Why is Putin slow?

As calculated at the National Bureau of Economic Research of the United States, "in the UK, Switzerland, Cyprus and other similar offshore centers, there are as many finances of wealthy Russians as the entire population of Russia holds within their own country." The national wealth of Russia did not grow from 90, but was redistributed, and then flowed offshore. Approximately 1% of the population in Russia controls about 75% well-being. Commented on the well-known economist, analyst, political scientist Mikhail Khazin.

Comments

[Sergey51]

Gorbachev-Yeltsin, do not drag Putin. These two traitors have convinced the great country, now we are recovering with difficulty and mistakes.

[Boris55]

Quote: rudolff

And where are we recovering? Since 2008

And why since 2008, and not since 1999?

Quote: rudolff

actually stand still.

And the US economy is falling

Quote: rudolff

At this pace, we will soon become a third world country.

At this pace, we maintained the integrity of the state, ensured its defense and food security. And only now you can deal with internal problems.

Quote: rudolff

Giant country with a dwarf economy

Before the crisis - the 5th economy of the World, now - the 8th.

[Nikolai Grek]

Quote: rudolff

At the end of last year, Russia is in the top ten in terms of nominal GDP. According to various sources at 12/14 place. We had such a place in the 90s.

you can insert a nominal value in one place !!!

[Sling cutter]

Quote: Nikolai the Greek

you can insert a nominal value in one place !!!

Trollar does not need to be rude to strangers to you.

[your1970]

Quote: rudolff

At the end of last year, Russia is in the top ten in terms of nominal GDP. According to various sources at 12/14 place. We had such a place in the 90s.

- if you discard the services of loers from the US GDP, it is not known where their GDP will be ...

[Zheleznostop]

You are a schoolboy, if not in courses on your childhood, google photo albums with the first Chechen one, and compare the army then and now. And then he hung in the 90s a cloudy drop on my daddy’s penis, but now Navalner has a bit brain smashed and give you a revolution. Z .. to all of you on the collar so that your neck is not rubbed.

[antivirus]

about 7-10 years ago I read- "Russia -SSSR in the 20th century escaped the fate of India or China"
paid the price (for integrity and the very "existence"). blood and territories.
When sci-fi boys came to power. it seemed right now they would sit down, in a circle, correctly, and they would count the money the same way --- that would be enough.
not caught.
mentality + education + example of a neighbor-- we have other landmarks,
not european yet.

[Viktor.12.71]

Quote: Boris55

And the US economy is falling

The US economy comes first. And they can continue to increase the public debt, who will forbid them? Corruption is the main enemy, if you introduce tough measures to fight it in the flesh before executions, then the leap in the economy as in China is quite real.

[Sling cutter]

Quote: Boris55

and food security

You are confused in the testimony

[gvsp]

The absolute GDP is already 12th. And the fall continues.

[Varyag71]

Apparently defending against their own people. Made the law enforcement agencies, spit on whom, always in uniform.
Food safety ... don’t tell. this is the crap that poison is fed to people.
Internal problems ... snickering and nonsense Caucasians, bureaucrats, security officials, low salaries, crime, requisitions and hundreds and hundreds of problems. Who will decide? Putin and his team?

[Sergey51]

It’s better for the State Department’s troll to prepare that you don’t give references, as everything is bad in our faces. Liberals are Putinophobes, you’re fed up with your whining, you’re getting in your feet, doing your best, all the echelons of power have pierced, State Department’s fodders.

[Sergey51]

No, I love Russia with all its shortcomings, I have never had and never will, although I have traveled half the world. And do not hang up noodles, I saw the West in all its glory, your demagogy is cheap for pimply youths, for the electorate of Navalny, and the notes are familiar. Hush up all the positive, and stick out the negative, you are complementary to the State Department!

[Siberia 9444]

They ask everyone for their debts, they help everyone, but they trampled their people into the mud! 60% gas tax! And who pays, people, and Putin says from the screen that cheap gasoline is bad bad sechin whose income is $ 1 million per month. Gref grants loans in Europe at a ridiculous interest, but yours !? The overpayment for apartments is almost the cost of this apartment, etc. And all this thieves are on his side! I'm not talking about the local kings who generally put on the decrees of the president. A prident travels around the country and solves problems calling callers Shorter than me and no Pontus

[zurbagan63]

... and he dumps landfills, he’s just laughing the whole country, the comedian is excellent)

[kasatky]

The state has nowhere else to take power except from its own people. Ivan 4, Peter 1, Stalin squeezed everything out of the people to the last drop and sent these forces to the great benefit of the country. I hope Putin will do the same. What are we too pampered steel? We love cookies and do not like to work? Then the fate of the Balkans awaits us.
But how many of us do at least something useful for the good of our country? And those who do, there is nothing to whine, it is necessary to rejoice that we have this opportunity. And who does not - start with yourself.

