Military Review

If tomorrow is war, the country is not ready

63



Analysis of the reality in which we exist allows us to evaluate it as a state of war. It is conducted against us in the economy, education, science, culture, even in the field of national personnel policy in the global civilizational and armed confrontation of the aggregate West (NATO-US). The readiness of the country and the population to protect the Fatherland becomes the most important criterion of security.

The war with Russia has not yet been transferred to the phase of open armed struggle and to our territory. Nevertheless, the United States is purposefully and systematically preparing - it is enough to name Ukraine, Poland, the Baltic States, the internal “fifth column”, which is supported from the outside and occupies serious positions in our economy, education, science and culture. A lot is said about the new US National Security Strategy (“Relationship of Intimidation”).

Return all-learning

In Russia, the mechanisms of governing a country in a war are formed slowly and indistinctly, the mobilization component is not elaborated in detail, the spheres of patriotic education and preparation of the population for the defense of the Fatherland are orphaned and ineffective.

In fairness, let us say that in recent years at least something is being done in this area. But the modern geopolitical situation requires a fundamentally different quality of the Armed Forces, and most importantly, a new level of citizens' preparation for the defense of the Fatherland, since wars, as the classic said, are fought not by armies, but by nations.

It seems obvious that one year of active service does not allow to form reserves of the necessary qualifications and in the required quantity. The reduction of the two-year term was important in the 90s and early 2000s. Thus, many issues were resolved, including the fight against hazing. But today, the challenges of the time require a training system for military-trained reservists in addition to the Armed Forces - autonomous, built to fulfill state orders and under the control of senior management. In other words, the army should receive trained recruits, and the country should have a competent and sufficient mobilization reserve. After all, the outcome of the war does not depend on quantity tanks, but from the spirit and cohesion of the nation, the effectiveness of its management in armed confrontation, the willingness of the population to defend the Fatherland, the general level of military training of the majority.

90 years ago in the country, OSOAVIAHIM was created - a public organization for the purposeful solution of the tasks of patriotic education, which has become a competent leader. Today, this role is intended to perform DOSAAF Russia. But for the full revival of the organization, an appropriate mobilization task and a state order are necessary.

First of all, it is necessary to clearly define the goals of the “National Strategy for the Development and Security of Russia for the period up to 2050 of the year” and until the end of the XXI century. They should find official expression not only in the above-mentioned document, but also in the Military Doctrine, the National Defense Plan. Then become the basis of applied strategies of all ministries and departments.

“In the sphere of preparing the population of the country, work is carried out without tension and of proper quality,” states the president of the Board of Military Experts of Russia, Candidate of Political Sciences, Major General (Ret.) Alexander Vladimirov. “For example, after the liquidation of the Rosvoencenter, Rosmolodezh, the principal executor of the State program of patriotic education, has already withdrawn work from veterans from its functions and areas of responsibility, which leads to the loss of continuity of generations.” According to Vladimirov, Rosmolodezh, by definition, composition and focus of activities should not lead the patriotic education. However, the proposal of the College of military experts on the inclusion in the government of the Ministry of Veterans Affairs, which should address these issues, is still unclaimed. Although back in 2010, Vladimir Putin, pointing to the growing threats to national security, identified the need to create a Federal system for preparing the population for military service (“The Concept of the Federal System for Preparing Citizens of the Russian Federation for Military Service for the period up to 2020”).

To repeat: more than seven years ago, a practical model of universal education with the leading role of DOSAAF was proposed. So what's stopping you?

First, DOSAAF was removed from the system of subjects of national defense and was deprived of a mobilization task, the main subject of preparing citizens for military service and military-patriotic education, the developer and performer of state programs in this area are not defined, and there are no indicators and criteria for the effectiveness of the elements of the system. Secondly, the need for a military-trained reserve of the state and the army is not framed in a mandatory state order, and the legal and economic basis for the effective functioning of the elements of the system has not been created. Besides financing annually decreases.

We add that our school excludes the practical possibility of high-quality teaching of students in subjects and programs of preparation for the defense of the Fatherland and does not set such a task. Civic education does not provide skills even for such massive military occupational specialties as the shooter — senior shooter, grenade thrower, paramedic, radio operator, troop scout, drone operator, etc. The educational infrastructure and material base of DOSAAF require serious updating.

A priori, one of the departments concerned is the Ministry of Defense.

“But the Ministry of Defense of the Russian Federation has not yet developed a list of mandatory and specific requirements, standards and practical skills that every student must master by graduating from institutions of general (special, cadet) secondary and higher education after completing the compulsory subject courses" Fundamentals of Military Training "and" Young fighter ", - said Vladimirov. - Not defined and financial security.

Chief of mobilization

The general preparation of the population for the defense of the Fatherland should be based on historical traditions, ability to national mobilization. It is advisable to restore the institution of military districts in the old strategic cut, in a functional connection with the territorial defense and DOSAAF. It is necessary to solve the problem of the purpose of its infrastructure during the threatened period as centers for the collection, distribution and preparation of local mobresources.

If tomorrow is war, the country is not readyIt is important to return to the military commissariats of all levels the professional component (including modern means of communication), the ability to keep records of military service and specialists in the MES, the formation of automobile columns, marching companies, etc. What is the absence of an institution of compulsory registration and registration today? while problematic, even impossible.

