Military Review

The Ministry of Finance predicted the huge windfall from the more expensive oil. Is there no money anyway?

140
The same Ministry of Finance, which so far is a department with personnel from the "acting", who proposed to cut the expenditure part of the program "Social Policy", led forecasts for super-profits for the current year. Considering the fact that the budgeted price of Urals oil at 2018 for the year is 43,8 dollars per barrel, while the real price of oil of the same brand is about 71 dollars, the inflow of super-returns was indicated. Recall that in the week the price of Brent crude oil has already risen to 78 dollars per barrel.


The forecast of the Ministry of Finance is as follows: the volume of additional revenues will be more than five (!) Times higher than originally expected: 2,7 trillion rubles instead of 527 billion. Almost two trillion increase based on increased oil prices and total federal budget revenues: 17,03 trillion instead of 15,2 trillion This is where the government “starts looking for” 8 trillion rubles to execute the May “super-order” of the president.

But here it is necessary to take into account an important factor: the so-called budget rule is incorporated into the budget law for the current year. Very tricky. It says that additional oil and gas revenues will not be directed to the federal budget at all for subsequent expenditure, but to reserve funds.



Thus, the state receives huge amounts of money on the sale of oil and gas alone, but at the same time it is not going to spend this money on any urgent needs. The classic Kudrinsky scheme works, which is aimed at filling the reserves of the "airbag" of the Russian economy. In fairness, it should be noted that in the 2014-2016 years - at the peak of economic problems - this very pillow worked properly.

The important question is whether the state is going to look for a “middle ground” between filling up reserve funds and implementing the same social programs. Or, nevertheless, in the first place, the main Kudrino rule is to make money and save it for a rainy day, forgetting that the country's economy requires investments for normal development here and now ...
Photos used:
kinokiwi.com
140 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. Thrall
    Thrall 11 May 2018 15: 06
    +24
    It is necessary to spend them on NANOtehnologii smile
    1. NEXUS
      NEXUS 11 May 2018 15: 09
      +12
      [quote = Thrall] [quote] It is necessary to spend them on NANOtehnologii smile[/ Quote]

      Don’t hesitate, put a respected question, wah ... your offer has too many beeches ...
      NANO WILL SPEND THEM.
      Oh, so it is! hi
      1. Thrall
        Thrall 11 May 2018 15: 10
        +14
        Superprofits are not a problem if you deal with them using nanotechnology smile
        1. For example
          For example 11 May 2018 15: 31
          +12
          Buy US bonds. Business! wink
    2. ANCIENT
      ANCIENT 11 May 2018 15: 09
      +18
      I propose to give Vedmedev and Chuubais to some cannibal tribe! And send Kudrin to Antarctica for life - to read lectures to penguins!
      1. NEXUS
        NEXUS 11 May 2018 15: 16
        +3
        Quote: ANCIENT
        I propose to give Vedmedev and Chuubais to some cannibal tribe!

        I believe they will have either indigestion, or wild heartburn, or diarrhea of ​​a planetary scale.
        Quote: ANCIENT
        And send Kudrin to Antarctica for life - to read lectures to penguins!

        What did the animals do to you? They have it all year round and it’s cold and life is not in the Maldives. recourse
      2. rocket757
        rocket757 11 May 2018 15: 19
        +6
        Of course, I understand that there will be no money again for the people, for the development of the country ... there will be offers \ screams like - There is no money \ there is, but you hold on again! - we’ll just see what we got into again!
        1. helmi8
          helmi8 11 May 2018 16: 21
          +13
          Quote: rocket757
          we’ll just see what we got into again!

          They swooped in to the same place they were. Banks will receive super-profits, people will remain poor. With the financial policies of Kudrin-Siluanov-Gref, with the support of Medvedev, no improvement is what to expect - even relying on them is pointless. Sadness again ...
          1. Yuyuka
            Yuyuka 11 May 2018 16: 45
            +1
            Quote: helmi8
            Quote: rocket757
            we’ll just see what we got into again!

            They swooped in to the same place they were. Banks will receive super-profits, people will remain poor. With the financial policies of Kudrin-Siluanov-Gref, with the support of Medvedev, no improvement is what to expect - even relying on them is pointless. Sadness again ...


            the question is - what is the reason for raising the retirement age right now with such budget revenues ?? belay some incontinence is direct! did not have time to come to power (return), as soon as they decided to tackle the most "pressing" ...
            1. helmi8
              helmi8 11 May 2018 16: 51
              +2
              Quote: Yuyuka
              the question is - what is the reason for raising the retirement age right now with such budget revenues ??

              Is this a question for me or rhetorically? laughing As I understand it, it is not profitable for banks to spend extra money on pensions, social projects and industry. Hence the whole mess in the economy. The main indicator of the Central Bank (according to Kudrin) is the availability of money supply. So he doesn’t want to spend money ...
              1. Yuyuka
                Yuyuka 11 May 2018 16: 59
                +1
                Quote: helmi8
                Quote: Yuyuka
                the question is - what is the reason for raising the retirement age right now with such budget revenues ??

                Is this a question for me or rhetorically? laughing As I understand it, it is not profitable for banks to spend extra money on pensions, social projects and industry. Hence the whole mess in the economy. The main indicator of the Central Bank (according to Kudrin) is the availability of money supply. So he doesn’t want to spend money ...


                the question is purely rhetorical, after the previous topic it has not cooled down yet ... but you gave an answer ... although we all already know it request
          2. Rostovchanin
            Rostovchanin 11 May 2018 16: 55
            +3
            All to support banks! Even our "people's" Sberbank yells at all angles, which gives 11,5 percent, but this is the wildest lie. In fact, during registration, the figure 19-21,9 flies ... + insurance 10% of the amount ... In insurance companies - daughters of Sberbank. The result is about 25-28% complete nonsense.
          3. Alf
            Alf 11 May 2018 21: 56
            +1
            Quote: helmi8
            With the financial policies of Kudrin-Siluanov-Gref supported by Medvedev

            You forgot to add someone who supports Medvedev.
      3. Semen1972
        Semen1972 11 May 2018 15: 19
        +7
        Quote: ANCIENT
        I propose to give Vedmedev and Chuubais to some cannibal tribe! And send Kudrin to Antarctica for life - to read lectures to penguins!

