Military Review

Speech by Evgeny Satanovsky in the Federation Council of the Russian Federation

65
President of the Middle East Institute Yevgeny Satanovsky spoke at the Federation Council of the Russian Federation.


65 comments
Ad

The editorial board of Voenniy Obozreniye urgently needs a proofreader. Requirements: impeccable knowledge of the Russian language, diligence, discipline. Contact: [email protected]

Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must to register.

I have an account? Sign in

  1. Some kind of compote
    Some kind of compote 6 November 2017 14: 13 New
    27
    Interesting and informative.
    1. Tatyana
      Tatyana 6 November 2017 15: 12 New
      16
      Yes! That's exactly what you need to perform - like Satanovsky! Professionally - competently, openly and honestly!
      1. Some kind of compote
        Some kind of compote 6 November 2017 15: 13 New
        24
        Agree
        The ability to work with a large and even sophisticated audience is a great thing
      2. Andkor1962
        Andkor1962 10 November 2017 13: 31 New
        0
        And most importantly, not a piece of paper !!!!!
    2. ★ VLADIMIR ★
      ★ VLADIMIR ★ 6 November 2017 22: 48 New
      +4
      Quote: Some Compote
      Interesting and informative.

      I agree.
      Everything is clear and on the shelves. If only the Pokémon at the top would listen to him.
      Look, and something in the Country is getting better.
    3. siberalt
      siberalt 7 November 2017 11: 42 New
      +5
      Well Satanovsky lowered the senator from Dagestan, saying that this was not his business, but professionals. And in general, to whom did Satanovsky say all this with his back to the podium? Or is our Federation Council secret? belay
      1. Nikolai Grek
        Nikolai Grek 7 November 2017 15: 17 New
        +2
        Quote: siberalt
        Well Satanovsky lowered the senator from Dagestan, saying that this was not his business, but professionals. And in general, to whom did Satanovsky say all this with his back to the podium? Or is our Federation Council secret? belay

        in the Duma when the performance of the invited is held, they are not showing deputies !!! wassat wassat laughing laughing laughing
  2. rehev931
    rehev931 6 November 2017 14: 38 New
    10
    Satan's serious man. Wadu will not chew
  3. bald
    bald 6 November 2017 15: 36 New
    +9
    Everything on the shelves and nothing more is normal.
  4. yuliatreb
    yuliatreb 6 November 2017 15: 43 New
    16
    Much attention is paid to the geopolitical influence of Israel in this region, which once again emphasizes its commitment and continuity to the ideological influence of historical roots. Israel, the 52th state of the terrorist American dermocratic state, is completely and completely exposed to the political and economic influence of the states. The Israeli government indirectly supports terrorist groups on the territory of the SAR, which makes them similar to the states at the blood level. It’s good that some people in the Russian and Israeli Foreign Ministries understand that if we can’t agree, there will be a disaster worse than the current conflict, we also allow much for Israel, in which we show favor, and they consider this to be our weakness, and generally wait a long time in this region of the world still have to.
    1. Mih1974
      Mih1974 6 November 2017 23: 21 New
      +6
      Chet I suspect that mirror statements sound just in the USA laughing . Look at how many immigrants from the USSR are in the leadership of Israel, I still admit that for them now the Motherland is not the USSR / Russia, but also not the USA. Again, as Yevgeny Yanych correctly says, unlike Turkey, our aircraft and UAVs flew over Izrail more than once and didn’t hit anyone (the case with an unmanned UAV repeat ).
      Yes, Satanovsky is not a "prophet" and he is mistaken and not omniscient, but he has the courage to speak at the highest level about the penetration of terrorists into the Muslim environment of the Caucasus, and about stealing the dough at the nuclear power plant in Ebipt and about lowering the threshold for using nuclear weapons 10 years. good
      I don’t know how much this is true, but according to him, he did not get a second citizenship and will not emigrate anywhere under any circumstances, despite the terrible history of his ancestors who fell under Jewish pogroms. good
  5. Fisher Alexander
    Fisher Alexander 6 November 2017 15: 58 New
    22
    My deepest sympathy for the loss of my mother. This is grief. Secondly, I am once again delighted with the deep analysis and possession of material on East Asia. And, at the same time, I’m sure that this rabble of pigs, called SF, is what to throw beads. Therefore, I am grateful to the authors who uploaded this video to the network. Whoever needs to hear.
  6. ODERVIT
    ODERVIT 6 November 2017 17: 34 New
    +3
    It is intelligible. Very interesting performance.
  7. Razvedka_Boem
    Razvedka_Boem 6 November 2017 17: 34 New
    13
    "On this I stop permitted speech " ..)))
    Half an hour and all without a piece of paper .. I respect professionalism.
    1. svp67
      svp67 6 November 2017 17: 37 New
      +7
      Quote: Razvedka_Boem
      Half an hour and all without a piece of paper .. I respect professionalism.

