Military Review

On the anniversary of the October Revolution without fanaticism

119
On Saturday, when Russia celebrated National Unity Day, Interfax distributed the appeal of the Head of the Russian Imperial House of Grand Duchess Maria Vladimirovna to compatriots in connection with the 100th anniversary of the October Revolution of 1917. It is an attempt to comprehend this historical the event leads the Grand Duchess to a very definite conclusion: "First of all, we all, regardless of the existing differences in views, must recognize that the Revolution is a common misfortune," the Head of the Romanov House convinces the Russians.


On the anniversary of the October Revolution without fanaticism


What is the value of the Russian Imperial House?

Russians mostly learned about the existence of Grand Duchess Maria Vladimirovna Romanova and the Russian Imperial House only in the post-Soviet period. Prior to this, all of their knowledge about the post-revolutionary succession to the throne was limited to the cheap popular scenes from the popular adventure film “The Crown of the Russian Empire”.

With the end of communist hegemony, the people of the Russian capital, whose fate was re-challenged by the socialist revolution and forced to live in emigration for many years, have become frequent. The authorities willingly accepted former compatriots, encouraged their attention to Russia and even decided to declare reconciliation of the participants in the civil war.

This reconciliation turned out to be somewhat strange. The overwhelming heirs of the white movement participants did not hurry to return to Russia, but insisted on the rehabilitation of their ancestors, returning to them a good name. The process has begun. A good name was returned, for example, to Admiral Kolchak.

The atrocities of his army are still remembered throughout Siberia. In the new Russia, the admiral appeared a patriot and a man of honor. They wrote books about him, made films (documentary and artistic). Over time, it turned out that this worthy man turned out to be shot by order of bastards from the Irkutsk Military Revolutionary Committee.

The circle is closed. Instead of reconciliation, they simply changed signs. White made even whiter and even fluffy, red - black fiend hell. Satisfied with such a favorable turnover, the heirs of the participants in the civil war returned to their European homes. In Russia, after them, there was a feeling of deep guilt for the revolution, so ruthlessly deciding the fate of compatriots.

Grand Duchess Maria Vladimirovna was also adopted by the highest persons of the Russian government. Taking advantage of this, the Russian Imperial House tried to obtain an official state status. However, it soon became clear that, as in the mentioned adventure film, there are at least two such houses, and, to put it mildly, they are not very friendly with each other.

The Russian authorities have become more restrained in relations with the Grand Duchess, although they did not hinder her various initiatives. For example, in 2008, the Head of the Russian Imperial House took under its patronage the Russian State University of Trade and Economics.

In 2012, Grand Duchess Maria Vladimirovna took patronage of the Baltic patrol ship, the latest at that time (commissioned in 2009) fleet "Yaroslav the Wise." Patronage of warships is a long-standing Russian and Soviet tradition. Labor collectives and even entire cities commit themselves to provide feasible cultural and material assistance to the crews.

So the Grand Duchess took the Baltic watchdog under her care. True, with reservations. Kirill Nemirovich-Danchenko, adviser on interaction with public organizations and state authorities of the Russian Federation of the Russian Imperial House, immediately warned the sailors: “The imperial house is not valuable material goods, but, above all, authority.” On that and conspired.

Communication with modern Russia did not melt the heart of the Grand Duchess. After all our reconciliation and repentance, the revolution, which has radically rebuilt Russian society, has remained a misfortune for it, which it has been quietly living in in Spanish Madrid since Franco times.

What is the trouble for the imperial house of the Romanovs, then for Zyuganov - “a breakthrough from the darkness of capitalist slavery”

In contrast to the Grand Duchess, the leader of the Communist Party of the Russian Federation, Gennady Zyuganov, spoke on the occasion of the 100 anniversary of the October Revolution, not with a message, but with congratulations from compatriots. As we have become accustomed, the leader of the Communist Party of the Russian Federation has listed in detail the slogans under which the socialist revolution took place. He noted its obvious achievements and significance for the world community.

“October marked the beginning of a new era,” Gennady Zyuganov wrote in his congratulations. “Labor and solidarity, equality, fraternity and collectivism were her main commandments. The course of events has acquired a qualitatively new direction. A country appeared on the world map where a man of labor took power into his own hands. The results hit the whole planet. "Soviet miracle" - is thousands of the best factories and plants. It is the elimination of illiteracy and advanced science, the exit into space and a powerful defense shield. These are unique guarantees in the field of education, health care and social protection. The emergence of a new man - a man-creator, ahead of time.

What did not appear in Zyuganov’s congratulations was compassion in memory of the sacrifices that Great October brought. Objective researchers agree that “they do not make revolution in white gloves,” and that “tectonic social transformations are not possible without struggle and blood.”

They recognize: the birth of a new social order, like the birth of a person into the world, occurs through pain, blood and tears. However, according to the estimates of modern official historians, this was excessive in the October Revolution. The expected conclusion brought with it not only compassion for the people killed in the hard times, but also some kind of shyness for the fact that a complete drama revolution took place on our land.

So in public discourse extremes did not overlap. The head of the Russian Imperial House sees revolution-trouble in the events of October. Gennady Zyuganov - a great breakthrough. The official authorities do not have a single position. Russian President Vladimir Putin is cautious. In his opinion, the October Revolution still “requires a deep objective professional evaluation.”

The straightforward Prime Minister Dmitry Medvedev does not bother in great doubt. Three years ago, at the opening of the Council for the Restoration of the New Jerusalem Monastery, he recalled that the day of the “October Revolution” in Soviet times was celebrated as the main state holiday. “Today, most of our citizens understand that this is the day of the tragedy, which largely determined the future history of the country and the civil war,” Medvedev drew the line of doubts and did not correct his position anymore.

It is quite clear that with such an attitude towards the history of October, the authorities did not properly respond to the numerous requests of Communist leader Gennady Zyuganov "to celebrate the 100 anniversary of the Great October Socialist Revolution as a public holiday."

How the Russian revolution is being driven into the shadow of the Chinese revolution

Last December, President Vladimir Putin still issued a decree on events for the 100 anniversary of the 1917 revolution. The document was unusual. By his decree, the President instructed the Association “Russian Historical Society” to form an organizing committee for the preparation and holding of events dedicated to the anniversary of the revolution. The government finally distanced itself from the historic jubilee, placing its holding on a public organization.

She performed her function. With the assistance of the Ministry of Culture, she organized several unnoticed by the press scientific conferences and seminars devoted to the analysis of the events of the October Revolution, and three thematic exhibitions in Moscow museums dedicated to the anniversary date. That's all.

The reserved attitude of the Russian authorities to the anniversary of the revolution was recently manifested in the reaction of the press secretary of the president Dmitry Peskov to the journalists' question, how will the Kremlin celebrate the anniversary of the revolution? “And in connection with what it is necessary to celebrate, explain to me. I don’t quite understand the question, ”said Putin’s spokesman.

Meanwhile, if you look closely, today the persons of the current Russian government are the main beneficiaries of the October revolution. Judge for yourself if under the tsarist regime could a boy from a simple working Petersburg family rise to the heights of the head of the Russian state? The answer is obvious - no. It can be attributed to almost all the current inhabitants of the Kremlin, including the "dull" press secretary and the categorical prime minister.

So why are these people so “quietly let down” the 100 anniversary of the revolution? Historian Nikita Sokolov offers his explanation. In his opinion, “the idea of ​​civil equality, social justice, under the slogan of which the revolution began, is uncomfortable for discussion, for example. And this topic is not timely in a country with a high coefficient of social inequality. ”

Political analyst Abbas Gallyamov makes an absolutely extravagant conclusion: “The idea that it’s right for the overthrow of the power should not come to the Russians. Only one way out is to hush up the topic. ” One can argue with him, remember how, in his message to the Federal Assembly last year, Vladimir Putin called for “using the lessons of history to strengthen civil peace and not speculate on the tragedies of Russian history in their own political and other interests.

However, most likely, the government simply focuses on the public mood, which has greatly changed in the post-Soviet period. A recent survey of the Institute of Sociology of the Russian Academy of Sciences showed that almost a third of Russians (32%) were at a loss to assess the October revolution of 1917. Approximately another third (29%) noted that from the revolution "there was approximately equal benefit and harm."

Only 21% of respondents, as liberal sociologists say, “continue to live by Soviet myths”. This part of the respondents believes that the revolution has brought “more benefits” to the people. Their opponents were 19% of respondents who were convinced that there was “more harm” from the revolution.

A similar alignment is in assessing the very fact of the seizure of power by the Bolsheviks. Positive to him are 30% of respondents, negatively - 35%. The rest find it difficult to answer. As sociologists noted, modern assessments do not proceed from the historical memory of generations, but from the practical knowledge of a person, which were influenced by schoolchildren, media, politics, etc., not deprived of subjectivity.

While Russia is arguing and quarreling when evaluating the October Revolution, its significance for the development of world civilization has long been recognized abroad. First of all, it concerns the enormous influence of the revolution in Russia on social policy in the countries of classical socialism. With less pleasure in the West, they say that the ideas of socialist equality have buried the world colonial system.

But they like to emphasize that the consequence of the October Revolution was the creation in the world of two antagonistic poles formed around the superpowers - the Soviet Union and the United States. One of these poles has become the center of evil, the other - the center of good. This extreme position has been gently formulated recently by the German historian Christiane Janeke.

Last Thursday in Berlin, as part of a series of monthly events at the Center for Eastern European and International Studies, Janeke took part in a panel discussion on the 1917 events of the year. The historian concluded that the October Revolution "was a key event of the twentieth century, because it led to the formation of the Soviet Union - the future superpower, which was one of the main reasons for the polarization of the world."

Such simplification has recently become a trend. It has a long-term desire of the West to infringe upon Russia, to belittle its importance for world civilization. At the discussion in Berlin, this was perfectly demonstrated by another historian, Jan Berends. He argued that the Russian revolution was the most important event of the twentieth century.

“If you look at the role China plays in the world now, assess its importance,” said Berends, “it is quite possible that the Chinese revolution was still more important than the Russian revolution in the 1917 year.” The historian forgot about the huge civilizational role of the USSR in the development of not only communist China, but also other Asian countries.

In these once backward regions, with the help of the Soviet Union, industry, health care, education, and science were rising. Berends preferred not to recall this. With the suggestion of the German scientist, Western historical thought has now received a new vector of development, which has good political prospects for it - to drive the Russian revolution into the shadow of the Chinese.