The leadership of the Armed Forces of the Russian Federation will need to appoint a person responsible for the interaction, setting tasks, determining the mobilization task, and forming a state order for DOSAAF. In Soviet times, such a man was the commander in chief of the Ground Forces. Today, these questions may be assigned to one of the deputy defense ministers of Russia.

It should be charged with the responsibility of the chief commanders of the types and types of troops of the Armed Forces of the Russian Federation, the National Guard, and other security agencies to develop lists of the MES required for them to be mastered in DOSAAF system. And through GOMU General Staff of the Armed Forces of the Russian Federation to issue an application in the form of a state order and a mobilization task. The headquarters in this complex work should by definition be the General Staff of the RF Armed Forces.

The experience of the interaction of parts of the regular army of Syria and our military advisers with local armed groups, tribes, commanders and informal leaders is very valuable. Today, these issues can and should be taken into account in the practice of combat and operational training. In the course of the command-staff exercise, operational and strategic level military exercises, work out not only the mobilization deployment, but also territorial defense, interaction with government bodies, the population. Similar tasks should be assigned to the National Guard, the Ministry of Internal Affairs, and the administrations of the subjects of the Russian Federation.

In all educational institutions of the civil service, full-time departments (streams, centers, courses) of military training are necessary. And in the system of cadet education of the Russian Federation of the main type (SVU, NVMU, PKU, KK of the Ministry of Defense, Rosgvardia, Ministry of Interior, FSB with a seven-year cycle) - study the subject "Basics of military training" with issuing certificates of junior commander-sergeant level to graduates. Where there is no full board, prepare students for the defense of the Fatherland at the level of the “Course of the Young Fighter”.

“These proposals were submitted by the Ministry of Defense of Russia, included in the Concept of cadet education, declared at the on-site meeting of the Interdepartmental Council of the Ministry of Education and Science of Russia on Cadet Education (November 13, 2017), explains Major General Vladimirov. - We believe that the founders of educational institutions, who are the customers of specialized education, can themselves determine the necessary level of general military training of pupils, organize it in conjunction with DOSAAF and local military units. That will serve as the basis for the title, and not necessarily the lieutenant of the reserve. You can cook and ensigns, sergeants.

Military departments (centers) should become part of all institutions of higher general and secondary vocational education, for example, at the State University of Management, Moscow State University of Technology and Management. Razumovsky, where the military departments yet.

Obviously, the more serious the attention of the state, the more military departments and centers in the national education system, the larger the coverage of the population with preparations for the defense of the Fatherland, the more substantive the patriotic self-identification.

It is necessary for the leadership of the Ministry of Defense to hear the leaders of DOSAAF, their proposals to raise the status of the organization, support the prepared draft Federal Law “On pre-conscription and extra-military training of citizens of the Russian Federation.

By and large, it is necessary to form a new model of the mobilization readiness of the country. This will require the inclusion in the statutes of all economic structures (state and non-state) of an obligatory "mobilization" section, the formation of mobile units in their structure (departments, divisions, groups). It is necessary to consider the possibility of returning the institution of secondments to military personnel (military acceptance, field institutions of the State Bank in the formations, DOSAAF Russia staff, military departments of civilian higher education institutions, institutions and organizations performing the state defense order, etc.). All this will ensure the overall military stability of Russia, the survival of the population and state power in the event of the most adverse conditions of war and natural disasters.

Without the right to buildup

No less important are the issues of unification and separation of powers in the Armed Forces of the Russian Federation. The recognition of the fact that the war being waged against Russia requires a transition to the state practice of planning and mobilization actions, increases the personal responsibility of commanders and civil servants for the quality of the decisions made. In China, for example, from 1 in January 2018, the internal troops (armed people's militia) were reassigned to the single highest governing body of the country - the Military Council of the CPC Central Committee (also known as the Central Military Council).

Today, the army and Rosgvardiya have different powers. MES is generally separated from the solution of military-political tasks. The Security Council, an advisory body under the President of the Russian Federation, cannot fulfill the functions of the Military Council. The National Center for Defense Management of the Russian Federation is endowed with information and coordination functions, again, on ensuring security, but not on managing the war. And the country needs a single body following the example of the General Headquarters of the Great Patriotic War. Army - prepared mobilization reserve. Society - comprehensively secured national civil defense system. All this can be combined by the State Defense Committee (GKO) - the body that governs the entire country (the Armed Forces, the front and rear, the national economy, the population, the territories).

Special study will require economic issues. How will the country proceed to planned economic management (estimated year of war), autarky and self-sufficiency (in conditions of forced isolation and blockade)? In which documents is it defined? What should be the mobilization right, mobilizations, plans for the calculated war years? How possible and necessary in such cases is nationalization (for the purposes of economic unity of command) of large private property (termination of dividend payments to shareholders, activities of boards of directors, etc.)? What, finally, will be the circulation of money in a belligerent country, the centralized accounting and the normative distribution of material resources? All this requires careful study.

The college of military experts of Russia offers:

1. Prepare a discussion of the issue at a special meeting of the Security Council of the Russian Federation.

2. Create a working group in the Security Council of the Russian Federation with the inclusion of representatives of ministries, departments and public organizations.

