Military Review

Jacob Kedmi: C-300 against Israeli aviation - this is serious

36
After the US coalition strike on Syria on the night of April 14, the Russian leadership threatened to return to the issue of supplying C-300 long-range air defense systems in the interests of Damascus. A little later, a number of media outlets reported that such a decision had already been made and the modern air defense system would be sold to the Syrians soon.


It should be understood that the supply of S-300 to Syria will not solve the current problems. For example, Israeli raids aviation. The fact is that the preparation of calculations for such air defense systems takes from a year or more. However, over time, these complexes can become a real headache for the Israeli Air Force.

According to Jacob Kedmi, the destruction of C-300 is not a trivial task. For such an operation, it is necessary to mobilize a large number of combat aircraft. But even in this case, to avoid losses will not be easy. For example, Russia at one time delivered such systems to Greece, and according to media reports, Israeli aircraft, using friendly relations with Athens, conducted special exercises to neutralize them. However, it should be understood that since then C-300 has undergone a number of upgrades.

36 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. Sonet
    Sonet April 30 2018 18: 38
    +1
    While these projects and projects are being discussed from all sides, Israel continues to bomb Syria as an informal do. Russian air defense point blank do not want to help Syria. Russia is a wonderful ally.
    1. svp67
      svp67 April 30 2018 18: 43
      +3
      Quote: Sonet
      Russian Air Defense point blank do not want to help Syria. Russia is a wonderful ally.

      What are you saying? But didn’t you try to figure out whom and what is not being covered by Russia? Everything that is not covered, for some reason, turns out to be very closely connected with Iran. Does this mean nothing to you?
      1. Golovan Jack
        Golovan Jack April 30 2018 18: 51
        +2
        Quote: svp67
        Does this mean nothing to you?

        Nah-nah ... for these soldiers, everyone who scares barmaley, modeled sidekicks and allies of the Russian Federation fellow
        Well, besides Israel, essno laughing
  2. Wolka
    Wolka April 30 2018 18: 42
    +1
    it's not just serious, the S-300 is peremptory ...
  3. svp67
    svp67 April 30 2018 18: 44
    +3
    S-300 versus Israeli aviation - this is serious
    More than. Complexes capable of hitting Israeli aircraft directly on takeoff or landing over Israeli territory is a very weighty argument
    1. Shahno
      Shahno April 30 2018 18: 54
      +2
      Well, you don’t put yours ... In the control car. Until then, "either the donkey will die or the padishah will die" ...
      1. svp67
        svp67 April 30 2018 19: 04
        +3
        Quote: Shahno
        Until then, "either the donkey will die or the padishah will die" ...

        And for me, they’d live like that for a thousand years and that they would live peacefully ...
        Quote: Shahno
        Well, you don’t put your own ...

        You know, it might be better if they were sitting there, if no one suddenly had a desire, to press the "permission" button, just like that. You have not only military aircraft flying.
      2. Cossack 471
        Cossack 471 April 30 2018 20: 22
        0
        I always wonder. and with what fright is Israel bombing a neighboring state? Well, if Syria buys "Caliber" from us and smashes Tel Aviv. You'll like it ? They will even explain to you. Why would they do that ...
        1. Shahno
          Shahno April 30 2018 20: 37
          0
          And you do not ask a question ... The answer is that you will not like it ...
      3. Baby sitter
        Baby sitter April 30 2018 23: 32
        0
        And let it be a surprise .... Fell a pack so immediately! Yes over the city, on takeoff. "To live with wolves, howl like a wolf" (c)
      4. SETTGF
        SETTGF 1 December 2018 16: 05
        0
        Or S-600 or others will appear ... so do not wait, Jews!
      5. GRIGORIY1957
        GRIGORIY1957 3 January 2019 16: 49
        0
        Of course not, in Korea, after all, only Koreans also flew ...)))
    2. RainTNT
      RainTNT April 30 2018 19: 23
      0
      But not from Jordan.
      1. svp67
        svp67 April 30 2018 19: 27
        +1
        Quote: RainTNT
        But not from Jordan.

