Military Review

Gazprom: Stockholm arbitration insists on paying $ 2,56 billion to Naftogaz

135
Gazprom confirms that the Stockholm arbitration has obliged it to pay 2,56 billion dollars in penalties to the Ukrainian Naftogaz. We are talking about partial satisfaction of the Ukrainian requirements for a claim for the transit of Russian gas to Europe. The total amount of the claim was approximately $ 4,7 billion - the amount that the Stockholm Arbitration accepted for consideration from the Kiev-issued 17-billion.


RIA News cites the message of "Gazprom":
Of the claims filed by Naftogaz in the amount of 17 billions of dollars, the arbitrators satisfied the claims in the amount of 4,673 billions of dollars in connection with the supply of gas for its transit to European consumers in a smaller volume than was stipulated by the contract. Taking into account the amount previously awarded to Gazprom, under the supply contract, the arbitrators set off counter claims, following which Gazprom is obliged to pay 2,56 billion dollars to Naftogaz.


Such a decision in the Stockholm arbitration was tied to the arguments of Naftogaz representatives about the deterioration of the state of affairs in the Ukrainian economy and the reduction of the necessary energy resources for it. Gazprom declares its disagreement with this kind of argument.

From the message of "Gazprom":
Earlier, the same arbitrators agreed with the arguments of Naftogaz about the sharp deterioration of the state of the Ukrainian economy, which led to a decrease in gas demand and non-fulfillment of Naftogaz’s gas selection obligations. However, with regard to Gazprom, which cited a decline in purchases by European clients of the company as the main reason for the decrease in transit through Ukraine, this argument was not taken into account.


Gazprom: Stockholm arbitration insists on paying $ 2,56 billion to Naftogaz


The Russian company noted that they intend to protect their rights under a previously concluded contract with Ukraine, which expires in the year 2019.
Photos used:
Gazprom
135 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. dik-nsk
    dik-nsk 1 March 2018 05: 49
    +16
    here’s an honest European court ... shame .. not only has international law been sent to waste for a long time, now it’s also civil law regulating economic relations between economic entities, and this is the inevitable collapse of the whole world system
    1. Vard
      Vard 1 March 2018 05: 53
      +30
      All honestly ... We all have to by definition ... And what is characteristic is we sell gas to them ... They raised local prices in connection with frosts ... But we can’t! What misery such contracts on our part are signing ...
      1. dik-nsk
        dik-nsk 1 March 2018 05: 55
        +23
        What misery such contracts on our part are signing ...
        judging by the news - it’s not a matter of contracts, no one abides by the agreements, only we play garlic
        1. Vladimir16
          Vladimir16 1 March 2018 07: 44
          +33
          With wolves live - wolf howl.
          The comrades from Gazprom decided that once in Russia they are doing what they want, this will be the case all over the world. But their Ukrainians bent over with cancer, which means that the rest will twist as they want. Sponsors of the liberals from the liberals and received the wort. Here is an echo ....
          The "people's property" should belong to the people, and not to individuals who do not particularly want to live in our country.
          Do not pity them a bit. they ... gas and oil.
          Quote: dik-nsk
          only we play garlic

          You say "WE" ... in Gazprom and they don’t know about your existence. They drive gas to Europe only because there is loot for it. And we are forced to pay hundreds of thousands of rubles for connection. Fuck yourself a public asset !!! They laid a bolt on our people.
          1. NEOZ
            NEOZ 1 March 2018 10: 40
            +3
            Quote: Vladimir16
            And we are forced to pay hundreds of thousands of rubles for connection.

            darling, and you did not think that if you do not supply gas for the currency, then no one will have hundreds of thousands for the connection ...
            1. New Year day
              New Year day 1 March 2018 10: 54
              +4
              Quote: NEOZ
              you didn’t think that if you don’t supply gas for the currency,

              but they didn’t think. that once the laf with sky-high gas prices will end? What was the need for import substitution then? What then had to raise the country's economy. After all, the war in Syria is also a war for gas. With whom else to fight. to have a currency? And how much can you fight in principle for this? You can tear yourself up. Health and education have already thrown into the furnace of gas war. What else do we destroy?
            2. passing
              passing 1 March 2018 16: 31
              0
              Quote: NEOZ
              Quote: Vladimir16
              And we are forced to pay hundreds of thousands of rubles for connection.

              darling, and you did not think that if you do not supply gas for the currency, then no one will have hundreds of thousands for the connection ...

              so they don’t exist, these hundreds of thousands. And judging by the fact that, even in the suburbs people live on electricity, most of them do not have hundreds of thousands
              1. NEOZ
                NEOZ 1 March 2018 20: 04
                +2
                Quote: passing
                no these hundreds of thousands

                but didn’t try to work?
                and if you do not earn, this does not mean that no one earns !!!
                s / n driver in the subway 90000 rubles.
                working metro builder 60000 rubles.
                foreman 90-110000 rub.
                Engineer 120-150000 rub.
                officer 55000 rub. + benefits
                look at car sales, is it the beggars who buy them?
                sales of apartments, are the beggars buying them too?
                1. passing
                  passing 1 March 2018 22: 21
                  +2
                  Stop lying ! even here was an article describing the salaries of engineers 25-30 sput in the space industry. The officer of the Ministry of Internal Affairs 22-30 tyr, there are no benefits for a long time.
                  Yes, I realized that you are from the sect of "witnesses of a wonderful life under Putin"
                  lie further, I'm not interested in you
                  1. NEOZ
                    NEOZ 5 March 2018 11: 49
                    0
                    Quote: passing
                    Stop lying !

                    What about the car and apartment market?
                    who buys them in such quantities?
                2. Anyone
                  Anyone 2 March 2018 21: 12
                  +1
                  Yeah. Metro builders and train drivers in the metro ... I see these specialties in the list of vacancies, for example, in Vologda, Khabarovsk or Medvezhyegorsk.
                  Z.Y. A gas connection in the Moscow region (if without a state gasification program for villages) costs an average of 1 million today. Personally, they ask me for 1,5 million. A type of “free” connection for a state gasification program for villages in the Moscow region costs 300 - 400 thousand. In Smolenskaya - 125 - 175 thousand
          2. klaus16
            klaus16 1 March 2018 11: 20
            +6
            Hey, you are our kindle! Well, explain "what is Gazprom doing in Russia ..."? And it turns out we did not bend Krajun, but she us? Why is this? Who is in the pope now? Are we? "... the public heritage of the people?" And it is already popular. Half the budget from gas. And this is the social sphere and the army. Or give it to you? Zadolbali you are all-knowing !!!
            1. passing
              passing 1 March 2018 16: 34
              +1
              Quote: klaus16
              Hey, you are our kindle! Well, explain "what is Gazprom doing in Russia ..."? And it turns out we did not bend Krajun, but she us? Why is this? Who is in the pope now? Are we? "... the public heritage of the people?" And it is already popular. Half the budget from gas. And this is the social sphere and the army. Or give it to you? Zadolbali you are all-knowing !!!