3. To make an analytical study and expert report on legal and departmental acts on preparing the population for the defense of the Fatherland and its patriotic education.

4. Hold a series of special (closed) hearings on the proposed topics in the State Duma and the Federation Council.

5. Prepare a meeting of the State Council of the Russian Federation on this issue.

6. To develop common views on the substance of the issues raised, which are enshrined in national law - laws and other normative acts, in the main documents of the national strategic goal setting.

7. To conduct strategic games and KShU on the topics raised.

The implementation of these proposals will help define the new model of the mobilization component of the national defense of Russia. There can be no time for the buildup - our sworn friends will not give it to us.
Author:
Originator:
https://vpk-news.ru/articles/40891
63 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must to register.

I have an account? Sign in

  1. pofigist_26_rus
    pofigist_26_rus 24 January 2018 15: 21 New
    +7
    I agree with many things, but you are focusing on cadet educational institutions, which is a somewhat incorrect approach and, thereby, losing sight of several aspects.
    A year of service is necessary for honing previously acquired skills and coordinating units (more precisely, training actions within units). Ask where can young people get the necessary skills and knowledge?
    The second point follows from here. Organization of mass training for young people starting from grades 5-6, with the involvement of DOSAAF employees and military personnel of local military units, units of the Russian Guard. Think Impossible? Far from it, the question is the desire of the leadership. The actual absence / insufficient funding of organizations involved in the training of young people follows, in my opinion, from the lack of a clear picture of the threats and methods of counteracting them among the leadership.
    1. vladimirZ
      vladimirZ 24 January 2018 17: 39 New
      10
      First, with great enthusiasm, we will ruin everything and everything, and then with no less enthusiasm we will restore the destroyed, forgetting that we destroyed not only the Mobilization System of State Defense, the Army - regiments, divisions, armies, districts; the defense industry, without which it is impossible for the country to resist the enemy, the PSYCHOLOGY OF PEOPLE has been DESTROYED to the defense of the state.
      Instead of patriots who had to defend the country, they brought up consumers who want to become "citizens of the world", who do not want to serve in the Army, the really necessary minimum period for training a warrior, who want to move to other warmer countries.
      They invented colleges, some obscure centers, public service academies, which are already preparing "professional sergeants," or no one knows, and there are no normal soldiers who have seriously mastered military affairs in reserve, since they have already reduced the service to a year and a half century ago.
      There is no mob reserve. There are no cropped parts that will have to accept the mobile reserve, there is no military equipment under the mobile reserve.
      With whom will we defend the country? And who will be responsible for the ruined?
    2. dSK
      dSK 24 January 2018 17: 52 New
      0

      Hello, Alexander!
      Quote: pofigist_26_rus
      Organization of mass education of young people starting from grades 5-6, with the involvement of
      military pensioners, many are willing to share their experience with young people.
      "Consolidation and moral mobilization", a natural reaction to external threats. hi
    3. Dr_engie
      Dr_engie 24 January 2018 19: 38 New
      0
      You propose for the sake of the army to ruin education. Well done.
      1. dauria
        dauria 24 January 2018 22: 28 New
        +8
        You offer for the sake of the army to ruin education


        Such an education and ruin is not a pity. Expensive day nurseries for over-age "kids." No fundamental knowledge, no perseverance, no skills ... But ambitions, selfishness are the greatest.
      2. Skarpzd
        Skarpzd 25 January 2018 02: 01 New
        +1
        Quote: Dr_Engie
        You propose for the sake of the army to ruin education. Well done.

        have something to break up?
        1. dSK
          dSK 25 January 2018 02: 54 New
          0
          Hello Eugene!
          Quote: Skarpzd
          there is that
          Russian President Vladimir Putin was at the United Engine Corporation in Ufa yesterday. During a meeting of the head of state, the worker asked if return the practice of rewarding state-owned advanced enterprises. “Let me just kiss you,” Putin replied. Read more at RBC.
  2. NEXUS
    NEXUS 24 January 2018 15: 27 New
    15
    I have already said that we need comprehensive work. Starting with the reconstruction of such organizations as the Oktyabrat, the Pioneer and the Komsomol (the names are of course different). Secondly, this is the introduction of the TRP standards, and with their subsequent refinement to the norms of 50-60 years. Third, the reconstruction of such a structure similar to ROSAVIAHIM, possibly DOSAAF, all kinds of circles, etc. Fourth is the education of patriotic youth, however ridiculous it may sound to some. And it’s not an unimportant moment to pay attention to our cinema, which can help in the patriotic education of youth.
    Well, military service to do at least 2 years. At the same time, seriously teach NVP lessons in schools, as well as turn to military departments at institutes. Suvorov and Nakhimov schools in every possible way support and welcome young people into them not only with words.
    1. 210ox
      210ox 24 January 2018 15: 32 New
      +7
      Andrei, I agree with you. And even more. It is necessary to conduct general exercises on mobilization, including all areas. Up to the transfer of the economy to military tracks.
      Quote: NEXUS
      I have already said that we need comprehensive work. Starting with the reconstruction of such organizations as the Oktyabrat, the Pioneer and the Komsomol (the names are of course different). Secondly, this is the introduction of the TRP standards, and with their subsequent refinement to the norms of 50-60 years. Third, the reconstruction of such a structure similar to ROSAVIAHIM, possibly DOSAAF, all kinds of circles, etc. Fourth is the education of patriotic youth, however ridiculous it may sound to some. And it’s not an unimportant moment to pay attention to our cinema, which can help in the patriotic education of youth.
      Well, military service to do at least 2 years. At the same time, seriously teach NVP lessons in schools, as well as turn to military departments at institutes. Suvorov and Nakhimov schools in every possible way support and welcome young people into them not only with words.
      1. NEXUS
        NEXUS 24 January 2018 18: 13 New
        +6
        Quote: 210ox
        Andrey, I agree with you

