quote: For example
            The dog barks, the caravan goes.

            "You have to drive you through the desert for another fifty years, Until everyone who voted dies."
            Shaov Timur
          4. Hefty literate
            Hefty literate 16 May 2018 08: 55
            +5
            That new weapons are emerging is good. But what does the bridge have to do with it? Is all life in Russia reduced to a bridge?
            1. DenZ
              DenZ 16 May 2018 09: 16
              0
              Quote: Hefty literate
              But what does the bridge have to do with it? Is all life in Russia reduced to a bridge?

              Life in the south of Russia in many respects and in Crimea was completely reduced to a bridge. Maybe it’s not noticeable from Belarus.
          5. Kent0001
            Kent0001 16 May 2018 09: 35
            +6
            And how did this affect the standard of living of ordinary citizens? Well, the bridge gave an increase to GDP, but it gave an even greater increase to the capital of the "friends" who built it, and the officials who served this topic. The bridge is needed, as well as much more, only we have no government efficiency. Therefore, the price of such "bridges" in the future will always be sky-high, with constant adjustment to growth during construction (Zenit Arena is the MOST best example for you). Yes, and the Vostochny spaceport is there too.
            1. NEOZ
              NEOZ 16 May 2018 10: 40
              0
              Quote: Kent0001
              but he gave even greater growth to the capital of "friends"

              and how do you like? tell me more ..
          6. The comment was deleted.
        2. Pax tecum
          Pax tecum 16 May 2018 08: 35
          +10
          Kudrin: Alternatives investing in American debt today no

          Here it is! Well, there is no alternative to them! Moreover, at the same time, the population is inspired and convinced that there are no alternatives to those in power either.
          Well, then there is no alternative to a qualitative change of power, except for the experimental-historical method ...
          1. MPN
            MPN 16 May 2018 09: 09
            +9
            Quote: Pax tecum
            Moreover, at the same time, the population is inspired and convinced,

            We were satisfied ... over there spat the pancake ... angry
          2. NordOst16
            NordOst16 16 May 2018 09: 21
            +1
            Focus on development and what's next? About 30-35 percent will get to the point, the rest will go into the pockets of officials, from there to the States and Europe. There is no big difference, and at least there will be more legal protection.
            In order to invest money in the economy and at the same time to make it work, we need tight control from society, i.e. where, how much and how. And for this it is necessary to bother a little power, so that she was afraid of her people (probably as it was in Novgorod)))
            But who will do this for this is rocking the boat or the wreckage of the Titanic
          3. Victor N
            Victor N 16 May 2018 09: 29
            0
            I apologize for entering a topic? Regarding the investment of reserves, Kudrin is right - any competent economist will confirm this. One can endlessly discuss the value of reserves - but this is another question ..
        3. Alber
          Alber 16 May 2018 16: 59
          0
          Quote: evp
          Quietly everyone will be returned who was involved in the destruction of the Russian Federation, it remains to wait ...


          Shaw, again?
      2. Alex-a832
        Alex-a832 16 May 2018 07: 28
        +15
        Quote: Andrew Y.
        Kudrin was returned by Putin, it remains Serdyukov and Vasilyeva to return to the MO, then certainly there will be a “breakthrough” ... at all seams.

        Serdyukov and Vasilyeva are commonplace crooks who have gained access to a large feeding trough. With Kudrin, the question is completely different - this is a terry liberalist. But Kudrino hoarding served Russia's very good service during the period of falling oil prices and “sanctions”. Due to these stash, we did not get inflation, we were able to pay huge government orders for the defense industry and not cut social programs in the most important areas. It is also pointless to deny it. Maybe for these merits and put him on the post of auditor (not manager).
        1. The_X_Factor
          The_X_Factor 20 May 2018 11: 32
          0
          You are one of the few sane in this thread.
      3. raw174
        raw174 16 May 2018 08: 52
        +1
        Quote: Andrey Yurievich
        Kudrin was returned by Putin, it remains Serdyukov and Vasilyeva to return to the MO, then certainly there will be a “breakthrough” ... at all seams.

        You see, whom to put on key posts in the Russian Federation is not so important. The power in the Russian Federation, in fact, is a monarchy (I already wrote about this), Kudrin can say, you can put Serdyukov as the Minister of Health, you can Mutko give the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, but HE determines the key decisions and strategy! I’m not talking about crooks and embezzlement, I’m talking about making decisions that determine the vector. So in this matter the decision will be made by Putin.
        1. NordOst16
          NordOst16 16 May 2018 09: 23
          +4
          This is the biggest trouble of the Russian Federation.
        2. gaura
          gaura 16 May 2018 09: 27
          0
          And you, of course, do not allow direct sabotage of HIS decisions in your thoughts? We had only 10 people in the branch of the large IT company, and they were biting among themselves. You do not even allow the thought of what kind of squabble can be on high-paying places in the government?
          You have from one extreme to another. Either the king is good, the boyars are bad. Or vice versa, the king is bad, the boyars are extras. I fundamentally disagree, cadres have always decided everything. Even the example of Britain, where a very clear structure is built, this can be seen.
          1. raw174
            raw174 16 May 2018 09: 36
            0
            Quote: gaura
            You have from one extreme to another. Either the king is good, the boyars are bad. Or vice versa, the king is bad, the boyars are extras.

            Rather, it’s not so, in my opinion, the Tsar is responsible for strategy, for the vector of movement, the boyars act locally in their directions ... In terms of a specific decision (investment in US bonds), Putin himself will decide.
        3. zoolu350
          zoolu350 16 May 2018 16: 48
          +2
          The power in the Russian Federation is the oligarchy and Putin is just a hired manager of the oligarchy of the Russian Federation.
          1. Gardamir
            Gardamir 16 May 2018 17: 05
            +2
            only
            but for some reason many consider him the savior of the nation.
            1. zoolu350
              zoolu350 16 May 2018 17: 16
              +2
              These adherents of the KhPP or the lackeys of the Russian oligarchy come up with complex constructions according to which: “The Tsar is good, the boyars are bad”, but every time they get out some kind of unexpected person or bummer. But if you simplify the design (according to Marx), everything immediately falls into place and predict future events like 2 fingers on asphalt.
            2. raw174
              raw174 17 May 2018 06: 45
              0
              Quote: Gardamir
              but for some reason many consider him the savior of the nation.

              Do not exaggerate. He is just the president. Good or not, everyone has their own opinion, I think that is not bad. Yes, he does not deal enough with internal problems, but judging by the latest statements, he is going to improve, let's see how it actually becomes ...
          2. raw174
            raw174 17 May 2018 06: 42
            0
            Quote: zoolu350
            The power in the Russian Federation is the oligarchy and Putin is just a hired manager of the oligarchy of the Russian Federation.

            This is one of the chapters of the theory of the big conspiracy. And behind our oligarchs are people from the Masonic lodge? followed by reptilians? Maybe of course it is, we don’t have to know about it, and there’s nothing to ...
      4. Kent0001
        Kent0001 16 May 2018 09: 31
        +3
        So already, it’s ... we’re rattling: the course is wild, despite rising oil prices, it’s just impossible to look at the price-free price tag, like the price tags for good goods in stores ... everything is fine with us. I’m glad for the bridge, but Russia does not live as a single bridge.
    2. Alex-a832
      Alex-a832 16 May 2018 06: 57
      +6
      Quote: ANCIENT
      I offer Kudrin to give free of charge - irrevocably the USA! We won’t be able to do any better “ownership” than to fuse it there! !!

      So there will be more harm from him, and in the place of the auditor there may even be benefits. Kudrin’s opinion will be taken into account, but the decision, I think, has already been made. Not for nothing that the ruble is untied from the dollar, devalued without taking into account the views of the Fed, reduce the dollar stash and investments in US bonds. I think that the process has moved slowly, but. And the opinion of Kudrin? The elephant also probably took into account the opinion of Moska ... lol
      1. Tatyana
        Tatyana 16 May 2018 07: 05
        +20
        Kudrin is a traitor to Russia's national interests!
        Kudrin as he was a traitor, so he remained!
        Where and how does the GDP look at it? That is what the people have a question!
        1. Merold
          Merold 16 May 2018 07: 15
          +6
          Quote: Tatiana
          Kudrin is a traitor to Russia's national interests!
          Kudrin as he was a traitor, so he remained!
          Where and how does the GDP look at it? That is what the people have a question!