And what are we? It seems that in our hearts we still remain on different sides of the civil conflict of a century ago and are unable to evaluate it calmly and impartially, as a historical reality. For example, as Peter's reforms, the hard realities of which have already been erased in human memory. There remained a country equipped by Great Peter and pride in the affairs of the first Russian Emperor, whose heirs were never able to understand the scale and significance of the October revolution of 1917.
Author:
119 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must to register.

I have an account? Sign in

  1. Gardamir
    Gardamir 6 November 2017 10: 03 New
    35
    I don’t know what relation this simply Maria has to the Romanovs, but in matters of inheritance, the deck was shuffled, so the closest heirs to the throne are Serbian Karageorgievichs. However, I do not care, I am for socialism.
    1. Sling cutter
      Sling cutter 6 November 2017 10: 59 New
      35
      The whole point of "reconciliation" is to reconcile thieves and scalded.
      1. stas
        stas 6 November 2017 21: 55 New
        15
        This is the king’s dream, only hell will not work.
        Thieves capitalism and the living bourgeoisie of Putin's Russia are not the best future of Russia.
        The tsar (even with Putin's face) and the bourgeois we do not need, that's for sure.
        We are united by Russia, and the thieves' power and the bourgeoisie are separating us.
        1. Sling cutter
          Sling cutter 6 November 2017 22: 08 New
          11
          Quote: stas
          We are united by Russia, and the thieves' power and the bourgeoisie are separating us.

          And the heart is anxious in the chest,
          And the new October is ahead!
          1. smart ass
            smart ass 8 November 2017 20: 47 New
            +1
            What are you guys in the 91st year, when the USSR came to an end, didn’t go beyond your power to go under the tanks? After all, the opportunity to defend their country was. The sofa stuck to the priest and hindered the action?
            1. Sling cutter
              Sling cutter 8 November 2017 21: 13 New
              +2
              Quote: Clever man
              What are you guys in the 91st year, when the USSR came to an end, didn’t go beyond your power to go under the tanks? After all, the opportunity to defend their country was. The sofa stuck to the priest and hindered the action?

              In the 91st year, I strengthened the country's defense.
              1. smart ass
                smart ass 9 November 2017 08: 30 New
                0
                Well then, maybe it’s not worth whining that everything was cool in the USSR and now everything is bad
                1. Sling cutter
                  Sling cutter 9 November 2017 08: 48 New
                  +6
                  Quote: Clever man
                  Well then, maybe it’s not worth whining that everything was cool in the USSR and now everything is bad

                  Eeee-ka, my friend, you suffered belay
                  Where did you see me whining?
                  And secondly, it’s even worse now than you can imagine.
                  For 25 years, the scientific, technical, industrial and, most importantly, human potential of the USSR has been practically exhausted. Everything and everything has collapsed, to which the hand of the market has reached.
                  And no propaganda of kissel-litter -tw can change the overall picture of degradation.
                  To make it easier for you to see the% depreciation of fixed assets, it’s even simpler how worn out the utilities are. All supply lines were laid the earliest in the early 90s.
                  Now can break through everywhere and any love moment. The housing stock has already exceeded all conceivable warranty periods, the infrastructure deteriorates from year to year.
                  Further, qualified personnel are absent, as well as the sister of a professional technical education.
                  Science is defeated. And where is the selection? She also remained in our glorious socialist past!
                  I hope you have enough arguments, or will you insistently insist on "doneunas"?
                  1. smart ass
                    smart ass 9 November 2017 11: 43 New
                    0
                    Naset Kiselevschiny in ears I agree to all 100% and even devastation on the face
      2. Ulan
        Ulan 7 November 2017 21: 21 New
        +6
        This is without me. Let others be reconciled with Chubais.
    2. Basil50
      Basil50 6 November 2017 11: 44 New
      42
      With the upcoming great anniversary of the GREAT SOCIALIST REVOLUTION!
      Let them go malice and go to * guano * and these bankrupt romanovs and other liberal riffraff.
      1. dSK
        dSK 6 November 2017 16: 40 New
        +4
        Social revolution always chaos, destruction, national woes. Need social evolution - development of positive qualities and the elimination of negative ones. The constant choice of man’s free will - with his Creator and creator, or you will fall into the arms of a destroyer and a liar horned.
        1. badens1111
          badens1111 6 November 2017 17: 14 New
          +8
          Quote: dsk
          Constant choice of human free will

          Your free will, exactly at the end of your nose, the rest of a person’s duties to others and to society as a whole, there is nothing to push Protestant nonsense into society.
        2. weksha50
          weksha50 6 November 2017 18: 35 New
          +4
          Quote: dsk
          We need social evolution - the development of positive qualities and the elimination of negative ones.


          One needs to be blissful in order to believe in the reality of such a homo sapiens in society ...
        3. stas
          stas 6 November 2017 21: 57 New
          +6
          So thieves in law and in power will not voluntarily give up power and stolen?
          1. dSK
            dSK 6 November 2017 22: 27 New
            +3
            To oppose thieves and liars is to voluntarily “go cross”, give a bribe, left “options” (everyone lives like that). Freedom of choice.
            "So in everything, as you want people to do with you, so do you with them, for this is the law and the prophets. Enter with narrow gates, because the gates are wide and the path leading to perdition is wide, and many go by them; because the gates are narrow and the path leading to life is narrow, and few find them. Beware of false prophets who come to you in sheep's clothing, but inside they are predatory wolves. By their fruits you know them. "
            1. Ulan
              Ulan 7 November 2017 21: 23 New
              +3
              With sermons - to the church.
          2. Sling cutter
            Sling cutter 6 November 2017 22: 29 New
            +4
            Quote: stas
            So thieves in law and in power will not voluntarily give up power and stolen?

            So much the worse for them!
            Quote: Sovetskiy
            Join us!

        4. Sotskiy
          Sotskiy 6 November 2017 23: 06 New
          12
          Quote: dsk
          We need social evolution - the development of positive qualities and the elimination of negative ones.

          First, they made a coup in the 90's with millions of victims after the separation of the USSR, and now are you calling for evolution based on the capitalist system?)))
          How many centuries has your capitalism evolved and what has it turned into? As a drover of a chewing herd without moral standards and principles? Do you call for such an “evolution"?
        5. Sergey2068
          Sergey2068 6 November 2017 23: 25 New
          11
          It’s great for you. After the victory of the counter-revolution in 1991, the Soviet people were robbed very quickly. And in order to return the loot to the people, in your opinion, you need a long evolutionary path. Maybe you just advise the people to stand together on the porch with outstretched hand and chant together - give the loot. Cool, all the same, after all, they will not give up for good. A difficult choice
      2. Sotskiy
        Sotskiy 6 November 2017 22: 19 New
        11
        Quote: Vasily50
        With the upcoming great anniversary of the GREAT SOCIALIST REVOLUTION!

        Join us!
        Tomorrow I will hang the red flag on the car, I will cut the “Internationale” all over the street and I will celebrate the Great Holiday, in spite of all these Peskov entrenched in the government’s offices with the delivery of the tolerant “Tsar”, who launched another coercion to repentance of all the “red”, the next “Wailing Wall” and pouring mud on the country in which I was born and raised.
        Interestingly, all these degenerates really think that they can after they ruined my homeland - in fact, my house, divided my large international family and doused it with their "shitty" slops, to force me to unite with them?
        1. dSK
          dSK 6 November 2017 23: 47 New
          +2
          You suggest experimenting again - "we will destroy the old world to the ground, and then we will build a new world, who was nobody he will become everything." Overseas partners will help to destroy forever - it is unlikely to build. There are legal, legal possibilities to eliminate negative aspects. Putin often says - "you need to work carefully. "
          1. Sotskiy
            Sotskiy 7 November 2017 00: 04 New
            +6
            Quote: dsk
            Putin often says - "you need to work carefully."

            We see how carefully Putin opens the Yeltsin centers, the Wailing Walls encouraging "liberal" degenerates who knocked "where should" on their own inner circle during the times of the USSR, on vigorous actions to de-Sovietize the remnants of the Soviet past. God forbid (I wonder from what time he became a believer? The KGB did not seem to encourage believers) the youth will absorb the Soviet ideas of their "ancestors"! We see a fat man, with a shiny coat of Chubais, who yelled about "privatization" as the last nail in the lid of the coffin of communism.
            So what does Putin say there? And what does?)))
          2. dSK
            dSK 7 November 2017 00: 26 New
            +2
            During the life of Christ, Palestine was occupied by the Romans. But Jesus Christ did not say a single word about rebellion against the power of the Romans, preached about the salvation of the soul. "When the days of His taking from the world were drawing near, He wanted to go to Jerusalem; and he sent messengers before his face; and they went and went into the village of Samaryan; to prepare for him; but they did not receive him, because he had the appearance of a traveler in Jerusalem. Seeing this, his disciples, James and John, said: Lord, do you want us to say that the fire descends from heaven and destroys them, just as Elijah did? But He turned to them, forbade them and said: you don’t know what kind of spirit are you; for the Son of Man came not to destroy the souls of men, but to save. And we went to another village. "At the trial, Pilate wanted to let Christ go, but the Pharisees insisted on his execution, threatening Pilate with a denunciation to Rome. As a result, now, with God's help, half of the world are Christians. Read at least one of the four Gospels - http: //days.pravoslavie.ru/Bible/Index.htm
            1. Sotskiy
              Sotskiy 7 November 2017 00: 40 New
              +5
              Quote: dsk
              During the life of Christ, Palestine was occupied by the Romans. But Jesus Christ did not say a single word about rebellion against the power of the Romans, preached about the salvation of the soul

              So according to the statements of the authorities, it seems like we have an independent country, what kind of occupation is it here? Or is there still an occupation and we are being deceived in the most arrogant way, through faith ?!)))
            2. ver_
              ver_ 7 November 2017 04: 18 New
              +2
              ... Rome was born after Christ for a hundred years - no less than ..
              1. badens1111
                badens1111 7 November 2017 08: 56 New
                +3
                Quote: ver_
                Rome was born after Christ for a hundred years - no less than ..

