Military Review

The Ministry of Finance has everything according to plan: "about zero"

174
The head of the Ministry of Finance made another forecast on the country's budget in 2018. According to Anton Siluanov, while maintaining the emerging macroeconomic indicators, the budget will be overwhelmed with a surplus. By what percentage? According to Siluanov, the surplus will be half a percentage point. In other words, the tendency for growth of “#solonol” by the current composition of the government continues. It is stated that "this is growth."


Siluanov:
For this year we, if the same price persists, will come out with a surplus, it may even be 0,5% of GDP surplus of the budget. We will replenish our National Wealth Fund in its pure form. We will be determined with the priorities that the government has set. Everything goes according to plan.


The Ministry of Finance has everything according to plan: "about zero"


That is, the output on 0,5% is a “planned order”? And what about the message of the president, in which he set ambitious goals for the growth of the Russian economy at a rate that should be ahead of the world average. Or is the remaining dynamics, in the opinion of the Ministry of Finance, already sufficient to impose a surplus budget?

The Ministry of Economic Development even more "optimistic" said that the budget surplus at current oil prices could be 1,2% for the year. In other words, the government does not hide the fact that even if the surplus in the treasury is noted, it is solely due to the increase in oil prices, and not the work of the Cabinet itself.

Recall that the original forecast for the budget was "deficient" - a total of minus 2,9% to 2020 of the year.

The previous time, the budget of the Russian Federation was a surplus of 7 years ago.
174 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. oleg-gr
    oleg-gr April 21 2018 07: 10
    +25
    Kudrin’s precepts are keeping the economic part of the current government. Everyone is trying to confirm that the Russian Federation is a big "oil" power. Bananas will grow, it will be a "banana".
    1. Vard
      Vard April 21 2018 07: 11
      +10
      For an ordinary person, an indicator of the state of the financial system of Russia ... is the dollar exchange rate ... and what you yourself see with it ...
      1. Click
        Click April 21 2018 07: 17
        +49
        For an ordinary person, an indicator of the state of the financial system, emptiness in pockets and price increases in stores ... yes
        1. Vard
          Vard April 21 2018 07: 19
          +7
          It’s just derivatives ... Anyway ... before the salary was in dollars twice as much ... and accordingly there was more to buy ...
          1. Xnumx vis
            Xnumx vis April 21 2018 07: 38
            +5
            And now, in order to stay at the same level, family welfare, a person needs to work twice as much. So stick in!
            1. Tatyana
              Tatyana April 21 2018 09: 10
              +10
              With Siluanov - a follower of the IMF member Kudrin - and with the existing Federal Law of the Russian Federation “On the Central Bank”, Russia, how to give it a drink, will colonize economically and politically under the applause of the United States and the collective West! And no revived RF Armed Forces will save our country!

              Siluanova with his proposal to increase the retirement age out of the Russian government!
              1. NIKNN
                NIKNN April 21 2018 11: 23
                +12
                Quote: Tatiana
                Siluanova with his proposal to increase the retirement age out of the Russian government!

                I don’t remember literally, nor the author, but the point is that people should constantly live in a survival mode and then they have no time to think about politics (or something like that) and it’s easier to manage, like you can’t let him go beyond a certain limit ... And as for the Siluanovs, so here
              2. Normal ok
                Normal ok April 21 2018 17: 43
                +3
                Quote: Tatiana
                With Siluanov - a follower of the IMF member Kudrin - and with the existing Federal Law of the Russian Federation “On the Central Bank”, Russia, how to give it a drink, will colonize economically and politically under the applause of the United States and the collective West!

                And do not put anyone there - the result will be the same. This is no longer a problem for an individual, but an established system. From a change of place ...
          2. hrych
            hrych April 21 2018 08: 00
            +17
            Quote: Vard
            For an ordinary person, an indicator of the state of the financial system of Russia ... this is the dollar exchange rate ...

            The average man should have been surprised then that Trump accused the Russian Federation of artificially depreciating the ruble laughing in order to increase the competitiveness of their products. Of course, the import substitution is difficult, that with EBN the market was completely captured by import, the most dangerous is the food market, but this period has been overcome. Consumer goods have also risen in price for this, but the people in the elections have shown that they are ready to tolerate for the sake of Victory.
            Quote: Vard
            Like it or not ... before the salary was in dollars twice as much ... and, accordingly, there was more to buy ...

            So do not count in dollars. Our fighters are bought by the state in rubles, submarines in rubles, and if you are ready to sell your homeland and the regime for reeling for half the price in rubles, iPhone or BMW, then especially now we are not on our way. Rather, on the way to the nearest wall wassat If you haven’t noticed, then there’s a war, while economic and informational, but almost exchanged blows, however, but the purchasing power of your salary, which has decreased by half traitors and prisoners) in 1941 they gave all that is, including life. Children stood up to the machine tools and the women volunteered for the front. And now we still have some whining ...
            1. DEDPIHTO
              DEDPIHTO April 21 2018 08: 09
              +5
              Quote: hrych
              Quote: Vard
              For an ordinary person, an indicator of the state of the financial system of Russia ... this is the dollar exchange rate ...

              The average man should have been surprised then that Trump accused the Russian Federation of artificially depreciating the ruble laughing in order to increase the competitiveness of their products. Of course, the import substitution is difficult, that with EBN the market was completely captured by import, the most dangerous is the food market, but this period has been overcome. Consumer goods have also risen in price for this, but the people in the elections have shown that they are ready to tolerate for the sake of Victory.
              Quote: Vard
              Like it or not ... before the salary was in dollars twice as much ... and, accordingly, there was more to buy ...

              So do not count in dollars. Our fighters are bought by the state in rubles, submarines in rubles, and if you are ready for half the price, in rubles, iPhone or BMW to sell your homeland and reel

              Grunt in his repertoire, do not reel mode !!!! laughing
              1. hrych
                hrych April 21 2018 19: 52
                +1
                So that the regime does not stagger, you need to put a column to the wall ... fifth wassat
                1. DEDPIHTO
                  DEDPIHTO April 22 2018 00: 21
                  +2
                  ,, Horses mixed in a bunch, people .. ,, (c) fool Rotten shed no matter how props ... yes
            2. Civilian
              Civilian April 21 2018 09: 43
              +5
              Quote: hrych
              ... If you have not noticed, then there is a war, while the economic and information ..

              I didn’t notice the war. There is a place to be "beating babies."
              But we, too, snarl. Our response by “counter-sanctions” almost torpedoed the enemy’s economy, the enemy began to deflate-lower prices for goods and services. In the future, this will undoubtedly adversely affect the economic growth rates of countries that have come under our counterattack.
              1. hrych
                hrych April 21 2018 19: 53
                +1
                It is immediately clear that the State, in the sense of the State laughing
            3. dobryKot pitersciy
              dobryKot pitersciy April 21 2018 10: 10
              +4
              My wife loves crackers with tea, from Dixie. So they have recently risen in price by 20p ((this is apparently also a luxury item.
              1. hrych
                hrych April 21 2018 19: 54
                +2
                And there’s nothing to eat any rubbish laughing
            4. Greenwood
              Greenwood April 22 2018 15: 11
              +2
              Quote: hrych
              If you haven’t noticed, then there’s a war, while economic and informational, but almost exchanged blows, however, but the purchasing power of your salary, which has decreased by half traitors and prisoners) in 1941 they gave all that is, including life. Children stood up to the machine tools and the women volunteered for the front. And now we still have some whining ...
              Did you spend anything in the madhouse? I just don’t believe that a normal person will carry such nonsense.
          3. Click
            Click April 21 2018 12: 35
            +1
            Such salaries in rubles, in new, greenbacks ... wink holding 200 ruble bills in their hands? One gets the feeling that they are printed on A4 sheets laughing at this pace on plywood, tsifiri will be scratching soon ... lol
        2. Andrey Yuryevich
          Andrey Yuryevich April 21 2018 07: 42
          +14
          Quote: Click
          For an ordinary person, an indicator of the state of the financial system, emptiness in pockets and price increases in stores ... yes

          the main thing is stability!
          1. hrych
            hrych April 21 2018 08: 08
            +7
            Quote: Andrey Yurievich
            the main thing is stability

            The main safety. Not sarcasm. Ask the Yugoslavs and Libyans, they know. Therefore, you need a strategic weapon and more.
            1. Greenwood
              Greenwood April 22 2018 15: 11
              +4
              Do you eat borshchik, potatoes and sausages for lunch? Or Sarmatians with poplars?
        3. Kent0001
          Kent0001 April 21 2018 11: 44
          +8
          Well damn guess, ahhh! But in general, it’s not funny for a long time to observe the complete impotence of our power in the economy, and now in politics ... and the reason is money in the West ... all have a complete lack of brains for some. I’ll just keep silent about corruption.
          1. My doctor
            My doctor April 21 2018 14: 35
            +1
            Quote: Kent0001
            Well damn guess, ahhh! But in general, it’s not funny for a long time to observe the complete impotence of our power in the economy, and now in politics ... and the reason is money in the West ... all have a complete lack of brains for some. I’ll just keep silent about corruption.