          We listened to the slogans. I would like to hear the rationale with examples and numbers.
          1. Tatyana
            Tatyana 16 May 2018 07: 18
            +9
            Quote: Merold
            We listened to the slogans. I would like to hear the rationale with examples and numbers.

            Talk a long time, if you ask such questions!
            1. Merold
              Merold 16 May 2018 07: 20
              +2
              Quote: Tatiana
              Quote: Merold
              We listened to the slogans. I would like to hear the rationale with examples and numbers.

              Talk a long time, if you ask such questions!

              Clear.
          2. edeligor
            edeligor 16 May 2018 07: 26
            +8
            Quote: Merold
            I would like to hear the rationale with examples and numbers.

            That is, do you think that the trajectory of development of the Russian Federation in "Kudrinsky" is the only correct and unchanging ?! Including investments in the US public debt at the risk that investments may be selected? Personally, this is enough for me to turn from this character as from a "garbage pit." And for figures and examples you are not on this site, economists are few ...
            1. Victor N
              Victor N 16 May 2018 09: 37
              +1
              That's just it, not a experts argue about a specific economic problem, but how fervently! When it’s funny, and when it’s scary: they can do it out of ignorance.
            2. Merold
              Merold 16 May 2018 11: 21
              0
              Quote: edeligor
              Quote: Merold
              I would like to hear the rationale with examples and numbers.

              That is, do you think that the trajectory of development of the Russian Federation in "Kudrinsky" is the only correct and unchanging ?! .

              If I thought so, then I would write. But I didn’t seem to write this?
              Quote: edeligor
              Personally, this is enough for me to turn from this character as from a "garbage pit."

              I’m afraid that if it weren’t for the one from whom you were “turned back”, you wouldn’t be writing on the forum now, but gathering dead wood in the forest. After 2009
              Quote: edeligor
              And for figures and examples you are not on this site, economists are few ...

              Well, if Tatyana wrote her slogans there, then I would answer her there. I’m only afraid that it would not be understood at the forum of economists, to put it mildly.
              1. edeligor
                edeligor 16 May 2018 14: 19
                0
                Quote: Merold
                I’m afraid that if it weren’t for the one from whom you were “turned back”, you wouldn’t be writing on the forum now, but gathering dead wood in the forest. After 2009

                I am always struck by the "severe" categorization of pseudo-liberals. Attention is the question - what if not? Or did your mighty brain think of all the probabilities of our economy developing in this period? Something tells me that you are either too categorical, or Mr. Kudrin is not a stranger to you ...
                1. Merold
                  Merold 16 May 2018 14: 42
                  0
                  Quote: edeligor
                  Quote: Merold
                  I’m afraid that if it weren’t for the one from whom you were “turned back”, you wouldn’t be writing on the forum now, but gathering dead wood in the forest. After 2009

                  I am always struck by the "severe" categorization of pseudo-liberals.

                  You first ascribe to me the words that I did not say, then hang the labels. You can’t argue dryly, sparingly, on business?
                  Attention is the question - what if not? Or did your mighty brain think of all the probabilities of our economy developing in this period?

                  The vast majority of economists (even those who disagree with Kudrin on his policies) agree that without a Kudrin stabilization fund, Russia would have been in a catastrophe at that time. Search links?
                  Something tells me that you are either too categorical, or Mr. Kudrin is not a stranger to you ...

                  You have something to guess, then a finger into the sky.
          3. aybolyt678
            aybolyt678 16 May 2018 07: 39
            +3
            Yes Yes ! You listen to Putin, everything seems to be normal, as you look at these curly gref’s, the Medvedevs, you think that nobody else like Putin is there anymore.
        2. The black
          The black 16 May 2018 07: 19
          +11
          Quote: Tatiana
          Where and how does the GDP look at it?

          Looks positively .... Such appointments are not made without his authorization
          1. Tatyana
            Tatyana 16 May 2018 07: 34
            +7
            Quote: Black
            Looks positively .... Such appointments are not made without his authorization

            That's it! And what should the people do now?
            They chose GDP as the president of Russia - they had fun, but how they chose it - so after the election they started to cry!
            1. cats
              cats 16 May 2018 08: 20
              +2
              Sorry, maybe I live in another Russia ..
              How did he make you cry?
              And immodest question, who did you vote for?
            2. raw174
              raw174 16 May 2018 09: 10
              +1
              Quote: Tatiana
              They chose GDP as the president of Russia - they had fun, but how they chose it - so after the election they started to cry!

              Judge your life. Remember how personally you and your loved ones lived 20 years ago, and 10 years ago? Is it getting worse or better? It seems to me that it’s better ... Of course, you can scream that everything is lost, everything failed, but touch each separately and it turns out that everything is not so bad ... Take crises, they are periodic and less and less affect ordinary people ... I don’t I pay and I do not advise you to shed tears ... The living conditions of SIMPLE people are improving! (do not throw a photo of homeless people)
              1. Severok
                Severok 16 May 2018 09: 32
                +5
                You recall how people lived 30-40 years ago. If you don’t remember, I’ll remind you - education is available and free, medicine is available and free + quality for all residents of the country, housing is available and free, guests are welcome, the streets are clean, the shores of the seas and rivers are without fences ...
                You can continue, however ...
                1. raw174
                  raw174 16 May 2018 10: 28
                  +1
                  Quote: Severok
                  education is available and free

                  Yes, I do not argue, under the Union, education was cheaper. This year I will take my daughter to grade 1, and my son to kindergarten (in December), the fee for the garden is 850 rubles, the school is free (for workbooks about 2 thousand you just need everything), we have a technical school that gives workers specialties ( welders, mechanics, etc.), absolutely free of charge, there is even a scholarship for good studies ... Higher, yes, paid, but there are budget places in almost all universities.
                  Quote: Severok
                  medicine is available and free + quality for all residents of the country

                  Now in medicine there are big problems with staff, I do not argue, especially in our village. I handled the injury (the dog bit off part of the finger), did it for free and well, my wife gave birth almost a year ago, full control, good attitude and everything is free, we liked it, we are going to give birth again in three months))) My grandfather (84 years old) recently performed abdominal surgery, also for free. I haven’t gone bankrupt for medicine yet ...
                  Quote: Severok
                  housing is available and free

                  Now it is quite accessible. Last year I issued a mortgage, then refinanced it, now 9,4% is a full payment, after 5 years it will be generally a penny ... I took an apartment in a two-apartment building, on the ground with a bathhouse and other buildings, 120 sq.m. satisfied. My sister took an apartment in Chelyabinsk, also in a mortgage, also acceptable conditions. Although this is also a private matter, some do not count their strengths and are torn, but this is a household financial illiteracy ...
                  Quote: Severok
                  guest products

                  Then I’ll tell you something about sausage according to GOST in the USSR! My father worked at the state farm as the main veterinarian, the number of livestock is good, because of this, the case is regular. Where to put the corpse? If you write off, reporting will slip, not good! And they take him to the sausage shop! At the exit, sausage and sausage in accordance with GOST! EVERYONE did it! This does not mean that quality was really monitored better, but there were fewer products in the store. How was lured to the polls? A car shop brought sausage. Now counters for every taste, color and prosperity.
                  Quote: Severok
                  the streets are clean

                  so do not litter! (not specifically you, I in general) Cleanliness is a matter of educating everyone in every family.
                  Quote: Severok
                  You can continue, however ...