                Pontius Pilate ... the procurator of Judea ... did you hear anything? Well, what about the cross and other things on the hill, but the words of the robber Varrava?
            3. zoolu350
              zoolu350 9 November 2017 11: 39 New
              +1
              Yeshua didn’t say that, but the Zealot sect used him in a showdown with the Romans, pulling out his follower Barabbas.
        2. badens1111
          badens1111 7 November 2017 08: 54 New
          +6
          Quote: Sovetskiy
          Tomorrow I will hang a red flag on the car, I will cut the "International" all over the street and

          Congratulations!
          The flag is already hanging, the local lumpen businessman is turning his face back. Well, let him ...
          Quote: Sovetskiy
          Interestingly, all these degenerates really think that they can after they ruined my homeland - in fact, my house, divided my large international family and doused it with their "shitty" slops, to force me to unite with them?

          You won’t believe it, but that’s exactly what they push as an idea. And they want to “unite” just like that, for example, Olgovich and Shpakovsky, and a lot of their “associates” with their dubious comments on a historical topic “illuminated” the question, so it's time to call an ambulance help from the unbearable smell of mercaptan
          1. Sotskiy
            Sotskiy 7 November 2017 10: 38 New
            +4
            Quote: badens1111
            Congratulations!

            Thank you!
            And you with the 100 summer anniversary of the Great October Revolution!
        3. smart ass
          smart ass 9 November 2017 15: 37 New
          0
          Hang the red flag and cut the international sooooo grieving peskov and all his coders, he probably will sob all night
    3. iouris
      iouris 6 November 2017 12: 19 New
      +4
      Quote: Gardamir
      what does this just Maria have to do with the Romanovs

      There is reason to believe that the Romanovs are an actual financial history. And the "bonds", "Palestinian" and other "imperial" societies are a cover. An expert opinion is needed here.
      1. weksha50
        weksha50 6 November 2017 18: 41 New
        10
        Quote: iouris
        An expert opinion is needed here.


        For what ? In order to return the monarchy to Russia ??? fool
        IT, who drew themselves the new noble titles?
        Well, Nikita Mikhalkov will be glad ...: yes
        Новth filmу about the revival of the monarchy will remove ... Which again will be difficult to understand the unenlightened ... slaves ... lol
  2. mac789
    mac789 6 November 2017 10: 11 New
    38
    The Great October Socialist Revolution is universal free education and health care, an eight-hour working day, holidays, motels and other social guarantees. She scared the rich Pinocchio all over the world to a nervous tick and made them share with the people. Even the current shattered and castrated, inactive paper pseudo-guarantees still somehow act thanks to her.
    1. Sadam
      Sadam 6 November 2017 22: 38 New
      +1
      hmm ... when I was a pioneer I was told that when I grow up here we will heal ... right now I grew up and they say that it turned out I lived happily when I was a pioneer ... I don’t understand where I am ....)))
      1. stas
        stas 6 November 2017 23: 25 New
        +5
        Sodom, but you are no longer given to understand where you were fucked.
        In 1991, we were raped by completing an anti-Soviet counter-revolution with a drunk EBN on a tank.
        And the clerks were clapping their ears, and now they are a wealthy elite and in power, they were defenders, and there was no need to have enemies.
        1. smart ass
          smart ass 9 November 2017 15: 39 New
          0
          And you sat on the couch and did nothing)
      2. mac789
        mac789 7 November 2017 07: 38 New
        +2
        It's funny ... You write correctly ... It’s not bad to see that they were taught in the Evil Empire ... wink
  3. vladimirvn
    vladimirvn 6 November 2017 10: 12 New
    21
    We are the heirs of both white and red. The 1917 revolution is a great event in the history of Russia. And you need to talk about it loudly and without embarrassment. Not bulging and not hiding everything that was.
  4. Eurodav
    Eurodav 6 November 2017 10: 17 New
    14
    "... Heads of the Russian Imperial House of the Grand Duchess Maria Vladimirovna ..."
    Whoever chose it as its head, otherwise we do not sleep, nor in spirit ...
    "... There are at least two such houses, and they, to put it mildly, are not very friendly with each other ..."
    That's it. Understand first, and then announce the chapter!
    "... the atrocities of his (Kolchak) army are still remembered throughout Siberia ..."
    Like the atrocities of Tukhachevsky, Putna, Uborevich, etc.
    "... In Russia, after them there remained a feeling of deep guilt for the revolution, so ruthlessly disposed of the fate of compatriots ..."
    My grandfather was a communist, and my neighbor had blue blood! And no discord, guilt or anything else that we never had with him! Disagreement and other garbage in the heads of high-seated, ordinary people are smarter and have long understood and forgave each other!
    "... A recent survey by the Institute of Sociology of the Russian Academy of Sciences showed that almost a third of Russians (32%) found it difficult to assess the October Revolution of 1917 ...."
    What estimates, what polls, if the Bolsheviks themselves called it a coup! Only then they propagandized ... So the Russians find it difficult, why is there something incomprehensible? You declassify the archives then, then ask the people what they think? True, then reparations for the genocide of the Russian people will have to be knocked out of Israel, but this is another topic ...
    1. Krasnodar
      Krasnodar 6 November 2017 10: 32 New
      +6
      Quote: Evrodav
      "... Heads of the Russian Imperial House of the Grand Duchess Maria Vladimirovna ..."
      Whoever chose it as its head, otherwise we do not sleep, nor in spirit ...
      "... There are at least two such houses, and they, to put it mildly, are not very friendly with each other ..."
      That's it. Understand first, and then announce the chapter!
      "... the atrocities of his (Kolchak) army are still remembered throughout Siberia ..."
      Like the atrocities of Tukhachevsky, Putna, Uborevich, etc.
      "... In Russia, after them there remained a feeling of deep guilt for the revolution, so ruthlessly disposed of the fate of compatriots ..."
      My grandfather was a communist, and my neighbor had blue blood! And no discord, guilt or anything else that we never had with him! Disagreement and other garbage in the heads of high-seated, ordinary people are smarter and have long understood and forgave each other!
      "... A recent survey by the Institute of Sociology of the Russian Academy of Sciences showed that almost a third of Russians (32%) found it difficult to assess the October Revolution of 1917 ...."
      What estimates, what polls, if the Bolsheviks themselves called it a coup! Only then they propagandized ... So the Russians find it difficult, why is there something incomprehensible? You declassify the archives then, then ask the people what they think? True, then reparations for the genocide of the Russian people will have to be knocked out of Israel, but this is another topic ...

      Well, yes, the Jews made a revolution, that is, it was they who burned the estates of the landowners before October, removed the tsar from power, forced the army to suffer enormous losses on the fronts of the First World War, which the country needed as a hare with a venereal disease.
      And to beat reparations from Israel is as profitable and successful in advance as getting money from oligarchs in Russia. In theory, you can, and even everyone agrees, but without pants and health you will remain until you get three pennies)))
    2. Vasya Vassin
      Vasya Vassin 6 November 2017 11: 58 New
      +2
      Rogues. BENDERS INTERNATIONAL. As we know, the Romanovs had an indirect relation to power, and even these ...
    3. Lycan
      Lycan 6 November 2017 14: 19 New
      +8
      Quote: Evrodav
      What estimates, what polls, if the Bolsheviks themselves called it a coup!

      The Bolsheviks called something. But there is clearly a fundamental difference (in the consequences).
      Coup:
      The goal is to remove the current leaders from power; the foundations of society are not affected.
      It is not supported to a large extent by popular support; it is carried out by a small group of persons or by a separate party.
      Far from class ideology.

      Revolution:
      The goal is to change the political regime or the entire social system.
      It is an incredible power movement of the masses.
      Occurs under the influence of class ideological principles.
      ----------------------
      Agree - when one primate with the interests of his pack overthrows the old primacy with his (and his retinue) interests - this is not the same when the primate with the interests of his pack takes power and gradually equalizes the fair access of pasture resources to all members of the population. Yes, it was not so smooth and “without a hitch” - this is all the same, the first “approach to the projectile” in our country. And the whole population has a psychological. inertia and revolution leaders far from always within the window of opportunity, they can act "slowly" and with a sense of tact in relation to individual, inhibiting events, groups. And what is happening in / in Ukraine does not fit in any way with any vector of societal change. formation and not equal to state building. For in the Ukrainian case all power is known whose puppets. But there are no alternatives supported by the popular movement, a visionary idea and weapons (we are not talking about L / DPR yet).
  5. Krasnodar
    Krasnodar 6 November 2017 10: 21 New
    25
    Citizens of Western countries should be grateful to Lenin - their chic social network is a derivative of the fear of the ruling classes of that time, frightened by a revolution in their own countries and agreed to social changes in order to maintain their dominant position. As for Russia, this is one of the most important milestones of its history. In my personal opinion, the tsarist system was neither able to initiate the launch of man into space, nor to build a nuclear shield of the country.
  6. populist
    populist 6 November 2017 10: 26 New
    13
    What was not in Zyuganov’s congratulation was compassion in memory of the victims of the Great October Revolution.

    So the opponents of the Great October Revolution are to blame for these victims. It was they who lit the fire of the civil war.
  7. Gardamir
    Gardamir 6 November 2017 10: 39 New
    22
    Here are the results of the first five-year period



    And now, in every five-year period, after 1991, how many were demolished. Then the giants built, now shopping centers.
    1. Boris55
      Boris55 6 November 2017 10: 52 New
      13
      Quote: Gardamir
      Then the giants built, now shopping centers.

      Then - Baikonur, today - East.
      Then - the gas pipeline Urengoy-Pamara-Uzhgorod, Today - Nord Stream one, two.
      And so on ...
      The fact that the media do not focus on this and Putin has to wander around the country and press the red buttons because in this case, the media will not be able to shut up this, this is another matter.
      Construction goes on both under capitalism and under socialism, but the approaches to the distribution of labor results are different. I am for socialism from the time of Stalin.
      1. Greenwood
        Greenwood 6 November 2017 11: 42 New
        17
        Quote: Boris55
        Then - Baikonur, today - East.
        Then - the gas pipeline Urengoy-Pamara-Uzhgorod, Today - Nord Stream one, two.
        The scale is now not the same. Sometimes private companies are built to advance their business interests. Yes, and theft on all these construction sites is prohibitive.
        1. Krasnodar
          Krasnodar 6 November 2017 11: 46 New
          +3
          Quote: Greenwood
          Quote: Boris55
          Then - Baikonur, today - East.
          Then - the gas pipeline Urengoy-Pamara-Uzhgorod, Today - Nord Stream one, two.
          The scale is now not the same. Sometimes private companies are built to advance their business interests. Yes, and theft on all these construction sites is prohibitive.