        And they should clone Stalin and make him President ... for life, and show everyone Mother Kuzkin !!!!
      4. lis-ik
        lis-ik 11 May 2018 22: 13
        0
        Quote: ANCIENT
        I propose to give Vedmedev and Chuubais to some cannibal tribe! And send Kudrin to Antarctica for life - to read lectures to penguins!

        I already suggested sending them on a lunar expedition with their friends, Americans.
      5. Sergey ippon
        Sergey ippon 11 May 2018 22: 25
        0
        Do ants propose to trample them? wassat
    3. Denis Obukhov
      Denis Obukhov 11 May 2018 15: 22
      +9
      The budget law contains a transition to a new budget rule - from 2018, excess revenues from oil and gas, resulting from exceeding the actual prices of the projected levels, are sent to reserves, and not to expenses. These funds are then sent to the Ministry of Finance to purchase currency. It seems that the Bank of Russia is a branch of the Fed
      1. Semen1972
        Semen1972 11 May 2018 15: 33
        0
        Quote: Denis Obukhov
        It seems that the Bank of Russia is a branch of the Fed

        Strange, but I also keep part of the money in the bank ... am I also a branch of the bank?
        1. Yuyuka
          Yuyuka 11 May 2018 16: 53
          +3
          Quote: Semen1972
          Quote: Denis Obukhov
          It seems that the Bank of Russia is a branch of the Fed

          Strange, but I also keep part of the money in the bank ... am I also a branch of the bank?


          if your children had nothing to buy things and products for, would you store money in this bank? Now the situation in the country is such that inflation, we are told, is already tending to zero ... But this is not due to economic growth, but because of the lack of money among the population. Although prices are slowly rising and getting louder every day belay
          1. lis-ik
            lis-ik 11 May 2018 22: 16
            +1
            Quote: Yuyuka
            Quote: Semen1972
            Quote: Denis Obukhov
            It seems that the Bank of Russia is a branch of the Fed

            Strange, but I also keep part of the money in the bank ... am I also a branch of the bank?


            if your children had nothing to buy things and products for, would you store money in this bank? Now the situation in the country is such that inflation, we are told, is already tending to zero ... But this is not due to economic growth, but because of the lack of money among the population. Although prices are slowly rising and getting louder every day belay

            Agree. This is just some kind of paradox. By the way, I tried to convey this on the forum more than two years ago.
            1. Yuyuka
              Yuyuka 12 May 2018 00: 51
              0
              and to whom to convey ?? few want to hear it ... the elections showed itrequest
              1. cast iron
                cast iron 13 May 2018 17: 57
                0
                Sheep 30 years choose ghouls. What they wanted and get all 30 years in a row.
          2. Semen1972
            Semen1972 14 May 2018 09: 19
            0
            Quote: Yuyuka
            if your children had nothing to buy things and products for, would you store money in this bank?

            And we have something to buy products for, moreover, we are ready to help foreign partners, invest in new aircraft and technologies, in new types of weapons, build bridges and roads. In Moscow, only curbs are changed 3 times a year. So I do not need about hungry children.
      2. helmi8
        helmi8 11 May 2018 16: 30
        +3
        Quote: Denis Obukhov
        It seems that the Bank of Russia is a branch of the Fed

        Not even a branch, but a subordinate structure.
        So, after analyzing the federal law on the Central Bank, you will find out that:
        1. The Central Bank is a legal entity independent of the state;
        2. Only the Central Bank of the Russian Federation has the exclusive right to issue cash and organize cash circulation;
        3. Without the permission of the Bank of Russia, the state cannot dispose of the property, and even more so the country's foreign exchange reserves;
        4. The state is not liable for the obligations of the Bank of Russia, and the Bank of Russia - for the obligations of the state;
        5. The relationship of currencies is regulated by the Central Bank of the Russian Federation regardless of the government of the Russian Federation;
        6. The Bank of Russia is entitled to apply for protection of its interests to international courts, courts of foreign states and arbitration courts;
        7. The Bank of Russia in the financial sector can give directions, regulations and instructions on what needs to be done, both for state governing bodies, and for legal entities and individuals, and everyone must comply with them implicitly;
        8. The Bank of Russia is not entitled to provide loans to the Government of the Russian Federation, but it is allowed to lend to the economies of other countries;
        9. The Bank of Russia is absolutely not obliged to comply with the orders of the President, the State Duma, the Ministry of Finance and any other government bodies.
        10. The Chairman of the Bank of Russia is almost impossible to dismiss until his term of office has expired, even if he does poor work or simply refuses to comply with government orders.
        11. The IMF (International Monetary Fund) is the only institution whose instructions the Central Bank must follow.


        More details in the source: http://sneg5.com/obshchestvo/dengi/komu-prinadlez
        hit-centrobank.html
        1. Golovan Jack
          Golovan Jack 11 May 2018 16: 37
          +2
          Quote: helmi8
          1 - 11

          Mostly lies. In some places diluted with truth, for a change.
          Not tired of still button accordions to post?
          Quote: helmi8
          11. IMF (International Monetary Fund) - the only structure whose instructions must be followed by the Central Bank

          This is from what hangover ??
          1. helmi8
            helmi8 11 May 2018 16: 40
            +2
            Quote: Golovan Jack
            This is from what hangover ??