                  Sure! You can find the same disadvantages in the USSR!
                  After the institute, you work not where you want, but where you will be sent, for talking about the incorrect course of power - they will give a deadline, and there was less corruption, just the “cotton business” was worth it ... There is no perfect system and system, everywhere there are + and -.
                2. cats
                  cats 16 May 2018 13: 27
                  +1
                  Quote: Severok
                  If you don’t remember, I’ll remind you

                  At the same time, remind the young generation why you allowed it all
                  about ... you? You mean lived in a fairy-tale country, but we left the ruins ..
                  And now you’re also bragging ..
                  You can continue, however .. wink
              2. Vladivostok1969
                Vladivostok1969 16 May 2018 10: 14
                +1
                Judge your life. Remember how personally you and your loved ones lived 20 years ago, and 10 years ago? Is it getting worse or better? It seems to me that it’s better ... Of course, you can scream that everything is lost, everything failed, but touch each separately and it turns out that everything is not so bad ... Take crises, they are periodic and less and less affect ordinary people ... I don’t I pay and I do not advise you to shed tears ... The living conditions of SIMPLE people are improving! (do not throw a photo of homeless people)

                Have your children been vacationing in the camp for a long time in the summer, while you weren’t afraid that they would drown? Did you go to the holiday home for a long time? And when was the last time you met a pensioner in a good mood, who did not think that he would be there tomorrow. And I don’t I cry, but I want to live with pleasure.
                1. raw174
                  raw174 16 May 2018 10: 55
                  +1
                  Quote: Vladivostok1969
                  Have your children rested in the camp for a long time in the summer, while you were not afraid that they would drown?

                  This year the daughter will go. It won’t drown, the camp is in the forest))) The pioneer camp (it is called so now) has been operating since the 50s or 60s, I rested there in childhood ... the 21-day season costs 1700 rubles, the main thing is there is no Internet ! You can go to a more prestigious and developed one, also in our region, there the price is about 3-5 thousand, in my opinion.
                  Quote: Vladivostok1969
                  Have you been to a holiday home for a long time?

                  To be honest, I have the opportunity, but I have no desire ... There are sanatoriums with us: Uvildy, Bannoye, Abzakovo, we’ll probably go there somehow, until I feel like it. The price is about 20 thousand per person for 10 days, with massages and baths. Many relatives and friends travel.
                  Quote: Vladivostok1969
                  And when was the last time you met a pensioner in a benevolent mood, not thinking that he would be there tomorrow.

                  Yesterday ... My mother is a pensioner. She does not work, does not starve ... There is a subsidiary farm, a garden, hens, ducks and turkeys. The pension is not large, but quite enough. I have a grandfather for 80 years, his words: "You can live now! They pay a pension, there is electricity, gas, water, everything is there." He likes to repeat it ... I believe him.
                  I’m not saying that everything is perfect with us, I’m saying that there is progress, the standard of living is growing. The Union had its advantages, but there were also disadvantages! He burst, it is a fait accompli ...
                  1. Merold
                    Merold 16 May 2018 11: 24
                    0
                    Quote: raw174
                    Quote: Vladivostok1969
                    Have your children rested in the camp for a long time in the summer, while you were not afraid that they would drown?

                    This year the daughter will go. It won’t drown, the camp is in the forest))) The pioneer camp (it is called so now) has been operating since the 50s or 60s, I rested there in childhood ... the season of 21 days costs 1700 rubles.,.

                    If it’s not difficult for you, could you name the bank where you took the mortgage, the maternity hospital in which your wife gave birth, the hospital in which they fixed your finger and the camp where your daughter will go to rest?
                    I just check them for fun and compare them with your words about how wonderful everything is. This is not a secret, right?
                    We have sanatoriums: Uvildy, Bannoye, Abzakovo, we’ll probably go there somehow, until I feel like it. The price is about 20 thousand per person for 10 days, with massages and baths.

                    A quick search says that "not everything is so simple,"




                    1. raw174
                      raw174 16 May 2018 12: 25
                      0
                      Quote: Merold
                      the bank in which they took a mortgage,

                      Russian Agricultural Bank. took at 15,5% after 9 months. refinanced up to 11,5%, immediately for add. the agreement was lowered to 9,4% for a villager. If there are delays on my part, they will return to 11,5%. Something like this.
                      Quote: Merold
                      the maternity hospital in which your wife gave birth

                      Regional perinatal center of Chelyabinsk.
                      Quote: Merold
                      the hospital where your finger was repaired

                      District hospital. Do not think that the bitten part was sewn, the surgeon processed the bone fracture and sutured, injected immunoglobulin and rabies vaccine.
                      Quote: Merold
                      the camp where your daughter will go to rest

                      In the neighboring area, Children's Health Camp "Sputnik". I was interested in the current year, the cost of a child's rest per shift is 18 tons., According to the calculation, of which the parental fee is 1700 rubles., The rest is subsidized by the regional budget.
                      Quote: Merold
                      A quick search says that "not everything is so simple,"

                      Of course. There are also entertainment, treatment and procedures in the sanatoriums for different budgets. I am talking about a 10 day stay in a sanatorium with massages and baths and walks. The price tag is easy to double and triple, visiting extra. treatments by choosing superior rooms ...
                      Quote: Merold
                      I just check them for fun

                      To my shame, I don’t know what “check” means, but I’m sure there’s nothing wrong ...
                      Quote: Merold
                      how wonderful everything is there.

                      I’m not saying that everything is great, I’m saying that everything is not as bad as some people think.
                      1. Merold
                        Merold 16 May 2018 13: 54
                        0
                        Quote: raw174
                        Quote: Merold
                        the bank in which they took a mortgage,

                        Russian Agricultural Bank. took at 15,5% after 9 months. refinanced up to 11,5%, immediately for add. the agreement was lowered to 9,4% for a villager.

                        There is one. But you are probably very lucky with the department and the staff.
                        http://www.banki.ru/services/responses/bank/rshb/
                        product / hypothec /
                        Regional perinatal center of Chelyabinsk.

                        You need to try your hand at gambling. You are a very lucky person.
                        https://prodoctorov.ru/chelyabinsk/lpu/13793-obla
                        stnoy-perinatalnyy-centr / otzivi / # all
                        In the neighboring area, Children's Health Camp "Sputnik". I was interested in the current year, the price of a child's rest per shift is 18 tons., According to the calculation, of which the parental fee is 1700 rubles., The rest is subsidized by the regional budget.

                        This is probably in the Bredinsky district, tk. in Katav-Ivanovo district the camp with that name closed in 2008. Lucky again.
                        Of course. There are also entertainment, treatment and procedures in the sanatoriums for different budgets. I am talking about a 10 day stay in a sanatorium with massages and baths and walks.

                        The average screen with a minimum price per person 3700 rubles. per day is exactly what you wrote about. General recovery. The remaining two screens for just staying without everything.
                        To my shame, I don’t know what “check” means, but I’m sure there’s nothing wrong ..

                        "Check the information."
                        I’m not saying that everything is great, I’m saying that everything is not as bad as some people think.

                        According to your comment, it personally seemed to me that in the Chelyabinsk region. There are no problems with anything.
        3. Reptiloid
          Reptiloid 16 May 2018 07: 31
          +9
          Quote: Tatiana
          Kudrin is a traitor to Russia's national interests! !
          ----- for him there is no alternative but to support the US economy in difficult times, because he does not care about Russia.
        4. The comment was deleted.
        5. victor50
          victor50 16 May 2018 08: 19
          +1
          Quote: Tatiana
          Kudrin is a traitor to Russia's national interests!
          Kudrin as he was a traitor, so he remained!
          Where and how does the GDP look at it? That’s what the people have a question

          Or maybe GDP mmm ...... ???? lol
        6. cats
          cats 16 May 2018 08: 53
          +1
          They deleted my koment, for some reason ..
          I repeat. Tell Tatyana, how so stupid Putin
          stayed in power for eighteen years?
          And so the enemies squeak ..
          1. Tatyana
            Tatyana 16 May 2018 13: 05
            0
            Quote: Kotovsky
            Tell Tatyana how such a stupid Putin stayed in power for eighteen years? And so the enemies squeak ..

            Quote: NordOst16
            And Sredyukov? And the one who created this whole system is not a traitor?

            Andrey Fursov will answer you in a professional and detailed manner.

