Military Review

President at a press conference: I consider the work of our government satisfactory

190
China Radio International:
In 2018, Russia will have a presidential election. How will these choices affect relations with China?



Xinhua:
Russia and China have announced a strategy for a single belt, a single path. How do you assess the Russian-Chinese relations? How do you assess the decisions of the CPC Congress in terms of the development of international relations?


Vladimir Putin:
China is our largest strategic partner. We have the largest turnover with China. Today it is about 63 billion dollars. We launched several major projects together with China, including the Yamal-LNG project. China is the largest investor in these projects. We have projects in space, aviation, energy.

As for the elections in Russia, I have full confidence that relations with China have a national consensus, and therefore relations with the PRC will remain unchanged after the elections.


President at a press conference: I consider the work of our government satisfactory


Question from NTV:
Will the current government survive the elections?


The president:
I consider the work of our government satisfactory. This is evidenced by a return to sustainable economic growth, sustainable macroeconomic development. The influx of investments from abroad is still a matter of trust in the government. I think that it is premature to raise the issue of personnel changes today.
Photos used:
Rossiya24
190 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must to register.

I have an account? Sign in

  1. Million
    Million 14 December 2017 14: 47 New
    28
    The conference can end ...
    1. Shura Perm
      Shura Perm 14 December 2017 14: 48 New
      16
      government work at 0 out of 5 ...
      1. Anarchist
        Anarchist 14 December 2017 14: 51 New
        36
        Quote: Shura Perm
        government work at 0 out of 5 ...

        Somewhere, in places by -2! In education, for example: they introduced the Singapore system when they praise the Soviet system! They also offer teachers to go to business, whom the salary does not suit ...
        Pests are sucks!
        1. Sergey-svs
          Sergey-svs 14 December 2017 15: 12 New
          16
          Quote: Anarchist
          Pests are sucks!

          The best scenario for a press conference of the President of Russia would be the following scenario. winked Putin appears in the hall and approaches a huge screen, and on it they show how well-known embezzlers and oligarchs are packed into the "craters"! good After a while, the screen darkens, the president says the phrase: “I think I answered all your questions,” and leaves! yes
          But, these were just dreams ... crying
          1. Pivot
            Pivot 14 December 2017 17: 54 New
            +2
            Yes, they would shout that they are planting the opposition and this is not democratic. In short gentlemen, one thing is clear that the government does not do, you will whine anyway. It’s like in Krasnodar we had streets with broken asphalt such as you whining that everything is bad, now they are repairing again whining they say that the elections are in progress and that the traffic jams are terrible, and I personally have to lay down the main thing for whiners in the near future on smooth roads.
            1. Anarchist
              Anarchist 14 December 2017 18: 44 New
              13
              And to teach children, too, will be smooth roads?
              Roads are local problems of individual regions! And education, healthcare and so on are the affairs of the state as a whole!
              1. Pivot
                Pivot 14 December 2017 20: 45 New
                0
                Health care is a global system for replacing people with drugs as drug addicts. The education system, which is so bad in it now, choose the direction of development in the humanities or the physics and technology department and go ahead. Whining is not necessary, no one is obliged to you, children’s education, the problem of parents has always been like that. It's just that they are openly talking about it now.
                1. Anarchist
                  Anarchist 14 December 2017 21: 14 New
                  14
                  Uncle, what have you started - whining, Yes whining? Did you hear me whining? I’m just right, everything is fine ... Work, salary, prosperity! Well, I’m thinking about others ... Unlike you!
                  Are you satisfied with our education? When Kolya Urengoysky apologizes to the Nazis ... Secondary education is free with us! And it is approved by the Constitution! And the teacher from whom the children go to the tutor is bad ... But they are not paid. It’s worthy not to think about how to feed their children at work ... But I understood you as egoists: this mode allows you to rake money, Most likely in the bureaucratic chair or in law enforcement, and the rest do not care! In this case, I have nothing to talk about with you! A concept like people is alien to you ...
                2. Overlock
                  Overlock 14 December 2017 21: 25 New
                  +4
                  you would probably need a doctor. Then all your arrogance will quickly disappear.
                3. Alf
                  Alf 14 December 2017 21: 46 New
                  +2
                  Quote: Pivot
                  Health care is a global system for replacing people with drugs as drug addicts.

                  Have you ever been treated at least once? Or not ?
                  1. Pivot
                    Pivot 14 December 2017 22: 38 New
                    0
                    No, and I do not advise you.
                    1. Overlock
                      Overlock 14 December 2017 23: 08 New
                      +2
                      But you have to. Testosterone will fall and hi
                    2. Alf
                      Alf 14 December 2017 23: 54 New
                      +3
                      Quote: Pivot
                      No, and I do not advise you.

                      Never in my life? Are you probably a cyborg?
            2. BecmepH
              BecmepH 15 December 2017 06: 10 New
              +1
              Quote: Pivot
              In short gentlemen, one thing is clear that the government does not do, you will whine anyway.

              Therefore, it (the government) does nothing ... Well, so that we do not ache
      2. papas-57
        papas-57 14 December 2017 16: 11 New
        12
        `` I consider the work of our government satisfactory. '' Here it really became funny!
        1. INTER
          INTER 14 December 2017 17: 26 New
          +1
          Quote: papas-57
          `` I consider the work of our government satisfactory. '' Here it really became funny!

          Satisfactory - this is 3, not 4, not 5.
    2. Black_Vatnik
      Black_Vatnik 14 December 2017 14: 50 New
      +1
      A satisfactory rating from Putin means that the Khalam in the government are worth considering.
      1. 210ox
        210ox 14 December 2017 14: 52 New
        15
        Uh! ... They’re out there in the armchairs of all of us ..
        Quote: Black_Jacket
        A satisfactory rating from Putin means that the Khalam in the government are worth considering.
        1. Frol 7525
          Frol 7525 14 December 2017 14: 58 New
          14
          Why, it’s warm, light, and, most importantly, dry !!! And you can also collect a collection of gold watches ... laughing
      2. Overlock
        Overlock 14 December 2017 16: 48 New
        +1
        about still grabbing
      3. Alf
        Alf 14 December 2017 21: 47 New
        +3
        Quote: Black_Jacket
        A satisfactory rating from Putin means that the Khalam in the government are worth considering.

        So they thought. Tight tight. And they realized, Steal, everything will be fine, the godfather will cover!
    3. Sling cutter
      Sling cutter 14 December 2017 15: 05 New
      19
      Quote: Million
      The conference can end ...

      could not start ...
    4. Kent0001
      Kent0001 14 December 2017 16: 15 New
      +6
      Those. IPhone and Co. steers as it should ... then I probably don’t understand something ......
      1. Nonna
        Nonna 14 December 2017 18: 36 New
        +9
        Talk about nothing, empty talk and all the same irresponsibility of the authorities before the country and the people. Everything is fine with him, well, almost everything. Only with thieves does not know what to do. And so everything is fine, the government is working, the king likes everything.
        What can the head of the capitalist state promise the people (state employees, small entrepreneurs, hard workers who plow the landlord)? For state employees, salary growth, or at least indexation, for entrepreneurs is not tax increases and weakening press checks, the ability to take loans for current or start-ups, hard workers are strictly observing labor laws and trade unions. Did you hear that? Me not
        There is absolutely no reaction to the events around the OI. Mutko stated that he was ready to resign, but there was no reaction that was accepted. It seems that Putin agreed that the IOC and usada are right, because everything is very soft and concordant, it seems that it happens, but next time it will be as it should, as if there was no Brazil. All the people against the trip and for a boycott, but Putin does not mind, they want to let them go A lot of words, but there is no specifics on any issue, even where he can decide, for example, OI. In general, stagnation and further impoverishment are guaranteed.
  2. forester
    forester 14 December 2017 14: 47 New
    27
    And the people consider the work of the government disgusting
    1. St Petrov
      St Petrov 14 December 2017 14: 48 New
      12
      and I believe that oil prices were $ 25
      but how many people here whined that at a price of $ 60, the economy will fly to tartarars.
      Well, because the government is wretched. Yeah.

      They also whined about the reserve fund and other things.