            Russia will never rise from its knees in the economy. In my opinion, this is basically impossible. China is an example of this, it is the multibillion-dollar investment of the West that has made China the way it is. But there were prerequisites for this in China, it was gratuitous, at that time, the labor force was not burdened with pension and medical (in rural areas) provision.
          2. hrych
            hrych April 21 2018 19: 56
            0
            Quote: Kent0001
            complete impotence ... complete lack of brain

            What hurts and speaks about? wassat
      2. Svarog
        Svarog April 21 2018 07: 18
        +20
        Quote: Vard
        For an ordinary person, an indicator of the state of the financial system of Russia ... is the dollar exchange rate ... and what you yourself see with it ...

        Yes, a lot of indicators for an ordinary person besides the course, he received and the indicator turns on already .. paid for housing and communal services, the kindergarten and the indicator lights up in red laughing Well, I paid OSAGO, repaired the car, all the indicator broke down, I need to pay my debts ..
      3. siberalt
        siberalt April 21 2018 07: 24
        +12
        We learn at home to make palm oil from oil, and then the economy will rise. lol
        1. Separ DNR
          Separ DNR April 21 2018 07: 35
          +8
          Quote: siberalt
          We learn at home to make palm oil from oil, and then the economy will rise.

          So they will make you eat this oil.
          1. Stas157
            Stas157 April 21 2018 07: 51
            +23
            Quote: Separ DNR

            So they will make you eat this oil.

            About half dreams of it, here on the forum! Check out the news that Indesia for the latest Su-35 fighters is calculated with palm oil, not real money. There will be a lot of comments from misapportement about the benefits and necessity for the Russians of this palm! I was personally convinced of this, wrapped up steeper than on Kissel TV!
            1. You Vlad
              You Vlad April 21 2018 09: 45
              0
              Quote: Stas157
              There will be a lot of comments from misapportement about the benefits and necessity for the Russians of this palm!

              I want to answer, but lazy lately, and it's useless! How can you get out of the way
              agarison wink and here again godfather to the king No.
          2. Gardamir
            Gardamir April 21 2018 07: 52
            +13
            So they will make you eat this oil.
            So eat! As I was making a tour of one of the shops of our vast Motherland, I saw lean sausages. Interested in. I began to read the composition. The word "meat" is not observed in any form.
            And they say that they lived poorly in the Union. There, if sausage, then sausage. And now the stalls are bursting with palm oil products.
            1. Alexander Romanov
              Alexander Romanov April 21 2018 08: 01
              +4
              Quote: Gardamir
              As I was making a tour of one of the shops of our vast Motherland, I saw lean sausages. Interested in. I began to read the composition. The word "meat" is not observed in any form

              There are such Mikoyanovsky, for vigatari. So what?
              How many sausages were in which there was meat?
              Quote: Gardamir
              And they say that they lived poorly in the Union. There, if sausage, then sausage.

              Yes, three species, Ostankino, and some sort of ham, and sometimes it was possible to get it. Smoked was thrown out by May 9 new year.
              1. Stas157
                Stas157 April 21 2018 08: 22
                +6
                Quote: Alexander Romanov
                Yes, three species, Ostankino, and some sort of ham, and sometimes it was possible to get it. Smoked was thrown out by May 9 new year.

                Meat production in the RSFSR and in Russia (now) is approximately the same in volume. So why was there no sausage in the RSFSR? Maybe now they just have less steel, or maybe then they gave it to other republics ... The fact is that then the meat opportunities were no worse than now.
              2. Gardamir
                Gardamir April 21 2018 15: 44
                +3
                How many sausages were in which there was meat?
                Probably it is necessary to compare how many collective farms and meat-packing plants in the Union were and how many are now.
                I do not argue about the deficit in the Union, but the priorities are different, for example, we were the most read ones. And they were really afraid of us, and not just in TV shows.
            2. Separ DNR
              Separ DNR April 21 2018 09: 00
              +1
              Quote: Gardamir
              So eat!

              Imported.
              And if it is as the sibiralt offers (Oleg) ↑:
              We learn at home to make palm oil from oil, then the economy will rise
              , it will be ours, and much more.
              That will be satisfying ...
            3. Muvka
              Muvka April 21 2018 09: 10
              +6
              Quote: Gardamir
              So they will make you eat this oil.
              So eat! As I was making a tour of one of the shops of our vast Motherland, I saw lean sausages. Interested in. I began to read the composition. The word "meat" is not observed in any form.
              And they say that they lived poorly in the Union. There, if sausage, then sausage. And now the stalls are bursting with palm oil products.

              How strange. AT lean no sausages meat ... Who would have thought ...
              1. Golovan Jack
                Golovan Jack April 21 2018 09: 18
                +3
                Quote: Muvka
                There is no meat in lean sausages ...

                This is Putin's fault laughing
                Quote: Muvka
                Who would have thought...

                Do not offend Gardamir-A stop
                Genius and villainy, chemistry and life, Gardamir and "think" ... well, you understand wink
            4. Nyrobsky
              Nyrobsky April 21 2018 09: 28
              +7
              Quote: Gardamir
              And they say that they lived poorly in the Union. There, if sausage, then sausage. And now the stalls are bursting with palm oil products.

              I want to the USSR !!!
              1. Civilian
                Civilian April 21 2018 10: 40
                +6
                Quote: Nyrobsky
                I want to the USSR !!!

                We ply here. Telecom - 3 salaries, upholstered furniture, for the comfort of a booty - 2500 rubles (more than 10 average salaries), women's boots, winter, from Chuhoni - one hundred and fifty rubles!, "Shuza" is drop dead fashionable, made of Portuguese leather, for the author of this replica - 70re. Four-wheeled friend, it is useless to know the cost, still will not get it. A BOTTLE of a popular alcoholic drink - you have to work all day !!!, an 8-hour working day, then eat for half an hour!
                Something is not very "hot" recourse
                laughing
                1. Alexander Romanov
                  Alexander Romanov April 21 2018 11: 09
                  +5
                  Quote: Civilian
                  Pluses here. TV set - 3 salaries, upholstered furniture, for the comfort of a booty - 2500 rublef (more than 10 average salary), women's boots, winter, from Chuhoni - one hundred and fifty rublekof !, The "shoose" is drop dead fashionable, made of Portuguese leather, for the author of this replica - 70re