            See Why Putin is not mass cleaning the ranks of parasites. Andrey Fursov. Published: 23 Nov 2016
            1. cats
              cats 16 May 2018 13: 21
              0
              Quote: Tatiana
              This will be answered professionally and in detail by you

              Tatyana, I thought you had your own thoughts. And the glamorous talkers I
              I don’t look, litter. hi
              And yet, to understand the situation, to whom did you cast your vote? Who was trusted?
              1. Tatyana
                Tatyana 16 May 2018 15: 31
                0
                Quote: Kotovsky
                Tatyana, I thought you had your own thoughts.
                There are, of course.
                Quote: Kotovsky
                And I don’t look glamorous talkers, litter.
                It is a pity that you refer A. Fursrva to the talkers! I specifically found for you a harmonious scientifically sound answer. There are few specialists like Andrei Fursov.
                I am reading the works of A. Fursov. The work is interesting. They illuminate the problem methodologically from a slightly different, more historical, perspective than me.
                In other words, in order to reveal the truth, it is necessary from the standpoint of the dialectical materialist method to observe the principle of unity of inductive and deductive thinking. Inductive - this is when they are going specific historical facts and then prognostic hypotheses are built on them according to the principle of historical ANALOGUES. Those., inductive thinking works at the level of specific thinking. Andrei Fursov, a historian by training, speaks excellently. He knows a lot of facts. But to prove the truth, deduction is also needed - deductive thinking - i.e. logically internally consistent calculation of the same problem at the abstract level.
                If the independent conclusions of induction and deduction coincide with each other, then the hypothesis can be considered reliable and tested in practice. For the criterion of truth is practice. And only then the hypothesis can be translated into the category of theory. Which, however, then - in a historical spiral in time - must be periodically checked periodically according to the indicated methodological scheme.
                Moreover, it is important with what philosophical method Andrei Fursov makes his deductive calculation. On the one hand, Fursov destroys metaphysicians, but on the other hand, he is more spontaneous, but not conscious, inclined towards the dialectical-materialistic method. As a result, my deductive conclusions coincide with him. Moreover, by virtue of his profession, academician Andrei Fursov generates very interesting ideas.
                Quote: Kotovsky
                And yet, to understand the situation, to whom did you cast your vote? Who was trusted?
                For GDP. And before the vote, I was not familiar with the video and the works of Andrei Fursov. I only discovered 2 weeks ago the video of A. Fursov for myself.
                With the top of the communist party organizations - I have not been communicating for 2 years already. It is useless to communicate with them: they themselves do not own the diamate method, in m / l. theories of error do not see. Therefore, the alien internal logical consistent conclusions from the point of view of the diamat are perceived with aggressive distrust and thus continue to historically generally give up the socialist positions of past generations one after another. And those who in their leadership understand this are in their team in a state of "white crow".
                In general, the late Soviet Communists from the 80-90-ies caught on to defend their homeland from the liberal nomenklatura in their ranks.

                On Monday, May 14 received the first book of A. Fursov on the Internet. I study it carefully - and have already ordered myself the next book for reading.

                I advise you, Konstantin, still watch this video. Learn a lot of interesting things.
                1. cats
                  cats 16 May 2018 16: 19
                  +1
                  Quote: Tatiana
                  Learn a lot of interesting things.

                  belay Thank you Tatiana, for such an extensive answer.
                  I’ll try to collect brains until tomorrow.
                  Thank you for being warned about Fursov, otherwise I’m really
                  I wanted to see.
            2. Merold
              Merold 16 May 2018 15: 24
              +1
              Quote: Tatiana

              Andrey Fursov will answer you in a professional and detailed manner.

              Not ashamed to spread this as arguments?
              1. Tatyana
                Tatyana 16 May 2018 15: 41
                0
                Quote: Merold
                Not ashamed to spread this as arguments?

                And we are not at the n / a. conferences. I offer the answers of an excellent author, accessible to all people for understanding.
                Andrey! Offer your arguments as an opposition.
                1. Merold
                  Merold 16 May 2018 16: 25
                  0
                  Quote: Tatiana

                  I offer the answers of an excellent author, accessible to all people for understanding.

                  What's so great about him? The author, (just like you, by the way) stigmatizes everyone and everything, hangs up labels without worrying about their slightest justification. Something like a deputy Fedorov.
                  “Societies controlled from abroad”, “fifth column”, “sixth column tied to the Rothschilds and Rockefellers”, “Putin is not free in his actions” ...
                  In addition, a person does not know how to solve the problem of corruption other than the introduction of a state of emergency and an emergency commission and the execution of these same corrupt officials. In my opinion, it is on the same level of adequacy with Delyagin and Glazyev. I already spoke about Fedorov.

                  Quote: Tatiana

                  Andrey! Offer your arguments as an opposition.

                  There is nothing to oppose. There are only cliches and slogans without the slightest justification.
                  1. Tatyana
                    Tatyana 16 May 2018 17: 18
                    0
                    Quote: Merold
                    There is nothing to oppose. There are only cliches and slogans without the slightest justification.

                    That is, you, Andrei, acknowledge that you have nothing to oppose! You have no justification for opposing, because either your horizons in their work are insufficient and superficial, or you do not know the methodology of dialectic and formal logic. Therefore, you are not in a position to offer your own objectively critical, scientifically sound, logically internally consistent solution to the problem.
                    TOTAL You accuse others of the people you named of allegedly sophism - namely, that the politicians you listed allegedly simply use “labels” to representatives of the liberal government. However, at the same time, you yourself also use sophism in the art of polemic, which is called the "argument to the personality" of those whom you named.

                    As a matter of fact, I did not expect another from you!
                    1. Merold
                      Merold 16 May 2018 17: 22
                      0
                      Quote: Tatiana
                      Quote: Merold
                      There is nothing to oppose. There are only cliches and slogans without the slightest justification.

                      That is, you acknowledge that you have nothing to oppose! You have no justification for opposing, because either you have a small outlook on their work, or you do not know the methodology.

                      Okay, persuaded. Give any statement of your "excellent author" and we will disassemble it. At the same time, let's see who owns what and what is the situation with the horizon.
        7. NordOst16
          NordOst16 16 May 2018 09: 22
          0
          And Sredyukov? And the one who created this whole system is not a traitor?
      2. bsk_mna54
        bsk_mna54 16 May 2018 07: 08
        +2
        This is Medvedev said with Putin a hundred years ago, but the cart has not moved
      3. Ross xnumx
        Ross xnumx 16 May 2018 07: 39
        +9
        Quote: Alex-a832
        reduce dollar stash and investment in US bonds.

        Are you viewing official sources? They say:
        TASS, May 15. Russia in March 2018 increased its investment in US government securities to $ 96,1 billion. In February, this amount was 93,8 billion, according to data released on Tuesday by the US Treasury.

        According to the agency, over the past year, the largest amount of investments by Russia was made in May - 108,7 billion.

        More on TASS:
        http://tass.ru/ekonomika/5203602

        Kudrin is a rotten egg. The chick will not hatch from it. And all the hopes for the success of this group are described in the lines:

        You with the bass, Misha, sit down against the viola,
        I, prima, will sit against the second;
        Then the music will not be the same:
        We will dance the forest and mountains! "


        The only one who will dance is a simple people who have become stupid to disgrace, believing that the president’s highest activity is not the opportunity to stand at the helm of a ship with the name Russia, but to sit behind the wheel of a KAMAZ truck, showing their involvement with the people:
        I want to easily, with the people - like you! Simple guys, which we have at every turn! ...

        What, what, but he succeeds. Only this does not wash away the shit from the jacket of the representative of Russia, nor the green stuff from his face ...
        The president’s involvement with the traitors and enemies of the Russian state, who, in the performance of their duties, were not able to achieve significant success (that is, success — positive progress) raises deep doubts about the correctness of the chosen course and its benefits for the Russian people.
        1. Alex-a832
          Alex-a832 16 May 2018 08: 10
          +4
          Quote: ROSS 42
          Are you viewing official sources? They say:

          From $ 170 billion in 2013 to $ 93 billion in 2018. Is something wrong?
      4. Hefty literate
        Hefty literate 16 May 2018 09: 03
        0
        You probably have not read the material you are commenting on. What kind of reduction in the nest egg are you talking about? After all, it is clearly written in Russian: in 2017, the share of Russian gold and foreign exchange reserves in dollars increased from 40,4% to 45,8%. Is Russia so detached from the dollar?
        1. Alex-a832
          Alex-a832 16 May 2018 09: 28
          0
          Quote: Dyuzhe literate
          You probably have not read the material you are commenting on. What kind of reduction in the nest egg are you talking about? After all, it is clearly written in Russian: in 2017, the share of Russian gold and foreign exchange reserves in dollars increased from 40,4% to 45,8%. Is Russia so detached from the dollar?