      And where are these forecasts? Where is the bankruptcy? The impoverishment of the masses? Correctly. I gave these forecasts a rotational motion

      So far, they have been whining about bad "government" for a dozen years now - GDP has increased from 7 to 86 trillion

      2001 - 8 trillion 943,6 billion rubles
      2002 - 10 trillion 830,5 billion rubles
      2003 - 13 trillion 208,2 billion rubles
      2004 - 17 trillion 027,2 billion rubles
      2005 - 21 trillion 609,8 billion rubles
      2006 - 26 trillion 917,2 billion rubles
      2007 - 33 trillion 247,5 billion rubles
      2008 - 41 trillion 276,8 billion rubles
      2009 - 38 trillion 807,2 billion rubles
      2010 - 46 trillion 308,5 billion rubles
      2011 - 60 trillion 282,5 billion rubles
      2012 - 68 trillion 163,9 billion rubles
      2013 - 73 trillion 133,9 billion rubles
      2014 - 79 trillion 199,7 billion rubles
      2015 - 83 trillion 232,6 billion rubles
      2016 - 86 trillion 043,6 billion rubles

      And while they will whine here and thereafter, a bad government will continue to work and increase GDP

      Dry your snot, gentlemen. Press the buttons and make predictions - I will read you in the toilet, nevertheless more interesting than the label on the air freshener
      1. Zhelezyakin
        Zhelezyakin 14 December 2017 15: 20 New
        +2
        The rating is satisfactory, it has always been so far from failure, by how much is far from ideal. On the C grade! And then a reasonable question, but where are the excellent students?
      2. AA17
        AA17 14 December 2017 15: 49 New
        20
        Dear, Mr. Petrov. Add a few digits to your data. The picture will look different.
        2001 - 8 trillion. 943,6 billion rubles - the number of $ billionaires in Russia - 8 people.
        2002 - 10 trillion. 830,5 billion rubles - 7 people.
        2003 - 13 trillion. 208,2 billion rubles - 17 people.
        2004 - 17 trillion. 027,2 billion rubles - 25 people.
        2005 - 21 trillion. 609,8 billion rubles - 30 people.
        2006 - 26 trillion. 917,2 billion rubles - 44 people.
        2007 - 33 trillion. 247,5 billion rubles - 60 people.
        2008 - 41 trillion. 276,8 billion rubles - 87 people.
        2009 - 38 trillion. 807,2 billion rubles - 32 people.
        2010 - 46 trillion. 308,5 billion rubles - 62 people.
        2011 - 60 trillion. 282,5 billion rubles - 101 people.
        2012 - 68 trillion. 163,9 billion rubles - 96 people.
        2013 - 73 trillion. 133,9 billion rubles - 110 people.
        2014 - 79 trillion. 199,7 billion rubles - 111 people.
        2017 - 86 trillion. 043,6 billion rubles - 97 people.
        "... Forbes Russia 2017." ... The global economy is clearly heading towards stabilization, even if Russian businessmen, crushed by sanctions and low oil prices, have such an impressive growth in capital over the year. Last year, 76 Russian entrepreneurs with a total capital of $ 275 billion were included in the Forbes list, and the 2017 rating already includes 96 Russians and their total assets added 40% in weight, reaching $ 387,2 billion. The pre-crisis level of 422 billion dollars recorded in the 2014 rating has not yet been restored, but the dynamics are convincing! ... "
        "... The number of dollar millionaires in Russia last year (2016-AA17) grew the fastest in the world, follows from the report of the World Wealth Report 2017, compiled by the consulting company Capgemini ..."
        P.S. "... a bad government will continue to work and increase GDP ..." - Your phrase. Conclusion: The larger the GDP of Russia, the more billionaires and millionaires in Russia. The rest of the Russians are getting poorer.
        1. St Petrov
          St Petrov 14 December 2017 16: 20 New
          +3
          Conclusion: The larger the GDP of Russia, the more billionaires and millionaires in Russia. The rest of the Russians are getting poorer.


          You will become poor until you learn how to draw the right conclusions.

          And counting other people's money, you certainly will not become richer.
          1. AA17
            AA17 14 December 2017 16: 24 New
            +9
            We are talking about Russia's GDP. There is also part of my work. So, I count my money.
            1. St Petrov
              St Petrov 14 December 2017 16: 26 New
              +1
              OK. how much poorer have you been since 2001?

              1. LPD17
                LPD17 14 December 2017 19: 32 New
                +8
                Quote: c-Petrov
                OK. how much poorer have you been since 2001?

                why not since 1913 ??? and?
                let's see easier in the last 5 years ???
                did you rate your post rate?

                Tov bots bosses on content ,! where do you find these? they are visible on the first sentence. !!! Replace the ignoramus !!!
                1. St Petrov
                  St Petrov 14 December 2017 20: 50 New
                  +1
                  let's see easier in the last 5 years ???


                  but not since 2014? are you hinting at it right? Here we are talking about Putin and the government. Build a logical chain, if you know how to do it.

                  And ask your boss to raise your bid. And then with non-existent "Tov Bosses" to talk - also a diagnosis
          2. Overlock
            Overlock 14 December 2017 16: 59 New
            +9
            Quote: c-Petrov
            And counting other people's money, you certainly will not become richer.

            you obviously live in good prosperity? you do not care about fellow citizens. The main thing is that everything is good at home
            1. St Petrov
              St Petrov 14 December 2017 20: 54 New
              +1
              it’s not a matter of dough - but that whining is your credo.

              And I don't care about you. Then you correctly noticed. And at home so that it’s good - so you need to make an effort to this, not Putin to swear on the forum

              In general, if you get used to the thought that nobody owes you anything, it will become easier to live and you will only blame yourself for your failures and this will be the beginning of your path to success
        2. SPACE
          SPACE 14 December 2017 19: 06 New
          0
          Quote: AA17
          Add a few digits to your data. The picture will look different.

          Not differently, but directly confirms GDP growth.
      3. andrej-shironov
        andrej-shironov 14 December 2017 15: 50 New
        15
        wink Dear Petrov! Please write, how can children feed their share of GDP and how to shovel and shoe them in GDP?
        1. St Petrov
          St Petrov 14 December 2017 16: 06 New
          +3
          Well, I understand that some probably only eat in my head. But okay. I'll tell you.

          The greater the GDP, the greater means the state can operate. To do infrastructure projects, pay social benefits for the birth of the first child, capital and other stuff

          And you, not working and not paying taxes - I think they should not count on anything at all. I would take a fine from you every month until you officially get a job. Like in Belarus. And then about children paint your hungry.

          And first of all, you need to ask from yourself, and not from Putin, Medvedev or anyone else.

          Although it is more complicated. But I wish you strength. And yes - your fight with Putin is ridiculous and wretched.

          So brace yourself and get ready to whine for another 6 years. Although I am sure you will always whine, no matter who is sitting in the Kremlin.

          As long as we have a population of 150 million people — 50 million pensioners + state employees — and even such characters who do not pay taxes above the roof and only 15 million do the added value of the product — we will live like that.

          Until you understand this, you’ll whine on the forum that the state should feed your children


          1. Old military officer
            Old military officer 14 December 2017 16: 38 New
            14
            I saw m .. eccentrics, the eccentric himself, but to such an extent ...
          2. andrej-shironov
            andrej-shironov 14 December 2017 16: 48 New
            +8
            wink The keyword in your tirade is "may." And as we know about men, "to be does not mean to want" wink So let the authorities create economic conditions that I found an official job with a decent salary and I will be happy to pay taxes. And you do not poke me.
            1. St Petrov
              St Petrov 14 December 2017 16: 54 New
              +2
              And you do not poke me.


              But what should I do with you? can i respect you unemployed? not paying taxes? and on the forum whining about their hungry children?

              So let the authorities create economic conditions that I found an official job


              you're funny. Go better work, you have hungry children. Not push buttons

              I will be happy to pay taxes


              yeah. wonderful you

              1. andrej-shironov
                andrej-shironov 14 December 2017 17: 26 New
                11
                smile Only understanding of my innocence keeps me from complaining to administrators about you. You worry about your children, and not mine. Petrov merged, blown away, became old! And now we are offered to vote for the same! And laughter and sin! wink
                1. St Petrov
                  St Petrov 14 December 2017 17: 29 New
                  +2
                  you have your own reality apparently. and I don’t worry about your children - I just note how lucky they are with Dad)
                  1. andrej-shironov
                    andrej-shironov 14 December 2017 17: 31 New
                    +6
                    smile Lucky Petrov, lucky! wink Unlike you.
                2. Stirbjorn
                  Stirbjorn 14 December 2017 21: 23 New
                  11
                  Quote: andrej-shironov
                  Petrov merged, blown away, became old!

                  You will be surprised, but Petrov is a freelancer himself (officially unemployed), who does not pay taxes - he reported this recently (I can give a link). And all his freelancing, which consists in stupid trolling on VO, makes money as best he can, because he is an invalid who is kept out of pity here, otherwise they would have been banned for a long time, because even the evil Ilyina, as a result, was sent to an eternal ban. They laugh sinfully over the wretched hi
                  1. andrej-shironov
                    andrej-shironov 14 December 2017 21: 34 New
                    +7
                    smile That he is disabled I already understood from the comments. But in any case, thanks dear Stirbjorn!
                  2. St Petrov
                    St Petrov 14 December 2017 21: 39 New
                    0
                    You will be surprised, but Petrov is a freelancer himself (officially unemployed), who does not pay taxes - he reported this recently (I can give a link).


                    I have been officially employed for 10 years. At the extreme place of work - 4 years, 6 months. I work not for Putin, but for representatives from the Syrian Arab Republic. Therefore, show the link, or finally understand that you are sick.

                    I’ll tell you more, 3 days a week I don’t go to work at all, because I work from home. And along the way, I'm already doing freelance work. After work.

                    And all his freelancing is dumb trolling on VO


                    you want to think so. because you are alternatively gifted.

                    for he is disabled


                    you're not yapping? now you will answer for your words and give the facts here.

                    They laugh sinfully over the wretched


                    I confess to you that I am sinful.

