Military Review

Russian Defense Ministry sues Yuzhnoye Design Bureau more than a billion rubles

30
The Moscow Arbitration Court terminated the contract of the Russian Ministry of Defense with the Ukrainian Yuzhnoye Design Bureau for development work on extending the service life of the Voevoda strategic missiles, follows from the information in the file of arbitration cases.


Russian Defense Ministry sues Yuzhnoye Design Bureau more than a billion rubles


In addition, the court ordered the design bureau to pay the defense ministry about 1,1 a billion rubles penalty for non-fulfillment of contractual obligations.

The agency demanded to recover from the 915,6 CBM a penalty fee for non-compliance with the terms of the contract, 183,6 million rubles of unjust enrichment (paid, but not completed work) and 3,2 million rubles percent.

In his turn, Yuzhniy pointed out that the disruption of orders is connected with the ban on military cooperation with Russia, which was previously imposed by the Kiev authorities. He was called a “force majeure in the KB”, but the court rejected this argument.

The consideration of the case at the final stage was closed, therefore the verdict itself will not be published. Earlier, at a meeting in September 2017 of the year, a representative of the bureau said that the company was “considering the possibility” of offering the Russian military a settlement agreement. Whether this was done is unknown.

The decision has not yet entered into force, it can be appealed within a month, RIA reports News
30 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. Zubr
    Zubr 15 March 2018 17: 33
    +18
    It remains only to pick up the babosiki .. in my opinion this can already be done in accounting as losses.
    1. Safer
      Safer 15 March 2018 17: 37
      +7
      It is obvious that no one will pay anything. I agree with your point of view.
      1. Shurik70
        Shurik70 15 March 2018 17: 52
        +8
        Moscow Arbitration Court

        So it’s Moscow ... And the court of Kiev is demanding a billion dollars from the Russian Federation in compensation for terminating the contracts.
        1. Crowe
          Crowe 15 March 2018 18: 03
          +3
          Let them conduct it through Yna, CB Yuzhnoye, apparently, is working in the DPRK.
        2. Starover_Z
          Starover_Z 15 March 2018 23: 14
          +1
          Quote: Shurik70
          Moscow Arbitration Court

          So it’s Moscow ... And the court of Kiev is demanding a billion dollars from the Russian Federation in compensation for terminating the contracts.

          Claimed "court of Kiev." And if Russia returns the compensation to them with defective products of CB Yuzhnoye ?!
    2. siberalt
      siberalt 15 March 2018 17: 52
      +1
      “Force Majeure” to repay the prepayment? Or maybe they will also be dragged into "extreme need", they say, there was nothing to eat, Poroshenko ate everything? Well, right, baby talk. winked
    3. Maz
      Maz 15 March 2018 18: 28
      +1
      Damn, take all the left bank ...
    4. seti
      seti 15 March 2018 20: 56
      +2
      In due time they will pay. This is a response to their claims.
  2. The comment was deleted.
  3. APASUS
    APASUS 15 March 2018 17: 37
    +3
    Late we realized, now with the South Bank you can take money only with scrap metal, after the demolition of the building.
    1. Ascetic
      Ascetic 15 March 2018 18: 37
      +6
      Quote: APASUS
      Late we realized, now with the South Bank you can take money only with scrap metal, after the demolition of the building.

      The Sumerians have grandiose plans to build cosmodromes in Brazil and Australia, and Canadian Bandera will build a cosmodrome specifically for ukroraket. And then some kind of impoverished Russia begs with rusty rockets. Not that level for the greatest cosmic power.
      1. APASUS
        APASUS 15 March 2018 18: 43
        +1
        Quote: Ascetic
        The Sumerians have grandiose plans to build cosmodromes in Brazil and Australia,