                  Hat mink 400 r, True, robbers can take it off laughing
                  Communists love to lay out prices for matches and all sorts of garbage, but the prices for Lada or vlog 9000 and 15 000 r, for some reason they do not spread
                  1. Civilian
                    Civilian April 21 2018 12: 20
                    +1
                    Quote: Alexander Romanov
                    Hat mink 400 r, True, robbers can take it off

                    laughing mine was stolen in restaurants. Absent for 2 minutes "on business." The wardrobe did not work ("the wardrobe did not work", "the wardrobe is closed" laughing ) in a restaurant! in winter! fellow
                    1. the lord
                      the lord April 23 2018 03: 47
                      0
                      Come on about the 88th year or later, remember, citizen mourner for a foreign holiday with NATO partners? So that was already the Gaidar USSR))))) Libration Chubayzetsydam- hello !!!!
                  2. not main
                    not main April 21 2018 22: 15
                    0
                    Quote: Alexander Romanov
                    Quote: Civilian
                    Pluses here. TV set - 3 salaries, upholstered furniture, for the comfort of a booty - 2500 rublef (more than 10 average salary), women's boots, winter, from Chuhoni - one hundred and fifty rublekof !, The "shoose" is drop dead fashionable, made of Portuguese leather, for the author of this replica - 70re

                    Hat mink 400 r, True, robbers can take it off laughing
                    Communists love to lay out prices for matches and all sorts of garbage, but the prices for Lada or vlog 9000 and 15 000 r, for some reason they do not spread

                    I wonder what year? In the late 70s, the VAZ-21011 cost 5300r, the M-412 5036r, and the GAZ-24 9180r!
                  3. Sergey ippon
                    Sergey ippon April 22 2018 15: 48
                    +1
                    it is not correct to compare - if the USSR were right now, then they would have cost a penny of a car just as well.
                    No one canceled scientific and technological progress, technology and mass character.
                    as if your bourgeoisie over a hill for a penny bought them at that time.
                  4. the lord
                    the lord April 23 2018 03: 45
                    +1
                    Come on, don’t. Prices for the "Lada" began at 5000 p. How not ashamed to lie! They wanted to do less, but Kosygin said, our cars were created to force the population to open the capsules. By that time, the people had learned to keep their savings not even in banks, but "under the pillow" (recall the "tormented" communists peasants who bought tanks and planes for personal savings for the Red Army). Moreover, these incomes were legitimate for the most part, people learned to save and save for retirement))))) And so they lived under the Communists. Not that right now, they get everything on credit))))
                2. Nyrobsky
                  Nyrobsky April 21 2018 12: 31
                  +6
                  Quote: Civilian
                  We ply here. Telecom - 3 salaries, upholstered furniture, for the convenience of sitting a booty - 2500 rubles (more than 10 average salaries) ..... etc. according to the text,
                  Sir, let's proceed from the fact that the minimum wage in Russia since May 18 will be a little higher than 11 thousand. I’ll open the “secret” now the mass of people is injecting a month for 10-20 thousand. So, transfer these crazy babosy to “plasmas”, refrigerators and sofas and after that you will have a third eye open, which will see that the level of purchasing power is now not better than then. In fairness, it must be admitted that the range of goods is now of course wider than in the USSR. Again, the trick is that now a significant part of the population sits on a credit needle, without paying which it is not the rightful owners of those "buns" that they have accumulated and are now being extinguished like rat pups from collectors, bailiffs and bandits, which was not the case before at all.
                  1. Alexander Romanov
                    Alexander Romanov April 21 2018 12: 34
                    +1
                    Quote: Nyrobsky
                    I’ll open the “secret” now a lot of people are injecting a month for 10-20 thousand

                    If a person works for 10 thousand rubles, then it suits him.
                    Although I don’t know such
                    And then, you post a picture where the amount is per family, and then you go over (I understand it’s profitable wink ) to a specific person.
                    Who bought cars with such income that there is nowhere to put a car in the yard?
                    1. Nyrobsky
                      Nyrobsky April 21 2018 12: 36
                      +4
                      Quote: Alexander Romanov
                      Quote: Nyrobsky
                      I’ll open the “secret” now a lot of people are injecting a month for 10-20 thousand

                      If a person works for 10 thousand rubles, then it suits him.
                      Although I don’t know such

                      Did you go to the people for a long time? This concept is not limited to the boundaries of large cities.
                      1. Alexander Romanov
                        Alexander Romanov April 21 2018 12: 57
                        0
                        Quote: Nyrobsky
                        Did you go to the people for a long time?

                        I'm not homeless
                        Quote: Nyrobsky
                        This concept is not limited to the boundaries of large cities.

                        Concepts, what are your concepts, if you talk about the mass of the people, do not confirm this with numbers.
                        If there is no profession, go to Yandex taxi and you will receive 70 000 per month and not whine.
                        If you don’t have your own car, rent it and take a taxi. There would be a desire to work
                  2. Civilian
                    Civilian April 21 2018 12: 58
                    +1
                    Quote: Nyrobsky
                    Sir, let's proceed from the fact that the minimum wage in Russia since May 18 will be a little higher than 11 thousand.

                    smile Sir, I proceed not from the minimum wage, but from the average wage in Russia.
                    2016 - 33876 p. ($ 549)
                    2017 - 36203 p. ($ 605) hi
                    “For the sake of justice” I want to note to you that my “third eye” is watching without closing. laughing , and therefore I agree with you, "whole and complete" wink But do not call in the USSR, I do not want to. (as I recall the back room of the meat department .. stand there, at the wall, how ... you wait for the butcher to deign to chop off the meat of ice cream for you, 3 re per kilo)
                    Every summer season I ask my neighbor (local) in the village - "buddy, what kind of .... do you go to work (60km back and forth), working for 10 hours and getting 18.000 rubles?"
                    He doesn’t say that he is keeping a “secret”. what
                    So, Dmitry. request A mystery covered in darkness. WHY "the mass of people work for 10-20 thousand"
                    1. Nyrobsky
                      Nyrobsky April 21 2018 14: 11
                      +3
                      Quote: Alexander Romanov
                      Quote: Nyrobsky
                      Did you go to the people for a long time?
                      I'm not homeless

                      YOU have strange associations - "PEOPLE = BUM". Of the Narusov-Sobchak family, will you probably be?
                      Quote: Alexander Romanov
                      Concepts, what are your concepts

                      There’s such a “concept" for you - Narcissism - property of character, concluded in narcissism and high self-esteem, in most cases not true This is bad “Shura”, work on yourself, because any fall on the career ladder or underestimation of your “genius” will lead you into a deep depression"
                      Quote: Alexander Romanov
                      If there is no profession, go to Yandex taxi and you will receive 70 a month and not whine. If you don’t have your own car, rent it and take a taxi. There would be a desire to work
                      Why is there such a conclusion that I “whine”? I have already served mine and am now in reserve. I don’t complain about my life - there are enough pensions. There is a car. I prefer to spend time on what I like - fishing and hunting, and not on killing babos, because I know for sure that they will not be needed in the next world. Because of my hobbies, I often visit the North and see how people live (for you homeless people) in the Russian outback. What the hell is Yandex Taxi - a child of asphalt and McDonald's?
                      1. Alexander Romanov
                        Alexander Romanov April 21 2018 14: 25
                        0
                        Quote: Nyrobsky
                        Of the Narusov-Sobchak family, will you probably be?

