Military Review

Automatics of the wrong system? .. About the problems of the French frigate when striking Syria

53
The French Navy faced serious problems when launching MdCN cruise missiles from frigates across Syria - only one of the 3 ships could strike, reports Look with reference to l'Opinion.


Automatics of the wrong system? .. About the problems of the French frigate when striking Syria


According to the report, “the frigates Aquitaine, Auvergne and Languedoc were deployed to the eastern Mediterranean, but only the last ship that launched three missiles fired at the site, although it was supposed to release more warheads.”

The choice fell on the frigate "Languedoc" only because the main version ("Aquitaine") and its understudy ("Auvergne") could not launch their missiles.



The publication said that it was originally intended to produce two volleys of three MdCN missiles each. But by the time the first volley was completed, the temporary “window” for shooting was over. Therefore, the second volley did not take place.

According to experts, “the compactness and automation of frigates of the FREMM type, which led to a crew reduction to 130 people, played a cruel joke on ships”, putting the combat mission at risk.
Photos used:
frame from video
53 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. Meckajiuhe
    Meckajiuhe April 19 2018 12: 14
    +12
    It would be better if they cooked each other. They could have grown smarter.
    1. Chertt
      Chertt April 19 2018 12: 19
      +9
      So the British with the submarine, also some kind of troubled story. Either they came to the wrong place, or they couldn’t shoot)))
      1. bazzbazz
        bazzbazz April 19 2018 12: 23
        +11
        Or maybe they just didn’t want to shoot, so that like, we supported the United States, but didn’t shoot, and it’s not our fault! Sabotage at the state level. So that later they are not strongly condemned ...
      2. novel66
        novel66 April 19 2018 12: 23
        +3
        ours were scared. they say. the combat order was not fulfilled! all to the wall. miserable cowards
        1. Chertt
          Chertt April 19 2018 12: 26
          +2
          Quote: novel xnumx
          ours were scared.

          This is the British voiced this version. Which Negro Joe, the “grenades of the wrong system” turned out, We won’t recognize
          1. amirbek
            amirbek April 19 2018 12: 37
            +1
            Quote: Chertt
            "grenades of the wrong system" turned out to be

            most likely "diapers of the wrong system turned out to be" wassat
        2. Lelek
          Lelek April 19 2018 12: 43
          +3
          Quote: novel xnumx
          ours were scared. they say. the combat order was not fulfilled! all to the wall. miserable cowards

          hi
          How is it, how is it, how is it scared? Macron hoofs the whole world in the media, proclaiming his determination to “kick” someone out of the clutches of his overlord. He smacked, won Wonderland and equated himself beloved with Putin at the same time. In how.
          1. novel66
            novel66 April 19 2018 12: 50
            +14
            no, Macron is a brave dude. He sees his woman every day without makeup and has not turned gray, and does not stutter. brave man!
            1. Beltasir matyagu
              Beltasir matyagu April 19 2018 21: 26
              0
              Macron is homosexual that's the whole clue
          2. NEXUS
            NEXUS April 19 2018 13: 41
            +3
            Quote: Lelek
            Macron hoofs the whole world in the media,

            Macron clearly showed who he was "beloved wife", and he really did not want to run into our answer. And therefore, the deflection is counted, and in both directions.
      3. Denis Obukhov
        Denis Obukhov April 19 2018 12: 30
        +3
        Sails or something confused ..... laughing
      4. sabakina
        sabakina April 19 2018 14: 11
        +1
        Quote: Chertt
        So the British with the submarine, also some kind of troubled story. Either they came to the wrong place, or they couldn’t shoot)))

        Lesha, they wanted to shoot, but so that no one knew. Mine I am not me and the rocket is not mine. And the Warsaw “tricks” spoiled everything.
    2. RASKAT
      RASKAT April 19 2018 12: 20
      +10
      We do not know for what purposes these frigates should have hit. Maybe the ship commanders were simply afraid of the consequences and, citing technical reasons, did not launch.
      How do you like this version?
      I would not be surprised if the US command thus tried to substitute its allies, it is in their spirit. Or maybe the English submarines didn’t shoot at this?
      1. Russia
        Russia April 19 2018 12: 36
        +4
        Someone entered data on Israel, but someone has relatives there. Well, at least it worked out like this, the world is not without good people.
      2. NIKNN
        NIKNN April 19 2018 12: 40
        +2
        Quote: RASKAT
        We do not know for what purposes these frigates should have hit. Maybe the ship commanders were simply afraid of the consequences and, citing technical reasons, did not launch.
        How do you like this version?
        I would not be surprised if the US command thus tried to substitute its allies, it is in their spirit. Or maybe the English submarines didn’t shoot at this?