              Apparently, you are related to Gasprom.
              look at what part of the profit people’s Gazprom gives to the budget. And judging by the shareholders, it is not the property of our people
        2. seti
          seti 1 March 2018 09: 40
          +13
          Well, what they wanted from cheaters. After all, you need to play only by your own rules.
          Everything is very clear. Take-pay does not work. Although this is a contract that does not change and is working. What is this:
          - The supplier produces gas at a cost and must be sure that he will sell it. The buyer agrees to buy it. But the volume that is negotiated for some reason was reduced by 10 (!) Times. One way game. The rule is canceled from the current contract. And we wiped ourselves off.
          - But nevertheless, the Western "partners" helped their six - she doesn’t have any money, but why not make money for us compassionate. They upheld the decision on gas pumping volumes. Although it didn’t bind us under the contract (I mean fines). That is, if the purchase was reduced in the same country 4o4 from 50 to 0 billion cubic meters, it is logical that transit will decrease. From 110 to 90-94. But they threw us like suckers and counted the debt.
          What is arbitration in Stockholm after? If we pay it is a loss of face.
          Yes, no words. It has long been said that gas pipelines with China will accelerate and develop LNG. And Europe is a big trick.
      2. 210ox
        210ox 1 March 2018 06: 11
        +8
        They are signed by those who depend on the same Europe. Interests, offspring, etc. A capitalist society is such. So the comrades in such a society can only repent! Since we agree with this situation!
        Quote: Vard
        All honestly ... We all have to by definition ... And what is characteristic is we sell gas to them ... They raised local prices in connection with frosts ... But we can’t! What misery such contracts on our part are signing ...
    2. antivirus
      antivirus 1 March 2018 08: 50
      0
      this is good news - it will shake up the "gas-breathing" gas of our "heroes" of market reforms.
      and 2.5 billion is enough for 2 years of transit?
      Russia equalized with Ukraine?
      we are on the same level - the BSSSR, ukrov was not allowed into the EU
    3. igor.borov775
      igor.borov775 1 March 2018 13: 04
      +1
      Hi !!! I’ve been waiting for everyone to hit us, GAZPROM is like a commercial company, and with Ukraine there is absolutely no gas price in commerce, It’s not Gazprom’s fault but the authorities, So-called discounts on gas supplies have come down to the company, I suspected that it’s good it will not end the gas price discount after the coup everyone was in trouble And please, it’s not the COURT that matters, but the Kiev gas sales system itself, remotely it was so basically negotiated prices are very favorable, Kiev is trying to play on it and it will be very difficult for GAZPROM to protest it's a judgment
  2. Sirocco
    Sirocco 1 March 2018 05: 50
    +11
    In view of the fact that the EU does not have enough funds to finance the bloody sabbath in Ukraine, we decided to arrange problems at our own expense.
    Well, Ukraine, as always.
  3. Petrol cutter
    Petrol cutter 1 March 2018 05: 50
    +12
    However, throwing hats on Ukrainian partners did not come up.
    1. New Year day
      New Year day 1 March 2018 11: 00
      +3
      Quote: Benzorez
      However, throwing hats on Ukrainian partners did not come up.

      it is not a show-off before the voters to show, it is necessary to THINK in the courts. but it’s better when you sign something. BUT folk money. and their signatories will never miss.
      Great is my dear country,
      there are many fields, forests and rivers in it!
      1. passing
        passing 1 March 2018 16: 37
        0
        it is not a show-off before the voters to show, it is necessary to THINK in the courts. but it’s better when you sign something. BUT folk money. and their signatories will never miss.

        It is interesting to the miller that the reprimand is slapped, or will they be deprived of the quarterly prize? what
  4. Comrade
    Comrade 1 March 2018 05: 57
    +7
    Bolt to score, and meet. And when the Nord Stream-2 is completed, then we'll talk.
    1. andrej-shironov
      andrej-shironov 1 March 2018 09: 40
      +5
      If you do not understand: there will be no Nord Stream 2 until Russia pays reparation! Do not build illusions. The authorities will pay out of our pockets, because there are more big profits waiting for it.
    2. New Year day
      New Year day 1 March 2018 09: 56
      +7
      Quote: Comrade
      And when the Nord Stream-2 is completed, then we'll talk.

      with about the same ending as this one. I read somewhere. that the gas pipeline to China with supplies for us is on the verge of profitability. But the essence of power is this: everything that profiled in Europe is offset by tax increases within the country. Rogues, in a word, Miller and Co.
      1. The comment was deleted.
      2. The comment was deleted.
  5. Odysseus
    Odysseus 1 March 2018 05: 58
    +31
    But what is going on, citizens, or, as Yura from Sumy would say, Putin’s next victory.
    It is hoped that after the dear Western partners once again dunked our huckster from the power of funny faces in shit they will have at least a bit of intelligence and they will understand that
    1) It is necessary to constitutionally establish the priority of Russian law over international.
    2) Compliance with respect to the West and its puppets (including Maidan Ukraine) is perceived as weakness.
    3) If possible, it is necessary, in general, not to enter into contracts for disputes over which are settled by Western courts.
    4) It is necessary by any means to stop the transit of gas through Maidan Ukraine. And to terminate any relations with the "Ukrainian partners."
    1. populist
      populist 1 March 2018 06: 16
      +8
      The announcement of the Stockholm court once again demonstrated all the fallacy of the foreign economic policy of integration into the global economy. Another peremoga. But another.
      Between January and November 2017, trade between Russia and Ukraine increased by 28,6% to $ 9,36 billion
      1. Odysseus
        Odysseus 1 March 2018 06: 32
        +4
        Quote: populist
        The announcement of the Stockholm court once again demonstrated the fallacy of foreign economic policy for integration into the global economy

        In general, I agree, but the damage from integration into the world economy does not follow from the decision of the Stockholm court. The harm from integration into the world economy, carried out according to the rules of others, and the harm from the surrender of part of national sovereignty results.
        For example, the PRC also integrated into the global economy, but it turned out to be only to their advantage.
        Quote: populist
        And here is another.

        Well, if even more actively trading gas at our expense, trade, in general, will flourish.
        Especially the inhabitants of Gorlovka sitting every day under shelling will be delighted ...
        1. populist
          populist 1 March 2018 06: 50
          0
          Damage arises from integration into the world economy, carried out according to the rules of others, and harm from the surrender of part of national sovereignty.