                        Well, yes, from them, from the communists
                3. the lord
                  the lord April 23 2018 03: 41
                  +1
                  I wanted to ask about telly; 3 salaries is how much? Of course, in the USSR there was upholstered furniture for 2500 r, but they were cheaper and much more. The same applies to women's boots. About 4-wheel - 5 thousand rubles was worth-quite commensurate with current prices, even to the plus of the Soviets. It seems to me, you worked in the USSR as a janitor or a very bad MNSom)))))
                  1. Civilian
                    Civilian April 23 2018 08: 16
                    0
                    Quote: znavel
                    I wanted to ask about telly; 3 salaries is how much? Of course, in the USSR there was upholstered furniture for 2500 r, but they were cheaper and much more. The same applies to women's boots. About 4-wheel - 5 thousand rubles was worth-quite commensurate with current prices, even to the plus of the Soviets. It seems to me, you worked in the USSR as a janitor or a very bad MNSom)))))

                    We divide the Rubin TV set by approx. 690 rubles by 3, and we get 230 rubles salary.
                    Upholstered furniture "Hyacinth", 2 armchairs, sofa, coffee table - 2500rub. x 2 (two, that's a big pull)
                    A set of cabinet furniture Slava (I don’t remember the number), in the common language "wall" - 2500 x 2
                    Winter women's boots on fur, made in Finland - 130 rubles (not 150 rubles, wife corrected)
                    A set of kitchen furniture "Nona" Romanian production - 600 rubles. Bought on a "postcard". Now attention is paid to the “postcard” in the lottery (lots were thrown) in production, 40 applicants for 2 sets. I translate - lots were drawn for the right to buy in the store at the state price.
                    Cloak Finnish ala Alan Delon for "real men" -220 rub.
                    Four-wheeled friend VAZ-21093 - 9046 rubles + 100 rubles pre-sale preparation of the store. Purchased on a card received by my mother in the trade union committee of workers after 8 years of waiting in line.
                    Jeans Levis Straus (such a scarecrow dog) - 110 checks in "Birch" on B. Akademicheskaya St., we multiply by two = 220 Soviet rubles, exactly my salary of the "janitor".
                    And you, the lordIt seems to me worked in the mines of Vorkuta? or fish hunted in the Far East? maybe right away we’ll sweep the great - are you an astronaut ?! oh .... I'm afraid to predict ... deputy unit commander for political work? How many three big stars "weighed" in ruble terms, plus the "for the position"? Do not tell methe lord?
                    1. Mordvin 3
                      Mordvin 3 April 23 2018 08: 26
                      0
                      Quote: Civilian
                      Upholstered furniture "Hyacinth", 2 armchairs, sofa, coffee table - 2500rub. x 2 (two, that's a big pull)

                      Hey don't whistle. Recently, this Hyacinth threw it from the grandmother in the trash, the price is from 512 to 518, depending on the belt.
                      1. Civilian
                        Civilian April 23 2018 08: 42
                        0
                        Fistula one more time, Vladimir, the last one. Two thousand five hundred rubles. Plus the same amount from above, I personally took it from the factory (Skhodnya, Moscow Region, if I don’t confuse). Two chairs, a sofa, a coffee table. You threw it away from your grandmother, but I still have it in my country house, and what is remarkable, the condition is “I believe buzz " wink
                        You probably meant the later cooperative Hyacinths (met such). I'm talking about Soviet factory furniture. The glory wall was made by the factory on Flotskaya St. (Moscow) smile
                    2. Civilian
                      Civilian April 23 2018 08: 35
                      0
                      Yes!! About vodka! I forgot about vodka! 10re- 0.5l. + coupon for receiving + two empty bottles + a hole in the left palm (I tried to get “out of turn” over the fence), got caught on my leg, lay flat ... with my hands on the empty glass container laughing So it is necessary to chitropopom bugs recourse
                      1. the lord
                        the lord April 23 2018 16: 27
                        0
                        But you nobly reminded it, means booze? Well, nobody has yet canceled evolution duck)))))
                      2. Sergey ippon
                        Sergey ippon April 24 2018 21: 29
                        0
                        not 10re-a 2.5 wheat,
                        electricity 2 kopecks, gas 12 kopecks, then rubas became.
                    3. the lord
                      the lord April 23 2018 16: 26
                      +1
                      And you know, the family budget was at 450 r per month. Apparently, they really exceeded your standard of living. It happens .... And cabinet furniture accounted for around 1500 p. But the cars we did not have for reluctance (they really considered it unnecessary and troublesome) in the cost of the Lada came from 5000 r. It is quite acceptable. Although color televisions - yes. those were worth the bite for the desire to watch, but in the end they bought, because save up was quick and efficient. But you do not pay the Jews and Armenians interest on bank loans. like right now))))) Happily revenge of the street and on))
          3. siberalt
            siberalt April 21 2018 07: 54
            +3
            And what if there is no other? Another bourgeoisie ate.belay And sausages are made from American soy (called food protein). We have a climate suitable for cultivating this culture, but according to the Constitution of the Russian Federation, there is no longer any climate for this land "belonging to the people". lol
            1. Pivot
              Pivot April 21 2018 08: 56
              +1
              Don't be silly, we export 50% of our soybeans. And in the main sausage they use wheat protein; it is three times cheaper than soy protein and also briquettes of chicken processing waste.
              1. siberalt
                siberalt April 21 2018 10: 31
                +3
                If we export 50% of our soybeans, then why import 43% of the stranger? lol
                1. Corporal Pupkin
                  Corporal Pupkin April 21 2018 13: 05
                  +1
                  this is called "GOODS EXCHANGE"! bully
              2. minus
                minus April 22 2018 09: 32
                0
                I have never observed wheat protein in production ... Well, except perhaps for the flour for the liver. Used soy and animal textures and isolates. Very often emulsion of pork skin. And everywhere chicken meat boning meat + chemistry 'taste of beef' and 'taste of pork'. Recently, a Moscow technologist again came. The use of chicken has grown 2 times ....
            2. Civilian
              Civilian April 21 2018 10: 24
              0
              Quote: siberalt
              And sausages are made from American soy (called food protein).

              Soya began to be loaded into sausages even during the USSR (hence jokes such as “make toilet paper, remember?). The “Doctoral” of the 70th year was very different from the “Doctoral" of the 85th.
              The bourgeoisie has a very wide assortment, OT and higher. This "OT" will be worse than ours wink
              The "Bavarian" sausages eaten directly in the "Bavaria", to taste, did not differ from home. lol
        2. Genry
          Genry April 21 2018 10: 22
          0
          Quote: siberalt
          We learn at home to make palm oil from oil, and then the economy will rise.

          This is what to learn? In the USSR, they made a combined ... In the army and ... they were widely fed. Very high melting point and when washing, from hot water, hands got burns.
      4. samarin1969
        samarin1969 April 21 2018 07: 25
        +5
        Quote: Vard
        For an ordinary person, an indicator of the state of the financial system of Russia ... is the dollar exchange rate ... and what you yourself see with it ...

        The army of proud owners of "economic" diplomas will not agree with you ... - but you are absolutely right. hi
        1. Vitaly Anisimov
          Vitaly Anisimov April 21 2018 07: 34
          +1
          There is nothing special to brag about in the economy, but as Obama and our liberals “dreamed”, it is stable and not torn to shreds .. Thanks to the sanctions!
          1. Gardamir
            Gardamir April 21 2018 07: 54
            +8
            our liberals
            I would like to stop using this word. Because who is called liberals depends on the context and how a person treats those who are called liberals. But who they call liberals is completely incomprehensible.
            1. Vitaly Anisimov
              Vitaly Anisimov April 21 2018 07: 59
              0
              Quote: Gardamir
              our liberals
              I would like to stop using this word. Because who is called liberals depends on the context and how a person treats those who are called liberals. But who they call liberals is completely incomprehensible.

              You know how to fool your head with your ornate reasoning .. hehe There are liberals, and there are liberals .. What do you think of yourself? laughing
              1. Gardamir
                Gardamir April 21 2018 08: 07
                +4
                How do you relate to yourself?
                And I sing a song, If my native country lived and there are no other worries ...
                1. Golovan Jack
                  Golovan Jack April 21 2018 08: 12
                  +3
                  Quote: Gardamir
                  I sing a song

                  Yeah, yeah ... Your songs have long been known to everyone. Singer, damn ... mouth negative
                2. Vitaly Anisimov
                  Vitaly Anisimov April 21 2018 08: 16
                  +2
                  Quote: Gardamir
                  How do you relate to yourself?
                  And I sing a song, If my native country lived and there are no other worries ...

                  Good song, straight to the soul catches .. Oh, there were times and there were few whiners all in the Kolyma forest fell .. hehe
                  I think in the topic for some, "everything is lost and pensioners are starving" ..
            2. Genry
              Genry April 21 2018 10: 25
              +1
              Quote: Gardamir
              But who they call liberals is completely incomprehensible.