                    And about the war, the character below. Yes. I didn’t have a chance to fight for my homeland). He served in the North Caucasus Military District in 2007 in unit 37115. When the war started, we were all told to be ready and we were ready. And they were assembled and staffed and waiting for the team, but after 5 days the political officer told us a fascinating story how the Armed Forces of the Russian Federation drove the enemy and that we did not manage to take part in this event.

                    Now I think you tell me a fascinating story about your exploits for the good of the motherland? Did you even serve?

                    I don’t understand how the officer who served or the person who swore allegiance can drown against the supreme so. Stoke for a forceful change of government and breed ochlocracy, breaking order
                    1. andrej-shironov
                      andrej-shironov 14 December 2017 22: 22 New
                      +2
                      Petrov, where did I write for a power change of power?
                    2. Nehist
                      Nehist 15 December 2017 00: 23 New
                      +3
                      Petrov! For me as a military man, Putin ceased to exist as supreme and as a person in 2000 after the famous event in Tangi-Chu.
                    3. zoolu350
                      zoolu350 15 December 2017 04: 26 New
                      +5
                      Quote: c-Petrov

                      I don’t understand how the officer who served or the person who swore allegiance can drown against the supreme so. Stoke for a forceful change of government and breed ochlocracy, breaking order

                      I explain. We took the oath to the people of Russia, and not to the oligarchy of the Russian Federation. If this supreme serves as outright thieves, spreading his guts and bending under the enemies of Russia (the owners of the Fed and their various slaves like Bandera-fascists, Zionofashists), then he is worthy only of a slow and painful death. The "order" of the Russian oligarchy is the humiliation of the country and the people, we need order for the people and the restoration of Russia from Brest to Vladivostok, from Cape Chelyuskin to Kushka, flights to Mars and Thermonuclear Reactors in Kamchatka. And the lackeys of the oligarchy of the Russian Federation need only a big trough and nishtyakov in it more for themselves loved ones because for the rest they ............
              2. Sling cutter
                Sling cutter 14 December 2017 22: 14 New
                +7
                Quote: c-Petrov
                Go better work, you have hungry children. Not push buttons

                Why are you so poor-tempered today? wassat
                after two years you’ll whine, how could I drive such garbage laughing
                He served in the North Caucasus Military District in 2007 in part 37115.

                Is this another 28 years old for you? belay
                Maladoy at all, it's very hot, it’s not in time for the Abatstsa, tyk is already dry wassat
                1. St Petrov
                  St Petrov 14 December 2017 22: 17 New
                  +1
                  Welcome hi

                  The government also needs to be cherished wisely; I am having fun over the weak. Selectively. Over the medalists. You, too, are of course seasoned, but I know why I respect you and I think you can ask the state, but I do not agree with some points of course. I agree with some.

                  And here I’m drowning for Putin and for his affairs in the army from the moment of registration in 12, and I registered because I wanted to tell you what I do not agree with the opinion I don’t remember anyone. - My comments here are still all saved. Until they seem to be deleted wassat

                  Well, let's see. Of course, one cannot be 100% sure of anything without possessing all the facts. But I'm from the heart)

                  Therefore, Straporez also leave room for doubt in your choice, she loves to mourn life)

                  ps I already walked the anniversary at 30 drinks

                  1. andrej-shironov
                    andrej-shironov 14 December 2017 22: 24 New
                    +6
                    smile In your case, age did not add intelligence.
                    1. St Petrov
                      St Petrov 14 December 2017 22: 26 New
                      +1
                      I already told you everything below. but I will soon be banned, rejoice, you'll be here to ply each other with the same non-Polite natives. And even no one will tell you that you are an eccentric when I leave

                      And there was a cool uncle Waf. Here he is when Medvedev "drenched" and the government - I put him the pluses laughing Because he is a husband and by deed has proved his love for the homeland.

                      but when muddy characters like you, a freedom-loving person who does not need a state, do it, that's another story

                      they may be Bandera or Georgians, and Latvians roam here, they write in Russian, but they bark at the Kremlin

                      maybe you are romanian

                      but at least an actor
                      1. andrej-shironov
                        andrej-shironov 14 December 2017 22: 28 New
                        +2
                        And I have already answered you all below.
                  2. The comment was deleted.
                  3. Sling cutter
                    Sling cutter 14 December 2017 23: 20 New
                    +7
                    Quote: c-Petrov
                    ps I already walked the anniversary at 30

                    Well so, I congratulate Kaneshn !!! good drinks I remember at 30 in the car in the morning I put Gaza Strip - "I am 30 years old today."
                    Quote: c-Petrov
                    from the moment of registration in the year 12, but I registered because I wanted to tell you why I disagree with the opinion I don’t remember anyone. - My comments here are still all saved.


                    I also found mine, somewhere at one time everything was “muttered.” “Gopota” was terrible, but how much was dashing people))) But all “hello”, “let me greet.” I remember “Ptah” broke))) ))).
                    Quote: c-Petrov
                    And I’m drowning for Putin and for his affairs in the army
                    Duc swamp, if you sense the truth, it’s just not true .... I myself didn’t understand the 89th ..
                    Old man, it’s still to analyze and analyze what matters there .... I’ll probably tell you in a personal link, read, do not be lazy ... This is me for this.
                    Quote: c-Petrov
                    Of course, one cannot be 100% sure of anything without possessing all the facts. But I'm from the heart)

                    Quote: c-Petrov
                    Therefore, Straporez also leave room for doubt in your choice, she loves to mourn life)

                    Stroporez from the words "sling" and cut " soldier
                    And about my choice, it took place back in the 91st, in the 93rd it strengthened, and most importantly, an understanding came of what would happen next. I read a lot of books, grumbled in the archives,
                    in waste paper dug PSS V.I. Lenin, then I.V. Stalin and everything in his head returned to normal. (Cursed himself that in the "instinct" political economy and Marxism-Leninism were poorly taught).
                    Putin is a damn to me, here the system that he represents is important, he is the “top”, and the “roots” are much deeper.
                    Voshchem read more and compare the facts. Here, even the Nexus "blushed", which can not but rejoice. good laughing
                    1. BecmepH
                      BecmepH 15 December 2017 06: 41 New
                      +3
                      Quote: Stroporez
                      And about my choice, it took place back in the 91st, in the 93rd it strengthened, and most importantly, an understanding came of what would happen next.

                      But I’m just now completely ripened. Although, it should be noted, before Krymnash also did not approve of the system. More precisely, hesitated. But now, finally ripened. Sling cutter, I'm with you.
                      1. Sling cutter
                        Sling cutter 15 December 2017 13: 49 New
                        +3
                        Quote: BecmepH
                        But now, finally ripened. Sling cutter, I'm with you.

                        It’s nice and very important, Comrade! good drinks
            2. SPACE
              SPACE 14 December 2017 19: 28 New
              +1
              Quote: andrej-shironov
              So let the authorities create economic conditions that I found an official job with a decent salary and I will be happy to pay taxes.

              Or can you also spread jam on your nose?
              Or you are the same as you yourself put it ...
              Quote: andrej-shironov
              And as we know about men, "to be does not mean to want"

              Our state is not a slave-owning state, it should not exploit and force its citizens to work, all are free in their choice.
              1. andrej-shironov
                andrej-shironov 14 December 2017 19: 34 New
                +7
                wink So I understand the state finally owes nothing to the people! Then nafik do people need it? Together with the government and the guarantor.
                1. St Petrov
                  St Petrov 14 December 2017 20: 56 New
                  +1
                  the state is necessary for the people. and the circus wandering is enough for clowns.
                  1. Overlock
                    Overlock 14 December 2017 21: 02 New
                    +4
                    Thank God you are not the whole nation. After all, such a people has no future
                    1. St Petrov
                      St Petrov 14 December 2017 21: 20 New
                      +1
                      from where so much pathos in speeches?

                      No, well, if you fought in the war for the Homeland, like the same Stroporez, then I will have respect for you, no matter how stubborn you are. And even if you write me insulting words, I will think, no, well, he’s a human, and he still has the right. By skin for the state he risked all things

                      But while I do not understand why you decided here to speak on behalf of the "people", I can only joke with you. You already streamline

                      1. Overlock
                        Overlock 14 December 2017 21: 26 New
                        +4
                        so it’s you, a bad person, broadcasting here on behalf of the people. Raise your eyes higher, open them wider and read your opus
                      2. St Petrov
                        St Petrov 14 December 2017 21: 33 New
                        +1
                        in the elections we will see with whom the people. With me - well, or I with him - or with the clowns who are here with Putin and the "Gangster" "thieving" government.

                        You still start fighting with Orthodoxy in an Orthodox country and be surprised then, whose one is looking at you as insane

                        You see that they are voting for Putin, but you drew a churov with fraud and other things in your head, and then you are surprised that there are people who will not pass by and tell you what they think.
                      3. andrej-shironov
                        andrej-shironov 14 December 2017 21: 36 New
                        +3
                        Petrov you yourself that miracle fought for your homeland?
                  2. andrej-shironov
                    andrej-shironov 14 December 2017 21: 16 New
                    +3
                    smile Petrov, this is a ram for a leader.
                    1. St Petrov
                      St Petrov 14 December 2017 21: 24 New
                      +1
                      you are a circus actor. You don’t understand why you need a state. You don’t understand who gave you education, who organized your defense during the war, only a clown can write phrases in style — why do I need a state? or - the state should create conditions for me so that I take the form to work officially and start paying taxes.