      It wasn’t difficult for a person belonging to the “most talkative nation in the world," he’s broadcasting on the radio for three hours every weekday ...
  8. Dead duck
    Dead duck 6 November 2017 18: 20 New
    18
    Type "unspoken agreement" not to touch (not to discuss) the Caucasian republics ...
    but Satanovsky could not resist and hinted "casually" about the state of certain affairs.
    ... and a disgruntled omniscient appeared ...
    and he still did not say anything about our former "Central Asia" ... a time bomb, the Caucasus will explode with flowers.
    1. Nikolai Grek
      Nikolai Grek 6 November 2017 23: 26 New
      +2
      Quote: Deadush
      Type of "tacit agreement"

      who with whom ???
      1. Velizariy
        Velizariy 7 November 2017 10: 04 New
        +3
        who with whom ???
        republics and the center.
      2. Dead duck
        Dead duck 7 November 2017 11: 34 New
        +6
        Quote: Nikolai the Greek
        who with whom ???

        Did you listen to what he said?
        and on the news over the past 5-10 years, as if nothing is noticeable ....
        1. Nikolai Grek
          Nikolai Grek 7 November 2017 15: 15 New
          +2
          Quote: Deadush
          Quote: Nikolai the Greek
          who with whom ???

          Did you listen to what he said?
          and on the news over the past 5-10 years, as if nothing is noticeable ....

          nuuuuuuuu ... I don’t know, I don’t know !!! what what what

          Patrushev reported an increase in the recruitment activities of terrorist organizations in the North Caucasus
          http://shop.russianpulse.ru/kavpolit/2017/04/19/1
          611490-patrushev-soobschil-o-narastanii-verbovoch
          noy-deyatelnosti-terroristicheskih-organizatsiy-n
          a-severnom-nbsp-kavkaze

          Ministry of Internal Affairs: Since the beginning of the year, about 300 militants have been detained in the North Caucasus
          https://eadaily.com/ru/news/2017/11/01/mvd-s-nach
          ala-goda-na-severnom-kavkaze-zaderzhano-okolo-300
          -boevikov

          Putin instructed the head of the Russian Guard to fight terrorism in the Caucasus
          https://rueconomics.ru/264450-putin-poruchil-glav
          e-rosgvardii-borbu-s-terrorizmom-na-kavkaze
  9. Urs
    Urs 6 November 2017 22: 07 New
    +2
    Well, that's wonderful. And all the points are above and spaced.
    There is an exhaustive and well-reasoned answer to the question "AND THIS SYRIA IS FUCKED FOR US"
    And a reasoned analysis of who is who in the Middle East and how delicate the east is.
    For my part, a standing ovation to the orator.
    Och a strong specialist in his business hats off.
  10. The comment was deleted.
  11. vlad007
    vlad007 7 November 2017 07: 00 New
    +3
    The translator and writer Andrei Konstantinov correctly said: the expert on the Middle East must know the Arabic language! Does Satanovsky know? Does not know! Chatterbox!
    I tried to find on the net the website of the Institute of the Middle East, of which Mr. Satanovsky was the president. NOT FOUND! Lobrom of the highest rank!
    1. Yakut14
      Yakut14 7 November 2017 07: 21 New
      +9
      You would have looked for the GRU site!
      1. Nikolai Grek
        Nikolai Grek 7 November 2017 15: 20 New
        +1
        Quote: Yakut14
        Satanovskiy

        lol lol lol good good good
    2. Igar
      7 November 2017 08: 26 New
      +8
      you didn’t look for anything, because search engines give a link to the Institute’s website: http://www.iimes.ru/
    3. Nikolay Fedorov
      Nikolay Fedorov 7 November 2017 09: 40 New
      10
      Quote: vlad007
      The translator and writer Andrei Konstantinov correctly said: the expert on the Middle East must know the Arabic language! Does Satanovsky know? Does not know! Chatterbox!
      I tried to find on the net the website of the Institute of the Middle East, of which Mr. Satanovsky was the president. NOT FOUND! Lobrom of the highest rank!