[gvsp]

Putin was 17 years old. With the rulers you have listed, for 17 years the country has changed beyond recognition. The fat oil years passed and rolled back into the 90s. 100% of youth again wants to go at least somewhere, but to the west.

[kasatky]

Do not tell me ... Peter's reforms were so tight that many of them bore fruit after his death. One of Peter's goals was to force all classes to work for the Fatherland: nobles, clergy, citizens, peasants. Therefore, everyone considered him the Antichrist, and they also dreamed of leaving "at least where." And not even to the west, but simply, away.
With Stalin, mind you, the same picture. And we still use the fruits of his reign: atomic weapons and energy, jet aircraft, hydroelectric power stations, river canals, etc.
Putin is bad because he is "not enough Putin." And if enough, everyone would moan, not just liberals)))

[wax]

Dostoevsky is a genius !!!

[Zheleznostop]

Well, what’s the problem, we’ll be safe from the outside, and 1% is easy to degrease if they can’t really help them outside.

[Nikolai Grek]

Quote: rudolff

These two were convinced, and Putin carefully preserved. And where are we recovering? Since 2008, average annual GDP growth of less than one percent actually stands still. The size of the state budget in the middle of the second ten countries of the world, even Spain is larger. Since the beginning of the 2000s, the price of oil has grown, and GDP has grown. Oil has fallen, and the economy has fallen. And this 1% both fattened and fattened with the Kremlin blessing. Every year Putin talked about the dangers of offshore, but as soon as the European Union took Cyprus for glands, the first rushed to his defense. Because, as it turned out, even state corporations have accounts there. At this pace, we will soon become a third world country. A giant country with a dwarf economy and nuclear weapons.

I wonder who slipped you statistics on GDP "since 2008" with an average annual growth of less than 1% ??? !!!

[Sergey Antipin]

Putin is a fraudster (selfishly became the president of Russia, misleading the Russians with his false election promises) and a traitor to Russia (for many years he has kept Russia in accordance with one of the ultimate goals of the US DropShot plan, namely, in deep economic dependence on the outside world). He is worthy of the forensic charge under Article 159 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation "Fraud" and under Article 275 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation "High Treason".

[wax]

Serezha, look at yourself in the mirror more closely.

[Berlin1945]

What are you talking about? You yourself believe what you said

[357 753]

Liberast, he and in Africa, the liberals piss shit on Russia And you yourself come from shit.

[Reptiloid]

And what infuriates me most is that no one scolded either drunk or hunchbacked, no one said that they were corrupt. Apparently there was a reason !!!!!!!!!!!!!! And now everyone understands everything in everything and they teach Putin! What country got drunk and what brought. ????? And Putin in 2001 What country did he receive?

[nov_tech.vrn]

The drunk did his best to ruin the economy of the USSR, at the same time ruining the economy of the Russian Federation, but what was left was sawn for a long time, and now the entire financial and economic block of miscarriages, of that time, and about weak growth, one more thing to remember is how There was not minimal growth, but a constant drop in production by 10 -15 percent per year, and the IMF sponsored the elimination of industry and coal mining, you don’t be lizard, we have a good memory, and even such basic things as the Russian Central Bank, we blocked the passage payments in the late USSR, and no one has yet answered for the Chechen memos. And about the media donated to the Yakovlev liberals with all their giblets, you also did not hear, or how they soothed Soot Umalatova with the help of mass disinformation.

[VAZ2106]

Putin is a man trained in the KGB of the USSR, which is important to him and no one knows, only speculation

[owl]

This is not the "KGB" that took part in the collapse of the country, and then in the division?

[Vpk72]

it is precisely that — but Trotskyist-Andropovsky.
from there everything is rot - Gorbachev and others

[owl]

I will tell you the "secret" rot from other places (erotic) and this "good" the vast majority, for a long time the figure goes 80%, just not everyone has a chance to take full advantage of their "gift" . I’m writing to you now, and you are most likely a rotten person

[Vpk72]

lover of nits andropov offended? so also rot

[owl]

Quote: vpk72

offended

I do not see the logic

Quote: vpk72

nits of andropov

Regarding whom ???