                      You are generally funny. I don’t know why you draw emoticons. It’s actually sad that there are such characters

                      It means dreaming about civilization, about direct roads, about infrastructure, about normal pensions - not an option at all

                      while there are characters like you.

                      And you need to get a job. You break the system. And she will not work well - as long as there are such "personalities" "Free" who do not need a pack leader.

                      I say - go to Ukraine and understand in contrast why the state is needed and why people need to pay taxes

                      If solid people like you inhabited Russia - who do not understand why their state is needed - then Russia would no longer exist and, in principle, it would not have appeared. without organization and hierarchy

                      Without the institutes “Army” and “Church” we would not be what we are now.

                      And without the “State”, you would have melted snow now, and mined a spark fire.

                      And only a circus actor, not an adult husband, can understand this.

                      You carefully read what I write to you, I will rarely write to you about the case.

                      Of course, I’m trying to understand people like you in order to communicate more respectfully with you, but I don’t always succeed, because this is a useless exercise

                      1. andrej-shironov
                        andrej-shironov 14 December 2017 21: 38 New
                        +3
                        Petrov, I’m your understanding of the drum. And no one gave me anything, unlike you. All that I can be proud of, I did to myself, unlike you. We can ride to Ukraine ourselves. Anestandand?
                      2. St Petrov
                        St Petrov 14 December 2017 21: 53 New
                        0
                        andrej-shironov, would be a doctor I would diagnose you. But I’ll just assume that you really work in the circus, the main star
                    2. SPACE
                      SPACE 14 December 2017 23: 20 New
                      0
                      Quote: andrej-shironov
                      Petrov, this is a ram for a leader.

                      Wolves and lions have leaders. People have respected elders and sages, the family has a head of the family, the army has a commander, the company has a leader, the state has a president and we give smart, better rights to rule and lead us! And you mean you do not need? Is it like bacteria? So they eat each other ...
                      1. andrej-shironov
                        andrej-shironov 15 December 2017 09: 37 New
                        +1
                        In this world of neoliberal capitalism everyone eats each other. He (capitalism) is imprisoned for this. By the way, is the head of the company responsible for the results of this company? And how then will the soldiers react to the commander when they realize that it was because of his wrong decisions that almost the entire unit was wasted?
                  3. Sling cutter
                    Sling cutter 15 December 2017 01: 09 New
                    +4
                    Quote: c-Petrov
                    And there was a cool uncle Waf. Here he is when Medvedev "drenched" and the government - I put him the pluses Because he is a husband, and by deed he proved his love for the homeland.

                    And Normal was not Husband?! And NVV -Vitya?
                    What about the wheel?
                    And here is this comrade:


                    It’s just that nothing happens, and the Boys will not speak in vain either!
                    All SERVICE people !!!
                2. SPACE
                  SPACE 14 December 2017 22: 33 New
                  0
                  Quote: andrej-shironov
                  So I understand the state finally owes nothing to the people

                  The state was created by people, by the people, it is people who pay taxes to the state, so that with these funds it would ensure law, equal rights, the rule of law within the state and protection against external encroachments, as well as help the disadvantaged. Everything! And this means what exactly you owe to the state. How much tax have you paid? What will the state have enough money for?
                  Education, health care, nutrition, you, as a competent person, must provide for yourself and do not forget to save 10% for retirement, how much you save, you will live on that. As they say, both drowned and dug, or do you want everything for free, more, at the expense of the state? And where will the state take this money for you? Maybe he will take it from others and give it to you? Maybe you are special? Gifted?
                  Quote: andrej-shironov
                  Then nafik do people need it? Together with the government and the guarantor.

                  But what for then do you need the state and government along with the guarantor? Who needs parasites?
                  1. andrej-shironov
                    andrej-shironov 14 December 2017 22: 42 New
                    +2
                    smile Well! For Petrov, Cosmos has drawn in! This makes me happy. I report: I received education exclusively myself for my money, I have not been using free medicine since the 90s, since it’s pointless, I don’t ask for retirement for unworked years. Now my questions are: does the state guarantee equal rights with us? With law, too, not everything is smooth, at least in the higher echelons of power. And by the way, neither the guarantor nor the government needs me, like my children, like the majority of the population. With this I unconditionally agree.
                    1. SPACE
                      SPACE 14 December 2017 23: 09 New
                      0
                      Quote: andrej-shironov
                      And now my questions: does the state ensure equal rights with us?

                      Do you know at least one country where not only are declared, but equal rights apply? No, of course, the state is still imperfect, but it is the fault of people including the government and yours.
                      Quote: andrej-shironov
                      With law, too, not everything is smooth, at least in the higher echelons of power.

                      And what's new? What will you do?
                      Quote: andrej-shironov
                      And by the way, neither the guarantor nor the government needs me, like my children, like the majority of the population. With this I unconditionally agree.

                      Suppose even that this is so, I am sure that the guarantor does not personally know you, like many, although in the government and so on, people are also from the people. But is it possible to conclude from this that the state does not need you and others? Today no one can live outside the state, but you have the choice to live in your own shit, or destroy it, and then another state will come to you, perhaps alien, will you be happy with this? If so, then you better go there and not interfere with those who are ready to build this state, invest in it and protect it.
                      1. andrej-shironov
                        andrej-shironov 15 December 2017 09: 41 New
                        +1
                        smile Space, such a country was, I think you remember the name yourself, however, if you passed the exam, you may not know. Further, your metaphor about the house neither to the star nor to the Red Army. The state is not a thing and, accordingly, does not fulfill the function of things. For your best understanding, I replaced the word state with the word power.
                  2. zoolu350
                    zoolu350 15 December 2017 04: 38 New
                    +1
                    Quote: SPACE
                    But what for then do you need the state and government along with the guarantor? Who needs parasites?

                    Well, of course. Why do RF workers, teachers, doctors, scientists? It's all parasites, but for some reason the school does not think so.
              2. zoolu350
                zoolu350 15 December 2017 04: 32 New
                0
                Quote: SPACE
                Our state is not a slave-owning state, it should not exploit and force its citizens to work, all are free in their choice.

                The school is just a slave state, because there is complete democracy - the power of slave owners (owners of the Fed). And here we have the oligarchy of the Russian Federation also seeks to establish full slavery, but Soviet traditions interfere.
      4. Overlock
        Overlock 14 December 2017 16: 58 New
        11
        If everything is so wonderful, then why are children collected for treatment by telly?
        Would you like to wipe the snot of 22 million beggars in Russia? or working for 10300? Or a granny retired with a pension of 11000?
        1. St Petrov
          St Petrov 14 December 2017 16: 58 New
          +3
          and whose one are you not telling how many beggars were before Medvedev and Putin?

          And what about retirement? You can $ for the sake of objectivity

          Or did Medvedev and Putin make granny retired just worse?

          or working for 10300


          everyone chooses for himself the salary and the job that he wants (in terms of there are no strict conditions for a person that he is obliged to work there or there) and for which he has enough abilities. In the end - if there is no work in the region - there is a computer - training courses and so on - in general, everything is real. And the remote work is enough. It would be a desire

          here
          andrej-shironov
          for the state is poor, unemployed and useless. But he goes to the hospital, counts on the best conditions and has his own requirements.
          1. Overlock
            Overlock 14 December 2017 17: 15 New
            11
            so EBN did not boast like GDP. EBN even promised to go on the rails, but the GDP does not promise, it just raises taxes and prices.
            1. St Petrov
              St Petrov 14 December 2017 17: 19 New
              +2
              You write on the topic.

              Started about retirement? So write about retirement. Again these be-be-be-be

              Let's talk about beggars: how many beggars were there before Medvedev and Putin?

              Are you Georgian? Or am I talking with a child? Or are there just enough posts to fight?
          2. andrej-shironov
            andrej-shironov 14 December 2017 17: 34 New
            12
            smile Good Petrov! Freud error. The authorities need people-functions, dibile, optimistic, assent to the authorities. 60 fulfilled, die! Is it not wet dreams. wink With such defenders, even enemies are not necessary.
            1. St Petrov
              St Petrov 14 December 2017 22: 13 New
              0
              I did not seal. I really consider you a useless ballast on the neck of my state.

              you don’t pay taxes, but go to the hospital and take the line. You use the roads and enjoy all the benefits, not giving the state anything in return.

              And I think you are as far from the army as you are from the "state"

              so I don’t know where you saw the error. You are only a loss.
              1. andrej-shironov
                andrej-shironov 14 December 2017 22: 30 New
                +3
                You think less, otherwise God forbid, the head will sweat, and not far from the common cold.
                1. St Petrov
                  St Petrov 14 December 2017 22: 42 New
                  0
                  cool joking now huh? are you waiting for a standing ovation? Now, in response, I will also be cool to joke

                  I have to pay more taxes because of you, as well as from a clown taking money offshore

                  he simply has more opportunities and more money, if you had money, you would reason the same way and write in a declaration that you are unemployed and take them to quiet harbors with a couple of passports

                  and when you would have been robbed of an unemployed by a couple of millions, you would go to write a statement to the police, I would read about you on the newsline later, spit on it and continue to turn the scroll, knowing that while there are people like you, everything will be slow in this country , with a rattle and with a breakdown in the timing of everything that is possible

                  you would work as an official, you would lie just like many people and it would not be a fact that you wouldn’t take bribes, because you would pay taxes all the time, and you would feel injustice because of your tiny salary.

