In Germany, considered a closed topic of reparations Poland

80
The government of Germany considers the question of reparations to Poland closed. Reports about it RIA News with reference to the statement of the representative of the press service of the German cabinet.

The interviewee stressed that the position of Berlin was formulated on August 2 and remains unchanged.

Then the deputy government spokesman Ulrike Demmer noted that Berlin is certainly responsible for unleashing World War II in moral, political and financial terms, but “the issue of the German reparations to Warsaw was finally settled at the political and legal level”. The press service stressed that this is a principled position of the German leadership.

In Germany, considered a closed topic of reparations Poland


Earlier, on August 25, Polish Prime Minister Beata Szydlot stated that her country has the right to reparations from Germany.

Poland speaks of justice. Poland is talking about what needs to be done. We are victims of the Second World War. We are victims for whom damage has not been repaid in any way.
- stressed Shidlo.

2 August, Polish Defense Minister Antoni Macherevic reminded that the country had never de facto denied claims against Germany, which launched 1 on September 1939 of the year, military aggression against the republic, and then occupied Polish territories for almost 5 years.

It is not true that the Polish state abandoned the German war reparations due to it. This Soviet colony, referred to as the Polish People's Republic, abandoned part of the reparations related to the puppet state also called the German Democratic Republic.
- the minister said. He also added that this waiver was never legally registered.
  • © AP
Our news channels

Subscribe and stay up to date with the latest news and the most important events of the day.

80 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. +3
    25 August 2017 14: 50
    Of course, the Germans don’t have to pay reparations to anyone else, they already paid for everything in full.
    1. vch
      +28
      25 August 2017 15: 04
      How many parasites have bred? What Poland, what the Baltic states! But is it so that Poland itself had a hand in unleashing the Second World War? Can remind the Pshekhs of their negotiations with Hitler about a joint attack on the Soviet Union? Or how did they chop off part of Czechoslovakia? Or how after the war did Stalin give them part of Germany? This Polish mongrel, feeling the support of the Americans yapping already at all. They say correctly - the Pole is not a nationality, the Pole is a profession ...... I think that one of the oldest ......
      1. +35
        25 August 2017 15: 05
        In the place of the Germans, I would say: “Let Poland first return Germany to Breslau, Danzig, Stettin and the rest of the land that had left to it as a result of the war, and even then they will start talking about reparations.”
        1. +1
          25 August 2017 15: 16
          I think the Germans do not need these lands, however, like Kaliningrad
          1. +8
            25 August 2017 15: 17
            Wrong you think.
            1. +8
              25 August 2017 15: 22
              Not just not right, not reasonable, there is no state that would refuse to increase territories ...
              1. +7
                25 August 2017 15: 24
                And only burdock does not want to return their lands.
                1. +1
                  25 August 2017 15: 26
                  So Ukrainians are not burdocks? They do not refuse territorial claims against the Russian Federation?
                  1. +19
                    25 August 2017 15: 28
                    What are you talking about ? About Crimea? So he was never Ukrainian, this is Nikita Kukuruznik who made a present, and EBN failed to return.
                    1. +14
                      25 August 2017 15: 30
                      And New Russia and Little Russia have never been Ukraine ...
                    2. +2
                      25 August 2017 15: 31
                      Well, in Ukraine they think a little differently, all the same Crimea was part of Ukraine in the 90s and in the zero and even several years in the 10s
                      1. +18
                        25 August 2017 15: 34
                        The fact that modern Ukraine has its own view of the world and history is a problem of exclusively modern Ukraine.
                      2. +9
                        25 August 2017 15: 35
                        And before that, whose he was and whether Ukraine was such a state before.
                      3. +12
                        25 August 2017 15: 49
                        Quote: vazxnumx
                        Well, in Ukraine they think a little differently,

                        What do they think in Ukraine? C'mon !, the State Department is doing an excellent job of them. And they only read the signs in a free translation.
                      4. 0
                        25 August 2017 20: 54
                        Quote: vazxnumx
                        Well, in Ukraine they think a little differently

                        That's right! laughing Everyone has already noticed the campaign ...
                    3. +4
                      25 August 2017 15: 31
                      Quote: vazxnumx
                      So Ukrainians are not burdocks? They do not refuse territorial claims against the Russian Federation?