[Vpk72]

this is the logic - he wrote, "This is not the" KGB "that took part in the collapse of the country, and then in the division?" and then he began to call names on a person criticizing the head of this KGB himself - the conclusion: lovers of andropov are not only rotten but also silly messes

[antivirus]

what Primakov bequeathed is what the GDP does (taking into account part of the EBN instructions)

[Vpk72]

and what did the kirshblat bequeath? to look for braces in the Middle East so dear to his heart and in every way please the people from him?

[antivirus]

everyone can bend their line

[gvsp]

It is important for him, as for everyone under capitalism, to ensure a comfortable old age, and a comfortable life for children and grandchildren.

[wax]

To do this, you do not need to be the President in general and for the third time, in particular.

[tax payerschik]

Actually the physical elimination of these, such as elites and their heirs, will solve all issues. When I take your life from you, I take everything.

[raw174]

Quote: nalogoplatelschik

When I take your life from you, I take everything.

Well, offer another drink of blood of the slain to take away his vitality ... What nonsense? What problem will physical elimination solve? where does the murdered money go?

[Dmitrik]

Lord Comrades !!! Let me tell you all that Putin is not slow ... He is waiting ...)))

[wax]

Yes, I have to. Such a ship cannot spin like a small boat.

[Bob 57]

We must be friends to spite enemies!

[monk2987]

The danger of the sectarian ideology of the bloody obscurantism of Islamism "believers - infidels" merging with "capitalElitarism" is equal to the birth of "neo-Hitlerism."
aw, vigilance in the context of anti-Russian propaganda !!!

[Sidel45]

Why hesitates? But how can you offend your own ...

[Krebs]

And now to return these 63 billion to Russia and deal with internal problems and social programs. Or no one is jarring that 1% of nouveau riche presses loot on their people?

[north]

You would try to search for the source that this Khazin used, carefully read it, and then polemize.

[vviller]

Let yourself count. And we have the law of the jungle.

[Duchamp]

I’m looking here, some wise men gathered to slander Putin, but what about the citizen of Medvedev and his team in bales?!? so they’re gondolating Russia from the inside while BB rakes up shit abroad a bear team does everything just doesn’t restore Russia

[Doctor007]

as always, anyone is to blame, but not Putin. Once called the main thing in Putin's propaganda - now there is nothing to frown. And then they settled down well: something good - thanks to Putin, something bad - but Putin had nothing to do with it at all, so, passed by.

[Sergey Antipin]

Putin is essentially a godfather of organized crime groups from high-ranking officials and oligarchs. The most important goal for which to rob the state treasury and transfer funds to foreign countries. Having created such a parasitic anti-Russian structure, Putin reveals himself to be a major internal enemy of our Motherland.

[Zheleznostop]

This concerns all the rulers, someone is just an authority, and with a nuclear weapon a thief in law and summits can be called their grooms, but when was the earth different on the planet?

[did]

I agree...

[Seraphimamur]

To answer the title of the article, you need to read the constitution of the Russian Federation and understand the simple truth that we do not live in the USSR.

[Molot1979]

Not a single forecast of Khazin came true. This is all you need to know about this character. With such a percentage of hits, it is not surprising that the “economist and political scientist” in the Kremlin is sent in three funny letters, but he is offended. That's tryndit about 75%, referring to enemy data.

[patriot74]

rudolff your mouth would lick this place to the Americans ...

[Nikolai Grek]

Quote: patriot74

rudolff your mouth would lick this place to the Americans ...

so licks in full growth !!!

[free]

How much conflicting information, and would be glad to believe yes ............... hard to believe

[myobius59]

So after all, in all ages, the Tsar was a GOOD man for Russians. The noblemen, monsters were to blame. But the Tsar-Father did not sleep and did not know the spirit of what they were doing with his people. After all, nothing has changed in Russia. Medvedev and his company are to blame, and GDP is good. We just need to tolerate (or hold on to Medvedev), a couple, a dozen, a hundred years, and everything will be fine, and we will live like cheese in butter. So we will continue to believe that our king will still lead us to a brighter future. Amen.

