Military Review

Mikhail Khazin: On the role and place of Putin

113
Mikhail Khazin: On the role and place of Putin



I don’t think I’ll reveal a big secret if I say that the propaganda attacks on Putin in the Western media are constantly increasing. The last topic is direct participation (not to say, the role of the main organizer) in the process of “brexit” (that is, British withdrawal from the European Union). In this case, we are not talking about evidence at all. But if the stars are lit, as the great Russian poet says, it means that someone needs it. And here is the question: why? In the end, there is the old rule: “there is no“ good ”PR or“ bad ”PR. He is either there or there is none. ” That is, in fact, thanks to such propaganda, Putin, although they are trying to demonize him, is still becoming an increasingly significant figure in the Western world. And why should they?

The answer to this question is, in general, more or less clear. I already wrote that the political plane is described by two main axes - left-right and liberal-conservative. And the last 35 years the world has developed under constant pressure and victories of right-liberal ideas. Actually, all famous stories with the development of homosexuality and other sexual perversions, the destruction of the family and other joys - this is just the implementation of liberal ideas. With the domination of bankers and a sharp increase in the stratification of people by income, of course.

But it has been several years since the pendulum has swung to the other side. This is most pronounced in the United States, where politics is most public. And we see how, on the one hand, the right-liberal ideology has swung to the left and left-wing liberal Sanders appeared (who would have defeated Clinton and Trump, if only the apparatus of the US Democratic Party was not controlled by the Clinton team by means of overt falsifications; By the way, they accused Putin again). On the other hand, the right-liberal ideology has swung to the conservative side and the right-wing conservative Trump has appeared, about which everyone already knows everything.

But if we move on (which is inevitable in the conditions of the crisis), then we find ourselves in the left-conservative sector. And if you recall history, the only stable left-conservative state in history is the Stalinist USSR. Then the movement towards liberalism began, with all the known results. And a sharp increase in interest (and positive attitude) towards Russia in the world among ordinary people is the result of what Russia is perceived as a phantom image of the USSR. It's clear that the right-wing liberal elite of the West does not like it very much.

But there is one more important circumstance. This is the role of the leader of the left-conservative USSR. This is the position of Stalin. In our country, his figure was wildly demonized (even during the late USSR and in the post-Soviet period), which, however, during the crisis led to the fact that his image (not historical, of course, but the same phantom) is supported by 80% of the population. But this is ours, since Stalin, after all, is a figure of our history and in each family either still exists, or quite recently there were people who had or have their own opinion about it, based on personal observations. And in the world, all the historical tales (mostly, contrasted by Stalin’s image as part of the campaign) are not very interesting, they are not very interested in their own history. But the phantom image of the USSR inevitably restores the closely related phantom image of Stalin.

Which, against the background of complete idleness of the right-liberal political elite (ordinary citizens do not see the real elite) looks more and more pretty. Not to say - the only way out of the situation. A man who acted in the interests of his people and at the same time won! What could be more relevant today? Given that the current leaders defiantly refuse to take any action, let alone think about the people. The trick is that the phantom image should somehow be visualized. The USSR is visualized in the image of modern Russia. And Stalin? And Stalin, of course, in the image of Putin.

It should be noted that Putin’s image in the West is strikingly different from his image in Russia, where he is also constantly complained that he refuses to act in part of removing the right-liberal elite group from power, which is destroying the Russian economy and leading people to impoverishment . That is, behaves opposite to the method of Stalin. But in the West, such details are unknown, including due to liberal propaganda. As a result, in the eyes of the western population, the phantom image of Stalin more and more “sticks together” with the image of real Putin.

Which, of course, causes the rabid hatred of the right-liberal elites. And because it causes hereditary horror that covered these elites in the mid-twentieth century (until the end of the 70-s) when they almost lost (in reality they lost, only the post-Stalinist elites of the USSR refused to draw this prize). And because they are wildly afraid that the old logic of Stalin may cause from non-existence those political forces in their own countries, which they, already after 1991, have considered disappeared. And, finally, because they themselves do not see a way out of the situation and understand that the situation will only get worse. And, accordingly, because the campaign to demonize Putin will only increase.

It’s another thing that Putin himself does not use this entire opportunity to improve his personal rating and the rating of Russia. Until? May be. But you need to be aware that if you don’t support the “gluing” described above for a long time, then another phantom image of Stalin may appear. And then it will be not only much more difficult to defend oneself against the charges already made, but it is hardly possible at all. Because you can get the image of a loser, and nobody defends a loser.

There are some grounds for believing that Putin may use the election campaign that has begun to change his policy. We'll see. But it seems to me that these considerations should play an important role in determining the new, post-election policy of Putin. Since the story rushed at a gallop and there was no time for waiting and maneuvers.
Author:
Originator:
https://izborsk-club.ru/14699
113 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must to register.

I have an account? Sign in

  1. Grandfather
    Grandfather 28 January 2018 05: 13
    32
    There is some reason to believe that Putin can use the campaign that has begun to change his policy. We will see.
    and friends, oligarchs, allow?
    1. Vard
      Vard 28 January 2018 05: 42
      +8
      And where will they go ... Everyone wants to live ...
      1. Esoteric
        Esoteric 28 January 2018 06: 50
        15
        Quote: Vard
        And where will they go ... Everyone wants to live ...

        So the picture stands before my eyes: Putin called Lisin or the same Usmanov to the Kremlin, shorter than all 96 billionaires (Medvedev will figure it out), talked to them “hard” and let go for the time being. And at night, these billionaires have the same dream (everyone !!! belay ):
        1. Don Analyst
          Don Analyst 28 January 2018 20: 52
          +9
          Rather, Chubais Tolik will summon Putin to himself and say - what kind of social demagogy have you spread here, into the shackles of all this patriotic Russia, into the bank bondage of one and all.
          This is a real political situation ...
          1. Overlock
            Overlock 29 January 2018 01: 12
            +8
            Quote: Don Analyst
            This is a real political situation ...

        2. Overlock
          Overlock 29 January 2018 01: 11
          +2
          only the Saudis can afford, barbarians, what can you get from them!
      2. weksha50
        weksha50 28 January 2018 11: 28
        +6
        Quote: Vard
        And where will they go ... Everybody wants to live ...