          I agree. But here an interesting question arises, what is integration into the global economy. Unfortunately, I’m hurrying to work.
      2. Antares
        Antares 1 March 2018 10: 52
        +2
        Quote: populist
        Between January and November 2017, trade between Russia and Ukraine increased by 28,6% to $ 9,36 billion

        I see this fact everywhere, but no one gives a scan. Russia sold 6 billion to Ukraine (mainly energy and chemicals) Ukraine 3 billion (products and raw materials with kits)
        Conclusion-RF is more profitable than the increase in commodity circulation. After all, when it was 15 billion, there was no predominance 2 times.
    2. New Year day
      New Year day 1 March 2018 09: 59
      +2
      Quote: Odyssey
      Sumy is Putin's next victory

      how many more! It is just necessary to immediately turn the defeat into a victory.
    3. The comment was deleted.
  6. Herculesic
    Herculesic 1 March 2018 06: 01
    +19
    I won’t be amazed if our secretly ukroiny pay, and we will ride on the ears! And did anyone really believe in the honesty of international courts in lawsuits against Russia?
    1. gukoyan
      gukoyan 1 March 2018 08: 32
      +5
      By the way, this will happen, unfortunately, and they will throw a duck in the news feed with praise, like we appealed the decision and won the case, the elections are on the way!
      And gas and gas prices unfortunately will show the opposite ...
      Sometimes I am ashamed of the country in which I live.
    2. Yaro Polk
      Yaro Polk 1 March 2018 08: 33
      +5
      The Sumerians about such Peremogu the Great will certainly report on their TV population, well, we will find out, respectively)
      1. The comment was deleted.
    3. andrej-shironov
      andrej-shironov 1 March 2018 09: 42
      +4
      Spit on international courts! Almost no one already believes in the honesty of the current government, not excluding Putin!
    4. New Year day
      New Year day 1 March 2018 10: 00
      +2
      Quote: Herkulesich
      And did someone really believe in the honesty of international courts

      Does anyone believe in honesty of power?
      1. ARES623
        ARES623 1 March 2018 20: 43
        +1
        Quote: Silvestr
        Does anyone believe in honesty of power?

        And in yours? Are you honest? This is a war, if anyone does not understand. And it's not about Miller and our power. And in the multifaceted confrontation of Russia to the united West. And Ukraine is just a hack for breaking. So, in war, as in war - there are no losses. You just have to pull your Faberge out of the wrong hands in time. And then 25 years Taldychili-brothers ....
  7. samarin1969
    samarin1969 1 March 2018 06: 13
    +9
    February turned out to be fun. Each week brought media and immediate anti-Russian "sensations." It doesn’t matter what the United States thinks about us (all the same, they will only love Russia in their grave). It is important whether the “RF” continues its ostrich position. ...
    ps "Poles" once again did not help.
  8. dFG
    dFG 1 March 2018 06: 18
    +3
    Quote: samarin1969
    February turned out to be fun. Each week brought media and immediate anti-Russian "sensations." It doesn’t matter what the United States thinks about us (all the same, they will only love Russia in their grave). It is important whether the “RF” continues its ostrich position. ...
    ps "Poles" once again did not help.

    but I think this is just the beginning .... and soon they will be obliged to pay for all Malomalsky claims, and therefore we need to think hard before paying for the first time
    1. samarin1969
      samarin1969 1 March 2018 07: 11
      +10
      Quote: dfg
      Quote: samarin1969
      February turned out to be fun. Each week brought media and immediate anti-Russian "sensations." It doesn’t matter what the United States thinks about us (all the same, they will only love Russia in their grave). It is important whether the “RF” continues its ostrich position. ...
      ps "Poles" once again did not help.

      but I think this is just the beginning .... and soon they will be obliged to pay for all Malomalsky claims, and therefore we need to think hard before paying for the first time


      Yes, we are already paying, and quite quickly ...
      Russia paid the International Olympic Committee (IOC) $ 15 million, which was fined in December, when the Russian Olympic Committee (OCD) was temporarily disqualified by the IOC because of the doping scandal at the Sochi Olympics. "..." thinkers "easily pay, tea is not its own "blood" ...
  9. cedar
    cedar 1 March 2018 06: 19
    +6
    Another plop came as a result of Russia's loss of sovereignty in 1991.
    There will be more. Catch ...
    1. Karabin
      Karabin 1 March 2018 07: 36
      +5
      Quote: cedar
      Another plop ...
      There will be more. Catch ...

      For that is
      Sovereignty. Russia. Putin
      .
      And how is the unedited stuff pushed into the heads of NODovtsev? A riddle, however.
  10. Wolka
    Wolka 1 March 2018 06: 19
    +1
    and apparently I’ll have to pay, although not in the horse oats
    1. 1vlad19
      1vlad19 1 March 2018 06: 41
      +1
      Yes, Gazprom will not pay, count yourself, you have obliged to buy 5 billion annually of gas, at a price of 180 per thousand it is 900 million, but what if the price rises? And there is nothing to pay in / on, and so they ask (blackmail) Geyrop.
      1. karish
        karish 1 March 2018 07: 03
        +6
        Quote: 1vlad19
        Yes, Gazprom will not pay, count yourself, you have obliged to buy 5 billion annually of gas, at a price of 180 per thousand it is 900 million, but what if the price rises? And there is nothing to pay in / on, and so they ask (blackmail) Geyrop.

        Of course it will be .
        You can not doubt it.
        1. 1vlad19
          1vlad19 1 March 2018 07: 20
          +2
          Naive Jewish ... We are deep and far away, he will try to set or block the SP-2 conditions for the geyrop, we won’t drive gas through the on / off, let them drown with wood. Maybe a hundred or two from hypothermia will die. And gas will go along the Power of Siberia to China.
          1. vasek5533
            vasek5533 1 March 2018 07: 45
            +8
            This is what they say from the screen and in the net .... and the reality is that this money will pay. And the debts to the Russian Federation, as they were, will remain, they will only grow, but nobody is even going to give them back. It always has been and will be so long as you play by the rules of others. Well, do you believe further that someone will freeze.
          2. karish
            karish 1 March 2018 07: 55
            +4
            Quote: 1vlad19
            We are deep and far away, will try to set or block SP-2 conditions for the geyrop, we will not drive gas through the on / off, let them drown with firewood.

            Are you still in the clouds?
            Quote: 1vlad19
            . Maybe a hundred or two from hypothermia will die. And gas will go along the Power of Siberia to China.

            HOW ?
            1. 1vlad19
              1vlad19 1 March 2018 08: 16
              +2
              Quote: karish
              Are you still in the clouds?

              Vital and flew at 18, the code was called from Volgograd to Khabarovsk.
              Let them buy LNG, they want it in America, they want ours from Yamal. If there is enough money.
              Quote: karish
              HOW ?

              On the gas pipeline, what else.
              1. karish
                karish 1 March 2018 08: 25
                +4
                Quote: 1vlad19
                Let them buy LNG, they want it in America, they want ours from Yamal. If there is enough money

                They just have enough money, the share of Russian gas is 30% (In Europe)
                LNG is one option. You answer a simple question - and if you stop buying (for which you so advocate) - in the Russian Federation there is enough money to cover the difference from a hole in the budget?
                Quote: 1vlad19
                On the gas pipeline, what else.

                You probably are not familiar with the geography of your native country
                Where does gas come to Europe and where will it go to China?
                This is the first question. Well, the second - and why the heck is so much gas to China?
                Are you sure that you can sell European volumes to CHINA? laughing
                1. evil partisan
                  evil partisan 1 March 2018 08: 55
                  +7
                  Quote: karish
                  Where does gas come to Europe and where will it go to China?
                  Dear Alexander! hi
                  Gazprom has long been considering the option of turning gas pipelines from Yamburg and Urengoy to China. yes The so-called "Western Route". Surely, design work is already underway.
                  Quote: karish
                  and why the heck is so much gas to China?