        Know where the wind blows
  4. d ^ Amir
    d ^ Amir 15 March 2018 17: 39
    +3
    Of course we won’t take the money, they simply don’t exist !!! and to continue to cooperate with the southern one is to inform the CIA about the state of the nuclear deterrence forces .. let them think ... maybe it will come to that, though hardly ...
    1. siberalt
      siberalt 15 March 2018 17: 59
      +2
      If Yuzhmash had nothing to really compensate for the damage from the transaction, it would not have made sense to go to arbitration and incur legal costs. winked
      1. d ^ Amir
        d ^ Amir 15 March 2018 18: 16
        +1
        Good afternoon!! they have no money !!! and even if they appear, there are more urgent expenses, ammunition for the atom, for example ... and in general is it like this, pay money to the aggressor ??? there is no aggression so aggression
  5. bmv04636
    bmv04636 15 March 2018 17: 43
    0
    Like the answer for gas there is three yards there is a yard
  6. Tusv
    Tusv 15 March 2018 17: 47
    0
    Money is good; on it Mother of her children can be additionally decorated with gold, a mink coat and give flowers weekly. But, in the morning she was not made up and so awesomely beautiful. Engineers from Yuzhmash where?
    We have? Then what is the article about?
  7. andrej-shironov
    andrej-shironov 15 March 2018 18: 10
    +2
    I sued it when this money was in the accounts of the Ministry of Defense or the Central Bank. Everything else is ephemeral.
    1. Golovan Jack
      Golovan Jack 15 March 2018 18: 15
      +5
      Quote: andrej-shironov
      I sued it when this money ends up in the accounts of the Ministry of Defense or the Central Bank

      You are definitely not a lawyer, but just his son request
      1. andrej-shironov
        andrej-shironov 15 March 2018 18: 23
        +2
        laughing Golovan, whom I see! I really thought they wouldn’t let out heavy insulting artillery! But no battle trolls at the post.
      2. andrej-shironov
        andrej-shironov 15 March 2018 18: 51
        +4
        Quote: Golovan Jack
        Quote: andrej-shironov
        I sued it when this money ends up in the accounts of the Ministry of Defense or the Central Bank

        You are definitely not a lawyer, but just his son request

        smile Golovan, Chess, I miss you. It’s just that the local propagandists have very dumb arguments, you really don’t have ice either, but at least you put emoticons. As a person who has repeatedly been present at court hearings, including on property matters, I have never heard from anyone that after the first trial people suddenly stated that they had sued something. In the best case, they claimed that they won the court of first, second instance. Even those who won the case, and not the court, never said that they had sued the money until they appeared with them. The same goes for arbitration. There are soy nuances there, of course, because years go by from a court verdict to real money. Ask women who have received child support through the courts. Therefore, the under-trained physicist-mathematician, I advise you still not to share the skin of an unkilled bear!
  8. captain
    captain 15 March 2018 18: 11
    0
    Late to conquer. As if we had not yet to pay this billion.
  9. Beltasir matyagu
    Beltasir matyagu 15 March 2018 18: 24
    +3
    To transfer kb to Russia as a penalty
  10. Slovak
    Slovak 15 March 2018 18: 39
    +1
    Is this a joke? Ukraine does not repay principal in principle.
  11. polkovnik manuch
    polkovnik manuch 15 March 2018 18: 40
    +1
    You need to take all the Yuzhnoye Design Bureau for debts to Russia, Parashka with its banderlogs does not need it at all, and Russia will come in handy. But the advance payment for gas was wasted in vain, it was possible to take away to repay the loan, which is not repaid!
  12. rocket757
    rocket757 15 March 2018 19: 07
    +1
    Exchange of ships and debts .... It won’t get to the point of money, like me!
  13. Metallurg_2
    Metallurg_2 15 March 2018 19: 29
    +1
    To recover from the 404 country according to the decision of the Moscow court is about the same prospects as the 404 country to recover from Gazprom by the decision of the Kuevsky court.
  14. Xscorpion
    Xscorpion 15 March 2018 19: 58
    +1
    Well, if you don’t want to serve the Voivode, then you need to return them to them, how to start writing them off. On your own move. It is possible without JBCH.
  15. Falcond
    Falcond 15 March 2018 22: 05
    0
    Moscow Arbitration ..., Ukrainian Design Bureau ..., you can close the question
  16. Zomanus
    Zomanus 16 March 2018 00: 06
    +1
    Yeah, well done. Now try to get them.
    In fact, the same fiction as the attempts of Ukraine
    recognize Crimea as Ukrainian.
  17. Antares
    Antares 16 March 2018 11: 28
    0
    The Ukrainian court fined Gazprom for a monopoly, the Moscow Design Bureau Yuzhnoye .. in general, the partners had fun ..
    It’s the same as demanding something from the Martians ...
    Until 2014, Ukrainian specialists were engaged in the extension of the Voevod’s operation, now these works have been discontinued. For the last time, the operational life of the Voivode on combat duty in Russia was extended to 2026.