        Hmm ... as well as the one in question ...
        THEM have the ability to "enforce peaceful coexistence" - no less, if not more ... request Alas...
      3. Nick
        Nick 30 January 2018 00: 27
        0
        Quote: Vard
        And where will they go ... Everyone wants to live ...

        ... And not just live, but in comfort, wink hi and not on the southern coast of the Arctic Ocean ...
    2. siberalt
      siberalt 28 January 2018 06: 17
      15
      Putin without his old team? belay This is a complete system.
      1. populist
        populist 28 January 2018 09: 20
        20
        siberalt
        Putin without his old team? belay This is a complete system.

        Absolutely right! Command, power system. The guarantor cannot change the economic model and himself - he is not capable.
        [media = http: //b1.imgsrc.ru/p/pycu4/9/13184439lqB.
        jpg]
      2. vladimirZ
        vladimirZ 28 January 2018 09: 22
        23
        V. Putin is the creator of the current oligarchy, over its period their number has grown from 10 to 100. How can he abandon this system if he is friendly, financially connected with them? One of his features is that he is faithful to friends and associates.
        So, there will be no change in politics after the election, if he remains President. Everything will continue to roll down: the economy, the impoverishment of the people amid growing wealth of the oligarchs.
        But what will it bring to Russia itself against the background of the hybrid war declared by it by the West, the USA?
        The only chance to change something, to elect another President of Russia. Moreover, this chance has one candidate of the Left Front, the Communist Party - Pavel Grudinin.
        1. SPACE
          SPACE 28 January 2018 12: 01
          +6
          Quote: vladimirZ
          what will it bring to Russia itself against the backdrop of the hybrid war declared by it by the West, the USA,?

          Warriors fight in any war, armies, soldiers and generals, machine guns and cartridges fight on the battlefield of a conventional war. In the information war, journalists, newspaper and TV reporters, microphones, cameras, flash drives. In the economic war, oligarchs and economists are financiers, factories, factories, goods and money. Each special war requires its own types of troops, its generals and commanders.
          So Putin, in fact, like Stalin, does everything correctly and logically. And what will your Grudinin offer? Honest honesty and love for the ephemeral people? By the way, people are smart and not very people, good and bad, and just like you.
          In war, in the army there can be no democracy and the commander in chief is not changed. And regardless of whether the soldier understands what is happening on the battlefield, he is obliged to carry out the order, and then think about his own skin or execution. Everything for the front, everything for victory, although traitors and rear rats will always be there.
          1. Karabin
            Karabin 28 January 2018 16: 27
            11
            In the information war, journalists, newspaper and TV reporters, microphones, cameras, flash drives. In the economic war, oligarchs and economists are financiers, factories, factories, goods and money.
            Good army. Goodbye and huckster. They can’t eat, everyone thinks about Russia. How is she there?
            Quote: SPACE
            So Putin, in fact, like Stalin

            But where to Stalin before Putin! negative
            Quote: SPACE
            Everything for the front, everything for the victory,

            Zampolit, wipe the pince-nez. Your informational-oligarchic army and Putin dug themselves dugouts with all the comforts on the territory of the enemy, children and households settled in them and themselves more often there than here.
        2. Victor N
          Victor N 28 January 2018 14: 52
          +4
          The change is taking place, you just could not notice it. However, to act inconspicuously when observers suddenly notice the result - this is aerobatics!
          1. Karabin
            Karabin 28 January 2018 16: 38
            13
            Quote: Victor N
            However, to act inconspicuously when observers suddenly notice the result - this is aerobatics!

            Aerobatics is when you don’t do a damn thing, but you are considered someone outstanding. And if you do, what does not fit into expectations, then the Cunning Plan is immediately invented.
        3. vitalm
          vitalm 28 January 2018 19: 45
          0
          And you will live in strawberries laughing
        4. Sergey Horuzhik
          Sergey Horuzhik 28 January 2018 23: 24
          0
          for the victory of Marxism-sternism!
        5. Sergey Horuzhik
          Sergey Horuzhik 28 January 2018 23: 29
          0
          What kind of barmaley is it crawling right into the mausoleum?
      3. Separ DNR
        Separ DNR 28 January 2018 13: 37
        +5
        Quote: siberalt
        Putin without his old team? belay This is a complete system.

        A nightmare: Putin without oligarchs (which are not in power ...) ...
    3. To be or not to be
      To be or not to be 28 January 2018 10: 43
      10
      Satanovsky .. burst ..
    4. Vladimir 5
      Vladimir 5 28 January 2018 22: 03
      +7
      Vladimir Putin, as a politician, is weak and he is being led: following the instructions: he flies, dives, now he’s climbed into the hole. USSR and 30 million Russians (demographic statistics, and his famous saying). So the laid egg V. Putin will not fight the chicken - a liberal Chubais environment in power ...
  2. Mezzotint
    Mezzotint 28 January 2018 05: 56
    +5
    Yes, Putin has so far been somehow not enough Putin ... Too soft and kind.
    1. siberalt
      siberalt 28 January 2018 06: 25
      13
      Grudinin, too, is somehow lacking. lol
      1. The comment was deleted.
      2. Stas157
        Stas157 28 January 2018 08: 54
        17
        Quote: siberalt
        Grudinin, too, is somehow lacking. lol. [/ img]

        What does Stalin and Grudinin have to do with it? Grudinin the way it is, no one does not adapt. A strong boss, a real man, a fair one ... What Putin cannot boast of.
        It is difficult to blame liberal Putin for sympathizing with Stalin, but nevertheless, if you take a psychological image, then Putin is more like Stalin. A quiet voice, never a speaker, secretive, master of cunning plans ... such a liberal "Stalin" who defends himself and the Russian oligarchs from world "evil", and leads through life. Well, the rest of the people are trailers, according to the residual principle.
        1. The comment was deleted.
          1. Overlock
            Overlock 28 January 2018 12: 35
            +4
            Quote: seos
            it is necessary to agree with the Hahel ...

