Military Review

Yuri Boldyrev - on the "transition of the economy to military rails": Voiced, but useless PR

60
Yuri Boldyrev - on the "transition of the economy to military rails": Voiced, but useless PR



President Vladimir Putin said that all large enterprises should be ready to increase military production. "The ability of the economy to quickly increase the volume of defense products and services at the right time is one of the most important conditions for ensuring the military security of the state," the president said. At the same time, Vladimir Putin noted that he gave the relevant instructions on the modernization of production facilities, the formation of a reserve of material and technical resources, ensuring the transportation of troops in 2016, and asked to take stock of what has been done. Economist, former deputy chairman of the Accounting Chamber Yuri Boldyrev is confident that this measure was late for 10 years. He shared his expert opinion with Nakanune.RU:

- These measures are ten years late. Ten years ago, if you remember, Putin’s Munich speech was delivered, and then Serdyukov was appointed Minister of Defense. It is characteristic that since then no deoshoring of the economy has happened, despite all the promises.

An attempt to transfer production to some kind of mobilization, military rails in conditions where real financial, organizational, human resources are not concentrated at all, unfortunately, for the time being resembles ringing, but useless PR.

And, God forbid, that there should be a situation when we have to really carry out military mobilization. In order to prevent this, it was necessary in order of priority already 10-20 years ago to begin to carry out socio-economic mobilization. Do not talk about de-offshoring, but actually do it, not create parasitic layers between state corporations and the budget, but create rigid control mechanisms so that every penny from such a corporation goes entirely to the budget, and not to fake opaque structures.

Now, at the very least, it is necessary to start concentrating financial and economic resources on accelerated industrial and technological development. Without this, talk of accelerated mobilization is meaningless. As this concentration was not, and no. We remain in the chains of the WTO, our science continues to be destroyed by the hands of our government. And without science, there can be no defense capability. If you really carry out mobilization, then, in the conditions of sanctions, it would seem that this is an extremely convenient moment for this.

Talking about military mobilization is very beautiful, but first there must be a scientific-technological, industrial mobilization. And it is not. And there is no sign that it will start sooner or later. Nabiulina, Dvorkovich and Shuvalov, but I don’t say anything about Chubais, Gref and others, and in no way contribute to the mobilization of the country. This is the real team of the president, not the one he gathers for the election of artists and athletes, and there can be no mobilization.

In general, if there is political will, any group of people, respectively, and any legal entity, enterprise, regardless of what form of ownership it is in - there is no problem to transfer to the mobilization rails. It is desirable that for this there was a real need, and not because "offshore friends" wanted to squeeze out the last juices from your enterprise under the guise of mobilization. The US experience after the military depression shows: private property or not private - there are no obstacles for mobilization. It is important that this be the mobilization of the whole society and the whole state. And not so that we tighten the belt, and friends of the authorities in offshore will be happy with how well they are all "prodinamili" under the guise of mobilization.
Originator:
https://www.nakanune.ru/articles/113480/
60 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must to register.

I have an account? Sign in

  1. iouris
    iouris 29 November 2017 15: 13
    22
    I trust the conclusions of Yuri Boldyrev, since he is one of the people with an impeccable reputation in a country where reputation means almost nothing.
    1. creak
      creak 29 November 2017 15: 22
      25
      Quote: iouris
      he is among the people with an impeccable reputation in a country where reputation means almost nothing.

      In addition to his reputation, he also has a smart head on his shoulders ...
      Therefore, he did not stay in power structures - there are now other values ​​in use and other personnel are in demand ...
      1. nickname7
        nickname7 29 November 2017 18: 16
        15
        In the Russian Federation, it is customary to look for shortcomings, to look for bad things, to criticize everything, but to express respect for worthy people is completely not accepted. For example, there are officials who upheld the country's interests and were subsequently dismissed, forgotten and spend their old age in poverty. Although these people need to erect monuments. In particular, Boldyrev himself was among those who fought against foreign concessions on shameful colonial conditions.
        Boldyrev’s book, about how the Yeltsin’s elite, almost gave Russian resources to the west.
        Abduction of Eurasia
        http://econ-secrets.narod.ru/2_eur.html
        1. You Vlad
          You Vlad 29 November 2017 20: 09
          +4
          Quote: nickname7
          In Russia, it is customary to look for flaws

          Aha
          Quote: nickname7
          Although these people need to erect monuments.