          The growth in stocks of dollars should have been greater, because the price of oil has risen sharply, but the state is deliberately holding it back. Look over the past ten years, the dynamics of gold reserves with a breakdown by composition and especially by changes in monetary gold reserves and $, everything is clear there.
          1. Hefty literate
            Hefty literate 16 May 2018 11: 46
            0
            What is the state deliberately holding back? After all, the article did not write about the absolute values ​​of gold and foreign exchange reserves in dollars, but about the fact that the share of these reserves in dollars is increasing! So what kind of containment are we talking about? Maybe such a “containment” in a few years will turn the entire gold and foreign exchange reserves of Russia into green American paper? Is Kudrin striving for this?
    3. Captain Pushkin
      Captain Pushkin 16 May 2018 11: 23
      0
      Quote: ANCIENT
      I offer Kudrin to give free of charge - irrevocably the USA! We won’t be able to do any better “ownership” than to fuse it there! !!

      And what do you offend Medvedev, Nabiulina, Chubais, Dvorkovich many other, no less colorful characters? Are you sorry to part with them, for which you are depriving them of the charms of an overseas existence? Can't they be loaded onto the same plane as Kudrin? Is it okay to drive a 300-seat airliner with one passenger back and forth? To save, it should be loaded to the eyeballs. For all passengers, the flight is free, plus a severance pay in the amount of a two-week salary.
  2. Vladivostok1969
    Vladivostok1969 16 May 2018 06: 46
    +29
    You give us sanctions, and we give you money. There is no alternative. Well done Kudrin. There is nothing to say.
    1. The black
      The black 16 May 2018 06: 51
      +14
      Quote: Vladivostok1969
      You give us sanctions, and we give you money. There is no alternative. Well done Kudrin. There is nothing to say.

      For whom they voted, he appointed him ... in the end, it is not Kudrin who authorizes the investment of money in American securities ...
      1. Vladivostok1969
        Vladivostok1969 16 May 2018 06: 56
        +13
        Did not vote. No. Sleight of hand and not any machinery.
        1. The black
          The black 16 May 2018 06: 58
          +10
          Quote: Vladivostok1969
          Did not vote.

          Sergey voted, voted. The fact that GDP won the election without "sleight of hand" is a fact.
          1. Vladivostok1969
            Vladivostok1969 16 May 2018 07: 01
            +21
            These are the cross. Of the acquaintances, only the wife and mother-in-law voted for the GDP. But I regularly recall this to them. They will soon go on foot to the cottage wassat
            1. The black
              The black 16 May 2018 07: 09
              +10
              Quote: Vladivostok1969
              Of the acquaintances, only my wife and mother-in-law voted for GDP. But I regularly recall this to them. They will soon walk to the cottage

              Wow ... the prosecution of supporters of GDP and EP in a single family .... and for political reasonslaughing
            2. milling machine
              milling machine 16 May 2018 07: 26
              +11
              Quote: Vladivostok1969
              These are the cross. Of the acquaintances, only the wife and mother-in-law voted for the GDP. But I regularly recall this to them. They will soon go on foot to the cottage wassat

              I’m sure that the supporters of GDP have an “iron” argument of the type - but what does Putin have to do with it? Or Old Russian "the king is good - the boyars are bad.
              Here the government is also going to raise the retirement age, they say that the issue has already been resolved, only the GDP said that this will not happen with it. Did you lie?
              It’s just a shame that the majority in the country do not catch a causal relationship. And they vote for that one.
              1. Elk
                Elk 16 May 2018 07: 44
                +2
                About pensions it was clear even before the election, where the wind was blowing.
                And who is the alternative to GDP?
                1. milling machine
                  milling machine 16 May 2018 07: 52
                  +15
                  Quote: Elk
                  About pensions it was clear even before the election, where the wind was blowing.
                  And who is the alternative to GDP?

                  In our country, 140 million. A man and among them, I am sure, are smart and worthy. It’s just that if such people appear, then they immediately get in the way with shit or are simply “jammed”. After all, one of the three principles of an authoritarian state is to create the appearance of a dictator without alternatives.
                2. victor50
                  victor50 16 May 2018 08: 32
                  +8
                  Quote: Elk
                  And who is the alternative to GDP?

                  Have you tried to look around? Maybe your housemate, work colleague? Did you know GDP well before? And if these people are given equal opportunities in the presidential election, maybe everything will not be so hopeless? It is on this argument (to a very serious degree) that the elections are built.
                  1. Victor N
                    Victor N 16 May 2018 10: 44
                    0
                    Naivety, simplicity - worse than theft.
                    All Kudrin correctly said, any competent economist will confirm this. Well, tell me: which family does not hold reserves for the "Black Day"? The state also cannot do without reserves. What to keep them in? - in reliable currency and gold. The most reliable currency now is the dollar, alas. Reasoning about investing in the US economy is a provocation for amateurs.
                    1. victor50
                      victor50 16 May 2018 13: 50
                      0
                      Quote: Victor N
                      Naivety, simplicity - worse than theft.
                      All Kudrin correctly said, any competent economist will confirm this. Well, tell me: which family does not hold reserves for the "Black Day"? The state also cannot do without reserves. What to keep them in? - in reliable currency and gold. The most reliable currency now is the dollar, alas. Reasoning about investing in the US economy is a provocation for amateurs.

                      Do you think it is not naive and correct to transfer the reserve for a rainy day to storage, to put it mildly, to an unfriendly neighbor? belay And there are no other ways to save them? winked Or maybe (on the topic of family) try to invest in real estate? Gold to buy? Well, it’s a very “naive” question: why are we all living under such outstanding economists and lawyers and a wonderful government at all .... okay - joyless, non-optimistic? request
                      1. Victor N
                        Victor N 16 May 2018 18: 06
                        +1
                        The national wealth of Russia includes our property. Is growing slowly? - means WE work poorly.
                        It’s easy to invest in real estate, but to extract from real estate - oh, how difficult! The topic of real estate liquidity is now being carefully hushed up so as not to scare away simpletons investing in buildings.
                        As for the mood - I recently became disabled and waking up in the morning I begin to look for something to enjoy: delicious tea, beautiful violet, rainy morning (there will be no heat) ......
                  2. Elk
                    Elk 16 May 2018 15: 22
                    +1
                    Of course there are honest and competent people in Russia. Just not their election bill. And my neighbor is a good man, only nobody knows him, and he himself is not eager to plunge into this shit. So there is a choice of GDP and extras with a clear result in advance. In Ukraine, too, they chose between a not very good present and a bright future under the guidance of honest people (as it seemed to them), and now c) \ (0pe. How to determine whether we are competent and honest or not. Mark Twain has an excellent story on this subject: “How I ran for governors.” I recommend.
            3. Vasyan1971
              Vasyan1971 16 May 2018 07: 33
              +11
              Quote: Vladivostok1969
              Will soon go to the cottage on foot

              Gasoline will rise in price, we’ll all go request
              1. Vladivostok1969
                Vladivostok1969 16 May 2018 07: 35
                +3
                But they are the first. tongue
                1. cats
                  cats 16 May 2018 08: 26
                  0
                  If not for them (mother-in-law and wife), then we would all go, and not to the cottage,
                  and from the barracks of the concentration camp to the place of work .. And then only those who are lucky.
                  1. Vladivostok1969
                    Vladivostok1969 16 May 2018 08: 39
                    0
                    Do you think I'm lucky? Maybe.
              2. Alexanast
                Alexanast 16 May 2018 08: 36
                +4
                Quote: Vasyan1971
                Gasoline will rise in price, we’ll all go


                Come on ... No matter how expensive it is - no one got off his horse ... More and more cars. yes
          2. victor50
            victor50 16 May 2018 08: 26
            0
            Quote: Black
            Sergey voted, voted. The fact that GDP won the election without "sleight of hand" is a fact.

            Alas, yes! Although playful little hands, they probably were, well, maybe so that the victory was more convincing.
            1. Vladivostok1969
              Vladivostok1969 16 May 2018 08: 45
              +1
              No one knows how these newfangled electronic ballot boxes were set up in which we dropped the ballots, by the way, daw down (so that no one would see the true place of the jackdaw?).
              All of these electronic systems will give the answer you need.
          3. I am Russian
            I am Russian 16 May 2018 09: 51
            +2
            Quote: Black
            that GDP won the election without "sleight of hand" - a fact.