[free]

Quote: myobius59

So after all, in all ages, the Tsar was a GOOD man for Russians. The noblemen, monsters were to blame. But the Tsar-Father did not sleep and did not know the spirit of what they were doing with his people. After all, nothing has changed in Russia. Medvedev and his company are to blame, and GDP is good. We just need to tolerate (or hold on to Medvedev), a couple, a dozen, a hundred years, and everything will be fine, and we will live like cheese in butter. So we will continue to believe that our king will still lead us to a brighter future. Amen.

So it’s only whom, instead of Putin? It’s clear what can be found, but after how long and the level of this chosen one? There’s no way I’m not going on with the country, but no matter how we miss the choice, it’s painfully big. what shall we be?

[patriot74]

Putin for the next term

[patriot74]

The people will vote for him ... and no Bandera propaganda will prevent this ...

[Gnuss122]

Divorced liberals here ...

[Sergey Kiryushin]

It is impossible with our mentality to solve everything in one moment with a simple wave of a saber in a punishing hand. It's not possible now. Late. We are not ready, like Koreans (Chinese), to work day and night for the sake of the economic prosperity of the state by abstract tomorrow. We want today, and even better, yesterday to be well-fed, smart and happy with life. And therefore, a radical solution to the problem of corruption can plunge the country into chaos by sabotage by various oligarchic groups of state decisions. After all, corrupt today and in the executive, and in the legislative branch at all levels. An example of the same Ulyukaev can be both a signal to corrupt officials and a signal to anti-corruption fighters. Especially when you consider the actors.
The "father" of the South Korean economic miracle, Park Jung-hee, was considered a tyrant, crushed dissent and was killed in an attempt. Lee Kuan Yew (Singapore) also acted by repression and considered Putin's economic reforms to be excessively liberal. But Asians are obedient people and the actions of these individuals were more often perceived by the local population as the norm. It is unlikely that we would not complain, if necessary, to buy permission to purchase a car at an auction or when paying a fine of 10k rubles for spitting on the street.
I mean, there is no pattern that could be used in our case. There are some rules, but they should always be applied taking into account the specifics of the moment, geography, level of education, etc. Otherwise, instead of prosperity, there will be chaos and destruction.

[Stalnov I.P.]

Why he’s hesitating because he himself is in this circle, a man has more power than autocratic monarchs, could create a CANDLET from the country, as Lee Kuan Yew, the prime minister (deceased) of Singapore, can say there is a small country and few people, but there and no natural resources. We have EVERYTHING, you understand EVERYTHING, as our Soviet school said: “the entire periodic table”, Qatar has GAS, the UAE has OIL, what is the standard of living of ordinary CITIZENS of these states and what we have, let us say just below skirting boards, it turns out the Arab sheikhs are better and smarter than our rulers dozens of times. I’m not talking about the GDP growth rate, the Chinese, Indian, Vietnamese rulers, for example, are 7 times smarter, more productive, quicker, we have 1% of GDP, they have 7% in the region. Here is the answer, for a handful of people COMMUNISM was created, and WE are so on the alert. It’s just a shame, some talk, but no business.

[wax]

Candy made Poroshenko. And our sweetie, precisely because we have everything, will be immediately taken away without the presence of Iskander, Barguzinov, Ash-tree, Arctic, etc.

[kig]

Well, firstly, Mr. Khazin has never been credible in these matters. Why is he delaying? Thinks, probably. For example: how exactly to return finances to their homeland? Any financial amnesties there do not help. Threaten? So the owners of the money tomorrow will go to the same place where their money is stored. You can, of course, not let them out ... the traffic police didn’t pay a fine, or child support .... Or hostages of relatives .... But this is not our method, Shurik. It will take a long time to create a financial paradise from Russia, like the Cayman Islands, and no one will believe ... It turns out that economic measures do not help, but force measures do not work. And anyway, how do we know whose money it is ...

[gvsp]

If Putin thinks and cannot come up with, then we must give way to those who know what to do. 17 years thinking, it’s time to come up with. For 17 years, you could manage to place your people in all key posts and now carry out the necessary actions. But Putin seems to be happy with everything: his daughters can be successfully married, and he’ll have enough for an old age and a small house in Germany.

[Sova_16]

It is time to introduce taxes on luxury over-income, and transactions abroad.
Why do people constantly raise taxes and lower wages. For the sake of the profits of the oligarchs and latent billionaires?
In the richest country in the world, a salary of 7-30 thousand is NATIONAL SHAME !!!