                      This is who should whom and can make claims. wink
                      1. +7
                        25 August 2017 15: 37
                        That's it, Vitya! If Russia begins to make territorial claims on the basis of historical documents, then some sprats will remain homeless. lol
                    4. +5
                      25 August 2017 15: 39
                      Quote: bouncyhunter
                      That's it, Vitya! If Russia begins to make territorial claims on the basis of historical documents, then some sprats will remain homeless. lol


                      And not only them ...
                      1. +2
                        25 August 2017 15: 44
                        I gave an example that has been given more than once here at VO. wink
          2. +1
            25 August 2017 19: 51
            Money is nothing, the earth is EVERYTHING !!!
        2. +2
          25 August 2017 15: 48
          Quote: bouncyhunter
          I gave an example that has been given more than once here at VO. wink


          There are many such examples, but this is a very "dangerous" topic.
        3. +5
          25 August 2017 16: 38
          Quote: bouncyhunter
          In the place of the Germans, I would say: “Let Poland first return Germany to Breslau, Danzig, Stettin and the rest of the land that had left to it as a result of the war, and even then they will start talking about reparations.”

          Ah yes Pasha, oh yes young man answered clearly for the Germans and I join! The Psheks remembered the reparation, destroying our monuments to the fallen soldiers who liberated them!
          We need to tear this off from Poland for saving them from destruction in gas chambers, etc. ... The bastards gritted their teeth ..
          1. +6
            25 August 2017 16: 43
            Hello Vitaly! hi Calm down, friend! The Germans - this is not a nation that will allow logs to yap. And the logs just feel behind their backs from behind the puddle, so they are fighting themselves out. Yes
            1. +7
              25 August 2017 17: 02
              Pasha! Greetings! drinks soldier puddle support, of course, yes. But, pšeki subsidies are received from the EU consolidated budget. And Germany is the main donor to this budget, and only then France. So it’s very easy for the Germans to cut back on these very subsidies. And what will proud hats do after that? run daddy for a puddle to complain.? A daddy now for money oh tight. So pshek before posing as proud and independent, it would be necessary to think, unless of course they have someone and what. And even in fact they can remain independent of subsidies from the European budget. Although this is their business, it is not for us to teach the "proud" gentry. They have a whole Matserevich. Head.............. laughing am
              1. +2
                25 August 2017 17: 04
                Hi, Kostya! soldier drinks
                Quote: Smog
                They have a whole Matserevich. Head...

                Yeah, no brains. lol
                1. +8
                  25 August 2017 17: 18
                  Quote: bouncyhunter
                  Yeah, no brains.

                  Brains, Pasha, for this head is an excess. laughing And suddenly in these brains there are also some thoughts that will burst. And it will already be bad.
            2. +3
              25 August 2017 18: 01
              Quote: bouncyhunter
              Hello Vitaly! hi Calm down, friend! The Germans - this is not a nation that will allow logs to yap. And the logs just feel behind their backs from behind the puddle, so they are fighting themselves out. Yes

              So it’s Pasha .. After the Second World War, these "brothers" Stalin cut the territories from the heart, supposedly use and don’t blather .. USSR fell apart, and the territories remained with them .. Well, terrible ones were hit and they still require money! Eh Germans, you are still more honest and fought to the last .. Don’t believe the United States and you throw off this witch Merkel! You are nevertheless closer to us than these "bedding brothers .." soldier
              1. +4
                25 August 2017 18: 16
                Quote: DEPARTMENT
                Quote: bouncyhunter
                Hello Vitaly! hi Calm down, friend! The Germans - this is not a nation that will allow logs to yap. And the logs just feel behind their backs from behind the puddle, so they are fighting themselves out. Yes