            The fact is that the financial statements are kept for 3 years, documents at the university for students are kept for 75 years, and so a bunch of examples of document storage. And the storage period for ballots is 14 days, then they are destroyed. Why would you?
            Here is the answer to all questions about fair elections.
      2. Ross xnumx
        Ross xnumx 16 May 2018 07: 43
        +5
        Quote: Black
        Who voted for, he appointed him ... after all, not Kudrin ...

        From this place more ... lol It’s quite possible that the vote and support of the people of Putin’s candidacy are far-fetched by the Central Election Commission ...
  3. Uncle lee
    Uncle lee 16 May 2018 06: 46
    +8
    It would be better if they burned this money, if only they had warmed themselves! And Kudrin is the head!
    1. Andrey Yuryevich
      Andrey Yuryevich 16 May 2018 06: 53
      +2
      Quote: Uncle Lee
      It would be better if they burned this money, if only they had warmed themselves! And Kudrin is the head!

      Only Escobar was capable of this, he burned money to warm his daughter when he was hiding with her in the mountains from the police.
    2. Cube123
      Cube123 16 May 2018 08: 30
      +5
      Quote: Uncle Lee
      It would be better if they burned this money, if only they had warmed themselves! And Kudrin is the head!

      Vladimir, you are a reasonable person. I read your comments with interest.

      Let's take a look at the situation objectively. There is such a document of the Central Bank of the Russian Federation http://www.cbr.ru/statistics/credit_statistics/ii
      p / debt_claims_liabilities.xlsx "Currency structure of external debt claims and external debt obligations of the Russian Federation". (taken from here http://www.cbr.ru/statistics/?ch=PAR_30241&pr
      tid = svs # CheckedItem)
      This is the structure of Russia's external debts by debt currency.

      Interesting conclusions can be drawn from the section TOTAL
      First, in two years, the amount of dollar debts in Russia decreased by $ 47 billion from $ 350,257 to $ 303,821 billion.
      Secondly, there is a gradual replacement of external debt by internal: debts in the national currency increased from $ 82,123 to 138,143 billion.
      Thirdly, debt in euros is growing: from $ 65,296 to $ 80,446 billion.

      Those. there is a gradual exit of Russia from dollar debt. And I like it.
      From the point of view of the economy, reserves must be kept in proportion to the structure of own debts in order to minimize exchange rate risks. Therefore, having 74% of the total debt, it is dollar debt ($ 303,821 out of 539,336 billion as of October 01.10.2017, 74), unfortunately Kudrin is right (I am not his fan either), there is currently no alternative to keeping XNUMX% of Russia's reserves in dollars .
      1. Uncle lee
        Uncle lee 16 May 2018 09: 16
        +1
        In dollars or in securities?
        And best of all in gold!
        1. Cube123
          Cube123 16 May 2018 09: 19
          +1
          In gold, it's always good good But the price of gold is set in London and cannot be controlled from Russia. Therefore, the size of Russia's reserves in this case is unpredictable and can be controlled from the outside.

          If the main debt is in dollars, and, apparently, Trump’s policy was taken to depreciate the dollar, then a dollar fall will depreciate the amount of debt.
          1. Vadim237
            Vadim237 16 May 2018 10: 42
            0
            Or it can be stored in diamonds - in a special storage.
            1. Cube123
              Cube123 16 May 2018 11: 52
              +1
              Quote: Vadim237
              Or it can be stored in diamonds - in a special storage.

              Will you also give loans with diamonds? If you store assets in something that is not what you owe, then at the time of debt repayment or interest repayment, you must first sell your asset for the currency in which you owe, and only then repay the debt. Moreover, it will have to be sold at the price that the buyer of the asset agrees to pay, and this value is always unpredictable. Those. unpredictable exchange rate risk arises. And when you keep reserves in what you owe, you have the opportunity to predict risks and manage your debts.
              1. Vadim237
                Vadim237 16 May 2018 12: 25
                +1
                That's good when you live without debt.
                1. Cube123
                  Cube123 16 May 2018 12: 43
                  +1
                  Quote: Vadim237
                  That's good when you live without debt.

                  Golden words good
  4. spirit
    spirit 16 May 2018 06: 51
    +25
    We look generally there is no alternative anywhere) Putin, there is no alternative. The government, there is no alternative. Non-alternative Country)
    1. Ross xnumx
      Ross xnumx 16 May 2018 07: 51
      +5
      Quote: spirit
      Putin-no alternative. Government-no alternative. Non-alternative Country)

      You overdid it here a little ... No. An alternative to Putin - Medvedev! fellow An alternative to the Medvedev government is the Putin government! fellow As for the country's non-alternative, it is for us non-alternative. We can only allow ourselves to get off on a trolleybus to the final stop, and these guys have an alternative ... yes You can ask Gorbachev, Usmanov, Abramovich ... how many of them were laid down, died in the vast old Europe, and near investments in US government bonds. request
  5. Livonetc
    Livonetc 16 May 2018 06: 53
    +10
    Kudrin can say anything.
    He does not decide on investments.
    But those who decide this, we approve.
    Applause.
    Loud applause.
    Applause passing into a standing ovation.
    Remember?
    1. Uncle lee
      Uncle lee 16 May 2018 06: 58
      +3
      Quote: Livonetc
      Applause passing into a standing ovation.

      Everybody get up!
      Remember!
    2. just exp
      just exp 16 May 2018 08: 37
      +2
      and that they approved the decision of Kudrin?
      and then a pretzel will come to post the opinion of bulk and a bunch of lemings will write that the power was sold to the West.
      kudrin take only what is useful to us. and what is not useful leave kudrin for good memory.
  6. Altona
    Altona 16 May 2018 06: 58
    +8
    Quote: spirit
    We look generally there is no alternative anywhere) Putin, there is no alternative. The government, there is no alternative. Non-alternative Country)

    ----------------------------
    Putin has exhausted himself long ago, trying again and again to spin this rusty wheel. Wants to double GDP or what? Rates of growth? And we have growth within 1,5%. This is how many years will we double?
    1. aybolyt678
      aybolyt678 16 May 2018 07: 45
      +1
      Quote: Altona
      Wants to double GDP or what? Rates of growth? And we have growth within 1,5%

      we have all the GDP is oil and gas. doubling growth is an increase in production. If they considered our GDP phones and cars, then growth would be negative
  7. Masya masya
    Masya masya 16 May 2018 06: 58
    +3
    the glasses are rather weak, but I think the magnifying glass will not help him ...
    1. Ross xnumx
      Ross xnumx 16 May 2018 07: 57
      +3
      I know which magnifier will help him ... yes So that the neck does not bend and the head does not hang. lol You can’t say better than a Janissary:
  8. saturn.mmm
    saturn.mmm 16 May 2018 06: 59
    +7
    What else can you expect from an American accountant?
    1. Vadim237
      Vadim237 16 May 2018 10: 44
      0
      Well, at least more than from the guys in the economy who have no idea whatsoever - paradoxically, Kudrin is right.
      1. saturn.mmm
        saturn.mmm 16 May 2018 16: 41
        0
        Quote: Vadim237
        than from the guys in the economy who have no idea whatsoever - paradoxically, Kudrin is right.

        Please tell us how positively affects the Russian economy the withdrawal of money from it?
  9. Nix1986
    Nix1986 16 May 2018 07: 00
    +7
    This dumpkopf even went to the same kickstarter ?! There is no alternative if you want to invest money and not work in any way, alas, squeeze the land, build a shopping center or a business center and rent and sit exactly on the pope, the dream of the huckster of the 90s of the early 2000s. On the one hand, we are crying about difficulties with lending to a business; on the other, they say that there is no alternative to US bonds. Circus.
  10. pepel
    pepel 16 May 2018 07: 03
    +4
    Investing in the US public debt is already for Kudrin DIAGNOSIS !!! wassat fool
  11. samarin1969
    samarin1969 16 May 2018 07: 03
    +7
    Only "ideological" nonsense like "forums" can be shown live. But the conversation of people's representatives on the most important issue is the secret for the "initiates". But even with these words it is obvious who is the power, and who are meek "servants ..." it is not clear what. It was the deputies who had to set tasks for Kudrin, and if he didn’t agree, they would simply drive him away ...
  12. bsk_mna54
    bsk_mna54 16 May 2018 07: 04
    +5
    Why the hell did this devil take the fate of Russia? Such "figures" are always capable of ditching, a lot of intelligence is not necessary, but to restore the economy in a quarter century is by the foot. When will these liberals and shit be completely destroyed, or will they live, but the people will not? Putin is all leading to this. His verbiage is shocking!
    1. Ross xnumx
      Ross xnumx 16 May 2018 08: 01
      +1
      Quote: bsk_mna54
      Putin is all leading to this. His verbiage is shocking!