[raw174]

Quote: Sova_16

Why do people constantly raise taxes and lower wages. For the sake of the profits of the oligarchs and latent billionaires?

When exactly did you raise the tax? for what? When did you lower your salary? What area do you work in? arguments like: "A taxi driver told me about this, and his grandmother told him, and she read in classmates," does not count.

[jonht]

Yes ..... so much couch delirium could be collected only by such nonsense ...
The same Trump holds money in offshore and nothing, but here you have lost your mustache .....
It is not the couch expert who decides whether or not it is lawful, but determines the COURT, and the glory of GOD is not so much from the "couch" .....
Lovers to pick and pick does not bother to remember how this ended (the last example of Venezuela) ....
But what really poisons life is corruption, but you need to fight it at all levels, and first of all start with yourself ..... I think 70-80% give money in clinics and many other institutions, so to speak speeding up the process, and it’s strange as well, corruption and a direct bribe .... And it’s not necessary from the smear that these are not the right amounts and the wrong money, it all starts with a small one.

[raw174]

Quote: jonht

I think 70-80% give money in clinics and many other institutions, so to speak, to speed up the process

What for? to whom in the district / city clinic give money? For what? What will your bribe affect? I do not understand...

[jonht]

Well, firstly, referrals to hospitals, secondly to free and very expensive examinations, thirdly there is an incredible number of vaccinations and certificates .... So, depending on the region, there may be many options on what and how to get it.
For example, if eye surgery is done in Khabarovsk, then people from Kamchatka are sent there according to a quota, or you can for yours ... ( )

[raw174]

Well, maybe I won’t argue, I haven’t encountered such cases personally. Although only this year my grandfather had surgery, his wife did a cesarean in the regional perinatal center, he underwent two medical commissions, did not pay a dime (except for the fee) ...
In general, my opinion, as I think of the majority, is that those who give are more guilty of corruption than those who take ... But this trouble in Russia, as elsewhere, is not certain.

[jonht]

So I’m talking about the same thing, it all starts with a small one, and here the 90s will come back to us more than once. I myself don’t give the same thing when I give it; I’d rather wait than bother someone.

[raw174]

I do not look at ratings and other information, but look around. I do not live richly in the countryside. The standard of living of people is really growing, but slowly growing. Now there are no hungry people, they really aren’t there, everyone who wants to have a car, and you can’t practically meet old huts, people in the village stopped holding cattle, they even stop planting potatoes! This is because I don’t want to work physically, it’s easier to buy, so the money is there. At school, almost all children are shod and dressed as expected, it's nice to see. Take a look around! The elemental order will melt more! Authorities cease to be impassable bureaucratic wilds! Yes, slowly, but with a creak, but any issue can be resolved without a bribe and blat! As for the analyzes and forecasts, the paper will endure everything! The West, on paper, has already rotted for about fifty years, but in fact, they have lived and still live, the same with Russia, the GDP does not grow and everything is about to fall apart, and people live normally.

[1536]

"Comrades! No meat is reported to the tiger at the zoo!" (sideshow on the eve of "perestroika"). And further: "About 1% of the population in Russia controls about 75% of welfare." (...).
It would be interesting to calculate how many percent of wealth would be controlled and by whom, if the so-called “non-systemic opposition” with their appetites were in power. And what fortune was 40-45 years ago? In our courtyard there was a Volga under a canvas case, the owner of which was a retired colonel of the Ministry of Internal Affairs, an official motorcycle with a sidecar, it was driven by a VOKhR worker from the factory and the brand new ZAZ-965 Zaporozhets, which belonged to a WWII disabled person, had no legs it was a car he received in return for the SMZ S-3A, a car for disabled people known from the movie "Operation" S ". That’s all from the means of transportation. This wasn’t in other yards either. Today, you don’t know where to park your French car. But it’s so, a sketch.Of course, an alarming life has come in our very Ogata, but not about our honor, country.

[Evgeny Bogat]

Now, according to the plan of Western "thinkers," we must run to joyfully take away the loot and transfer this loot to another "one percent", which will be more accommodating to America. The option with a fair distribution of benefits is not considered, since it is not possible for objective reasons.

[Snake]

Maybe this 1% FSB officers and bring money in bags to the budget. And bulk officers too. Otherwise, what kind of Crimea with a bridge, new nuclear icebreakers, rocket engines for the United States and other goodies. And the former 1% has long been a pauper in exile, while others are even further ...