        And they enter Jordan by the will of the holy spirit. They actually need to take off first, and then land ... and all this from Israeli airfields
        1. RainTNT
          RainTNT April 30 2018 19: 43
          0
          Destroying a post factum is logical, but not rational. Shoot down during take-off is critical. The Israelis boast of 400 nuclear warheads, of course they lie. But their new radars shine through to Moscow and there are non-nuclear missiles with a radius of 3,500 km in service. it is almost to Moscow.
          1. sabakina
            sabakina 1 May 2018 14: 07
            +2
            What? Straight to Moscow? Why not to the Urals? They have no nichrome! Ponty is.
            1. RainTNT
              RainTNT 1 May 2018 18: 51
              0
              It's like 15 of our Mig shot down, or what they don’t have.)
  4. Sonet
    Sonet April 30 2018 18: 57
    0
    Quote: svp67
    Quote: Sonet
    Russian Air Defense point blank do not want to help Syria. Russia is a wonderful ally.

    What are you saying? But didn’t you try to figure out whom and what is not being covered by Russia? Everything that is not covered, for some reason, turns out to be very closely connected with Iran. Does this mean nothing to you?

    Give proofs when Russian air defense massively shot down American, Israeli and missiles of other states in the sky of Syria, aimed against Syria. This time.
    Two, you want to say that Russian air defense covers all of Syria, except for the places of deployment of Iranian troops. But this is not so, because in the famous American raid on Syria, our Ministry of Defense wrote in black in Russian that, “Missiles fired over Syria are in the zone of responsibility Russian air defense did not enter ,,. Roughly speaking, Russian air defense in Syria is covering only its Russian bases and is not going to shoot down those missiles that bomb directly the territory of Syria. And the Iranians don’t have to dodge them, we don’t cover them, let them die like rats. That's Russia such an ally.
    1. svp67
      svp67 April 30 2018 19: 01
      +4
      Quote: Sonet
      Give proofs when Russian air defense massively shot down American, Israeli and missiles of other states in the sky of Syria.

      Do you have any doubt that the BIG part of the American missiles did not reach their destination? There is no merit of our air defense specialists? Oh well...
      And give me an example, where Israeli rockets hit objects unrelated to Iran in Syria?
    2. RainTNT
      RainTNT April 30 2018 19: 04
      -1

      Tonight, such GBU-39 missiles, 40 km from the S-400, S-300, Shell-C1, fell to warehouses in Syria. Destroying 200 missiles at the SA depots.
      1. svp67
        svp67 April 30 2018 19: 29
        +2
        Quote: RainTNT
        Destroying 200 missiles at the SA depots.

        Iranian missiles.
        The same source confirmed the death of 16 people as a result of an attack on a base in the area of ​​Hama. According to him, among the dead at this military facility 11 Iranians.

        The Lebanese television channel Al-Manar, owned by Hezbollah, and the Iranian media published a statement by Iran’s Supreme Leader Ali Khamenei regarding another missile strike on military bases in Syria.

        Khamenei said that from now on, the Iranian military will respond to every such attack. “Now for every blow you get, retaliatory strikes. The times when the enemy managed to avoid an answer after striking were over, ”he said.

        Lebanese Hezbollah officials said Israel was responsible for missile strikes at military bases on Monday night, April 30th. The statement of the leadership of this organization, circulated by the website of the Al-Ahbar publication, said that the retaliatory strike would be "quick and inevitable."
        1. RainTNT
          RainTNT April 30 2018 19: 37
          0
          Israel has the opportunity to repulse the massive strike of even 2000 ballistic missiles, as the Iranians say. This is suicide. Without Alabuga, Kraukha 4, it’s like pricking an elephant with a needle.
          1. Cossack 471
            Cossack 471 April 30 2018 20: 26
            +3
            But Palestinian home-made missiles do not shoot down everything!
          2. sabakina
            sabakina 1 May 2018 14: 11
            +3
            Quote: RainTNT
            Israel has the opportunity to repulse the massive strike of even 2000 ballistic missiles, as the Iranians say. This is suicide. Without Alabuga, Kraukha 4, it’s like pricking an elephant with a needle.

