Military Review

How Poland will reflect the air attack of Russia

82
In the event of war, Poland will defend itself against Russian missiles and Soviet aircraft. weapons, writes an American expert in his article for the National Interest.


How Poland will reflect the air attack of Russia


He notes that the airspace over Poland is protected by Soviet weapons, along with some domestic developments.

“At the same time, the country still uses the C-60 anti-aircraft artillery complex, developed in the middle of the 1940-s. Also used anti-aircraft installation ZU-23-2, which in the USSR adopted for use in 1960 year. However, an electric drive and fire control system was added to this combat vehicle, ”the article quotes. RIA News.

The author also reminds that in a short time the forces of the Polish air defense will be replenished with the American “Patriots”. However, in his opinion, this innovation may lead to "some integration problems in air defense."

The agreement to supply Poland with the Patriot anti-aircraft systems was signed in July 2017. According to the treaties, the Polish military will receive an air defense missile system for the XXMX. The United States must supply an ally with two Patriot batteries with PAC-2022 MSE missiles and elements of an IBCS control and communications system.
Photos used:
http://war-only.com
82 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. Dormidont
    Dormidont April 23 2018 11: 54
    +3
    Tennis Rackets More Reliable
    1. vkl.47
      vkl.47 April 23 2018 11: 57
      +2
      The old is not the old but shoots.
      1. Major Yurik
        Major Yurik April 23 2018 12: 18
        +4
        Sorry for the Poles, but they could live! With them too amerika! recourse
    2. 210ox
      210ox April 23 2018 11: 57
      +5
      And ambition is generally a 100% result ..
      Quote: Dormidont
      Tennis Rackets More Reliable
      1. Logall
        Logall April 23 2018 12: 23
        +10
        "–When you see a bear, then throw poop at it.
        –And where can I get poop?
        –When you see, they will be! "
    3. Vitaly Anisimov
      Vitaly Anisimov April 23 2018 11: 58
      +7
      This time, I think the Poles will live a couple of minutes .. If the United States and Russia begin kneading! I won’t even feel sorry .. They asked for it themselves, destroying our monuments to the soldiers who died, saving you from furnaces and destruction by the Nazis.
      1. Sergey-svs
        Sergey-svs April 23 2018 12: 03
        +6
        2 Patriot complexes throughout the country and ancient air defense systems from Soviet times? !!!request As Lavrov said: - "D, B!" fool They would have better calculated how quickly this anti-aircraft defense would be suppressed, at least some use from the article "National Interest" would have been ... yes
        1. Thunderbolt
          Thunderbolt April 23 2018 12: 11
          +2
          Quote: Sergey-svs
          2 Patriot complexes for the whole country and ancient air defense systems from Soviet times ?!

          Not to the whole country, but 60 km from the Kaliningrad region ... and this fundamentally changes the whole thing. It’s not for the defense of NATO that it is pulling forces into Poland and the Baltic states, although the talk is ONLY about defense. Here is an unnamed “expert” from a well-known magazine about the defense of the song sings, as if on assignment.
          1. alstr
            alstr April 23 2018 13: 51
            +2
            Well, the border with the Kaliningrad region is 200 km by land plus sea 100 minimum.
            Plus, the border with Belarus and Lithuania (they will not even ask her).
            In the end, and through Ukraine you can hit.
            So decently typed.
        2. Orionvit
          Orionvit April 23 2018 17: 07
          0
          Quote: Sergey-svs
          They would have better calculated how quickly this anti-aircraft defense will be suppressed,

          This they have long known and bark only from behind the owner. But in how many minutes they will have time to change their shoes, in which case, they have definitely calculated this for a long time.
          1. Slovak
            Slovak April 23 2018 19: 56
            +3
            [quote = Orionvit] [quote = Sergey-svs] But in how many minutes they will have time to change shoes, in which case, they have definitely calculated it for a long time. [/ quote]
            You do not underestimate the Poles. The speed with which they know how to lie under the right owner has been practiced for centuries.
  2. oleg-gr
    oleg-gr April 23 2018 11: 54
    +1
    Do we need them, these psheks? This is the idea of ​​"fixation" eating them. Empire "from sea to sea."
    1. Dormidont
      Dormidont April 23 2018 11: 55
      +2
      overdose of apples
    2. Prisoner
      Prisoner April 23 2018 12: 04
      +1
      They recall the famous grandmother from the song.
      "Like Nedibasovskaya, the corner of Vasilyevskaya,
      At eight o'clock in the evening the news spread:
      Like our grandmother, grandmother’s grandmother,
      Four raiders took away the honor!