          IN USA?
          Boldyrev is one of those who, as part of Yabloko, pushed the production sharing agreement!
          From 1991 to 1992 - Member of the Supreme Advisory Council under the Chairman of the Supreme Council of the RSFSR, then - under President B. Yeltsin.
          One of the representatives of the Crible Institute brainchild of the CIA yes He worked as best he could for the benefit of the ideas of perestroika (tirelessly) angry
          “Billions of dollars to pay traitors through various intermediary structures (the Public Committee for Russian Reforms, the American Association for National Contribution to Democracy, the Crible Institute, various foundations and commissions) come to our country.

          Who is interested hi More information at http://voprosik.net/kto-takoj-yurij-boldyrev/ © QUESTION
        2. MOSKVITYANIN
          MOSKVITYANIN 30 November 2017 00: 32
          +3
          nickname7 these people need to erect monuments.

          Monuments in our country should be put to those who are trying to engage in small and medium-sized businesses in the Russian Federation ....
    2. Hlavaty
      Hlavaty 29 November 2017 15: 48
      +9
      Quote: iouris
      I trust the conclusions of Yuri Boldyrev, since he is among the people with an impeccable reputation

      Reputation is good. But adequacy will not be superfluous. As for the "sonorous, but useless PR" I absolutely agree with him. But about what country he says this:
      In general, if there is political will, any group of people, respectively, and any legal entity, enterprise, regardless of what form of ownership it is - there is no problem translating into mobilization rails.

      Magical "political will" can mobilize Usmanov, Abramovich and other oligarchs? As the experience of Ukraine shows, the oligarchs betray the country first. And then the West arranges with their hands the economic collapse in the country, the political crisis and op-ah ... "political will" in retirement or stroke.
      In Russia, "political will" must first materialize in the form of a guardsman or the NKVD, and then it can already mobilize someone.
      1. passing
        passing 29 November 2017 17: 39
        +4
        Magical "political will" can mobilize Usmanov, Abramovich and other oligarchs? As the experience of Ukraine shows, the oligarchs betray the country first.

        Control asset movement! And let him later betray, will remain with what he brought to this offshore. External management, nationalization of assets for treason. Maybe so?
        1. Antianglosax
          Antianglosax 29 November 2017 19: 39
          +4
          Quote: passing
          Magical "political will" can mobilize Usmanov, Abramovich and other oligarchs? As the experience of Ukraine shows, the oligarchs betray the country first.

          Control asset movement! And let him later betray, will remain with what he brought to this offshore. External management, nationalization of assets for treason. Maybe so?

          Firstly, on the basis of what? Secondly, the "masters" of the country will control themselves? laughing
        2. Hlavaty
          Hlavaty 29 November 2017 23: 00
          +2
          Quote: passing
          Control asset movement!

          What body to put and control? What specific people should do this?
          Colonels Zakharchenko in the Ministry of Internal Affairs or businessmen from the FSB?
          Then you have to go to extreme measures. Otherwise, no one will simply give up control over billions.
          And we need to come up with some very powerful incentive for that major who will control billionaires. An incentive that will not allow him to take a bribe of several tens of millions of dollars. I can’t even imagine what incentive this might be in modern Russia.
        3. MOSKVITYANIN
          MOSKVITYANIN 30 November 2017 00: 29
          0
          Quote: passing
          Magical "political will" can mobilize Usmanov, Abramovich and other oligarchs? As the experience of Ukraine shows, the oligarchs betray the country first.

          Control asset movement! And let him later betray, will remain with what he brought to this offshore. External management, nationalization of assets for treason. Maybe so?