        Here is the response of the Kremlin cadets to the video of the Ulyanovsk cadets ... no comment ...
        1. 210ox
          210ox 24 January 2018 18: 41 New
          +3
          A worthy answer to these fools, with whom we must trust our lives and the lives of our loved ones in the air and on the earth ..
          Quote: NEXUS
          Quote: 210ox
          Andrey, I agree with you

          Here is the response of the Kremlin cadets to the video of the Ulyanovsk cadets ... no comment ...
    2. Dr_engie
      Dr_engie 24 January 2018 19: 39 New
      +7
      How can one TEACH, or MAKE a person be a patriot?
      He will be if he has something to be proud of. And now there is only something to be ashamed of.
      1. NEXUS
        NEXUS 24 January 2018 21: 55 New
        +5
        Quote: Dr_Engie
        How can one TEACH, or MAKE a person be a patriot?

        But the cat learned ... laughing
  3. Vard
    Vard 24 January 2018 15: 32 New
    +6
    The whole preparation ... it is for the last war ... and the one that will be ... we, by definition, are not ready ... As always, they will kill someone right away, who will go to the end without a scratch ... and it will depend on ten percent of military skill and ninety of luck ...
    1. dSK
      dSK 24 January 2018 17: 59 New
      0
      Quote: Vard
      it will depend on ten percent of military skill and ninety of luck.
      They say "Success is 30% of talent and 70% of work," I don’t remember exactly.hi
  4. Dzmicer
    Dzmicer 24 January 2018 15: 35 New
    10
    Go to an economical and efficient system with a professional contract core (officers, special forces, artillery, aviation, communications, etc.) plus the militia "our" power will never go, because there aren’t any weapons put up in Russia’s pig man whether those in power will turn him against?
    In general, judging by the budgets and the size of the so-called the national guard, the biggest danger to the Kremlin is not a foreign invader, but its own people.
  5. Blue cop
    Blue cop 24 January 2018 15: 40 New
    22
    If there is no full-fledged economy, everything else is good, but so to speak ...
    1. Plate
      Plate 24 January 2018 18: 29 New
      +5
      I agree with you. Any war - this is economics. If there is no economy, then whatever the army, it will lose. Even if enough weapons are accumulated, while the industry is not normal (for example, by purchasing abroad or producing for a long, long time in order to get the desired result in a few years), an army that does not have a good economy behind will still lose. At least if you wage a war lasting more than two weeks.
      We must finally begin to actively increase the volume of defense industry products, and not engage in the conversion of military production to civilian ones. And so that supporters of the development of the civilian economy do not begin to resent: the military-industrial complex creates great demand for products of heavy engineering, metallurgy, precision engineering and many other advanced industries. So, I think that ultimately it is useful for the entire economy.
      1. iDOLLM4STER
        iDOLLM4STER 24 January 2018 21: 01 New
        +2
        This is called the “Athena War” / war of economies. Russia has a way to win the “Athena War”, it is only necessary to observe 3 conditions:
        - Developed logistics and information infrastructure
        - The Doctrine of Natural Benefits
        - Energy Excellence
        1. Plate
          Plate 25 January 2018 15: 13 New
          0
          I can confidently say that we already have a third. But with the first, the problems are quite large. Okay, roads, you can’t drive a lot on them. The main thing, as for me, is the railways due to their heavy load capacity. And if we look at the map, we will understand that most of the country does not have such roads.
          I also ask you to explain to me what this doctrine of natural benefits means.
          Well, I’d add a production base to the fourth point: agriculture and heavy industry.
          1. iDOLLM4STER
            iDOLLM4STER 31 January 2018 14: 40 New
            0
            My friend ... of course you can’t transport it by what’s not, it's about the roads))) Have you heard the term - multiple reservations? So this concerns the duplication of railway by the same railway ... which are not. It should be everything, and twice as much as everything. And it is not discussed.

            We do not have Energy Superiority ... not Socialism and not the USSR. Russia-s.

            The Doctrine of Natural Benefits - The combination of using both the physical and geographical position, natural resources, and cheap energy, and therefore cheap production in the sectors of the economy.