      The main thing is that he should not be shocked by the uncovered bayonets of those lucky ones whom they have “benefited” with the whole team for a quarter century ... lol
  13. rotmistr60
    rotmistr60 16 May 2018 07: 05
    +6
    at the moment he sees no alternatives
    What kind of alternative can be discussed if he (Kudrin) soul and body in his beloved "liberal" world and of course on the top of a hill in the United States. He did not even consider possible alternatives.
    1. Vladivostok1969
      Vladivostok1969 16 May 2018 07: 27
      +3
      body and soul in his beloved "liberal" world

      Quotation marks seem to me out of place. Kudrin is a real liberal. And he never denied it.
  14. keeper03
    keeper03 16 May 2018 07: 08
    +1
    And how such the Earth wears !!! am angry
    1. Ross xnumx
      Ross xnumx 16 May 2018 08: 02
      +1
      Quote: keeper03
      And how such the Earth wears !!! am angry

      He grimaces and holds ... Most of the time he walks on the ground ... lol
    2. tank66
      tank66 16 May 2018 09: 44
      +1
      Judas, they say, also walked, did not fail ...
  15. Vard
    Vard 16 May 2018 07: 08
    +4
    Well done! What kind of economist is he ... To lend a floor of 3% and at the same time to borrow at 10% ... There are no words ..
  16. Strips
    Strips 16 May 2018 07: 14
    +1
    And does anyone think that Europe will ultimately trade Iran for US sanctions?
    1. Graz
      Graz 16 May 2018 07: 59
      0
      the Germans have already lost huge money on Russian sanctions, they will soon lose on Iranian, then on Chinese, and then grandmother Merkel kick in the ass their businessmen will send
  17. GRIGORIY76
    GRIGORIY76 16 May 2018 07: 16
    +4
    Want an active "Putin" foreign policy? Then get Kudrin and the company in the kit.
  18. Merold
    Merold 16 May 2018 07: 18
    +3
    Kudrin: There is no alternative to investing in American debt today

    Another sucked out article.
    The following are the words of the deputy and about something else.
    1. cats
      cats 16 May 2018 08: 31
      +1
      Have you noticed too? Regularly began to publish articles without a signature,
      where the facts are mixed up with speculation. Pensions, gas, now here is Kudrin.
      Heaped up rage or who probes the soil. request
      And our local prowlers for saliva come out ..
  19. Prisoner
    Prisoner 16 May 2018 07: 19
    +4
    So they launched the American goat into the Russian garden!
  20. Altona
    Altona 16 May 2018 07: 19
    0
    Quote: Nix1986
    On the one hand, we are crying about difficulties with lending to a business; on the other, they say that there is no alternative to US bonds.

    -----------------------------------
    Dvorkovich’s doctrine is being implemented - Russia must pay for US stability. Only now we are paying, China, a few more countries, and the USA is an increasingly unstable country.
    1. Vasyan1971
      Vasyan1971 16 May 2018 07: 30
      +2
      Quote: Altona
      Dvorkovich’s doctrine is being implemented - Russia must pay for US stability. Only now we are paying, China, a few more countries, and the USA is an increasingly unstable country.

      Not enough, apparently, pay. We need more, more ...
  21. Altona
    Altona 16 May 2018 07: 22
    +2
    Quote: GRIGORIY76
    Want an active "Putin" foreign policy? Then get Kudrin and the company in the kit.

    ------------------------------
    What is the activity there? In the neutral flags and concerns of the Foreign Ministry? Now there will be complete trouble everywhere - only regrets and preoccupation of visas action of aua diir partners. Summer mi Speak From May Hart.
  22. Mountain shooter
    Mountain shooter 16 May 2018 07: 22
    +4
    In place of the chief auditor, this will be very useful. Because every speck in the eye will see.
    And about Amer’s papers, he answers as an economist, not as a politician. They are (at the moment) the most profitable and reliable of government securities.
    1. rocket757
      rocket757 16 May 2018 07: 33
      +3
      Suppose amersky paper is not the most profitable, this is a choo-choo-choo-error. It is believed that they are highly profitable, with a high degree of reliability!
      Is it true to understand who is considered and who has proven reliability ???
      And Kudrin shaw, he is stable from the point of view of upholding specific economic rules / laws, is this a plus ???
    2. Ross xnumx
      Ross xnumx 16 May 2018 08: 06
      +1
      Quote: Mountain Shooter
      In place of the chief auditor, this will be very useful. Because every speck in the eye will see.

      In the early fifties of the last century, children were shown the benefits of appointing such "auditors" and "economic strategists":
  23. Mwg
    Mwg 16 May 2018 07: 24
    0
    "Thus, the Russian financial system continues to not only make investments in American debt, but also to increase these investments." - pure substitution of the concept. The previous phrases stated: "... by the end of 2017, the share of Russian gold and foreign exchange reserves in US dollars increased from 40,4% to 45,8%. At the same time, the share of gold reserves in euros decreased significantly."
    It turns out “in this way” that the Russian Federation reduced the volume of gold and the euro and replaced them with dollars, all in all. And does not increase investment. And rightly so: let the United States keep its candy wrappers.
    In general, the share of gold and foreign exchange reserves of Russia in US dollars should be brought up to 100%, if there is no way to pick them up in the Russian Federation
  24. Vasyan1971
    Vasyan1971 16 May 2018 07: 28
    +3
    "Kudrin: There is no alternative to investing in American debt today."
    "... at the moment he (Kudrin) sees no alternatives."
    So there is no alternative or does Kudrin not see her? And in the summer of 1941 would Kudrin also see no alternative but to surrender? In the "soft form".
  25. jovanni
    jovanni 16 May 2018 07: 31
    +1
    Kudrin has long counted everything. And why would the bourgeoisie not call him the best again! A pump that pumps grandmothers from Russia ...
  26. Per se.
    Per se. 16 May 2018 07: 31
    +2
    In a mild form, he (Kudrin) made it clear that he considers the placement of gold reserves and state savings in American securities to be quite acceptable.
  27. free
    free 16 May 2018 07: 34
    +1
    We are waiting for comments from the stubborn!
  28. Vladimir K.
    Vladimir K. 16 May 2018 07: 37
    +2
    This does not concern him now. And by the way, is he ready to bear personal responsibility in case of freezing, and possibly confiscation, on a far-fetched pretext, of this money? There, Iran was fined 7 yards for not having been proved by his authorities !!! that they are not related to the terrorist attack of September 11.09.2001, XNUMX. For Russia, a similar reason can be found even faster.
  29. Abram
    Abram 16 May 2018 07: 40
    +2
    Kudrin’s cunning plan is to strangle the United States and give so much that they cannot service the debt
    1. Vadim237
      Vadim237 16 May 2018 10: 47
      0
      Such a plan at the moment is only similar in China - more than a trillion investments in the United States.
  30. aybolyt678
    aybolyt678 16 May 2018 07: 51
    +2
    Get up! cursed branded ...
    1. Vladivostok1969
      Vladivostok1969 16 May 2018 10: 31
      +2
      Where is May Day? I'm ready.
      Hostile whirlwinds blow over us ..... (while in a whisper)
  31. Bok tubres
    Bok tubres 16 May 2018 07: 55
    +1
    After this statements, someone has questions to account Mr. Kudrin?
    Rather, questions aboutwho does he work for...
    1. aybolyt678
      aybolyt678 16 May 2018 12: 30
      0
      in general, some kind of rebus turns out .. Kudrin officially works for Putin, but for America, Putin is officially against America but for Kudrin wassat
  32. Graz
    Graz 16 May 2018 07: 55
    +2
    Yes, this counter must be put against the wall, our banks are looking for long loans because of sanctions, and because of this enemy of the people they keep money in the USA, some kind of wrecking
  33. serg123
    serg123 16 May 2018 07: 58
    +1
    If you do not develop your economy, but the American, then yes. Then what is the point of having a high-tech economy in general, it is enough to service the pipe. Does this not remind of something near from our history?
  34. Press
    Press 16 May 2018 08: 02
    +4
    Why do not try to invest in Russia ...
    1. Million
      Million 16 May 2018 08: 13
      +9
      Money is not stored where it is stolen)
    2. aybolyt678
      aybolyt678 16 May 2018 12: 54
      0
      Quote: Pulse
      Why do not try to invest in Russia ...