            all wars once end. And you have to agree with the Hahel. So Surkov works in this thread. You suppose. that Ukraine will resolve itself? I assure you, no. This is a problem for decades and will have to be negotiated. Unless you drop the atomic bomb on them, but they also have enough of their own (nuclear power plants). So there are negotiations and negotiations.
            1. Northern warrior
              Northern warrior 28 January 2018 13: 39
              +2
              It is better to walk through a mazepia with a steel skating rink than trying to talk to degenerates. Loss So they were, are and will be in any war. Have you seen the staff roll out the Syrian Racca with air strikes? Do you think we can not surpass them in this field? We can and surpass! The birds are just waiting for the command from above to rise to the sky with "gifts" in their paws.
              1. Overlock
                Overlock 28 January 2018 19: 05
                +1
                Quote: Northern warrior
                Loss So they were, are and will be in any war

                there are material losses, there are human losses, there are moral / image losses. What is afraid of GDP?
                1. Northern warrior
                  Northern warrior 29 January 2018 01: 34
                  0
                  Russia has already suffered losses for four years, so an open conflict will not change much. The potential risks for the country from the reserve of idiots at hand exceed the costs of a military operation many times over. No one talks about the occupation of territories, but a hostile regime must be swept away. Better be a wild field torn by gangs than a unitary Russophobic entity with NATO bases from Kharkov to Odessa.
              2. Overlock
                Overlock 28 January 2018 19: 24
                0
                By the way, one sociological office in Ukraine conducted a survey: will you go to partisan against Russia or not? 51% - "YES"
                1. Northern warrior
                  Northern warrior 29 January 2018 01: 43
                  +2
                  This is not Vietnam - the jungle is not there! How many people will tear ass from a warm sofa and go to the woods to dig caches? No, there are undoubtedly those who are stubborn, but there are not more than a few thousand. It is impossible to compare the 404 population with Chechens and Afghans - those warriors who have been able to hold a machine gun in their hands since childhood, and their religion motivates them to fight against infidels. Haremongers are ordinary traitors, informers, thieves, licking, but not warriors, ready to lay their heads in the struggle for their beliefs. Do you think that a German accidentally managed to occupy the entire territory of 404 during the Second World War, but stumbled on the territory of present-day Russia? Ukroshluha always fall under the strong, but then betray the "master" who has lost strength.
                2. Hlavaty
                  Hlavaty 29 January 2018 10: 23
                  0
                  Quote: Overlock
                  one sociological office in Ukraine conducted a survey

                  It already sounds like the beginning of a joke! Stop trusting opinion polls, especially Ukrainian ones. Some Mykola interviewed his drinking buddies and published the results. And you are already making far-reaching conclusions from this nonsense.
                  1. Overlock
                    Overlock 30 January 2018 18: 27
                    +1
                    Quote: Hlavaty
                    And you are already making far-reaching conclusions from this nonsense.

                    you reason like EBN. I felt this nonsense on my own skin. It was you who woke up and asked yourself: "What have you done for Ukraine?" and made what happened what happened. And Natsik has been growing since 1999 thanks to such blind people as you. And now sprinkle our heads with ash. Silent, "wise guy"
                    1. Hlavaty
                      Hlavaty 30 January 2018 22: 02
                      0
                      Quote: Overlock
                      I felt this nonsense on my own skin.

                      51% OF YOUR FAMILIAR UKRAINIANS ARE READY TO GO TO PARTISANATE? If so, then I sympathize with you. I have a completely different environment. Which I wish you too.
                      Although they say everything similar is mutually attracted ....

                      Quote: Overlock
                      Silent, "wise guy"

                      You’ll shut up all commentators. Will you discuss with yourself?
                      1. Overlock
                        Overlock 30 January 2018 22: 27
                        0
                        Quote: Hlavaty
                        51% OF YOUR FAMILIAR UKRAINIANS ARE READY TO GO TO PARTISANATE?

                        would you even read what was written! I am from the Crimea! I traveled to Ukraine. Ukraine must be read and studied! Nowhere without it!
                        I know how much the Malyshev factory is working, I have been there. Pavlograd also visited. Note. They said- When the Union for a week-long bunch of local newspapers of Germany gave a monetary reward
                      2. Hlavaty
                        Hlavaty 31 January 2018 08: 30
                        0
                        Quote: Overlock
                        Ukraine must be read and studied!

                        While you study it, I live in it, and I see everything with my own eyes.
          2. Sling cutter
            Sling cutter 28 January 2018 13: 00
            15
            Quote: seos
            Putin can boast that he is not a sub-mattress, unlike Grudinin

            Come on belay Again chatter and snack!
            Colleague Freeman already answered such a zaputinets:
            And now we read what Grudinin said, and not just spun "expaird"
            - And what, in your opinion, will be with the Donetsk and Lugansk people's republics?
            - Of course, the Minsk agreements played an important role in ending the genocide of the population of these republics. But the fighting there continues, albeit not with so many casualties among the civilian population. Bandera shortcomings daily bombard cities and villages of the DPR and LPR, as a result of which ordinary people suffer and die. The Minsk agreements turned into a kind of screen for the preparation of a forceful solution to the "problems of New Russia".
            I am convinced that Russia, in view of the frank sabotage by Kiev of these agreements, should take the next logical step: recognize the will of the people expressed in referenda in 2014 and recognize the independence of these republics.
            And then you can not keep the population of the LPR and the DPR in limbo. Recall that initially the Donbass is a purely Russian region. He, along with Kharkov, Dnepropetrovsk, Odessa, was transferred to the Ukrainian Soviet Socialist Republic by a decree of the Council of People's Commissars to strengthen the industrial power of the then rural Ukraine. Therefore, if the population of Donbass (mainly Russian) shows a will to return to Russia, then we must seriously consider this possibility. If we took Crimea into Russia, it would be natural to satisfy the desire of the population of Donbass to return to Russia.
            http://sovross.ru/articles/1647/37509/comments/2#
            comments
            1. seos
              seos 28 January 2018 21: 21
              +2
              On TV, I talked about something completely different ... and something vaguely mumbled on questions regarding Crimea and Donbas ... and you can understand it, say that our Crimea will lose Western support, tell Ukrainians everyone will send it as they sent Navalny ...
              Now, then naturally, with political scientists, everything was discussed with the mattresses; permission was asked to hait them and order ....
              Now Navalny is beyond Crimea! but no one believes him ...
              You can tell a lot about a person by looking at his speeches ... Grudinin interested me, I listened to what he was saying ... and I realized that he was hanging noodles ... this is clear from the answers ... by reaction to questions, etc. ... I'm sure that he is a tramp inmate.
              1. Sling cutter
                Sling cutter 28 January 2018 22: 07
                10
                Quote: seos
                On TV, I talked about something completely different.