                  And such characters always justify themselves in front of their conscience. And you will begin to tell others that white is black. How else is that? Do not admit to yourself that you are an eccentric letter M.
                  1. andrej-shironov
                    andrej-shironov 14 December 2017 22: 45 New
                    +2
                    smile Petroov! I do not expect ovations.
                  2. andrej-shironov
                    andrej-shironov 14 December 2017 22: 52 New
                    +2
                    Petrov, you won’t believe it, but even in the harsh 90s you didn’t turn to the police, tried to solve it yourself, it was scary, I’ll tell you honestly, but it was like that, you can’t change that. In my case, there wouldn’t be millions, especially not taken abroad, simply because I need a minimum of money to live. Do you really think that I envy the oligarchs or those who have a lot of money? Petrov you are wretched.
                    1. St Petrov
                      St Petrov 14 December 2017 22: 59 New
                      0
                      Petrov, you won’t believe it, but you didn’t even contact the police in severe 90


                      Andrei, you survived because the police eventually took control of the situation. The state has made you let your daughter go to the store. If it weren’t for the state and the police, you would have lived in hell. Andrew.

                      And while you "decided" with the bandits, the employees were at war with the bandits and with illegal groups in the Caucasus.

                      While the State owed you, they gave their lives for the constitutional system and crushed the enemies of the State. Andryusha got a little pathetic, but it’s so

                      1. andrej-shironov
                        andrej-shironov 14 December 2017 23: 06 New
                        +1
                        smile Andrew? Fi, Petrov, sounds like from the lips of a person of non-traditional sexual orientation, in the common people we will not write what is called. I survived and live Petrov first of all thanks to myself, then thanks to people close to me. The state at the moment has made it so that I do not need to let my daughter into the store, it makes no sense.
                      2. St Petrov
                        St Petrov 14 December 2017 23: 09 New
                        0
                        it smells of you, Andryusha) I am writing to you as such a character. Because I understand what a clown you are and that same word in the letter Pe

                        There is no sense not because of the state, but because you are just the way you are and after Putin leaves - in front of the mirror you will see only your reflection anyway. And your being from this will not change

                        It’s a pity, of course, that they’ll ban and will probably erase the account, but on the other hand, I told the eccentric that he is an eccentric.

                        And then you would have lived in ignorance and considered yourself a cool father, whose daughter has nothing to buy in the store because of Putin
                      3. zoolu350
                        zoolu350 15 December 2017 04: 45 New
                        +1
                        Quote: c-Petrov
                        employees were at war with both bandits and illegal groups in the Caucasus.

                        While the State owed you, they gave their lives for the constitutional system and crushed the enemies of the State. Andryusha got a little pathetic, but it’s so

                        And at that time, the oligarchy of the Russian Federation was just being created, shamelessly robbing its people and selling to the Chechens and others all who fought in the Caucasus. Not pathetic, but true.
      5. Pivot
        Pivot 14 December 2017 17: 57 New
        +4
        The fate of a whiner is always whining. He needs to get everything in hand, whiners do not like to work.
        1. andrej-shironov
          andrej-shironov 14 December 2017 19: 35 New
          +2
          smile Do you hear whining like Turbris? Do not sleep in dog kennels!
          1. Pivot
            Pivot 14 December 2017 22: 48 New
            0
            dogs compared to people like you are the top of the exposure, so it will be offensive to them if you mention them.
            1. andrej-shironov
              andrej-shironov 14 December 2017 22: 59 New
              +2
              smile And then I think why Pavlov set experiments exclusively on dogs! And you people are unhappy that the government is putting experiments on it. Whining panimash. Well, I will replace the word dog with the word Pivot.
      6. Mordvin 3
        Mordvin 3 14 December 2017 23: 19 New
        +4
        Petrov, do you remember how much cigarettes cost in 2001? Or kilo meat?
        1. Sling cutter
          Sling cutter 15 December 2017 00: 45 New
          +2
          Quote: mordvin xnumx
          how much did 2001 cigarettes cost? Or kilo meat?

          Damn, but really how much? I remember before default 6 rubles. a pack of marlboro red and 6 with a half green.
          In the 95th, there were still “Millions” along the way, and in the 97th I bought a “nine” re-export for 5 Baku fittings, the “odnushka” cost so much ... The heaviest one I had was the 95th, I really handed over the bottles ....., and then the trick got better)))))
          1. Mordvin 3
            Mordvin 3 15 December 2017 18: 25 New
            +4
            I at the housing and communal services remembered the prices, because the uncle came, asked. In general, there were about 650 rubles, more than 7 thousand. So let Petrov go to hell with his GDP table. drinks
            1. Sling cutter
              Sling cutter 15 December 2017 19: 12 New
              +2
              Quote: mordvin xnumx
              In general, there were about 650 rubles, more than 7 thousand.

              Here, Brother, we must understand that then there were state-owned ZhKOs, and then private UK.
              Quote: mordvin xnumx
              So let Petrov go to hell with his GDP table

              He is still young, from such "zaputintsev" radical revolutionaries very quickly appear.
              Remember, "if at 18 you are not a revolutionary, then you have a cold heart, and if you are at 40 after a revolutionary, then you are an efdiot" laughing
              So sho it's up to the youth yes
              And I, apparently, got stuck in my youth fellow drinks
      7. BecmepH
        BecmepH 15 December 2017 06: 18 New
        +1
        Quote: c-Petrov
        I will read you in the toilet, still more interesting than the label on the air freshener

        Each person determines his place in life and his interests
      8. BecmepH
        BecmepH 15 December 2017 06: 24 New
        +1
        Quote: c-Petrov
        and I believe that oil prices were $ 25
        but how many people here whined that at a price of $ 60, the economy will fly to tartarars.
        Well, because the government is wretched. Yeah.

        They also whined about the reserve fund and other things.

        And where are these forecasts? Where is the bankruptcy? The impoverishment of the masses? Correctly. I gave these forecasts a rotational motion

        So far, they have been whining about bad "government" for a dozen years now - GDP has increased from 7 to 86 trillion

        2001 - 8 trillion 943,6 billion rubles
        2002 - 10 trillion 830,5 billion rubles
        2003 - 13 trillion 208,2 billion rubles
        2004 - 17 trillion 027,2 billion rubles
        2005 - 21 trillion 609,8 billion rubles
        2006 - 26 trillion 917,2 billion rubles
        2007 - 33 trillion 247,5 billion rubles
        2008 - 41 trillion 276,8 billion rubles
        2009 - 38 trillion 807,2 billion rubles
        2010 - 46 trillion 308,5 billion rubles
        2011 - 60 trillion 282,5 billion rubles
        2012 - 68 trillion 163,9 billion rubles
        2013 - 73 trillion 133,9 billion rubles
        2014 - 79 trillion 199,7 billion rubles
        2015 - 83 trillion 232,6 billion rubles
        2016 - 86 trillion 043,6 billion rubles

        And while they will whine here and thereafter, a bad government will continue to work and increase GDP

        Dry your snot, gentlemen. Press the buttons and make predictions - I will read you in the toilet, nevertheless more interesting than the label on the air freshener

        Well this in rubles is so optimistic. And in the bucks ?. And minus, if you look at the percentages of 2009, 2015 and 2016?
    2. 210ox
      210ox 14 December 2017 14: 48 New
      +9
      The people and the government of DAM are incompatible things ..
      Quote: forester
      And the people consider the work of the government disgusting
      1. Observer2014
        Observer2014 14 December 2017 14: 55 New
        +6
        210ox
        The people and the government of DAM are incompatible things ..
        And providentially, how are you LADIES laughing Without Putin, is it formed and lives its own anti-Russian life? laughing Ha ha. Here are the artists.
    3. SPACE
      SPACE 14 December 2017 14: 59 New
      +4
      Quote: forester
      And the people consider the work of the government disgusting

      Well, yes, we have every cook to understand the work of the government, I also have professors of sour cabbage soup. fool
      The GDP was modest in its assessment, so that the unstable mentality of the mentally ill would not be unnecessarily injured.
      1. andrej-shironov
        andrej-shironov 14 December 2017 19: 37 New
        +3
        smile Really! Every cook can diagnose people! Many of you, cooks!
    4. I doubt it
      I doubt it 14 December 2017 15: 16 New
      17
      Quote: forester
      And the people consider the work of the government disgusting

      And the people no one asks.
      Quote: 210ox
      The people and the government of DAM are incompatible things ..

      But Vova and the government of DAM are compatible things.
      Quote: c-Petrov
      ... GDP increased from 7 to 86 trillion ...