      Satanovsky is fluent in Arabic. Like a native. So the chatterbox is not him.
      Inability to search the necessary material on the Internet only shows you as an inept and quick-tempered person. Ignorance is most often aggressive.
      Note to you: IBV is a unique institution, uniting many excellent specialists. It has been working since 1993. It brings real benefits to Russia. If you do not know anything about this, this does not mean that it is not. fool
    4. Alexander Wolf
      Alexander Wolf 7 November 2017 09: 49 New
      +5
      .... Satanovsky - in the frames of special services! All that is needed is known, even a lot of things have not been taught! you cannot reach it!
    5. BYV
      BYV 7 November 2017 21: 50 New
      0
      Quote: vlad007
      I tried to find on the net the website of the Institute of the Middle East, of which Mr. Satanovsky was the president. NOT FOUND! Lobrom of the highest rank!

      Maybe this is Google broke?))
      https://google.gik-team.com/?q=%D1%81%D0%B0%D0%B9
      %D1%82+%D0%B8%D0%BD%D1%81%D1%82%D0%B8%D1%82%D1%83
      %D1%82%D0%B0+%D0%B1%D0%BB%D0%B8%D0%B6%D0%BD%D0%B5
      %D0%B3%D0%BE+%D0%B2%D0%BE%D1%81%D1%82%D0%BE%D0%BA
      % D0% B0
    6. krasnoderevshik
      krasnoderevshik 8 November 2017 22: 08 New
      0
      somehow I tried to find materials about my grandfathers ... they were almost all in high officer ranks, one had been working with weapons since 1941. the other seemed to be .... honestly scary to say (what if the guests stop by for a minute. ...), and so about that grandfather about whom it’s scary to speak, he didn’t even find his name anywhere, not just the titles and positions, but hell has passed and he knows how many decades he died.
    7. Andkor1962
      Andkor1962 10 November 2017 13: 39 New
      0
      Did you understand what you wrote? So that the director of the institute does not know the Arabic language ....
  12. My_log_in
    My_log_in 7 November 2017 09: 52 New
    0
    Quote: Mih1974

    ... and about stealing the dough at the nuclear power plant in Ebipt ... good
    :

    I didn’t hear, sorry. There is a justification for the need, but I didn’t hear something about the theft. There was a hint about the Turkish nuclear power plant, moreover transparent.
    1. Nikolai Grek
      Nikolai Grek 7 November 2017 15: 25 New
      +1
      Quote: My_Log_In
      Quote: Mih1974

      ... and about stealing the dough at the nuclear power plant in Ebipt ... good
      :

      I didn’t hear, sorry. There is a justification for the need, but I didn’t hear something about the theft. There was a hint about the Turkish nuclear power plant, moreover transparent.

      about Turkish there is such extensive material here !!!
      https://regnum.ru/news/economy/2313745.html
      1. My_log_in
        My_log_in 9 November 2017 15: 18 New
        0
        Thank you, I got acquainted with the pleasure, the author of the material - in pink glasses for half a day.
        The question was to the TS about "stealing the dough" ...
        1. Nikolai Grek
          Nikolai Grek 9 November 2017 15: 56 New
          +1
          in fact, about the Turkish nuclear power plant they constantly yell that everything was built at the expense of Russia + periodically worn out that Turkey had taken away all the rights associated with the station from Russia !!
          I don’t know what you are stealing there !!! wassat wassat laughing laughing laughing
          1. My_log_in
            My_log_in 29 November 2017 13: 49 New
            0
            even they didn’t even start digging the earth there hi so there’s nothing to take away yet repeat
            and, yes, the question was addressed to the topic starter, and not to you.
  13. garnik
    garnik 7 November 2017 11: 15 New
    +4
    I respect Satanovsky and Soloviev very much. I would like to believe that their speeches do not diverge from their deeds.
    1. Karen
      Karen 8 November 2017 15: 59 New
      +1
      Quote: garnik
      I respect Satanovsky and Soloviev very much. I would like to believe that their speeches do not diverge from their deeds.