                If you remove the TV from your head, you will feel better!
                And with a duroscope, you and milk yields are growing, and we have defeated everyone, and we have grown industry, corruption has been defeated, and Nedimon is the best prime minister of all time wassat
                Quote: seos
                Grudinin interested me, I listened to what he was saying ... and I realized that he was hanging noodles ... this is clear from the answers ... from the reaction to questions, etc. ... I'm sure that he is a tramp in bed.

                Vote for Nedimon, Kudrin, Sechin, Shuvalov, Friedman, Potanin, Surkov, Kinder Surprise, Timchenko, Rottenberg, Michelson, Shalamov, Serdyukov, Vasilyev, etc. .....
                This is Putin’s team. Come on, go ahead, vote ......
              2. yehat
                yehat 30 January 2018 12: 28
                0
                Well, who is the sternum, I don’t want to guess, but I’ll note the same thing as you -
                regularly jarring some of his answers. I heard strange things from him several times,
                which are alarming. In this regard, Zyuganov is much less concerned.
        2. Hlavaty
          Hlavaty 28 January 2018 17: 54
          +3
          Quote: Stas157
          What does Stalin and Grudinin have to do with it?

          Grudinin is not interesting in itself. An interesting fact is its appearance. The article has a good thought:
          Another thing is that Putin himself does not use this entire opportunity to increase his personal rating and Russia's rating. Until? May be. But you need to be aware that if you do not maintain the “bonding” described above for a long time, then another phantom image of Stalin may appear.

          The appearance of Grudinin is a sign that people are beginning to look for “another phantom image of Stalin,” and at the same time a signal to Putin that beautiful speeches of people are no longer comforting. We need real victories that every Russian can feel.
          Yes, Grudinin is clearly not drawn to a new leader, but he personifies the popular demand for a new leader. And if there is such a request, then a leader will appear. Or a talented mimic of a leader.
          1. Stas157
            Stas157 28 January 2018 19: 35
            +9
            Quote: Hlavaty
            Yes Grudinin clearly does not pull on a new leader

            Do you know what qualities a leader should have? From the point of view of psychology, Putin does not have leadership qualities, which can not be said about Grudinin. Grudinin is a natural leader. Direct, courageous, striving for his shortest way, generous ... Putin, on the contrary! Secretive, not direct, master of cunning plans, afraid of opponents (public disputes, where he can be lowered in rank), very well-considered and will not take risks once again, outwardly seems kind (even sugary), but this is more likely a form of behavior, it is more convenient for him . Putin is a man of compromise with any enemies, and even where he should not be. I do not think this is bad, by the way! Maybe our country with a relatively weak economy is just what is needed. But, alas, these are not leadership qualities at all.
            1. Hlavaty
              Hlavaty 28 January 2018 22: 51
              +1
              Quote: Stas157
              Do you know what qualities a leader should have?

              We need not just a leader, but a NEW leader. One that can give people a NEW goal and inspire to achieve this goal.
              Previously, the goal was to survive. It was just about food, a roof over your head, security, etc. (the first two levels of the Maslow pyramid). The goal is achieved. It is necessary to set the following goal. Otherwise, society will begin to disintegrate (who is in the woods for firewood), moral decline, drug addiction, alcoholism, suicide and other problems will begin.
              By the way, the next level of the Maslow pyramid is the "need for belonging and love." That the people will begin to intensively search in different sects, religions, nationalist movements and political organizations. And this is the favorite battlefield of Americans and Europeans. From this they successfully grow the "orange revolution" and the Maidan.
        3. Sergey Horuzhik
          Sergey Horuzhik 28 January 2018 23: 27
          0
          kuda-kuda sterninum?
      3. Sergey Horuzhik
        Sergey Horuzhik 28 January 2018 23: 25
        0

        Raise it higher!
  3. Proton
    Proton 28 January 2018 06: 54
    22
    Under Stalin, the whole "elite" went on hippies, and right now they do what they want, so that there’s nothing to compare Stalin with Putin am
    1. gla172
      gla172 28 January 2018 07: 06
      +9
      ... I agree ... they were afraid of going to managerial positions and were unlocked to the last ... because responsibility was for the task entrusted .... but right now? ....
    2. Same lech
      Same lech 28 January 2018 07: 45
      +6
      The illegal withdrawal of capital from Russia continues to accelerate, Deputy Chairman of the Central Bank Dmitry Skobelkin said at a meeting of the State Duma Committee on Financial Markets.
      One of the most popular ways to make money with your feet is an irrevocable loan from a foreign company. At the same time, the Russian legal entity that has lent is declared bankrupt, and the offshore recipient transfers the money to a third company, after which they dissolve almost without a trace.

      ➡ Source: https://publizist.ru/blogs/108984/22955/35?utm_so
      urce = finobzor.ru
      smile Chubais is fattening on state grubs ... well, a crook belay
    3. Stas157
      Stas157 28 January 2018 09: 29
      11
      Quote: Proton
      Under Stalin, the whole "elite" went on hippies, and right now they do what they want, so that there’s nothing to compare Stalin with Putin am

      This hour is also afraid. They say that his unblinking eyes can not stand. Stalin, of course, is far from liberal Putin, but he can fall into the top ten, easily. But, this applies only to the completely untied type of Khodorkovsky, because the good Tsar Putin serves the interests of the oligarchs most of all.
    4. seos
      seos 28 January 2018 11: 46
      +2
      There is nothing to compare Stalin with the corrupt Sisyan ... Stalin was the Great Leader.
      Photos of Stalin with a face of Grudinin is a direct insult to the history of our country and our people ...
      1. Yegorchik
        Yegorchik 28 January 2018 21: 15
        +6
        Quote: seos
        it is a direct insult to the history of our country and our people ...

        A direct insult to our people is the bashful hanging of the mausoleum during the parades, at the foot of which the victorious people threw Nazi banners. And a direct insult to our country is a thief in power.
  4. Monster_Fat
    Monster_Fat 28 January 2018 06: 59
    11
    Stalin, of course, in the image of Putin.