      Ots Tots flipper, grandmother is healthy,
      Otsotz flipper eats compote.
      Oz Tots flip and dreams again
      Ots Tots flipper survive the raid ... "(c) winked
      1. akims
        akims April 23 2018 23: 23
        0
        Correct: On Deribasovskaya, the corner of Rishelievskaya. These are the streets in Odessa.
      2. Lint64
        Lint64 April 30 2018 22: 13
        0
        Blessed Circle!
    3. Romka47
      Romka47 April 23 2018 14: 21
      +4
      We need it if the war starts and we slander part of the territories (let's say something is being occupied with us) Then the most cruel-western Slavs will come to kill, torture, and mock civilians. So, in the event of war, from Kiev to the left it is necessary to leave everything without a population of draft age. Those Hungarians generally mow under 0 (why ask our locals from near Voronezh) That is why the end of the camp was built in the same Poland, the animals were ready to break their brother, albeit a 3-year-old.
      1. Weyland
        Weyland April 23 2018 15: 13
        +2
        Quote: Romka47
        That will kill, torture, and mock civilians come the most cruel-Western Slavs.

        I will not say about Slovaks, but it’s hard to say who is more cruel - Poles or Czechs. If we recall how the "exploits" of the Czechs in Siberia in 1918-19, and the deportation of the Germans in 1945 (especially when you consider that it was the Germans who didn’t particularly tyrannize the Czechs)
      2. Lint64
        Lint64 April 30 2018 22: 15
        +1
        By the way, yes! Hungarians near Balaton really spoiled the blood!
        1. Romka47
          Romka47 3 May 2018 09: 01
          +1
          I myself am from Voronezh, here they were especially distinguished, there was an unspoken order of the Hungarians not to be taken prisoner, and they did not.
  3. RASKAT
    RASKAT April 23 2018 11: 54
    +2
    Twenty-five again, but who needs your Poland, live there for your health, just don’t touch us. And you do not need air defense.
  4. NIKNN
    NIKNN April 23 2018 11: 55
    +1
    Well, clearly our weapons in Syria showed themselves ... smile
    In case of war, Poland will defend itself against Russian missiles and aircraft with Soviet weapons, an American expert writes.
    Why not patriots, where are NATO standards? request
    1. tlauicol
      tlauicol April 23 2018 11: 56
      +2
      "In the event of war, Poland will defend itself against Russian missiles and aircraft with Soviet weapons, an American expert writes in an article for National Interest."
      guess for yourself What is it written for?
  5. Masya masya
    Masya masya April 23 2018 11: 55
    +2
    immediately cover yourself with a copper basin ... wink as they say, "I'm in the house!"lol
    1. Vitaly Anisimov
      Vitaly Anisimov April 23 2018 12: 13
      +1
      Quote: Masya Masya
      immediately cover yourself with a copper basin ... wink as they say, "I'm in the house!"lol

      laughing bully love
  6. rotmistr60
    rotmistr60 April 23 2018 11: 58
    +7
    Poland, like the rest of Europe, has a lot of ambition, and military exhaust is approaching 0. When Poland was admitted to NATO, one of the generals stated that they now have infantry, which, if necessary, will fight on the ground with the Russians. I didn’t take into account one thing - the Poles imagine themselves not as infantry, but as a minimum, dragoons with fake wings and will fight only in words. Today, their herald Yakub Koreyba yells at every talk show we (the EU and most importantly the Americans) will show you ... Thus, emphasizing that the hope is only on the Americans.
    1. voyaka uh
      voyaka uh April 23 2018 12: 23
      +1
      Check the weapons that Poland has.
      They now have perhaps the largest land army
      to NATO. Tanks, for sure, most of all.
      And they strengthened their aircraft.
      1. rotmistr60
        rotmistr60 April 23 2018 12: 27
        +2
        Are you (the Poles) ready to fight? Ukraine also has the "strongest" army in Europe. But the largest army in NATO is still perhaps Turkish.
        1. voyaka uh
          voyaka uh April 23 2018 12: 32
          0
          The Poles usually fought bravely.
          Rarely did they have chances to defeat large opponents, like Russia or Germany, but they always gave the go-ahead.
          1. den3080
            den3080 April 23 2018 12: 42
            +3
            Right! Poles always fight bravely. One minus is not for long. They would be weaker than the enemy, well, like Lithuania and Vilna in 1920.
            1. voyaka uh
              voyaka uh April 23 2018 13: 25
              0
              Do you mean Budenny and Tukhachevsky? They fought
              also bravely. But also not for long. sad
              1. Vitaly Anisimov
                Vitaly Anisimov April 23 2018 13: 34
                +1
                Quote: voyaka uh
                Do you mean Budenny and Tukhachevsky? They fought
                also bravely. But also not for long. sad