            REALITY IS SUCH ... that with the current system we do not have any of the above items, and will not be in the foreseeable 100 years.
            1. Plate
              Plate 31 January 2018 20: 38 New
              0
              Well ... I agree with your judgments about the roads. Indeed, everything should be duplicated for reliability. But I spoke in the short term. Because, apparently, the problems with roads are systemic, and to eliminate this, you need either some kind of sharp movement, or time. Well, the desire.
              How does the presence or absence of energy resources depend on the state system? We pumped oil as well as pumped it, pumped gas, mined coal, and our rivers run hydroelectric power stations. But, alas, uranium has to be imported from Kazakhstan.
  6. Vasya Vassin
    Vasya Vassin 24 January 2018 15: 47 New
    19
    You do not raise the main question, who should we defend in this upcoming war? The oligarchs who seized 90% of all Russian property, or maybe their debt on loans, faith in a better future? It all starts with motivation, what kind of motivation does people have to resist enemies from outside, if they are enough above the roof at home?
    1. Vard
      Vard 24 January 2018 16: 21 New
      11
      The oligarchs ... they will wash off right away ... and most likely the aggressors in the countries ... And we will protect those whom we usually protect ... Mothers, fathers, wives, children ...
    2. Moore
      Moore 24 January 2018 16: 45 New
      +7
      Quote: Vasya Vassin
      You do not raise the main question, who should we defend in this upcoming war? The oligarchs who seized 90% of all Russian property, or maybe their debt on loans, faith in a better future?

      To protect your family, your house. Or, do you think it will be a war not to destroy our people, but to squeeze Abramovich’s yacht and a couple of hydrocarbon deposits?
      But those who during the war will doubt the need to defend their homeland, I believe, will be correctly freed from this solution to this painful issue.
      1. Vasya Vassin
        Vasya Vassin 24 January 2018 23: 07 New
        13
        My dear, open your eyes: no one needs your family, home, homeland, or even a broken six. No one will come and take away all this wealth that you have made overwork. We are talking about resources, the infrastructure for their free export, and a little about the personnel serving all this. How did the English flashback say there? How many millions are needed to service the pipe?
        So, this plan is ALREADY executed. If you have eyes, you will notice that the state CONSCIOUSLY does not do anything other than the SERVICE of this plan. We are not talking about people at all, no need to bomb, capture, poison poisons. Such an atmosphere is created that they either die or scatter themselves.
        So there will be no war. It was necessary to fight before, when there were opportunities and means for this.
    3. Golovan Jack
      Golovan Jack 24 January 2018 22: 38 New
      +3
      Quote: Vasya Vassin
      Vasya Vassin


      Vasya laughing
    4. max702
      max702 25 January 2018 01: 03 New
      +1
      Quote: Vasya Vassin
      It all starts with motivation, what kind of motivation does people have to resist enemies from outside, if they are enough above the roof at home?

      The trouble is that there is a choice of two evils .. Yes, the outsiders got it at all, BUT they don’t even put it under the knife, but those who come as a result of losing the war will not bother us! Everyone will be cut out and nafig ... And this detail raises the storm of the people's war from the time of Minin and Pozharsky, and even earlier ..
  7. a.sirin
    a.sirin 24 January 2018 16: 09 New
    +2
    Yes, it seems that psychosis is moving into the main phase ...
  8. maxim1987
    maxim1987 24 January 2018 16: 16 New
    +3
    Quote: Vasya Vassin
    or maybe your loan debts


    Putin handed a loan to you?
    1. Vasya Vassin
      Vasya Vassin 25 January 2018 08: 22 New
      0
      Yes, personally forced. So he said, you get a lot, in principle, your salary is enough to postpone housing and buy for half a year. I know what your average salary is, but you’d better take a mortgage for 20 years, be a man ...
  9. Curious
    Curious 24 January 2018 16: 47 New
    +4
    The author is getting ready for the last war. It seems to me that there will not be such a war. And the front line will not pass through the fields and forests, but along the heads. This is where the main front for the defense of the Fatherland is. And if there, in the brains, the front is broken, then neither the universal education, nor the recruitment, will save anything. The brains of citizens are the main component of national defense.
    1. dSK
      dSK 24 January 2018 18: 12 New
      0
      Quote: Curious
      main component
      Fortitude. In a critical situation, the advantage is morally sustainable.
      1. The comment was deleted.
  10. Nemesis
    Nemesis 24 January 2018 17: 17 New
    12
    As long as Russia’s money goes to the Ulyukaev’s yachts, and not to the Russian army and economy, Russia will not be ready for either war or development ...
  11. panzerfaust
    panzerfaust 24 January 2018 19: 09 New
    11
    For example, Switzerland is a neutral country, and the level of training of reservists is 5 points. Weapons and equipment are stored at home. And no one refuses military training. Estonia - Kaitseliit, the Union of Reservists. Militarized volunteer organization under the auspices of the Ministry of Defense. To participate in it is both prestigious and profitable - a whole bunch of benefits. I will not speak about Ukraine. And what we have - Cossacks with whips! Or Yunarmia, playing the "lightning"? Think, comrades cheers patriots!
    1. Antares
      Antares 25 January 2018 12: 14 New
      +3
      Quote: panzerfaust
      And no one coughs up military training

      Would you mow, if it’s 2-3 weeks paid, with space and a great place to make contacts, because there are all the leaders and simple hard workers? Although the load is great, it’s a great opportunity. Yes, the whole country has ready-made saboteurs and partisans on its territory .
  12. Strategy
    Strategy 24 January 2018 20: 10 New
    0
    On serious topics you need to write seriously.
  13. iDOLLM4STER
    iDOLLM4STER 24 January 2018 21: 13 New
    +5
    Well, so far we have Tsar-Vova ... you can immediately give up ... better than Belarus)))))))