            Yes, read the Central Bank Law for a start.
            In accordance with the Constitution of the Russian Federation (Article 15, paragraph 4), the Law on the Central Bank (Federal Law No. 86) and the Resolution of the Plenum of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation (No. 5 dated October 10, 2003), the Central Bank of Russia is obliged to comply with the instructions of the International Monetary Fund (IMF ) and actually turned into a branch of the US Federal Reserve System (FRS).
            1. Golovan Jack
              Golovan Jack 11 May 2018 16: 51
              +2
              Quote: helmi8
              Yes read the Law on the Central Bank for a start

              Impudence is not necessary ... I read the law on the Central Bank.
              What you quote is not the Central Bank Law ever laughing
              Quote: helmi8
              The Central Bank of Russia is obliged to comply with the instructions of the International Monetary Fund (IMF) and has actually turned into a branch of the US Federal Reserve System (FRS)

              Quote yellow press? Expected ... Okay:
              Quote: helmi8
              In accordance with the Constitution of the Russian Federation (Article 15, paragraph 4), the Law on the Central Bank (Federal Law No. 86) and the Resolution of the Plenum of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation (No. 5 of October 10, 2003)

              - Constitution of Art. 15 clause 4 - on international treaties. It’s already imposed on the teeth, there’s no “crime” there.
              - The law on the Central Bank in this context - nothing to do with it, purely for beauty.
              - No. 5 of October 10, 2003 - clarifications under Art. 15 of the Constitution.
              None of the document approval
              Quote: helmi8
              The Central Bank of Russia is obliged to comply with the instructions of the International Monetary Fund (IMF) and has actually become a branch of the US Federal Reserve

              do not do it... Pichalka to you request
              1. helmi8
                helmi8 11 May 2018 17: 29
                +3
                Quote: Golovan Jack
                Constitution Art. 15 clause 4 - on international treaties. It’s already imposed on the teeth, there’s no “crime” there.

                4. The generally recognized principles and norms of international law and international treaties of the Russian Federation are an integral part of its legal system. If other rules are established by an international treaty of the Russian Federation than those provided by law, the rules of the international treaty shall apply.

                Let me remind you that, unfortunately, international law dominates in our country.
                1. Golovan Jack
                  Golovan Jack 11 May 2018 17: 50
                  0
                  Quote: helmi8
                  we have international law

                  Smoke carefully Art. 15 of the Constitution. And, by the way, the Resolution of the Plenum of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation No. 5 of October 10, 2003 that you cited.
                  Everything is very clearly written there.
                  "Leadership" is only within the framework of international treaties concluded by the Russian Federation, in very special and specific cases.
                  And all request
    4. Non liberoid Russian
      Non liberoid Russian 11 May 2018 15: 37
      0
      for God's sake, take away the squirrel and the rosanna, and the chubais ... and advise there what and where to spend ... but your money, not strangers
    5. Lavrenti Pavlovich
      Lavrenti Pavlovich 11 May 2018 17: 59
      +1
      Quote: Thrall
      It is necessary to spend them on NANOtehnologii

      Do not worry, there is still no money, so rely only on yourself, money is not a problem for our government. It is because of the large profits that the government thinks how to reduce pensions and social programs. Question to GDP - What society is he building? Capitalist where the rich get richer and the poor get poorer, without any ideology? Where are we going? If the communists built communism, then what are we building now?
      1. rocket757
        rocket757 11 May 2018 22: 50
        +3
        They started an empty argument, who is the most important cockroach in our hostel? We have adopted various debbb-fig laws, either from corruption or from stupidity for the sake of “our foreign partners” ... now it has become clear that the capital in our hostel has realized that it’s stupid to substitute like that, it’s not profitable, they start kicking, canceling disavow!
        It’s just a dispute, our capitals and theirs, didn’t let ours into the common “corridor” and that’s it!
        It’s not easier for us simple “tenants”, some inconveniences will arise! But they won’t ask us anyway, but what is it like for us.
        Everything is just as written - they argue the Bar, the peasants crack at the peasants !!! - they will continue to crack, or who thinks that it will be different!?!?!?
    6. tTshka
      tTshka 11 May 2018 23: 08
      0
      Technologies are so "nano" that no one has ever seen them)))
      Drive the redhead ... with a pissing rag ... on the bunk)))
  2. Hunter 2
    Hunter 2 11 May 2018 15: 06
    +6
    But we will definitely know who they have! yes
    And people with disabilities and retirees - and so, are “fattening”, since they cut the budget for them!
  3. ANCIENT
    ANCIENT 11 May 2018 15: 07
    +4
    So they have their own pockets closer than the population, with their own problems that the authorities are not eager, and don’t know how to solve these very problems! They only know two matrimatic actions - subtract and share!
  4. evil partisan
    evil partisan 11 May 2018 15: 08
    +4
    As for the budget rule, as I understood from reading articles in the Institute, economists have no consensus on the word at all. He is abused and praised by liberal economists and Marxists. I do not think that the VO forum will clarify this issue ... sad
    1. NEXUS
      NEXUS 11 May 2018 15: 12
      +16
      Quote: Angry Guerrilla
      I do not think that the VO forum will clarify this issue ...

      Land for peasants, workers, factories, Chubais lifelong. wassat
      1. rocket757
        rocket757 11 May 2018 15: 21
        +5
        But who will suit him ??? He is the eternal monument of our restructuring!
        1. NEXUS
          NEXUS 11 May 2018 15: 23
          +3
          Quote: rocket757
          But who will suit him ??? He is the eternal monument of our restructuring!

          I propose to aggravate the proposal ... sorry no armored car. laughing
          Make a retirement age of 200 years. Live like that. Spite not die, Schaub see how this mess will end.
        2. evil partisan
          evil partisan 11 May 2018 15: 24
          +2
          Quote: rocket757
          But who will suit him ??? He is the eternal monument of our restructuring!

          I even agree to a mausoleum for Chubais. But only so that tomorrow ... repeat
      2. tank66
        tank66 11 May 2018 18: 27
        +2
        life-long ettsih with nails redhead, ku
    2. ANCIENT
      ANCIENT 11 May 2018 15: 15
      +3
      Aha hi hello to the best of the partisans! !! drinks I hope the adversary is afraid to hiccup with fear even to think about what will happen when we give our liberals, especially financiers, to them for free? ?? wassat
      1. evil partisan
        evil partisan 11 May 2018 15: 22
        +2
        Quote: ANCIENT
        we give them our liberals, especially financiers, we give them away for free

        stop Stand!
        How is it - for free ??? Yes, the skin of a liberal now comes at the price of a good polar gopher! good I won’t let the country ruin !! am
        Hello, oldest! drinks
        1. ANCIENT
          ANCIENT 11 May 2018 15: 31
          +3
          So skins, we will back from them and demand! good hi And fiery hello to you drinks
        2. ANCIENT
          ANCIENT 11 May 2018 15: 32
          +2
          So skins, we will back from them and demand! good hi And fiery hello to you drinks
          1. rocket757
            rocket757 11 May 2018 23: 13
            +3
            Yes, the red-haired devil is unforgettable here, Ilyich won the armored car! By the number of jokes soon all Jews will overtake !!! He had already prepared a mattress with nails ... probably the last greetings can be stored, but .... nothing!
  5. The comment was deleted.
  6. Victor_B
    Victor_B 11 May 2018 15: 10
    +7
    Does anyone doubt that they will all go to American papers, to the penny?
    Our Central Bank and the Ministry of Finance are offices working in the interests of the USA!
    1. barclay
      barclay 11 May 2018 15: 13
      +8
      Quote: Victor_B
      Does anyone doubt that