    Seriously? winked
  5. vlad007
    vlad007 28 January 2018 07: 20
    +7
    Unfortunately, little depends on Putin - it’s not he who gives the cards, but as they rightly say about him, he plays well with bad cards. Bad cards are events in Ukraine, falling oil prices, demographic situation, etc.
    1. Stas157
      Stas157 28 January 2018 09: 43
      22
      Quote: vlad007
      Unfortunately, little depends on Putin - it’s not he who gives the cards, but as they rightly say about him, he plays well with bad cards. Bad cards are events in Ukraine, falling oil prices, demographic situation, etc.

      Little depends on those who do not play. Putin is a stable player. The tops are not enough, but will not miss their own. He refers to the most fierce enemies, as someone calls his friends and partners and respects them very much. It won’t go to aggravation, there won’t be a direct answer, even though you hit him with a plane! A master of asymmetric answers and tomatoes, literally in everything! What events in Ukraine to take is the rejection of the idea of ​​New Russia and the non-recognition of Donbass. But Crimea pinched off! This is his Everest. That in Syria, Assad defended, but he lost half of the territory of modern Syria with oil to partners. That the Russian economy-saved the economy and the oligarchs, at the expense of the shoulders of the people, collapsing the ruble in half, essentially making the common man as much poorer.
      1. groks
        groks 28 January 2018 11: 13
        +5
        Well yes. After Siluanov sequentially spat in his physics, and then Shoigu - he is a strong player.
        1. The comment was deleted.
          1. groks
            groks 28 January 2018 13: 12
            +6
            Well, at least something could be read, except for himself? The first said that the instructions for 2012 will not even be executed at 17, and the second is just Whack - he promised to cope at 17.
            Five years have passed. FIVE.
            1. Golovan Jack
              Golovan Jack 28 January 2018 13: 18
              +6
              Quote: groks
              The first said that the instructions for 2012 will not even be executed at 17, and the second is just Whack - he promised to cope at 17

              I’m aware of this. But about it -
              Quote: groks
              Siluanov, and then Shoigu, sequentially spat at him in physics

              - "up to date", the campaign, only you request
              1. groks
                groks 28 January 2018 14: 08
                +5
                Slowing down again? You can search directly on this site. Not, well, if you are from the sect of the Witnesses of the FMM, then of course - the oligarchy is a mat and the father is native.
      2. SPACE
        SPACE 28 January 2018 12: 06
        +3
        Quote: Stas157
        collapsing the ruble twice, essentially making it as much poorer than the average person

        This is how, explain?
      3. Overlock
        Overlock 28 January 2018 12: 38
        +7
        Quote: Stas157
        That the Russian economy saved the economy and the oligarchs, at the expense of the shoulders of the people, having collapsed the ruble twice, essentially making the common man as much poorer.

        This is what I liked most
      4. BecmepH
        BecmepH 29 January 2018 08: 00
        +2
        Quote: Stas157
        But Crimea pinched off!

        I think that GDP was just lucky with the Crimea. So the card went down. And events unfolded not by the will of GDP. Those. I want to say that no plan for the Crimea has been developed. I repeat: "He was lucky!"
        1. 406ppm2gv
          406ppm2gv 29 January 2018 20: 34
          +3
          I adhere to the same view, Crimea itself nipped off, it would have been difficult, but nipped off.
  6. rotmistr60
    rotmistr60 28 January 2018 07: 30
    11
    The fact that GDP for Western liberalism is enemy No. 1 has been clear for a long time. But such active-aggressive actions in the pre-election period indicate that the West believes that there is one last chance for him to change power in Russia, and there may be no other chance. So it remains only to wait, but what vile provocation will the proponents of "democracy and human rights" arrange tomorrow? And the president will just have to deal with his “team” after the election. Otherwise, the rating from sky-high heights could fall sharply with the consequences that come from here.
    1. Monster_Fat
      Monster_Fat 28 January 2018 07: 39
      17
      Are you serious? Well, what kind of "enemy" is he ... is it really still not clear that Russia in the "big game" of "big uncles" is "canned food" that Putin or someone else must save from premature plunder before the transition of the "world community" to the next stage of globalization. wink
      1. rotmistr60
        rotmistr60 28 January 2018 07: 42
        +8
        Well, if Russia is a "canned food" that protects GDP for the West, then there are even no questions for you, because it is clear who you represent.
        1. Tatanka Yotanka
          Tatanka Yotanka 28 January 2018 10: 34
          11
          Quote: rotmistr60
          Well, if Russia is a "canned food" that protects GDP for the West, then there are even no questions for you, because it is clear who you represent.

          who is the ministry of education then if the ministers openly say that consumers are needed and not thinkers, and all sorts of grefs are completely in solidarity with such a task, in the old days they would have flied right away and felled the forest, but here they live hello and continue to steer fulfilling the task
      2. Golovan Jack
        Golovan Jack 28 January 2018 07: 54
        +8
        Quote: Monster_Fat
        Russia-in the "big game" "big uncles" is "canned food"

        Ahem ... cool model. A couple of questions:
        - where firewood intelligence? Manyu Thatcher with "15 million Russians" - not to offer.
        - What kind of "big uncles" are they?
        Thank you yes
        1. Monster_Fat
          Monster_Fat 28 January 2018 08: 09
          15
          And, that links to someone from Yale, Stanford, Cambridge, etc., are necessary. Information can come from different sources and each of them needs to be analyzed according to a comparison of different sources, their experience, education, social circle, etc. You can assume that this exactly my conclusion is ... wink
          1. Golovan Jack
            Golovan Jack 28 January 2018 08: 13
            +8
            Quote: Monster_Fat
            You can assume that this is exactly my conclusion!

            The fact that this is your conclusion does not cause doubts. And what about
            Quote: Monster_Fat
            different sources, their experience, education, social circle, etc.