    And so, I'm afraid I will have to work hard, first get rid of the oligarchs and the rag-king, create some kind of socialism, and accelerate the economy.
  14. boni592807
    boni592807 24 January 2018 21: 33 New
    +6
    hi You can talk about what is and what happened. But that will not help what is needed now. And many have already formulated the answers. For instance:
    Analysis:
    • work written in the 60s of the last century by a Russian emigrant, Colonel E. Messner in his work "Rebellion - the name of the third world". It is “successfully” implemented by our “partners” am . Well, we do not have prophets in our own country (veterans of the Great Patriotic War, Afghanistan, Chechnya, etc.). I am glad for the experience of Syria and only in the Moscow Region.
    • training experience in the war (Sudoplatov) yes , more developed than, for example, the Popovskikhs (In the magazine “Main Topic” No. 3 for 2005. Editor-in-chief: M. Leontyev, RUSSIAN SECURITY YESTERDAY, TODAY, TOMORROW. (Who is to blame and what to do?);
    • our experience, pre-war and military (WWII) - NVP, GO, Mob.P.
    • the experience of Israel, Switzerland (for those who want to laugh - find and familiarize yourself) for example in the NVP, GO, Mob.P.
    • the experience of the latest rebellion wars (ongoing World War 4) from Yugoslavia to Ukraine. All signs and results. For us, they are unlikely to leave working developments. For example: Libya. Gaddafi commenting on the actions of the so-called rebels. He drew attention to the fact that among them there were no or minuscule Libyans. Basically, these are mercenaries from nearby countries or those who were on the territory of Libya in the so-called. job search. “Pay attention to their faces, these are not Libyans!” - he said. Libya under the "totalitarian" Gaddafi in terms of living was not inferior to Europe, but in some ways ahead. Libyans were very wealthy people. Those interested check. the keyboard is in your hands ..
    • revise overloaded science programs No. (recall the Soviet school programs, and what, besides computer science, has appeared during this time?), secondary - special (technical), higher education institutions to provide hours for students based on the experience of the USSR. Regulatory framework - COUNCIL OF MINISTERS OF THE USSR RESOLUTION of April 29, 1968 N 289. Everything is scheduled. Adapt and go!

    Based on an analysis of experience, urgent or yesterday implementation:
    • Army and ...,
    • Industry (economy) - Mob ... and dual-use production, here are import substitution and goods for Russia of a decent level, lower prices due to turnover (for example, communications, navigation, diesel locomotives, IT - technologies, how much you can depend on the West, etc. .). Those. what the whole world has been using for a long time.
    • Mob. P. and civil defense in the country, NVP schools here to universities, enterprises and organizations.

    • AFP - on the basis of NVP from schools to universities, enterprises and organizations using experience of working off a single (unit - platoon) airsoft (laser tag).
    • Special. P. - on the basis of DOSAAF, in \ h, patriotic clubs depending on local opportunities.
    • Why not remember for Mob. P and those in the reserve (reserve) the experience of militia, for understanding, simplify -. territorial units for the Moscow Region. Those. training, coordination and ready-made formation with a regular structure are in progress. If. what ... so right away!
    Someone will say that capitalism and they will not go for it. Those same capitalists who do not go for it will lose a lot. This is all special with us. As a question with a progressive tax scale. recourse Everything else: Will, desire, result. And in the army - to establish, bring and demand.
    The most important thing is that in the head. This has been brought up since at least 7 years old, as they already wrote on the forum - an analogue of October. pioneers, Komsomol members. Without understanding - who is his own, who is a stranger and why, and for what. All is superfluous. Like Kolya from the Bundestag or the gray Olympic form of “athletes from Russia”. They seem to be from Russia, but also by themselves.
    Yours faithfully, hi
  15. Mikhail3
    Mikhail3 24 January 2018 22: 04 New
    11
    On the way to raising the country's defense capability lies a pebble.

    How on the Bald Mountain devil's stone lies
    From under the stone of that Witch River runs!

    This little stone is called the "legitimization of capital." After all, what are the rulers of our country at the moment? This is completely and completely the worst thief. This, in fact, is all that can be said about them. Each year, these people hold an expensive ball in Moscow, at which they present themselves and their children as the current aristocracy and the future of the country. And people hear:

    Turn off the light, floated b.