      I doubt. Some of these "excess profits" will be used to index the salaries of deputies and ministers, because they refused to level their salaries with the national average.
      And then, after all, the disease impoverished.
      1. Victor_B
        Victor_B 11 May 2018 15: 18
        +5
        To support the "poor" London sitters.
        They are robbed of their arrogant Saxons!
    2. Vadim237
      Vadim237 11 May 2018 15: 15
      0
      These are offices - working primarily on the interests of themselves. And rightly so, that the airbag is being made - the time will come in handy.
      1. Victor_B
        Victor_B 11 May 2018 15: 17
        0
        To their leaders.
        And the money will be frozen. Soon.
      2. teu
        teu 11 May 2018 15: 21
        +1
        The Central Bank de facto does what the Fed requires. I completely agree that the Central Bank and the Ministry of Finance primarily serve the interests of the SGA, then their own, about the people, i.e. I’m silent with you ...
        1. Semen1972
          Semen1972 11 May 2018 15: 47
          +1
          Quote: evp
          The Central Bank and the Ministry of Finance primarily serve the interests of the SGA, then their own, about the people, i.e. I am silent with you ..

          Salary then they are not some kind of "people" pays. And it is not the "people" who asks from them. A specific person. And people are already choosing these people. So ask them. Ask Putin, who was chosen, those who voted for him. “People” chose the course, chose a person who has been in power for many years with the same team. So "people" trust .. And the rest of us do not care. We are the People, are pleased with the President’s course and you cannot break it !!!!
          1. Don
            Don 11 May 2018 16: 22
            0
            Something in the last days of those whom you call the people has greatly diminished, as stupid people predicted before the election. And all because they were once again deceived by promising a breakthrough and changes in leadership.
            1. Vadim237
              Vadim237 11 May 2018 16: 26
              0
              To this drum guide, they are all mine.
            2. Semen1972
              Semen1972 11 May 2018 16: 27
              +1
              Quote: Donskoy
              And all because they were once again deceived by promising a breakthrough and changes in leadership.

              Seriously??? You can quote Putin about leadership changes. I've heard that he is pleased with the government. Give a link ?? !!!!
    3. Ivan Tarava
      Ivan Tarava 11 May 2018 16: 06
      0
      Putin was recruited in the GDR in the 80s. He’s just at work, don’t be angry.
      1. Don
        Don 11 May 2018 16: 25
        +1
        It was unlikely at that time, but then uncle Anatoly Sobchak lucidly explained to him how to live today and who to serve hi
  7. gukoyan
    gukoyan 11 May 2018 15: 10
    +7
    Urgently need to invest these grandmothers in the USA!))))
    1. Greenwood
      Greenwood 11 May 2018 15: 37
      +5
      There is more reliable, of course. At home, "everything is stolen." (C) lol
      1. ammunition
        ammunition 11 May 2018 16: 08
        +1
        Quote: Greenwood
        At home, "they will steal everything"

        But how! repeat Immediately let's go .. and drink. Barbarians -...Skyphes -))))))
        And in civilized Gamerica, these pennies are confiscated in a civilized way! Through a civilized merikansky court. And in the civilized pockets of the American Democratic ("elected") .. supposedly-people. -))))
    2. tank66
      tank66 11 May 2018 18: 40
      0
      and cut pensions. know how to stay ...
  8. solzh
    solzh 11 May 2018 15: 11
    +1
    the country's economy requires investment for normal development here and now ...

    It would be nice if the money went to invest in industry. By investing in industry, the country ensures economic independence from the West and strengthens the country's defense capabilities.
    1. Vadim237
      Vadim237 11 May 2018 15: 16
      0
      Private traders, with state support, are already doing this.
    2. DenZ
      DenZ 11 May 2018 15: 18
      +3
      We are not looking for easy ways. We will puff up at various economic forums, attract investors from abroad and put the money into American obligations ourselves. You understand the budget rule ... Nothing will change with this government team. I will be glad if I make a mistake.
  9. The comment was deleted.
    1. The comment was deleted.
      1. Ross xnumx
        Ross xnumx 11 May 2018 16: 12
        0
        Quote: Golovan Jack
        And in general - I do not understand why everyone was so excited? Have you been robbed? Or do you have a hunch that they will rob?

        So Medvedev does not understand how this turns out, he did not give money, but they are holding on. Can sprinkle DUST on top? wassat
        1. Golovan Jack
          Golovan Jack 11 May 2018 16: 23
          0
          Quote: ROSS 42
          So Medvedev does not understand ...

          Are you his secretary?
          Quote: ROSS 42
          did not give money, but they hold on

          You do not get paid? Should they? wink
          Quote: ROSS 42
          Can sprinkle DUST on top?

          You also need to know how to troll. Don’t push you like that, still burst, then clean up after you stop
          1. lis-ik
            lis-ik 11 May 2018 22: 22
            0
            Quote: Golovan Jack
            Quote: ROSS 42
            So Medvedev does not understand ...

            Are you his secretary?
            Quote: ROSS 42
            did not give money, but they hold on

            You do not get paid? Should they? wink
            Quote: ROSS 42
            Can sprinkle DUST on top?

            You also need to know how to troll. Don’t push you like that, still burst, then clean up after you stop

            Not everyone knows how to troll like you. In general, a novel of what is wrong with your life, one bile for any comment. Are you married at all? Is there anyone to quarrel with and take your soul?
            1. Golovan Jack
              Golovan Jack 11 May 2018 22: 38
              +1
              Quote: lis-ik
              one bile on any comment

              “For anyone” - superfluous, with normal people I communicate quite normally.
              And, yes - where is the bile * And life taught me to say "with pictures" ... dog laughing
              Quote: lis-ik
              Are you married at all?