          They also stolen the Soviet ones ... more modest, of course, but still
          1. badens1111
            badens1111 6 November 2017 12: 02 New
            18
            Quote: Krasnodar
            They also stolen the Soviet ones ... more modest, of course, but still

            Not without it, the truth was received by a fair amount and some were getting to the wall. And now I stole, the airport, the plane, London and hello.
            And those who then stole and sat down for it ... now their descendants howl endlessly about repression.
            1. Krasnodar
              Krasnodar 6 November 2017 12: 16 New
              +4
              Quote: badens1111
              Quote: Krasnodar
              They also stolen the Soviet ones ... more modest, of course, but still

              Not without it, the truth was received by a fair amount and some were getting to the wall. And now I stole, the airport, the plane, London and hello.
              And those who then stole and sat down for it ... now their descendants howl endlessly about repression.

              :)
              Almost everything was stolen in the USSR. From saleswomen in pavilions of beer to water, to the CEOs of factories. Dozens sat down, units were shot.
              In the era of total deficit, theft and exchange of ala subsistence farming was the norm.
              Now if you have stolen, in London you will only find yourself sharing 80% of the stolen goods. If you stole a little - you can’t last more than a year in London :)
              1. badens1111
                badens1111 6 November 2017 13: 56 New
                10
                Quote: Krasnodar
                Almost everything was stolen in the USSR. From saleswomen in pavilions of beer to water, to the CEOs of factories. Dozens sat down, units were shot.

                You see sir by age is very young, if so you evaluate life under the Union. Judging by your words, did your dad and mom steal the same thing? No? And why are you then slandering the entire population?
                Quote: Krasnodar
                In the era of total deficit, theft and exchange of ala subsistence farming was the norm.

                Well, well .. well, and by whom and when the “total deficit” was created, exert your undoubtedly powerful intellect and give out information. So that you don’t strain too hard, I can tell you the beginning of your “total deficit” -1987, from the moment you cooperative and trade laws
                Quote: Krasnodar
                Now if you have stolen, in London you will only find yourself sharing 80% of the stolen goods. If you stole a little - you can’t last more than a year in London

                Are you justifying thieves of various scales now? With the warriors so brazen that soon the country's treasury will empty for you to joy, because now there is an "era of plenty", only weirdness is seized by what we did not create, but who built it in Soviet times , isn’t it strange that you’ve been able to devour everything in a row for 30 years already, and you spit everything in the past?
                So ..to remind you ..
                “Deficiency is a mismatch between product supply and demand.”
                Now compare with your situation. Yes, there was nothing on the shelves of the stores, but people had full refrigerators, no one was hungry, the goods reached the consumer completely, which means that the demand was satisfied. It turns out there was no shortage of nebilo, but there was a simple speculation.
                Traders sold most of the goods coming to them to the market, leaving the worst products for reporting in stores. They tried to hide the goods, hold it and sell more expensive from under the floor. So the shadow market was born, the volume of which, by the mid-80s, was already at least 30% of the national income of the USSR. Https: //topwar.ru/48706-pravda-o-deficite-v-
                sssr.html
                The deficit in the USSR was created artificially, warehouses were bursting with goods. http://kprf.ru/rus_soc/99032.html Deficit under Gorbachev was created artificially http://www.duel.ru/200605/?05_3_2 Deficit of goods in the USSR was created intentionally
                Nikolai Ryzhkov, in 1985-1990. - Chairman of the Council of Ministers of the USSR, in the television program “USSR. The collapse of the empire ”(episode 7), shown on December 11, 2011 (NTV channel) tells how this tobacco famine was artificially created in the country:“ Gorbachev calls me and says: “Here’s Yeltsin, can’t you come to me? " I've come. And I already knew what was going on. For several days almost riots took place. I say: “Mikhail Sergeyevich, why are you asking me? There is Boris Nikolaevich next to you, and ask him. Boris Nikolaevich, I may be mistaken, 28 tobacco factories. Of these, 26 were stopped for repair in one day. So what are you asking? That (ie Gorbachev): “Boris Nikolaevich, on what basis did you decide to stop the tobacco industry of the republic almost completely. Why did you do this? ” And really, why? If this is not deliberate sabotage and sabotage, then what is it? And all this was done by the new, already democratic, power of the Russian Federation for the sake of the final discredit and liquidation of the power of his rival, Gorbachev, together with the USSR, and to seize the sole power through the collapse of the country.

                Source: http://politikus.ru/articles/66442-kak-razvalili-
                sssr-cherez-iskusstvenno-sozdavaemyy-deficit.html

                Politikus.ru
                1. Krasnodar
                  Krasnodar 7 November 2017 00: 46 New
                  0
                  Quote: badens1111
                  Quote: Krasnodar
                  Almost everything was stolen in the USSR. From saleswomen in pavilions of beer to water, to the CEOs of factories. Dozens sat down, units were shot.

                  You see sir by age is very young, if so you evaluate life under the Union. Judging by your words, did your dad and mom steal the same thing? No? And why are you then slandering the entire population?
                  Quote: Krasnodar
                  In the era of total deficit, theft and exchange of ala subsistence farming was the norm.

                  Well, well .. well, and by whom and when the “total deficit” was created, exert your undoubtedly powerful intellect and give out information. So that you don’t strain too hard, I can tell you the beginning of your “total deficit” -1987, from the moment you cooperative and trade laws
                  Quote: Krasnodar
                  Now if you have stolen, in London you will only find yourself sharing 80% of the stolen goods. If you stole a little - you can’t last more than a year in London

                  Are you justifying thieves of various scales now? With the warriors so brazen that soon the country's treasury will empty for you to joy, because now there is an "era of plenty", only weirdness is seized by what we did not create, but who built it in Soviet times , isn’t it strange that you’ve been able to devour everything in a row for 30 years already, and you spit everything in the past?
                  So ..to remind you ..
                  “Deficiency is a mismatch between product supply and demand.”
                  Now compare with your situation. Yes, there was nothing on the shelves of the stores, but people had full refrigerators, no one was hungry, the goods reached the consumer completely, which means that the demand was satisfied. It turns out there was no shortage of nebilo, but there was a simple speculation.
                  Traders sold most of the goods coming to them to the market, leaving the worst products for reporting in stores. They tried to hide the goods, hold it and sell more expensive from under the floor. So the shadow market was born, the volume of which, by the mid-80s, was already at least 30% of the national income of the USSR. Https: //topwar.ru/48706-pravda-o-deficite-v-
                  sssr.html
                  The deficit in the USSR was created artificially, warehouses were bursting with goods. http://kprf.ru/rus_soc/99032.html Deficit under Gorbachev was created artificially http://www.duel.ru/200605/?05_3_2 Deficit of goods in the USSR was created intentionally
                  Nikolai Ryzhkov, in 1985-1990. - Chairman of the Council of Ministers of the USSR, in the television program “USSR. The collapse of the empire ”(episode 7), shown on December 11, 2011 (NTV channel) tells how this tobacco famine was artificially created in the country:“ Gorbachev calls me and says: “Here’s Yeltsin, can’t you come to me? " I've come. And I already knew what was going on. For several days almost riots took place. I say: “Mikhail Sergeyevich, why are you asking me? There is Boris Nikolaevich next to you, and ask him. Boris Nikolaevich, I may be mistaken, 28 tobacco factories. Of these, 26 were stopped for repair in one day. So what are you asking? That (ie Gorbachev): “Boris Nikolaevich, on what basis did you decide to stop the tobacco industry of the republic almost completely. Why did you do this? ” And really, why? If this is not deliberate sabotage and sabotage, then what is it? And all this was done by the new, already democratic, power of the Russian Federation for the sake of the final discredit and liquidation of the power of his rival, Gorbachev, together with the USSR, and to seize the sole power through the collapse of the country.

                  Source: http://politikus.ru/articles/66442-kak-razvalili-
                  sssr-cherez-iskusstvenno-sozdavaemyy-deficit.html

                  Politikus.ru

                  Hello to Zyuganov and Kalashnikov.
          2. Sotskiy
            Sotskiy 6 November 2017 23: 16 New
            +2
            Quote: Krasnodar
            They also stolen the Soviet ones ... more modest, of course, but still

            For those who plundered state property in the USSR, there was such an unpretentious raster article in the Criminal Code!
            And now?)))
            1. Krasnodar
              Krasnodar 7 November 2017 00: 44 New
              +1
              Quote: Sovetskiy
              Quote: Krasnodar
              They also stolen the Soviet ones ... more modest, of course, but still

              For those who plundered state property in the USSR, there was such an unpretentious raster article in the Criminal Code!
              And now?)))

              Now there are no shots :)
              Skid - rollback - cut :)
              Scheme of Russian business.
      2. Gardamir
        Gardamir 6 November 2017 12: 44 New
        +8
        Then - Baikonur, today - East.
        Then - the gas pipeline Urengoy-Pamara-Uzhgorod, Today - Nord Stream one, two.
        missiles are still being launched from Baikonur, while the East cannot launch. Industrial giants were built then and demolished now.
        By the way, say thanks whether Sobyanin, whether Putin, but in Moscow for the second time they put asphalt, even where they laid why six months ago. And why without storm drains?
        1. Boris55
          Boris55 6 November 2017 15: 22 New
          0
          Quote: Gardamir
          Industrial giants were built then and demolished now.

          There was an era of industrialization requiring great efforts to eliminate the consequences of a lag behind the West as a result of the rule of tsarism and civil war. Today, there is simply no need for so many construction projects. Today there is a need for the reverse process - the relocation of citizens in a modern village with all amenities ... but this is not another topic.
          1. Greenwood
            Greenwood 7 November 2017 15: 47 New
            +2
            Quote: Boris55
            Today there is a need for the reverse process - the relocation of citizens in a modern village with all amenities ... but this is not another topic.
            And where is the process? I’m watching for the time being how the people in Moscow and Peter fells.
            1. Boris55
              Boris55 7 November 2017 17: 08 New
              0
              Quote: Greenwood
              And where is the process?

              I wrote that there is a need, but here with desires - strained.
        2. gladcu2
          gladcu2 7 November 2017 17: 26 New
          +1
          Speak asphalt laying, tearing a new one? Left behind from life.