            - to be honest, there are some doubts.
            Therefore, he asked what specific sources. Well, or considerations that to conclusions usually, ahem ... happen. And from which, in fact, conclusions are drawn yes
            1. Monster_Fat
              Monster_Fat 28 January 2018 09: 01
              +5
              There are many “Sources”, I also communicate in different forums (and on the Censor too, yes, yes ... wink ) the opinions of different people are very interesting, there is something to listen to ... I just read it recently, maybe someone will be interested ....
              http://www.iarex.ru/articles/55381.html?utm_sourc
              e = finobzor.ru
              1. Golovan Jack
                Golovan Jack 28 January 2018 11: 20
                +6
                Quote: Monster_Fat
                I just read it maybe someone will be interested

                I read it. Alas, I have not discovered anything fundamentally new to myself (I am about facts now). Forecasts, IMHO, are quite robust, not the first time I've seen them, by the way.
                "About canned food" - did not find out a source of information. Unfortunately.
                Keep on "shocking Narott" wink
      3. samarin1969
        samarin1969 28 January 2018 08: 38
        +8
        Quote: Monster_Fat
        Well, what kind of "enemy" is he ... is it really still not clear that Russia in the "big game" of "big uncles" is "canned food" that Putin or someone else must save from premature plunder before the transition of the "world community" to the next stage of globalization

        You are right, dear. hi This is the essence of his policy: the people of Russia - separately, the resources ("canned") of Russia - separately. Everything else is staged shows. Mr. Khazin said a lot of things here which he hardly believes. But in one thing he is right - propagandists are increasingly "trying on" the "uniform" of Stalin on the modern Guarantor.
        1. Monster_Fat
          Monster_Fat 28 January 2018 10: 16
          +5
          The subject reminds me very much of Captain Zhiglov from "The Place of Meeting ..." - that same-burned September, like a patriot, and a professional "from God," stands behind his "mountain", etc., but, as the other said about him, "not from the system "man:" He is a bad man .... For him, people are nothing rubbish ..... "
      4. Don Analyst
        Don Analyst 28 January 2018 21: 04
        0
        What a pity the West - die from botulism, the shelf life of our "canned food" is very old ...
  7. Fedorov
    Fedorov 28 January 2018 07: 45
    +8
    And what did the author mean by this? We are in the kitchen and in the smoking room and discuss more.
    Putin is clear for the next term. And then what? Will the little dogs come? Or will the entire House-2 be replaced in the Duma by Zhirinovsky and Zyuganov? Well there Valuev still is, but from all will not wave.
    1. kepmor
      kepmor 28 January 2018 08: 52
      +4
      who? who? ... and the faithful LAD at what? ... it’s too early to write it off ...
  8. Metlik
    Metlik 28 January 2018 07: 54
    19
    For Western business circles, Putin is useful and .... rather than Stalin. While the team, approved in Washington, squanders Russia's budget into bridges and stadiums, corporations are taking over Russian factories, brands and our market as a whole. To ruin the economy and sell off the remaining state enterprises is the program of these people for the next six years.
    1. kush62
      kush62 28 January 2018 08: 21
      +5
      Metlik Today, 07:54 AM New
      For Western business circles, Putin is useful and .... rather than Stalin. While the team, approved in Washington, squanders Russia's budget into bridges and stadiums, corporations are taking over Russian factories, brands and our market as a whole. To ruin the economy and sell off the remaining state enterprises is the program of these people for the next six years.

      Tales of the collapse of the economy are not tired? In the 90s they ruined it to the bottom. Now a little raised. to break up? Some kind of nonsense turns out. You can still believe in “tidy up”.
      1. Metlik
        Metlik 28 January 2018 09: 14
        +4
        Quote: kush62
        Tales of the collapse of the economy are not tired?

        To start privatization again, you need to again create a 90s situation. The Gaidar model - the worse - the better it continues to work. In order to sell the defense to our “friends” from NATO - ministers must show Putin - these plants are unprofitable.
        1. kush62
          kush62 28 January 2018 13: 14
          +2
          Metlik Today, 09:14 ↑ New
          Quote: kush62
          Tales of the collapse of the economy are not tired?
          To start privatization again, you need to again create a 90s situation. The Gaidar model - the worse - the better it continues to work. In order to sell the defense to our “friends” from NATO - ministers must show Putin - these plants are unprofitable.

          Therefore, the Kazan aircraft plant and other defense plants were loaded with work for 10 years ahead. Very cunning system of collapse. Only very advanced sofas can solve HPP laughing .
      2. Antianglosax
        Antianglosax 28 January 2018 12: 54
        +7
        Quote: kush62
        For Western business circles, Putin is useful and ....,

        Apparently, all the disagreements of our authorities with the Western pack of cannibals are only about who will rob Russia. Our thieves want to do this on their own, and the western one believes that our scum of the snout did not work out for such a fatty piece. That’s the whole point of friction.
    2. Sergey Horuzhik
      Sergey Horuzhik 29 January 2018 00: 46
      +2
      and, most importantly, your Mosk will be stolen. And you have such a powerful Mosk, more than 10 okodemikoff.
  9. akudr48
    akudr48 28 January 2018 10: 01
    16
    Khazin, who is distinguished by deep and often mocking criticisms of the well-known “right-liberal political elite,” which made him famous, almost always excludes Putin from the goals of his attacks. It implies, but does not name, as in the song "My dear, good, guess yourself!"

    It turns out a familiar song - the king is good, the boyars are scum. True, the khazin performs her masterfully.

    And the people are being led, believing that a little more, a little more, and Putin will defeat this anonymous right-liberal elite, he just needs to help a little, collapse together and things will go!

    Everything is possible to see in this fantastic picture, for example, Putin gave the command to increase pensions, and Kudrin and Siluyanov disobeyed, Putin ordered Medvedev to import everything, and Prime Minister Dima did the opposite, Putin was opposed, and the Transport Minister of the Falcons launched a private platoon to extort drivers heavy trucks in the pocket of the rotenbergs ...

    The calculation of the lack of brains among the people
    1. Sergeant71
      Sergeant71 28 January 2018 10: 21
      +2
      I am embarrassed to ask, who is this Khazin and what is famous for?
      1. akudr48
        akudr48 28 January 2018 10: 38
        +1
        Here you can see
        http://worldcrisis.ru/
  10. Altona
    Altona 28 January 2018 10: 54
    13
    Quote: rotmistr60
    The fact that GDP for Western liberalism is enemy No. 1 has been clear for a long time.