              It was. There were a lot of things.
              Quote: lis-ik
              Is there anyone to quarrel with and take your soul?

              Yes, this good is always in bulk ... but what not to swear - in no way? wink
              Quote: lis-ik
              Not everyone can troll like you

              Yes, I basically indulge in plush I specialize in trolls ... funny little animals sometimes come across yes
              1. lis-ik
                lis-ik 11 May 2018 22: 56
                +1
                For a normal answer + to you, but about bile, re-read your comments and feelings at your leisure. that you are constantly looking for opposition.
                1. Golovan Jack
                  Golovan Jack 11 May 2018 23: 05
                  +2
                  Sergey, I really mainly specialize here in the fact that I drive (very completely overgrown) trolls. Intuitively, it’s probably clear that it’s hard to be white and fluffy.
                  And so - everything is in order, I assure you.
                  Normal work, adequate bosses, a couple of cats and dogs.
                  What else does a person need to meet old age? (with) laughing
      2. Paranoid50
        Paranoid50 11 May 2018 16: 13
        +2
        Quote: Golovan Jack
        Why is everyone so excited?

        Duc, spring, Roman.fellow Well, the article is “clockwork” - an expensive edition keeps the audience in good shape. laughing
        Quote: Golovan Jack
        Have you been robbed?

        Here, just, everyone will check their pockets and bags, just in case. yes
        Quote: Golovan Jack
        a hunch that they’ll rob? laughing
        Hmm, it's harder here ... request I definitely don’t, although, it seems, it is supposed to have such a hunch all the time (see nickname). I won’t tell you for the rest - go and know. laughing
      3. Don
        Don 11 May 2018 16: 15
        +2
        Quote: Golovan Jack
        And in general - I don’t understand why everyone was so excited

        I’ve predicted this for a long time. Everything just goes according to its own laws. Do you remember how you used to, about five years ago, how everyone on this resource shouted ury and believed in Putin? Yes, even in March, many stood up for him. Now VO does not recognize, as if exchanged people. Remember, soon the very word Putin will become a curse word, such as Chubais, Gaidar and Do.
        1. The comment was deleted.
        2. Alexander Romanov
          Alexander Romanov 11 May 2018 16: 33
          +3
          Quote: Donskoy
          . Remember soon Putin himself will become a curse word

          I read Ukrainian forums
          Putin will die soon.
          Putin overthrown soon
          Russia will fall apart soon
          Krymsky Bridge will collapse soon
          Soon, soon, soon, soon, and many more soon.
          You to them, a good guest will be respected
          1. Don
            Don 11 May 2018 17: 24
            0
            Quote: Alexander Romanov
            I read Ukrainian forums

            You read, and read on with your wife and discuss, but my nerves will still be useful to me
            1. Alexander Romanov
              Alexander Romanov 11 May 2018 17: 25
              0
              Quote: Donskoy
              and my nerves are still useful to me

              Yeah, during interrogation in the investigator’s office laughing laughing
              we’ll frustrate your entire fifth column like cockroaches
              1. Don
                Don 11 May 2018 17: 27
                0
                Do you happen to work in a circus? You look very much like a circus worker laughing
                1. Alexander Romanov
                  Alexander Romanov 11 May 2018 17: 30
                  0
                  Quote: Donskoy
                  Do you happen to work in a circus?

                  Put a circus on your avatar, you will come when I heard that Chapaev did not drown, was not surprised, it does not sink
                  1. Don
                    Don 11 May 2018 17: 36
                    0
                    So guessed it, all the same in the circus laughing Yes, and the whole family sit on hohlyatskih forums, it is not surprising that your psyche is .. lol My advice to you, contact specialized medical institutions, they will try to help you there. yes
                    1. Alexander Romanov
                      Alexander Romanov 11 May 2018 17: 37
                      0
                      Quote: Donskoy
                      So guessed it, all the same in the circus

                      You guess the shit and the prophet you’re not. In a word zero
                      1. Don
                        Don 11 May 2018 17: 40
                        0
                        Come on, Sanchez, don’t be upset, not everything is so bad, you probably have your own audience, or is it still bad with you? Well, you write it, if there’s no one else to talk to, I’ll listen, I’ll try to help you wink
              2. lis-ik
                lis-ik 11 May 2018 22: 24
                0
                Quote: Alexander Romanov
                Quote: Donskoy
                and my nerves are still useful to me

                Yeah, during interrogation in the investigator’s office laughing laughing
                we’ll frustrate your entire fifth column like cockroaches

                Alexander in collaboration with Meehan write?
  10. Livonetc
    Livonetc 11 May 2018 15: 18
    +1
    The budget is made up with a surplus of 0.5%.
    At one time, or at 10 or in 11, the surplus was 0,8%.
  11. Nix1986
    Nix1986 11 May 2018 15: 18
    +3
    It’s not good for the author to count other people's money wink laughing
    1. Ross xnumx
      Ross xnumx 11 May 2018 16: 13
      0
      Quote: Nix1986
      It’s not good for the author to count other people's money

      And he doesn’t have his own ... request
  12. tap
    tap 11 May 2018 15: 20
    +3
    Let them dispose at their discretion. They have a right. 76% in March expressed confidence.
  13. Million
    Million 11 May 2018 15: 21
    +5
    Extra-earnings for super-Russians!
  14. Victor_B
    Victor_B 11 May 2018 15: 23
    +1
    People! Aw!
    Until generally, these petrodollars never went into our economy! From the word - "in general"!
    And here it is in the American - from the word "always." Well, in Europe - partially.
    Now, in favor of the 404 Hague court has allowed the confiscation.
    1. Vadim237
      Vadim237 11 May 2018 16: 29
      0
      Let these until the end of days, engage in confiscation - sitting in a madhouse.
    2. Semen1972
      Semen1972 11 May 2018 16: 33
      0
      Until generally, these petrodollars never went into our economy! From the word - "in general"!
      And here it is in the American - from the word "always."