          Those. You are telling businessmen to open processing industries, borrow foreign technology, risk their businesses from acquisitions and get loans at a frantic %%, all for the sake of the fact that they can come to them at any time with jackets and mobilize their property, and will they smile at that?
          Such businessmen, even in Kashchenko, will not be found, they will send you far away .... with this Government ..... especially at the beginning of the last century, we have already gone through this ....
          1. passing
            passing 30 November 2017 08: 57
            0
            Those. You are telling businessmen to open processing industries, borrow foreign technology, risk their businesses from acquisitions and get loans at a frantic %%, all for the sake of the fact that they can come to them at any time with jackets and mobilize their property, and will they smile at that?
            Such businessmen, even in Kashchenko, will not be found, they will send you far away .... with this Government ..... especially at the beginning of the last century, we have already gone through this ....


            NO. Open large-scale production, invest in development, etc. should the state. And about everything else, look at China, it works the same, and even how, but we are still something, and we are afraid of someone
            1. MOSKVITYANIN
              MOSKVITYANIN 30 November 2017 20: 25
              0
              passing look at China works the same way

              In China, they cherish and cherish their business, which brings revenue to the state and creates jobs ....
              and we are still something, and we are afraid of someone

              and we are afraid of fabricated criminal cases against businessmen, at the moment when, after 3-5 years of exhausting work, you got your first income from your business ...
              GDP itself speaks about this in business forums ....
      2. iouris
        iouris 29 November 2017 18: 10
        +6
        Quote: Hlavaty
        In Russia, "political will" must first materialize in the form of a guardsman or the NKVD

        First answer the question, what kind of social system in the Russian Federation and in what century does it abide.
        1. passing
          passing 29 November 2017 18: 20
          +3
          First answer the question, what kind of social system in the Russian Federation and in what century does it stay

          Capitalism! unfortunately in the state. in its worst incarnation! Determine the age yourself, just do not flatter yourself and the Russian Federation hi
          1. iouris
            iouris 29 November 2017 18: 21
            +1
            Quote: passing
            Capitalism! unfortunately in the state. in its worst incarnation!

            No, comrade! There is no capitalism in the Russian Federation, no socialism either. Go on.
            1. passing
              passing 29 November 2017 19: 37
              +1
              So how does social order influence my proposal?
              It seems to me, even for a not popular solution, we need political will! And how popular will be the decision to nationalize the assets of the traitor!
          2. passing
            passing 29 November 2017 18: 30
            0
            hi I'm talking about economic, that in my head is on the keyboard. slowed down
        2. Hlavaty
          Hlavaty 29 November 2017 23: 12
          0
          Quote: iouris
          First answer the question, and what is the social system in the Russian Federation

          In Russia, the social system Russian. wassat This is not expressed in terms of Western science of political economy. They do not know such such systems. what And even the Russian Bolsheviks could not really adapt Marxism to this country. This was recognized by Stalin in his work "The economic problems of socialism in the USSR."
          Quote: iouris
          and in what age she abides.

          God, in what century can a country reside in which there are two New Years?!?! fellow
          Yes, in any, which at the moment we wish. Want to space 21? You are welcome!
          Want off-road and lack of gas and electricity as in the 19 century? For God's sake! A hundred kilometers from Moscow and you are already there. Well and so on.
          Russia is a country of contrasts. Only the regulator of contrast demons pamper. love
      3. White and fluffy
        White and fluffy 30 November 2017 05: 28
        0
        Quote: Hlavaty
        In Russia, "political will" must first materialize in the form of a guardsman or the NKVD, and then it can already mobilize someone.

        Will so far materialized in words
    3. Sofa General
      Sofa General 29 November 2017 17: 20
      +8
      Boldyrev - as yap as Petya Valtsman. "Apple" - including his brainchild. So, so ...
    4. vovanpain
      vovanpain 29 November 2017 17: 59
      +6
      Quote: iouris
      I trust the conclusions of Yuri Boldyrev, since he is among the people with an impeccable reputation

      Yavlinsky-Boldyrev-Lukin. The reputation is spoiled completely by a rotten apple. wink
      1. iouris
        iouris 29 November 2017 18: 12
        +3
        Quote: vovanpain
        Reputation spoiled completely rotten apple.