    --------------------------------
    You, my friend, watch less TV. GDP is not an enemy for them. Russia in any form is an enemy to the West. And in order to defame Russia, they first defame the ruler.
  11. nnz226
    nnz226 28 January 2018 12: 21
    +4
    Here the whole government (at least the economic bloc) needs to be changed! But on who? On the deputies? So those are also the feeding ups of the fat robber of the Russian people - Gaidar. There are of course several economists such as Glazyev, but they did not work in a gadushnik called the Government of the Russian Federation. Devour, sir ...
  12. Overlock
    Overlock 28 January 2018 12: 31
    11
    Quote: SPACE
    soldier what is happening on the battlefield, he is obliged to comply with the order

    you confuse the soldiers with the citizens of the country. There will be no blind obedience. because man assumes that his commander is an unreliable man. And in the army, if the soldier does not believe in the commander, then the order will be executed randomly.
    Everyone believed Stalin. He was considered God, therefore this faith helped to conquer. What about Putin? Maybe he is crystal clear (I doubt it), but his entourage is mired in money and seen in an enemy camp (children and relatives behind the cordon). What could be the result?
  13. noodles
    noodles 28 January 2018 14: 58
    0
    Hard, but still read all the comments! They will undoubtedly help the journalist Khazin - to write the next article which would differ from the first one by the most CONCRETE! What personally concerns me today when discussing the identity of our president, the absolutely probable leader of the country for the next 6 years! The main thing is that I would really like to finally see HIS PRE-ELECTION PROGRAM - clear - clear and understandable for us dull! Of the 400 million, you can probably allocate funds to prepare it - printed on Finnish paper and did not forget to put each resident of Russia in the mailbox!
    1. dSK
      dSK 28 January 2018 15: 28
      0
      Hello Vladislav!
      Quote: noodles
      I'd love to finally see HIS PRE-ELECTION PROGRAM
      You will see on February 6They said the same. hi
    2. Karabin
      Karabin 28 January 2018 16: 46
      +5
      Quote: noodles
      I would like to finally see HIS PRE-ELECTION PROGRAM

      Come on. Maybe you want to see the debate with GDP?
  14. sxfRipper
    sxfRipper 28 January 2018 15: 33
    0
    Licked by the very best! And what is fair - but there are no others ...
  15. Romin
    Romin 28 January 2018 16: 17
    +9
    I absolutely do not care about the perception of the “Western elites” of the President of the Russian Federation V.V. Putin.
    To rejoice that Russia, in the person of Its leader, is afraid or not afraid, love or dislike, gossip about it, this is the same as drinking water from a tap. Not good and not bad, but quenches thirst!
    Who has nothing to do, he relishes such information.
    I'm more interested in not pursuing foreign policy of the Russian Federation for the sake of foreign policy (excuse me for butter), i.e. For the sake of PR without monetization (without benefit for the Russian Federation).
    I do not accept humanitarian aid to various countries to nothing
    I do not accept billions of dollars forgiveness for nothing
    I do not accept the creation of a kind, all-forgiving Russia in the foreign policy space. This product is only for our domestic consumption and its transfer to the outside causes other peoples only laughter and misunderstanding, because Their mentality, upbringing and historical memory are different. And they do not understand the policy of this strange country, which will give the last shirt to a neighbor, will remain naked, will rejoice at this, praise itself and call for all nations to be the same! And after the rest of the world spins on this appeal at the temple, to talk and say that here they are, and we are good! Nothing but naked, but good!
    Nothing like the average wage at the level of "third world countries"
    Nothing that charitable funds collect for medicines and treatment for children and adults.
    Nothing that a large part of Russia arrives in the infrastructure mordor
    Nothing that collects things and money in orphanages
    .....
    The state machine is engaged in everything, but partly its direct responsibilities!
    And the most interesting thing is that the mentality of the virtues of the last shirts can’t be broken and we won’t get to the fact that let’s take care of ourselves, in our state, so that the salaries of “state employees” are not at the cost of living, so that the state provides social and scientific not on the residual principle, that we have everything advanced, that the infrastructure is better than in Europe itself, that it is clean and modern, that all the cities of Russia have high-speed rail links with each other, that there are multi-lane illuminated "highways" ... .
    What am I talking about again! We are ... the last shirt, we are good, they are bad.
    As soon as our minds return in foreign policy, that Russia's interests are above all!
    What kind of ruble invested, donated or forgiven should two rubles return to us.
    As soon as in any emergency situation, if there are citizens of different countries, we will save Ours first! And then we will help first to the allies, and then according to foreign policy priorities!
    Only then, they will reckon with us in foreign policy, without showing Kuzkina.
    Only then will words or intentions be enough
    And only then will there be respect for Russia, since only those who respect themselves will respect.
    And the foreign policy pretense is quickly discovered and used by Russia in their interests.
    For kindness and a freebie in foreign policy, you can’t buy or buy anything, much less influence and respect!
    I hope that the future Presidents of the Russian Federation will someday come to this understanding.
    1. Cossack 471
      Cossack 471 1 February 2018 20: 42
      0
      ROMIN I support 100 percent !!!
  16. andrej-shironov
    andrej-shironov 28 January 2018 16: 17
    12
    Dear Mikhail Khazin! Take off your pink glasses! There will be no Putin policy change after the election! Do not flatter yourself! Look at things more critically.
  17. Karabin
    Karabin 28 January 2018 16: 58
    +9
    There is some reason to believe that Putin can use the campaign that has begun to change his policy.
    I like these passages. The circle is closed. Six years ago, Khazins, Dugins, Prokhanovs and other fighters wrote the same thing, except with more confidence. Everyone dreams that the good king will finally wake up. Oh well.
  18. rocket757
    rocket757 28 January 2018 18: 23
    +1
    Fantasy in a person has played out ... can we play along, can we vice versa ???
    We’re vanging to the fullest, once again ... and the system does not sleep, like the cat that eats sour cream, so it does / builds what it needs !!!
  19. Radikal
    Radikal 28 January 2018 20: 18
    +1
    Quote: Overlock
    Quote: seos
    it is necessary to agree with the Hahel ...

    all wars once end. And you have to agree with the Hahel. So Surkov works in this thread. You suppose. that Ukraine will resolve itself? I assure you, no. This is a problem for decades and will have to be negotiated. Unless you drop the atomic bomb on them, but they also have enough of their own (nuclear power plants). So there are negotiations and negotiations.

    We, and you?
    1. Overlock
      Overlock 28 January 2018 22: 48
      +1
      Quote: Radikal
      We, and you?

      did not understand
      1. Radikal
        Radikal 29 January 2018 00: 13
        +1
        I'm talking about the bomb. wassat
        Unless you drop the atomic bomb on them
        Who do you mean when you say “you”? That is, you yourself from another "company"? Fershteyn? Or chew more?
        1. The comment was deleted.
          1. Sling cutter
            Sling cutter 29 January 2018 01: 46
            +3
            Quote: Overlock
            Who do you mean when you say “you”? That is, you yourself from another "company"? Fershteyn? Or chew more?