      Is GDP Vladimir Putin? Does he have something increased? Or did his friends increase? Or have deputies, senators increased? Or has the Fed increased its bonds?
      It may very well be. But all the others have decreased ...
      1. St Petrov
        St Petrov 14 December 2017 15: 27 New
        +3
        Is GDP Vladimir Putin? Does he have something increased? Or did his friends increase? Or have deputies, senators increased? Or has the Fed increased its bonds?


        sick, go by
    5. Overlock
      Overlock 14 December 2017 16: 49 New
      10
      Putin’s opinion often does not coincide with the opinion of the people. But Putin is not cold from this, not hot
      1. Golovan Jack
        Golovan Jack 14 December 2017 23: 49 New
        +7
        Quote: Overlock
        Putin’s opinion often does not coincide with the opinion of the people. But Putin is not cold from this, not hot

        The opinion of the PIC of a passenger plane ... well, the opinion of the driver of the trolleybus also often does not coincide with the opinion of the "people." At the same time, the people remain alive, healthy ... but still unhappy.
        Is the analogy clear? wink
        1. Overlock
          Overlock 14 December 2017 23: 53 New
          +2
          there is no analogy. You are not buying FAC, but a plane ticket. Show at least one ticket full name FAC? The difference was caught. If you're lucky with FAC - fly, no - wooden mac. On the plane from you already NOTHING depends.
          Everyone selects the President consciously, personally. His name is known. And everyone understands how he will live. everyone depends his future.
          The analogy does not count.
          1. Golovan Jack
            Golovan Jack 15 December 2017 00: 24 New
            +7
            Quote: B. Zakhoder "Kit and Cat"
            There is no order in this tale
            A word is a mystery ...


            Quote: Overlock
            Everyone selects the President consciously, personally. His name is known

            Ksyushad, for example. Will you choose? wink
            In addition to the name and the set of (quite standard) promises about the candidate, as a rule, nothing is known. That is - pure play "blind" (well, of course, if Ksyushad is not taken into account. Here, of course, a complete fly away).

            Quote: Overlock
            And everyone understands how he will live

            И everyone thinks he understands something. And he is being played at this time. In the dark, as I said already.
            Quote: Overlock
            On the plane, Nothing depends on you

            And I (and you too) in life "on the plane." Or do you really think that you really influence something in the elections?
            Do not make me funny.
            And the analogy - I repeat for the lost - is complete. The top manager will never think about what your cat stinks in the stairwell.
            And he should not do this. It is your concern to keep the staircase clean.
            That's about as request
            1. Overlock
              Overlock 15 December 2017 10: 07 New
              0
              It’s funny to me from your arguments - do you see anything besides Ksyusha? They threw this Sobchak to you like suckers, and you are being fooled. For this, Ksyusha goes to the polls so that you come and vote. In this, its function is to make you come to elections. All.
              For the rest.
              If you do not understand what is happening, this is bad. You need to know and anticipate. And in an airplane, called life, there is always an opportunity to go before the plane crashes. For that, the mind is needed. to calculate which KBC-ac or loser, especially since everything is in sight. Well, if blind, then rightly so, in a crumple.
              Worst of all. when a person believes that he is the smartest, he knows everything and teaches others. But he- in shit up to his ears and everything smears this shit. Here is an analogy for smart
        2. zoolu350
          zoolu350 15 December 2017 04: 51 New
          0
          It is very clear. The opinions of the passenger and the pilot coincide if they both fly to the airport they need, but the opinions of the pilot and passenger diverge sharply if the pilot flies to the wrong airport that the passenger needs and is not pleasant to take into account at the passenger's arrival (death, slavery, beatings). Is the analogy clear?
          1. Golovan Jack
            Golovan Jack 15 December 2017 06: 50 New
            +7
            Quote: zoolu350
            Is the analogy clear?

            And you, my friend, are extreme ... well, or an extremist. laughing
            I'm not talking about that at all.
            And about the fact that if the plane (on the road exactly where you need to, be afraid) gets, for example, into a chatter - the passengers, of course, are slightly scared and very unhappy.
            This discontent is in no way a reason for the FAC to change course / level.
            So clearer?
            What you ... baby yet love
            1. zoolu350
              zoolu350 15 December 2017 08: 55 New
              +3
              I am calm as a boa constrictor before an attack. I have no way with the oligarchy of Russia and its slaves, for people like you need a full belly, and I have a Great State and a happy people, but if you meant your path, then of course, everything is normal for you.
              1. Golovan Jack
                Golovan Jack 15 December 2017 09: 54 New
                +7
                Quote: zoolu350
                I'm calm like a boa constrictor before an attack


                Other uninteresting request
  3. 210ox
    210ox 14 December 2017 14: 47 New
    +3
    They don’t change horses at the crossing ?! I didn’t doubt it at all. Even if there was a strong recession ... Anyway, SATISFACTORY.
    1. Tatanka Yotanka
      Tatanka Yotanka 14 December 2017 14: 57 New
      12
      Quote: 210ox
      Crossing horses do not change

      they changed horses during the war — the commanding districts, fronts, armies, it happened, and they shot, but right now there are expensive trotters in the stalls and miserable nags who make oats, well, a couple of ministers who cost hay for draft horses)))
    2. Nehist
      Nehist 15 December 2017 00: 35 New
      +3
      You are absolutely right! Horses do not change at the crossing, they just shoot
  4. Herculesic
    Herculesic 14 December 2017 14: 48 New
    14
    Well, yes, it turns out here, the economy is growing in breadth and at night! recourse And there’s Ayfoniy Vedmedev — a man was stuck in childhood, he would have been like to go to kindergarten, and they had put him in charge belay
  5. Observer2014
    Observer2014 14 December 2017 14: 49 New
    18
    I consider the work of our government satisfactory. This is also evidenced by the return to sustainable economic growth, sustainable macroeconomic development. Inflow of investments from abroad
    YES!!! wassat laughing laughing
  6. Bulrumeb
    Bulrumeb 14 December 2017 14: 50 New
    15
    I consider the work of our government satisfactory. This is also evidenced by the return to sustainable economic growth, sustainable macroeconomic development. The inflow of investments from abroad is another matter of trust in the government.

    Well, who was talking about a good king and bad boyars? Although I think there will be again
    1. Tatanka Yotanka
      Tatanka Yotanka 14 December 2017 15: 03 New
      +4
      Quote: Bulrumeb
      Well, who was talking about a good king and bad boyars? Although I think there will be again

      here, popular opinion on the branches of the site is bundled up - if it's about foreign policy - it's all about the king, but if the internal one is mainly about the boyars, although the king also gets here)))
      1. Paranoid50
        Paranoid50 15 December 2017 01: 09 New
        +2
        Quote: Tatanka Yotanka
        although the king here also gets)))

        Heh, a lot of opinions ... Wow, chopped wood for the evening! yes There was a moment about the king this morning. Going to work, there was an underground passage near Vyborgskaya, and someone fresh autograph appeared on the wall, which read: “Putin is king”. Five meters later, the same organism scribbled: "The king is not eternal, he will die ...", "Down with the power of thieves", etc. The quintessence appeared at the end of the tunnel, at the exit, where, of course, the same "writer" summed up: "I want to sleep with sluts and never work." Comments will be redundant. yes Such is the story.
  7. Vend
    Vend 14 December 2017 14: 52 New
    +4
    I consider the work of our government satisfactory.
    Satisfactory is not good or excellent. As they say, there is still work to do.
    1. Gardamir
      Gardamir 14 December 2017 15: 12 New
      +4
      Satisfactory it is not good or excellent
      there are two ratings satisfactory and not satisfactory. So let them work. If you remove these, there will be nobody to work with.
      1. andrej-shironov
        andrej-shironov 14 December 2017 15: 52 New
        +2
        laughing Did the chtoli-headed people in Russia transfer or do they (the government) decide so themselves?
    2. Sotskiy
      Sotskiy 14 December 2017 18: 54 New
      +1
      Quote: Wend
      I consider the work of our government satisfactory.
      Satisfactory is not good or excellent. As they say, there is still work to do.

      Perhaps the privatization of state property has not yet been completed. There is something to work on!) Chubais forever!
  8. Herculesic
    Herculesic 14 December 2017 15: 03 New
    +5
    Our economy is like a woman who could only be satisfied with the maximum, but don’t know how to make happy!
  9. Gardamir
    Gardamir 14 December 2017 15: 15 New
    11
    With what measure you measure, such is measured to you.
    I consider the work of our government satisfactory. This is also evidenced by the return to sustainable economic growth, sustainable macroeconomic development. The inflow of investments from abroad is another matter of trust in the government.

    Will there be a ruler in this century, for whom the well-being of the people, and not macroeconomic indicators, is important?
    1. vadsonen
      vadsonen 14 December 2017 15: 40 New
      14
      Will there be a ruler in this century, for whom the well-being of the people, and not macroeconomic indicators, is important?