        The "apple" was stolen by Yavlinsky. From now on, the party should be referred to simply as "I".
        1. Sofa General
          Sofa General 29 November 2017 18: 28
          +2
          http://perebezhchik.ru/parties/partiya-yabloko/
          Read here ...
          What did Yavlinsky stole?
      2. siberalt
        siberalt 29 November 2017 21: 56
        +6
        Boldyrev created the "Apple", but diverged from the "co-founders" views. And since the last century has nothing to do with it. At the same time, he really worked hard on the state, and did not grumble from the opposition, like Yavlinsky and his followers.
    5. siberalt
      siberalt 29 November 2017 21: 48
      +2
      Before the election, Putin will not touch any offshore. They have our elite on the American financial hook. Let's see what the new government will be like. But I'm afraid the miracle will not happen. hi
    6. Sergey Cojocari
      Sergey Cojocari 30 November 2017 18: 43
      +1
      And why is he (Boldyrev) not a CANDIDATE for the presidency?
      1. Sofa General
        Sofa General 30 November 2017 18: 47
        +2
        Well, I agree ... Let it be in the team sobchak or berkovoy ...
  2. andrej-shironov
    andrej-shironov 29 November 2017 15: 37
    +2
    Ordinary public relations by the authorities.
  3. 16112014nk
    16112014nk 29 November 2017 16: 27
    +8
    Anti-people authorities have really taken care of the "military rails". But this is most likely for internal use, against picking up the pitchfork of the people. Power, it is like a cat - it senses whose meat is eating. And what could be the consequences. Here are preventive measures against all this.
    1. AUL
      AUL 29 November 2017 19: 17
      +2
      This campaign is another feast and another feeding trough for someone! I’m sure that in this “translation”, as is customary, someone will do well to warm their paws.
  4. turbris
    turbris 29 November 2017 16: 50
    +1
    The US experience after the war depression shows whether private property or not private - there are no obstacles to mobilizing. It is important that this is the mobilization of the whole society and the whole state. And it’s not that we will tighten our belts, and the friends of the authorities in offshore will be happy about how they have successfully “promoted” everyone here under the guise of mobilization.
    In my opinion, the author contradicts himself here, it was the oligarchs in the USA who made money on military orders, and they did not have to be mobilized. And the willingness to mobilize is a necessary part of the state’s defense capability, it’s a pity that no one has dealt with this before, so criticism is somehow inappropriate, it’s not politics, and it’s really not important whose property this is, the main thing is for the oligarchs to understand this.
  5. Lnglr
    Lnglr 29 November 2017 17: 00
    10
    I respect Boldyrev for honesty and decency. It is surprising that it did not break (did not sell out) and was still alive.
    1. Sofa General
      Sofa General 29 November 2017 17: 26
      +7
      I repeat once again. This leader is one of the founding fathers of the Yabloko party. So he is dear to him - from the beach and without a panama hat.
      1. passing
        passing 29 November 2017 17: 42
        +7
        I repeat once again. This leader is one of the founding fathers of the Yabloko party. So he is dear to him - from the beach and without a panama hat.

        I don’t know how right you are about the apple.
        But let me remind Putin, the founder of EP, so what to do with him for this gift?
        1. Sofa General
          Sofa General 29 November 2017 18: 16
          +1
          that's just stuffing about Putin is not necessary ...
          [media = http: //www.compromat.ru/page_28343.htm]
          read here
          1. passing
            passing 29 November 2017 18: 23
            +2
            that's just stuffing about Putin is not necessary ...

            ok co-founder
            1. Sofa General
              Sofa General 29 November 2017 18: 25
              +1
              Lord ... Can you read?
              Putin there from what side? They wanted to drag him in there - he’s much smarter, he didn’t go ...
              The fact that he uses EP as his support is yes, but he is not a member of EdR.
              The fact that EdRo looks into his mouth and foresees all desires - yes.
              But Putin does not dirty his name with membership in EdR ...
              1. passing
                passing 29 November 2017 18: 40
                +7
                Lord ... Can you read?

                And you? https://ria.ru/politics/20160627/1453066426.html
                He headed it from 2008 to 2012
                https://www.kakprosto.ru/kak-889244-kogda-byla-so
                zdana-partiya-edinaya-rossiya
              2. Alf
                Alf 29 November 2017 19: 12
                11
                Quote: Sofa General
                Lord ... Can you read?
                Putin there from what side? They wanted to drag him in there - he’s much smarter, he didn’t go ...
                The fact that he uses EP as his support is yes, but he is not a member of EdR.
                The fact that EdRo looks into his mouth and foresees all desires - yes.
                But Putin does not dirty his name with membership in EdR ...