              They call pseudo-liberals who want not freedom but slavery (economic and political) of the people.
      5. populist
        populist April 21 2018 07: 45
        +5
        Vard
        For an ordinary person, an indicator of the state of the financial system of Russia ... this is the dollar

        Naive fool Russian population believes the new old (or old new) president crying
        The population doesn’t care at all what
        That is, a 0,5% yield is a “planned order”? But what about the president’s message, in which he set ambitious goals for the growth of the Russian economy at a pace that should be ahead of the global average.

        As they say ... Then you yourself know recourse
      6. tolmachiev51
        tolmachiev51 April 21 2018 17: 50
        0
        for an ordinary person, the “dollar exchange rate” is a scam, for it was stupidly tied to the price of oil, the GDP from it is 27% —where else?
    2. tchoni
      tchoni April 21 2018 08: 36
      +9
      Quote: oleg-gr
      Kudrin’s precepts are keeping the economic part of the current government. Everyone is trying to confirm that the Russian Federation is a big "oil" power. Bananas will grow, it will be a "banana".

      That's right. The budget includes oil at 47 bucks. It costs 77. oil industry - half of the budget revenue. Purely in theory, the budget surplus should be 15-20%. We have 0.5 !!! Where is the money, Zin !? And there they are, in the fund of the "national treasure" (or the "braking of the Russian economy" !?), which is lying in American securities in America))) Why not in our high-tech industries !? - It would be nice to ask the guarantor)
      1. Genry
        Genry April 21 2018 10: 30
        +1
        Quote: tchoni
        Why not in our high-tech industries !? - It would be nice to ask the guarantor)

        And you contact SportLoto ... They, too, as a guarantor, are related to the economy.
        And do not forget yourself when choosing to parliament.
    3. Dreamboat
      Dreamboat April 21 2018 13: 30
      0
      The author is an "ignoramus" or an intentional alarmist telling fools that the budget surplus and the economic growth rate are the same .... wassat
      A budget is just a balance of income and expenses. With a tight budget, there can be growth and vice versa!
  2. rotmistr60
    rotmistr60 April 21 2018 07: 14
    +3
    We must proceed from the fact that under the current government, a surplus of even 0,5% is much better than a deficit.
    1. Separ DNR
      Separ DNR April 21 2018 07: 21
      +5
      Quote: rotmistr60
      under the current government

      Tell me, but what about the new composition of the government, already “overthrown”, having won the presidential candidate?
      And will there be any qualitative changes in its composition?
      1. 210ox
        210ox April 21 2018 07: 24
        +6
        And why did you decide that the Cabinet will be changed? No.
        Quote: Separ DNR
        Quote: rotmistr60
        under the current government

        Tell me, but what about the new composition of the government, already “overthrown”, having won the presidential candidate?
        And will there be any qualitative changes in its composition?
        1. Separ DNR
          Separ DNR April 21 2018 07: 30
          +7
          Quote: 210ox
          And why did you decide that the Cabinet will be changed?

          I do not decide for the Russians, but ask a question yes . It seems to me reasonable, since significant part of the population there is some dissatisfaction with the somewhat "comprador-liberal" (I will call it that) course of a number of members of the government.
          1. Alexander Romanov
            Alexander Romanov April 21 2018 07: 40
            0
            Quote: Separ DNR
            I do not decide for the Russians, but ask a question

            Who are you asking the question to?
            1. Separ DNR
              Separ DNR April 21 2018 07: 42
              +2
              Quote: Alexander Romanov
              Who are you asking the question to?

              Commenting on the actions of the current government, the user rotmistr60 (Gennady).
              1. Alexander Romanov
                Alexander Romanov April 21 2018 07: 45
                0
                Quote: Separ DNR
                rotmistr60 (Gennady).

                Who is he? How did he know that they would not let him into the Kremlin for a cannon shot.
                1. Separ DNR
                  Separ DNR April 21 2018 07: 53
                  +6
                  Quote: Alexander Romanov
                  Who is he? How did he know that they would not let him into the Kremlin for a cannon shot.

                  That is, both he and you (obviously), living in Russia, are in a complete information vacuum?
                  It’s excusable to me. But the Russians, at least a little could be aware of political, economic and other processes.
                  1. Alexander Romanov
                    Alexander Romanov April 21 2018 07: 56
                    +1
                    Quote: Separ DNR
                    That is, both he and you (obviously), living in Russia, are in a complete information vacuum?

                    Announce, then we'll find out.
                    Quote: Separ DNR
                    But the Russians, at least a little could be aware of political, economic and other processes.

                    Judging by the comments, economists do not smell here. And he wrote the article, which is also far from the economy
          2. samarin1969
            samarin1969 April 21 2018 07: 44
            +8
            [quote = Separ DNR] [quote = 210quq] .... It seems quite reasonable to me, since significant part of the population there is some dissatisfaction with the somewhat "comprador-liberal" (I will call it that) course of a number of members of the government. [/ quote]

            And who cares about "a significant part of the population" ...
            And generally speaking..
            “This is my very long-standing, good friend, close friend. I understand his position on many issues, moreover, he did a lot to strengthen the country's economy”
      2. DEDPIHTO
        DEDPIHTO April 21 2018 07: 27
        +8
        There is no time to “make up” the new government, because the old president is busy transferring affairs to the “new” president.
      3. Tatar 174
        Tatar 174 April 21 2018 07: 44
        +3
        It seems obvious that the current government was frightened by Amero-European sanctions. Well, how else to explain this stomp on the spot near zero? How much more will we go around? What, wait another month?
      4. Gardamir
        Gardamir April 21 2018 07: 57
        +5
        And will there be any qualitative changes in its composition?
        as far as I remember, he transferred past ministers to other posts, and made their deputies ministers. We'll wait and see, or they hint that Kudrin will be the head of the government.
      5. vovanpain
        vovanpain April 21 2018 07: 58
        +2
        Quote: Separ DNR
        Tell me, what about the new composition of the government, already “overwhelmed,” having won the presidential candidate? And will there be any qualitative changes in its composition?

        Sergei hi We will not see Vanga wondering whether or not we’ll guess after the inauguration and change both cutting and sewing. Although here vanguards and all the experts on the site, whether they meet with Putin every day and he reports to them. laughing
    2. Vard
      Vard April 21 2018 07: 21
      +1
      It's like in a village ... if it rains (oil prices go up) we will be with the crop (we will be in surplus) ...
    3. Stas157
      Stas157 April 21 2018 08: 09
      +6
      Quote: rotmistr60
      We must proceed from the fact that under the current government, a surplus of even 0,5% is much better than a deficit.

      And can it come from how to see the GDP growth of leading countries and set a bar for yourself in order to enter this circle? Putin himself already promised this to us in 2012 when he was elected president. But, that deadline has passed, and his promises, for Russia, to enter the top five most developed countries, it is no longer decent to even remember!
  3. Korsar4
    Korsar4 April 21 2018 07: 24
    +4
    Are there grounds for plans?
    Classic - "it was smooth on paper." Which industry do not take.
  4. Storming the Washington
    Storming the Washington April 21 2018 07: 26
    +3
    to have a budget without deficits you just have to live within our means smile simple truths need to be explained to these economic felt boots
    1. Vard
      Vard April 21 2018 07: 37
      +8
      A small example ... 3.2 trillion rubles were spent on saving troubled banks (well, frankly, the money was stolen from them ... 3 is either 200 rubles for each resident of our country, or if we say to pay to pensioners, it will be 000 rubles per person ... and after that you say that we have a poor country?
      1. Separ DNR
        Separ DNR April 21 2018 07: 40
        +9
        Quote: Vard
        and after that you say that we have a poor country?