                Jews of course in the first place .. We would not have won the Second World War without them! Tashkent front, stood on death .. hehe
              2. stalkerwalker
                stalkerwalker April 23 2018 13: 37
                +3
                Quote: voyaka uh
                also bravely. But also not for long.

                Against the forces of Y. Pilsudsky - yes. The Poles fled, bringing down the front all the way to Warsaw.
                And only the intervention of the "black international" with the urgent supply of artillery, and the leadership of the General Staff of France, allowed to make a "miracle on the Vistula."
                1. Vitaly Anisimov
                  Vitaly Anisimov April 23 2018 14: 06
                  +1
                  Quote: stalkerwalker
                  Quote: voyaka uh
                  also bravely. But also not for long.

                  Against the forces of Y. Pilsudsky - yes. The Poles fled, bringing down the front all the way to Warsaw.
                  And only the intervention of the "black international" with the urgent supply of artillery, and the leadership of the General Staff of France, allowed to make a "miracle on the Vistula."

                  laughing wassat No comments.. bully
                2. voyaka uh
                  voyaka uh April 23 2018 15: 19
                  +3
                  The Poles fled, bringing down the front all the way to Warsaw "///

                  And already from there, the Red Army fled, caving in the front and massively surrendering. It happens.
                  The main thing is not to engage in hatred and do not underestimate the enemy.
                  1. stalkerwalker
                    stalkerwalker April 23 2018 15: 37
                    +1
                    Quote: voyaka uh
                    And already from there, the Red Army fled, caving in the front and massively surrendering. It happens.

                    Quote: stalkerwalker
                    And only the intervention of the "black international" with the urgent supply of artillery, and the leadership of the General Staff of France, allowed to make a "miracle on the Vistula."
                  2. akims
                    akims April 23 2018 23: 28
                    +1
                    This begs the question, why should the Russian Federation attack Poland? I have such an impression that the Poles themselves, like our Petya, want to be attacked. It’s like in childhood, some do-it-yourself imagining Bruce Lee: come on, attack me! Yes, you go to the stump, we do not want to fight with you. Go, knock your head on a tree, maybe it’s better.
              3. Weyland
                Weyland April 23 2018 15: 05
                0
                Quote: voyaka uh
                Do you mean Budenny and Tukhachevsky?

                EMNIP, Budyonny - Ukrainian. and Tukhachevsky - Belarusian, and from the east - from Smolensk region (it was included in the RSFSR for political reasons, the population there was almost completely Belarusian)
              4. Vkd dvk
                Vkd dvk April 23 2018 18: 36
                +1
                Quote: voyaka uh
                Do you mean Budenny and Tukhachevsky? They fought
                also bravely. But also not for long. sad

                Victories, like defeats, do not depend on one belligerent. But from two.
          2. stalkerwalker
            stalkerwalker April 23 2018 14: 20
            +1
            Quote: voyaka uh
            The Poles usually fought bravely.

            The personal qualities of Polish salvages were at their best. One problem - where did these politicians send Polish politicians .....
            Quote: voyaka uh
            but they always gave the go-ahead.