            When 2000 ballistic missiles strike, any system will go crazy! Go to the nursery to tell tales!
            1. RainTNT
              RainTNT 1 May 2018 18: 55
              0
              Fabulous for ... b. And from 6000 tamahawks the system will not go crazy? How much did you drink?
          3. igorka357
            igorka357 2 May 2018 15: 19
            +2
            How many. 2000 ballistic missiles ... laughing and then how many warheads? You have ten Yars for your eyes, and there will be no more promised land, NEVER ...
      2. flicker
        flicker April 30 2018 21: 28
        0
        Doubtfully, this is a guided bomb. The maximum range of defeat is 110 km from an altitude of about 10 km.
    3. Baby sitter
      Baby sitter April 30 2018 23: 37
      +1
      It’s good to drive bullshit, tired of it already .... Read the Agreement and the conditions for the Russian troops in Syria. Or ask adults what the purpose of inviting the Russian Federation to Syria is.
  5. RainTNT
    RainTNT April 30 2018 19: 00
    0
    Do not have time to deliver.
    On Monday, April 30, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu will make an official appeal to the nation regarding the “dramatic development of events related to the nuclear deal with Iran.” This was reported by the press service of the office of the head of government. Benjamin Netanyahu will deliver a speech at 20 p.m. at the Kiriya Defense Ministry complex in Tel Aviv.

    Source: https://infoportalru.ru/binjamin-netanijagu-gotov
    itsja-vystupit-so-specialnym-obrashheniem-k-nacii

    .html
    1. Shahno
      Shahno April 30 2018 19: 05
      +1
      Yes, sometimes something explodes ... When you have a tough stance, and the other side stubbornly ...
      1. tchoni
        tchoni April 30 2018 21: 35
        0
        Quote: Shahno
        Yes, sometimes something explodes ... When you have a tough stance, and the other side stubbornly ...

        This is what I like about the God-chosen. And how infuriating the absence of such a "tough supplication" was when it comes to ours ... (We recall the "Nord", the case of the "musicians" and so on)
  6. Sonet
    Sonet April 30 2018 19: 14
    +1
    Quote: svp67
    Quote: Sonet
    Give proofs when Russian air defense massively shot down American, Israeli and missiles of other states in the sky of Syria.

    Do you have any doubt that the BIG part of the American missiles did not reach their destination? There is no merit of our air defense specialists? Oh well...
    And give me an example, where Israeli rockets hit objects unrelated to Iran in Syria?

    Proofs. Please proofs that our anti-aircraft defense worked in that American raid. You know, don’t seriously wink with an eye saying, well, you think so, it’s not so simple there .....
    The fact that Israel is bombing the Iranians is absolutely understandable. They bomb and bomb and will bomb. But let's think about who the Iranians are? They are investing in Syria’s victory no less, but perhaps more Russians. They are allies to them and to us, and what’s the result, their Israelis they’re bombing like there’s nothing to do. Nobody shoots missiles. Maybe Syrian air defense is weak. And Russian? Why don’t we shoot these missiles if all modern air defense is delivered there in Syria? We don’t want to?
    1. RainTNT
      RainTNT April 30 2018 19: 17
      0
      They fly low. 9 pieces at once. And do not forget about the horizon.
      In addition to accuracy, the main advantage of GBU-39 is stealth: with a length of 1,8 m and a shell diameter of 0,19 m, the bomb has an EPR of about 0,015 m2, which makes it difficult to repulse a massive strike with such means with the help of SAM
  7. Sonet
    Sonet April 30 2018 19: 31
    0
    Quote: RainTNT

    Tonight, such GBU-39 missiles, 40 km from the S-400, S-300, Shell-C1, fell to warehouses in Syria. Destroying 200 missiles at the SA depots.

    It doesn’t matter that it’s only 40km from our base. They flew low. Very low. We couldn’t shoot them down. We didn’t even see them. Probably they were super hyper speed. Mach 10 is no different. We can’t shoot such missiles. Forgive the Syrians. Forgive Iranians.
  8. tchoni
    tchoni April 30 2018 21: 38
    +2
    You know, I have already expressed this idea, I repeat once again: for now, the S-300 is a paper tiger. He growls loudly, looks menacing, has glory, BUT DIDN'T TURN OFF ANY ANTILOPE in battle conditions
    1. Conserp
      Conserp 1 May 2018 09: 26
      +1
      Quote: tchoni
      You know, I already expressed this idea.

      This is called differently.

      Not a “thought,” no.