                Very thoughtful and great policy.
                Success is the result of the work of the president.
                The failure is to blame for the EP, but not the president.
                The position is ingenious, only the country is no better off.
                1. Sofa General
                  Sofa General 29 November 2017 21: 12
                  +1
                  And nobody talks about the country ...
                  Groups of people pull the Soviet legacy. That's all...
      2. Lnglr
        Lnglr 30 November 2017 09: 51
        +2
        yes, the letter "B" is Boldyrev. And then what? Is it nothing that he later left this sharaga when he realized that everything went wrong?
      3. Sergey Cojocari
        Sergey Cojocari 30 November 2017 18: 45
        +1
        Half of the party in power, "Eat Russia," thieves and embezzlers, where they cherish?
  6. The comment was deleted.
    1. The comment was deleted.
  7. vanavatny
    vanavatny 29 November 2017 19: 57
    +1
    Before writing that Boldarev has an impeccable reputation - baptize or something, well, there’s the Internet, if there is no memory .... but it is said in color, that are torn from the feeder and unable to return to it often tell the truth
    1. You Vlad
      You Vlad 29 November 2017 20: 17
      0
      Quote: vanavate
      Before writing that Boldarev has an impeccable reputation - be baptized or something, well, there is the Internet, if there is no memory ....

      All the color you say Seryoga wink
      1. vanavatny
        vanavatny 29 November 2017 23: 10
        +1
        I’ll tell you about the identity of your ideas about the moral character of the Russian political establishment
  8. Fedya2017
    Fedya2017 29 November 2017 20: 24
    11
    With whom is the Russian elite going to fight, led by its leader ??! Could it be with China to force the Chinese to make even more use of Siberian natural resources and energy? Or maybe with the United States and Europe? So their children study there and real estate with money to save ... Here from Sudan they invite to fight against piracy and the slave trade ... Then, of course, for such a case it is time to transfer the economy to military tracks! Everything for the front, everything for the victory ... Urrryaaa !!!!!!!!!!!!! The main thing - the unity of thieves with the robbed should be.
  9. Settlement Oparyshev
    Settlement Oparyshev 29 November 2017 20: 28
    +1
    Well, why did Yura drive the foam? There are people who tightly control construction and the military economy .. There’s nothing at all about this article.
  10. samarin1969
    samarin1969 29 November 2017 20: 41
    +4
    About the "military rails" - this is not even PR. PR is when something is done, at least for PR. And it was just a “statement." ..In the article itself, the most unexpected is its placement, incl. on the VO resource. Boldyrev is rather harsh in relation to the authorities and, at the same time, is actively forming an opposition political project.
    1. Vadim237
      Vadim237 29 November 2017 21: 51
      +3
      In the middle of this year, they ordered 30000 railway platforms for transporting military equipment.
      1. samarin1969
        samarin1969 29 November 2017 22: 33
        +3
        The keywords "ordered to order on until 2019." ... This program is working now - it’s hard to say ... As long as the number of new units, Armat, new aviation models, fleet replenishment is in pieces - this is PR, not "military rails" .... But this is not the main thing , The Russian Federation does not look much like a state that is engaged in reorganization for military needs. More: show sports, show forums, show business, ... "just" elections.
        1. You Vlad
          You Vlad 30 November 2017 02: 47
          0
          Quote: samarin1969
          The keywords "ordered to order on until 2019." ... This program is working now - it’s hard to say ... So far the number of new units, Armat, new aviation models, fleet replenishment is in pieces - this is PR, not "military rails" ...