        The version is quite convincing ... Somehow in such punctures, I practically don’t really believe in field launches ...
    3. NIKNN
      NIKNN April 19 2018 12: 38
      +2
      Quote: Meckajiuhe
      It would be better if they cooked each other. They could have grown smarter.

      Don't believe smile dreamed ... just like about first love, well, I really wanted to, really regretted that there were no wizards familiar ... winked
  2. shalim
    shalim April 19 2018 12: 15
    +1
    because of cuts, I see everywhere problems. not only with us ...)))
    1. Chertt
      Chertt April 19 2018 12: 20
      +3
      Quote: shalim
      because of cuts, I see everywhere problems. not only with us ...)))

      And what is shrinking with you, let me curiosity
      1. Lord of the Sith
        Lord of the Sith April 19 2018 12: 47
        +3
        Why are you picking? laughing
    2. Kleber
      Kleber April 19 2018 12: 30
      +2
      We then have no problems with this)))))
      1. Chertt
        Chertt April 19 2018 12: 35
        +1
        Quote: Kleber
        We then have no problems with this)))))

        Well, what are you screaming, Let there be a surprise for the enemies)))
  3. Aaron Zawi
    Aaron Zawi April 19 2018 12: 15
    +4
    There is nothing more valuable than combat experience. The French now have a lot of work to do.
    1. vorobey
      vorobey April 19 2018 12: 20
      +5
      Quote: Aaron Zawi
      There is nothing more valuable than combat experience. The French now have a lot of work to do.


      it’s more difficult for the British .. They won’t fix the Varshavyanka .. laughing laughing
    2. gukoyan
      gukoyan April 19 2018 12: 21
      0
      Well, yes, the little boy was disgraced, there is something to take experience with ...
      1. novel66
        novel66 April 19 2018 12: 26
        +3
        the French will turn any shame into valor
        1. Russia
          Russia April 19 2018 12: 32
          +5
          Put wine, cheese and frog thighs in front of them and that's all, sadness aside, life goes on. smile Macron easier to Peter to go to a meeting, with a clear conscience.
          1. Lelek
            Lelek April 19 2018 12: 47
            +1
            Quote: Rusland
            Put wine, cheese and frog thighs in front of them and that's all, sadness aside, life goes on.

            hi
            Well, in a particular case they were given something else, which they bowed to the least, bought.
    3. Kleber
      Kleber April 19 2018 12: 31
      0
      Is Israel for you?
    4. Orionvit
      Orionvit April 19 2018 16: 56
      0
      Quote: Aron Zaavi
      There is nothing more valuable than combat experience

      Not the ability to shoot back, is this a combat experience? laughing
  4. taiga2018
    taiga2018 April 19 2018 12: 16
    +1
    and after all, somewhere else the frogmen climb with such technology, the Germans turned out to be smarter, did not begin to disgrace ...
  5. Bolo
    Bolo April 19 2018 12: 16
    +3
    Which cars: a dog, a cap and a Christmas tree, such and rockets.
  6. Masya masya
    Masya masya April 19 2018 12: 18
    +1
    just decided to save ..
  7. Nikolai Petrov
    Nikolai Petrov April 19 2018 12: 20
    +1
    Perhaps the frogs are trying to otmazatsya from this adventure on April 14th. That is to say save the face. And the second option, in the case of our otvetka (and most likely they were afraid of it), they could cry out: it's not us! we didn’t shoot, it's all Americans!
  8. rotmistr60
    rotmistr60 April 19 2018 12: 23
    +4
    But how proudly and pathos Macron reported on the delivered powerful blow and defeat of all planned goals. It seemed that France was a leading player in this act of aggression. The military, of course, will quietly, without publicity, conduct a debriefing, but the fact remains.
    1. den3080
      den3080 April 19 2018 12: 28
      +1
      Moreover, Macron does not even know about it, because he is not interested, he crowed already))
  9. Sergey985
    Sergey985 April 19 2018 12: 24
    +1
    There is no reason to worry! It didn’t work out this time, maybe another time ... they won’t be able to shoot back.
    1. Topotun
      Topotun April 19 2018 12: 30
      +2
      Nafik, nafik. They may not be able to shoot back. But if from their position the Amersky submarine launches at our air base? And our answer ....
  10. Denis Obukhov
    Denis Obukhov April 19 2018 12: 28
    +2
    Russian hackers cynically brewed hatches of launchers.
  11. Vard
    Vard April 19 2018 12: 29
    +1
    I worked with French controllers ... They are installed at their NPPs ... They work only after thorough processing with a soldering iron, threats to kill with a sledgehammer and thoroughly wiping the contacts with alcohol, which I bought at the pharmacy for my money ...
  12. Nikolai Petrov
    Nikolai Petrov April 19 2018 12: 32
    +3
    The "civilized" ones were ignored at the very reluctance with this "blow" to Syria. The results are more than sad for them. 71 axes out of 103 shot down, and moreover, shot down by museum exhibits. 2 axes already interested people are dismantled in Russia. The strategic boat of the "mistress of the seas" "Varshavyanka" drove like a lousy bathhouse throughout the eastern Mediterranean. And the frogs are trying to generally say that "they have nothing to do with it."
    And a little off topic rocket joke.
    - Hello, is this the base? I'm about the barn.
    - This is a missile base, you didn’t get there.
    - No, b ...! You didn’t get there!
    1. den3080
      den3080 April 19 2018 12: 36
      +1
      Inspired me something winked