                  China will be forced to switch from coal power, as the main one, to any other in the coming decades due to the deteriorating environment (this is one of the reasons). Plus developing chemistry. China will gobble up ALL the gas that Russia will give him and ask for more. yes
                  Hi, spiteful high voltage! drinks
                  1. The comment was deleted.
                    1. Nikolai Grek
                      Nikolai Grek 1 March 2018 18: 47
                      +3
                      Quote: Genadiy
                      why pay if you can squeeze

                      you can squeeze the current from the cowardly Ukrainians !! wink and then, do not squeeze, but by the will of the people to take home back !!! yes and you continue to dream that China is plotting against Russia !!! wassat tongue tongue laughing laughing laughing
                      1. Genadiy
                        Genadiy 1 March 2018 21: 04
                        0
                        I do not dream, but quote from your own holy prophets. The one who smiles last is smiling.
                2. 1vlad19
                  1vlad19 1 March 2018 09: 09
                  +4
                  Quote: karish
                  You probably are not familiar with the geography of your native country
                  Where does gas come to Europe and where will it go to China?

                  I’m very familiar, I also know what will go from Yakutia to Primorye and then to China. And to Europe is mainly Siberian gas. And about 30%, this is the total figure in Europe and not 30%, but 36%, add resellers (as recently as “European gas” to the USA from Novatek).
                  Quote: karish
                  and why the heck is so much gas to China?
                  Are you sure that you can sell European volumes to CHINA?

                  China is not Israel or even Germany, enterprises are being built, thermal power plants are switching from coal and fuel oil to gas. And do not forget, our country is huge, but gasification is small, even of large cities. Where there is a gas pipeline, a branch is extended.
          3. andrej-shironov
            andrej-shironov 1 March 2018 09: 45
            +1
            Quote: 1vlad19
            Naive Jewish ... We are deep and far away, he will try to set or block the SP-2 conditions for the geyrop, we won’t drive gas through the on / off, let them drown with wood. Maybe a hundred or two from hypothermia will die. And gas will go along the Power of Siberia to China.

            laughing Aha ha! Another sacred believer in infallibility you yourself know whom
            1. 1vlad19
              1vlad19 1 March 2018 10: 33
              +2
              I know, but you go to the liberals or better leave my country far away. You can go to the swamp under the banners of dogs, bulk and others like them, just take the medicine, they will beat gently, but it hurts.
              1. andrej-shironov
                andrej-shironov 1 March 2018 17: 13
                0
                wink You yourself go ..... from my country. Tortured to beat like you. My good with fists. wink
                1. 1vlad19
                  1vlad19 1 March 2018 23: 51
                  +1
                  Let's see, I have been serving since 1992 and saw how liberals destroyed the army and how they restored under the guarantor. And not one military man will follow the liberals. And for good with fists there is an “argument”.
                  1. andrej-shironov
                    andrej-shironov 12 March 2018 09: 45
                    0
                    smile Yes, I do not care about the liberals. Tell me, what does the country consist of of the military alone? New oprichnina?
            2. evil partisan
              evil partisan 2 March 2018 01: 43
              +2
              Quote: andrej-shironov
              in infallibility you know who

              Dude. Mommy's demolition diary wink - let him check it out ... sad
              If he says that gut, then okay, I will listen to you ... request
              1. andrej-shironov
                andrej-shironov 12 March 2018 09: 46
                0
                smile Yes, you can not listen to a small loss.
  11. ul_vitalii
    ul_vitalii 1 March 2018 06: 38
    +5
    Poroshenko again went into a sweep after this change. Such a day, such a day, give him that cucumber on a little fork.
  12. rotmistr60
    rotmistr60 1 March 2018 06: 47
    +5
    Strange, Gazprom, with the presence of professional and probably the best lawyers in this area, is losing the courts. It is clear that the attitude towards Russian companies is biased, but it also constantly hopes for Russian maybe also should not be.
    1. karish
      karish 1 March 2018 07: 12
      +4
      Quote: rotmistr60
      Strange, Gazprom, with the presence of professional and probably the best lawyers in this area, is losing the courts.

      nothing strange, the contract was originally with a 100% corruption component.
      I don’t remember who signed it there, in my Tymoshenko.
      Having received her kickback and hung all this bondage on the neck of Ukraine.
      According to this contract, gas was more expensive for Ukraine than for Europe, transit cost for Ukraine was more expensive than for Europe and in addition - even if you didn’t take the necessary quota, pay the whole amount.
      Because of this contract, Julia went into political oblivion and her rating in Ukraine is rapidly approaching the baseboard.
      Note that such enslaving conditions were put forward at that time, fraternal Ukraine.
      Quote: rotmistr60
      . It is clear that the attitude towards Russian companies is biased

      In general, Gazprom was unable to explain anything biased as the mk on what grounds such enslaving conditions were set.
      For signing such contracts of robbing their people - officials must immediately be sent to prison - which, in general, happened to Yulia.
      1. B.T.V.
        B.T.V. 1 March 2018 09: 10
        +1
        Quote: karish
        For signing such contracts of robbing their people - officials must immediately be sent to prison - which, in general, happened to Yulia.


        Yeah, and then, when released from the "dungeons of Yanukovych", she was portrayed as a "victim of the regime."

        Quote: karish
        Because of this contract, Julia went into political oblivion and her rating in Ukraine is rapidly approaching the baseboard.


        Julia has not yet said her last word.
      2. Yuyuka
        Yuyuka 1 March 2018 10: 07
        +3
        According to this contract, gas was more expensive for Ukraine than for Europe, transit cost for Ukraine was more expensive than for Europe and in addition - even if you didn’t take the necessary quota, pay the whole amount.
        Because of this contract, Julia went into political oblivion and her rating in Ukraine is rapidly approaching the baseboard.
        Note that such enslaving conditions were put forward at that time, fraternal Ukraine.


        unfortunately, I also have to agree - even then I read about the terms of the contract and it was somehow unpleasant ... Everything was clear, business and nothing personal, but it was too much on the surface to “act on the letter of the contract” and squeeze the most out of the situation. Gazprom behaved too shabbyly, as at home - they say, they will not go anywhere. Dizzy from success ... Now, if we do not win back, in addition to billions, we will also get political costs. It was necessary to bypass Ukraine to start pulling pipes for a long time - as soon as the "independence" was formed, there was an obvious miscalculation and unwillingness to spend on risks - why? after all, there is a “fraternal” trumpet that has come up with where to go ... Few were the examples of the Hague tribunal? Who are we looking for legality ??
      3. Antares
        Antares 1 March 2018 11: 11
        +2
        Quote: karish
        I don’t remember who signed it there, in my Tymoshenko.