    Our rulers did not prove in any way that they at least somehow deserve their position. Putin. Shoigu and Lavrov. Very cool, but that’s all! The rest are rightly perceived by the people as enemies. What will the appeal to the essence of a warrior-nation lead to? First of all, to the fact that the vigorous neighing of Shuvalov will respond to him with a butt in his physiognomy. Yes, Russian people are able to fight the whole world, and defeat it. But at the same time it will not work with the people and the ridge! And this means that almost the entire current gang will lose power.
    So there will be no rise in combat readiness, universal education and other miracles. Nothing. In a situation of choice between preserving the stolen and the fate of the country, what will our "vertical" choose? Alas...
  16. flicker
    flicker 24 January 2018 22: 07 New
    +3
    One thing inspires optimism - our potential enemies are even worse prepared.
    1. Antianglosax
      Antianglosax 25 January 2018 10: 23 New
      +1
      This is true, but they have goals and a strategy, even if tactics are sometimes lame. Our thieves' rabble is only a belated reaction to spitting, a crack and cuffs.
      Quote: Mikhail3
      But at the same time it will not work with the people and the ridge! And this means that almost the entire current gang will lose power.
      Also, definitely freedom and, possibly, life. So beat the kudrinshuvalovychubaisykasyyanovobchaki alikperovyb
      yergimans and other fetid abomination will be desperate.
  17. Apollo
    Apollo 24 January 2018 22: 25 New
    +4
    And who, in fact, send to the war, do not tell? Over the past 25 years, 90% of citizens of draft age did not serve in the army. They don’t even know how to carry weapons, let alone more. So what kind of war is it ..
    1. Svist
      Svist 25 January 2018 04: 34 New
      +2
      And we will immediately launch a nuclear war. We must trust the government, which promises that we will repel any aggression. There, on TV show our teachings against the "terrorists." Every time we destroy, every year. And most of the enterprises we have are in private hands. Do they know how effective they are ?! Not effective long gone bankrupt. Or they themselves fell apart, did not know how to survive in a market economy. And Yunarmia we have. So not everything is so bad. The officers are now building housing, everyone has enough. Because the excess was reduced, with an effective manager. We have no enemies. Well, except for the terrorists, of course. Therefore, the budget began to slowly cut money for the defense industry. Expensive. American debt may not be enough. Here we will buy everything, and then how we will present it for payment! He is a sacred duty, they will immediately give it back. And it will be worse. As last time.
      So don't panic, hold on
      1. Rey_ka
        Rey_ka 25 January 2018 07: 53 New
        0
        Moreover, nuclear weapons are easier to detonate on their territory on the principle: "So don’t get to anyone!"
  18. Apollo
    Apollo 24 January 2018 22: 27 New
    +1
    Quote: flicker
    One thing inspires optimism - our potential enemies are even worse prepared.

    This is true, but their strength, superiority in manpower and technology .. Moreover, in manpower it can be 3-4 times.
    1. Antianglosax
      Antianglosax 25 January 2018 10: 28 New
      0
      We have a 20-fold advantage in manpower! There is no doubt that one Rusich 10-20 Natava pederasts is worth. And our unpredictability, unpretentiousness, the ability to think outside the box, ingenuity and the Russian spirit further increase this advantage by an order of magnitude!
  19. Dedall
    Dedall 24 January 2018 22: 36 New
    +5
    By the way, regarding the plan at DOSAAF. I remember in 178 my friends came to the Tashkent flying club to sign up for the parachute section, and a gray-haired caperang meets us at the entrance and says: "Guys, I have a plan for commandants, and you all want to be paratroopers. Let's do it - you do it with me, I’ll help you with the jumps. " And so it happened that I jumped with a parachute in DOSAAF and studied at the artilleryman. It turned out that one day you run around with a 16-pound shell, and the next day I jumped from the "column". But then how amazed the artillery officers that the doctor knows the intricacies of their profession. By the way, he studied at the commandant for 2 years and in a purely practical sense knew no less than the lieutenants from artillery schools. So this is the right thing.
    As for material support, for some reason our “Crimean legacy” of the Ukrainian Armed Forces is going to be returned to Ukraine. So, for educational purposes it is quite suitable and on the basis of it it is quite possible to deploy a network of military-patriotic schools and clubs.
  20. Radikal
    Radikal 24 January 2018 22: 54 New
    +4
    Quote: Dr_Engie
    You propose for the sake of the army to ruin education. Well done.

    The army did not take part in the collapse of education - the people who committed this crime have specific names and surnames, but they do not have military ranks. wassat
  21. iouris
    iouris 24 January 2018 23: 10 New
    0
    Hassle. The war ended yesterday.
  22. Sotskiy
    Sotskiy 25 January 2018 00: 52 New
    +3
    An article from the series: "Citizens, let us collect the money for a child for an operation, because the authorities have a strategic task to remove oneself from the duties of the state."
    How will we fight, if the roads are paid and soon we will pay for entry into any city, not to mention the contentment?) Is there enough money?) This is not for the USSR. Under the feudal lords "for darma" you don’t fight much.
  23. Clone
    Clone 25 January 2018 01: 31 New
    0
    Quote: Apollo
    do not know how to carry weapons

    For the first time I hear such an interpretation ... In fact, they are taught to use weapons correctly. And wear ... however! belay
  24. sgapich
    sgapich 25 January 2018 04: 03 New
    0
    Quote: vladimirZ
    ... since it's been a quarter of a century since they reduced their service to a year ...