                So it’s Pasha .. After the Second World War, these "brothers" Stalin cut the territories from the heart, supposedly use and don’t blather .. USSR fell apart, and the territories remained with them .. Well, terrible ones were hit and they still require money! Eh Germans, you are still more honest and fought to the last .. Don’t believe the United States and you throw off this witch Merkel! You are nevertheless closer to us than these "bedding brothers .." soldier

                Merkel is not German, Jewish, maiden name kazmirchak, of Polish Jews her ancestors.
                and here’s an interesting video, listen and watch carefully until the end
          2. +4
            25 August 2017 17: 42
            "... We need to rip it off from Poland for saving them from destruction in gas chambers, etc ..."
            Totally agree with you. One clarification, what kind of gas chambers are you talking about?
            No need to fall for the "propaganda ducks" of muddy Holocaust supporters.
            There is not a single photograph of the notorious "gas chambers" for exterminating people, not in any of the many concentration camps of the Second World War. Only for the disinfection of personal items they are. But people were not killed in them. This is fiction.
            Fiction of the same chosen repairers from Germany, Russia, etc.
            1. +2
              25 August 2017 18: 09
              Quote: japs
              "... We need to rip it off from Poland for saving them from destruction in gas chambers, etc ..."
              Totally agree with you. One clarification, what kind of gas chambers are you talking about?
              No need to fall for the "propaganda ducks" of muddy Holocaust supporters.
              There is not a single photograph of the notorious "gas chambers" for exterminating people, not in any of the many concentration camps of the Second World War. Only for the disinfection of personal items they are. But people were not killed in them. This is fiction.
              Fiction of the same chosen repairers from Germany, Russia, etc.

              Well, the destruction of the Poles, Russians, etc. It was a priority .. Although you watch movies and docks about the Holocaust, it’s all played out .. I feel so simple! Here OUR 25 million was filled up, but we do not cry ... Only stronger have we become and we honor the memory of soldiers! And they’re ready to break the ridge of any aggressor .. soldier
            2. +3
              25 August 2017 18: 22
              Quote: japs
              "... We need to rip it off from Poland for saving them from destruction in gas chambers, etc ..."
              Totally agree with you. One clarification, what kind of gas chambers are you talking about?
              No need to fall for the "propaganda ducks" of muddy Holocaust supporters.
              There is not a single photograph of the notorious "gas chambers" for exterminating people, not in any of the many concentration camps of the Second World War. Only for the disinfection of personal items they are. But people were not killed in them. This is fiction.
              Fiction of the same chosen repairers from Germany, Russia, etc.

              how do you feel about the miracle saved by the holocaust
              193 thousand for 2016 and only in Israel, do they need stem cells in the camps?
              screen from the Jewish newspaper of Germany
        4. +1
          25 August 2017 22: 44
          War loser pays reparations to the winner. Did I miss something, in which war did Poland defeat the FRG? Here, apparently, the fact is that the Poles from 1979 received a lot of money from Germany in the form of loans, and now they have to give their own.
          Tell you, who is the next candidate for paying reparations to Poland?
        5. +1
          26 August 2017 08: 58
          I think that someday the Germans will return to this question.
      2. +2
        25 August 2017 17: 05
        Quote: vch
        This Polish mongrel, feeling the support of Americans, is yelping at all.

        More Zhiglov told them

        in the sense of "not reparation"
    2. +10
      25 August 2017 15: 06
      If I am not mistaken, then in 2010 we finished paying.
      Handsome, no snot and discussion: free. But I really want to see how their patience will burst, the Psheks will not stop, and the Germans will demand their own: at least restitution of property and compensation. The maximum is even more interesting ..
      1. 0
        25 August 2017 16: 29
        Since 54 th GDR did not pay Poland
  2. 0
    25 August 2017 14: 53
    Simple, clear and categorical. No snot.
    Well done!
  3. +6
    25 August 2017 14: 55
    But are the Poles overgrown? The Germans have already paid everyone. What only reparations cost Israel (+ free equipment in the form of submarines and other fits). The Germans were milked for the Second World War very powerfully. Not to mention that blaming Germany at the beginning of WWII is fundamentally wrong.
    1. 0
      25 August 2017 21: 46
      Quote: Equalized
      Not to mention that blaming Germany at the beginning of WWII is fundamentally wrong.