      Well, according to Solovyov, one can note: he is one of those who do not agree with the opinion of the need to magnify the activities of Stalin. Together with his opinion that there is no secret of Khazaria, it becomes clear for what purpose he was assigned there ...
      1. garnik
        garnik 8 November 2017 16: 52 New
        +4
        A Jew who is not a member of the Knesset can support the actions of Russia in Syria, especially Assad, what we hear from his lips. He speaks correctly, but I do not believe that he wants Russia what he says.
        And the Jews despise Stalin, the man who brought order to the country, and of course the Jewish stratum was mostly affected. I have nothing against the Jews, but unfortunately, when a critical mass of Jews gather in power, a revolution must be expected.
  14. Sergey Rudov
    Sergey Rudov 7 November 2017 11: 52 New
    +1
    Voice in the wilderness.
  15. Retvizan 8
    Retvizan 8 7 November 2017 13: 39 New
    +3
    Literate uncle!
  16. fox21h
    fox21h 7 November 2017 13: 45 New
    +1
    Listened from start to finish, really crackling
  17. valerei
    valerei 7 November 2017 14: 31 New
    +1
    Bravo, Satanovsky. Professionally competent. However, it will not work out by the saying: "Crowed, but at least do not dawn." How likely is the reality of taking into account this report and its influence on specific foreign policy actions of the Russian leadership? And the last question, as a result of Satanovsky’s assertion about the independence of his Institute: the content of this Institute from Satanovsky’s pocket? It is unlikely that we will get any answer to this question.
  18. vandarus
    vandarus 7 November 2017 15: 33 New
    +3
    Firstly, I congratulate everyone on the 100th anniversary of the Great October Socialist Revolution!
    What is it? Middle East review lecture for 3rd year students?
    The following points draw attention to themselves:
    1. Everything is bad in relations with the entire Middle East, except for Israel. (But what about the demonstrative bombing of our ward (ally)?)
    2. "After the fall of the Assad regime, we would have received a terrorist war in the North Caucasus" (C) (Why all of a sudden? Would terrorists in marching columns have arrived in our North Caucasus?)
    3. "We are micro-forces acting effectively in Syria and have achieved impressive success." Perhaps, but not micro-means. The war in Syria required the financial resources that are needed elsewhere. It seems to me alone that it’s a little expensive to drive “rams” with gauges? And, as a result of the end of the civil war in Syria, the main oil-bearing areas are not controlled by Assad and this seems irrevocable, and we still have to restore this country i.e. at our expense.
    1. Razvedka_Boem
      Razvedka_Boem 8 November 2017 19: 41 New
      +1
      Perhaps, but not micro-means

      As it has been said more than once by the Supreme Administration that the MO is the money spent on the operation in Syria, it is the money that would have been spent on EXERCISES IN THE TERRITORY OF RUSSIA.
      Those. all expenses as planned.
      This is for starters ..
      All the rest of your "conclusions" also do not shine with deep analysis.
      For example
      It seems to me alone that it’s a little expensive to drive “rams” with gauges?

      And you probably want to chase terrorists in Russia? Are you ready for a state of emergency throughout Russia? Do you even imagine what it is?
      Go to Israel .. And when you sit down there to taste the ice cream, be prepared that something will explode ..
      In Russia, this is not and it is worth a lot, even a few Caliber.
      1. vandarus
        vandarus 9 November 2017 15: 50 New
        0
        1. Enough demagoguery.
        2. See p. 2.
        3. What is "that" and what is "this" I know well.
        1. Golovan Jack
          Golovan Jack 9 November 2017 16: 02 New
          +8
          Quote: vandarus
          Stop demagoguery

          That's it, that's enough.
          I read your pick, IMHO the demagogue here is you.
          For example, Syria is a free training ground for testing and running in combat conditions. And weapons (the same Caliber - at a distance, from the underwater position etc), and troops. You ignore it.
          Quote: vandarus
          It seems to me alone that it’s a little expensive to drive “rams” with gauges?