      Why do you get pensions? If you are not banned on the Internet, then in 2 minutes you can see the budget structure.
  15. Blue fox
    Blue fox 11 May 2018 15: 27
    +4
    Extra-incomes in our country are quickly converted to the number of billionaires on the Forbes list.
  16. Loess
    Loess 11 May 2018 15: 28
    +2
    In fairness, it should be noted that in the 2014-2016 years - at the peak of economic problems - this same pillow worked properly.
    In my opinion, this "pillow" worked before. I remember the crisis of the 8 year, when the economy was pouring in almost all over the world ... So, for two years every news release began with words about the crisis, but I could not understand what this crisis is expressed in ... And not only me, practically all working acquaintances (even a couple of taxi drivers) did not understand what they were talking about because the crisis did not affect us ... But at the end of the 10, it was heavily covered, but before that it was two years when the crisis was not felt at all. Yes, some banks were closing and ruining, but this was practically not reflected in ordinary hard workers. Hmm ... I am not a supporter of Medvedev, but now I remembered that it was during his reign ... It would be necessary to comprehend this fact request
  17. Maximys
    Maximys 11 May 2018 15: 29
    +1
    I should be ashamed of the Ministry of Finance, from the discussion of such issues. In the age of NANOtechnology, the level of state revenue depends on the price of natural resources. Where is industry, production, services, why are we developing so slowly. What are we waiting for?
  18. Denis Obukhov
    Denis Obukhov 11 May 2018 15: 30
    +3
    So on the oil needle and stay and it turns out that the crisis of 2014 did not teach us anything ...
    1. Vadim237
      Vadim237 11 May 2018 16: 31
      0
      The budget share of oil and gas is 45% - the rest is brought by goods and services.
  19. Masya masya
    Masya masya 11 May 2018 15: 35
    +1
    no matter how much you give, everything will not be enough ...
    1. Ross xnumx
      Ross xnumx 11 May 2018 16: 15
      +2
      Quote: Masya Masya
      no matter how much you give, everything will not be enough ...

      Why so? It is enough to give a kick or 8 years of "strict" with confiscation ... belay
  20. Denis Obukhov
    Denis Obukhov 11 May 2018 15: 37
    +3
    Russia was predicted by huge excess profits from oil and gas, but it will turn out like an oldtimer - huge over-investments in offshore and capital flight ... The new composition of the Cabinet will only help this!
  21. Altona
    Altona 11 May 2018 15: 40
    +2
    Quote: Golovan Jack
    I repeat - running into ... purposefully.

    --------------------------------
    You would behave decently in the morning, I was not the first to be rude. If you already got me, then be patient, intramad programmer. And hold your bulk with you.
    1. Golovan Jack
      Golovan Jack 11 May 2018 18: 06
      0
      Quote: Altona
      If you got me, then bear with me

      And you, in fact, who is there? Take too much on yourself, dear ...
      I, I can say, your demagoguery and gentlemanly tone too ... got a little tired.
      Quits laughing
      Quote: Altona
      intramad programmer

      This is some new kind of programmer. Patent.
      Quote: Altona
      And hold your bulk with you

      I’m trying to warn you. You violate the Site Rules in almost every comment, have you noticed? Reread the Rules, it won’t hurt yes
      PS: and - yes ... I’m not rude to you request
  22. sabakina
    sabakina 11 May 2018 15: 45
    0
    The Ministry of Finance predicted the huge windfall from the more expensive oil. Is there no money anyway?
    And ho said that oil is a national treasure?
    1. Ross xnumx
      Ross xnumx 11 May 2018 16: 23
      +1
      Quote: sabakina
      And ho said that oil is a national treasure?

      To be honest, then - the Constitution:
      Article 9
      1. Land and other natural resources are used and protected in the Russian Federation as the basis of the life and work of peoplesliving in the respective territory.

      yes fellow
      True, Sobchak immediately attributed the second paragraph, mutually exclusive of this basis and the right of the people to it:
      2. Land and other natural resources may be in private, state, municipal and other forms of ownership.

      belay
      And as said:
      Article 8
      2. In Russian federation equally recognized and protected private, state, municipal and other forms of ownership.

      request
      Some kind of epidemic ...
      1. sabakina
        sabakina 11 May 2018 16: 37
        0
        That's it ROSS, that's it ...
      2. Vadim237
        Vadim237 11 May 2018 17: 14
        0
        “To be honest, then - the Constitution” - This is how you will own what other people extract, transport, store, process, transport and sell again - investing money in it - oil, gas and other minerals are the property of only those who works in these areas, so the freebie, according to the Constitution, for all - is canceled.
  23. tractor driver73
    tractor driver73 11 May 2018 15: 50
    +2
    The money will go to the rescue of our oligarchs who have fallen under sanctions! Without help, the poor cannot survive! For ordinary people, shops of reinforced belts will be opened everywhere!
  24. Alex-a832
    Alex-a832 11 May 2018 15: 52
    +2
    There is no cabinet, there is no minister of finance, nothing of the kind was submitted to the government, but the stuffing is flying like a machine gun saying that everything will be bad: they’ll shorten the chain and move the bowl, it’s time to buy salt, which will especially rise in price, as usual like V.S. Vysotsky bequeathed lol Without panic citizens, u will be fine ... laughing
    1. Vadim237
      Vadim237 11 May 2018 16: 35
      +1
      These emissions are mainly aimed at the clients of the chamber: “Everything will fall apart - Russia will disappear”
  25. nikoliski
    nikoliski 11 May 2018 15: 55
    0
    Why not? The Forbes Russian list will still expand (even if only one ethnic Russian could be seen there)
  26. bald
    bald 11 May 2018 16: 13
    +2
    Gas prices will creep up, and the rest will catch up with him. Well damn when will it be the other way around? !!!
    1. Vadim237
      Vadim237 11 May 2018 16: 38
      0
      If the population can pay for gas, then no matter what, the government takes 60% of the cost of gas and Russian gas is the cheapest in Europe.
      1. bald
        bald 11 May 2018 18: 04
        +1
        Yes, the other day a sign was put up here - the cheapest. That's just, if you go over all the indicators of income - income (living standards), it would not hurt the statisticians to recall the theory of relativity. It is not funny, unfortunately it sounds, but the natural resources belong (should) to the people.
  27. Grandfather Makar
    Grandfather Makar 11 May 2018 16: 19
    +3
    Early rejoice, this jump in prices is very beneficial for the United States to sell its "shale oil" .. It smells like war!
    1. Vadim237
      Vadim237 11 May 2018 16: 40
      +1
      And let their drinking water and farmland continue to be poisoned by this production of shale oil.
  28. Dikson
    Dikson 11 May 2018 16: 23
    +1
    Mr. Sechin once gave an interview to Russia-24 inadvertently let slip - the cost of oil production in Yamal is only $ 2 per barrel .. Two oh dollars .. in difficult conditions .. All other talk about the price of oil that has fallen, or jumped up, is from the evil one .. It's just indescribable income .. in almost any situation .. Everything, as in the dashing 90s, - profit below 300%? then you are unprofitable ..)))
    1. Vadim237
      Vadim237 11 May 2018 17: 18
      0
      "The cost of oil production in Yamal is only $ 2 per barrel." You do not forget that it still needs to be transported, stored, processed and maintained by this entire system, and there will be 20 bucks at the output - plus taxes.
      1. Dikson
        Dikson 11 May 2018 17: 58
        0
        OK. even 20 Baku .. Why then they groan that everything is bad? 40 dollars per barrel, the office earns great .. But there were times when they paid for two hundred ...
    2. Grandfather Makar
      Grandfather Makar 11 May 2018 17: 21
      +3
      Quote: Dikson
      Mr. Sechin once gave an interview to Russia-24 inadvertently let slip - the cost of oil production in Yamal is only $ 2 per barrel .. Two oh dollars .. in difficult conditions .. All other talk about the price of oil that has fallen, or jumped up, is from the evil one ..