          You’re just a magician to manipulate like that! There is a plan for the rearmament of the Russian army and despite all the keyboard knocks on all the resources that we have (everything is piece by piece fellow ) It is fulfilled from year to year, well, it’s true, if that, well, if you don’t know!
          1. samarin1969
            samarin1969 30 November 2017 06: 44
            +4
            "There is a plan for the rearmament of the Russian army and despite all the knocking of the keyboard on all the resources that we (everything is piece by piece ) it is fulfilled from year to year"

            “But today, information has leaked to the press that funding for the rearmament program for the army and navy will be reduced by 5 trillion rubles: from 22 trillion requested by the RF Ministry of Defense to 17 trillion rubles allocated to it. That’s such a sequestration.” - "IN.

            For comparison ... "Developed the artillery industry, from May 1940 to the beginning of the war, the gun fleet was increased by one and a half times. Mobilization reserves of all kinds were created. Over the years of the third five-year plan, the growth of military production amounted to 39% annually, with the growth of the entire industry by 13% By the beginning of the war, a new tank industry was actually created, the aviation industry was qualitatively rebuilt, the foundations for a qualitative renewal and growth in the production of small arms and artillery were created. The Navy was regularly replenished with new warships and submarines.
            Training of the Armed Forces: in 1939, the transition to a personnel system of recruitment based on universal military service was completed. From August 1939 to June 1941, the army grew more than two and a half times - to 5,4 million people. In 1940, 9 created mechanized corps, the Air Force was reorganized - 75 divisions and 5 brigades were created for war, of which 25 divisions were at the formative stage. Army quickly re-equipped.
            In the pre-war period, the state virtually destroyed or defeated the "internal enemies", a possible "fifth column" of the enemy. Society was united and united. "- VO.
            1. You Vlad
              You Vlad 30 November 2017 16: 52
              0
              Quote: samarin1969
              “But today, information has leaked to the press that funding for the rearmament of the army and navy will be reduced by 5 trillion rubles:

              It oozes every year, so what? Dogs bark the caravan is coming!
              And let's be fine without pathos?
            2. Alf
              Alf 30 November 2017 19: 01
              +1
              Quote: samarin1969
              In the pre-war period, the state virtually destroyed or defeated the "internal enemies", a possible "fifth column" of the enemy.

              It is impossible, Russia is a free and democratic state in which the rights and freedoms of citizens are respected.
      2. Alf
        Alf 30 November 2017 18: 58
        0
        Quote: Vadim237
        In the middle of this year, they ordered 30000 railway platforms for transporting military equipment.

        It is for military equipment or in general?
        And if they don’t say later, Sorry, but the money ran out before it came to the calculation.
  11. Radikal
    Radikal 29 November 2017 21: 58
    +3
    Excellent article! good
  12. tasha
    tasha 30 November 2017 07: 58
    +1
    It seems to me that Boldyrev’s performance is also a PR ...
    We are talking about existing industries, so that at hour H they open a folder where everything is scheduled, receive raw materials from mobile warehouses and increase production.
  13. komvap
    komvap 30 November 2017 10: 50
    +3
    Boldyreva as President of Russia !!
    1. slaventi
      slaventi 1 December 2017 06: 05
      0
      A traitor to the presidency is a class !!!
  14. slaventi
    slaventi 1 December 2017 06: 03
    0
    Boldyrev is an ordinary traitor, a member of an interregional group. This is the group that participated in the collapse of the USSR together with Gorbachev
    He also received training at the Cribble Institute.
    The Cribble Institute (whose leader, in his own words, decided to "devote his energy to the collapse of the Soviet empire"), created a whole network of its representative offices in the republics of the former USSR.

    Through a network of representative offices of the Cribble Institute and similar institutions funded by the CIA funds, thousands of people passed instructional training of influence agents from among the Interregional Deputy Group, and a little later from the Democratic Russia association, which subsequently formed the cadre of the destroyers of the USSR and the foundation of the future Yeltsin regime including: Y. Afanasyev, Y. Boldyrev, E. Bonner, Boxer, M. Bocharov, G. Burbulis, E. Gaidar, B. Yeltsin, S. Kovalev, V. Lukin, A. Murashov, A. Nuikin, L. Ponomarev, G. Popov, M. Poltoranin, A. Saharo c., A. Sobchak, S. Stankevich, G. Starovoitova, A. Chubais, N. Shmelev,
    http://voprosik.net/kto-takoj-yurij-boldyrev/