          In the modern capitalist city, bike tracks have become fashionable. Of the four lane roads make two lane and bike paths. And then, after heated discussions, they turn over back.

          Then again discuss and redo. These are the means of production for profit.
    2. Lycan
      Lycan 6 November 2017 14: 33 New
      0
      The paper certainly does.
      But (I’ve been looking through the years recently) - there are the surplus appraisal, and the NEP, and the population exhausted by the forced collectivization of the late 20s, and hunger, as a result ... And then, of course, the results, according to your paper. In short - until the beginning of the 30s - the authorities, alas, could not order positively. the dynamics of rural households. On the one hand, not everything happens right away. But on the other hand, how many people were killed while they ordered s / x.
      1. Sotskiy
        Sotskiy 6 November 2017 23: 28 New
        +3
        Quote: Lycan
        But on the other hand, how many people were killed while they ordered s / x.

        The people "lay down" naturally only in Soviet Russia, and in tsarist Russia and in the West in general, everything was tolerant from the day the World arose?))))
        People, understand, you judge that time from the "bell tower" of the modern world, not understanding those traditions, principles and customs of that time, and this, as they say, is two big differences).
        Can we recall how America was "peacefully" discovered, tolerantly carving the indigenous population, and then bringing slaves from Africa into the new "democratic" country of the United States? Or was it a long time ago and was already "not true", because how does it tarnish the bright face of Western "democracy"?)))))
        1. Lycan
          Lycan 7 November 2017 09: 29 New
          0
          No, no one whitewashes the Western manner of "discovering new lands" with a population cut out.
          But whatever the morals - the death of approx. 5,75 million people (http://militera.lib.ru/research/sokolov1/06.html
          ) for the years 1917-1926. without the direct participation of the enemy - this is a lot. Plus, the ruin of countless accumulated farms, people with no hope for the future, a mess in power ... And the west ... well, there’s no reason for them.
  8. Eurodav
    Eurodav 6 November 2017 10: 53 New
    +1
    Quote: Krasnodar
    Quote: Evrodav
    "... Heads of the Russian Imperial House of the Grand Duchess Maria Vladimirovna ..."
    Whoever chose it as its head, otherwise we do not sleep, nor in spirit ...
    "... There are at least two such houses, and they, to put it mildly, are not very friendly with each other ..."
    That's it. Understand first, and then announce the chapter!
    "... the atrocities of his (Kolchak) army are still remembered throughout Siberia ..."
    Like the atrocities of Tukhachevsky, Putna, Uborevich, etc.
    "... In Russia, after them there remained a feeling of deep guilt for the revolution, so ruthlessly disposed of the fate of compatriots ..."
    My grandfather was a communist, and my neighbor had blue blood! And no discord, guilt or anything else that we never had with him! Disagreement and other garbage in the heads of high-seated, ordinary people are smarter and have long understood and forgave each other!
    "... A recent survey by the Institute of Sociology of the Russian Academy of Sciences showed that almost a third of Russians (32%) found it difficult to assess the October Revolution of 1917 ...."
    What estimates, what polls, if the Bolsheviks themselves called it a coup! Only then they propagandized ... So the Russians find it difficult, why is there something incomprehensible? You declassify the archives then, then ask the people what they think? True, then reparations for the genocide of the Russian people will have to be knocked out of Israel, but this is another topic ...

    Well, yes, the Jews made a revolution, that is, it was they who burned the estates of the landowners before October, removed the tsar from power, forced the army to suffer enormous losses on the fronts of the First World War, which the country needed as a hare with a venereal disease.
    And to beat reparations from Israel is as profitable and successful in advance as getting money from oligarchs in Russia. In theory, you can, and even everyone agrees, but without pants and health you will remain until you get three pennies)))

    Teach History, no one will lose time with you, explaining ... As for the Jews, the devil jumps out of the snuffbox!
    1. Krasnodar
      Krasnodar 6 November 2017 11: 21 New
      +1
      Quote: Evrodav
      Quote: Krasnodar
      Quote: Evrodav
      "... Heads of the Russian Imperial House of the Grand Duchess Maria Vladimirovna ..."
      Whoever chose it as its head, otherwise we do not sleep, nor in spirit ...
      "... There are at least two such houses, and they, to put it mildly, are not very friendly with each other ..."
      That's it. Understand first, and then announce the chapter!
      "... the atrocities of his (Kolchak) army are still remembered throughout Siberia ..."
      Like the atrocities of Tukhachevsky, Putna, Uborevich, etc.
      "... In Russia, after them there remained a feeling of deep guilt for the revolution, so ruthlessly disposed of the fate of compatriots ..."
      My grandfather was a communist, and my neighbor had blue blood! And no discord, guilt or anything else that we never had with him! Disagreement and other garbage in the heads of high-seated, ordinary people are smarter and have long understood and forgave each other!
      "... A recent survey by the Institute of Sociology of the Russian Academy of Sciences showed that almost a third of Russians (32%) found it difficult to assess the October Revolution of 1917 ...."
      What estimates, what polls, if the Bolsheviks themselves called it a coup! Only then they propagandized ... So the Russians find it difficult, why is there something incomprehensible? You declassify the archives then, then ask the people what they think? True, then reparations for the genocide of the Russian people will have to be knocked out of Israel, but this is another topic ...

      Well, yes, the Jews made a revolution, that is, it was they who burned the estates of the landowners before October, removed the tsar from power, forced the army to suffer enormous losses on the fronts of the First World War, which the country needed as a hare with a venereal disease.
      And to beat reparations from Israel is as profitable and successful in advance as getting money from oligarchs in Russia. In theory, you can, and even everyone agrees, but without pants and health you will remain until you get three pennies)))

      Teach History, no one will lose time with you, explaining ... As for the Jews, the devil jumps out of the snuffbox!

      Unlike you, I know the story, namely, your time, of course, money)))))
  9. rotmistr60
    rotmistr60 6 November 2017 10: 54 New
    18
    “The Imperial House is valuable not by material goods, but, first of all, by authority”

    No one expected material wealth from the imperial house, and before the revolution, what is now to be expected. And about the authority can be argued. What kind of authority can one speak of if the emperor rode the country, abdicated? Why today should the Romanov House build something authoritative from itself?
    1. Paranoid50
      Paranoid50 6 November 2017 11: 18 New
      10
      Quote: rotmistr60
      Why today should the Romanov House build something authoritative from itself?

      Duc, demand creates supply. yes The merchant, of course, is stale (delay), if not counterfeit at all, laughing but their substance is also found in this substance.
  10. SERGUS
    SERGUS 6 November 2017 11: 10 New
    19
    “First of all, all of us, regardless of differences of opinion, must recognize that the Revolution is a common misfortune,” the Head of the Romanov House convinces the Russians.

    The trouble is your Nicholas 2, who, like Gorbachev, has asked ... the country, and everything else is consequences.
  11. 23rus
    23rus 6 November 2017 11: 24 New
    16
    Canonization of the king, whose hands are in blood ... Or 9 January 1905 year was not?
    1. Sotskiy
      Sotskiy 6 November 2017 23: 35 New
      +2
      Quote: 23rus
      Canonization of the king, whose hands are in blood ... Or 9 January 1905 year was not?

      Those were the machinations of the Japanese and the British. It’s necessary to watch TV!))) And there are simply no other messages to popular uprisings on the new version of the historical events that occurred from the 1902-1905 years presented by the Russia 24 channel!)))
  12. horhe48
    horhe48 6 November 2017 11: 40 New
    +9
    The article is balanced and edifying. But the attitude on the anniversary of the author himself remains incomprehensible. It seems, however, that: 1) The Great October Socialist Revolution is a natural and necessary phenomenon in a historical context. But the tragedy of the revolution was that it should have happened in in another place and at another time. (Maybe in France, Germany, etc.) V.I. Lenin correctly noted that Russia was the "weak link" in the chain of the largest imperialist powers, but he, who proclaimed the idea of ​​an imminent world revolution, underestimated the reserves of capitalism and, as a result, the USSR found itself face to face with the power of the entire capitalist world. Russia was 90% a peasant country, so the proletarian socialist revolution in a peasant country turned many problems “inside” and not as planned “outside” the country, which caused a heavy bloody civil war and forced catch-up development of industry due to robbery of the peasantry. 2) Arising from the first: we have gone too far, so to speak about the country. As history has shown, we can achieve the development of energy, transport, coal, oil, iron and steel and arms production in a historically short time due to ideology and the concentration of all reserves and strength in given directions. But the next generation does not want to live like their fathers and mothers. A dormitory bed or a room in a hut, poor fashionable clothes, monotonous and rather meager food ... And at the same time you have to work hard and be unbending a soldier of the party, contented with the smallest. And while we were surviving, other countries not only developed, but were also able to increase the welfare of their citizens. This is not bourgeois morality that replaced the socialist, but the “refrigerator” defeated the “TV.” from life, aged-sick old men from the Politburo for decades could not do anything to stop the mockery of the population with the help of "sausage" trains and trains to Moscow Then the hunchback who proclaimed change, put the country on meager coupons, destroyed the army and surrendered all the country's military and post-war achievements to NATO's mercy, so socialism began to be associated with an empty hunchback talker, coupons, etc. And there was no force in the country that would come out to defend them. But then you know everything.
    1. a.sirin
      a.sirin 6 November 2017 18: 56 New
      +2
      This is you in essence. thank
  13. Eurodav
    Eurodav 6 November 2017 11: 47 New
    +5
    Quote: Krasnodar
    Quote: Evrodav
    Quote: Krasnodar
    Quote: Evrodav
    "... Heads of the Russian Imperial House of the Grand Duchess Maria Vladimirovna ..."
    Whoever chose it as its head, otherwise we do not sleep, nor in spirit ...
    "... There are at least two such houses, and they, to put it mildly, are not very friendly with each other ..."
    That's it. Understand first, and then announce the chapter!
    "... the atrocities of his (Kolchak) army are still remembered throughout Siberia ..."
    Like the atrocities of Tukhachevsky, Putna, Uborevich, etc.
    "... In Russia, after them there remained a feeling of deep guilt for the revolution, so ruthlessly disposed of the fate of compatriots ..."
    My grandfather was a communist, and my neighbor had blue blood! And no discord, guilt or anything else that we never had with him! Disagreement and other garbage in the heads of high-seated, ordinary people are smarter and have long understood and forgave each other!
    "... A recent survey by the Institute of Sociology of the Russian Academy of Sciences showed that almost a third of Russians (32%) found it difficult to assess the October Revolution of 1917 ...."
    What estimates, what polls, if the Bolsheviks themselves called it a coup! Only then they propagandized ... So the Russians find it difficult, why is there something incomprehensible? You declassify the archives then, then ask the people what they think? True, then reparations for the genocide of the Russian people will have to be knocked out of Israel, but this is another topic ...