        It was you who only touched the banking sector ...
        And if you "reveal" the entire scale of the country's robbery at the state level?
        1. Vadim237
          Vadim237 April 21 2018 12: 51
          +2
          In Russia, the lion's share of the local budget is stolen: regional, provincial, district rural.
      2. Storming the Washington
        Storming the Washington April 21 2018 07: 45
        +8
        we say that we have a rich country but poor officials laughing the muzzles can’t get enough in any way; they don’t fit in the television box and you have to choose more distant foreshortenings on protocol shootings
    2. Gardamir
      Gardamir April 21 2018 07: 58
      +8
      just live within our means
      I agree. But I know the method is even easier, stop dropping billions to America.
      1. Golovan Jack
        Golovan Jack April 21 2018 08: 08
        0
        Quote: Gardamir
        I know the method is even easier

        I know even easier, you yourself let slip, see:
        Quote: Gardamir
        ... stop driving ...

        ... so stop it already wink
        1. Goodmen
          Goodmen April 21 2018 10: 15
          +10
          Quote: Golovan Jack
          ... so stop it already

          Scatter, Troll. Not a commentator, but some kind of war. Nothing to say in the case? Constant trolling from you.
  5. dvina71
    dvina71 April 21 2018 07: 31
    +7
    The author of the article mixed everything .. and the budget and surplus and somehow the gross product .. As a result, shit turned on the fan ..
    I explain to him .. it's about the budget. This year, his surplus is planned for a certain amount, which is equal to half a percent of GDP. Siluanov did not say a word about the growth of the economy and the notorious GDP. This is not his concern, he is the head of the Ministry of Finance .. his concern is the budget, how to fill it and how to spend it. The ministry with a telling name is responsible for economic growth. And the Central Bank.
    1. Alexander Romanov
      Alexander Romanov April 21 2018 07: 41
      +4
      Quote: dvina71
      The author of the article mixed everything .. and the budget and surplus and somehow the gross product .. As a result, shit turned on the fan ..

      At least one person paid attention to this laughing
    2. Muvka
      Muvka April 21 2018 09: 13
      +1
      I also did not understand how the size of economic growth and the size of the budget are related ...
  6. Iline
    Iline April 21 2018 07: 33
    +4
    It seems that in our government there are not experts who understand where to go and what to do for this, but vanguard predictors.
    With them, for sure, the country will not come out of the hole.
    1. Alexander Romanov
      Alexander Romanov April 21 2018 07: 42
      +4
      Quote: Iline
      It seems that in our government there are not experts who understand where to go and what to do for this, but vanguard predictors.

      It seems that the article was written by a person with the formation of 8 classes.
    2. Gardamir
      Gardamir April 21 2018 08: 00
      +5
      foretelling predictors.

      My grandmother said, you need to put the money in the sock, go to the intersection and whisper the money to dig.
      Mr. Minister of Finance, do you have other proposals for filling the budget?
    3. Vadim237
      Vadim237 April 21 2018 12: 53
      0
      So what are you sitting, you are our specialist in macroeconomics, quickly save the situation - in the White House, in the government.
  7. Horseman without a head
    Horseman without a head April 21 2018 07: 34
    +17
    Zero all
    That yes
  8. Professor
    Professor April 21 2018 07: 39
    +4
    This year we, if the prices remain the same, will come up with a surplus, perhaps even 0,5% of GDP will be a budget surplus.

    You will not envy Siluanov. Trump decided that the price of oil is too high and will “drop” it.
    http://www.newsru.co.il/finance/20apr2018/oil_109
    z.html

    On Friday, 20 April, US President Donald Trump criticized the Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC) for too high a price. He claims that the organization artificially inflates oil prices.

    "With record amounts of oil in every place, including fully loaded ships at sea, oil prices are artificially high. This is bad and unacceptable," the president wrote on his Twitter account.

    The Reuters news agency notes that after the publication of Trump's critical post, oil prices fell by 52 cents. At the moment, a barrel of Brent crude costs 73,26 dollars.
    1. Korsar4
      Korsar4 April 21 2018 07: 44
      0
      This we have already passed. And more than once.
    2. Vard
      Vard April 21 2018 07: 45
      +1
      The devil is in the details ... watch your hands .... the trick is that in Russia, the export of oil and petroleum products is actually equal in volume ... and the difference continues to increase ...
    3. PN
      PN April 21 2018 07: 50
      +2
      Well, he will not be able to drop it either, for then his homegrown shale oil will not be recouped. Stick about 2 ends.
      1. Professor
        Professor April 21 2018 08: 13
        +6
        Quote: PN
        Well, he will not be able to drop it either, for then his homegrown shale oil will not be recouped. Stick about 2 ends.

        Russian television has repeatedly buried shale oil, and Putin has generally promised the collapse of the global economy at a barrel price below $ 80. Fortune tellers sat in a puddle. Trump, if desired, can greatly drop oil. The US economy will benefit from cheap energy. Personally, I am for oil at $ 300. Expensive oil is the engine of progress.
        1. PN
          PN April 21 2018 08: 17
          +2
          How many mothballed shale wells are there today? Here you have the trotter Trump.
          1. Professor
            Professor April 21 2018 08: 34
            +1
            Quote: PN
            How many mothballed shale wells are there today? Here you have the trotter Trump.

            And at least 200%. Slate is good in that conservation and de-preservation are very simple. Almost like "shut the tap" and "opened the tap."

            For your information:
            In 2017, the United States imported approximately 10,1 million barrels per day of oil from approximately 84 countries. Oil includes crude oil, gas condensate, petroleum products such as gasoline and diesel, and biofuels, including ethanol and biodiesel. About 79% of gross oil imports were crude oil.

            In 2017, the United States exported about 6,3 million barrels per day to 180 countries. About 82% of total oil exports are oil products. As a result, net imports amounted to about 3,7 million barrels per day.

            The five leading US oil countries in the 2017 year are Canada, Saudi Arabia, Mexico, Venezuela and Iraq.

            https://www.eia.gov/tools/faqs/faq.php?id=727&
            ;
            ; t = 6

            PS
            In July 2015, the US strategic oil reserve was 692 million barrels, commercial oil reserves - 465,8 million barrels.
            1. PN
              PN April 21 2018 08: 41
              0
              A business is invested in order to have a return, not a conservation.
            2. Muvka
              Muvka April 21 2018 09: 15
              0
              Where did you read such crap about conservation?
              1. PN
                PN April 21 2018 09: 17
                +1
                You’ll crap my friend in the toilet on the spray bottle.
            3. the lord
              the lord April 23 2018 04: 01
              0
              Proffessor, let’s lower yourself in the rank ... to "NATO graduate student")))))). Somehow your comments do not correspond to such a high and honorary title)))))
        2. Vadim237
          Vadim237 April 21 2018 08: 35
          0
          "Oil for $ 300." This is only when the war with Iran begins, and there the entire Persian Gulf will be blocked by mines.
    4. Mountain shooter
      Mountain shooter April 21 2018 09: 20
      +1
      Professor, oil has already returned to maximum (almost). Twitter from Trump must be taken away. And then it can greatly "swing the boat" wassat at the moment 73.46! This is almost 4's summer ceiling. So Siluanov is not so wrong ... laughing
      1. Professor
        Professor April 21 2018 11: 32
        +2
        Quote: Mountain Shooter
        Professor, oil has already returned to maximum (almost). Twitter from Trump must be taken away. And then it can greatly "swing the boat" wassat at the moment 73.46! This is almost 4's summer ceiling. So Siluanov is not so wrong ... laughing