            Oh, yes-ah-ah-ah .... In the summer of 1939, this was especially noticeable. As a result, the disappearance of the Polish state from the maps of Europe until the 1945.
            1. voyaka uh
              voyaka uh April 23 2018 15: 21
              0
              "In the summer of 1939 it was especially noticeable" ////

              In the summer of 41, it was not sweet either. sad
              Only the Poles had nowhere to retreat.
              1. stalkerwalker
                stalkerwalker April 23 2018 15: 36
                0
                Quote: voyaka uh
                Only the Poles had nowhere to retreat.

                Maybe it was necessary to skip parts of the Red Army in the 1938 in order to eliminate the Czechoslovak crisis? And France asked for it. But in the end, Poland itself bit off the Tishinsky region from the Czechs, thereby de facto becoming a military alliance with Germany.
                Quote: voyaka uh
                41 wasn't sweet either in summer

                And in 42, and in 43, it was very unsweetened.
                But at the very end of August 1944, the head of the Polish government in exile Mkolaichik flew to Moscow, on the eve of the Warsaw uprising. And he didn’t say a word about this in the negotiations with I. Stalin.
                And only when the Poles began to be massively burned with napalm in the basements, he asked for help. How to perceive it? Only how
                Quote: voyaka uh
                but they always gave the go-ahead.

                And the Poles raked, who sacredly believed the leadership of the AK and Mikołajczyk.
                I can also recall the provocation with the capture of Vilnius by AK detachments who wanted to "liberate" the city from the invaders.
              2. The comment was deleted.
          3. Weyland
            Weyland April 23 2018 15: 03
            0
            Quote: voyaka uh
            The Poles usually fought bravely.

            That is yes. Only usually within the framework of the Hannibal maxim about the "army of lions under the leadership of a ram." There were talented Polish military leaders, but for some reason they usually fought for some other countries, often at war - like Rokossovsky and Levinsky (better known as Manstein)
      2. viktor.
        viktor. April 23 2018 15: 34
        0
        One well-known Russian politician said that these dwarf states would be swept away, he had in mind the Baltic states and the Psheks! he is right with a good batch they do not need tanks and infantry. I watched a doc film about this policy, everything that he said and about which he warned comes true as in Cinema, to take the same Ukraine, look at your leisure time will be.
      3. icant007
        icant007 April 23 2018 18: 49
        0
        They also have 4 tankers and a dog. wink
        1. Hiller
          Hiller April 25 2018 20: 19
          0
          with a Soviet tank, a Georgian driver and a Soviet nurse lol
    2. Lint64
      Lint64 April 30 2018 22: 18
      0
      Oh! Sadness! Now Ukraine-pehtura!
  7. Prisoner
    Prisoner April 23 2018 12: 00
    +2
    As if they did not have to defend themselves against their "patriots" with Soviet missiles. Veslma is a frivolous rocket and lazy. Everything strives to return home. laughing
  8. jncnfdybr
    jncnfdybr April 23 2018 12: 01
    +3
    How does everyone want Russia to attack them. What is it for? )))
    1. Lint64
      Lint64 April 30 2018 22: 21
      0
      Here I have a desire, in recent years more and more often to create the Canadian-Mexican Strait!
  9. Tarasve
    Tarasve April 23 2018 12: 05
    +1
    With such powerful weapons, you can only fight back from Ukraine. It was written in case of war, but not written with anyone. Yes, there are three more military superpowers nearby: Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania. wassat
  10. Kelwin
    Kelwin April 23 2018 12: 07
    0
    Still need pots, so more reliable)))
  11. CAT BAIYUN
    CAT BAIYUN April 23 2018 12: 10
    +1
    In case of war, Poland will defend itself against Russian missiles and aircraft with Soviet weapons

    It’s good that this expedition did not write that Poland would attack with these weapons ... But he could! laughing There is enough level in NI at the local sports clubs.
    Poland, of course, proud and arrogant, but a prostitute. Let there be hopes for anything, but next year the LAST tranche of 70 lard promised and listed Poland for joining the European Union. Further ... Well, try it yourself, as they say. They’re trying to dig money themselves ... They’ve sold to amers for installing a missile defense system and have become suicide bombers .... Congratulations. And about the old weapon ... Well, do not throw it away in the end. On bezrybe and .op nightingale.
    1. Lint64
      Lint64 April 30 2018 22: 23
      0
      "... Poland, of course, proud and arrogant, but a prostitute ...." Bravo!
  12. san4es
    san4es April 23 2018 12: 13
    +3
    Poland still uses the S-60 anti-aircraft artillery system, developed in the mid-1940s. Also used anti-aircraft installation ZU-23-2 ...