    Well, yes, the Jews made a revolution, that is, it was they who burned the estates of the landowners before October, removed the tsar from power, forced the army to suffer enormous losses on the fronts of the First World War, which the country needed as a hare with a venereal disease.
    And to beat reparations from Israel is as profitable and successful in advance as getting money from oligarchs in Russia. In theory, you can, and even everyone agrees, but without pants and health you will remain until you get three pennies)))

    Teach History, no one will lose time with you, explaining ... As for the Jews, the devil jumps out of the snuffbox!

    Unlike you, I know the story, namely, your time, of course, money)))))


    What can you know if you write without hesitation? Read, it seems you are the last who does not know, although - you know, but you are hypocritical, as usual! And note for yourself, we are talking about Zionists, and not all Jews, you know the difference?

    "The Zionist composition of the 1917 coup:

    Central Committee of the Right Wing of the ESER Party:
    Kerensky, Aronovich, Gissler, Lvovich-Davidovich, Gurevich, Gotz, Goldstein, Lihach, Kintshuk, Verlinrut, Distler, Chernyavsky, Rosenberg, Tchaikovsky, Ratner.

    The Central Committee of the Social Democratic Party MENSHEVIKOV:
    Dimand, N. Himmer, Strauss, Ratner, Lieber, Zonn, Dan, Abramovich, Rappoport, Cederbaum (Martov), ​​Tsederbaum (Levitsky).

    Central Committee of the Left Wing of the ESER Party:
    Sternberg, Levin, Fishman, Lenberg, Stytsa, Lander. Kagan (Gresser-Kamkov), Katz (Bernstein), Feiga Ostrovskaya, Nachman, Karelin, Maria Spiridonova.

    Central Committee of the Social Democratic Labor Party - Bolsheviks:
    Bronstein (Trotsky), Ulyanov-Blank (Lenin), Apfelbaum-Radomyslsky (Zinoviev), Lurie (Larin), Krylenko, Mandelstam (Lunacharsky), Uritsky, Goldshtein (Volodarsky), Rosenfeld (Kamenev), Smidovich (Yoshua-Yoshua) Sverdlov), Nakhamkes (Glass) ...

    After the October reversal:

    in the Council of People's Commissars of 22 members - 19 were Jews;
    in the military commissariat led by Trotsky - only 1 Latvian, and the rest are all Jews;
    in the People’s Commissariat of Internal Affairs - the future of the Cheka, the NKVD - all Jews;
    in the People’s Commissariat of Finance - out of 30 people - 26 Jews;
    in the People’s Commissariat of Justice - all Jews ... etc.
    Jews seized power in Russia.

    Even Winston Churchill, a Jewish mother, while still a young politician and far from a friend of Russia, in 1920, returning to the Jewish question, wrote:
    "... Starting from Spartak, Weishaupt to Karl Marx, up to Trotsky in Russia, Bela Kun in Hungary, Rosa Luxemburg in Germany, Emma Goldman in the USA, this is a worldwide conspiracy to overthrow culture and remake society on the basis of stopping progress, envious malice and the unthinkable equality continued to grow continuously ... It was the main spring of all the subversive movements of the XNUMXth century, and finally this gang of unusual personalities, scum of the big cities of Europe and America grabbed the hair and holds the Russian people in their hands, in fact becoming the undivided master of a vast empire. "these international and mostly godless Jews in creating Bolshevism and in conducting the Russian revolution. Their role is undoubtedly very large."
    1. Krasnodar
      Krasnodar 6 November 2017 12: 37 New
      +3
      What can you know if you write without hesitation? Read, it seems you are the last who does not know, although - you know, but you are hypocritical, as usual! And note for yourself, we are talking about Zionists, and not all Jews, you know the difference?

      "The Zionist composition of the 1917 coup:

      Central Committee of the Right Wing of the ESER Party:
      Kerensky, Aronovich, Gissler, Lvovich-Davidovich, Gurevich, Gotz, Goldstein, Lihach, Kintshuk, Verlinrut, Distler, Chernyavsky, Rosenberg, Tchaikovsky, Ratner.

      The Central Committee of the Social Democratic Party MENSHEVIKOV:
      Dimand, N. Himmer, Strauss, Ratner, Lieber, Zonn, Dan, Abramovich, Rappoport, Cederbaum (Martov), ​​Tsederbaum (Levitsky).

      Central Committee of the Left Wing of the ESER Party:
      Sternberg, Levin, Fishman, Lenberg, Stytsa, Lander. Kagan (Gresser-Kamkov), Katz (Bernstein), Feiga Ostrovskaya, Nachman, Karelin, Maria Spiridonova.

      Central Committee of the Social Democratic Labor Party - Bolsheviks:
      Bronstein (Trotsky), Ulyanov-Blank (Lenin), Apfelbaum-Radomyslsky (Zinoviev), Lurie (Larin), Krylenko, Mandelstam (Lunacharsky), Uritsky, Goldshtein (Volodarsky), Rosenfeld (Kamenev), Smidovich (Yoshua-Yoshua) Sverdlov), Nakhamkes (Glass) ...

      After the October reversal:

      in the Council of People's Commissars of 22 members - 19 were Jews;
      in the military commissariat led by Trotsky - only 1 Latvian, and the rest are all Jews;
      in the People’s Commissariat of Internal Affairs - the future of the Cheka, the NKVD - all Jews;
      in the People’s Commissariat of Finance - out of 30 people - 26 Jews;
      in the People’s Commissariat of Justice - all Jews ... etc.
      Jews seized power in Russia.

      Even Winston Churchill, a Jewish mother, while still a young politician and far from a friend of Russia, in 1920, returning to the Jewish question, wrote:
      "... Starting from Spartak, Weishaupt to Karl Marx, up to Trotsky in Russia, Bela Kun in Hungary, Rosa Luxemburg in Germany, Emma Goldman in the USA, this is a worldwide conspiracy to overthrow culture and remake society on the basis of stopping progress, envious malice and the unthinkable equality continued to grow continuously ... It was the main spring of all the subversive movements of the XNUMXth century, and finally this gang of unusual personalities, scum of the big cities of Europe and America grabbed the hair and holds the Russian people in their hands, in fact becoming the undivided master of a vast empire. these international and mostly godless Jews in the creation of Bolshevism and in the conduct of the Russian Revolution. Their role is undoubtedly very large. "[/ quote]
      -------------
      Lenin just praised the Jews you listed, while he cursed the Zionists, stating that they put forward the idea of ​​the superiority of the national over the class struggle, in contrast to the Jewish Socialists from the BUND and the Communist Jews.
      Jews lived in the Pale of Settlement, for the most part, were a discriminated and defenseless minority. The part sought salvation in Zionism - i.e. we are building our country in a historical homeland, there we will be an ordinary free Mediterranean people such as Italians and Greeks. Others wanted to remake the society in which they live - there will be international, communism, and everyone will be poh, what kind of nation you are. Still others fell quietly to the States, Australia, and Argentina. There were fourth ones - they were happy with everything in tsarist Russia and they got over from the Bolsheviks together with the white emigration - the ancestors of the current Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Olmert, white emigrants from Harbin.
      But, in any case, the driving force of the revolution was the Russian people, who were tired of fighting for Nicolas and plowing the well-fed freaks who squandered the fruits of their labor on luxury goods and leisure abroad.
      In this regard, Jews such as Brodsky (sugar) and Vysotsky (tea) are more to blame for the revolution than such as Trotsky. Although I relate to Vysotsky and Brodsky much better than to Bronstein, they at least plowed, and Lev Davydovich had been banging around Europe for the money of his parents and came to RI to usurp power from Austrian and Swiss cafes.
      1. dSK
        dSK 6 November 2017 17: 25 New
        +2
        Yes, the mind is not everything - an evil genius can do a lot of trouble. "A large cupboard and falling louder."
        1. dSK
          dSK 6 November 2017 19: 52 New
          +4
          “Today, at the request of relatives and friends Mikhail Nikolaevich Zadornov. Two months ago, Mikhail Nikolaevich brought God repentance in the sacrament of Confession in the Kazan Cathedral in Moscow. He goes through this difficult period of his life as an Orthodox Christian who reconciled with the Holy Church. I ask for prayers for the servant of God Michael, including, may God forgive him the years of shocking flirting with paganism, ”wrote Father Andrei. The rector of the church noted that he places this information in agreement with the closest relatives of Mikhail Zadornov. Earlier, Mikhail Zadornov repeatedly gave interviews and actively gave public lectures on neopaganism and ambiguously spoke out about the Orthodox faith. http://www.pravmir.ru/mihail-zadornov-prines-poka
          yanie-i-primirilsya-s-tserkovyu /? utm_referrer = htt
          ps% 3A% 2F% 2Fzen.yandex.com
          "Until the thunder strikes ... God save and have mercy. Theologian Alexey Ilyich Osipov often says that the robber (crucified with Christ) first entered paradise:" One of the hanged villains cursed Him and said: If You are Christ, save Yourself and U.S. The other, on the contrary, appeased him and said: or are you not afraid of God, when you yourself are condemned to the same thing? and we are rightly condemned, because we have received the worthy according to our deeds, but He has done nothing wrong. And he said to Jesus: Remember me, Lord, when you come to Your Kingdom!
          And Jesus said unto him, Verily I say unto thee, now you will be with me in paradise. "
  14. iury.vorgul
    iury.vorgul 6 November 2017 11: 49 New
    12
    The existence of the Grand Duchess Maria Vladimirovna Romanova and the Russian Imperial House, the Russians for the most part learned only in the post-Soviet era.
    This is the same Maria Vladimirovna, whose father, Vladimir Kirillovich, collaborated with the Nazis in occupied France, which is why after the war he fled to Spain, under Franco's wing. And why on earth is she a "Grand Duchess," if, according to the Russian "Regulation on the Imperial Family Name", only the daughters of the reigning Emperor and the legal wives of the Grand Dukes could have a grand title.
    1. Sotskiy
      Sotskiy 6 November 2017 23: 44 New
      +2
      Quote: iury.vorgul
      And why on earth is she a "Grand Duchess," if, according to the Russian "Regulation on the Imperial Family Name", only the daughters of the reigning Emperor and the legal wives of the Grand Dukes could have a grand title.