      smile
      1. Nikolai Petrov
        Nikolai Petrov April 19 2018 12: 42
        0
        The video does not start. But I know this film literally. They were able to shoot precisely Masterpieces with a capital letter.
        1. The comment was deleted.
    2. Lelek
      Lelek April 19 2018 13: 06
      0
      Quote: Nikolai Petrov
      Nikolai Petrov

      hi
      Today, the media reported on the destruction by Israel of the Tor air defense system, which belongs to Iran.
      1. Nikolai Petrov
        Nikolai Petrov April 19 2018 13: 12
        +1
        Fresh tradition, but hard to believe. Kosher can not only destroy Thor, but also “fly” without a fawn over Iran. Complete nonsense.
  13. The comment was deleted.
  14. askort154
    askort154 April 19 2018 12: 40
    0
    Something the British and French have solid problems. This seems to be the work of our electronic warfare. They "covered" the east of the Mediterranean, where these "warriors" were. And the Americans struck from the Red Sea, through the SA, Jordan or Israel, where our electronic warfare could not work.
  15. Vol4ara
    Vol4ara April 19 2018 13: 28
    0
    1. Where did the information come from and how many times had to shoot?
    2. The French didn’t shoot at all, but MO can’t lie?
    1. Opera
      Opera April 19 2018 13: 53
      +4
      Carefully read the statement and comments of the Russian Ministry of Defense on this matter! Considering that the Russian language is probably not native to you, refer to the English version of Russian sources! Just in case, I inform you that the exact translation (not literary) into Polish and Hebrew will be more difficult to find. Contact the translation agency.
  16. sabakina
    sabakina April 19 2018 13: 56
    +2
    when it was possible to execute the first salvo, the temporary "window" ended
    What is another time window? Did they throw a satellite into orbit?
    1. den3080
      den3080 April 19 2018 14: 03
      +2
      I probably had an agreement with Russia - a temporary window)) firing from so many to so many, and then everyone came to headquarters to Konashenkov for analysis. :))
  17. Evil 55
    Evil 55 April 19 2018 15: 58
    +1
    From 1812-1815 they didn’t understand that God’s objects were defending the Russians, and not the slender, painted-up boys in ladies’ skirts ..
  18. AID.S
    AID.S April 19 2018 16: 45
    0
    the temporary “window” has ended,

    Has the lunch break begun? Or prayer?
  19. Dikson
    Dikson April 19 2018 19: 49
    0
    So our MO seems to be reporting to the Supreme under television cameras that the French did not shoot ?! And then it turns out that they fired ...)) Yes, and even their missiles that didn’t work in Russia have already been brought ... Everyone hangs noodles around their ears ..
  20. Nikolay Kuznetsov
    Nikolay Kuznetsov April 20 2018 15: 04
    0
    Can our electronic warfare affect missile launches? Or can not? If maybe our submarines-ships were nearby (relatively), then why not .. I don’t know how, but somehow they could have influenced, for example, the launch control or the guidance system. Or the great-grandson of Russian emigrants knocked out the switch with the Start command .. . And here's another version ... do not?