          The main goal is not to “drive rams” at all, see above.
          Quote: vandarus
          as a result of the end of the civil war in Syria, the main oil-bearing areas are not controlled by Assad and it seems irrevocably

          Who told you that the war is over there? It’s not going to end there for another ten years ...
          As for the "irrevocably" - also ... wagging on the water.
          Quote: vandarus
          and we still have to restore this country i.e. at our expense

          This is what a fright? Who signed up for this?
          If you know something - say, do not know ... be silent stop
          1. vandarus
            vandarus 14 November 2017 13: 32 New
            0
            "For example, Syria is a free training ground for testing and running in combat conditions. And weapons (the same Caliber - at a distance, from a submerged position etc), and troops. You ignore this." -Don't ignore it. How many launches of calibers of one modification? Is there a lot to break in?
            "This is what a fright? Who signed up for it?" -And what do you think that we will remove the unnecessary further, leave the bases and will calmly observe how our client is quietly outbid with investments for restoration? Why then fought?
      2. krasnoderevshik
        krasnoderevshik 9 November 2017 21: 50 New
        0
        "As it has been said more than once by the Supreme Administration, the MO - the funds spent on the operation in Syria, these are the funds that would have been spent on EXERCISES IN THE RUSSIAN TERRITORY.
        Those. all expenses as planned.
        This is for starters .. "Let me disagree with you and your quote. For starters, look at how the Russian budget was decided in past years, and you will see an interesting item such as" secret expenses "and, if you draw parallels with the beginning of the Syrian conflict, then these the so-called "secret expenditures" are growing and growing, from this we can conclude that our state is participating in the war and is planning expenditures for it separately from the defense industry in a sense.
    2. Andkor1962
      Andkor1962 10 November 2017 13: 44 New
      +1
      There would be cons, I would put it without hesitation (to you)
  19. Bourgeois
    Bourgeois 7 November 2017 19: 54 New
    +1
    Of course, that Evg. Yanovich is one of the few people who not only has a great command of the situation and situation in that region, but also a person who is worried about the country. They just would have listened at the top to the advice of such people
  20. Sergef
    Sergef 7 November 2017 20: 35 New
    0
    Bravo and condolences.
  21. terapevt
    terapevt 8 November 2017 04: 33 New
    +3
    If this happens ... me first, and then all the rest ... There will be military bases in Syria! With the rest ... just "collaborate." Dialogues between diplomats and US diplomats are useless at the "before" stage ... everything will be completely deceived. Satanovsky, with his conviction and knowledge of the matter, would head the Foreign Ministry, and not give lectures to senators ...
  22. Alex alexandr
    Alex alexandr 8 November 2017 07: 38 New
    +1
    Armageddonitch as always on top !!!
  23. nalogoplatelschik
    nalogoplatelschik 8 November 2017 21: 21 New
    0
    Who is he telling this to? And for what?
    1. nalogoplatelschik
      nalogoplatelschik 8 November 2017 21: 28 New
      0
      Matvienko there probably is sleeping on the mound during his speech.
  24. w70
    w70 8 November 2017 21: 29 New
    0
    Clever all the same Jews, you will not say anything
  25. nalogoplatelschik
    nalogoplatelschik 8 November 2017 21: 35 New
    +2
    Speaking unwritten. Worth it. Very competent special.
  26. Yugra
    Yugra 8 November 2017 21: 45 New
    0
    A clever man. But Jerusalem in vain protects ....
  27. nalogoplatelschik
    nalogoplatelschik 8 November 2017 21: 51 New
    0
    Maybe you will pull Dagestan out of the most subsidized republic of Russia. Critic. Get started already.
  28. 1 alexander
    1 alexander 9 November 2017 16: 01 New
    +1
    Tough, powerful, exciting!
  29. Alex rad
    Alex rad 9 November 2017 21: 17 New
    0
    A sensible man like these in foreign policy!
  30. skobars
    skobars 10 November 2017 00: 24 New
    +1
    A competent comrade, it is clear that the heart aches for Russia, unlike many deputies and ministers.
  31. harkin victor
    harkin victor 10 November 2017 09: 52 New
    +1
    I have long been watching and admiring his speeches. Openly and accurately formulates the essence of the topic. He always accurately gives an assessment to certain events, not only in the Middle East topic. Well versed in the intricacies of Middle Eastern diplomacy. It is good to listen to their discussions on the Middle East topic with Bagdasarov.
  32. Des10
    Des10 10 November 2017 19: 35 New
    0
    Stunned, finally heard the speech of a normal, competent, intelligent and with dignity - a man.
    Thank you.
  33. taisant
    taisant 12 November 2017 13: 04 New
    0
    He speaks like an oil painting.