      With which, with what !?
      With the same with which our ilk with workers and peasants' past suddenly turn out to be counts, princes, etc., etc.)))
  15. Reklastik
    Reklastik 6 November 2017 11: 51 New
    +4
    “The idea that overthrowing power is right should not occur to the Russians. There is only one way out - to hush up the topic ”- that’s it) A protest is not a protest if it is agreed with those who rule, it’s some kind of Gaponism. But it is possible and necessary to overthrow the power if the power ruins the people and the country.
  16. Starik72
    Starik72 6 November 2017 11: 55 New
    16
    Do not be the Great October Revolution and the aftermath of the Soviet Power, wherever YOU Genadiy Granovsky WAS ??? And I am a simple citizen of the Great Country THANKS to the Great October Revolution and the Soviet Authority for becoming a man. Indeed, under the current DEMOCRATIC power, a simple person turns into a bug, and for a simple one into a SLAVE, depending on the powers that be.
  17. vitalm
    vitalm 6 November 2017 12: 39 New
    14
    Happy holiday - the 100th anniversary of the Great October Revolution!
    It is time to end the experiment with capitalism and a market economy.
  18. iouris
    iouris 6 November 2017 12: 41 New
    +4
    If without fanaticism, then it's time to end hiding behind the Romanovs, Lenin, the “white” and “red”. You can believe either in God or in the devil, and not in one or another version of the story, especially if the source is such a "truth-teller" as Medinsky. History is party science. There are no political parties in the Russian Federation, therefore there is no and cannot be a definite history. History adapts to the tasks of the apparatus yqj struggle. Contemporaries, we must tackle pressing issues. To understand the history of the Russian Federation (how we got to such a life), we need to study very well, i.e. to work a lot. This is not given to everyone, and not everyone has such an opportunity - you also need to earn a living, and today it is very difficult. Each "historian" must be able to answer himself and others to the question: "What social class do I belong to, and which social class opposes me in matters of production and distribution of material and spiritual goods."
  19. Fitter65
    Fitter65 6 November 2017 12: 52 New
    +7
    Interfax distributed the appeal of the Head of the Russian Imperial House of Grand Duchess Maria Vladimirovna

    No, when I write my Motherland Russia, in capital letters I can understand it, Russia is alone, it is my MOTHERLAND. But these are lice typhoid, great princesses who have already scoured all the mosles of the last fallen Kolchak horse with which vegetable is capitalized. a relative drunk the country, and now they’re the head of the Russian imperial one. We’ve gone raven! Our grandfathers built a country with a PLEASANT population, a developed economy, and social benefits for everyone !!! True, GREAT STALIN didn’t uproot all the roots of our Motherland, the remnants of this mucks put their rottenness into the structures of power, and we grabbed it deeply in the 90s ...
  20. Fitter65
    Fitter65 6 November 2017 13: 15 New
    +4
    Heads of the Russian Imperial House of Grand Duchess Maria Vladimirovna
    But it’s interesting what is it great? Well, there are like ancestors from the same line, only with the line of the same great Geyropeyts, so by the end of the XVIIIth, all these kings-princes-Hohenzollers-Valois and other these blue-blooded roughly talked among themselves for 300 years that some even had diseases that arise only from close family relationships. Yes, my Kuzya (photo below), he doesn’t climb a female dog for the same dog twice, so he’s a bastard for the last 5 years (young STILL only 8 years old) on his street he doesn’t swagger.
    1. Krasnodar
      Krasnodar 6 November 2017 13: 32 New
      +2
      Quote: Fitter65
      Heads of the Russian Imperial House of Grand Duchess Maria Vladimirovna
      But it’s interesting what is it great? Well, there are like ancestors from the same line, only with the line of the same great Geyropeyts, so by the end of the XVIIIth, all these kings-princes-Hohenzollers-Valois and other these blue-blooded roughly talked among themselves for 300 years that some even had diseases that arise only from close family relationships. Yes, my Kuzya (photo below), he doesn’t climb a female dog for the same dog twice, so he’s a bastard for the last 5 years (young STILL only 8 years old) on his street he doesn’t swagger.

      Cool dog! :)
      1. Fitter65
        Fitter65 6 November 2017 13: 41 New
        +2
        Pure "nobleman" !!! But he’s smart ... he doesn’t take an inventory of his car (once he’ve noticed and enough), and most importantly he doesn’t allow anyone to enter his garage row. That’s a real autocrat, he couldn’t excite the whole row (the state raised the struggle) people looked at what was there ... It seems to be a joke, but in reality it is ...
  21. evil partisan
    evil partisan 6 November 2017 14: 52 New
    10
    And I believe that socialism in Russia will triumph. And not only in Russia.
    1. kalibr
      kalibr 6 November 2017 15: 27 New
      0
      You wrote this from the dugout of the partisan detachment "Back to Socialism"? Or sitting at the clave of a Malay computer?
      1. 23rus
        23rus 6 November 2017 16: 25 New
        +1
        ... made from petroleum products from Western Siberia. laughing
  22. kalibr
    kalibr 6 November 2017 15: 24 New
    +1
    Quote: badens1111
    people’s refrigerators were full

    If it was not on the shelves, then where was it in the fridges? The answer was "taken away ..." "You are the master, not the guest, to take away even a nail!"
    1. 23rus
      23rus 6 November 2017 16: 27 New
      +2
      But because there were people around, our People.
    2. Krasnodar
      Krasnodar 6 November 2017 19: 52 New
      0
      Quote: kalibr
      Quote: badens1111
      people’s refrigerators were full

      If it was not on the shelves, then where was it in the fridges? The answer was "taken away ..." "You are the master, not the guest, to take away even a nail!"

      Here I am about the same ...
  23. NordUral
    NordUral 6 November 2017 17: 39 New
    +4
    Last Thursday in Berlin, as part of a series of monthly events at the Center for East European and International Studies, Janeke took part in a public discussion on the assessment of the events of 1917. The historian concluded that The October Revolution “was a key event of the twentieth century, as it led to the formation of the Soviet Union - the future superpower, which has become one of the main reasons for the polarization of the world. "

    This is what the West does not like.
    And all these royal houses are clowning for liberals. Russia has only one right way - socialism. Moreover, the Stalinist.
    1. Krasnodar
      Krasnodar 7 November 2017 00: 41 New
      0
      Quote: NordUral
      Last Thursday in Berlin, as part of a series of monthly events at the Center for East European and International Studies, Janeke took part in a public discussion on the assessment of the events of 1917. The historian concluded that The October Revolution “was a key event of the twentieth century, as it led to the formation of the Soviet Union - the future superpower, which has become one of the main reasons for the polarization of the world. "

      This is what the West does not like.
      And all these royal houses are clowning for liberals. Russia has only one right way - socialism. Moreover, the Stalinist.

      4 million denunciations?
      1. Sotskiy
        Sotskiy 7 November 2017 00: 51 New
        0
        Quote: Krasnodar
        4 million denunciations?

        Then for free. And now for the money!) Is this the essence of market transformation?)
  24. weksha50
    weksha50 6 November 2017 18: 32 New
    +4
    "There remained a country equipped with Great Peter and pride in the affairs of the first Russian Emperor, whose heirs could not understand the scale and significance of the October Revolution of 1917.".

    Here is the whole brief essence of the actions of the current government, arising from this article:
    ““ “Uncomfortable for discussion, for example, is the idea of ​​civil equality, social justice, under the slogan of which the revolution began” ...
    - ““ The idea that overthrowing the government is right should not occur to the Russians. There is only one way out - to hush up the topic »» ...

    And such a statement is surprising: "Only 21% of respondents, as liberal sociologists say," continue to live on Soviet myths. " This part of the respondents believes that the revolution brought the people “more benefit” ”...
    Well, yes ... I’m personally still living with Soviet myths ... Watching how they rob and still have not plundered the Soviet legacy ... Until now, Russian science and production on a Soviet foundation, on Soviet groundwork exist, stretch ...

    And about blood ... War, especially civil war, is horror, death, blood ...
    But let the Europeans and the Americans be clean, once again blame Russia for this blood ... Who should blame it? USA. Velikonagliy, Germany, Spain, Portugal, France ??? Oh, tired of listing ... There are too many of them, “righteous” poking a goat's hoof into Russia ...

    And as for the attempts to restore the monarchy ... It’s not the Russian dynasty — the Romanovs ... Half the Aglitsky, half the Prussian ... Let all the great princesses not climb on their neck to put on our neck ... 100 years have passed ... We just forgot them and do not want to remember ...
  25. ser6119
    ser6119 6 November 2017 19: 12 New
    +1
    Quote: 23rus
    Canonization of the king, whose hands are in blood ... Or 9 January 1905 year was not?