        she is the most. Gas is the business of the presidents. (Usually the president would roll back from the contract, but the cunning Julia outwitted everyone, though it was expensive)
        At that time, the largest consumer of the buyer was two - Ukraine and Germany. So they made gas more expensive than German for the nearest buyer. Plus buns for the Russian Federation in the form of Kharkiv agreements, credit conditions and legal issues (all lawsuits were lost)
        What Tymoshenko did, she worked for life. And rightly sat in prison. This is the only (except for the Moscow agreements) achievement of the Yanukovych regime for me. Although it coincided simply with the need for competition between clans.
    2. Antares
      Antares 1 March 2018 11: 04
      0
      Quote: rotmistr60
      Gazprom with the presence of professional and probably the best lawyers in this area is losing the courts

      as far as I remember, American and English law firms were suing (Gazprom always hires them) representing the interests of Ukraine and the Russian Federation in different courts. From English to Swedish.
      Not cheap offices. But the office of Gazprom has repeatedly won litigation with Naftogaz.
  13. Observer2014
    Observer2014 1 March 2018 07: 05
    +7
    And the other day Putin said that after January 1 transit through Ukraine would remain possible. But on a smaller scale repeat
    I would dig up at the border of the pipe. So that there would be no transit through the on / off anymore. Why leave a reason for further claims? Or continue to humiliate ourselves further?
  14. Snail N9
    Snail N9 1 March 2018 07: 22
    +8
    Well done Ukrainians, they deftly used the column of the contract on "the obligation to supply contracted volumes of gas in any case." Well, it means that there will be no increase in retirement for Russian pensioners ...
    1. Nikolai Grek
      Nikolai Grek 1 March 2018 18: 53
      +1
      Quote: Snail N9
      Well done Ukrainians,

      Ukrainians have nothing to do with it ... the court applied double standards !!!
      write yourself that
      Quote: Snail N9
      used the column of the contract on "the obligation to supply contracted volumes of gas in any case."

      at the same time, they turned a blind eye to such Khokhlyat commitments of this kind about the compulsory purchase of gas volumes ... here we read, we don’t read there ... the bias of the court !!! request request most likely, again, an attempt to push the contents of hohland on the shoulders of Russia !!! negative negative negative
  15. Karabin
    Karabin 1 March 2018 07: 38
    +6
    Stockholm arbitration insists on paying $ 2,56 billion to Naftogaz

    Well now what. To pay and repent is the motto of Federal Neutralia.
    1. karish
      karish 1 March 2018 08: 00
      +3
      Quote: Karabin
      Stockholm arbitration insists on paying $ 2,56 billion to Naftogaz

      Well now what. To pay and repent is the motto of Federal Neutralia.

      when two parties apply to arbitration, they automatically recognize its legitimacy and are required to comply with its decision.
      No international contract is concluded without a paragraph on the case of controversial decisions and jurisdiction (recognized by both parties) - for their resolution.
      Therefore, do not twist it, and the decision of the arbitration will have to be implemented both by Ukraine and Gazprom.
      Naftogaz lost one of the disputes, Gazprom lost the second.
      It's nobody's fault . that Gazprom wanted to naphtha gas to a large amount. than Naftogaz Gazprom.
      In the toga, the difference is in favor of Naftogaz.
      Both thieves - but the people are paying.
      1. Vita vko
        Vita vko 1 March 2018 08: 17
        +1
        Quote: karish
        In toga, the difference is in favor of Naftogaz

        These are still flowers. The closer the presidential election in Russia, the provocations to discredit GDP will be more serious on all fronts. In Syria, for example, terrorists and their American curators have long been planning a chemical attack, followed by a blow to the SAA troops, and possibly to Russian bases. Will it succeed or not, in fact, it doesn’t matter, the main resonance in the media before the election.
        1. karish
          karish 1 March 2018 08: 19
          +3
          Quote: Vita VKO
          These are still flowers. The closer the presidential election in Russia, the provocations to discredit GDP will be more serious on all fronts.

          What provocations?
          Gazprom seems to have filed an arbitration.
          Quote: Vita VKO
          In Syria, for example, terrorists and their American curators have long planned a chemical attack

          Did they report to you personally?
          Quote: Vita VKO
          Will it succeed or not, in fact, it doesn’t matter, the main resonance in the media before the election.

          Quote: Vita VKO
          provocations to discredit GDP

          Calm down - GDP will be president, do you really doubt it belay
          1. Vita vko
            Vita vko 1 March 2018 08: 45
            +3
            Quote: karish
            Did they report to you personally?

            Nebenzya announced these data at a speech in the UN Security Council yesterday. And you, with your "stormy" reaction, only confirmed the conclusions of Russian intelligence. So, if terrorists from eastern Guta report to someone, it’s exclusively to their sponsors and those who provide them with informational cover.
          2. andrej-shironov
            andrej-shironov 1 March 2018 09: 47
            +2
            Quote: karish
            Quote: Vita VKO
            These are still flowers. The closer the presidential election in Russia, the provocations to discredit GDP will be more serious on all fronts.

            What provocations?
            Gazprom seems to have filed an arbitration.
            Quote: Vita VKO
            In Syria, for example, terrorists and their American curators have long planned a chemical attack

            Did they report to you personally?
            Quote: Vita VKO
            Will it succeed or not, in fact, it doesn’t matter, the main resonance in the media before the election.

            Quote: Vita VKO
            provocations to discredit GDP

            Calm down - GDP will be president, do you really doubt it belay

            It is also bad that, contrary to the people, the GDP will be president.
          3. Genadiy
            Genadiy 1 March 2018 21: 10
            0
            Yes, you just do not know how the Russian oligarchs fidgeted after they introduced sanctions against them. They in 1996 made President Yeltsin although Zyuganov defeated. They will throw themselves off and organize a victory for anyone if this promises them a profit. Here Grudinin will take revenge for the Communist Party. Although what a clever and friendly candidate for the people there is no blood on his hands like Putin.
        2. uskrabut
          uskrabut 1 March 2018 08: 49
          +4
          Quote: Vita VKO
          The closer the presidential election in Russia, the provocations to discredit GDP will be more serious on all fronts

          No one can discredit him more than himself.
          1. Vita vko
            Vita vko 1 March 2018 09: 22
            +1
            Quote: uskrabut
            No one can discredit him more than himself.

            You're not right. This is each person in itself an individual with free thinking. But when it comes to a group of people of 100 or more, located in a single information field, then statistical and psychological laws come into force, which political scientists use “successfully”. But the most interesting thing is when whole nations from 10 million hours are in the general information field. and more, then it’s not worth talking about statistics and probability since the laws of "large numbers" begin to operate and most of the events become regular and predictable.
            1. uskrabut
              uskrabut 1 March 2018 15: 43
              0
              Quote: Vita VKO
              when in the general information field there are entire nations from 10 million hours and more

              It was about provocations against a single person, and where are the laws of large numbers? We have one President, not 10 million. And for nonsense, in the sense of knowledge of the existence of the theory of large numbers, you are a plus.
      2. Nikolai Grek
        Nikolai Grek 1 March 2018 19: 01
        0
        Quote: karish
        Naftogaz lost one of the disputes,

        they didn’t lose anything ... they forced to pay for unpaid selected gas - this is not a loss !!! but in fact - the explicit use of double standards when considering cases !!! negative negative
  16. The comment was deleted.
  17. private person
    private person 1 March 2018 08: 03
    +9
    And then they hung up the noodles. Gazprom won, but then there is a thick bolt from under the bed. That's interesting at whose expense partying? Russia also supplies gas and pays extra for it, DEBILS !!!!!!
    1. gukoyan
      gukoyan 1 March 2018 08: 42
      +6
      In any case, we will pay for this, unfortunately ...
    2. Yuyuka
      Yuyuka 1 March 2018 10: 21
      0
      Quote: private person
      And then they hung up the noodles. Gazprom won, but then there is a thick bolt from under the bed. That's interesting at whose expense partying? Russia also supplies gas and pays extra for it, DEBILS !!!!!!


      if this party were at the expense of Gazprom’s well-paid “workers”, then okay ... in July we’ll look at the paychecks, and maybe even earlier - the elections will be held ...

      it’s not good to consider other people's money, but ... there, as it were, my contribution, because -

      In 2016, Alexey Miller’s remuneration for work in Gazprom reached, according to Forbes, $ 17,7 million. Whereas the average salary of a Russian for a month amounted to 36 thousand rubles (432 thousand per year), according to Rosstat.
      Consequently, Miller earns the annual salary of an ordinary Russian in 3,6 hours.