      St. Petersburg organized crime group led by Vovan herself from the feeding bowl does not come off.
  10. LPD17
    LPD17 14 December 2017 15: 31 New
    +2
    but for example, what with the abolition of the transport tax after the excise tax on gasoline ??? .....
  11. rruvim
    rruvim 14 December 2017 15: 34 New
    12
    Shchyutka: "The steady fall of satellites into the ocean, the withdrawal of our troops from Syria, the liquefaction of gas at the stop of the North and South streams, hundreds of thousands of video cards bought from China for Sberbank, a selected basket of wine and sausages from Ulyukaev ... Therefore, I consider the work of our government to be satisfactory . "
  12. Romin
    Romin 14 December 2017 15: 38 New
    12
    And I consider the work of the Government of the Russian Federation and the assessment of this work by the President of the Russian Federation - Unsatisfactory.
  13. andrej-shironov
    andrej-shironov 14 December 2017 15: 46 New
    +7
    Well, at least someone our government is satisfying. In general, it pleases when power is monolithic in protecting itself.
    1. St Petrov
      St Petrov 14 December 2017 15: 51 New
      +3
      are you all fighting Confused on the internet?

      Go to Ukraine, the state there just distributes what did not work out in the opinion of the pan-leg-killers. Maybe you will be in time

      And I can send you a pot by Russian post. So you fit into the "community"
      1. andrej-shironov
        andrej-shironov 14 December 2017 15: 57 New
        10
        smile Drive yourself! And then such advisers as you are a dime a dozen.
        1. St Petrov
          St Petrov 14 December 2017 16: 12 New
          +2
          a dime a dozen here those who explain their personal problems with the poor work of Medvedev or Putin

          fairy tale characters. With a fabulous fight
          1. andrej-shironov
            andrej-shironov 14 December 2017 16: 51 New
            +9
            smile Come on! Your problems? So I have no problems, there are tasks! I agree Putin and Medvedev are fabulous characters.
          2. rruvim
            rruvim 14 December 2017 19: 02 New
            +3
            And what do Medvedev and Putin work? Or fly on airplanes? By the way, American (English engines). Or on Mozhaika on Mercedes blocking the entire highway. They do not work, but "lead". Two fundamental differences. And we have the right to reason how they lead. And fairy tales have nothing to do with it, everyone came across an illiterate leadership, and what it leads to ...
    2. Overlock
      Overlock 14 December 2017 17: 18 New
      10
      so they satisfy each other: GDP- government, government-GDP
  14. 16112014nk
    16112014nk 14 December 2017 16: 08 New
    12
    As I said yesterday - transfusion from empty to empty. The influx of investment? And what about the outflow of the "sewn" excessively acquired ?. Many times more inflow, but this is not said. One Karimov brought to France several suitcases in cash, weighing more than tons.In cash, over 700 million, across the border, through customs. Try a simple tourist to take out an undeclared currency - they will immediately bind.
  15. Brushing
    Brushing 14 December 2017 16: 08 New
    +2
    Life has become better, life has become happier.... wassat
  16. The comment was deleted.
    1. The comment was deleted.
      1. The comment was deleted.
        1. The comment was deleted.
      2. The comment was deleted.
        1. The comment was deleted.
          1. The comment was deleted.
  17. Radikal
    Radikal 14 December 2017 16: 32 New
    10
    President at a press conference: I consider the work of our government satisfactory
    Any other questions for the speaker? wassat
    1. Sotskiy
      Sotskiy 14 December 2017 18: 47 New
      +1
      Quote: Radikal
      President at a press conference: I consider the work of our government satisfactory
      Any other questions for the speaker? wassat

      The program for the next 6 years is understandable.
  18. Old military officer
    Old military officer 14 December 2017 16: 34 New
    13
    Well, what else can you expect from him, your people will figure it out. And the fact that the people are very alarmed and angry is not important. He, this people, is always unhappy. Should I pay attention to it?
  19. Altona
    Altona 14 December 2017 16: 35 New
    +8
    Quote: Black_Jacket
    A satisfactory rating from Putin means that the Khalam in the government are worth considering.

    ----------------------------
    There are only two ratings in the reporting - satisfactory and unsatisfactory. The rest of the grading scale is missing. Another thing is that Putin does not pose any large-scale tasks to the Government, except for the construction of 12 stadiums for the next Mundial. Hence the mundial work of our Government for the whole society. And the interests of the oligarchy, the ruling class, are fully respected, here the Government has a solid five. The question is after all, who looks at the work of the Government from what angle.
    1. Sergey53
      Sergey53 14 December 2017 16: 49 New
      0
      Another rating is only unsatisfactory. Those. one of two. There is no gap.
    2. Sotskiy
      Sotskiy 14 December 2017 18: 43 New
      0
      Quote: Altona
      The question is after all, who looks at the work of the Government from what angle.

      good
      I’ll add my five cents: and depending on what it has political weight and post).
  20. Overlock
    Overlock 14 December 2017 16: 47 New
    12
    I consider the work of our government satisfactory. This is also evidenced by the return to sustainable economic growth, sustainable macroeconomic development.
    --------------
    What are the questions for the liberal course of the government led by Medvedev?
    The President believes the guys did a good job.
    When voting for Putin, remember Prime Minister Medvedev.
  21. Sergey53
    Sergey53 14 December 2017 16: 47 New
    +9
    Perhaps for the president the work of the government is satisfactory, but without shocks, they lived, well, okay. And for the people, the work of the government is not satisfactory, since it \ work \ was anti-people, anti-social. We do not need populism, we need a normal, human life and not its living. Myself in the government probably raised the salary is not 4%?
  22. Overlock
    Overlock 14 December 2017 16: 49 New
    +9
    Quote: 210ox
    Do not change the horses at the crossing ?!

    and if it's donkeys?
    1. Sergey53
      Sergey53 14 December 2017 16: 54 New
      +6
      These words are heard at every conference. Usually a nag is shot at a crossing, as it prevents other horses from doing their job. That is, it creates congestion.
  23. Old Horseradish
    Old Horseradish 14 December 2017 17: 00 New
    16
    I also consider the work of the government to be satisfactory. In the US, 1 trillion dollars pumped from Russia. If they worked perfectly, there would be two trillion in the USA. In short, there is much to strive for. There are still labor reserves!
  24. Overlock
    Overlock 14 December 2017 17: 01 New
    12
    Quote: c-Petrov
    As long as we have a population of 150 million people — 50 million pensioners + state employees — and even such characters who do not pay taxes above the roof and only 15 million do the added value of the product — we will live like that.

    I offer: pensioners in gas chambers, state employees - per count. Why spend money on them! This is your logic, Mr. Liberal. For this is exactly what Dvorkovich proposes to do
    1. St Petrov
      St Petrov 14 December 2017 17: 05 New
      0
      I offer: pensioners in gas chambers, state employees - per count. Why spend money on them! This is your logic, Mr. Liberal. For this is exactly what Dvorkovich proposes to do


      you are funny. Now it offers not only Dvorkovich but also you. Read what you wrote.

      but you didn’t understand my logic. But I'm not surprised)
      1. Overlock
        Overlock 14 December 2017 17: 08 New
        +9
        you are stupid and stupid person
        1. St Petrov
          St Petrov 14 December 2017 17: 13 New
          0
          you are cool and smart. Notably did I parry?
          1. Overlock
            Overlock 14 December 2017 17: 20 New
            12
            thank you for rating. The department also think so.
            They say that the mind comes with age, but in your case only age has come
  25. Overlock
    Overlock 14 December 2017 17: 04 New
    +6
    Quote: c-Petrov
    I just don’t want to discuss on this site how you suck each other after a forum fight with Putin

    yes you have homosexual inclinations! maybe share your success in this process? Looks like you are a major specialist in sucking! You’re just a boor
    1. St Petrov
      St Petrov 14 December 2017 17: 07 New
      0
      You’re just a boor


      laughing You didn’t read what I answered this way? and developed what thoughts

      maybe share your success in this process?


      pulled? So you turn to this character. I'm on "licking" - on suction - opponents)
      1. Overlock
        Overlock 14 December 2017 17: 08 New
        10
        The premieres were attended by presidential press secretary Dmitry Peskov, former finance minister Alexei Kudrin, head of Rostec Sergey Chemezov, minister of transport Maxim Sokolov, deputy foreign minister Grigory Karasin, head of Gazprom Alexei Miller, member of the Russian Olympic Committee Shamil Tarpishchev, former and the current heads of the Moscow Department of Culture, billionaires led by Roman Abramovich, Ksenia Sobchak and other “lionesses”.
        Go ahead, behind the leaders, sucker
        1. St Petrov
          St Petrov 14 December 2017 17: 09 New
          0
          are you offended or what? not worth it. turn to him - you have something to talk about. Discuss success. Or what were you interested in there

          You’re just a boor


          laughing
          1. Overlock
            Overlock 14 December 2017 17: 22 New
            +7
            fools are not offended. pity them
          2. andrej-shironov
            andrej-shironov 14 December 2017 17: 42 New
            +3
            wink But shaw, it’s now customary to be offended by inadequate ones, and Petrov?
  26. Evdokim E
    Evdokim E 14 December 2017 18: 31 New
    +8
    Quote: c-Petrov

    But once he raised the topic, he heard about himself. You, too, were not offended by the truth?