    I read "The Sewer of the King" lol
    1. dSK
      dSK 6 November 2017 20: 04 New
      +3
      Today on TV films on historical facts: Russia 1, 20:20, Demon of the revolution. 2nd film; "The first" - 21:20, Trotsky. 1st and 2nd series, 23:15, The true history of the Russian revolution. 1st and 2nd series. Facts are a stubborn thing.
    2. Vlad5307
      Vlad5307 6 November 2017 20: 33 New
      0
      Well, from January 9, the story is just dark - all these are provocations against the tsar, or rather against the Russian Empire. This is a puncture of the royal secret police who did not dare to prevent it. And people that then, that today are equally verbally processed - to think this work is harder than chopping wood. The consequences are very different.
  26. then
    then 6 November 2017 20: 28 New
    +5
    Brains are constantly powdering people, distorting the history of Russia and the October Revolution in particular. How to treat white (and fluffy)? As well as to Vlasovites. On the face of a clear substitution of the concept. External intervention was called the Civil War. And now the defectors with us are of the same blood and if they had won, the history of Russia could have gone differently. IT WASN’T IN THE DRAFT INTERVENTS OF SUCH STATE AS RUSSIA. And given that the Russian peasant never tolerated interventionists on his territory, then they had no chance to win, since the Bolsheviks at that time had legal power. If there had not been the October Revolution, I don’t know, we would be able to read and write now, but I know for sure that we would work now six days a week and for 12 hours.
  27. Vlad5307
    Vlad5307 6 November 2017 20: 28 New
    +4
    The current attempts of the "world elite" are aimed at creating a modern world colonial power - in the center of the FSA with vassals - under the shadow leadership of the Zionists. Everything else is entourage, and therefore they need to overthrow the significance of the October Revolution, which has grown into a socialist revolution. In the world, not one coup was complete without blood and turmoil, but given the scale of the Russian Empire and the active participation of such powers as Germany, Japan, Britain and the USA, the genius of Lenin and his associates is precisely that their money is their ideas the collapse of Russia were turned into their opposite. And this was precisely the reason for the civil war, in which whites were generously supplied with all these countries. And they themselves did not stand aside, having carried out direct intervention in Russia. So, not only the Bolsheviks contributed to the outbreak of civil war in the country, the slogan “we will turn the imperialist war into a civil one!”, Not ready for a socialist revolution, but basically just the “allies” of the tsar’s court.
  28. 1536
    1536 6 November 2017 20: 35 New
    +2
    The Great Russian Revolution of the 1917 of the year was the greatest event of the 20th century. And its first part - from February 1917, and the second - from October 1917 of the year. It was made by the people of Russia, who could no longer endure the tsarist regime, which had rotted at all levels, despised and hated its people, no matter what the words of the followers of the autocratic monarchy, which actually destroyed the state in 1917, were hidden. Further rule of the tsar in the form in which it existed during the 1905-1917 period, it continued for another 10 years, would put Russia in complete disintegration and complete disaster for the people who would lose their state forever. It was stopped on October 1917 of the year. However, almost immediately all the democratic gains of the revolution were curtailed in connection with the beginning of the struggle against Russia and its people internal and external enemies. They were defeated, but at the cost of the return of the virtually autocratic rule of a small group of people. However, for almost 80 years, the people believed in the ideas of socialism and communism, until, finally, by the end of the 1980's - the beginning of the 1990's, the sales top of the CPSU did not carry out a coup, destroying all the gains of the Great Russian Revolution, returning the country almost a hundred years ago . And now, from the stands, spewing curses, the “fragments” of this world of traitors are trying to blame anyone, not themselves, for the betrayal. How, then, are they these figures who differ from the reigning house in almost the same scenario who allowed the death of the existing state instead of its transformation in relation to modern conditions? And this is instead of saying repentance words, begging the people to unite and forget the bloody turmoil that similar ones created in 1917, but not its reasons that must be eradicated from social and socio-economic life, charting the way for further development. It should be a shame to these gentlemen! We must look ahead and perceive the events of 100 years ago, as if they had happened last night.
  29. sxfRipper
    sxfRipper 6 November 2017 21: 36 New
    +1
    Maybe enough to confuse the descendants of Tsar Kiryuha to the heirs of the House of Romanov?
  30. olimpiada15
    olimpiada15 6 November 2017 22: 08 New
    +5
    The anniversary of the great event should be celebrated. And to analyze so that disasters in our Great country are not repeated. But those in power cannot allow this, for the stigma in the cannon.
    This lady from the imperial dos declares that the revolution was a disaster. Yes, trouble. But who is to blame for this misfortune? The authorities were to blame, bringing their subjects to despair. There is someone to repent, and these are not revolutionaries, but the imperial house.
    But the revolution was also a victory, a victory of those who changed life in the country, made people literate, an industrial country.
    The forces of providence were what happened. Fascism is not something that came from nowhere, it was ripening in Europe, only the agrarian country could not defeat fascism, and the industrial USSR could, the price of Victory was incredibly high, but the Victory was due to the system that was in the country after October revolution.
    The October Revolution is an event of world significance, for the world has become different. The West parted with the colonies, the capitalists gritted their teeth and were forced to make concessions to the working people — they were afraid of popular anger and revolution.
    Socialism was an effective form of government. I was born and lived in the USSR, I have something to compare. Yes, people did not live well, and it could not be otherwise, for the USSR kept the gunpowder dry, which required enormous expenses. And for good reason, the threats were real. What happened Traitors came to power, dreaming of undivided power. And stagnation, when for many years the first person of the country could not rule the country for health reasons, and the rest could not make the necessary decisions on time. As a result, it was not the Communists who were at the helm, but rogues, but with party cards in their pockets. Remember, Chechen terrorists are also former Komsomol leaders. The shortage of goods could be dealt with, but this was not done, specifically, to discredit the idea of ​​socialism. But now the praise of capitalism, when the Russian Federation is not considered a state having the right to protect its own interests. There is no shortage, but what is there? Food stuffed with preservatives, modified soybean, palm oil. It is impossible to buy even banal herring and pollock without preservatives and signs of rot. Yes, the counters are full of all kinds of fish, but not freshly frozen. And other goods are full, disposable, with a reduced service life, repairable. Not happy, because while you are changing one or the other, it's time to throw away what you started with. This morning I read an article about Rosreestr, a journalistic investigation, I wanted to make a link, but the article was gone, probably deleted. I had to deal with land at work when satellite images appeared: everything was perfectly combined, and cadastral numbers and relief and objects. What Rosreestr is doing now, I am not a supporter of repressions, but in fairness, everyone should be shot from the leadership to the rank and file. That there was no revolution, because everyone has real estate, houses, gardens, garages. Remember, the protests of the Krasnodar farmers, who were not allowed to reach Moscow, were delayed, they were left without land. I am holding a title deed in my hands and cannot explain to the 80-year-old person that this certificate is not for his garage, but virtual, because the cadastral number is for a non-existent piece of land, and where there is a garage, there are no garages. And what will happen next? In gardening, where 150 plots and land are distributed, there are 300 plots, who gave the right to sell privatized land? Or will they draw it today, remove it tomorrow, and the day after tomorrow “bona fide” buyers will come?
    It is unfortunate that by the 100th anniversary of such a significant event, no fair assessment was given, not unambiguous, but fair. Not for the sake of the past, but for the sake of the future, so that it does not become a tragedy for future generations, and that they take place, future generations and Russia
    1. olimpiada15
      olimpiada15 7 November 2017 06: 55 New
      +1
      Read this article and enjoy the ensuing democracy in the country.
      http://ren.tv/novosti/2017-11-06/dengi-ushli-na-b
      azu-specrassledovanie-ren-tv-ob-oshibkah-rosreest
      ra
      Money went to the base: REN TV special investigation about Rosreestr errors
  31. wax
    wax 6 November 2017 23: 12 New
    +1
    Who is Maria? Keeper of truth?
  32. Comrade
    Comrade 7 November 2017 00: 47 New
    0
    Glory to the CPSU!
  33. iury.vorgul
    iury.vorgul 7 November 2017 06: 26 New
    +3
    Comrades !!!!!! Congratulations to all on the occasion of the GREAT OCTOBER SOCIALIST REVOLUTION !!!!!
  34. MaksoMelan
    MaksoMelan 7 November 2017 07: 04 New
    0
    I consider the first Russian emperor of Grozny! I advise. The title of King Tobes Caesar. Just Peter 1 called himself in a European manner.
  35. ver_
    ver_ 7 November 2017 10: 42 New
    0
    Quote: badens1111
    Quote: ver_
    Rome was born after Christ for a hundred years - no less than ..

    Pontius Pilate ... the procurator of Judea ... did you hear anything? Well, what about the cross and other things on the hill, but the words of the robber Varrava?

    ... learn the mat. part .. Rome was founded by the brothers Yaroslav and Yuri .. This is 1 Rome, the territory of Russia of the 12th century ..
  36. Like in Crimea
    Like in Crimea 7 November 2017 11: 53 New
    +1
    With the upcoming great anniversary of the GREAT SOCIALIST REVOLUTION!

    HOORAY!
    They are silent on the Internet, but people know that they are celebrating!)
  37. solzh
    solzh 7 November 2017 11: 55 New
    0
    appeal of the Head of the Russian Imperial House of the Grand Duchess Maria Vladimirovna to compatriots

    1. We, born in the USSR, are not compatriots to her.
    2. What ... an imperial house? We have no heirs to the throne! The last heirs in 1918 were allowed to expend.
    1. smart ass
      smart ass 8 November 2017 21: 00 New
      +1
      Is there anything to be proud of? Killing defenseless women and children in the basement?
      1. solzh
        solzh 13 November 2017 13: 31 New
        0
        Yes, there is something to be proud of. And I'm proud. And at the expense of women and children, it may be enough to lie and talk nonsense.
  38. smart ass
    smart ass 8 November 2017 20: 57 New
    +1
    The article lacks the mention of the kind and fluffy red commanders who distributed candy. And about the losses of 12.5 million Russian citizens as a result of the civil war
  39. Old military officer
    Old military officer 9 November 2017 18: 49 New
    +1
    Congratulations to all on the occasion of the Great October Revolution! He was, is and will remain the greatest event of the twentieth century, truly turning the world around, showing the world the way to a society of justice. Yes, capitalism has taken revenge, but most likely it will be similar to Napoleon’s capture of Moscow, whether "friends and partners" abroad or fifth-column compradors want or don’t want to. And these so-called imperial houses are where they should be, where they were thrown out during the revolution and civil war. In Russia, they have nothing to do, except to sell noble titles to the snickering bourgeoisie, who have forgotten Ivan Andreevich Krylov. "And you, friends, no matter how you sit down, everyone is not good at musicians."
  40. Dzafdet
    Dzafdet 9 November 2017 20: 49 New
    0
    In the Urals alone, Kolchakites killed and tortured 35 thousand workers. Romanovs in the furnace! am
  41. Dzafdet
    Dzafdet 9 November 2017 20: 52 New
    0
    Quote: Clever man
    The article lacks the mention of the kind and fluffy red commanders who distributed candy. And about the losses of 12.5 million Russian citizens as a result of the civil war

    Losses in the Civil War 8 million. then there was typhus, Spaniard, famines and the Great Patriotic War. But the greatest vileness was committed by the last of the Romanovs in 1991: without any war, the loss of population in Russia is terrible!
  42. ver_
    ver_ 12 November 2017 15: 37 New
    0
    Quote: Clever man
    Is there anything to be proud of? Killing defenseless women and children in the basement?

    ... well, it worked proletarian - with an ax ...