      Maybe so, but you just ask how much the rearmament of the Army and Navy costs, and what kind of construction is going on in Russia. These are all long-term investments and they are already yielding results. Of course there are many problems, and yet, we are moving forward
      Quote: Dikson
      Everything, as in the dashing 90s, is the profit below 300%?

      But this comparison is incorrect (I have spoken softly so far))) .. You mean you didn’t live then! hi
      1. Dikson
        Dikson 11 May 2018 17: 37
        +1
        Grandfather Makar ..))) I was born in 1966 .. And, thank God, I am in sober memory and sound mind .. And I saw Brezhnev on the podium, and all the others ... And there is definitely something to compare and who .. About MMM with 1000 percent per annum you can not recall? I still think why Mavrodi did not give the Hero of Russia, or at least "For Merit to the Fatherland" .. after all, a person squeezed out so much money from the population without any state loan bonds .. Remember these? - In my family still remained .. As a keepsake. More Stalin's bottling ..
        1. Grandfather Makar
          Grandfather Makar 11 May 2018 17: 49
          +3
          Quote: Dikson
          And surely there is something to compare and who .. About MMM with 1000 percent per annum you can not recall? I still think why Mavrodi did not give the Hero of Russia, or at least "For Merit to the Fatherland" .. after all, a person squeezed out so much money from the population without any state loan bonds .. Remember these? - In my family still remained .. As a keepsake. More Stalin's bottling ..

          And you mean from the "offended" to the Soviet power ..? And MMM ..)))) Well, themselves to blame .. I wanted to become the "new Russian" and were in flight? Well, it happens .. I did not participate in these frauds, although I also suffered on deposits, like many in the former USSR! Navar was then over 5000%, the wildest scumbags ... And Mavrodi died in poverty and on the street .. (they took away all his assets from him) .. And he never admitted WHO!
          1. Dikson
            Dikson 11 May 2018 18: 21
            +4
            No. You're wrong. I am not offended by Soviet power. And still I think that the Power of the Soviets is the best that was invented in terms of caring for their country. And about its citizens. Although there weren’t elementary things, as a matter of fact, in everyday life, there was also a lot of good and correct things in this system .. It united people, gave them, if not starry, ephemeral, but quite tangible, calculated vision of their future, confidence in tomorrow .. the USSR could be loved. In a pioneer way, just .. go and die for your country, like pioneers are heroes .. Very few current students will die for today's Russia .. Because love for the Motherland is not the amount of money earned in it .. Since the collapse of the USSR our leadership was never able to give rise to any intelligible national idea .. Except as "Steal and grab, until you catch!" But this is not an idea ..
      2. Dikson
        Dikson 11 May 2018 17: 55
        +3
        Yes, yes .. Zenit-Arena, Vostochny ... is a perfect example of “re-equipment” .. “innovations” and “new items” taken from the journals “Science and Life and Technology-Youth for 1976-88. . idiotic projects that have no analogues in the world .. Schoolchildren discovering elementary physics from the Internet and can not add double-digit numbers without a calculator ..)) The binder of old magazines will end soon and there will be nothing to pass off for new projects under which the state scatters money .. Grandfather Makar, do you remember how resembling a turkey, the first civilian minister of defense of our country, hung on the neck of our president’s favorite dog a portable station Glonass? The size and weight (judging by the emotions and behavior of the dog) with a good silicate brick? Red and pleased Mr. Ivanov was terribly proud of the victory of our engineers .. Damn .. In the Second World War, the Americans had fewer field radio stations .. It’s not even a matter of life’s consumer attitude .. - but if you are not able to make a washing machine , or a normal, simple smartphone, or a car that meets at least the minimum modern requirements - then you are a third world country ..
        1. Vadim237
          Vadim237 11 May 2018 19: 32
          0
          Zenit-Arena, Vostochny ... - a great example of "rearmament" .. "innovations" and "new items" taken from the journals "Science and Life and Technology-Youth for 1976-88." In the USSR, there were also megaprojects, which all current Russian combined take, one of them is a turn of the flow of Siberian rivers. And it should be noted in the USSR that normal teapots, cars, and generally all public consumer goods were not able to do normally, and the medical equipment was the same.
          1. lesnik1978
            lesnik1978 11 May 2018 20: 49
            +1
            Do not lie, normal kettles, vacuum cleaners, washing machines, refrigerators, which went without repair for 25 years. A friend in a garage has a Vityaz vacuum cleaner of 80s in the garage and is still working. The deceased granny worked for 40 years.
      3. Dikson
        Dikson 11 May 2018 18: 02
        0
        Grandfather Makar .. and MMM with its 1000:% per annum, you don’t remember? )))
        1. Grandfather Makar
          Grandfather Makar 11 May 2018 18: 12
          +3
          Quote: Dikson
          Grandfather Makar .. and MMM with its 1000:% per annum, you don’t remember? )))

          Everything is clear with you. Eugene and it makes no sense to argue ..
          Of the offended liberalists ..! Live in the West and take advantage of their "benefits", and here we are somehow in Russia, we’ll manage without your whining .. hi Do not bother us simply and everything will be fine.
          1. Dikson
            Dikson 12 May 2018 06: 15
            0
            Gorazdy You, grandfather Makar, hang labels ..))) Calves do not lose the abandoned pastures of our vast Motherland ..))
    3. Alex-a832
      Alex-a832 11 May 2018 20: 53
      +1
      Quote: Dikson
      Mr. Sechin once gave an interview to Russia-24 inadvertently let slip - the cost of oil production in Yamal is only $ 2 per barrel ..