        Siluanov can only pray to the god of oil production and ask for a high oil price since Siluanov does not solve anything. But Trump can make the price of oil what he wants. Remember the barrel at $ 8? wink The following vendors will be very pleased:
        China: US $ 116.2 billion (17.3% of total crude oil imports)
        United States: $ 108.1 billion (16.1%)
        India: $ 60.9 billion (9.1%)
        Japan: $ 50.8 billion (7.6%)
        South Korea: $ 44.2 billion (6.6%)
        Netherlands: $ 29.3 billion (4.4%)
        Germany: $ 28.7 billion (4.3%)
        Italy: $ 18.9 billion (2.8%)
        Spain: $ 18.7 billion (2.8%)
        France: $ 17.9 billion (2.7%)
        Thailand: $ 15.2 billion (2.3%)
        Singapore: $ 15.1 billion (2.2%)
        United Kingdom: $ 14.3 billion (2.1%)
        Taiwan: $ 12.9 billion (1.9%)
        Belgium: $ 11.5 billion (1.7%)
        The listed 15 countries purchased 83.8% of all crude oil imports in 2016 (by value).
        1. the lord
          the lord April 23 2018 04: 03
          0
          Professor, there are simply no words ... you are awarded the honorary title - entrant))))))
  9. Grim Reaper
    Grim Reaper April 21 2018 07: 46
    +3
    Gogi, how many will be two plus two?
    Davyat, teacher!
    Sit down, two.
    Archie, how much will be two plus two?
    Shast, uchitel!
    Yes, somewhere like that, five, six. But not nine!
    winked
  10. Altona
    Altona April 21 2018 07: 52
    +7

    What can I say about Siluanov? The pig was documenting. laughing laughing
  11. Stoler
    Stoler April 21 2018 07: 53
    0
    I love oil !!! love And Gas !!!! love laughing laughing laughing
  12. Herculesic
    Herculesic April 21 2018 08: 02
    +5
    This government should almost completely (except the Minister of Defense) leave for Novaya Zemlya, about 15 years ago, with confiscation, for the deliberate collapse of the Russian economy, that is, for anti-Russian activities in the interests of the United States, NATO, and countries that clearly want the collapse of our state!
    1. Alexander Romanov
      Alexander Romanov April 21 2018 08: 51
      0
      Quote: Herkulesich
      for the deliberate collapse of the Russian economy,

      Russian economy torn to shreds Obama
      Two of a Kind wassat
      1. Herculesic
        Herculesic April 21 2018 09: 37
        +2
        We have real economic growth, probably under 30 percent, there is no unemployment from the word at all, salaries are not delayed, or have they stopped paying in parts? ??? sad
  13. The comment was deleted.
  14. igorbrsv
    igorbrsv April 21 2018 08: 10
    +5
    Quote "0.5% of GDP surplus budget." I understand that this is not an increase in GDP, and 0.5% of GDP is not expended from the planned cost. And where is the growth of GDP? Or I didn’t understand the meaning correctly, or someone missed it
  15. Nix1986
    Nix1986 April 21 2018 08: 11
    +4
    If it weren’t for oil and gas, then we would have Ukraine N2 with its Donbass in the North Caucasus and there would be not so many reasons for jokes about Ukrainians.
  16. igorbrsv
    igorbrsv April 21 2018 08: 12
    +4
    A budget surplus is one thing, and GDP growth is another.
  17. Livonetc
    Livonetc April 21 2018 08: 20
    +5
    Budget surplus and GDP growth are not related phenomena.
  18. Vitaly Anisimov
    Vitaly Anisimov April 21 2018 08: 24
    +4
    Here's another for whiners and all-mutters ..
    Our economy is stable, in spite of all the attempts of the West and internal liberals to loosen it and catch fish in troubled waters .. Your time has ended, gentlemen!
  19. impostor
    impostor April 21 2018 08: 37
    +2
    Gaydarovsky’s extortionist with a salary of almost 10 million. I went to the USA to report to the finance minister there how painfully the sanctions hit the Russian economy.
  20. Oleg Kozlov
    Oleg Kozlov April 21 2018 08: 38
    +4
    An open betrayal of the interests of the country shines through from all the cracks. And we still want something other than poverty and slavery, we want to get from the current masters from the government?
  21. Mountain shooter
    Mountain shooter April 21 2018 09: 08
    +2
    The author, but how are the BUDGET and GDP GROWTH related? What nonsense is this article? A surplus budget is GOOD. But this has nothing to do with economic growth. laughing Rather, it helps him (growth).
    1. siberalt
      siberalt April 21 2018 11: 01
      0
      A budget with surplus is worse than a budget with deficit, as well as surpluses are worse than shortages. The disadvantage is when they have already stolen, and the excess - when they planned to steal the hidden. lol
  22. APASUS
    APASUS April 21 2018 09: 15
    +4
    Is it a vicious circle?
    They want to get economic growth without investing money in it, all in storage.
    It's time to drive you Mr. Siluanov!
  23. megadeth
    megadeth April 21 2018 09: 51
    +4
    Having said A, we must say B, and not otherwise. In the meantime, at the moment, our government is slightly pregnant with economic reforms.
    And our indecision begins to come out to us sideways!
    Foreign policy is a continuation of the domestic, and here we sign our own impotence and impotence. And the fact that the United States is dipping us in the mud in Syria is the result of unresolved internal problems. Surely Trump knows how US henchmen manage our economy and how they can block our oxygen if necessary.
    For some reason, only our authorities do not know about this, trying to protect our people from unrest and social upheaval. And while they manage to do this: inflation is falling before our eyes, though the income of the population is falling even faster. And a targeted attack on the ruble, is designed to increase inflation. And since the incomes of citizens are miserable, its surge is quite capable of leading to a social explosion.
    A paradoxical situation has developed, the welfare of our citizens directly depends on the economy, and it is ruled by a host of “Skripals”! And it seems that no “Beginner” can etch them. They will survive even with a nuclear strike, like the red-haired cockroaches “Prusak”.
    After Russia annexed Crimea, the Anglo-Saxon world signed a verdict for us. And the attempts of Nebenzi and our military to substantiate all the falsehood of the accusations of chem. attack, just pointless. The Yankees have long said that we do not care about your intentions, we care about your potential. And also the willingness to apply it.

    And Putin tried to keep the world from sliding into a nuclear Apocalypse, in his already-famous speech to the Federal Assembly.
    But as always was not heard! It seems that the situation has begun to get out of control and little is already dependent on us.
    Let me remind you that the keys to both Syria and Ukraine and the sanctions lie inside our economy. And until we clean up the economic clearing from the American managers: Kudrin, Siluanov, Nabiullina and Gref, then they will wipe our feet about us.
    And if we wait for the inauguration, after the World Cup, then when the cancer on the mountain whistles, then no reforms may be needed. Because we all die out like mammoths!

    Ivan Zabelin, specially for RIAP "APRAL"
  24. kefan
    kefan April 21 2018 10: 00
    +2
    As we sat on the oil needle, we continue to sit on it, but this is a separate song about the economic block of the Government.
  25. kunstkammer
    kunstkammer April 21 2018 10: 16
    +1
    Siluanov:
    ... we will leave with a surplus ... We will replenish our National Wealth Fund ..... Everything is going as planned.

    Do not you understand? This is a direct report to their curators in the West: Do not worry! All that we earn is immediately sent to you.
    It is not for nothing that he is now in America and reassuring his curators ... Everything is going according to plan!

    Py.Sy. Sorry, but I can’t resist! Our rulers and Western elites are one gang-watering can.
    In many television and radio programs, our different politicians sarcastically notice: on the sidelines of meetings with Western politicians, they look away and assure that each of them personally “loves” Russia and is against sanctions ... but they twist their arms. Here they say the real situation in the world! They are all hypocrites.
    I watched a movie yesterday with which the American establishment treats its audience: everything is exactly the opposite - they are Russian acting ministers, businessmen and politicians (I emphasize - not opposition) when they come to America, they crawl on their knees and claim that they love it so much .. they love American freedom so much ... but they’re constantly twisting their arms in Russia! The abomination and unprincipledness of Russian is just off scale!
    That is why the Anglo-Saxons have such confidence that a little more pressure and the Russian authorities will crawl to their feet in saliva and snot of remorse! And the American people are also sure of this.
  26. naidas
    naidas April 21 2018 10: 32
    +4
    According to Anton Siluanov:
    macroeconomic indicators show a good level and growth, as an example, the head of the Central Bank of Russia Elvira Nabiullina in 2017 increased her income by 25% to 33,8 million rubles.
    But otherwise you are holding on there.
  27. The comment was deleted.
  28. kunstkammer
    kunstkammer April 21 2018 11: 03
    0
    Quote: Berkut24
    Author, what do you smoke ???
    ... the government lives within its means. And thank God, it will not be necessary to borrow money! Rejoice