      Now is 2018, I hope he is still doing well ... at least for someone I can be happy
      1. New Year day
        New Year day 1 March 2018 10: 56
        +6
        Quote: Yuyuka
        remuneration for work in Gazprom Alexey Miller

        and how many children could be treated!
  18. ramzes1776
    ramzes1776 1 March 2018 08: 09
    +3
    And 3 lard for which Russia bought the bonds in 2013, no one to give us and is not going to go.
    1. private person
      private person 1 March 2018 08: 26
      +6
      So it was originally conceived that the loot was divided between us and their leaders, and people were hanging noodles on their ears. Hola they are not fools to pay, they won how Russia deployed and still and should and will pay. We are "reliable partners."
  19. -ш-
    -ш- 1 March 2018 08: 27
    +4
    that nobody is going to pay anything yet, but the number of whiners rolls over
    1. private person
      private person 1 March 2018 08: 46
      +3
      Do not worry Russia will pay a generous soul.
      1. -ш-
        -ш- 1 March 2018 09: 14
        +2
        something your authority in the world does not guarantee that they will pay, it will be the same as with 3 lyamas of bonds for from the Russian Federation for Ukrainians, and an appeal has already been filed, so let’s go cool
    2. andrej-shironov
      andrej-shironov 1 March 2018 09: 50
      +2
      So don’t go to the grandmother, we’ll pay! IOC paid 15 million and now we will pay. Nobody has yet canceled the indemnity regarding the vassal
      1. -ш-
        -ш- 1 March 2018 10: 39
        +1
        Well, Mok and Ukra are two different things, and this is Gazprom, so they easily gave money
        1. andrej-shironov
          andrej-shironov 1 March 2018 17: 15
          +1
          What difference does it make: IOC, Ukraine! The desire of the current government to pay and wipe off is important here.
          1. -ш-
            -ш- 1 March 2018 20: 14
            0
            Well, Gazprom didn’t listen to you and completely turned off the gas to Ukraine, thereby spitting on this court
      2. New Year day
        New Year day 1 March 2018 10: 57
        +6
        Quote: andrej-shironov
        IOC paid 15 million

    3. Yuyuka
      Yuyuka 1 March 2018 10: 26
      +1
      Quote: -sh-
      that nobody is going to pay anything yet, but the number of whiners rolls over


      really ... think a billion there, a billion here ... why whine ?? u is fine, chef! judging by the trend of recent years, "whiners", as you say, are really thinking ... which, unfortunately,
      not much in government.
      1. -ш-
        -ш- 1 March 2018 10: 37
        +1
        no one has paid anyone yet, and the nagging is already pouring ... blah blah, power is such a power, all are bad, and as always before the election, still say that you are the granddaughter of the admiral
        1. Yuyuka
          Yuyuka 1 March 2018 10: 44
          0
          Quote: -sh-
          no one has paid anyone yet, and the nagging is already pouring ... blah blah, power is such a power, all are bad, and as always before the election, still say that you are the granddaughter of the admiral

          belay fool
          1. -ш-
            -ш- 1 March 2018 10: 49
            +1
            survived, the "thinker of the whole oppressed people" had no words to answer
            1. Yuyuka
              Yuyuka 1 March 2018 10: 55
              +1
              duck there is doubt that the words do not perceive request , juggle with letters and see what you want to see - see the "enemy" and give labels more quickly wassat
              1. -ш-
                -ш- 1 March 2018 11: 03
                +1
                Well, I’ve offended) heh .... in general I don’t know who will be right, no one here knows, they just write that it’s painful or some assumptions there, but so many offended by the government, and I repeat, no one is going to pay money yet that, and then we'll see, but to include all-inclusiveness is clearly not an option
                1. Yuyuka
                  Yuyuka 1 March 2018 12: 08
                  +1
                  yes not ... not offended wink and not all the weeder at all, but only really ached - they got these double standards of the same "national wealth." Forgive or make concessions to "foreign" and spread rot for their consumers. In the first place should be the interests of his people ... As Raikin said - I feel so ... I think so ... hi
  20. uskrabut
    uskrabut 1 March 2018 08: 47
    +3
    It was necessary to shut off the crane before the end of the proceedings. The European judges' brains would cool down, and they would make a decision based on the need to warm themselves. By the way, such a fad should be included in all energy supply contracts, so that there would be less people wishing to profit.
    1. Nikolai Grek
      Nikolai Grek 1 March 2018 19: 13
      0
      Quote: uskrabut
      It was necessary to shut off the crane before the end of the proceedings. The European judges' brains would cool down, and they would make a decision based on the need to warm themselves. By the way, such a fad should be included in all energy supply contracts, so that there would be less people wishing to profit.

      After Gazprom’s refusal to supply gas to Ukraine, there may be a shortage of this fuel already this weekend, it is necessary to introduce a saving regime, Naftogaz said.

      The head of Naftogaz Andrey Kobolev said that severe frosts are expected in Ukraine from March 1 to March 4, because of this there is a shortage in daily gas volumes of 18–20 million cubic meters. Naftogaz was planning to acquire these volumes from Gazprom, but due to the failure of the Russian company, Ukraine will try to close the shortage by importing from the European market. Nevertheless, 10 million cubic meters per day is still not enough, RIA Novosti reports. request request wassat wassat wassat

      https://vz.ru/news/2018/3/1/910642.html
  21. BAI
    BAI 1 March 2018 08: 49
    +1
    Who would doubt that. As we still don’t understand, no international court will objectively make decisions regarding Russia.
    1. Town Hall
      Town Hall 1 March 2018 09: 09
      +3
      Quote: BAI
      Who would doubt that. As we still don’t understand, no international court will objectively make decisions regarding Russia.




      In your understanding, is it objective, is it only if the Russian Federation wins? ... in any other cases, is it biased and biased?)
      1. Romulus
        Romulus 1 March 2018 09: 18
        +1
        Quote: Town Hall
        In your understanding, is it objective only if the Russian Federation wins? ..