    Why should I be offended by you. Sin is offended by the wretched. I made a remark to you as being idle in life. These are those who always strive to lick the big bosses. There was no talk of sexual orientation.
    I did not touch on the topic of your rudeness, it is immediately clear that you have not been beaten for a long time. But you raised such a pornographic stench (with such knowledge of the subject) that it became clear: they offended not just a pathological lackey, but, as in most cases, this happens, a lackey with a sexual orientation in a passive version.
    Here is such a bouquet! A boor (not beaten for a long time) and a wretched lackey with non-traditional sexual orientation in one bottle. It turns out a complete pervert. Of course I will not discuss further with you, because it’s a bit of a bitch. I sympathize, however, with the president and the prime minister if they have such supporters.
    1. St Petrov
      St Petrov 14 December 2017 19: 08 New
      0
      Why should I be offended by you. Sin is offended by the wretched. I made a remark to you as being idle in life. These are those who always strive to lick the big bosses.


      explain to me how on the forum you can lick Putin or Medvedev? Are you sick

      Or who votes for Putin or considers him a worthy president - he "licked" the authorities? With a thought you obviously have trouble. And I’m not a civil servant and my bosses are different

      I did not touch on the topic of your rudeness, it is immediately clear that you have not been beaten for a long time. But you raised such a pornographic stink


      about lick it? Not rudeness? Doesn’t click anywhere in my head?
      you don’t spread your diagnoses to me. So far, it has not been written about licking - no one was rude to you. And for such nonsense - you got what you got.

      Therefore, follow the language - and in return you will not receive rudeness. And then, as a Ukrainian with an eternal question: "Are we for sho?"
  27. Sotskiy
    Sotskiy 14 December 2017 18: 37 New
    +4
    The inflow of investments from abroad is another matter of trust in the government. I believe that raising the issue of personnel changes today is incorrect, premature.

    That's all and fell into place.
    Maybe someone didn’t get it again? Our government works for foreign investors, for their trust, and not for the trust of the country's population. It, the population still does not understand anything in the "new" economy, so sit and wait for investors to do better for you, and the Government and the President to do better for investors. And if they don’t do it, then well, there’s nobody to punish anyway, they’re all their own!)
  28. rruvim
    rruvim 14 December 2017 18: 42 New
    0
    I always want to understand something, even where the hairpin "rolled". The brigadier’s answer to the “Horses” question regarding Navalny is simply brilliant: “Power is power!” And that’s it !!! He respected him again. Directly and openly! We decided that Navalny was guilty and Basta! Bravo to the Foreman !!! Now you can write comments on Unian for another six years ...
  29. DEDPIHTO
    DEDPIHTO 14 December 2017 19: 11 New
    +7
    That's all sad .. The head of the country needs a strong business practitioner and not a liberal politician with Napoleonic ambitions. And there is such a business manager. On December 24th there will be a congress of the Communist Party of the Russian Federation, where they should nominate Pavel Grudinin (successful director of the prosperous state farm named after V.I. Lenin) for the presidential election, a single candidate from all left forces ... unless, of course ... Duck Zyu does not ruin everything.
    1. zoolu350
      zoolu350 15 December 2017 05: 11 New
      0
      I hope that you wrote the truth and the Communist Party will be led by a worthy person. After that, the Communist Party will begin activities to pull Russia away from the abyss, where the oligarchy of the Russian Federation is pushing it.
      1. DEDPIHTO
        DEDPIHTO 15 December 2017 10: 55 New
        0
        You have already outlined the maximum program. So far, he will only run for president as a candidate .. and Grudinin is not a member of the Communist Party, but shares communist views. hi
  30. LPD17
    LPD17 14 December 2017 19: 33 New
    +4
    Quote: andrej-shironov
    wink Dear Petrov! Please write, how can children feed their share of GDP and how to shovel and shoe them in GDP?

    He is what ??? so he was told to answer in the morning from the manual in the crib))) and he drinks Klinskoe right now)))
  31. Overlock
    Overlock 14 December 2017 20: 01 New
    +8
    Questions from the regions boiled down to requests for help. And rightly so. Veliky Novgorod, I know how poor he is. In Vladivostok, parks began to be cut down and cottages began to be built in the environmental zone.
    Russia, through journalists, cried out for help.
    By the end of the press conference, the audience simply shouted. Help!
    “You won’t help everyone,” Putin thought, “let Medvedev work,” and drove on.
  32. DEDPIHTO
    DEDPIHTO 14 December 2017 20: 16 New
    +3
    Quote: Overlock
    Questions from the regions boiled down to requests for help. And rightly so. Veliky Novgorod, I know how poor he is. In Vladivostok, parks began to be cut down and cottages began to be built in the environmental zone.
    Russia, through journalists, cried out for help.
    By the end of the press conference, the audience simply shouted. Help!
    “You won’t help everyone,” Putin thought, “let Medvedev work,” and drove on.

    Continue. hi .. ,, there is no money, but you hold on, ”answered Medvedev, and thought to himself,“ let the profile ministers work, ”... what the profile ministers answered and thought, you probably already guess.
  33. LPD17
    LPD17 14 December 2017 20: 17 New
    +1
    Quote: 16112014nk
    As I said yesterday - transfusion from empty to empty. The influx of investment? And what about the outflow of the "sewn" excessively acquired ?. Many times more inflow, but this is not said. One Karimov brought to France several suitcases in cash, weighing more than tons.In cash, over 700 million, across the border, through customs. Try a simple tourist to take out an undeclared currency - they will immediately bind.

    and ask the question where does the money come from?
    From VTB (state i.e.)
    Bought on okriene factories idle ....
  34. alexhol
    alexhol 14 December 2017 20: 35 New
    0
    "... Yes, here are my bosom friends of youth, very satisfied" wink
  35. kefan
    kefan 14 December 2017 20: 45 New
    +2
    Well, it would be better if he talked about work, and even less so to the Government’s assessment, would have said nothing at all, especially before the elections.
  36. Giants
    Giants 14 December 2017 22: 00 New
    +4
    I believe that raising the issue of personnel changes today is incorrect, premature.
    Mr. President, we have some kind of masochist. He wants to repeat the fate of Carrafi with all his might. Russian rebellion, he is blind and merciless.
    1. Giants
      Giants 14 December 2017 22: 52 New
      0
      I apologize for distorting the name of the Libyan president. Of course, Gaddafi.
  37. andrej-shironov
    andrej-shironov 14 December 2017 22: 26 New
    +1
    Quote: c-Petrov
    andrej-shironov, would be a doctor I would diagnose you. But I’ll just assume that you really work in the circus, the main star

    Petrov, the drain is counted! In your case, "would" interfere.
  38. Fedya2017
    Fedya2017 14 December 2017 22: 34 New
    +2
    Someone hoped for a different assessment of the government from the president ?! Like, the boyars are bad, and the king is good ...
  39. Overlock
    Overlock 14 December 2017 23: 12 New
    0
    St Petrov,
    just a little cold-headed, go to your psychiatrist at your leisure, help
  40. Overlock
    Overlock 14 December 2017 23: 55 New
    0
    andrej-shironov,
    he beat his head on the toilet
  41. andrej-shironov
    andrej-shironov 15 December 2017 09: 45 New
    0
    Quote: c-Petrov
    it smells of you, Andryusha) I am writing to you as such a character. Because I understand what a clown you are and that same word in the letter Pe

    There is no sense not because of the state, but because you are just the way you are and after Putin leaves - in front of the mirror you will see only your reflection anyway. And your being from this will not change

    It’s a pity, of course, that they’ll ban and will probably erase the account, but on the other hand, I told the eccentric that he is an eccentric.

    And then you would have lived in ignorance and considered yourself a cool father, whose daughter has nothing to buy in the store because of Putin

    Noooo Petrov, you were not banned, you merged. The level of your intelligence leaves much to be desired. However, a level can only have a “vessel” with something. In your case, this word is not applicable.
  42. Overlock
    Overlock 15 December 2017 09: 56 New
    0
    Quote: Stroporez
    in waste paper dug PSS V.I. Lenin, then I.V. Stalin and everything in his head returned to normal. (Cursed himself that in the "instinct" political economy and Marxism-Leninism were poorly taught).

    I have a friend who lives in South Africa. When he studied, he slept on the history of the CPSU, did not teach dialectics and changed political economy for football. We met in 25 years. He has the handbook Capital, curses. how could you not save the USSR. And this is the one who partisan in Angola, became a convinced Marxist. That's what life does
  43. Overlock
    Overlock 15 December 2017 09: 59 New
    0
    Quote: Stroporez
    Damn, but really how much?

    I worked for the chervonets bombing, from Maryino to Kuzminok for only 10 rubles. Now you remember, it's funny, but then - not to laugh. A bag of gypsum plaster about 40 rubles. A full gas tank cost 80 rubles.
  44. Overlock
    Overlock 15 December 2017 10: 10 New
    +3
    Quote: Golovan Jack
    And the fact that if the plane (on the road exactly where you need to, be afraid) gets, for example, into a chatterbox -

    Before you get into the dummy, you need to take off. So far, the chassis of this aircraft has broken and the engine is intermittently working. And the brave FAC shouts at us: everything is fine, the flight will be normal. That's just hard to believe this pic