      And who is to blame right?
  4. +2
    25 August 2017 14: 56
    In fact, Poland is a bankrupt country. The Greeks made claims to facilitate debt negotiations. A similar feint is now made by the Poles.
    1. +7
      25 August 2017 15: 02
      Poland is definitely NOT economically bankrupt :)
      With regard to claims against Germany, Poland is essentially the "mole" of the United States in the EU and is engaged there in what they say. One of the main US allies in the region. And of course, a chance to get a freebie if a ride.

      The US and the EU are not friends, as many people think for some reason. The EU is trying to get out of influence, the United States, at least the same attempts to create its own army speak about this. By the way, these attempts were sabotaged by Great Britain at one time for obvious reasons.
      1. +1
        25 August 2017 15: 37
        How many pscheks have international debt?
        1. +1
          25 August 2017 16: 49
          The question is not correct. Correct they give the debt or not
        2. +3
          25 August 2017 18: 03
          Quote: ivan5572
          How many pscheks have international debt?


          Poland's GDP and External Debt
          25-08-2017 17:49:35
          $ 638 437 528 584
          GDP (Gross Domestic Product) this year
          (at purchasing power parity)
          $ 16
          This year's GDP per capita (annual $ 25 480)
          $ 2 003 073 790
          GDP for today
          $52
          GDP for the current day per capita
          $ 491 303 775 484
          Public debt counter

          $ 12
          Government debt per capita
          $ 14 004 314 884
          Public debt this year
          $0.93153
          Government debt today
  5. +2
    25 August 2017 15: 01
    We are victims for whom the damage has not yet been repaired.
    I imagine if we Russians fell just as low, continue to ask for handouts, and whoever suffered the most is the Russians, the legal successors of the Soviet people, the most affected side in WWII, along with the Belarusians ....
  6. +1
    25 August 2017 15: 02
    The finish. What did the Poles count on? For US support?
  7. +1
    25 August 2017 15: 02
    Bummer. "In the words of our beloved chef - strike the iron without leaving the cash register."
  8. +3
    25 August 2017 15: 10
    Quote: vazxnumx
    Of course, the Germans don’t have to pay reparations to anyone else, they already paid for everything in full.
    interesting Rabinovich, Russian prisoners of fascist concentration camps on equal terms with Israeli receive German compensation? Oh yes, you have gained a bunch of citizenships, that now the hell will break-who are you and where ...
    1. +3
      25 August 2017 17: 59
      If passports give real money, then why shouldn’t citizen Rabinovich buy a couple of such passports?
  9. 0
    25 August 2017 15: 14
    Quote: Equalized
    But are the Poles overgrown? The Germans have already paid everyone. What only reparations cost Israel (+ free equipment in the form of submarines and other fits). The Germans were milked for the Second World War very powerfully. Not to mention that blaming Germany at the beginning of WWII is fundamentally wrong.

    yes, I agree with you, Rabinovich, you can blame, in principle, the whole of Europe and the American corporations that contributed to Hitler’s rise to power, financed, made it possible to seize part of continental Europe, which would ultimately send them a well-fed war machine to destroy the USSR .....
  10. +4
    25 August 2017 15: 16
    in Europe, crowds of former faithful Leninists rush about, with outstretched hands, faith in America and some rotten presentations to anyone who has a wallet
    1. +6
      25 August 2017 18: 02
      What to do ... Children of Lieutenant Schmidt, hungry childhood, lack of vitamins ...
  11. +2
    25 August 2017 15: 19
    And the Poles also fought against Germany ??? And the Poles are also winners ??? winked
  12. +1
    25 August 2017 15: 19
    Poles: "Well, they said it was closed ... well, okay. We tried ...."
  13. +2
    25 August 2017 15: 28
    The Germans remembered international law, when the "squelch" began to clang quite indecently. We also just need to remind the Germans, and Poles, and the Americans, and the Baltic states, and God forgive the Romanians, when they begin to weave fake claims about the "Soviet occupation".
  14. +1
    25 August 2017 15: 32
    Quote: Hoc vince
    In fact, Poland is a bankrupt country.