      Russia is a lamb for the slaughter
  35. The comment was deleted.
  36. Million
    Million 16 May 2018 08: 13
    +8
    Thanks to Putin for Kudrin! Now Russia will rise from its knees!
  37. midshipman
    midshipman 16 May 2018 08: 15
    +3
    Amazing position. There is a Russian Academy of Sciences, an economic department, and the Institute of Economic Forecasting of the Russian Academy of Sciences (academician Ivanter V.V.). Where is their opinion on this subject and the blizzard? After all, we have a civilized state, the people want the development of the economy, and not its inhibition.
    1. Vadim237
      Vadim237 16 May 2018 10: 49
      0
      So engage in economic development - start with yourself, open your own business.
  38. LeonidL
    LeonidL 16 May 2018 08: 27
    +3
    Kudrin and the other fifth column is high time to send to a known address
  39. 23rus
    23rus 16 May 2018 08: 36
    +2
    Accumulation is a good thing, but I would like to know WHY? hi
  40. Old Horseradish
    Old Horseradish 16 May 2018 08: 39
    +4
    Total nonsense and lies. There is no truth from the word at all. Now they will kill pensioners who will not receive their pensions, and grandmothers will throw, as they hang noodles to us, "sworn enemies of Russia." Those. USA.

    "Putin was again caught in a lie: Back in 2005, the president promised never to raise his retirement age

    The question of raising the retirement age in Russia is being discussed more and more often, and not without reason it seriously worries citizens, because many still remember the promise of Vladimir Putin, which he made as president in 2005.
    Let's remember what the president said then. So, in 2005, Russian President Vladimir Putin said that this issue is primarily associated with the demographic situation, as well as with the fact that there are more working pensioners in Russia. The current demographic situation, the president said then, can create certain difficulties for the Pension Fund of the Russian Federation. Another factor he called lower than in Europe, the total life expectancy, which is mainly associated with death at working age. Often this is due to alcoholism, drug addiction, and industrial injuries. All this together creates problems, however, then Putin assured that while he is the president of the Russian Federation, he will not allow raising the retirement age, and all conversations around this are conducted solely to stimulate citizens.

    What we have today, because in 2018 it can become not just empty talk, but a reality. Increasingly, officials are raising the issue of raising the retirement age. In particular, Dmitry Medvedev said that one way or another, the government should take this step. "
    1. dik-nsk
      dik-nsk 16 May 2018 11: 18
      0
      In fairness - there is no need to take a phrase out of context, there are two statements in his words - life expectancy is low, while I am president - there will be no increase .. at the moment, life expectancy has increased significantly (approximately, too lazy to look - from 63-65 to 70-73 ), therefore one of the conditions has changed .. so don’t need to be "caught lying"
      1. Old Horseradish
        Old Horseradish 16 May 2018 11: 56
        +1
        Go sweet man to the cemetery. See how many young people are. So you don’t need nonsense about increasing life expectancy.
  41. kaschey
    kaschey 16 May 2018 08: 41
    +1
    It is interesting to see how much finance Kudrin invested in US debt.
    And the idea is simply wonderful - to invest your salary in the debts of your competitor, good luck in this field to him.
    Although the salary in this case, to put it mildly, is not his.
  42. Gardamir
    Gardamir 16 May 2018 08: 44
    +4
    Offending Kudrin and Medvedev, are you ready to repeat your words to the one who appointed these two? Or are they self-appointed?
    1. rocket757
      rocket757 16 May 2018 11: 04
      +4
      Our power is anti-people in its very essence. Nothing new.
      The top of the country serves the interests of the fat .... is an integral part of the exploiters, also not news.
      They talk about it a lot where. It’s just that it doesn’t change anything; Empty chatter.
  43. CAT BAIYUN
    CAT BAIYUN 16 May 2018 08: 48
    +4
    Gentlemen .. Why is Kudrin not yet in jail? Anyone in the know?
    1. Vadim237
      Vadim237 16 May 2018 10: 53
      0
      Because unlike any other "know-it-all" in macroeconomics on the forums - he is a real, cold, professional in his field, with extensive experience in Russian macroeconomics.
      1. Gardamir
        Gardamir 16 May 2018 15: 15
        0
        cold, professional
        you called the chief financier scumbag?
        1. Vadim237
          Vadim237 16 May 2018 15: 51
          0
          He simply is not subject to impulsive decisions and opinions that someone who does not like something does as the market system requires.
  44. Amateur
    Amateur 16 May 2018 08: 55
    +1
    Elbasy Kazakh already bent, freezing grandmother. But Kudrin probably does not know about it. And GDP with DAM is the same.
  45. Romanenko
    Romanenko 16 May 2018 08: 56
    +1
    If Kudrin does not see an alternative with the investment of Russian funds, can give him a kick in the ass, before it is too late, but look for a more worthy candidate for this place ???
  46. Altona
    Altona 16 May 2018 09: 03
    +1
    Quote: midshipman
    After all, we have a civilized state, the people want the development of the economy, and not its inhibition.

    ---------------------------
    The opinion of the liberal clan is a priori considered "scientifically sound." Kudrin, for us, is also the "best minister of economics" and the developer of strategic concepts, scientific titles and regalia, probably not one bag.
  47. Altona
    Altona 16 May 2018 09: 05
    +1
    Quote: Romanenko
    If Kudrin does not see an alternative with the investment of Russian funds, can give him a kick in the ass, before it is too late, but look for a more worthy candidate for this place ???

    ------------------------------------
    The government works in the interests of 5% of the population maximum, and for these 5% the whole concept is archaic. It’s important for Cypriots to keep their candy wrappers, patriots' incomes do not worry them much. There they are not going to share excess profit from oil.
  48. Shurale
    Shurale 16 May 2018 09: 15
    +2
    In any company, a person in his position who believes that development is worse than investing in competitors ’securities would have been dismissed long ago, but the logic does not apply to our leadership. When a person meets a person whose actions are not logical and not adequate, he tries not to communicate with him and generally keeps away from him. And we have those in the leadership of the country. What shall we do?
  49. Turkestan
    Turkestan 16 May 2018 09: 15
    +1
    And yet, someone popularly in a simple working RUSSIAN language can explain why Russia is investing its capital in the US economy? Who will answer if tomorrow this capital is FROZEN? Why is this capital not used in the interests of the ECONOMY of the Russian Federation? Maybe the answer is one. The world bourgeoisie is not interconnected by PUBLIC financial, economic obligations, where personal enrichment is the primary task and they wanted to spit on the interests of their country and people.
  50. Monarchist
    Monarchist 16 May 2018 09: 22
    0
    MY opinion: do not invest all funds in the ACB. Popular wisdom says: "Do not put all the eggs in one basket." But to a certain extent, Kudrin: is it good or bad (now it’s not about that), but EVERYTHING and EVERYTHING closes on the dolor and if you sharply come out of the dolor, you can DIE EVERYTHING. Take China, and there the guys are smart, they could pack amers in baskets and in the sea, as Mao was going to, but hesitated. Then, when the Yugoslavia was bombed, the Americans snooped into the Chinese embassy and the Chinese ZERO ATTENTION Pound recognition. And all because EVERYTHING is closed on a dolor.
    I remembered a funny picture (I can’t spread it and I don’t have it at hand): a heron swallows a frog, and a frog grabs a chain by the throat. So I thought, maybe it’s a specialist: after all, Amers are also not interested if the investments decrease sharply? Of course, you need WILL.