        Gazprom and Naftogaz reported that Stockholm arbitration made a final decision on the suit of Naftogaz under a gas transit contract. The court upheld the claims of Naftogaz against Gazprom in the amount of $ 4,637 billion, which Gazprom should compensate Naftogaz
        This is objectively) As the beloved on this site Lenin used to say, it is an objective reality given to us in sensations .. (I have already forgotten the dogmas of faith)
      2. Nikolai Grek
        Nikolai Grek 1 March 2018 19: 31
        +1
        Quote: Town Hall
        Quote: BAI
        Who would doubt that. As we still don’t understand, no international court will objectively make decisions regarding Russia.




        In your understanding, is it objective, is it only if the Russian Federation wins? ... in any other cases, is it biased and biased?)

        objectively, this is the application of the same principle to transit volumes for Russia as to the Khokhlyat “take or pay” !! request request
  22. trophy
    trophy 1 March 2018 09: 01
    +6
    Come on, now they will collect from us quietly and pay quietly the same.
  23. XXXIII
    XXXIII 1 March 2018 09: 12
    +5
    Gazprom: Stockholm arbitration insists on paying $ 2,56 billion to Naftogaz
    Officially, there is no explanation from Gazprom on the decision of the Stockholm court on the official website, which is not known in detail in the decision. And the news came from ukrov with their help, I’m not ready to believe this miracle, we are waiting for official clarifications of the court decision.
    ps the devil is in the details .... laughing
    1. Antares
      Antares 1 March 2018 11: 14
      0
      Quote: XXXIII
      Officially, there is no explanation from Gazprom on the decision of the Stockholm court on the official website, which is not known in detail in the decision.

      The Russian Gazprom did not agree with the decision of the Stockholm arbitration in the transit case with Naftogaz Ukraine.
      This is stated in the statement of the gas holding, writes TASS.
      Gazprom notes that it will defend its rights "by all means available to it in accordance with applicable law."
      1. Town Hall
        Town Hall 1 March 2018 11: 17
        0
        Quote: Antares
        Gazprom "notes that it will protect its rights" by all means available to it in accordance with applicable law. "



        And what are these ways?
      2. XXXIII
        XXXIII 1 March 2018 11: 47
        +2
        Quote: Antares
        Quote: XXXIII
        Officially, there is no explanation from Gazprom on the decision of the Stockholm court on the official website, which is not known in detail in the decision.

        The Russian Gazprom did not agree with the decision of the Stockholm arbitration in the transit case with Naftogaz Ukraine.
        This is stated in the statement of the gas holding, writes TASS.
        Gazprom notes that it will defend its rights "by all means available to it in accordance with applicable law."

        Silence on the official website, Gazprom shareholders should know how this decision will affect the state of the company and the shares, otherwise these weather sensations will not make me any weather ..... laughing In Ukraine, too, every time they write a break, then it turns out that there seem to be no losers, they just didn’t divide the loot equally or the calculator broke .... wassat Why doesn’t anyone pay anything on the decisions of these courts, I don’t think a coincidence ..... fellow
        1. Antares
          Antares 1 March 2018 12: 14
          +1
          Quote: XXXIII
          In Ukraine, too, every time they write,

          TASS apparently in Ukraine ....
          The RU tape cited both TASS and Naftogaz.
          But I trust TASS most of all.
          1. XXXIII
            XXXIII 1 March 2018 12: 24
            +1
            Quote: Antares
            Quote: XXXIII
            In Ukraine, too, every time they write,

            TASS apparently in Ukraine ....
            The RU tape cited both TASS and Naftogaz.
            But I trust TASS most of all.
            Yes, this tass is also boiled in one boiler, now the fashion is for official sources, not that I do not believe it, I just want to get the exact information, and there is silence ....
  24. andrej-shironov
    andrej-shironov 1 March 2018 09: 37
    +3
    Just as I wrote: these are reparations for Nord Stream 2! Be sure the Russian authorities will go to such costs as Kolya from Urengoy! After all, this is money for the ruling elite, and not a national treasure!
    1. XXXIII
      XXXIII 1 March 2018 12: 10
      +3
      Quote: andrej-shironov
      Just as I wrote: these are reparations for Nord Stream 2! Be sure the Russian authorities will go to such costs as Kolya from Urengoy! After all, this is money for the ruling elite, and not a national treasure!
      Do you think that a fly in the ointment will spoil a barrel of honey ?! wink
      Russia's income from natural gas exports for 11 months of 2017 increased by 21 percent, to $ 33,8 billion, according to the FCS. The volume of fuel supplies amounted to 188,8 billion cubic meters of gas, including 158,3 billion cubic meters to non-CIS countries.
      It’s just that we (people) don’t get anything from this pie (a little bit into the air), and there is enough money there, they don’t even mind fighting for them. We still need to wait for the official clarification of what and for what, and how much it will be on the whole, otherwise the gas solders are silent .... yes
      1. andrej-shironov
        andrej-shironov 1 March 2018 17: 17
        +1
        I think that one spoon of shit easily turns a barrel of honey into a barrel of shit! wink
  25. maratk
    maratk 1 March 2018 09: 43
    +2
    [quote] [/ quote] Earlier, these same arbitrators agreed with Naftogaz’s arguments about a sharp deterioration in the state of the Ukrainian economy, which led to a decrease in gas demand and Naftogaz’s default on gas withdrawals. However, with regard to Gazprom, which referred to a decrease in purchases by European customers of the company as the main reason for the decrease in transit through Ukraine, this argument was not taken into account.
    here it is justice about which EVERYONE so much love to talk !!!!
  26. New Year day
    New Year day 1 March 2018 10: 02
    +1
    All clear. The court ordered the alimony of the mother for the indecent behavior of the child until the teenager is over the age of majority.
  27. NKT
    NKT 1 March 2018 10: 05
    0
    Quote: 1vlad19

    I’m very familiar, I also know what will go from Yakutia to Primorye and then to China. And to Europe is mainly Siberian gas. And about 30%, this is the total figure for Europe and not 30% ....



    Gas goes to Europe from fields in the Yamal-Nenets Autonomous Okrug, more precisely: Urengoyskoye, Yu-Russkoye, Bovanenkovskoye, Yamburgskoye
  28. Gungar
    Gungar 1 March 2018 10: 23
    +3
    Everything is designed for elections. To heat the atmosphere, so to speak.
    As a result, Gazprom will appeal, everything will be delayed. The elections will be held, Putin will win and the partners in the political process will begin to hint that this is misunderstanding, let's forget, etc.
    ps
    Well, for that kind of money, you can sponsor a military company and there will be neither whole Ukraine nor Naftogaz.
  29. Zomanus
    Zomanus 1 March 2018 10: 50
    +1
    Well, now it’s exactly the end of transit through Ukraine.
    We will chop off until physical circumcision.
    After 2019. by itself.
    By the way, a little over a year and a half is left.
    1. Town Hall
      Town Hall 1 March 2018 11: 08
      +1
      Quote: Zomanus
      Well, now it’s exactly the end of transit through Ukraine.
      We will chop off until physical circumcision.
      After 2019. by itself.
      By the way, a little over a year and a half is left.