    --------------------------
    Not bankrupt, that's for sure, and the average salary is bigger than the Russian one.
  15. +1
    25 August 2017 15: 35
    I wanted Poland to succumb to her own outrageous desires ...
  16. BAI
    +1
    25 August 2017 15: 38
    Yes, let them squabble among themselves as much as possible. In World War II, all of Europe participated. Let each other make claims to each other. Nevertheless, it’s better than getting to the bottom of Russia.
  17. 0
    25 August 2017 15: 50
    "settled in the past at the political and legal level," but in a simple way: would you go to ... Leshem to confession
  18. 0
    25 August 2017 15: 53
    Quote: vanavate
    in Europe, crowds of former faithful Leninists rush about, with outstretched hands, faith in America and some rotten presentations to anyone who has a wallet

    They are ready to work the Kamarinsky dance and ride on their heads to please the Americans
  19. 0
    25 August 2017 15: 57
    "On August 2, Polish Minister of Defense Anthony Macherevich recalled that the country has never de facto rejected claims against Germany, which began military aggression against the republic on September 1, 1939, and then occupied Polish territory for almost 5 years."


    And the Minister of Defense of Poland does not want to recall who liberated Poland from occupation?
    1. +3
      25 August 2017 18: 08
      And also remember who brazenly attacked the peaceful German radio station in Gleivitz.
      You have to be as simple as Psaki. Let them make excuses.
  20. +1
    25 August 2017 15: 58
    Quote: bouncyhunter
    What are you talking about ? About Crimea? So he was never Ukrainian, this is Nikita Kukuruznik who made a present, and EBN failed to return.