            Quote: Overlock
            I believe that we will have to agree and the process is already underway. Does it bother you that Putin agrees? Fershteyn?

            EEEE, Guys, you at least do not fight! stop
            Here to figs with whom to fight yes angry
            There are mumipupi trolls laughing
            citizen Putin did not live up to the expectations of most citizens, so citizen Putin, I hope, will be re-elected in accordance with the Constitution of the Russian Federation.
            although the 4th is already a lot, pah.
            IMHO. my citizenship.
  20. VladGashek
    VladGashek 28 January 2018 21: 54
    +2
    All this propaganda attack on the GDP is a piracy to increase its rating on the eve of the presidential election in the Russian Federation. Who, no matter how GDP is beneficial to the interests of the West. It supports economically (by money), heats up with gas, delivers intellectual cadres (the best graduates of reputable universities), protects interests from overthrown bandits in BV. Etc.
    1. Radikal
      Radikal 29 January 2018 00: 16
      0
      Quote: Vladgashek
      All this propaganda attack on the GDP is a piracy to increase its rating on the eve of the presidential election in the Russian Federation. Who, no matter how GDP is beneficial to the interests of the West. It supports economically (by money), heats up with gas, delivers intellectual cadres (the best graduates of reputable universities), protects interests from overthrown bandits in BV. Etc.

      There is a rational grain in your mind, if you mean the West, and not the citizens of Russia. yes
  21. Earnest
    Earnest 29 January 2018 10: 34
    +3
    Quote: Overlock
    Quote: Don Analyst
    This is a real political situation ...


    And you think, why, when meeting with Medvedev, they squat and bend their necks. He really has a complex because of growth, at outreach “meetings with workers” even workers are sorted by growth: “Medvedev =” or “Medvedev minus X cm” - go through, “Medvedev + Hcm” - for a day off or re-change. I myself saw this selection at the Sayano-Shushenskaya hydroelectric station.
  22. Earnest
    Earnest 29 January 2018 10: 44
    +1
    Quote: Northern warrior
    This is not Vietnam - the jungle is not there! How many people will tear ass from a warm sofa and go to the woods to dig caches? No, there are undoubtedly those who are stubborn, but there are not more than a few thousand. It is impossible to compare the 404 population with Chechens and Afghans - those warriors who have been able to hold a machine gun in their hands since childhood, and their religion motivates them to fight against infidels. Haremongers are ordinary traitors, informers, thieves, licking, but not warriors, ready to lay their heads in the struggle for their beliefs. Do you think that a German accidentally managed to occupy the entire territory of 404 during the Second World War, but stumbled on the territory of present-day Russia? Ukroshluha always fall under the strong, but then betray the "master" who has lost strength.

    Do you know why normal people don’t spit shit? Because they were told to them from childhood that shit should not be taken in the mouth. But they didn’t have time to explain this to you, or couldn’t, therefore, in response to Nazi statements, I will appeal to the rudiments of your mind ... Do not spit shit at people who filled your mouth!
  23. Radikal
    Radikal 29 January 2018 12: 36
    0
    Quote: Overlock
    I understood the question. If a person, by definition, is not ready to agree, then the solution to the question is one-war.
    The simplest solution is an atomic bomb, there is no country, there are no problems. Other methods of warfare are fraught with human, material and image losses for the country.
    Quote: Radikal
    any normal peasant is jarred by Grudinin’s answers about having to negotiate with the Hahel..

    I believe that we will have to agree and the process is already underway. Does it bother you that Putin agrees? Fershteyn?

    My dear, where did you get this quote about Grudinin under my nickname, which I did not write ?! I am waiting for a refutation, or I will contact the admins !!!
  24. Nemesis
    Nemesis 29 January 2018 15: 39
    +3
    Putin is a bad Susanin ... Susanin drowned the Polish invaders in the swamp and benefited Russia, and Putin has been leading Russia around the Yeltsin swamp for 20 years, not wanting to move away from its shores to healthy soil, which causes Russia only harm
    1. rocket757
      rocket757 30 January 2018 09: 55
      +1
      But now the nightingale is flooded and turned to the people by everyone, everyone ... but with what, however, I have doubts.
      1. Nemesis
        Nemesis 30 January 2018 10: 35
        +3
        Even Mikhail Zadornov said that - It's time to produce chocolate, with the name of Putin's Tales ... A person who is only able to grind with his tongue quickly gets bored, and this one for 20 years is completely tired. Not fulfilled promises cause only disappointment ...
        1. rocket757
          rocket757 30 January 2018 10: 58
          +1
          He didn’t promise to lay down on the rails, like some ... even if he gave a mortgage, he didn’t ... as there was a Pokemon lounging - There is no money, but you hold on! -
          Maybe not everything is so "sour", but we can’t wait for sweets ... not in this life. It's a shame!
  25. iouris
    iouris 30 January 2018 13: 04
    0
    "The story started to jump," it is very generally said. The apparent leap is just the electoral cycle. We would only have to stand day, and hold out the night ... And after us - even a flood.
  26. Overlock
    Overlock 31 January 2018 09: 04
    0
    Hlavaty,
    I am. fortunately lived there
  27. looker-on
    looker-on 31 January 2018 17: 11
    0
    In our country, his figure was wildly demonized (both during the late USSR and in the post-Soviet period), which, however, during the crisis led to the fact that his image (not historical, of course, but the same phantom) supports already 80% of the population.


    Is it you who got this figure from? Did you conduct a survey with your family and talked with a neighbor?
  28. A.
    A. 2 February 2018 06: 29
    0
    But it has been several years since the pendulum has swung to the other side. This is most pronounced in the United States, where politics is most public. And we see how, on the one hand, the right-liberal ideology has swung to the left and left-wing liberal Sanders appeared (who would have defeated Clinton and Trump, if only the apparatus of the US Democratic Party was not controlled by the Clinton team by means of overt falsifications; By the way, they accused Putin again). On the other hand, the right-liberal ideology has swung to the conservative side and the right-wing conservative Trump has appeared, about which everyone already knows everything.
    You probably know that in the states these two teams create an imitation of violent activity for the people, and the general line has remained unchanged for centuries, since it is formed by a team of a different level of the so-called backstage.