      Cut off all 80.000.000.000 cubic meters of gas going through Ukraine? ... will you carry in bags?
      1. XXXIII
        XXXIII 1 March 2018 12: 31
        +2
        Quote: Town Hall
        Quote: Zomanus
        Well, now it’s exactly the end of transit through Ukraine.
        We will chop off until physical circumcision.
        After 2019. by itself.
        By the way, a little over a year and a half is left.

        Cut off all 80.000.000.000 cubic meters of gas going through Ukraine? ... will you carry in bags?

        They will simply reduce risks, cut back on transit to self-sufficiency, by the way it will be useful to everyone, ow. Ukraine will have less to steal, our parachutes will be cut into tents ..... laughing
    2. Lev Bronsch
      Lev Bronsch 2 March 2018 21: 36
      0
      Write nonsense! A minimum of 25 billion cubic meters will remain, and this is subject to the absence of dirty tricks on the part of the European Commission. By the way, Ukraine is actively preparing for such a scenario - it invites foreign companies to manage the gas transportation system. Yes, most likely 1/2 of the remaining capacity and those who enter the gas transportation system will think of the Ukrainian gas market. But, this is their business, but pumping will still remain!
  30. Antares
    Antares 1 March 2018 11: 25
    +2
    The news is incomplete.
    Although I recognized her here.
    Yes, Gazprom partially lost this lawsuit.
    Arbitration of the Stockholm Chamber of Commerce partially satisfied Naftogaz’s claim for a dispute with Gazprom and decided that the Russian holding should reimburse the Ukrainian company $ 4,63 billion for non-delivery of gas under a transit agreement concluded between them

    but
    At the same time, the arbitration court rejected the requirements of Naftogaz to increase the tariff for gas transit and to amend the contract with the Russian side in accordance with the legislation of Ukraine. The court ruled that the provisions of European or Ukrainian antitrust law are not applicable to the contract.

    That is, Wishlist Ukrainians in terms of increases in transit prices were only Wishlist.
    I don’t know how much one day delay for Gazprom costs
    One day of delay costs Naftogaz $ 600 thousand for the previous lawsuit. So these debts are included in the offset amount.
    In general, the court, as usual, does not completely satisfy the Wishlist on one side. But the amount of compensation is cut off greatly ... These two economic entities of the Russian Federation and Ukraine wanted to sue for more than 100 billion money ...
    1. Nikolai Grek
      Nikolai Grek 1 March 2018 20: 22
      0
      Quote: Antares
      I don’t know how much one day delay for Gazprom costs

      like Ukrainians said that 500 thousand !!
    2. Lev Bronsch
      Lev Bronsch 2 March 2018 21: 32
      0
      Thanks for the sane comment! wink
  31. Goldmitro
    Goldmitro 1 March 2018 11: 28
    +1
    When it comes to our liberals seated in power that all attempts to find truth and justice in the West in the institutions that he created, supposedly strictly following international law, for Russia will always end in a blow to her rights, interests, prestige, and WILL NOT be otherwise ! Throughout its history, Russia has been and remains a bone in the throat of the West, which interferes with swallowing the whole world, and he always did and will do EVERYTHING possible on all "fronts" to eliminate it!
  32. XXXIII
    XXXIII 1 March 2018 12: 40
    +2
    28 February 2018, 15: 00
    Alexey Miller: Blue Stream has become a powerful catalyst for the development of the Turkish gas market
    And someone already notes the defeat ..... And there is no matter what concerns our earthly .... lol
    ps Where is infa Alekseich, it’s good to fill in the blue ..... lol
  33. sib.ataman
    sib.ataman 1 March 2018 13: 38
    +2
    I would be very surprised if this court sided with Gazprom! Well, now it remains to wait for the bailiffs on the tanks to recover everything that you like! Oh, how grandfather Stalin was wise when he took the last pennies from a half-starved and dilapidated country and spent it on nuclear and missile projects! Now, these judges and plaintiffs can conduct anal-masturbatory prophylaxis to each other to reduce their own hatred and anger, while these “freaking” Muscovites will do a gas tap back and forth.
  34. eugraphus
    eugraphus 2 March 2018 07: 02
    0
    That's the way Gazprom trades, and what else should it stay!
  35. Lev Bronsch
    Lev Bronsch 2 March 2018 21: 30
    0
    Dear commentators, just read these contracts online! They are available in any search engine and each of 10-12 pages is available. Briefly - we need to pray for the Stockholm arbitration, because for good, such contracts, especially gas sales and purchases, simply need to be recognized as null and void! and we were awarded 2 billion percent with it !! And there is the essence of what - the obligation of Ukraine to buy 52 billion cubic meters. per year, with total consumption less than this figure and Ukraine’s own production at 20 billion !! This is a clear corruption scheme. And the arbitration affirmed the provisions of the contract, yes, brought the gas volume on a take-or-pay basis in accordance with the realities, but at the same time set the price for the previous period at $ 93 per 1000 cubic meters than we took from Naftogaz !! Yes, this is a fairy tale, not a solution ...
    Now about transit: in 2009 we signed 110 billion cubic meters of guaranteed pumping through the Ukrainian gas transportation system. At the same time, in 2008, the SP-1 project was completed, in 2009 permissions for laying from a number of countries are obtained! while the general pumping to the East / West. Europe did not fall below 120 billion a year !! Gazprom website to help you, and I subtracted Finland and the Baltic states. Well? If we sign a contract that we are certainly NOT going to fulfill? Otherwise, why do we stretch the pipe 55 billion cubic meters at the time of signing the contract? Thanks to the arbitration, I must say that I did not accept the Ukrainian sum. Most likely, the profit earned by Naftogaz from the transit for 10 years has been taken into account. Again, what for to hammer such figure in the contract and then in no way to try to correct it ?? And why it was impossible to indicate 60-70 billion cubic meters, as the lower limit on the profitability of pumping through the hydraulic system?
    In general, the flagrant incompetence of Gazprom lawyers and executives !! And our luck that the main parameters of the contracts were confirmed by the arbitration on the basis of "continental" law - the contract has been signed, must be fulfilled. Well, special thanks to the idiocy of Naftogaz! laughing
  36. logobobah
    logobobah 3 March 2018 02: 40
    0
    Quote: andrej-shironov
    Quote: 1vlad19
    Naive Jewish ... We are deep and far away, he will try to set or block the SP-2 conditions for the geyrop, we won’t drive gas through the on / off, let them drown with wood. Maybe a hundred or two from hypothermia will die. And gas will go along the Power of Siberia to China.

    laughing Aha ha! Another sacred believer in infallibility you yourself know whom

    Explain why the decision of this arbitration is related to yourself you know with whom. If in this arbitration the decision is made just like in sports, then these decisions have helped you know who you are. For me, this is an indicator of the independence and objectivity of these courts themselves.
    I’m wondering what will happen next. In theory, you need to think about it, but is it necessary to do sp2? The risks are high. Any clown can throw suits. Maybe enough already built gas pipelines? Transit through Ukraine - well, it’s easier to close immediately than these courts to lead them. It remains only to pump through existing pipelines and if Europe does not have enough gas (and I think it will not be enough) then let them pull SP2 at their own expense.