    hi I forgot about aviation:
    A contract for the modernization of the MiG-29 fighters of the national air force worth $ 44,5 million was signed between the Armed Forces Inspectorate of Poland and the military airline No. 2 (Wojskowe Zaklady Lomicze 2, Bydgoszcz) in September 2011. The aim of the work is to extend the life of the MiG-29 fighters until 2028, increase their combat capabilities and interoperability with the Polish Air Force F-16 fighters. In accordance with the contract, 13 MiG-29A fighters and three MiG-29UB fighters are subject to modernization. During the modernization, new on-board electronic equipment is installed on the MiG-29 fighters, including MDP on-board computers, MIL-Std-1553B data buses, INSB-29, AVB-29 and HDB-29 interfaces, color multifunction displays (127 x 102 mm) and navigation systems with SAASM (Selective Availability Anti-Spoofing Module) GPS signal protection from interference.

    am ...Besides:
    http://factmil.com/publ/strana/polsha/sostojanie_
    i_perspektivy_stroitelstva_vvs_polshi_2015 / 25-1-0
    -697% hi
    1. voyaka uh
      voyaka uh April 23 2018 12: 47
      +1
      F-16 they have 48 pieces. They still ordered the same.
      And 30 MiG-39. With a hundred modern combat aircraft
      can live ...
      1. san4es
        san4es April 23 2018 13: 19
        +1
        Quote: voyaka uh
        F-16 they have 48 pieces ... And 30 MiG-39 ..

        hi ... "Refreshed" means --Moreover ... And then vparuyu misinformation, about memory 23 sad
      2. Vitaly Anisimov
        Vitaly Anisimov April 23 2018 13: 43
        0
        Quote: voyaka uh
        F-16 they have 48 pieces. They still ordered the same.
        And 30 MiG-39. With a hundred modern combat aircraft
        can live ...

        And it’s already possible to fight with the Russians .. heh heh .. Do you hope there too in Israel?
        1. voyaka uh
          voyaka uh April 23 2018 15: 26
          +1
          We - like the cry of Leninist pioneers - "Always ready!" drinks
          And - for three - too! fellow drinks
      3. Lint64
        Lint64 April 30 2018 22: 26
        0
        And also they will be "fired" with the F-35? F-22 secret, but also vparit.
    2. Bongo
      Bongo April 23 2018 14: 57
      +1
      Quote: san4es
      Besides:

      According to the SA-N-data is not reliable. No.
      1. san4es
        san4es April 23 2018 15: 43
        0
        Quote: Bongo
        For SAM systems, the data are not reliable. : no

        ... They are not new, (for 2015)
        The structure of the Polish air defense system includes: three air defense regiments equipped with the Kub and Osa air defense systems; air defense missile brigade consisting of six divisions equipped with SAM "Neva" and S-200 "Vega"; two frigates of the Oliver X. Perry type with SM-1 missiles, which are planned to be decommissioned in 2015.
        ... Infa is different everywhere. But there is a final acquisition:
        On March 28, 2018 in Warsaw, on the territory of the Polish military-industrial enterprise PIT-Radwar, the Minister of National Defense of Poland Mariusz Blaszczczak and the US Ambassador to Poland Paul W. Jones signed a contract (in the form of an exchange of letters between the governments of Letters of Offer and Acceptance - LOA) for the supply Poland through the intergovernmental military sales Foreign Military Sales (FMS) of the first two batteries of the American Patriot anti-aircraft missile systems in the PAC-3 + configuration with the new integrated combat air defense and missile defense system Integrated Air and Missile Defense (IAMD) Battle Command System (IBCS). The contract value is $ 4,75 billion (about 16,1 billion Polish zlotys), which makes it the largest import arms purchase in Polish history hi .
        1. Lint64
          Lint64 April 30 2018 22: 29
          0
          It's all licking Trump. Trampyatinki wanted. In order to protect the Poles from the Germanicists, iki.
  13. bumerang.
    bumerang. April 23 2018 12: 19
    +3
    Russia does not attack anyone, unlike Nato. Poland needs to think about how to defend against US smart missiles in case Poland threatens democracy, that is, the dollar. It is unlikely that Patriot will protect against their smart missiles.
  14. Vitaly Anisimov
    Vitaly Anisimov April 23 2018 12: 19
    +1
    Everything was in vain in Poland .. We were mistaken at the expense of the Poles and suffered such losses saving their cities
    historical ... soldier