    Oh, I’m so glad ... so glad that I don’t have to ... It’s time, it’s time to start investing Russian money in America again, well, to destroy the Russian economy by them.
    Yes, in Russia, all the chiki-farts! The government lives well, the roads are in order, the children in the entertainment centers do not burn, the pensioners do not breathe anymore ... Health and circumcision are at the highest level!
    The main thing is not a deficit, otherwise you would have to borrow from a native adversary ... and he would not be satisfied with the "greatest managers of our time"!
  29. Comrade Kim
    Comrade Kim April 21 2018 11: 35
    +2
    "Back porch" Anton Siluanov is still open (C 5:27).
  30. tochila
    tochila April 21 2018 12: 08
    +1
    A bottle of vodka and a can of red caviar in Russia cost about the same !!! But everyone knows where the delicacy is, and where the essentials !!!!))))
  31. AlexanderVP
    AlexanderVP April 21 2018 12: 28
    0
    Uhh. I think that it is not so much what the surplus or even the deficit is, how much is the size of the budget itself. If it grows, then everything is OK.
    1. Vadim237
      Vadim237 April 21 2018 12: 59
      0
      Well, here it is, the budget for 2018, the price of 43 dollars per barrel - all that is higher, from one dollar 116 billion rubles plus.
  32. Hiw
    Hiw April 21 2018 12: 29
    +2
    All in all, you just need to transfer the profit from carbohydrates not to private gaskets, but directly to the budget of the country, otherwise only 30% of the profit of oil and gas falls into the budget and 85-90% in the new
    1. Vadim237
      Vadim237 April 21 2018 13: 04
      0
      There are no such long pipelines and other things in Novogiya - the maintenance of all this costs the companies a pretty penny.
      1. Gene Concrete
        Gene Concrete April 21 2018 13: 49
        +3
        Pipeline transportation is the cheapest of the existing, this time.
        The cost of Nervous oil produced on the shelf is 2 times (15 against $ 30) higher than that produced in the North of Russia, these are two.
        Arabs generally ship oil across half the world, which does not prevent them from earning superprofits.
        And the fourth point is the question: can a "patriot" justify, encouraging the sacking of his country rightfully consider himself a patriot?
        1. Vadim237
          Vadim237 April 21 2018 14: 47
          0
          "Pipeline transportation is the cheapest available." So you do not need to maintain the entire system. For Arabs, oil under pressure does not go deep into the most unpretentious production, which means costs are lower. And to compare Norway and Arabia with Russia is, to put it mildly, stupid - the dimensions are significant in everything.
  33. lis-ik
    lis-ik April 21 2018 14: 33
    +3
    Then I recently read about Sberbank that 51 shares belong to the state, and the remaining 49 are owned by England and the USA, so actually no sanctions are needed. Nabiulina and Gref tried to hit harder than the West, even if it was a lie about stocks, then their efforts were not in vain, more than 500 banks were launched around the world, and especially they managed with an interest rate, production was simply reset.
    1. Vadim237
      Vadim237 April 21 2018 14: 49
      0
      49 are all foreign and domestic - private shareholders.
      1. lis-ik
        lis-ik April 21 2018 15: 02
        +1
        Quote: Vadim237
        49 are all foreign and domestic - private shareholders.

        Anyway, you see, for the main bank of the country this is not a normal situation, in fact, management from outside. And if this is state policy, then it’s still sadder.
        1. Vadim237
          Vadim237 April 21 2018 18: 08
          0
          Sberbank is governed by the state.
          1. Evgeny Strygin
            Evgeny Strygin April 21 2018 20: 05
            +4
            the state remains to find out who leads
  34. kunstkammer
    kunstkammer April 21 2018 20: 04
    +1
    Quote: megadeth
    we will clear the economic clearing from the American managers: Kudrin, Siluanov, Nabiullina and Gref

    Who has not heard, I will tell a semi-fresh joke:
    Trump gathers an office and raises the question:
    - It is urgent to find another 4,5 billion dollars to fight this insolent Putin!
    They shyly answer:
    - Mr. President, such funds are not planned in the budget!
    - Yes? Well then print bonds for that amount. We will borrow this money from the Russians.
    Py.Sy. I would like to ask an actual question from this film:
    And who is this stupid person?

    A worthy change by Naibullina is growing ...
  35. Evgeny Strygin
    Evgeny Strygin April 21 2018 20: 04
    +1
    why so much surprise in the comments? we were an appendage and did not do anything real to change this - it would be strange if it was different
  36. manne mann
    manne mann April 21 2018 20: 18
    +3
    The president has not been able to determine financial policy for 5 years, he has reduced the military budget, the Ministry for Emergencies destroyed the huckster of bunches, the whole country noticed, but not in the Kremlin!
    1. Vadim237
      Vadim237 April 21 2018 21: 08
      0
      "The military budget has reduced." - He is already bloated 19 trillion to 25 years old, and the Ministry of Emergencies - nothing, such fires as in 2010 will begin - they will immediately return everyone.
  37. Indifferent
    Indifferent April 21 2018 20: 39
    +3
    Siluanov, as I understand it, has just returned from the United States. Received instructions! Now for the job! If he remains in the government, I will be glad that I did not vote for Putin! And if Medvedev stays, I’ll go to the church to light a candle for our unhappy people!
  38. Comrade Kim
    Comrade Kim April 22 2018 00: 43
    +2
    Quote: Vadim237
    all that is higher, with one dollar 116 billion plus.

    And this plus Sahibzadovna will tumble into us treasuries (+ to those $ 105 yards that she swelled in there).
    Instead of lending at low% of domestic industry and agriculture.
    Relative Central Bank prefers to lend to the American economy at 1,5% per annum!
    He (our Central Bank) then takes the filthy $ from America at 5-6% per annum, then he gives the rubles for 10-12% to commercial banks that lend to the real sector at 15-17%.

    This is just a business - nothing personal.
    1. shirkoled
      shirkoled April 22 2018 20: 10
      0
      !!!!!!
      !!!!!!!!!!!
  39. hotrod
    hotrod April 22 2018 07: 03
    +2
    The author confuses economic growth and budget deficit (surplus). This is such an illiteracy that there are simply no words. But I wrote an article! I thought the author in the first comments will point to the bout, but no, the commentators are also in a faint ..
  40. Mihail55
    Mihail55 April 22 2018 15: 10
    +1
    On TV, I see, to put it mildly, the “faces” of Kudrin and Siluanov ... honestly, I want to throw the monitor out of the balcony. But is it worth it? Why are they dragged to the studio with enviable regularity? Our media are the most TRUE in the world ????
    1. shirkoled
      shirkoled April 22 2018 20: 04
      0
      Michael! Our media are the most corrupt in the world, everyone exists with money from Soros !!!
  41. serge siberian
    serge siberian April 22 2018 15: 35
    +2
    For an ordinary person, this means minus 50% of the purchasing power of his salary !!! And for alligarchs, plus 100% of profit per month !!! But their profit is from the pocket of an ordinary person and the state budget. As usual, the rich will grow rich and the poor will turn in beggars!
  42. shirkoled
    shirkoled April 22 2018 20: 01
    0
    And these gentlemen from the Ministry of Finance put with the device on the decrees of the president !!! They are on their own, and the country itself! What are the salaries of these chosen ones? What are the benefits of their relatives? After all, they crushed everything for themselves, looking at them, regional ministers also live !!! And the ministers divorced with a light arm EBN, like a flea in a dog !!!
  43. Mordvin 3
    Mordvin 3 April 23 2018 08: 50
    0
    Civilian,
    I don’t know what year you bought, but I threw out a sofa with armchairs of the seventies. I do not remember exactly. And the vodka was then on 3,62. laughing And you are talking about Gorbachev’s times.