    The service life of 12 months was established from January 1, 2008 (from January 1, 2007 - 18 months), before that, since 1967, the service life was 2 years (3 years in the Navy).
  25. Northern warrior
    Northern warrior 25 January 2018 09: 30 New
    +1
    Russia should bet on nuclear weapons. An attack by NATO should be immediately repulsed by a massive use of nuclear weapons by our side, if the enemy uses weapons of mass destruction, the strategic nuclear forces must enter the battle.
    1. Vadim237
      Vadim237 25 January 2018 10: 57 New
      0
      Russia now needs to bet on the development of the BTA, critically few heavy aircraft like the An 124.
  26. valek97
    valek97 25 January 2018 11: 08 New
    +4
    Good day! I express my opinion, it may seem messy.
    Here we have a call, well, year-2, etc., so far not so important. I asked 5 acquaintances who served in the army, "What did the army teach you and what did you find useful in civilian life." 4 people replied that they had been busy for 3 months while they were in school, in the future they simply swept the barracks, stood on the nightstand, cut grass with scissors and painted snowdrifts in winter. 1 friend was in the tank, well, there he came in handy and the driver was trained in heavy equipment driving, he spent the year not in vain. We do not take into account those who go to the public service and bodies. And actually, my questions are that I do not understand:
    1) Why are you busy 3 months plainly and then you sit around playing around with bullshit, and for state money that they don’t train you, if you have already been taken into the army, if you please drive the whole life and use it efficiently. Who will say that for many 18 years, I do not agree at all, yes, there are enough such personnel, but this is a problem of education.
    2) Why can’t you calmly pay the state a certain amount so that it can recruit volunteers, put on shoes and dress them, but for example, do not call you. After all, you can do this without problems, but for some reason we go to this rake. After all, we pay so much on our paw.
    3) We have problems in the economy. Until there is a strong economy, there will be no strong army.
    4) For some reason, it is accepted that in the army a person gains wisdom and loses nonsense, although I can tell from people from the circle that if a person was a fool, then he remained like that.
    5) Why is our army so far from the profession that you received at the university, for example, you study to be a programmer, but they send you to artillery only because a buyer from such a unit came to you?
  27. Apollo
    Apollo 25 January 2018 11: 43 New
    +3
    Quote: Antianglosaks
    We have a 20-fold advantage in manpower! There is no doubt that one Rusich 10-20 Natava pederasts is worth. And our unpredictability, unpretentiousness, the ability to think outside the box, ingenuity and the Russian spirit further increase this advantage by an order of magnitude!

    Probably in childhood you were "fed" with fairy tales about Russian heroes.
  28. Apollo
    Apollo 25 January 2018 11: 53 New
    +6
    Quote: Svist
    And we will immediately launch a nuclear war. We must trust the government, which promises that we will repel any aggression. There, on TV show our teachings against the "terrorists." Every time we destroy, every year. And most of the enterprises we have are in private hands. Do they know how effective they are ?! Not effective long gone bankrupt. Or they themselves fell apart, did not know how to survive in a market economy. And Yunarmia we have. So not everything is so bad. The officers are now building housing, everyone has enough. Because the excess was reduced, with an effective manager. We have no enemies. Well, except for the terrorists, of course. Therefore, the budget began to slowly cut money for the defense industry. Expensive. American debt may not be enough. Here we will buy everything, and then how we will present it for payment! He is a sacred duty, they will immediately give it back. And it will be worse. As last time.
    So don't panic, hold on

    You tell this to Putin. Over the 18 years of rule, our great and multi-way president has not been able to collect a damn from the creditors of the USSR, and here you rolled your lips. Whistle on ..
  29. Horseman without a head
    Horseman without a head 26 January 2018 00: 33 New
    15
    Tortured sleeves comrades
  30. Severok
    Severok 26 January 2018 20: 54 New
    0
    To ensure the country's defense, it is imperative to introduce dictatorships in the country with generalized nationalization. Otherwise, we are waiting for a repetition of 1904-1905 and 1914-1918. Then we urgently need the introduction of the Soviet Criminal Code in the country on the model of 1940, the strict responsibility of the local authorities, the resumption of the education system as in the USSR, the restoration and construction of the civil defense infrastructure.
  31. Seraphimamur
    Seraphimamur 27 January 2018 05: 28 New
    +2
    Yes, Russia is not ready for a war of attrition, as during the Great Patriotic War, but only for participation in local conflicts and anti-terrorism measures.
  32. alavrin
    alavrin 28 January 2018 12: 20 New
    0
    The message itself is debatable. The author believes that World War III will be akin to the first and second? And what goals will the enemy pursue? If the resources, then they are already under the control of transnational corporations, like the national bank, the gold and foreign exchange reserves are also partly in the USA, and partly converted into US government bonds.
    So, you must first answer the question: what and from whom are you going to protect?
  33. Thomas the Unbelieving
    Thomas the Unbelieving 28 January 2018 14: 16 New
    0
    I read the comments (60) and was upset. After all, we were taught how to: assess the situation, and then make decisions. So, it bothers me that we still misjudge the situation, identifying the Second World War with the Second World War: I wrote about this at the forum (The Third World is impossible until the Second Imperialist Ends). We poorly represent our strengths and our enemies. I already spoke about this at the forum in detail in three parts under the heading “Who are we and where are we going?). The last, third part, I called Si vis pacem, para bellum-to put it another way: if you want peace, prepare for war. In general, I often some passages from our combatant are recalled, for example: “Ukraine is golden, Belarus is dear ..” And also: “Far East, strong support, the Union stands, stands indestructible, And what we have won with blood, we will never give to the enemy.” A You say DOSAAF.