    But EBNa did not hesitate. The main thing for him is that grass rest on the table and the rest
    1. +1
      25 August 2017 16: 18
      That's why the Crimea profucu. He waved at the booze / snack without looking.
  21. 0
    25 August 2017 16: 12
    Below the Mountain shooter asks: what did the Poles expect? I myself consulted the sofa about this and we decided: the Poles didn’t know how to come up with anti-Russian from afar: we remember that the Soviet Union helped us in WWII, but the Bolsheviks offended us in 1939 and, as a continuation, “drive the money”! You look at a freebie, something will fall
  22. +1
    25 August 2017 16: 22
    If a lady said to Frau: “Pay!”, This also applies to us directly.
    The Germans can always say: "Clairvoyant, return Danzig and Celesia, then we’ll pay off immediately!" Poles: "The question is closed, have already settled." But there is Russia, the legal successor of the USSR, and here the Poles have already rolled out a couple of zeroes more. And the young man behind the godfather (USA) .......
  23. +1
    25 August 2017 16: 26
    Well done Mr.! The main thing now is what? The main thing is ambition .. Soon, they will start talking about how "Polish rabbits run between walruses".
  24. 0
    25 August 2017 16: 28
    It’s time, oh time, for Germany to create, within the framework of NATO, a “Group of German Forces in Poland”. And then it will be too late.
  25. +1
    25 August 2017 16: 31
    This requirement looks strange. I would understand if Poland took Germany’s place in the EU in terms of economic power, and being practically a colony to demand from Germany?
    You can certainly ask, but demand ..................
  26. +1
    25 August 2017 16: 48
    Not a ride from the Psheks with Germany .... bummer.
    Ours was also approached with a standard presentation - the first, you started a war, the second - chase grandmas.
    It seems that nothing will break off either.
    There were Turks, Swedes, Ukrainians and Tatars ...
    They, too, somehow raped Poland.
    Maybe a ride there?
  27. +1
    25 August 2017 16: 49
    Does it seem to me or is it still an attempt to rock the situation in Europe with such statements? Poland, the Baltic countries, Ukraine. It seems that everyone suddenly needs something from everyone. That everything seemed to break loose ...
  28. 0
    25 August 2017 17: 12
    [quote = Monster_Fat] Poles: "Well, they said it was closed ... well, okay. We tried ...." [quote = Monster_Fat]
    They wanted the best for us, but it turned out as always laughing
  29. 0
    25 August 2017 17: 21
    Germans respect and respect for the answer ...
  30. 0
    25 August 2017 18: 28
    oh eat like a hunt ...
  31. +2
    25 August 2017 19: 47
    And by the way, how much Germany dumped the dough in Poland when it tore its claws from the Warsaw Pact?
    From two sources is going to suck. Or two? ...
    Hyena, such a hyena.
    1. +3
      26 August 2017 07: 01
      Oh, how old was Churchill, oh, how right !!!!
  32. 0
    25 August 2017 22: 00
    that's offended on the planet divorced ...)))) around q, Artagnans)
  33. +1
    25 August 2017 23: 28
    No matter how much the Poles got heartburn from such demands ... They quarreled with us, they are trying with the Teutons. Something happening is reminiscent of the plot of a fairy tale about the Golden Fish ... like this grandmother, who is the Prime Minister of Poland, was not at a trough.
    In general ... I suppose it could not do without the vile instigators from the United States.
    1. +3
      26 August 2017 07: 02
      With quarrels, they also quarreled ... Still not settled with the Czechs for the Tyshin volost?
  34. +5
    26 August 2017 07: 00
    The impudence is awesome! They got a fat slice of Germany, its historical lands with developed industry, drove the Germans out of pants, literally restored the rest of Poland at the expense of the USSR, and now they have the audacity to demand more! probably the zloty in the country of developed European civilization is coming to an end, but here is such a freebie + the experience of a neighboring power, suing right and left (maybe yes it will burn out). Freebies spoil countries and peoples! ... However, they may demand from the bribes the return of the East Kresy. Only the local people will have to feed for the Polish cat in this case. Or will they expel them as Germans from Pomerania, Prussia and Silesia?

"Right Sector" (banned in Russia), "Ukrainian Insurgent Army" (UPA) (banned in Russia), ISIS (banned in Russia), "Jabhat Fatah al-Sham" formerly "Jabhat al-Nusra" (banned in Russia) , Taliban (banned in Russia), Al-Qaeda (banned in Russia), Anti-Corruption Foundation (banned in Russia), Navalny Headquarters (banned in Russia), Facebook (banned in Russia), Instagram (banned in Russia), Meta (banned in Russia), Misanthropic Division (banned in Russia), Azov (banned in Russia), Muslim Brotherhood (banned in Russia), Aum Shinrikyo (banned in Russia), AUE (banned in Russia), UNA-UNSO (banned in Russia), Mejlis of the Crimean Tatar People (banned in Russia), Legion “Freedom of Russia” (armed formation, recognized as terrorist in the Russian Federation and banned)

“Non-profit organizations, unregistered public associations or individuals performing the functions of a foreign agent,” as well as media outlets performing the functions of a foreign agent: “Medusa”; "Voice of America"; "Realities"; "Present time"; "Radio Freedom"; Ponomarev Lev; Ponomarev Ilya; Savitskaya; Markelov; Kamalyagin; Apakhonchich; Makarevich; Dud; Gordon; Zhdanov; Medvedev; Fedorov; Mikhail Kasyanov; "Owl"; "Alliance of Doctors"; "RKK" "Levada Center"; "Memorial"; "Voice"; "Person and law"; "Rain"; "Mediazone"; "Deutsche Welle"; QMS "Caucasian Knot"; "Insider"; "New Newspaper"