    Now everything will be different .. Thank you "brothers" for finally opening our eyes to everything that happens ... As you are with us, we will be with you now .. No offense! soldier
    1. Hiller
      Hiller April 25 2018 20: 35
      0
      My dad didn’t live well in troubled times ... after all, he has the Polish Order of the Cross of the Brave and a pool from the Germans and Bandera ... the generation of Victors has passed and the time for permissiveness has come. Sad
    2. Lint64
      Lint64 April 30 2018 22: 32
      0
      Thank you for understanding this! May 9 is coming!
  15. voyaka uh
    voyaka uh April 23 2018 12: 20
    0
    Duc, did they order the Patriots?
    In a couple of years they will be able to repel an air attack.
    And F-16 they have.
    1. Vitaly Anisimov
      Vitaly Anisimov April 23 2018 14: 09
      0
      Quote: voyaka uh
      Duc, did they order the Patriots?
      In a couple of years they will be able to repel an air attack.
      And F-16 they have.

      It’s a pity you can’t swear on the site ... negative Well enough of the "comrade" is enough to rouse the Slavs?
      Why don’t you calm down then ..?
    2. Weyland
      Weyland April 23 2018 15: 17
      0
      Quote: voyaka uh
      In a couple of years they will be able to repel an air attack.

      the attack of most neighboring countries - no problem: Czech, Slovak, Ukrainian and Lithuanian!
    3. Lint64
      Lint64 April 30 2018 22: 36
      0
      Are you kidding me? In "Tribaltia" slammed F-16. A pilot, I hope a normal guy will say: "I love Putin!". Kaliningrad with electronic warfare is not in vain!
  16. shuravi
    shuravi April 23 2018 12: 32
    0
    Quote: voyaka uh
    Duc, did they order the Patriots?
    In a couple of years they will be able to repel an air attack.
    And F-16 they have.



    Yeah. laughing
  17. gerkost2012
    gerkost2012 April 23 2018 12: 36
    +1
    Even Poland is not overpowered! Chop Poles Moskalsky VKS with oriental saber-balls.
    After all this is seen in a dream by Yakub Koreyba, he bites the hosts on a TV show. After all, dreams sometimes come true.
    1. Lint64
      Lint64 April 30 2018 22: 38
      0
      Good! Thanks for the joke.
  18. Amateur
    Amateur April 23 2018 12: 51
    0
    "" Patriot "+ ZU-23 is power" - Alexander Dumas, "3 Poles + dog"
  19. nafanal
    nafanal April 23 2018 14: 10
    0
    At that anti-aircraft installations, old as shit of a mammoth, are going to cover with patriots. However ....
  20. gukoyan
    gukoyan April 23 2018 14: 14
    +2
    Phahahaha, oh ... I can not))))
    Some shields of Europe, the second are afraid of the advance of our army ... Around one paranoia ... Of course it is clear why this is all done, but I can’t read without tears))
  21. NF68
    NF68 April 23 2018 14: 40
    0
    Can take on arms and slingshots.
  22. 22 dmdc
    22 dmdc April 23 2018 15: 29
    0
    Quote: voyaka uh
    can live ...

    With airplanes, in airplanes or with Iskanders.
  23. Stavr Godinovich
    Stavr Godinovich April 23 2018 20: 20
    0
    They will go out to the square, take off their trousers and scare the naked asshole of a rocket !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
  24. earloop
    earloop April 24 2018 10: 11
    0
    The title of the article "How Poland will repel an air attack of Russia" - To the question: "How"? The likely answer is "No way." Before the "attack", all the "reflectors" listed in the article will be suitable only for the local scrap metal collection point.
  25. Lint64
    Lint64 April 30 2018 22: 09
    0
    Sweaty “Patriot” looks to the East, and “Iskander” will fly from the north, or from the south or from the west! "Patriot" as a mouse for a cat. I am proud!