      I will clarify. Mr. Sechin unambiguously breached. $ 2 is only at the stage of industrial operation, without preparation and transport. And if you add here all the project costs that Rosneft drags on Yamal for oil dollars, plus the price of loans, then the figure will not only be double-digit, but above 30 or under $ 40. Maybe in five years it will begin to decline if the projects are finished, because the effectiveness of oil management on large production projects stagnates terribly.
  29. APASUS
    APASUS 11 May 2018 16: 56
    +2
    It would be better if the Ministry of Finance predicted the construction of a couple of hundred new factories in a place to drive money to the USA
    1. Vadim237
      Vadim237 11 May 2018 17: 22
      0
      The Ministry of Finance is not involved in the construction of factories, holding companies and private entities are engaged in this, and the state gives them loans and credits for this matter.
      1. bald
        bald 11 May 2018 18: 10
        0
        And in this lies the partial problems of the state. You need to build yourself.
  30. Peace Resident
    Peace Resident 11 May 2018 17: 56
    0
    We get the next “dose of the needle", it’s getting harder to get out of it
  31. g1v2
    g1v2 11 May 2018 18: 03
    +3
    You read komenty and it is not clear whether it was a gathering of the mentally ill or a raid of liberals. whether the children fled from the lessons. belay But rather both.
    Kids, if we didn’t have this very pillow of money, which the evil uncles from the management had accumulated from oil revenues, we would easily survive the hell of 2014-16. In 2008–9, the RF GDP decreased by 10 percent simply because of the crisis. Then nobody really ran into us. In 2014, a world hegemon ran over us with the whole "civilized world." And all they could do was lower our GDP by 4 percent in 2 years. In 2008, without a collision, it fell by 10 percent, and then with such a massive attack by only 4 and already in 2017, growth began. The dollar grew 2 times. and prices are only 20 percent. Why not 2 times as well? At the same time, they kept the social program, did not stop rearmament and did not get into debt. Did it happen? Or at the behest of the holy spirit? Or maybe with the help of this very money pillow? wink
    And if the war begins, then what will you fight for, sickly? Few people will need a ruble outside the country. What will you buy imports for? The same medicines, for example? I'm afraid to upset, but we are still quite dependent on many items for imports. It’s not like it was in 2014, but anyway. request
    To have a small egg is the right and necessary thing. The same oil prices will not always be the same. And if they fall, then what shisha deficit will we cover?
    That’s what always surprises me is how many people want to spend something and not one who wants to earn something. am
    1. onix757
      onix757 11 May 2018 18: 11
      +2
      Quote: g1v2
      Kids, if we didn’t have this very pillow of money, which the evil uncles from the management had accumulated from oil revenues, we would easily survive the hell of 2014-16. In 2008–9, the RF GDP decreased by 10 percent simply because of the crisis. Then nobody really ran into us. In 2014, a world hegemon ran over us with the whole "civilized world."

      And the evil uncles did not try to rebuild industry for 18 years before being measured ... with the collective west? Or the confrontation only concerns the people, and uncles integrated into the global economy and decompose the adversary from the inside, from the laser shores
    2. Golovan Jack
      Golovan Jack 11 May 2018 18: 13
      +2
      Quote: g1v2
      how many want to spend something and not one who wants to earn something

      This is a feature of the mentality of the vast majority of the local horse of Tingent. request
      Quote: onix757
      uncles integrated into the global economy and accumulate adversary from the inside, from the laser shores

      They themselves understood what did they say? laughing
    3. Dikson
      Dikson 11 May 2018 18: 37
      0
      Are you talking about the deal to exchange weapons-grade plutonium for Bush’s legs now? There was such a time .. when, thanks to successful privatization and the collapse of agriculture, there was simply nothing to eat in the country .. And the Americans had to sell for years the accumulated stock of weapons-grade plutonium in exchange for broiler chicken .. And so that prices do not fall on oil, burn the same obscure PMCs several towers in the Persian Gulf (they still fight there all the time) ..
      1. Vadim237
        Vadim237 11 May 2018 19: 40
        0
        It would be better if the Americans worked out all this weapons-grade plutonium than we had it for another 20 years - and then we would have to spend a lot of money on its disposal.
  32. Sergey ippon
    Sergey ippon 11 May 2018 22: 29
    0
    in the center of Russia between the two cities of Kovrov-Shuya there is one small road, only 65 km.
    At work, every week a business trip for shooting road workers after each business trip.
    Even if it weren’t bombing, it wouldn’t be so hard to get. Everyone goes on the sidelines and has been doing it for 20 years in a row.
    On the topic of money? And where the road is infuriating straight can not!
    Road, excise triple, and where are the roads or loot on them !!!
    villains.
  33. Dzungar
    Dzungar 12 May 2018 02: 52
    0
    Have you forgotten about the "budget rule" ...? All that is more than $ 50 per barrel will go to the USA ......
  34. Seaflame
    Seaflame 12 May 2018 17: 34
    0
    I propose to spend part of the extra profit on increasing the series of frigates of the Admiral Gorshkov type, the number of Armata and PAK FA tanks. Just do not need more Olympics, World Cup and other pathos events. The country has much more serious problems! Dmitry Anatolyevich, break away from the iPhone ...
  35. top_war_shit
    top_war_shit 12 May 2018 22: 53
    0
    let red money have a lot to share, let Kudrin go to Africa